madsen digital preservation policy & strategy
TRANSCRIPT
Athenaeum2lChristine Madsen & Megan Hurst@mccarthymadsen @MHzUXwww.athenaeum21.com
December 7 2016 | NISO & NFAIS Virtual Conference
Digital Preservation Policy & Strategy: Where Do I Start?
www.athenaeum21.com © Athenaeum21
Athenaeum21: Who We Are
2
Megan Hurst, MLIS, MFA Co-Founder, Chief Experience Officer & Head of US Operations@MHzUX
Christine Madsen, MLIS, DPhil Co-Founder, Chief Innovation Officer & Head of UK Operations@mccarthymadsen
Expertise
• Web & SaaS Product Development & Management
• Agile Software Development
• Optimization for Multi-Channel Publishing (web, mobile, audio, video, print)
• Assessment of Digital Services
• User Experience Research & Design
Work Experience MIDIOR Consulting, Harvard, EBSCO, Athenaeum21
Expertise • Information Management Systems
• Data Management Strategy
• Data Preservation
• Process Design & Management
• Information Conversion (Physical to Digital)
Work ExperienceUCSD, Harvard, Oxford, Bodleian, Athenaeum21
Our Philosophy
High-quality data and information is fundamental to human agency, citizenship, scholarship, research, enterprise, and government.
Human use and access to data and information determines its value.
Data and information are valuable assets, and should be managed as such.
3
www.athenaeum21.com © Athenaeum21
Contents
4
Digital Preservation Policy & Strategy
1. Why
2. What
3. How
www.athenaeum21.com © Athenaeum21
LOTS of
Data
6
1.Increasing quantity
2.Increasing variety
3.Increasing pressure to preserve
www.athenaeum21.com © Athenaeum21
Rules vs. Framework
9
NOT about giving you the rules to decide what to
keep vs. what to toss
ABOUT providing a framework for understanding what decisions
to make
www.athenaeum21.com © Athenaeum2110
The answers about what “to keep” and what “to toss” differ for each institution
However,
The PRINCIPLES of how to make these decisions are the same.
First Principles
www.athenaeum21.com © Athenaeum2111
“we just need a digital repository”
Or
“we should take an emulation approach rather than a migration approach”
Common Traps
www.athenaeum21.com © Athenaeum21
Saving time and money
12
• Think about your strategy and policies• Start with a basic plan• What do you want to do? • What is the mission of your organization?• What are its goals?
www.athenaeum21.com © Athenaeum2113
“a plan of action designed to achieve a long-term or overall aim”
So, in order to create a strategy, you need to know what your aim is
Strategy First
www.athenaeum21.com © Athenaeum2114
Basic Premise
www.athenaeum21.com © Athenaeum21
A Policy Should Provide:
17
• The people on the ground with the answers to ‘should I keep this? Or toss it?’
• A cost-effective way for people to make decisions.
• The CONFIDENCE to make decisions on their own without having to check with a bunch of people.
• Some clarity for end-users about why you are making certain decisions
www.athenaeum21.com © Athenaeum2118
• Break the work into bite-sized pieces
• Stay focused on defining the problem BEFORE deciding on a solution
Why the separation
?
www.athenaeum21.com © Athenaeum21
Taxonomy of Topics (From LoC Review - 2013)
19
Access and UseAccessioning and IngestAuditBibliographyCollaborationContent ScopeGlossary/TerminologyMandatesMetadata or DocumentationPolicy/Strategy ReviewPreservation Model/ Strategy
Preservation PlanningRights and Restriction ManagementRoles and ResponsibilitiesSecurity ManagementSelection/AppraisalStaff Training/EducationStorage, Duplication, and BackupSustainability Planning
http://blogs.loc.gov/thesignal/2013/08/analysis-of-current-digital-preservation-policies-archives-libraries-and-museums/
www.athenaeum21.com © Athenaeum2120
• tackles too much at once
• conflates three different things
• makes the task overwhelming • has the wrong people making the
decisions at the wrong level
The Problem
www.athenaeum21.com © Athenaeum2122
• Collaboration• Content Scope
• Mandates• Policy/Strategy Review• Sustainability Planning
1Strategy
www.athenaeum21.com © Athenaeum2123
• Access and Use• Metadata or Documentation• Preservation Model/ Strategy• Preservation Planning• Rights and Restriction
Management• Selection/Appraisal• Staff Training/Education
2Policy
www.athenaeum21.com © Athenaeum2124
• Accessioning and Ingest• Audit• Roles and Responsibilities• Security Management• Storage, Duplication, and
Backup
3Operations
www.athenaeum21.com © Athenaeum2125
Strategy = senior leadershipPolicy = managers - the people who have contact with your user baseOperations = techies - the people on the ground
People
www.athenaeum21.com © Athenaeum2126
Strategy = revise every 10 years Policy = every 3-5 years Operations = review annually and revise as needed
Shelf Life
www.athenaeum21.com © Athenaeum21
3 Essential Things
27
• Technology -- most people focus here and people want a shiny solution, even if it is expensive. But the technology should be the end-point, not the beginning.
• Organizational support -- people have to believe this is critical to the mission and goals of an organization and that is why a strategy that makes that connection explicitly is important.
• Resources -- and those resources need to be both human and financial
www.athenaeum21.com © Athenaeum21
Human & Financial Resources
28
• You need a team of committed people at all three of these levels → strategy, policy, and operations
• You need a budget• And advocacy at all levels
www.athenaeum21.com © Athenaeum21
3 part approachto digital preservation
29
Strategy
Policy
Digital Preservation
Operations
Tech-nologyPeople
A Good Strategic ApproachCan Make things MORE Preservable(in addition to reinforcing organisational mission & strategy)
www.athenaeum21.com © Athenaeum2131
“if we start collecting digital research data to preserve, do we also need to start preserving the software that was used to create and manipulate the dataset?”
Common Questions
www.athenaeum21.com © Athenaeum2132
“What are the significant properties of any given object?”
And how do they fit with what we are trying to achieve?
Are the methods new?
Or are just the research outputs important?
Better Question
www.athenaeum21.com © Athenaeum2133
• Is yours an organization that collects the raw materials of research?
• Do you have as part of your mission to preserve the process of scholarship (archives, manuscripts, etc.) or do you only collect the outputs?
• If the latter, why would you start now?
Better Question
www.athenaeum21.com © Athenaeum21
Engaging with Researchers
34
• Engage in a conversation about the significant properties of their digital outputs
• And help them understand how separating the data from the interface can have a significant impact on the preservability of their research data.
www.athenaeum21.com © Athenaeum2139
• What is important or unique?• Is it really the software? • Can it be designed in such a way
to separate them easily?
• Software becomes out of date in 12-24 months
• Data should last!
Software vs Data
www.athenaeum21.com © Athenaeum2140
• Wherever possible - separate the data from the interface
• And use your strategy / policy / operations documents to frame these conversation on a daily basis.
StrategyPolicy
Operations
www.athenaeum21.com © Athenaeum21
Thank You!
Athenaeum2lwww.athenaeum21.com
Christine Madsen (UK) [email protected]
@mccarthymadsen
Megan Hurst (US)[email protected]
@MHzUX