indiana university bloomington d.t. dibaba mph, s. horbal mph, m. a. sayegh phd, mph indiana...

17
INDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTON INDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTON D.T. Dibaba MPH, S. Horbal MPH, M. A. Sayegh PhD, MPH Indiana University School of Public Health- Bloomington Department of Epidemiology and Biostatistics Bloomington, IN USA The association between maternal alcohol intake during pregnancy and the risk of intrauterine growth restriction, low birth weight, preterm birth and small for gestational age: A Meta-analysis

Upload: phillip-campbell

Post on 21-Jan-2016

237 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: INDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTON D.T. Dibaba MPH, S. Horbal MPH, M. A. Sayegh PhD, MPH Indiana University School of Public Health- Bloomington Department

INDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTONINDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTON

D.T. Dibaba MPH, S. Horbal MPH, M. A. Sayegh PhD, MPH

Indiana University School of Public Health- Bloomington Department of Epidemiology and Biostatistics

Bloomington, IN USA

The association between maternal alcohol intake during pregnancy and the risk of intrauterine growth restriction, low birth weight, preterm birth and small for gestational age: A Meta-analysis

Page 2: INDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTON D.T. Dibaba MPH, S. Horbal MPH, M. A. Sayegh PhD, MPH Indiana University School of Public Health- Bloomington Department

INDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTONINDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTON

The prevalence of alcohol use during pregnancy in the USA is about 12.5%, in 2011. (CDC, 2012).

Maternal alcohol use during pregnancy is one of the major risk factors related with adverse birth outcomes.

Introduction

Page 3: INDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTON D.T. Dibaba MPH, S. Horbal MPH, M. A. Sayegh PhD, MPH Indiana University School of Public Health- Bloomington Department

INDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTONINDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTON

Conditions related to preterm birth and low birth weight are the second leading cause of infant death (after birth defects). Mathews T.J. & MacDorman M.F. (2008)

In 2012, 1 of every 9 infant was born premature. CDC (2014)

Introduction

Page 4: INDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTON D.T. Dibaba MPH, S. Horbal MPH, M. A. Sayegh PhD, MPH Indiana University School of Public Health- Bloomington Department

INDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTONINDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTON

Inconsistent epidemiological research findings Chen J.H. (2012), Kesmodel U. et al( 2000), McCarthy F.P. et al

(2013), Pfinder M. et al (2013), Patra et al (2011

No other recent meta-analysis on the association between drinking of different levels and the risk of IUGR, LBW, preterm birth or SGA separately

New studies have been conducted since previous meta-analyses

Background

Page 5: INDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTON D.T. Dibaba MPH, S. Horbal MPH, M. A. Sayegh PhD, MPH Indiana University School of Public Health- Bloomington Department

INDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTONINDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTON

Investigate the association of alcohol intake by category (moderate, and heavy intake) during pregnancy with risk of IUGR, LBW, preterm birth and SGA birth by doing meta-analyses of original studies

Objective

Page 6: INDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTON D.T. Dibaba MPH, S. Horbal MPH, M. A. Sayegh PhD, MPH Indiana University School of Public Health- Bloomington Department

INDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTONINDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTON

Drinking Abstinent: no alcoholic drink during pregnancy

Light drinking: <1 drink/day or <5 drinks/week

Moderate drinking : 1 drink/day or 5-7 drinks/week

Heavy drinking: ≥3 drinks/day or >7 drinks/week

Methods: Measures

Page 7: INDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTON D.T. Dibaba MPH, S. Horbal MPH, M. A. Sayegh PhD, MPH Indiana University School of Public Health- Bloomington Department

INDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTONINDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTON

Outcomes

LBW: birth weight<2500g

SGA: birth weight <10th percentile of babies with the same gestational age

IUGR: birth weight<10th percentile for birth weight and <2.5th percentile for abdominal circumference

Preterm: birth<37th weeks of gestation

Methods: Measures

Page 8: INDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTON D.T. Dibaba MPH, S. Horbal MPH, M. A. Sayegh PhD, MPH Indiana University School of Public Health- Bloomington Department

INDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTONINDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTON

Searched online original studies indexed in PubMed, ScienceDirect, and Google Scholar

Used key words and medical subject headings

Retrieved additional articles through hand search of reference lists in relevant articles

Methods:Literature Search

Page 9: INDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTON D.T. Dibaba MPH, S. Horbal MPH, M. A. Sayegh PhD, MPH Indiana University School of Public Health- Bloomington Department

INDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTONINDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTON

Used Fixed and random effects meta-analysis models in

STATA to pool OR and 95%CIs.Used I2 to assess heterogeneityUsed Egger’s test and funnel plot to assess

publication bias

Methods:Analysis

Page 10: INDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTON D.T. Dibaba MPH, S. Horbal MPH, M. A. Sayegh PhD, MPH Indiana University School of Public Health- Bloomington Department

INDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTONINDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTON

A total of 208,519 mother-infant dyads including:

89,763 participants from 7 cohort studies

9,262 from 5 case-control studies, and

109,494 participants from 8 cross-sectional studies

Results

Page 11: INDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTON D.T. Dibaba MPH, S. Horbal MPH, M. A. Sayegh PhD, MPH Indiana University School of Public Health- Bloomington Department

INDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTONINDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTON

In the cohort studies, compared to abstainers, heavy alcohol intake during pregnancy is directly associated with increased risk of preterm birth.

Results

Page 12: INDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTON D.T. Dibaba MPH, S. Horbal MPH, M. A. Sayegh PhD, MPH Indiana University School of Public Health- Bloomington Department

INDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTONINDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTON

In cohort studies, heavy alcohol intake is not significantly associated with the following outcomes:

IUGR, OR = 1.14 (0.48, 2.70)

LBW, OR = 1.51 (0.67, 3.39)

SGA, OR = 0.95 (0.59, 1.53)

Results

Page 13: INDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTON D.T. Dibaba MPH, S. Horbal MPH, M. A. Sayegh PhD, MPH Indiana University School of Public Health- Bloomington Department

INDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTONINDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTON

Heavy alcohol intake is directly associated with the risk of LBW in cross-sectional studies.

Results

Page 14: INDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTON D.T. Dibaba MPH, S. Horbal MPH, M. A. Sayegh PhD, MPH Indiana University School of Public Health- Bloomington Department

INDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTONINDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTON

ResultsIn case-control studies, moderate alcohol intake is inversely associated with risk of SGA.

Page 15: INDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTON D.T. Dibaba MPH, S. Horbal MPH, M. A. Sayegh PhD, MPH Indiana University School of Public Health- Bloomington Department

INDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTONINDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTON

In case-control studies, moderate alcohol intake is inversely associated with risk of preterm birth. OR = 0.80 (0.66, 0.97)

In cross-sectional studies, moderate alcohol intake showed borderline inverse association with risk of low birth weight and preterm birth.

LBW, OR = 0.87 (0.75, 1.02)

Preterm birth, OR = 0.89 (0.78, 1.02)

Results

Page 16: INDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTON D.T. Dibaba MPH, S. Horbal MPH, M. A. Sayegh PhD, MPH Indiana University School of Public Health- Bloomington Department

INDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTONINDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTON

Heavy alcohol intake during pregnancy is directly associated with risk of LBW and preterm birth.

While analyses showed an association between moderate alcohol intake and lowered risk of preterm birth and SGA, these results do not indicate that pregnant women should consume alcohol in any quantity, but only indicate associations that need to be investigated further.

Future studies are needed to understand the effect of moderate and light alcohol intake during pregnancy and adverse birth outcomes.

Conclusion

Page 17: INDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTON D.T. Dibaba MPH, S. Horbal MPH, M. A. Sayegh PhD, MPH Indiana University School of Public Health- Bloomington Department

INDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTONINDIANA UNIVERSITY BLOOMINGTON

Thank you! Questions? Email: [email protected]

The End!