mining and ecosystem services: hard trade-offs in ecuador · 2012-12-18 · rivers and lakes...

43
© 2012 Earth Economics Lola Flores, Research Analyst Maya Kocian, Economist Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador

Upload: others

Post on 04-Jul-2020

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

© 2012 Earth Economics

Lola Flores, Research Analyst

Maya Kocian, Economist

Mining and Ecosystem

Services: Hard trade-offs

in Ecuador

Page 2: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

© 2012 Earth Economics

Overview: Study Area

The Dilemma

Applying Ecological Economics

About Us

Agenda

Page 3: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

© 2012 Earth Economics Credit: Conservation International

Biological Hot Spots

Page 4: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

© 2012 Earth Economics

Tumbes-Chocó-Magdalena

Page 5: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

© 2012 Earth Economics

Sumak Kawsay

Page 6: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

© 2012 Earth Economics

Rights for Nature

Page 7: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

© 2012 Earth Economics

Imbabura

Province

Page 8: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

Intag

Page 9: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

© 2012 Earth Economics

Page 10: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

© 2012 Earth Economics

Page 11: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

© 2012 Earth Economics

Page 12: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

© 2012 Earth Economics

Page 13: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

© 2012 Earth Economics

Page 14: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

© 2012 Earth Economics

Page 15: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

© 2012 Earth Economics

The Dilemma in Intag

Page 16: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

© 2012 Earth Economics

Cu

Page 17: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

© 2012 Earth Economics

Page 18: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

© 2012 Earth Economics

Page 19: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

© 2012 Earth Economics

“Impacts to the local

climate, leading to

desertification”

(JICA 1996)

Page 20: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

© 2012 Earth Economics

Page 21: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

© 2012 Earth Economics

• DECOIN (Defense and Conservation of Intag)

• AACRI (Río Intag Agroartesanal Coffee Growers’ Association)

• ACAI (Association of Agro-Ecological Farmers of Intag)

• TOISÁN CONSORTIUM(social and sustainable development)

• Member groups of the WOMEN’S COORDINATING COMMITTEE OF INTAG

• COMMUNITY COUNCIL of García Moreno

• Flor deMayo and other forest ranger groups

• Cotacachi-Cayapas Reserve Committee for the Cuellaje District

• JUNÍN Ecotourism Group

• CTGV (Greater Valley Workshop Corporation)

• LOS CEDROS Foundation

• Manduriacos TourismCommittee

• YOUNG PEOPLE’S COORDINATING COMMITTEE OF INTAG

• RAINFOREST CONCERN

• NGO ZOO BREVIVEN

• PRODECI-AYUDA ENACCIÓN

• PRODERENA, ECOPAR, FBU, XCS, USAID

• Chalguayaco Alto Farming and Livestock Association

• AUCC (Environmental Management Council CGAMRN)

Page 22: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

© 2012 Earth Economics

Page 23: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

© 2012 Earth Economics

1) Bishimetals

2) Ascendant Copper (Copper Mesa)

Page 24: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

© 2012 Earth Economics

Source: aljazeera.com/news/americas/2012/03/20123921342425380.html

Page 25: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

© 2012 Earth Economics

Page 26: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

© 2012 Earth Economics

Page 27: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

© 2012 Earth Economics

Applying Ecological Economics

Page 28: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

© 2012 Earth Economics

Medicinal Resources Carbon Sequestration

Page 29: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

© 2012 Earth Economics

Freshwater Supply

Page 30: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

© 2012 Earth Economics

Ecosystems Services

Page 31: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

© 2012 Earth Economics

Values for Intag

Page 32: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

© 2012 Earth Economics

Final Report

Page 33: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

501(c)3 founded in 1998

About Us

Page 34: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

Where we work

Page 35: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

EVT and SERVES SERVES = Simple, Effective Resource for Valuing

Ecosystem Services

EVT = Ecosystem Valuation Toolkit

Page 36: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

And so on…

Page 38: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87
Page 39: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest

Gas and Climate Regulation x x Flood Protection x x Habitat Refugium x x x

Pollination x Soil Erosion Control x x

Water Flow Regulation x x x Nutrient Cycling x Water Supply x x x Water Quality x x x

Biological Control x Aesthetic & Recreational x x x

Soil Formation x x Food Provisioning x x

Biodiversity x x x

Page 40: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest

Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87 $7.56 Habitat Refugium $17.13 $58.89 $269.85

Pollination x x Soil Erosion Control

Water Flow Regulation x x x Nutrient Cycling x Water Supply $58.89 $199.11 $2,105 Water Quality x x

Biological Control

Aesthetic & Recreational $1.69 x $1,043 Soil Formation

Food Provisioning x x

Biodiversity x x

Page 41: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest

Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56

Flood Protection $117.87 $7.56

Habitat Refugium $17.13 $58.89 $269.85

Pollination

Soil Erosion Control

Water Flow Regulation x x x

Nutrient Cycling x

Water Supply $58.89 $199.11 $2,105

Water Quality x x

Biological Control

Aesthetic & Recreational $1.69 x $1,043

Soil Formation

Food Provisioning x x

Biodiversity x x

Page 42: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest

Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56

Flood Protection $117.87 $7.56

Habitat Refugium $17.13 $58.89 $269.85

Pollination

Soil Erosion Control

Water Flow Regulation x x x

Nutrient Cycling x

Water Supply $58.89 $199.11 $2,105

Water Quality x x

Biological Control

Aesthetic & Recreational $1.69 x $1,043

Soil Formation

Food Provisioning x x

Biodiversity x x

Rivers & Lakes

$77.71 per acre

each year

Total Low Value of Rivers and

Lakes

Page 43: Mining and Ecosystem Services: Hard trade-offs in Ecuador · 2012-12-18 · Rivers and Lakes Wetlands Riparian Forest Gas and Climate Regulation $29.43 $43.56 Flood Protection $117.87

Rivers & Lakes

$77.71 per acre

each year

Open Water

Perennial Ice/Snow

Deciduous Forest

Evergreen Forest

Mixed Forest

Scrub/Shrub

Grassland/Herbaceous

Pasture/Hay

Cultivated Crops

Woody Wetlands

Herbaceous Wetlands

Eelgrass

Rivers and Lakes

Total Low Value

of each

landcover type * [ ] Acres