Lecture 10: New Media and Journalism: Trends and Consequences

New Media: A Recapitulation

• It refers to a group of relatively recent mass media such as the Internet and World Wide Web, video games and interactive media, CD-ROM and other forms of multimedia popular from the 1990s onwards

• At the heart of the new media lies information processing technology which is based on digitization and miniaturization technologies.

• As a result, new media technologies are extremely portable where given its falling costs together with its low to medium learning curve have made it extremely accessible to non-media trained people.

• Together with the fact that the backbone of the new media is the Internet where falling cost as well as real-time global connection, the use of the new media in gathering news has spread beyond the confines of traditional journalism.

Citizen Journalism: An alternative way to report news?

• Also known as "participatory journalism," is the act of citizens "playing an active role in the process of collecting, reporting, analyzing and disseminating news and information," according to the seminal report We Media: How Audiences are Shaping the Future of News and Information, by Shayne Bowman and Chris Willis.

• They say, "The intent of this participation is to provide independent, reliable, accurate, wide-ranging and relevant information that a democracy requires."

• Should not be confused with Civic Journalism, which is practiced by professional journalists. Citizen journalism usually involves empowering ordinary citizens -- including traditionally marginalized members of society.

Characteristics of Citizen Journalism

• In a 2003, Online Journalism Review article, J. D. Lasica defines Citizen Journalism as having the following characteristics:

1. Audience participation (such as user comments attached to news stories, personal blogs, photos or video footage captured from personal mobile cameras, or local news written by residents of a community),

2. Independent news and information Websites (Consumer Reports, the Drudge Report),

3. Full-fledged participatory news sites (OhMyNews),

4. Collaborative and contributory media sites (Slashdot, Kuro5hin),

5. Other kinds of "thin media." (mailing lists, email newsletters),

6. Personal broadcasting sites (video broadcast sites such as KenRadio).

• There is some disagreement over whether blogs should be included in this list, however. Since most blogs are not subjected to the same checks and balances to ensure that a story is balanced and represents fair comment, they are not truly journalism and should not be treated in the same way as a professional news source.

Who Is Involved?

• "Doing citizen journalism right means crafting a crew of correspondents who are typically excluded from or misrepresented by local television news: low-income women, minorities and youth -- the very demographic and lifestyle groups who have little access to the media and that advertisers don't want," says Robert Huesca, an associate professor of communication at Trinity University in San Antonio, Texas.

• Citizen journalism can also be the product of circumstance. NowPublic, for example, features photographs, videos and written accounts from people who are not trained journalists but have acquired footage as a result of witnessing news events. In many cases citizen journalists are just accidental bystanders who have a camera or camera phone.

• Citizen journalists may be activists within the communities they write about. This has drawn some criticism from traditional media institutions such as The New York Times, which have accused proponents of public journalism of abandoning the traditional goal of ‘objectivity’

History of Citizen Journalism

• The public journalism movement emerged after the 1988 U.S. presidential election as a countermeasure against the eroding trust in the news media and widespread public disillusionment with politics and civic affairs.

• Jay Rosen, a journalism professor at New York University, was one of its earliest proponents. From 1993 to 1997, he directed the Project on Public Life and the Press, funded by the Knight Foundation and housed at NYU. He also currently runs the PressThink weblog.

• Initially, discussions of public journalism focused on promoting journalism that was, "for the people," by changing the way professional reporters did their work. A recent study done for the Pew Center and the Associated Press Managing Editors found that, " Forty-five percent of all editors surveyed say that their newsrooms use the tools and techniques of civic journalism. Sixty-six percent say they either embrace the label or like the philosophy and tools, suggesting that there are even more practitioners."

• According to Leonard Witt, however, early public journalism efforts were, "often part of 'special projects' that were expensive, time-consuming and episodic. Too often these projects dealt with an issue and moved on. Journalists were driving the discussion. They would say, "Let's do a story on welfare-to-work (or the environment, or traffic problems, or the economy)," and then they would recruit a cross-section of citizens and chronicle their points of view.

• Since not all reporters and editors bought into public journalism, and some outright opposed it, reaching out to the people from the newsroom was never an easy task." By 2003, in fact, the movement seemed to be petering out, with the Pew Center for Civic Journalism closing its doors.

• Simultaneously, however, journalism that was "by the people" began to flourish, enabled in part by emerging internet and networking technologies, such as weblogs, chat rooms, message boards, wikis and mobile computing. A relatively new development is the use of convergent polls, allowing editorials and opinions to be submitted and voted on. Overtime, the poll converges on the most broadly accepted editorials and opinions.

• In South Korea, Ohmynews became popular and commercially successful with the motto, "Every Citizen is a Reporter." Founded by Oh Yeoh-Ho on Feb. 22, 2000, it has a staff of some 40-plus traditional reporters and editors who write about 20% of its content, with the rest coming from other freelance contributors who are mostly ordinary citizens. OhmyNews has been credited with transforming South Korea's conservative political environment.

• During the 2004 U.S. presidential election, both the Democratic and Republican parties issued press credentials to citizen bloggers covering the convention, marking a new level of influence and credibility for nontraditional journalists.

• Some bloggers also began watchdogging the work of conventional journalists, monitoring their work for biases and inaccuracy.

• A recent trend in citizen journalism has been the emergence of what blogger Jeff Jarvis terms hyperlocal journalism, as online news sites invite contributions from local residents of their subscription areas, who often report on topics that conventional newspapers tend to ignore. “

• ‘We are the traditional journalism model turned upside down," explains Mary Lou Fulton, the publisher of the Northwest Voice in Bakersfield, California. "Instead

of being the gatekeeper, telling people that what's important to them 'isn't news,' we're just opening up the gates and letting people come on in. We are a better community newspaper for having thousands of readers who serve as the eyes and ears for the Voice, rather than having everything filtered through the views of a small group of reporters and editors."

The Dark Side of the New Media

• The issue of privacy.

• The rise of information conglomerates and the control of search engines and net contents.

• Greater access to information = democracy?

• The growing divide among information rich and information poor in society and around the globe.