int workshop science case for an eic seattle, wa, november 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · going beyond...

56
The LHeC project Olaf Behnke (DESY) INT workshop – Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, 2010 1 ..Logo from the ongoing logo contest..

Upload: others

Post on 22-Aug-2021

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

The LHeC project

Olaf Behnke (DESY)

INT workshop – Science case for an EIC

Seattle, WA, November 18, 2010

1

..Logo from the ongoing logo contest..

Page 2: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

Need for LHeC

27.5 GeV x 920 GeV ep HERA

with integrated L~0.5 fb-1 was a

high precision machine for QCD

modest precision machine for electroweak physics

Where could we go with a

20-150 GeV x 7 TeV e±p, also eA collider

with integrated L~1-100 fb-1 ?

2

Page 3: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

Lepton proton scattering experiments

LHeC = highest

energy and high lumi

3

Page 4: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

Physics and Range

High mass 1-2 TeV

rq few times 10-20 m

High precision

partons in plateau

of the LHC

Nuclear

Structure

& dynamics

High Density Matter

Large x

LHeC grand

picture

Talk Content: Accelerator 1. Inclusive DIS & PDFs 2. Jets, c,b,t 3. Low x, saturation 4. EW and BSM

4

Page 5: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

LHeC Accelerator options

4

11

1232

)(

11

])[/100(][35.0

507.1

10102.8

,)5.0(8.1,8.3,107.1

4

GeVEMWPmAI

mA

ImNscmL

M

EmmN

I

e

NL

ee

e

pypx

p

p

p

ypxpp

pypx

e

pn

p

Ring-Ring Power Limit of 100 MW wall plug “ultimate” LHC proton beam 60 GeV e± beam

L = 2 1033 cm-2s-1

O(100) fb-1

5

Page 6: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

LHeC Accelerator options

L 1

4N p

p1

*

Ie

e

N p 1.7 1011, p 3.8m,

* 0.2m, 7000 /0.94

L 8 1031cm 2s1N p10

11

1.70.2

* /mIe /mA

1

Ie mAP /MW

Ee /GeV

LINAC Ring 60 GeV “Circus Maximus” with Energy recovery: P=P0/(1-η) β*=0.1m L = 1033 cm-2s-1

O(100) fb-1

140 GeV LINAC few times 1032

6

Page 7: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

Max Klein - Scenarios and Measurements

1. Inclusive NC & CC DIS: simulated Default Scenarios http://hep.ph.liv.ac.uk/~mklein/simdis09/lhecsim.Dmp.CC, readfirst

Not simulated

Max Klein, LHeC

7

Page 8: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

8 Max Klein - Scenarios and Measurements

Kinematics – high Q2

Need

excellent

forward

hadron

calorimetry &

calibration 8

Page 9: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

The Detector ‘that should do it’: - Low Lumi (Low Q2) Setup

- Solenoid surrounding the HAC modules

-Outer detectors (HAC tailcatcher/muon detectors not shown)

to be discussed: very forward detector setup (proton taggers)

To be optimised

9

Page 10: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

Max Klein - Scenarios and Measurements

Trivial, but

important:

largest Elep

allows highest

Q2 scales

Pseudodata: Neutral Current Event Rates

10

Page 11: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

Photon and Z exchanges are 1:1

11

2 charges and 2 polarisations very desirable

for electroweak precision physics

and a new spectroscopy should that appear.

Z effects depend on lepton charge and

polarisation.

x=0.2

100 GeV

7000 GeV

F2 yZ ZZ

11

Page 12: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

Charge Asymmetry xF3Z

60x7000 GeV2 P=0

10fb-1

Get handle on valence quarks down to x~0.001 12

Page 13: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

Parity violating polarisation asymmetries (for 60 GeV and 140 GeV lepton beams)

SLAC 1978 13

Page 14: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

14 Max Klein - Scenarios and Measurements

Rates

LHeC: expect ~

two orders of

magnitude

more events

+ better

coverage for

x>0.5

Max Klein - Scenarios and Measurements

Pseudodata: Charged Current Event Rates

q

q’

14

Page 15: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

Charged Currents

Valence quarks

up to x=0.8

Unfold U,D and

anti U,D

15

Page 16: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

Strange =? Anti-strange quark density

o

h

o

h

syst

q

c

fb

csW

10

1

1.0

01.0

1.0

1 1

Some dimuon and K data, but never properly measured Use e- p data for sbar

16

Page 17: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

How well do we know PDFs today? gg parton luminosities

Agree in region relevant for Higgs at LHC,

but diverge towards smaller/largest shat

G. Watt

17

Page 18: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

18

Proton PDF fit at LHeC Q2 = 100 GeV2

Scenario D

» only PDF parameters free

(LHeC NC and CC e±p

included)

Large improvements, model and

parameterisation uncertainties to

be studied

Claire Gwenlan

18

Page 19: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

Sea quark uncertainties and usual constraint ubar=dbar for x0

release constraint

Voica Radescu

With LHeC can get rid

of such assumptions

with constraint

HERA only

Adding LHeC

19

Page 20: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

Plenary ECFA, LHeC, Max Klein, CERN 30.11.2007

Further PDF improvements at LHeC with ep + eD

crucial constraint on evolution (S-NS), improved

s

20

Page 21: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

Simulation of s measurement at LHeC

1/

fine structure

weak

strong

T.Kluge/M.Klein Divonne 09

Improve at LHeC to

~ permille precision level 21

Page 22: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

2. High pt Jets

sensitive to g(x),

photon structure and s 22

Page 23: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

23

Page 24: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

24

Page 25: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

Will reduce significantly theory (higher order)

uncertainty for s extraction from jet data

O(s3)

25

Page 26: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

2. Charm & beauty

sensitive to g(x) 26

Page 27: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

for PDF fits

27

Page 28: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

x=0.00003

x=0.00007

x=0.0003

x=0.0007

x=0.003

x=0.007

x=0.0000

x=0.03

x=0.1

x=0.3

1 fb1

c 0.1

bgdq 0.01

syst 0.1

h 1o

h 10o

Max Klein

Charm in DIS: test intrinsic charm in p

Expected to show up

at xb >0.1

Requires c-tagging in very foward direction (q~1 deg.) 28

Page 29: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

O.B.

Beauty in DIS: determine b-density in proton x=0.000001

HERA

coverage

Q2>>mb2

O.Behnke

x=0.2

In MSSM Higgs production

is b dominated

29

Use for LHC

predictions

Page 30: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

30

Page 31: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

31

Page 32: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

3. Entering the mysterious world

of low x physics

32

Page 33: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

33

Low-x Physics and Non-linear Evolution

• Somewhere & somehow, the low x growth of cross sections must be tamed to satisfy unitarity … non-linear effects • Usually characterised in terms of an x dependent “saturation scale”, Q2

s(x), to be determined experimentally

Note: This and

following slides

Courtesy Paul Newman or Anna Statso

33

Page 34: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

34

Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data

[Armesto]

Enhance target `blackness’ by: 1) Probing lower x at fixed Q2 in ep 2) Increasing target matter in eA … target density ~ A1/3 ~ 6 for Pb

34

Page 35: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

35

Saturation region reach: LHeC vs EIC

EIC

LHeC

7 TeV x 100 GeV

35

Page 36: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

36

Non DGLAP

36

Page 37: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

Including LHeC data in NNPDF DGLAP fit approach … … sizeable improvement in error on low x gluon when both LHeC F2 & FL data are included.

… but would DGLAP fits fail if non-linear effects present?

Fitting for the Gluon with LHeC F2 and FL

(Gufanti, Rojo …)

HERA + LHeC F2 HERA + LHeC F2, FL

(Q2 = 2 GeV2)

37

Page 38: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

Conclusion: clearly establishing non-linear effects needs a minimum of 2 observables … next try F2

c in place of FL …

Can Parton Saturation be Established @ LHeC?

Simulated LHeC F2 and FL data based on a dipole model containing low x saturation (FS04-sat)… … NNPDF (also HERA framework) DGLAP QCD fits cannot accommodate saturation effects if F2 and FL both fitted

[Rojo]

38

Page 39: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

39

eA: Impact of LHeC data on nuclear parton densities

39

Page 40: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

40

40

Page 41: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

Q2

VM:,r,,J/y,U

Elastic Vector meson production in ep scattering

p p

e

e

t

Wp

➔ Obtain 3d-picture of proton

qqbar-dipol

gluons

Large t probe densest part of proton

41

Page 42: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

Dedicated Low x Linac-Ring Scenario

Dream scenario!!!

42

J/y photoproduction double differentially in W and t, Ee=150 GeV 1o acceptance Probing x ~ 3.10-6

at eff Q2 ~ 2.5 GeV2

c.f. GB-W model xs ~ 7.10-6 at Q2 ~ 2.5 GeV2

Page 43: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

43

43

Page 44: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

Inclusive Diffraction

Additional variables …

xIP = fractional momentum loss of proton (momentum fraction IP/p)

b = x / xIP (momentum fraction q / IP)

Further sensitivity to saturation phenomena Diffractive parton densities in much increased range Sensitivity to rapidity gap survival issues Can relate ep diffraction to eA shadowing … Link between ep and eA for interpreting inclusive data

44

Page 45: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

Worked well: The methods have very different systs! What is possible at LHeC?…

Signatures and Selection Methods at HERA

`Large Rapidity Gap’ adjacent to outgoing (untagged) proton

- Allows t measurement - Limited by stats and p-tagging systs Limited by p-diss systs

Scattered proton in ZEUS LPS or H1 FPS

ηmax

45

Page 46: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

46

New region of Diffractive Masses No alternative to proton spectrometer to select high Mx

• `Proper’ QCD (e.g. large ET) with jets and charm accessible • New diffractive channels … beauty, W / Z / H(?) bosons • Unfold quantum numbers / precisely measure new 1-- states

(xIP<0.05)

46

Page 47: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

4. SM electroweak and new physics

at the high energy frontier

HERA

LHeC

Light quark couplings to Z

SM Higgs production

Leptoquarks + many other possibilities, e.g. excited leptons, anomalous single top production, etc.

47

Page 48: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

Fermion couplings to Z boson

Claire Gwenlan.

LHeC could measure u and d couplings with ~1% precision

48

Page 49: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

Backup slides

49

Page 50: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

50

New physics example

Leptoquarks: determine

quantum Numbers at LHeC

Charge asymmetry much

cleaner in ep than in pp.

Similar for simultaneous

determination of coupling

and quark flavour. Polarisation

for spectroscopy

JINST 1 2006 P10001

Single LQ production at LHC

Single LQ

production

at LHeC

e-p vs e+p asymmetries at LHeC

will reveal the Fermion number F 50

Page 51: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

The LHeC has potential to completely unfold the partonic content of the proton: u,d, c,s,

t,b for the first time and in an unprecedent kinematic range. This is based on inclusive

NC, CC cross sections complemented by heavy quark identification.

Puzzles as u/d at large x or a strange-antistrange asymmetry will be solved.

Precision measurements are possible of xg (up to large x) and the beauty density which

are of particular relevance for the LHC. The (almost) whole p structure which the LHC

assumes to know will become accurately known.

Determine s with permille level precision

Wealth of QCD tests with final states (not much discussed in this talk : Jets (study also

photon structure), heavy flavours, prompt photons, other identified particles

Low x and diffractive physics with ep and eA: Measuring multiple observables (F2, Fl,

F2c, F2D, Vector mesons…) in ep and eA can lead to a microscopic understanding of

non-linear evolution, unitarity constraints and parton saturation

Electroweak and new physics

- Light quark couplings to Z at ~1% level

- SM Higgs production for H-> bb coupling

- New physics: Leptoquarks and quantum numbers, quark radius, leptons* and more!

Summary

51

Page 52: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

Backup slides

52

Page 53: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

Master formulae for NC DIS

Vary charge and polarisation and beam energy to

disentangle contributions

Page 54: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

Charged Currents

Complete unfolding of all parton distributions

to unprecedented accuracy

Page 55: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

55 55

1⁰ and 179⁰ 2⁰ and 178⁰ 3⁰ and 177⁰ 4⁰ and 176⁰ 5⁰ and 175⁰

10⁰ and 170⁰

250 217 250 250 217

177 40 40

177

[cm]

289

112

40 20

The High Lumi (High Q2) Setup

HaC-Barrel

Modules

EmC-Barrel

Central Tracking HaC-insert-2

EmC-insert-2

L1 Low Q2 SetUp High Q2 SetUp - Fwd/Bwd Tracking & EmC-Extensions, HaC-Insert-1 removed -Calo-Inserts in position -Strong Focussing Magnet installed

Strong Focussing

Magnet

(to be optimised)

Page 56: INT workshop Science case for an EIC Seattle, WA, November 18, … · 2010. 12. 6. · Going beyond HERA with Inclusive LHeC Data [Armesto] ... J/y photoproduction double differentially

O.B.

HERA 27.5 x 920

Obtained with PYTHIA, RAPGAP and LEPTO

LHeC is a

multi

flavour

factory

Events per 10 fb-1 Lumi

1010

108

4x106

4x105

105

103

Single Top