I have several questions. 1. Do you believe the earth is warming? 2. Do you believe CO2 is a pollutant? 3. Do you believe the earth’s warming is being caused by man through the burning of fossil fuels? 4. Why do you believe what you believe?

Media Research Center Global Warming Stories ABC, CBS, NBC Jan. 1, 2013 – July 1, 2013

92

Media Research Center Global Warming Stories ABC, CBS, NBC Jan. 1, 2013 – July 1, 2013

92 How many told you the earth has not warmed for for the last 16 years?

0

The experts they used in their stories favored man-made global warming by a ratio of 8 to 1

AntarcticAntarctic

Pres. Obama - Coast Guard - May 20, 2015 “ The Science is indisputable - more intense droughts….. - rising seas….. - more extreme storms….. - by mid century Artic summer could be Ice free….. Doubling the pace at which we cut carbon pollution”

Fact–Checks 1. The Antarctic ice is increasing 2. The Arctic ice has been stable since 2007 3. Worldwide decrease in hurricanes/typhoons/cyclones during the past three decades 4. A decrease in tornadoes during the past 20 years 5. The number of droughts has been normal 6. Polar bears are thriving 7. Sea level has leveled off

What is the global warming controversy? It is not a question of the earth warming. It has been for over 150 years as we emerge from the Little Ice Age. The debate is over what is causing the warming. Is it CO2 or natural cycles. The intent of this presentation is to show you that data support natural cycles and the case for CO2 very weak.

What does history tell us about the earth’s temperature? The earth’s temperature occurs in cycles. The longest cycle we are aware of is the ice age. An ice age lasts about 100,000 years followed by a 10,000 year warm period. We have been in the current warm period almost 12,000 years.

Cowboy Stadium

1/4

40

CO 2/Temp History

-0.7

-0.5

-0.4

-0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.5

1850 1880 1920 1940 1975 1998 2011

CO 2 Temp

• 380

• 280 CO2

Numerical Model A hypothesis expressed in mathematical terms

TEMP = 1 + 2 + 3 + ETC ? - 3 Greenhouses gases

X

X

T. L. Huxley The great tragedy in science; The slaying of a beautiful hypothesis by an ugly fact! The ugly fact in global warming is there has been no warming for the past 19 years!

97% (?) Scientists support man made Global Warming Survey of 11,944 papers on global Warming 1991 – 2012 Category Number

1. Man primary cause 64 2. Man is cause but how much? 922 3. Man could be cause? 2910 4. No opinion or uncertain 7930 5. Man probably not the cause 54 6. Man not cause but qualifications 15 7. Man not the cause 9 11,944

2009-2013 Climategate Scandal (Based on 22,000 E-mail) - Controlled Climatology Journals

- Greatly influenced other professional Journals i.e. Science, Nature, Geophysical Research Letters

- Controlled Wikipedia - Gained access to key national media - Manipulated data - Demonized skeptics

Forbes magazine Survey 1077 earth scientists 64% believe warming is natural

In 2013, 47 retired NASA Scientists and astronauts challenged NASA’s position on global warming.

Interior Secretary Sally Jewell 2014 “I hope there are no climate change deniers in the Department of Interior”

Recently a number of hard-core warming supporters have become skeptics

Dr. Judith Curry – National Press Club in D.C. 9/2014 “If I were a non-tenured scientist, I would fear for my job! But I am a senior scientist with retirement in sight, so I can afford to do what I want, say what I think”

Dr. Joanne Simpson “Since I am no longer affiliated with any organization nor receive any funding. I can speak frankly and as a scientist I remain skeptical.”

Dr. Patrick Moore (founder of Greenpeace) “Confessions of a Greenpeace Dropout” There is no definitive scientific proof, through real world observations, that CO2 is responsible for warming of the globe.

The Heartland Institute has sponsored 10 international Conferences for skeptics over the last several years. 650 people attended the one in Las Vegas last July.

Who is pushing Global Warming? 1. Some scientist truly believe, particularly the modelers 2. Environmentalist (EPA) - Dr. Jay Lehr - Dr. Alan Carlin “Environmentalism gone Mad”

Who is pushing Global Warming? 3. Profit: Global Warming (G.W.) is a huge business - U.S. spent $150 billion last 15 years - U.S. budget for 2014 was $18 billion 4. International pressure for a One World Government

Maurice Strong Chairman first international meeting on Global Warming Rio 1992 “Isn’t the only hope for the planet, that the industrialized civilizations collapse? Isn’t it our responsibility to bring that about?”

Maurice Strong Chairman first international meeting on Global Warming Rio 1992 “Our concept of ballot-box democracy may need to be modified to produce a strong central government capable of making difficult decisions”

Strobe Talbert – Deputy Sec. of State under Clinton “Nationhood as we know it will be obsolete – all states will recognize a single global authority …… National Sovereignty wasn’t such a good idea”

Vice President Biden Defense Secretary Hagel 2014 We are moving towards a new world order

Ottmar Odenhofer (UN IPCC Official-Lead author of the 4th IPCC Report) Interview with German Newpaper Nov 18, 2010 “We redistribute de facto the world’s wealth by climate policy. One has to free oneself from the illusion that international climate policy is environmental policy”

Dana Rohrabacher U. S. Representative , California “Global Warming is a fraud being used as a tool to create a Global Government”

Christiana Figueres U.N Climate Chief Chairman, Paris Conference 2015 We are setting ourselves the task of changing the economic model that has reigned in the world for the last 150 years

What does that mean? The real goal of environmental activists is not to save the world from ecological calamity, but to destory capitalism

What do we have to show for the billions of dollars we are spending? Numerical models that can’t make accurate forecasts and numerous failed green energy projects

Green Venture Disasters 2009 $535 million to Solyndra - bankrupt 2009 $2.4 billion to 11 electric car companies

- Six are bankrupt - 5 are floundering

2009 $300 million for electric car batteries - Dow Kokam and LG Chem (Korean) - Both bankrupt

Comments on Man-made Global Warming John Coleman – Fox News: 10/27/2014 “A Myth” Tim Ball, PhD – Book: “Corruption of Climate Science” “Greatest Deception” Col. Walt Cunningham – KSTP T.V.: 10/27/2014 “One of the biggest scientific hoaxes In history” Dr. Richard Tol – U.N. IPCC Lead Author “Gore’s claim is complete madness” Russian President Vladimir Putin “Climate Change is a Fraud” Senator James Inhofe’s book “The Greatest Hoax” “Greatest Hoax”