molecular phylogeny and species definition within the species rich … · 2019-06-26 · molecular...

1
Molecular phylogeny and species definition within the species rich / complex (Fabaceae) Astragalus Oxytropis M. Schlee , M. Göker , G. W. Grimm , V. Hemleben 1 2 3 1 1 2 3 Center for Plant Molecular Biology (ZMBP) - General Genetics; German Collection of Microorganisms and Cell Cultures (DSMZ), Braunschweig, Swedish Museum of Natural History, Dep. Palaeobotany, Stockholm Fig. 2a: Oxytropis pilosa, Italy, Marche Fig. 2b: O. pilosa, Switzerland, Valais Introduction Oxytropis pilosa is a widespread but highly disjunctive relict species that originated in the steppes of the Altai, Siberia, from where it spread to the West (Fig. 1). Having left the steppe-like areas where its distribution is facilitated by the tumbleweed-like behaviour of the infructescences, the species is now restricted to extreme xeric habitats such as gypsum or disturbed stony banks (Figs. 2 a-b). Divergence in species of and Oxytropis Astragalus Additionally, the genetic divergence within was compared to other taxa within the / complex (2.500/300 species) – one of the largest Angiosperm genus complexes altogether (Fig. 6). Species clusters were defined by non-hierarchical single-linkage clustering (Göker et al. 2009); as threshold the smallest possible distance was chosen that resulted in all sequences being assigned to the same cluster. The ENT transformation of Göker & Grimm (2008) was applied to detect statistically significant differences between the genetic diversity of the resulting clusters. Molecular divergence within was insignificantly different from that observed in clusters comprising numerous accepted and species (Schlee et al., in press). O. pilosa Astragalus Oxytropis O. pilosa O. pilosa Astragalus Oxytropis A deep glance into Oxytropis pilosa The morphologically very homogeneous was studied by phytosociological and molecular methods (Schlee et al. 2003). We obtained more than 200 cloned sequences which enabled us to evaluate the intra- and interindividual variability (Fig. 3). Genetic diversity within individuals is comparable to that within populations. The populations can be grouped into two main types using the MOD transformation (Göker & Grimm 2008; Fig. 4) and p . One type is characteristic for the putative stem populations of Russia (Fig. 3). The second main type replaces the first type throughout Europe, the stem type is completely lost within the most remote populations in the French Sea Alps (Fig. 4). Mixtures of both types occur within Central Europe and Northern Europe. The data indicate repeated (post-)glacial exchange between temporally disjunct populations. Unique mutations (Hegau mountains, SW Germany; Bormio, Italian Alps; Östergotland, Sweden; Fig. 3) could possibly mirror such nunatak-associated relicts. O. pilosa ITS rDNA rincipal coordinate analysis of uncorrected distances between the clones (Fig. 5) gradually Outlook: Identifying genetic resources beyond species concepts The outlined methods provide objective means to identify populations which represent evolutionary hot spots. Also, . These populations should considerably benefit from protection efforts. Habitats of show dramatic secondary successions due to improper management regimes, highlighting the need for improved protection efforts (cf. phytosociological relevées, Tab. 1). relict populations within assumed homogeneous ranges can be detected easily O. pilosa Acknowledgements: Special thanks go toAngela Dressel and Karin Stögerer for technical assistance, and to Wilhelm Sauer for discussion. Reiner Schmahl, Eberhard Koch, Matthias Kropf and Natalie Schmalz, Ludmilla Barjaewa, Ludmilla Mantschenkowa, and Erich Kalmbach, Friedrich Schlee, Evgenia Zeidler-Schewzowa, and the University of Barnaul (Altai, Siberia) are kindly acknowledged for contributing plant material. GZU, LY, M, and MAfor sending specimens for revision. Special thanks go to the visited herbaria BC, BOLO, C, DR, E, FB, FI, FR, G, HBG, K, LE, LI, LJU, M, MPU (incl. SIGMA), P, RO, S, STU, TUB, UPS, W, WU, and Z. Funding: Landesgraduiertenförderung Baden-Württemberg, Reinhold-und-Maria-Teufel-Stiftung, DAAD References: Göker M, Grimm GW (2008): General functions to transform associate data to host data, and their use in phylogenetic inference from sequences with intra-individual variability. – BMC Evolutionary Biology 8: 86 Göker M, García-Blázquez G, Voglmayr H, Tellería MT, Martín MP(2009): Molecular taxonomy of phytopathogenic fungi: a case study in PLoS ONE 4: e6319 Schlee M, Sauer W, Hemleben V (2003): Molekulare und pflanzensoziologische Analyse von pontisch-pannonischen Reliktarten aus wärmebegünstigten Saum-Gesellschaften Süddeutschlands und benachbarter Gebiete. – Nova Acta Leopoldina NF 87 (328): 379-387 Schlee M, Göker M, Grimm GW, Hemleben V (in press): Relicts within the genus complex / (Fabaceae), and the comparison of diversity by objective means. – in: Habel J, Assmann T (eds.): Relict species: Phylogeography and conservation biology; Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer Stamatakis A (2006): RAxML-VI-HPC: maximum likelihood-based phylogenetic analyses with thousands of taxa and mixed models. – Bioinformatics 22 (21): 2688-2690 Swofford DL (2002): PAUP*: Phylogenetic analysis using parsimony (* and other methods). 4th ed. Champaign, USA: National Illinois History Survey Peronospora. Astragalus Oxytropis Fig. 3: Part of the alignment of ITS1, 5.8S rDNA, and ITS2 sequences for (extract only shows variable positions anywhere in the total alignment). Data inferred via cloning technique. Oxytropis pilosa L.p.pannonicus, Italy, Abruzzo Map source: Wikimedia commons 1a putative stem type 2a second main type replacing the stem type 1b variant variants 2b 2c 2d Fig. 1: Distribution map of the obtained types inferred by UPGMA analysis for (cf. Fig. 4). O. pilosa Fig. 6: Maximum likelihood tree inferred with RAxML (Stamatakis 2006) from and sequences, including both cloned and gene bank data. Astragalus Oxytropis Fig. 5: Boxplots of the first (largest) eigenvector obtained by principle coordinate analysis of uncorrected distances between the clones. sequences were combined according to their countries of origin: Russia (R) - Sweden (S). O. pilosa Austria (A) - Switzerland (C) - Germany (D) - France (F) - Italy (I) - No. S84 S83 S85 R14 R4 R5 Country D D D I A A Relevée dimension 1 1,5 1 4 0,4 1 Inclination 20 45 45 15 45 5 Exposition SSW SSW S SSO SW SSW Coverage altogether 60 15 50 75 60 70 Coronilla varia + . . . . . Peucedanum cervaria v . . . . . Lotus corniculatus subsp. corniculatus r . . . . . Galium glaucum 2m 1 . . . . Aster amellus + + . . . . Hieracium pilosella + + . 1 . . Onobrychis viciifolia subsp. viciifolia r v . . . . Euphorbia cyparissias + + 1 . . . Sanguisorba minor subsp. minor r + . . . . Bromus erectus 3 1 1 . r . Ligustrum vulgare (K) 1 . 1 . . . Aster linosyris + + 1 . . . Bupleurum falcatum + + + . . . Stachys recta + v v . . . Poa angustifolia v . r . . . Oxytropis pilosa r + + 2a 1 2b Salvia pratensis . . r . . . Fragaria viridis . . r . . . Trinia glauca subsp. glauca . . . + . . Helictotrichon versicolor subsp. versicolor . . . + . . Thymus pulegioides subsp. chamaedrys . . . 2m 2a . Scabiosa columbaria . . . . 1 + Festuca ovina agg. . . . . 3 2b Potentilla alba . . . . r . Sisymbrium loeselii . . . . r . Scorzonera cana . . . . r . Salvia sclarea . . . . . 2a Dictamnus albus . . . . . v Arrhenatherum elatius subsp. elatius . . . . . 2a Lotus corniculatus subsp. hirsutus . . . . . 3 Centaurea scabiosa agg. . . . . . + Achillea millefolium agg. . . . . . r Column 1-3: near Tübingen, 4: Abruzzo, 5-6: Lower Austria. secondary stands. Increase of species numbers and abundances related to the fringing communities leads to overgrowing of the whilom open stands (decrease of ). Only disturbances keep the habitats open and favour the rare plants. Oxytropis pilosa O. pilosa Tab. 1: Relevées inferred via Braun-Blanquet approach (extract). A allochrous varallochrous EU282972@1 Cluster 2 Cluster 88 Cluster 89 Cluster 4 Cluster 1 Opil003z06ABrenner@88 Opil036z04RUSKaukasus@88 Opil047n22RUSSiberiaAltai@88 Opil029n01IBormio@88 Opil046g16RUSSiberiaAltai@88 Opil007c03IBormio@88 Opil047h26RUSSiberiaAltai@88 Opil003b03ABrenner@88 Opil007c04IBormio@88 Opil036a09RUSKaukasus@88 Opil053z08DHemleben@88 Opil028b01IBormio@88 Opil053z10DHemleben@88 Opil029n05IBormio@88 Opil003m03ABrenner@88 Opil036z05RUSKaukasus@88 Opil029b06IBormio@88 Opil053z02DHemleben@88 Opil063d03FLaRocheDeRame@88 Opil060c06AEichkogel@88 Opil063a07FLaRocheDeRame@88 Opil061b03DHegau@88 Opil037a03IRivaDelGarda@88 Opil013z09CHChur@88 Opil061a01DHegau@88 Opil068b01IValleDAosta@88 Opil001b01DTuebingen@88 Opil031n02IKastellbell@88 Opil062c03FBriancon@88 Opil063c01FLaRocheDeRame@88 Opil003z01ABrenner@88 Opil033b08CHInnVelaz@88 Opil050z13SGotlandLummelunda@88 Opil006m10CHScuols@88 Opil061b01DHegau@88 Opil026z11IPradStilfserjoch@88 Opil031z04IKastellbell@88 Opil033n05CHInnVelaz@88 Opil068b02IValleDAosta@88 Opil048n01DKoennern@88 Opil001a03DTuebingen@88 Opil006b01CHScuols@88 Opil064b01FStJeanDeMaurienne@88 Opil052z02SHegaIsberga@88 Opil001a04DTuebingen@88 Opil001b05DTuebingen@88 Opil064b02FStJeanDeMaurienne@88 Opil006m02CHScuols@88 Opil001a01DTuebingen@88 Opil003a03ABrenner@88 Opil052a03SHegaIsberga@88 Opil052z01SHegaIsberga@88 Opil063c06FLaRocheDeRame@88 Opil040n01CHMartigny@88 Opil006m09CHScuols@88 Opil053z03DHemleben@88 Opil066b01ALienz@88 Opil039n01IRovere@88 Opil066b04ALienz@88 Opil039a07IRovere@88 OpilosaAF121759@88 OoreophilavarjuniperinaAF121755@89 Ohal044c05FQueyras@89 Ohal044c02FQueyras@89 OcampestrisL10802|03@89 OarcvarbarnebyanaAF366322|23@89 OcampestrisvarjordaliiAF366299|301@89 OtananensisAF366344|45@89 OarcvararcticaAF366326|27@89 OarcvararcticaAF366324|25@89 OlambertiiL10806|07@89 OlambertiiAF121753@89 Ocam055b04CHPassCastainas@89 Ocam042z03FColDuGalibier@89 Ocam042z05FColDuGalibier@89 Ocam042z02FColDuGalibier@89 Ocam055b01CHPassCastainas@89 Ocam041z07EPicosPerdidos@89 Ocam041z08EPicosPerdidos@89 Ocam049z03SOelandVickelby@89 Ocam045a01ANDCasamanya@89 Ocam049a02SOelandVickelby@89 OcampestrisvargracilisAF366338|39@89 OcampestrisvargracilisAF366336|37@89 OarcvarbarnebyanaAF366304|05@89 OarcvarbarnebyanaAF366302|03@89 OarcvarbarnebyanaAF366298|300@89 OarcvarbarnebyanaAF366314|15@89 OarcvarkoyukuensisAF366328|29@89 OarcvarbarnebyanaAF366318|19@89 OkobukensisAF366346|47@89 OanertiiEF685971@89 Ocam041z01EPicosPerdidos@89 OarcvarbarnebyanaAF366316|17@89 Ocam045a03ANDCasamanya@89 OarcvarbarnebyanaAF366308|09@89 OarcvarbarnebyanaAF366310|11@89 OarcvararcticaAF366320|21@89 OarcvarbarnebyanaAF366312|13@89 OarcvarkoyukuensisAF366330|31@89 OarcvarkoyukuensisAF366334|35@89 OarcvarkoyukuensisAF366332|33@89 OsplendensAF121761@89 OmulticepsAF121760@89 ObesseyivarventosaAF121756@89 OnigrescensAF366348|49@89 OszovitsiiAF121754@89 OdeflexaL10804|05@91 A. vogelii U50498 99@86 A. cysticalyx AF121682@64 A. milingensis AF521954@78 A. yatungensis AF521955@87 A. hendersonii AF521957@72 A. balfourianus AF521951@57 A. tanguticus AF521956@84 A. sinicus U50502|03@61 A. complanatus U50500|01@61 A. complanatus AF521950@61 A. epiglottis U50506|07@66 A. pelecinus U50518|19@80 A. corrugatus L10774|75@62 A. eucosmus AF121684@67 A. robbinsii varminor U50490|91@67 A. williamsii AF121685@56 A. australis varglabriusculus AF121686@56 A. atropilosulus varvenosus U50504|05@55 Aexs005b02ILaasEyrs@68 A. chinensis AF121681@60 A. hoantchy AF359754@73 A. hoantchy subspdshimensis AF359755@74 A. alopecias U50508|09@52 Aalo004b02FSeealpen225@54 A. lehmannianus AF359756@75 A. sieversianus AF359757@83 A. lepsensis AF359752@76 A. umbellatus AF121683@85 Afri003a06ATannheim@69 A. membranaceus AF359749@77 A. membranaceus varmongholicus EF685969@77 A. propinquus AF359751@82 A. aksuensis AF359753@51 Agly006b03ESoria@70 A. hamosus L10778@71 A. cymbicarpos AF121678@63 A. edulis AF121677@65 A. boeticus AF121679@58 A. uliginosus EF685970@59 A. canadensis L10770@59 A. canadensis varbrevidens U50496|97@59 A. oreganus AF121687@59 A. falcatus U50488|89@59 A. echidniformis U50512|13@49 A. cerasocrenus U50514|15@49 A. peristerus U50494|95@49 A. polycladus AF121676@81 Aalp002b02ATannheim@53 A. alpinus L10760@53 A. nankotaizanensis AF121680@79 A. cicer L10772@50 A agrestis L10758|59@9 A pulchellus L10786|87@39 A chaborasicus L10808|09@17 A asterias L10764|65@11 A tribuloides L10794|95@11 A adsurgens AF121674@7 A austrosibiricus AF359758@8 A adsurgens L10756|57@8 A brandegei L10768|69@13 A sabulonum AF121706@42 A berteroanus EU282983@2 A arnottianus EU282975@2 A arnottianus AF121748@2 A patagonicus AF121746@2 A amatus EU282976@2 A uniflorus EU282986@2 A pickeringii AF121741@2 A garbancillo AF121740@2 A garbancillo EU282987@2 A arizonicus AF121690@10 A nivicola EU282985@6 A didymocarpus DQ403841@20 A didymocarpus DQ403840@20 A didymocarpus DQ403839@19 A didymocarpus vardispermus AF121721@21 A utahensis L10796|97@47 A eremiticus AF121736@23 A lentiginosus varpalans EU282969@5 A layneae DQ403844@27 A layneae DQ403843@27 A layneae DQ403842@27 A chamaemeniscus AF121727@4 A cibarius AF121729@4 A lentiginosus L10812|13@4 A lentiginosus vardiphysus EU282977@4 A lentiginosus varvariabilis EU282970@4 A obscurus AF121701@4 A salmonis AF121735@4 A sheldonii AF121704@4 A reventus AF121702@4 A caricinus AF121734@15 A miser AF121717@32 A molybdenus AF121694@34 A tener AF121697@46 A rattanii AF121712@40 A hallii L10776|77@25 A nuttallianus L10816|17@36 A preussii AF121726@4 A asclepiadoides AF121725@4 A lindheimeri AF121711@29 A neglectus AF121713@35 A lonchocarpus AF121689@31 A ceramicus AF121730@16 A cremnophylA. L10810|11@4 A oocalycis L10784|85@4 A bisulcatus L10766|67@4 A cobrensis AF121720@18 A scopulorum L10790|91@43 A praelongus AF121716@4 A tenellus AF121718@4 A humillimus L10780|81@4 A gilviflorus AF121692@24 A polaris AF121714@38 A rubyi AF121715@41 A leptaleus AF121695@28 A spatulatus AF121732@45 A monumentalis L10814|15@4 A speirocarpus AF121733@4 A alvordensis AF121700@4 A curvicarpus AF121698@4 A tetrapterus AF121728@4 A arthuri AF121739@4 A collinus AF121703@4 A inyoensis AF121737@4 A kentrophyta varimplexus AF121723@4 A sesquiflorus AF121731@44 A woodruffii AF121724@48 A linifolius AF121696@30 A echinatus U50510|11@22 A calycosus AF121691@14 A bodinii U50592|93@12 A mollissimus AF121719@33 A jaegerianus DQ403838@26 A pachypus AF121722@37 A edmondstonei EU282978@3 A monticola EU282982@1 A curvicaulis EU282984@1 A darumbium EU282973@1 A pehuenches AF121747@1 A pehuenches EU282981@1 A johnstonii EU282988@1 A vagus EU282979@1 A douglasii AF121709@1 A oxyphysus AF121708@1 A asymmetricus AF121710@1 A nuttallii AF121705@1 A thurberi L10792|93@1 A allochrous AF121707@1 O. pilosa other spp. Oxytropis Coluteoids Astragalus s.str. 19 78 87 79 88 52 65 96 100 100 34 60 <5 91 93 28 26 Neo- Astragalus 98 98 A A B B C C D D E E G G F F country individuals : clones 17 21 34 35 38 46 49 51 74 136 149 154 167 190 196 202 235 318 341 342 352 364 368 376 387 402 403 404 405 406 407 408 409 410 411 412 413 414 415 416 461 470 478 486 498 502 515 519 539 544 570 577 590 605 Opil046g16RUSSiberiaAltai ACTGTCG-ACGGGGGTATAAGTGCTCGTTGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil047h26RUSSiberiaAltai ACTGTCG-ACGAGGGTATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil047n22RUSSiberiaAltai ACTGCCG-ACGGGGGTATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil036z01RUSKaukasus ACTGTCG-ACGGGGGTATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil036z02RUSKaukasus ACTGTCG-ACGGGGGTATAGGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil036z04RUSKaukasus ACTATCG-ACGGGGGTATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil036z05RUSKaukasus ACTGTCG-ACGGGGGTATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTATCGTATCATCTC Opil066b04ALienz ACTGTCG-ACTGGGGCATAAGTGCCCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil066b03ALienz ACTGTCG-ACGGGGGCATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil066b02ALienz ACTGTCG-ACGGGGGCATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil066b01ALienz ACTGTCG-ACGGGGACATAAGCGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGCATCATCTC Opil066a03ALienz ACTGTCG-ACGGGGGCATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil066a01ALienz ACTGTCG-ACGGGAGCATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil061b05DHegau ACTGTCG-ACGGGAGCATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil061b04DHegau ACTGTCG-ACGGGAGCATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil061b01DHegau ACTGTCG-ACGGGAGCATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil061a04DHegau ACTGTCG-ACGGGAGCATAAGTACTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil061b08DHegau ACTGTCG-ACGGGAGCATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCCC Opil061a01DHegau ACTGTCG-ACGGGAGCATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCCC Opil001b02DTuebingen ACTGTCG-ACGGGAGCATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil001b01DTuebingen ACTGTCG-ATGGGAGCATAAGTGTTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil001a01DTuebingen ACTGTTG-ACGGGAGCATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil001a03DTuebingen ACTGTCG-ACGGGAGCATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTACCATCTC Opil001a04DTuebingen ACTGTCG-ACGGGAGCACAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil001a05DTuebingen ACTGTCG-ACGGGAGCATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil001a06DTuebingen ACTGTCG-ACGGGAGCATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTT Opil053z02DHemleben ACTGTCG-ACGGGGGTATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATTCTCTC Opil053z03DHemleben ACTGTCGGACGGGGGCATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTTGTATCATCTC Opil053z04DHemleben ACTGTCG-ACGGGGGTATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil053z08DHemleben ACTGTCG-ACGGGGGTATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil053z10DHemleben ACTGTCG-ACGGGGGTATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTTGTATCATCTC Opil050a03SGotlandLummelunda ACTGTCG-ACGGGAGCATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil050m03SGotlandLummelunda ACTGTCG-ACGGGGGTATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil050m08SGotlandLummelunda ACTGTCG-ACGGGGGTATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil050m11SGotlandLummelunda ACTGTCG-ACGGGGGTATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil050z05SGotlandLummelunda ACTGTCG-ACGGGGGTATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil050z13SGotlandLummelunda ACTGTCG-ACGGGAGCATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATTTC Opil051a02SGotlandSjoelgeHamn ACTGTCG-ACGGGGGTATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil051z01SGotlandSjoelgeHamn ACTGTCG-ACGGGGGTATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil051z04SGotlandSjoelgeHamn ACTGTCG-ACGGGGGTATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil052a02SHegaIsberga ACTGTCG-ACGGGAGCATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil052a03SHegaIsberga ACTGTCA-ACGGGAGCATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil052b01SHegaIsberga ACTGTCA-ACGGGAGCATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil052b02SHegaIsberga ACTGTCA-ACGGGAGCATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil052z01SHegaIsberga GCTGTCA-ACGGGAGCATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil052z02SHegaIsberga ACTGTCG-ACGGGAGCATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCATTTCATCTC Opil040n01CHMartigny ACTGTCG-ACGGGAGCATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil040n02CHMartigny ACTGTCG-ACGGGAGCTTAAATGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil040n03CHMartigny ACTGTCG-ACGGGAGCTTAAATGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil040n04CHMartigny ACTGTCG-ACGGGAGCTTAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil040n05CHMartigny ACTGTCG-ACGGGAGCATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil012z01FDuranceSGap ACTGTCG-ACGGGAGCATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil012z02FDuranceSGap ACTGTCG-ACGGGAGCATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil012z04FDuranceSGap ACTGTCG-ACGGGAGCATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil012z07FDuranceSGap ACTGTCG-ACGGGAGCATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil012z08FDuranceSGap ACTGTCG-ACGGGAGCATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil031n02IKastellbell ACCTTCG-ACGGGAGCATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil031z01IKastellbell ACTGTCG-ACGGGAGCATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil031z04IKastellbell ACTGTCG-ACGGGAGCATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACCGTCGTATCATCTC Opil028a04IBormio ACTGTCG-ACGGGGGTATAAGTGCT - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -TGTCGTATCATCTC Opil028b03IBormio ACTGTCG-ACGGGGGTATAAGTGCT - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -TGTCGTATCATCTC Opil029b08IBormio ACTGTCG-ACGGGGGTATAAGTGCT - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -TGTCGTATCATCTC Opil007c06IBormio ACTGTCG-ACGGGGGTGTAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil007c05IBormio ACTGTCG-ACGGGGGTATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil028b06IBormio ACTGTCG-ACGGGGGTATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil028b02IBormio ACTGTCG-ACGGGGGTATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil028b01IBormio ACTGTCG-ACGGGGGTATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil028a05IBormio ACTGTCG-ACGGGGGTATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil028a03IBormio ACTGTCG-ACGGGGGTATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil028a02IBormio ACTGTCG-ACGGGGGTATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil028a01IBormio ACTGTCG-ACGGGGGTATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil007a03IBormio ACTGTCG-ACGGGGGTATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil007a02IBormio ACTGTCG-ACGGGGGTATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil029b02IBormio ACTGTCG-ACGGGGGTATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil029b03IBormio ACTGTCG-ACGGGGGTATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil029b06IBormio ACTGTCG-ACGGAGGTATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil029n01IBormio ACTGTCG-ACGGGGGTATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCACCTC Opil029n05IBormio ACTGTCG-GCGGGGGTATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGCCGTATCATCTC Opil029z01IBormio ACTGTCG-ACGGGGGTATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil007a01IBormio ACTGTCG-ACGGGAGCATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil038n03IAscoliPiceno ACTGTCG-ACGGGAGCATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil038z06IAscoliPiceno ACTGTCG-ACGGGAGCATGAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil039a07IRovere ATTGTCG-ACGGGGGCATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC Opil039n01IRovere ACTGTCG-ACGGGGGCATAAGTGCTCGATGCCTATTGCACTGTCGTATCATCTC 1:3 1:5 CH I (N1) 1:2 1:2 1:3 1:6 1:5 3:21 1:6 1:7 1:5 1:6 RUS (E) 2:3 1:4 1:6 D (SW) D (S) A RUS (S) S S (G2) S (G1) D (E) I (C2) I (C1) I (N2) F Fig. 4: UPGMA tree inferred with PAUP* (Swofford 2002) from MOD-transformed ITS rDNA clones of . O. pilosa

Upload: others

Post on 02-Aug-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Molecular phylogeny and species definition within the species rich … · 2019-06-26 · Molecular phylogeny and species definition within the species rich / complex (Fabaceae) Astragalus

Molecular phylogeny and species definition withinthe species rich / complex

(Fabaceae)Astragalus Oxytropis

M. Schlee , M. Göker , G. W. Grimm , V. Hemleben1 2 3 1

1 2 3Center for Plant Molecular Biology (ZMBP) - General Genetics; German Collection of Microorganisms and Cell Cultures (DSMZ), Braunschweig, Swedish Museum of Natural History, Dep. Palaeobotany, Stockholm

Fig. 2a: Oxytropis pilosa, Italy, Marche Fig. 2b: O. pilosa, Switzerland, Valais

Introduction

Oxytropis pilosa is a widespread but highly disjunctive relict species that originated in the steppes of the Altai, Siberia, from whereit spread to the West (Fig. 1). Having left the steppe-like areas where its distribution is facilitated by the tumbleweed-like behaviourof the infructescences, the species is now restricted to extreme xeric habitats such as gypsum or disturbed stony banks (Figs. 2 a-b).

Divergence in species of andOxytropis Astragalus

Additionally, the genetic divergence within was compared toother taxa within the / complex (2.500/300 species) –one of the largestAngiosperm genus complexes altogether (Fig. 6).Species clusters were defined by non-hierarchical single-linkage clustering(Göker et al. 2009); as threshold the smallest possible distance was chosenthat resulted in all sequences being assigned to the same cluster.The ENT transformation of Göker & Grimm (2008) was applied to detectstatistically significant differences between the genetic diversity of theresulting clusters. Molecular divergence within wasinsignificantly different from that observed in clusters comprisingnumerous accepted and species (Schlee et al., inpress).

O. pilosa

Astragalus Oxytropis

O. pilosa

O. pilosa

Astragalus Oxytropis

Adeep glance into Oxytropis pilosa

The morphologically very homogeneous was studied by phytosociological and molecular methods (Schlee et al. 2003).We obtained more than 200 cloned sequences which enabled us to evaluate the intra- and interindividual variability(Fig. 3). Genetic diversity within individuals is comparable to that within populations. The populations can be grouped into twomain types using the MOD transformation (Göker & Grimm 2008; Fig. 4) and p

. One type is characteristic for the putative stem populations of Russia (Fig. 3). The secondmain type replaces the first type throughout Europe, the stem type is completely lost within the most remotepopulations in the French Sea Alps (Fig. 4). Mixtures of both types occur within Central Europe and Northern Europe. The dataindicate repeated (post-)glacial exchange between temporally disjunct populations. Unique mutations (Hegau mountains, SWGermany; Bormio, ItalianAlps; Östergotland, Sweden; Fig. 3) could possibly mirror such nunatak-associated relicts.

O. pilosa

ITS rDNA

rincipal coordinate analysis of uncorrecteddistances between the clones (Fig. 5)

gradually

Outlook: Identifying genetic resources beyond species concepts

The outlined methods provide objective means to identify populations which represent evolutionary hot spots. Also,. These populations should considerably benefit from protection efforts.

Habitats of show dramatic secondary successions due to improper management regimes, highlighting the need for improved protection efforts (cf.phytosociological relevées, Tab. 1).

relict populations within assumedhomogeneous ranges can be detected easily

O. pilosa

Acknowledgements:Special thanks go toAngela Dressel and Karin Stögerer for technical assistance, and to Wilhelm Sauer for discussion. Reiner Schmahl, Eberhard Koch, Matthias Kropf and Natalie Schmalz, LudmillaBarjaewa, Ludmilla Mantschenkowa, and Erich Kalmbach, Friedrich Schlee, Evgenia Zeidler-Schewzowa, and the University of Barnaul (Altai, Siberia) are kindly acknowledged for contributingplant material. GZU, LY, M, and MAfor sending specimens for revision. Special thanks go to the visited herbaria BC, BOLO, C, DR, E, FB, FI, FR, G, HBG, K, LE, LI, LJU, M, MPU (incl. SIGMA), P,RO, S, STU, TUB, UPS, W, WU, and Z. Funding: Landesgraduiertenförderung Baden-Württemberg, Reinhold-und-Maria-Teufel-Stiftung, DAAD

References:Göker M, Grimm GW (2008): General functions to transform associate data to host data, and their use in phylogenetic inference from sequences with intra-individual variability. – BMC

Evolutionary Biology 8: 86Göker M, García-Blázquez G, Voglmayr H, Tellería MT, Martín MP (2009): Molecular taxonomy of phytopathogenic fungi: a case study in PLoS ONE 4: e6319Schlee M, Sauer W, Hemleben V (2003): Molekulare und pflanzensoziologische Analyse von pontisch-pannonischen Reliktarten aus wärmebegünstigten Saum-Gesellschaften Süddeutschlands

und benachbarter Gebiete. – Nova Acta Leopoldina NF 87 (328): 379-387Schlee M, Göker M, Grimm GW, Hemleben V (in press): Relicts within the genus complex / (Fabaceae), and the comparison of diversity by objective means. – in: Habel J,

Assmann T (eds.): Relict species: Phylogeography and conservation biology; Berlin, Heidelberg: SpringerStamatakis A (2006): RAxML-VI-HPC: maximum likelihood-based phylogenetic analyses with thousands of taxa and mixed models. – Bioinformatics 22 (21): 2688-2690Swofford DL (2002): PAUP*: Phylogenetic analysis using parsimony (* and other methods). 4th ed. Champaign, USA: National Illinois History Survey

Peronospora.

Astragalus Oxytropis

Fig. 3: Part of the alignment of ITS1, 5.8S rDNA, andITS2 sequences for (extract only showsvariable positions anywhere in the total alignment). Datainferred via cloning technique.

Oxytropis pilosa

L.p.pannonicus, Italy, Abruzzo

Ma

pso

urc

e:

Wik

ime

dia

co

mm

on

s

1a putative stem type2a second main type replacing the stem type

1b variant

variants2b 2c 2d

Fig. 1: Distribution map of the obtained types inferred by UPGMA analysis for(cf. Fig. 4).

O. pilosa

Fig. 6: Maximum likelihood treeinferred with RAxML (Stamatakis2006) from and

sequences, includingboth cloned and gene bank data.

AstragalusOxytropis

Fig. 5: Boxplots of the first (largest)eigenvector obtained by principlecoordinate analysis of uncorrecteddistances between the clones.

sequences were combinedaccording to their countries of origin:

Russia (R) - Sweden (S).

O.pilosa

A u s t r i a ( A ) - S w i t z e r l a n d ( C ) -Germany (D) - France (F) - Italy (I) -

No. S84 S83 S85 R14 R4 R5

Country D D D I A A

Relevée dimension 1 1,5 1 4 0,4 1

Inclination 20 45 45 15 45 5

Exposition SSW SSW S SSO SW SSW

Coverage altogether 60 15 50 75 60 70

Coronilla varia + . . . . .

Peucedanum cervaria v . . . . .

Lotus corniculatus subsp. corniculatus r . . . . .

Galium glaucum 2m 1 . . . .

Aster amellus + + . . . .

Hieracium pilosella + + . 1 . .

Onobrychis viciifolia subsp. viciifolia r v . . . .

Euphorbia cyparissias + + 1 . . .

Sanguisorba minor subsp. minor r + . . . .

Bromus erectus 3 1 1 . r .

Ligustrum vulgare (K) 1 . 1 . . .

Aster linosyris + + 1 . . .

Bupleurum falcatum + + + . . .

Stachys recta + v v . . .

Poa angustifolia v . r . . .

Oxytropis pilosa r + + 2a 1 2b

Salvia pratensis . . r . . .

Fragaria viridis . . r . . .

Trinia glauca subsp. glauca . . . + . .

Helictotrichon versicolor subsp. versicolor . . . + . .

Thymus pulegioides subsp. chamaedrys . . . 2m 2a .

Scabiosa columbaria . . . . 1 +

Festuca ovina agg. . . . . 3 2b

Potentilla alba . . . . r .

Sisymbrium loeselii . . . . r .

Scorzonera cana . . . . r .

Salvia sclarea . . . . . 2a

Dictamnus albus . . . . . v

Arrhenatherum elatius subsp. elatius . . . . . 2a

Lotus corniculatus subsp. hirsutus . . . . . 3

Centaurea scabiosa agg. . . . . . +

Achillea millefolium agg. . . . . . r

Column 1-3: near Tübingen,

4: Abruzzo, 5-6: Lower

Austria.secondary

stands. Increase of species

numbers and abundances

related to the fringing

c o m m u n i t i e s l e a d s t o

overgrowing of the whilom

open stands (decrease of

). Only disturbances

keep the habitats open and

favour the rare plants.

Oxytropis pilosa

O. pilosa

Tab. 1: Relevées inferred via Braun-Blanquet approach(extract).

A allochrous varallochrous EU282972@1

Cluster 2

Cluster 88

Cluster 89

Cluster 4

Cluster 1

Opil003z06ABrenner@88

Opil036z04RUSKaukasus@88

Opil047n22RUSSiberiaAltai@88

Opil029n01IBormio@88

Opil046g16RUSSiberiaAltai@88

Opil007c03IBormio@88

Opil047h26RUSSiberiaAltai@88

Opil003b03ABrenner@88

Opil007c04IBormio@88

Opil036a09RUSKaukasus@88

Opil053z08DHemleben@88

Opil028b01IBormio@88

Opil053z10DHemleben@88

Opil029n05IBormio@88

Opil003m03ABrenner@88

Opil036z05RUSKaukasus@88

Opil029b06IBormio@88

Opil053z02DHemleben@88

Opil063d03FLaRocheDeRame@88

Opil060c06AEichkogel@88

Opil063a07FLaRocheDeRame@88

Opil061b03DHegau@88

Opil037a03IRivaDelGarda@88

Opil013z09CHChur@88

Opil061a01DHegau@88

Opil068b01IValleDAosta@88

Opil001b01DTuebingen@88

Opil031n02IKastellbell@88

Opil062c03FBriancon@88

Opil063c01FLaRocheDeRame@88

Opil003z01ABrenner@88

Opil033b08CHInnVelaz@88

Opil050z13SGotlandLummelunda@88

Opil006m10CHScuols@88

Opil061b01DHegau@88

Opil026z11IPradStilfserjoch@88

Opil031z04IKastellbell@88

Opil033n05CHInnVelaz@88

Opil068b02IValleDAosta@88

Opil048n01DKoennern@88

Opil001a03DTuebingen@88

Opil006b01CHScuols@88

Opil064b01FStJeanDeMaurienne@88

Opil052z02SHegaIsberga@88

Opil001a04DTuebingen@88

Opil001b05DTuebingen@88

Opil064b02FStJeanDeMaurienne@88

Opil006m02CHScuols@88

Opil001a01DTuebingen@88

Opil003a03ABrenner@88

Opil052a03SHegaIsberga@88

Opil052z01SHegaIsberga@88

Opil063c06FLaRocheDeRame@88

Opil040n01CHMartigny@88

Opil006m09CHScuols@88

Opil053z03DHemleben@88

Opil066b01ALienz@88

Opil039n01IRovere@88

Opil066b04ALienz@88

Opil039a07IRovere@88

OpilosaAF121759@88

OoreophilavarjuniperinaAF121755@89

Ohal044c05FQueyras@89

Ohal044c02FQueyras@89

OcampestrisL10802|03@89

OarcvarbarnebyanaAF366322|23@89

OcampestrisvarjordaliiAF366299|301@89

OtananensisAF366344|45@89

OarcvararcticaAF366326|27@89

OarcvararcticaAF366324|25@89

OlambertiiL10806|07@89

OlambertiiAF121753@89

Ocam055b04CHPassCastainas@89

Ocam042z03FColDuGalibier@89

Ocam042z05FColDuGalibier@89

Ocam042z02FColDuGalibier@89

Ocam055b01CHPassCastainas@89

Ocam041z07EPicosPerdidos@89

Ocam041z08EPicosPerdidos@89

Ocam049z03SOelandVickelby@89

Ocam045a01ANDCasamanya@89

Ocam049a02SOelandVickelby@89

OcampestrisvargracilisAF366338|39@89

OcampestrisvargracilisAF366336|37@89

OarcvarbarnebyanaAF366304|05@89

OarcvarbarnebyanaAF366302|03@89

OarcvarbarnebyanaAF366298|300@89

OarcvarbarnebyanaAF366314|15@89

OarcvarkoyukuensisAF366328|29@89

OarcvarbarnebyanaAF366318|19@89

OkobukensisAF366346|47@89

OanertiiEF685971@89

Ocam041z01EPicosPerdidos@89

OarcvarbarnebyanaAF366316|17@89

Ocam045a03ANDCasamanya@89

OarcvarbarnebyanaAF366308|09@89

OarcvarbarnebyanaAF366310|11@89

OarcvararcticaAF366320|21@89

OarcvarbarnebyanaAF366312|13@89

OarcvarkoyukuensisAF366330|31@89

OarcvarkoyukuensisAF366334|35@89

OarcvarkoyukuensisAF366332|33@89

OsplendensAF121761@89

OmulticepsAF121760@89

ObesseyivarventosaAF121756@89

OnigrescensAF366348|49@89

OszovitsiiAF121754@89

OdeflexaL10804|05@91

A. vogelii U50498 99@86

A. cysticalyx AF121682@64

A. milingensis AF521954@78

A. yatungensis AF521955@87

A. hendersonii AF521957@72

A. balfourianus AF521951@57

A. tanguticus AF521956@84

A. sinicus U50502|03@61

A. complanatus U50500|01@61

A. complanatus AF521950@61

A. epiglottis U50506|07@66

A. pelecinus U50518|19@80

A. corrugatus L10774|75@62

A. eucosmus AF121684@67

A. robbinsii varminor U50490|91@67

A. williamsii AF121685@56

A. australis varglabriusculus AF121686@56

A. atropilosulus varvenosus U50504|05@55

Aexs005b02ILaasEyrs@68

A. chinensis AF121681@60

A. hoantchy AF359754@73

A. hoantchy subspdshimensis AF359755@74

A. alopecias U50508|09@52

Aalo004b02FSeealpen225@54

A. lehmannianus AF359756@75

A. sieversianus AF359757@83

A. lepsensis AF359752@76

A. umbellatus AF121683@85

Afri003a06ATannheim@69

A. membranaceus AF359749@77

A. membranaceus varmongholicus EF685969@77

A. propinquus AF359751@82

A. aksuensis AF359753@51

Agly006b03ESoria@70

A. hamosus L10778@71

A. cymbicarpos AF121678@63

A. edulis AF121677@65

A. boeticus AF121679@58

A. uliginosus EF685970@59

A. canadensis L10770@59

A. canadensis varbrevidens U50496|97@59

A. oreganus AF121687@59

A. falcatus U50488|89@59

A. echidniformis U50512|13@49

A. cerasocrenus U50514|15@49

A. peristerus U50494|95@49

A. polycladus AF121676@81

Aalp002b02ATannheim@53

A. alpinus L10760@53

A. nankotaizanensis AF121680@79

A. cicer L10772@50

A agrestis L10758|59@9

A pulchellus L10786|87@39

A chaborasicus L10808|09@17

A asterias L10764|65@11

A tribuloides L10794|95@11

A adsurgens AF121674@7

A austrosibiricus AF359758@8

A adsurgens L10756|57@8

A brandegei L10768|69@13

A sabulonum AF121706@42

A berteroanus EU282983@2

A arnottianus EU282975@2

A arnottianus AF121748@2

A patagonicus AF121746@2

A amatus EU282976@2

A uniflorus EU282986@2

A pickeringii AF121741@2

A garbancillo AF121740@2

A garbancillo EU282987@2

A arizonicus AF121690@10

A nivicola EU282985@6

A didymocarpus DQ403841@20

A didymocarpus DQ403840@20

A didymocarpus DQ403839@19

A didymocarpus vardispermus AF121721@21

A utahensis L10796|97@47

A eremiticus AF121736@23

A lentiginosus varpalans EU282969@5

A layneae DQ403844@27

A layneae DQ403843@27

A layneae DQ403842@27

A chamaemeniscus AF121727@4

A cibarius AF121729@4

A lentiginosus L10812|13@4

A lentiginosus vardiphysus EU282977@4

A lentiginosus varvariabilis EU282970@4

A obscurus AF121701@4

A salmonis AF121735@4

A sheldonii AF121704@4

A reventus AF121702@4

A caricinus AF121734@15

A miser AF121717@32

A molybdenus AF121694@34

A tener AF121697@46

A rattanii AF121712@40

A hallii L10776|77@25

A nuttallianus L10816|17@36

A preussii AF121726@4

A asclepiadoides AF121725@4

A lindheimeri AF121711@29

A neglectus AF121713@35

A lonchocarpus AF121689@31

A ceramicus AF121730@16

A cremnophylA. L10810|11@4

A oocalycis L10784|85@4

A bisulcatus L10766|67@4

A cobrensis AF121720@18

A scopulorum L10790|91@43

A praelongus AF121716@4

A tenellus AF121718@4

A humillimus L10780|81@4

A gilviflorus AF121692@24

A polaris AF121714@38

A rubyi AF121715@41

A leptaleus AF121695@28

A spatulatus AF121732@45

A monumentalis L10814|15@4

A speirocarpus AF121733@4

A alvordensis AF121700@4

A curvicarpus AF121698@4

A tetrapterus AF121728@4

A arthuri AF121739@4

A collinus AF121703@4

A inyoensis AF121737@4

A kentrophyta varimplexus AF121723@4

A sesquiflorus AF121731@44

A woodruffii AF121724@48

A linifolius AF121696@30

A echinatus U50510|11@22

A calycosus AF121691@14

A bodinii U50592|93@12

A mollissimus AF121719@33

A jaegerianus DQ403838@26

A pachypus AF121722@37

A edmondstonei EU282978@3

A monticola EU282982@1

A curvicaulis EU282984@1

A darumbium EU282973@1

A pehuenches AF121747@1

A pehuenches EU282981@1

A johnstonii EU282988@1

A vagus EU282979@1

A douglasii AF121709@1

A oxyphysus AF121708@1

A asymmetricus AF121710@1

A nuttallii AF121705@1

A thurberi L10792|93@1

A allochrous AF121707@1

O. pilosa

otherspp.Oxytropis

Coluteoids

As

tra

ga

lus

s.s

tr.

19

78

87

79

88

52

65

96

100

100

34

60

<5

91

93

2826

Ne

o-A

str

ag

alu

s

9898

AA

BBCC

DD

EE

GG

FF

country

ind

ivid

uals

:clo

nes

17

21

34

35

38

46

49

51

74

13

61

49

15

41

67

19

01

96

20

22

35

31

83

41

34

23

52

36

43

68

37

63

87

40

24

03

40

44

05

40

64

07

40

84

09

41

04

11

41

24

13

41

44

15

41

64

61

47

04

78

48

64

98

50

25

15

51

95

39

54

45

70

57

75

90

60

5

Opil046g16RUSSiberiaAltai A C T G T C G - A C G G G G G T A T A A G T G C T C G T T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil047h26RUSSiberiaAltai A C T G T C G - A C G A G G G T A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil047n22RUSSiberiaAltai A C T G C C G - A C G G G G G T A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil036z01RUSKaukasus A C T G T C G - A C G G G G G T A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil036z02RUSKaukasus A C T G T C G - A C G G G G G T A T A G G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil036z04RUSKaukasus A C T A T C G - A C G G G G G T A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil036z05RUSKaukasus A C T G T C G - A C G G G G G T A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T A T C G T A T C A T C T COpil066b04ALienz A C T G T C G - A C T G G G G C A T A A G T G C C C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil066b03ALienz A C T G T C G - A C G G G G G C A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil066b02ALienz A C T G T C G - A C G G G G G C A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil066b01ALienz A C T G T C G - A C G G G G A C A T A A G C G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G C A T C A T C T COpil066a03ALienz A C T G T C G - A C G G G G G C A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil066a01ALienz A C T G T C G - A C G G G A G C A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil061b05DHegau A C T G T C G - A C G G G A G C A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil061b04DHegau A C T G T C G - A C G G G A G C A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil061b01DHegau A C T G T C G - A C G G G A G C A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil061a04DHegau A C T G T C G - A C G G G A G C A T A A G T A C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil061b08DHegau A C T G T C G - A C G G G A G C A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C C COpil061a01DHegau A C T G T C G - A C G G G A G C A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C C COpil001b02DTuebingen A C T G T C G - A C G G G A G C A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil001b01DTuebingen A C T G T C G - A T G G G A G C A T A A G T G T T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil001a01DTuebingen A C T G T T G - A C G G G A G C A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil001a03DTuebingen A C T G T C G - A C G G G A G C A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A C C A T C T COpil001a04DTuebingen A C T G T C G - A C G G G A G C A C A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil001a05DTuebingen A C T G T C G - A C G G G A G C A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil001a06DTuebingen A C T G T C G - A C G G G A G C A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T TOpil053z02DHemleben A C T G T C G - A C G G G G G T A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T T C T C T COpil053z03DHemleben A C T G T C G G A C G G G G G C A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T T G T A T C A T C T COpil053z04DHemleben A C T G T C G - A C G G G G G T A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil053z08DHemleben A C T G T C G - A C G G G G G T A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil053z10DHemleben A C T G T C G - A C G G G G G T A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T T G T A T C A T C T COpil050a03SGotlandLummelunda A C T G T C G - A C G G G A G C A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil050m03SGotlandLummelunda A C T G T C G - A C G G G G G T A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil050m08SGotlandLummelunda A C T G T C G - A C G G G G G T A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil050m11SGotlandLummelunda A C T G T C G - A C G G G G G T A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil050z05SGotlandLummelunda A C T G T C G - A C G G G G G T A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil050z13SGotlandLummelunda A C T G T C G - A C G G G A G C A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T T T COpil051a02SGotlandSjoelgeHamn A C T G T C G - A C G G G G G T A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil051z01SGotlandSjoelgeHamn A C T G T C G - A C G G G G G T A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil051z04SGotlandSjoelgeHamn A C T G T C G - A C G G G G G T A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil052a02SHegaIsberga A C T G T C G - A C G G G A G C A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil052a03SHegaIsberga A C T G T C A - A C G G G A G C A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil052b01SHegaIsberga A C T G T C A - A C G G G A G C A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil052b02SHegaIsberga A C T G T C A - A C G G G A G C A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil052z01SHegaIsberga G C T G T C A - A C G G G A G C A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil052z02SHegaIsberga A C T G T C G - A C G G G A G C A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C A T T T C A T C T C

Opil040n01CHMartigny A C T G T C G - A C G G G A G C A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T C

Opil040n02CHMartigny A C T G T C G - A C G G G A G C T T A A A T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T C

Opil040n03CHMartigny A C T G T C G - A C G G G A G C T T A A A T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T C

Opil040n04CHMartigny A C T G T C G - A C G G G A G C T T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T C

Opil040n05CHMartigny A C T G T C G - A C G G G A G C A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil012z01FDuranceSGap A C T G T C G - A C G G G A G C A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil012z02FDuranceSGap A C T G T C G - A C G G G A G C A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil012z04FDuranceSGap A C T G T C G - A C G G G A G C A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil012z07FDuranceSGap A C T G T C G - A C G G G A G C A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil012z08FDuranceSGap A C T G T C G - A C G G G A G C A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T C

Opil031n02IKastellbell A C C T T C G - A C G G G A G C A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T C

Opil031z01IKastellbell A C T G T C G - A C G G G A G C A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T C

Opil031z04IKastellbell A C T G T C G - A C G G G A G C A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C C G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil028a04IBormio A C T G T C G - A C G G G G G T A T A A G T G C T - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil028b03IBormio A C T G T C G - A C G G G G G T A T A A G T G C T - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil029b08IBormio A C T G T C G - A C G G G G G T A T A A G T G C T - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil007c06IBormio A C T G T C G - A C G G G G G T G T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil007c05IBormio A C T G T C G - A C G G G G G T A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil028b06IBormio A C T G T C G - A C G G G G G T A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil028b02IBormio A C T G T C G - A C G G G G G T A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil028b01IBormio A C T G T C G - A C G G G G G T A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil028a05IBormio A C T G T C G - A C G G G G G T A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil028a03IBormio A C T G T C G - A C G G G G G T A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil028a02IBormio A C T G T C G - A C G G G G G T A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil028a01IBormio A C T G T C G - A C G G G G G T A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil007a03IBormio A C T G T C G - A C G G G G G T A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil007a02IBormio A C T G T C G - A C G G G G G T A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil029b02IBormio A C T G T C G - A C G G G G G T A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil029b03IBormio A C T G T C G - A C G G G G G T A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil029b06IBormio A C T G T C G - A C G G A G G T A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil029n01IBormio A C T G T C G - A C G G G G G T A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A C C T COpil029n05IBormio A C T G T C G - G C G G G G G T A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G C C G T A T C A T C T COpil029z01IBormio A C T G T C G - A C G G G G G T A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil007a01IBormio A C T G T C G - A C G G G A G C A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil038n03IAscoliPiceno A C T G T C G - A C G G G A G C A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil038z06IAscoliPiceno A C T G T C G - A C G G G A G C A T G A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil039a07IRovere A T T G T C G - A C G G G G G C A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T COpil039n01IRovere A C T G T C G - A C G G G G G C A T A A G T G C T C G A T G C C T A T T G C A C T G T C G T A T C A T C T C

1:3

1:5CH

I (N1)

1:2

1:2

1:3

1:6

1:5

3:21

1:6

1:7

1:5

1:6

RUS (E) 2:3

1:4

1:6

D (SW)

D (S)

A

RUS (S)

S

S (G2)

S (G1)

D (E)

I (C2)

I (C1)

I (N2)

F

Fig. 4: UPGMA treeinferred with PAUP*(Swofford 2002) fromMOD-transformed ITSrDNAclones of .O. pilosa