june 2011. demotech, inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial...

42
June 2011

Upload: alexina-barker

Post on 20-Jan-2016

215 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

June 2011

Page 2: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting opportunity for corporate growth.

2

Page 3: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

How We Review and Rate Title underwriters&

Value Proposition of Title Insurance

3

Page 4: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

Since 1992 Demotech has been reviewing and rating Title underwriters. We were the first company to review and rate the entire industry. Demotech did so two years prior to the secondary mortgage

marketplace requirement to have an independent third-party review. In 1994, Financial Stability Ratings® of S or better became acceptable,

upon the issuance by Fannie Mae of its Announcement 94-13.

4

Page 5: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

Financial Stability Ratings® are reviewed every quarter. This schedule coincides with the availability of quarterly financial information.

Each company is reviewed as a stand-alone entity. Although we may reflect the existence of a well-defined corporate relationship within a group, each and every Title underwriter, regardless of size, is reviewed, analyzed and, when applicable, affirmed every 90 days.

5

Page 6: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

Along with the quarterly analysis and dialogue related to the financial analysis of each Title underwriter, we have frequent discussions related to critical Title industry issues, such as reinsurance, defalcations, alternative distribution methods and loss trends.

Evidence of the effectiveness of our review and analysis process, consider the following: from 1992 to date, no Title underwriter rated A or better has failed.

6

Page 7: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

Each quarter’s financial statement is analyzed to ensure that:The investment portfolio remains liquid and of a high quality,Loss and loss adjustment expense reserves remain consistent with the

estimate underlying the opinion of the Company’s actuary,Financial leverage remains within reasonable tolerance,And other financial criteria continue to meet Demotech’s standards for an

FSR of A, Exceptional or higher.

7

Page 8: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

Annually we review:The latest available financial information,Statement of actuarial opinion as regards loss and loss adjustment expense

reservesThe year-end audit,The composition of the investment portfolio,Changes in personnel (if any),Anticipated changes in the business plan,Operating philosophy,Reinsurance treaties or marketing philosophy,As well as changes in pricing, rate levels or claim philosophy.

8

Page 9: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

Annually we review and/or discuss with the professional who authored the document(s):The independent auditStatement of actuarial opinionOther regulatory requirements

9

Page 10: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

Executive summary, page 1: Comparisons of Demotech ratings to other agencies show relative consistency in the factors that drive Demotech ratings compared to agencies such as A.M. Best, Moody’s, Standard and Poor’s, and Fitch.

Executive summary, page 5: These results have important public policy implications for insurers, regulators and consumers as they work to better understand the ratings process. Of particular importance to most is the comparability of Demotech ratings to other agencies.

Executive summary, page 5: Given that lenders often have requirements related to the use of rated insurers and some states require ratings to operate in a state, the results suggest that Demotech serves an important service within the ratings community and plays a very important role in the insurance market.

10

Page 11: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

11

Page 12: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

Company DPW Share1 Lawyers Title Insurance Corporation $ 156,323,542 16.3%

2 Stewart Title Guaranty Company $ 154,506,539 16.1%

3 Chicago Title Insurance Company $ 132,464,680 13.8%

4 Alamo Title Insurance $ 94,220,282 9.8%

5 Commonwealth Land Title Insurance Company $ 91,137,464 9.5%

6 First American Title Insurance Company TX $ 83,433,089 8.7%

7 Fidelity National Title Insurance Company $ 72,791,761 7.6%

8 First American Title Insurance Company $ 41,919,971 4.4%

9 Title Resources Guaranty Company $ 39,825,177 4.2%

10 Old Republic National Title Insurance Company $ 32,024,273 3.3%

11 Ticor Title Insurance Company $ 16,924,977 1.8%

12 United General Title Insurance Company $ 12,382,736 1.3%

13 Title America Insurance Company $ 10,796,993 1.1%

14 Title Insurance Company of America $ 8,993,272 0.9%

15 Security Union Title Insurance Company $ 5,338,405 0.6%

16 Transnation Title Insurance Company $ 3,249,585 0.3%

17 Benefit Land Title Insurance Company (Commerce TIC) $ 2,393,952 0.2%

Texas Total: $ 958,726,698

12

Page 13: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

Company DPW Share1 First American Title Insurance Company $ 1,413,493,587 19.4%

2 Chicago Title Insurance Company $ 1,019,054,601 14.0%

3 Lawyers Title Insurance Corporation $ 670,324,023 9.2%

4 Stewart Title Guaranty Company $ 655,790,481 9.0%

5 Commonwealth Land Title Insurance Company $ 634,562,585 8.7%

6 Fidelity National Title Insurance Company $ 426,824,265 5.9%

7 Old Republic National Title Insurance Company $ 418,269,346 5.7%

8 Fidelity National Title Insurance Company (NY) $ 314,529,969 4.3%

9 Ticor Title Insurance Company $ 191,295,334 2.6%

10 Attorneys' Title Insurance Fund (FL) $ 190,052,660 2.6%

11 Transnation Title Insurance Company $ 161,432,208 2.2%

12 United General Title Insurance Company $ 111,803,693 1.5%

13 American Pioneer Title Insurance Company $ 97,738,582 1.3%

14 Alamo Title Insurance $ 94,747,282 1.3%

15 First American Title Insurance Company NY $ 93,436,287 1.3%

All Other Underwriters $ 787,356,473 10.8%

Countrywide Total: $ 7,280,711,376

13

Page 14: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

Company DPW Market Share

1 Stewart Title Guaranty Company $ 210,600,722 19.8%2 First American Title Insurance Company $ 203,663,526 19.1%3 Fidelity National Title Insurance Company $ 175,649,119 16.5%4 Chicago Title Insurance Company $ 138,958,345 13.1%5 Title Resources Guaranty Company $ 80,125,605 7.5%6 Old Republic National Title Insurance Company $ 74,110,631 7.0%7 Alamo Title Insurance $ 50,297,008 4.7%8 Commonwealth Land Title Insurance Company $ 45,792,386 4.3%9 Alliant National Title Insurance Company $ 33,981,028 3.2%10 National Title Insurance of New York, Inc. $ 17,889,569 1.7%11 North American Title Insurance Company $ 11,670,320 1.1%12 Westcor Land Title Insurance Company $ 9,107,066 0.9%13 Commerce Title Insurance Company $ 4,847,352 0.5%14 WFG National Title Insurance Company $ 2,784,123 0.3%15 Sierra Title Insurance Guaranty Company $ 2,496,129 0.2%16 National Investors Title Insurance Company $ 2,144,908 0.2%17 Southern Title Insurance Corporation $ 197,320 0.0%

Texas Total: $ 1,064,315,157

14

10 years plus 11%

Page 15: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

Company DPW Share1 First American Title Insurance Company $ 2,369,361,728 25.1%

2 Chicago Title Insurance Company $ 1,641,750,584 17.4%

3 Fidelity National Title Insurance Company $ 1,403,221,265 14.8%

4 Stewart Title Guaranty Company $ 1,177,860,022 12.5%

5 Old Republic National Title Insurance Company $ 1,026,516,851 10.9%

6 Commonwealth Land Title Insurance Company $ 535,986,147 5.7%

7 National Title Insurance of New York, Inc. $ 295,497,797 3.1%

8 Title Resources Guaranty Company $ 134,064,289 1.4%

9 Westcor Land Title Insurance Company $ 127,489,016 1.3%

10 Stewart Title Insurance Company $ 124,694,025 1.3%

11 North American Title Insurance Company $ 74,415,425 0.8%

12 Investors Title Insurance Company $ 56,665,339 0.6%

13 Connecticut Attorneys Title Insurance Company $ 52,391,004 0.6%

14 Alamo Title Insurance $ 50,297,008 0.5%

15 Alliant National Title Insurance Company $ 49,970,662 0.5%

All Other Underwriters $ 334,968,207 3.5%

Countrywide Total: $ 9,455,149,369

15

+ 30%

Page 16: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

16

Page 17: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

17

Page 18: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

18

Page 19: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

19

Q3 2008

Page 20: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

While Title insurance coverage looks backward from a certain date, P&C insurance coverage looks forward, utilizing a finite future period, to provide coverage. The timeframe of coverage provided and cost containment activities are fundamental differences between Title and P&C insurance.

The distinctions have not been properly reflected in financial reporting nor statistical reporting requirements.

A focus on the number of matters identified, addressed or otherwise resolved is necessary to put the Title insurance loss and loss adjustment expense ratio and operating ratio in perspective prior to a comparison to P&C insurance.

Page 21: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

Subject to the exclusions from coverage, the exceptions from coverage contained in Schedule B and the conditions and stipulations, the Title insurance company, as of the Date of Policy shown in Schedule A, against loss or damage…

Coverage is Retrospective.

We reviewed the available information, made corrections and revisions, as well as summarized our major findings in

Schedules A and B.

Page 22: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

In Consideration of the Provisions and Stipulations herein, the Property and Casualty Insurance Company, for the term of this date at 12:01 a.m. to one year later at 12:01 a.m., does insure…

Coverage is Prospective.

We won’t pay for anything that happened before or after the policy period.

Page 23: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

Title is Retrospective

Incident must have occurred prior to policy effective date to be considered covered

P & C is Prospective

Incident must occur within policy period to be considered covered

Date o

f Po

licy

Page 24: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

Loss adjustment expenses include allocated loss adjustment expenses and unallocated loss adjustment expenses, also called defense and cost containment or other adjusting expense.

Allocated loss adjustment expenses are those expenses, such as attorneys’ fees and other legal costs, that are incurred in connection with specific claims.

Unallocated loss adjustment expenses are all other claim adjustment expenses, such as salaries, utilities and rent apportioned to support the claim adjustment function, although not readily assignable to a specific claim. Postage, cost of claims checks, envelops claim checks are mailed in …

Page 25: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

For a P&C insurer: an expense directly allocated to a particular claim or incident.

Addressing specific defects and everything in Schedules A and B?

Page 26: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

For a P&C insurer: an expense pertaining to handling claims that cannot be specifically attributable to a specific claim.

Your entire preliminary investigation? Looking for situations that need to be cured is unallocated loss adjustment expense. Once found, the time and effort should be allocated loss adjustment expense.

◦ Rent and utilities

◦ Postage and envelopes

◦ Benefits and salaries

◦ Allocation of executive time

Page 27: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

Order Entry◦ Verify property address

◦ Verify owner(s)

◦ Legal Description Run the Chain◦ Run names and nicknames

◦ Determining encumbrances or possible encumbrances

◦ Back ground – determining and indication of legal incompetence – conservator, bankruptcy, etc.

◦ Impairments in chain of Title

◦ Determine adverse claims

◦ Interest which affects tenancy

◦ Property tax

Page 28: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

Examination◦ Legal Description

◦ Conveyances

◦ Execution

◦ Notarization

◦ Evidence of fraud, forgery, competence, etc.

Page 29: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

Matters Affecting◦ Covenants and restrictions

◦ Easements

◦ Rights of first refusal

◦ Judgment of lien

◦ Market requirement to cure

◦ Indemnities

◦ Review prior transaction

◦ Application of statute of limitations

Page 30: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

Matters Affecting (cont.)◦ Update for last minute items

◦ Fallout

◦ Review tax certificate

◦ Reconcile difference with tax discrepancies

◦ Check for outstanding tax sales

◦ Review survey for adverse matters

◦ Verify legal access

◦ Mineral reservations

◦ Geographic posting

Page 31: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

File Work Up◦ Verify sellers names on contract match vesting

◦ In a refinance, verify borrowers names match vesting

◦ Ensure all Title requirements are addressed on the settlement statement

◦ Comply with terms of real estate contract

◦ Comply with requirements in lender’s closing instructions

◦ Verify borrowers names on loan document match contract

Page 32: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

Closing◦ Ensure all documents are executed properly

◦ Correctly notarize all appropriate documents

◦ Comply with lender’s funding requirements

◦ Ensure no disbursements are made without all funds being received Post-closing◦ Disburse all funds per HUD-1

◦ Return lender’s package

◦ Record documents in correct order

Page 33: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

Once you found a situation that needed to be resolved, no matter how simple or routine, the time and effort on that specific situation would be allocated loss adjustment expense.

Property tax allocation between buyer and seller.

Determining payoffs of liens, each separately.

Alimony, child support.

Patriot Act.

Verification of address, metes and bounds.

Page 34: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

“Allocated loss adjustment expense” or “ALAE” means expenses paid to defend and litigate a claim. These expenses may be internal or external, and include:◦ Attorney’s fees paid to defend claims;◦ The cost of engaging experts;◦ Litigation management expenses;◦ Fees or salaries for private investigators, hearing representatives or

fraud investigators;◦ Surveillance expenses;◦ Court costs;◦ Stenographic expenses;◦ Fees associated with witnesses and summonses; ◦ The costs to obtain copies of documents.

Page 35: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

Missed lien by a Title professional.

Taxi driver in a fender bender.

No police report, no photos, no witnesses.

Page 36: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

Demotech reviewed and analyzed a sample of 114 Title insurance files. The source of data was HUD-1s, commitments and the observations of a licensed Title insurance agent who is also a real estate attorney.

Based upon a random sample of 114 files, the Title agents discovery, review and analysis process uncovered 585 matters that needed to be addressed or cured prior to being able to transfer a marketable title.

Left unresolved, any of these 585 matters could have resulted in the transfer of a defective title to real property and, therefore, could have resulted in a claim under the Title insurance policy.

36

Page 37: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

Based upon our review of the sample, we concluded that 70% of the Title insurance cost on HUD-1s would meet the P&C definitions of allocated or unallocated loss adjustment expense.

The estimated loss adjustment expense of 70% does NOT include the losses expected to be paid by the Title underwriter. In Louisiana, the Title insurance loss ratio would represent an additional 8% of Title insurance premium.

To estimate the expenses that were considered loss adjustment expenses, we apportioned the costs associated with Section 1100 of the HUD-1, Title insurance expenses, according to the following allocation process:

37

Page 38: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

38

Page 39: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

39

Page 40: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

Lieutenant Governor’s Task Force in Florida

Page 41: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

Given the retrospective nature of a Title insurance policy, appreciable loss adjustment expense – unallocated and allocated – must be expended PRIOR to policy issuance. This effort identifies and resolves claims that would otherwise occur absent the analysis.

Unfortunately, current financial reporting requirements are based upon the prospective nature of P&C policies, thereby overstating the Title expense ratio and understating the Title loss adjustment expense ratio applicable to Title insurance.

Page 42: June 2011. Demotech, Inc. will become the leading provider of innovative solutions to financial analysis issues by focusing our resources on niches presenting

Title insurance coverage is retrospective from the policy’s effective date and remains in force throughout the term of a loan or the ownership of real property. Policies are issued when the Title insurance professional has addressed the issues associated with the marketability of title, i.e. matters have been identified, addressed or resolved.

In contrast, P&C insurance coverage is prospective, utilizing a finite future period with a definitive expiration date, to provide coverage for covered incidents that arise during the term of the policy. Events occurring prior to the effective date or subsequent to that date are excluded.

The coverage timeframe differential in conjunction with a misunderstanding of Title insurance cost containment activities are not reflected in reporting requirements – financial or statistical. As a result, the value proposition of Title insurance is not properly presented or captured by regulatory authorities.