lack of a theoretical framework

8
Edurne Ecay Amor Irune Labiano De Goñi

Upload: edurne

Post on 29-Jun-2015

351 views

Category:

Documents


3 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Lack of a theoretical framework

Edurne Ecay Amor Irune Labiano De Goñi

Page 2: Lack of a theoretical framework

A lack of CALL guidelines has meant that CALL authors have no reliable conceptual framework.

But It is necessary a generally accepted theoretical framework that authors can use to guide their work.

Page 3: Lack of a theoretical framework

A general theoretical framework has not emerged for a number of reasons.

Materials developers fall into two broad bands in their approach to their work:o On the one side, many developers rely on their

intuition as teachers rather than on learning research (practitioner not researcher)

o On the other side, there are many developers who are primarily interested in solving problems by formulating theory (formalists), and many other who prefer to solve problems by writing programs (proceduralists)

Page 4: Lack of a theoretical framework

A perception of this division was reiterated at two CALL Conferences:

◦ The EURO CALL Conference in Valencia

◦ The CALL Conference in Exeter, Sussex

Page 5: Lack of a theoretical framework

Where theory has been used as a point of departure, the theoretical sources that have been proposed and used have been diverse. For example:

◦Theories emanating from psychology (cognitive psychology and Second Language Acquisition) are usually drawn from a restricted context to the CALL context in general.

Page 6: Lack of a theoretical framework

Integrated frameworks have been proposed, such as Hubbard or Mitterer et al. who suggest an integrated framework using theories from instructional design, language teaching, language learning, and knowledge of the applicability of the technology.

Integrated frameworks recognize the multifaceted nature of CALL materials development

A number of CALL projects have not been driven directly by theory as such.

This CALL projects include vocational language programs which begin with addressing student needs:◦ KanjiCard which uses a specific language problem as a point of

departure◦ CLEF where developing grammar skills is the goal

Page 7: Lack of a theoretical framework

It also seems apparent that some CALL projects do not begin with a theory at all

Sussex stresses the importance of investigating the processes of CALL materials production

At the present time rather little work has been done on the question of How teachers become CALL authors:◦ how they objectify their knowledge domains learning, and

teaching ◦ how they conceptualize learning materials and learning modes for

transfer to the CALL medium◦ how they achieve this transfer◦ how the existence and use of CAL media influence theories of

CALL, and vice versa.

Page 8: Lack of a theoretical framework

Reviewing what has already been done, and by exploring the ways in which CALL is conceptualized, a clearer understanding of theory and practice will emerge.

This book attempts to address these areas of concern by shedding light on the nature of the problems.

Such a description has the potential to improve our understanding of:◦ the scope of CALL and prominent areas of focus within it◦ the theoretical sources and conceptual frameworks of CALL

authors◦ the possible weaknesses or gaps between theory and practice.