inside hong kong to quash dissent china makes move · safeguarding national security in hong kong....

1
U(D54G1D)y+$!=!,!$!z BEIJING — China signaled on Thursday that it would move for- ward with laws that would take aim at antigovernment protests and other dissent in Hong Kong. It is the clearest message yet that the Communist Party is moving to undermine the civil liberties the semiautonomous territory has known since the 1997 British handoff. The proposal to enact new secu- rity laws affecting Hong Kong was announced ahead of the annual meeting of China’s legislature, which is expected to approve a broad outline of the plan. While specifics of the proposal were not immediately disclosed, the rules could be harsher than anything Hong Kong’s pro-Beijing govern- ment has done to curb opposition to the mainland. The freedoms that have distin- guished Hong Kong from the mainland, like an unfettered judi- ciary and freedom of assembly, have helped the former British colony prosper as a global city of commerce and capital. But the proposal raised the possibility that the Beijing government would damage the “one country, two systems” policy that has en- sured such liberties since the ter- ritory was reclaimed by China. The plan also revives the threat of violent demonstrations that convulsed the city for months and risks worsening China’s deterio- rating relationship with the Trump administration, which said the United States would respond strongly to any crackdown in Hong Kong. In the Communist Party’s view, tightened security laws in Hong Kong are necessary to protect China from external forces deter- mined to impinge on its sovereignty. The legislation would give Beijing the power to counter the Hong Kong protests, which are seen as a blatant challenge to the party and to China’s leader, Xi Jinping. Security rules proposed by the Hong Kong government in 2003 would have empowered the au- thorities to close seditious news- papers and conduct searches without warrants. That proposal was abandoned after it set off large protests. This time, China is effectively circumventing the Hong Kong government, undercutting the rel- ative autonomy granted to the ter- ritory. Instead, it is going through China’s rubber stamp legislature, the National People’s Congress, which holds its annual session starting Friday. Zhang Yesui, spokesman for the National People’s Congress, said at a news briefing on Thursday that delegates would review a plan to create a legal framework and enforcement mechanism for safeguarding national security in Hong Kong. He did not elaborate CHINA MAKES MOVE TO QUASH DISSENT INSIDE HONG KONG Plan to Undercut Region’s Civil Liberties Risks a Revival of Violent Protests This article is by Keith Bradsher, Austin Ramzy and Tiffany May. President Xi Jinping of China, maskless at left, in Beijing on Thursday. Protests in Hong Kong are seen as a direct challenge to Mr. Xi. POOL PHOTO BY ANDY WONG Continued on Page A16 KM ASAD/REUTERS Satkhira, Bangladesh, on Thursday. The worst damage from the storm was reported in the Indian state of West Bengal. Page A15. Cyclone Kills 80 WASHINGTON — President Trump has blamed many others for his administration’s flawed re- sponse to the coronavirus: China, governors, the Obama adminis- tration, the World Health Organi- zation. In recent weeks, he has also faulted the information he re- ceived from an obscure analyst who delivers his intelligence briefings. Mr. Trump has insisted that the intelligence agencies gave him in- adequate warnings about the threat of the virus, describing it as “not a big deal.” Intelligence offi- cials have publicly backed him, ac- knowledging that Beth Sanner, the analyst who regularly briefs the president, underplayed the dangers when she first mentioned the virus to him on Jan. 23. But in blaming Ms. Sanner, a C.I.A. analyst with three decades of experience, Mr. Trump ignored a host of warnings he received around that time from higher- ranking officials, epidemiologists, scientists, biodefense officials, other national security aides and the news media about the virus’s growing threat. Mr. Trump’s own health secretary had alerted him five days earlier to the potential seriousness of the virus. By the time of the Jan. 23 intelli- gence briefing, many government officials were already alarmed by Trump, Diverting Virus Blame, Points Finger at a Messenger By JULIAN E. BARNES and ADAM GOLDMAN Continued on Page A19 Intelligence Reports for a Restless Recipient SACRAMENTO — The Univer- sity of California on Thursday voted to phase out the SAT and ACT as requirements to apply to its system of 10 schools, which in- clude some of the nation’s most popular campuses, in a decision with major implications for the use of standardized tests in col- lege admissions. Given the size and influence of the California system, whose marquee schools include the Uni- versity of California, Los Angeles, and the University of California, Berkeley, the move is expected to accelerate the momentum of American colleges away from the tests, amid charges that they are unfair to poor, black and Hispanic students. The school system’s action, which follows many small liberal arts colleges, comes as the ACT and the College Board, a nonprofit organization that administers the SAT, are suffering financially from the cancellation of test dates dur- ing the coronavirus pandemic. No SAT or ACT For University Of California By SHAWN HUBLER Continued on Page A24 This article is a collaboration among The New York Times, The Baltimore Sun, KPPC/LAist and The Southern Illinoisan. In the suburbs of Baltimore, workers at one nursing home said they were given rain ponchos to protect from infection. Twenty- seven employees at the facility, where most residents are African- American, tested positive for the coronavirus. One of the many black residents of a nursing home in Belleville, Ill., died in April amid a coronavirus outbreak. But his niece com- plained that he was never tested for the virus. In East Los Angeles, a staff member at a predominantly Lati- no nursing home where an out- break emerged said she was given swimming goggles before profes- sional gear could be obtained. She said she later tested positive for the virus. The coronavirus pandemic has devastated the nation’s nursing homes, sickening staff members, ravaging residents and contribut- ing to at least 20 percent of the na- tion’s Covid-19 death toll. The im- pact has been felt in cities and sub- urbs, in large facilities and small, in poorly rated homes and in those with stellar marks. But Covid-19 has been particu- larly virulent toward African- Americans and Latinos: Nursing homes where those groups make up a significant portion of the resi- dents — no matter their location, no matter their size, no matter their government rating — have been twice as likely to get hit by the coronavirus as those where the population is overwhelmingly white. More than 60 percent of nursing homes where at least a quarter of the residents are black or Latino have reported at least one coro- navirus case, a New York Times analysis shows. That is double the rate of homes where black and La- tino people make up less than 5 percent of the population. And in The Racial Divide of Nursing Home Outbreaks Bria of Belleville, a rehabilitation and nursing facility in Illinois. WHITNEY CURTIS FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES Continued on Page A8 Even as states begin to reopen for business, a further 2.4 million workers joined the nation’s unem- ployment rolls last week, and there is growing concern among economists that many of the lost jobs are gone for good. The Labor Department’s report of new jobless claims, released Thursday, brought the total to 38.6 million since mid-March, when the coronavirus outbreak forced widespread shutdowns. While workers and their em- ployers have expressed optimism that most of the joblessness will be temporary, many who are study- ing the pandemic’s impact are in- creasingly worried about the em- ployment situation. “I hate to say it, but this is going to take longer and look grimmer than we thought,” Nicholas Bloom, an economist at Stanford University, said of the path to re- covery. Mr. Bloom is a co-author of an analysis that estimates 42 percent of recent layoffs will result in per- manent job loss. “Firms intend to hire these peo- ple back,” he said, referring to a re- cent survey of businesses by the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta. “But we know from the past that these aspirations often don’t turn out to be true.” The precariousness of the path ahead was underscored Thursday by the Federal Reserve chair, Je- rome H. Powell. “We are now ex- periencing a whole new level of uncertainty, as questions only the virus can answer complicate the outlook,” he said in remarks for delivery at an online forum. The economy that does come back is likely to look quite differ- ent from the one that closed. If so- Another 2.4 Million Jobs Vanish, And Many May Be Gone Forever By PATRICIA COHEN Some Analysts Forecast a Fundamental Shift Continued on Page A11 When a stay-at-home order in March all but closed the revered labs of the gene-editing pioneer Jennifer Doudna, her team at the University of California, Berkeley, dropped everything and started testing for the coronavirus. They expected their institute to be inundated with samples since it was offering the service at no charge, with support from philan- thropies. But there were few tak- ers. Instead, the scientists learned, many local hospitals and doctors’ offices continued sending sam- ples to national laboratory compa- nies — like LabCorp and Quest Di- agnostics — even though, early on, patients had to wait a week or more for results. The bureaucratic hurdles of quickly switching to a new lab were just too high. “It’s still amazing to me, like, how can that be the case, that there is not a more systematic way to address a central need?” said Fyodor Urnov, the scientist who oversaw the transformation of the Innovative Genomics Insti- tute into a clinical laboratory. The inability of the United States to provide broad diagnostic testing, widely seen as a pivotal failing in the nation’s effort to con- tain the virus, has been traced to the botched rollout by the Centers for Disease Control and Preven- tion, the tardy response by the Food and Drug Administration, and supply shortages of swabs and masks. Yet one major impediment to testing has been largely over- looked: the fragmented, poorly or- ganized American health care system, which made it difficult for hospitals and other medical providers to quickly overcome ob- In Testing Chaos, Some Labs Drowned While Others Sat Idle By KATIE THOMAS Bureaucratic Obstacles Favor a Few Giants Continued on Page A5 Engineers fear there may be more failures like the one this week in Michi- gan as the world gets warmer. PAGE A20 NATIONAL A17-25 Dams vs. Climate Change A strict weekend curfew leaves the Turkish city’s streets mostly empty, but the ovens of the baklava makers are full of life. Istanbul Dispatch. PAGE A10 TRACKING AN OUTBREAK A4-13 Quiet Istanbul, but Busy Bakers A scientist argues that the quest for fully automated robots is misguided, perhaps even dangerous. His decades of warn- ings are gaining attention. PAGE B1 BUSINESS B1-7 Robots That Lean on Humans This summer’s reading list will have to do a little more than usual to help us escape our surroundings. PAGE C1 WEEKEND ARTS C1-16 Pages That’ll Take You Away Facing health questions and a shrinking window of opportunity, Tiger Woods is set to return to competition. PAGE B8 SPORTSFRIDAY B8-9 All Eyes Are on Woods’s Back With 14 months to go before the re- scheduled Tokyo Olympics, everything about them is uncertain. PAGE B9 The Doubtful Games Tim Morrison PAGE A27 EDITORIAL, OP-ED A26-27 The move is a dramatic change from an office-centric culture. But there’s a catch: Salaries are likely to change to match local costs of living. PAGE B1 Facebook to Keep Remote Work Despite the addition of 90,000 sub- scribers since March, the venerable publication said it would eliminate 68 jobs, or 17 percent of its staff. PAGE B1 Layoffs at The Atlantic Watching theater online can feel like a pale imitation of being there, but some technologies are changing that. PAGE C4 Bringing Digital Plays to Life A 130-mile coastline that is an economic engine and a cultural touchstone has had its usual rhythms upended. PAGE A13 Distancing at the Jersey Shore Relatives of an ex-intelligence official who has hidden in Canada since 2017 were arrested in Riyadh. PAGE A14 INTERNATIONAL A14-16 Saudi Intimidation Alleged The president has decided to tell Russia that the United States will withdraw from the Open Skies Treaty. PAGE A20 Trump to Leave Arms Pact Late Edition VOL. CLXIX . . . No. 58,701 © 2020 The New York Times Company NEW YORK, FRIDAY, MAY 22, 2020 Today, sunshine, increasing clouds, afternoon showers, not as cool, high 70. Tonight, cloudy, showers, low 59. Tomorrow, rather cloudy, showers, high 69. Weather map, Page A22. $3.00

Upload: others

Post on 17-Jun-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: INSIDE HONG KONG TO QUASH DISSENT CHINA MAKES MOVE · safeguarding national security in Hong Kong. He did not elaborate CHINA MAKES MOVE TO QUASH DISSENT INSIDE HONG KONG Plan to

C M Y K Nxxx,2020-05-22,A,001,Bs-4C,E2

U(D54G1D)y+$!=!,!$!z

BEIJING — China signaled onThursday that it would move for-ward with laws that would takeaim at antigovernment protestsand other dissent in Hong Kong. Itis the clearest message yet thatthe Communist Party is moving toundermine the civil liberties thesemiautonomous territory hasknown since the 1997 Britishhandoff.

The proposal to enact new secu-rity laws affecting Hong Kong wasannounced ahead of the annualmeeting of China’s legislature,which is expected to approve abroad outline of the plan. Whilespecifics of the proposal were notimmediately disclosed, the rulescould be harsher than anythingHong Kong’s pro-Beijing govern-ment has done to curb oppositionto the mainland.

The freedoms that have distin-guished Hong Kong from themainland, like an unfettered judi-ciary and freedom of assembly,have helped the former Britishcolony prosper as a global city ofcommerce and capital. But theproposal raised the possibilitythat the Beijing governmentwould damage the “one country,two systems” policy that has en-sured such liberties since the ter-ritory was reclaimed by China.

The plan also revives the threatof violent demonstrations thatconvulsed the city for months andrisks worsening China’s deterio-

rating relationship with theTrump administration, which saidthe United States would respondstrongly to any crackdown inHong Kong.

In the Communist Party’s view,tightened security laws in HongKong are necessary to protectChina from external forces deter-mined to impinge on itssovereignty. The legislation wouldgive Beijing the power to counterthe Hong Kong protests, whichare seen as a blatant challenge tothe party and to China’s leader, XiJinping.

Security rules proposed by theHong Kong government in 2003would have empowered the au-thorities to close seditious news-papers and conduct searcheswithout warrants. That proposalwas abandoned after it set offlarge protests.

This time, China is effectivelycircumventing the Hong Konggovernment, undercutting the rel-ative autonomy granted to the ter-ritory. Instead, it is going throughChina’s rubber stamp legislature,the National People’s Congress,which holds its annual sessionstarting Friday.

Zhang Yesui, spokesman for theNational People’s Congress, saidat a news briefing on Thursdaythat delegates would review aplan to create a legal frameworkand enforcement mechanism forsafeguarding national security inHong Kong. He did not elaborate

CHINA MAKES MOVETO QUASH DISSENT INSIDE HONG KONG

Plan to Undercut Region’s Civil Liberties Risks a Revival of Violent Protests

This article is by Keith Bradsher,Austin Ramzy and Tiffany May.

President Xi Jinping of China, maskless at left, in Beijing on Thursday. Protests in Hong Kong are seen as a direct challenge to Mr. Xi.POOL PHOTO BY ANDY WONG

Continued on Page A16

KM ASAD/REUTERS

Satkhira, Bangladesh, on Thursday. The worst damage from thestorm was reported in the Indian state of West Bengal. Page A15.

Cyclone Kills 80

WASHINGTON — PresidentTrump has blamed many othersfor his administration’s flawed re-sponse to the coronavirus: China,governors, the Obama adminis-tration, the World Health Organi-zation. In recent weeks, he hasalso faulted the information he re-ceived from an obscure analystwho delivers his intelligencebriefings.

Mr. Trump has insisted that theintelligence agencies gave him in-adequate warnings about thethreat of the virus, describing it as“not a big deal.” Intelligence offi-cials have publicly backed him, ac-knowledging that Beth Sanner,the analyst who regularly briefsthe president, underplayed thedangers when she first mentioned

the virus to him on Jan. 23.But in blaming Ms. Sanner, a

C.I.A. analyst with three decadesof experience, Mr. Trump ignoreda host of warnings he receivedaround that time from higher-ranking officials, epidemiologists,scientists, biodefense officials,other national security aides andthe news media about the virus’sgrowing threat. Mr. Trump’s ownhealth secretary had alerted himfive days earlier to the potentialseriousness of the virus.

By the time of the Jan. 23 intelli-gence briefing, many governmentofficials were already alarmed by

Trump, Diverting Virus Blame,Points Finger at a Messenger

By JULIAN E. BARNESand ADAM GOLDMAN

Continued on Page A19

Intelligence Reports for a Restless Recipient

SACRAMENTO — The Univer-sity of California on Thursdayvoted to phase out the SAT andACT as requirements to apply toits system of 10 schools, which in-clude some of the nation’s mostpopular campuses, in a decisionwith major implications for theuse of standardized tests in col-lege admissions.

Given the size and influence ofthe California system, whosemarquee schools include the Uni-versity of California, Los Angeles,and the University of California,Berkeley, the move is expected toaccelerate the momentum ofAmerican colleges away from thetests, amid charges that they areunfair to poor, black and Hispanicstudents.

The school system’s action,which follows many small liberalarts colleges, comes as the ACTand the College Board, a nonprofitorganization that administers theSAT, are suffering financially fromthe cancellation of test dates dur-ing the coronavirus pandemic.

No SAT or ACTFor University

Of CaliforniaBy SHAWN HUBLER

Continued on Page A24

This article is a collaborationamong The New York Times, TheBaltimore Sun, KPPC/LAist and TheSouthern Illinoisan.

In the suburbs of Baltimore,workers at one nursing home saidthey were given rain ponchos toprotect from infection. Twenty-seven employees at the facility,where most residents are African-American, tested positive for thecoronavirus.

One of the many black residentsof a nursing home in Belleville, Ill.,died in April amid a coronavirusoutbreak. But his niece com-plained that he was never testedfor the virus.

In East Los Angeles, a staffmember at a predominantly Lati-no nursing home where an out-break emerged said she was givenswimming goggles before profes-sional gear could be obtained. Shesaid she later tested positive forthe virus.

The coronavirus pandemic hasdevastated the nation’s nursinghomes, sickening staff members,ravaging residents and contribut-ing to at least 20 percent of the na-tion’s Covid-19 death toll. The im-pact has been felt in cities and sub-urbs, in large facilities and small,in poorly rated homes and in thosewith stellar marks.

But Covid-19 has been particu-larly virulent toward African-Americans and Latinos: Nursinghomes where those groups makeup a significant portion of the resi-dents — no matter their location,no matter their size, no mattertheir government rating — havebeen twice as likely to get hit bythe coronavirus as those wherethe population is overwhelmingly

white.More than 60 percent of nursing

homes where at least a quarter ofthe residents are black or Latinohave reported at least one coro-navirus case, a New York Timesanalysis shows. That is double therate of homes where black and La-tino people make up less than 5percent of the population. And in

The Racial Divide of Nursing Home Outbreaks

Bria of Belleville, a rehabilitation and nursing facility in Illinois.WHITNEY CURTIS FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES

Continued on Page A8

Even as states begin to reopenfor business, a further 2.4 millionworkers joined the nation’s unem-ployment rolls last week, andthere is growing concern amongeconomists that many of the lostjobs are gone for good.

The Labor Department’s reportof new jobless claims, releasedThursday, brought the total to 38.6million since mid-March, whenthe coronavirus outbreak forcedwidespread shutdowns.

While workers and their em-ployers have expressed optimismthat most of the joblessness will betemporary, many who are study-ing the pandemic’s impact are in-creasingly worried about the em-ployment situation.

“I hate to say it, but this is goingto take longer and look grimmerthan we thought,” NicholasBloom, an economist at StanfordUniversity, said of the path to re-covery.

Mr. Bloom is a co-author of an

analysis that estimates 42 percentof recent layoffs will result in per-manent job loss.

“Firms intend to hire these peo-ple back,” he said, referring to a re-cent survey of businesses by theFederal Reserve Bank of Atlanta.“But we know from the past thatthese aspirations often don’t turnout to be true.”

The precariousness of the pathahead was underscored Thursdayby the Federal Reserve chair, Je-rome H. Powell. “We are now ex-periencing a whole new level ofuncertainty, as questions only thevirus can answer complicate theoutlook,” he said in remarks fordelivery at an online forum.

The economy that does comeback is likely to look quite differ-ent from the one that closed. If so-

Another 2.4 Million Jobs Vanish,And Many May Be Gone Forever

By PATRICIA COHEN Some Analysts Forecasta Fundamental Shift

Continued on Page A11

When a stay-at-home order inMarch all but closed the reveredlabs of the gene-editing pioneerJennifer Doudna, her team at theUniversity of California, Berkeley,dropped everything and startedtesting for the coronavirus.

They expected their institute tobe inundated with samples since itwas offering the service at nocharge, with support from philan-thropies. But there were few tak-ers.

Instead, the scientists learned,many local hospitals and doctors’offices continued sending sam-ples to national laboratory compa-nies — like LabCorp and Quest Di-agnostics — even though, earlyon, patients had to wait a week ormore for results. The bureaucratichurdles of quickly switching to anew lab were just too high.

“It’s still amazing to me, like,how can that be the case, thatthere is not a more systematicway to address a central need?”

said Fyodor Urnov, the scientistwho oversaw the transformationof the Innovative Genomics Insti-tute into a clinical laboratory.

The inability of the UnitedStates to provide broad diagnostictesting, widely seen as a pivotalfailing in the nation’s effort to con-tain the virus, has been traced tothe botched rollout by the Centersfor Disease Control and Preven-tion, the tardy response by theFood and Drug Administration,and supply shortages of swabsand masks.

Yet one major impediment totesting has been largely over-looked: the fragmented, poorly or-ganized American health caresystem, which made it difficult forhospitals and other medicalproviders to quickly overcome ob-

In Testing Chaos, Some LabsDrowned While Others Sat Idle

By KATIE THOMAS Bureaucratic ObstaclesFavor a Few Giants

Continued on Page A5

Engineers fear there may be morefailures like the one this week in Michi-gan as the world gets warmer. PAGE A20

NATIONAL A17-25

Dams vs. Climate Change

A strict weekend curfew leaves theTurkish city’s streets mostly empty, butthe ovens of the baklava makers are fullof life. Istanbul Dispatch. PAGE A10

TRACKING AN OUTBREAK A4-13

Quiet Istanbul, but Busy BakersA scientist argues that the quest for fullyautomated robots is misguided, perhapseven dangerous. His decades of warn-ings are gaining attention. PAGE B1

BUSINESS B1-7

Robots That Lean on Humans

This summer’s reading list will have todo a little more than usual to help usescape our surroundings. PAGE C1

WEEKEND ARTS C1-16

Pages That’ll Take You Away

Facing health questions and a shrinkingwindow of opportunity, Tiger Woods isset to return to competition. PAGE B8

SPORTSFRIDAY B8-9

All Eyes Are on Woods’s Back

With 14 months to go before the re-scheduled Tokyo Olympics, everythingabout them is uncertain. PAGE B9

The Doubtful Games

Tim Morrison PAGE A27

EDITORIAL, OP-ED A26-27

The move is a dramatic change from anoffice-centric culture. But there’s acatch: Salaries are likely to change tomatch local costs of living. PAGE B1

Facebook to Keep Remote Work

Despite the addition of 90,000 sub-scribers since March, the venerablepublication said it would eliminate 68jobs, or 17 percent of its staff. PAGE B1

Layoffs at The Atlantic

Watching theater online can feel like apale imitation of being there, but sometechnologies are changing that. PAGE C4

Bringing Digital Plays to Life

A 130-mile coastline that is an economicengine and a cultural touchstone has hadits usual rhythms upended. PAGE A13

Distancing at the Jersey Shore

Relatives of an ex-intelligence officialwho has hidden in Canada since 2017were arrested in Riyadh. PAGE A14

INTERNATIONAL A14-16

Saudi Intimidation AllegedThe president has decided to tell Russiathat the United States will withdrawfrom the Open Skies Treaty. PAGE A20

Trump to Leave Arms Pact

Late Edition

VOL. CLXIX . . . No. 58,701 © 2020 The New York Times Company NEW YORK, FRIDAY, MAY 22, 2020

Today, sunshine, increasing clouds,afternoon showers, not as cool, high70. Tonight, cloudy, showers, low 59.Tomorrow, rather cloudy, showers,high 69. Weather map, Page A22.

$3.00