mark b. taylor san marcos 1. legislative outlook on water issues overview broader legislative...
TRANSCRIPT
Legislative Outlook on Water IssuesOverviewBroader Legislative OutlookWhat issues are in the courts?TCEQ/TWDB Sunset ReviewLegislation
BackgroundGroundwaterSurface WaterFunding
Q & A
2
Legislative Outlook on Water Issues
Broader Legislative OutlookTwo major issues will take precedence:
Budget Possible $20-25 billion shortfall Balanced budget required by constitution Will spending cuts or revenue increases impact
water-related agencies?Redistricting
Legislature did not complete this process after the last two censuses; will they succeed this time?
Water-related bills will compete for attention
3
Legislative Outlook on Water IssuesWhat issues are in the Courts?Nature of ownership of groundwater – EAA and
State of Texas v. Day and McDaniel (Texas Supreme Court)Is groundwater owned in place, or only when
pumped to the surface? Landowners have argued the former, and
Edwards Aquifer Authority and Attorney General have argued the latter
Ownership in place would curtail ability of groundwater districts to manage production
Ownership at surface would curtail ability of landowners to challenge regulations
4
Legislative Outlook on Water IssuesWhat issues are in the Courts?Groundwater management process – Mesa
Water, LP v. TWDB (Travis Co. District Court)Can DFCs be different for different areas of an
aquifer? DFCs based on historic use often mean some areas
get more production per acre than other areas Requiring uniform DFCs across an aquifer can result
in greater depletion, or curtailment of historic usesDoes the groundwater planning process afford
due process for landowners? Decisions are made by administrative bodies and
appealed to state agencies w/o formal hearings5
Legislative Outlook on Water Issues
What issues are in the Courts?Miscellaneous issues
Aransas Project case - Challenge to TCEQ administration of surface water permits as a violation of the Endangered Species Act
Challenges to groundwater district moratoriums on permit applications
Challenges to groundwater district granting or denial of permits on constitutional/other grounds
Challenge to an Oklahoma law prohibiting permits to export water to Texas
6
Legislative Outlook on Water IssuesTCEQ/TWDB Sunset ReviewSunset Advisory Commission – 6 senators, 6
House membersSunset process
Agencies have submitted self-evaluationsSunset staff prepares reportsCommission to meet and take testimony
TWDB-Nov. 16; TCEQ: Dec.15 & 16Commission will submit recommendations to
legislature in January 2011Legislature debates and amends the billsBills must pass to continue agencies’ existence
7
Legislative Outlook on Water Issues
TCEQ/TWDB Sunset ReviewSunset provides opportunities:
Reorganization of agencies Combining or separating of functions Changes to management structures
Repurposing of agencies Changes in authority Transfers of authority between agencies
Sunset bills are often “vehicles” for enacting unrelated legislation
8
Legislative Outlook on Water Issues
TCEQ Sunset ReviewTCEQ self-evaluation – water policy issues: Need to define state’s role in fixing aging damsIncrease funding and authority to enforce
drought contingency plans?Establish statewide watermaster program? (15
major basins w/o watermaster)Require monthly reports of surface water use?Enhance state control over groundwater
districts?
9
Legislative Outlook on Water Issues
TWDB Sunset ReviewTWDB self-evaluation – water policy issues:Authority to issue more water project bonds
(requires constitutional amendment)Provide funding for enhanced water
conservation activitiesRevise substance and process of DFC adoption
so a “fuller range” of DFCs is consideredProvide funding to continue environmental
flows process
10
Legislative Outlook on Water Issues
TWDB Sunset ReviewSunset staff report - water policy issues:Allow TWDB to issue more water project bonds Increase coordination of GMAs with RPGs for
groundwater planning processStrengthen notice reqmts. for GMA meetingsTransfer appeals of DFCs to TCEQ and allow
contested case hearings on DFCsEnhance reporting standards and data
collection for water conservation activities
11
Legislative Outlook on Water IssuesLegislation - Background Legislature has expressed a clear preference
for development of groundwaterSurface water markets suppressed by
interbasin transfer restrictionsGroundwater markets enhanced by rule
prohibiting discrimination against exports Has made rural landowners significant
stakeholders in water markets Has created conflicts among landowners as
available groundwater supplies are developedMay lead to decline in agricultural areas as
groundwater is exported to urban areas
12
Legislative Outlook on Water IssuesLegislation - Groundwater Draft bill on groundwater ownership - Texas
Farm Bureau and other landowner groupsRecognition that groundwater is owned in placeMay recognize correlative rights
(apportionment of ownership over the surface area of aquifers)
Draft bills by Texas Water Conservation AssociationClarify definition of “management plans” for
groundwater districts Change MAG from “managed” to “modeled”
available groundwater
13
Legislative Outlook on Water IssuesLegislation – Surface water Loosen restrictions on inter-basin transfers?
Level the playing field for transfers of groundwater and surface water
Promote capture/storage of stormwater flows Support for reservoir construction?
E.g., Region C (D/FW region) 2010 Water Plan includes 3 new major reservoirs
Bill designating reservoir sitesState funding support
14
Legislative Outlook on Water IssuesLegislation-Funding for water projectsProjects in 2007 Water Plan: $30.7 billionPast funding: State bonds for loans/grantsProposals for State funding :
Apply sales tax to retail water sales13¢ State fee per 1,000 gallons of retail waterIncrease in TCEQ annual fee on surface water
Current fee (8 or 22¢/a-f) - $416,483 in 2006 $1.50/a-f would yield $49.3 million/year
$1 monthly fee on each retail water connectionApply sales tax to bottled water sales
15
Legislative Outlook on Water Issues
Source: Texas Water Development Board. and Texas Comptroller of Public Accounts
16
Proposed Revenue Sources
Fiscal 2008 Fiscal 2011
State Sales Tax $243,270,000 $266,579,375
State fee/1,000 gal $127,250,019 $130,001,766
Water Rights Fee $49,339,946 $49,339,946
Water Connection Fee
$94,573,104 $97,280,928
Sales Tax on Bottled Water
$78,000,000 $101,750,000
Legislation-Funding for water projects
Legislative Outlook on Water Issues
“All the water that will ever be is, right now.” National Geographic magazine, October 1993
Questions?
17
Legislative Outlook on Water IssuesReferences TCEQ self-evaluation to Sunset Commission:
http://www.sunset.state.tx.us/82ndreports/tceq/ser.pdf TWDB self-evaluation to Sunset Commission:
http://www.twdb.state.tx.us/publications/reports/ser_documents/2009/ser.asp
TWDB evaluation by Sunset Commission staff: http://www.sunset.state.tx.us/82ndreports/wdb/wdb_sr.pdf
2009 Report by Comptroller Susan Combs, Liquid Assets: The State of Texas’ Water Resources: http://www.window.state.tx.us/specialrpt/water/stateplan.php
Position paper by Texas Farm Bureau and other associations on groundwater ownership: http://www.groundwaterownership.com/PDF/10-25-2010-Joint-GW-v-3.pdf
18