hitting the books every which way

1
81 H aving written, in 1945, of “wholly new forms of encyclopedias, ready- made with a mesh of associative trails running through them,” Vannevar Bush is credited with being the first to envi- sion the World Wide Web. Bush, who was then chair of the wartime U.S. Office of Sci- entific Research and Development, proba- bly didn’t have in mind such items as Brit- ney Spears fan sites, instant messaging, and Web cams that flash a new picture each minute to an indifferent world. But when Bush went on to describe the “memex,” his conception of a local device capable of searching and browsing a large collection of data, he may well have had Questia in mind. Indeed, many of the imagined attributes of memex are surpassed by Questia, an on-line research library service launched in January by Questia Media Inc., Houston. Questia aims squarely at students in liberal arts programs who could use a hand with research—and can pay for it. It provides the ability to search through its collection of “scholarly works” for a fee of US $19.95 per month. The collec- tion includes original fiction and non- fiction source works, but no textbooks. Questia can skim an entire book or search its entire collection. How is it dif- ferent from searching the Web? It is broader, because it contains the complete text of many works not available on the Web, and narrower, because it avoids much of the non-scholarly chaff that a typical Web search would include, such as press releases, personal histories, and those ubiquitous fan sites. Users can search bibliographic data for free. Subscribers get to search the full text for keywords and view the results. Nonsubscribers can also hunt for the full text, though they cannot view the actual pages where matches are found. Thus, even a nonsubscriber would be able to dig for a term, or several terms, and see what works contain them, and then go to his or her own school library with some of the initial research legwork done. At its launch, Questia covered about 30 000 books. It intends to grow its col- lection to 250 000 books and journals— a size that, it claims, would be larger than 80 percent of all academic libraries in the United States. Better than memex Anticipating other features of the Web and Web browsers, Bush wrote: “Any given book of his library can thus be called up and consulted with far greater facility than if it were taken from a shelf…he can leave one item in position while he calls up another. He can add marginal notes and comments….” Bush gave as an example a student in- terested in the origin of the bow and arrow: “Specifically he is studying why the short Turkish bow was apparently superior to the English long bow in the skirmishes of the Crusades….First he runs through an encyclopedia….Next, in a history, he finds another pertinent item, and ties the two together….When it becomes evident that the elastic properties of available materials had a great deal to do with the bow, he branches off on a side .... This is almost exactly the Questia experience. While unable to answer complex historical questions, Questia does cut through some of the most tedious and time-con- suming aspects of under- graduate liberal arts research. It allows for bookmarks, as well as the margin notes Bush mentioned, and for longer notes distinct from the text. Stored on the Questia sys- tem, the notes feature accommodates stu- dents working from several locations—a dorm room, a public library, a motel room while on spring break, and so on. What’s more, Questia lets the user create bibliographic entries at the click of a button, in any of four standard styles for writing bibliographies (say, The Chicago Manual of Style). The Questia document database cur- rently consists of between three and four terabytes of data, stored in an Oracle Intermedia database. (Intermedia is an extension of Oracle’s software for use with text-rich databases.) According to Allan Jones, Questia’s vice president for technical operations, the service has been stress-tested, without failure, with up to 500 simultaneous searches, the operation that most inten- sively uses the database. Jones expects the current infrastructure to easily accom- modate the spring semester. IEEE SPECTRUM March 2001 RESOURCES WEBSIGHTS With Questia, students can mark up virtual books without getting thrown out of the library. Hitting the Books Every Which Way BY STEVEN M. CHERRY Managing Editor, Spectrum Online

Upload: s

Post on 25-Mar-2017

214 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

81

Having written, in 1945, of “whollynew forms of encyclopedias, ready-made with a mesh of associative

trails running through them,” VannevarBush is credited with being the first to envi-sion the World Wide Web. Bush, who wasthen chair of the wartime U.S. Office of Sci-entific Research and Development, proba-bly didn’t have in mind such items as Brit-ney Spears fan sites, instant messaging,and Web cams that flash a new pictureeach minute to an indifferent world.

But when Bush went on to describethe “memex,” his conception of a localdevice capable of searching and browsinga large collection of data, he may wellhave had Questia in mind. Indeed, manyof the imagined attributes of memex aresurpassed by Questia, an on-line researchlibrary service launched in January byQuestia Media Inc., Houston.

Questia aims squarely at students inliberal arts programs who could use ahand with research—and can pay for it.It provides the ability to search throughits collection of “scholarly works” for afee of US $19.95 per month. The collec-tion includes original fiction and non-fiction source works, but no textbooks.

Questia can skim an entire book orsearch its entire collection. How is it dif-ferent from searching the Web? It isbroader, because it contains the completetext of many works not available on theWeb, and narrower, because it avoidsmuch of the non-scholarly chaff that atypical Web search would include, such aspress releases, personal histories, andthose ubiquitous fan sites.

Users can search bibliographic datafor free. Subscribers get to search the

full text for keywords and view theresults. Nonsubscribers can also huntfor the full text, though they cannot viewthe actual pages where matches arefound. Thus, even a nonsubscriberwould be able to dig for a term, or severalterms, and see what works contain them,and then go to his or her own schoollibrary with some of the initial researchlegwork done.

At its launch, Questia covered about30 000 books. It intends to grow its col-lection to 250 000 books and journals—a size that, it claims, would be largerthan 80 percent of all academic librariesin the United States.

Better than memex

Anticipating other features of theWeb and Web browsers, Bush wrote:“Any given book of his library can thus becalled up and consulted with far greaterfacility than if it were taken from a

shelf…he can leave one item in positionwhile he calls up another. He can addmarginal notes and comments….”

Bush gave as an example a student in-terested in the origin of the bow and arrow:“Specifically he is studying why the shortTurkish bow was apparently superior tothe English long bow in the skirmishes ofthe Crusades….First he runs through anencyclopedia….Next, in a history, he findsanother pertinent item, and ties the twotogether….When it becomes evident thatthe elastic properties of available materialshad a great deal to do with the bow, hebranches off on a side ....”

This is almost exactly theQuestia experience. Whileunable to answer complexhistorical questions, Questiadoes cut through some of themost tedious and time-con-suming aspects of under-graduate liberal arts research.

It allows for bookmarks,as well as the margin notesBush mentioned, and forlonger notes distinct from the

text. Stored on the Questia sys-tem, the notes feature accommodates stu-dents working from several locations—adorm room, a public library, a motel roomwhile on spring break, and so on.

What’s more, Questia lets the usercreate bibliographic entries at the click ofa button, in any of four standard stylesfor writing bibliographies (say, TheChicago Manual of Style).

The Questia document database cur-rently consists of between three and fourterabytes of data, stored in an OracleIntermedia database. (Intermedia is anextension of Oracle’s software for usewith text-rich databases.)

According to Allan Jones, Questia’svice president for technical operations,the service has been stress-tested, withoutfailure, with up to 500 simultaneoussearches, the operation that most inten-sively uses the database. Jones expects thecurrent infrastructure to easily accom-modate the spring semester. •

IEE

ES

PE

CT

RU

M•

Mar

ch 20

01

R E S O U R C E S

W E B S I G H T S

With Questia, students can mark up virtual books

without getting thrown out of the library.

Hitting the BooksEvery Which WayBY STEVEN M. CHERRYManaging Editor, Spectrum Online