innovations in thermal conversion
TRANSCRIPT
Innovations in Thermal Conversion
Bill Toffey, MABA
Stan Chilson, GHD-CET
Biosolids Session, WaterJAM
September 10, 2012
A Holy Grail for Biosolids
Biosolids to Biofuels
• Enjoys popular public support as “sustainable”
• Addresses risks of land application and disposal for release of pollutants and odors
• Biofuels for transportation the highest value form of energy
• Draws from the innovative-rich biofuels sector
• The wastewater agency itself is customer and avoids retail costs
• High biosolids disposal costs attracts investors
Inn
ova
tio
ns
in T
he
rma
l Co
nve
rsio
n,
Bill
To
ffe
y (M
AB
A)
& S
tan
Ch
ilso
n
(GH
D-C
ET
), S
ep
tem
be
r 1
0,
20
12
2
Like the Grail Search… an Adventure
What we face with conversion of biosolids
• Landscape littered with failures over 30 years
• “Oil from Sludge” (OFS) efforts in Canada , LA City
gasifier, Carver-Greenfield, and the Subiaco Plant in
Australia ended long ago
• A more complicated biomass than woodchips
• A wet material with a high inorganic content
• Complicated material handling
• A “gummy” phase at the 55% to 75% content
• Procurement difficulty: long-term, innovative
Inn
ova
tio
ns
in T
he
rma
l Co
nve
rsio
n,
Bill
To
ffe
y (M
AB
A)
& S
tan
Ch
ilso
n
(GH
D-C
ET
), S
ep
tem
be
r 1
0,
20
12
3
The Energy in Wastewater Solids
Rules of Thumb• Influent Organic Energy per Population
Equivalent = 0.12 pounds per day
• BTU of a pound of organic matter = 10,000
• Proportion of O.M. = 60 to 80%
• Rough conversion of influent organic matter to sludge solids = 1.0 : 0.8, so about 1/10th pound of organic energy per capita or 1,000 BTUs per capita.
• If all converted to biomethane = 1 S.C.F.
Inn
ova
tio
ns
in T
he
rma
l Co
nve
rsio
n,
Bill
To
ffe
y (M
AB
A)
& S
tan
Ch
ilso
n
(GH
D-C
ET
), S
ep
tem
be
r 1
0,
20
12
4
The Variable Value of Energy
Energy Units vary in price• Natural Gas is CHEAP: $8/MMBTU ($.03/kWh)
• Biodiesel is EXPENSIVE: $24/MMBTU ($.10/kWh)
• Electricity is EXPENSIVE: $30/MMBTU ($.12/kWh)
Energy Production Varies in Cost• Natural Gas Fueled Generator: $1,000/kW
• Biogas CHP production: $4,000/kW
• Solar PV: $6,000/kW
• MSW Electric: $8,000/KW
Biosolids Thermal Processing• Biosolids dryer: $ 1000/dryton/yr or $60,000/ MGGY
Inn
ova
tio
ns
in T
he
rma
l Co
nve
rsio
n,
Bill
To
ffe
y (M
AB
A)
& S
tan
Ch
ilso
n
(GH
D-C
ET
), S
ep
tem
be
r 1
0,
20
12
5
Biosolids to Biofuels
Status of Full Scale Operations
EnerTech: thermal
depolymerization and drying to fuel in
Rialto, California, recently declared
bankruptcy
MaxWest: facility in Sanford, CA,
with “second generation” gasifier, now
undergoing commissioning.
Inn
ova
tio
ns
in T
he
rma
l Co
nve
rsio
n,
Bill
To
ffe
y (M
AB
A)
& S
tan
Ch
ilso
n
(GH
D-C
ET
), S
ep
tem
be
r 1
0,
20
12
6
EnerTech Slurry Carb Process
SlurryCarb® technology thermally converts biosolids and other high-moisture feedstocks into a renewable fuel through a molecular rearrangement, processing biosolids as a fluid and creating an eFuel that is an excellent replacement for fossil fuels with zero net greenhouse gas emissions.
Inn
ova
tio
ns
in T
he
rma
l Co
nve
rsio
n,
Bill
To
ffe
y (M
AB
A)
& S
tan
Ch
ilso
n
(GH
D-C
ET
), S
ep
tem
be
r 1
0,
20
12
7
Biosolids to Biofuels
Examples of Demonstration/Proposed Facilities• California demonstration unit: conversion of biosolids to
syngas followed by steam reformation to liquid fuel using Fischer-Tropsch catalysis.
• Greenharvestone: demo unit planned in Lancaster County PA WWTF digester and gasifier.
• Intellergy a thermal process in California to produce hydrogen for fuel cell operation, demo not funded.
• Enginuity Engineers’ “Ecoremedy” gasification of biomass to syngas to steam-powered generator.
• PyroBioMethane create pyrolysis oil from dried pellets, returned to anaerobic digester for methane for CHP.
• Delta Thermo in Allentown PA plans to pressurize biosolids with MSW as fuel for steam-fired generator.
Inn
ova
tio
ns
in T
he
rma
l Co
nve
rsio
n,
Bill
To
ffe
y (M
AB
A)
& S
tan
Ch
ilso
n
(GH
D-C
ET
), S
ep
tem
be
r 1
0,
20
12
8
Pyrolysis/Gasification - the Distinction
Pyrolysis:
Thermal Conversion of solid fuel in the complete absence of oxidizing agent (air / oxygen)
Volatile matter is chemically changed to carbon by heat. ( typically 1,200 to 1,650 F)
Gasification:Carbon is gasified through reaction with air / oxygen / steam / hydrogen at elevated temperatures.
Inn
ova
tio
ns
in T
he
rma
l Co
nve
rsio
n,
Bill
To
ffe
y (M
AB
A)
& S
tan
Ch
ilso
n
(GH
D-C
ET
), S
ep
tem
be
r 1
0,
20
12
9
Indirectly Heated Rotary Kiln for Pyrolysis
The most common pyrolysis furnace has been the indirectly heated rotary
kiln (externally heated, high alloy, stainless steel tube). Only a very limited
number have been used in waste-to-energy applications.
Few of these have been used for biosolids
Inn
ova
tio
ns
in T
he
rma
l Co
nve
rsio
n,
Bill
To
ffe
y (M
AB
A)
& S
tan
Ch
ilso
n
(GH
D-C
ET
), S
ep
tem
be
r 1
0,
20
12
10
Pyrolysis Typical Heat & Material Balance
Pyrolysis
Reactor
Inn
ova
tio
ns
in T
he
rma
l Co
nve
rsio
n,
Bill
To
ffe
y (M
AB
A)
& S
tan
Ch
ilso
n
(GH
D-C
ET
), S
ep
tem
be
r 1
0,
20
12
11
Fast pyrolysis yield of bio-fuels up to 75% of dry feed, typically, 65% liquids
and 10% non-condensable gases; at higher temps, convert more to syngas
Slow pyrolysis maximizes the charcoal yield.
Fast vs. Slow Pyrolysis Yield
Inn
ova
tio
ns
in T
he
rma
l Co
nve
rsio
n,
Bill
To
ffe
y (M
AB
A)
& S
tan
Ch
ilso
n
(GH
D-C
ET
), S
ep
tem
be
r 1
0,
20
12
12
What is Gasification ?
Gasification is a two step or combined step
thermo-chemical reaction.
1. Pyrolysis – Volatile matter is chemically changed to
carbon by heat.
2. Carbon is gasified through reaction with air /
oxygen / steam / hydrogen.
(about 30% of oxygen required for combustion)
Inn
ova
tio
ns
in T
he
rma
l Co
nve
rsio
n,
Bill
To
ffe
y (M
AB
A)
& S
tan
Ch
ilso
n
(GH
D-C
ET
), S
ep
tem
be
r 1
0,
20
12
13
Gasifier Configuration
• Air / Oxygen / Steam Heating Systems
Air - 150 to 250 Btu / cu ft Syngas
Oxygen - 300 to 350 Btu / cu ft Syngas
Steam - 350 to 500 Btu / cu ft Syngas
• Up-Draft - Counter - Current Fixed Bed
• Down-Draft - Co-Current Fixed Bed
• Fluid Bed, Mixed Bed, Entrained Bed
Inn
ova
tio
ns
in T
he
rma
l Co
nve
rsio
n,
Bill
To
ffe
y (M
AB
A)
& S
tan
Ch
ilso
n
(GH
D-C
ET
), S
ep
tem
be
r 1
0,
20
12
14
COUNTER-CURRENT FIXED BED (up-draft) GASIFIER
Fixed bed of carbonaceous fuel through which the "gasification agent" (steam, oxygen and/or air) flows in counter-current configuration.
CO-CURRENT FIXED BED (down-flow) GASIFIER
Similar to the counter-current type, but the gasification agent gas flows in co-current configuration with the fuel.
Gasifiers Deployed for Biomass
Inn
ova
tio
ns
in T
he
rma
l Co
nve
rsio
n,
Bill
To
ffe
y (M
AB
A)
& S
tan
Ch
ilso
n
(GH
D-C
ET
), S
ep
tem
be
r 1
0,
20
12
15
Small Downdraft Gasifier
Inn
ova
tio
ns
in T
he
rma
l Co
nve
rsio
n,
Bill
To
ffe
y (M
AB
A)
& S
tan
Ch
ilso
n
(GH
D-C
ET
), S
ep
tem
be
r 1
0,
20
12
16
Nexterra Up-flow Gasifier Eisenmann
Corporation Pyrobustor
Updraft Gasifiers
Inn
ova
tio
ns
in T
he
rma
l Co
nve
rsio
n,
Bill
To
ffe
y (M
AB
A)
& S
tan
Ch
ilso
n
(GH
D-C
ET
), S
ep
tem
be
r 1
0,
20
12
17
Feedstock is fluidized in air, or oxygen and steam. The ash is removed dry as heavy agglomerates that defluidize.
Fluidized Bed Gasifier
Courtesy:
Energy Products of Idaho
Inn
ova
tio
ns
in T
he
rma
l Co
nve
rsio
n,
Bill
To
ffe
y (M
AB
A)
& S
tan
Ch
ilso
n
(GH
D-C
ET
), S
ep
tem
be
r 1
0,
20
12
18
Thermal Conversion Benefits
• Clean emissions, Carbon Neutral
• Greater biosolids volume reduction than dryers alone.
• Process autogenous, No auxiliary fuel if input is dry.
• No wet scrubber, no recycle streams to WWTP.
• No pathogens, odors,
• Persistent organics destroyed
• Low or no NOx, SOx.
• Immobilization of heavy metals.
• Carbon char may have beneficial uses.
• Even antibiosolids activists, support energy conversion
Inn
ova
tio
ns
in T
he
rma
l Co
nve
rsio
n,
Bill
To
ffe
y (M
AB
A)
& S
tan
Ch
ilso
n
(GH
D-C
ET
), S
ep
tem
be
r 1
0,
20
12
19
ChallengesReduction of moisture in biosolids is the primary
impediment to export energy from thermal biosolids
processes. Separate stage drying is necessary for
process viability.
Biosolids can have low ash fusion temperatures.
Addition of aluminum or lime may be required for the
raising the fusion temperatures.
Gasification of biosolids biomass remains in the
development stage, with rare exceptions, based on its
relatively high cost and the low reliability for long-term
operation compared to direct combustion
Inn
ova
tio
ns
in T
he
rma
l Co
nve
rsio
n,
Bill
To
ffe
y (M
AB
A)
& S
tan
Ch
ilso
n
(GH
D-C
ET
), S
ep
tem
be
r 1
0,
20
12
20
Pyrolysis / Gasification used to produce liquid fuels (oil)
using Integrated Gasification Combined Cycles, with the
possibility of producing methane and hydrogen for fuel
cells.
Challenges
Gasification technologies have been developed that use
plastic-rich waste as a feed. In Germany such a
technology converts plastic waste via syngas into
methanol.
Inn
ova
tio
ns
in T
he
rma
l Co
nve
rsio
n,
Bill
To
ffe
y (M
AB
A)
& S
tan
Ch
ilso
n
(GH
D-C
ET
), S
ep
tem
be
r 1
0,
20
12
21
The efficient removal of tar / slag remains a technical
barrier for the successful commercialization of
biomass gasification technologies.
Financial and regulatory climate averse to risk, energy
prices are soft, and public demand for response to
climate change has softened.