ippc licence reg. no. p0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up...

46
West Offaly Power Generating Station IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 Annual Environmental Report For the period of 1 st Jan 2010 to 31 st Dec 2010

Upload: others

Post on 16-May-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

West Offaly Power Generating Station

IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01

Annual Environmental Report

For the period of 1st Jan 2010 to 31st Dec 2010

Page 2: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 2

Table of Contents

Page No.

1. Introduction.....................................................................................................3 1.1 IPPC licence number .......................................................................................3 1.2 Name and Location of site ...............................................................................3 1.3 Description of Activities ....................................................................................3 1.4 Environmental Policy and Key Objectives .......................................................4 1.5 Environmental Management Structure and Responsibility ............................ 5/6

2. Summary Information Jan – Dec 2010 .........................................................7 2.1 Emissions to Water ..........................................................................................7 2.2 Outfall Drain from Holding Lagoon at Ash Disposal Facility (ADF)..................9 2.3 Annual Toxicity Results ....................................................................................9 2.4 Groundwater Monitoring Results.....................................................................10 2.4.1 Annual Groundwater Results .................................................................10 2.4.2 Quarterly Groundwater Results..............................................................11 2.5 Metals in Peat Ash ..........................................................................................11 2.6 Emissions to Water – Non Compliance Summary..........................................12 2.7 Emissions to Atmosphere ...............................................................................13 2.7.1 Summary of Emissions to Atmosphere………………………… ...........13 2.7.2 Emissions to Atmosphere – Non Compliance Summary……… ............13 2.8 Waste Management Report………………………………………………............14 2.9 Energy and Water Consumption………………………………………. ...........17 2.10 Environmental Incidents, Complaints and Queries…………………… ............18 2.10.1 Complaints Summary ......................................................................18 2.10.2 Incidents Summary ..........................................................................18

3. Management of the activity ......................................................................... 19 3.1 Objectives and Targets 2010 ......................................................................... 19 3.2 Environmental Management Programme 2011 ............................................. 19 3.3 Pollution Emission Register (PRTR) Proposal 2010 and Future Years......... .23 3.3.1 Methodology for determination of Mass Emissions…………………… ......... 23

3.3.2 PER Report for 2010 ...................................................................................... .24 4.0 Licence Specific Reports ............................................................................ 25

4.1 Noise Monitoring Reports............................................................................... 25 4.2 Underground Tanks and Pipelines…………………………………… .......... 25 4.3 Report on List I and List II Substance Reductions…………………… ......... 25 4.4 Energy Efficiency Audit Report Summary...................................................... 25 4.5 Review of Environmental Liabilities Insurance Cover .................................... 26 4.6 Groundwater Monitoring................................................................................. 26 4.7 Bund Testing……………………………………………………………… .......... 26 4.8 Annual Landfill Status Report......................................................................... 27 4.9 Auxiliary Boilers.............................................................................................. 27 4.10 Total annual Emissions of SO2, NO2 and CO.2 & Particulates ................... 28 4.11 Fuel Use and Energy Input Summary............................................................ 28

Appendix 1 Map of Sampling Locations ..............................................................29 Appendix 2 Noise Survey 2010...............................................................................31

Page 3: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 3

1. Introduction

1.1 IPPC Licence Number IPPCL P0611-01

1.2 Name and Location

Electricity Supply Board West Offaly Power Shannonbridge Co Offaly.

1.3 Description of Activities

The production of energy in a combustion plant, which has a rated thermal input greater than 50 MW. West Offaly Power is one of two new peat stations and construction commenced in the Summer of 2002 with a commercial operation date (COD) of 27-1-2005. West Offaly Power station has one unit, consisting of a boiler, turbine and auxiliary plant, with an electricity generating capacity of 150MWe. The boiler operates on peat with gas oil used for start up. It is scheduled to burn approximately 1,245,000 tonnes of peat each year. Note: This report covers Environmental activities for the period of January 2010 to December 2010. The station is still operating under the construction warranty period. The contractor – Foster Wheeler and ESB concluded an agreement in December 2008 to implement in 2011 a permanent solution to the long standing corrosion problems The station will have a major outage in 2011 for 23 weeks after which the station will operate under the terms of the Corrosion Remediation Agreement and Warranty. Biomass The station conducted a number of handling trials throughout 2010 with the primary biomass, being a composition of the following biomass; sawdust ,woodchip, miscanthus and willow. In November the station completed a combustion trial on sawdust and woodchip. All details are held in the station and recorded for the purposes of Co2 verification and were done so with the conjunction of both OEE and GHG divisions of the EPA. Total Running Hrs 2010 Run Hours for 2010 was a total of 8136 hrs, which is slightly elevated in comparison to 2009 run hours as seen below in the Table. 2009 had a reduced running requirement, which was due to the flood conditions experienced in Qtr 4 which resulted in large stockpiles of peat being lost to the floods as well as railway line becoming impassable and a restriction on fuel supply occurred . The elevated run hours of 2010 could be a result of a number of factors including the cold weather conditions experienced both in early and late 2010 which resulted in reduced wind generation ensuring more thermal plant running and at higher loads due to considerable demand. Table of Total Running Hrs from 2005- 2010

Year Total Run hrs for Station

2010 8136 2009 7249 2008 7335 2007 5326 2006 4607 2005 6631

Page 4: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 4

1.4 West Offaly Power Environmental Policy and Key Objectives.

West Offaly Power Generating Station is part of ESB Power Generation Business Unit. It exports approximately 137 Megawatts of electricity produced from steam generation plant burning peat and uses gas oil for start up. The station is located on the east bank of the River Shannon in an area of significant environmental importance. Environmental monitoring demonstrates that the operation of West Offaly Power does not have a significant impact on the environment.

It is the policy at West Offaly Power Generating Station to operate our facilities in a safe, efficient and environmentally responsible manner. In doing so we will:

• Define clear accountabilities and responsibilities for the management and operation of all environmental protection systems.

• Actively promote environmental awareness among all staff through communication and training programs.

• Integrate environmental concerns into all decision making and planning at the earliest stage.

• Ensure and demonstrate compliance with applicable permits, licences and relevant legal requirements, in particular Integrated Pollution Prevention and Control Licence No P0611-01.

• Ensure all significant risks are identified, evaluated and reduced to a minimum and the necessary plans and programmes are in place to minimise or eliminate potential impacts including those arising from emergency incidents.

• Put in place systems to reduce waste production and to monitor and ensure the safe disposal of all residual wastes.

• Have regard for the concerns of neighbours and other stakeholders.

• Recognise the need for special sensitivity in all operations arising from the station's location adjacent to the River Shannon, in an area of significant tourist and amenity value.

• Encourage good environmental practices from suppliers of goods and services.

• Achieve and maintain ISO 14001:2004 certification.

• Review our environmental policy and practices on an ongoing basis, to take cognisance of changes in technology and regulations.

• Minimise the consumption of energy, water and other process raw materials.

• Acknowledge the impact of peat extraction and to influence our fuel supplier towards optimum environmental management of that resource.

• Audit and review the environmental performance of the station at regular intervals and adjust our policy, procedures, objectives and practices in the light of findings and experience.

WOP will set and update appropriate targets on a regular basis in order to deliver the above objectives and ensure continuous improvement in environmental performance.

Originally Issued : Date: 27-5-‘05

Revised : 28-8-‘08

Signed: Station Manager

Page 5: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 5

1.5 Environmental Management Structure and Responsibility Environmental Management is fully integrated into all aspects of management on site. The management structure is shown in Figure 1.1. Those marked in green have a significant environmental role within the station. The Station Chemist is the Environmental Co-ordinator and is responsible for the co-ordination and management of all environmental activity at the station. The Environmental Co-ordinator works with the management team and environmental management group (EMG) to ensure that

• the station complies with or improves on the requirements of any environmental provisions specified under its IPPC licence, other licences, planning permission and environmental legislation.

• the station’s EMS is operated and maintained to the required standard.

• by way of audit and management review, the EMS is effective, is adaptive to changing circumstances and is delivering continuous improvement.

Page 6: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 6

Figure Figure 1.1 Organisation Chart

Pat O’ Doherty

Executive Director

Jerry McKenna

Station Manager

Eimear Dennehy

Station Chemist/Environmental Coordinator

Tom Hanrahan

Production Manager

Patrick Grogan

Civil Engineer

Una Clarke

Station Financial Officer/Hr Manager

Brian Flynn

Technical Services Team Leader

Maintenance Team

Leader

Operations Team

Leaders

Chemical Team

Leader

Technical Services

Jimmy Farrell

Commercial /Financial

Team Leader

Commercial/

Financial

Page 7: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 7

2. Summary Information : Jan – Dec 2010 2.1 Emissions to Water ESB West Offaly Power has 3 licensed emission points discharging to the River Shannon. The following 2 have a common emission point

• PS-SW1 Condenser Cooling Water

• PS-SW2 Screen Wash Water The following 2 also have a common emission point

• PS-SW3 Treated Sewage Effluent

• PS-SW7 Surface Water Drainage (2) Finally, the following 3 have a common emission point

• PS-SW4 Boiler Blow-down

• PS-SW5 Water Treatment Effluent

• PS-SW6 Surface Water Drainage (1) However, each of the above discharges has individual sampling points Monitoring of these emission points is carried out in accordance with Schedule 2(iii) of West Offaly Power IPPC license P0611-01.A summary of the monitoring results for mass emissions to water at each of the above emission points is presented in the tables below.

Ref Point : PS-SW1 & PS-SW2 – Condenser Cooling Water & Screen Wash Water

Parameter Licensed Mass Emission Annually kg

Results for 2010 Annually mg/l

Results for 2009 Annually Mg/l

Temperature Not specified 95% of discharges < 8 ºC and 100% < 10 ºC

95% of discharges < 8 ºC and 100% < 10 ºC

Chlorine 0.1mg/l Cl not being used Cl not being used

Thermal Load 186 MWth (max) Full Compliance Full Compliance Volume m3 219,000,000 203,400,000 181,225,000 Discussion : Sodium Hypochlorite is not to prevent condenser fouling in the station, instead the station uses a taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage Treatment Effluent 2010 Licensed Mass

Emission kg

Average Conc 2010 mg/l

Average Conc 2009 mg/l

Temp C 25 13.5 14.5

BOD mg/l 20 1.1 1.3

SS mg/l 30 4 14 pH 6-9 6-9 6-9

Page 8: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 8

Discussion: All quarterly figures were within the IPPCL emission limit values and similar to trends of 2009. Ref Point: PS-SW4 Boiler Blowdown prior to dilution with surface water

Parameter Licensed Mass Emissions Annually kg

Mass Emissions 2010 annually

Mass Emissions 2009 annually

Flow Not given 10-17t/hr 10 -17 t/hr

Orthophospate (PO4) 2 Not being used Not being used Ammonia (kg) 25.5 1.0 1.0

Volume (m3) 43,800 390 390 Hydrazine 0.37 Not being used Not being used Discussion; We do not dose phosphate into the station drum, hence there is no requirement to measure this parameter. Hydrazine is not dosed into the feed water as the station operates on a chemical regime of OT oxygenated treatment, therefore we no to monitor this parameter. Figures for 2010 are largely inline with 2009 and all parameters are within the stated IPPCL emission limit values Ref Point : PS-SW5 Neutralised Water Treatment Effluent ( prior to dilution with surface water) Parameter Licensed Mass

Emissions ( kg) annually

Average Conc 2010 (mg/l)

Mass Emissions (kg) 2010 annually

pH 6 – 8.5 7.65 7.5-7.8

Total Dissolved Solids

3,285,000 6,158 674.3

Mineral Oil mg/l Not given 1 101.7

SS mg/l 3,285 11 1144

Ammonia (as N) 21.9 0.2 21.6

Volume (m3) 109,500 2148m3 25,780m3 Discussion ; All values are within the stated ELV limits for PS-SW5

PS-SW3

1 1

2.3

1

6

2

6

2

15

17

14

8

0.5

2 2 2

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

1 2 3 4

Qua r t e r 2 0 10

BOD

SS

Temp

Flow

Page 9: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 9

Ref Point : PS-SW6 Surface Water (1) Parameter Licensed

Emissions Average Concentration (mg/l)

Average Conc 2010 (mg/l)

Average Conc 2009 (mg/l)

Average Conc 2008 (mg/l)

pH 6 – 8.5 8.25 8.1 7.6 – 8.4

Conductivity Not given 562 590 Total Dissolved Solids

Not given 420 343 624

Mineral Oil (µg/l) Not given <10 <10 < 10

SS Not given 4.25 17.3 < 10

Ammonia (as N) Not given 0.225 0.7 < 0.2

BOD Not given 1.475 12.1 < 3

Oil, fats & greases Not given <1 <1 < 1

Total Nitrogen Not given 2.5 6

Ref Point : PS-SW7 Surface Water (2) Parameter Licensed Emissions

Average Concentration (mg/l)

Average Conc 2010 (mg/l)

Average Conc 2009 (mg/l)

Average Conc(mg/l) 2008

pH 6 – 8.5 8.325 8.1 pH = 7.5 - 8

Conductivity Us/cm

Us/cm 595 827

Total Dissolved Solids

Not given 480 342 325

Mineral Oil (µg/l) Not given 10 <10 < 10 SS Not given 2.5 6 < 10

Ammonia (as N) Not given 0.2025 0.3 < 0.2 BOD Not given 1.6 1.3 < 3

Oil, fats & greases

Not given 1 4 < 1

Total N Not given 1.975 3

Discussion: Values for PS-SW6 and PS-SW7 are similar to 2009 trends.

2.2 Outfall Drain from Holding Lagoon at Ash Disposal Facility: ADF-SW1: There is no leachate from the ADF being sent to the leachate lagoon. All leachate is recycled onto the ADF to condition the ash and to minimise dust emission. This was confirmed by the Agency during site visits.

2.3 Toxicity PS-SW5 Neutralised Water Treatment Plant Results There was no requirement issued by the EPA in 2010 to conduct any toxicology testing after testing occurred in 2009, results of which can be seen below. Parameter Test Species Limits 2009 Results

Toxicity Daphnia Magna 10 TU 1.5 TU Vibrio Fischeri 10 TU <2.2 TU

Page 10: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 10

2.4 Groundwater Monitoring Results 2.4 1 Annual Groundwater Monitoring

• Station: PS-GW1 & PS-GW2

• Ash Disposal Facility (ADF): ADF–GW3, ADF-GW4, ADF-GW5, ADF-GW6

2010

Parameter PS-GW1

PS-GW2

ADF-GW3

ADF-GW4

ADF-GW5

ADF-GW6

Al (µg/l) <3 1 9 8 6 <0.4

As (µg/l) 5 8 3 1.4 6 0.4

Mo (µg/l) 1 0.6 0.5 <1 2.7 1

Fe (µg/l) <0.02 <0.02 0.1 0.16 0.06 2

Cd (µg/l) 0.2 <0.1 0.3 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1

Se (µg/l) 9 13 1 1 6 <0.4

Cu (µg/l) 1 1 1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1

Ni (µg/l) 3 2 2.5 1.7 5.5 2

Zn (µg/l) 50 12 39 118 31 10

Chloride mg/l 23 82 13 74 10 12

Hydrocarbons (µg/l)

1.1 1.1 3.3 3.3 3.3 3.3

Ammonia (N) mg/l (Avg)

0.2 7.6 0.55 2.9 2.5 1.8

Conductivity us/cm (Avg)

692 1036 312 682 490 535

pH (Avg) 7.8 7.5 8.1 8.0 8.1 8.1

2009

Parameter PS-GW1

PS-GW2

ADF-GW3

ADF-GW4

ADF-GW5

ADF-GW6

Al (µg/l) <2 14 <2 4 <2 <2

As (µg/l) 4 6 4 4 4 2

Mo (µg/l) <1 <1 <1 1 2 <1

Fe (µg/l) 47 99 249 200 116 80

Cd (µg/l) <0.4 <0.4 <0.4 <0.4 <0.4 <0.4

Se (µg/l) 15 17 12 10 7 6

Cu (µg/l) 3 3 3 4 4 2

Ni (µg/l) 14 2 1 1 9 1

Zn (µg/l) 16 15 15 46 38 6

Chloride mg/l 29 96 15 23 14 12

Hydrocarbons (µg/l)

<10 <10 <10 <10 <10 <10

Ammonia (N) mg/l

<0.2 8.7 0.9 2.5 5.3 3.9

Conductivity 804 1271 330 600 652 661

pH 7.6 7.6 7.5 7.4 7.6 7.4

Avg= Average of the quarterly results, if you wish to review quarterly figures See section 2.4.2

Page 11: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 11

2.4.2 Quarterly Groundwater Monitoring

PS –GW1 PS-GW 2

2010 NH4 mg/l N

TPH mg/l

Cl mg/l

NH4 mg/l N

TPH mg/l

Cl mg/l

Qtr 1 <0.2 1 26 8.5 1 98

Qtr 2 <0.2 1.2 35 9.8 1.2 89

Qtr 3 <0.2 1 12 6.9 1 73

Qtr 4 <0.2 1 17 5.5 1 66

ADF- GW3 ADF-GW4

2010 NH4 mg/l N

TPH mg/l

Cl mg/l

NH4 mg/l N

TPH mg/l

Cl mg/l

Qtr 1 0.6 10 12 2.3 10 10

Qtr 2 1.2 1 14 2.6 1 10

Qtr 3 <0.2 1 12 3.6 1 9

Qtr 4 <0.2 1 15 3.2 1 9

ADF –GW5 ADF-GW 6

2010 NH4 mg/l N

TPH mg/l

Cl mg/l

NH4 mg/l N

TPH mg/l

Cl mg/l

Qtr 1 1.9 10 10 2.1 10 12

Qtr 2 3.5 1 10 2.3 1 12

Qtr 3 2 1 9 2.5 1 12

Qtr 4 2.5 1 9 0.2 1 12

*:NS= No sample. As stated in Quarter 4 reports, no samples from the ADF could be taken due to flooding and hazardous conditions.

2.5 Metals in Peat Ash, based on Quarterly Results

2010 Peat Ash mg/kg 2009 Peat Ash mg/Kg

Parameter Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4

pH 11.4 12 11.9 12.5 11.9 11.6 10.7 12.6

Al 9700 9060 9250 8810 8234 8980 9250 8280

As 27 35 24 25 32 18 27 43

Fe 28200 16000 19700 16000 11730 13400 25200 24600

Cd <0.2 0.8 0.9 0.8 <0.5 0.4 0.6 0.6

Ca 204000 105000 110000 146000 62760 98800 120000 128000

Cu 18 10 20 20 12 9 21 16

Ni 33 24 23 23 12 21 26 33

Zn 57 48 46 47 48 40 52 69

Se 7 6 15 11 <0.5 6 8 5

Mo 5 5 7 3 3 2 4 5

Page 12: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 12

2.6 Emissions to Water Non-Compliance Summary:

Date Source NC Cause Corrective Action

2010 Full compliance

Page 13: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 13

2.7 Emissions to Atmosphere

There are two IPPC licensed air emissions points at ESB West Offaly Power: PS-A1, Boiler Stack and PS- A2: Auxiliary Boiler.

Table 2.7.1: Summary of Emissions to Atmosphere for 2010

Emission

Point

NOx

(tonnes)

SOx

(tonnes)

Particulates

(tonnes)

CO2

Emitted tonnes Calculated

From fuel use

PS-A1

790 44.6 44.32 1,126,302

PS-A2

0.3* 1.4* - -

Note: It was agreed with the Agency that due to the very intermittent operation of the auxiliary boiler it is not

good environmental practice to operate the boiler for a number of days in order that a test be carried out. These values are calculated based on hours run and 0.1% sulphur in gas oil

• Total Run hours for WOP in 2010 was 8136hrs.

Table 2.7.2: Emissions to Atmosphere Non-compliance Summary

Year Date Non-compliance Cause Corrective Action

Aug Nox breach of the ELV 227mg/Nm3V 200mg/Nm3

Station tripped causing elevated Nox Values.

Briefing note issued to Operations in relation to the ELV and low load running

2010

Nov Nox breach of the ELV 206mg/Nm3 V 200mg/Nm3

Fault on the LP bypass lead to large swings in load which generated unstable conditions in the boiler resulting in elevated Nox levels for periods of both high and low load

Repair of LP bypass valve

Table 2.7.3 Emissions to Atmosphere Incident Summary

Year Date Non-compliance Cause Corrective Action

March CEMS Malfunction Faulty connection with probe and analyser

OEM contractor reset equipment to clear fault

Nov CEMS Malfunction Change over to new software and hardware CEMS system resulted in some data being lost

None required- changeover error

2010

Dec CEMS Malfunction Low flow in sample line during auto calibration which never cleared itself resulted in loss of data for a period

Briefing note issued to all Operations staff on auto calibrations and alarms

Page 14: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 14

2.8 Waste Management Report West Offaly Power

Summary of Waste Information for 2010

Summary of Waste Information for 2010

Item Tonnes

Total quantity of waste produced in 2010 47,013.6

total quantity of waste disposed of on-site 46321.18

total quantity of waste disposed of off-site 30.456

total quantity of waste recovered on-site 660.82

total quantity of waste recovered off-site 15.437

Quantity of non-hazardous waste produced in 2010 47002.63

quantity of non-hazardous waste disposed of on-site 46321

quantity of non-hazardous waste disposed of off-site 14.909

quantity of non-hazardous waste recovered on-site 660.82

quantity of non-hazardous waste recovered off-site 5.721

Quantity of hazardous waste produced in 2010 9.826

quantity of hazardous waste disposed of on-site 0

quantity of hazardous waste disposed of off-site 0.11

quantity of hazardous waste recovered on-site 0

quantity of hazardous waste recovered off-site 9.716

Page 15: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 15

Information on each Waste stream for 2010 (Non-Hazardous)

Carrier / Transporter Ultimate Disposal / Recovery European

Waste

Catalogue

Code

Hazardous

(Yes/No)

Description*

(Sample of wastes types listed below -

use/delete as applicable & add required waste

streams)

Quantity

(tonnes)

Disposal /

Reuse /

Recycling Name & Permit Details Location Name & Permit Details

10 01 99 No Fuel Debris 3190.00 D1 Bord na Mona IPPCL No 502 Blackwater, Co Offaly Bord na Mona IPPCL No 502

17 05 04 No Stones/Sand 661.00 R5 Bord na Mona IPPCL No 502 Blackwater, Co Offaly Bord na Mona IPPCL No 502

10 01 01 No Bottom Ash 5381.00 D1 Bord na Mona IPPCL No 502 Blackwater, Co Offaly Bord na Mona IPPCL No 502

10 01 03 No Fly Ash 37750.00 D1 Bord na Mona IPPCL No 502 Blackwater, Co Offaly Bord na Mona IPPCL No 502

15 01 06 No Mixed Dry Recyclables 2.301 R5

AES, WCP-0Y-08--601-01/ W0104-02 Tullamore

Failand Paper Services, Bristol, Uk

20 03 01 No

General Waste (food waste, canteen waste, Commerical) 14.909 D1

AES, WCP-0Y-08--601-01/ W0104-02 Tullamore

Drehid WMF WO201-02

17 02 01 No Timber 3.420 R1 AES 053(2)/OY/351/06 Tullamore AES Waste Licence 104-01/ Conroy Recycling

Total Non Hazardous Waste Volume: 47,003 tonnes

Page 16: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 16

Information on each Waste stream for 2010 (Hazardous)

Carrier / Transporter Ultimate Disposal / Recovery European

Waste

Catalogue

Code

Hazardous

(Yes/No)

Description*

(Sample of wastes types listed below -

use/delete as applicable & add required waste

streams)

Quantity

(tonnes)

Disposal /

Reuse /

Recycling Name & Permit Details Location Name & Permit Details

13 08 02* Yes Oil- Liquid 9.040 R1 ENVA Portlaoise WCP -DC-08-116-01/WO184-1 Ireland Enva, Port Laoise ,W0184-1

15 02 02* Yes Oil - Solid 0.380 R1 ENVA Portlaoise WCP -DC-08-116-01/WO184-1 Germany Lindenschimdt KG, E97095037

15 02 02* Yes Oil Filters 0.11 D10 ENVA Portlaoise WCP -DC-08-116-16/WO184-1 Germany KWA ,E17012100

15 01 10* Yes Oil Drums 0.05 R5 ENVA ,WO184-1 WCP-DC-08-1116-01 Ireland

Leinster Environmentals, Louth. WP 2008/06

16 06 06* Yes Potassium Chromate 0.006 R1 ENVA ,WO184-1 WCP-DC-08-1116-01 Germany Lindenschimdt KG, E97095037

15 01 10* Yes Paint Tins 0.240 R3 ENVA Portlaoise WCP -DC-08-116-16/WO184-1 Germany Nehlsen, Bremen, D33300040

Total Hazardous Waste :9.826 tonnes

Page 17: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 17

2.9 Energy and Water Consumption

Energy Consumption

Year Peat (tonnes) Gas Oil (tonnes) House Load MWhrs 2010 1,274,900 697 115,566

2009 1,256,824 1182 105,158

2008 1,235,992 748 117,979

Biomass trials Trials were conducted on the following types of Biomass in 2010; Woodchip, willow, Miscanthus and Sawdust. Combustion trials only occurred in Woodchip/Sawdust with A 60:40 ratio of biomass product during the month of November Total volume of biomass: 8,384.78tonnes with an average NCV of 6.497tj/KTonne as reported in the 2010 AIER. The combustion trials accounted for approx 6,748.45 tonnes of the mixture of woodchip and sawdust. Only handling trials occurred on the other listed biomass above. Energy Generated MWhrs

Year MW hrs Generated MWhrs Exported 2010 1,073,069 960,381

2009 1,001,689 892,343

2008 1,069,941 951,962

Total run hours for 2009 was 7249 hours. Water Consumption m

3

Year Domestic Water Usage Other Plant Operation

Total

2010 25,000 0* 120,000 145,000

2009 1,300 0* **100,800 102,100

2008 2,100 0* **107,250 109,350

Note: *this is water used mainly in the DeSox plant for SO2 removal and the DeSOx was not in operation in 2009 or in 2010 ** this is water used solely for make-up to the steam/water cycle Comments; It was discovered that incorrect readings of the county council water meter for the site, had resulted in the county council providing incorrect consumptions figures for the previous years. Upon discovering this issue, we engaged in a programme of water surveys and repairs over several weeks in conjunction with the water services department of the county council. We discovered three major leaks and repaired them reducing consumption figures from approx 100m3/day down to 20m3/day. We have since installed water meters on site in addition to the county council water meter, which tracks consumption and plots consumption every half hour as an aid to identify the potential for future leaks. Water consumption reduction is also one of the five main targets in 2011.

Page 18: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 18

2.10 Environmental Incidents and Complaints 2.10.1 Complaints Summary

Year Date Complaint Corrective Action

2010

Jan Noise High pitched noise coming from a tail roller from a fuel belt in the screening room in the BNM site section during cold weather. Several maintenance programs were engaged to reduce the noise- however the noise remained intermittent. A specialist noise monitoring survey was conducted in this area- it was determined the problem was known as “Squeal Noise”. It occurs when there are relatively large bearings used under a radial load. Squeal noise is most likely to occur in winter with cold weather conditions. Since the complaint the station has ensured that the door to the screening room remains closed throughout the day and night. No complaints have occurred since this measure was taken.

2.10.2 Incidents Summary

Please note Section 2.7.3 Emissions to atmosphere Incident summary, where their was three CEMS malfunctions for 2010.

Page 19: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 19

3.0 Management of the Activity The EMP is reviewed quarterly by the station’s management team and status of objectives is discussed and noted. 3.1 Environmental Management Program (Objectives and Targets) 2010 In Table 3.1 is a summary of the progress on the 15 objectives in the EMP for 2010. Three of these objectives will be rolled over to 2011 Targets and Objectives. 3.2 Environmental Management Program (Objectives and Targets) 2011 In Table 3.2 is a summary of the progress on 5 objectives in the EMP for 2011

Page 20: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 20

Table 3.1 West Offaly Summary Programme 2010

Objective Number Objective Summary 2010

Management Group Responsible

Status

2010/01 Investigate utilising heated water at the CW outfall and Settlement pond to provide heat to the station

• Energy saving

Production Manager/ Sustainability Coordinator/ Moneypoint Environmental Co-ordinator

Not a viable project due to excessive cost

2010/02 Investigate harnessing the flow energy at the CW outfall using a marine turbine and supply the station with an alternative energy source that is environmentally friendly

• To conserve energy

Production Manager/ Sustainability Coordinator/ Moneypoint Environmental Co-ordinator

Not a viable project, not viable due to excessive cost

2010/03 Promote Sustainability awareness (I) week dedicated to sustainability (ii) Give presentation to tours on sustainability (iii)Ongoing interaction with staff in relation to identifying areas for further improvement

Production Manager/ Sustainability Coordinator

Completed

2010/04 Install timer on Kitchen hot water boiler Sustainability Co-ordinator / maintenance team leader

Completed

2010/05 Investigate installing energy monitoring Equipment

• Stores

• Workshop

Sustainability Co-ordinator / maintenance team leader

Completed

2010/06 Investigate the use of occupancy detectors in

• Toilets

• Canteen

• Automation Room(1&2)

Sustainability Co-ordinator / maintenance team leader

To be completed in March 2011

2010/07 Review the Lifetime of Halides V Fluorescent Review the lighting in the turbine hall- Use of timers within the station and outside the station

Sustainability Co-ordinator / maintenance team leader

To be completed in March 2011

2010/08 Investigate with Johnson control the optimisation of the air conditioning system

• Use of VSD

Sustainability Co-ordinator / maintenance team leader

Completed

2010/09 Investigate feasibility of fitting VSDs to the major drives to reduce house load consumption during low load running.

Production Manager/ESBI This project was deemed not viable due to excessive cost

2010/10 Conduct a survey on settlement pond to ensure adequate station drainage during times of flooding

Environmental Co-ordinator/ Civil Engineer

Completed

2010/11 CEMS Upgrade –Software change out and Hardware upgrade

Maintenance TL & Thermal Services Completed

2010/12 BNM Occupational Noise Survey Annual Noise Survey

BNM Engineer Environmental Co-ordinator

Completed

Page 21: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 21

Objective Number Objective Summary 2010

Management Group Responsible

Status

2010/13 Conduct Water Survey Maintenance TL and Sustainability Champion

Completed

2010/14 Waste recycling initiatives- PPE

Technical Services TL This projects was deemed not viable due company logo and health and safety issues

2010/15 Investigate the use of Biomass for co-firing

Production Mgr, Station Mgr Ongoing – 2011- trials to conclude March 2011

3.2 West Offaly Summary Environmental Management Programme 2011

Objective Number Objective Summary 2011

Management Group Responsible

Target Milestone Completion Date

2011/01 Reduction in Water consumption

• Reduce water volume for Qtr 1 by 5% by conducting water survey and leak repair

• Qtr 2 & 3 – establish a water consumption figure due to increase volumes of usage due to contractors on site for 5 month outage. Display monthly consumption figures on the contractors tv- to create awareness on the issue and to maintain a steady figure

• Qtr 4- reduce water consumption – initiatives Rain harvesting, change out showering heads

• Expect to reduce 2010 consumption by 365m3 to achieve 5% reduction

Maintenance TL and Sustainability Champion

Dec 2011

2011/02 Reduce Energy Consumption

• Qtr 1 Nightwatch-Pc automatic shutdown

• Install Energy Meters

• Lighting review

• Trend House load for previous years to determine what the maximum consumption volume is and take 5%- 115000 MWhrs

• Qtr 2 & 3 Ongoing Energy Readings- 5month outage energy usage will initially drop, however due to volume of contractors and 24 operation it is expected that usage will increase

• Qtr 4 5% Energy initiatives- printers sleep mode ,occupancy detectors

• Expect to reduce 2010 consumption by 11,500m3 to achieve 5% reduction

• Determine if any change in House load to changes to primary and secondary air fans modifications during outage.

Maintenance TL and Sustainability Champion

Dec 2011

Page 22: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 22

2011/03 Sustainability

• Identify corporate policies regarding sustainability

• Review Financial legalisation

• Develop strategy

• Discuss with key stakeholders in procurement and sustainability

• Determine whether the practice is suitable to roll out in both stations

• Training

Sustainability Champion, procurement

Dec 2011

Objective Number Objective Summary 2011

Management Group Responsible

Target Milestone Completion Date

2011/04 Reduce Waste

• Qtr 1 Reduce waste by 5%

• Establish waste figures for 2010, trend profile for 2009

• Use of clear plastic bags in canteen

• New signage to be assessed- Review Networks signage

• Establish a waste procedure for Overhaul- define key contractors and specific wastes in a bid to increase recycling rates

• Qtr 2 % Qtr 3 Waste

• Waste levels will rise dramatically during this period- the focus will be on maintaining segregation levels of 55% during the overall for recycling

• Qtr4

• Surveillance survey on what exactly is not being segregated

• Awareness through monthly reports of tonnages consumed.

• Look at new possible ways to reduce canteen waste further

Chemical &Environmental Manager Enva(waste contractor)

Dec 2011

2011/05 Sustainability Awareness Monthly presentations to staff on sustainability issues and consumption levels Sustainability week- participate Workshop review- of pervious years data – to see if items are outstanding Review other stations sustainability projects.

Sustainability Champion Dec 2011

Page 23: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 23

3.3 E-PRTR 2010

ESB West Offaly Power expected to carry out a study on heavy metals in air emissions in 2009 to coincide with similar work in other ESB power plant, however this has been postponed in other plants to 2010

3.3.1 Methodology for determination of mass emissions

The methodology for the determination of mass emissions for inclusion in the PER is as follows. The flue gas volume generated is not measured directly in the station CEMS equipment. It is, however, possible to calculate flue gas volumes under standard conditions (as is required to express measured emission concentrations) to a high degree of accuracy based on knowledge of fuel composition, calorific value and activity. NOx

The NOx has an ELV of 200 mg/Nm3. It is proposed that the NOx emitted be calculated on the basis of the

fuel quantity consumed, its consequent flue gas volume (under standard conditions) and the average NOx concentration measured over the reporting period SO2 Similarly, the SO2 is limited to an ELV of 200 mg/Nm

3 and is measured by an extractive system in the CEMS

system. It is proposed that the SO2 emitted be calculated on the basis of the fuel quantity consumed, its consequent flue gas volume (under standard conditions) and the average SO2 concentration measured over the reporting period. Particulate The dust has an ELV of 30 mg/Nm

3 and is measured by the CEMS. It is proposed that the dust emitted be

calculated on the basis of the fuel quantity consumed, its consequent flue gas volume (under standard conditions) and the average dust concentration measured over the reporting period. CO2

The calculation of CO2 emissions is as agreed for verification of compliance with the Emissions Trading Directive: CO2 emitted = Fuel consumed (in tonnes) x Fuel Carbon (C content as %/100) x Conversion Factor (3.667) x Oxidation Factor (as measured) In WOP the fuel is subject to a complex sampling regime to define its characteristics. 36 Primary samples are taken each day. These are combined and reduced to a daily sample that is analysed for moisture content. A week’s set of daily samples is used to generate a period sample and that is used to calculate C and H2 compositions. Analysis of C content and Carbon in Ash is done by an independent laboratory to EN ISO 17025. Fuel consumption is measured by independently calibrated belt-weighers. A calibrated weighbridge is used to measure deliveries of peat by road. The oxidation factor is calculated from the product of ash quantity and fraction of carbon-in-ash. Exclusion of other Substances. Please see 2008 AER for explanation on the exclusion of, Heavy Metals, Ammonia, Hydrazine and Ortho-phosphate .:

Page 24: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 24

3.3.2 West Offaly Power PER Report for 2010

Facility Identification

Name ESB West Offaly Power

IPC Register Number P0611-01

Reporting Period 1st January - 31

st December 2010

National Grid Reference E 197300 N 224800

Employee No. 41

Pollutant Summary

Output to Air (tonnes)

Pollutant Name

PS-A1 PS-A2 Total

Sulphur Dioxide (SO2) 44.6 1.4 46

Nitrogen Oxides (as NO2) 790 0.3 790.3

Carbon Dioxide 1,126,302 - 1,126,302

Particulates 44.32 - 44.32

Methane 0

Carbon Monoxide 80.851

Nitrous Oxide 68.709

Ammonia 14.9 NMVOC 3.855

Benzene 0.241

PAHS 0.0008

IPPCL P0611-01 states the following under condition 5: Emission to Air. 5.7 The licensee shall report the total annual emissions of SO2, NOx, and dust (as total suspended particulates) annually as part of the AER. When continuous monitoring is used, the licensee shall separately calculate for each substance the mass emitted each day, on the basis of volumetric flow rates of waste gases. The basis of the calculation of the pollutants in the Table is that the ultimate analysis data for the fuel was used to calculate dry flue gas volumes generated under standard conditions of 6% O2 dry and hence multiplied out to estimate this for the annual tonnage (including the contribution of gas oil to the total flue gas volume). The concentrations recorded on a 24 hour average by the CEMS was then used to determine the amount emitted annually NCVs of fuels used in 2010

Year Peat NCV mJ/kg Gas Oil NCV mJ/kg 2010 7.535 43.31*

2009 7.051 43.31

2008 7.56 43.31

*this is an country specific net calorific values for AIER 2010.

Biomass trials occurred in 2010, the average NCV for biomass used was 6.487TJ/kTonne

Page 25: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 25

4 Licence Specific Reports

4.1 Noise Monitoring Reports

See Appendix 4.2 Underground Tanks and Pipelines CCTV inspection surveys were conducted in 2008. Copies of the survey are held within the station for viewing at any time by the Agency. The next survey is due in 2011.

4.3 Report on List 1 and List 11 Substance Reduction

(i) List I and List II Substance Reductions

Hydrazine, Trisodium Phosphate and Sodium Hypochlorite were originally considered during the application of this licence, following an internal review it was deemed that other treatment technologies could be used in their place therefore none of these items are currently used in the station for operation. 4.4 Energy Efficiency Audit Report Summary General The generating plant at West Offaly Power (WOP) station consists of one circulating fluidised bed boiler (CFB) and a Fuji steam turbine with a capacity of 150Megawatts. . West Offaly Power is one of the most modern and efficient generating stations of its kind in the world with a conversion efficiency of the order of 37%. The CFB is the most up to date technology available. It operates almost exclusively on peat with gas oil used only in start-up. All possible operations are computerised and automated. Sophisticated monitoring systems provide immediate warning of any deviation from normal standards. The following are the configuration and operating particulars to year end 2010. The overall efficiency for 2010 was 36%.

Date Design Conditions M.C.R

MW Hrs

Gen

C.O.D Press. Temp.

MPa Deg. C MW 2010

28-1-‘05 165 560 150

1,073,069

Design Parameters The plant is required to meet design operating conditions and efficiency and this determined by an ‘Acceptance Test’ prior to takeover of the plant by ESB. The ‘Acceptance Test’ was successfully carried out in Nov-Dec 2004 and the plant was accepted by ESB on commercial operation date (COD) of the 28-1-‘05. All operating parameters of the plant are recorded on a computer system called the DCS. All operating parameters are analysed by a computer system known as the Operating Information System (OIS). These monitoring systems provide immediate warning of any deviation from normal standards. Plant Corrosion The contractor Foster Wheeler and ESB reached agreement in December 2008 on the implementation of corrective measures to eliminate the corrosion problems that have limited the output from the plant since commissioning in Jan 2005. Program planning has commenced by both parties and the corrective action will be implemented in the Summer of 2011 from 31

th of March till the 16

th of September.

Page 26: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 26

Review of Efficiency Monitoring Practice in the Station Unit efficiency is reported by Operations staff to the Production Manager who reviews the information on an ongoing basis. Appropriate remedial action, where necessary, is decided upon and progressed through the maintenance/operations work planning system, known as ‘Maximo’. The Production Manager in turn reports efficiency performance to the Station Manager on a regular basis, but daily information is also provided. Future Plans Environmental During design all environmental considerations were taken into account and during construction all necessary equipment was installed. Periodically minor improvements have been instituted and this will continue to be the case with station staff continually assessing procedures/plant for improvement. Each year a list of environmental objectives are drawn up for continual environmental improvement and these are monitored by station management for implementation A number of Environmental & Sustainability projects are planned for 2011, these are incorporated into the stations Targets &Objectives for 2011 or the stations environmental management programme. Three environmental projects from 2010 have been pushed out to early 2011.Therefore a total of 8 targets and Objectives are ongoing for 2011. 4.5 Review of Environmental Liabilities Insurance Cover / Environmental Risk Assessment Report

Report submitted on 12/6/2006.

The lndemnity bond is submitted on an annual basis to the inspector, this occurred 21/05/2010. The liability is covered till the 30

th of March 2011.

4.6 Groundwater Monitoring Submitted in the quarterly reports to the EPA and available in 2.4.1 4.7 Bund Testing Report submitted in 2008. Three yearly Bund testing scheduled for 2011.

Page 27: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 27

4.8 Annual Landfill Status Report

Landfill Name Ash Disposal Facility (ADF)

Licence Number P0611-01

Landfill Location Blackwater, Co Offaly

Owner ESB Operator Bord na Mona

Active Areas

Cell in Operation 1st cell Full in Dec 07 and 2

nd cell in

operation.

Area occupied by waste 15,600 m2

Volume and composition of waste deposited in 2010

Pulverised Fuel Ash 37,750 tonnes

Furnace Bottom Ash 5,381tonnes Total 43,131tonnes

Methods of Depositing Delivered by wagon train. Fill and Compact

Time and duration of depositing One wagon train of 12 wagons daily 8AM to 5PM 6 days a week

Total Accumulated quantities of waste deposited to date

211,858 tonnes

Stability Checks Undertaken None required

Results of Monitoring Programme:

a) Surface Water Monitoring Refer to Section 2.2

b) Groundwater Monitoring Refer to section 2.4

c) Leachate Monitoring Refer to Section 2.2

d) Waste Stability ,levels, Void Monitoring None

e) Meteorological Monitoring 2010 Rainfall 1,176.4 mm

f) Dust Monitoring None – ash conditioned with water prior to leaving the power station

Summary of Monitoring Non Compliance & Corrective Actions

None

Revisions to Landfill Operational Plan None

Summary of any developmental / remedial works carried out in the preceding year

None since construction. Operational Plan, CQA Report and Leachate Lagoon Report submitted to the EPA in 2004.

Calculated Remaining Capacity 1st cell full – Cell 2 is nearing 100%

capacity, 3nd

cell is open and 33% commissioned

Calculated final capacity of site 550,000 tonnes (estimated)

Year in which final capacity of site is expected to be reached

2019

Progress on restoration of completed cells 1st cell was capped in the Summer of 2008 -

following discussion with the EPA. 2nd

cell due to be capped in 2011. Total of 10 cells

4.9 Auxiliary Boilers The auxiliary boiler is only in operation intermittently for short periods when plant is off load

Date Hours in Operation 2010 125

2009 208

2008 153

Page 28: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 28

4.10 Total Annual Emissions of SO2, NOx, CO2 and Particulates.

Method of calculations is described in section 3.3 SO2 44.6 tonnes

NO2 790 tonnes CO2 1,126,302 tonnes Particulates 44.32 tonnes 4.11 Fuel Use and Energy Input Summary Fuel Use

Peat (tonnes) Gas Oil (tonnes) Year

1,274,900 697 2010

1,256,824 1180 2009

1,235,992 748 2008

Run hours on Peat and Gas oil.

Peat Gas Oil Year

8136 0 2010

7249 0 2009

7335 0 2008

Note: Gas oil used only for start-up.

Energy Input MWHrs Generated

Peat Gas oil Total Year

1,073,069 0 1,073,069 2010

1,001,688 0 1,001,688 2009

1,069,941 0 1,069,941 2008 Energy Produced MWHrs Generated V Exported

Generated Exported House Load Year 1,073,069 960,381 115,566 2010 1,001,688 893,144 108,544 2009

1,069,941 951,962 117,979 2008

Page 29: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 29

Appendix 1

Map of Sampling Locations

Page 30: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 30

Page 31: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 31

Appendix 2

Annual Noise Survey

Page 32: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 32

GENERATION OPERATIONS

ESB ENERGY INTERNATIONAL

WEST OFFALY POWER STATION

IPCL

NOISE REPORT

Turbine Section October 2010

Page 33: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 33

Introduction This work was carried out to ascertain the Db sound levels at the NSL’s as an annual requirement for the ESB

West Offaly Station IPCL.

2. Test Personnel This work was carried out by Liam Broderick of ESB Energy International

3. Equipment The noise measurements were made using the following:

Bruel & Kjaer noise meter type 2260 (S N 2001649) Microphone type 4189 (serial No. 2021133) Calibrator type 4231 (serial No. 2084922)

Wind shield (type UA0237)

The NAMAS certificates dated 08/10/09 for the meter and calibrator are included in this report in Appendix 3.

Pre and Post meter calibrations were completed for each test period.

Meter set to A weighting, 1/3 octave analysis and Fast response. The microphone was positioned 1.3 m above

the ground and mounted on a tripod for all samples.

4. Tests A total of six LeqA 30 measurements were made, one for Night and one for Day at NSL1, 2 and 3 The measurements are being submitted for the 2010 report dated 11th and 12th Oct 2010. All measurements

were made in accordance the latest guidelines laid down in the EPA guidance document 2nd edition dated 2006.

Full details of each NSL result are given in Appendix 2

5. Conditions The weather was bright with dry conditions and wind speeds of 1 m/s for the duration of all measurements.

The plant was on load as per normal running regime for the duration of these noise measurements.

The station was clearly audible in all these tests as per comments.

Comments regarding specific local conditions are contained in Appendix 1

WOP NSL Site Map is shown in Appendix 4

6. Results Location LeqA 30 LA 90 LA 10 LA Max LA Min

NSL1 Day 53.1 39.4 57.4 67.7 35.7

NSL1 Night 37.1 34.1 38.4 56.3 31.7

NSL2 Day 50.1 38.5 52.4 78.9 35.7

NSL2 Night 42.6 40.2 43.8 62.6 37.5

NSL3 Day 48.5 40.7 51.9 69.8 36.3

NSL3 Night 43.4 40.8 45.7 55.9 38.4

7. Summary The results of these tests show that the Station is clearly compliant with the requirements of its noise IPCL set

at (Leq30) 55db Day and 45db Night, particularly with the La90 background values. Tonal components are not

present and very low LEQ levels achieved during night period.

…………………………….. Liam Broderick (ESB) 14-10-2010

Page 34: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 34

Appendix 1

Location Day Time Night Time

NSL 1

Residential housing estate

on Main Road R357

Nearest dwellings located

northeast of the site

approx 300m from the

boundary.

Average W/S 1 m/s.,

westerly

Weather dry with clear

skies

Temp 15C

Main Station clearly

audible.

Regular passing traffic

heard on main road and

paused as appropriate.

Line of sight to station and

clearly audible at all times.

Average W/S < 1 m/s., westerly

Weather dry with overcast skies

Temp 6C

Main Station clearly audible.

Occasional passing traffic heard on main

road and paused as appropriate.

Line of sight to station and clearly audible

at all times.

NSL 2

Junction of Station

entrance road and main

road at church entrance.

Approx 500M from the

site boundary.

Average W/S 1 m/s.,

westerly

Weather dry with clear

skies

Temp 15C

Main Station clearly

audible.

Regular passing traffic

heard on main road and

paused as appropriate.

Line of sight to station and

clearly audible at all times.

Average W/S < 1 m/s., westerly

Weather dry with overcast skies

Temp 6C

Main Station clearly audible.

Occasional passing traffic heard on main

road and paused as appropriate.

Line of sight to station and clearly audible

at all times.

NSL3 Across the river Shannon

in courtyard of the “Old

Fort” restaurant.

Located northwest of the

site and the most suitable

point for a line of sight to

station.

53,16,46 N

08,03,07 W

Average W/S 1 m/s.,

westerly

Weather dry with clear

skies

Temp 15C

Main Station clearly

audible.

Regular passing traffic

heard on main road and

paused as appropriate.

Occasional cruiser boats

passing along the river but

not paused.

Line of sight to station and

clearly audible at all times.

Average W/S < 1 m/s., westerly

Weather dry with overcast skies

Temp 6C

Main Station clearly audible.

Bunkering activity seems to generate

additional noise and more clearly heard at

this location over the other NSL,s

Occasional voices and activity heard from

moored boats.

Occasional passing traffic heard on main

road and paused as appropriate.

Line of sight to station and clearly audible

at all times.

Page 35: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 35

APPENDIX 2

Measurement data

1. Bruel & Kjaer Noise Measurement Printouts for NSL’s

It should be noted that all Calibration measurements have been grouped together and spectrum data omitted for

clarity.

Sample set up for Actual Tests Pre Cal NSL1 Day Instrument: 2260 Application: BZ7210 version 1.0 Start Time: 11/10/2010 13:57:34 End Time: 11/10/2010 13:57:42 Elapsed Time: 0:00:08 Bandwidth: 1/3 Octave Peaks Over: 140.0 dB Range: 31.3-111.3 dB Time Frequency Broad-band measurements: S F I A L Broad-band statistics: F A Instrument Serial Number: 2001649 Microphone Serial Number: 2021133 Input: Microphone Pol. Voltage: 0 V S. I. Correction: Frontal Calibration Time: 09/10/2009 08:52:28 Calibration Level: 94.5 dB Sensitivity: -27.5 dB ZF0023: Not used Pre Cal NSL1 Day Text Start Elapsed Overload LAeq LAF90 LAF10 LAFMax LAFMin time time [%] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] Value 0.0 93.9 93.8 94.0 93.9 93.9 Time 13:57:34 0:00:08 Date 11/10/2010 Post cal NSL3 Day Text Start Elapsed Overload LAeq LAF90 LAF10 LAFMax LAFMin time time [%] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] Value 0.0 94.0 94.0 94.2 94.0 94.0 Time 16:32:48 0:00:08 Date 11/10/2010

Page 36: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 36

Pre Cal NSL3 Night Text Start Elapsed Overload LAeq LAF90 LAF10 LAFMax LAFMin time time [%] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] Value 0.0 93.9 93.8 94.0 93.9 93.9 Time 23:55:28 0:00:06 Date 11/10/2010 Post Cal NSL1 Night Text Start Elapsed Overload LAeq LAF90 LAF10 LAFMax LAFMin time time [%] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] Value 0.0 93.9 93.8 94.0 93.9 93.9 Time 01:49:20 0:00:08 Date 12/10/2010

Page 37: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 37

NSL1 Day Text Start Elapsed Overload LAeq LAF90 LAF10 LAFMax LAFMin time time [%] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] Value 0.0 53.1 39.4 57.4 67.7 35.7 Time 14:04:10 0:30:00 Date 11/10/2010

Cursor: (A) Leq=53.1 dB LSMax=66.1 dB LSMin=37.1 dB

NSL1 Day

16 31.50 63 125 250 500 1000 2000 4000 8000 A L

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

110dB 11/10/2010 14:04:10 - 14:34:10

Hz

LAeq

Cursor: [71.2 ; 71.4[ dB Level: 0.0% Cumulative: 0.0%

NSL1 Day

40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100% Based on LAF(Inst), 10ms Class width: 0.2 dB 11/10/2010 14:04:10 - 14:34:10

dB

L1 = 63.6 dBL5 = 59.9 dBL10 = 57.4 dBL50 = 46.4 dBL90 = 39.4 dBL95 = 38.5 dBL99 = 37.4 dB

Level Cumulative

Page 38: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 38

NSL1 Night Text Start Elapsed Overload LAeq LAF90 LAF10 LAFMax LAFMin time time [%] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] Value 0.0 37.1 34.1 38.4 56.3 31.7 Time 01:17:30 0:30:00 Date 12/10/2010

Cursor: (A) Leq=37.1 dB LSMax=53.8 dB LSMin=32.6 dB

NSL1 Night

16 31.50 63 125 250 500 1000 2000 4000 8000 A L

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

110dB 12/10/2010 01:17:30 - 01:47:30

Hz

LAeq LASMax LASMin

Cursor: [71.2 ; 71.4[ dB Level: 0.0% Cumulative: 0.0%

NSL1 Night

40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100% Based on LAF(Inst), 10ms Class width: 0.2 dB 12/10/2010 01:17:30 - 01:47:30

dB

L1 = 44.6 dBL5 = 40.0 dBL10 = 38.4 dBL50 = 35.6 dBL90 = 34.1 dBL95 = 33.7 dBL99 = 33.0 dB

Level Cumulative

Page 39: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 39

NSL2 Day Text Start Elapsed Overload LAeq LAF90 LAF10 LAFMax LAFMin time time [%] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] Value 0.0 50.1 38.5 52.4 78.9 35.7 Time 15:08:01 0:30:00 Date11/10/2010

Cursor: (A) Leq=50.1 dB LSMax=71.8 dB LSMin=36.4 dB

NSL2 Day

16 31.50 63 125 250 500 1000 2000 4000 8000 A L

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

110dB 11/10/2010 15:08:01 - 15:38:01

Hz

LAeq

Page 40: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 40

Cursor: [71.2 ; 71.4[ dB Level: 0.0% Cumulative: 0.0%

NSL2 Day

40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100% Based on LAF(Inst), 10ms Class width: 0.2 dB 11/10/2010 15:08:01 - 15:38:01

dB

L1 = 60.6 dBL5 = 56.2 dBL10 = 52.4 dBL50 = 43.5 dBL90 = 38.5 dBL95 = 37.9 dBL99 = 37.0 dB

Level Cumulative

NSL2 Night Text Start Elapsed Overload LAeq LAF90 LAF10 LAFMax LAFMin time time [%] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] Value 0.0 42.6 40.2 43.8 62.6 37.5 Time 00:35:25 0:30:00 Date 12/10/2010

Cursor: (A) Leq=42.6 dB LSMax=59.9 dB LSMin=38.5 dB

NSL2 Night

16 31.50 63 125 250 500 1000 2000 4000 8000 A L

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

110dB 12/10/2010 00:35:25 - 01:05:25

Hz

LAeq LASMax LASMin

Page 41: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 41

Cursor: [71.2 ; 71.4[ dB Level: 0.0% Cumulative: 0.0%

NSL2 Night

40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100% Based on LAF(Inst), 10ms Class width: 0.2 dB 12/10/2010 00:35:25 - 01:05:25

dB

L1 = 47.6 dBL5 = 44.8 dBL10 = 43.8 dBL50 = 41.8 dBL90 = 40.2 dBL95 = 39.8 dBL99 = 39.1 dB

Level Cumulative

NSL3 Day Text Start Elapsed Overload LAeq LAF90 LAF10 LAFMax LAFMin time time [%] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] Value 0.0 48.5 40.7 51.9 69.8 36.3 Time 15:58:05 0:30:00 Date 11/10/2010

Page 42: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 42

Cursor: (A) Leq=48.5 dB LSMax=67.4 dB LSMin=37.2 dB

NSL3 Day

16 31.50 63 125 250 500 1000 2000 4000 8000 A L

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

110dB 11/10/2010 15:58:05 - 16:28:05

Hz

LAeq

Cursor: [71.2 ; 71.4[ dB Level: 0.0% Cumulative: 0.0%

NSL3 Day

40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100% Based on LAF(Inst), 10ms Class width: 0.2 dB 11/10/2010 15:58:05 - 16:28:05

dB

L1 = 56.8 dBL5 = 53.7 dBL10 = 51.9 dBL50 = 45.1 dBL90 = 40.7 dBL95 = 40.0 dBL99 = 38.6 dB

Level Cumulative

NSL3 Night Text Start Elapsed Overload LAeq LAF90 LAF10 LAFMax LAFMin time time [%] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] [dB] Value 0.0 43.4 40.8 45.7 55.9 38.4 Time 23:56:09 0:30:00 Date 11/10/2010

Page 43: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 43

Cursor: (A) Leq=43.4 dB LSMax=54.2 dB LSMin=38.9 dB

NSL3 Night

16 31.50 63 125 250 500 1000 2000 4000 8000 A L

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

110dB 11/10/2010 23:56:09 - 00:26:09

Hz

LAeq

Cursor: [71.2 ; 71.4[ dB Level: 0.0% Cumulative: 0.0%

NSL3 Night

40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100% Based on LAF(Inst), 10ms Class width: 0.2 dB 11/10/2010 23:56:09 - 00:26:09

dB

L1 = 49.0 dBL5 = 46.8 dBL10 = 45.7 dBL50 = 42.5 dBL90 = 40.8 dBL95 = 40.4 dBL99 = 39.7 dB

Level Cumulative

Page 44: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 44

APPENDIX 3a Certification Calibrator

Page 45: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 45

APPENDIX 3b Certification meter

Page 46: IPPC Licence Reg. No. P0611-01 · taprogge system which uses small balls to remove scale build up in the condenser hence we do not monitor for chloride. Ref Point : PS-SW3 – Sewage

Page 46

APPENDIX 4 Site Map