ii nd half yearly monitoring report of giri institute of development studies, lucknow on mdm for the...
TRANSCRIPT
2
Giri Institute of Development Studies, Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh
District Monitored : Ambedkar Nagar, Raibarelie, Bahraich ,Gonda
Period of the Report : 1st April 2012 to 30th September 2012
No. of Schools Monitored (Primary & Upper Primary ) :
40 schools in each district
Date of Visit to the Schools/Districts
Ambedkar Nagar: (August 2012)Raibarelie: (August 2012)Bahraich : (August 2012)Gonda : (August 2012)
GIDS has covered MDM Programme in 4 districts of
U.P. namely- Ambedkar Nagar, Raibarelie, Bahraich and
Gonda in its second half yearly monitoring report.
Total number of 27 primary and 10 upper primary
schools have been selected for monitoring from each
district. Thus, the presentation is based on the sample of
total 148 (108 primary and 40 upper primary) schools.
Sl.
No
Particulars Ambedkar
Nagar
Raibarelie Bahraich Gonda Total District
PS UPS TOTAL
1 No. of children
enrolled in schools
6108
(100)
6806
(100)
6163
(100)
5794
(100)
18942 (100)
5929 (100)
24871
(100)
2 No. of children
attending the
school on the day
of visit
2683
(43.93)
3838
(56.39)
3511
(56.97)
2491
(42.99)
9542 (50.37)
2981 (50.28)
12523
(50.35)
3 No. of children
availing MDM as
per MDM register
2393
(39.18)
3730
(54.80)
3511
(56.97)
2491
(42.99)
9354 (49.38)
2771(46.74)
12125
(48.75)
4 No. of children
actually availing
MDM on the day
of visit
2384
(39.03)
3730
(54.80)
3511
(56.97)
2491
(42.99)
9345(49.33)
2771(46.74)
12116
(48.72)
5 No. of children
availed MDM on
the previous day of
visit
2711
(44.38)
3639
(53.47)
4119
(66.83)
3115
(53.76)
10648(56.21)
2936(49.52)
13584
(54.62)
Source: Field Survey, SSA Programme
Sl.NO
Particulars Ambedkar
Nagar
Raibarelie Bahraich Gonda Total District
PS UPS TOTAL
1 No. of schools in which children were satisfied with the quantity of meal
27 (93.11)
34(100)
37 (100)
32(86.49)
96(94.12)
34(97.15)
130(94.89)
2 No. of schools in which children were satisfied with the quality of meal
26(89.66)
28(82.36)
37(100)
32(86.49)
89(87.26)
34(97.15)
123(89.79)
3 If not satisfied with MDM then reason
Menu based food is not provided
- 1(2.95)
- - 1(0.98)
- 1(0.73)
Lack of green vegetable and spice in MDM
1(3.45)
2(5.89)
- - 3(2.95)
- 3(2.19)
Quality of MDM is not better
2(6.92)
3(8.83)
- - 5(4.91)
- 5(3.65)
Total No. of School 29 34 37 37 102 35 137
Table 3: Infrastructure of Kitchen
Source: Field Survey, SSA Programme
Sl.No.
Particulars Ambedkar Nagar
Raibarelie
Bahraich
Gonda Total DistrictPS UPS TOTAL
1 Kitchens are available 35 (94.60)
35(94.60)
36(97.30)
30(81.09)
103(94.50)
33(84.62)
136(91.89)
2 No. of school in which pucca kitchen available
Kitchen-cum-store
29(82.86)
35(100)
36(100)
25(83.33)
95(92.23)
30(90.91)
125(91.91)
Only kitchen
6(17.14)
- - 5(16.67)
8(7.76)
3(9.09)
11(8.09)
3 No. of school in which puccakitchen constructed and used
Kitchen-cum-store
29(82.86)
35(100)
36(100)
23(76.67)
93(90.29)
30(90.91)
123(90.44)
Only kitchen
6(17.14)
- - 4(13.33)
7(6.79)
3(9.09)
10(7.35)
4 No. of school in which puccakitchen constructed and but not used
Kitchen-cum-store
- - - 2(6.67)
2(1.94)
- 2(1.94)
Only kitchen
- - - 1(3.33)
1(0.97)
- 1(0.74)
Table 3: conti…
Source: Field Survey, SSA Programme
Sl.No.
Particulars Ambedkar Nagar
Raibarelie
Bahraich Gonda Total DistrictPS UPS TOTAL
5 No. of school in which puccakitchen constructed under
MDM scheme
1(2.86)
6(17.14)
3(8.33)
15(50.0)
20(19.42)
5(15.15)
25(18.38)
SSAscheme
34(97.14)
29(82.86)
33(91.67)
15(50.0)
83(80.58)
28(84.85)
111(81.62)
6 Sanctioned, but construction not started
- 1(2.70)
- - 1(0.92)
- 1(0.68)
7 Not Sanctioned 2(5.41)
- - 7(18.92)
5(4.59)
4(10.26)
9(6.08)
8 Kitchen not constructed
- - - - - 1(2.56)
1(0.68)
9 Total no of school 37 37 37 37 109 39 148
S.No.
Particulars Ambedkar Nagar
Raibarelie Bahraich Gonda Total DistrictPS UPS TOTAL
1 Number of schools in which weakly menu was displayed at noticeable place
37(100)
37(100)
37(100)
37(100) 109
(100)39
(100)148
(100)
2 Weakly menu followed
29(78.38)
32(86.48)
37
(100)
32
(86.49)
96(88.07)
34(87.18)
130(87.84)
3
Who ensures the weekly menu
MD
M
Auth
ority
37(100)
37(100)
37(100)
37(100)
109(100)
39(100)
148(100)
4MDM was served according to menu
29(78.38)
32(86.48)
37 (100)
32
(86.49
)
96(88.07)
34(87.18)
130(87.84)
Table 4 : Variety in the Menu of MDM
Source: Field Survey, SSA Programme
S.No.
Particulars Ambedkar Nagar
Raibarelie Bahraich Gonda Total DistrictPS UPS TOTAL
5If No, mention reason- (no cooking)
8
(21.62)
5
(32.51)
- 5
(13.51)
13
(11.93)
5
(12.82)
18
(12.16)
6
No. of schools in which MDM was served according to menu on the day of visit
29
(78.38)
32
(86.49)
37
(100)
32
(86.49)
96
(88.07)
34
(87.18)
130
(87.84)
7
Daily menu includes rice/wheat/pulses/vegetables
29
(78.38)
27
(72.97)
37
(100)
34
(91.89)
97
(88.99)
30
(76.92)
127
(85.81)
8Total No. of
schools
37
(100)
37
(100)
37
(100)
37
(100)
109
(100)
39
(100)
148
(100)
Source: Field Survey, SSA Programme
S.No.
Particulars Ambedkar Nagar
Raibarelie
Bahraich
Gonda Total DistrictPS UPS TOTAL
1According to Students
29(78.38)
34
(91.89)
37
(100)
32
(86.49)
98
(89.91)
34
(87.18)
132
(89.19)
2According to Teachers
29(78.38)
34
(91.89)
37
(100)
32
(86.49)
98
(89.91)
34
(87.18)
132
(89.19)
3According to Parents
29(78.38)
34
(91.89)
37
(100)
32
(86.49)
98
(89.91)
34
(87.18)
132
(89.19)
4According to MDM Register
29(78.38)
34
(91.89)
37
(100)
32
(86.49)
98
(89.91)
34
(87.18)
132
(89.19)
Total No. of Schools
37(100)
37(100)
37(100)
37(100)
109(100)
39(100)
148(100)
Source: Field Survey, SSA Programme
S.No.
Particulars Ambedkar Nagar
Raibarelie
Bahraich Gonda Total DistrictPS UPS TOTAL
1
Observe any gender or caste or community discrimination in cooking or serving or seating arrangement
- - - - - - -
2
System of
serving MDM
By cooks/helpers
29(100)
34(100)
37 (100)37
(100)102
(100)35
(100)137
(100)
3
Seating arrange
ment for
MDM
Seating arrangement in class-wise was in line
22(75.86)
27(79.41)
37(100)
37(100)
94(92.16)
29(82.86)
123(89.78)
Tatptti 7 (24.14)7
(20.59)- -
8(7.84)
6(17.14)
14 (10.22)
Total No. of schools29
(100)34
(100)37
(100)37
(100)102
(100)35
(100)137
(100)
Source: Field Survey, SSA Programme
S.No.
Particulars Ambedkar
Nagar
Raibarelie
Bahraich
Gonda Total DistrictPS UPS TOTAL
1 Children encouraged to wash hands before and after meal
29(100)
33(97.06)
37 (100)
37 (100)
101(99.02)
35(100)
136(99.27)
2 Children received MDM in Queue
29(100)
32(94.12)
37 (100)
37 (100)
100(98.04)
35(100)
135(98.54)
3 Conservation of water to clean utensils
29(100)
25(73.53)
30(81.08)
37(100)
90(88.24)
31(88.57)
121(88.32)
4 Cooking process and storage of fuel is safe from fire hazard.
29(100)
34(100)
37(100)
37(100)
102(100)
35(100)
137(100)
5 Total No. of School 29(100)
34(100)
37(100)
37(100)
102(100)
35(100)
137(100)
Table 7: Encouragement to Children to Adopt Good Practices
Source: Field Survey, SSA Programme
S.No Source of Community Awareness
Ambedkar Nagar
Raibarelie
Bahraich Gonda Total DistrictPS UPS TOTAL
1 Newspaper / Magazine
36(97.30)
37(100)
35(94.60)
26(70.27)
96(88.07)
38(97.44)
134(90.54)
2 Villagers / friends / Relatives
25(67.57)
23(62.16)
30(81.08)
37(100)
83(76.15)
32(82.05)
115(77.70)
3 Teacher 36(37.30)
37(100)
30(81.08)
37(100)
102(93.58)
38(97.44)
140(94.60)
4 School (where children studying)
28(75.68)
21(56.76)
29(78.38)
37(100)
83(76.15)
32(82.05)
115(77.70)
5 Radio 32(86.49)
37(100)
5(13.51)
22(59.46)
70(64.22)
26(66.67)
96(64.86)
6 Television 25(67.57)
36(97.30)
6(16.22)
20(54.06)
63(57.80)
24(61.54)
87(58.78)
8 Other (NGO) - - - - - - - Total No. of
Schools37
(100)37
(100)37
(100)37
(100)109
(100)39
(100)148
(100)
Source: Field Survey, SSA Programme
Table 9 : Cost of Cooking Received In Advance by Schools / Implementing Agency
Sl.No
Particulars Ambedkar
Nagar
Raibarelie
Bahraich
Gonda All DistrictPS UPS TOTAL
1 No. of schools in which cooking cost received in advance and regular
27(72.97)
21(56.76)
37(100)
34(91.89)
87(79.82)
32(82.05)
119(80.40)
2 If No, how much delay
With in 30 Days
2(5.41)
- - -2
(1.84)-
2(1.35)
Months 8(21.62)
16(47.06)
-3
(8.82)20
(18.35)7
(17.95)27
(18.24)3 Reasons of
delay1. Not received the money
10(27.03)
16(47.06)
-3
(8.82)22
(20.18)7
(17.95)29
(19.60)
Total No. of schools 37(100)
37(100)
37(100)
37(100)
109(100)
39(100)
148(100)
Source: Field Survey, SSA Programme
Table 9 : Conti..Sl.No
Particulars Ambedkar Nagar
Raibarelie Bahraich
Gonda All DistrictPS UPS TOTAL
4 In case of delay, how does the school/implementing agency manages to ensure that there is no disruption in the feeding programme
Own resources by Gram pradhan/ Head Teacher
2(5.41)
13(38.24)
-3
(8.82)15
(13.7)3
(7.69)18
(12.16)
5 Mode of payment of cooking Cost
Through Bank
37(100)
37(100)
37(100)
37(100)
109(100)
39(100)
148(100)
Total No. of schools 37(100)
37(100)
37(100)
37(100)
109(100)
39(100)
148(100)
Source: Field Survey, SSA Programme
Table 10: Impact of MDM
Sl.
No
ParticularsAmbed
kar Nagar
Raibarelie
Bahraich
Gonda Total DistrictPS UPS TOTAL
1Mid
day
meal
impr
oved
Enrollment of
student
33
(89.19)
33
(89.19)
37
(100)
37
(100)
103
(94.50)
37
(94.83)
140
(94.59)
Attendance of
student
35
(94.59)
35
(94.59)
37
(100)
37
(100)
106
(97.25)
38
(97.44)
144
(97.30)
Improvement
in general
well being
(Health)
33
(89.19)
24
(64.86)
37
(100)
37
(100)
99
(90.83)
32
(82.05)
131
(88.51)
Any other
(specify)- - - - - - -
2 Total No. of School37
(100)37
(100)37
(100)37
(100)109
(100)39
(100)148
(100)
Source: Field Survey, SSA Programme
17
Presentation by: Nodal Officer: Dr. B.K. Bajpai, Senior Fellow,
Giri Institute of Development Studies, Sector – O, Aliganj
Housing Scheme, Lucknow – 226024, Uttar Pradesh
Mobile No:9839300811Email ID : [email protected]