it takes a village - arizona state university · it takes a village collaborating with traditional...
TRANSCRIPT
It Takes a Village
Collaborating with traditional and non-traditional resources
to reduce DWI’s in our community
AADCPApril, 26 2016
It Takes A Village
Mark StodolaProbation Fellow
American Probation and Parole AssociationKrista Forster
Program SpecialistArizona Administrative Office of the Courts
Course Objectives
Participants will• Identify the most effective tools in the supervision of DWI Offenders
• Determine treatment/program gaps in your community
• Identify and prioritize traditional and non-traditional community resources
• Identify strategies to promote collaboration and enhance community resources
What’s the problem?
•In 2011, there were 1.2 million drivers arrested for driving under the influence
• In 2014 there were 9,967 alcohol related traffic fatalities.
• 94 million drunk driving episodes in 2013
Arizona DWI Fatalities
Alcohol-Impaired Driving
Fatalities (BAC=.08+)
*
2010
206
2011
212
2012
230
2013
219
2014
199
Arizona DWI Fatalities
Other Arizona Statistics
• DWI fatalities represent 26% of all traffic fatalities in Arizona. National average is 31%
• Alcohol related crash injuries-3,480 (2013)• DWI Arrests- 26,843• DWI Convictions- Not available • Tax payer subsidy of fatalities- $1 billion • 74% of alc. Fatalities had .15% BAC• 5 time offenders- Not available
GOOD NEWS!
•Two Thirds of DWI Offenders self correct!
4,751,400 individuals under community supervision in 2013
15% of this probation population have been convicted of DWIs
8% of the probation population have been convicted of multiple DWIs
Impaired drivers:Who ends up on a supervised probation
caseload?
• High risk drunk drivers who drive with a high BAC level of .15 or above, with more than one drunk driving arrest
• Highly resistant to changing their behavior despite previous sanctions, treatment or education efforts.
• Less than five percent of these drivers account for about 80 percent of the impaired driving episodes
Unique challenges to supervising these impaired drivers?
• Don’t identify with being a criminal• Criminal history includes prior non alcohol related convictions
• White males late 20’s to early 30’s
• Low level of education
Unique challenges
Unemployed/Under-employed
Unmarried
More Hostile
33% of males, 50% of females have a psychiatric disorder
What challenges do you have with DWI Offenders?
What works in the Supervision of Impaired Drivers (and does your community have what works?)
Assessments•Alcohol Risk Assessment Instruments
• ADS (Alcohol Dependence Scale)• ASUDS-R (Adult Substance Use and Driving Survey – Revised)• ASI (Alcohol Severity Index)• AUDIT (Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Test)• IDTS (Inventory Drug-Taking Situations)• DAST (Drug Abuse Screening Test)• LSI-R (Level of Service Inventory-Revised)• MAST (Michigan Alcoholism Screening Test)• SASSI (Substance Abuse Subtle Screening Inventory)• RIASI (Research Institute on Addiction Self Inventory)• IDA (Impaired Driver Assessment)• CARS (Computerized Assessment and Referral System)
Supervision that:
•Places focus on the person, not the charge
•Addresses criminogenic needs•The Big Four•The Next Four
The Big Four
Criminogenic Need Response
History of anti-social behavior Build non-criminal alternative behaviors to risky situations
Anti-social personality Build problem solving, self management, anger management, and coping skills
Anti-social cognition Reduce anti-social cognition, recognize risky thinking and feelings, adopt an alternative identity
Anti-social companions Reduce association with criminals, enhance contact with pro-social
Source: Ed Latessa, Ph.D.
The Next Four
Criminogenic Need Response
Family and/or marital Reduce conflict, build positive relationships and communication, enhance monitoring/supervision
Substance abuse Reduce usage, reduce the supports for abuse behavior, enhance alternatives to abuse
School and/or work Enhance performance rewards and satisfaction
Leisure and/or recreation Enhance involvement and satisfaction in pro-social activities
Source: Ed Latessa, Ph.D.
2 factors for behavioral change…..
•Time
•Interventions
Supervision that: includes Technology
• Ignition Interlock•Transdermal Alcohol Devices•Mobile Alcohol Monitoring Technology
Supervision and collaboration
• DWI Courts • Community based alcohol treatment• Detox programs• Mental health treatment• Motivational Interviewing• Medication Assisted Treatment (MAT)• Community based support
• 12 step groups• Rational Recovery
Other Considerations for Success
•Employment•Transportation•Housing•Re-entry•Transitional living/halfway house
Law Enforcement/Probation
Treatment
Social Services
Family Therapy
Government Agencies/Officials
Mentoring Programs Faith CommunityArts
Health
Housing
LiteracyPrograms
Service Organizations
Schools/Colleges/Universities
Recreational/Libraries
Employment/Job Training
Mental Health Services
Community BasedOrganizations
CommunityFoundations
Businesses
Community Map
CLIENT
Challenges getting from here to there…
•Treatment Limitations•Community indifference •High Caseloads•Difficult population for empathy
Challenges getting from here to there
•Costs associated with offense• Court fines• Probation Service Fees• Attorney Fees• Increase in insurance rates• Ignition Interlock or other technologies• Treatment• Court program costs• Transportation costs after license suspension
• Average costs-$300-$500 a month
What’s your wish list to improve success with DWI
Offenders?
How can we engage the community?
DANCIN DUDE
Community and Treatment Mapping: Getting to know your community
Community/Treatment Mapping•What is the purpose:
•What’s out there?•Are there gaps in service?•Are services being provided that meet the needs of specific counties?
•Are providers using Evidence Based Practices?•What are the barriers to treatment?•How can probation departments find the right provider?
•Appropriate funding sources•Assumptions
What are the characteristics of your town, community or neighborhood?
Decide if your community would be considered urban, rural or somewhere in between according to your
understanding of the terms.
Rural Healthcare• In many rural areas, low population is combined with a lack of health services, poverty, underserved areas and geographic isolation.
• Transportation issues such as distance, topography, and lack of mass transit
Urban Healthcare• In many urban areas, there are too many choices. • “Favorites”• Difficulty finding the most appropriate treatment
Service gaps
•Consistency (staff, funding, participants)•Lack of treatment programs (IOP, residential, detox, in-patient acute care facility)
•Access to treatment/Geographical challenges•Specialty services (ie. DV, DUI, Sex Offender)
•Statutorily mandated services •Emergency Housing/Homeless Shelters•Sober Support/12 step meetings
How can we engage the community?
Arm yourself with great information!
• Understand the problem and the need • Gap analysis• Statistical analysis
• Look at the # of DWI’s• Where do I get this????
• Look at DWI trends• How many are on probation?• What is their violation rate?• Talk to treatment providers. What do they see as needs?• Understand the research on what works
Discuss Facts!• # of DWI’s• What research shows with this population• Rate of recidivism/Cost of Incarceration• Need in community with research support Cost of DWI’s on community
BROWARD COUNTY FLORIDA DWI’s 2013
VIOL GROUP
CRIMINAL
FHP CityPD ShrfDept Other
* TotalViol Guilty
PD CivilP
Adj w/h Judge
NotGuilty Dism NollPros
TotaDisp
DispPend
DUI 310 1,757 1,885 22 3,974 1,653 1 90 36 26 1,101 2,907 1,067
TOTALS 310 1,757 1,885 22 3,974 1,653 1 90 36 26 1,101 2,907 1,067
PERCENTAGES 8% 44% 47% 1% 100% 57% 0% 3% 1% 1% 38% 73% 27%
GRAND TOTALS
GRAND TOTALS 310 1,757 1,885 22 3,974 1,653 1 90 36 26 1,101 2,907 1,067
PERCENTAGES 8% 44% 47% 1% 100% 57% 0% 3% 1% 1% 38% 73% 27%
FLORIDA UNIFORM TRAFFIC CITATION STATISTICS VIOLATIONS AND DISPOSITIONS MADE DURING PERIOD 01/2013- 12/2013COUNTY TOTAL BROWARD
DISPOSITION OF VIOLATIONS, INCLUDING THOSE REDUCED OR CHANGED
WHAT THE COMMUNITY NEEDS TO REMEMBER ABOUT OUR
DWI POPULATION?
•They are part of our community•They are not going anywhere•Punishment alone does not change behaviors
Focus on the Issue!
Who is giving the message? Who needs to be at the table?
Who is your audience? (traditional)
• Courts• Governing authorities• Treatment providers• Treatment oversight (RBHA)• Law enforcement• Corrections• Federal authorities• Governor’s Office of Highway Safety
Who is your audience?(community based)
•12 Step Groups•Faith based Treatment•MADD•SADD•Victims
Who is your audience?(non-traditional)
• Who are the points of light in your community • Churches• Local Businesses
• depending on what you are asking for• Neighborhood groups• Animal Clubs• Community leaders
NEXT STEPS – ACTION
•Developing an Action Plan• Implementing an Action Plan
Developing your elevator speech
Final Thoughts-If not you, then who?
SUMMARY
•Understand the problem (Get the facts!)
•Understand what works•Understand your community gaps/needs
•Lead and Collaborate!
“Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed, citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has.” ― Margaret Mead
Resources
American Probation and Parole Association-http://www.appa-net.org/eweb/
National Highway Traffic Safety Administration-http://www.nhtsa.gov/
Traffic Injury Research Foundation-http://www.tirf.ca/index.php
National Center for DWI Courts http://www.dwicourts.org/
?????????????????