implementing bim concepts on karavanke tunnelling project · bim pilot projects infrastructure,...

44
PARIS15 November 2017 Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project Marko Žibert M.Sc.Civ.Eng. Head of tunnelling, iC group Ljubljana Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project Marko Žibert

Upload: others

Post on 31-Jul-2020

12 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

Implementing BIM concepts on

Karavanke tunnelling projectMarko Žibert M.Sc.Civ.Eng. – Head of tunnelling, iC group Ljubljana

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Page 2: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

Stakeholders

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Page 3: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

Implementing BIM concepts on

Karavanke tunnelling project

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Page 4: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

With our global know-how andcompetencies on site as well as more than 450 colleagues and our experience in 100 countries we provide solutions for projects worldwide.

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Page 5: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017 Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Why using BIM? Are there any benefits?

Page 6: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

Why using BIM? Are there any benefits?

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Page 7: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

BIM Implementation planning

Behind the Scenes

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Page 8: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

Definition of processes (BIM Overview process map)

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Page 9: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

Definition of processes (BIM Coordination)

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Page 10: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

Definition of processes (Other detailed process maps)

5D Modeling

4D Modeling

Model-based revision

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Page 11: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

Communication, Collaboration and Coordination

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Page 12: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

7 joint-venture partners | 15 companies | 60 engineers | > 120.000 hours

Project organization in the design stage

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Page 13: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

Project organization on BIM side

BIM Manager

BIM Overall coordination

BIM Discipline/Trade coordination

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Page 14: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

▪ 8.000 m long tunnel

▪ NATM

▪ > 1.000 m overburden

▪ Complex geology

▪ 2 countries, 2 clients

▪ Apart from tunnel manyother structures are included in the design

Project scope

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Page 15: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

Start of activities: 2014 2016

No. of involved companies:

9 3

No. of partial models: 160 29

3D BIM and Coordination:

4D BIM:

5D BIM:

6D BIM:

LoD: 300 - 400 300

LoI: 400 500

Summary of BIM relatedactivities

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Page 16: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

The Strategy | SLOVENIAN SIDE

KARAVANKE TUNNEL

TRADITIONAL APPROACH

BIM METHODOLOGY

Operation

3D BIM(Design team)

BIM STRATEGY, EIR

Execution

4D, 5D BIM(Design team)

4D, 5D BIM (Contractor)

3D BIM(Design team)

?

4D, 5D BIM(Supervision)

BIM EXECUTION PLAN (BEP)

Projectassignment

Design phase

BIM COORDINATION

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Page 17: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

The Strategy | AUSTRIAN SIDE

INFRA

BIM DATA

STRUCTURE

Research

project

IFC INFRAIFC ROAD

IFC RAIL

IFC BRIDGE

IFC TUNNEL

PLATFORM 4.0ASI, ÖBV, OIAV, FMA

BIM PILOT PROJECTSINFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING

GR

AN

ITZT

AL

TUN

NEL

RA

ILW

AY

STAT

ION

LA

VA

NTA

L KARAVANKE TUNNEL

DesignConstruction

TRADITIONAL APPROACH

BIM METHODOLOGY

Operation

3D BIM, Coordination

6D BIM

EIR, BEP

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Page 18: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

Coordination – 5 Coordination models

Austrian NationalCoordinate System

Slovenian NationalCoordinate System

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Page 19: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

Information modelling in tunnelling

GEOLOGY AND GEOTECHNICS

DRIVEN BY MINING EXPLORATIONLOGGING, MANAGING AND

INTERPRETING DATA

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Page 20: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

Information modelling in tunnelling

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Page 21: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

Information modelling in tunnelling

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Page 22: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

Information modelling in tunnelling

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Page 23: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

Information modelling in tunnelling

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Page 24: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

3D Geological modelling

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Page 25: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

3D Geological modelling

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Page 26: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

3D Geological modelling – using geological data as a basis forcomplex numerical calculations

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

1. Create geotechnical model based on geological & design data

2. Create virtual drillholes describing discrete model

3. Generate ground model forfurther numerical calculations

Page 27: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

Modelling of temporary support structures

"The devil is in the detail"

information

Page 28: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

Spatial data analytics

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Page 29: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

Spatial data analytics

Open GIS database

XML/GML conversion ofparameters

Basis for BIM model of utilities

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Page 30: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

BIM – modelling of permanent works

Early stage modelling goals:

▪ Investigate different scenarios

▪ Costs and time analysis

▪ Communication with stakeholders

Detailed design modelling goals:

▪ Detailed geometry mimicking construction process

▪ Quality assurance by 3C

▪ Quantity take off analysis

▪ Time scheduling and budgeting

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Page 31: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

Early stage of model developmentC

reat

ep

aram

etri

cfa

mili

es

Cre

ate

corr

ido

rp

oin

ts

Re

adco

ord

inat

es

&

cre

ate

pro

file

s

Assembly: distribute parametricfamilies over profiles

BLOCK PROFILE START X START Y START Z END X END Y END Z TM START TM END CROSS SLOPE START CROSS SLOPE END

A001 RQ151 11981.1880 13588.8360 655.328 11978.266 13580.924 655.323 -0+000.304 0+008.130 -4.00% -4.00%

A002 RQ151 > RQ151.1 11978.2660 13580.9240 655.323 11975.434 13572.979 655.320 0+008.130 0+016.565 -4.00% -4.00%

A003 RQ151.1 > RQ104 11975.4340 13572.9790 655.320 11972.691 13565.003 655.322 0+016.565 0+024.999 -4.00% -4.00%

A004 RQ104 11972.6910 13565.0030 655.322 11968.792 13553.127 655.330 0+024.999 0+037.499 -4.00% -4.00%

A005 RQ104 11968.7920 13553.1270 655.330 11965.230 13541.650 655.345 0+037.499 0+049.516 -4.00% -4.00%

A006 RQ104 11965.2300 13541.6500 655.345 11961.721 13529.653 655.369 0+049.516 0+062.016 -4.00% -4.00%

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Page 32: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

Early stage of model development

distribute parametric familiesover profiles

INTERVENTIONS

Distribute niches and otherinterventions according to the

requirementsAll elements are

governed by series of queries each

defining the required

parameters

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Page 33: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

Early stage - 4D (costs) and 5D (time) Modelling

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Page 34: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

Early stage - Communication with stakeholders

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Page 35: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

CONCRETE LINING

¸RO

AD

DES

IGN

MEC

HA

NIC

AL

ELEC

TRIC

AL

DEW

ATE

RIN

G

Detailed design stage - Model segregation

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Page 36: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

UTILITIES

ROAD DESIGN

INNERLINING - STRUCTURES

EQUIPMENT

REINFORCEMENT

Detailed design stage - Model segregation

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Page 37: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

Model Delivery Schedule

Detailed design stage - 190 Partial models

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Page 38: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

Segr

ega

tege

ne

ric

mo

de

l to

d

isci

plin

e sp

ecif

icm

od

els

Create & Analyze detaileddiscipline specific models

Compile federated model

5

UPDATE PROJECT6

Each team uses its owndesign specific tools

COMPILEPROJECT1

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Detailed design stage – Coordination workflows

Page 39: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017 Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Detailed design stage – Efficient design coordination

Page 40: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

Detailed design stage – 1500 inconsistencies resolved in designstage

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Page 41: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

1. Creating „Selection sets“

2. QTO rules for each item in the BoQ connecting „Selection sets“ to QTO rules

Detailed design stage – 4D and 5D Modelling

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Page 42: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

3. Scheduling by means of connecting BIM elements with time schedule

4. Checking simulations, reporting (S-curve, budgeting, etc.)

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Detailed design stage – 4D and 5D Modelling

Page 43: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

?Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert

Detailed design stage – 4D and 5D Modelling

Page 44: Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project · BIM PILOT PROJECTS INFRASTRUCTURE, TUNNELLING GRANITZ T AL TUNNEL TION AL KARAVANKE TUNNEL Design Construction TRADITIONAL

PARIS– 15 November 2017

Detailed design stage – 4D and 5D Modelling

Implementing BIM concepts on Karavanke tunnelling project –

Marko Žibert