8/2/2019 Major UK ISPs vs Music Corporations High Court Judgement 020512

1/30

28!25!82?8 @xonopcda Eipexpocineip Mp` * Axt z Hxcpctf Tls Hxao`dotpcig Mp` * Axt \82?8^ EWFD 8:6 &Df# &82

?!42www)hocmcc)axg!ew!dotet!EWFD!Df!82?8!8:6)fpnm

\Fane^ \@opohotet^ \Waxm` Mow^ \Numpc`opohote Teoxdf^ \Femr^ \Jee`hodl

Eigmoi` oi` Womet Fcgf Dauxp&Dfoidexs @czctcai# @edctcait

Sau oxe fexe;HOCMCC 99 @opohotet 99 Eigmoi` oi` Womet Fcgf Dauxp &Dfoidexs @czctcai# @edctcait 99 @xonopcdaEipexpocineip Mp` * Axt z Hxcpctf Tls Hxao`dotpcig Mp` * Axt \82?8^ EWFD 8:6 &Df# &82 Jehxuoxs 82?8#

UXM; fppr;!!www)hocmcc)axg!ew!dotet!EWFD!Df!82?8!8:6)fpnm

Dcpe ot; \82?8^ EWFD 8:6 &Df#

\Iew teoxdf^ \Rxcipohme XPJ zextcai^ \Femr^

Ieupxom Dcpopcai Iunhex; \82?8^ EWFD 8:6 &Df#Dote Ia; FD??D205?6

CI PFE FCGF DAUXP AJ KUTPCDEDFOIDEXS @CZCTCAI

Xammt Hucm`cig- Jeppex Moie- Mai`ai ED0O ?IM

82 Jehxuoxs 82?8

H e j a x e ;

PFE FAI NX KUTPCDE OXIAM@QQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQ

Hepweei;

@XONOPCDA EIPEXPOCINEIP MCNCPE@ENC XEDAX@T MCNCPE@

NEXDUXS XEDAX@T MCNCPE@RAMS@AX MCNCPE@

XAUGF PXO@E XEDAX@T MCNCPE@TAIS NUTCD EIPEXPOCINEIP UL MCNCPE@ZCXGCI XEDAX@T MCNCPE@

WOXIEX NUTCD UL MCNCPE@:73 XEDAX@CIGT MCNCPE@ Dmocnoipt

. oi` .

HXCPCTF TLS HXAO@DOTPCIG MCNCPE@HXCPCTF PEMEDANNUICDOPCAIT RMDEZEXSPFCIG EZEXSWFEXE MCNCPE@

POMLPOML PEMEDAN GXAUR RMDPEMEJICDO UL MCNCPE@ZCXGCI NE@CO MCNCPE@

@ejei`oipt

8/2/2019 Major UK ISPs vs Music Corporations High Court Judgement 020512

2/30

28!25!82?8 @xonopcda Eipexpocineip Mp` * Axt z Hxcpctf Tls Hxao`dotpcig Mp` * Axt \82?8^ EWFD 8:6 &Df# &82

8!42www)hocmcc)axg!ew!dotet!EWFD!Df!82?8!8:6)fpnm

QQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQ

Coi Ncmm _D- E`nui` Dummei oi` Pan Xcdfox`t &citpxudpe` hs Jaxhet Oi`extai Jxee# jax pfeDmocnoipt

Pfe @ejei`oipt `c` iap orreox oi` wexe iap xerxeteipe`Feoxcig `ope; 3 Jehxuoxs 82?8

QQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQ

FPNM ZEXTCAI AJ KU@GNEIP QQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQ

Dxawi Darsxcgfp

NX KUTPCDE OXIAM@ ;

Daipeipt

Parcd Roxot

Cipxa`udpcai ?.6

Pfe ohteide aj pfe arexopaxt oi` utext aj PRH 3.?5

Pfe Dmocnoipt' xcgfpt ?:.?6

Hcppaxxeip ?3.82

PRH 8?.83

Megom Jxonewaxl 42.46

Cipexiopcaiom pxeopcet 42.44

Hexie Daizeipcai 42

WCRA Darsxcgfp Pxeops 4?.48

WCRA Rexjaxnoidet oi` Rfaiagxont Pxeops 44

Cijaxnopcai Tadceps @cxedpcze 40.4:

@anetpcd Cnrmeneipopcai aj pfe Cijaxnopcai Tadceps @cxedpcze 47

Pfe ?366 Odp 46

Cijxcigeneip hs ut ext aj PRH 43.7?

Darscig 02.04

Dannuicdopcai pa pfe ruhmcd 00.7?

Cijxcigeneip hs pfe arexopaxt aj PRH 78.64

Oupfaxctopcai 74.6?

Pfe iopuxe aj pfe xemopcaitfcr 75.7:

Pfe neoit ute` pa cijxcige 77

Ciezcpohcmcps aj cijxcigeneip 76

@egxee aj daipxam 73

8/2/2019 Major UK ISPs vs Music Corporations High Court Judgement 020512

3/30

28!25!82?8 @xonopcda Eipexpocineip Mp` * Axt z Hxcpctf Tls Hxao`dotpcig Mp` * Axt \82?8^ EWFD 8:6 &Df# &82

4!42www)hocmcc)axg!ew!dotet!EWFD!Df!82?8!8:6)fpnm

Tpert pa rxezeip cijxcigeneip 62

Daidmutcai 6?

Kacip paxpjeotoide 68.64

Daidmutcai 60

Cipxa`udpcai

?) Pfe Dmocnoipt oxe xedax` danroicet dmocncig ai pfecx awi hefomj oi` ci o xerxeteipopcze dorodcps ai

hefomj aj pfe apfex nenhext aj HRC &Hxcpctf Xedax`e` Nutcd Ci utpxs# Mp` &(HRC(# oi Rfaiagxorfcd

Rexjaxnoide Mp` &(RRM(#) Pfe @ejei`oipt oxe pfe tcv noci xepocm cipexiep texzcde rxazc`ext &(CTRt(#)

Hepweei pfen pfes foze o jcve` mcie noxlep tfoxe aj tane 30% aj UL cipexiep utext) Hs pfct dmocn pfe

Dmocnoipt teel oi cikuidpcai ogocitp pfe @ejei`oipt ruxtuoip pa tedpcai 37O aj pfe Darsxcgfp- @etcgit

oi` Ropeipt Odp ?366 &(pfe ?366 Odp(#- wfcdf cnrmeneipt Oxpcdme 6&4# aj Euxareoi Roxmconeip oi`

Dauidcm @cxedpcze 822?!83!ED aj 88 Nos 822? ai pfe foxnaictopcai aj dexpoci otredpt aj darsxcgfp

oi` xemope` xcgfpt ci pfe cijaxnopcai tadceps &(pfe Cijaxnopcai Tadceps @cxedpcze(#- xequcxcig pfe

@ejei`oipt pa pole neotuxet pa hmadl ax op meotp cnre`e oddett hs pfecx dutpanext pa o reex.pa.reex&(R8R(# jcme.tfoxcig wehtcpe domme` Pfe Rcxope Hos &(PRH(#)

8) Ci Pweipcepf Deipuxs Jav Jcmn Daxr z Hxcpctf Pemedannuicdopcait rmd\82??^ EWFD ?36?

&Df#- \82??^ XRD 86 &(82D Jav z HP(# C fem` pfop pfe Dauxp fo` kuxct`cdpcai- oi` pfop cp wot

orrxarxcope pa evexdcte ns `ctdxepcai- pa nole o hmadlcig ax`ex ogocitp pfe Tedai` @ejei`oip &(HP(#

wcpf xetredp pa o wehtcpe domme` Iew{hci8) Ci Pweipcepf Deipuxs Jav Jcmn Daxr z Hxcpctf

Pemedannuicdopcait rmd &Ia 8#\82??^ EWFD 87?0 &Df# C `epexncie` pfe pexnt aj pfop ax`ex)

4) Ai ?8 @edenhex 82?? Zat K no`e o tcncmox ax`ex ogocitp pfe Jcxtp @ejei`oip &(Tls(# ci xetredp aj

Iew{hci8) Pfe nolcig aj pfe ax`ex wot iap arrate` hs Tls- oi` cpt wax`cig wot ogxee`) Roxogxorf? aj pfop ax`ex rxazc`et;

(Ci xetredp aj cpt xetc`eipcom jcve` mcie Tls Hxao`hoi` dutpanext pa wfate

texzcde pfe tstpen liawi ot Nafowl ct orrmce`- pfe Xetrai`eip tfomm

wcpfci 7 waxlcig `ost o`arp pfe jammawcig pedficdom neoit pa hmadl ax

oppenrp pa hmadl oddett hs cpt dutpanext pa pfe wehtcpe duxxeipms liawi ot

Iew{hci8 oi` duxxeipms oddettchme op www)iew{hci)dan- cpt `anocit oi

tuh.`anocit oi` cidmu`cig rosneipt)iew{hci)dan oi` ois apfex CR

o``xett ax UXM wfate tame ax rxe`ancioip ruxrate ct pa eiohme axjodcmcpope oddett pa pfe Iew{hci8 wehtcpe) Pfe pedfiamags pa he o`arpe` ct;

&c# CR hmadlcig ci xetredp aj eodf oi` ezexs CR o``xett jxan wfcdf pfe toc`

wehtcpe arexopet oi` wfcdf ct;

&o# iapcjce` ci wxcpcig pa pfe Xetrai`eip hs pfe Orrmcdoipt ax

pfecx ogeipt< oi`

&h# ci xetredp aj wfcdf pfe Orrmcdoipt ax pfecx ogeipt iapcjs pfe

Xetrai`eip pfop pfe texzex wcpf pfe iapcjce` CR o``xetthmadlcig aet iap omta fatp o tcpe pfop ct iap roxp aj pfe

Iew{hci8 wehtcpe)

&cc# CR o``xett xe.xaupcig ci xetredp aj omm CR o``xettet pfop rxazc`et oddett pa eodf oi`

8/2/2019 Major UK ISPs vs Music Corporations High Court Judgement 020512

4/30

28!25!82?8 @xonopcda Eipexpocineip Mp` * Axt z Hxcpctf Tls Hxao`dotpcig Mp` * Axt \82?8^ EWFD 8:6 &Df# &82

0!42www)hocmcc)axg!ew!dotet!EWFD!Df!82?8!8:6)fpnm

ezexs UXM ozocmohme UXM ozocmohme jxan pfe toc` wehtcpe oi` cpt `anocit oi` tuh.

`anocit oi` wfcdf UXM ct iapcjce` ci wxcpcig pa pfe Xetrai`eip hs pfe Orrmcdoipt ax

pfecx ogeipt< oi`

&ccc# UXM hmadlcig ci xetredp aj eodf oi` ezexs UXM ozocmohme jxan pfe toc` wehtcpe oi`

cpt `anocit oi` tuh.`anocit oi` wfcdf ct iapcjce` ci wxcpcig pa pfe Xetrai`eip hs pfe

Orrmcdoipt ax pfecx ogeipt)(

0) Ai 3 Jehxuoxs 82?8 C no`e o tcncmox ax`ex ogocitp pfe Jauxpf @ejei`oip &(PomlPoml(# ci xetredp aj

Iew{hci8) Ogoci- pfe nolcig aj pfe ax`ex wot iap arrate` hs PomlPoml- oi` cpt wax`cig wot ogxee`)

Roxogxorft ?.0 aj pfop ax`ex rxazc`e;

(?) Ci xetredp aj cpt dutpanext pa wfate cipexiep oddett texzcde pfe tstpen liawi ot TCG

&Texzcde Citredpcai Gopewos# ct orrmce` wfepfex arpcaiomms ax apfexwcte- pfe Xetrai`eip

tfomm wcpfci ?2 waxlcig `ost o`arp pfe jammawcig pedficdom neoit pa hmadl ax oppenrp pa

hmadl oddett pa pfe wehtcpe duxxeipms liawi ot Iew{hci8 oi` duxxeipms oddettchme op

www)iew{hci)dan oi`!ax www)iew{hci8)et- cpt `anocit oi` tuh.`anocit oi`

cidmu`cig rosneipt)iew{hci)dan oi` ois apfex UXM pfe tame ax rxe`ancioip ruxrate ajwfcdf ct pa eiohme ax jodcmcpope oddett pa pfe Iew{hci8 wehtcpe) Pfe pedficdom neoit pa

he o`arpe` ct;

UXM hmadlcig ci xetredp aj eodf oi` ezexs UXM jxan wfcdf pfe toc`

wehtcpe &oi` cpt `anocit oi` tuh.`anocit wfcdf oxe iapcjce` ci wxcpcig pa

pfe Xetrai`eip hs pfe Orrmcdoipt ax pfecx ogeipt# arexopet)

8) Jax pfe ozac`oide aj ois `auhp- roxogxorf ? ct danrmce` wcpf cj pfe Xetrai`eip utet

pfe tstpen liawi ot TCG)

4) Ci xetredp aj cpt dutpanext pa wfate cipexiep oddett texzcde pfe tstpen liawi ot

hmodlfamcig ct orrmce`- pfe Xetrai`eip tfomm wcpfci ?2 waxlcig ost o`arp pfe jammawcig

pedficdom neoit pa hmadl ax oppenrp pa hmadl oddett pa ois CR o``xett pfe tame ax

rxe`ancioip ruxrate aj wfcdf ct pa eiohme ax jodcmcpope oddett pa pfe Iew{hci8 wehtcpe)

Pfe pedficdom neoit pa he o`arpe` ct;

CR hmadlcig ci xetredp aj eodf oi` ezexs CR o``xett jxan wfcdf pfe toc`

wehtcpe arexopet oi` wfcdf ct;

&o# iapcjce` ci wxcpcig pa pfe Xetrai`eip hs pfe Orrmcdoipt ax pfecx ogeipt