hugh nibley - zeal without knowledge

Upload: syncorswim

Post on 09-Apr-2018

222 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/8/2019 Hugh Nibley - Zeal Without Knowledge

    1/23

    Wtot

    KnowdBy Hugh W. Nibley

    I

  • 8/8/2019 Hugh Nibley - Zeal Without Knowledge

    2/23

    Hugh Nibley (orn 1910) was on o t most accompsdl T C J C L-dSants. A radat o UCLA and UC, Brk, N jond t

    Hstor Dpartmnt at Bram Yon Unvrst n 1946. For

    mor tan or dcads, s wrtns covrd an arra o topcs:

    ancnt stor, potcs, casscs, dcaton, scnc, Eptoo,

    ar Isra, Crstan orns, Book o Mormon and tmps.

    D B d Fd A Rd Mm Sd -pld T Clld W

    H N, a mt-vom srs. Za wtot Knowd

    orna appard n Dao: A Jorna o Mormon Tot,

    smmr 1978, and was atr rprntd n N on t Tm

    and t Tmss: Cassc Essas o H N (1978).

    I

  • 8/8/2019 Hugh Nibley - Zeal Without Knowledge

    3/23

    In one o his ascinating scientiic survey books, tm dan wt t atst dscovrs aot t ran, NCld , Tw m l-d

    md (1) md d m, d (2) l d

    mnd s swtcd o. Bot o ts opratons ar compt

    mracos and compt mstros. I wod k to tak aot

    t rst o tm. Yo can tnk o on on tn at a tm!

    I o pt on a par o asss, on ns n rn, t otr

    n rd, o w not s a r son o t two wn o

    ook aot o, t a fasn o rd and rn. On momnt

    wll , mm wll

    d. O m j m

    tms as o stn to a Bac , wt qa awarnss o

    m, ll jmp w

    rconton rst o on and tn anotr. T ar, k t ,

    , wd N. S. Sld, lw f .. . . dd mp

    pd, d m w l m w w

    s and mak a rapd sccsson o mods o t word n or

    md. O w w Wllm Jm ll

    lm, zz wld, w

    strctr or own mann comnaton o mprssons, and

    a or vs sct ot o t vast nmr o mprssons crtan w . A N , T

    models wat w s and notn s. W od tosands o

    mp p j l

    mak or cocs and drop tos w dont want. As on xprt

    pts t: Tr sms to a knd o tr nsd t ad wc

    wakns nwantd snas wtot ockn tm ot. Ot o t

    1. N Cadr, T Mnd o Man (London: BBC, 1970), p. 25.

    2. Id., p. 169.

    3. Loc. Ct.

  • 8/8/2019 Hugh Nibley - Zeal Without Knowledge

    4/23

    ackrond o t mnd constant snas drat cocs.

    W t mnd cooss to ocs on on ojct to t xcson

    ll m m. B l:

    ld- l wd , d wavor ar or drat cocs.

    T p p -l w

    ntrodcd nto a cav o ncrd trasrs and prmttd to

    m p w m w l .

    Wat a dt staton! I can tnk o antn I want to

    ll ! W p, w I

    to ocs m attnton on on ojct, a otr ojcts drop nto

    t ackrond. I am on prmttd to tnk o on tn at a

    tm, tat s on r o t am.

    An qa mportant r s tat I mst kp tnkn! Excpt

    dl - pd I d . Lm

    pns tojors, sas Maranc: W ar awas tnkn o

    something, sctn wat w t nto t word w ar makn l. Sp w : D Wl m

    Vll. Ad d I : W wld

    l I ld w d w m

    onc, I cod s at on and t sam momnt not on wat

    s rt or m, t qa w wat s on m t sd, m

    d, w m d lw m? I ml

    crtant tat somtn s tr and as m s fckr aot, Itnk I can sstantat tat mprsson. Bt as to takn a cam

    and drat ook at mor tan on tn at a tm, tat s a

    t dnd s at prsnt. I cannot man wat sc a vw o

    t word wod k, t t wod mor ra and corrct

    tan t on w av now. I rn p ts ovos pont cas

    -dml w w

    mastra pass jdmnt on God. T smart atst and pos

    4. Id., p. 29.

    5. Id., pp. 29, 184.

  • 8/8/2019 Hugh Nibley - Zeal Without Knowledge

    5/23

    scooman ak can t s a aot Godwat can do and

    w , w m l d w

    kon t ass o tr on-dmnsona xprnc o rat.

    Toda t astronomrs ar arpn on t od avort tm o - lpd w, p d

    t nvrs to consdra arr tan t tot or ad

    n tat, mmdat annoncd tat man was a vr mnor

    cratr ndd, wod av to rnonc an spca cam to

    dvn avor, snc tr ar mc r words tan ors or

    God to concrnd aot, and n t nd v p s ntmat

    and prvat God atotr.

    Ts jant conocasm rstd on t assmpton tat God

    s sjct to t sam mnta mtatons tat w ar; tat

    P, dl Pl

    sam tm, t aon markn t a o t sparrow. Bt onc

    w pl l l m

    tan on tn at a tm (and n tor t xprts t s tr w w ld ), w

    dm d Gd . L mm

    qt pcar to t ns o Mormonsm s t doctrn o

    Gd w ld pp ml w l m

    : T m, d

    nmrd nto man; t t ar nmrd nto m, or t

    ar mn. (Moss 1:37.)Pan, w ar dan wt two ordrs o mnds. For m

    tots ar not or tots, ntr ar or was m was,

    sat t Lord. For as t avns ar r tan t art, so

    ar . . . m tots tan or tots. (Isaa 55:8-9.)

    B w ppl lm w

    ar Gods cdrn? It s prcs ts mtaton wc s t

    ssnc o or morta xstnc. I vr coc I mak xprsss

    a prrnc; t word I d p s t word I ra ov and

    want, tn wt vr coc I am jdn ms, procamn

  • 8/8/2019 Hugh Nibley - Zeal Without Knowledge

    6/23

    ll d l Gd, l d m llwm w m

    ra vas , wr m trasr s, t tns to wc I v

    sprm mportanc. Hnc, n ts vr momnt provds

    a prct and ooproo tst o or ra caractr, makn ts a tm o tstn and proaton.

    Ad z pp Mm

    p . (I p w

    prsnt, and t ar not. Bt od, Jss Crst at sown

    o nto m, and I know or don. (Mormon 8:35). H cas

    p , B w d p . . . ,

    tat ma consm t on or sts (Mormon 9:28); .., tat

    o ma s p or consm or proaton tm jst avn a

    d m d w l l d ld

    mor trr tan tat: Bt woe nto m . . . tat wasteth

    t das o s proaton, or awfuls s stat! (2 Np 9:27,

    Itacs addd.) It s trown or awa, to tnk o t wron

    tns, as w ar tod n t nxt vrs tat t cnnn pano t v on s to t s to do jst tat; trn, n Bram

    Y p, d , md

    trva tots, on t tns o ts word aanst wc w

    av so otn n warnd.

    S w. I d w ld

    don otr and ttr tns or wc o av t capact.

    Hnc, tr ar no nnocnt d tots. Tat s w vnt rtos mst rpnt, constant and prorssv, snc

    a a sort o tr capact and can. Proa 99 prcnt

    o man at as n wo wastd, wrts Artr Cark,

    d w p . . . m m m

    macns, and mps t proondr rsorcs o or mnds

    l w lm. 6 N d

    d m l m ll

    and occasona parastc occpatons as aw, advrtsn, and

    6. Artr Cark, Pros o t Ftr (N.Y.: Harpr and Row, 1962), p. 197.

  • 8/8/2019 Hugh Nibley - Zeal Without Knowledge

    7/23

    ankn. Tos ocas wom Moron cds cas t

    st pon [tr] trons n a stat o totss stpor (Ama

    60:7) wr not drat or macos armn anont

    w mm . W d ppl l l tv? W w w ? J

    a t wondr tns o wc t mnd s capa, avn

    t drd n a stat o totss stpor. For t sam rason

    a mdocr scoo or tacr s a badscoo or tacr.

    L w w d pp l

    d w l d dd

    l m m ld d

    tacrs aktat t man cas o t msc was boredom.

    Udpm, j d ll ,

    mak o sck: work wc pts rptton and rotn n t

    pac o ra work ts a sns o t; mr doodn and

    dl mm l, , d

    l. Gd pld w ml n mtns: How van and trfn av n or sprts, or

    conrncs, or concs, or mtns, or prvat as w as

    pl , w Pp Jp m L

    Ja, too ow, too man, too var, too condscndn or t

    dnd caractrs cad and cosn o God.

    T p . I w d

    pl d md plojct, w tr to stt or a mdr proram at owr staks and

    sar rsks, w ar mmdat sappd and td a powr

    tat w not t s rst. Bn r, w mst pa t proaton

    am, and w pa an aw ort or vr ort to vad t.

    W mst tnk t wat aot? T sstanc o tot s

    knowd. T man ran dpnds or ts norma artnss,

    ll d fw m

    7. Id., p. 96.

    8. DHC, 3:295.

  • 8/8/2019 Hugh Nibley - Zeal Without Knowledge

    8/23

    aot t word. . . . t ran cravs or normaton as t od

    cravs or ood. Bot ndvdas and socts can com

    w ml. I md dd

    nctonn to capact, t w tak trr rvn.T pnat w pa or starvn or mnds s a pnomnon

    tat s on too conspcos at t byu: Arstot pontd ot

    l wld ll

    and so t mnd w do antn to scap t; n partcar, t

    wll wld . Expm d

    tat ack o normaton qck rds nscrt n a staton

    w m dd . I

    mp, l m f d j

    tsts ar ar to stn to and v an sort o prpostros

    . W ? W p,

    m q m md p. T md

    ntnc wc man posssss, sas Josp Smt, s co-qa

    wt God ms. Wat ratr crm tan t mnmzn osc capact? T Propt contns: A t mnds and sprts

    tat God vr snt nto t word ar sscpt o narmnt.

    God ms, ndn was n t mdst o t sprts and or,

    w m ll, w pp lw

    wr t rst cod av a prv to advanc k ms.

    T ratonsp w av wt God pacs s n a staton to

    advanc n knowd. Expanson s t tm, and w cannotxpand t ondars nss w rst rac tos ondars,

    wc mans xrtn orsvs to t asot mt.

    Now w com to a sjct wt wc t Propt Josp

    was rat concrnd. To kp t Sants awas racn or t

    9. Cadr, p. 33.

    10. Cark, p. 83.11. La Watson, Sprnatr (N.Y.: Ancor Prss, 1973), p. 239.

    12. Cadr, p. 77.

    13. Josp Fdn Smt, comp., Tacns o t Propt Josp Smt, (Sat Lak Ct:Dsrt Book Co., 1967), p. 354. Itacs addd. Hratr ctd as TPJS.

  • 8/8/2019 Hugh Nibley - Zeal Without Knowledge

    9/23

    st and st, t tmost o tr capact, rqrs normos

    motvatonand t osp spps t. Notn can xct mn

    to acton k t contmpaton o t trnts. T qat n

    wc t Sants av awas xcd s za. Za s t nntat drvs t wo vc, wtot t w wod t nowr.

    B w l, l, , d wl,

    mt nn coms an nstrmnt o dstrcton, and t

    m pwl m, m d l

    crackp t propr knowd s ackn. Tr s a natra

    tndnc to t t mt motor carr s aon, to v t ts

    ad, opn p and s wat t can do. W s ts n or soct

    toda.

    S ll dm lz

    dpnds on two tns: (a) t amont o nr at ts dsposa,

    and () t amont o normaton at ts dsposa. Toda w

    lmd l pw, w ll l

    ncssar normaton to contro and tz t. W av t zat not t knowd, so to spak. And ts t Propt Josp

    consdrd a vr danros staton n t Crc. Spakn to

    t nw R Soct, commndd tm or tr za, t

    sad tat somtms tr za was not accordn to knowledge.

    H advsd rstrant n an ort to kp tns ndr contro.

    T Soct, osrvd, was rown too ast. It sod row

    p drs, sad, and . . . ts av a sct soct ot vrtos, and tos wo wod wak crcmspct. Wat

    ood s t powr, asks, wtot ra ntnc and sod

    knowd?

    H vs t xamp o tos Sants wo wr carrd awa

    at t tot and prospct o a oros manstaton rom

    God. And ds tm ask, a manstaton o wat? Is tr an

    ntnc commncatd? . . . A t ntnc tat can

    14. Car Saan, T Cosmc Conncton (N.Y.: D, 1973), C. 34.

    15. TPJS, p. 201. Itacs addd.

    16. Id.

  • 8/8/2019 Hugh Nibley - Zeal Without Knowledge

    10/23

    d m m w , l,

    aja, or som ncornt xprsson; t t av ad

    t powr. Anotr tm warnd t sstrs aanst n

    sjct to overmuchzeal, wc mst vr prov danros, andcas tm to rigid in a religious capacity. Za maks s

    oa and nfncn, t God wants mor tan tat. In t sam

    , Pp d ppl w dpd

    t Propt, nc wr darkened in their minds, n consqnc

    l d dl p themselves. T

    mst do tr own tnkn and dscpn tr mnds. I not,

    wll pp w ppd Kld: M,

    zl d wld, d Pp,

    . . . av, no dot, n t at o ntsasm, tat and sad

    man tns wc ar droator to t nn caractr and

    prncps o t Crc. Spcca, soon atr t Gosp

    was stasd n Krtand . . . man as sprts wr ntrodcd,

    man stran vsons wr sn, and wd, ntsastc notonswr ntrtand. . . . man rdcos tns wr ntrd nto,

    cacatd to rn dsrac pon t Crc o God. Ts

    was t tm wn som o t rtrn n Krtand wr ot

    to prov tat t wr smartr tan t Propt and prodcd

    -lld Egyptian Alphabet and Grammar, m his

    prodcton o t Book o Araam.

    T ll p wld ad st. It as ads to an xcss o zato sons o

    randr and a dsr to mprss otrs and acv mnnc.

    T nvrst s notn mor nor ss tan a pac to sow o:

    t casd to tat, t wod cas to xst. Aan, t Propt

    Josp s rt on tart wn ts s tat tr knowd

    can nvr srv tat nd. Knowd s ndvda, osrvs,

    17. TPJS, p. 204.

    18. TPJS, p. 238. Itacs addd.

    19. Id. Itacs addd.

    20. TPJS, p. 80.

    21. TPJS, pp. 213,214.

  • 8/8/2019 Hugh Nibley - Zeal Without Knowledge

    11/23

    and a prson as t, wo wod know t? . . . T ratst, t

    st and t most s ts wod known notn aot

    an osrvr. . . . Tr ar on two ts tat cod mad

    vst t o tons and t t o propc.Or sarc or knowd sod casss, wc mans

    tat t s opn-ndd, nvr rstn on ars, drs, or past

    m. I w pd p w

    m wld, w p p, d

    wat s t cr? Corrct knowd s ncssar to cast ot

    tat sprt. T cr or nadqat knowd s vr mor

    t and knowd.

    Bt wo s on to stn patnt to corrct knowd

    tnks as t answrs arad? Tr ar a rat man ws

    mn and womn too n or mdst wo ar too ws to tat;

    tror t mst d n tr noranc. I av trd or

    m md S ppd

    rcv t tns o God; t w rqnt s som o tm. . . [tat] w f to pcs k ass as soon as antn coms

    tat s contrar to tr tradtons: t cannot stand t r at

    a . . . . [I I] o nto an nvstaton nto antn, tat s not

    contand n t B . . . I tnk tr ar so man ovr-ws

    mn r, tat t wod cr trason and pt m to dat.

    Bt, asks, w so crtan tat o comprnd t tns

    Gd, w ll w ? 7 Tknowd nvr sts t door on mor knowd, t za

    otn dos. On tnks o t dctm: W ar not skn or

    trt at t byu; w av t trt! So dd Adam and Araam

    av t trt, ar ratr and mor trt tan wat w av,

    22. TPJS, p. 246.

    23. TPJS, p. 287.24. TPJS, p. 309.

    25. TPJS, p. 331.

    26. TPJS, p. 348.

    26. TPJS, p. 348.

  • 8/8/2019 Hugh Nibley - Zeal Without Knowledge

    12/23

    and t t partcar ns o ac was tat was constant

    skn or ratr t and knowd.

    T , w lmd wld pll

    sscpt to xcssv za. W do t t ard wa, t ask att byu, wn God as vn s t answr ook? T answr

    to tat s, cas o s t answr ook or or Latn or

    or mat, or antn s, o w awas av a as sns

    o powr and nvr arn t ra tn. T pop xpct to

    s som wondr manstaton, som rat dspa o powr,

    sas Josp Smt, or som xtraordnar mrac prormd;

    and t s otn t cas tatyoungmmrs o ts Crc, or

    w m, l w m ld

    notons o tns, and somtms a nto ros rrors.

    B car aot sndn os to prac t Gosp to t word,

    sad Josp Smt. W? Crtan not cas t ackd za,

    tats t on tn t ad. T Propt xpans: Lst t

    com pd p, and a ndr condmnaton . . . war oprd . . . . app orsvs dnt tostudy, tat or mnds

    ma stord wt a ncssarinformation. Tat s don

    t t ard wa.

    Cant t Sprt rr tns p? Notr s no pac or

    t cram cors or qck, or aov a t sprca srv

    q p Hl Ld, w pl

    concrnd. W consdr tat God as cratd man wt a mndpl , d l w m ld

    pp d d dl l

    commncatd rom avn to t ntct . . . t . . . no man

    vr arrvd n a momnt: mst av n nstrctd . . .

    proper degrees. T tns o God ar o dp mport; and

    m, d xp, d l d pd d lm

    28. TPJS, p. 242.

    29. TPJS, p. 43. Itacs addd.

    30. TPJS, p. 51. Itacs addd.

  • 8/8/2019 Hugh Nibley - Zeal Without Knowledge

    13/23

    tots . . . strtc as as t tmost avns. No sort-

    cts or as ssons r! Not w tat t Propt maks no

    dstncton twn tns o t sprt and tns o t ntct.

    Som ars ao, wn t was pontd ot tat byu radatswr t owst n t naton n a cators o t radat

    d xm, ll m

    ll l xm. I w d

    d dd l m q

    sprtat. W takd xtnsv aot t dcaton o t

    wo man, and dpord tat dcatona maanc tat coms

    wn stdnts ads ar mr std wt actsas tr

    was an danr o tat r! Bt acta, sros maanc s

    mpl pl m l: zl d

    wld, wld x w zl. B

    ar sprta qats. A knowd s t osp, t tr

    mst a prort, propr drs, as sas, n t tmn

    and mpass o or arnn, st k t doctors o t Jws,w stran at a nat and swaow a cam. Frtrmor, snc

    on prson dos not rcv rvaton or anotr, w wod

    x wld, w m wll

    wld d. T d d zl M. Ol w

    dsowsppd, cas wod not av s wrtns tested

    by the word of God, accordn to Josp Smt.

    Not nrqnt, Lattr-da Sants t m tat t avld x pd , ld

    arcaooca dscovr as a drct answr to prar, and tat

    or m to qston or tst t rsts s to qston t rat

    l; d I m d pp

    dscovr wc I nd nconvncn, cas t as n t

    m ppl C. S p

    m zl dq

    31. TPJS, p. 137.

    32. TPJS, p. 215. Itacs addd.

  • 8/8/2019 Hugh Nibley - Zeal Without Knowledge

    14/23

    wld, l B Ol,

    wld d. T, d l , d

    v s knowd o t tns o God, t on t ard

    w xp : I wdm wsod av a knowd at onc prsntd or s; t tat

    w sod av tt at a tm; tn w can comprehendt. W

    mst know wat w ar don, ndrstand t prom, v wt

    t, a a propr ondatonow man a Lattr-da Sant as

    tod m tat can ndrstand t scrptrs pr rvaton

    and dos not nd to to at Grk or Hrw as t Propt

    and t Brtrn dd n t Scoo o t Propts at Krtand

    and Navoo? Evn Ovr Cowdr nto tat trap and was

    d . (D&C 9.) T ppl wld

    prncp o savaton. Ts prncp can comprndd

    t at and dnt, sas t Propt Josp.

    Nw convrts otn t t da tat, avn accptd t

    osp, t av arrvd at adqat knowd. Otrs sa tat m

    and ond t kndom o avn; t tr mnds o rt on

    w j m, d d p w

    and tsta knowd, t w assrd mrac tos wd,

    w Kld. N

    w d pd Jp Sm p: [T]

    Cm Hl G pntnc [t s not a ot, motona sr]. It s mor powr

    xpd md, l dd, d

    storn t ntct wt prsnt knowd, o a man wo s o

    t tra sd o Araam, tan on wo s a Gnt. For

    as t Ho Gost as pon on o t tra sd o Araam,

    lm d ; d wl l d d l

    33. TPJS, p. 217.

    34. TPJS, p. 297.

    35. Id.

    36. TPJS, p. 149.

  • 8/8/2019 Hugh Nibley - Zeal Without Knowledge

    15/23

    xd p p ll. 37 T Sp

    Rvaton s n conncton wt ts ssns. A prson ma

    prot notcn t rst ntmaton o t sprt o rvaton;

    or nstanc, wn o pr ntnc fown nto o, m dd d . . . , l

    Sp Gd d dd , m w

    t prncp o rvaton. Ts s rmarka k t nw

    traptc dscpn cad odack.

    T mp ll , ,

    onst acqston o knowd. Ts admonton to sort

    d dl l w Pp p

    mmd Jw d pl m d

    dnc or tns o t mnd. I tr s antn cacatd

    to ntrst t mnd o t Sants, to awakn n tm t nst

    snsts, and aros tm to ntrprs and xrton, sr

    d p pm . . . Am d . . .

    Jda . . . and nasmc as o ntrstd or t covnantpop o t Lord, t God o tr atrs sa ss o. . . .

    H w ndow o wt powr, wsdom, mt and ntnc,

    and vr qacaton ncssar: w or mnds w xpand

    wdr and wdr, nt o can . . . contmpat t mt acts

    o Jova n a tr vart and or.

    I Il d, w

    pop and od rom a parts o t word dspa tr knowd p d ll m, , mm, .,

    l mp. T d d

    rac o nsra arroant, conctd tt sow-os and

    m pm. T d l Jw ld,

    w ld dd,

    ookn ond t mark, and nc an on tr acs: t

    nds mst a. (Jaco 4:14.) Yt Josp Smt commnds tr

    37. TPJS, pp. 149, 150.

    38. TPJS, p. 151.

    39. TPJS, p. 163.

  • 8/8/2019 Hugh Nibley - Zeal Without Knowledge

    16/23

    ntcta orts as a corrctv to t Lattr-da Sants, wo

    an too ar n t otr drcton, vn tr on pop and

    od awards or za aon, za wtot knowdor sttn

    dl m, ddd m, d lmdcapact or srn ordom. W tnk t mor commnda

    p 5:00 .m. w d p

    nn ocock to wrt a ood ontat s pr za tat tnds

    to rd a rac o nsra, s-rtos prs and arrn

    md. O l d p p

    nspratona ooks n t Crc wc rn tt nw n t

    w wld: m, d pld, , d l

    av com or vrda dt. T Propt wod nvr stt

    or tat. I advs o to o on to prcton and sarc dpr

    and dpr nto t mstrs o Godnss . . . . It as awas

    m p d p dd m, new things,

    m arrs. It acta appns at t byu, and tat not rar,

    tat stdnts com to a tacr, sa at t nnn o atrm, wt t sncr rqst tat rran rom tacn tm

    antn nw. T av no dsr, t xpan, to ar wat

    t do not know arad! I cannot man tat appnn at

    an otr scoo, t ma t dos. Unss w o on to otr

    nw tns, w ar stfn or powrs.

    In or mtd tm r, wat ar w on to tnk aot?

    Tat s t a mportant qston. Wv n assrd tat ts not too ar to start tnkn aot tns o t trnts.

    In act, Lattr-da Sants sod takn rapd strds toward

    sttn p tat trna csta ordr wc t Crc mst

    md pl Gd. Al, w pdl

    nstrctd rardn tns w sod not tnk aot. I wod

    pass ts natv tn t, t t scrptrs ar xpct,

    otspokn, and mpatc n ts mattr; and wnvr anon

    l m byu, l

    40. TPJS, p. 364. Itacs addd.

  • 8/8/2019 Hugh Nibley - Zeal Without Knowledge

    17/23

    somon sas, I wod k to spnd m tm tnkn aot

    sc tns and stdn tm, t I cannot aord t xr. I

    av to tnk aot t ra mportant snss o , wc s

    makn a vn. Ts s t wtrn ct o t ntmdatnll w ll m ldd: D

    av an mon? Wt ts asot dcaraton o poc and

    prncp: Yo can av antn n ts word or mon! and

    ts parazn coroar: Wtot t, o can av notn! I do

    not av to t o wr tat posop cam rom. Somod

    s ot to dco or mnds, to s Bram Yons xprsson,

    rom t tns w sod tnkn aot to tos wc w

    sod not car aot at a.

    T most ot-rpatd command n t scrptrs, rpatd

    m Sp Gpl, B Mm, d

    D d C 4 T

    mw, w ll , w ll d,

    wrwta sa cotd. For consdr t s o td . . . . W cannot o r nto t on catao o scrptr o

    commandmnts tn s to sk or knowd n on drcton

    t not n anotr. Sknotor rcs, t or wsdom; anot

    p trasrs on art, t n avn, or wr or trasr

    s, tr w or art aso. Yo cannotsrv two mastrs,

    o mst coos on and oow m aon: Watsovr s n

    t word s noto t Fatr t s o t word, (1 Jon 2:16;tacs addd)

    W tak comort n crtan paras; or xamp, Wc

    o o, ntndn to d a towr, sttt not down rst, and

    contt t cost . . . . (Lk 14:28. ), as t jstd or

    prsnt cors. Bt t Lord s not nstrctn pop to tak

    m m ld d :

    W d not? Ld. H p

    ppl l l d pd w

    41. Mattw 6:25, Mark 13:11, Lk 12:11, 3 np 13:25, D&C 84:81.

  • 8/8/2019 Hugh Nibley - Zeal Without Knowledge

    18/23

    thisword ar concrnd and sas, to tr sam: I or so

    zaos n sc mattrs, w cant o tak or trna tr

    l? Ad d pl w dm:

    W ll , m dpl. T same d, wll

    osrv, tat av to t rc on man. T Lord ra

    mans wat sas wn commands s notto tnk aot

    ; d w d d

    opss mpractca or or tms (not tat t rc on

    man ond t jst as mpractca or s tms!), t trasrs o

    knowd av n wtd rom s. God [as] otn sad

    p , d Jp Sm, covetousness

    n t Crc. Yo mst coos twn on rot or t

    . I w l l

    , sas Bram Yon, w rman xd wt a vr mtd

    amont o knowd, k a door pon ts ns, movn to

    and ro rom ar to ar wtot an vs advancmnt ormprovmnt . . . . Man s mad n t ma o God, t wat

    do w know o Hm or o orsvs wn w sr orsvs to

    ov and worsp t God o ts wordrcs? I dsr to

    s vrod on t track o mprovmnt . . . t wn o so

    ov or proprt as to a or actons wr pacd on

    t cann, adn tns o art, t s mposs to ncras

    n knowd o t trt.Wat tns sod w tnk aot tn, and ow? Hr t

    Propt s vr p. In t rst pac, tat qston ts s

    wat w sod tnk aot. W wont t vr ar on or wa

    l w d p . B w l

    tnkn aot tat, w nd orsvs covrd wt conson,

    ovrwmd or ns o t and nadqacn otr

    words, rpntn or or past dnqnc. In ts condton, w

    42. TPJS, p. 9. Itacs addd.

    43. Bram Yon n Jorna o Dscorss, 26 vos. (London: Lattr-da Sants Book Dpot,

  • 8/8/2019 Hugh Nibley - Zeal Without Knowledge

    19/23

    ca pon t Lord or ad and ars s. W n to know

    wat t Propt Josp mant aot t constant sarcn,

    stad storn or mnds wt knowd and normaton

    t mor w t o t, t ttr w ar a to jd t proprprorts as w or wa orward, as w com ncrasn

    art to t promptns o t Sprt wc com vr mor

    l d m q, llw d Hl

    Gost: and as w o orward, w arn to cop wt t ost

    word wt wc or wa s sr to rn s nto coson n

    m. T ll , w ? El l

    not cap ot.

    Ts ma sond vr mpractca to som, t ow otn do

    w av to rmndd o t sor and mmora natr o

    w ? E w

    powrs o dstrcton tat ar ann ovr or ads at ts

    mm, m pl d wld, w

    wod s tm vansn or or s. Sc pnomna aspmrazaton and rpcaton, onc drams o t scnc-

    cton wrtrs, ar rapd comn rats. Spakn o t

    pmlz, ll l, A. R. Cl

    wrts, Wtn t orsa tr a t most powr and

    cratv cans n or word w xst no mor. Bcas o nw

    procss o sntszn, oranzn, prorammn asc matras

    o nmtd spp nto t ncssts o , w sa soon st nd o a actors and praps o a transportaton o raw

    matras and a armn. T ntr strctr o ndstr and

    commrc . . . wod cas to xst. . . . a matra possssons

    wod tra as cap as drt. . . . Tn wn matra ojcts

    ar ntrnsca wortss, praps on tn w a ra sns

    o vas ars.

    Y, , mm, w m l wld

    p. M w? M ppl p

    44. Cark, p. 16.

  • 8/8/2019 Hugh Nibley - Zeal Without Knowledge

    20/23

    aon wtot t nstttons wc w tnk, or t momnt,

    ndspnsa. And w ar xprss commandd to t ot o

    tat snss. No on spposs or on momnt, sas Bram

    Yon, tat n avn t ans ar spcatn, tat t ardn raroads and actors, takn advanta o on anotr,

    atrn p t sstanc n avn to arandz tmsvs,

    and tat t v on t sam prncp tat w ar n t at

    o don. . . . No sctaran Crstan n t word vs ts;

    t v tat t natants o avn v as a am, tat

    , , d p d w

    l Gd d w l, m

    mor and mor. . . . W a v ts, and sppos w o to

    work and mtat tm as ar as w can.

    It s not too soon to n rt now. Wat ar t tns

    o t trnts tat w sod consdr vn now? T ar

    t tns tat no on vr trs o don, tns n tmsvs

    ll d dl. Spl, w ppd

    ddcatd. In t Zon o God, n t csta and trna ordr,

    wr tr s no dat tr w no mortcans, wr tr

    s no scknss tr no mor doctors, wr tr s no dca

    tr w no dntsts, wr tr s no taton tr w

    no awrs, wr tr s no n and sn tr w

    m, w , wll no nsranc, wr tr s no mon tr w no anks,

    wr tr s no crm tr w no jas, no poc; wr

    tr ar no xcss oods tr w no advrtsn, no wars,

    no arms, and so on and so on.

    B pp d lmd ll lm

    o t tr; t acta as n acvd morta mn on

    ts art a nmr o tms, and rprsnts t on stat o

    soct o wc God approvs. A t tns tat ar passn

    45. JD 17:117.

  • 8/8/2019 Hugh Nibley - Zeal Without Knowledge

    21/23

    awa toda ar t vr ssnc o t conom, t t w

    mssn n Zon. T ar arad ososcnt, vr on o

    tm s mad work o a tmporar and artca natr or wc

    an artca dmand mst cratd. Morovr, w pop arll ddd m, m qd

    spr- qota o powr and an, cts ot and avs t scn

    mp, w m l

    word as pd crat-prra to Tat. T rac as

    sown s otn ts capact to do wtot ts tns w now

    nd ndspnsa. T Dv as t mastr o t art:

    as corrptd t, and as corrptd t cdrn o mn. H as

    d tm n v nt t ar amost ntr rnd, and ar

    so ar rom God tat t ntr know Hm nor s nfnc,

    and av amost ost st o vrtn tat prtans to trnt.

    Ts darknss s mor prvant, mor dns, amon t pop

    o Crstndom tat t s amon t atn.

    T av ost st o a tat s rat and oroso aprncps tat prtan to trna. Sppos tat or Fatr

    n avn, or dr rotr, t rsn Rdmr, t Savor o

    t word, or an o t Gods o trnt sod act pon ts

    prncp, to ov trt, knowd, and wsdom, cas t

    ar a-powr, sas Bram Yon, t wod cas to

    Gods; . . . t xtnson o tr kndom wod cas, and tr

    God-ad com to an nd.A w wld d

    w t s aad n t word? On o t oros nts and

    promss o t osp vn t Sants n ts attr das tat

    nasmc as tsoughtwsdom t mt nstrctd; And

    nasmc as t wr m t mt mad stron, and

    ssd rom on , and rcv knowledge rom tm to tm.

    (D&C 1:26, 28. Itacs addd.) Bt t ad to want t and sk

    46. JD 8:209.

    47. JD 1:117.

  • 8/8/2019 Hugh Nibley - Zeal Without Knowledge

    22/23

    or t. Wat s tat stat o tns? T at Prsdnt Josp

    Fdn Smt wrot: W ar normd tat man mportant

    wld m d

    arts and t nwnnss as mmrs o t Crc to ad d d wld. O l

    ld, d Jp Sm, pp d

    and dnc vn to t t commncatd rom avn to

    t ntct. I [a man] dos not t knowd, w

    rot nto captvt som v powr n t otr word,

    l p wll m wld, d ql

    mor powr tan man mn wo ar on t art. [W nd]

    rvaton to assst s, and v s knowd o t tns o

    Gd.4 T dd d p. T

    God com rst, and t skr vr trs to com awar o

    p. All , Kl Ppp, l,

    d dmll w q l. T

    most mportant qston o a s tat o or trna savaton.I d l d Cll

    Commrc or a cop o ars. Most o ts stdnts wr

    napp aot on nto snss and admttd tat Satan rs

    d l dl, w ld d ,

    pontd ot t ntmdatn crcmstanc tat o cannot av

    mon wtot pan s am cas owns t trasrs

    o t art. T cod s owns tm as oot, and vrt ll w w , Jp Sm m,

    rvtd t crds o t atrs, t st t stdnts wod

    ask m n dspar, I w av s mpo, wat w com o

    s? T answr s smp. Dont o trst t Lord? I o do,

    w v o t danc o t Ho Sprt and o w

    not nd p don t tns tat as xprss commandd

    s not to do.

    48. Josp Fdn Smt, Answrs to Gosp Qstons, Mczdk Prstood Mana,1972-

    49. TPJS, p. 217.

  • 8/8/2019 Hugh Nibley - Zeal Without Knowledge

    23/23

    Ma God p s a n t das o or proaton to sk t

    knowdHe wants s to sk.