maagement study
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
1/89
Reference for study material
Management/Community Development Planning
Initiative for the
Obajana Cement Project
Kogi tate! "igeria
ituation Report! Conclusions and Recommendations
#inal $ersion
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
Submitted to
&he Dangote Industries 'imited
by
OIC International! Inc( )OICI*
OICI Nigeria Program Coordination Office
Kano, August 10, 2005
________________________________________________________________________
Contact information !ac"ue#ine $ard%are in, Country 'e(resentati)e,OICI Nigeria *+e# 2-././20/1-12 Ce## 030-/--2/224. 6/mai# 7a8ard%are9oiciorg
1
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
2/89
2
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
3/89
Influ+ Management/Community Development Planning
Initiative for the Obajana Cement Project
Contents
,+ecutive ummary
-( .acground
0( Methodology
1( 2ap 3nalysis
4( Insights from Previous Reports
5( ocioeconomic ,nvironment of Core Communities
6( Community ,+pectations
7( Results #rame8or
9( Influ+ Management Plan
:( 2ender 3nalysis
-;( Detailed Implementation Plans
--( .udget
-0( Potential Partnerships
-1( Monitoring and ,valuation
-4( Performance Monitoring #rame8or
-5( Performance Monitoring and ,valuation Plan
-6( Performance Indicator &racing &able
-7( Program
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
4/89
-:( Conclusions and Recommendations
0;( 3ppendices
.
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
5/89
,+ecutive ummary
+8e Dangote Industries Ltd., t8roug8 its subsidiary Obanaja Cement Plc., 8as embar:ed
on a &reenfie#d cement de)e#o(ment (ro7ect in Oba7ana, near ;o:o7a in Kogi State,
Nigeria According to t8e im(act assessments carried out, t8e (ro7ect %i## resu#t in
significant beneficia# and ad)erse socia# im(acts +8ere %i## a#so be inf#u< of bot8
eutc8 =inance Com(any for >e)e#o(ing Countries *=?O are considering a
(ro(osed in)estment in t8e Oba7ana Cement Pro7ect *OCP and re"uires assurance t8at
t8e ris:s from inf#u< and ot8er im(acts on t8e #oca# communities can be (ro(er#y
mitigated In order to a##e)iate some of t8e identified socia# im(acts,
+8e ob7ecti)e of t8e (re(aration of t8is Inf#u< ?anagementCommunity >e)e#o(ment
P#an *I?C>P is to estab#is8 a mode# for sustainab#e socia# and economic de)e#o(ment
for communities confronted %it8 t8e )arious negati)e im(acts t8at %i## resu#t from
acti)ities associated %it8 t8e o(erations of t8e cement factory at Oba7ana( OIC
Internationa# *OICI, an N&O %it8 eP for t8e Oba7ana
Cement Pro7ect +8e tas: for OICI %as to use a)ai#ab#e data and re(orts and (re(are a
com(re8ensi)e I?C>P incor(orating resu#ts frame%or:, monitoring and e)a#uation,
detai#ed im(#ementation (#an and inf#u< management mitigation (#ans
A four/member OICI team (re(ared t8e I?C>P using t8e data generated from t8ecommunity assessments and %or:ing(#anning sessions ?ainstream statistica# data
co##ection met8ods %ere combined %it8 (artici(atory met8ods@Partici(atory 'ura#A((raisa# *P'A and Partici(atory ;earning and Action *P;A@to co##ect t8e neededdata and information re"uired to fi## in t8e ga(s of t8e draft I?C>P re(ort In addition,OICI embar:ed on semi/structured inter)ie%s and focus grou( discussions =urt8ermore,t8ere %i## be consu#tations %it8 re#e)ant sta:e8o#ders inc#uding #oca# communities,go)ernment ministries, community/based organiations, ci)i# society organiations,o(inion #eaders and #oca# #eaders
OICIBs recommends t8at I?C>PBs s(ecific ob7ecti)es for t8e eig8t (rimary sta:e8o#dercommunities be to
• Increase income and economic opportunities of farm 8ouse8o#ds
• Improve the health status of targeted beneficiaries
• Improve the level of education and livelihood s:i##s and,
• Increase the organizational and conflict resolution capacities of t8e re(resentati)es
and :ey members of t8e (rimary sta:e8o#der communities
5
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
6/89
In addition to t8e acti)ities out#ined in t8e I?C>P for effecti)e, amicab#e, #ong #astingre#ations and mutua##y beneficia# re#ations bet%een OCP and its surroundingcommunities, t8e fo##o%ing recommendations are (ro(osed
Recommendation "o( -= Identify a Nongovernmental Organization to Implement this
Program
+8e OCP needs to engage a re(utab#e and eP +8e N&O is e
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
7/89
Recommendation "o( 5= "mploy an Additional Community )iaison Officer from the
Pipeline Community Indigenes# An additiona# Community ;iaison Officer *C;O s8ou#d be em(#oyed by OCP from t8e indigenes of t8e (i(e#ine communities +8is %i## gi)et8em re(resentation, sense of be#onging and ease communication (rob#ems %it8 t8ecommunities
Recommendation "o( 6= Constitute the *rievance +esolution Committee ,ithout
(elay# +8e OCP &rie)ance 'eso#ution Committee *&'C s8ou#d be constituted %it8outde#ay +8e committee s8ou#d deri)e its members8i( from t8e S$6S de(artment ands(ecifica##y t8e 6IA team %8o 8a)e )ast :no%#edge of t8e terrain and t8e communitiesin)o#)ed t8e office of t8e &? S(ecia# >uties %8o are current#y res(onsib#e for (ub#icconsu#tation and disc#osure in t8e communities one re(resentati)e eac8 from t8e Security>e(artment, ?aintenance >e(artment t8at is res(onsib#e of a## trans(ortation acti)ities,t8e ?edica# >e(artment, and t8e Ci)i# 6ngineering >e(artment %8o is current#yres(onsib#e for insta##ation of infrastructure (ro7ects re#ated to community de)e#o(mentacti)ities being eangote &rou(
Recommendation "o( --= Provide 1usiness Opportunities to Community!ased
Contractors# OCP s8ou#d (atronie Community/based Contractors %it8 contracts t8at8a)e #ess tec8nica# re"uirements +8is is anot8er %ay of em(o%ering t8e communities
Recommendation "o( -0= Construct Additional 1oreholes# ased on t8e )o#ume ofinf#u< of (eo(#e into Oba7ana, an additiona# bore8o#e s8ou#d be constructed for Oba7anaCommunity
D
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
8/89
Recommendation "o( -1= 'acilitate the "nforcement of *ood (riving Practices# ased on t8e en)isage )o#ume of )e8icu#ar traffic t8at is e
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
9/89
-( .acground
101 +8e Oba7ana Cement P#c *OCP is #ocated in Oba7ana, near ;o:o7a, t8e district
ca(ita# of Kogi State +8ere are se)era# )i##ages #ocated in t8e o(erationa# area of t8e
factory A## t8ese communities are going to be im(acted by t8e estab#is8ment of t8e
factory and t8e )arious acti)ities %i## (ose difficu#t socia#, economic and en)ironmenta#
issues for t8e #oca# (o(u#ations of t8ese )i##ages Eit8in t8is contee)e#o(ment P#an *I?C>P
is create t8at %i## create a foundation for sustainab#e community de)e#o(ment initiati)es
t8at %i## continue to benefit affected communities bot8 during t8e timeframe %it8in
%8ic8 factory o(erations %i## be under%ay and after its e)entua# c#osure
102 +8e goa# of t8e OCP in t8is (rocess is to (romote economic de)e#o(ment t8roug8
t8e im(#ementation of community/based acti)ities t8at %i## im(ro)e t8e "ua#ity of #ife for
t8e (rimary sta:e8o#der communities and t8e #oca# region Eit8in t8is conte
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
10/89
t8e cement factory at Oba7ana +8is document see:s to (ro)ide a %or:ab#e (#an t8at #endsitse#f to easy decisions t8at %i## be made regarding a##ocation of funds for t8e )ariousacti)ities, im(#ementation sc8edu#ing, monitoring and e)a#uation of t8e (rogram
Information re"uirements for a com(re8ensi)e I?C>P a#so (resu((ose a continuous andconstructi)e engagement of target communities and ot8er sta:e8o#ders on %ays andmeans of ac8ie)ing t8is to t8e satisfaction of t8e ma7ority of sta:e8o#ders +8e OICI
team, as (art of its acti)ities, initiated and (ursued consu#tations %it8 di)erse grou(s ofsta:e8o#ders %8o %ere ab#e to (ro)ide t8e information re"uired to enab#e t8e (re(arationof a com(re8ensi)e I?C>P ref#ecti)e of t8e de)e#o(ment needs of t8e communities to be affected +8is document ref#ects t8e resu#ts of eP t8at8ad been submitted to t8e I=C +8is re(ort is t8e (roduct of 7oint co##aboration %it8officia#s of t8e OCP *t8e &enera# ?anager, S(ecia# Pro7ects and 8is team and )arioussta:e8o#ders inc#uding t8e c8iefs and (eo(#e of t8e affected communities
202 OICIBs strategy in conducting t8is study %as to ensure t8at as many sta:e8o#ders as (ossib#e 8ad (rior :no%#edge of t8e sc8edu#e of our )isits and its im(ortance for
e)eryone +8is significant#y affected t8e turnout in t8e )arious communities y t8is, t8etri(s recorded more (artici(ation by more sta:e8o#ders inc#uding t8ose %8o ordinari#y%ou#d not 8a)e attended Information eiscussionscentered on so#iciting )ie%s, c#ues, suggestions and o(inions on (ossib#e inter)entions toaddress t8e many (rob#ems t8at confronted t8e (eo(#e concerned +8e +eam obtainedse)era# and ne% insig8ts from t8ese interactions %it8 t8e (eo(#e
20- +o ma
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
11/89
of t8e men According to t8e %omen, for a #ong time t8ey 8ad #oo:ed for t8is o((ortunityto eiscussions %ere a#so 8e#d %it8 a## sta:e8o#dersconcerning disc#osure of information on t8e I?C>P and (ossib#e conf#ict management (rocedures
1( 2ap 3nalysis
-01 +8e OICI +eam re)ie%ed a## re#e)ant (rimary and secondary data in order to assessany identified data ga(s t8at %ou#d 8a)e to be fi##ed to enab#e t8e conce(tua#iation anddesigning of com(re8ensi)e I?C>P 6)en t8oug8 documents (ro)ided met most of t8ere"uirements of t8e +O', it %as conc#uded t8at t8e (#an (re)ious#y (ro(osed re"uired
furt8er im(ro)ements in order to address a## t8e outstanding issues and ga(s
-02 +8e ma7or (arameters on %8ic8 information is re"uired in order to effecti)e#yde)e#o( a com(re8ensi)e I?C>P are #isted be#o% +8e )arious re(orts t8at 8a)e been (re(ared %ere re)ie%ed and com(ared %it8 t8e under/#isted (arameters on %8ic8 data arere"uired to estab#is8 t8e #e)e# of com(re8ensi)eness in (ro)iding as muc8 of t8einformation re"uired to start t8e (rocess of de)e#o(ing t8e I?C>P
Identification of Sta%eholders
• Identification of sta:e8o#ders• Affected communities• Affected %or:ers
Political and Institutional "nvironment
• ;oca# go)ernment and administration• Sources of re)enue• &o)ernment (o#icies and (#ans• +raditiona# structure• ;oca# N&Os and COs• Socia# organiation and #eaders8i(• Socia# net%or: structure ri)a#ries
11
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
12/89
Present )and 0se Patterns and Management
• ;and use• ;and tenure and o%ners8i(• Sett#ement (atterns• Cro((ing and #i)estoc: (roduction• &raing areas• Eood#ots and (rotected areas• Fti#iation of indigenous f#ora and fauna
)ocal Infrastructure
• 'oads and communication systems• Eater and energy su((#y systems• Easte dis(osa# faci#ities
Social and Other Community Services and 'acilities
• 6ducation• $ea#t8• 'etai# business• +rans(ort• Po#ice and security• 6ntertainment• 'e#igion• 'o#es of #oca# and nationa# go)ernment, N&Os and COs and t8e Cement Com(any in (ro)iding
ser)ices and faci#ities
Population and (emographic Characteristics of Affected Communities
• Po(u#ation distribution• >emogra(8ic (rofi#e of sett#ements and 8ouse8o#ds• ?igration• &ender distribution• 6t8nicity• Gu#nerab#e grou(s
)ivelihood3 &ealth and ,elfare Characteristics of Affected Communities• Community #i)e#i8ood (rofi#es• $ouse8o#d economies income and e
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
13/89
Impact Assessment
• 6conomic en)ironment• Socia# en)ironment• Po#itica# and institutiona# en)ironment• Infrastructure• ;and use and natura# en)ironment
4( Insights from Previous Reports
.01 A #arge body of information re"uired to (ro)ide t8e e#ements for de)e#o(ing anI?C>P is a)ai#ab#e from t8e )ery eP
• (esign of the IM2C(P t8at detai#s t8e &oa#, Ob7ecti)es, Strategies, Acti)ities,
associated 'esource 'e"uirements and Indicators t8at estab#is8 t8e means and endsre#ations8i(s and %8ic8 %i## be uti#ied in t8e de)e#o(ment of t8e 'esu#ts =rame%or:
• (etailed Implementation Plan .(IP/ t8at (ro)ides detai#s of t8e se"uencing of
)arious (ro7ect acti)ities inc#uding agricu#ture im(ro)ement initiati)es andincor(orating communities a#ong side t8e (i(e#ine
• Activity!ased 1udget t8at detai#s t8e resource re"uirements *8uman and materia#
re"uired for t8e im(#ementation of t8e (ro7ects ref#ecting first year funding
• Monitoring and "valuation Plan t8at %i## a##o% management to fo##o%
de)e#o(ments during im(#ementation and ensure t8e (ro)ision of information formanagement re)ie% and action
• Project Performance $rac%ing $a!le .PP$$/ by %8ic8 ac8ie)ements can be trac:ed
suc8 t8at t8e (rogram can #end itse#f for (eriodic e)a#uation
1-
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
14/89
• *ender Analysis to (ro)ide information and (roacti)e strategies for targeting %omen
%8o are genera##y t8e most )u#nerab#e and )oice#ess in traditiona# societies
• Structures and Mechanisms for effecti)e communication and conf#ict reso#ution
bet%een t8e communities and t8e Com(any
• Analysis of :ey com(onents re"uired for an effecti)e Inf#u< ?anagement *I? (#an
+8ese )arious e#ements@%8ic8 constitute t8e bui#ding/b#oc:s for t8e de)e#o(ment ofcom(re8ensi)e I?C>P@8a)e been e#aborated in t8is re(ort
5( ocioeconomic ,nvironment of Core Communities
501 +8is section summaries t8e outcomes and findings of t8e )arious studies t8at 8a)e been conducted in t8e area +8ese re(orts (ro)ide t8e bac:ground and 7ustification for t8erecommended inter)entions to be addressed in t8e I?C>P( +8e affected communitiesand target grou( of t8e I?C>P are as fo##o%s
502 O!ajana2Apata %as founded about eig8ty years ago %8en a younger brot8er toC8ief of A(ata mo)ed to its (resent site to farm in order to reduce incessant "uarre#s %it8t8e 6#der brot8er No one dared to farm at t8is site, %8ic8 %as t8en ca##ed I%omirin*;ionBs den because #ions #i)ed in ca)es a#ong t8e 8i##s sides, for fear of being :i##ed+8e younger brot8er bra)ed it, bui#t a 8ut and estab#is8ed a farm a#ong %it8 members of8is fami#y E8en 8e sur)i)ed it, ot8er farmers mo)ed in to 7oin 8im but a## returned 8ometo A(ata for ceremonies, festi)a#s, and fami#y #arge meetings
50- Oyo2I-a Oyo is a brot8er community to I%a +8e t%o communities used to becontiguous but Oyo mo)ed to its (resent site bet%een 14D and 1430, %8i#e I%aremained at t8e o#d site Oyo and I%a %ere founded by t%o brot8ers and t8e t%o
communities toget8er o%n %8at is today Oyo/I%a #and +8at situation remains to datee)en t8oug8 t8e t%o sett#ements mo)ed a(art t8an before +8e resources of t8e #and %ereused 7oint#y and t8e t%o brot8er communities ce#ebrate t8e same festi)a#s, 8a)e t8e samecu#ture, #anguage and be#iefs and interming#e as brot8ers An indigene of one of t8e t%o)i##ages is seen as a citien of t8e ot8er ?oderniation first came into t8is area %it8 t8econstruction of t8e Kabba ;o:o7a road, %8ic8 %as about t%o :i#ometers a%ay from I%aand se)en :i#ometers from Oyo S8ort#y after t8is (eriod, Os8o:os8o:o %as founded ont8e road by a grou( sett#es %8o actua##y soug8t for and obtained t8e (ermission of I%a@ and by e
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
15/89
t8e entire (o(u#ation A(ata is estimated to 8a)e a (o(u#ation of 2,500 %it8 1,-00 asindigenes re(resenting 52J of t8e entire (o(u#ation +8e 1441, (o(u#ation census (utst8e Oyo (o(u#ation at 2D2 (eo(#e, based on %8ic8 a (ro7ection of -D- %as made for200. $o%e)er, res(ondents in Oyo estimated t8eir tota# (o(u#ation to be muc8 8ig8er*bet%een 2,500 and -,000, consisting of t8ose in t8e )i##age, t8ose #i)ing e#se%8ere andmigrants and t8at some of t8eir members %ere not counted during t8e 1441 nationa#census e
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
16/89
Cement com(any In eac8 community t8ere are yout8 and %omen #eaders %8o re(resentt8eir res(ecti)e constituencies at t8e )i##age counci# meetings +8ere are a#sode)e#o(ment associations %8ic8 ser)e as subsets of t8e Community >e)e#o(mentAssociations
512 "ducational 'acilities# +8ere is on#y one (rimary sc8oo# eac8 in Oba7ana, A(ata,I%a and Oyo In !u#y 2005, t8e management of OCP a%arded t8e contract for t8e
construction of a ne% t%o/c#assroom b#oc: in eac8 of t8e four core communities inO%oro #and to en8ance better #earning en)ironmentincrease t8e ca(acity of e
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
17/89
(#anted on mounds8ea(s +8e cro(s gro%n in t8e area are ran:ed according to t8e #e)e#of im(ortance as fo##o%s yam cassa)a (e((er &uinea corn maie me#ons )egetab#escas8e%s +8e most im(ortant in(uts to farming are #abor, (#anting materia#s, andim(#ements +8e 8oe and cut#ass are t8e most im(ortant farm im(#ements used byfarmers =arming 8as been t8e (redominant occu(ation before t8e construction ofOba7ana Cement P#ant As at !u#y 2005, 8o%e)er, t8ere 8as been a #arge increase in t8enumber of (eo(#e engaged in micro and sma## business acti)ities
513 Availa!ility of Credit 'acilities# +8ere is a genera# absence of any credit faci#ities int8e (ro7ect area, and t8ere are no ban:ing faci#ities at a## +8e nearest ban: is #ocated at;o:o7a %8ere a fe% farmers 8a)e t8eir sa)ings +8e farmers do not benefit from creditfaci#ities because of t8e co##atera# re"uirements of t8e of t8ese commercia# ban:s
514 Mar%eting System +8e entire mar:eting system for t8e core communities is a subsetof t8e big fi)e/day mar:et in ;o:o7a ;ate#y, commercia# acti)ities 8a)e been on t8eincrease because of t8e significant increase in (o(u#ation arising from t8e sitting of t8ecement (#ant in t8e area +8e mar:et sta##s are not officia##y a##ocated to indi)idua#s andanyone is free to se## any%8ere ecause of t8e (re)ai#ing circumstance of increased
trade, bot8 indigenes and strangers can buy and se## basic commodities to satisfy t8eirimmediate needs %it8out necessari#y tra)e#ing to ;o:o7a again
520 ased on t8e OICI +eamBs assessment, t8e fo##o%ing conc#usions %ere a#so reac8ed%it8 res(ect to t8e (ro7ect target areas socio/economic conditions
521 Agricultural Production is restricted by inefficient farming (ractices, #ac: of too#sand e"ui(ment, #ac: of critica# in(uts *suc8 as im(ro)ed seeds and ferti#iers, (oor soi#ferti#ity in some areas, e#e(8ant grass in)asion ;o% (roduction is com(ounded by 8ig8 (ost/8ar)est #osses #arge#y due to (oor storage faci#ities and a #ac: of s:i## and :no%#edgeof (ost/8ar)est 8and#ing and (rocessing Eea: mar:et #in:ages and (oor su((orting
infrastructure suc8 as credit faci#ities, irrigation systems, roads, (ub#ic trans(ortation,e#ectricity, and communications net%or:s furt8er 8am(er agricu#tura# de)e#o(ment
522 "nvironmental Security is at ris: in t8e area due to destructi)e farming (ractices,and inade"uate natura# resource management Conser)ation (ractices suc8 as tree (#anting, soi# and %ater conser)ation, use of agro/forestry, co)er cro(s, natura#ferti#iation, and com(osting are #imited A## t8ese factors are #eading to #and and soi#degradation and #oss of bio/di)ersity %8ic8 t8reaten sustainab#e in)estments inde)e#o(ment initiati)es in t8e future
52- "conomic (evelopment is constrained by #o% income and #imited economico((ortunities =armers recei)e #o% farm gate (rices, se##ing farm (roduction at 8ar)est tomeet immediate cas8 needs and to #i"uidate accumu#ated debt Annua# cas8 incomes of8ouse8o#ds are )ery #o% A #arge (ro(ortion of incomes deri)ed (rimari#y fromagricu#tura# acti)ities are s(ent on food =arm 8ouse8o#ds 8a)e fe% s:i##s ando((ortunities to get s:i##s training to generate su((#ementa# non/farm income andem(#oyment
52. Access to Clean Pota!le ,ater year round in t8e concession as %e## as inade"uatesanitation faci#ities are ma7or (rob#ems for t8ese communities +8ese im(ro(er#ydesigned %ater and sanitation systems function as (rime breeding grounds for
1D
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
18/89
mos"uitoes, t8e (rimary carriers of ma#aria, %8ic8 is one of t8e #eading causes of deat8 in Nigeria Poor %ater and sanitation faci#ities are a#so t8e cause of se)era# %ater/borne andinfectious diseases t8at account for t8e 8ig8 morbidity and morta#ity in bot8 adu#ts andc8i#dren in t8ese communities
525 Access to &ealth Services and Care3 "ssential (rugs3 'irst Aid is a#so constrained but (rimari#y in t8e rura# areas of t8e concession +8ere are )ery #imited o((ortunities to
access 8ea#t8 ser)ices, training in be8a)ior c8ange communication and education on :eymessages in 8ea#t8, nutrition and sanitation, training in (re)ention and treatment ofdiarr8ea, ma#aria and ot8er %ater/borne diseases and gro%t8 monitoring to ensureim(ro)ed community, materna# and c8i#d 8ea#t8
6( Community ,+pectations
01 +8e process of arri)ing at t8e )arious community de)e#o(ment issues %as structuredas fo##o%s
• Previous work on t8e I?C>P 8ad identified )arious basic fe#t needs and
inter)entions t8at t8e communities 8ad #isted +8ese %ere s8ared again %it8 t8ecommunity members for t8eir consideration and discussion
• In a validation process, t8e initia# fe#t needs %ere discussed by t8e +eam %it8 %omen
and men se(arate#y in eac8 community to ascertain %8et8er t8ese needs are regardedas suitab#e and necessary by t8e community members and %8et8er t8ere is no o)er#a(%it8 acti)ities of ot8er sta:e8o#ders in t8e communities, and %8et8er t8ese acti)itiesfit into t8e de)e#o(ment strategies of t8e #oca# go)ernment +8ese needs %ere ada(tedaccording to t8e comments of t8e community members
• The groups o women and men, consulted separatel!, selected their priorit! needs t8at
%ere con)erted into (ro7ects co)ering "ua#ity of #ife im(ro)ement and economico((ortunities (ro7ects Incidenta##y, t8e (riorities of t8e %omen 8armonied %it8t8ose of t8e men s8o%ing unanimity of (ur(ose in a## t8e communities
02 ituation 3nalysis( +8e communities e
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
19/89
communities stem (art#y from t8e treatment t8ey got from t8e acti)ities of certainagencies and com(anies in t8e (ast
0- In 6gayin, one of t8e (i(e#ine communities, t8e en)ironment %as ad)erse#yim(acted by a ma7or construction com(any %it8out a((ro(riate mitigation measures +8ecommunity is sti## #i)ing %it8 t8e effects of t8is ad)erse im(act +8ey consider t8is ama#treatment of t8eir citiens and community and are e
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
20/89
• &ealth 'acility A 20/bed cottage 8os(ita# is (#anned for OCP staff and core
communities for im(ro)ed 8ea#t8 care ser)ices OICI furt8er recommends t8e (ro)ision of an ambu#ance ser)ice to su((ort t8e cottage 8os(ita#
• Police Station As of !u#y 2005, t8e OCP 8as estab#is8ed (#ans to contact Nigerian
Po#ice to site a Po#ice Station bet%een ariagi and A(ata, and a#so to site a Po#ice (ost in t8e "uarry area and anot8er one near t8e OCP 8ousing estate to dea# %it8
crimina# acti)ities in t8e area
0 Validating Community Needs A## t8e communities 8a)e a )ery c#ear (icture of%8at constitute t8eir needs +8e (rocedure ado(ted by t8e team started %it8 re)ie% of t8eneeds submitted ear#ier and re(orts from (re)ious meetings Ee sti## made efforts,8o%e)er, to notify t8e communities of t8e re"uirement to )a#idate and t8en ran:according#y +8ey recognie resource constraint as a #imitation %8ic8 %ou#d ma:e itunad)isab#e to attem(t to meet a## t8e needs at t8e same time +o ac8ie)e t8is, %ediscussed a## t8e needs %it8 t8em and t8ey %ere a##o%ed to resume consu#tations amongt8emse#)es, men and %omen +8ey t8en communicated t8eir decisions to us t8roug8 t8ec8iefs and community #eaders Ee confirmed t8eir decisions t8roug8 )oice and 8and
)otes after %8ic8 t8e agreements %ere a((ro(riate#y recorded
0D =urt8ermore, our )isits re)ea#ed se)era# ma7or (riority needs of t8e affectedcommunities In A7ao:uta ;oca# &o)ernment Area under %8ose 7urisdiction t8e (i(e#ine/communities fa##, t8e aut8orities 8a)e been in touc8 %it8 OC P#c on (riority areas of t8eir needs In O8unene *one of t8e (i(e#ine communities %it8 a (o(u#ation of fi)e t8ousand (eo(#e, t8ey 8a)e to tra)e# to A7ao:uta, 2:m a%ay to recei)e medica# ser)ices =or t8e (eo(#e of O8unene, t8is is t8e nearest 8os(ita# In Ada)i ;oca# &o)ernment in %8ose 7urisdiction t8ree of t8e (i(e#ine communities *Idodenge, Ire(eni, Ira(ana fa##, t8eaut8orities of t8e #oca# go)ernment underscored t8e im(ortance of ca(acity/bui#ding as anim(ortant factor in transforming t8ese communities
6.08 Ana#yses of )arious documents and site )isits re)ea#ed se)era# major priorityneeds of t8e affected communities +8ese (riority needs and t8e inter)entions re"uiredfu#fi## t8em are as fo##o%s
Pota!le ,ater
• Su((#y of bore8o#e
• Protection of surface %ater sources
• $ygiene (romotion
Sanitation
• 6stab#is8ment and training of %ater and sanitation *EA+SAN committees *training in (re)entionof diarr8ea, ma#aria ot8er %ater/borne diseases
• Construction of sanitation faci#ities *toi#ets, and so#id %aste dum(s
• 6stab#is8ment and training of (um( and %ater faci#ities care/ta:er committees
"ducation
• Im(ro)ement of sc8oo#s bui#dings *bui#ding or reno)ating, su((#y of furniture, teac8ing materia#s
• Im(ro)ement of s:i## base of #oca# communities t8roug8 )ocationa# training
• 6stab#is8ment of a sc8o#ars8i( (rogram
20
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
21/89
&ealthCare Services and Access $o &ealth 'acilities
• Subsidiing 8ea#t8 unit for (urc8ase of drugs
• Pro)ide trans(ort for 8ea#t8 unit outreac8 %or:ers
• 6stab#is8 8ea#t8 (osts
• +raining of community )o#unteers in first aid
(evelopment of "conomic Opportunities
•
6n8ancement of grou( formation• e8a)iora#attitudina# and socia#organiationa# ca(acity bui#ding
• Professiona# and tec8nica# training *targeting yout8 for em(#oyab#e s:i##s training
Improvement of )ivelihood Activities
• Im(ro)ement of (roduction and (roducti)ity of farmers
• 6n8ancement of access to ser)ices and su((#ies of ser)ice (ro)iders to im(ro)e out(ut of
current cu#ti)ated cro(s
• ?easures to (romote #oca# business de)e#o(ment and estab#is8ment of Sma## and ?edium/
Sca#e 6nter(rises *S?6s
• 6stab#is8ment of micro/credit sc8eme
Organizational and motivational Capacity !uilding of communities• A%areness creation for identification of (resent and emerging o((ortunities
• Organiation and ;eaders8i( training
21
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
22/89
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
23/89
IR 5= 3ccess to
potable 8ater
and sanitation
facilities
increased for >
people
51 Construction of M bore8o#e %e##s
52 6stab#is8ment of M of surface/tan: %ater systems
5- Construction(romotion of M #atrines, #i"uid drains, and M of %aste dum( (its
5. 6stab#is8ment and training of M community %ater and sanitation committees
55 6stab#is8ment and training of M bore8o#e (um( and %ater source care/ta:ercommittees
Objective 1= &o improve the level of education and livelihood sills of > population
living in 9 primary staeholder target communities
Intermediate
Results
Primary 3ctivities
IR 6= Improved
access to
@uality?
education! and
recreation
facilities(
1 Construction'e8abi#itation of eS +raining
/A%areness
• +o im(ro)e t8e
8ea#t8 and %e##/ being of 2000
Se(t 2005/Ser)ices to be (ro)ided on a %ee:#y basis
OCP
N&O/ +o bedetermined
Ambu#ance, (8armaceutica#s,+%o 8ea#t8care (ro)iders,
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
24/89
/6ducation/Pre)ention/Counse#ing/+esting
communitymembers
• +o (ro)ide medica#
assistance andtreatment to 2000communitymembers
and I6CCCmateria#s,
Se(t 2005/+8ree %ee:training course Peerfaci#itation meeting tocontinue after forma#training
3"I&3&IO"
• 'ecruitment and
training of community8ea#t8 )o#unteers
• Construction of "#$
#atrines, and %astedum( site
• 6stab#is8ment,
recruitment and trainingof community%atersanitationcommittees, inc#udingse#ection and trainingof bore8o#e (um( and%ater source careta:ers
• +o assist in t8e
(re)ention ofdiarr8ea, c8o#era,and guinea %orm
• +o (romote and
im(ro)ecommunity8ygiene
• +o estab#is8
communityo%ners8i( of t8e%ater andsanitation faci#ities
Se(t 2005/'ecruitmentand +raining
OCP/ Ci)i#6ngineering>e(t
N&O/ +o bedetermined
+rainers,trainingmateria#s and)enue
Oct 2005/ Constructionto commence aftertrainings
Constructionand bui#dingmateria#s
Oct 2005/ 'ecruitmentand +raining andSe#ection
+rainers,trainingmateria#s and)enue
Socioeconomic Impact of Project and 5ey Issues
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
25/89
D02 1eneficial Impacts of Project
• Provision of em(#oyment to about t%o t8ousand (ersons during construction, in addition
to a boost in #oca# trade accentuated by currency infusion o((ortunities (ro)ided for)endors and (etty traders %8o ser)ice t8e needs of t8e construction %or:ers E8en
commissioned, t8e OCP (ro7ect *inc#uding t8e $ousing Co#ony %i## (ro)ide directem(#oyment to about four 8undred to four 8undred and fifty *.00 .50 s:i##ed em(#oyees,and 8undreds of uns:i##ed %or:force +8e mining (ro7ect %i## (ro)ide additiona#em(#oyment to a((ro
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
26/89
ta:e ad)antage of o((ortunities (resented by OCP +8is 8as (ut a sudden (ressure on scarcesocia# amenities and im(osed demands for non/eue to #and ta:e and inf#u< of (eo(#e, t8ere is a serious #ac: of %ater in
t8e (ro7ect affected communities Oba7ana seem to be %orse 8it because of its (roue to inf#u< of (eo(#e cou(#ed %it8 a)ai#ab#e of cas8 due to
construction acti)ities, a 8ig8/ris: scenario 8as been created for ina((ro(riate seS A#t8oug8 no suc8 incident 8as been re(orted in t8ecommunities, t8is may be because of t8e (eo(#eBs attitude of not %anting to discuss issues
bot8ering on se< and se
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
27/89
9( Influ+ Management Plan
301 +8e increase in economic acti)ities t8at are coming u( as a resu#t of t8e estab#is8ment of t8e (ro7ect 8as a#ready started to attract many (eo(#e #oo:ing for o((ortunities to f#oc: to t8e areaSome of t8ese in/migrants are definite#y going to ta:e ad)antage of t8e inf#u< of (eo(#e to t8e
area to (ro)ide goods and ser)ices for (rofit %8i#e t8ere %i## be a #arge grou( of f#oaters #oo:ingfor non/e
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
28/89
I"CR,3,D RO3D 32, 3"D
&R3##IC
'oad signs (#aced in strategic (ositions
=edera# 'oadSafetyCommission
K&S&
'ecommended
'oad mar:s and crossings for (edestrians
;&A 'ecommended
6ye test for dri)ers Sig8t Sa)ersInternationa#
'ecommended
Ad 8oc training by =edera# 'oadSafety Commission
=edera# 'oadSafetyCommission
'ecommended
Se#ect roads im(ro)ed OCP On/going
6nforcement of safe dri)inget8ics
Nigerian Po#ice 'ecommended
ridge construction in Oyo OCP Com(#eted
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
29/89
2O$,R"M,"& ,R$IC, 6rection of go)ernment officesand residentia# "uarters
Construction of mar:et sta##sto create a mar:et in Oba7ana
K&S&
;&A
On/going
I"CR,3,D D,M3"D #OR,',C&RICI&F Co##aboration bet%een OCP,;&A and t8e state go)ernmentto (ro)ide e#ectricity to corecommunities
OCP, ;&A,K&S& 'ecommended
C'&R3' .R,3KDOB" ;oca# CCCs estab#is8ed toreinforce cu#tura# identity,indigenous communityem(o%erment and traditiona##eaders8i(
OCP and +o bedetermined N&O
On/going
I"CR,3,D ",,D #OR
3CCOMMOD3&IO"
$ousing 6state consisting of atota# of -03 8ouses
OCP Com(#eted
&o)ernment bui#t residentia#8ousing
;&A, K&S& 'ecommended
Indigenes of Oba7ana and I%aare earning money by rentingrooms to migrant %or:ers
Community On/going
Community membersencouraged to bui#d renta#8ouses
Community 'ecommended
I"CR,3,D CO& O# 'I$I"2 Im(ro)ement in agricu#tura# (roduction
N&O/+o bedetermined
Pro(osed
I"CR,3,D ",,D #OR
,MP'OFM,"&OCP em(#oyment *.2 fromcore communities as of !u#y2005
OCP On/going
OCP em(#oyment * from (i(e#ine communities as of!u#y 2005
OCP Contractors Com(#eted
OCP In/8ouse Gocationa#+rainings
OCP P#anned
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
30/89
I"CR,3,D ,MP'OFM,"&
OPPOR&"I&I,
OCP em(#oymento((ortunities
OCP P#anned
Community/based Gocationa#+raining
N&O/+o bedetermined
Pro(osed
?icro/6nter(rise +raining N&O/+o bedetermined
Pro(osed
I"CR,3,D ",,D #OR
&R3"POR&3&IO"
In)estment in trans(ort)e8ic#es
Community 'ecommended
+rans(ort ser)ices for OCPand contractors
OCP On/going
I"CR,3,D CRIM,/CRIMI"3'
3C&I$I&F
One di)isiona# (o#ice station bet%een Oba7ana and A(ata
+%o (o#ice (ost #ocated at t8e"uarry and 8ousing estate
res(ecti)e#y
Po#ice (atro#
OCP P#anned
Community Gigi#ante &rou( Community P#anned
I"CR,3,D ",,D #OR R.3"
P'3""I"2
+raditiona# #eaders, t8eCommissioner for t8e?inistry of6n)ironment %it8 t8e su((ortof OCP 8as started off t8eurban (#anning (rocess bydesignation of Oba7ana as anurban center and e
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
31/89
I"CR,3,D ",,D #OR
3CCOMOD3&IO"
Indigenes earn money byrenting rooms
Communitymembers
On/going
Community membersencouraged to bui#d renta#8ouses
Community and indi)idua#access micro/credit #oans toestab#is8 renta#accommodations
N&O/+o bedetermined
Pro(osed
I"CR,3,D ",,D #OR #OOD
PRO$ID,R
?icro/enter(rise training toestab#is8 food ser)ice businesses
N&O/+o bedetermined
Pro(osed
Community and indi)idua#access micro/credit #oans toestab#is8 food ser)ice businesses
N&O/+o bedetermined
Pro(osed
Agricu#tura# ProductionIm(ro)ement +raining ;oca#
farmers gro% more food to se##
N&O/+o bedetermined
Pro(osed
Staff canteen and renta# s(acefor restaurants and ot8er (ersona# ser)ices inside ofOCPBs main faci#ity
OCP P#anned
Purc8ase of cassa)a grindingmi##s for communities Eomense## more food, greatereconomic em(o%erment
OCP Pro(osed
I"CR,3,D ",,D #OR P,RO"3'
,R$IC,
?icro/enter(rise trainings toestab#is8 businesses in
arbers, Cobb#ers, P8armaciesPetty (roduct trading, usinessCenters, +e#e Com Centers,Gendors/Ne%s(a(er, +ai#ors
N&O/+o bedetermined
Pro(osed
Access ?icro/Credit arbers,Cobb#ers, P8armacies, Petty (roduct trading, usinessCenters, +e#e Com Centers,Gendors/ Ne%s(a(er, +ai#ors
N&O/+o bedetermined
Pro(osed
I"CR,3,D #OR BORK?R,'3&,D
,R$IC, #OR &RCK,R
?icro/6nter(rise +raining forcommunity members toestab#is8 businessesGu#caniing, S(are Auto Parts
and accessories, 'adio 'e(air,?ec8anics, attery c8argers,Pane# beaters
N&O/+o bedetermined
Pro(osed
I"CR,3,D ",,D #OR 2,",R3'
,R$IC,
Gocationa# training Car(entry,Ee#ding, 6#ectrica# Eiring,+ai#oring, ric:#aying
Pro(osed
",,D #OR &RCK &R3I',R P3RK Interna# +rai#er Par:
• Commercia#ied %it8
gate fee, renta# s(ace
OCP P#anned
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
32/89
designed forrestaurants, restrooms, a (8armacy, ban: and s8o(s foradditiona# (ro)isions
6
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
33/89
40- &ender/sensiti)eness in de)e#o(ment assistance is ref#ected in t8e estab#is8ment ofmec8anisms t8at ensure t8at t8ere is incor(oration of a com(re8ensi)e frame%or: andmet8odo#ogy to ensure t8at t8e design, im(#ementation and monitoring and e)a#uation of (ro7ects are a((roac8ed from a gender (ers(ecti)e for effecti)e de)e#o(ment (ractice A ser)ice
(ro)ider needs to estab#is8 a gender (o#icy t8at affirms its commitment to gi)ing %omene"uitab#e and e"ua# o((ortunities to 8e#( t8emse#)es not as an aftert8oug8t, but as an integra# (art of (rogramming In %or:ing to%ard gender e"uity, t8e focus is not on#y on %omen, but a#soon t8e re#ations bet%een men and %omen and t8e use of s:i##s training as a )e8ic#e fortransforming t8ese re#ations
40. In designing t8e C>P for t8e OCP, OICI during t8e )a#idation and (rioritiation e
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
34/89
-;( Detailed Implementation Plan )DIP*= Obajana
entified Project Purpose &iming of
Implementation
Implementing
Party
Resources
"eeded
.udget )D*
3&,R
• $and (um( bo#e 8o#e• +o (ro)ide an
additiona# sourceof %ater to t8ecommunity
• +o meet t8e
additiona# needsgenerated from (o(u#ation increase
Se(t 2005 OCP ore8o#econstructionmateria#s
2 =irst Aido
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
35/89
MICRO,"&,RPRI,
&R3I"I"2
• Introduction +o Sma##
usiness 6nter(rise
• Introduction +o
6ntre(reneurs8i(
• Fn#oc:ing 6ntre(reneuria#Ca(acity
• usiness Orientation
*matc8ing (eo(#e %it8 business
• ?ar:eting P#an
• Production P#anning
• Organiationa#
?anagement P#anning
• =inancia# P#anning
• usiness Credit
?anagement
• Negotiation S:i##s
• =ormation of men and%omenBs business grou(sfor mar:et and in(utaccess
• +ec8nica# s:i##s training
for men and %omen in (rocessing, crafts, trades,and ot8er sma##/sca#eenter(rises
+o (roduce -1 entre(reneursfor t8e de)e#o(ment of t8ecommunity
+o bui#d ca(acity of -1community members for
em(#oyment generation
No) 2005 to !an 200/3 %ee: training course
N&O/+o bedetermined
+rainers, micro/enter(risetrainingmateria#s
Centra#ied
training )enueto be uti#ied bya## corecommunity
(artici(ates
Q3
$OC3&IO"3' &R3I"I"2/
KI'' 3C
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
36/89
-;( Detailed Implementation Plan )DIP*= Obajana *Continued
32RIC'&R3'
IMPRO$,M,"&/
R,&OR3&IO"
• Community cassa)a
grinding mi## for %omen• +raining in (ro)ision of
a((ro(riate tec8no#ogiesfor (rocessing, )a#ueaddition
• +raining in domestic
#i)estoc: (roduction/S8ee(/&oat/Catt#e
• +raining in domestic
(ou#try (roduction
• =ood and cas8 cro(
(roduction training/Cassa)a/Lam/&roundnut/?aie/Pe((er
• Pro)ision of agricu#tura#
in(uts/seeds/seed#ings/ferti#ier /too#s
• 'e(#anting of
cro(economic trees/Cas8e%/?ango
/Castor
• +o im(ro)e and
increase efficiency of 20 %omenBs
%or:#oad for greatereconomicem(o%erment and
better "ua#ity of #ife
• +o em(o%er 20
%omen to (roducemore )a#ue/added
(roducts for greatereconomicem(o%erment
• +o im(ro)e
(roduction andrearing of domestic#i)estoc:
• +o im(ro)e rearing
and (roduction of (ou#try
• +o im(ro)e food and
cas8 cro( yie#d of .4farmers
• +o restore and
im(ro)e cas8 cro( (roduction for .4farmers
• +o restore .4
#i)e#i8oodsinterru(ted by t8eremo)a# of trees
Oct 2005/ Purc8ase ofgrinding mi##
OCP
N&O/+o bedetermined /
Cassa)agrinding mi##
Agricu#tura#Im(ro)ementtrainers ande
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
37/89
3CC, &O MICRO?CR,DI&
• Co##aboration %it8 ?icro/
=inance Institutions *?=I
• =ormation and
im(ro)ement ofcommunity coo(erati)esfor grou( #ending %it8em(8asis in micro/creditmanagement and basic
boo: and record :ee(ing
• 6stab#is8ment of OCP
Community =oundation
• +o (ro)ide micro/credit
financing to -1 (otentia#entre(reneurs
• +o (ro)ide direct access to
needed financia# resourcesfor se#f and communityem(o%erment for -1)i##agers
• +o im(ro)e organiationa#
structure and ca(acity of24 farmers and 20 %omencoo(erati)es to increase#i:e#i8ood of #oana((ro)a#
Se(t 2005/Co##aborations
>angote&rou(OCP
N&O / +o bedetermined
Start/u( ca(ita#
usiness
>e)e#o(mentS(ecia#ist
$3
Oct 2005/=ormation of Coo(erati)es
!an 200/=unds forfoundation
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
38/89
-;( Detailed Implementation Plan )DIP*= OyoIdentified Project Purpose &iming of Implementation Implementing
Party
Resources
"eeded
.
,3'& ,R$IC,
• ?obi#e $ea#t8 Fnit
• $IGAI>S +raining
/A%areness/6ducation/Pre)ention/Counse#ing/+esting
• +o im(ro)e t8e
8ea#t8 and %e##/beingof D50 communitymembers
• +o (ro)ide medica#
assistance andtreatment toD50community members
Se(t 2005/Ser)ices to be (ro)ided on a %ee:#y basis
OCP
N&O/ +o bedetermined
Ambu#ance, (8armaceutica#s,+%o 8ea#t8 care
(ro)iders, and
I6CCCmateria#s,=irst Aid oe(t
N&O/ +o bedetermined
+rainers,trainingmateria#s and)enue
Q1
Q2
Q1
Oct 2005/ Construction to
commence after trainings
Construction
and bui#dingmateria#s
Oct 2005/ 'ecruitment and+raining and Se#ection
+rainers,trainingmateria#s and)enue
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
39/89
-;( Detailed Implementation Plan )DIP*= Oyo *Continued
MICRO?,"&,RPRI,
&R3I"I"2
• Introduction +o Sma##
usiness 6nter(rise• Introduction +o
6ntre(reneurs8i(
• Fn#oc:ing 6ntre(reneuria#
Ca(acity
• usiness Orientation
*matc8ing (eo(#e %it8 business
• ?ar:eting P#an
• Production P#anning
• Organiationa#
?anagement P#anning
• =inancia# P#anning
• usiness Credit
?anagement• Negotiation S:i##s
• =ormation of men and
%omenBs business grou(sfor mar:et and in(utaccess
• +ec8nica# s:i##s training
for men and %omen in (rocessing, crafts, trades,and ot8er sma##/sca#eenter(rises
+o (roduce -D entre(reneursfor t8e de)e#o(ment of t8ecommunity
+o bui#d ca(acity of -Dcommunity members forem(#oyment generation
No) 2005 to !an 200/3 %ee: training course
N&O/+o bedetermined
+rainers, micro/enter(risetraining
materia#s
Centra#iedtraining )enueto be uti#ied bya## corecommunity
(artici(ates
$9
$OC3&IO"3' &R3I"I"2/
KI'' 3C
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
40/89
-;( Detailed Implementation Plan )DIP*= Oyo *Continued
32RIC'&R3'
IMPRO$,M,"&/
R,&OR3&IO"
• Community cassa)a
grinding mi## for %omen
• +raining in (ro)ision of
a((ro(riate tec8no#ogiesfor (rocessing, )a#ueaddition
• +raining in domestic
#i)estoc: (roduction/S8ee(/&oat/Catt#e
• +raining in domestic
(ou#try (roduction
• =ood and cas8 cro(
(roduction training/Cassa)a/Lam/&roundnut/?aie/Pe((er
• Pro)ision of agricu#tura#
in(uts/seeds/seed#ings
/ferti#ier /too#s
• 'e(#anting of
cro(economic trees/Cas8e%/?ango/Castor
• +o im(ro)e and
increase efficiency of -D %omenBs
%or:#oad for greatereconomicem(o%erment and
better "ua#ity of #ife
• +o em(o%er -D
%omen to (roducemore )a#ue/added
(roducts ie gari, forgreater economicem(o%erment
• +o im(ro)e
(roduction andrearing of domestic#i)estoc:
• +o im(ro)e rearing
and (roduction of (ou#try
• +o im(ro)e food and
cas8 cro( yie#d of 5farmers
• +o restore and
im(ro)e cas8 cro( (roduction for 5farmers
• +o restore 5
#i)e#i8oodsinterru(ted by t8eremo)a# of trees
Oct 2005/ Purc8ase ofgrinding mi##
OCP
N&O/+o bedetermined /
Cassa)agrinding mi##
Agricu#tura#Im(ro)ementtrainers ande
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
41/89
-;( Detailed Implementation Plan )DIP*= Oyo *Continued
3CC, &O MICRO?CR,DI&
• Co##aboration %it8 ?icro/
=inance Institutions *?=I
• =ormation and
im(ro)ement ofcommunity coo(erati)esfor grou( #ending %it8em(8asis in micro/creditmanagement and basic
boo: and record :ee(ing
• 6stab#is8ment of OCP
Community =oundation
• +o (ro)ide micro/credit
financing to -D (otentia#entre(reneurs
• +o (ro)ide direct access to
needed financia# resourcesfor se#f and communityem(o%erment for -D)i##agers
• +o im(ro)e organiationa#
structure and ca(acity of5 farmers and -D %omencoo(erati)es to increase#i:e#i8ood of #oana((ro)a#
Se(t 2005/Co##aborations
>angote&rou(OCP
N&O / +o bedetermined
Start/u( ca(ita#
usiness
>e)e#o(mentS(ecia#ist
Oct 2005/=ormation of Coo(erati)es
!an 200/=unds forfoundation
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
42/89
Identified Project Purpose &iming of Implementation Implementing
Party
Resources
"eeded.
,3'& ,R$IC,
• ?obi#e $ea#t8 Fnit
• $IGAI>S +raining
/A%areness/6ducation
/Pre)ention/Counse#ing/+esting
• +o im(ro)e t8e
8ea#t8 and %e##/beingof D50 communitymembers
• +o (ro)ide medica#assistance andtreatment to D50community members
Se(t 2005/Ser)ices to be (ro)ided on a %ee:#y basis
OCP
N&O/ +o bedetermined
Ambu#ance, (8armaceutica#s,+%o 8ea#t8 care
(ro)iders, andI6CCC
materia#s,
=irst Aid oe(t
N&O/ +o bedetermined
+rainers,trainingmateria#s and)enue
Q1
Q1
Q2
Q1
Oct 2005/ Construction tocommence after trainings
Constructionand bui#dingmateria#s
Oct 2005/ 'ecruitment and+raining and Se#ection
+rainers,trainingmateria#s and)enue
-;( Detailed Implementation Plan )DIP*= I8a
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
43/89
-;( Detailed Implementation Plan )DIP*= I8a *Continued
MICRO,"&,RPRI,
&R3I"I"2
• Introduction +o Sma##
usiness 6nter(rise
•
Introduction +o6ntre(reneurs8i(
• Fn#oc:ing 6ntre(reneuria#
Ca(acity
• usiness Orientation
*matc8ing (eo(#e %it8 business
• ?ar:eting P#an
• Production P#anning
• Organiationa#
?anagement P#anning
• =inancia# P#anning
• usiness Credit
?anagement
• Negotiation S:i##s
• =ormation of men and
%omenBs business grou(sfor mar:et and in(utaccess
• +ec8nica# s:i##s training
for men and %omen in (rocessing, crafts, trades,and ot8er sma##/sca#eenter(rises
+o (roduce -4 entre(reneursfor t8e de)e#o(ment of t8ecommunity
+o bui#d ca(acity of -4community members forem(#oyment generation
No) 2005 to !an 200/3 %ee: training course
N&O/+o bedetermined
+rainers, micro/enter(risetrainingmateria#s
Centra#iedtraining )enueto be uti#ied bya## corecommunity
(artici(ates
Q4
$OC3&IO"3' &R3I"I"2/
KI'' 3C
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
44/89
-;( Detailed Implementation Plan )DIP*= I8a *Continued
32RIC'&R3'
IMPRO$,M,"&/
R,&OR3&IO"
• Community cassa)a
grinding mi## for %omen• +raining in (ro)ision of
a((ro(riate tec8no#ogiesfor (rocessing, )a#ueaddition
• +raining in domestic
#i)estoc: (roduction/S8ee(/&oat/Catt#e
• +raining in domestic
(ou#try (roduction
• =ood and cas8 cro(
(roduction training/Cassa)a/Lam/&roundnut/?aie/Pe((er
• Pro)ision of agricu#tura#
in(uts/seeds/seed#ings/ferti#ier /too#s
• 'e(#anting of
cro(economic trees/Cas8e%/?ango
/Castor
• +o im(ro)e and increase
efficiency of -4 %omenBs%or:#oad for greater
economic em(o%ermentand better "ua#ity of #ife
• +o em(o%er -4 %omen to
(roduce more )a#ue/added (roducts ie gari, forgreater economicem(o%erment
• +o im(ro)e (roduction and
rearing of domestic#i)estoc:
• +o im(ro)e rearing and
(roduction of (ou#try and (ou#try re#ated (roducts
• +o im(ro)e food and cas8
cro( yie#d of 1 farmers
• +o restore and im(ro)e cas8
cro( (roduction for 1farmers
• +o restore 1 #i)e#i8oods
interru(ted by t8e remo)a#of trees
Oct 2005/ Purc8aseof grinding mi##
OCP
N&O/+o bedetermined /
Cassa)agrinding mi##
Agricu#tura#Im(ro)ementtrainers ande
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
45/89
3CC, &O MICRO?CR,DI&
• Co##aboration %it8 ?icro/
=inance Institutions *?=I
• =ormation and
im(ro)ement of
community coo(erati)esfor grou( #ending %it8em(8asis in micro/creditmanagement and basic
boo: and record :ee(ing
• 6stab#is8ment of OCP
Community =oundation
• +o (ro)ide micro/credit
financing to -4 (otentia#entre(reneurs
• +o (ro)ide direct access to
needed financia# resourcesfor se#f and community
em(o%erment for -4)i##agers
• +o im(ro)e organiationa#
structure and ca(acity of 1farmers and -4 %omencoo(erati)es to increase#i:e#i8ood of #oan a((ro)a#
Se(t 2005/Co##aborations
>angote&rou(OCP
N&O / +o bedetermined
Start/u( ca(ita#
usiness>e)e#o(mentS(ecia#ist
Q-
-;( Detailed Implementation Plan )DIP*= 3pataIdentified Project Purpose &iming of Implementation Implementing
Party
Resources
"eeded.
,3'& ,R$IC,
• ?obi#e $ea#t8 Fnit
• $IGAI>S +raining
/A%areness/6ducation
/Pre)ention/Counse#ing/+esting
• +o im(ro)e t8e
8ea#t8 and %e##/beingof 500 communitymembers
• +o (ro)ide medica#assistance andtreatment to 500community members
Se(t 2005/Ser)ices to be (ro)ided on a %ee:#y basis
OCP
N&O/ +o bedetermined
Ambu#ance, (8armaceutica#s,+%o 8ea#t8 care
(ro)iders, andI6CCC
materia#s,
=irst Aid oe(t
N&O/ +o bedetermined
+rainers,trainingmateria#s and)enue
Q1
Q1
Q2
Q1
Oct 2005/ Construction tocommence after trainings
Constructionand bui#dingmateria#s
Oct 2005/ 'ecruitment and+raining and Se#ection
+rainers,trainingmateria#s and)enue
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
46/89
-;( Detailed Implementation Plan )DIP*= 3pata *Continued
MICRO?,"&,RPRI,
&R3I"I"2
• Introduction +o Sma##
usiness 6nter(rise
•
Introduction +o6ntre(reneurs8i(
• Fn#oc:ing 6ntre(reneuria#
Ca(acity
• usiness Orientation
*matc8ing (eo(#e %it8 business
• ?ar:eting P#an
• Production P#anning
• Organiationa#
?anagement P#anning
• =inancia# P#anning
• usiness Credit
?anagement
• Negotiation S:i##s
• =ormation of men and
%omenBs business grou(sfor mar:et and in(utaccess
• +ec8nica# s:i##s training
for men and %omen in (rocessing, crafts, trades,and ot8er sma##/sca#eenter(rises
+o (roduce -0 entre(reneursfor t8e de)e#o(ment of t8ecommunity
+o bui#d ca(acity of -0community members forem(#oyment generation
No) 2005 to !an 200/3 %ee: training course
N&O/+o bedetermined
+rainers, micro/enter(risetrainingmateria#s
Centra#iedtraining )enueto be uti#ied bya## corecommunity
(artici(ates
$8
$OC3&IO"3' &R3I"I"2/
KI'' 3C
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
47/89
-;( Detailed Implementation Plan )DIP*= 3pata *Continued
32RIC'&R3'
IMPRO$,M,"&/
R,&OR3&IO"
• Community cassa)a
grinding mi## for %omen
• +raining in (ro)ision of
a((ro(riate tec8no#ogiesfor (rocessing, )a#ueaddition
• +raining in domestic
#i)estoc: (roduction/S8ee(/&oat/Catt#e
• +raining in domestic
(ou#try (roduction
• =ood and cas8 cro(
(roduction training/Cassa)a/Lam/&roundnut/?aie/Pe((er
• Pro)ision of agricu#tura#
in(uts/seeds/seed#ings
/ferti#ier /too#s
• 'e(#anting of
cro(economic trees/Cas8e%/?ango/Castor
• +o im(ro)e and
increase efficiencyof 22 %omenBs
%or:#oad for greater economicem(o%erment and
better "ua#ity of #ife
• +o em(o%er 22
%omen to (roducemore )a#ue/added
(roducts ie gari,for greater economicem(o%erment
• +o im(ro)e
(roduction andrearing of domestic#i)estoc:
• +o im(ro)e rearing
and (roduction of (ou#try and (ou#try re#ated (roducts
• +o im(ro)e food
and cas8 cro( yie#dof .2 farmers
• +o restore and
im(ro)e cas8 cro( (roduction for .2
farmers
• +o restore .2
#i)e#i8oodsinterru(ted by t8eremo)a# of trees
Oct 2005/ Purc8ase ofgrinding mi##
OCP
N&O/+o bedetermined /
Cassa)agrinding mi##
Agricu#tura#Im(ro)ementtrainers ande
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
48/89
3CC, &O MICRO?CR,DI&
• Co##aboration %it8 ?icro/
=inance Institutions *?=I
• =ormation and
im(ro)ement of
community coo(erati)esfor grou( #ending %it8em(8asis in micro/creditmanagement and basic
boo: and record :ee(ing
• 6stab#is8ment of OCP
Community =oundation
• +o (ro)ide micro/
credit financing to-0 (otentia#entre(reneurs
• +o (ro)ide direct
access to needed
financia# resourcesfor se#f andcommunityem(o%erment for-0 )i##agers
• +o im(ro)e
organiationa#structure andca(acity of 20farmers and 22%omen coo(erati)esto increase#i:e#i8ood of #oana((ro)a#
Se(t 2005/Co##aborations >angote&rou(OCP
N&O / +o bedetermined
Start/u( ca(ita#
usiness>e)e#o(mentS(ecia#ist
$3
Oct 2005/=ormation ofCoo(erati)es
!an 200/=unds for
foundation
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
49/89
-;( Detailed Implementation Plan )DIP*
elect Pipeline CommunitiesCommunity Identified Project Purpose &iming of
Implementation
Implementing
Party
B3&,R
• Construction of 8and (um( bore 8o#es
• 6stab#is8ment,
recruitment and trainingof community%atersanitationcommittees, inc#udingse#ection and training of bore8o#e (um( and%ater source careta:ers
• +o (ro)ide
communities%it8 %atersu((#y and to (romote andim(ro)ecommunity8ygiene
• +o estab#is8
communityo%ners8i( oft8e %ater andsanitation
faci#ities
Oct 2005/ Construction
to commence aftertrainings
OCP/ Ci)i#6ngineering
>e(t
Ohunene
Irapana
,ganyin N&O/ +o bedetermined3tami
Oct 2005/ 'ecruitmentand +raining andSe#ection
32RIC'&R3'
IMPRO$,M,"&/
R,&OR3&IO"
• Agricu#tura# 6angote&rou(OCP
N&O / +o bedetermined
Oct 2005/=ormationof Coo(erati)es
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
50/89
management and basic boo: and record:ee(ing
• 6stab#is8ment of OCP
Community =oundation
and ca(acity of 2farmers and 1 %omenscoo(erati)es to increase#i:e#i8ood of #oana((ro)a#
!an 200/=unds forfoundation
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
51/89
--( .udget
1101 In t8e assessment, (rioritiation and de)e#o(ment of t8e >IP, t8e Q150,000 figure *Q50,000 (er core community %it8 OyoI%a being treated as one community %as not ta:en intoconsideration Instead t8e consu#tant decided to assess and (rioritie t8e needs of t8e
communities, de)e#o( t8e im(#ementation (#an and t8en consider budget im(#icationsAdditiona##y, t8e consu#tant %as (ro)ided no bac:ground information from I=C orre(resentati)es of t8e >angote &rou( to eIP far euties t8at a memo 8ad been submitted to >angote &rou( 8ead"uarters recommending t8e (artia# commercia#iation oft8e interna# truc: trai#er (ar: and t8at if a((ro)ed (roceeds generated from t8e interna# truc:trai#er (ar: directed to%ards t8e additiona# funding of OCPBs community de)e#o(ment initiati)es+8e (otentia# mont8#y earnings, so#e#y from t8e (ro(osed 100 naira *Q0D )e8ic#e gate fee,%ou#d be a((roe)e#o(ment =oundation +8e eP is Q1 to 1-1naira t8e ban: e
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
52/89
Identified Project Possible Partners ,+pected Outcome
ealth ervices Nationa# Lout8 Ser)ice Cor(s*NLSC, Kogi State ActionCommittee on $IGAI>S*KSACA, Society =or =ami#y
$ea#t8 *S=$
Organiations co##aborate to (ro)ide8ea#t8 (ersonne#, treatment andser)ices to communities
3"I&3&IO" NLSC, ;&A 6n)ironmenta#$ea#t8 Officers
Organisations to (ro)ideim(ro)ement of sanitation in t8ecommunities
MICRO,"&,RPRI,
&R3I"I"2
Nationa# (o)erty eradication (rogram *NAP6P, Sma## and?edium 6nter(rise >e)e#o(mentAgency*S?6>A
Contribute in t8e training of (otentia# entre(reneurs
$OC3&IO"3' &R3I"I"2/
KI'' 3Ce(artment ofAgricu#ture,
Contribute in t8e im(ro)ement ofAgricu#tura# (roduction in t8ecommunities
3CC, &O MICRO?CR,DI& Nigeria Agricu#tura#, cor(orati)eand 'ura# >e)e#o(ment ban:*NAC'>, Kogi Communityan: ;o:o7a
Pro)ision of micro/credit faci#itiesfor t8e estab#is8ment micro/enter(rises and im(ro)ement ofagricu#tura# in(ut
-0( Potential Partnerships
-1( Monitoring and ,valuation
1-01 ?onitoring and e)a#uation is an integra# (art of t8is (ro7ect +8e #ogica# nature of t8e (ro7ect defines desired (ro7ect resu#ts and indicators at t8e (ro7ects ince(tion +8e monitoring oft8e (ro7ect ta:es (#ace t8roug8out t8e #ife of t8e (ro7ect $o%e)er, em(8asis %i## be (#aced ont8e fo##o%ing (eriods
• Pre)project implementation *gat8ering of 8ouse8o#d base#ine data
• *t the beginning o each major task *confirmation of %8at needs to be done and %8ere its8ou#d be done
• *t the conclusion o each task *assessment of (rogress made to%ards t8e (ro7ectBs stated
(ur(ose, using estab#is8ed (ro7ect indicators
• Periodic site visits *=aci#itation for data ca(ture t8roug8 obser)ations, inter)ie%s and
subse"uent (re(aration of "uarter#y u(dates to t8e (erformance/monitoring (#an
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
53/89
1-02 +8e (ro7ect design (resents a #ogica# frame%or: t8at #in:s (ro7ect acti)ities to eetai#ed uarter#y %or: (#ans and t8e o)era## Performance ?onitoring P#ans t8at%i## (ermit t8e efficient monitoring and e)a#uation of t8e (ro7ect
1-0 +8e ?R6 (#an is a tab#e t8at organies data co##ection by ty(e of data, fre"uency ofco##ection, co##ection met8odo#ogy, t8e (o(u#ation to be sur)eyed and t8e (ersonne# res(onsib#efor data co##ection +8e ?R6 (#an is designed to (ro)ide data on (ro7ect in(uts *eg,infrastructure, e"ui(ment, and #i)estoc:, out(uts *eg training, and outcomes *eg c8anges inagricu#ture (roducti)ity, income, and 8ea#t8 and nutrition for t8e (ur(ose of informedmanagement decision/ma:ing and for re#iab#e re(orting to t8e OCP and ot8er interested (arties+8e staff res(onsib#e for monitoring and e)a#uation enters t8e data co##ected from fie#d re(orts,sur)eys, and studies into a management information system for ana#ysis and re(orting +8e ?R6indicators data are "uantitati)e, #in:ed to s(ecific 8ouse8o#ds or communities +8e base#inecommunity and 8ouse8o#d data %i## inc#ude "ua#itati)e information and %i## a##o% stratificationof indicator data *eg, by gender, acti)ity, and #ocation for more detai#ed ana#ysis
1-0D 1aseline (ata Collection# $ouse8o#d base#ine information %i## be co##ected from eac8 (artici(ant %8en t8ey are recruited into t8e (rogram +8is %i## a##o% t8e (rogram to monitor (rogress and im(act at t8e 8ouse8o#d #e)e# as %e## as to stratify and aggregate t8e data to
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
54/89
e)a#uate community and sector im(acts Periodic data co##ection of im(act and monitoringindicators by (ro7ect staff %i## a##o% t8e continuous e)a#uation of t8e (rogramBs (rogress
1-03 Participatory Methodologies and (ata Collection Community members a#ong %it8 (rogram staff %i## monitor (ro7ect acti)ities suc8 as %or:s8o(s, site )isits, trainings, etc,
t8roug8 a((ro(riate#y designed instruments t8at do not re"uire e
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
55/89
-4( Performance Monitoring #rame8or
/" Component 3ctivity &ype of Information/Data
Collected
ource of
Information/Data
Collection Methods
Responsibility
for Data
Collection!
3nalysis and
Reporting
#re@uency/3u
dience of
Reporting
1 Performance?onitoring
?easurement of in(utindicators against (ro(osedtimetab#e and budget
inc#uding (rocurement and (8ysica# de#i)ery of goods,structures and ser)ices
?ont8#y or "uarter#ynarrati)e status andfinancia# re(orts
OCP N&OCCC
?ont8#y
2 Im(act ?onitoring +rac:ing effecti)eness ofin(uts against targets
Assessment of Pro7ectAffected Persons *PAPsatisfaction %it8 in(uts
uarter#y or semi/annua# "uantitati)e and"ua#itati)e sur)eys
'egu#ar (ub#icmeetings and ot8erconsu#tation %it8 (eo(#e affected by t8e (ro7ect re)ie% ofgrie)ance mec8anismout(uts
N&O uarter#y
- Com(#etion Audit ?easurement of out(utindicators suc8 as (roducti)ity gains,
#i)e#i8ood restoration, andde)e#o(ment im(act against>e)e#o(mentIm(#ementation P#an *>IP
6
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
56/89
• $IGAI>S
+raining/A%areness/6ducation/Pre)ention/Counse#ing/+esting
communitymembers
• +o (ro)ide
medica#assistance andtreatment to.000 communitymembers
first aid
/Number of beneficiaries attended8ea#t8 and nutrition%or:s8o(s
/ Number of8ouse8o#ds %8orecei)ed
immuniation
/ Number of (o(u#ation ab#e todescribe 2 %ays to (re)ent aidstransmission
/ Number of (ersonstested for $IGAI>S
>iscussions*=&>
/Stoc:8o#dersBmeetings
/ CCC
/ ?icro =inanceInstitutions*?=I
N&OBs
/i/annua#
/ Annua#
d
/ OCP
/ CCC
-5( Performance Monitoring and ,valuation Plan
-5( Performance Monitoring and ,valuation Plan *Continued
/ Number of beneficiaries %8o candescribe t%o
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
57/89
o((ortunistic infectionsand t%o met8ods ofcare and treatment
/ Number ofcommunities uti#iingmobi#e 8ea#t8 ser)ices
/ Number of first aid bo
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
58/89
-5( Performance Monitoring and ,valuation Plan *Continued
/ 6stab#is8ment andtraining of (um( and%ater faci#ities careta:er committees/ No of functioning%ater and sanitationcommittees estab#is8ed/ No of 8ouse8o#ds %it8
access to sanitationfaci#ities/ Sanitation faci#itiesconstructed
MICRO?,"&,RPRI,
&R3I"I"2
• Introduction +o
Sma## usiness6nter(rise
• Introduction +o
6ntre(reneurs8i(
• Fn#oc:ing
6ntre(reneuria#Ca(acity
• usiness
Orientation*matc8ing (eo(#e%it8 business
• ?ar:eting P#an
• Production
P#anning
• Organiationa#
?anagementP#anning
• =inancia# P#ans
• usiness Credit
?anagement
• Negotiation S:i##s
+o (roduce 150entre(reneurs for t8ede)e#o(ment of t8ecommunity
+o bui#d ca(acity of 150community members forem(#oyment generation
/ A%areness creationfor identification of (resent and emergingo((ortunities
/ Number of ne% sma##and medium sca#e business enter(riseestab#is8ed
/ Number of beneficiaries trained in
micro/enter(risede)e#o(ment,management andmar:eting
/ Number of grou(strained in creditmanagement andmicro/enter(risede)e#o(ment
/ Inter)ie%
/ =&>
/Sta:e8o#dersmeeting
/ Community
/ OCP
/ CCC
/ ?=IBs
N&OBs
/ ?ont8#y
/ uarter#y
/i/annua#
/ Annua#
N&O to bedetermined
/ OCP
/ CCC
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
59/89
-5( Performance Monitoring and ,valuation Plan *Continued
$OC3&IO"3'
&R3I"I"2/
KI'' 3C
/ Sta:e8o#ders
meeting
/ Inter)ie%
/ =&>
/ OCP
/ CCC
/ ?=IBs
/N&OBs
/ ?ont8#y
/ uarter#y
/i/annua#
/ Annua#
/ N&O to bedetermined
/ OCP
/ CCC
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
60/89
32RIC'&R3'
IMPRO$,M,"&/
R,&OR3&IO"
• 'e(#anting of
Cro(economictrees/Cas8e%/?ango/Castor /;ocust ean/?a8ogany
• =ood and cas8
cro( (roductiontraining
/Cassa)a/Lam/&roundnut/?aie/Pe((er
• Pro)ision of
agricu#tura# in(uts/seeds/seed#ings/ferti#ier /too#s
• +raining in
domestic#i)estoc:
(roduction/S8ee(/&oats/Catt#e
• +raining in
domestic (ou#try (roduction
• +raining in
(ro)ision ofa((ro(riatetec8no#ogies for (rocessing, )a#ueaddition
•
Cassa)a grindingmi## for %omen
/Increasedsustainab#e foodand anima# (roduction among250 farmers toensure a)ai#abi#ityand access
/ Number of farmerstrained in sustainab#e food (roduction met8ods
/ Number of farmerstrained in (artici(atory=arm management
/ Number of farmersin)o#)ed in t8een8ancement of access toser)ices and su((#ies ofser)ice (ro)iders toim(ro)e out (ut of currentcu#ti)ated cro(s
/ Number of farmersado(ting at #east . (romoted agricu#tura# (ractices
/ Number of increase in#i)estoc: (roduced
/ Number of community#i)estoc: %or:ers trained
/ Number of (rocessinggrinding mi##s a)ai#ab#e int8e community
/A)erage 8erd sie byty(e of anima# (er 8ouse
8o#d
/ Number of (ersons %8orecei)e e
/ Sta:e8o#ders?eeting
/ Community
/ OCP
/ CCC
/ ?=IBs
N&OBs
/ ?ont8#y
/ uarter#y
/i/annua#
/ Annua#
/ N&O to bedetermined
/ OCP
/ CCC
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
61/89
-5( Performance Monitoring and ,valuation Plan *Continued
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
62/89
-6( Performance Indicator &racing &able
Indicators #or Monitoring Fear -
&arget
Fear -
3chieved
Fear -
3chieved
vs &arget
Remars
,3'& ,R$IC,
Number of community )o#unteers trained in first aidmanagement
3
Number of beneficiaries attending 8ea#t8, sanitation and$IGAI>S %or:s8o(s
30
Immuniation co)erage rate for c8i#dren 0/5 years 100J
Number of adu#t (o(u#ation ab#e to describe 2 %ays to (re)ent aids transmission
2000
Number of (eo(#e uti#iing mobi#e 8ea#t8 ser)ices .000
Number of first aid bo
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
63/89
-6( Performance Indicator &racing &able *Continued
Indicators #or Monitoring Fear -
&arget
Fear -
3chieved
Fear -
3chieved
vs &arget
Remars
3"I&3&IO"
6stab#is8ment and training of %ater and sanitation*EA+SAN committees in (re)ention of diarr8ea and%ater borne diseases
.
No of #atrines constructed and functiona# 10
No %aste dum( site constructed and functiona# .
No of #atrines unused, un/maintained or (osed 8ea#t88aards
0
6stab#is8ment and training of (um( and %ater faci#itiescare ta:er committees
3
No of functioning %ater and sanitation committeesestab#is8ed
3
No of 8ouse8o#ds %it8 access to sanitation faci#ities 500
No of sanitation faci#ities constructed 1.
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
64/89
-6( Performance Indicator &racing &able *Continued
Indicators #or Monitoring Fear -
&arget
Fear -
3chieved
Fear -
3chieved
vs &arget
Remars
MICRO?,"&,RPRI, &R3I"I"2
No of beneficiaries trained in micro/enter(risede)e#o(ment, management and mar:eting
150
No of ne% sma## and medium sca#e business enter(riseestab#is8ed
100
No of grou(s trained in credit management and micro/enter(rise de)e#o(ment
5
I"DIC3&OR #OR MO"I&ORI"2 Fear -
&arget
Fear -
3chieved
Fear -
3chieved
vs &arget
Remars
$OC3&IO"3' &R3I"I"2/
KI'' 3C
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
65/89
-6( Performance Indicator &racing &able *Continued
Indicators for monitoring Fear -
&arget
Fear -
3chieved
Fear -
3chieved
vs &arget
Remars
32RIC'&R3' IMPRO$,M,"&/ R,&OR3&IO"
No of farmers trained in sustainab#e food (roductionmet8ods
250
No of farmers trained in (artici(atory farm management 250
No of increase in #i)estoc: (roduced +> No of community #i)estoc: %or:ers trained +>
No of cassa)a grinding mi##s a)ai#ab#e in t8e community .
No of (ersons in (i(e#ine communities recei)ingagricu#tura# e
A)erage #oan sie NA
'e(ayment rate J 100J
Sectora# segregation of #oan distribution
• Agricu#tura#
• Gocationa#
• ?icro/6nter(rise
+>
No of community foundations estab#is8ed 1
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
66/89
-7( Program
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
67/89
-7( Program
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
68/89
-7( Program
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
69/89
-9( Public Consultation! Disclosure and 2rievance Plan
1301 Introduction. +8e (ub#ic consu#tation, disc#osure and grie)ance (rocess is fundamenta#
to t8e success not on#y of t8e community de)e#o(ment (#an but t8e entire o(erations of OCP
1302 +egulations and +e7uirements2)egal 'rame-or%# +8e OCP is go)erned by bot8
Nigerian statutory frame%or: and internationa# *I=C guide#ines Eit8 res(ect to
consu#tation, (ub#ic disc#osure and community de)e#o(ment, t8e #ega# frame%or: may be
summaried as fo##o%s
*1 "igerian Regulations/2uidelines/Policies +8e Nigerian #a%s and regu#ations (rescribet8e need for consu#tations and (ub#ic disc#osure, %8ic8 is in #ine %it8 democratic (rinci(#esPro7ect s(onsors are encouraged to consu#t %it8 re#e)ant agencies to ensure ear#y notificationof t8e nature, sca#e and timing of a (ro(osed acti)ity Consu#tation and (ub#ic disc#osure a#so
ac8ie)es information gat8ering and e
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
70/89
• Private Land Tenure "PLT$+ +8is is a common ;+S %8ere (ri)ate indi)idua#*s or
cor(orate organisation*s ac"uire #and t8roug8 (urc8ase, in8eritance, gift or e
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
71/89
• +8e Pi(e#ine Communities *O8unene, 6gayin, Ire(eni, Ira(ana, Idodeng8e and ariagi
• Kogi State ;and Office
• ;o:o7a ;oca# &o)ernment Area * Core Communities &o)erning Aut8ority
• Ada)i and A7a:uota ;oca# &o)ernment Areas * Pi(e#ine Communities &o)erning
Aut8ority
• +raditiona# ;eaders8i( and >e)e#o(ment Associations of core communities *Oba7ana,
Oyo, I%a, A(at8a
• +raditiona# ;eaders8i( of Pi(e#ine Communities *O8unene, 6gayin, Ire(eni, Ira(ana,
Idodeng8e and ariagi
• $ea#t8care =aci#ities *=isayo C#inic and ?aternity, Oba7ana
1305 In order to a)oid du(#ication of efforts misinformation and t8e #i:e#i8ood ofcom(etition among sta:e8o#ders in t8e area, t8ere is a need for coordination mec8anisms t8at%i## engender coo(eration, en8ance synergies and reduce com(etition and du(#ication ofefforts and %aste of scarce resources An institutiona# arrangement in %8ic8 t8e ro#es of e)ery
:ey (#ayer are c#ear#y de#ineated and (erformed in a com(#imentary manner is a (re/re"uisitefor effecti)e im(#ementation of t8e I?C>P
130 Pu!lic Consultation and (isclosure Program A standard 8as been set by t8e I=Cregarding a Pub#ic Consu#tation and >isc#osure P#an *PC>P go)erning consu#tation anddisc#osure of information in)o#)ing t8e com(any and t8e communities As is eP out#ines t8e basic community #iaison structure t8at is aimed at im(ro)ing mutua# trust,coo(eration and good neig8bor re#ations8i( bet%een t8e com(any and t8e communities
130D +8e OICI team obser)ed a #ac: of information f#o% bet%een t8e Communities andOCP +8is %as attributed to t8e #ac: of a structured information e
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
72/89
de)e#o(ment +8e im(#ication of t8is arrangement is t8at at t8e indi)idua# )i##age #e)e# t8eCCC is t8e (oint of contact but for issues in)o#)ing t8e entire surrounding community, t8eCCC= is t8e centra#, re(resentati)e grou( for communication and co##aboration F(on OCP
(ro7ect a((ro)a# t8ese bodies %i## a#so assist in t8e im(#ementation and monitoring of t8eI?C>P acti)ities (ro(osed by OICI
1310 O!ajana Cement Plant . It is recommended t8at OCP maintain a %e##/trained team ofmu#ti/disci(#inary (rofessiona#s to 8and#e t8e (ub#ic consu#tation and disc#osure %it8 and%it8in t8e communities +8e team s8ou#d be (roacti)e in consu#tation and disc#osure ofinformation to sta:e8o#ders In addition to community consu#tation, it is recommended t8atOCP staff res(onsib#e for community de)e#o(ment 8a)e regu#ar contact and briefing sessions%it8 #eaders8i( of ;o:o7a, Ada)i and A7a:uota ;oca# &o)ernment Aut8orities
1311 Pipeline Communities# In co##aboration %it8 OICI, t8e se#ect (i(e#ine communitiesformed Community Consu#tati)e Committees *CCC +8e Pi(e#ine CCCs are com(osed oft8e e#ected members of res(ecti)e community de)e#o(ment associations and ot8er
community #eaders +8e Pi(e#ine CCC %i## be res(onsib#e for a## consu#tations and discourse%it8 OCP, as %e## as grie)ance management It is t8e recommendation of t8e OICI fie#d teamt8at OCP gi)e serious consideration to em(#oying an additiona# Community ;iaison Officer*C;O %8o is an indigene of one of t8e (i(e#ine communities +8is action %i## go a#ong %ayto%ards ensuring continued (ositi)e re#ations and o(en dia#ogue bet%een t8e (i(e#inecommunities and OCP e)en after t8e (i(e#ine is buried under ground
1312 Mechanism for Pu!lic Consultation and (isclosure +8e (ub#ic consu#tation anddisc#osure (rocess estab#is8ed in t8e core and (i(e#ine communities is designed to be inconformity %it8 t8e I=C standard
131- Methods of Consultation# +8e main met8ods of consu#tation bet%een OCP and t8esurrounding communities bot8 core and (i(e#ine %i## be t8roug8 in/(erson meetings Erittenre"uest and documentation %i## be uti#ied on an as needed basis
131. $imeta!le for Consultation -ith Sta%eholders# +8e recommended (rocess for (eriodic
interaction is as fo##o%s
• 9onthl! meetings bet%een OCP and t8e CCC=
• 9onthl! meetings bet%een OCP and t8e Pi(e#ine CCC
• :uarterl! brieings to +raditiona# ;eaders *C8iefs 8ig8#ig8ting community de)e#o(ment
acti)ities, issues and u(dates
• :uarterl! brieings to t8e ;oca# &o)ernments Aut8ority #eaders8i( *;o:o7a, Ada)i, and
A7a:uota 8ig8#ig8ting community de)e#o(ment acti)ities, issues and u(dates
1315 +esources and +esponsi!ilities Current#y a## (ub#ic consu#tation and disc#osure
bet%een OCP and t8e surrounding communities are managed by t8e &enera# ?anager
S(ecia# >uties 6it8er 8e 8and#es issues direct#y or de#egates to t8e C;O, Community
>e)e#o(ment Officer *C>O or t8e Coordinator for Safety, $ea#t8 and 6n)ironment
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
73/89
131 *rievance Management &rie)ances are e
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
74/89
*rievance Management (iagram
FigCom(#aint recei)edCom(#aint recei)ed )erba##y
or in %riting
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
75/89
Immediate and /or long term corrective actions agreed by GRCAdjust project procedures to reduce adverse efects or conicts with a
Corrective action Implemented"upplementary actions agreed by GRC/Co
#o $es
%iscuss proposed corrective action with the complainant
&utcome accepted by complainant
Com(#aint recorded in&rie)ances ;og
>etai#s of correcti)eaction recorded
Agreed correcti)e action,timeframe andim(#ementing (artyrecorded in t8e #og
'ecord outcome in #ogboo: and c#ose out
!udicia# Proceedings
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
76/89
-:( Conclusions and Recommendations
1401 In addition to t8e acti)ities out#ined in t8e I?C>P for effecti)e, amicab#e, #ong #astingre#ations and mutua##y beneficia# re#ations bet%een OCP and its surrounding communities,
t8e fo##o%ing recommendations are (ro(osed
Recommendation "o( -= Identify a Nongovernmental Organization to Implement this
Program
1402 +8e OCP needs to engage a re(utab#e and eP +8e N&O is e
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
77/89
1405 +8ese contributions are ta:en as buy/ins by t8e communities and it ensures t8at fromt8e beginning t8e communities :no% t8at t8ey are res(onsib#e for t8eir o%n de)e#o(ment+8e communities, as current#y constituted, do not 8a)e t8e ca(acity to manage t8e (#anned
(ro7ects and t8erefore it is our recommendation t8at t8e communities not be seen as t8e main
im(#ementers of t8e I?C>P but (artners in t8eir o%n de)e#o(ment
Recommendation "o( 0= "nsure that the OCP Community Management team is at all
times made up of Nigerians#
140 +8e cu#tura# nuances and sensiti)ities need for effecti)e consu#tation and disc#osures8ou#d not be under estimated
Recommendation "o( 1= Commercialize the Proposed Internal $ruc% Par%ing Area to
&elp 'inance Community (evelopment Initiatives#
140D +8e OCP (ro(osed interna# truc: (ar:ing area s8ou#d be on com(#etion,commercia#ied Proceeds from t8e truc: (ar: area s8ou#d t8en be c8anne#ed to%ards t8eeuties %8o are current#y res(onsib#e for (ub#ic consu#tation and disc#osure int8e communities one re(resentati)e eac8 from t8e Security >e(artment, ?aintenance>e(artment t8at is res(onsib#e of a## trans(ortation acti)ities, t8e ?edica# >e(artment, andt8e Ci)i# 6ngineering >e(artment %8o is current#y res(onsib#e for insta##ation ofinfrastructure (ro7ects re#ated to community de)e#o(ment acti)ities being e
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
78/89
1411 OCP s8ou#d discuss %it8 bot8 t8e Core Community Consu#tati)e =orum *CCC= andt8e Community C8iefs on t8e issue of OCP em(#oyment )acancies +8e communities s8ou#d
be gi)en t8e c8ance to source for candidates t8at may be em(#oyed $o%e)er, it s8ou#dcontinue to be made c#ear, t8at getting em(#oyments are based on t8e (ast (erformance,"ua#ification and com(etences:i##s of t8e candidates
Recommendation "o( 9= (eemphasize the 0se of Money to Solve Community Pro!lems
and *rievances#
1412 OCP s8ou#d de/em(8asie t8e use of money to so#)e community (rob#ems andgrie)ances +8is strategy ser)es as a tem(orary so#ution to %8at cou#d be #ong/term (rob#emsOCP s8ou#d focus a## its energy on (ub#ic consu#tation and disc#osure, grie)ance managementand eangote Industries ;imited
Recommendation "o( --= Provide 1usiness Opportunities to Community!ased
Contractors#
1415 OCP s8ou#d (atronie Community/based Contractors %it8 contracts t8at 8a)e #esstec8nica# re"uirements +8is is anot8er %ay of em(o%ering t8e communities
Recommendation "o( -0= Construct Additional 1oreholes#
141 ased on t8e )o#ume of inf#u< of (eo(#e into Oba7ana, an additiona# bore8o#e s8ou#d beconstructed for Oba7ana Community
Recommendation "o( -1= 'acilitate the "nforcement of *ood (riving Practices#
141D ased on t8e en)isage )o#ume of )e8icu#ar traffic t8at is e
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
79/89
1413 OCP in co##aboration %it8 ;o:o7a ;oca# &o)ernment and Kogi State &o)ernments8ou#d e
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
80/89
# &armonized *rievance +esolution Plan
?# Maps
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
81/89
2RI,$3"C, R,O'&IO"
#OR
2R,,,"#I,'D C,M,"& PROG,C& 3&
O.3G3"3! KO2I &3&,! "I2,RI3
&3.', O# CO"&,"&
C3P&,R P32,
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
82/89
-(; 2RI,$3"C, 3"D DIP&, R,O'&IO"(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((0
11 &enera#212 Ob7ecti)es of t8e grie)ances (rocess are as fo##o%s2
0(; 2RI,$3"C, #R3M,BORK(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((0
21 Institutiona# Arrangements *Committee members222 Procedures for recording and (rocessing grie)ances-
1(; 3$,", #OR PROG,C& 3##,C&,D P,OP', &O ,,K R,DR,(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((6
-1 Pro7ect based &rie)ance Contacts-2 Gi##age Administrati)e &rie)ance Contacts-- Pre !udicia# and !udicia# Proceedings-. ?onitoring of Outcomes
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
83/89
1.0 GRIEVANCES AND DISPUTES RESOLUTION
1.1 General
'his document describes the avenues that &bajana Cement (roject willma)e available *or project afected people to lodge a complaint or e+pressa grievance against the project, its staf or contractors- 'he documentalso describes the procedures, roles and responsibility *or addressinggrievances and resolving disputes- 'here would be monitoringmechanism to see or veri*y the outcome o* the grievance resolutionprocess-
'he *ocus o* the grievance resolution process is to achieve prompt redress*or complainants through negotiation or mediation directly with theproject, or through community or local administrative channels-
1.2 Objective !" t#e $rievance %r!ce.
'he objectives o* the grievances process are as *ollows.
'o provide afected people with straight*orward and accessibleavenues *or ma)ing a complaint or resolving any dispute that mayarise during the course o* the project
0- 'o ensure that appropriate and mutually acceptable correctivemeasures are identi1ed and summarily implemented to address
complaints2- 'o veri*y that complainants are satis1ed with the outcomes o* corrective actions
3- 'o avoid the need to resort to judicial or prejudicial proceedings-
Generally grievances provide a use*ul indicator o* project and contractorper*ormance- 4igh numbers o* grievances may point to a need to adjustwor) practices or procedures in order to reduce the adverse efects orconicts with afected households and communities-
2.0 GRIEVANCES RESOLUTION PROCESS
2.1 Intit&ti!nal Arran$e'ent (C!''ittee 'e'ber)
'here would be a Grievance Resolution Committee GRC! comprisingmembers o* the &C( (roject staf, traditional authorities, Communitymembers, non indigenes and other vulnerable groups-
2.2 Pr!ce*&re "!r rec!r*in$ an* %r!cein$ $rievance
'he grievance resolution process recommended is *ollows.
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
84/89
Ste% 1 + C!'%laint i receive*
Complaints will be received either directly, or through the respectivecommunity leadership to the %angote Industries 5imited at &bajana- 'he
complaint will be recorded in the Grievance 5og 6oo)- 'he constructionmanager will maintain the log boo) during the construction phase- 'heinitial log entry will include a description o* the grievance, details, detailso* the person lodging it and the date it was received-
Ste% 2 + Deter'inati!n !" C!rrecti!n Acti!n
'he Grievances Redress Committee will consider the complaint anddetermine the appropriate corrective action, in consultation with thecomplainant- 'he nature o* the corrective action, the time *ramewor)within which it is to be completed and the party to be responsible *orimplementing the action will be recorded in the log boo)- In addition tothe immediate complaint the GRC will determine whether any proceduralchanges are warranted to reduce the li)elihood o* similar adverse impactsor conicts in the *uture-
Ste% , + Dic&i!n -it# t#e C!'%lainant
'he proposed correction measure and the time*rame *or itsimplementation will be noti1ed and discussed with the complainant within7 days o* the receipt o* the complaint
Ste% + C!rrective Acti!n i i'%le'ente*
'he correction action will be carried out by the GRC within the agreedtime*rame- 'he date when the corrective action is completed will berecorded in the grievance log-
Ste% / + O&tc!'e !" t#e C!rrective Acti!n i verie* -it# t#eC!'%lainant
Following completion o* the corrective action, the outcome will be veri1ed
with the complainant by the Community Relations 8anager- 'hecomplainant will be signed of on the acceptance o* the solution- In casethe complainant remains dissatis1ed with the outcome, additionalcorrective measure may be agreed and carried out by the GRC
Ste% + Ot#er Aven&e
In the event the complainant is still dissatis1ed, and no satis*actoryresponse can be negotiated, the complainant has recourse to the judiciarysystem under the #igerian Civil Code-
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
85/89
FigCom(#aint recei)edCom(#aint recei)ed )erba##yor in %riting
-
8/18/2019 Maagement Study
86/89
Immediate and /or long term corrective actions agreed by GRC
Corrective action Implemented"upplementary actions agreed by GRC/Co
#o $es
%iscuss proposed corrective action with the complainant
&utcome accepted by complainant
!udicia# (roceedings
Ad7ust (ro7ect (rocedures to reducead)erse effects orconf#icts %it8 affected
(ersons *as necessary
>etai#s of correcti)eaction recorded
Agreed correcti)e action,timeframe andim(#ementing (artyrecorded in t8e #og
Com(#aint recorded in&rie)ances ;og
'ecord outcome in #ogboo: and c#ose out