kalinago (carib) resistance to european colonisation of the caribbean author(s)- hilary mcd. beckles

Upload: dionisio-mesye

Post on 26-Feb-2018

220 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/25/2019 Kalinago (Carib) Resistance to European Colonisation of the Caribbean Author(s)- HILARY McD. BECKLES

    1/19

    University of the West Indies and Caribbean Quarterlyare collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend accessto Caribbean Quarterly.

    http://www.jstor.org

    Kalinago (Carib) Resistance to European Colonisation of the CaribbeanAuthor(s): HILARY McD. BECKLESSource: Caribbean Quarterly, Vol. 54, No. 4, The 60th Anniversary Edition: West Indian History(December, 2008), pp. 77-94Published by: andUniversity of the West Indies Caribbean QuarterlyStable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/40654700Accessed: 20-01-2016 22:23 UTC

    Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

    JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of contentin a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship.For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected].

    This content downloaded from 198.82.230.35 on Wed, 20 Jan 2016 22:23:31 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/http://www.jstor.org/publisher/uwihttp://www.jstor.org/publisher/cariquarhttp://www.jstor.org/stable/40654700http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/stable/40654700http://www.jstor.org/publisher/cariquarhttp://www.jstor.org/publisher/uwihttp://www.jstor.org/
  • 7/25/2019 Kalinago (Carib) Resistance to European Colonisation of the Caribbean Author(s)- HILARY McD. BECKLES

    2/19

    77

    Kalinago Carib) Resistance oEuropean

    Colonisation

    f

    theCaribbean

    HILARY

    McD.. BECKLES

    The resistance f nativeCaribbean eople to the colonialdispensation

    established

    y

    Europeans

    ollowing

    heColumbus

    andfall

    f 1492 has

    received

    insufficient

    ttention

    rom cholars.

    Unlike

    the case

    with the

    experience

    f

    enslaved

    African

    eople

    few tudies

    ave

    presentedystematic

    ccounts

    f their

    anti-colonial

    nd

    anti-slaverytruggle.

    he reasons

    for

    his

    historiographie

    imbalance

    re not

    ltogether

    lear.

    No one

    has

    suggested,

    or

    xample,

    hat heir

    fight

    or

    iberty,

    ife

    and land was

    any

    less endemic

    r

    virulent

    han

    hat

    f

    Africans.

    n the

    ontrary,-*most

    ccounts f

    European

    ettlement

    ave

    ndicated

    ina general ort fwaytheir eterminationndtenacitynconfrontinghenew

    order

    n

    spite

    f

    their elative

    echnological

    imitations

    ith

    espect

    o

    warfare.1

    This

    study

    eeks

    to

    specify

    omeof

    the

    political

    nd

    militaryesponses

    f

    the

    Kalinago people

    (known

    n

    the

    colonial documentation

    s

    Caribs)

    to the

    European

    nvasion

    s

    they

    ought

    o maintain

    ontrol ver

    ands

    nd ives

    n the

    islands f

    theLesser

    Antilles.

    he examination

    akes

    eference

    o the mmediate

    post

    Columbian

    ecades,

    nd ouches

    rieflypon

    he

    arly

    ighteenth

    entury

    o

    the

    Treaty

    fUtrecht

    n

    1713,

    but s concerned

    rincipally

    ith he

    eriod

    624to

    1700whenKalinagoswereconfrontedyconsiderablemilitaryressuresrom

    English

    and French

    olonising gents.

    During

    this

    period

    Kalinagos

    in

    the

    Windward

    nd Leeward

    Islands

    launched

    protracted

    ar of

    resistance

    o

    colonisation

    nd

    slavery. hey

    held

    out

    gainst

    he

    English

    nd

    French ntil

    he

    mid-

    90

    s,

    protecting

    ome

    territory,

    aintaining

    heir

    ocial

    freedom,

    nd

    determining

    heeconomic

    nd

    political

    history

    f

    the

    region

    n

    very mportant

    ways.2

    According

    o recent

    rchaeological

    vidence,

    he

    Kalinago

    were the

    ast

    migrantroup o settlell theCaribbean rior o the rrival ftheEuropeansn

    1492. The

    Columbus

    mission ound

    hree

    ative

    roups,

    f different

    erivation

    and ultural

    ttainments,

    ut

    ll

    of

    whom ntered

    heCaribbean

    rom he

    egion

    f

    South

    America

    known s the

    Guianas.

    These were

    the

    Ciboney,

    he Taino

    (Arawaks)

    nd

    the

    Kalinago.

    The

    Ciboney

    ad arrived

    bout

    00

    B.C.,

    followed

    This content downloaded from 198.82.230.35 on Wed, 20 Jan 2016 22:23:31 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Kalinago (Carib) Resistance to European Colonisation of the Caribbean Author(s)- HILARY McD. BECKLES

    3/19

    78

    by heTaino, heir thnicelatives,bout 00yearsater ndwhoby650 A.D. had

    migrated

    orthwards

    hrough

    he slands

    stablishingarge

    ommunities

    n

    the

    Greater ntilles.

    tarting

    heir

    migration

    nto he slands rom bout

    1000

    A.D.,

    Kalinagos

    were till

    rriving

    t

    the ime f heColumbus andfall.

    hey

    were

    lso

    in

    the

    process

    f

    establishing

    ontrol ver

    erritory

    nd communities

    ccupied

    y

    Tainos ntheLesser

    Antilles,

    nd

    parts

    ftheGreater ntilles.When he

    panish

    arrivedn the

    northern

    aribbean,

    herefore,

    hey

    ound heTainos o some xtent

    already

    n the

    defensive,

    ut ater ncountered

    alinagos

    who

    they

    escribed s

    more

    repared

    or

    ggression

    Kalinagos,

    ike their aino cousins

    nd

    predecessors,

    ad

    been

    nhabiting

    the slands

    ong nough

    o

    perceive

    hem s

    part

    f heir

    atural,ncestral,

    urvival

    environment.s a

    result,

    otedG.K.

    Lewis,

    they

    repared

    hemselveso defend

    their

    homeland

    n

    a

    spirit

    f defiant

    patriotism," aving

    wished

    that the

    "Europeans

    ad never et

    foot

    n

    their

    ountry."

    From he

    outset, owever,

    European

    colonial forceswere

    technologically

    ore

    prepared

    or

    a

    violent

    struggle

    or

    space

    since

    in

    real

    terms,

    he

    Columbusmission

    represented

    n

    addition othemaritimeouragenddeterminationfEurope,hemobilisationf

    large-scale

    inance

    apital,

    nd science nd

    technology

    or

    mperialist

    ilitary

    ends. This

    process

    was also

    buttressed

    y

    the frenzied earchfor

    dentity

    nd

    globalranking y Europeans hrough

    he

    onquest

    nd cultural

    egation

    f other

    races.

    In

    the Greater

    Antilles,

    ainos

    offered

    spirited

    ut

    argely

    neffective

    military

    esistanceo the

    Spanish

    ven

    though

    n occasions

    hey

    were

    upported

    by

    the

    Kalinago.

    This was

    particularly

    lear

    n

    the

    arly

    ixteenth

    entury

    n

    the

    case of the truggleorPuertoRico inwhichKalinagosfrom eighbouringt

    Croix ame oTaino

    ssistance.

    n

    1494,

    Columbused

    an

    armed

    arty

    f400 men

    into he nteriorf

    Hispaniola

    n

    search f

    food,

    old,

    nd slavesto which aino

    Caciques

    mobilised heir

    rmies or esistance.

    uacanagari, leadingCacique,

    who

    hadtried

    reviously

    o

    negotiate

    n

    accommodating

    ettlement

    ith

    military

    commander

    lonso de

    Ojeba,

    marched

    nsuccessfully

    n

    1494 with a few

    thousand en

    pon

    he

    panish.

    n

    1503,

    nother

    orty aciques

    were

    aptured

    t

    Hispaniola

    ndburntlive

    by

    Governor vando'

    troops;

    nacaona,

    he

    rincipal

    Cacique

    was

    hungpublicly

    n Santo

    Domingo.

    n Puerto

    Rico,

    the

    Spanish

    settlement

    arty,

    ed

    by

    Ponce

    de

    Leon,

    was attacked

    requently

    y

    Taino

    warriors;

    many

    panish

    ettlers erekilledbut

    Tainos and

    Kalinagos

    weredefeated nd

    crushednthe

    ounterssault,

    i 1

    11 resistancen

    Cuba,

    ed

    by

    CaciqueHatuey,

    was

    put

    down;

    he was

    captured

    nd

    burnt

    live;

    another

    ising

    n 1

    29 was also

    This content downloaded from 198.82.230.35 on Wed, 20 Jan 2016 22:23:31 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Kalinago (Carib) Resistance to European Colonisation of the Caribbean Author(s)- HILARY McD. BECKLES

    4/19

    79

    crushed.nthese truggles,aino

    fatalities ere

    high.

    Thousandswere

    killed

    n

    battle

    nd

    publicly

    xecuted or

    he

    purpose

    f

    breaking

    he

    pirit

    f collective

    resistance;

    ome

    rebels led

    o themountains

    nd forests here

    hey

    stablished

    maroon

    ettlements

    hat

    ontinued

    ntermittently

    he

    war

    gainst

    he

    panish.5

    y

    the

    middle f the

    ixteenth

    entury,

    owever,

    aino and

    Kalinago

    resistance

    ad

    been

    effectively

    rushed

    n the Greater

    Antilles;

    heir

    ommunity

    tructures

    smashed.and

    members educed

    o

    various forms f

    enslavementn

    Spanish

    agricultural

    nd

    mining nterprises.

    In the LesserAntilles, owever, heKalinagoweremore successfuln

    defying

    irsthe

    panish,

    nd hen ater

    he

    nglish

    nd

    French,

    herebyreserving

    their

    olitical

    reedomnd

    maintaining

    ontrol f heir

    erritory.

    ccording

    oCarl

    Sauer,

    As

    the abor

    upply

    n

    Espaola

    declined,

    ttention

    urnedo

    the outhern

    islands"

    which

    rom t.

    Croix,

    neighbouring

    uerto

    Rico,

    to theGuianas

    were

    inhabited

    y

    he

    Kalinagos.

    panish oyal

    dicts

    atedNovember

    ,

    1

    08

    and

    July

    3,1512,

    authorised

    ettlers

    o

    capture

    ndenslave

    Kalinagos

    n "the sland

    fLos

    Barbados

    [Barbados],

    Dominica,

    Matinino

    Martinique],

    anta

    Lucia,

    San

    Vincente,a Asuncion Grenada], nd Tavaco [Tobago],"because of their

    "resistance

    o Christians."6

    y

    the end

    of the sixteenth

    entury,

    owever,

    he

    Spanish

    had

    decided,

    aving ccepted

    s

    fact he bsence

    of

    gold

    n theLesser

    Antilles,

    nd the

    nevitability

    f

    considerable

    atalities

    t

    thehands f

    Kalinago

    warriors,

    hat

    twas wiser

    o

    adopt

    "hands ff

    olicy"

    while

    oncentrating

    heir

    efforts

    ntheGreater

    ntilles. s

    a

    result,

    heGreater

    ndLesser

    Antilles

    ecame

    politically

    eparated

    t

    this ime

    y

    what

    roy loyd

    escribed

    s a

    "poison

    rrow

    curtain."?

    he

    English

    nd French

    nitiating

    heir

    olonizing

    missions

    uring

    he

    early

    seventeenth

    entury,

    herefore,

    ad

    a

    clear

    choice.

    They

    could

    either

    confront

    he

    panish

    orth f

    he

    poison

    rrow urtain"

    r

    Kalinago

    forces outh

    of

    it. Either

    way,

    they xpected

    o encounter

    onsiderable

    rganised

    rmed

    resistance.

    hey

    hose

    he

    atter,

    artly

    ecauseof

    the

    perception

    hat

    Kalinagos

    were he

    weaker,

    ut

    lso because

    ofthebelief

    hat

    alinagos

    were he

    common

    enemy'

    of

    all

    Europeans

    nd

    that

    olidarity

    ould

    be achieved

    forcollective

    militaryperations

    gainst

    hem.

    Having

    ecured

    ome

    respite

    rom

    he

    pressures

    f

    Spanish

    olonisation

    y

    the nd

    ofthe

    ixteenth

    entury,hen,

    a

    Kalinagos

    were

    mmediately

    onfronted

    by

    the more

    economically ggressive

    nd

    militarily

    etermined

    nglish

    nd

    French

    olonists.

    Once

    again,

    theybegan

    to

    reorganise

    heir ommunities

    n

    preparation

    or ounter

    trategies.

    his

    ime,

    twouldbe

    a clear

    ase of

    resistance

    on

    the retreat.

    y

    the

    1630s,

    their

    apidly

    iminishing

    umbers

    were

    being

    This content downloaded from 198.82.230.35 on Wed, 20 Jan 2016 22:23:31 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Kalinago (Carib) Resistance to European Colonisation of the Caribbean Author(s)- HILARY McD. BECKLES

    5/19

    80

    consolidatedround smaller roup fspecially hosen slands mostly

    n

    the

    Windwards

    ut also

    in

    the

    Leewards.

    By

    this

    time,

    for

    nstance,

    arbados,

    identified

    n

    a

    Spanish

    document f 1511

    as an island

    densely opulated

    with

    Kalinagos,

    no

    longer

    had

    a native

    presence. Europeans

    understood

    he

    significance

    f his

    eorganisation

    ndresettlementf

    Kalinago

    ommunities,

    nd

    establishedheir

    nfantolonies

    n

    peripheral

    arts

    ftheLeeward slands

    where

    their

    resence

    as ess

    formidable,

    nd nBarbadoswhere twas now bsent.

    he

    English

    nd

    French,hen,

    ere

    ware

    hat

    most f heir ettlements

    ouldhave o

    come

    o terms ith

    Kalinago

    esistance.

    his

    expectation,

    owever,

    id

    notdeter

    them,

    nd

    they

    ontinuedo seek out slandniches

    where n effectiveoothold

    couldbe

    gained

    ntil

    uch ime s

    Kalinago

    orces ould

    be subdued nd

    destroyed

    by

    their

    espectivemperial

    orces.

    The

    English

    nd French

    ought

    he

    pacification

    f the

    Kalinago

    for

    wo

    distinct,

    ut related

    reasons,

    and overtime

    dopted

    different

    trategies

    nd

    methods ut maintainedhe

    deological

    osition

    hat

    hey

    houldbe

    enslaved,

    driven

    ut,

    r exterminated.

    irst,

    ands

    ccupied y

    the

    Kalinago

    were

    required

    for argescale commodity roduction ithin heexpansive, apitalist, orth

    Atlantic

    grarian omplex.

    The effective

    ntegration

    f

    theCaribbean

    nto his

    mercantilend

    productive

    ystem equired

    he

    ppropriation

    f and

    through

    he

    agency

    f the

    plantation

    nterprise,

    inance

    apital,

    hen,

    ought

    o

    revolutionize

    the market alue

    of

    Kalinago

    lands

    by making

    hem vailable to

    European

    commercialnterests.

    y resisting

    and

    confiscation

    alinagos

    were therefore

    confronting

    he full

    ideological

    and economic force of Atlantic

    apitalism.

    Second,

    European

    conomic

    ctivities

    n

    the Caribbeanwere based

    upon

    the

    enslavementf

    ndigenes

    nd

    mported

    fricans. he

    principal

    ole nd relation

    assigned

    o these ndother

    on-Europeans

    ithin he olonial ormationas

    that

    of servitude.

    uropeans

    n

    theLesser

    Antilles,

    owever,

    erenot uccessful

    n

    reducing

    n economic umber f

    Kalinago

    o chattel

    lavery,

    r other

    orms f

    servitude.

    nlike

    he

    Taino,

    their abour ould notbe

    effectively

    ommodified,

    simply

    ecause

    heir ommunities

    roved mpossible

    o subdue.

    t

    was

    not

    hat

    he

    Kalinago

    weremore

    militanthan heTaino.

    Rather,

    t

    was because henomadic

    nature f heir mall

    ommunities,

    ndtheir

    mphasis pon

    erritorial

    cquisition,

    in

    part response

    othe

    eographical

    eaturesf

    he esser

    Antilles,

    nabled hem

    to makemore ffectivese of the nvironmentna "strike nd sail"resistance

    strategy. alinago,

    hen,

    while not

    prepared

    o suffer ither and or labour

    o

    Europeans,

    erebetter

    laced

    o

    mplement

    ffective

    ounter-aggression.

    This content downloaded from 198.82.230.35 on Wed, 20 Jan 2016 22:23:31 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Kalinago (Carib) Resistance to European Colonisation of the Caribbean Author(s)- HILARY McD. BECKLES

    6/19

    81

    Primarilyecause f heirrrepressiblearofresistance,hich ntimidated

    all

    Europeans

    n

    the

    region,Kalinago

    were

    targeted

    irst or

    an

    ideological

    campaign

    nwhich

    hey

    were stablished

    ithin

    he

    uropean

    mind,

    ot s noble

    savages,'

    s

    was the ase

    with he ess effective

    ainos,

    ut s

    'vicious annibals'

    worthy

    f extermination

    ithin hecontext f

    genocidal

    militaryxpeditions.8

    Voluminous

    etails

    were

    prepared

    y

    Spanish

    and

    later

    English

    nd

    French

    colonial

    hroniclersn the

    political

    nd

    ideological

    mentality

    f the

    Kalinago,

    most

    fwhom alled

    for

    holy

    wars"

    gainst

    Les

    sauvages

    as

    a

    principal

    ay

    o

    achieve

    their

    ubjugation. iterature,ating

    ack to Columbus

    n

    1494,

    in

    a

    contradictory

    ashion,

    enied

    Kalinago

    humanity

    hile t the ame

    time utlined

    their

    eneral

    nti-colonial

    nd

    anti-slavery

    onsciousness

    nd attitudes.

    n

    the

    writings

    f

    Jean-Baptiste

    e

    Tertre,

    ieurde

    la

    Borde,

    nd

    Pere

    Labat,

    for

    example,

    all

    late

    seventeenth

    entury

    rench

    reporters

    f

    Kalinago

    ontology,hey

    re

    presented

    s

    a

    people

    who

    would

    "prefer

    o die of

    hunger

    han ive s

    a slave."9

    abat,

    whocommented

    ost f

    their

    sychological

    profile,

    ound

    hem obe "careless

    nd

    azy

    reatures,"

    ot

    tall

    suited

    mentally

    o

    arduous, ustained abour. In addition,he considered hena "proudand

    indomitable"

    nd

    exceedingly

    indictive"

    eople

    who one

    has tobe

    very

    areful

    not

    o

    offend,"

    ence he

    popular

    rench

    aribbean

    roverb,fight

    Caribe nd

    you

    must

    illhim

    r

    be killed."10

    The French

    iscovered,

    ikethe

    Spanish

    efore

    hem,

    oted

    abat,

    that

    t

    was

    always

    est,

    f

    possible,

    to have

    nothing

    o do

    with he

    Kalinago."11

    utthis

    was

    not

    ossible.

    Relations

    adtobe

    established,

    nd

    here

    uropeans

    iscovered,

    Labat

    noted,

    hat he

    Kalinago

    knew how

    to ook

    after heir wn

    nterests

    ery

    well.,,12There renopeople ntheworld," estated,so ealousoftheiriberty,

    or who

    resentmore

    he mallest

    heck o their

    reedom."13

    ltogether,

    alinago

    world

    iewwas

    anathema

    o

    Europeans,

    hus he

    general

    iew,

    choed

    by

    Labat,

    that

    no

    European

    ation

    asbeen ble

    to ive

    n

    he

    ame sland

    with

    hem ithout

    being ompelled

    o

    destroy

    hem,

    nddrive hem

    ut."14

    The

    English

    and French

    tarted ut

    simultaneously

    n

    1624

    with

    the

    establishment

    f

    agricultural

    ettlements

    n St. Kitts.

    From

    there,

    he

    English

    moved

    on to

    Barbados

    n

    1627,

    and between

    1632

    and 1635

    to

    Antigua,

    MontserratndNevis,while he rench oncentratedheirffortsuringhe1 30s

    at

    Martinique

    nd

    Guadeloupe,

    hefirsthree

    ears

    t St.

    Kittswere

    difficultor

    both

    nglish

    nd French ettlers.

    hey

    wereharassed

    nd attacked

    y

    Kalinago

    soldiers,

    nd

    in

    1635 the

    French

    t

    Guadeloupe

    were

    engulfed

    n

    a

    protracted

    battle. rench uccess

    ntheir ar

    with

    Kalinago

    t

    Guadeloupe

    ncouraged

    hem

    This content downloaded from 198.82.230.35 on Wed, 20 Jan 2016 22:23:31 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Kalinago (Carib) Resistance to European Colonisation of the Caribbean Author(s)- HILARY McD. BECKLES

    7/19

    82

    during

    he emainderfthe ecade o

    expand

    heir olonial

    missions,

    ut ailed o

    gain

    effective ontrol f the

    Kalinago

    inhabited slands

    of

    Grenada,

    Marie

    Galante,

    nd

    La

    Desirada.

    Meanwhile,

    small

    nglish xpedition

    rom t.Kitts o

    St. Lucia

    n

    the

    Windwards,

    heheart f

    Kalinago

    erritory,

    as

    easily epelled

    n

    1639.

    the

    following ear Kalinagos

    aunched full-scale ttack

    pon English

    settlementst

    Antigua, illing ifty

    ettlers,

    apturing

    heGovernor'swife nd

    children,

    nd

    destroyingrops

    ndhouses.15

    While

    English

    ettlementsn the Leewards

    struggled

    o

    make

    progress

    againstKalinagoresistance, arbados lone of theWindwards,orged head

    uninterrupted.

    nlike theirLeewards

    counterparts,arly

    Barbadian

    planters

    rapidly

    xpanded

    heir

    roduction

    ase,

    made

    living

    rom he

    xports

    f

    obacco,

    indigo

    nd

    cotton,

    nd feared

    nly

    their ndentured

    ervants nd few African

    slaves.

    By

    1650,

    following

    he uccessful ultivation

    f

    sugar

    ane

    with

    African

    slaves,

    he

    slandwas. considered

    y

    mercantileconomic

    heoristss the ichest

    agriculturalolony

    nthe

    emisphere.

    t.Kitts

    olonists,

    oth

    nglish

    nd

    French,

    determinedo

    keep up

    with

    heir

    arbadian

    ompetitors,

    ere first o

    adopt

    common

    military

    ront ith

    espectoKalinago esistance.uringhe1630s hey

    enterednto

    greements,

    n

    pite

    f heir ival laims oexclusive

    wnership

    f he

    island,

    o combine orces

    gainstKalinago

    communities.n

    thefirst

    ccasion,

    they pooled

    their

    alents,"

    nd

    in

    a

    "sneak

    night

    ttack"killed over

    eighty

    Kalinagos

    nd drove

    many

    ff he sland.After

    elebrating

    he uccessof their

    military

    lliance,

    heFrench nd

    English

    ontinued heir

    ivalry

    ver

    he sland

    until 1713 when the

    matterwas settled n favour of

    the

    English

    by

    the

    Treaty

    f

    Utrecht.16

    The successof Kalinagos n holding n to a significantortion f the

    Windwards,

    nd their

    eakening

    f

    planting

    ettlements

    n

    the

    Leewards,

    ueled

    the determinationf the

    English

    and French to

    destroy

    hem.

    By

    the

    mid-seventeenth

    entury, uropean

    merchants,

    lanters

    nd

    colonial

    officials,

    were

    n

    greement

    hat

    alinagos

    were

    arbarousnd ruel

    et f

    avagesbeyond

    reason r

    persuasion

    ndmust hereforee

    eliminated.."17

    y

    this ime twas also

    clear hat he

    lave-based

    lantationystem

    emandedn

    "absolute

    monopoly"

    f

    the

    Caribbean,

    nd

    tolerated o "alternative

    ystem."18

    hat

    RichardDunn

    referred o as "Carib

    independence

    nd

    self-reliance"

    onstituted

    major

    contradictiono the nternal

    ogic

    of

    capitalist

    ccumulation ithin he

    lantation

    economy.

    9

    As

    a

    result,

    therefore,

    he economic

    leaders and

    political

    representatives

    f this

    ncreasinglyowerful roduction

    nd trade

    omplex

    were

    This content downloaded from 198.82.230.35 on Wed, 20 Jan 2016 22:23:31 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Kalinago (Carib) Resistance to European Colonisation of the Caribbean Author(s)- HILARY McD. BECKLES

    8/19

    83

    determined o

    bring

    the

    contradiction o

    a

    speedy

    resolution

    by any

    means

    necessary

    or

    possible.

    By

    the

    mid-seventeenth

    entury,

    he

    need

    for

    a full scale war

    against

    the

    Kalinagos,

    though learly

    stablished

    nd articulated n

    Spanish

    colonial

    thinking

    during

    he sixteenth

    entury,

    ow

    assumed

    greater rgency

    with the

    English

    and

    French.

    By

    this time the

    English

    were

    first o

    successfully

    establish

    productive

    structures ased on

    sugar

    cultivation nd black

    slavery,

    nd

    not

    surprisingly

    ook

    the lead in

    attempting

    he removal

    of

    principal

    obstacles to the

    smooth and

    profitable xpansionof thesystem.Also, theEnglishwiththe argestnumber f

    enslaved

    Africans

    n

    the

    region,

    were

    concerned that efficient

    ontrol on their

    plantations

    would be

    adversely

    ffected

    y

    the

    persistence

    f

    Kalinago

    resistance

    It

    did not take

    ong

    for

    he Africans o

    become aware of

    Kalinago struggle gainst

    Europeans,

    and

    to realise

    that

    hey

    ould

    possibly

    secure

    their reedom

    y fleeing

    to their

    erritory.

    abat,

    who studied

    inter-island lave

    marronage

    n the

    Lesser

    Antilles,

    during

    his

    period,

    stated that slaves knew that St.

    Vincent was

    easily

    reached from

    arbados,

    and

    many

    scaped

    there from

    heirmasters

    n

    canoes and

    rafts."

    During

    the

    formative

    tage

    of this

    development,

    etween 1645 and

    1660,

    the

    Kalinago

    generally

    took

    "the

    runaway

    slaves

    back to their

    masters,

    or sold

    them o the

    French nd

    Spanish,"

    but

    as the

    Kalinago

    came undermore ntensive

    attack

    during

    he

    mid-century,

    abat

    noted,

    heir

    olicy

    towards

    African

    maroons

    changed.

    They

    refused o return he

    Africans,

    e

    stated,

    nd

    began

    regarding

    hem

    "as an addition o their

    ation."

    By

    1

    70,

    Labat estimated hat ver 500 Barbadian

    runaways

    were

    living

    in

    St. Vincent.

    This

    community

    was reinforced

    n

    1675

    when

    a

    slave

    ship

    carrying

    hundreds of Africans to Jamaica via

    Barbados

    ran

    aground

    offthe coast of

    Bequia.

    Survivorscame ashore at St.

    Vincent and were

    integrated

    in

    the maroon

    communities.

    By

    1700,

    Labat

    stated,

    Africans

    outnumbered

    alinagos

    at

    St. Vincent.20

    n

    1675,

    William

    Stapleton,governor

    f

    the

    Leewards,

    noting

    he

    significant resence

    of

    Africans

    among

    the

    Kalinagos

    suggested

    hat f the

    1,500

    native bowmen"

    in theLeewards six hundred f them

    "are

    negroes,

    ome

    runaway

    from

    Barbados elsewhere."21

    Throughout

    the second

    half of the seventeenth

    enturyEuropeans

    tried

    unsuccessfully

    o

    exploit

    the sometimes

    trained elationsbetween

    Kalinagos

    and

    Africans

    by encouraging

    the former to

    return

    runaways

    to their

    owners.

    Miscegenation

    bet}

    Veen the

    predominantly

    male Africanmaroon

    community

    nd

    Kalinago

    females

    was

    a

    principal

    ause of

    social tensionbetween the two ethnic

    groups.22

    oth the French

    nd

    English alleged

    that

    Kalinago

    leaders

    occasionally

    sought

    heir ssistance

    n

    ridding

    heir ommunities f Africans.The

    significance

    This content downloaded from 198.82.230.35 on Wed, 20 Jan 2016 22:23:31 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Kalinago (Carib) Resistance to European Colonisation of the Caribbean Author(s)- HILARY McD. BECKLES

    9/19

    84

    of such

    llegations,

    owever,

    hould e

    assessed

    gainst

    he

    background

    f

    two

    important

    developments

    n

    African-Kalinago

    elations.

    First,

    by

    the

    mid-seventeenth

    entury,

    he

    group

    mixed

    bloods,

    now known s the

    Garifiina,

    was

    increasing apidly

    n

    numbers,

    nd

    by

    1700 had outnumberedoth

    parent

    groups

    n

    St.

    Vincent.23

    econd,

    oint African-Kalinago

    ilitary xpeditions

    against

    the French nd

    English

    were

    common,

    nd

    represented

    principal

    characteristiceaturef

    anti-Europeanctivity

    on both and

    nd sea.24 he full

    scale attack n the French

    t

    Martinique uring

    he mid-

    650s,

    for

    xample,

    involved

    oth

    African nd

    Kalinago

    forces.25he warriors ho attacked rench

    settlementst Grenada

    during

    he same

    period

    nd

    kept

    themn a weak and

    defensive onditionwere also described

    s

    having

    an

    African

    omponent,

    similarly,

    oted

    abat,

    he

    English xpeditions

    rom arbados ent o

    capture

    t.

    Vincent

    uring

    he1670s

    were

    epelled y

    both

    Africansnd

    Kalinagos.26

    The

    presence

    of effective nti-colonial

    alinago

    communities

    n the

    outskirts

    f

    the lave

    plantations,

    herefore,

    onstituted

    major roblem

    or

    lave

    owners

    n

    so

    far

    as

    they

    fostered nd

    encouraged

    African

    nti-slavery.

    he

    merging

    f

    Kalinago

    nti-colonialnd African

    nti-slaverytruggles,

    herefore,

    represented

    he twinforces hat

    hreatened

    he

    very

    urvival f the

    colonising

    missionn heWindwards. s

    such,

    uropeans

    ith he

    reatest

    conomic take n

    the

    enterprise

    f

    the ndieswastedno time

    n

    adopting range

    f measures o

    suppress

    he

    Kalinago.

    Both the

    English

    nd French

    ursued

    n initial

    olicy

    characterised

    y

    the

    projection

    f

    anti-Kalinago

    ocial

    images

    n

    Europe,

    while

    seeking

    t

    the ametime o

    promote iplomatic

    ffortso settle erritoriallaims.

    In 1664 Barbados ocumentntitledThe

    State f

    he

    Case

    concerning

    ur

    Title o St.

    Lucia,

    "described he sland s

    being infected"

    ith

    Kalinagos

    who

    were "abetted

    y

    the

    French"

    n

    their

    war

    againstEnglish

    settlers.

    n

    this

    document,

    arbadians

    ought

    o

    reject

    rench laims

    o

    the slands

    y tating

    hat

    they

    ad

    purchased

    t

    from u

    Parquet,

    heGovernor f

    Martinique,

    who had

    bought

    t from

    he

    Kalinagos

    in 1650 for

    1,500

    ivres.27

    ikewise,

    n

    1668,

    Thomas

    Modyford,

    overnor f

    Jamaica,

    ormer arbadosGovernornd

    sugar

    magnate,

    escribed t.

    Vincent,

    nother

    alinago tronghold

    n

    the

    Windwards,

    as a

    place

    which the ndiansmuch nfect."28hese statements

    epresent

    art

    f

    the

    deological reparation

    f the

    English

    mindforwhatwouldbe

    a

    genocidal

    offensive

    gainst

    he

    Kalinago

    that

    London merchant ouses were

    eager

    to

    finance.

    But full-scale

    ar,

    he

    nglish

    ndFrench

    new,

    wouldbe

    costly,

    oth

    n

    terms fhumanife nd

    capital,

    nd

    hoped

    t ouldbe averted. he

    significance

    f

    This content downloaded from 198.82.230.35 on Wed, 20 Jan 2016 22:23:31 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Kalinago (Carib) Resistance to European Colonisation of the Caribbean Author(s)- HILARY McD. BECKLES

    10/19

    85

    an ultimatemilitaryolutionwas clearlyperceived y Kalinagoleaders nd

    colonial officials like. The

    Kalinago, by participating

    n

    tactful

    iplomatic

    intrique

    esigned

    o

    exploit

    differencesnd conflicts etween

    uropeans,

    he

    Kalinago ought

    o advance heir

    wn

    nterests.

    n

    1655,

    for

    xample, aptain

    Gregory

    utler nformed liver

    Cromwell,

    he

    Protector,

    hat he ettlementt

    Antigua

    was unable o

    get

    ff o a

    good

    start n

    account

    f

    frequent

    olestations

    by

    he

    Kalinagos,

    ho t hat ime eemed obe n

    eague

    with he rench.29

    gain,

    in

    1667,

    Major

    John

    cott,

    n

    mperial

    ommander-in-Chief,

    eported

    hat

    e led

    an

    expeditiongainst

    utch ettlements

    n

    Tobago

    with

    he assistance f

    a

    party

    of Caribs."30

    uring

    he second Dutch

    War,

    1665-1667,

    n whichFrance nd

    Holland

    allied

    against

    he

    English

    n

    the

    Caribbean,

    he

    Kalinago played

    an

    important

    ole

    n

    shifting

    hebalanceof

    power

    between

    uropeans

    while t the

    same time

    eeking

    o

    expand

    he

    scope

    and effectivenessf their wn

    war of

    resistance.31

    n June

    667,

    HenryWilloughby

    tationedn the eewards nformed

    his

    father

    illiam

    ord

    Willoughby,

    overnor f

    Barbados,

    hat

    whenhe arrived

    at

    St.

    Kittshe received

    intelligence"

    f furthertrocities ommitted

    y

    the

    Kalinagos gainst

    he

    English

    whichwere

    instigated"

    y

    theFrench.

    uropean

    rivalry,

    ichaelCraton

    oncluded,

    as

    effectively

    sed

    by

    he

    Kalinago

    nation s

    evident

    n

    the

    elayed

    oss ofSt.Lucia and

    Grenada,

    nd

    n

    the

    onger

    etentionf

    full ontrol ver t. Vincent

    ndDominica.32

    The

    English

    and French also

    targeted

    he

    Kalinago

    for

    diplomatic

    offensives.

    he first

    ystematicallyursued iplomatic

    ffort

    y

    the

    English

    o

    establish

    footing

    within

    Kalinago

    territory

    n

    the Windwards

    was the

    Willoughby

    nitiativef 1667.

    William

    ord

    Willoughby,

    overnor f

    Barbados,

    had

    long recognised

    he

    great

    financial

    ain

    thatwould accrue to

    himself,

    Barbados,

    nd

    England,

    f

    the

    Windwards,

    he last island

    frontier,

    ould

    be

    converted

    nto lave-based

    ugar lantations.

    orover

    decade,

    he

    ugar ings

    f

    Barbadoshad been

    signalling

    heir emand or andson which

    o

    expand

    heir

    operations,

    ndtheWindwards ere he

    erfect

    lace given revailing

    conomic

    concepts

    bout he conditionalities

    f laved-based

    ugar

    ultivation.mall cale

    militaryxpeditions

    ad been

    repelled y

    the

    Kalinago

    ince

    the

    1630s,

    nd so

    Willoughby,

    ot

    yetorganised

    or

    large

    cale

    military

    ssault,

    pted

    o send

    missaires

    o

    open

    negotiations

    ith

    Kalinago

    eaders.

    The

    Kalinagos,

    n

    response,

    howed ome

    degree

    f

    flexibility,

    s is often

    the ase

    with

    eoples

    nvolved

    n

    protractedtruggles. illoughby

    anted

    peace

    treaty

    hatwould

    promote

    nglish

    nterests

    y removing

    bstacles

    to

    slave

    plantationxpansionism,

    ut he

    Kalinago

    were

    uspicious

    nd

    vigilant.

    n

    1666,

    This content downloaded from 198.82.230.35 on Wed, 20 Jan 2016 22:23:31 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Kalinago (Carib) Resistance to European Colonisation of the Caribbean Author(s)- HILARY McD. BECKLES

    11/19

    86

    theywere rickedy

    the

    English osign way by treaty

    heir

    rights"

    o inhabit

    Tortola,

    nd weredriven

    ff

    he sland.33 he

    Windward

    slandswere

    heir ast

    refuge,

    nd their

    iege

    mentality

    as now more

    eveloped

    han

    ver.

    On March

    23, 1667,

    Kalinago

    eaders

    of St.

    Vincent,

    ominica nd St.

    Lucia metwith

    Willoughby's

    elegation

    n order o

    negotiate

    he

    peace.34

    t the

    signing

    of

    the

    Treaty

    were

    Anniwatta,

    he Grand

    Babba,

    (or

    chief of all

    Kalinagos),

    hiefs

    Wappya,

    Nay,

    Le

    Suroe,

    Rebura nd Aloons.The conditions

    of he

    reaty

    ere

    verything

    heBarbadian laverswanted t that

    articulartage

    ofdevelopment:

    1

    The Caribsof St.

    Vincent hallever

    acknowledge

    hemselves

    subjects

    fthe

    King

    of

    England,

    nd

    be friendso

    all

    n

    amity

    ith

    the

    English,

    nd enemies o their nemies.

    2 The Caribs shall have

    liberty

    o come to and

    depart

    rom,

    t

    pleasure,

    nyEnglish

    slands nd receive heir

    rotection

    herein,

    andthe

    English

    hall

    njoy

    he ame

    n

    St.

    Vincent nd St. Lucia.

    3.His

    Majesty's subjects

    aken

    by

    the

    French nd Indians nd

    remainingmong

    he

    ndians,

    hall e

    mmediately

    elivered

    p,

    s

    also

    any

    ndian

    aptives mong

    he

    English

    when emanded.

    4.Negroes

    ormerly

    un

    way

    from arbados hallbe delivered

    o

    His

    Excellency;

    nd such s shallhereafter

    e

    fugitives

    rom

    ny

    English

    sland

    shall be

    secured

    and

    delivered

    y

    as soon as

    required.35

    The

    Willoughby

    nitiative as

    designed

    o

    pave

    the

    way

    for

    English

    colonisationftheWindwards,singBarbados s the pringboardor ettlement.

    In

    essence,

    t

    was

    an

    elaborationf

    similar

    greement

    hat

    was madebetween he

    defeated

    alinago

    and victorious rench orces t

    Martinique

    fter he war of

    1654-1656.

    On that

    ccasion,

    noted

    Jean-Baptiste

    u

    Tertre,

    ho described

    n

    detail henature f the onflictnd ts

    resolution,

    heFrenchwere ble to obtain

    settlement

    ights

    rom he

    Kalinago,

    s well s

    guarantees

    hat

    hey

    would

    ssist

    n

    the ontrol frebel laves

    by

    not

    ncouraging,

    ndmore

    mportantly,

    eturning

    ll

    runaways.36

    Within womonths f the

    Kalinago-Willoughby reaty, party

    f

    fifty-fournglish olonists rom arbados arrived t St. Vincentn order o

    pioneer

    settlement.he

    Kalinago,

    Garifuna,

    nd Africans

    bjected

    o their

    presence,

    rove hem

    ff he

    sland,

    ndbroke he

    Treaty

    ith

    arbados.

    The

    collapse

    of

    the Barbados

    diplomatic

    mission

    angered

    Governor

    Willoughby

    ho

    swiftly

    moved to the next

    stage

    of his

    plan

    -

    full

    military

    This content downloaded from 198.82.230.35 on Wed, 20 Jan 2016 22:23:31 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Kalinago (Carib) Resistance to European Colonisation of the Caribbean Author(s)- HILARY McD. BECKLES

    12/19

    87

    offensive. is

    opportunity

    ame

    in

    March the

    following earwhenEnglish

    military

    ommander,

    ir

    John

    arman,

    eft

    ehind

    n

    Barbados

    regiment

    ffoot

    soldiers nd five

    rigates.

    illoughby

    nformedheColonial

    Office hat incehe

    knew othow o

    "keep

    he oldiers

    uiet

    nd

    without

    ay"

    he

    nly

    ourse

    pen

    o

    him

    was to

    "try

    is fortune

    mong

    heCaribs t St.

    Vincent."37nce

    again,

    he

    Kalinago proved

    too

    much for

    Willoughby,

    nd

    the

    expedition

    eturnedo

    Barbados

    aving

    uffered

    eavy

    osses.

    English

    wareness f

    Kalinago solidarity

    nd efficient

    ommunications

    throughouthe slands f he esserAntillesmeanthathey adreasons oexpect

    reprisals

    or the

    Willoughby

    ffensive

    nywhere

    nd at

    anytime.

    Governor

    Modyford

    f

    Jamaica,

    most

    knowledgeable

    man about

    EasternCaribbean

    affairs,

    as

    opposed

    Willoughby

    s war

    plan.

    He told heDuke ofAlbermarlehat

    while

    Willoughby

    as

    "making

    arwith

    heCaribs f St. Vincent"

    e feared he

    consequences

    or ettlerst

    Antigua,

    nd other

    laces.

    Such an

    untimely

    ar,

    he

    said,

    may gain ut

    hose

    lantations

    n

    hazard,

    r

    t

    best nto ear roils." Ithad

    been

    far

    etter,"

    e

    continued,

    to havemade

    peace

    with

    hem,"

    or

    f

    they

    ssist

    the French gainstus the resultwould be "the total ruinof all theEnglish

    Islanders" nd "waste fthe evenue f

    Barbados."38

    Modyford

    as

    perceptive

    nhis

    assessmentf

    Kalinago esponses. report

    sent o

    theColonial

    Office n

    Londonfrom fficialsn Nevis dated

    April

    1669,

    entitled

    An

    ntelligence

    f

    n

    ndian

    Designupon

    he

    People

    of

    Antigua,"

    tated

    that "The Caribbee ndians have

    lately

    broken he

    peace

    made

    with

    Lord

    Willoughby,

    ndhavekilled wo nd

    eft eadtwomore fHis

    Majesty's ubjects

    in

    Antigua."

    eference as made o

    twenty-eightalinago

    warriors ho arrived

    fromMontserratntwocanoes nd whoparticipatedntheraiduponAntiguan

    response

    o

    Willoughby'

    war

    n

    St.Vincent.39n

    addition,

    overnor

    tapleton

    f

    the

    Leewards,

    n a

    separate

    ocument,

    utlined is fear or he ives of Leeward

    Islanders,

    ncluding

    hose

    who had

    gone

    to work

    n a

    silvermine

    n

    Dominica

    under n

    agreement

    ith the

    Kalinago.40

    he Barbadians lso offered heir

    criticismsf

    Willoughby'

    war ffort.

    n

    1676,

    Governor tkins escribedt s a

    "fruitless

    esign,"

    hose

    verall esult as

    that

    here emainno ikelihood f

    ny

    plantationspon

    Dominica,

    t.

    Vincent,

    t. Lucia and

    Tobago.,,41

    Meanwhile,

    the

    Antiguans

    ereforced o

    keep"fourteen

    iles f

    men,"doubled hree ays

    before nd after fullmoon" s a

    protective

    easure

    gainst

    alinago

    warriors.

    Governor

    tapleton,eflecting

    n the

    ollapse

    fthe

    Willoughby

    nitiative,

    and

    considering

    he

    prospects

    or

    English

    settlements

    n

    the Leewards and

    Windwards,

    uickly

    moved o

    the ront

    tage

    what adbeen

    Willoughby

    s hidden

    This content downloaded from 198.82.230.35 on Wed, 20 Jan 2016 22:23:31 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Kalinago (Carib) Resistance to European Colonisation of the Caribbean Author(s)- HILARY McD. BECKLES

    13/19

    88

    agenda.Only hedestructionf

    all

    theCaribbee ndians" econcluded,ouldbe

    the best

    iece

    of ervice or he ettlementf hese

    arts."42

    n

    December, 675,

    petition

    f "SeveralMerchantsf London" ddressed o theLordsof Trade nd

    Plantations

    n

    support

    f

    governortapleton's

    xtermination

    hesis,

    alledfor he

    granting

    f commissiono

    Philip

    Warner,

    tapleton's eputy,

    oraise oldiers o

    go

    into

    ominica

    o

    "destroy

    he arbarous

    avages."43

    Stapleton,

    owever,

    ad

    pre-empted

    heColonialOffice

    n

    their

    esponse

    o

    theLondonmerchantsndhad

    already

    entWarner with ix small

    ompanies

    f

    foot," otaling00 men, ntoDominica o "revenge" n the heathens or heir

    bloody erfidious

    illanies.

    sic]"44

    ne William

    Hamlyn

    who

    participated

    n

    the

    Warner

    xpedition,

    escribedhe ssault

    pon

    he

    Kalinago

    s a

    massacre.

    t east

    thirty

    alinago,

    he

    said,

    were aken nd killed n thefirst

    ound,

    ot

    ncluding

    "three hatwere drawn

    by

    a

    flag

    of truce" nd shot.After

    hese

    executions,

    Hamlyn

    eported,

    nother

    sixty

    r

    seventy

    men,

    women

    nd children"were

    invited o Warner's

    amp

    o settlemattersver ntertainment.

    hesewere

    given

    rum o

    drink,

    ndwhenWarner

    gave

    the

    ignal,"

    he

    nglish

    fell

    pon

    hem nd

    destroyedhem."46ncludednthosekilledbytheEnglishwas IndianWarner,

    Phillip

    Warner's wn

    half-brother,

    hosemother as a

    Kalinago,

    nd who had

    risen obecome

    powerful alinago

    eader.Warner as

    mprisoned

    n

    he

    Tower,

    tried or hemurderfhis

    brother,

    ut

    was found ot

    guilty.

    he decision

    leased

    the London

    merchants ho described im as "a man of

    great

    oyalty"

    whose

    service

    to the Crown n the destructionf the

    Kalinagos

    "who have often

    attempted

    o

    ruin he

    lantations"

    hould e commended.47

    In

    spite

    f osses sustained

    n

    Dominica,

    Kalinagos

    here ontinuedo use

    the sland s a militaryase for xpeditionsgainstheEnglish.nJuly 681, 00

    Kalinagos

    rom t. Vincent ndDominica n six

    periagos,

    ed

    by

    one whonamed

    himself

    aptain

    Peter,

    nd who was described s a

    "good speaker

    f

    English

    having

    ived for some time

    n

    Barbados,"

    attacked he

    unguarded nglish

    settlements

    n

    Barbuda.48The

    English

    were

    caught y surprise. ight

    f them

    were

    killed,

    nd their ouses

    destroyed.

    he actionwas described s swift nd

    without

    arning.

    Frustrated

    gainby

    his

    nability

    o

    protect

    he ives nd

    property

    f

    Leeward

    Islanders, tapleton eiterated is call for war of exterminationgainst he

    Kalinagos.

    He wrote otheColonialOffice:

    I

    beg

    your

    ardon

    f am

    tedious,

    ut

    I

    beg

    you

    to

    represent

    he

    King

    he

    necessity

    or

    estroying

    heseCarib ndians."

    "We arenow s much n our

    guard

    s

    if

    we had Christian

    nemy,

    either

    an

    any

    such

    surprise

    s butthese annibalswho never

    ome 'marte

    perto'...

    f

    their

    This content downloaded from 198.82.230.35 on Wed, 20 Jan 2016 22:23:31 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Kalinago (Carib) Resistance to European Colonisation of the Caribbean Author(s)- HILARY McD. BECKLES

    14/19

    89

    destructionannot e "total,"nsisted tapleton,tleastwe must drive hem o

    themain."49 e was

    aware,however,

    f the

    nability

    f Leeward slanders o

    finance

    major

    war

    ffort,

    nd had also become

    espectful

    or

    Kalinagos'

    bility

    toobtain

    intelligence"

    ith

    espect

    otheir

    lans,

    iven

    hese wo

    ircumstances,

    Stapleton

    nstructedondonto order he

    Barbados

    government

    o

    prepare

    he

    granddesign against

    he

    Kalinagos.

    Barbados,

    he

    added,

    was closer

    to the

    Kalinago

    infested'

    slands f St. Vincent

    nd

    Dominica; lso,

    on account f the

    colony's

    wealth,

    t

    would

    be the best

    piece

    of service"

    hey

    ouldoffer

    ngland

    whilst here as

    "amity

    ith

    heFrench."50

    Colonial fficials

    n

    London

    ccepted

    tapleton;s lan

    n

    ts

    ntirety.hey

    instructed

    im o make

    lans

    o

    "utterlyuppress"

    he

    Kalinagos

    r drive

    hem o

    themain"51

    hey

    lso directed overnor

    utton fBarbados o make

    ll

    possible

    contributions

    o thewar ffort.

    utton, owever,

    ouldhaveno

    part

    f

    t,

    utnot

    wishing

    o contradict

    he

    King's

    orders,

    e

    informedhe Colonial Office

    hat

    though

    e was n

    greement,

    arbadians ould

    upport

    o such

    design gainst

    he

    Kalinagos

    or hree easons.

    irst,

    hey

    onsider he ffairs

    f he eeward slands

    noneof their usiness. econd,theydo not consider he advancementfthe

    Leewards

    s

    good

    thing,

    ndeed

    hey

    onsider

    t

    n

    theirnterest

    f

    theLeewards

    would decline

    rather han

    progress.

    hird,

    lanters

    onsidered

    eace

    with he

    Kalinagos

    n

    the Windwards better

    bjective

    s this would

    assist them

    n

    securing

    utwood ndother

    uilding

    materials

    rom hose slands.52

    The Leeward

    slanders,

    herefore,

    ad to look to their wn resources

    o

    finance heir

    military perations.

    n June

    1682,

    a bill was

    proposed

    o

    the

    Leewards

    Assembly equesting

    unds ooutfit

    n

    expedition

    gainst

    he

    Kalinagos

    inDominica.The council greed, uttheAssembly f Nevis dissentedn the

    grounds

    hat ince

    hey

    ad notbeen attacked

    y

    the

    Kalinagos

    n over

    twenty

    years:

    hey

    id

    not ntendo

    endanger

    heir

    eace.53

    Monthswent

    y

    nd

    Stapleton

    failed

    o

    get

    his

    planters

    o

    agree

    n

    a

    financial

    lan

    for he

    xpedition. y

    1700,

    the

    grand

    esign

    ad not

    yet

    materialised.

    When n

    the

    1

    th

    April,

    713,

    England

    nd

    France ettled heirAmerican'

    difference

    ith

    he

    Treaty

    f

    Utrecht,

    alinagos

    were

    till

    olding

    n

    tenaciously

    to considerable

    erritory.

    t. Vincent nd

    Dominica,

    hough

    nhabited

    y

    some

    Europeans, ere till nder heirontrol,ndtheywerefightingrear uardwar

    to

    retain ome

    space

    at St.

    Lucia,

    Tobago

    and Grenada.

    ince theFrench eared

    that uccessful

    nglish

    ettlementf

    Dominica

    would lead to the

    cutting

    f

    communications

    etween

    Martinique

    nd

    Guadeloupe

    n

    timesof

    war,

    they

    continued

    oassist he

    Kalinagos

    with nformation

    nd

    occasionally

    ith

    weapons

    This content downloaded from 198.82.230.35 on Wed, 20 Jan 2016 22:23:31 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Kalinago (Carib) Resistance to European Colonisation of the Caribbean Author(s)- HILARY McD. BECKLES

    15/19

    90

    intheir nti-English esistance.The best theEnglishcould do was to continue he

    attempt

    o settle

    rivate

    reaties

    with

    he

    French,

    s

    they

    had done

    during

    he

    peace

    of

    Ryswick

    in

    1697,

    which enabled

    them

    o

    go

    unmolested

    o Dominica forthe

    sole

    purpose

    of

    purchasing

    umberfrom he

    Kalinago.

    Kalinagos,

    then,

    succeeded in

    preserving

    some of their territorial

    sovereignty

    nd

    by

    so

    doing

    were able to

    maintain

    heir reedomfrom

    uropean

    enslavement.While othernative Caribbean

    peoples

    suffered

    arge

    scale

    slavery

    t

    thehands of

    Europeans,

    the

    Kalinagos

    were neverfound n

    arge

    numbers

    working

    themines, atifudia, r plantations n the Lesser Antilles.Though Spanish slave

    raids

    during

    the sixteenth

    entury

    did take

    many

    into the Greater Antilles to

    supplement

    aino labour

    gangs, European

    controlled

    roductive

    tructuresn the

    Lesser

    Antilles

    were

    not built and maintained n the basis of a

    Kalinago

    labour

    supply.

    The involvement f

    Kalinagos

    intothe colonial

    economy,

    hen,

    ended o be

    small

    scale,

    and confined to

    areas such as

    fishing, tracking

    and

    hunting,

    agricultural onsulting

    nd a

    range

    of

    petty

    omestic ervices.

    When,

    for

    xample,

    a group of Barbadian sugar planters,concerned about the shortageof white

    indentured

    ervants,

    nd the

    rising

    cost of African

    slaves,

    encouraged Captain

    Peter

    Wroth n 1673 to establish a slave trade in

    Kalinagos

    from he

    Guianas,

    colonial officials nstructed overnor

    Atkins o

    make

    arrangements

    or he return

    of

    all

    those

    "captured

    and enslaved." The reason

    being, they

    stated,

    was

    that

    "considering

    he

    greater

    mportance

    f a fair

    correspondence

    between the Carib

    Indians

    and

    the

    English"

    in

    establishing

    ettlements

    n the Amazon

    coast,

    it was

    necessary

    that

    provocation

    be avoided" and

    all

    proper

    measures be takento

    gain

    their goodwill and affection."54 overnorAtkins, n informing is superiorsof

    this

    ompliance

    ndicatedhis

    agreement

    hat t

    was

    necessary

    o

    "keep amity"

    with

    Kalinagos,

    since

    they

    have

    "always

    been

    verypernicious, specially

    to the maller

    Leeward Islands."55

    Between 1492 and 1700 the

    Kalinago

    population

    n

    the Lesser Antilles

    may

    have fallen

    by

    as much as 90

    percent,

    noted Michael

    Craton,

    but

    they

    had

    done

    much to

    "preserve

    and extend their

    ndependence."56 y

    this time the Dominica

    population, ccording

    o

    Labat,

    "did notexceed 2000" and warriorswere too weak

    innumbers o do anyseriousharm" oEuropeancolonies.57Nonetheless, olonists

    in

    the

    "outlying

    districts"

    till had reasons

    to believe

    that

    any

    night Kalinago

    warriors

    could take them

    by

    surprise

    and "cut their throats and burn their

    houses."58

    By refusing

    o

    capitulate

    under the

    collective

    militarymight

    of the

    Europeans, Kalinagos certainly ept

    theWindwards slands in a

    marginal

    elation

    This content downloaded from 198.82.230.35 on Wed, 20 Jan 2016 22:23:31 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Kalinago (Carib) Resistance to European Colonisation of the Caribbean Author(s)- HILARY McD. BECKLES

    16/19

    91

    to the slaveplantationomplex f the NorthAtlanticystem or wo hundred

    years,

    and

    in

    so

    doing,

    made a

    principal

    ontributiono the Caribbean's

    anti-colonialnd

    anti-slavery

    radition.

    (Reproduced

    rom aribbean

    Quarterly,

    ol.38,

    Nos.2&3,

    Special

    ssue

    -

    Caribbean

    uincentennial,

    une-

    ept.

    1992)

    Notes

    1 See Michael

    Craton,

    esting

    he hains:Resistance

    o

    Slavery

    n the

    BritishWest

    Indies

    Ithaca,

    1

    982) pp.

    2 1

    23

    Hilary

    eckles,

    The

    200 Years War: Slave

    Resistance

    n

    the

    BritishWest Indies:

    An

    Overview f the

    Historiography,"

    amaica

    Historical

    eview^

    oV

    13, 1982,

    1-10.

    2.

    See

    J.Paul

    Thomas,

    The Caribs f St. Vincent:

    Study

    n

    mperial

    Maladministration,

    763-73

    "

    Journal

    f

    Caribbean

    History,

    ol.

    18,No.2, 1984,

    pp.

    60-74;

    Craton

    esting

    he

    Chains,

    p.

    141

    153, 183-194;

    Richard

    .

    Sheridan,

    The

    Condition

    f laves

    n

    the ettlementnd Economic

    evelopment

    fthe

    British

    Windwardslands, 763-1775," ournal fCaribbeanHistory, ol. 24, No.2, 1991,pp.

    128-129;

    Bernard

    Marshall,

    Slave Resistance

    ndWhiteReaction

    n

    the

    British

    Windward

    slands, 763-1833,"

    ee

    this olume.

    3.

    David

    Watts,

    he Westndies:Patterns

    fDevelopment,

    ulture

    nd

    Environmental

    hange

    ince 1492

    'Cambridge,

    987)

    pp.

    41,

    51-52.

    W.

    Borah,

    The

    Historical

    emography

    f

    Aboriginal

    nd Colonial

    America:

    An

    Attempt

    t

    perspective,"

    n

    W.

    Denevan,

    TheNative

    opulation f

    he Americas

    n 1492

    Madison,

    Wisconsin

    niv.

    Press,

    976)

    pp.

    13-34.J.M.Cruxent

    nd .

    Rouse,

    Early

    man n the

    West

    ndies"

    cientific

    merican,

    o.

    221,

    1969,

    pp.

    42-52.

    B.

    Meggers

    ndC.

    Evans,

    "Lowland outhAmerica

    ndthe

    Antilles,"

    n

    J.D.

    Jennings,

    ncient ative

    Americans

    (San

    Francisco,

    W.H.

    Freeman,

    978)

    pp.

    543-92.

    4. Gordon

    ewis,

    Main Currents

    n

    Caribbean

    Thought:

    heHistorical volution

    f

    Caribbean

    ociety

    n its

    deologicalAspects,

    492-1900

    Heinemann, ingston,

    83)

    41.

    5.

    On

    Kalinago

    ssistance o

    Tainos n Puerto

    ico,

    ee

    Carl

    Sauer,

    The

    Early

    panish

    Main

    Berkeley,

    niv. fCalifornia

    ress,

    A,

    1966)

    pp.32,

    8,

    192.See

    Eric

    Williams,

    Documents

    f

    Westndian

    History,

    492-1655

    Port-of

    pain,

    PNM

    Publishing

    o.,

    1963)

    pp.

    62-70,

    9-94.Robert

    reenwood,

    Sketchmap

    History

    f

    heCaribbean

    (MacMillan, 991)pp.18,23.

    6.

    Sauer,

    C. The

    Early

    panish

    Main,

    pp.

    35, 180, 193;

    see

    also

    Lewis,

    Main

    Currents,

    .

    64.

    7.

    Troy

    .

    Floyd,

    TheColumbian

    ynasty

    n the

    Caribbean,

    492-1526

    (Albuquerque,

    niv.ofNew

    Mexico

    Press,

    973)

    p.

    97. For an account f

    the

    panish

    This content downloaded from 198.82.230.35 on Wed, 20 Jan 2016 22:23:31 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Kalinago (Carib) Resistance to European Colonisation of the Caribbean Author(s)- HILARY McD. BECKLES

    17/19

    'hands ff

    olicy

    with

    espect

    o theLesser

    Antilles,

    ee K.R.

    Andrews,

    rade,

    lunder

    and Settlement: aritime

    nterprises

    nd theGenesis

    f

    heBritish

    mpire,

    480.1630

    (Cambridge,

    1986)

    p.

    282.Craton,

    esting

    he

    Chains,

    .

    22.

    See

    also,

    NellisM.

    Crouse,

    The

    French

    truggleor

    theWestndies1665-1713

    N.Y.

    Columbia

    University

    ress,

    1943)

    p.

    8-10.

    8. See

    Sauer,

    .

    35;

    Lewis,

    p.

    64.

    9. See

    Lewis,

    p.

    64;

    Richard

    unn,

    ugar

    nd Slaves: the ise

    of

    he

    lanterClass in

    the

    nglish

    West

    ndies,

    624-1713

    N.Y.,

    1973)

    p.

    24;

    Sieurde la

    Borde,

    Relacindes

    Caraibes

    Paris,

    Coleccin

    Billaine,

    1694);

    Jean

    aptiste

    e

    Uertre,

    istoire

    Generale

    des

    Antilles abites

    ar

    les Fran,cais

    (Paris,1667-71);

    John

    aden, d.,

    The

    Memoirs fPere

    Labat,

    1 93- 05 1 70

    edition,

    rank

    ass,

    London).

    10. Memoirs f

    Pere

    Labat,

    p.

    75.

    11.

    Ibid, .

    S3,

    12.

    Ibid,p.9S.

    13.

    Ibid,

    .

    104.

    14.

    Ibid,

    .

    109.

    1

    Watts,

    p.

    1 1 1

    2. Richard

    heridan,

    ugar

    nd

    slavery:

    n

    Economic

    History f

    theBritish

    Westndies

    Caribbean

    niversities

    ress,

    ridgetown,974) pp.

    80, 85,

    87,456.

    16. See

    Dunn,

    .

    8.

    17.

    Lewis,

    p.

    104.

    18.

    Ibid,

    p.

    105.

    20. Memoirs f Pere

    Labat,

    p.

    137.

    21

    Governor

    tapleton

    ftheLeewards o theLords fTrade nd

    Plantations,

    ov.

    22,

    1676,Calendar f StatePapers, olonial eries C.S.P.c.) 1676,p.499.

    22.

    See C.

    Gullick,

    Black Caribs

    Origins

    nd

    Early ociety,"

    n

    Transactionsfthe

    Seventhnternational

    ongress

    n Pre-Columbianultures f

    theLesserAntilles

    (Quebec, 1978)

    pp.

    283-87.

    23. See

    William

    oung,

    An Account ftheBlack

    Caribs

    n

    the sland f St. Vincent's

    (London,

    795

    reprint,

    ondon

    1971)

    pp.

    5-8;

    Also

    Vancy

    Gonzalez,

    ojourners f

    he

    Caribbean:

    thnogenesis

    nd

    Ethnohistoryf

    he

    Garifunta

    Chicago,

    1988).

    24.

    See Vincent

    Murga,

    d.,

    Historia ocument e Puerto

    ico,

    Vol.

    I

    (Rio

    Pedras,

    n.d.)

    p.

    227. 25. See for n account fthe

    battles

    t

    Martinique,

    u

    Tertre,

    istoire

    General . 467-68.

    26. See

    Hilary

    eckles,

    BlackRebellion

    n

    Barbados:

    the

    truggle gainst lavery,

    1627-1838

    Carib

    Research nd

    Publications,

    ridgetown,

    988)

    p.

    36.

    92

    This content downloaded from 198.82.230.35 on Wed, 20 Jan 2016 22:23:31 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Kalinago (Carib) Resistance to European Colonisation of the Caribbean Author(s)- HILARY McD. BECKLES

    18/19

    27.

    'The State f

    theCase

    Concerning

    ur

    itle o St.

    Lucia," 1664;

    C.S.~.,

    1661-68,

    No. 887. See

    also,

    Rev. C.

    Jesse,

    Barbadians

    uy

    St.

    Lucia from

    aribs,"

    ournal

    f

    he

    Barbados

    Museum

    nd Historical

    ociety,

    J.B.M.H.S.)

    Vol.

    32,

    Feb.

    1968,

    pp.

    180-182.

    28. Governor

    ir

    Thomas

    Modyford

    o the

    Duke of

    Albermarle,

    arch

    16, 1668,

    C.S.P.c.

    1661-68,

    No.

    1714.

    29. Vere

    LOliver,

    he

    History

    fthesland

    f

    Antigua

    London

    1894-99)

    Vol.

    I,

    p.

    xix,

    XXV;

    also, Sheridan,

    ugar

    nd

    Slavery, .

    87.

    30.

    Petition f

    Major

    John

    cott o

    the

    King,

    1667,

    C.S.P.c,

    1661-68,

    No. 1525.

    31. Governor

    William ord

    Willoughby

    o the

    King,

    eb.

    1

    1,

    1668,

    C.S.P.CA

    1661-68,

    p. 547; Watts,heWest ndies, . 24243.HenryWilloughbyoWilliamWilloughby,

    June

    5,

    1667,

    C.S.P.c,

    1661-68,

    No. 1498.

    32.

    Craton,

    esting

    he

    Chains,

    p.

    22-23.

    33.

    Governor

    William

    ord

    Willoughby

    o

    the

    King,

    July

    ,

    1668,C.S.P.C,

    1661-68;

    No.

    1788.

    34.

    Copy

    of a

    Treaty

    etween

    William

    ord

    Willoughby

    nd

    several fthe

    Chief

    Captains

    f

    Caribs,

    march

    3.1668,

    C.S.P.C.

    1661-68,

    No.

    1717.

    35.

    Ibid

    36. Du Tertre, istoire enerale, p.467-68.

    37.

    Lord

    Willoughby

    o the

    King,

    March

    13,

    1668,

    Colonial

    Papers,

    ol.

    22,

    November

    5,es.p.c,No.

    1714.

    38. Governor

    ir

    Thomas

    Modyford

    o

    theDuke of

    Albemarle,

    arch

    16, 1668,

    C.S.P.C.

    ,

    No. 1714.

    39. Governor

    tapleton

    o

    theLords

    f Trade nd

    Plantations,

    ay

    27,

    1672;

    Colonial

    Papers,

    Vol.

    28,

    No. 61.

    40.

    Ibid. The

    English

    laimed

    hat heDominica

    ilver

    mine

    was

    "lawfully urchased"

    from heKalinagoswhorecognisedhe ontract.eolinLloydtoSecretaryrlington,

    Colonial

    Papers,

    oL, 29,

    No.

    46; also,

    Colonial

    Papers,

    ol.

    28,

    No.

    12.

    41. Governor

    tkins o Lords

    fTrade

    nd

    Plantations,

    uly

    ,

    1676,

    Colonial

    Papers,

    Vol.

    37,

    No.

    22.

    42. Governor

    tapleton

    o Council

    fTrade nd

    Plantations,

    ecember

    675,

    Colonial

    Papers

    Vol.

    35,

    No.63.

    124

    43.

    Petition f

    SeveralMerchants

    f London

    n

    Adventures

    o theCaribbean

    slands o

    the Lords

    of Trade nd

    Plantations,

    676,

    Colonial

    Papers,

    ol.

    36,

    No.5.

    44. Governor

    tapleton

    o theCouncil

    for

    lantations,

    ebruary

    ,

    1675,

    C.S.P.C.

    1675-76,

    No.

    428.

    45.

    SirJonathan

    tkins

    o

    Secretary

    or

    olonies,

    ebruary

    7,

    1675

    C.S.P.C,

    1675-76,

    No.

    439.

    46. ibid

    47. Petition f

    SeveralMerchants

    f London

    Adventurers

    o theCaribbee

    slands

    o

    Lords ftrade

    nd

    Plantations,

    anuary

    0,1676,

    .S.P.c, 1675-76,

    No. 774.

    93

    This content downloaded from 198.82.230.35 on Wed, 20 Jan 2016 22:23:31 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Kalinago (Carib) Resistance to European Colonisation of the Caribbean Author(s)- HILARY McD. BECKLES

    19/19

    48. Governor

    tapleton

    o Lords

    fTrade nd

    Plantations,

    ugust

    6, 1681,

    Colonial

    Papers,Vol.46,No. 45; see also C.S.P.c. 1681-85, os. 410-41 .

    49. SirWilliam

    tapleton

    o Lords f

    Trade nd

    Plantations,

    ugust

    6, 1681,

    C.S.P.c.

    1681-85,

    No. 204. See

    Also,

    Journal

    f

    Lords

    of

    Trade nd

    Plantations,

    ctober

    8,

    1681,

    No. 259.

    50.

    Ibid.

    51. The

    King

    o Sir William

    tapleton,

    ebruary,

    682,

    C.S.P.C.

    1681-85,

    No.

    411.

    52. Sir Richard utton o Lords

    f

    Trade

    nd

    Plantations,

    anuary

    , 1682,

    C.S.P.c.

    1681-85,

    .

    181,No.357;

    also colonial

    Papers,

    Vol.

    48,

    No.l.

    53. Journal f heAssemblyfNevisJun4,1682,C.S.P.C. 1681-85.

    54. The

    King

    o

    Sir

    Jonathan

    tkins,

    ecember

    0, 1674,

    C.S.P.C.

    1675-76,

    No.

    401

    55. SirJonathan tkins o

    Secretary

    f

    Plantations,.S.P.C,

    February

    7,

    No. 439.

    See

    Jerome

    andler,

    Amerindiansnd their ontributionoBarbados

    Life

    nthe

    Seventeenth

    entury,

    .B.M.H.S., 971,35,

    112-117. TheAmerindian

    lave

    Population

    of

    Barbados n the eventeenthnd

    early ighteenth

    enturies,

    .B.M.H.S.,

    ol.

    xxxiii,

    No.3,

    May

    1970,1

    1-135.For

    an

    account fthis

    ttempt

    o establish

    Barbados-Guianas

    slave trade

    n

    Kalinagos,

    .G.

    Breslaw,

    Price s

    -

    His

    Desposition

    :

    Kidnapping

    Amerindiansn

    Guyana,

    674,

    J.B.M.H.S.,

    ol.

    39, 1991,

    pp.

    47-50.

    56.

    Craton,

    esting

    he

    Chains,

    .

    23.

    57 Memoirs

    f

    Pere

    Labat,

    p

    115.

    58.

    Ibid,,

    p.

    110-111.

    94