lactate measured in diluted and undiluted - clinical chemistry

5
2430 CLINICAL CHEMISTRY, Vol. 38, No. 12, 1992 donor liver and early outcome oftransplantation. Transplant Proc 1991;23:1575-8. 4. Schroeder TJ, Gremse DA, Mansour ME, et a!. Lidocaine metabolism as an index of liver function in hepatic transplant donors and recipients. Transplant Proc 1989;21:2299-301. 5. Nation RL, Peng GW, Chiou WL. High-performance liquid chromatographic method for the simultaneous determination of hidocaine and its N-dealkylated metabohites in plasma. J Chro- matogr 1979;162:466-73. 6. Hill J, Roussin A, Lelorier J, Caille G. High-pressure liquid chromatographic determination of lidocaine and its active do- ethylated metabohites. J Pharm Sci 1980;69:1341-2. 7. Verbesselt R, Ijandramaga TB, De Schepper PJ. High-perfor- mance liquid chromatographic determination of 12 antiarrhyth- mic drugs in plasma using solid-phase column extraction. Ther Drug Monit 1991;13:157-65. 8. Chen Y, Potter JM, Ravenscroft PJ. A high-performance liquid chromatographic method for the simultaneous determination of MEGX and hignocaine. J Chromatogr 1992;574:361-4. 9. Chen Y, Potter JM, Ravenscroft PJ. A quick, sensitive HPLC CLIN. CHEM. 38/12, 2430-2434 (1992) assay for MEGX and hignocaine in serum/plasma using solid-phase extraction. Ther Drug Monit (in press). 10. Bland JM, Altman DG. Statistical methods for assessing agreement between two methods of clinical measurement. Lancet 1986;i:307-10. 11. Scott CB, Henderson A, Potter JM, et al. Impaired hepatic metabolism of IV lignocaine as an index of cellular damage from carbon monoxide poisoning. Med J Aust 1992;156:367. 12. Schroeder TJ, Tasset JJ, Poses AJ. Lidocaine metabolism as an indicathr of liver function. Am Assoc Cliii Chem TDM-T 1990;12(3):7-13. 13. Thomson AH, Kelnian AW, Vane PJ, Hills WS, Whiting B. Changes in hignocaine disposition during long-term infusion in patients with acute ventricular arrhythmias. Ther Drug Momt 1987;9:283-91. 14. Sherwin JE. Liver function. In: Kaplan LA, Pesos AJ, eds. Clinical chemistry. St. Louis, MO: CV Mosby, 1984:420-38. 15. Potter JM, Hickman PE, Balderson GA, Lynch SV, Strong R. Lignocaine metabolism and MEGX production in the liver trans. plant donor. Transplant Proc 1992;24:198-9. Lactate Measured in Diluted and Undiluted Whole Blood and Plasma: Comparison of Methods and Effect of Hematocrit John Toffaletti, Mary Ellen Hammes, Rudethia Gray, Beverly Lineberry, and Billy Abrams We evaluated a new analyzer that measures lactate in undiluted whole blood by direct (or undiluted) amperom- etry [Nova Stat Profile 7 Analyzer (SP7); Nova Biomedi- cal, Waltham, MA] by comparing it with two other anaiyz- ers, one for measuring lactate in whole blood by indirect (or diluted) amperometry [Model 2300; Yellow Springs Instrument Co. (YSI), Yellow Springs, OH] and another for measuring lactate in plasma by enzymatic coiorimetry (aca; Du Pont Co., Wilmington, DE). All between-method comparisons of the three methods showed that the results for plasma were comparable (S1 = 0.24-0.33 mmol/L). Within-method comparisons by the YSI differed substan- tiaily between plasma and whole blood (Si,,, = 0.48 mmoi/L), but within-method comparisons by the SP7 produced better agreement between plasma and whole blood = 0.18 mmol/L). The difference between whole blood and plasma by YSI is reiated to hematocrit, with the greatest differences noted for samples with the highest hematocrit. Serum lactate measured by SP7 had between-day imprecision (CV) ranging from 1 2% at 0.5 mmoi/L to 4.2% at 3.7 mmoi/L, showed a linear standard curve to at least 1 1 .5 mmol/L, and was independent of hematocrit. There was a mean bias of -0.4 mmol/L for results in the reference range for both plasma and whole blood by SP7 compared with plasma results by either aca orYSi. AdditIonal Keyphrases: amperometry . enzymatic co!orimetiy compared Measuring blood lactate concentrations is important for detecting impaired circulatory and tissue oxygen- ation in critical-care patients (1-4). Because most crit- ical-care monitoring requires rapid availability of re- sults, methods that measure lactate quickly in whole blood are desirable. Although an analyzer that mea- sures lactate in whole blood both rapidly (45 s) and in a small sample volume (25 L) is available (5), the methodology requires dilution of whole blood before measurement oflactate, introducing an analytical error that increases with increasing hematocrit. An equation may be used to correct for hematocrit (5), but this has at least two drawbacks: correction ofresults by equation is inherently inaccurate, and correction requires measur- ing one or more additional variables. Furthermore, direct measurements in plasma and whole blood, by detecting the molahity of constituents such as glucose (6), detect the physiologically and clinically relevant quantity. Therefore, the availability of a direct-reading electrode method for measuring lactate in whole blood that is unaffected by hematocrit would be desirable for critical-care monitoring. Materials and Methods Blood Gas Services, Division of Clinical Laboratories, Depart- ment ofPathology, P0 Box 3015, Duke University Medical Center, Durham, NC 27710. Received March 13, 1992; accepted July 24, 1992. Instrumentation. The enzymatic colorimetric method for the aca (Du Pont Co., Wilmington, DE) uses rabbit muscle lactate dehydrogenase (EC.1.1.1.27) to catalyze the oxidation ofL-lactate to pyruvate with simultaneous

Upload: others

Post on 22-Feb-2022

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

2430 CLINICAL CHEMISTRY, Vol. 38, No. 12, 1992

donor liver and early outcome oftransplantation. Transplant Proc1991;23:1575-8.4. Schroeder TJ, Gremse DA, Mansour ME, et a!. Lidocainemetabolism as an index of liver function in hepatic transplantdonors and recipients. Transplant Proc 1989;21:2299-301.5. Nation RL, Peng GW, Chiou WL. High-performance liquidchromatographic method for the simultaneous determination ofhidocaine and its N-dealkylated metabohites in plasma. J Chro-matogr 1979;162:466-73.6. Hill J, Roussin A, Lelorier J, Caille G. High-pressure liquidchromatographic determination of lidocaine and its active do-ethylated metabohites. J Pharm Sci 1980;69:1341-2.7. Verbesselt R, Ijandramaga TB, De Schepper PJ. High-perfor-mance liquid chromatographic determination of 12 antiarrhyth-mic drugs in plasma using solid-phase column extraction. TherDrug Monit 1991;13:157-65.8. Chen Y, Potter JM, Ravenscroft PJ. A high-performance liquidchromatographic method for the simultaneous determination ofMEGX and hignocaine. J Chromatogr 1992;574:361-4.9. Chen Y, Potter JM, Ravenscroft PJ. A quick, sensitive HPLC

CLIN. CHEM. 38/12, 2430-2434 (1992)

assay for MEGX and hignocaine in serum/plasma using solid-phaseextraction. Ther Drug Monit (in press).10. Bland JM, Altman DG. Statistical methods for assessingagreement between two methods of clinical measurement. Lancet1986;i:307-10.

11. Scott CB, Henderson A, Potter JM, et al. Impaired hepaticmetabolism of IV lignocaine as an index of cellular damage fromcarbon monoxide poisoning. Med J Aust 1992;156:367.12. Schroeder TJ, Tasset JJ, Poses AJ. Lidocaine metabolism asan indicathr of liver function. Am Assoc Cliii Chem TDM-T1990;12(3):7-13.13. Thomson AH, Kelnian AW, Vane PJ, Hills WS, Whiting B.Changes in hignocaine disposition during long-term infusion inpatients with acute ventricular arrhythmias. Ther Drug Momt1987;9:283-91.14. Sherwin JE. Liver function. In: Kaplan LA, Pesos AJ, eds.Clinical chemistry. St. Louis, MO: CV Mosby, 1984:420-38.15. Potter JM, Hickman PE, Balderson GA, Lynch SV, Strong R.Lignocaine metabolism and MEGX production in the liver trans.plant donor. Transplant Proc 1992;24:198-9.

Lactate Measured in Diluted and Undiluted Whole Blood and Plasma: Comparison ofMethods and Effect of Hematocrit

John Toffaletti, Mary Ellen Hammes, Rudethia Gray, Beverly Lineberry, and Billy Abrams

We evaluated a new analyzer that measures lactate inundiluted whole blood by direct (or undiluted) amperom-etry [Nova Stat Profile 7 Analyzer (SP7); Nova Biomedi-cal, Waltham, MA] by comparing it with two other anaiyz-ers, one for measuring lactate in whole blood by indirect(or diluted) amperometry [Model 2300; Yellow SpringsInstrument Co. (YSI), Yellow Springs, OH] and another formeasuring lactate in plasma by enzymatic coiorimetry(aca; Du Pont Co., Wilmington, DE). All between-methodcomparisons of the three methods showed that the resultsfor plasma were comparable (S�1� = 0.24-0.33 mmol/L).Within-method comparisons by the YSI differed substan-tiaily between plasma and whole blood (Si,,, = 0.48

mmoi/L), but within-method comparisons by the SP7produced better agreement between plasma and whole

blood � = 0.18 mmol/L). The difference betweenwhole blood and plasma by YSI is reiated to hematocrit,with the greatest differences noted for samples with thehighest hematocrit. Serum lactate measured by SP7 hadbetween-day imprecision (CV) ranging from 1 2% at 0.5mmoi/L to 4.2% at 3.7 mmoi/L, showed a linear standardcurve to at least 1 1 .5 mmol/L, and was independent ofhematocrit. There was a mean bias of �-0.4 mmol/L forresults in the reference range for both plasma and whole

blood by SP7 compared with plasma results by either acaorYSi.

AdditIonal Keyphrases: amperometry . enzymatic co!orimetiycompared

Measuring blood lactate concentrations is importantfor detecting impaired circulatory and tissue oxygen-ation in critical-care patients (1-4). Because most crit-ical-care monitoring requires rapid availability of re-

sults, methods that measure lactate quickly in wholeblood are desirable. Although an analyzer that mea-sures lactate in whole blood both rapidly (45 s) and in a

small sample volume (25 �L) is available (5), themethodology requires dilution of whole blood before

measurement oflactate, introducing an analytical error

that increases with increasing hematocrit. An equationmay be used to correct for hematocrit (5), but this has atleast two drawbacks: correction ofresults by equation isinherently inaccurate, and correction requires measur-ing one or more additional variables. Furthermore,direct measurements in plasma and whole blood, bydetecting the molahity of constituents such as glucose(6), detect the physiologically and clinically relevantquantity. Therefore, the availability of a direct-readingelectrode method for measuring lactate in whole bloodthat is unaffected by hematocrit would be desirable forcritical-care monitoring.

Materials and Methods

Blood Gas Services, Division of Clinical Laboratories, Depart-ment ofPathology, P0 Box 3015, Duke University Medical Center,Durham, NC 27710.

Received March 13, 1992; accepted July 24, 1992.

Instrumentation. The enzymatic colorimetric methodfor the aca (Du Pont Co., Wilmington, DE) uses rabbitmuscle lactate dehydrogenase (EC.1.1.1.27) to catalyze

the oxidation ofL-lactate to pyruvate with simultaneous

CLINICAL CHEMISTRY, Vol. 38, No. 12, 1992 2431

reduction of NAD�. The formation of NADH, which is

proportional to lactate concentration, is monitored asthe difference in absorbance at 340 run (analytical) and

383 nm (background). The method requires 40 p�L of

serum, plasma, or cerebrospinal fluid (CSF).The diluted amperometric method of the YSI Model

2300 (Yellow Springs Instrument Co., Yellow Springs,OH) was described previously (5). This method uses a

lactate-sensitive electrode in which L-lactate oxidase isattached to one of the membrane layers covering the

electrode. This method measures lactate in 25 p.L ofwhole blood, plasma, or CSF diluted with 600 �L of

buffer.

The undiluted amperometric method on the Nova

Stat Proffle 7 analyzer (SP7; Nova Biomedical,Waltham, MA) uses a lactate-sensitive electrode inwhich L-lactate oxidase is immobilized on a membrane

covering an amperometric electrode. The reactions aresimilar to those for the YSI method (5). Briefly, lactate

oxidase generates hydrogen peroxide from lactate and

oxygen. The H202 diffuses to a platinum anode held at apotential of +0.7 V relative to a silver reference cathode.The H202 is then oxidized to 02 at the amperometricelectrode. The method measures lactate in 190 �L ofwhole blood, plasma, or CSF. The instrument is cali-brated with aqueous solutions containing lactate at

either 1, 3, or 10 mmol/L.

Cost and longevity ofmembranes. During the 50 daysof our study, we changed the lactate electrode mem-

brane (part no. 09925) on the SP7 eight times. Thus,new membranes were required about every 6 days. As of

November 1991, lactate membranes cost -�--$14 each.Over the past year, lactate membranes for the YSI haverequired changing about every 7 days. As of November

1991, the list price for the YSI electrodes was ‘-$20each. For the Du Pont aca, individual lactate reagentpacks had a 1991 list price of $2.09.

Controls. We used both aqueous and serum-basedmaterials as controls. The aqueous material was sup-

plied by Nova as the Stat Profile Control, levels 1, 2, and3. The ranges (in mmol/L) for each were as follows:0.3-0.7, 1.0-1.4, and 3.4-4.2, respectively.

The serum-based materials were prepared from

pooled sera that contained both normal and high con-

centrations of lactate. Individual portions of each poolwere frozen in 2.5-mL plastic screw-cap tubes. Theseportions were stored frozen and were thawed on the day

of analysis.Blood-collection devices. We used the following blood-

collection devices: 20-mL plain syringes (Becton Dickin-son Co., Rutherford, NJ); 3-mL syringes with 40 kIU/L

calcium-titrated lyophilized heparin (Radiometer Amer-ica, Westlake, OH); 3-mL syringes with 15 kJU/L dry

lithium heparin (Martell Medical Products, Temecula,CA); 3-mL evacuated tubes containing 1.5 mg of lithium

iodoacetate and 43 RI oflithium heparmn (Becton Dick-inson); and 7-mL evacuated tubes containing 15 kIUIL

lithium heparin (Becton Dickinson).Our results corroborated the reference interval for

venous plasma lactate established at Duke Medical

Center, 0.5-2.2 mmol/L. This range was determined in

plasma from blood collected into fluoride/oxalate tubesfrom ‘-30 apparently healthy individuals and analyzedwith the Du Pont aca. The upper limit of 2.2 mmolIL

included �95% of the results.Whole blood andplasma for rnethod-compari�on stud-

ies. Immediately after collecting blood in 3-mL heparin-ized syringes containing 15 kIUfL lithium heparin, we

transferred ‘-2 mL of blood to 2.5-mL capped plastictubes and centrifuged the tubes to obtain plasma. The

original heparinized whole blood was analyzed as soon

as possible.Modification ofhematocrit in whole-blood samples. To

obtain samples with either high or low hematocrits, we

centrifuged the whole-blood samples from several vol-unteers and then selectively removed either plasma (toincrease hematocrit) or erythrocytes (to decrease hemat-

ocrit).

Volunteers. We collected blood both from apparently

healthy people and from patients during surgery (ages19-65 years). All had read and signed a consent formapproved by the Duke Medical Center Review Board forClinical Investigations.

Interfereru,e studies. To study the effect of potentiallyinterfering compounds, we prepared concentrated aque-ous solutions (100 or 200 m.mollL) of the followingchemicals: L-ascorbic acid (176.1 g/mol; Fisher Scien-tific, Fair Lawn, NJ); pyruvic acid, sodium salt (110

g/mol); acetoacetic acid, lithium salt (108 g/mol); andf3-hydroxybutyric acid, sodium salt (126.1 g/mol), allfrom Sigma Chemical Co., St. Louis, MO.

Statistical cakulations. The regression equations, cor-relation coefficients (r), and standard errors of y on x(S,,�) were calculated by least-squares analysis as de-

scribed by Barnett (7). The established methods used forcomparison (x) were in priority of higher to lower val-

ues: plasma by aca, plasma by YSI, whole blood by YSI.

Results

Within-analyzer and between-analyzer comparisons.

The results for lactate measured in whole blood andplasma by the two methods are compared in Table 1.Although there is a large variability between the

plasma and whole-blood results by YSI � 0.48mmol/L), the plasma-whole-blood variability is rela-

Table 1. Summary of Whole-Blood (WB) and Plasma

(P) Comparisons between Methods

syx,n r mmol/L

81 SP7-P = 0.92 (YSI-P) + 0.46 mmol/L 0.993 0.33

68 SP7.P 0.91 (aca-P) + 0.63 mmoVL 0.993 0.3379 SP7-WB = 0.95 (SP7-P) + 0.1 5 mmoVL 0.997 0.1881 SP7-WB = I .1 9 (YSI-WB) + 0.82 mmol/L 0.965 0.7281 SP7-WB = 0.86 (YSI-P) + 0.67 mmoVL 0.991 0.3355 SP7WB = 0.86 (aca-P) + 0.81 mmoIIL 0.990 0.34

70 YSI-P = 1 .00 (aca-P) + 0.1 9 mmol/L 0.997 0.24

81 YSI-WB = 0.73 (YSI-P) - 0.23 mmoVL 0.974 0.4855 YSI-WB = 0.72 (aca-P) - 0.02 mmoVL 0.982 0.39

Equation

MeanSD95% reference interval

n = 19.

lactate concentration, we collected blood into 20-mLsyringes. We then distributed the blood from each sy-

ringe into three blood-collection containers: one syringe

with 40 kIi.JIL calcium heparin, one tube with 15 kIU/Llithium heparin, and one tube with 15 kIU/L lithium

heparin and 0.15 g/L lithium iodoacetate. To serve as

the control sample from each donor, whole blood col-lected without anticoagulant was analyzed by SP7

within 2 mm after collection to provide results mini-

mally affected by either cellular metabolism or antico-

agulants (8).Although the mean differences from results for the

control sample differed little among the three containersstudied, both the syringe containing 40 kIU/L dry cal-

cium-titrated heparin and the evacuated tube contain-

ing 15 kfl.JIL dry lithium heparin gave the most consis-

tent results (in mmollL), -0.2 ± 0.14 (mean ± SD,

range -0.3 to 0.1) and 0.07 ± 0.16 (range -0.3 to 0.3),

respectively. The calcium heparin syringe showed theleast variability, closely followed by the lithium heparin

tube. lodoacetate heparin tubes gave the highest van-

ability (0.06 ± 0.30 mmolfL), with differences ranging

from -0.5 to +0.5 mmol/L. This suggests that hepanin isa satisfactory anticoagulant if samples are either stored

in ice or analyzed soon after collection.

Effects of storage time and temperature on lactate

concentrations. We collected both plasma and hepanin-

ized whole blood (containing 15-20 kIUIL heparin) fromfive volunteers to establish the effects of storage timeand temperature on the stability of lactate concentra-tions measured by the SP7. Our data showed that

plasma was quite stable: storage on ice showed no

detectable change after 120 mm, and plasma stored at

room temperature changed by only 0.1 mmolJL after 120mm. Whole blood was also stable when stored in an icebath, changing by 0.1 mmolJL after 60 mm and by 0.2mmol/L after 120 mm. Although the above conditions

would be acceptable for at least 60 mm, in whole bloodstored at room temperature lactate increased by --0.5

mmol/L after 30 mm. Clearly, room-temperature stor-

age of heparinized whole blood must be avoided.Potential interferents. To determine the effect of pa-

____ tential interfering substances on lactate measured by

SD cv, s the SP7, we diluted serum 9:1 with a solution contain-ing, per liter, either 160 mmol of NaC1 (control), 200

8.5 mmol of acetoacetate, 100 mmol of pyruvate, 200 mmol6.3 of /3-hydroxybutyrate, or 100 mmol of ascorbate. To0 avoid the possible enzymatic conversion of pyruvate to

0 0 lactate in serum, we also studied the potential interfer-I .1 ence of pyruvate by diluting 100 mmol/L pyruvate 9:10.6 with an aqueous solution containing 5 mmol/L lactate.5.0 The results indicate that only ascorbate at 10 mmol/L6.2 had a detectable effect, lowering the measured lactate1 .4 concentration by 0.3 mmol/L. Because 10 mmolfL ascor-1 .5 bate is 50- to 100-fold greater than the usual plasma

concentration, ascorbate would rarely, if ever, interfere12.1 with the amperometric measurement of lactate.

� Effect ofhematocrit on differences in lactate concentra-. tion. To study the effect ofhematocrit on lactate results,

- we adjusted hematocrits to 0.18-0.69 by selectively

YSI

1.36

0.440.5-2.2

Table 3. PrecIsion of Lactate Measurements byUndiluted Amperometry (SP7)

Lactate, mmol/L

Aqueous

Serum

Serum

Between-day (n = 41)Aqueous

AqueousAqueous

0.5 0.061.2 0.033.7 0.15

a Aqueous or serum-based control material.

2432 CLINICAL CHEMISTRY, Vol. 38, No. 12,1992

tively small by SP7 (S� = 0.18 mmolIL). The compari-

sons between aca and YSI for plasma give less variabil-ity (S�� = 0.24 mmol/L) than do the comparisons

between either aca and SP7 or YSI and 5P7 (S�� = 0.33mmol/L). The y-intercept data are higher by 0.5-0.8

mmol/L for SP7 compared with either aca or YSI.Because hematocrit is not an issue in plasma compari-

sons, these differences may be due either to calibrationset points or plasma water content (6). Correcting for

plasma water content (dividing aca results by 0.93) didnot improve agreement; we conclude that differences incalibration set points accounted for the bias.

We collected 19 samples from persons having a lactate

concentration within our reference interval of 0.5-2.2mmol/L (venous plasma by colorimetric method) (Table

2). In this range of lactate concentrations, results from

both amperometric methods (SP7 and YSI) were higherthan by the colorimetric method (aca); results from SP7

were the highest, -0.4 mmol/L higher than by aca.

Precision. Between-day precision was determined by

analyzing three concentrations of aqueous controls for41 days. Within-run precision was studied by analyzing

the three aqueous controls and two pools of human

serum 20 times on each of 2 days. Results of between-day and within-run precision are shown in Table 3.

Blood-collection containers for lactate analyses. From

each of 10 healthy volunteers, some of whom had exer-

cised before blood was collected to increase the blood

Table 2. Lactate Concentrations (mmol/L) In PlasmaSamples in the aca Reference Interval

ace SP7

1.17 1.56

0.48 0.450.4-2.1 0.7-2.5

Matsrlal Mean

Within-run (n = 20)Aqueous 0.5 0.04

0.03Aqueous 1.2 0

3.7 0.040.02

1.3 0.070.08

7.9 0.110.12

12

10

,27‘20

I2

I023 133 Ii

CLINICAL CHEMISTRY, Vol. 38, No. 12, 1992 2433

removing either packed erythrocytes or plasma from 25

samples of blood that had settled in syringes. As ex-

pected from a previous study (5), hematocrit was signif-

icantly related to the difference between lactate in

whole blood measured by YSI and in either plasma

measured by YSI or whole blood measured by 5P7

(Table 4).Linearity. Using centrifugation and selective removal

of either plasma or erythrocytes, we prepared sevenwhole-blood samples having hematocrits of 0.20-0.63.

To achieve high lactate concentrations, we held thesamples at room temperature for 16-20 h. We then

diluted each sample with saline to produce samples

containing 50%, 33%, and 25% of their original compo-sition. These diluted samples and the original sample

were analyzed by SP7 (Figure 1). Although the mean ofall results at each dilution gave a nearly straight line(not shown), one sample deviated by 15% below linear-

ity (hematocrit of 0.27) and another sample deviated by

15% above linearity (hematocrit of 0.51). Because thesedeviations were apparently not related to either hemat-

ocrit or initial lactate concentration, we conclude these

are method-related variations.

Table 4. RelatIonship of Hematocrlt (Hct) to DifferencesIn Lactate Measurements

Dlffessncss

comparsd wIth Hct Difference In lactate, mmolIL r

YSI� - YSIWB 0.071(Hct)-0.44 0.70 (P <0.0001)

� � YSI� 0.077(Hct)-0.94 0.79 (P <0.0001)SP7� - SP7�8 0.003(Hct) +0.36 -0.10 (NS)YSI� - SP7WB 0.002(Hct) +0.06 0.08 (NS)

n = 25. P. plasma samples; WB, whole-blood samples; N5. not significant

(P >0.05).

Da�l_�sa_

Fig. 1 . Linearity of SP7 response to lactate concentrationDilution of sample refers to the proportion of the original sample remainingafter dilution; the hematocrft of each original sample is shown

Discussion

Many reports have shown that blood lactate concen-trations indicate the severity of illness and potential

outcome in critically ill patients (1-4) and that changes

in blood lactate are superior to either oxygen delivery or

oxygen consumption in predicting ultimate survival in

patients with septic shock (4). For lactate measure-

ments to be useful in critical care, they must be provided

within 30 mm. Although the usefulness oflactate mea-

surements in critical care was limited in the past by

slow methods (9) or methods requiring preparation of

plasma (10), rapid measurements on whole blood have

been available for several years (11 ). However, these

methods have remained inadequate for providing reli-

able results on a 24-h/day schedule.

An improved version of a whole-blood analyzer, with

enzyme electrodes requiring replacement every 4-S

days, shows acceptable precision and reliability (5).However, because the analyzer measures lactate inwhole blood diluted 15-fold with buffer, and becauselactate in erythrocytes does not quickly equilibrate with

plasma, a source of error is present that is related to

hematocrit: the greater the hematocrit, the greater the

difference between results measured in whole blood and

those measured in plasma of the same sample.

Because hematocrit can vary considerably in patients

under intensive care, a method that eliminates this

source of error is desirable. By measuring lactate inundiluted samples, SP7 has eliminated the variation

due to hematocnit. Although an algorithm improved the

correlations between results in diluted whole blood and

undiluted plasma (5), corrected results have the inher-

ent problems listed earlier.One drawback of the undiluted SP7 method is that

200 �AL of sample is required to measure both lactate

and blood gases, compared with only 25 p.L required to

measure lactate by the diluted YSI method. Because

monitoring pediatric patients after surgery is a major

use of stat whole-blood lactate measurements at our

hospital (1 ), the greater sample volume required may bean important factor when considering the relative ad-

vantages of lactate methods.The combination of lactate with blood gas measure-

ments by the SP7 seems appropriate. However, further

clinical studies are needed to establish the utility of thistest panel. Clearly, measuring blood lactate is simpler

and more useful for a greater variety ofpatients than ismeasuring oxygen consumption, which requires mea-suring cardiac output (with a thermodilution catheter)

and both arterial and venous oxygen content.

Performance characteristks. The precision of SP7 ap-

pears to be acceptable, with SDs of sO.05 mmol/L atmost concentrations tested, which is comparable withthose ofother analyzers that measure lactate (5). Over-

alllinearity was good among the samples studied, which

had lactate concentrations of �11.5 mmollL and was

independent of hematocrit. In our study of potentialinterferents, none would be likely to cause problems at

concentrations encountered in blood. Although the re-

2434 CLINICAL CHEMISTRY, Vol. 38, No. 12, 1992

ducing substance ascorbate, at -100-fold a normal con-

centration, lowered lactate slightly (by 0.3 mmolIL), this

should not be significant in any samples from patients.

The main concern we have with lactate measured by

the SP7 method described here is that the results,

particularly at lower concentrations, appear to be --0.3-

0.4 mmol/L higher than other methods. Correcting for

the average difference in water content ofplasma (0.93)

did not appreciably lower this bias between methods;

therefore, we conclude that the calibration set points for

the SP7 should be modified by the manufacturer.

The necessity to change the lactate oxidase mem-

brane about every 6 days may be acceptable for opera-

tion in high-test-volume clinical laboratories. However,

for laboratories with fewer tests for lactate, a cost of

--$14 for each membrane may be comparable with the

prepackaged colorimetric (aca) test pack.

By comparing results from anticoagulated blood with

results from uncoagulated blood analyzed immediately

after collection, we show that heparin is a satisfactory

anticoagulant and is preferred over heparinized tubes

containing iodoacetate. However, whole-blood samples

must be kept in ice until they are either analyzed or

centrifuged to obtain plasma. Whole blood appears to be

stable for at least 60 mm when stored in an ice bath.

With a slight adjustment of calibrator set points, theSF7 method for lactate can provide potentially accurate,precise, and linear results in an analyzer that is inde-pendent of hematocrit. Because the analyzer also mea-

sures pH, Pco2, and P02, further studies are needed to

CLIN. CHEM. 38/12, 2434-2489 (1992)

establish the clinical value of this apparently logicalcombination of tests in critical care.

We acknowledge the financial support of Nova Biomedical in

this study.

References1. Toffaletti JG. Blood lactate: biochemistry, laboratory methods,and clinical interpretation. Crit Rev Clin Lab Sci 1991;28:253-68.2. Rashkin MC, Bosken C, Baughman RP. Oxygen delivery incritically ill patients: relationship to blood lactate and survival.Cheat 1985;87:580-4.3. Vincent J-L, Dufaye P, Berre J, Leeman M, Degante J-P, KahnRJ. Serial lactate determinations during circulatory shock. CritCare Med 1983;11:449-51.4. Bakker J, Coffernils M, Leon M, Gris P, Vincent J-L Bloodlactate levels are superior to oxygen-derived variables in predict-ing outcome in human septic shock. Chest 1991;99:956-62.5. Wandrup J, Tvede K, Grinsted J, Jordening H. “Stat” measure-ments of L-lactate in whole blood and CSF assessed. Cliii Chem1989;35:1740-3.6. Fogh-Andersen N, Wimberley PD, Thode J, Siggaard-Andersen0. Direct reading glucose electrodes detect the molality of glucosein plasma and whole blood. Clin Chim Acta 1990;189:33-8.7. Barnett RN. Clinical laboratory statistics, 2nd ed. Boston:Little, Brown, 1979:50-2.8. Toffaletti J, Ernst P, Hunt P, Abrams B. Dry electrolyte-balanced heparinized syringes evaluated for determining ionizedcalcium and other electrolytes in whole blood. Cliii Chem 1991;37:1730-3.9. Marbach EP, Weil MH. Rapid enzymatic measurement of bloodlactate and pyruvate: use and significance ofmetaphosphoric acidas a common precipitant. Clin Chem 1967;13:314-25.10. Westgard JO, Lahmayer BL, Birnbaum ML. Use of the DuPont “Automatic Clinical Analyzer” in direct determination oflactic acid in plasma stabilized with sodium fluoride. Cliii Chem1972;18:1334-8.11. Geyssant A, Dormois D, Barthelemy JC, Lacour JR. Lactatedetermination with the lactate analyzer LA 640: a critical study.Scand J Clin Lab Invest 1985;45:145-9.

Performance of an Enzyme-Linked Immunosorbent Assay System for Antibodies toHepatitis C Virus with Two New Antigens (ci 1/c7)

Miho Saito,’ Akira ase2 Tomiko Kashiwakuma,’ Michinori Kohara,’ Masahito Sugi,’ Keizaburo Mlki,�TakayUki Yainamoto,3 Hiroyuki Mon,3 Yohsuke Ohta,3 Eiji Tanaka,4 Kendo Kiyosawa,4 Selichi Furuta,4Masanobu Wakashima,5 Satoshi Tanaka,5 and Nobu Hattori5

We developed an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay(ELIsA) system for antibodies to the hepatitis C virus(HCV), using two new recombinant antigens (ci 1 and c7)derived from the HCV genome. The performance of this

1 Tonen Corporation, Fundamental Research Laboratory, 1-3-1,

Nishiteurugaoka, Ohi-Machi, Iruma-Gun, Saitama 354, Japan.2 Author for correspondence.

3 International Reagents Corporation, 1-1-2, Murotani, Nishi-Ku, Kobe 651-22, Japan.

4 Department of Internal Medicine, Shinshu University Schoolof Medicine, Matsumoto 390, Japan.

5 Liver Unit, The Tokyo Metropolitan Komagome Hospital,Tokyo 113, Japan.

Received March 2, 1992; accepted July 21, 1992.

ELISA system (Imucheck HCV Ab) was examined. The CVvalues for both intra-assay precision and reproducibility ofidentifying HCV antibody in the panel sera ranged from3.5% to 6.4%. The blood elements in serum and antico-agulants did not interfere in this ELISA system. The spec-ificity of Imucheck HCV Ab to samples from patients withnon-A, non-B (NANB)-type chronic hepatitis, liver cirrho-sis, and hepatocellular carcinoma was 93.7%, 93.5%, and

� 81 .4%, respectively. These results are more sensitivethan those obtained by the first-generation anti-HCV ELISAsystem. In the samples from patients with NANB-typeacute hepatitis, Imucheck HCV Ab enabled detection ofHCV antibodies at an early stage. This system increasedthe sensitivity for blood donor screening and for monitor-ing patients with acute hepatitis.