more is better (dwyer, 2004)

Post on 14-Apr-2018

217 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/27/2019 More is Better (Dwyer, 2004)

    1/14

    MoreIsBetter:TheImpactofStudyAbroadProgramDurationMaryM.Dwyer InstitutefortheInternationalEducationofStudentsIntroductionConventionalwisdominthestudyabroadfieldhasheldthatmoreisbetter;thatis,

    thelongerstudentsstudyabroadthemoresignificanttheacademic,culturaldevelop-mentandpersonalgrowthbenefitsthataccrue.Thestandardassumptionisthatmean-ingfuladvancementinlanguagelearningandotheracademicdisciplinesusingaculture-specificpedagogyrequiresatleastafullyearofstudyabroad.

    Duringthepast16years,duetoavarietyofacademic,social,collegepolicyandeconomicreasons,nationalstudyabroadenrollmenttrendshavebeenmovingtowardsignificantlyfewerstudentsstudyingabroadforafullyear.Althoughtheaggregatenumberofstudentsstudyingabroadhasincreaseddramatically,a232%increasefrom1985-86through2001-02(IIE,2002),thedatashowasteadydeclineinthenumberofstudentsstudyingabroadforafullacademicyear.In1985-86,forexample,17.7%ofU.S.studentsstudyingabroadstudiedforafullyearwhereasin2001-02thispercentagehaddeclined to7.8%.Moreover, thesesamedata show that the largestenrollmentgrowthsince1990hasoccurredinprogramsthatarelessthanoneacademicquarterinlength,growingfrom36%ofthetotalstudyabroadenrollmentsin1985-86to49%ofsuchenrollmentsin2001-02.Figure1illustratesthesharpdeclineinfull-yearenrollments inInstitute for the InternationalEducationofStudents (IES)programsacrossthedecades,from72%ofthosewhostudiedwithIESinthe1950sand60stoonly20%inthe1990s.

    151

  • 7/27/2019 More is Better (Dwyer, 2004)

    2/14

    DwyerFigure1:Percentageof IESstudentsstudyingabroad for fullyear,bydecade

    80%70%60%

    72%

    50% 49%40%30% 33%

    20%20%10%0%

    1950sand60s 1970s 1980s 1990sWhile thebenefitsof full-yearstudyabroadarestronglyembracedbystudy

    abroadprofessionals,thereisadearthofquantitativeresearchsupportingacorrelationwithpositiveoutcomes.Resourcesareavailablewhichmeasurethenumberofstudentswhostudyabroadbytermlengths,mostnotablytheInstituteforInternationalEducations(IIE)OpenDoors.Descriptivearticleshavebeenwrittenaboutthebenefitsofstudyingforafullyearovershortertermlengths.Numerousstudies(i.e.:Barnhart&Groth,1987;Carsello&Creaser,1976;Flack,1976;Hensley&Sell,1979;Isabelli-Garcia,2003;James,1976;Kuh&Kauffman,1985;Marion,1980;McEvoy,1986;Morgan,1972,1975;Pfnister,1972;Salter&Tefer,1975;Stauffer,1973)investigatetheeffectsofstudyingabroadonavarietyofstudentvalues,academiccompetenciesandinterests.Noneofthesestudiesattemptedtomeasurelongitudinalimpact;mosthadrelativelysmallsamplesizes,andreportedinconsistentfindings.Also,sustainabilityofresultswasnotaddressedinthesestudies.

    A searchof the literaturenettednineotherempirical studies thatcorrelatedlengthofstudywithlongitudinaloutcomemeasures(Akande&Slawson,2000;Biligmeier&Forman,1975;Dwyer,2004,2004;Dwyer&Peters,2004;Nash,1976;RuhterMcMillan&Opem,2004;Steinberg,2002).Sixof theseninestudieswereconductedbyresearchersatIES,whosampledfromthesamealumnipopulation.Study Design

    Thisstudy,conductedbyIESinlate2002,wasdesignedtomeasurethelongitu-dinalcorrelationsbetweenspecificprogramfeatureslanguagestudy,housingchoice,durationofstudy,enrollmentinforeignuniversitycourses,participationinanintern-152

  • 7/27/2019 More is Better (Dwyer, 2004)

    3/14

    Frontiers: TheInterdisciplinaryJournalofStudyAbroadshiporfieldstudy,amongothersandavarietyofstudentoutcomes.A54-year-old,not-for-profit,academicconsortium,IESregularlyconductsformativeandsummativeevaluationsof itsprograms,surveyingstudentsbothduringand immediatelyaftertheirstudyabroadexperiences.Thislongitudinalstudywasundertakenwiththeintentofcomparingendofacademictermevaluationresultswithlongitudinalresults.Onlythroughsucharetrospectivelongitudinalstudycouldthesustainabilityofresults,theeffectsofprogramdesign,andtheimpactofshiftsinstudentparticipationpatternsbeassessed.

    Foravarietyofreasons,thisstudypresentsuniquemerits.First,theIESalumnipoolprovidedanopportunitytodrawupon50yearsofdata.IESestimatesthatithaseducatedover45,000students.Second,thesizeofthepoolofstudyabroadalumnitosurvey (17,000:available,currentaddresses)wasmuch larger thanmostcollegeoruniversities studyabroad enrollmentsduring the same50yearperiod.Third, therangeoftypesofprogramsandlocationswasusefulforstatisticalanalysesandcompari-sonsacrosseducationalmodelsandcultures.Throughoutthe50years,IEShasoffered25programslocatedin14countries,inmultipleacademicstudyabroadmodels,fromislandprogramstohybridtodirectenrollmentandfullimmersion.Similarly,thehousingarrangementsforstudentsrepresentedthefullspectrumofopportunitiesfromdormitoriestohomestaystoapartments.

    Thenumberofyearsofdata,thenumberofdifferent locations,thevarietyofacademicmodels andhousingarrangementsused, and the sizeof the alumnipoolallowedIEStoisolateandassessthelongitudinalimpactofspecificprogramcompo-nentsforlargeenoughsamplesizestomaketheresultsstatisticallyvalidandreliable.Fewotherorganizationshavethesustainedhistoryofprogrammingnecessarytorepli-catethesestudyfeatures.

    In1997,IESestablishedtheIESModelAssessmentProgram(TheIESMAP),asetofguidelinesfordevelopingandassessingstudyabroadprogramsbyusingthesecategories:studentlearningenvironment,interculturaldevelopment,resourcesrequiredforacademicandstudentsupport,andprogramadministrationanddevelopment.Theendoftermstudentsatisfactionsurvey,a2000pilotsurvey,aswellasthe2002surveyforthisstudy,weredesignedusingthecategoriesoftheIESMAP.

    In1999,apilotstudywasconductedwithalimitedsamplingof10%(2100)oftheIESalumnipopulation(Akande&Slawson,2000).Thissurveyachievedaresponserateof44%(707respondents),afterfactoringintheundeliverablesurveysdue tooutdatedaddresses.Thereweremany responses toanumberofopen-endedquestionsaskingrespondentstocharacterizetheimpactofstudyabroadontheirlives.Thesedatawereused toexpandand refine thequestionsused in the retrospectivelongitudinal2002survey.

    153

  • 7/27/2019 More is Better (Dwyer, 2004)

    4/14

    DwyerThe2002surveyconsistedof28questions,manyofwhichhadnumerous

    sub-questions.Thequestionsweredividedinto3types:basicdemographics,impactofkeystudyabroadelements,andimpactofstudyabroadonselectbehaviors,attitudesandspecificachievements.Thesurveyresultsarereportedacrossfiveareas:generalfindings,academicattainment,interculturaldevelopment,careerimpactandpersonalgrowth.

    Withineachcategoryrespondentsansweredbetweenfourandsevenquestionsaskingthemtorate,ona5-pointLikertscale,theimpactoftheirstudyabroadexperi-enceonaspecificdevelopmentalmeasure.Severalotherquestionsaskedrespondentstoprovideinformationonspecificbehaviorssincestudyingabroad,suchasthefre-quencywithwhichtheyusedaforeignlanguage,whetherornottheyhadworkedorvolunteeredinaninternationalcapacitysincestudyingabroad,andthehighestaca-demicdegreetheyhadobtained.

    Thesurveywassentto17,000alumniwhostudiedwithIESforvaryingtermlengthsbetween theacademicyearsof1950-51and1999-00.More recentalumniwerenotsurveyedbecauselesstimehadelapsedsincetheirstudyabroadexperience,makingsustainabilityofimpactdifficulttoassess.

    Anoverall25%responserate(3723ofthe14,800alumnicurrentaddresses)wasachieved.The1980sand90sproducedlargeresponseratesof40%and41%,respec-tively.ThesurveywasdisseminatedbyU.S.mailonlyoncebecausetheresponserateandthesamplesizewerelargeenoughtomakegeneralizations.Conductingthestudywithanon-linesurveywouldhavebeenmuchlessexpensiveanditwouldhaveallowedforrepeatedrequeststobemademoreeasily.However,it wasassumedthatusinganelec-tronicsurveywouldhaveresultedinsignificantlylowerresponseratesfromtheclassesofalumniwhostudiedabroadbetween1950and1970.

    A representativesamplewasproducedbyU.S.geographicregions,decadeofparticipationinanIESstudyabroadprogram,andattendanceacross25IESprogramslocatedacross14countries.Usingstatisticalanalyses,whichtakeintoaccounterrorsduetosampling,theconfidenceleveloftheresults(theprobabilitythatthesamplerepresentsthepopulationfromwhichit wasdrawn)oftheentirepopulationof14,800alumniwasdeterminedtobe95%.

    Whilethehighresponserateandthecorrespondinglargesamplesizemakethestudyparticularlyvaluable, itsmethodologyhas limitations.Alumnisatisfac-tionsurveysuseself-reporteddatathatcanonlyrevealcorrelationsnotinfercausa-tion.As is thecaseofmostsurveysmeasuring the impactofhighereducationonindividuals(Pascarella&Terenzini,1991),thereisnocontrolgroup.Itisdifficulttoattainacontrolgroupthatistrulycomparablewiththeexperimentalgroupbecausetherearetoomanyconfoundingvariablesduringthecollegeyears(i.e.,socio-economiclevels,academicchoices,maturation,etc.)andafter(i.e.,lackof154

  • 7/27/2019 More is Better (Dwyer, 2004)

    5/14

    Frontiers: TheInterdisciplinaryJournalofStudyAbroadmotivationtorespond).The14,800alumnioriginatedfromover500 U.S.collegesanduniversities.Likewise,thesamplingmethodnecessarytoachieveacontrolgroupisveryexpensiveanddifficulttoachieveatastatisticallysignificantlevel.Evenwiththesecommon limitations, the studyoffers auniqueopportunity tomeasure thesustainabilityofstudyabroadoutcomes.Results and Discussion

    TheresultsarereportedbytermlengthduringwhichrespondentsstudiedabroadwithIES.Duringthis50-yearperiodfull-yearprogramsweretypically32weeksinlength;semesterprogramswereaminimumof16weekslong,andsummertermprogramsrangedfromsix tosevenweeks induration.Of the totalsampleof3723respondents,32%(1191students)studiedabroadwithIESforafullyear.Sixty-twopercent(2308students)ofthesamplestudiedwithIESforasemesterand6%(224students)studiedforasummerterm.

    Theresultsarereportedacross5areas:generalfindings,academicattainment,interculturaldevelopment,careerimpactandpersonalgrowth.Alloftheresultsre-portedarestatisticallysignificantatthe.05 level,meaningthattheseresultswouldoccurbychancelessthan5%ofthetime.Thus,wecanstatethatwehave95%confidencethattheresultsrepresentsignificantdifference.

    Table1illustratesthat:Full-yearstudentsaremuchmorelikelytochoosetolivewithhost-countrynationals.Thetwoprimarypurposesforfull-yearstudentstostudyabroadarelanguageacquisitionandlearningaboutanotherculture.Thisstudysuggeststhattheychooseprogramsinwhichtheycanlivewithhost-countrynationalsinordertobetterattainthesegoals.Thefactthatsummerstudentsaremorelikelythansemesterstudentstolivewithhost-countrynationalsmaysuggestthattheyarehopingtoachievethesesamegoalsinamoreintensemanner.SomeoftheseprogramswereofferedinEnglish-speakingcountrieswherestudentswereelectingtoliveinresidencehallswithhostcountrynationalspresumablytolearnmoreabouttheculture.However,atsomeEnglishspeakinglocationsthestudentslivedwithotherU.S.students.Alternatively,theseresultscouldbeanartifactofthehousingoptionsofferedacrossthefivedecades.

    Full-yearstudentsmayrepresentaself-selectedgroupthathasmoreinterestinstudyingabroadtobeginwith,andtheexperiencethenservestoreinforcethiscommitment.Thus,20%offull-yearstudentsstudiedabroadmorethanonce.Perhapstheyaremorelikelytobeinterestedinstudyingforeignlanguagesandimprovetheirfacilitywithoneormorelanguagesbystudyingabroadrepeatedly.

    155

  • 7/27/2019 More is Better (Dwyer, 2004)

    6/14

    YEAR FALLSEMESTERSEMESTER SUMMERTERM TOTAL

    DwyerTable1indicatesthatfull-yearstudents(27%)weremorelikelythansemes-ter(22%)andsummerterm(10%)studentstousetheabilitytostudyabroadasacriterionforchoosingtheirundergraduatecollege.Whenthedatawereanalyzedbydecadeofparticipation inan IES study abroadprogram, thestudyrevealedthatalmostthreetimesasmanystudents inthe90s(28%)usedtheabilitytostudyabroadasonecriterionforchoosing theirunder-graduatecollegeincomparisonwiththoseinthe1950sand60s(11%).Thisfindingsuggeststhatincreasingnumbersofstudentsarethinkingaboutstudyingabroadwhiletheyareinhighschoolandthattheyconsiderstudyabroadanessentialaspectoftheircollegeeducation.

    Table1:General findingsbystudyabroad term lengthSURVEYITEM FULL SPRING

    Table2detailstheimpactofstudyingabroadonavarietyofacademicattain-mentmeasuresbystudyabroadtermlength.Themoststrikingresultsare:

    Full-yearstudentsweremuchmorelikelytoenrollinforeignuniversitycourseswhilestudyingabroad.Thismaymeanthattheadditionalsemesterallowsthestudenttoacquiremoreconfidenceandlanguagefacilityinordertosucceedina foreignuniversity course.Theymaybemore committed to learning theforeignlanguage.Linkedwiththefindingaboutfull-yearstudentsattainingPh.D.degreesinsignificantlylargernumbers,it isfeasiblethatmoreacademi-callysophisticated,committedstudentsareattractedtofull-yearstudy.Alter-natively,theiracademicmajorsmayencouragelongerstudyduration.

    Full-yearstudentsappeartohaveincreasedconfidenceintheirlinguisticabili-tiesduetolengthofexposureandamountofpractice.Theyaremuchmorelikelytolivewithhost-countrynationalsandslightlymorelikelytopartici-pateinaninternship/fieldstudyortakeauniversitycourse.Withthesemul-tipletypesofexposuretothecultureandopportunitiestoimprovetheirlanguagefacility,itfollowsthatthefull-yearstudentswouldcontinuetouseaforeignlanguageregularlyandbemorecommittedtoforeignlanguagestudy.Auniquefindingisthatsummertermstudentsincreasedtheircommitmenttousingaforeignlanguageregularlymorethansemesterlengthstudents.

    Full-yearstudentsweremoreinclinedtochangeorexpandtheircollegemajor(s), increase their interest in academic study,bemore influenced in

    156

  • 7/27/2019 More is Better (Dwyer, 2004)

    7/14

    Frontiers: TheInterdisciplinaryJournalofStudyAbroadtheirsubsequenteducationalexperiences,andbeslightlymorelikelytoattendgraduateschool.Thelongerperiodofstudyingabroadmayhaveprovidedthemmoretimetoengageinnewareasofstudyandthereforehadmoreimpactontheirfutureacademicendeavors.

    Forty-sixpercentoffull-yearstudentsreportedacquiringgraduatedegrees.TheyweretwiceaslikelytoattainaPh.D.degree(7%)thanstudentsattend-ingshorterterms(3%).

    Table2:Academicattainmentbystudyabroadterm lengthFULL FALL SPRING SUMMER

    SURVEYITEM YEARSEMESTERSEMESTER TERM TOTALTookforeignuniversitycourse 64% 43% 47% 51% 51%Useaforeignlanguageonaregularbasis 44% 30% 31% 37% 35%Studyingabroadreinforcedcommitmenttoforeignlanguagestudy 88% 83% 85% 90% 86%Enrolled inan internship/fieldstudycourseforcredit 19% 17% 18% 8% 18%Influenceddecision toexpand/changeacademicmajor(s) 72% 59% 57% 60% 63%Enhanced interest inacademicstudy 81% 80% 79% 84% 80%Influencedsubsequenteducationalexperiences 91% 85% 86% 84% 87%Influenceddecisiontoattendgraduateschool 70% 60% 60% 65% 64%HighestDegreeAttained: BA 41% 52% 47% 46% 47%

    MA(otherthanMBA) 28% 22% 27% 24% 26%MBA 11% 10% 12% 11% 11%

    LawDegree(JD) 9% 9% 9% 8% 9%Medicaldegree(MD,DDS,DVM) 1% 2% 1% 4% 2%

    Ph.D. 7% 3% 3% 3% 5%Table3displaystheinterculturalcompetenceoutcomesreportedbyrespondents

    bystudyabroadtermlength.Themostsignificantfindingsinclude:Studentswhostudiedabroadforafullyearweretwiceaslikelytocultivatelifelongfriendshipswithhost-countrynationals.Lastingrelationshipstaketimetodevelop.

    157

  • 7/27/2019 More is Better (Dwyer, 2004)

    8/14

    YEAR FALLSEMESTER SEMESTER SUMMERSURVEYITEM FULL TERM TOTAL

    DwyerNumerousresultsinTable3supporttheideathattheculturaldevelopmentaspectofthestudyabroadexperienceendures.Auniquefindingisthatstudying inonecultureand languagehas leda significantnumberof re-spondentstolearnmoreaboutanothercultureorlearnanotherlanguage.

    Achievinggreaterunderstandingofonesownculturalvaluesandbiases,con-tinuingtobeinfluencedinonesinteractionswithpeoplefromdifferentcul-tures,anddevelopingamoresophisticatedwayoflookingattheworldareallstrongfindings,particularlyforthoserespondentswhostudiedforafullyear.

    Onaverage,90%ofrespondentsagreedorstronglyagreedwiththestatementthatstudyabroadinfluencedthemtoseekoutagreaterdiversityoffriends.This

    is

    acritical

    finding,

    and

    its

    distribution

    across

    all

    term

    lengths

    is

    note-

    worthy.Thisfindingraisesthequestionofwhethertheexperiencepromotesgreaterracial,ethnic,andculturaltolerance,orwhether thestudentswhostudyabroadareaprioriaself-selected,moretolerantgroup.

    Thestudent interest inparticipating in internships/fieldstudyhas increasedsignificantlyinthepast5decades.OfthoserespondentswhostudiedwithIESinthe1950sand60s,0.5%participated in internships/fieldstudy.Duringthe1990sthepercentageofalumnirespondentsparticipatingininternships/fieldstudyhadin-creased to51%.This findingmaybeconfoundedby IESplacing lessemphasisonexperientialeducationasaprogramelement in the1950sand60sversus the laterTable3:Interculturaldevelopmentoutcomesbystudyabroadterm length

    SPRING

    158

  • 7/27/2019 More is Better (Dwyer, 2004)

    9/14

    YEAR FALLSEMESTER SEMESTER SUMMERSURVEYITEM FULL TERM TOTAL

    Frontiers: TheInterdisciplinaryJournalofStudyAbroaddecades.Thequestionis:Dointernships/fieldstudyandstudyingabroadingeneralhaveanyimpactoncareerdevelopment?

    Table4showstheimpactalumnireportedstudyingabroadhadoncareerdevel-opmentbytermlength.Themostimportantfindingsarethat:

    Full-yearstudents(57%)weremorelikelythanthosestudyingothertermlengthstoengageininternationalworkorvolunteeractivities.

    Full-yearstudentsweremuchmorelikelytohavepursuedacareerdirection,stillspeaka languageother thanEnglish regularly in theworkplace,andacquireskillsetsandprofessionalcontactsthatinfluencedtheircareerpaths.

    Full-yearstudentsweremorelikelytoworkforamulti-nationalorganiza-tionintheU.S.andtogetajoboverseas.

    Studyingabroadwasalmosttwotothreetimesaslikelytocausechangesincareerplansoffull-yearstudentsthanthosestudyingforshortertermlengths.

    Table4:Career impactbystudyabroadtermlengthSPRING

    Table5illustratesalumnisreportingofthedramaticimpactofstudyingabroadonawidevarietyofpersonalgrowthattributes.

    159

  • 7/27/2019 More is Better (Dwyer, 2004)

    10/14

    YEAR FALLSEMESTER SEMESTER SUMMERSURVEYITEM FULL TERM TOTAL

    DwyerFull-yearstudentsweremorelikelytoachievethesegains,buttheimpactisimpressiveregardlessoftermlength.Thisisparticularlythecaseintheareasofincreasedself-confidence,toleranceofambiguityandmaturation.

    Full-yearstudentsweresomewhatmorelikelytohavechanged,refinedand/orcontinuetobeinfluencedintheirpoliticalandsocialviewsduetostudy-ingabroad.Ninety-fivepercentofall respondents reported thatstudyingabroadhashadalastingimpactonhowtheyviewtheworld.

    Full-yearstudentsweremorelikelytohavebeeninfluencedtocontinuetheirparticipationincommunityorganizations,feelthatstudyingabroadinflu-encedthechoicestheymadeintheirfamilylivesandstillbeincontactwith U.S.

    friends

    they

    met

    while

    studying

    abroad

    with

    IES.

    Table5:Personalgrowthbystudyabroadterm length

    SPRING

    160

  • 7/27/2019 More is Better (Dwyer, 2004)

    11/14

    Frontiers: TheInterdisciplinaryJournalofStudyAbroadConclusions

    Long-heldbeliefsthatstudyingabroadforafullyearhasmoresignificantandenduringimpactonstudentsweresupportedbythedataofthisstudy.While it hasbeenlongbelievedthatstudyabroadchangespeopleslives,littleevidenceexiststoexplainwhatkindsoftangiblechangesoccurandforhowlong.Thisstudyshowsthatstudyabroadhasasignificantimpactonstudentsintheareasofcontinuedlanguageuse,academicattainmentmeasures,interculturalandpersonaldevelopment,andcareerchoices.Mostimportantly,thestudyillustratesthatthisimpactcanbesustainedoveraperiodaslongas50years.

    Insomecategoriesoffactors,summerstudentswereaslikelyormorelikelytoachievesustainablebenefitfromstudyingabroad incomparisonwithsemesterstu-dents.Thisseemscounter-intuitivesinceonewouldexpectthatwithdecliningdura-tionofstudyabroadacorrespondinglesseningpatternofimpactwouldresult.

    Oneexplanationisthatwell-planned,intensivesummerprogramsofatleast6weeksdurationcanhaveasignificant impactonstudentgrowthacrossavarietyofimportantoutcomes.Whileitrequiresverycarefuleducationalplanning,expertimple-mentation,andsignificantresourcestoachievetheseoutcomesinashorter-termlength,theresultsofthisstudyshouldencouragestudyabroadeducatorsandshouldreinforcethe

    value

    of

    short-term

    programming

    of

    at

    least

    6

    weeks

    duration.

    Whether

    these

    resultswouldholdfortheincreasinglypopular1-5weekprogramsisunknown.Nevertheless,clearlythegreatestgainsacrossall outcomecategoriesaremadebyfull-yearstudents.FutureResearch

    Numerousother researchprojectscouldbepursuedusing thedata from thisstudy.Futureresearchcouldincludeanalyzingoutcomesbycountry,languagestudiedandprogrammodelused.Aqualitativestudycouldbeconductedtoprobeforgreaterdetailwithintheseoriginalfindingsbycategoryofoutcomes.Astudyonthedifferentcareerpathsofstudentsbydecadewouldrevealthechangingemploymentcontextswithinwhichstudentsapplytheirstudyabroadexperiences.Also,it wouldbeinter-estingtocomparepre-studyabroadandpost-studyabroadgradepointaverages(GPAs)offull-yearstudentswithsemesterstudents.

    Otherresearchquestionsthatcouldbeprobedusingtheavailabledatafromthisstudyincludebutarenotlimitedtotheimpactof

    host-countryuniversityenrollmentonmultipleoutcomes?studyabroadonmenversuswomen?differenthousingmodelsonoutcomes?

    161

  • 7/27/2019 More is Better (Dwyer, 2004)

    12/14

    Dwyerthehost-citysizeonoutcomes?anintensiveforeignlanguageprogramonoutcomes?Inconclusion,theage-oldpremisethatmoreisbetterholdstruewhenitcomesto

    thedurationofastudyabroadexperience.However,theresultsofthisstudywouldsuggestthatprogramsofat least6weeksdurationcanbeenormouslysuccessful inachievingimportantacademic,personal,careerandinterculturaldevelopmentoutcomes.ReferencesAkande,Y.,&Slawson,C.(2000).Acasestudyof50yearsofstudyabroadalumni.

    InternationalEducator,9(3),12-16.Barnhart,

    R.,

    and

    Groth,

    L.

    (1987).

    The

    assessment

    of

    college

    student

    growth

    resulting

    fromaninternationalcourseandstudyexperience.CollegeStudentJournal,21,78-85.

    Billigmeier,R.,&Forman,D.(1975).Gttingeninretrospect:Alongitudinalassess-mentoftheUniversityofCaliforniaseducationabroadprograminGttingenby1956-66participants.InternationalReviewofEducation,21,217-230.

    Carsello,C.,&Creaser,J.(1976).Howcollegestudentschangeduringstudyabroad.CollegeStudentJour nal ,10,276-278.

    Chin,H-K.,ed.(2003).OpenDoors2003:Reportoninternationaleducationexchange.NewYork:InstituteofInternationalEducation.Dwyer,M.,&Peters,C.(2004).Thebenefitsofstudyabroad.TransitionsAbroad,27(5),

    56-57.Dwyer,M.(2004).Chartingtheimpactofstudyingabroad.InternationalEducator,

    13(1),14-17.Dwyer,M.(2004).Theinternshipeffect:Academic?InternationalEducator,13(1),18&20.Flack,M.(1976).Resultsandeffectsofstudyabroad.AnnalsoftheAmericanAcademy

    ofPoliticalandSocialSciences,424 ,107-117.Hensley,T.,&Sell,D.(1979).Astudyabroadprogram:Anexaminationofimpactson

    studentattitudes.TeachingPoliticalScience,6,387-412.Isabelli-Garcia,C.L.(2003).Developmentoforalcommunicationskillsabroad.Fron-

    tiers:TheInterdisciplinaryJournalofStudyAbroad,Fall,149-174.James,N.(1976).Studentsabroad:Expectationsversusreality.LiberalEducation,62,

    599-607.Kuh,

    G.,

    &

    Kauffman,

    N.

    (1985).

    The

    impact

    of

    study

    abroad

    on

    personal

    develop-

    ment.Jour nalofInternationalStudentPersonnel,2,6-10.

    Marion,P.(1980).Relationshipsofstudentcharacteristicsandexperienceswithattitudechangesinaprogramofstudyabroad.JournalofCollegeStudentPersonnel,21,58-64.

    162

  • 7/27/2019 More is Better (Dwyer, 2004)

    13/14

    Frontiers: TheInterdisciplinaryJournalofStudyAbroadMcEvoy,T.(1986).Cosmopolitanism.JournalofHigherEducation,57,84-91.Morgan,E.(1972).TheAmericancollegestudentinSwitzerland:Astudyofcross-

    culturaladaptationandchange.DissertationAbstractsInternational,33,529A.Nash,D.(1976).Thepersonalconsequencesofayearofstudyabroad.JournalofHigher

    Education,47(2),191-203.Pascarella,E.,&Terenzini,P.(1991).HowCollegeAffectsStudents.SanFrancisco:

    Jossey-Bass.Pfnister,A. (1972).Impact of study abroad on theAmerican college undergraduate.Paper

    presentedatthemeetingoftheNationalAssociationforForeignStudentAffairs.(ERICDocumentNo.ED063882).

    RuhterMcMillan,A.,&Opem,G.(2004).Studyabroad:Alifetimeofbenefits.AbroadViewMagazine,6(2),58&60-61.

    Salter,C.,&Teger,A.(1975).Changeinattitudestowardothernationsasafunctionofthetypeofinternationalcontact.Sociometry,38, 213-222.

    Stauffer,M.(1973).Theimpactofstudyabroadexperienceonprospectiveteachers.DissertationAbstracts International,34,2448A.

    Steinberg,M.(2002).InvolvemeandIwillunderstand:Academicqualityinexpe-rientialprogramsabroad.Frontiers:TheInterdisciplinaryJournalOfStudyAbroad,SpecialIssue-Winter,207-227.

    The IESMAPforStudyAbroad:Chartinga courseforquality.Chicago,1999,2001,2003.

    163

  • 7/27/2019 More is Better (Dwyer, 2004)

    14/14

    164