ideology versus justice , democracy and future in sri lanka by udaya r. tennakoon
TRANSCRIPT
Location:
Southern Asia, island in the Indian Ocean, south of India
Area:
total: 65,610 sq km
country comparison to the world: 122land: 64,630 sq km
Slightly larger than Switzerland
water: 980 sq km
We cannot talk about justice and democracy separating from past and present and also other social and political issues
All are interrelated. So that, democracy and justice are sources of politics, economics, social and cultural sections.
Sri Lankan social formation widely can be understood under three periods
1.Pre colonial period
2.Colonial period
3.Post- colonial period
Ethnic conflict
Class Conflict
Environment
And so on
Historiography – Mahavamsa chronical
Narratives
Identity – Split in Identiy (1)
Sinhala vs Sri Lankan
Sinhala vs Tamils
Ideologies – Sinhala- Buddhist- Aryan
Mahavamsa as a historical text, though it has gaps and
contradictions, we cannot avoid in its soul that has being emerging
with glamour throughout the time. In academic scholarship, people
do analyze and deconstruct but in common sense, though people
read or not, listen or not, they believe in its stories and it is
considered more or less as a holy text. Its hegemonic effectiveness
is more powerful than a historical source, when it is brought in
means of identity issues and communalistic sense for political and
religious propagandas. Particularly in ethnic issue, there are lots of
narratives that create Sinhala Buddhist ideology as the safe guard
of Buddhism and the land.
The great chronical
Mahavamsa
“Buddha’s three visits to the Island; first to‘Mahiyaganaya’, second to ‘Nagadeepa’and third to ‘Kelaniya’ are legendrynarratives strongly woven to build thefoundation of Buddhism, though it ishistorically questionable. However, it isbelieved thoroughly and these three visitshave placed sacred feelings in the hearts ofcommon Sinhala Buddhist public and theyconsider the above three places as holyplaces, The importance of this narrativeconveys the recognition of the ideologyfrom generation to generation as symbolsof Sinhala Buddhist power. According toMahavamsa and some arguments ofscholars based on the chronicle, it isimportant to mention here how these threevisits generate the conflict in justificationand it help to strengthen the ideology forSinhalese Buddhists”
Buddha’s Three
Visits
“ When we go through the mythical story ofarrival of Vijaya (in chapters 5-10), Mahavamsatakes us to the past and gives us a wonderfulstory to read about the origin of thegeneration of Vijaya. In the same time, thelegacy of Sinhalese and purity of Buddhismbecome questionable with its relationshipwith Vijaya. These all together do not bring acorrect legitimacy for the legacy of Sinhalese.When the myths are taken to fill the gap ofhistory by making the bridge, the output ofthe ideology that comes out from narrativesbecome controversial. Identity of Sinhaleseand philosophy of Buddhism are connectedthrough with unethical lines of illegitimacyand violence.”
Vijaya- Founder of
Sinhala race
“Dutthagamini in Mahavamsa is one of theeffective mega narratives, which is like arising star constantly in the sky of theBuddhism and Sinhala nationalism in SriLanka. The brightness of the epic has beenexpanding throughout the history in variousstages in politics and it has been reincarnatedin postcolonial Sri Lanka in the context ofethnic issues and the logic of nation building.In this mega narrative, there are subnarratives also go together and separately tostrengthen the ideology of Sinhala Buddhistnationalism.”
Saga of
Duttagamini
Sinhala Buddhist Ideological Triangle
Sinhala Ideology
Buddhist Ideology
Aryan Ideology
“The most elementary definition of ideology is probably the well-known phrase from Marx’s Capital: ‘Siewissen das nicht, abersie tun es’- ‘they do not know it, but they are doing it’. (Zizek)
ownership
ABC Triangle
Politcal changes
have happened
many times in the
post colonial history
Root causes of social
justice and
democracy is always
forgotten after the
political power.
Behavior
Atitiudes
Invisible
Contradictions
B
A C
Sinhalese
TamilsMuslims
BuddhismHinduism
Islam
Chritian
Colonialism - Impacts of colonialism has created conflicts its own for building a new nation after the independence
Social change- capitalism was super imposed.
Perverted society, contradiction with tradition
Ideology – primodial + modern with Sinhala Buddhsit
Aryan ideology
Identity – split of the soul (2)
Portuguese- 1505
Dutch- 1658
British- 1796- 1948
«According to foster asserts that colonialism is more than just a narrative of momentary disarray, for colonialism has become nature itself (colonialism and culture)”
S/B ideological agent: Dharmapala
Abscence of Justice and Democracy
Problem of the nation building
Ethnic conflcit
Political changes
1956- power shifts to a new class
1977- introduction of Liberal economy
1994- so called of humanistic face to the economy
Uprisings- 1971 Southern Youth
1988/ 89
Black July- a historical phenomenan
Last war 2009- Rajapaksha Regime + Tamil Tigers
So called
independence
From 1948
S/B ideological
conveyor: Nalin de
Silva
Sri Lanka can be identified as two sections
1. Post Colonial capitalized part (Sothern) Sinhalese)
2. Neo colonial capitalizing part (North & east) Tamils Muslims
North and East has a different social structure.
Minority Tamils still dominated like slaves, labors,
Clash of Tamils Civilization
Land issues comes out as significant factor
Militarization
Reconciliation
War crimes
Political solution
People – increasing selfishness(in family/ education/ society)
present regime and power hegemony
Other Political power structures
Representative democracy
Law and order
Media
Intellectuals
Religious power
INGOs and NGOs
Civil society
Challenges for
Justics, Democracy
and Peace
Family oriented, corruption, Theft, Drugs
Authoritarian, dictatorship, nationalistic .
Because of these reasons, basic principles of
peace, justice and democracy cannot be
expected
Verbally, government uses Justice, democracy
and Humanity for its survival and
propaganda. In practice: it is problematic
Peace is “their peace”/ “Victor’s peace”
One example:
See the Rajapaksha family tree
A new type of rule in
the post colonial
history
He is accepted
because of the
destruction of LTTE
A new Dutugemunu
A new thought for a
destruction
For all of these, he
uses the executuve
power
Opposition - internal conflict/leadership/policies(It is also one side of the same coin)
Leftist parties- Theory oriented/ Powerless
Pressure groups-
Civil society
About 67 registered political parties
But in mainstream: only a few
Powerless, ideologically weakness
Most of politics are sunk in the sea of
Sinhala Buddhist nationalism
So called progressive politics are also more or less weaker to face the ideology
No space for a single
structure
Divided and
complicated
Frustated people
State controlled
Non Policies
In danger
Freedom of expression for truth
Vagabond(lumpen) “ dangerous class” Truth based, justice
and democracy
based, a media
culture creation is a
challenge
Tactically used by the government
Indirectly silenced, oppression
Disgusted
Outside
So called groups of intellectuals guide the society
Support for the dictatorship and protect the injustice rule
Used by the regime
Partial
Nationalistic/ extremists
Justify violence and oppression
A Virus for peace and harmony
Anti- west
Intolerance
Buddhism
New type of Buddhist
movements –
Bodu Bala sena
Ravana Balakaya
Hela Urumaya
Controlled by the government/ bias
Hidden agendas
Bad images
UN role – unsatisfied
(Blind and Deaf Elephant) Registered NGOs:
1349
Most of these are
talking about peace,
justice, equality
There are three actors
Regime – Victor's peace
International – Agenda peace
Traditional- survival peace
Radical - ?
Political change
Ideological change
su
pe
rstr
uc
ture
Infra
struc
ture
Only a political change
does not support to
gain justice, democracy
and peace
Alternative politics
does not signify for a
holistic change for the
above elements
Base on power, not for
the humanity base
From top to Bottom and bottom to top
Learning by doing
Theory and practice
With holistic approaches
This is to be elaborated by Karl Brunner in the next presentation
It is to be created.
Others experiences
Basic needs (Survival)
Well being
Identiy and dignity
Equity
Unity in DiversityPeace would come
alongwith these
elements
People can be motivated
Time /Space/ Leadership
Honesty/ dedication
Theory and practice
Democratic practice for its own culture