longitudinal patterns of fine sediment infiltration and implications for chinook egg-to-fry survival...

24
Longitudinal Patterns of Fine Sediment Infiltration and Implications for Chinook Egg-to- Fry survival Ryan Klett1, Christian Torgersen2, Jeremy Cram1, Andrew Dittman3, George Pess3, Phil Roni3 1 College of Forest Resources, University of Washington, Seattle, WA 98195 2 U.S. Geological Survey, Forest and Rangeland Ecosystem Science Center, Cascadia Field Station 3 NOAA Northwest Fisheries Science Center, 2725 Montlake Boulevard East, Seattle, WA 98112

Upload: thomas-shields

Post on 22-Dec-2015

220 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Longitudinal Patterns of Fine Sediment Infiltration and Implications for Chinook Egg-to-Fry survival Ryan Klett1, Christian Torgersen2, Jeremy Cram1, Andrew

Longitudinal Patterns of Fine Sediment Infiltration and Implications for Chinook

Egg-to-Fry survival

Ryan Klett1, Christian Torgersen2, Jeremy Cram1, Andrew Dittman3, George Pess3, Phil Roni3

1 College of Forest Resources, University of Washington, Seattle, WA 981952 U.S. Geological Survey, Forest and Rangeland Ecosystem Science Center, Cascadia Field Station3 NOAA Northwest Fisheries Science Center, 2725 Montlake Boulevard East, Seattle, WA 98112

Page 2: Longitudinal Patterns of Fine Sediment Infiltration and Implications for Chinook Egg-to-Fry survival Ryan Klett1, Christian Torgersen2, Jeremy Cram1, Andrew

Fine Sediment and Egg to Fry survival

Levasseur et al. 2006

Page 3: Longitudinal Patterns of Fine Sediment Infiltration and Implications for Chinook Egg-to-Fry survival Ryan Klett1, Christian Torgersen2, Jeremy Cram1, Andrew

Objectives1. Dominant scale of spatial variation

2. Correlation between fine sediment infiltration, physical/geomorphic features

3. Associations between fine sediment infiltration and Chinook spawning patterns.

Page 4: Longitudinal Patterns of Fine Sediment Infiltration and Implications for Chinook Egg-to-Fry survival Ryan Klett1, Christian Torgersen2, Jeremy Cram1, Andrew

N

Easton

Thorp

Cle Elum

Cle Elum R.

Teanaway R.

Yakima R.

Study Area

• 3 reaches,14 sites per reach with 3 redds• 4 paired sites with 6 redds• 46 sites, 132 redds

Page 5: Longitudinal Patterns of Fine Sediment Infiltration and Implications for Chinook Egg-to-Fry survival Ryan Klett1, Christian Torgersen2, Jeremy Cram1, Andrew

The Whitlock-Vibert Box

• Simple, cheap, reliable index of sediment infiltration

• Filled with pre-sorted gravels in equal proportions: 6-12 mm, 12-24, and 24-36mm.

• Used by WDFW for concurrent survival study

Page 6: Longitudinal Patterns of Fine Sediment Infiltration and Implications for Chinook Egg-to-Fry survival Ryan Klett1, Christian Torgersen2, Jeremy Cram1, Andrew

Timing of Deployment and Retrieval

Page 7: Longitudinal Patterns of Fine Sediment Infiltration and Implications for Chinook Egg-to-Fry survival Ryan Klett1, Christian Torgersen2, Jeremy Cram1, Andrew

Deployment

Page 8: Longitudinal Patterns of Fine Sediment Infiltration and Implications for Chinook Egg-to-Fry survival Ryan Klett1, Christian Torgersen2, Jeremy Cram1, Andrew

Retrieval

Page 9: Longitudinal Patterns of Fine Sediment Infiltration and Implications for Chinook Egg-to-Fry survival Ryan Klett1, Christian Torgersen2, Jeremy Cram1, Andrew

Analysis of Sediment Samples

• Wet sieve, dry, dry sieve,weigh

• Reported as mass of fines <2mm/mass of gravel and fines in WV box

Page 10: Longitudinal Patterns of Fine Sediment Infiltration and Implications for Chinook Egg-to-Fry survival Ryan Klett1, Christian Torgersen2, Jeremy Cram1, Andrew

Within-Site Variability in Fine Sediment

D50

Velocity

Spacing

Page 11: Longitudinal Patterns of Fine Sediment Infiltration and Implications for Chinook Egg-to-Fry survival Ryan Klett1, Christian Torgersen2, Jeremy Cram1, Andrew

Within-Site Variability in Fine Sediment

0.35 m/s

0.72 m/s

0.91 m/s

101 spacing=2 and 5 m

Page 12: Longitudinal Patterns of Fine Sediment Infiltration and Implications for Chinook Egg-to-Fry survival Ryan Klett1, Christian Torgersen2, Jeremy Cram1, Andrew

Paired Set, Within Habitat Unit

Page 13: Longitudinal Patterns of Fine Sediment Infiltration and Implications for Chinook Egg-to-Fry survival Ryan Klett1, Christian Torgersen2, Jeremy Cram1, Andrew

Paired Set, Within Habitat Unit

Page 14: Longitudinal Patterns of Fine Sediment Infiltration and Implications for Chinook Egg-to-Fry survival Ryan Klett1, Christian Torgersen2, Jeremy Cram1, Andrew

Paired Set, Within Habitat Unit

two sample t-test P=0.07

5m from left bank

15m from left bank

Page 15: Longitudinal Patterns of Fine Sediment Infiltration and Implications for Chinook Egg-to-Fry survival Ryan Klett1, Christian Torgersen2, Jeremy Cram1, Andrew

Multiple Habitat Units <100 m apart

Page 16: Longitudinal Patterns of Fine Sediment Infiltration and Implications for Chinook Egg-to-Fry survival Ryan Klett1, Christian Torgersen2, Jeremy Cram1, Andrew

Multiple Habitat Units <100 m apart

Page 17: Longitudinal Patterns of Fine Sediment Infiltration and Implications for Chinook Egg-to-Fry survival Ryan Klett1, Christian Torgersen2, Jeremy Cram1, Andrew

Multiple Habitat Units <100 m apart

1118

1119

1120

Page 18: Longitudinal Patterns of Fine Sediment Infiltration and Implications for Chinook Egg-to-Fry survival Ryan Klett1, Christian Torgersen2, Jeremy Cram1, Andrew

Reach Scale

Page 19: Longitudinal Patterns of Fine Sediment Infiltration and Implications for Chinook Egg-to-Fry survival Ryan Klett1, Christian Torgersen2, Jeremy Cram1, Andrew

Reach Scale

Page 20: Longitudinal Patterns of Fine Sediment Infiltration and Implications for Chinook Egg-to-Fry survival Ryan Klett1, Christian Torgersen2, Jeremy Cram1, Andrew

Reach Scale

Page 21: Longitudinal Patterns of Fine Sediment Infiltration and Implications for Chinook Egg-to-Fry survival Ryan Klett1, Christian Torgersen2, Jeremy Cram1, Andrew

Intrusion across Mulitple Reaches

Page 22: Longitudinal Patterns of Fine Sediment Infiltration and Implications for Chinook Egg-to-Fry survival Ryan Klett1, Christian Torgersen2, Jeremy Cram1, Andrew

Site selection and fine sediment

Page 23: Longitudinal Patterns of Fine Sediment Infiltration and Implications for Chinook Egg-to-Fry survival Ryan Klett1, Christian Torgersen2, Jeremy Cram1, Andrew

Implications

• Threshold typically established at 15-20%• No sites exceeding 12%

Page 24: Longitudinal Patterns of Fine Sediment Infiltration and Implications for Chinook Egg-to-Fry survival Ryan Klett1, Christian Torgersen2, Jeremy Cram1, Andrew

Thanks

• Committee: chair- Christian Torgersen (USGS, UW) Tom Quinn

(UW). Phil Roni, (NWFSC,NOAA)

• Chris Johnson, (WDFW)

• George Pess, Andy Dittman (NWFSC, NOAA)

• Jeremy Cram, Katie Murray, Thomas Buehrens (UW)

• Charles Strom and the Cle Elum Supplementation and Research Facility staff