marketing model for high technology projects
DESCRIPTION
Study of Typical Marketing Model pursued in promoting Business for High Technology Projects at ECILTRANSCRIPT
PREFACE
The Dissertation presents a study of marketing practice followed by high
technology projects oriented medium scale industry.
To start any business the success entirely depends on the marketing
research done about the particular company and the consumer attitude
towards the product. Marketing research plays a vital role in a business to
make it success
Conventional Marketing concepts and methods those work best for
consumer products suits here, once technology has matured and
established itself in the market place. But for high technology products, in
the initial stages of market acceptance, what we term the supply-side
stages the same marketing concepts and techniques sometimes do not
work.
The same conventional marketing concepts and techniques that are so
largely responsible for the high standard of living enjoyed by mass
distribution societies need adaptation and sometimes refinement to fit the
specialized and often singular needs of companies engaged in high
technology.
In comparison to conventional marketing, selling a project poses unusual
challenges to the marketing team. Indeed, the development of high
technology that fulfils a significant human need or desire, present or
future, is a critical marketing task.
Adeptness depends not only on the collective ability of a nation’s
scientists to make head way in R&D but also the prowess of its business
people in making and developing incipient technologies into a commercial
success.
For the product line, which I have chosen that, is High Technology
Projects, normally a standard product does not exist rather they are
1
configured/customized out of standard products according to customer’s
requirements.
Project marketing studied here, presents a customer defined, unique
solution envisaged by the user department.
Each project is unique in the sense that the requirement varies from
customer to customer and the environment in which the project is
expected to work.
The main objective of marketing in a high technology project/ product
oriented organization is to achieve customer acceptance and satisfaction,
before profitability can be aimed at.
Best acceptance of customer is achieved when his expectations are met
adequately and when the project best suits the purpose for which the
system is intended.
I was looking for an opportunity to study about marketing methodology of
high technology projects with reference to conventional marketing
concepts. Electronic Corporation Of India Limited is one such organization
I felt that will best suit for my study.
I have got myself associated with Security Systems Business Unit dealing
with products, which are prevailing in India, specifically designed for
varying environments.
As gathered, ECIL has been dealing with either individual System or
integrated configuration using two or more systems.
The report that follows reflects studies made by me after going into the
details of each activity and through my interactions with the officials
practicing them.
COMPANY PROFILE
BRIEF HISTORY
2
ECIL was setup under the Department of Atomic Energy in the year 1967
with a view to generating a strong indigenous capability in the field of
professional grade electronics. The initial accent was on total self-reliance
and ECIL was engaged in the Design Development, Manufacture and
Marketing of several products emphasis on three technology lines viz.
Computers, Control Systems and Communications. Over the years, ECIL
pioneered the development of various complex electronics products
without any external technological help and scored several 'firsts' in
these fields prominent among them being country's
First Digital Computer
First Solid State TV
First Control & Instrumentation for Nuclear Power Plants
First Earth Station Antenna
The company played a very significant role in the training and growth of
high caliber technical and managerial manpower especially in the fields of
Computers and Information Technology. Though the initial thrust
was on meeting the Control & Instrumentation requirements of the
Nuclear Power Program, the expanded scope of self-reliance pursued by
ECIL enabled the company to develop various products to cater to the
needs of Defense, Civil Aviation, Information & Broadcasting,
Telecommunications, Insurance, Banking, Police, and Para-Military Forces,
Oil & Gas, Power, Space Education, Health, Agriculture, Steel and Coal
sectors and various user departments in the Government domain. ECIL
thus evolved as a multi-product company serving multiple sectors of
Indian economy with emphasis on import of country substitution and
development of products & services that are of economic and strategic
significance to the country.
Electronics Corporation of India LimitedPO.ECIL, HYDERABAD - 500 062, AP, INDIA
Phone: 91-40-27120131(10 lines)
MISSION AND OBJECTIVES MISSION
3
ECIL's mission is to consolidate its status as a valued national asset in the
area of strategic electronics with specific focus on Atomic Energy,
Defense, Security and such critical sectors of strategic national
importance.
OBJECTIVES
To continue services to the country's needs for the peaceful uses
Atomic Energy. Special and Strategic requirements of Defense and
Space, Electronics Security Systems and Support for Civil Aviation
sector.
To establish newer technology products such as Container Scanning
Systems and Explosive Detectors.
To explore new avenues of business and work for growth in
strategic sectors in addition to working for realizing technological
solutions for the benefit of society in areas like Agriculture,
Education, Health, Power, Transportation, Food, Disaster
Management etc.
To progressively improve shareholder value of the company.
To strengthen the technology base, enhance skill base and ensure
succession planning in the company.
To re-engineer the company to become nationally and
internationally competitive by paying particular attention to
delivery, cost and quality in all its activities.
To consciously work for finding export markets for the company's
products.
DIVISIONS
The COMPANY is organized into DIVISIONS serving various
SECTORS, National and Commercial Importance.
4
SECTOR DIVISIONS
Divisions serving
Nuclear sector
Control & Automation Division (CAD)
Instruments & Systems Division (ISD)
Components Division (CD)
Divisions serving
Defence sector
Communications Division (CND)
Antenna Products Division (APD)
Servo Systems Division (SSD)
Strategic Electronics Division (SED)
Special Products Division (SPD)
Divisions handling
Commercial
Products
Supervisory Control & Data Acquisition
Division (SCADA)
Business Systems Division (BSD)
Telecom Division (TCD)
Customer Support Division (CSD)
Computer Education Division (CED)
CONVENTIONAL MARKETING AND ITS CONCEPTS
Marketing is typically seen as the task of creating, promoting and
delivering Goods and Services to consumers and Businesses. It deals with
identifying and meeting human and social needs. Marketers are skilled in
stimulating demand for a company’s products.
5
Marketing managers face a host of decision making challenges from
major ones such as what product features to design into a new product,
how many sales people to hire, or how much to spend on advertising etc.
Under product marketing, companies selling mass consumer Goods
and Services such as soft drinks, Tooth Paste, television sets and Air
Travel, spend a great deal of time trying to establish a superior brand
image.
This requires getting a clear sense of the target customers, what
needs their product will have to meet, and communicating brand
positioning forcefully and creatively.
Much of a brand’s strengths depend on developing a superior
product and packaging and backing it with continuous advertising and
reliable service.
Marketing is a societal process by which individuals and groups
obtain what they need and want through creating, offering and freely
exchanging products and services of value with each other.
It is an art of selling products.
Marketing Management is the process of planning and executing
the conception, pricing, promotion and distribution of ideas, goods, and
services to create exchanges that satisfy individual and organizational
goals.
CONSUMER BUYING BEHAVIOUR
Understanding the buying behaviour of the target market is the essential
task of marketing management under marketing concept. The consumer
market consists of all the individuals and households who buy or acquire
good and services for personal consumptions. The buying behaviour tries
to find out the answers for the questions, who buys? How do they buy?
Where do they buy? Do they buy?
(A) FACTORS INFLUENCING CONSUMER BUYING BEHAVIOR
6
There are four major factors that influence the buying behaviour such as
cultural factors, social factors, personal factors, and psychological factors.
i. CULTURAL FACTORS: Culture is the most fundamental
determinant of a person wants and behaviour. Values, perceptions,
preferences, and behaviour are the main variable under culture of
an individual. Each culture contains sub-culture like nationality,
religious group, geographical area, and linguistic divisions etc.
ii. SOCIAL FACTORS: Consumer behaviour is also influenced by
social factors such as the consumer reference group family and
social roles and status.
iii. PERSONAL FACTORS: A buyer decision is also influenced by his or
personal characteristics, notably the buyers age, lifestyle,
occupation, economic circumstances etc.
iv. PSYCHOLOGICAL FACTORS: a person buying choice is also
influenced by four major psychological factors such as motivation,
perception, learning belief and attitudes.
(B) BUYING DECISION PROCESS
It includes buying roles, types of buying and steps in buying process.
I. BUYING ROLE
The buying role could be classified into four parts. These are initiator,
influencer, decider and buyer.
II. TYPES OF BUYING BEHAVIOR
Consumer decision taking varies with the type of buying decision. There
are four types buying behaviour such as Complex buying behaviour,
Habitual buying behaviour, Variety seeking buying behaviour.
7
III. STAGES IN BUYING DECISION PROCESS
Here are five stages in buying decision process namely problem
recognition search, evaluation of alternatives purchase decision and past
purchase behaviour.
NEED RECOGNITION
The buying process starts with the buyer’s recognition of a problem of
need. The buyer senses a difference between his actual state and desired
state.
INFORMATION SEARCH
There are different sources from where a consumer can gather
information like personal sources commercial sources, experimental
sources.
EVALUATION OF ALTERNATIVES
After gathering information about different products the customer will be
in a fuss as to choose which product among the mainly alternatives
consumer usually evaluate the alternatives on traditional basis, on the
basis of utility function etc. from the many alternative consumers at last
choose the best one for him.
PURCHASE DECISION
A consumer who decides to execute purchase intention will be making up
to five purchase decisions.
POST PURCHASE BEHAVIOR
After purchasing the product and services the consumer will experience
some level of satisfaction or dissatisfaction with the product and services
that will influence subsequent behaviour. If consumer is satisfied he may
show the probability of buying the product the next time, satisfied
customer will say good thing about the product, proving the statement
that "satisfied customer is the best advertisement.” A dissatisfied
8
customer may take some action against it. They may try to reduce the
dissonance by abandoning returning the product.
Understanding consumer needs and buying process is the foundation of
any company. By understanding how buyers go through problem
recognition, information search evaluation of alternatives, the purchase
decision and post purchase behaviour marketers can pick up many clues
as to how to meet buyers need.
LITERATURE REVIEW
MARKETING
Marketing is a societal process by which individuals and groups obtain
what they need and want through creating, offering and freely
exchanging products and services of value with others or otherwise it is
the process of planning and executing the conception, pricing, promotion
and distribution of ideas, goods, services to create exchanges that satisfy
individual and organizational goals.
MARKETING STRATEGY
Marketing strategy is a set of objectives, policies and rules that leads the
company's marketing efforts. It is the marketing approach to accomplish
the bread objective of the marketing approach to accomplish the bread
objective of the marketing plan. The various process of marketing
strategy are given below.
1. Selecting largest markets segmentation
2. Positioning
3. Product
4. Price
9
5. Place
6. Promotion
7. Research and development
8. Marketing research
MARKET SEGMENTATION AND SELECTING TARGET MARKET
It is an effort to increase a company's precision marketing. The starting
point of any segmentation discussion is mass marketing. In mass
marketing, the seller engaged in the mass production, mass distribution
and mass promotion of one product for all buyers. Market segment
consists of a large identifiable group within a market with similar wants,
purchasing power geographical location, buying attitudes or buying
habita. It is an approach midway between mass marketing and individual
marketing. Through this the choice of distribution channels and
communication channels become much easier. The researchers try to
form segments by looking at consumer characteristics; geographic,
demographic, and psychographic. After segmenting the market then
target market selected.
2. POSITIONING: - The positioning is a creative exercise down with an
existing product. The well known products generally hold a distinctive
position in consumer's minds. The positioning requires that every tangible
aspect of product, price, place and promotion must support the chosen
positioning strategy. Company should develop a unique selling
proposition (USP) for each brand and stick to it, PPL consistently promotes
its DAP fertilizer by Higher yield at lower cost. As companies increase the
number of claims for their brand, they risk disbelief and a loss of clear
positioning. In general a company must avoid four major positioning
errors. Those are under positioning over positioning, confused positioning
and doubtful positioning.
3. PRODUCT: - A product is any offering that can satisfy a need or want.
The major types of basic offerings are goods, services, experiences,
10
events, places, properties, organizations, information and ideas. The
company gives more importance in quality, packaging, services etc. to
satisfy the customers. The products has it's life cycle. The product
strategies are modified in different stages of product life cycle.
4. PRICE: - It is the most important aspect in company's point of view.
Price of the product will be decided by the company according to the
competitor's price.
5. PLACE: - This plays a major role in the entire marketing system. The
company emphasis on its distribution network. Proper distribution
network gives proper availability of the product.
6. PROMOTION: - Promotion is the one of the major aspects in
marketing strategies. By adopting various promotional activities the
company create strong brand image. It also helps in increasing the brand
awareness. It includes advertising, sales promotions and public relations
etc.
7. RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT: - after testing, the new product
manager must develop a preliminary marketing strategy plan for
introducing the new product in to the market. The plan consists of three
parts. The first part describes the target market's size, structure and
behaviour. The second part outlines the planned price, distribution
strategy and marketing budget for the first year. The third part of the
development describes the long run sales and profit goals and marketing
mix strategy over time.
Product Price Promotion Place
11
Marketing Mix
Product
varietyList price
Sales
promotionChannels
Quality Discounts Advertising Coverage
Design Allowances Sales forcesAssortment
s
FeaturesPayment
period
Public
relationLocations
Brand
name
Credit
terms
Direct
marketingInventory
Packaging Transport
Sizes
Services
MARKETING HIGH TECHNOLOGY
Technology progress in any society is fostered ad facilitated by the
presence of three key ingredients-
1. Innovation and creative people,
2. An economic climate conductive to entrepreneurship and
3. The managerial know-how both for
a. Stimulating new concepts
b. Taking the promising ideas through successful initial
communication and beyond
12
These three elements complement one another and produce synergies.
Innovation works best when all these ingredients are presents.
High technology oriented products, services, processes and projects
represent totally new concepts which are un heard and of break thoughts.
They are modified and configured in their lines with improvements of
existing products or projects according to the requirement of the
customer.
Technological innovation is managerial know-how to develop and market
high tech products.
There is a real need now for much more planned technological innovation
with in the corporate structure, rather than having society rely on the
single – person venture that has historically characterised technological
breakthroughs.
Technological research, development, and marketing simply require too
much capital and expertise for the single – venture entrepreneur.
Fortunately, marketing thought and practise has advanced and been
refined to the point where a great deal is known about enhancing the
success of high tech product endeavours. Marketing technology has kept
pace with engineering technology.
Yet in high technology firms there is too frequently an absence of
adequate marketing knowledge and skills, consequently the product
failure rate is higher than it should be or would be with the application of
appropriate marketing concepts and method. Marketing knowledge and
expertise is vital to the success of high technology projects oriented firms.
SUPPLY SIDE MARKETING
13
Marketing concepts have traditionally been demand Side oriented and
have devoted most of it attention consumer products.
High technology marketing however, involves demand side
and supply side marketing expertise and pertains to industrial
and technical projects.
The supply – side concept has its origins in classical, pre-Keynesian
economic theory.
The idea that supply can create its own demand is known as
say’s law.
Supply side – marketing, then refers to any instance where a product
can create a market – in other words, the product is responsible for the
demand, rather than the demand being responsible for the product.
Supply – side marketing is a more aggressive approach to business
than its demand side counterpart.
It is founded on the entrepreneurial spirit, calculated but high-risk
taking, and the bent to exploit the unknown for great personal and/or
corporate gain.
Yet, supply side projects and divisions are disproportionately important
in auguring long term corporate profitability and more broadly, in
technological progress for society.
CHARACTERISTICS OF HIGH TECHNOLOGY ORIENTED PROJECTS
The business requires a strong scientific/technical basis.
New technology can obsolete existing technology rapidly
As new technologies come on stream, their application. Create or
revolutionize markets and demands.
No of players (sellers) in such business as usual more and the buyers
are few hence it is buyers market.
It represents an imperfect competition, in market structure.
Forward Company customer
Offers Customer company
14
Requests
R AND D MARKETING FUNCTION
The role of high – technology marketing management is to apply
technology strategically in the market place so that the firm gains
competitive advantage.
The achievement requires close linkage between the high tech firms R
and D Marketing Functions.
THE NATURE OF HIGH TECH MARKETS
There is ample evidence pointing to specific ways in which high tech
markets are different from consumer package goods markets. Because
high tech companies exploit and create change rather than consolidate
and defend existing conditions the interdependence between marketing
and technology is of crucial importance. Companies regarded as low-tech
may basically adjust their marketing strategies to reflect relatively
unchanging technological conditions. High tech companies, however,
must recognize that both technological and marketing conditions are
rapidly changing (Nystrom 1990). This dynamic environment necessitates
stronger consideration for the marriage of marketing and technology.
Research and practice indicate that high tech markets are characterized
as dynamic and complex which results in a changing target market over
the life cycle (Abell 1978, Davidow 1986, Beard and Easing wood 1996).
The complexity of the product also impacts market acceptance in
15
different ways in high tech markets (Davidow 1986). As high tech
products are more complicated, they require greater customer education
and more product information. This necessity results in greater effort on
the part of marketing to adequately convey the necessary information as
well as greater effort on the part of the consumer to digest the
information.
PROMINENT ISSUES IN HIGH TECH MARKETS HIGH TECH MARKETS:
• exploit and create change
• are complex
• need to be targeted carefully
• Exhibit risk
• require deliberate timing
• are extremely fast-paced
Consumers of high tech offerings, particularly those first to adopt a
technology, are extremely sophisticated and product/technology savvy
this means that you can ignore getting to know your customers while
focusing on product leadership. The level of sophistication prevalent in
high tech markets, however, demands developing an intimate knowledge
of the consumer in order to ensure that the offering is captures what the
customer considers being desirable.
Target marketing is another critical factor for firms introducing high tech
products. Easingwood and Lunn (1992) found that clearly targeted
products diffuse more rapidly than non-targeted products. Complicating
this factor is evidence that the customer base changes for each stage of
the product life cycle as different segments of the market become
interested in the product at different times (Davidow 1986).
Consequently, it is important to recognize the need to clearly identify and
profile a target market as well as take into account that the profile of the
target market will change over time.
PRODUCT LAUNCH PROCESSES
16
Inherent in the adoption process concept is the notion that different
stages of adopters have different requirements. Combining these different
requirements with the emphasis on shorter development cycles and
shorter life cycles prevalent in high tech markets makes correctly
targeting each adopter category critical.
THE NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT PROCESS
Models of new product development prescribe critical stages that
organizations should go through to have a successful product launch.
Regardless of the model, critical phases include: product idea generation,
idea screening, concept testing, business analysis, marketing mix
development, test marketing and commercialization. In theory, going
through these stages systematically helps organizations weed out the
potential failures.
Customer focus is an integral component of the product development
process that is often ignored. The need to incorporate the voice of the
customer (adopt the marketing concept) at every phase is imbedded in
these models of new product development, each phase contributing
additional knowledge as to what customers want. Yet concept testing and
test marketing are most often overlooked by new product development
teams as they rush to get their product to market before the competition.
Unfortunately, this can lead to fatal errors when customer expectations
are extremely high - or when dealing with a sophisticated customer - as is
the case for high tech products. One of the ways to understand how
different types of customers respond to new product offerings is to
examine Rogers’ Diffusions of Innovation model (Rogers 1962).
DIFFUSION OF INNOVATIONS AND ITS ROLE IN HIGH TECH DIFFUSION
Developing the belief that individuals differ in their readiness to adopt
new products, Rogers describes five types of individuals innovators, early
adopters, early majority, late majority and laggards (Table 3). These types
differ in terms of their timing to adopt a new product and the sources of
information they rely on to adopt new products.
17
Understanding the differences in the five adopter groups presents a way
to successfully reach individuals at various stages of adoption as the main
uses of research on characteristics of adopter categories is to provide a
basis for audience segmentation strategies..." (Robinson, Fornell and
Sullivan 1992).
As the requirements for success change as the market evolves (Abell
1978), this widely accepted adopter classification system should cause
the innovative firm to research the characteristics of the innovators and
early adopters and direct introductory marketing strategies specifically at
them.
Adopter Categories Category Characteristics Role in Diffusion
Innovators willing to take risks
impersonal and
scientific information
"gatekeeper"
Early Adopters accept new ideas
early
rely on multiple
sources of information
opinion leaders
Early Majority risk adverse;
rely on company-
generated
promotional
information and word-
of-mouth
don’t purchase until
late growth stage
Late Majority and
Laggards
require early
categories to "test
drive" the product
this is an advantage
for companies who
enter during
maturity (Dell
Computer, AMA
18
1988)
R&D - MARKETING FUNCTION
The role of high–technology marketing management is to apply
technology strategically in the market place so that the firm gains
competitive advantage.
The achievement requires close linkage between the high tech firms R
and D Marketing Functions.
THE R & D EFFORT PORT FOLIO GRID
In this grid, the high tech company’s products can be classified into
several “effort warranted” categories, according to the degree of
technical/market fir:
Heavy emphasis – deserving full support, including basio R and D
Selective opportunistic emphasis – may be good or may be bad, requires
a careful approach and top management attention.
Limited defensive support – merits only minimum support.
19
SelectiveEmphasis
HeavyEmphasis
HeavyEmphasis
LimitedSupport
SelectiveEmphasis
HeavyEmphasis
LimitedSupport
LimitedSupport
SelectiveEmphasis
Tech
nolo
gy
Opport
unit
y
H
igh
Mediu
mlo
w
Marketing Opportunity
NEED FOR A MARKETING AND R AND D INTERFACE
Marketing – R and D interface is essential because both groups play
critical roles in the product development process especially in high tech
firms.
First, it must be recognised that the new product or process tends to be
extremely complex and often has a number of potential uses.
Some of these applications may be determined by marketing during the
process of positioning the new product or process in an appropriate
industry or niche with in an industry.
Each group has special expertise to contribute in the introductory stage of
the products development, and one or the others absence from such
deliberation can produce redundancy of effort, as well as numerous false
starts.
Second, it needs to be remembered that high tech products, unlike other
industrial or consumer goods, tend to be supply – generated.
The conventional marketing concept or purely demand oriented product
development results in product nuance, not product breakthroughs.
20
Low Moderate High
Since the high tech product or process break through represents truly
new developments, R and D tend to dominate the firm in its early stage of
development.
Thus, the need to involve R and D and marketing in product development
or application efforts is essential.
DEVELOPMENT OF MARKETING – R AND D INTERFACE
There have been various organisational arrangements suggested for
ensuring continued interaction between R and D and Marketing.
An approach to new product development is the use of venture team.
This group typically includes rep’s from marketing, R and D, production
etc, involved in product development task from idea generation to
marketing introduction.
MARKETING DECISION VARIABLES
The elements that the marketing manager has under his or her control
and can manipulate are referred to in marketing parlance as the 4Ps –
Product, Price, Place (distribution), and Promotion (advertising, personal
selling, sales promotion, and public relation)
Collectively, when integrated into and overall marketing program for a
company, these marketing decision variables are known as the
company’s marketing mix.
21
The marketing mix decision is extremely critical because it is instrumental
in determining the degree of success experienced by a company in the
market place vis – a – vis its organisation.
The true test of the marketing executive is low cost is allocated among
the marketing mix variables and ultimately what performance results in
the market place.
STRATEGIC MARKET PLANNING
The high – technology firm operates in an environment that can change
almost overnight with the discovery or application of new technology
which obsoletes the old.
Strategic planning is even more imperative in high – tech firms than in
companies doing business in more predictable mature markets.
This is because conditions are evolving so rapidly – conditions that can
literally make or break a company quickly. The high – tech organisation
can be proactive.
PRODUCTIVE DEVELOPMENT:
There are various identifiable stages of development in any industry or
form of industry evolution.
In the supply – driven, introductory phase, the emphasis in the firm
continues to come from R and D, as the new improvements and
applications tend to push them on the market.
The industry itself has not really been totally sorted out, as the number of
producers continues to grow.
In this immature industry sitting, the emphasis is on R and D technically
skilled sales people who must demonstrate how the product or process
can be applied. The perspective of managers involved in developing new
products often seems to be at odds with the perspectives of customers
22
(Table 1). When selecting products, consumers focus on features, what
the consequences are from using those features and how the
consumption experience fits into their values (Gutman 1982; Gardial,
Clemons, Woodruff, Schumann, and Burns 1994). Product adoption is
smoother when the product is easy to operate and does not require
behavioral changes (Davidow 1986). To get people to adopt a new
technology, it should possess unique qualities which current offerings
cannot deliver (Porter 1980). Last, but not least, their goal is to fulfill
unmet needs.
TABLE Customer Focus versus Managerial Focus
Customer Focus Managerial Focus
Features Design Consequences, values Cost Ease of operation Ease of production Unique qualities Unique technologies Consumption Production
In the supply – driven, introductory phase, the emphasis in the firm
continues to come from R and D, as the new improvements and
applications tend to push them on the market.
The industry itself has not really been totally sorted out, as the number of
producers continues to grow.
In this immature industry sitting, the emphasis is on R and D technically
skilled sales people who must demonstrate how the product or process
can be applied.
In the supply driven stage, the shift is to applications and to product
modifications that will maintain its state of art.
The company’s purpose will be to demonstrate its ability in the field.
23
R and D will still receive significant attention in the organisation, but it will
now be coupled with marketing applications and considerable attention
will be focused on determining which applications will be most productive.
In the supply driven stage, the shift is to applications and to product
modifications that will maintain its state of art.
The company’s purpose will be to demonstrate its ability in the field.
R and D will still receive significant attention in the organisation, but it will
now be coupled with marketing applications and considerable attention
will be focused on determining which applications will be most productive.
MARKETING ORGANISATION
When evaluating the marketing organisational arrangement in any
organisation, there are a number of rather fundamental avenues that
need to be explored. They are
1. The reporting level of marketing
2. The interface between R and D and marketing
3. The relationship between marketing and sales
4. The locus of marketing decision making
Positioning and the selection of Target Markets
POSITIONING –
Positioning seems to best describe the steps that the high – tech marketer
needs to follow if it is to identify correctly the firms target markets and to
place them is priorities.
Positioning connotes a degree of flexibility that allows the marketer to
contemplate a broad range of users or applications for its products or
process.
24
The process of positioning allows the high tech marketer to determine the
various industries or buying groups that can use the product and away
them in an ordered fashion.
As a result of its positioning of forts, a high – technology company should
be able to indicate which industries offers it greatest potential, which firm
in those industries would benefit most from its product or process and
which markets (in rank order) it will attempt to exploit.
Stages in positioning for the high – technology marketer
Proceeding through the stages of positioning, the company should be able
to identify most of the opportunities and potential target markets for it
product or processes.
Stage 1 R and D Breakthrough(Multipurpose product or process)
Stage 2 Intra corporate Applications Analysis(Industry)
Stage 3 Formal Market opportunityIdentification Analysis
Stage 4 Market priorityAssessment
Stage 5 In depth Marketing ResearchIn priority industry
25
Stage 6 Selection and Ranking Of Target Market(s)
Stages in positioning for Targeting high – tech Markets
Product life cycle for High tech companies
The product life cycle can be the key to successful and profitable product
management, from the introduction of new products to profitable disposal
of obsolescent products.
A company’s positioning and differentiation strategy changes as the
product, market, competitors change over the product life cycle.
Bell shaped curve that represents the four stages of PLC (Introduction,
Growth, Maturity, and Decline) is of little value to managers in high tech
companies.
The traditional product life cycle concept suggests market conditions and
sales volume as means to ascertain when a product is growing, maturing
and absolution.
But, sales volume of high tech products can be misleading when used as
a processor of life cycle evolution.
The revenues or units sold of a product associated with a particular
technology typically reach an apex after a competing superior technology
is introduced that ultimately renders the old product obsolete.
So, in addition to general market conditions and sales volume
performance, astute high – tech executives will also closely monitor
technology life cycles. This approach will lead to more effective
marketing and technical decisions.
In introductory market phases, there is usually enough growth to
accommodate most of the pioneering competitors, and entrepreneurial –
type executives thrive.
26
There is nearly undivided focus on technical competence and
inventiveness.
But a markets mature, competitors intensely war with one another for
share and as a result, executive with different orientation and expertise
are required.
The emphasis in the market will have shifted away from technical
innovation to distribution, advertising and sales promotion, and pricing.
Man --- hours Invested
Technological Life Cycle
The horizontal axis designates units of effort that have been expended on
a technology to date, such as the total R and D man-years or dollars
spent.
The vertical axis refers to the most crucial measure of products and
process performance.
More Technology A starts out slowly, because of intense and heavily
financed R and D efforts performs markedly better, and finally plateaus as
the technology reaches its performance limits.
27
Limit of particular technology
Technology B
Technology A
On set of effort
Prod
uct a
nd P
erfo
rman
ce
At technology A’s performance capacity, the new Technology B is already
wending its way through its own s – curve, a curve that starts out at a
performance level far above technology A’s origin. For a while the
technologies compete (theirs – curves overlap), until the superior
Technology B eventually wins out and captures the market.
The high tech company that is successful in staying on the cutting edge of
its industry’s technology must spend more time analysing technology life
cycles than on studying experience curves.
28
The Typical New Product Development Process in the Successful High – Tech firm
Marketing involvement R and D Involvement
Begins Begins
29
Obtain new product idea and concept test
Identify prospective customers
Conduct market Research
Estimate Demand
Develop and test prototype
Make product Introduction Decision
Final Product development
Test Marketing
Commercialisation
The dotted line indicates that
the test marketing in
process high – tech companies is neither typical
nor atypical
First, both Marketing and R and D are involved in the formative stages.
Second, demand estimate are considered at best estimates of market
potential and are not sophisticated projections normally associated with
nature markets.
Third, leading high tech firm are calculated risk takers. There is a
noticeable lack of test marketing where usually a product is marketed
in a limited geographic area or with a small number of buyers before a
full – fledged communication effort is made.
In many market situations, particularly in mature consumer products
industries, test marketing is the rule.
In high tech industries, test marketing neither the rule nor the exception.
Test marketing of high tech products runs the risk of providing
competitors with the time and technological information it needs to react.
As technological secrecy and surprise cue key elements of
innovativeness, test marketing is not considered as rule for high
technology projects.
High technology oriented companies rely on a great deal of customer
identification, demand forecasting and marketing research.
30
MARKETING STRATEGIES AT ECIL
A leader in Indian electronic industry, Electronic Corporation of India Ltd
has been in the fore front of many breakthroughs in the field of
electronics. Backed by a strong R & D team, ECIL developed a unique
capability to configure, manufacture, install, commission, maintain and
gain customer satisfaction for tailor made systems is the field of
information technology, controls, communication and instruments.
Here the industry understands the customers requirement and shows then
how their technology is beneficial over other business players.
Unlike conventional marketing practices for consumer products which use
heavy expenses on promotional activates, ECIL in order to make the
customer aware of the product uses road show and mail shots and gather
feedback information, based on promotion program.
With progressive awareness, apparently lucrative security system market
has been attracting more and more players, which has created a
competitive environment. The competition is becoming fiercer as there
are few buyers and many suppliers for high technology oriented projects.
so, to sustain in such a market ECIL tries to achieve competitive
advantage by earning more and more credentials from customers and by
gaining better customer satisfaction in return.
ECIL differentiates itself from other market players as it deals with product
which are prevailing in India , having wide range of customers, engaged
in strategic& nationally important activities like
1) space research
2) nuclear research
3) thermal power research generator
4) Nuclear power generator
31
5) Cement industry
6) Steel industry and its modernisation
7) Defense sector’s instrumentation
8) Oil sector’s exploratory efforts
9) Govt establishments and institutions asset management etc.
Business on this line is performed in ways unique to project marketing
improvising upon certain conventionally practised steps.
Business activities/ projects initiates in either of following.
i. Forward way: - The Company in order to publish tries to make the
customer aware of the product /technology through the road shows,
advertising mail shots etc.
ii. Backward way: - seeking expression of internet (EOI) from
interested and capable entities who and user releases an
advertisement can fulfil his requirement. Based on fulfilments of
qualifying criteria presented by the tendered, his shortlists the
respondents for further progress in the matter.
1. Awareness – exploring in taped market and personal contact.
2. Enquiry - purchase order- order acknowledgement
3. Release of work order- Q AP- Dispatch
4. Installation – Release of Payments – sale compacts
5. After sale service – PBG – maintenance- clearance certificate –AMC offer.
All products services or projects/processes represent totally new concepts,
are unheard- of breakthrough.
Which are modified and configured in their lines with improvements of
existing products or projects according to the requirement of the
customers?
Sin conisation of specific customization and the offered system that
fulfils the customer requirement is the dynamic challenge of making
manager.
32
Marketing research techniques if adapted and developed especially for
evaluating the future market feasibilities of technological breakthrough
it’s can at least do a better job of producing improved linkage between R
and D and the marketing team.
The project team and marketing team present their skills in designing a
project in such a way that it has adaptability and upgradeability to meet
the customer requirements.
From exploring to the unknown market by promotional activities such as
technical exhibitions, demonstration etc. to the after sale service and
gaining value in return in form of customer feedback is typical marketing
task.
33
Reach EOI
through
Road shows Mail shots (In order to generate Personal contacts customer awareness)
(Making the requirement
Felt by Customer)
What is expected?
34
Market prospect/marketing team
Target Market
Selection
Address potential customers
Threat perception Analysis
Gather feedback from prospect customer
Initial contract proposal
Prospective Supplier Receives enquiry
Respond to Enquiry
Building technology that fulfils the
Customer requirement
Technical negotiations
Revised technical Requirement
PROCESS DESCRIPTION:-
The product or system is categorized as
a) Catalogue or standard product or system, which are offered based on
published data sheets for technical aspects and commercially operated
approved price list. As input requirements and expected outputs are
clearly defined for such instruments there is a likelihood of presence of
fair degree of competition.
b) Custom built product or system where the product/system is
manufactured based on inputs and requirements from the customer.
Majority of projects come under this category, is the sense that each
project/system is unique and is tailor-made to serve specific purpose of
user.
c) Joint venture products /systems where the technical and commercial
aspects are governed by MOU (Memorandum of Understanding) entered
in to by both the companies. Such ventures are normally enacted through
amalgamation of strength of each and every individual partner.
Initially, customer and supplier may/may not know each other. If they don’t know
each other, then seller has to try hard to position their product/technology in the
customers’ notice. In order to target the untapped market, he tries to create
awareness among customers and try to influence them by using certain
promotional activities such as road shows, mail shorts, advertising in selected
papers and journals
In Road shows, equipments, or technical products are brought out or
exhibited in public place, in order to persuade prospective customers by showing
their effectiveness and utility.
Technical journals, Indian security, space security journals are used
specifically at security systems. Business unit for advertising.
Personal contacts: Awareness among potential users can be spread even
by using corporate relationships and contact network is society.
All these are expected to be a major cornerstone in the firms position
BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT INITIATIVE35
Company’s success and survival depends not only on its continued ability
to develop new products and processes but also on its ability to make its
target markets aware of their availability at right price.
This phase of business activity usually aims to:
36
ECIL MESSAGE (S)
Personal communications
Personal contacts Old customers Direct contact Seminars
Non Personal Contact
Public relations Advertising
News papers Journals Technical magazines
Road shows Mail shots Industrial Exhibitions/
Trade shows
Tar
get M
arke
t Dev
elop
men
t
Create awareness among untapped market
Provide customers or potential customers with information.
Presecuren the potential customers via the media selection.
Provide leads by stimulating interest in the product or process.
Assist in forming and/or enhancing the company’s image or
reputation.
Increase the public and prospectuses customer awareness of the
company and its products or process.
Through this process of communication to untapped market, free
company gains value in form of feedback in return.
Depending on feedback information collected, the product /project is
moulded and modified.
APPRAISAL: It is done to gain the customers attention positioning the
company’s performance, value, nature in terms of quality, leadership,
R&D, excellence and product attributes using credentials like order
copies, performance certificates, awards and companies reputation etc.
this is to show their presence in market and to ensure their excellence in
market to develop further business deals with customer.
PRESENTATION AND DEMONSTRATIONS:
In order to differentiate its Technology and prowess from other players in
customers view; company presents an efficient demonstration, proving its
uniqueness and excellence in fulfilling the customer requirements.
Presentation embodies all the planned external and internal contact that
occurs between the company and its targeted public.
The sort of targeted public that the firm may wish to contact plausibly
includes its customers and prospective customers, its shareholders,
37
decision maker, the broader financial community, key government
officials, event employers.
In every instance, the contact is carefully planned so that it is consistent
with the desired objective of quality the firm seeks to project.
Depending on customer’s requirement, study of site and threat
perception analysis, the company gives presentation explaining the
parameters, on what basis, this technology has been selected, the
uniqueness, the benefits what the customer acquires, etc.
Decision makers of Customers Company react accordingly. If they had a
position impact they would further by forwarding an enquiry to
prospective supplier.
HIGH LEVEL INTERACTION:
After the prospective customer is identified and targeted, the
communication between the prospective customer and the designer or
indenter of company is strengthened by high level interactions.
Company communicates with old customers through courtesy calls, for up
gradation reporting and expansion proposals. This is two – way interaction
program that brings out interest of old customer to fulfil their
requirement.
Making the requirement felt by the customer is the immediate job of the
marketing R & D team.
38
This team supports and if feasible assists the customer in framing
requirements, because the customer may not have full knowledge about
the technical specifications and their importance.
It is this team’s duty to give complete information regarding the product,
its uses, combinations, its types and from etc.
ENQUIRY:-
DETERMINATION OF REQUIREMENTS RELATED TO THE
PRODUCT/SYSTEM:
1) CATALOGUE AND STANDARD PRODUCT/SYSTEM:
On receipt of enquiry or an obtaining tender documents, latest
datasheet/ catalogue will be considered or review covering all the
aspect.
2) CUSTOM BUILT PRODUCT/SYSTEM:
On receipt of enquiring or an obtaining tender document, incharge
marketing and project leader of the respective business unit
determine the product or system requirement/ specifications
covering all the aspects in consultation with incharges,
manufacturing and quality assurance or any other process owner as
required.
Product/system specifications are decided depending on the
technical negotiations between the prospectus customer and
supplier.
PRODUCT SPECIFICATION COVERS:
1) Requirements specified by the customers, including the
requirements for delivery and post-delivery activities.
2) Requirements not stated by the customers but necessary for
specified or intended use.
3) Statutory and regulatory requirements related to the product.
4) Any additional requirements determined by the project
leader.
39
Product/system specifications are configured according to the
customer’s enquiry so as to meet their requirements and to
achieve fitness for the purpose which the project is intend for.
TENDER REVIEW:
1) CATALOGUE AND STANDARD PRODUCT/SYSTEM.
Incharge marketing section reviews the tender with the project
leader whether the customer requirements are completely met.
The observations of the review are recorded in tender/contract
review form and quotation is sent based on the price list or suitable
letter and customer supplied form.
Quotation is a written statement by the supplier that includes
technical details of product/ project/service, price details incidental
charges like insurance and transport validity period and also the
delivery time details.
Normally a quotation is to response of an enquiry of customer.
Quotation is of three types:-
1) One part quotation
2) Two part quotation
3) Three part quotation
One part quotation includes total technical terms and commercial and
price information and certain other documents towards proving suppliers
suitability, experience etc.
TWO PART QUOTATION INCLUDES :
1) TECHNICAL PART: detailed technical information of the product/
products offered, compliance statement towards proving that the
item offered is the best possible match to their requirement. List of
items offered with quantities but without price. Terms and
40
conditions of sale also forms a part of the technical offer also called
as techno-commercial offer.
2) PRICED PART: in this part of quotation only the prices of items
offered are mentioned. This part of quotation may undergo changes
when a changed system or enhanced quantity of delivery is decided
between the seller and the buyer in course of technical negotiation.
THREE PART QUOTATION INCLUDES :
1) Experience and credentionals of company
2) Technical part
3) Priced part
Then, a sale lead number is allotted to the offer and the same is
posted in sale lead register.
CUSTOMER BUILT PRODUCT OR SYSTEM:
After obtaining clarifications(if any) and understanding the
requirement of customers, incharge marketing and project leader shall
organize review with all concerned departments as required to
consider the following before preparing cost estimates for the enquiry.
1) Whether quality requirements of the customer can be met,
2) Special standards to be applied
3) Special manufacturing facilities required
4) Documentation supply needs
5) Special inspection and test equipment requirements
6) Commercial terms and conditions
Presenting Quotation (Price Promotion)
(1part / 2part / 3part)
Price Revision
41
Price Negotiations
Rejected to order accepted to order
Delay in ordering
Once purchase order is received, the prospective supplier becomes ultimate supplier or authorised seller
The observations of the review are recorded in tender or contract review
form.
After preparation of cost estimates, it is verified by quotation review
committee (QRC). Consisting of representatives from manufacturing
department, marketing department, finance and accounts department.
42
Quotation validity expires
Revalidation of Quotation
Purchase order
Contract review Comm. Req terms Quality Req Tech. spec Completeness of
order Rate of taxes Delivery period Other cond’s to run
the project
Discrepancy / mistakes
Verify and modify the contract
Contract review
Order acknowledgment
Production / project team activity starts
STOP
Based on quotation review committee, recommended estimates haed of
business group/competent authority will finalize the price to be quoted.
Incharge marketing section prepares and submits the bid in the required
format as provided in the tender or in the standard quotation form under
covs of a suitable forwarding. Quotations are normally kept valid for
customer acceptance for a definite period or (for period during which
drastic changes are not anticipated) or on enquiry o0f validity period or
earlier than that a customer may ask for extension to complete his
inhouse procedure. On receipt of such request for extension the
marketing section reviews the possibility with respect to current cost up
and on ascertaining the feasibility, revalidates the quotation for the
desired period. Sometimes, extended validity is offered to wean back a
prospective buyer or as a means of customer support program.
PURCHASE ORDER:
A purchase order (PO) is a commercial document issued by a buyer to
a seller, indicating types, quantities, and agreed prices for products or
services the seller will provide to the buyer. Sending a PO to a supplier
constitutes a legal offer to buy products or services. Acceptance of a PO
by a seller usually forms a one-off contract between the buyer and seller,
so no contract exists until the PO is accepted.[1]
POs usually specify terms of payment, incoterms for liability and freight
responsibility required delivery date, and specifications and reference or
part numbers of the items to be purchased, with quantities and prices.
When accepted by the seller, it forms an agreement between the buyer
and seller.
From an internal control perspective, Purchase Orders are the end result
of an authorization process that is traditionally triggered by the creation
43
of a Purchase requisition. An internally authorized Purchase requisition is
normally converted into a PO
CONTRACT REVIEW:
1. Contract review for catalogue and standard products or systems and
customer based product:
The details of scope of contract and its technical aspects in the
customers order is compared with the quotation by project leader.
The details of commercial aspects in the customer order are
compared with the quotation of marketing section.
The observation of the review is recorded in the tender or contact
review.
Only after completion of these activities, the deviations if any are
listed and suitable amendment to the order is requested through
order acknowledgment sent to customer by incharge marketing.
Contract/ purchase order is registered in order booking register.
At this stage all the preorder documents are transferred to a
separate order file according to order acknowledgment numbers.
The relevant data regarding the contract/ purchase order are noted
in contract profile form.
The contract profile provides details to monitor the status of the
contract at any given time.
2. Contract review for joint ventures product system:-
when order or letter of interest is received from customer, in
charge marketing and project leader review the order whether the
technical and communicable aspects are as per memorandum of
understanding and recorded the observations in tender or contract
review form and the details are registered in the order booking system.
RELEASE OF WORK ORDER:-
1) for catalogues and standard products and systems:-
Marketing section operates an annual production plan.
Respective marketing section of business unit prepares and issues
44
annual work order to PPC- production planning and control for
preparation of annual plan.
2) for customer based product /system :-
Marketing section prepares the detailed scope of supply,
delivery schedule and other relevant data required for the extension
of order/contract and sends a letter along with a copy of purchase
order to PPC for allotment of job number. PPC issues the job number
allotment letters to various sections for initiating necessary
manufacturing actions
For joint venture products, in charge marketing places the requirements
as and when the order received.
AMENDMENT TO CONTRACT ORDER:
1) Any amendment that is required from customers before or during
execution of orders are discussed and communicated to all relevant
departments.
2) Any variations during execution of contract are tak4en up with
customers and project leader obtains clearances/approvals for the
variation before proceeding with the further work.
CUSTOMER COMMUNICATION:
Product information:
Incharge marketing of concerned business unit posts or updates the
product information.
Incharge marketing of concerned project leader uses effective
communication to contact customer at different stages regarding
enquires, contracts or orders including amendments.
Components test by QC Test Req. – plan
45
Quality control tests
Supplier generates Quality Assurances Plan
Pre Despach Inspection
Neg
ative
resu
lts
corr
ectiv
e ac
tions
in p
roje
ct s
ysby
pro
ject
team
Test report authenticity has to be given
After 3rd party Inspector approves (consignment note
for transport)
QUALITY ASSURANCE PLAN:
After the production activity completes, the systems sent for the quality
tests. Quality assurance plan and approval will be given by the supplier to
the customer depending in quality test performed.
Inspection clearances certificate is forwarded to supplier from
customer on basis pf pre-dispatch inspection.
This gives an approval or authorization to ship. Shipment order is
released by the customer asking the supplies to deliver the system.
The delivery of the goods as per contract is made through delivery
challan.
46
Approval /Authorisation to ship finished system
Release Payment
Ownership transfers to buyers
The materials required for installation and commissioning the other
items required for field work are delivered through general delivery
challan.
Consignment note for transportation is given.
System installation commissioning starts at the customer site. After
completion, the customer gives system acceptance certificate to
the suppliers.
The claim for payment of the contract amount is made through invoice,
and the customers are followed up for the payments due.
Submission of bills that includes even the installation and
transportation charges, by the supplier to the customers. The
customer releases the payments through bank/DD/cash. This results in
transfer of ownership from supplier to the customer. Then the
customer forward commissioning certificate saying the system is here
by accepted. Thus a sale completes and after sales service function
takes its roles.
Supplier gives guarantee in form of PGB- performance Bank
guarantee and commitment to keep the system in working state for
guaranteed period.
On basis of the maintenance service given by the supplier;
customer gives a clearance or performance certificate which
becomes a creditionals for the company.
Contract closure:
Receipt of the clearance certificate results in the contract closure.
If the customer wants the maintain service by the supplier to be
continued, he may be proceed for annual maintenance contract
with supplier.
47
AFTER SALES
Becomes credential Performance certificateto win more customers.
Optional
CUSTOMER FEEDBACK AND CUSTOMER COMPLAINTS:
48
Supplier – commitment to keep the system in working state
Maintenance and guarantee for agreed a year period
Clearance certificate
Maintenance contract
In charge marketing sends customer feedback forms to each
customer and obtains the satisfaction level on rendered services or
product supplied by ISD. The customer satisfaction level is
computed and corrective actions will be initiated where require as
per procedure.
In charge marketing of respective business unit receives and enters
in customers complaints register:
a) The complaints received from customer.
b) Complaints received but cannot be attended by branch office, and
forwards to the concerned project leader.
Respective project leader analyses the complaints involves action
plan and schedule for attending customer complaint
Respective business unit in charge/project leader ensures all
necessary follow-up action to attend customer complaints
satisfactorily.
If any additional work is involved and there is need for offering
commercial proposal, in charge marketing initiates and
communicates the same to the customer.
After the complaint is attended, in charge marketing of respective
business unit closes the complaint in the register.
In charge marketing of respective business unit sends the status of
the customer complaints to in charge customer complaints cell
every week for review.
Based on this information, the in charge customer complaints cell
complies the pending complaints monthly and quarterly on
customer complaints compliance review committee.
Customer complaints are reviewed quarterly by customer
complaints review committee and conveyed by customer
complaints cell in which all business units in charges and quality
department incharge are the members. The minutes of meeting will
be circulated to all the concerned for implementation.
49
SWOT ANALYSIS:
The strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and treats of ECIL are:
1. Reputation, goodwill skilled manpower
2. Shot length of manufacturing line
3. Ability to source components globally
4. Long-term relationship with suppliers
5. Vendor development programme
WEAKNESSES:
1. The decision making is widely dispersed in the organization. As a result
of this no one has absolute authority to take quick, independent
decisions. There are too many checks and watch dogs like internal audits,
statutory audit, government audit and vigilance dept etc.
2. Users expectations or aspirations are notional, they need to be met to
add satisfaction. But it becomes difficult for marketing personal to meet
50
that requirement under same expectations and satisfaction as day by day
there may be in technology and also the customer requirements.
3. Because of govt policy even in the favourable market conditions the
company could not charge higher price to increase profits.
EPILOGUE:
It is a universal truth that at the extremities if a venture- small or big,
there are eager buyer and motivated seller. This holds well for across the
country business, consultancy, corporate business, promoting various
social activities, entertainment.
Fun making, leisure industry, tourism promotion and many more stoking
of human attributes of eagerness and motivation promoters business,
progress of the society, industrialization, prosperity, international
corporation and many more.
In course of my academic life, I set my eyes on a career in marketing as I
am fascinated with the knowledge of overall progress made over the
centuries by mankind, pursuit of excellence that always goes on in human
brain and shows up in various innovations reported all over the world.
51
Over and above the study of MBA (marketing) which normally imitates as
to general marketing concepts, I have developed desires to know the
application aspects of acquired knowledge in practiced field.
As my first step, I have tried to understand the psyche of the entities
involved and modalities followed by an elite business house in promoting
business in project conceptualization, design, manufacturing, and
implementation.
Study based on exposure in the activities and interaction with the
marketing team members, forming a part of my curriculum is dedicated
to my institute and to my fellow an future colleagues to refer to.
52