hugo schuchardt and georgia - wordpress.com · 2019. 10. 1. · an eight-page letter by hugo...

29
1 Hugo Schuchardt and Georgia compiled by Marine Aroshidze and Nino Aroshidze Version July 2019 The correspondence of Hugo Schuchardt (1842–1927), a famous Austrian philologist, with Georgian scholars, writers and public figures concerning the Georgian language and culture is one of the most interesting and important phases for Kartvelology. Schuchardt worked in times of great “social turmoil and turbulence”, hence it is not surprising that this stage in the history of Georgian philology was insufficiently covered in Soviet scientific journals praising the superiority of Soviet science over the “representatives of the West.” Publications analysing the impact of western European philology on Georgian scholars appeared only in the post-Soviet period. These publications specifically stress the crucial role of Schuchardt in shaping Kartvelology. The Georgian National Center of Manuscripts cherishes the letters of the Austrian scholar who was multilingual and fluent in Georgian. Zhuzhuna Peikrishvili and Iveta Vashakidze, the authors of Materials for the History of International Kartvelian Studies, indicate that Schuchardt was so knowledgeable of the structure of the Georgian language that he was the first to draw the Georgian scholar’s attention to certain interesting characteristics such as: (1) the features of the Georgian ejectives, (2) the character of stress, (3) forms of the instrumental case, (4) transitive verbs, (5) ergative structures, etc. Furthermore, Georgian culturologists note the invaluable contribution of Schuchardt to the study of the ancient Georgian manuscripts. Unfortunately, only a small part of Schuchardt’s letters was preserved in Georgia. His lively correspondence with scientists, writers and public figures in Georgia included prominent names such as Ilia Chavchavadze, Nicholas Marr, Akaki Shanidze, Petre Melikishvili, Mose Janashvili, Alexander Khakhanashvili, or Ivane Javakhishvili. These letters reveal the exchange of opinions, requests to send books in Georgian, verification of the opinions, and, of course, scientific disputes. Vakhtang Imnaishvili, who studied the correspondence of the Georgian scientists and public figures, also worked with the Hugo Schuchardt Archive established at Graz University (http://schuchardt.uni-graz.at), and very symbolically titled his study Ardavitskebaeba Mokvrisa (which in antonymic translation results in something like “Memory of the Loved Ones”), which analyses the correspondence of Hugo Schuchardt with Georgian scholars. The present document aims to provide a first insight into the traces of materials on Schuchardt kept in Georgia today. Despite the importance of his works to the development of Kartvelology, there is no separate book devoted to Schuchardt in Georgian language. Also, his books were never translated into the Georgian, mostly because his contemporary linguists such as A. Shanidze, N. Marr or A. Chikobava knew German and/or French and were therefore able to draw on his German-language books as references. In Soviet Georgia, translations into Georgian got very limited in general, and translations of foreign scientists were not encouraged at all, neither into Russian nor into Georgian. Therefore, section 1 exemplarily shows a pre-Soviet translation of one of Schuchardt’s works into Russian. Section 2 stresses the public attention to Schuchardt’s works in Georgian society by looking at late 19 th -century newspapers and contemporary comments on the philologist’s work on the Georgian language. Section 3 then reproduces the correspondence between Schuchardt and Georgian public figures of the time, in German, Georgian and French language, as they are kept today at the Georgian National Centre of Manuscripts. Section 4 then provides a few references to Schuchardt and his work by Georgian scholars with the already mentioned lack of a single monograph in Georgian language.

Upload: others

Post on 14-Aug-2021

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Hugo Schuchardt and Georgia - WordPress.com · 2019. 10. 1. · An eight-page letter by Hugo Schuchardt to Alexandr Khakhanashvili. In German. 01.03.1896. Sent from Graz. The extensive

1

HugoSchuchardtandGeorgia

compiledbyMarineAroshidzeandNinoAroshidze

VersionJuly2019

The correspondence of Hugo Schuchardt (1842–1927), a famous Austrian philologist, with

Georgianscholars,writersandpublicfiguresconcerningtheGeorgianlanguageandcultureisoneof

themost interesting and important phases for Kartvelology. Schuchardt worked in times of great

“social turmoilandturbulence”,hence it isnotsurprisingthatthisstage inthehistoryofGeorgian

philology was insufficiently covered in Soviet scientific journals praising the superiority of Soviet

scienceoverthe“representativesoftheWest.”PublicationsanalysingtheimpactofwesternEuropean

philologyonGeorgianscholarsappearedonlyinthepost-Sovietperiod.Thesepublicationsspecifically

stressthecrucialroleofSchuchardtinshapingKartvelology.

TheGeorgianNationalCenterofManuscriptscherishesthelettersoftheAustrianscholarwho

wasmultilingualand fluent inGeorgian.ZhuzhunaPeikrishviliand IvetaVashakidze, theauthorsof

Materials for the History of International Kartvelian Studies, indicate that Schuchardt was soknowledgeableofthestructureoftheGeorgianlanguagethathewasthefirsttodrawtheGeorgian

scholar’s attention to certain interesting characteristics such as: (1) the features of the Georgian

ejectives,(2)thecharacterofstress,(3)formsoftheinstrumentalcase,(4)transitiveverbs,(5)ergative

structures,etc.Furthermore,GeorgianculturologistsnotetheinvaluablecontributionofSchuchardt

tothestudyoftheancientGeorgianmanuscripts.

Unfortunately,onlyasmallpartofSchuchardt’s letterswaspreserved inGeorgia.His lively

correspondencewithscientists,writersandpublicfiguresinGeorgiaincludedprominentnamessuch

as Ilia Chavchavadze,NicholasMarr, Akaki Shanidze, PetreMelikishvili,Mose Janashvili, Alexander

Khakhanashvili,orIvaneJavakhishvili.Theselettersrevealtheexchangeofopinions,requeststosend

booksinGeorgian,verificationoftheopinions,and,ofcourse,scientificdisputes.VakhtangImnaishvili,

whostudiedthecorrespondenceoftheGeorgianscientistsandpublicfigures,alsoworkedwiththe

Hugo Schuchardt Archive established at Graz University (http://schuchardt.uni-graz.at), and very

symbolically titled his study Ardavitskebaeba Mokvrisa (which in antonymic translation results in

somethinglike“MemoryoftheLovedOnes”),whichanalysesthecorrespondenceofHugoSchuchardt

withGeorgianscholars.

ThepresentdocumentaimstoprovideafirstinsightintothetracesofmaterialsonSchuchardt

keptinGeorgiatoday.DespitetheimportanceofhisworkstothedevelopmentofKartvelology,there

isnoseparatebookdevotedtoSchuchardtinGeorgianlanguage.Also,hisbookswerenevertranslated

into the Georgian, mostly because his contemporary linguists such as A. Shanidze, N.Marr or A.

ChikobavaknewGermanand/orFrenchandwere thereforeable todrawonhisGerman-language

books as references. In SovietGeorgia, translations intoGeorgian got very limited in general, and

translationsofforeignscientistswerenotencouragedatall,neitherintoRussiannorintoGeorgian.

Therefore, section 1 exemplarily shows a pre-Soviet translation of one of Schuchardt’sworks into

Russian.Section2stressesthepublicattentiontoSchuchardt’sworksinGeorgiansocietybylooking

at late 19th

-century newspapers and contemporary comments on the philologist’s work on the

Georgianlanguage.Section3thenreproducesthecorrespondencebetweenSchuchardtandGeorgian

publicfiguresofthetime, inGerman,GeorgianandFrenchlanguage,astheyarekepttodayatthe

GeorgianNationalCentreofManuscripts.Section4thenprovidesafewreferencestoSchuchardtand

hisworkbyGeorgianscholarswith thealreadymentioned lackofa singlemonograph inGeorgian

language.

Page 2: Hugo Schuchardt and Georgia - WordPress.com · 2019. 10. 1. · An eight-page letter by Hugo Schuchardt to Alexandr Khakhanashvili. In German. 01.03.1896. Sent from Graz. The extensive

2

1.BooksbyHugoSchuchardt

HugoSchuchardt.Ogeografiiistatistikekartvelskikh(juzhnokavkazskikh)iazikov.Tiflis,1899.

Schuchardt’s“OnGeographyandStatisticsofKartvelian(SouthCaucasian)languages”isasignificant

contribution to the development of Kartvelology, published in Russian in 1899. As a result of

scrupulous work, he drafted a map (“Oblast’ of the Kartvelian language in the South-Western

Caucasus”) that outlines the area of the Kartvelian languages in the south-western Caucasus. He

analysedlanguage,cultureandreligionofthepopulationintheBatumidistrict.

Page 3: Hugo Schuchardt and Georgia - WordPress.com · 2019. 10. 1. · An eight-page letter by Hugo Schuchardt to Alexandr Khakhanashvili. In German. 01.03.1896. Sent from Graz. The extensive

3

2.GeorgianNewspapersonHugoSchuchardt

GeorgianscientistsfollowedHugoSchuchardt‘spublicationsontheGeorgianlanguageasnewspapers

ofthatperiodindicate.Schuchardt’ssurnameaswellashisbooktitlesisgiveninGermanlanguage,

i.e.inLatinletters.

2.1‘Iveria’16September1895

ThiscolumninformsthereadershipofthepublicationofHugoSchuchardt’sbookUberdasGeorgiche

(sic!)inVienna.Attheendofthemessage,itisstressedthattheauthordedicatedhisbooktoprofessor

P.Melikishvili.

Page 4: Hugo Schuchardt and Georgia - WordPress.com · 2019. 10. 1. · An eight-page letter by Hugo Schuchardt to Alexandr Khakhanashvili. In German. 01.03.1896. Sent from Graz. The extensive

4

2.2‘Iveria’21September1895

Fivedayslater,thenewspaperincludedanotherbriefcommentonthebookÜbeddasGeorgische(sic!)

byHugoSchuchardt.Theauthorhighlightsthegreatimportanceofthisworkforthedevelopmentof

Kartvelology.

Page 5: Hugo Schuchardt and Georgia - WordPress.com · 2019. 10. 1. · An eight-page letter by Hugo Schuchardt to Alexandr Khakhanashvili. In German. 01.03.1896. Sent from Graz. The extensive

5

2.3‘Iveria’17November1895

Laterin1895,IveriacommentedonaletterbyHugoSchuchardttoprofessorP.Melikishviliinwhich

theformercommentedontheroleofthenativelanguage.TheeditorialteamnotifiedthatMelikishvili

wouldsoonpublishtheletterbySchuchardtinGeorgian.

Page 6: Hugo Schuchardt and Georgia - WordPress.com · 2019. 10. 1. · An eight-page letter by Hugo Schuchardt to Alexandr Khakhanashvili. In German. 01.03.1896. Sent from Graz. The extensive

6

2.4‘BulletinoftheAjaraArchive’

TheGeorgianinterest inthestudyoftheworksofHugoSchuchardtremainshightothisday.After

havingworkedatUniversityofGraz,Austria,Prof.TamazPutkaradzepublishedanarticleontherole

ofHugoSchuchardtinsecuringancientGeorgianmanuscripts(7th

–11th

centuries)todaykeptinthe

specialcollectionsofUniversityofGraz’slibrary.

Page 7: Hugo Schuchardt and Georgia - WordPress.com · 2019. 10. 1. · An eight-page letter by Hugo Schuchardt to Alexandr Khakhanashvili. In German. 01.03.1896. Sent from Graz. The extensive

7

3.CorrespondencebyH.Schuchardt

The Georgian National Centre of Manuscripts boasts a collection of letters to and from Hugo

Schuchardt; in Georgian, German and in French. They are reproduced here with courtesy of the

GeorgianNationalCentreofManuscripts.

636-1

Atwo-pageletterbyHugoSchuchardttoIliaChavchavadze.InFrench.11.06.1895.SentfromGraz.

Page 8: Hugo Schuchardt and Georgia - WordPress.com · 2019. 10. 1. · An eight-page letter by Hugo Schuchardt to Alexandr Khakhanashvili. In German. 01.03.1896. Sent from Graz. The extensive

8

636-2

Page 9: Hugo Schuchardt and Georgia - WordPress.com · 2019. 10. 1. · An eight-page letter by Hugo Schuchardt to Alexandr Khakhanashvili. In German. 01.03.1896. Sent from Graz. The extensive

9

638

A letterbyHugoSchuchardt to IliaChavchavadze inGeorgian (8.12.1895) inwhichhe thankedthe

latterforsendingthebooksinGeorgian.TheletterwassentfromGraz.

Page 10: Hugo Schuchardt and Georgia - WordPress.com · 2019. 10. 1. · An eight-page letter by Hugo Schuchardt to Alexandr Khakhanashvili. In German. 01.03.1896. Sent from Graz. The extensive

10

639

Aone-pageletterbyHugoSchuchardttoIliaChavchavadze.InFrench.01.07.1895.SentfromGraz.

Page 11: Hugo Schuchardt and Georgia - WordPress.com · 2019. 10. 1. · An eight-page letter by Hugo Schuchardt to Alexandr Khakhanashvili. In German. 01.03.1896. Sent from Graz. The extensive

11

703-1

Atwo-pageletterbyHugoSchuchardttoAlexandrKhakhanashvili.InGerman.06.10.1895.Sentfrom

Friedrichroda.

Page 12: Hugo Schuchardt and Georgia - WordPress.com · 2019. 10. 1. · An eight-page letter by Hugo Schuchardt to Alexandr Khakhanashvili. In German. 01.03.1896. Sent from Graz. The extensive

12

703-2

Page 13: Hugo Schuchardt and Georgia - WordPress.com · 2019. 10. 1. · An eight-page letter by Hugo Schuchardt to Alexandr Khakhanashvili. In German. 01.03.1896. Sent from Graz. The extensive

13

705-1

Aneight-page letterbyHugoSchuchardt toAlexandrKhakhanashvili. InGerman. 01.03.1896. Sent

fromGraz.Theextensive lengthofthe letter isexplainedbythescientificdispute.Theauthorcalls

Khakhanashvili his ‘dear colleague’. Pay attention to page 4with theGeorgian exampleswith the

transcription.

Page 14: Hugo Schuchardt and Georgia - WordPress.com · 2019. 10. 1. · An eight-page letter by Hugo Schuchardt to Alexandr Khakhanashvili. In German. 01.03.1896. Sent from Graz. The extensive

14

705-2

Page 15: Hugo Schuchardt and Georgia - WordPress.com · 2019. 10. 1. · An eight-page letter by Hugo Schuchardt to Alexandr Khakhanashvili. In German. 01.03.1896. Sent from Graz. The extensive

15

705-3

Page 16: Hugo Schuchardt and Georgia - WordPress.com · 2019. 10. 1. · An eight-page letter by Hugo Schuchardt to Alexandr Khakhanashvili. In German. 01.03.1896. Sent from Graz. The extensive

16

705-4

Page 17: Hugo Schuchardt and Georgia - WordPress.com · 2019. 10. 1. · An eight-page letter by Hugo Schuchardt to Alexandr Khakhanashvili. In German. 01.03.1896. Sent from Graz. The extensive

17

705-5

Page 18: Hugo Schuchardt and Georgia - WordPress.com · 2019. 10. 1. · An eight-page letter by Hugo Schuchardt to Alexandr Khakhanashvili. In German. 01.03.1896. Sent from Graz. The extensive

18

705-6

Page 19: Hugo Schuchardt and Georgia - WordPress.com · 2019. 10. 1. · An eight-page letter by Hugo Schuchardt to Alexandr Khakhanashvili. In German. 01.03.1896. Sent from Graz. The extensive

19

705-7

Page 20: Hugo Schuchardt and Georgia - WordPress.com · 2019. 10. 1. · An eight-page letter by Hugo Schuchardt to Alexandr Khakhanashvili. In German. 01.03.1896. Sent from Graz. The extensive

20

705-8

Page 21: Hugo Schuchardt and Georgia - WordPress.com · 2019. 10. 1. · An eight-page letter by Hugo Schuchardt to Alexandr Khakhanashvili. In German. 01.03.1896. Sent from Graz. The extensive

21

707-1

Afour-pageletterbyHugoSchuchardttoAlexandrKhakhanashvili.InGerman.27.09.1896.Sentfrom

Gotha.AscientificconversationbetweentwocolleagueswithGeorgianexamplesonthesecondpage.

Page 22: Hugo Schuchardt and Georgia - WordPress.com · 2019. 10. 1. · An eight-page letter by Hugo Schuchardt to Alexandr Khakhanashvili. In German. 01.03.1896. Sent from Graz. The extensive

22

707-2

Page 23: Hugo Schuchardt and Georgia - WordPress.com · 2019. 10. 1. · An eight-page letter by Hugo Schuchardt to Alexandr Khakhanashvili. In German. 01.03.1896. Sent from Graz. The extensive

23

707-3

Page 24: Hugo Schuchardt and Georgia - WordPress.com · 2019. 10. 1. · An eight-page letter by Hugo Schuchardt to Alexandr Khakhanashvili. In German. 01.03.1896. Sent from Graz. The extensive

24

707-4

Page 25: Hugo Schuchardt and Georgia - WordPress.com · 2019. 10. 1. · An eight-page letter by Hugo Schuchardt to Alexandr Khakhanashvili. In German. 01.03.1896. Sent from Graz. The extensive

25

713-1

Afour-pageletterbyHugoSchuchardttoAlexandrKhakhanashvili.InGerman.23.11.1902.Sentfrom

Graz.ThelatestlettersentbySchuchardt.

Page 26: Hugo Schuchardt and Georgia - WordPress.com · 2019. 10. 1. · An eight-page letter by Hugo Schuchardt to Alexandr Khakhanashvili. In German. 01.03.1896. Sent from Graz. The extensive

26

713-2

Page 27: Hugo Schuchardt and Georgia - WordPress.com · 2019. 10. 1. · An eight-page letter by Hugo Schuchardt to Alexandr Khakhanashvili. In German. 01.03.1896. Sent from Graz. The extensive

27

713-3

Page 28: Hugo Schuchardt and Georgia - WordPress.com · 2019. 10. 1. · An eight-page letter by Hugo Schuchardt to Alexandr Khakhanashvili. In German. 01.03.1896. Sent from Graz. The extensive

28

713-4

Page 29: Hugo Schuchardt and Georgia - WordPress.com · 2019. 10. 1. · An eight-page letter by Hugo Schuchardt to Alexandr Khakhanashvili. In German. 01.03.1896. Sent from Graz. The extensive

29

4.LiteratureaboutHugoSchuchardtbyGeorgianscientists

Chikovaba,Arnold.Istoriiaizucheniiaiberiĭsko-kavkazskikhiazykov.Tbilisi,1sted.,Tbilisi1965.

Chikovaba,Arnold.Iberiul-kavkasiurenatashescavlisistoria.2nded.,Tbilisi2008.

Imnaishvili,Vakhtang.Vinyiddaavstriashiqarthulkhelnaverebs.Tbilisi1979.

Imnaishvili,Vakhtang.Ardavicqebamoqvrisa…(kartvelmecniertadasazogadomoghvacetaepistoluri

memkvidreobidan).Tbilisi2006.

Putkaradze,Tamazet.al.(eds.).Kartulienasistoria.Kutaisi2006.

Peikrishvili, Zhuzhuna and Iveta Vashakidze.Masalebi sazghvargaretuli kartvelologiis istoriisatvis.

(MaterialsfortheHistoryofInternationalKartvelianStudies).Tbilisi2012.

Shanidze,Akaki.Qarthulienisstruqturisadaistoriissakithxebi.Tbilisi1957.

Shanidze,Akaki.Qarthulixelnaverebigracshi.TomiIX.Tbilisi1957.