I.,.U't1't1 4

~ d ca,.. dd fi' g,.i AnTH'ln M1 b'Hl-:J fl nl.1ilfi'bHu':'Yl'V'l-:JtI~:~-:Jfl"1lfl-:J~t1~: b:IJUflnUl1'V'l1l1~Ufl n

q '11 q

~:~'l.Jn1~~nM1.ffu ~Uqj1'U,1fi1:IJrlf'fU:"1Ifl-:J~'l.J~'VITHnnU~n M1bb~:fl~~ ~flU t ~-:Jb'i~ui-:Jrllfi• '11 '11'11

Wn.t'n-:J1Ub"1I1fi~U~m~~m~1~Mmt ~m"1l1fi1 mi~"1Im.t1b~um.j~m~i bfl~1:~"li fl:IJ~1fi1:IJ~1~'l.Jq '11 '11

f1e'Wri 1 ~~m~i bfl~1:~"li fl:IJ~vt11tl"1lfl-:J~1fifl'l.Jbb'l.J'l.J~fl'l.Jr:l1:IJtlfi~m~'VI1fhi'mJ~:'11 '11

~ A ~~f1e'loU1 2 ~~m~1bfl~:'VI"1Ifl:IJ~

'11

d ~ dd ~ ~ A1. ~ ~n1~f'fn M1fl m~n Mm:'Yl'V'l-:JtI~:~-:Jfl"1lfl-:J~t1~: b:IJUflm1l1 'V'l1l1~Ufl n

q '11 q

~:~'l.Jn1~~nM1.ffu ~Uqj1UIfi1:IJrlf'fU:"1Ifl-:J~'l.J~'VI1~~r:l1U~nM1bb~:fl~~ ~flU t ~-:Jb'i~ui-:Jrllfi• '11 '11'11

itl,rn-:J1Ub"1I1fi~U~n1~~n M1~Mmt ~n b"1llfi1q

2. ~~n1~bm~'l.Jb.yj~'l.Jflmin'JYm:~Vi-:JtI~:~-:Jf1"11fl-:J~t1~:bijUfl m1l1'V'l1l1~Ufl nq '11 q

~:~'l.Jn1~~nM1.ff U~Uqj1U1fi1:lJrlf'fU:"1Ifl-:J~'l.J~'VI1~~r:l1U~n'JY1bb~:fl~~ ~flU t ~-:Jb'i~ui-:Jrllfi· ~ ~.• ••... ..f d •• A T ...l1 •• '" d~un-:J1Ub1J91'V'lU'Ylm~f'fn'JY1'V'l'JYmt~n b"11911'111bbun 911:IJ911bb'VIU-:J'VIU1'Yl

q ._ t':! ••••..•••••• I ~ ~.I A3. ~~n1~bIJ~~'l.Jb'Yl~'l.Jflm~n'JYm:'Yl'V'l-:JlJ~:~-:Jfl"llB-:J~lJ~:b:IJUflm1l1'V'l1l1~UBn

q '11 q

~:~'l.Jn1~~n'JY1,ru~Uqj1U1fi1:lJrlf'fU:"1IB-:J~'l.J~'VI1~~r:l1U~n'JY1bb~:fl~~ ~BU t ~-:Jb'i~ui-:Jrl91• '11 '11'11

itl,rn-:J1Ub"1lIfi~U~m~~nM1 ~Mmt~m"ll91 1 ')1bbUn911:IJtI~:;bll'Yl"llB-:Jh-:Jb'i~Uq

'. '.

56

~H)'Wr1 1 1YeUJtut'J 1tJtlD~ ~ fI DU LLUUt; fl1Hl111" "'iJ1nm';jfrm~1f1d1:IJ~~ bV; 'I.l.b~ tI1ntJf1 r;u,trn1Yr;u,:~Vi\llh:~\I~"1J el\I~lh:dJ'I.l.f1 fJl.ll1'Vi

q ~ q

111~'I.l.Bn ';j:~tJm';jfrn1Y1.ff'l.l. .yf'l.l.qn'l.l.~1:IJ'Ylf'l'l.l.:"1JB\I~tJ~'VI1';j~rn'l.l.frn 1Y1bbi,'l:fl';j~ ~el'l.l.1';j\lb~~'I.l... ~ ~~

~\ln~a-ntn\l1'1.l.b"1J~~'I.l.~m';jfrn1Y1-W'l2tr;u,1i,'lnb"1J~11bf1';j1:'VI1~~\litq

~tl1'1.l.111'Vi

f1';j~~el'l.l.~~

1.h::::bll'Yl"1JB\l1';j\l~~'I.l.

h\lb~~'I.l.i'~'jJ1i,'l..1';j\lb~~'I.l.beln"J5'1.l.

N= 180

66

114

145

35

180

36.67

63.33

80.56

19.44

100

'iJ1n~1';j1\1 2 'VitJ11 ~~B'Ubb1JtJ~BtJtl1:IJa-1'1.l.1'VInhtl'l.l.fl';j~a'B'I.l.-;l1'1.l.1'1.l.114 fl'l.l.CU QI cu CU

f1~btl'l.l.i'el~i,'l::::63.33 ';jB\la\l:IJ1~el~tJ;-'VI1';ja'tl1'1.l.frn'l2t1-;l1'1.l.1'1.l.66 fl'\.t f1~btl'l.l.i'B~a: 36.67~

~1Wl.h:bll'Yl"1JB\l1';j\lb~~'I.l.~91el1JbbtJtJ~BtJtl1:IJ~'I.l.1'VInibtl'l.l.1';j\lb~~'I.l.i'~tJ1 a -;l1'1.l.1'1.l.~ ~ ..'c 145 fl'l.l. ~~btl'l.l.i'B~a:::: 80:'56 ';jel\la\l:IJ1btl'l.l.h\lb~~'I.l.bBnir'l.l. -;l1'1.l.1'1.l.35 fl'l.l. ~~btl'l.l.i'B~~::

19.44 ~1:IJ&h~1J

57

~ A ~ Q,J de( 6 g,,; AG1e:J'wn2 nT11 L~11t:'Vi~ nLliHl'l!tnLt:'Y1'VHItJ1t:~~~nJ e:J~~U1t:L;jJ'1,HHlUl1n, ~,......

111~'Ue:Jn 1t: ~ 'lJn11~n 'l!t1<U'Uft'U;)"1'UGl1;jJY1~'Ut:t1e:J~~ 'lJ1'Vi11~ f11"~n 'l!t1Lt~ t:~ 1~~ e:J'UoIll ~ ~~....

r 1~L~~'Ui~il~ th"n~l'UL 1.1G1ft",nn11~n'l!t1"'l!tnLr ~n Lt1G11,,

d IQ; Ad .,.I ~ Q.J •• I A1. ~ ~nl'H'ln ~1 fl nl.~ n ~nl.::'Yl W-:IlJ 1:: a--:Ifl"ll el-:l~ lJ 1:: L3.1'U,flnl.Jl1 WJl 1 rJ'U,elnq 'lI q

1::~'U nT1~n ~1.ff'U,~'U,~1'U,~13J't1fo'l'U,::"1Jel-:l~'U~'VI11a-r\1'U,~n ~1 bL~::fl1~ a-el'U, t 1-:1b~rJ'U,i-:lrl ~•• qJ cucu

tt1un-:l1'U,b"1J~~'U,~n11~n~l'Yi~nl.t~n b"1J~1q

2. '~l1n n11~n ~1 ~ ~ n11bu~rJ'U b.yjrJ'Ufl113Jf)~ bV;'U,b~ rJ1rl'Ufl nl.&rn ~nl.::q

~oW-:lU1::a--:l~"1Jel-:l~U1:: bii'U,flnl.Jl1WJl1 rJ'U,eln1::~'Un11fln ~1.ff'U,~'U,~1'U,~13J"fo'l'U,::"1Jel-:l~'U~'VI11'lI q •• 'lI

a-r\1'U,flnM1 bb~::fl1~ a-el'U, t1-:1b~rJ'U,i-:lrl~ a1Un-:l1'U,b"1J~i4''U,~n11fln M1~Mnl. t~n b"1J~ 1'lI'lI q

lfi1'U,flnl.1l113Jbb~::'Ufl~nJl1W lfi1'U,fl113Jifl113Ja-13J11r\1'U,n11th::bii'U,bL~::lfi1'U,fl113Ja-13J11r\1'U,q q 'lI

n11~Ela-11 Llfi~-:ld

•...

Q.I d ~ tJ ••.

1::~'Ufl nl.~n ~nl.::'YlW-:I 1::a--:lfl

XS.D.

Aaq fl113Jfl~b 'VI'U,

1. lfi1'U,flnl.1l113JLL~::'Ufl~nJl1W

4.310.483J1nq

q

2. lfi1'U,fl113Jifl113Ja-13J11r\1'U,n11U1::bii'U,4.210.56:I..nn'lI

3. ~1'U,fl11:IJa-13J11r\1'U,n1':i~Ela-1':i••4.20" 0.54:lJ1n

':i13J

4.250.493J1n

N= 180,

I Q.J A ,:::!i Q.J d q",. I q",. d<iI1n~l':il-:1 3 W'U11 ~'U':i'VI1':ia-r\1'U,fo'ln~1 bb~::fl':i~ a-el'U,3.I'Ylfo'l'U,::~elfl nl.~n ~nl.::'Yl'lI 'lI'lI q

oW-:IU':i:: a--:lf1"1Jel-:l~lh::bii'U,fl nl.Jll WJll rJ'U,eln1::~'Unl':ifln ~1.ff'U,~'U,~1'U, 1'U,Jll W':i1:1Jbb~:: b1I'U,'lI q ••

':i1rJlfil'U,rmlfi1'U,mjl 'U,':i::~'U:lJ1nq 'lI

,d A ~ Q.J I Q.J da. Q..oP dd (i' Q.J Ab3JelW<ill':inl.l bU'U,11 rJ~l'U, W'U11 ~1'U,'Y13Jflnl.~ n ~nl.::'YlW-:lU1:: a--:lfl"1Jel-:l~'l.h::b:IJ'U,

q 'lI'" '"

Q..I d Q.,o do Q../I Q.JA d Vfl nl.JllWJll rJ'U,eln1::~'Un11fo'ln~1"1J'U,W'U,~1'U,~13J'Ylfo'l'U,::"1Jel-:l~'U1'V111a-r\1 'U,fo'ln~1 bb~::fl1 ~ a-a'U,

q ••• CU cucu

a--:la-~ Llfibbn lfil'U,flnl.1l11:1Jbb~::'Ufl~nJllW (X = 4.31) 1el-:l~-:l3J1Llfibbn lfil'U,fl113Ji'lI q q q 'lI

fl113Ja-13J11r\1'U,n11U1::bii'U, (X = 4.21) bb~::lfil'U,fl113Ja-13J1':ir\1'U,n11~aa-1':i (X = 4.20)

"7

Q"'~"7

{f:;HIr'--;::l"7'lI~It~H~~~~~C;:'"Q-(9;11;;6-11~~Q{f:;~;;r0'1r'0'c;:H~~~

'lI~~r~{f:;Ir'rgs::GIr';:1~;;r0'"7Qi'lH ;;6

CO~

C""LO ~&:Ir'

~~

C""

rQ;J

~itS

~~

;f1Igs:: r-" lIV'1€> ~

GC;: .,~~ ~~~C"" i'lc;: ~~~ ~H 'lI~Ir' Ir'H

r~

~~

~~r

Hl/O"

Ir'Ir' ~(9; r

Q;;6

~~

Q;J

~r

~"7~Q;J r

It~ ~~

~C""

C;:'"-{f:; ~

Q;JG~

\la;;~~r.:: Ir'-" ~r

-c;:~;;r0'

"<t

"7rIr'r(9; ~

~~

II~

~~~~~

GC;:

rrrrH ;;6;;6;;6;;6;;6Ir' r

C""c;:

~

Q 0..-ex>ex>C')(f:;

LOLOLOLO~;;r0' Cl)

00001r'0' c;:

C")

C')NCO

I~C")NNC'!

"<t

"<t"<t"<t

~

~~

II~

€>

~~~~GC;:

rrrrH ;;6;;6;;6;;6;;6Ir' rC""c;:

§; ~'lI~~r 0NNex>"<t~ ~It:!~~

(f:; Cl)0000Ir' rgs::GIr';:1~;;r0'

CO

ex>CO..-I~ C'!

..-..-C'!"<t

"<t"<t"<t

~

G~ H"'c;:

Ir'

"7

--;::l

(f:;

Ir'Ir'r ~H ~Ir' ~--;::l

~ Q"7

re-" \l{f:;

'lI~

~~Ir'~Ir'r;;6

\l~Ga;;

r~C""H c;:;;6~Ir'

~;:1'"~e-"

H

~;;6

Ir'

~~~r

r;;6

C"";;6~ Ir'~~O'~C;:'"

Ir'lR

;;6;;6~

rrC""

C""

C;:'"c;:c;:

~~~

~r~r~r

@>@>~

..-NC')

~ -~ ~ ~1r'0'r ::jl r ;;6"",, ~~ ~~ r"-~ ~ ~ C""-'I ••.. ~ ••. c;:

~~ r ~ ~i'l ;;6 r rr "7 ~~ ~€>~ a;; Q;J

~ "7 r -~1l~ Q Ir' ::jlIr' Ir' ~ ~€>r 0 ~~ _ i'i r;:1 ID a;; ;;6

~€> N -" "7

~a "<t ~ ~Ir' c"" Q~ 11 Ir' Ir'Q ~~ r-~ I~ ~ ~~ -- ~ "<t

F ~ ~ 11~ r l/O',

~ ~ "-~ I~C;:'" ~ -'1~

GS G~ .~~ ~-" ;:1'" _ r rH H CO ~ ~Ir' a;; ""': ~ ~? ::jl "<t 'lI~ Ga;;;;r0' ;;6 Ir' c;:

"7 Ir' 11 r ;:1'"Q Ir' IVI ~ Hi'l lR ~;:1 a;;

"'c;: ~ -- ~~ ::jl-{;;; C;:'" ~ ~ ;;6 ~H ~ l!D ~ ~...tIr' r Q Q lR

--;::l ~€>"1I{f:; ~ ~ 11"7 Ir' Q;J I'D

1l~ r r C;:'" I~It~ -~ ~ ~ ~--H ::jl ~ ~ ~r Ir'

~ ~~r ~~~ ~ ~ -S Q

~~ €>;;6 C;:'" ~~ "11::;

~ {f:;'" ~ ~ •.•• rI'D "7;;6 (;;6 ~ ~C;:'" {f:;0' r -" {f:;'" ~Q Q;J C"" a~ "7 e-"

-@> Ita;; c;: ~ {f:;0' ~H r.:: ~ ~;;r0' Q;J r~ r ~r "7 1ta;;;;6

,~ _~ ~ Q c:: r<~ •••• H i'l -" l!D

,11;;6 11;;6 s: "'c;: _r;;6. r \l~ -" "7 C;:, r~ ~ _ (f:; 11;;6• C""~ ~ r CO aa \l~ c;:

'lI~ r ~€> ..- ~ ~ ~~;;6 "<t "7 ~~ ~~

r ~~ r 11 1l~ HE H -C"" IVI It~ r a;;\'"' Ir' ;:1 ~ H -C""::jlIr'~~--~ ;:1-r e-" ~ 7" C')gs:: -Q;JO' ~ ~.r< a- N

GIr' Q r G~,~ ~...t;:1 ~ ~ -" <a;;

~;;r0' r ~ H ~ ~~ 11~ Q;J Ir' I'D ':l>r ~ r --;::l C;:'" Q;J IVI

-C"" ~ Ir' Ir' Q r ~;:1 ~ ••. ~ r -@> Ir'~~O~H ~ ...••r-"~~ Or

"<t ~~ re-"&: -" G;;6

"7 Q;J ~ ~ ~~ ~ i'ir ~ Ir' r 11;;6 Ir'-!C:

Ir' ~ r ;;6 ~ r"'"r",-..,\o'rQ Ir'(9; u~ G~ l!D {f:; \0' r~ H Q ;;6 ~;;r0' G~ §i~ ~"11~ ~ lr.'0' ~ -'«;;6 e-". c;: c;: r -" ~

~ ~1r'0' S ~o Ir' ;;6 ~€> ;;6CO ~ ~ H r..- r c;: Ir' {f:;

11 ~ ...•• ~ ;;6...•• r e-" rZ r ~r -Q;JO' C""e-" @> Q c;:

" 59

~nn-'l 5 f11b~~ tJ G{l'I,Un tJ..:JbU'l-baJ1Cfi1qjl'l-bbbSl:1:~Ufl113J~1ilb~'l-bb~tJ-rnf'l'l-b:"lJeJ..:J~U1'V111~m'l-b~m~nfl~~ ~eJ'l-b11..:Jb~tJ'l-b1QJUlSlbbSl:beJm.m ~ihlft'l-b:•• 'lJ 'lJ 'lJ ••

, "" d d • I •.•.•• I •• "" d ~.l 1CfieJflrnSln ~rn:'Yl'Y'l..:JlJ1:~-'lfl"lJ eJ..:Jj:.JlJ1:b3J'l-bflrn1l1'Y'l1l1tJ'l-beJn1:lillml~f'ln~1"lJ'l-b 'Y'l'l-btl'l-b'l-b1l1'Y'l~13Jq '11 q ••

h..:Jb~tJ'l-b1tU1Slh..:Jb~tJ'l-bbeJn"D''l-b•••• .:{~tI ~""

""

f1n1.€lni!J.nl.tYl \:l ~t~\:lfl ~:IilUfl113J1:CfiUfl113Jq SD.S.O.X..<t X ..<t,

. fllilb'VI'l-b flCfib'VI'l-b

1.~1'l-bflrn1i1~3JbbSl:Ufl~n1l1'Y'l

4.490.37d

4.280.483Jln 3Jln'Yl ~Iil

q

q q

2.~1'l-bfl113Ji'fl113J~3Jl1rll 'l-bm1iJ1::bij'l-b4,190,543Jln4.310.673Jln

'11 ... 1 d0.54

4.390.563,lill'l-bfl113J~3Jl1rl 'l-bm1~eJ~1 4.183Jln 3Jln

~18J

4.210.493Jln4.400.513Jln

N= 180

~nnCfil11..:J 5 'Y'lUll ~U1'V11~~rll'l-b~m~lbbSl:fl'j~~eJ'l-b1 'j..:Jb~tJ'l-bi'tUl Sl3j'Y1f'l'l-b:~eJflrn&rn~rn:~~..:JiJ1:~..:J1i1"lJ f)..:J~iJ1: bij'l-bflrn1l1'Y'l1l1 fJ'l-beJn'11 '11'11 •• q '11 q

1:~um1~n ~1.ff'l-b~'l-btl'l-b 1'l-b1l1'Y'l113JbbSl:blJ'l-b'jl !:J~l'tt'Yln~l'l-beJ~1'l-b'j:~UaJ1n•• q '11

bdeJ~~11rnlblJ'l-b11fJ~1'l-b'Y'lUll ~1'l-b~3jf11b~~!:J~..:J~1il i.~bbri ~1'l-bflrn1i~'j3JbbSl:Ufl~n1l1'Y'l (X = 4.28) 1eJ..:JSl..:J3Jli.~bbri'lJ q q q

~1'l-bfl113Ji'fl113J~3Jl'jrll'l-bm1iJ'j:bij'J,l, (X = 4.19) bbSl::~1'J,l,fl113J~3Jl'jrll'l-bm'j~eJ~1 (X = 4.18)'11.

~U~'VI11~rll'J,l,~n ~1 bbSl:fl~~ ~f) 'J,l,11-'1b~!:J'l-bbeJn"D''J,l,3j'Y1f'l'J,l,::~eJflrn&rn ~rn::~~..:JiJ~::~..:Jli1"lJ eJ..:J~iJ1: bij'l-bflrn1l1 'Y'l1l1 fJ'l-beJn1:~unl'j~n ~1'11 'lJ '11 q '11 q

.ff'l-b~'l-btl'l-b1'l-b1l1'Y'l'j13JbbSl::blJ'J,l,'jltJ~l'J,l,'Yln~l'l-beJ~l 'J,l,'j:~U3Jln•• q '11

bdeJ~~l'jrnlblJ'J,l,'jltJ~l'J,l, 'Y'lUll ~l'J,l,~3j~lbU~!:J~..:J~Cfii.~bbri ~1'l-bflrnti'j'j3JbbSl:UfI~n1l1'Y'l (X = 4.49) 'jeJ..:JSl..:J3Jli.~bbri~1'J,l,fl113J~13Jl1rl'11 q q q

1'l-bm'j~eJ~11 (X = 4.39) bbSl:~1'l-bfl113Ji'f1113J~3Jl1rll 'J,l,m'jiJ'j::bij'l-b (X = 4.31)'11

"

lfl1Th'l6

60

, ,I d I A Q.,/I A r;:;; d Q,; Q"

fl1 b% G!rJ 1i1'U,b'lJ rJ\I b'lJ'U,:lJ1~":iq)1 'U,bbG!:;":i:;~ 'lJWn:lJ fl ~ b'VI'U,bn rJ1 n 'lJmu.G! m~Hu.:;"" q

~ ~ \llh:; 1i \I vl"ll B \I ~ lh:; dJ 'U,fl nt111 ~ 111 rJ'U,B n ":i:; ~ 'lJn1 ":ifi n M1.ff 'U,;{ 'U,q)1 'U,'11 q ""

1. fl11:lJ1i111~eiB'U,'lXB:lJq

2. fl11:lJ,;)~\I hlb1J'U,3J~":in'lJ'lJflflG!...t1 LtIq

3. fl'11:lJ'iU~fl'HIU

4. fl11:lJbB1 hts(~ eJ\l1'U,bbG!:;'VI'lX1~~L~i''lJ

:lJeJ'lJ'VI:lJlrJ

5. nT'3t1~mi\ll'U,lm :lJ~"~i''lJ:lJ B'lJ'VI:lJl rJBtil\1•.. ~

fl ":i'lJrI 1 'U,1i:lJ'lJ":int'11

6. fl11:lJ hJ,*\lt1ifl":i1,;)1iB'lJ"~

7. m":itl":i1f1,;)lneJfl~bbG!:;fl11:lJa1bBtI\lt 'U,

m":itl":i:;b3J'U,

8. nl":iijb 'VIflj:..jG!bbiil::ij'V\'inq)1'U,mr'lJ~ 'U,t'U,q "" q

x

4.19

4.30

4.37

4.33

4.32

4.37

4.27

4.29

S.D.

0.66

0.63

0.56

0.56

0.63

0.63

0.78

0.63

:lJ1n

:lJ1n

:lJ1n

,••.•••.•aB'U,f1'lJ'YI

19

10

3

6

9

3

16

11

'.

..a A d.::t 6"Q../I

9. m":i:lJ1i"lJ111~,;)fl'YIfl Bl":i:lJ nt:lJ'U,fl\l bbiil:;q

1i1 :lJ1":irlfl1'lJfl:lJ Bl":i:lJ nt"ll B\lfl'U,b B\I"~q

4.28 ,~ 0.74 1~

-nflbbrJ\I

11. m":ii'nM1,yB:lJiiI~b1J'U,fl11:lJi'lJ"lleJ\I'11

""

1irl1'U,flnMl

12. m":i":i1 rJ\l1'U,i\l~f'i''U, ~'lJfl1:lJfl11:lJ b1J'U,,;)~\I

Bti1\1.,rfl b';)'U,

13. nl":i1.l~Uilfl1:lJ":i:;djrJ'lJ,y eJtI~Ui"llB\I

1i:lJfI. Btil\1fl":i'lJn1'U,1i:lJ'lJ":irnfll :lJ~"~i''lJ'11

:lJBU'VI:lJlrJ

4.24

4.39

4.35

4.33

0.77

0.58

0.62

0.61

:lJ1n 17

1

5

6

14. ~dl~~ul~lunl~~~iul~~~~~nl~

ll~::biiu il<i1~~<ill~,j'fl~ SlbbSl::~fl~~afl~'lI

ca" cr"d Q.o<

nlJbVl<ilm~nt'YI~lJ~UUq q

15. nl~ll~lJ~d i.~~lmllJm~bll~[JUbbll~~iu

<ilflulunl'':i'Yh~lu

16. m~bb~~~b~<ilUl~~rn~3.1~atulum~q

1l~::biiUbblJlJfl ~[J1ntii<il~

17. nl~i.3.1bbw:l~V11~Slll~::t[J"ll'UV1.o:s-fl'th1i~n~q

~ul<i11um~<iI~d~b~[J~bb~::m~ll~::biiu

mUJlTrUll [JUflnq

18. m~~[J~lu~~nl~ll~::biiubi~GfhJ~fld '" '" d

b~B~dl~nldVlUl~fl~~nlUfln~l

19. m~llnilB~bbSl::fhit~~~i'YI~tnUlJ~~Slq

1UfllU~B bff[J~bb~::~dl~ll~ B~.n[J~B~

~nnll~biiu'lI'l1'.

N= 180

61

x

4.28

4.21

4.33

4.38

4.28

4.28

4.31

s.o.

0.62

0.66

0.63

0.76

0.55

0.62

'.

0.48

~ln

~ln

~ln

~ln

~ln

~ln

~ln

12

18

6

2

12

12

~ln<ill~l~ 6 ~lJil ~lJ~V11~~nlUfln~lbbSl::~~~~flUih1flU::lf\ fl~nttrn'Mnt::'lI 'lI'lI q, '" '"

d~ 01 6"" Vtl A Q.oI .dt Q..o A ""'YI~~ u~::~~~~B~~ ~::b~U~ntfll~fll[JUfln ~::<illJnlWIn~l~U~UqjlU<illU~nt1i~':l~ bbSl::'lI q •• q

lJ~tinfll~ 1Ufll~~d~bbSl::~[J,j' fl'YIn,j'f)elcilU':l::~lJ~lnq q 'lI

b~flb~[J~t1l1~lJ~nttrn 'Mnt::~~~1l':l::~~fl~ fl~Hll':l::biiu~ UlJll~fll [JUfln <ill~ 'YiflU::q 'lI q

~B~~lJ~V1l':l~nlUfln~lbb~::~':l~~flU ~lJ';h,j'fl~iifilbli:t~[J~~~~ 5 aU~lJbb':ln i.~bbri'lI \ 'lI 'lI 'lI q

m~~n~l,jfl~Sl~btJU~dl~trlJ~B~~nlUfln'Ml (X = 4.39) nl~i.3.1bb~d~V11~Slll~::1[J"ll'UV1~fl'lI

'I'111pn~~u 1~ 1Unl~<iI':ld~ b~ [JmbSl::nl':lll':l::biiu~ ntfll~fll [JUfln (X = 4.38)

~dl~~lJ~~"ll'fllJ (X = 4.37) ~dl~ 1tH~1~<iI~d~~BlJi.fl (X = 4.37) bbSl::nT':i':ll[J~lU

~~~~U~lJ<ill~~dl~btJU~~~flcil~i~b~U (X = 4.35)

62

1. fl11:IJiUlTruiel'U,zEnJ•

2. fl11:IJ"i~,'Jhdj'Uiifl'nluuflflfl •

vr11tl

3. fl11:IJ~U~f1"lfelU

'I 'I • 0 '" 0=14. fl11:IJLel1 ~"i~ffflel,'Jl'ULLfl:'PI'Ul'Yl

0=1111 "' ••.•'Yl~f1'nJ:lJelU'PI:lJlt1

.IA""",, 0=1111 "' ••.•5. nl'i"uL]UfI,'Jl'Uf11:IJ'Yl Lf1'i"U

:IJelU'PI:lJlt1 elr.ll,'Jfl'i"utlTU

x

4.09

4.26

4.33

4.24

S.D.

0.59

0.65

0.47

0.52

:lJln I 4.26

:lJln 14.32:lJln 4.39

:IJ1n I 4.39

S.D.

0.70

0.62

0.62

0.57

•...

'i":f1U

fl11:IJfif1L~'U

:lJln

:lJln

:lJln

:IJ1n

..ff:IJU'i"m

••

6. fl11:IJ ttl1,'J tfffl'i"1"i ffelULfl

7. nl'i"tl'i1fl"ilnelfl91LLfl:fl11:IJ

~1 LatI,'J1'Unl'i"tl'i":Lii'U

4.30 I 0.554.35 0.60

4.26 I 0.74

:lJln

:lJln

:lJln

4.32

4.38

4.28

0.68

0.66

0.80

:lJln

:lJln

:lJln

........8. nl'i":lJL'PIflj:.jflLLfl::IJ'PIflnil'U....

ffUU i'fU 'U1'Unl'i"th:Lii'U•et .::It. dA r(

9. nl'i":lJtnl111W"ifl'Ylf1 ell'i":lJm•

4.24 \1 0.60 :lJln 4.32 '" 0.64 :IJ1n "

•...

:IJ'Ufl,'JLLfl:ff1:1J1'i"flfl1Ufl:IJ•

ell'i":IJm"llel,'J91'ULel,'Jlti'a ~ d jQ,

10. fl11:IJtnI:lJLtlelnbtl'U L:lJelLj:.j"lfnl••••

••"lIel,'Jffm'Uflm~n

~ d .•...12. nlTIlt1,'Jl'Uff,'J'Ylfl'UWU911:IJ

fl11 :lJLU'U"i~,'Jelr.ll,'J,ff1 L"i'U

13. nl'i"tliJUfl911:IJ'i":::LUtlUiTel

tliJUi"llel,'J ff:IJfl.elr.ll,'Jfl'iUn1'U

•• 0=1111 "' ••.•ff:IJU'i"m911:IJ'YlLf1'i"U:lJelU'PI:lJlt1••

4.26

4.26

4.39

4.35

4.33

0.71

0.71

0.54

0.57

0.52

:IJ1n

:IJ1n

:IJ1n

:IJ1n

:IJ1n

4.28

4.23

4.39

4.35

4.34

0.77

0.80

0.62

0.65

0.67

:IJ1n

:lJln

:lJln

:IJ1n

:IJ1n

63

S.D.xS.D.x

14. m1:lJ~'U.hh4m~i~ti'U.hCl\l

t:J~m~tl~::L3J'U.11f1~\1f11:lJ,jeJ:lJ~'ll••••.•• 6'

LL~::a'eJ~f1~eJ\ln1JL'P\f1m~t\l,q

d •...'Yla''U.1Ja''U.'U. I 4.22 I 0.55•

15. n1~tl~1Ji1'~J1~n1Jd .-

m~Ltl ~£J'U.LLtl~\I,)'U.f1eJ'U.

l'U.m~'Yi1\11'U. I 4.09 I 0.63

6'.1, l. 116. m~LLa'~\IL"ifl'U.1~:lJt\l,'Yl:lJ\I:lJ'U.'U.q

m~tl~::L3J'U.LL1J1Jn~mt\l,3JfI~ I 4.26 I 0.65

17. m~':i.iLLa'1\1'P\1t:J~tl~d£J~,r

•• 0 Ad'l'l'P\~a'Yl11f'5n"iia'U.b~ b'U.q

d .1 Am~f1~1"i L£J~:lJLL~:;m~u~:;L:lJ'U.

f1t\l,1l1~1l1£J'U.an I 4.28 I 0.72q

:lJ1n

:lJ1n

mn

:lJ1n

4.32 I 0.66

4.28 I 0.67

4.38 I 0.61

4.45 I 0.78

:lJ1n

:lJ1n

:lJ1n

:lJ1n

'.••

"lIa\la'f:l1'U.f1n'M\I I 4.22 I 0.51 '.19. m~tlniJa\lLL~:;fhil\lCl\ltiY1~

ff1'U.1JflfI~1'U.~l'U.;mR£J\I LL~:;•

m1:lJtl~a~.n£J"lIa\l~rlntl~:;L3J'U. I 4.20 I 0.65'll'll

:lJ1n

mn

4.32 I 0.58 I'.

4.34 I 0.60

mn

mn

4.26 I 0.42 :lJ1n 4.33 I 0.51 mn

N= 180

"illn~ndl.J 7 ~u"h ~U~'VIl"Him'U,ftmY1ii'Ylff'U,::~ Bfl rnim~m4:~~.Jtl~:: a'.J~"lIeJ.J'll q

~tl~:dj'U,fl rn.n1~.nl ~'U,Bn ~:iUn1~ftm.~n.ff'U, ~'U,qjl'U, ~l'U,fl rnll~"a:mb &:I:Ufl ~ n .nl~qJ q • q. q

1'U,.n1~"a13Jbb&:l:dl[J;rB'Ym,jeleltil 'U,~:iu3J1nq 'll

b~Bb~[J.Jlihiufl rnin 1Yrn:~~.Jtl"a:ti.J~"lI B.J~lh:bil'U,m\un~.n1 ~ 'U,Bn lQn3.1rlff'U,:q 'll q

"llB.J~U~'VI1~titl1'U,ftn1Y1 ~u'-h;rel~iifi1Vil.~[Jti.Jti~ 5 el'U,~Ubb"an"~bbfi m~i'n1Y1,yel3J&:I~dJ'U,'ll 'll q 'lJ

fl113Jiu"llel.Jl.nl1'U,ftn1Yl (X = 4.39) fl113J1tl1.Jlti~~1"iltiBU"~ (X = 4.35) m"a"al[J.Jl'U,~.J~

64

~'U,'VfjJ~1:IJfl11:1.Jblh.I,';ij~.:Jfl£h.:Ji~H';ij'U,(X = 4.35) fl11:IJi''lJ~~·lHl'lJbb~:U?j~~1:IJ~:dhJ'lJ

,] BUiJ~"ll B.:J ~:lJfl. Bci1.:JfI~m11'U,~:IJ\!~nt~1:IJ~j,~i''lJ:IJB'lJVI:lJ1IJ (X = 4.33) bb~:

m~uiJUi.:J1'U,~1:IJ~b~i''lJ:lJB'lJ'V\:IJ1IJBci1.:JfI~'lJi11'U,~:IJ\!~nt(X = 4.30)

fI~~ ~B'U,r,'Y1fl'U,:~BfI rninMrn:~~.:JU~:~.:Jfl"ll B.:J~U~: baJ'U,fIrnl11'YUl1IJ'U,Bn<u<u q <u q

~:~'lJn1~fim~n.ffwi~''U,qj1'U,~1'U,fIrnfi~~:lJbb~:'lJflanl11'~ 1'U,111'W~1:IJbb~:~1t1,rBrm,] BBrit 'U,•• q q q Cl!

b~ Bb~t1.:J~1~'lJfI rni n Mrn:~ ~ .:JU~:~.:Jfl"ll B.:J~U~: baJ'U,fIrn111'W111tI 'U,Bnq <u q

~1:IJ'Y1fl'U,:"llB.:JfI~~~B'U,'W'lJ';h,rB~r,fi1bu~t1~.:J~~5 B'U,~'lJbb~n i.~bbn n1~i.3.ibb~1.:JVl1<u<u '11 q

.1 t ... "'. A A'!'! d .1"~ ~lJ~: IJ~'U, V\'~El'Yl1fi~n';ijEl'U,bt'lb'U,n1"a~·n';ijbtJIJ:lJbb~:n1"alJ"a:b:IJ'U,fIrn111'Y4111IJ'U,Elnq q

(X = 4.45) fl11:IJi''lJ~~''15B'lJ(X = 4.39) fl11:IJbB1hh~9iB.:J1'U,bb~:WU1~~'~i''lJ:IJB'lJVI:lJ1tI

(X = 4.39) n1~i'nM1,rEl:IJ~~dJ'U,fl11:IJi'lJ"llEl.:!~tl1'U,finM1 (X = 4.39) fl11:IJtui.:!l~'11

~~1';ij~B'lJ'~ (X = 4.38) bb~:fl11:IJ~:lJbtiBm~'U,b~m~iqJn'lJfl11:IJ;r~bb~.:! (X = 4.38)

~ , ,I .c::t Id •••• A ~ .et Q,otI ~A

fl1 bu~IJ ~1'U,b'lJt1.:!b'lJ'U,:lJ1~~qj1'U,bb~:~:t'I'lJfl11:IJflt'IbVI'U,bnIJTYlfl'U,:"llEl.:!~1J~Vl1~• <u

~tl1'U,fin M1 fI~~ ~B'U,t~.:!b~IJ'U,i'qj'lJ1~bb~:bBn"15'U,~r,'Y1fl'U,:9iBflrninMrn:~CUCU'" q

~.:!U~: ~.:!fl"ll El.:!~U"a: baJ'U,fIrn111'W111t1'U,Bn ~:~'lJn1~fln M1.ff'\.l,'~''U,qj1'U,'11 q ••

S.D.XS.D.X"

1. fl11:IJR111'Y48el'U,U£l:IJ 14.15 I 0.68•

2. fl11:IJ"i~\1hdj'UiJfl·Hl'lJ'lJt'lt'l~•

Yi'11tl I 4.27 I 0.64

3. fl11:IJi''lJi4t'1'tl'fl'lJ I 4.33 I 0.57

'I 'I • , •• "I4. t'l11:IJLalL"iLRflEl\ll'ULL~:::'V\'UTY1

,,1111 •.•••••'YILfl';j'lJ:lJEl'lJ'V\:IJ1£J I 4.32 I 0.56

5. m';jtlDUt1\11'Ufll:IJ~1~i''lJ

:IJfl'lJ'V\:IJ1£Jfltil\1t'l';j'lJn1'U

:IJ1n

4.47 I 0.52

4.53 I 0.524.60 0.51

4.40 I 0.51

:IJ1n

:IJ1n

4.33 I 0.60 :IJ1n 420 I 0.86 :IJ1n

65

x x S.D.

•..':i::flU

m1:IJflfl Ll\ 'U.

:lJ1n

0.59

0.52

0.63

0.64

4.53

4.60

4.73

4.47

:lJ1n

mn

0.61

0.64

0.79

4.35

4.23

4.23.......8. m':i:IJL'VI9I~·laLLa:::IJ'VIami1'U....

£fUU £f'U.'U.1'U.m':ilh::Lii'U.••• •• ..I•• .-

9. m':i:IJ\flJ1l1Vf~91'Y1fl B1':i:IJUl.••..:IJ'U.fl-llLLa::ff1 :lJ1':i"mUfl:IJ•

m':i:IJm"llB-Il9l'U.LB-Illti I 4.24 I 0.77

a ~ .d A10. fl11:IJ\flJ:lJLEJBnLEJ'U.L:lJm~~nJ.. .,

6. fl11:IJ hJi-ll h'91':iT~£fBUlti

7. m':itl':i1f11";l1nBflt1LLa::

m1:IJ~1 L8EJ-Illum':il.h::Lii'U.

nUm1:IJ..uflLLrj'-Il I 4.22 I 0.80

"'" •.. d .fl Go;11.n1':i':in~"lIB:lJa'YILu'U.fl11:IJau'lI

"lIB-Il£fm'U.fln~ I 4.35 I 0.59~ d •..

12. m':i':i1EJ-Il1'U.£f-ll'YIfl'U.'ViU9I1:IJ

fl11:IJLtJ'U.~~-IlBci1-1li'flL~'U. I 4.33 I 0.61

13. m':il.li.ju"i9l1:IJ':i::djEJu"limJi.j~

mn

:lJ1n

mn

4.40

4.67

4.47

0.51

0.49

0.64

:lJ1n

:lJ1n

, '" .-

'. "lIB-Il £f:IJfII.BEJ1-1lfl':iUf:I1'U.£f:IJ\I':itll

d"l ",,,,911:IJ'YILfl':iU:lJBU'VI:lJ1EJ

14. fl11:IJ~'U.1";l1'U.n1':iifl~'U.1";ln-ll

~ a mW':i::Lii'U. 1191':i-ll9l1:IJ"liB:IJa'11

4.32 0.63 mn 4.40 0.51

4.25 I 0.63 4.47 0.52

q"" 6'd Q...o

nUL'VI91m ':iUl.'YI£f'U.U£f'U.'U.••

15. n1w~ui11ti~1EJnud '"

m':iLl.l a EJ'U.LLl.la-ll..u'U.91B'U.l'U.

m':i'YI1-1l1'U. I 4.23 I 0.67

.-..1, .;" 116. m':iLL£ffl-llL";l9l'U.1':i:IJUl.'YI:IJ-Il:IJ'U.'U.•

mn 4.07 0.59

mn 4.47 0.52 mn

66

x x S.D.

17. n1~L:Utta'1\ll'\1j:.jfl1.h:1EJ"J5,rl'\1eJ

o "" d 1 1 d'Yl11i~mm.1.~ 'U.n1~91~T;JtEJEJ3Jq

tt fl ::n1~lh::dj 'U.flnl.1l1~q

1l1EJ'U.eJn

18. n1~~1EJ\l1'U.j:.jfln1~lh::dj'U.t~-1

4.30 I 0.77 4.93 0.26d

3J1n'Yla'91q

a'tn 'U.flm~1 I 4.26 I 0.56

19. n1~tlnileJ-1Ufl::fhit\li1..1tm~

. 1 '" d ,cla'1'U.1Jfl fl fl 'U.911'U."J5m a'EJ-1Ufl::q

m13JtlfleJ91.ntJ~eJ\l~flntl,)::tii'U. I 4.26 I 0.64'lI'l1

~13J I 4.28 I 0.48

N= 180

3J1n

3J1n

3J1n

4.47 I 0.52

4.47 I 0.52

4.49 I 0.37

mn

3J1n

3J1n

"iI1nWl1':i1'l 8 vnrh ~U~'VI1':itnn'U.flm~1LL~::fl':i~tn)'u)h'lL~El'U.i'~U1~ih1Fl'U.::cu CU«U"

~ ElflmtTh Mm::~~'l1h:: a'ltl"ll El.:!~1h:: iij'U.fl m.fl1'VUl1 El'U.Eln ':i::~uri'1':ifln M1.ff 'U.~'U.~1'U. '.q 'lI q dO

~1'U.flm1i':i':i3JLt~::Ufl~n.fll'W 1'U..fl1Vi':il:lJLL~::tU'U.':i1mJ el'Y1n-nElEl~1'U.':i::iU:lJ1nq q q 'lI

trl Elt~m ~1~Ufl manMnt::~~.:!lh::a.:!tl"ll El.:!~tl':i::tiJ'U.fl nl,.fl1Vi.fl1 El'U.Bn W11:lJ'YlFl'U.::q 'lI q

"lIB.:!~U~'VI1':iarr1'U.flnM1Lt~::fl':i~aB'U. h.:!L~t1'U.i'~ul~ Viuil-n B~iifil tu~t1a.:!a~ 5 B'U.~Utt ':in'lI 'lI 'lI dO 'lI q

i.~uri fll1:lJhh.:!laWl':il"i1aBUl~ (X = 4.35) fll1:lJi'U~~"J5BU (X = 4.33) n1':iU~~.:!1'U.

W11:lJ~i.~i'U:lJBU'VI:lJlt1B~l.:!fl':iurl'l'U.a:lJU':irr! (X = 4.33) m':i':ilt1.:!l'U.~.:!~fi'U.ViUWll:lJ'U

fl113J tU'U."iI~'lEl~1.:!,r~ t"il'U. (X = 4.33) fl113JtB1 h 1~~B.:!1'U.tt~::wiX1~~b~i'U3J BU'VI:lJ1tI

(X = 4.32) u~::n1':iU~1MWl1:lJ':i::tUtlU-nElU~1M"lIEl'l a:lJFl. B~1.:!fl':iurl'1'U.a:lJ\!':irr!W11:lJ~b~

3JElU'VI:lJlt1(X = 4.32)

~U~'VI1':iarr1'U.fln M1tt~::fl':i t':i.:!t~t1'U.tBn"J5'U.ii'YlFl'U.::~Bfl man Mnt::~~.:!U':i::a.:!tl"ll El'I'lI 'lI q

~ U':i:: t iJ 'U.flm.fl 1 Vi.fll tI 'U.Bn ':i:: ~U nl':ifln Ml.ff 'U.~ 'U.~1'U.~1'U.flm])':i':i:lJ tt ~::U fl ~ n.fll ViqJ q • q q

1'U..fllVi':i13Jttfil::bU'U.':i1t1-nB~l'U.l 'VIlli B~1'U.':i::~U3J1n iiU1.:!-n Bi.~tni fll1:lJ"iI~'l h tu'U.iJWI':inu'" 'lI

Uflflfilrtl i.u fll1:lJi'U~~"J5ElU nl':iU':ilFl"illn Bfl~ttfil::fll1:lJtht~t1.:! 1'U.nl':iU':i::tiJ'U. nl':iiit 'V\W1~filq q

67

~~&l::ii'V\imi1u~'I!u~u U1um~lh::dJU m~ii ~lll'V'l~til~t1 en~lmritufl':Ib~&l::~l ~l~nfllUfl~• q q q

e:n~~rn"1JEl\ltilU~el.:Jl~ m~~mYl"1l El~&l~~ilUflll~~U"1J El\l~nlUflmYl ~~&l::nl~hh~~l\l'V\l'lJ

t:-J&l'l.h::t~"15" 'V\~mljl1i~n~~ultill um~til~l~~fl~m~&l::m~lh::~iium\l,lll'V'llll ~UEln EltilU~::~Uq q 'lJ

d~ln'Yl~til

q

~rlEl~~~\l~l~Ufl nb~n 'lYrn::~~\llh:: ~..:Jfl"1JEl..:J~ll~::~iiUfl nblll'V'llll ~UEln till ~ 'YiflU::q 'lJ q

"1JEl..:JaU~'V\l~~nlUfln'lYl~~&l::fl~a~ElUh..:J~~~u~Eln"15U'V'lUil"1lEl~iifil ~u~ ~ ~\l ~~ 5 auim~ ~n'lJ 'lJ'lJ 'lJ q

l~bbri nl~t3Jbb~l..:J'V\lt:-J&lll~::t~"15\f 'V\~El'Yil1i~n~~ul~ 1Um~til~l~ ~m~~bb&l::m~ll~::~iiuq

flnblll'V'llll~UEln (X = 4.93) m~ii~'V\tilt:-J&l~~&l::ii'V\~n~u~'I!u~uulum~ll~::~iiu (X = 4.73)q q. q

nl~~n'lYl,rB~~~~iJUflll~iu"1Ja..:J~nlUfln'lYl (X = 4,67) fl1l~i'U~~"15BU (X = 4.60)'lJ

m~1l~1f1~lnBfl~bb&l::fl1l~~1~m~..:J1um~ll~::~iiu (X = 4.60)

.•... .rLL&i::f11U\I"ll'flnl.f11'Vi•

o .d ••••

2. m~f1aUfl1rn~Lnr.nn1J3J1f1~.!1'ULL&i::

.... ·.r.dl ":'I 1.1 A"" .....f111J\1"ll''Yl"ll'L'Um~ ~::UJ'ULflarn\l"ll'flL,'U

dAd 1.1 A.d3. m~3J1tm1~ -a::L3J'U'Yl'V\&i1ml&i1[J

4. m~diu~1U~13J"lia3Ji.'r'i1nLL 'V\~\I9i1\16J"~'lJ

mh\l'V\&i1n'V\&i1[J

"lia3J1,'l"~rJnYia\l'lJ 'lJ

••.•~ d7. m~,flU'U'Ylm 'Viam-afl~1''iltfaU~1[J\l1'U

f1~\InUm13Jbll'U,~\1

X

4.22

4.20

4.09

4.15

4.22

4.19

S.D.

0.67

0.72

0.76

0.75

0.70

0.73

3J1n

3J1n

3J1n

3J1n

•••••••• .dEl'UflU'Yl

6

8

14

12

6

9

68

lA"''''8. fl"'Jl:IJft'1:iJ1'iCl'Um'i1Lfl'i1:::'VI"lltl:IJ~'lI

9. fl11:IJft'1:iJ1'iCll'Um'i1.h:::L3J'ULL~:::tl'itl~~•

l'UflTVi'i1:IJ

10. fl11:IJft'1:IJ1'iCll'Um'itl'itltl'i:::Lfl'U•

'UIL~'U - "iflfie:I£JLfitl:IJL'VI91tl:IJ~~•••

1 .• "".11. fl11:IJft'1:IJ1'iCl'Um'iL"ll£J'U'i1£h'l1'U"Jl\'1tl£J'lI

g.o d'l •...Q"of AU'U~l'U"lltl:IJ~nLfl'iUnl'i~"il'iml•• 'lI

mh\!'itlUfl'itlU

12. m'itl'itl~~m'i91'i1"iL~£J:lJLfi91'i\!tl'i:::Lfl'U•o G..oO • .:f

911:IJLnm'YIU~:::911U\!1r

1 1"'''' od13. fl11:IJft'1:IJ1'iCl'Um'i 'VI"lltlLtl'UtlLL'U:::n

m\! tl'i'ifl1fl £J~fli tl:IJ~LL~:::'VI~n~l'ULu'U'VI~fi'lI ••

14. fl11:IJft'1:IJ1'iCll'Un1'iliitlLtl'UmL'U:::

••• od ofl 111.1111'" ", •••n1'i~f.U'UlnLlJ'U LlJLflU~::tltlflfl~tl\!nUtlfll~

x

4.28

4.18

4.29

4.12

4.17

4.27

4.27

4.25

4.21

S.D.

0.61

0.67

0.61

0.60

0.68

6.63

0.62

0.66

0.56

:lJlfi

:iJ1fi

:lJlfi

:lJlfi

:lJlfi

:iJ1n

:lJlfi

:lJln

:lJln

••••..• od

tl'UfllJn

2

10

1

13

11

3

3

5

N= 180'.

I 'IV A d l}..oI &:t Q"ol I Q..<o d~ln ~l'il \I 9 'ViU11~U'i'V\l'itHl1'Uf'ln Ml bbiil::fl'HHHIU:IJ'Ylf'lU::~Bfl nu~m~HlI,::'Yl'lI 'lI'lI'

w.:Jlh::ff\lfl"ll B\I~lh::dJUfl nlJ11'Vi!l1 t1UBn 'i::iUfi1'ifln Ml.ffU~Uq;lU~lUfl11:IJ~fl11:IJ ff1:IJ1'ifl~ q • ~

1Ufi1'ilh::dJU 1U!l1'Vi":i1:IJbbiil::'i1t1-nB'Yln-nBmJlU'i::iU:lJln• 'lI

b~Bb~t1\1~l~Umll,~n Mnt::fiw\ll.h:: ff\lfl"ll B\I~lh::biJUfl nlJ11'Vi!l1t1UBn ~1 :lJrlf'lU::• 'lI q

"lIB\I~ U~'V\l'i L'Hl1Ufl n Ml bbiil::fl 'i~ ffB '" 'Viu'h-n Bfi ij fil bu~ tI ff \Ifffl 5 eruiUbb":in i. ~ bbri'lI 'lI 'lI 'lI q

fl11:IJffl:IJ1'ifll Unl":il.h::biJUUiil::ff1U ~ iill U!l1'Vi":i1:IJ (X = 4.29) nl'i~flU'\.l,'nm ~ B

nl'i~'i1~ffBU'ilt1\11U~'i\lnUfl11:1JbllU~~\I (X = 4.28) nl'iff'iU~iilnl'i~'i1~b~tI:IJi.~q

~":i\lU":i::b~U~l:IJbnnl,.nbbiil::i1'U\l;f (X = 4.27) fl11:IJffl:IJ1'ifllunl'ili-nmffumbu::fi

ff~l\1ff":i'ifl1fltl~fl-nB~iilbbiil::'V\in!lubll'\.l,'V\in (X = 4.27) fl11:IJff1:IJ1'ifllufi1":iliimrnmm::

fi1'iWVllUlfibllui.ui.~bbiil::ffBflfl~B\lnUfffll'Vi"llB\lfffll,"flnMl (X = 4.25)

o/Il~l~ 10

69

..I a I a Q..oI a. ~ a Q..oO Q..oo' Q,.iA

fllbu~ ~ fflUblW~ blm:lJ1o/1~qjlUbb~:;~:;o/I1Jflll:JJflo/lb'VIUbn ~ln1J'Ylf'lU:;"1I fJ~~1J~'VI1~. ~

ff{Jl ut;n:IYl bb~:;fl~~ fffJ U~ fJfl rn~ n :lYrn:;~.w ~1.h:;ff~~"1I fJ~~1.h:;b~Ufl rn111 'Vi~~ q ~ q

111~UBn ~:;1i11Jm~t;n:IY1.ffu~UqjlU'i11Uflll:JJ~flll:JJ ff1:JJ~{J1um~l.h:;biju. ~

x S.D.

•..~:~uml3Jfl~b~'U.

x S.D.

4.24 I 0.74

fi'" Q.,.oo I ~~13Jbnnl."Y1ua:911U..1~flnUn'V'lI 4.17 I 0.64

q

• ..I •••2. nl':i91fJUfl1tl13Jbntl1nU

•... .r.d, o}l3J191':it1'U.LLa:911U..1~'YlL~L'U.•m':i'Lh:b3j'U.'timh..1,r~b"'U. I 4.15 I 0.67

dAA •...•.1 A d3. n1~3J11im-;}lJ~:b3J'U'Yl

'VIa1n'VIa1t1 I 4.15 I 0.73

4. m':ibnU':i1U~13J-na3Ja'11

.•lmL 'VI~..1fi1..1'J 'timh..1

'VIfl1n'VIfl1t1

:U1n

3J1n

3J1n

3J1n

4.26

4.23

4.05

4.09

0.68

0.75

0.77

0.76

:U1n

3J1n

3J1n......5. m':i3JL'Ylfl'U.flm~bnUTIU~1:U

l).oI d '\LoI do a " •..."lIfJ3Ja'Ylt1n91fJ..1/L~BnaL~'11 '11

d6. m~~fJml3J'VI:U1t1"l1fJ..1

m':iLnu-nfJ:ua I'11

LL'VI~..1-nfJ:Ufl'tin n9i'fJ..1'11 '11

•.. '" d7. m':i"~U'U.'Ylm'V'lB

n1':i91~1.•~aU~1t1..11'U.

9l~..1nUml3JLiJ'U..•~..1

, .....8. fl11:U~:U1':in L'Um~1Lfl':i1:'VI

-nfJ3JfI'11

"

4.17 I 0.68

4.07 I 0.71

4.15 I 0.56

4.15 I 0.63

3J1n

3J1fi

3J1fi

3J1fi

4.24

4.27

4.35

4.20

0.72

0.73

0.63

0.70

3J1n

:U1fi

3J1fi

70

•...

~::fl1J

ml3JtlflL ~'US.D.xS.D.x

9. ml3J813Jl1TllunT':il.h"::L3J'U

LL~::ft"nJ~~l'U1l1'Vfn3Jq

10. ~113J813Jl~~1'Unl~~~Uq

U~::Lt1'U''iflLfi'U- ~flfiEl£J••

'fi~3JL'VIfI~3J~~q

11. ml3J813Jl~~ l'Un1~L;j£J'U.4, '"

~1 £J-ill'U"1l'-iIEl£J1J'Uil'U"lIEl3J~..........cl" •..••... A I'YILfI~1Jm~'Vf;)I~nl.1El£l1-i1

4.24

4.07

0.57

0.53

3Jln

mn

4.32

4.15

0.64

0.63

3Jln

3Jln

":i"El1J~":i"El1J

12. n1~~U~~n1~f1~1~L£1£J3J'fiq

f1~';!U":i"::Lt1'Ufll3JLn nI..n

4.11 0.64 3Jln 4.20 0.70 3Jln

•... , .rLL~::f111J-i1'!l"

13. ml3J813Jl~~l'Un1~li

4.26 0.57 3Jln 4.27 0.67 3Jln

'" d '""lIElLmElLL'U::'YI~';!

~~ 1f1£J~fli El3J~LL~::'l'Ian il '"......dJ'U'I1Ian

14. ml3J81m~~l'Un1~li

4.24.. I 0.71 mn 4.28.. 0.56 .- 3Jln '.

'" •..."lIElL~'UmL'U::m~'ViiU'U1

.y1 LU'U'u'fiLL~::~Elfl~ ~El,;!

4.28 0.72

4.18 0.52

3Jln

3Jln

4.23

4.23

0.63

0.58

:l.nn

mn

N= 180

"'iJlnlfll~-J 10 'Vilr:h ~1J~'VI1~tnn'UflmYI5j'Ylt'l'U::'ii Bflmam~nc;fi~-Ju~::;a"-J~"LI B-J••• q

~u~::;Lih~fl rnllTVml rJuBn~::iunl~flm~n.ff'U ~U~U~T\.tfllll1ffllll1 a"1:JJl~bll um~lh:: dJ U••• q •••••

1U111'Vi~1:JJLL~::~r.J"1rel'Yln,rBBril U~::;iu:JJ1nq •••

L3.1BbirJ-JthiUfl manMnc;fi~-Ju~::;a"-J~'1I B-J~th::dJUfl rnlll'Vi111 rJU Bn Vll:JJ'Ylt'lU::;q ••• q

'1IB-J~u~'vn~a"rnUflnMl 'ViUil,rBfi5jfilLu~rJa"-Ja"fI 5 aU~ULL~n"~LLri flll:JJa"I:JJTmlu•••••• q

nl~a"1:JJ1~bll ~oiJBLa-UBLLu::;m~.w~u lfi LUU"U"~LLGl::;a"Bflfl tr B-Jnu a"111'Vi"LIB-Ja"bllUfln Ml

71

(X = 4.28) m~a"·:nJ~~m~~~l~bfltl1Jj,~~l':i-1l.l~:b~:hl,~l1Jmmsnbb~:~lti-1:§ (X = 4.26)q

nl~dl'U~TIJ~l1J-n B1J~~lmb'VIsi-1~l-1".Ij,~mh-1'V1~ln'VI~ltl (X = 4.24) flll1Ja"l1Jl~bll U'lJ

nl~1.l~:dJUbb~:a"~1.l~~lu111'W~11J (X = 4.24) flll1Ja"l1Jl~bllunl~lV;-nBba"UBbb'\.l,:~q

a"~\,'j~~fl1~ tl[j~,j B1J~bb~:'VIimilubllu 'VIin m~~Bflll1J'VI1Jltl"1JB-1m~bn'U-nB1J~/bb'VIlii-1-n B1J~'lJ dO 'lJ 'lJ

j,~rm~B-1 (X = 4.24)'lJ

fl":i~a"BUih1f1U:~Bflmim~rn:~W-1l.l~:a"-1fl"1JB-1~1.l~:dJUfl m111'W111tlU Bn~:~'U'lJ 'lJ q 'lJ q

nl~flnMl.ffu ~U~lU~lUflll1Ji'flll1Ja"l1Jl~bll um~l.l~:dJu 1U111'W~11Jbb~:~ltl-n B'Ym-n BdO 'lJ q

BcilU~:~'U1Jln'lJ

b~Elb~tl-:J~l~'Ufl man Mrn:.yIw-:Jtl~::a"-:Jff"1JEl-:J~tl":i::bihl,fl nUll 'Wll1 EJUf)n ~n 1J""flU::;q 'lJ q

"1JEl-1fl":i~a"ElU'W'U';h-nEl~iifilbu~tla"-1a"~5 Bufi'Ubb":in '~bb1i nl":i~~iJuYim~Elnl":i~":il~a"B'U'lJ'lJ 'lJ q

":i1EJ-11U~":i-1n'Uflll1JbllU~~-1(X = 4.35) flll1Jal1Jl":ibll Unl":itl":i::bDubba::a"":itl~a1U111'W":i11Jq

(X = 4.32) flll1Ja"l1Jl":ibll unl":il V;,jBba"UBbbU:~a"i'l-1a"":i":if11f1tl[jfl,jEl1J~bb~:'VIin~lU'lJ dO

bllu'VIin (X = 4.28) m":i~Elflll1J'VI1J1EJ"1JB-1m":ibn'U,jf)1JCl/bb'VIlii-1,jmJCl'~bln~El-1(X = 4.27)'lJ 'lJ 'lJ

nl":ia'1tl~anl":i~":il~brlEJ1Jj,~~":i-1tl":i::btiu~l1JmmsnuCl::~TU-1*(X = 4.27)

I .J. • d Q,oI A ~ d IQ; l).,oI,Q.

~l":il-1 11 fll buatl a"lUb'UEJ-1b'UU1Jl~":i~lUbbCl::":i::f1'Uflll1Jflflb'VIum tlTYlflU::"1JEl-1~'U":i'VI1":idO 'lJ

a"bllUfln Ml fl":i~ a"BU1":i-1b~tlUi'~'Ula UCl::bEln1l'U~ii""f1u::~ E1flmin Mm::~~~. q

W-11h::a"-1fl"1JE1-1~1.l":i::bDuflW11'W111tlUf) n ":i::i'Unl":ifln ~l,rU ~U~lU~lUflll1Ji'qJ q • cv

flll1Jal1Jl":ibll Unl":il.l":i::bDu

X S.D.

•...

':i::;fllJ

~rn:IJtiflL~lI. X S.D.

•...

':i::;fllJ~ ~

fll1:IJfl~H'VIlI.

flnLfJ1Wq

od •...2. nl':iflfllJfllrn:lJbnEldfilJ

.... , .fdl '.'l:lJlf1':iill1.U~::;f11lJ\I~'Y1~LlI....

nl':itl':i::;LSjll.'lilfl£ll\1,ffl L~lI.

AAa ",I A d-3. nl':i:lJltinl':iu':i::;L:lJlI.'Y1

4.22 I 0.64

4.19 I 0.69

4.08 I 0.76

mfi

mfi

4.27 I 0.88

4.27 I 0.88

4.20 I 0.77

mfi

mfi

:lJlfi

72

S.D.xS.D.x~ "

4. nT'nnU~1U~1:IJ1IB:lJGlIi1nOf

U'VI~\l9i1\1') Lvlmh\l

'VIGl1n'VI~1EJ 4.13 I 0.75 4.27 I 0.80 mn"' .. ~

5. n1~:IJ L'Ylfl'Ufln1~LnU~1U~1:IJ" od "

11B:IJGl'Yltln fl B\1/Of Of

d •• 'II"L"ll'BClBLfld

6. nT5a'Bfl11:IJ'VI:lJ1EJ1IB\I

n1~LnU-nB:lJGlILL'VI~\I-nB:lJGlLtlOf Of

4.21 I 0.69 :lJ1n 4.27 , 0.80

4.16 I 0.71 :lJ1n 4.20 , 0.86 :lJ1n

•...

n1~fl~11i ffBUTI EJ\l1'Uf1~\lnU

m1:IJLtl'UIi~\I

1 ....8. m1:IJff1:IJ1~Cl 'Un1~1LflTI::'VI

-nB:lJGlOf

9. fl11:IJff1:IJ1~Cll'Un1nh::Lij'U

LLGl::~tJj:J~l'U1l1~~d:IJq •

10. fl11:IJa'1:IJ1~Cll'Un1~ff~tJq

lh::L~'U"flL~'U - IifltlB£ILtlq q

4.24 , 0.61

4.16 I 0.65

4.29 , 0.58

:lJ1n

4.53 I 0.52

4.33 I 0.82

4.33 I 0.82

mn

a.nn

ff:IJL'VIf1a':IJj:JGlq

11. m1:IJa'1m~Cll'Un1~LiiEJ'U

4.13 , 0.59 mn 4.00 , 0.65

d, "~1EJ\l1Wll'\I BEJU'U~1'U1IB:IJGl

Of'" 'lI

~Lvl~U n1~ViIi1~m1 Bcl1\1

~BUfl~BU

12. n1~~tJj:JGln1~fl~1IiL~£J:lJLtlq

fl~ \llh:: L~'Ufl1:IJ LnmsyfLLi~::

•... , .rfl1U\I"ll'

13. m1:IJa'1m~Cll'Un1~li

4.13 I 0.65

4.24 I 0.60

mn

:lJ1n

4.40 I 0.83

4.47 I 0.83

mn

" od" •.1IBLrnmL 'U::'Yl~1\1a'~~fl

1fl EJ~fl-nB:IJ~UGl::'VIin ~1'UOf •••

4.24 I 0.61 mn 4.47 , 0.64 mn

73

~1~1.;J 11 (lfi~)

S.D.xS.D.x

14. fl11:lJWl:JJ1'.iflLUnl'.iLi

,jm~ue:HLU::nl'.i

~t.lJU1~ dJU 'hJ'fiLU'i::

~elflf1~el,Hl1J~1l1W

4.25 0.68

4.19 0.54

:Inn

:Inn 4~.594~30TO.67

N = 180

·;iI1n~l'al.;J 11 'YflJ11 ~U~'VI1~GHn'U.fln'JY1Lbi;'i::fI'a~t1'el'U.h.;J b~tJ'U.-r~Uli;'iiirlfl'U.::~ ~~.lfi elfl man 'JYm::~~.;Jlh::t1'.;J fl"!J~.:I~lh::Lii'U.flm.nl"'Ull tJ'U.~n 'a::~unl~fln 'JYl.ff'U.~'U.~1 'U.

q 'lI q .-

~1'U.fl113Ji'fl113Ja13Jl~f11 'U.nT~lh::Lii'U. 1Ml~'.i13JLbi;'i::Ltl'U.~tJ"liel'Yln"liel Elcil'U.~::~U3J1n'lI q 'lI

b~elL~tJ.;JaliufI man'JYf).l,:;ti~.:Il.l'a::t1'.:Ifl"!Jel.;J~l.l~::bii'U.mu.ln~.nl tJ'U.eln ~13Jr1f1'U.::q 'lI q

"!JEl.;J~U~'VI1~t1'm'U.fln'JY1bbi;'i::fI~~t1'El'U.h.:lb~tJ'U.-r~Ul i;'i ~U11"li eltiiifilLu~ tJt1'.:It1'fl 5 e1'U.imb~n'lI 'lI'l1" 'lI q

"~bb7i fl113Ja13Jl'afll 'U.nl'al.l~::bii'U.bLi;'i::t1''al.l~i;'i1'U..nl~'a13J (X = 4.29) fl113Jt1'13Jl'afll 'U.q

nl~ 1i"1T m t1''U.mb'U.::m'a~~'U.ltiLtl'U. "1.l"~bbi;'i::t1'Elflflael.:lnUt1'.nl~"!Jel.:lt1'f11'U.fln'JYl (X = 4.25)t I , •• \0 L •••

nT'r~flU'U. rim.yjelm'a~~1"ilt1'elU'a1[J.:I1Wvl~.:InUfl113J Ltl'U.'~~.:I (X = 4.24) n1'at1''a1.l~i;'iq

nl~fl'a11Ibfl tJ3J"~~'a.:ll.l'.i::b~'U.~l3Jmm6f1 bbi;'i::1Vl1U.:Iii'(X = 4.24) fl113J~13J1'afll 'U.n1'a1i"1Tmt1''U.mb'U.::ti~f1.;J~~fl1fltJ[jfl-nel~i;'ibbi;'i::'VIanfl'U.btl'U.'VIan (X = 4.24)

~ U~ 'VI1 'at1'fI1 'U.fl n 'JY1bbi;'i::fI 'a~ t1'el'U.t'.i.:lb~ [J'U.Leln'n'U.ii rI fI 'U.::lfielfI m an 'JYm:: ti'lI 'lI 'lI q

vbl.l~:: ~.;Jfl"!Jel.:l~1.l'a::bii'U.fIf).l,.f11~.n1tJ'U.eln~::~um~fln'JY1.ff'U. ~'U.~'U.~1'U.fl113Ji'fl113J a13Jl'milU q ••• ClJ

1'U.nl'.il.l~:: bii'U. 1'U..n1~'.i13Jbbi;'i::bU'U.'al tJ-nmh'U.l 'VIni mil 'U.'.i::~U 3J1n iiU1.:1"1Tel "~bbri•• 'lI

m~"ilflU'U. -rin b.yjelm'a~'a1"il t1'elU'altJ.:Il'U.~'a.:lnUfl113Jbtl'U."il~.;Jelcil 'U.'a::~U3Jln~ t1'fl'lI q

b~elb~tJ.:Ia1~UfI man 'JYf).l,:;ti~.;Jl.l'.i::t1'.:Ifl"!Jel.;J~l.l'a::bii'U.fIf).l,.f11~.n1tJ'U.eln ~13JrI fI'U.::q 'lI q

"!Jel.:l~U~'VI1'a~f11'U.fln'JY1bbSl::fI'a~t1'el'U.h.:l b~tJ'U.beln'n'U.~U11"1Teltiiifilbu~ tJ 5 e1'U.~ubb'.in "~bbri'lI 'lI'l1

m~"ilflU'U. -rim.yj ~m'a~'al"il ~elU~ tJ.:I1'U.~'a.:lnUfl113Jbtl'U."il~.;J(X = 4.53) m'at1''.il.l~i;'im~~'al''ilq

bfltJ3J"~~'a.:ll.l'a::b~'U.m3Jbnm6f1bbi;'i::i1U.:I;}(X = 4.47) fl113Ja13J1'.ifll 'U.n1'a1i"1T mt1''U.elbb'U.::ti

t1'f1.;J~'a'afl1fltJ[jfl-nel~SlbbSl::'VIan!l'U.bU'U. 'VIan (X = 4.47) fl113J~13J1'afll 'U.m'ab~tJ'U.'al tJ.;Jl'U.

74

~-'lel~UU~lU;rmJ~~j,~~lmT:i~~l~rnleJ~l-'l'H)U~"H)U (X = 4.40) ~113Ji;n:lJ1~n 1unl~'lJ dO 'lJ

lb~~l::;~;rel3J~ (X = 4.33) ~113Ji;flm~nlum~lh::b§JUbb~::~'l.J~~lulll~~13J (X = 4.33)'lJ q

I I I II do Id Q,./I Ar;;ed Q; Q; .at

~1 bu~ ~ ff1UbU~-'lbUU3Jl~~~lUbb~::~::;~U~113J~~ bVIUbmJ1nU~rn~n Mrn::'YldO q

~-'l 'l.J~::;ff-'lf1'i1el-'l~'l.J~::dJU~ rnlll~lll ~ueJn ~::~U nl~ftn Ml.ffU ~ U~l U'lJ q dO

~lU~113Ji;fl3Jl~n 1Um~~eli;fl~

,

1. m~ih1mY::bb~::b'Yl~U~m~~~~~fi~'lJ q

2. nl~a-fHu~mmf'll um~~~~~ l"li'lllMl'lI q~ ~

.c:t I Q; Q,.oI Q,./I

'Yl-'l1~ffU n::'Yl~~~ bb~::;fflll~q

3. m~1"li'filnl3Jb~eJsE'nnl3Jlui-'lVl1::;~

bVI3Jl:::ff3J

4. ~1111i;fl3Jl~n1unl~hrlllMlbb~:::;r el~113J

~ ,.do A • .4. •.••

b3Jel~~~BffB1n~~1ml~1

5. m~§j b'YlflU~bb~:::ln-m~~~~~:: hirh1i'lI

d A Q; do ~ffnlUf'lnMlbn~~113JBUB1~VI~B~ffn

'lJ

X

4.28

4.25

4.13

4.17

S.D.

0.68

0.70

0.69

0.69

mn

3Jln

3J1n

3J1n

2

4

12

11

~~lU

6. m~bthm 1"li'filnl3J~§j~~~BirnMrn:::d d J' 0

~113Jb'Yl~-'l~~-'lbb~::~113J~n6Jl'-'l'ileJ-'l~l~elU

7. ~113J1n3Jl~n 1um~~eJi;fl~li~~b~m;reJ-'l'lJ

'YlmhrJ i'u{mh-'li'~b~Ubb~::btJ~b~rJq 'lI

8. ~113Ji;fl3Jl~nlum~lb~~::~i-'l~l~1Ju

~ln~~~ 1~~m~ l"li'filnl3J'lI'l1

9. ~113Ji;fl3Jl~nlum~iu'l.J~:::b~U~b1Ju

,rmfif1rul~'"

1O. ~113Ji;flm~n 1unT~·:5bb~-'lVl~eJueJmVI~~~q

"1.IeJ-'li;fl~::;reJ3J~liu~~ln~b,yl h~~-'lnu'lJ q

4.28

4.18

4.24

4.19

4.13

4.18

0.66 I '. mn

0.63 I 3J1n

0.61 I mn

0.66 I 3J1n

0.60 I 3J1n

0.66 I mn

2

9

5

8

13

9

75

I•...

Q..I ~~ 11 ~

".i::~J'lJ,..........~miunHlLtYl"''' ".iti'lf"~ X

S.D.A

r;: eJ'U,~1J'Ylq

fl1l:lJfl~b 'Vl'U,

11. fl1l:lJW1:lJl".irl t 'U,nl".itifhi'VnnMi~l".icl 1'U,'Yll>1a-fl >1a-TI~ imynt::~ b11'U,ijlQI".i

4.300.67mn1

12. fl1l:lJW1:lJ1".irll'U,n1".i~eJfl11:lJ~n"n~~'lI:lJ:lJ:lJeJ>1~l'U,m".ib ii[J'U,m".i'Vi~fl[J'flq

'lIq

b'Vl:lJl::tru

4.230.67mn6

13. fl1l:lJW1:lJl".irll'U,nl".ia>1~eJ:lJ~~11W1".in>1'lI~-r1J'fl".i1~ b~1 bb~::rlni eJ>1

4.090.76mn14'lI

'lI

14. fl1l:lJW1:lJl".irl t 'U,n1".ib;j[J'U,".il[J>1l'U,1~'" 1 A , •.•••

4.200.69b"1.11~bb~::a-eJfl11:lJ'Vlm[J ~~ mn7

".i1:lJ

4.200.54:inn

N= 180

IQ;~ d "" ••••• Lot d~lnlQll".il>1 12 'Vi1J11~1J".i'Vl1".ia-rll'U,fln1o:t1U~::fl".i~ a-eJ'U,'Ylfl'U,::~eJmll.~n 1o:tm::'Yl'lI 'lI'l1 q

oW>11h::a->1~"LIeJ>1~lh::bij'U,fl mill 'ViIII [J'U,eJn".i::~1Jn1".ifln1o:t1,f'U,~'U,~1'U,iil 'U,fl11 :lJW1:lJl".irll 'U,'lI q ••

m";i~eJW1";i t 'U,lll'Vi".i1:lJbb~::";i1[J~eJ'Yln~eJmjl 'U,".i::~1Jmnq 'lI

b~'flb'i[J>1ih~1Jfl min 1Ym::~oW>1th~a->1~"LIeJ>1~th:: bij'U,flnLll1'Vi1l1 [JoUeJn lQIl:lJflfl'U,::q 'lI q

"LIeJ>1~ 1J~'Vl1".ia-rl1'U,fl myl bb~::fl ".i~aeJ 'U, 'Vi1J-;h~ eJ~ ii fl1 bu ~ [Ja >1a~ 5 B'U,~1JU".in 'fl bbri'lI 'lI 'lI 'lI q

fl1l:lJa-l:lJl".irll 'U,nl".il ifhi'VilnMi~1".im1 'U,'Yl1>1a-f1>1a-".i".i~in1Ynt::~b1l'U,ij~".i (X = 4.30)

nl".iiifln1Y::bb~::b 'Ylflu.fln1".i'Vi~fl[J~ti (X = 4.28) m".iiib 'YlflU.flbb~::i~nl".i'Vi~.yi~::'3.hh 1~'lI q 'lI

a-rl1'U,fln1Ylbn~fl11:lJB1JeJ1[J'Vl~eJ~n~eJi1'U, (X = 4.28) nl".ia-fl>11J".i".i[J1nlfll'U,nl".i'Vi~fl[J'lI 'lI q

liIl11Yl~~1[J iu. n::fl~-r~u~::a-1l1'Vi (X = 4.25) fl11:lJW1:lJ1".irll'U,nl".i~eJa-1".il~~~b~[J1~eJ>1q 'lI

'Yln~h[J-r1Jfmjl>1,r~b~'U,bb~::btJ~b~[J (X = 4.24)q 'lI

lfll~l\J 13

76

, , 'I &::t I &::t q."o A ~ &t Q..oI Q..f Vc!'

mmGl £J ~1'UblW\J bU'Umlfl~~1'UbbGl::~::~\'lJfl113Jfllilb'VI'Ubnmnu'Ywl'U::"lI el\J~U~'VI1~. ~

~~n'Ufln ~1 bbGl::fl~~ ~el'Ulfl elfl ma n~m:::~~\Jlh::~\J~"lI el\J~lh::dj'Ufl mlll'V'l~~ q ~ q

11l£J'Ueln ~::ium~f1n~1.ff'U~'U~'U~1'Ufl113J~3J1~fll 'Um~iel~~•

x S.D. A .:fl113Jfllil b'VI'U

x S.D. A .:fl113Jfllil b'VI'U

"I ••

'V'llilfltl'YIlil I 4.33 I 0.60~ q

2. m~~fl\Junmmfll'U

m~'V'llilfltllilll~l~~lt1 iu~ q

n:::'Yilili'liIbbGl:::~lll'V'l I 4.24 I 0.57q

3. m~lifilfll3Jb~elsrrnfll3Jl'U

i\J'VI1:::fib'VI3J1::~3J I 4.09 I 0.55

4. fl113J~3Jl~rtl'Um~lilll~1

.........3Jfl113J'VI3J1t1rtn~ el\J"1l"liIb~'U~

3Jln

3Jln

3Jln

4.26 10.72

4.26 10.78

4.16 I 0.76

3Jln

3Jln

4.20 I 0.62 3J1n 4.15 I 0.73 3Jln

5. m~iib 'YIflUflbbGl:::iim~'V'lfl.yj~

~:::L:l-iih1~~fll'Uftn~l

lflel'ill'U I 4.24 I 0.57

6. m~b~ eln1ifilm3J~ii~Gllflel......Gln~m::fl113Jb'YI£J\Jlfl~\J bbGl:::

•• .r 0 I Ifl113JGln6jf\J"lIel\Jm~elU 4.11 0.60

7. fl113J~3Jl~fll 'j.j,nl";jiel~";j

1~~~b~t11iel\J'YIn~lt1i'uf~ q ~

mh\Jililb~'j.j,bbGl:::blllilb~t1 I 4.20 I 0.58

'.

mn

3Jln

4.30 10.72

4.23 10.65

4.27 10.63

3Jln

3Jln

3Jln

77

S.D.xS.D.x

4.09 I 0.59

8. fll13Jal3JT'Hll U

nl'~1 bfl·n:~~-:t~"~1ju~n n

~W~ 1~£Jnl'~lif11m3J'11'11

9. fl113Jal3Jl1111U

••••• f ~ d fln11';)UlJ1:b~WmlJU

UtJWlf1ru"~'"

1o. fl113Jal3Jl1111 Un1~bb,;)-:t

4.11 0.64 3Jln 4.24

4.15

0.68

0.61

••W'HIUelm \lI~~a"1l B-:tal":i:

q

"11el3Jal~Uflaln":ib"111h'11 q

~":i-:triu

11. fl113Jal3Jl":illlUn1":ilif11

4.13 I 0.65 4.22 0.67

#::It. tl"A •.•

1Wln1Y1';)1":inl.

1U'YI1-:twil-:ta"nfl an 1Yrn:

.y1dJuiJ~1

<,12. fl113Jal3Jl":illlUn1":iiel "

4.28 I 0.69 3Jln

"

4.31 0.66

~ d .A Ifll13J":i~nUnfl~3J3J3JB-:t~lU

'11 q

n1":ib1jtJUn1":iW~fl£J"~'11 q

b\ll3Jl:~3J

13. fl113Jal3Jl":illlunl":i~-:t

4.26 I 0.68 3Jln 4.22 0.67

QI I d: ~"11el3Ja"1l11 a1":im ~":iU

'11 '11

"~":i1~b ~lbba:lln~B-:t'11

14. fll13Jal3Jl":illlUn1":ib1jtJU

":il£J-:tlul ~b"111h bba:

iBfl113J\lI3JltJ"~

4.07 I 0.71

4.22 I 0.66

4.11

4.19

0.79

0.72

4.18 I 0.48 4.22 0.58

N= 180

78

·'il1mndl.J 13 ~1J-h ir1J~'V\1~~b11'\.l,flm~n3h1f'1'\.l,:lfielflmimYm:~~.J1J~:~.J~"lIel.J~ q

~1J~: dJ'\.l,flmlll~lll tJ'\.l,eln ~:~1J nl~flm~n.ff'\.l, ~'\.l,~1'\.l, ~l'\.l,Wn1J ~11Jl~b11'\.l,nl~~el ~1~~ q ~

1'\.l,1l1~~11Jbba:dltJ-nel'Yln-nelmjl '\.l,~:~1Jmnq ~

brlelb~tJ.J~l~1Jfl mi mYm:.yi~.J1J~: ~.J~"lIel.J~1J~: baJ'\.l,flmlll~lll tJ'\.l,eln ~n 1J'l1f'I'\.l,:q ~ q

"lIel.J~1J~'V\1~~b11'\.l,flm~1~1J·;h-nel.yi3jfllbU~tJ~.J~~ 5 a'\.l,~1Jbb~n"~bbfi nl~3j'Yln~:bba:'11 ~ q

b'YlflUflnl~~~fl tJ.yi~ (X = 4.33) fl111J~m~b11 '\.l,m~1ifi11~ln ~1~1~m1'\.l,'Yll.J~fl.J ~~~fl'11 q

trn~m:.yibil'\.l,aJlil~ (X = 4.28) m~~fl.J1J~·Wlnlf'11 '\.l,nT':i~~fltJ1illl~l.yi~l tJ i'\.l, n:'Yl~~~'11 q

bba::~lll~ (X = 4.24) fl111J~1Jl~b11 '\.l,nl~b;jtJ'\.l,~ltJ.Jl'\.l,l~b-nl hbbt'l:ielfl111J'V\1JltJ"~~q

(X = 4.22) fl111J~1Jl~b11 '\.l,m~lilll~lbbt'l:;-nElfl111J.yin:;'Yllil~~3jfl111J'V\1JltJ~nr;lEl.Ji~ b~'\.l,

b~El~f1lfieliEl~~~1tJ11~1 (X = 4.20) fl111J~1Jl~b11'\.l,m~~el~~1~ir.yib~tJ1,rEl.J'Yln~htJ~1Jf~ q '11

m.h.Ji~b~'\.l,bba::biJflb~tJ (X = 4.20)

fl~ ir~el'\.l,3j'Ylf'l'\.l,::~elflmi n Mm:~~.J1J~:: ~.Jfl'll el.J~ 1J~: baJ'\.l,flmlll~lll tJ'\.l,eln~ ~ q '11 q

~::~1Jm~flnMl.ff'\.l,~'\.l,~'\.l, ~1'\.l,fl111J~ 1Jl~b11'\.l,nl~~El~~ 1'\.l,1l1~~11Jbba:;~l tJ-nel'Yln,j' Elelri~ q ~

l'\.l,~:~1J1Jln

b~elb~tJ.J~l~1JflminMm:.yi~.J1J~::~.Jfl'll El.J~1J~::baJ'\.l,flmlll~lll tJ'\.l,Eln ~11J'Ylf'l'\.l,:q ~ q

"lIEl.Jfl~ir~El'\.l,~1Jil-nEl.yi3jfllbU~tJ~.J~f1 5 el'\.l,~1Jbb~n L~bbri fl111J~11Jl~b11ifh'11'11 '11 q

1~ln~1~1~m1'\.l,'Yll.Jrn.J~flinMm:.yid:I'\.l,aJ~~ (X = 4.31) m~3jb'YlflUflbba::lfun~~f1.yi~::'11

Lajrh 1~~b11'\.l,flnMlbnflfl111Jel1JElltJ'V\ieliinlfiElr;l1'\.l,(X = 4.28) fl111J~1Jl~b11 '\.l,nl~~El~~~

liir.yib~tJ1-nel\l'Yln~ltJi'1Jfmh.J,rflb~'\.l,bba:biJflb~tJ (X = 4.27) nl~3j'YlnM::bba::b'YlflUfl~ q ~

nl~WflfltJ.yi~ ~fl.J1J~~tJ1mf'll '\.l,mWiflfltJlilllMl.yi~ltJ i'\.l, n:'Yl~i''ilbbt'l::~lll~ (X = 4.26)'11 q ~ q q

fl111J~1Jl~b11'\.l,m~lbfl~1:,~'i~.J.yiL~1)'\.l,~lnir~f1tfltJm~li~1b111J (X = 4.24)~'ll

79

, , 'I a I a Q.I A a a Q..f VA

'il1"a1~ 14 f11tusHJ ~l'l.mJ£.I~ tUlt:lJ1'il"aiTtUtG'l:"a:'ilUW.l1:lJf1fH 'VI'l.um.J1't1f'lll,:"l.IB~ ~U"a'VI1"a

~rl1ll,fim~n f1"aH~eJll,t "a~t~£.Ill,~~Ul sHtiil:: teJn".I5ll,~ ih1f'1ll,::lii eJflnbi m~Hlb::'lI 'lI <Ill q

~~~lh: ~~~"l.I B~ H1.h: djll,f1 nb11l 'Vi111 £.Ill,Bn "a:~un1"afin M1.ffll,~ll,~l ll,'lI q <Ill

~lll,f111:lJ~:lJ1"a~lll,n1"aieJ~"a

S.D.xS.D.x

.,lan1"a'Vi'ilf1£.1't1'il

'lI q

2. m"arn.,'luTI£J1mf'llll,

m"a'Vi'ilf1£.11i111M1~~1£.1'lI q

4.26 0.69 :lJ1n 4.47 I 0.52 :lJln

•..•... •... •...

~ n:'t1'il"a'il ttiil::~l1l'Viq

3. m"alifil~l:lJt~eJoin~l:lJ

1 .... .,Ill,~~'VI1::'t1t'VI:lJl::~:lJ

4. f111:lJ~:lJl"a~lll,m"ali

4.24

4.10

0.67

0.69

:lJ1n

:lJln

4.33 I 0.90

4.40 I 0.63

:lJln

:lJ1n

.'" a11lMl t~iiI::'lIeJfll1:lJ't1

4.13 0.67 :lJ1n 4.40 I 0.83 :lJln

5. nl"aiit't1f1ii.mtiil::in-nl"a'Vi'il'lI

~~: L3.i'rh 1i ~mll,flnMl

liiB~lll, I 4.22

6. m"at~eJnlifil~l:lJ~ii~iiI

0.66 :lJ1n 4.67 I 0.49

, •..• a'ileJiilnMnb::f1111/t 't1£J~'il";j.,'l

d1.r 0ttiil::f111:lJiiln6Jl'~"l.IeJ.,'lf11'ileJU

7. f111:lJ~:lJl";j~lll, I 4.13

n1"a~eJ~";jli~~t~m,reJ~'lI

't1n~l£.1~ufBci1~i'ilt~ll,q 'lI

ttiil::tiJ'ilt~£.1 I 4.24

0.62

0.56

lJ1n 4.53 I 0.64

4.27 I 0.88

,a:lJln't1~'il

q

:lJln

80

S.o.xS.D.x

8. fl11:lJaI:lJTH11U

n1':i1 bfl~::V;~..:J~"~'\.l,'<il1n

~'Vi~1~[Jn1':il,rfhn1:lJ'Il'll

9. fl11:lJaI:lJ1':inlun1':iiu

• I .:.cl If•••...•••... " •..lJ':i::b~U'YIblJUU[Jalflfil L~'"

1O. fl11:lJaI:lJ1':inl Un1~bb';J..:J

4.18

4.11

0.66

0.61

:lJ1n 4.27

4.20

0.70

0.56

:lJ1n

AVl':ieUElnbVl~t.l~11e..:JaI':i::

q

,yEl:lJ~liUfl~1n':ib,j1 h'Il q

~':i..:Jnu I 4.15 I 066

11. fl11:lJaI:lJ1':inlun1':il,rfi1

1'Vi1n';1';J1':icl1 U'YI1..:J

4.40 I 0.63

~ cr'-... d.W'r'l..:Ja'':i':ifl~mynL::'YI

djuii~':i I 4.30 I 0.68

12. fl11:lJaI:lJ1':inlun1':iie

4.33 I 0.62

'. '., ..

t.l1Un1':ib11[JUn1':i'Vi~fl [J'Il q

"~bVl:lJ1::a':lJ I 4.21 I 0.68

13. fl11:lJaI:lJ1':inlun1':i~..:J

,yEl:lJ~~11a1':in..:J~U"~'Il 'Il

4.40 I 0.63

':i1~b~1bb~::nnIf1El..:J I 4.06 I 0.73'Il

14. fl11:lJaI:lJ1':inlun1':ibii[Ju

~[J..:J1ulib,j1hbb~::

~am1lJl"J1"Mii 14.161 0.68':i1:lJ 4.18 0.54

4.33 I 0.90

4.471 0.744.39 0.56

N= 180

81

"iIlnIflTSl.:J 14 'ViUll ~U~'VITHHn'U,flmYl bb~:fl·Hr tH)'U,h.:Jti-rJ'U,~qjUl~3J'flff'U,::~ ~~.~ Bfl rn.trn 1Yrn.::~~.:JU":i::;~.:Jfl"ll B.:J~ 1.h:: biJ'U,flrn.fll 'Vifll rJ'U,Bn ":i::;~U nl":ifln lYl.ff 'U,~'U,qjl 'U,

q qJ q ••

~1'U,fll13J~:IJl":itl 1'U,m":iiB~":i 1'U,fll'Vi":il3Jbb~::;b1J'U,":il rJ'Yln"llBBtit 'U,":i:~u:IJlnq ~

b~Bb~rJ.:Jth~Ufl rn.trn lYrn.::;~~.:JU":i::;~.:Jfl"llB.:J~U":i::;bij'U,flfibfll'Vifll rJ'U,Bn 1fl13J'flff'U,::;q ~ q

"llB.:J~U~'VI1":i~tll'U,flnlYl bb~:fl":i~~B'U,h.:Jb~rJ'U,~qjUl ~ 'ViUll"ll B~ iifil bli)'~rJ~.:J~~ 5 a'U,~mb":in~ ~~. ~ q

'~bbfi fll1:lJ ~l :lJl":itl 1'U,nl":i1itill'Viln ~1"i11":irn.1'U,'Yll.:J~il.:Ja":i":ifl trnlYrn.::;~ b1J'U,ij~":i

(X = 4.30) nl":i3jl1nlY::bb~::;b 'YlflUflm":i~~~rJ~~ (X = 4.26) nl":i~il.:JU":i":ir.Jlnlffl 'U,

nl":i'Vi~fl rJ1iflllYl~~l rJ i'U,n:'fl~~~ ~fll'Vi (X = 4.24) fll1:lJ~3Jl":itl 1'U,nl":i~B ~":i 1i~ q q

~~b~rJl"liB.:J'Yln~hrJ~ui'Btil.:J,r~b"il'U,bb~:btJ~bI\W (X = 4.24) nl":iiib 'YlflUflbb~:ln-nl":i'Vi~~"iI:~ q ~ ~

,a.;rh 1i~tll'U,flnlYlbn~fll1:lJ au B1rJ'VI~Biinfi B~l'U, (X = 4.22)~

~U~'VI l":i~tll'U,fln lYl bb~:fl ":i~~B'U,t":i.:lb~rJ'U,bBn"lf'U,3Jl.1ff'U,: fi Bfl rn.tr n 1Yrn.:~'lI ~ ~ q

a U 6" "'u A Q.oI od ~.¥ •... 1'Vi.:J ":i:a.:Jfl"ll B.:JI\.l ":i:::b:lJ'U,flrn.fll 'Vifll rJ'U,Bn ":i:i1Unl":iffn lYl"1J'U,'Vi'U,qjl'U,i11'U,fll1:lJa'l3Jl":itl 'U,'Il q •

nl":i~B~":i 1'U,fll'Vi":il:lJU~:b1J'U,":ilrJ"llflal'U,t 'VIruBtit 'U,":i:iU:lJln iiUl.:J"li B'l~uri nl":iiib 'YlflUfl., 'Il

bb~:ln-m":i'Vi~~"iI: ,a.;rh 1iatll'U,fln lYlb nilfll1:lJ au Bl rJ'VI~fliinfi fl~l'U, nl":iba fln 1itiltll:lJ'Il 'Il

d", ,'" d d.l' A '1'" d'Yl3JI\.l~~B~n 1Yrn.::fll1:lJb'YlrJ.:J9I":i.:Jbb~::;fll1:lJan'll".:I"1Jfl.:l"ll91 BUBtJ 'U,":i:;~U3Jln'Yla~'Il q

b~m'irJ.:Jal~Ufl rn.trn 1Yrn.::;~~ .:IU":i:::~.:Jfl"1JB.:J~U":i: bij'U,flfibfll'Vifll rJ'U,em ~1:lJ'fl ff'U,:;q 'Il q

"llfl.:J~U~'VI1":iatll'U,flnlYlbba:fl":i~afl'U, h.:Jb'irJ'U,bBn"lf'U,'ViU"h"llB~3Jfilbu~ rJ 5 fl'U,iu u":in '~Lbri'Il 'Il'll

nl":iii L'YlflUfl LL~:ln-nl":i'Vi~~ "iI: La.;rill i atll 'U,fln ~1 Ln91fll1:lJ flU Bl rJ'VI~Bi'in fi B~1 'U,'Il 'Il

(X = 4.67) nl":iLaBn 1itiltll:lJ~iil\.l~fiBtrn~rn.::;fl113JL ~rJ.:J9I":i.:lbb~:fll1:lJan;.:J"llB.:Jtil91 BU

\ (X = 4.53) nl":i3J'flnlY::;U~::L'YlflUflnl":i'Vi~flrJfi~ (X = 4.47) fl113Ja'l:lJl":itll'U,nl":iLiiml'Il q

":iltJ.:Il'U,l iL"lll hLLa:~Bfll1:lJ'VI:lJlrJL~1i (X = 4.47) nl":ititiltll:lJL ~Bsintll3J t W~;.:I'VI1::

fiL'VI:lJl:a:lJ (X = 4.40) fl113Jal:lJl":itl 1'U,m":ilifll1Y1LL~::"llBfl113Jfin:'fl~i'~3Jfll1:lJ'VI:lJlrJ

tlniB.:J,r~L"iI'U,L~B~~~B~B~":i~lrJl1"ill (X = 4.40) fll1:lJ~1:lJl":itll'U,nl":i;rLL"iI.:J'VI~BUBn~

b'VI~I\.l~"llfl.:l~":i:"llB:lJ~ 1iUfl~ln":iL"lll h~":i.:Jn'U, (X = 4.40) fll1:lJ~3Jl":itl 1'U,m":i~Bfll1:lJ-mnq 'Il q 'Il

i1nfl~:lJ3J3JB.:Je.Jl'U,nl":iLiirJ'U,nl":i'Vi~flrJL~L'VI:IJl:a3J (X = 4.40)q ~ q ,ftr.;! a •.• ad U ••. "'U A2. I\.l~nl":ibu":irJm 'YlrJUfl rn.an 1Yrn.:'Yl'Vi.:J":i: ~.:Jfl"llB.:II\.l ":i:L:lJ'U,flrn.fll'Vi fll tJ'U,Bn

q 'Il q

":i:iu nl":ifln lYl.ff'U,~'U,qjl'U,~l :lJ'flff'U,::"llB.:J~U~'VI1":iatll'U,fln lYl LLa::fl":i~ ~B'U, 1":i.:JL~rJ'U,i.:Jn~• 'Il 'Il'll

tfi,xn.:Jl'U,L"ll1fl~'U,fim":ifln 1Y1'~1Yrn.tam"ll~ 1 '<illLL'U,nm3J ~1 bb'VI'U.:J'VI,rl~q

"iIlnnl":ifln 1Y11\Janl":iLmrJU b.yjrJUfll1 :lJfl~ b~ 'U,b~ rJl nu fl rn.trnlYrn.:fi~.:JU":i:a.:lflq

"llB.:J~U":i::;bij'U,flfibfll'Vifll tJ'U,Bn":i::;~unl":ifln lYl,T'U,~'U,qjl 'U,lfll :lJ'flff'U,::"llB.:J~U~'VI1":iatll 'U,fln lYl'Il q • 'Il

bba:fl":i~~B'U, h.:Jb~rJ'U,i.:Jn~til,xn.:Jl'U,b"llIfl~'U, ~m":iflnlYl~lYrn. hn b"lllfl 1 ~l'U,fl rn.1I":i":i:lJbba:'Il'Il q q

Uflanfll'Vi ~1'U,fll13Ji'fll13J a'l:lJl":itl 1'U,nl":iU":i::;bij'U,bba:~1'U,fl113J~1:lJl":itl 1'U,nl":iiB a'l":iq 'Il

"ill bb'U,nlfll:lJ~lU w\.i.:l'VIlb~j,~~.:Jd'

~l"al~ 15

82

nl"a~mtn..J~.yjtJuflntin Hnl.:.yiW~tJ"a:~~f>l"l.leh'!~tJ"a:~~\tflntJll'VUlltJ\tBn"a:i Uq ~ q

,:9: :; et' ~ Q,.I A d: Q,.I

nl "afln Hl'l1 \t ~ \t;il \t~ 1~ 'YIfl\t:"l.IB~~U"a'V\l"a~nl \tfln Hl ~~~:fl "a~~B\t. ~ ~~

h\l~~tJ\ti~n~ttl\t'n\ll\t~'lI~~\t .yinl"aftm~l~Hnthn ~'lI~1 ~1~~\tn~l~cpil ~~'V\li~q

1. ~l\tflntm"a~~~~:UflanJll~q q

2. ~1\tfl11~i'fl11~&n3J1"anl\tn1"a'Il

" "'" "~U"a'V\l"a fl"a~~B\t~

~'Ilt - value IP-value

X

S.D.X

S.D.

4.26

0.424.330.510.846I0.339

tJ"a:L3J\t 4.18 0.52 4.23 0.58

•.••• .si3. ~1\tfl11~~~1"anmnl"a~el&n"a 4.18 0.48 4.22 0.58

TI1J 4.21 0.45 4.26 0.53

N= 180

0.631

0.723

0.564

0.631

0.711

0.564

.I C),I.:::::::., 4 g; do •.•. I •••• et

'~nn~l"al~ 15 ~U11 ~U"a'V\l"a~nl\tfln'lYlbLa::fl"a~~B\tll'YIfl\t:~Bflntan'lYnt::'Y1'Il 'Il'll q......

"" tJ ••. "tJ .ell. •••• d •••• A •...~~ "a::~~fl'llB~~ "a::~~\tflnL1l1~JlltJ\tBn "a::~unl"afln'lYl'l1\t~\t;il\t ~l\tflnt1i"a"all u.a::tU 'I •• q

UflanJll~ ~1\tfl11 ~i'fl11~~1~1"an 1\tnl"atJ"a::L~\t ~1\tfl11~ ~l~l"an 1\tnl"aiB ~1"aq 'Il

1\tJll~"a11Ju.a::dJ\t"a1tJ~l\t'~ u.91n~l\1n\t

" "

83

~l'n\l 16 nl'H 1J~rJm.yj rnJfl rn&rm~Hu.:~W\l1J~: a-\lf>1 ~1J~: dhj,fl m 111'W111rJUfl n ~:~tJq ~ q

.- .-~ Q..o a q.; ,Q, Q.,.I •••• A

fl'lWJ m~'l"ll U'WU~lU W1'lUflrn1)~~:lJbU~:tJmm11'l'W ~'l3J'YlflU:;"llfl\l ~tJ 'a'VI'l~.as q q cu

GnnUflm~n ~~~:;fl'a~a-flU 1'a\l~~rJui\ln~ al'Un\llU~ "ll~~U ~m'aflfl ~l~Mrn hn~ ~ q

~"ll~ 1 '<il'lbbUfl~'l3Jlf'i'l~~'VIti\l'VI'l.tl'Yi

4.33 I 0.47 I 4.39 I 0.62

0.136

0.594

0.512

0.158

P-value

1.501

0.535

0.658

1.423

t - value

0.62

S.D.

0.70

X

4.26

4.320.65

S.D.

0.59

4.24 I 0.52 I 4.39 I 0.57

4.26

X

4.091. fl113Ja-111'W~flU'l.tel3Jq

2. fI1'13J'iil1.Jl'iildJuijlfl1"nUUflflSlq

rY1b1J

3. f11'l3J~U~lfl"15flU

4. fl1'l3J~fllhl~~eh'l'lU~~Sl:;

'VI'l.tl~~b~~tJ3JfltJ'VI3J'l~

5. m1"tI~~.J'lUlfl'l3J~b~~U

3JelU'VI3Jl~mh\lfl1"Utl1U6"

a"3JU1"rn~

6. fl113J1t1i\l1a-lfl1"1''ila-flUb~

7. nl~tl1"'lfl'iilln flfl~ib~~:;f1113J

~'l~B~-11um'atl1":;~iju

4.30 I 0.55 I 4.32 I 0.684.35 0.60 4.38 0.66

4.26 I 0.74 I 4.28 I 0.80

0.175

0.256

0.156

0.861

0.799

0.876

8. m'aij~'VI~~Slm~dj'VI&rfl~lUq ••

mt'ua-uul um1"lh:;~ijuq

4.24 I 0.60 I 4.32 I 0.64 0.722 0.472o

9. m'aii~111'W~lfl.yj~ ell'a3Jclq

••...

3JUfI-1~~Sl:;a"'l3J'l'anf11Ufl3Jq

fl'l'a3Jcl"lla-1lflU~el\lj,~ I 4.26 I 0.71 I 4.28 I 0.77,

10. fl113J~3J~flamflu ~ijelq q

0.163 0.871

~~it}JntJfl1'l3Jilfl~~~-1 I 4.26 I 0.71 I 4.23 I 0.80

11. m'ai'nMl-nfl3JSl~~iJUfl113J&rtJ~

0.215 0.830

"llfl-1a"n'lUftnM'l I 4.39 I 0.54 I 4.39 I 0.62 0.005 0.996o 0

12. m'a1"'l~-11ui-1.yjf)U'WUlfl'l3J

fl113J~iJU'iil1-1mh-1,r~~'iilu I 4.35 I 0.57 I 4.35 I 0.65 0.030 0.976

84

•.. '"•..

Q..I d~ 1J ~

~1J~m~fl~~GfB't.I.fllll.a m~ml,::'Y1~ >'I ~::Gf>'Ifl

'11'11'11

t - valueP-valueq

S.D.S.D.X X

13. n1~1.l~lM~1:u~::bij ~1J,jB1.l~~"lIB-:I Gf:Ufl.mh-:lfl~1J51"~:U1J~nL~1:U~L~~1J

'11:uB1J'VI3J1~4.330.524.340.670.1080.914

14. fl11:u~'t.I.l~1't.l.n1~~~Wul~n>'l ~am~1.l~::bijw;h~~>'I~l:U•..

•...•..

"lIB:u~ua:GfB~fl~B-:ln1J'lI fi"d IU 4.220.554.310.660.8330.407b'VI~m~lll. 'YI~'t.I.1J~ 't.I. q

q

15. n1~1.l~1J~1L~~1~n1Jn1~b1.l~~'t.I.IJ.1.la>'l.ff't.l.~B't.I.l't.I.n1~Vh"l't.1.

4.090.634.280.671.6270.107..

6'.-:::1 I QJ16. n1~IJ.Gf~-:lb~~"1~:Ulll.'YI:U":U" q1't.I.n1~1.l~::bij't.l.bblJlJnamlll.ij~~

17. m~LliuGf1"'VI1~~1.l~d£J'!nr

4.260.654.380.610.9990.320

'VI~B~1~~n~~'t.I.l~1"n1~~~1~qbr]~:uua:m~1.l~:: bij't.l.fllM1~

,'.q

ll1tJ"Bn4.280.724.450.781.1490.253

18. m~~~"1't.1.~an1~1.l~:bij't.l.b.:a"•..

••.d •..•..~"~~flb ~ Bfl11:um1'V1"1

••4.220.514.320.581.0310.305"lIB"Gftl1't.1.fln'M1

19. n1~1.lnUB-:lUa:~lu"n"i'YI~th't.l.lJflfla l't.l.~l't.1.~Bbi~-:lbb~:qfl11:U 1.laB~.n~"lIB>'I~tln'11'111.l~::bij't.l.

4.200.654.340.601.2160.227

~1:U

4.260.424.330.510.8460.339

N= 180

85

I Q.)Q d g; ~Q,.I I Q..oo a~lfi~l"al-:J 16 'VflJ11 t:.lU"a'VI1"ai>1'rll'U.flfi'M1bb~::fl"a~Hifl'lUJ'Ylfl'U.::~flfl rni.'m 'Mrn::'Yl

~ ~~ q

~·:n.h::i>1'-:Jfl"1lfl-:Jirth:: b3J'U.flrnlll'Vil11 t1'U.fln~::~Unl"a~n'Ml.ff'U. ~'U.qjl'U. ~lUfl rn1i~~3Jbb~::~ q dO q

Uflanlll'W 1'U.lll'W~13Jbb~::dj'U."a1mJ fl"aj bb~n~l-:Jn'U.q

~1~1-:J 17 nl~b ll~t1u b.yjt1Ufl rnan 'Mrn::~~-:J1.h:: i>1'."fl"1lfl." irlb:: dJ Ufl rnlll 'WIIItI 'U.fl nq ~ q

~::~unl"afln 'Ml,r'U.~Uqjl'U.~lUfl113Ji'fl113J i>1'13Jl~rll'U.m"all~::biJ'U.1iI13J'Ylfl'U.::"1lfl-:JdO 'Il

irU~'VI1~i>1'rll 'U.~n 'Ml bb~::fl~ir i>1'flU1~."b~t1ui -:Jn~~l'~rn."l 'U.b"1l~~U ~ nl~~n 'Ml'Il 'Il'll

w'Mrn1~n b"1l1il1-;llbb'U.n~l3J~lbb'VI'l.t"''VI'ltl~q

x S.D. x S.D.t - value P-value

4.17 I 0.64 I 4.26 I 0.68 I 0.660 0.511.

2. m"ailfluf\lrll3JbntldnU3J11i1~

••. J~~ '!:'I ~I •••~ 'U.bb~::il 1U"'1l''Y1t "1St 'U.m ~lJ"a::b3J'U..."~flth."i~b~'U.

3. n1~1finl"a1l"a::bij'U.~'VI~ln'VI~lt1 4.151 0.6714.231 0.751 0.5744.15 0.73 4.05 0.77 0.690

0.567

0.492

4. nl~bfiu~1U"a13J,yfl3J~~1n'Il

bb'VIt'i"'~1'" 6J "~mh.,,'VI ~1n'VI~1 tI 4.24 I 0.74 I 4.09 I 0.76 I 1.024 0.308

'.

0.6000.5260.724.244.17 I 0.68

••••• re:

5. n1"a3Jb'Ylfl'U.flm"abnU"a1U'i13J

,rfl3J~~rln~fl"" b~fli1fl'i'Il 'Ij

A re:

6. nl"ai>1'flfl113J'VI3Jlt1"1lfl-:Jm"abnU

,yfl3J~1 bb'VIt'i.",yfl3J~"~rln~fl'" I 4.07 I 0.71 I 4.27 I 0.73 I 1.514 I 0.133~ 'Il ~.... '"

7. m~~~U'U.'YlmWflm~fil~1~

i>1'flU"a1t1-:J1Uil"a-:Jnufl113JdJ'U.~~", I 4.15 I 0.56 I 4.35 I 0.63 I 1.813 I 0.073

8. fl113Ji>1'13Jl"arll'U.mnbfl"a1::~,rfl3J~ I 4.15 I 0.63 I 4.20 I 0.70 I 0.395 I 0.691'Il

9. fl113J i>1'13Jl"arll'U.m"alh::bij'U.

bb~::i>1'~llt:.l~ I 4.24 I 0.57 I 4.32 I 0.64 I 0.738 I 0.462q

10.fl113Ji>1'13Jl"arll'U.m~~llq

lh::b~'U.~ilb~'U.q

-~~~fltl"~G1'3Jb'VI~G1'3Jt:.l~ I 4.07 I 0.53 I 4.15 I 0.63 I 0.774 I 0.441q q

..d I 9J,:::fj

"rl tI~1U6jf~mJUU~U"1JEl:IJGm'll" 'll

l~i'u m~~~T'Hll,1El£h~~Elu

x

86

s.o. x S.D.t - value P-value

..

flElU I 4.11 I 0.64 I 4.20 I 0.70

12.fl11:IJa'1:IJ1~t11unl"n~·".illt:-l~m".iq

~~1~LfltI:lJl~~~~th:~~\t~1:IJr ~,.J'

mm""~~:~1U~~ I 4.26 I 0.57 I 4.27 I 0.67

13.fl11:IJa'1:IJ1~t11un1~1i1iEl

~~El~1-I,:~~~a".i".ifl1~tI~~1iEl

:IJ~~~~::'VIimi1ud]wvlan I 4.24 I 0.71 I 4.28 I 0.56'll ••

14.a1111".ifll\tn1".i1i1im~m~ 1-1,:

m".iw~u1ftd]u llll~m~:aEl~•.. ~ ...

fl~El~nUa1l1~"1JEl~afl1\tf'lnM14.28 0.63

".i1:IJ 4.18 0.58

N= 180

'.

0.737

0.079

0.383

0.423

0.484

0.462

0.937

0.702

0.673

0.631

'.

~1n~l1'n~ 17 WU11 ~U~'VI1".iafl1UflnM1~~:fl".i~aElu3jfl11:IJfl'il~~U'nf'lu:'ll 'll'll

~ Elflman ~m::~~~lh:a~fl'll El~~lh:Lijuflm1l1~1l1 tI\tEln ~::f1Unl'aflnM1,r 1,.1, ~Wb1\tq cu et ,.

~1Ufl11:IJi'f111:IJa'1:IJ1~f11um~ll~::djul U1l1W".i1:IJ~~~:~tJU"rltl1iElla-i~~lfInlfh~nu'll

87

18 n11b1J~£J1Jb.yj£J1Jflnl.anlYnl.:~~\l1J1:~\I~"IIfl\l ~1J1:dhtfl nl.flTVi111mtEl nq 'IJ q

1:~1Jn11t1n lY1.ff'U.~'U.~1'U.~1'U.fl113J~13J11f11'U.n11iEl~11 ~13Jl1f1'U.:"IIEl\I..

~1J~'VI11~f11'U.t1nlY1bb~:;fl1~~fl'U.t 1\1b~£J'U.i\ln~ ~1in\l1'U.b '1J~~'U.~n11t1n lY1'IJ 'IJ'IJ

~lYnl.t~n b"II~1'<ii1bb'U.n~13J~1b1.W~i\l'VI,r1~q

x S.D. x S.D.t - value P-value

.,lAfl£J'YIfl

q

2. n1~ai1\11J~£J1n1f11'U.

m~Wflfl £J1'15111lY1'Yi~1£Jitt'IJ q

n::'Y1fli'~bb~::~fl1Wq

3. m11,rfl1f113Jb~flinfl13Jl'U..••.•• A

~\I'VI1::'YIL'VI:ln::~3J

4. fl113J~3J11f11'U.m11,rl1TIY1

d A A~ d5. n113JL'YIflltfl LLa::11m11Wfl'YI~::

'IJ

l1if'h 1iarn'U.flnlY1bn~fl113J

4.33

4.24

4.09

4.20

0.60 I 4.26 I 0.72

0.57 I 4.26 I 0.78

0.55 I 4.16 I 0.76

0.62 I 4.15 I 0.73

0.545

0.143

0.627

0.361

0.587

0.894

0.532

0.718

.,el1JEl1£J'VI~fl~n9i2li1'U. I 4.24

'IJ

6. nT~LaEln1,rfl1f113J~ii~a9i21••.•• A~nlYnl.::fl113JL'YI£J\lfl1\1LLa::

•• .J' 0 Ifl113J~nsn\l"IIe.J\lfl1~eJ1J 4.11

7. fl113J~3J11f11'U.m1ie.J~11i~'IJ

~b~£J1~El\l'YIn~1£Ji'1J{21ci1\1i~q 'IJ

L~'U.bb~:biJflb~£J I 4.20

, A ••8. fl113J~3J11m 'U.m11bfl~::'VI

i\l-Yiloo'U.~1n~w~ t~£Jm11,r'IJ'IJ

fl1f113J I 4.11

0.57 I 4.30 I 0.72

0.60 I 4.23 I 0.65

0.58 I 4.27 I 0.63

0.64 I 4.24 I 0.68

0.467

1.015

0.652

1.079

0.641

0.312

0.516

0.283

x

88

S.D. x S.D.t - value P-value

9. fill1:uat:Ul'Hl1um":i~iJ1h::Lt1U

~dJUUiJtt1f1ruLi 14.09 I 0.59 I 4.15 I 0.6101 "'I ••••10. fill1:U at:U1":itH UmTIl"LL~.JVI":iB

u Bm V1~(:.l~"!IB.Jat":i::,yB:U~1~q ~

Ufil~1n":iL,y1h~":i.Jnu I 4.13 I 0.65 I 4.22 I 0.67q

11. fill1:uat:U1":it11un1":ilitlh

1W1n~1~1":inl1 U'YI1.Jm-'la"':i":it>l

imYnl.::~LiJuii~":i I 4.28 I 0.69 I 4.31 I 0.66

12. fill1:uat:U1":it11un1":i~Bfill1:U~ d: .Q. I d":itffiUnfil~:U:U:UB.J(:.l1Un1":iL"!IUU~ q

m":iw~filutfiLVI:U1::«:U I 4.26 I 0.69 I 4.22 I 0.67~ q

13. fill1:uat:U1":it11un1":ia.",ya:u~~

'7i11at":ifi.JmuttlTIflL ~lLL~::~

0.544

0.690

0.224

0.353

0.587

0.492

0.823

0.724

t1nflB.J~

14. fill1:uat:U1":it11 Un1":iL;JUU":i1U

.J1uliL,y1hLL~:s. ~Bfill1:U

V1:U1ULfl1i

N= 180

4.07 I 0.71 I 4.11 I 0.79

4.22 0.72

4.18 0.58

0.301

0.216

0.356

0.764

0.830

0.723

I 'IV,Q, .cS 'ILoI a Q,; I Q..t d

~1n ~1":i1.J 18 WU11 (:.lU":iVl1":i«t11Uflm~nLL~::fil":i(:.l«BU:U'YlflU::~ f)fil nl,~mynl,::'Yl~ ~~ q

W-:Jl.h::«-:Jt>l"!lB.Jir'l.h::dJUfil nl,1l1W1l1 UUBn ":i::iUn1":ifln'lY1,rU i4'U~1U t11Ufill1:U a'1:U1":it11U~ q ••

n1":i~Bat":i 1U1l1W":il:ULL~::":i1U,yelL:ULL~n~1-:Jnu

89

3. ~iilnT~btl~tl'JJb-n tl'JJflmim~Hu.:~.w~t1~:~~fl"ll B~~t1~:dJ'\.tflm11l'W 111rmBnq ~ q

~:~'JJnl~ftmYl,1'\.t ~'\.tqjl'\.t~1:iJ't1fl'\.t:"lJB~~'JJ~'V\I~~b11'\.tftn1Ylbbiil:fl~~~B'\.t t ~~b~tl'\.ti~n~... ~ ~ ~

Wlirn~I'\.tb"lJ~~'\.t~m~ftn1Yl ~1Ymtiilm"lJ~ 1 :51bb'\.tn~l:iJtI~:b11'Yl"llB~h~b~tJ'\.tq

"'iIlnnl~ftn 1Yl~ iilnl~bmtl'JJ b-n tl'JJfl11:iJf1~b~'\.tb~ tl1n'JJflmin1Ym:~.w~t1~:~~flq

"lJB~~t1~: baJ'\.tflnlJ1Trml tl'\.tBn~:~'JJnl~ftn 1Yl,1'\.t~'\.tqjl '\.t~I:iJ't1fl'\.t:"lIB~~'JJ~'V\1~~b11'\.tftn 1YlqJ q • Cl)

bbiil:fl~~~B'\.th~b~tJ'\.ti~n~~lirn~I'\.tb"ll~i4''\.t~nl~ftn1Yl~1Ymtiiln b"lJ~1 ~1'\.tflblUj~~:iJbbiil:~ ~ q q

'JJfl~n11TW~1'\.tfl11:iJffl11:iJ~:iJl~b11'\.tm~t1~:baJ'\.tbbiil:~I'\.tfl11:iJ~:iJl~b11'\.tm~iB~~:51 bb'\.tnq ~

.1 t .. vt •.••••• .¥IJ~:b11'Yl~~b~tl'\.tb~~..:I'\.t

~1~1~ 19.

••Id d ..., A dI ft I ff' ~ •• I An 1~ bIJ~tl 'JJb'Yltl 'JJfl miiln 1Ym:'Yl'Yi..:llJ~:ti ..:Ifl'ilB~~ lJ~: b:iJ'\.tflm111'Yi111rJ'\.tBnq ~ q

Q,,/I A ~J Q..I l)",IA A •..••':i::~'JJnl':ifln ~1'i1'\.t'Yi'\.t~I'\.tfll :iJ'Ylfm::'iIB..:I~'JJ':i'V\I':i~b11'\.ttm1Ylbbiil::fl':i~~B'\.t

••• ~ ~ '11

t ~~b~tl'\.ti..:lnflWlirn..:ll'\.tb'ilfli4''\.t~m':iflmYl~1Ym tiiln b"lJfl1 :51U'\.tnfll:iJtI':i::b11'Ylq

"lm.:Jh~b~tl'\.t

"

h.Jb~rJ'\.th.Jb~rJ'\.t..., dd ~

.•..fl man 1Ym::'Yl'Yi~t1':i::ti..:lfl ~;;'JJlabBn"Jl''\.tt - valueP-valueq

...

X

S.D.X

S.D.

1.~I'\.tflm~:iJUiil::'JJfl~n111'Yi

4.280.484.490.371.1060.106q

q

2. ~1'\.tfl11:iJffl11:iJ~:iJl':ibll'\.tnl':i~t1':i:bn'\.t., 4.190.5'44.310.670.730,0.467

3. ~1'\.tfl11:iJ~:iJl~b11'\.tnl':iiB~~

4.180.544.390.561.4250.157

':i1:iJ

4.220.494.390.511.3110.192

N= 180

"'iIln~I~..:I 19 'Yi'JJil ~'JJ'i'V\I~~b11'\.tfln1Ylfl':i~tiB'\.th..:lb~tl'\.ti'qj'JJliilbbiil:h..:lb~rJ'\.tcu qJqj ""

bBn"Jl''\.tij't1fl'\.t:'iiBfl uti n 1Ym:~.w..:ltl~::~~fl"lJB..:I~t1':i:bn'\.tflnlJ11'Yi111rJ'\.tBn ~:~ 'JJnl~fln 1Ylq '11 q

.ff'\.ti4''\.tqjl'\.t1'\.t111'Yi~1:iJ'Yln~I'\.ti.ajbb~n'iil~n'\.t••• q

90

~ 1 "S1.J 20 fl1"S b1J~ tJ U bfi tJ U fI n!. i fl M n!.::::~ ~ .J 1J"S::::~ .Jf1"llfl.J iJ1J "S::::biJ '\..bfI n!. Jl1 'ViJll tJ '\..bfl flq 'lJ q

Q..ol .cS ~ ~ V A Q..<l V A.

"S::::~Un1"Sfln M1"ll'\..b'Vi'\..b~l'\..b~l'\..bfln!.ti"S"S:lJbba::::UfI a fl Jl1'Vi ~1:lJ 'Ylfl'\..b::::"lleJ.J~U"S'VI1"S••• q q 'lJ

~r11'\..bftnM1 bba::::fI"S~~eJ'\..b 1"S.Jb~tJ'\..bi.J n~tDin..'ll'\..bb "ll~~'\..b ~ fl1"Sftfl M1.w Mn!.l an'lJ 'lJ q

b"ll~ 1 '<il1bb'\..bfl~1:lJ1J"S::::bJl'Yl"llfl.Jh.Jb~tJ'\..b

t - value P-value

2. fl11:lJ~;-.J hbtJ'\..b3J~"SnUUflflaq

Yi'1'1J

3. fl11:lJi'U~~'l5flU

4. fl11:lJbfl1hlti~fl.J1'\..bbb~::::'V\'ll'1

~~'tii'U:lJ ElU'V\:lJ1tJ

5. n1"S1Jil~\I1U.~1:lJ~'tii'u

:lJElU'V\:lJ1tJ Elf.i1.Jfl"Sml1u.

x I S.D.4.15 0.68

4.271 0.644.33 0.57

4.32 I 0.56

X4.47

4.53

4.60

4.40

S.D.

0.52

0.52

0.51

0.51

1.727

1.543

1.727

0.496

0.087

0.126

0.087

0.621

4.35 I 0.59 I 4.67 I 0.49 I . 1.973

.•..

~:lJU"Sn!.'lJ

6. fl11:lJt1Ji.Jl~~"S1~~flu'ti

7. n1"S1J"S1fl~lnflfl~bba::::fl11:lJ

~lbBtJ.J 1'\..bfl1"S1J"S::::biJU.

~u~u.lu.m"S1J"S::::biJ'\..bq

9. m"S3j~lll'Vi~~fi~ fll"Smuq

iJU.fI-3 bba::::~ :lJ1"Srlfl1UfI:lJq

fl1"S:lJm"ll fh'l~'\..bbEl.J'ti

~ ~ d1 O. fl11:lJ~:lJbtJflflbtJU. b:lJeJ

q q

b~~runufl11 :lJ;r~ bb~.J01

11. m"Si'flM1-neJ:lJ~~btJ'\..bfl11:lJiu'lJ

Cl

"llEl.J~r11u.flnM1

~ d Q.,I

12. m"S"S1tJ.J1'\..b~.J'Ylfl'\..b'ViU~l:lJ

fl11:lJ d~Iu.~~-3 Elci1.Ji'~ b~U.

4.331 0.60 I 4.20 I 0.864.35 0.64 4.47 0.64

4.23 I 0'~79 I 4.60 I 0.63

4.23 I 0.61 I 4.73 I 0.59

4.24 I 0.77 I 4.53 I 0.52

4.22 I 0.80 I 4.40 I 0.51

4.33 I 0.61 I 4.47 I 0.64

0.579

0.651

1.746 '.

3.014*

1.444

0.854

0.782

0.570

0.516

0.083

0.003

0.152

0.395

0.051

0.436

91

"

h·:n~tJ'U,h-:Jb~tJ'U,

Q..oo d ~ 11 6"'"

•...P-valueflnl.GltlHnl.:'Y1~-:J 'i:Gf-:Jfl 'iQJ'lJ1Glbfltl'15'U,t - value

q

••

X

S.D.X

S.D.

13. n1'iU~iffi~l:lJ'i:bUtJ'lJ,yfl U~iffi'llfH Gf:lJfl.mh-:Jfl'i'lJn1'U,Gf:lJ'lJ'im~1:lJ~l~~'lJ'11:lJE1lJ'VI:lJltJ

4.320.634.400.510.4490.654

14. fl1l:lJ~'U,1~1'U,tll'i~~~'U,1~n-:J ~Gln1'ilh:bi)'U, 1l'il'i\l 'ill:lJ•..

•..•...

'llfl:lJGlUGl:Gffl'ilflGlfl-:Jtl'lJ'11 ••..,1•... 4.250.634.470.52b'VI'il n1 'inl. 'Y1Gf'U,'lJGf'U,'U, 1.2810.203

q

q

15. tll'iU~lJi1'~~ltJn'lJtll'ibU~tJ'U,UllGl-:J,r'U,~fl'U,l'U,n1'i'Yil-:Jl'U,

4.230.674.070.590.8880.376.. 16. tll'ibbGf'il-:Jb~~'U,l'i:lJmrh,i-:J1J'U, q1'U,n1'ill'i:bi)'U,bb'lJ'lJ

nGltJ1nl.i)'il'i

4.310.644.470.520.8810.380

17. tll'i"aJbbGf1-:J'VI1~Glth::1tJ'15'lt

,, "

'VI~fl'Yil~'in~~'U,t'ilt'U,tll'i'il'i1~qb~tJ:lJbbGl:tll'ill'i: bi)'U,flnlJll ~ ql1ltJ'U,E1tl

4.300.774.930.266.241 *0.000

18. tll111tJ-:J1'U,~i.'In1111'i:bi)'U,bi-:J•..

••. ,,1 •..•..~-:JGf'i'iflb ~ flfl11:lJn1TVI 'U,1

•••

4.260.564.470.52'll E1-:Jmll'U,fltl1Yl 1.3780.171

19. n1'illtliJfl-:Jbbi.'l:fhit-:Jn-:J~'Y1~ &f1'U,'lJflflGll'U,~l'U,~m~tJ-:Jbbi.'l:

qfl1l:lJ1I GlE1'il.1ltJ'll fl-:J~rltl 'Il'lllI'i:bi)'U,4.260.644.470.521.2190.255

'i1:lJ

4.280.484.490.371.6300.106

* P < .05

92

"iJln~T'n.:J 20 'Vur;h ~U~'VITHHn'U,ftn'Mlf1':i~tn)'U, h,:n~tJ'\.l.i'qjU1Slbb~::h..:Jb~tJ'U,'11 '11'11 ••

bfl mmii yJf'l'U,::~flfl m~ n 'Mm::li W..:Jl.h::~.:Jfl"ll fl.:J~lh::dj 'U,fImln 'VUll tJ'U,fln':i::~unl':iftn 'Mlq '11 q

.ff'U,~'\.l.qjl'U, ~1'U,flll3Ji'fl113J~3Jl':itll 'U,nl':ilh::bij'U, 1~tJ1l1'V'4':i13Jj,3Jbb~nwh:J tJnd''U,l 'U,,jfl•• '11

nl':iii b'VI~ ~ ~bb~::ii'VIin qjl'\.l.~,rU ~'U,'U,1'U,nl':ilh::dJ'U,bb~:: nl':ij,3J bb~l.:J'VIl~ ~lh::1tJ'n'.u 'VI~flq •• q

'Yhmn"iJ ~'U,1~1'U,m':i~':il"iJb~tJ3Jbb~::m':ilh::bi)'\.l.m'\.bln'V'4llltJ'U,fln iifll13Jfl~ b~ 'U,li bb~nvil..:Jn'U,q q

I .at Q,..I 0 ca; ~A,,:t, Q,..I

flm.:J3J'U,tJ~flty'Yll..:J~tl~'Yl':i::~U .05

~l':il..:J 21 nl':ib1J~tJ1Jb Yt tJUfI man 'Mm::~w.:Jlh:: ~.:J~"lleh'!~lh::bi)'\.l.flm1l1'V'41l1 tJ'U,elnq '11 q

IV d ~ ~ ~ ~ 1.1 A •••••':i:::f1Unl':if'ln 'Ml"ll'\.l,'V'4'\.1,qj1'\.1,fI1'\.I,fl113J':ifl113JtrI3J1':irt '\.I,nT:ilJ1:::L3J'\.I,~ 13.1'Ylf'l'\.l,:::'7lfl.:J•• '11

~U~'VI1':i~tl1'U.ftmYl bbSl::fI':i~~B'\.l.1':i.:Jb~tJ'\.l.i.:Jnflttl,rn.:Jl'U, b"lJ~~'U.~nl':iftmYl'11 '11'11

~1Yml~m"ll~ 1 ,)1bb'U,nfl13Jl.h:::bll'Yl'!JB.:Jh.:Jb~tJ'U,q

t - value P-value

x S.D. x S.D.

,2. nl':i~BUfiltl13JbnmnU3Jlf1':i

qj1'\.1,LLa:::ilti-:l~lil,n '\.l.n1':i.." lh:::bi)'U,l~m~h..:Jiflb"iJ'U, "

3. n11iiin-n1':il.h:::bi)'\.I,li

4.22 I 0.64 I 4.27

4.19 I 0.69 I 4.21

0.88

0.88

0.201

0.320

0.843

0.7-53

'VIGnn'VI~1tJ I 4.08 I 0.76 I 4.20

4. nl':ibnU':ilU':i13J,j B3J~"iJlmb'VIiii.:J'11

vi1.:J6J 'l~mj1.:J'VI~1n'VI~1tJ I 4.13 I 0.75 I 4.27

5. m':iiib'Ylflilflm':ibnU':ilU':i13J

,rB3J~litln~fJ.:J1 b~fliifJ'~ I 4.21 I 0.69 I 4.27'11 '11~ ~

6. m':i~Bfll13J'VI3J1tJ"llfl.:Jm':iLnU

ifJ3J~lbb'VIiii.:Jia3J~'~tln~fl.:J I 4.19 I 0.71 I 4.20'11 '11 '11,

••... "" '"7. n11"iJflU'U,'Ylm'V'4Bn1':ifl':il"iJ~aU

':iltJ.:Jl'U,f1':i.,'jnufll13Jbll'\.l."iJ~.:J I 4.24 I 0.61 I 4.53

8. fl113Jtrl3J1':itll'\.1,m':iibfl':i1:::~,rfJ3J~ 14.16 I 0.65 I 4.33'11

0.77

0.80

0.80

0.86

0,52

0.82

0.592

0.641

0.294

0.047

1.776

0.92

0.555

0.523

0.769

0.962

0.078

0.359

93

t - value P-value

x S.D. x S.D.

9. fldl3JWl3Jl'Hl1 'U,m~tl~::bii'U,

bbCl:;~~tl ~ Clq

10. fldl3JWl3J1~nl'U,n1~~~tlq

lh:;btl'\.l.,;)f1bfi'\.l.-,;)f1fie)£J'.r~3Jq q

b'VIfI~3J~C1q

11. fl113JWl3J1~n 1 'U,nT~b1i[J'U,d I Q.I d

~ [J.J1Wlf.JBmm~'\.l,'ile3JtWI'lI" 'lI

'fi~u m~'W,;)1~ut1 Bti1.J

~eufleu

12. n1~~1.I~C1n1~f1TI,;)bti[J3J'fiq

.1 ~ ~f1~.JlJ~::bfl'U,f113Jbn ut'" bbCl:

4.29 I 0.58 I 4.33

4.13 I 0.59 I 4.00

4.13 I 0.65 I 4.40

0.82

0.65

0.83

0.218

0.808

1.195

0.830

0.420

0.249

iTU.J~ 14.24 I 0.60 I 4.47

13. fldl3JWl3J1~nl'U,n1~1\t,rm~e

dO' !T •••.•bb'U,:;'YI~.J ~~fl bfI [J[Jf1'!JB3JClbl.Cl:;'lI

'VIin~l'U,btl'U,'VIin ,~ 4.24 I 0.61 I 4.47..14. fldl3JWl3J1~nl'U,m~1\t,rm~e

bb'U,:;n1~W~'\.l.1~ btl'U,'1.I'fibbCl:;

~E1flflaE1"rlU~111W'!JB"

0.83

0.64'.

1.025

1.344

0.321

0.181 "

4.25 I 0.68 I 4.27 0.59 0.103 0.918

4.19 I 0.54 I 4.19

N= 180

0.67 0.730 0.467

,;)lnm~l" 21 WUi1 ~U~'VI1~~n1'U,flm~lfl~~~E1'\.l. h"b~[J'\.l.h"b~[J'U,~~U1ClbbCl:;tU cucu .-

t~"b~ [J'\.l.bBn"ll"'\.l.ihl f'I'\.1,:;fi Bfl uti m~ut:;~ ~.J 1.1~:;~ .Jf11.1El" ~1.1~:; dj '\.I,flut 111 W111 [J'\.l.Elnq 'lI q

~:~um~flmY1.ff'U, ~'U,~1'U, v11'U,fldl3Ji'fldl3JWl3J1~n 1'U,m~tl~::bii'\.l. lfl[J111W~d3Jbbiil:btJ'U,~mj a•• 'lI

'YInfl uti n HUL::~ ~ ,,1.1~:;a-"fl1a.ibbfIn cqj1.Jrl'U,q q

~1~1~ 22

94

fll'HU~t1'JJ ~fl tI 'JJflnl,imynl,~~ ~~u~~ ~.J~"lJB-:l~u~~dJ 'U,flnl,l1TW111tI 'U,Bflq 'll q

~~i'JJfl1~flfl 'JY1.ff'U,~'U,~1'U,~1'U,fld11J~11J1~f11'U,fll~~B ~1~ ~l1Jy]ft'U,~"lJB~...

~'JJ~'V\1~~f11'U,flfl'JYl~~Sl~fl~~~B'U,t ~~~~t1'U,i~n~ttl'l!fl~l'U,~ "lJ~~'U,~ fl1~flfl 'JYl'll 'll'll

~'JYnl,tSlfl~"lJ~1 'li1~~'U,flm1JU~~~11'Yl"1lB~h~b~t1'U,q

t - value P-value

x S.D. x S.D.

'.

.AAfll~'W~fltl'Yl~'ll q

2. fll~rn~'JJTItI1fl1ft 1'U,

fl1~'W~fltll,r111'JY1~~1t1iu'lI q

fl~y]~i'~bbSl~~l1l'Wq

3. fll~1,rfilf111J~~Bi'flfl11Jl 'U,Q.oo od

,;)~'V\1~'Ylb'V\1J1::~1J

4. ~1J1~f11'U,fl1~l,r11TjYl~bSl::,rB

.5. fl1~ii b'Ylflitfl bbSl::1~fl1~'W~fl,;)::

'lI

't:u.yi11~~1'U,flm~mn~fldl1JQ".lI A ~ • Q,J

B'JJBlt1'V\~B~~fl~B~l'U,'lI

6. fll~~iBfll,rfilf111J~ii~SlwiB

4.26 I 06.9 I 4.47 I 0.52

4.24 I 0.67 I 4.33 I 0.90

4.10 I 0.69 I 4.40 I 0.63

4.13 I 0.67 I 4.40 I 0.83

'.

4.22 I 0.66 I 4.67 I 0.49

1.124

0.395

1.622

1.406

'.

2.509*

0.263

0.698

0.107

0.162

0.013

fl111Jafl4.J"1IB-:lfil~B'JJ I 4.13 I 0.62 I 4.53 I 0.64

7. fldl1J~m~f11'U,fl1~~B~~1~~'lI

~bfitl1,rB.J'Ylfl~1t1i''JJfBtil~q 'lI

i~b,;)'U,bU;~~~t1~~~t1 I 4.24 I 0.56 I 4.27 I 0.88

8. ~1Jl~f11 'U,fll~1~fl~::~~.J~

'ttW'U,,;)lfl~'W~t~t1fl1~l ifilf111J I 4.18 I 0.66 I 4.27 I 0.70'll'll

9. ~1J1~f1i'JJu~::b~'U,~ dJ'U,'I!t1

ttlt>1ru't~ '4.11 I 0.61 I 4.20 I 0.56.,

2.324*

0.122

0.466

0.514

0.022

0.905

0.642

0.608

95

t - value P-value

x S.D. x S.D.

1 O. fl11:JJaJ:JJT'Hll'U.m"a~~~'h'l'VI;'eJ

lJeJnL'VIVI~~"lJeJ.JaJ"a:::,reJ:JJ~1~q '11

lJfl~ln"a~,rl hVl"a.Jn'U. I 4.15 I 0.66 I 4.40 I 0.63q

11. fl11:JJaJ:JJ1"atl1'U.m"alif'il

i'Wln';i"ill"am1'U. 'Yll-:J

t'ffl-:Jt'f"a"af1im~nt:::~~lI'U.iiVl"a I 4.30 I 0.68 I 4.33 I 0.62

12. fl11:JJaJ:JJ1"atll 'U.nl"a~eJfl11:JJQ.d d ~ I

"at'fn'U.nflVl:JJ:JJ:JJeJ-:J~l'U.'11 q

nl"a~ ii £J'U.nl"a'W~fl£JL~'11 q

1.362

0.206

0.176

0.837

~'VI:JJ1~t'f:JJ

13. fl11:JJaJ:JJ1"atll 'U.m"aGf-:J;)eJ:JJ~'11

"Ill1 aJ"aii.J~i'lJ L~"a1fl~~1 ~~~:::'11

4.21 I 0.68 I 4.40 I 0.63 1.030 0.305

"

tln9leJ-:J I 4.06'11

14. fl11:JJaJ:JJ1"atll 'U.m"a~ii£J'U."a1£J

-:Jl'U.l~~"lhh bL~~ieJfl11:JJ'VI:JJlt1

Lmi 14.16

0.73 I 4.33

"

0.68 I 4.47

0.90

0.74

1.136

1.603

0.272

"

0.112

4.18 I 0.54 I 4.39 I 0.56

* P < .05

1.425 0.157

"iIlnVll"a1-:J22 'WlJil ~1J"''VI1''at'ftll'U.flm~nfl''a~t'fEl'U.h-:J~'i£J'U.h-:J~'i£J'U.i'~lJl~ ~~~:'11 '11'11 •

t"a -:J~'i £I'U.~Eln"15'U.ii'YTt'I'U.: 'ii Elfl m in 'Mm::: ~ ~ -:J1h:::t'f-:Jf1"lJEl-:J~1h: ~ii 'U.flnUll 'W111 tI 'U.Elnq '11 q

"a:~lJnl"aflm~l.ffwVr'U.~'U. ~1'U.fl11:JJaJ:JJ1"atll 'U.m"a~E1aJ"at~£Jll1'W"a1:JJL:ULbVln'iil-:Jn'U.£1nL1'U.•1'U."al£J;)El m"aii~ 'YlflUm~a:::l~m"a'Wfl~"iI::: L:uih 1~t'ftllitfln'Ml ~n~fl11:JJBlJ Ell tI 'VI;'eJi'iffi'iiB9l1'U.

'11 '11

•• 1"'0 .d..r=t I Q..oo d d J' 0~~~: nl"a~ aB n "15fll tll:JJ 'Yl:JJ~ a VIEla n 'Mm:::fl11:JJ ~'Ylt1-:JVI"a" ~~a:::fl11:JJ a nsn -:J"lJB-:Jfll VIa 1J