hhimh npe,nctabhtejuimh ebponerckor u;hbhjih3au;hh....
TRANSCRIPT
MHJIaH XaYHep
-BOCTOIlHHKW Ii -EBPA3liAQblmiddot
-XltEflTAJI OnACHOCTb
nOCKOJIbKY llocToeBcKHR CqHTaJI OOPbOY xpHcTHaHcTBa
npoTHB HCJIaMa H npoTHBoneAcTBHe BceMHpHoR rereMOHHH
BeJIHKOOpHTaHHH JIerHTHMHhIM cTpeMJIeHHeM POCCHH TO Bonshy
JIOmeHHeM A3HH nJIJI Hero OblJIa MYCYJIbMaHCKaJl CpenHJlB
A3HJI a He OynnHCTCKaJI BOCTOqHaJi A3HJI OnHaKO B 1880-e ronbl
Ha pOCCHRcKOA cueHe nOJlBHJIOCb 3KCTpeMHCTCKoe KpbIJIO pashy
30qapOBaHHbIX CJIaBJlHoIJIHJIOB KOTopoe OOJIbme BHHMaHHJI
oopamaeT Ha BOCTOqHYIO A3HIO np03BaHHbIe BOCTOqHHKaMH
OHH nponOBenYIOT HnelO qTO CBJlmeHHaJi MHCCHJI POCHH He MOshy
gtKeT naJIee ocymeCTBJIJlTbCJI Ha TeppHTOpHJlX onpeneJIJlIOshy
mHXCJI TpanHUHOHHOA HneOJIOrHeR naHCJIaBH3Ma Te npe)lne
Bcero Ha BaJIKaHaX H B BOCTOqHOR EBpone CJIenyeT HnTH B
npOTHBOnOJIO)lHOM HanpaBJIeHHH BrJIYOb CpenHeA H Bocshy
TOqHOA A3HH
B pJlnax BOCTOqHHKOB BblcTynHJIH H3BeCTHbie yqeHbIe
npolJleccopa ltpltpMapTeHC (1845-1909 IT) H Bn BaCHJIbeB (1818shy
1900 rr) MapTeHc ObIJI caMbIM aBTOpHTeTHbIM B POCCHH cneUHshy
aJIHCTOM no Me)lnYHaponHoMY npaBY BaCHJIbeB - BenYmHM
CHHOJIOrOM neTepoyprcKoro YHHBepCHTeTa MapTeHc B nposhy
naraHnHCTCKHX opomlOpax POCCHJI H KHTaR H POCCHJI H AHrshy
JIHJI B CpenHeR A3HH onpaBnbIBaJI pyccKHe 3aBOeBaHHJI B Cpenshy
HeR A3HH H Ha KHTaAcKHx 3eMJIJlX nOKa3bIBaJl qTO Me)lnyshy
HaponHoe npaBO He MO)leT npHHHMaTbCJI B paCqeT Korna HMeshy
emb neJIO C nOJIYBapBapCKHMH HaponaMH1
BynyqH BJIHJlTeJIbHhIM nponaraHnHCTOM nOJIHTHKH KHJl3B
rOpqaKOBa Ha Me)lnYHaponHOA apeHe MapTeHC neJIaJI Bce OT
Hero 3aBHCJlmee qTOObI pa3pJlnHTb pacTYmHA aHrJIo-pocCHAcshy
KHR aHTarOHH3M OH npJlMO 3aJIBJlJlJI qTO ooe HMnepHH nOJI)IHbi
COTpynHHqaTb B CpenHeR A3HH rne OHH JlBJIJlIOTCJI enHHCTBeHshy
-DraBbl H3 KHHrH Milan Hauner What is Asia to Us Unwin Hyman London-Sydney-Wellington 1990 (nelaTaIOTCH C He(iOJIbIIIHMH COKpashy
I1IeHHHMH - Pell )
130
HhIMH npenCTaBHTeJUIMH eBponeRcKOR UHBHJIH3aUHH POCshy
CIUI He nbITaeTCJI HaHeCTH nOpa)leHHe opHTaHUaM B HHnHH
nHCaJI MapTeHC HOO CTOJIb COMHHTeJIbHaJi noOena C nOMOmblO
MeCTHhIX BoopY)IeHHblX CHJI JIHmb nOBpenHJIa ObI POCCHH
3TO nOqTH HaBepHJlKa peBOJIlOUHOHH3HpOBaJIO Obi He TOJIbKO
HHnHlO HO H BClO A3HlO He B HaUHOHaJIbHbIX HHTepecax Pocshy
CHH pa3)1HraTb TJIelOmee nJIaMJI eme onHoro aHTHopHTaHshy
CKoro MJlTe)la B HHnHH nonooHo CHnaRcKoMY BOCCTaHHlO
nonaBJIeHHoMY B 1858 r C03naHHe He3aBHCHMbiX rocynapcTB
B A3HH noKa3bIBaJI MapTeHc MOgtKeT npHqHHHTb JIHmb orshy
pOMHble TpynHOCTH neTepoypry rne npennOqHTaIOT qTOObi
B KaJIbKYTTe ObIJIO UHBHJIH30BaHHoe XPHCTHaHCKoe npaBHshy
TeJIbCTBO 2
Bo BTOpoR nponaraHnHCTCKOR opomlOpe MapTeHC B Tex
gtKe BbIpa)leHHJlX KpaCHOpeqHBO nHmeT qTO KHTalO HeJIb3J1 n03shy
BOJIHTb onOJIeTb POCCHlO aTO pa30)lgtKeT JIHmb eme OOJIbmylO
HeHaBHCTb npOTHB eBponeRcKHX nep)laB H npHBeneT K HaCHJIbshy
CTBeHHOMY BbInBopeHHIO H3 KHTaJI Bcex qYgtKHX nbJlBOJIOB~ BaCHJIbeB gtKe OTKPbITO nponOBenOBaJI qTO POCCHJI B npOTHshy
BOnOJIO)lHOCTb BceM npyrHM eBponeAcKHM KOJIOHHaJIbHbIM
nepgtKaBaM nOJI)IHa nponBHraTbCJI Ha BOCTOK qTOObI OCBOOOnHTb
yrHeTeHHbIe Haponbi OT THpaHHH Me)lnyYCOOHOA OOPbOblmiddot~ B CTaTbe npOnBH)IeHHe KHTaJl BaCHJIbeB HapHCOBaJI KapTHHy
HOBoro MOHrOJIbCKOrO HameCTBHJI OH npenynpegtKnaJI qTO eCJIH
non KOHTPOJIb KHTaJi nonanYT ooraTbIe OCTpOBa THxoro OKeshy
aHa TO KHTaR MO)leT CTaTb yrp030A H POCCHH H AMepHKe H
HHnHH H 3ananHoR EBpone H B KOHeqHOM cqeTe pa3pymHT
BeCb MHp KOTOPbIA 3aTeM oyneT 3aceneH HCKJIlOqHTeJIbHO KHshy
TaAuaMHS
HeCKOJIbKO MJlrqe H nOgtKaJIyR HeCKOJIbKO OJIarOCKJIOHHee
OTHOCHJICJI K HeapHRuaM H3BeCTHbIA HCCJIenOBaTeJIb a3HaTCshy
KHX rpaHHU POCCHH reHepaJI HM np)leBaJIbCKHR (1839-1888 rrgt
OH nblTaJICJI yoenHTb pyCCKylO oomecTBeHHocTb qTO gtKHTeshy
JIH MOHrOJIHH H CHHbU3J1Ha gtKa)lnYT CTaTb nonnaHHbIMH oeshy
JIoro uapJl KOTOpoMy OHH npHnHchIBalOT TaKYlO gtKe MHCTHshy
qecKYIO npHpony KaK H naJIaA-JIaMe6 lla)le BenymHR Pycshy
CKHA aHapxHcT XIX B MHXaHJI BaKYHHH (1814-1876 rrJ qyBCTBOshy
BaJI HeooxonHMOCTb BKJIlOqHTbCJI - npaBna HeCKOJIbKO
cTpaHHbIM 00pa30M - B pa3BepHYBmYlOcJI nHCKYCCHIO 0 gtKeJIshy
131
ToA OnaCHOCTH B 1861 r nOCJIe ()erCTBa H3 CH()HpCKOA
KH B flOHllOH (lJepe3 HnoHHIO H CIIlA) OH BbICKa3aJI
B3rJIffJlbI B ()pomlOpe noll HalBaHHeM La theologie poIitique
Mazzini et lInternacionale (nOJIHTHlJeCKaR TeOJIOrHR Mall3H~ HH H MHTepHaIlHOHaJI) BaKYHHHCKoe BHlleHHe ()YllYIIlero
pOBoro KOHJlJIHKTa OCHOBbIBaJIOCb Ha paCOBbIX HHCTbullmiddot---shy
3TO ()bIJI ()HnOJIRpHbIA 0()pa3 MHpa KOTOPbIA lleJIHTCR
()eJIoR rpynnoA lJHCJIeHHOCTblO npHMepHo 350 MJIH
HaXOllRIIlHXCR noll yrp030A H MegtKllY 850 MJIH a3HaToB
yrp0gtKaIOIIlHX ()eJIbIM YgtKe TOrlla BaKYHHH npellcKa3bIBaJI
pacnan KOJIOHHaJIbHblX HMnepHA BeJIHKo()pHTaHHH H POCCHH
OH ClJHTaJI JlHKTHBHbIM KOHTPOJIb POCCHH Hall AMYPCKoA 01Sshy
JIaCTblO H CH()HpblO H()O TaM lJHCJIeHHOCTb eBponeAcKHX
nOCeJIeHueB HHKOrlla He ()YlleT llOCTaTOlJHOA lJTO()bl npo
THBOCTORTb orpoMHoMy nOTeHUHaJIY KHTaAcKoA MHrpaUHH
lJepe3 rpaHHUY OH npellCKa3bIBaJI lJTO PYCCKHe BJIalleHHJI
B A3HH npOCYIIleCTBYIOT He ()OJIee nRTHllecRTH JIeT
PemeHHe aToA npO()JIeMbI BaKYHHH BHlleJI BO BceMHpHoR
npOJIeTapCKoA COJIHllapHOCTH KOTOPaR OlSbellHHHT HeHMYIIlHX
He3aBHCHMO OT paCbI Ha OCHOBe KJIaccoBoA ()OpbObIbull llpyroR
PYCCKHA COBepmeHHO HHoro npoJleccHOHaJIbHOrO CKJIalla BHshy
lleJI npOTHBolleAcTBHe yrp03e C BOCTOKa B CBoero pOlla KOshy
JIOHHaJIbHOA COJIHllapHOCTH MegtKllY xpHCTHaHCKHMH llep~ashyBaMH 3anana B ocolSeHHOCTH MegtKllY PoccHeA H BeJIHKOlSpHTashy
HHeA KOTopble ISYllYT npOTHBOCTORTb HexpHCTHaHCKHM CHJIaM
A3HH 3TO OblJI reHepaJI AH KyponaTKHH (1848-1925 rr) OH
YlJaCTBOBaJI B 3aBoeBaHHH CpellHeA A3HH B KalJecTBe anblOTaHshy
Ta reHepaJIa CKOOeJIeBa ISbIJI BoeHHbIM MHHHCTPOM POCCHH
(1898-1904 rr) H rJIaBHOKOMaHllYlOIIlHM PYCCKHX BoAcK B BoAshy
He C HnoHHeA H CJIellOBaTeJIbHO OllHHM H3 BHHOBHHKOB HX noshy
pagtKeHHR 3aKOHlJHJI KyponaTKHH CBOIO Kapbepy KaK nOCJIellHHR
reHepaJI-rylSepHaTOp TypKeCTaHa (1916-1917 rr) OllHaKO ero
MHeHHe lJTO TOHKaR npOCJIOAKa PYCCKHX nOCeJIeHHA B A3HH
He nepe)KHBeT Hanopa BOJIHbI )KeJIToA paCbI B OCHOBHOM COBshy
nallaJIO co B3JIRllaMH aHapXHCTa BaKYHHHa~
MapTeHC BaCHJIbeB H HM nOllOOHbIe npellCTaBJIRIOT KpaRshy
Hee HanpaBJIeHHe PYCCKoA HlleH no OTHomeHHIO K A3HH Mx
n03HUHIO MO)KHO onpelleJIHTb KaK paCHCTCKHA HMnepHaJIH3M
nOpO)KlleHHbIA CTPaxOM nepell )KeJIToA onaCHOCTbIO nponoshy
132
aBzlHHKH 3THX MpalJHbIX npOpOlJeCTB HHCTHHKTHBHO npOTHBHshy
JlHCb Hzlee CJIHRHHR PYCCKo-apHAcKoA paCbI C )KeJITbIMH H
TYPaHCKHMH pacaMH A3HH 11M npOTHBOCTORJIH JIHOepaJIbHbIe
HMnePHaJIHCTbl nOzlOOHbIe nOJIKOBHHKY BeHIOKOBY KOTopble
l)J1aroCKJIOHHO OTHOCHJIHCb K Hzlee aCCHMHJIRUHH BoooIlle )Ke
cneKTp OJlHUHaJIbHbIX H O()IIleCTBeHHbIX B033peHHA B POCCHH B
OTHomeHHH )KeJ1ToA onaCHOCTH BeCbMa CJIO)KeH ero HeJIb3J1
npellCTaBHTb KaK OllHOMepHoe lJepHo-OeJIOe H300pa)leHHe zlBYX
npOTHBOn0J10)KHbIX nOzlXOllOB 3zleCb HeJIb3R He ynOMRHYTb
cpezlH MHorHX llPyrHx HCTOlJHHKOB TOJICTOBCKoe nHCbMO K
KHTaAUY 9 H B3rJIRllbI BbIllalOIIleroCR naUHJlHcTa-CaMOYlJKH H
TeopeTHKa BoAHbI 110raHHa BJIoxa (1836-1902 rr)~o B POCCHH KaK H B zlPyrHx eBponeAcKHx K0J10HHaJIbHbIX
rocYllapCTBax HMnepHaJIHCTHlJeCKaR HlleR nocTpOeHHaJi Ha
gtKeJ1ToA onaCHOCTH He MOrJIa H30e)KaTb HeKOToporo OH0J10shy
rnlJeCKOrO H 3KOHOMHlJeCKOrO lleTepMHHH3Ma 1lt0TOPbIR npHshy
CYTCTByeT B HeOMaJIbTy3HaHCIltHX H HeOllapBHHHCTCKHX TeopHshy
$IX 3TH TeopHH npellCKa3bIBalOT YBeJIHlJeHHe llHc6aJIaHCa
Me)KllY POCTOM HaCeJIeHHR B reOMeTpHlJeClltoR nporpeCCHH H
CpellCTB K CYIIleCTBOBaHHIO - B apHJlMeTHlJeCKoR1 OllHaKO B
POCCHH CTPax nepell nepeHaCeJIeHHeM He OblJ1 nOpO)KzleH Heshy
llOCTaTOlJHOA lJHCJIeHHOCTblO ee COOCTBeHHoro HaCeJ1eHHB
CHaooopOT lleMOrpaJlHlJeCKHA B3PbIB B POCCHH nOllTBepmiddot
)KlleHHbIA nepenHcblO 1897 r llaBaJI eA HeocnopHMble
npeHMYIIlecTBa nepezl llPyrHMH BeJ1HKHMH zlep)KaBaMH a
poccHRcKOMY J1HlSepaJ1bHO-HMnepHaJ1HCTHlJeCKoMY J1areplO
zlonOJIHHTeJ1bHbIe CTHMyJ1bl) TpeBory BbI3bIBaJIH KHTaRcKHe KYJIH
Ka3aJ10Cb OHH HeOTBpaTHMo HacTynalOT co Bcex
CTOpOH 12 TOHKHA CJ10A PYCCIltHX KpeCTbRH H ToprosueB B Iltashy
3alJbHX nOrpaHHlJHbIX nOCeJ1eHHRX no AMYPY H YCCYPH He
CMor ISbI npOTHBOCTORTb npHTOllty TPYzl0J1100HBbIX KHTaAueB
H KopeAueB eCJIH ObI He llHClltpHMHHaUHOHHbIA YKa3 uapshy
clltoro npaBHTeJlbCTBa 1882 r 1lt0TOPbIA 3anpeIllaJI HepyccKHM
npHOOpeTaTb 3eMJIIO B CHOHpH13
IOgtKAKOB H ~EllOPOB
Korl(a CTOJ1KHOBeHHe POCCHH H AHrJIHH H3-3a AJlraHHCTaHa
nOCTaBHJ10 HX Ha rpaHb BoAHbl CepreA lO)KaKOB (1849-1910 rr)
133
npe~nO~Hn HCTOPHOCO~CKOe TOnKOBaHHe ~Byx npOTHBOCTOshy
HmHX 3KCnaHCHOHHCTCKHX nOTOKOB B A3HH KpeCTbRHCKaR POcshy
CHR npHmna CnaCTH CenbCKOX03RRcTBeHHble CTpaHbI A3HH OT
A3HH KOtleBOA - OT TypaHa (A3HH ApHMaHaH) Cne~OBaTenbHO
PYCCKHR KOnOHHanH3M OCHOBbIBaIOIQHRcR Ha KpeCTbRHCKOM
nOCeneHtlecTBe - pe3KaR npOTHBOnOnO~HOCTb B~OXHOMReshy
MOMY POCTOBIQHtleCTBOM ~pHTaHCKOMY TOprOBOMY KOnOHHashy
nH3MY OCHOBaHHOMY Ha ~e3~anOCTHoR 3KcnnyaTaQHH pecypshy
COB A3HH H He B03BpaIQalOIQeMY HHtlerO ee nOtlBe lO~aKOB
nHcaTenb HapO~HHtlecKoro HanpaBneHHR nonaran tlTO o()ecshy
netlHBaR npHTOK CBoero KpeCTbRHCTBa POCCHR CTaHeT O()HOshy
BHTenbHHQeA A3HH 3aIQHTHHQeR alHaTCKHX HapO~OB CH~HpH
POCCHR nepe~aCT nocnaHHe KpeCTbRHCKOrO COQHanH3Ma
cenbCKHW o~mHHaM I1H~HH H KHTaR H nOBe~eT HX Ha ()Opb()Y
npOTHB KanHTanHCTHtleCKOR 3KcnnyaTaQHH co CTOpOH~
3ana~a14
llHXOTOMHR Me~~y QHBHnH3aQHeR OCHOBaHHOR Ha o~pashy
~OTKe 3eMnH H QHBHnH3aQHeA CTenHblX KOtleBHHKOB CTana ~Hshy
HaMHtleCKHM npHHQHnOM HCTOPHH B ~HnOCO~CKOM ytleHHH
HHKOnaR clgte~opoBa (1828-1903 rr) KOToporo MHOrHe CtlHTalOT
HaH()onee 3HatlHTenbHbiM H opHrHHanbHblM PYCCKHM MblcnHTeshy
neM XIX BeKa1S OH BepHn tlTO PYCCKaR KpeCTbRHCKaR O()IQHHa
o~na~aeT OCO~bIMH ~o~pO~eTenRMH KOTopble MorYT cnacm
MHp OT pa3nO~eHHR tlTO cenbCKoe X03RACTBO npOTHBOCTORshy
IQee ToprOBne H POCTOBIQHIQeCTBY o()na~aeT BOCKpemaJOIQHMH
cnOCO~HOCTRMH KOTopble MorYT o~paTHTb npax YMepmHX
npe~KOB B ~HBble paCTeHHR H ~HBOTHbIX no MHeHHIO clgte~oshy
pOBa cenbCKHe QHBHnH3aQHH POCCHH H A3HH (Te I1paHa I1Hshy
~HH H KHTaR) Be~YT O()opOHHTenbHYIO ~OPb()Y npOTHS KOshy
tleBbIX CTenHblX rocy~apcTB H MOPCKHX ~ep~aB B BoRHax
Me~~y AHrnHeA H KHTaeM clgte~opoB BH~en npo~on~HTenbshy
HblR KOH~nHKT KynbTa npe~KOB H KynbTa 30nOTa POCCHR
~on~Ha npHcoe~HHHTbCR K ToR HnH HHOR CTopOHe OHa MOshy
~eT npHcoe~HHHTbCR K 3ana~y tlTO~bl 3a~ymHTb CTapeAmylO
HMnepHIO MHpa HnH ~e OHa Mo~eT B03~ep~aTbCR OT
CTonb 3nOK03HeHHoro O~be~HHeHHR H pa~OTaTb ~nR ~OCTHshy~eHHR BetlHOrO MHpa Me~~y ()enblM H ~enTblM QapRMH clgteshy
~OpOB npe~naran POCCHH OTCTpaHHTbCR OT eBponeACKHX
H aMepHKaHCKHX ~aH~HTOB H BCTaTb Ha CTOPOHY cna~blX
B A3HH - H TeM nOMOtlb HH~HAcKHM KpeCTbRHaM BepHYTb
3eMnlO B CBoe Ma~eHHe16 YBnetleHHe clgte~opoBa HH~HRcKHM BonpOCOM He ~blno
cnytlaRHblM B 1899 r OH nocemn ~pyra ~HBmero B Amxa()~e cTonHQe pyccKoro 3aKaCnHR H npoexan no TypKeCTaHY ~o cashy
Moro naMHpa B Amxa()a~e clgte~opoB cornaCHnCR ony~RHKOshy
BaTb B MecrnoM ~ypHane CTaTblO B KOTOpoR OH pa3MblmRRn
ot) aHrno-poccHAcKOM cOnepHHtlecTBe 3TO t)b1na aHOHHMHaR
CTaTbR - ~Hnoco~-YTOnHCT clgte~opoB OTKaaanCR on~nHKoshyBaTb ee no~ CBOHM HMeHeM H nonyqHTb aa Hee rOHopap OHa
HOCHna HeO~bltlHOe Ha3BaHHe - 0 npeBpameHHH pa3pymHshy
TenbHoro Opy~HR B opy~He cnaCeHHRP POCCHR YBepReT
tlHTaTeneR clgte~opOB He XOtleT npaBHTb I1H~HeA OHa npOCTO
HIQeT cnpaBe~nHBOCTH ~nR t)e~Horo HH~HAcKoro KpeCTbRHHshy
Ha H 3aIQHTbI ~nR Bcex 3KcnnyaTHpyeMbIx HapO~OB HaH()Oshy
nee 3~~eKTHBHoe Hepa3pymalOIQee opY~He KOTopoe Mo~eT
HCnOnb30BaTb POCCHR tlTOt)b1 3aCTaBHTb npOMbimneHHYJO BPHshy
TaHHIO OTKa3aTbCR OT BnaCTH H~ KpeCTbRHCKOR I1H~HeR shy
npOBe~eHHe ~ene3HoR ~OpOrH ~O BOPOT I1H~HH
BH~HMO npH HanHcaHHH 3TOA CTaTbH clgte~opoB BHOBb neshy
pe~HBan Te MHHYTbl Kor~a OH CTORR B ()narorOBeHHH nepe~ naMHpOM KpblmeR MHpa HrpaBmHM CTonb Ba~HylO CHMshy
BOnHtleCKyIO ponb B ero KOCMorOHHH neR3a~H naMHpa MornH
HanOMHHTb eMY Ot) YHHBepCanbHoA ponH I1H~HH H()O clgte~oshypOB npH3HaBan ~Ba OCHOBHblX QeHTpa QHBHnH3aQHH KOHshy
CTaHTHHOnonb - ~HBYIO CTonHQY r~e rpeKO-CnaBRHCKHR MHp
BCTpetlaeTCR C xpHCTHaHCKHM 3ana~OM H naMHp - HeKpononb
npe~KOB apHAcKoR paCbI H Konbl~enb HH~oeBponeRcKHX R3~shy
KOB 3TO YTonHtleCKoe BH~eHHe npHBeno clgte~opoBa K H~ee
tlTO B ~y~YIQeM 3Ta CBRIQeHHaR BepmHHa CTaHeT CBH~eTeneM
npHMHpeHHR POCCHH C BenHKo()pHTaHHeR18
YTonHtleCKHe pe~neKCHH clgte~opOBa OTHOCHTenbHO Bceshy
MHpHoro QeHTpa HCKynneHHR19 nonytlHnH BeCbMa Manoe
pacnpOCTpaHeHHe H TonbKO B POCCHH nOCKonbKY npH ~H3HH
OH netlaTanCR OtleHb Mano OHH ()bIRH H3BecTHbi nHmb HeMHorHM
ero ~nH3KHM ~py3bRM (BAKo~eBHHKOBY H HnneTepCOHY)
H HeCKonbKHM Ot)IQHM 3HaKOMblM cpe~H KOTOPblX t)b1nH cIgt llocshy
ToeBCKHR 11 TonCToR H B ConOBbeB cnocne~HHA npH3Hasan
CBoR HHTenneKTyanbHblR ~onr clgte~opOBY) npe~CTaBnReTCR
134 135
OllHaKO qTO B nOCJIellHHe llBa lleC$lTHJIeTH$I XIX BeKa npOH30shy
WeJI KpynHbIA CllBHr B pYCCKOA HMnepHaJIHCTHqeCKOA nOJIHTHshy
Ke KOToporo He 3aMeTHJI ctgtellOpOB B CpellHeA A3HH nOJIO)f(eshy
HHe nOflrH He H3MeHHerCH HeCMOTp$l Ha TO qTO BpHraHHH
COXpaHHer B 3rOM perHOHe craryc KBO A3HaTCKa$l nOJIHTHKa
POCCHH cOCpellOTOqHJIaCb Ha ~aJIbHeM BOCTOKe CTOJIKHOBeshy
HHe C $InOHCKoA 3KCnaHCHeA B KHTae H Kopee CTaJIO JIHWb Bonshy
POCOM BpeMeHH npellBHlleHHe 3Toro KOHJlJIHKTa HaJIO)f(HJIO
OTneqaTOK Ha Bce llHCKYCCHH 06 A3HH B cpelle PyccKoA HHshy
TeJIJIHreHUHH HMeHHO 3TO npellBHlleHHe llaJIO B03MO)f(HOCTb
CTOpoHHHKaM HlleH )f(eJIToA onacHoCTH OllOJIeTb yMepeHHbIX
nAHMOHrOnH3M
nO)f(aJIyA HHKTO He 6blJI 60JIee 3aXBaqeH npellCTaBJIeHHeM
o POCCHH KaK 0 3amHTHHue EBponbI OT HacTynalOmHx Opll a3Hshy
aTCKHX 3aXBaTqHKOB qeM BHllHbIA peJIHrH03HbiA JlHJIOCOJl H
MHCTHK BJIallHMHP COJIOBbeB (1853-1900 rr) CblH H3BeCTHoro
HCTopHKa CM COJIOBbeBa HBHO pacHcTcKHe ynpa)f(HeHH$I Coshy
JIOBbeBa Ha TeMY )f(eJIToA onaHocTH BpOlle 3HaMeHHToA noshy
3MbI naHMOHrOJIH3M (1894 rgt H nOCJIellHerO ero 3cce AHTHshy
XPHCT (1900 r) rlle H306pa)f(eHO HOBoe MOHrOJIbCKOe HaweCTshy
BHe Ha EBpony B XX BeKe noll BOllHTeJIbCTBOM HnoHHH 3aXBashy
THJIH Bo06pa)f(eHHe WHPOKOA ny6JIHKH H B POCCHH H BHe ee20
COJIOBbeB KaK H MHorne ero cOBpeMeHHHKH paJlleJI$lBWHe HllelO
)f(eJIToA onacHocTH BepHJI qTO pacbl KOTopble OH KJIaCCHshy
JlHUHpOBaJI KaK HH3wHe 06peqeHbi Ha nOllqHHeHHe BbICWHM
pacaM HJIH Ha HCqe3HOBeHHe JlHWb aHapxHcTbl BpOlle neTpa
KponoTKHHa21 OTBa)f(HBaJIHCb Bnp$lMylO B03pa)f(aTb npOTHB
B3rJI$IllOB COJIOBbeBa BOJIbWeBHKH lleJIaJIH TO )f(e HO HX B03shy
pa)f(eHH$I ObIJIH ynpOmeHHbIMH OHH npOBOllHJIH napaJIJIeJIb
Me)f(lly OJlHUHaJIbHOA nponaraHlloA )f(eJIToA onaCHOCTH H aHshy
THCeMHTH3MOM22
BJIH$lHHe nponoBelleA COJIOBbeBa HenOCpellCTBeHHO HcnbIshy
TaJIH pYCCKHe n03Tbl-CHMBOJIHCTbI B HX qHCJIe AHllpeA BeJIbIA23
H AJIeKcaHllp BJIOK B npOWJIOM - yqeHHK COJIOBbeBa n03Ma
middotCKHJlbI HanHCaHHa$l B KaHYH 3aKJIlOqeHH$I BpeCTCKoro MHpa
OTKpbIBaeTC$I 3nHrpaJloM H3 naHMOHrOJIH3Ma naHMOHroshy
JIH3M XOTb HM$I llHKOl Ho MHe JIaCKaeT CJIYX OHO JTa n03Ma
BJIOKa llaJIa HM$I ueJIOMY JIHTepaTYPHOMY HanpaBJIeHHIO24 BJIOK
nOTp$lCeHHblA TparHqeCKOA cYllbooA POCCHH HlleT HanepeKop
Hlle$lM CBoero yqHTeJI$I H OTCTaHBaeT COlO3 PYCCKHX H CKHJlOB
npOTHB HarJIoA EBponbl ero npellOCTepe)f(eHHe - HenpHKpblshy
Ta$l a3HaTflHHa
MHJIbOHbl- Bac Hac - TbMbl H TbMbl H TbMbI
nonpooyATe cpa3HTecb C HaMHI
~a CKHJlbl- MbI ~a a3HaTbl- Mbll
C pacKocblMH H )f(allHblMH oqaMHI
POCCH$I - CJlHHKC JlHKY$l H CKOPO$l
Ii OOJIHBaRCb qepHoA KPOBblO
OHa rJI$IllHT rJI$IllHT rJIMHT B Te6$1
Ii C HeHaBHCTblO H C JII060BblO2S
Y)f(e B 1923 r Korlla OOJIbWeBHCTCKaR POCCH$I n06ellHJIa
B rpa)f(llaHCKOA BoAHe llpyroA PYCCKHA n03T CepreA Eceshy
HHH nHllleT H3 repMaHHH HHKaK He CTapaRCb CKpbITb CBoero
r JIy60Koro OTBpameHH$I K EBpone nYCTb Mbl a3HaTbl nYCTh Mbl
BOH$leM nYCTb Mbl oeCCTbIllHO qellleM 3allHHUY Ha rJIa3aX y
Bcex nYCTb TaK HO HeT B Hac 3Toro 3anaxa rHHeHH$I HHKaKa$l
peBOJIIOUH$I 3lleCb HeB03MO)f(Ha Bce B 3aCToe B TynHKe TOJIbshy
KO HaweCTBHe BapBapOB BpOlle Hac MO)f(eT cnaCTH HX H nepeshy
lleJIaTb Be3 HalllecTBH$I Ha EBpony He OOOAlleTC$I 26 Ho HH Pycshy
CKoe 06mecTBo HH uapcKoe npaBHTeJIbCTBO He npHH$lJIH arpecshy
CHBHoA HlleOJIOrHH BOCTOqHHKOB OHH npOllOJI)f(aJIH CB$l3blshy
BaTh 6Yllymee POCCHH C TpallHUHOHHblMH HanpaBJIeHH$lMH HMshy
nepHaJIHCTHqeCKOA nOJIHTHKH cJlOKYCHpOBaHHbIMH Ha EBPOshy
ny C npellnOqTeHHeM 3KcnaHCHH uapH3Ma Ha BaJIKaHbI H K
npOJIHBaM BOJIee Toro pHCKOBaHHble a3HaTCKHe aBaHTlOpbl
KPHTHKOBaJIHCb neqaTblO KaK $IBHa$l JIOByIIIKa nOpO)f(lleHHaR
repMaHCKHM JI066H BCerlla HMeBIlIHM BJIH$lHHe B neTepoypre
CqHTaJIOCb qTO BbIllYMaHHaR HM a3HaTCKaR MHCCH$I POCCHH shy
orpOMHa$l llHBepCH$I KOTOpa$l llOJI)f(Ha 06JIerqHTb COOCTBeHshy
HblA repMaHCKHA llpaHr Hax OCTeH B UeHTpaJIbHOA EBpone
a 3aTeM H no BceA JIHHHH BepJIHH-Barllall27
-)f(EJITOPOCCH)1shy
CTpaHHOe H llBYCMbICJIeHHOe llBH)f(eHHe )I(eJITOpOCCH$I -
HaHOOJIee JIIOOOnbITHOe H KpaAHee KPbIJIO BOCTOqHHKOB nOJIshy
136 137
Hee BCerO ero H~eH OTpa~eH~ B pa60TaX H npe~npHHHMashy
TeRbCKOA ~e~TeRbHOCTH KH~3~ 3cnepa YXToMcKoro (1861shy
1921 rr) 3TOT BRa~eRel HeCKORbKHX ra3eT 6RH3KHA copaTHHK
BH~Horo rocy~apCTBeHHOrO ~emeR~ POCCHH C 10 BHTTe B noshy
nYR~pH3alHH H~eH TpaHccH6HPCKOA ~eRe3HoA ~oporH HaCTaBHHK 6y~y~ero HMnepaTopa HaCRe~Horo npHHla HHKOshy
Ra~ pa3BHBaR nopa~alO~He MeraROMaHHeA H~eH OCHOBaHHbIe
Ha cOMHHTeRbHoA TeopHH 0 ~K06bI OpraHHtIeCKOA 6RH30CTH
POCCHH K KHTalO H ~a~e K I1H~HH28 YXTOMCKHA neR ~H(I)HPaMshy6bI KHTaAcKoA lHBHRH3alHH HO CKpbITbIM HX ReATMoTHBOM
HeCOMHeHHO 6bIRa H~e~ ~eRToA onacHocTH To tITO HCTOshy
pHK 3MaR03eMOB Ha3bIBaR H~eOROrHtIeCKOA CYTblO HBOCTOtIshy
HHKOB OTpa~eHO B Kpe~O YXTOMCKOrO A3H~ - Mbl BCer~a
npHHa~Re~aRH K HeA MbI ~HRH ee ~H3HblO H O~~aRH ee HHshy
TepeCbI LJepe3 Hac BOCTOK npHweR K OC03HaHHIO ceo~ K BbICshy
meA ~H3HH HaM He HY~HO 3aBoeBaHHA Bce 3TH HapO~bI pa3shy
RHtIHbIX pac tIYBCTBYIOT npHT~~eHHe K HaM - KPOBblO Tpa~Hshy
lHeA H~e~MH MbI npOCTO 60Ree 6RH3KH HM HHTHMHO 3TOT Beshy
RH KHA H 3ar~OtIHbIA BOCTOK rOTOB CTaTb HawHM~9 TaKHM 06pa30M MO~HO 6bIRO 6bI CKa3aTb tITO onTHshy
MHCTHtIeCKa~ BepCH~ PycCKoA lHBHRH3aTopCKoA MHCCHH Ha
BOCTOKe (BO BC~KOM CRYtIae B ~eKRapalH~X) OCHOBaHHa~
Ha pacoBoA H KYRbTYPHOA aCCHMHRH~lHH HRH no MeHbmeA
Mepe Ha COTpY~HHtIeCTBe H TepnHMOCTH KOTOPYIO npOB03shy
r RaCHR BeHIOKOB B 70-e ro~~ XIX BeKa B OTHoweHHH Cpe~HeA
A3HH MorRa HaATH npHRo~eHHe H no OTHoweHHIO K BOCTOtIHOA
A3HH CaM BHTTe 6bIR CTOPOHHHKOM H~eH tITO POCCHACK~
HMnepH~ pacnORo~eHHa~ Me~~y 6Y~~HCTCKHM HH~HAcKHM H MYCYRbMaHCKHM MHpaMH ~BR~eTC~ MHpOM B ce6e CorRaCHO
3anHCKe no~aHHoA BHTTe laplO B 1893 r TO tITO OTRHtIaeT
POCCHIO OT 3ana~a - 3TO ee OC06bIA HalHOHaRbHbIA ~yx 3TOT
~yx Hap~~y C ~pyrHMH 3ReMeHTaMH CKpenR~IO~HMH POCshy
CHIO (reOrpajJHtIeCKOe nORo~eHHe npaBOCRaBHoe xpHCTHaHshy
CTBO H caMo~ep~aBHe) 06pa3yeT KpenKoe ~~po npOtIHO
06be~HHeHHoe HO cB060~Hoe OT HalHOHaRHCTHtIeCKOA HCshy
KRlOtIHTeRbHOCTH 06Ra~aeT orpOMHbIMH B03MO~HOCT~MH
~R~ ~py~eCTBeHHOrO 6paTCTBa H COTpY~HHtIeCTBa C caMbIMH
PaJRHtIHbIMH pacaMH H Hapo~aMHO B TOM ~e ro~y BHTTe no~aR laplO e~e O~HY ~OKRa~shy
HYIO 3anHCKY B KOTOpoA no~~ep~HBaR BeCbMa B3pbIBoonacshy
HYIO H COMHHTeRbHYIO H~elO BbI~BHHYTYIO neTpOM Ba~MaeBbIM
6YP~TCKHM leRHTeReM npHH~BwHM npaBOCRaBHe (ero
KpeCTHbIM OTlOM 6bIR HMnepaTOp AReKcaH~p III) CTpaHHbIA
nRaH OCHOBbIBaRC~ Ha CHCTeMaTHtIeCKOM npOHHKHOBeHHH
6YP~TOB 06yqeHHbIx PYCCKHMH B KatIeCTBe ToprOBbIX areHTOB
B 3a~HHA ~BOp KHTa~ - Ha 3an~HYIO nOrpaHHtIHYIO nOROCy
3eMeRb npOT~HYBWHXC~ OT CHHb13~Ha ~O MOHrORHH H MaHbtIshy
~YPHH BKRlOtI~ TH6eT B 1895-1897 rr nRaH 6bIR onp060BaH
HO nOTepneR nORHYIO Hey~atIY JlHHHeA npo~BH~eHH~ POCCHH
~OR~Ha 6bIRa CTaTb HOBa~ ~eRe3Ha~ ~opora Ha JlaHbtI~oy B
npOBHHlHH KaHcyA rRaBHbIM HanpaBReHHeM nO~PbIBHOA ~e~shy
TeRbHOCTH 6bIRa no~~ep~Ka aHTHKHTaAcKoro BOCCTaHH~
MOHrOROB m6eTleB H KHTaACKHX MYCYRbMaH ECRH 6bl nRaH
Ba~MaeBa OKa3aRC~ CTORb ~e ycnewHbIM KaK r RaBH~A nRaH
BHTTe - cTpoHTeRbcTBO TpaHccH6HPCKOA ~eRe3HOA ~oporH TO BHTTe 6bIR 6bI npaB B CBoeM 3aKRlOtIeHHH tITO ftc 6eperOB
THxoro OKeaHa H BepWHH rHMaRaeB POCCH~ 6y~eT BepWHTb
He TORbKO a3HaTCKHe HO H eBponeAcKHe ~eRaft 31 XOT~ BHTTe
CTapaRC~ tIT06bI MHp nOBepHR ero ~eKRapalH~M 0 cnoc06shy
HOCTH POCCHH ocy~ecTBHTb CBOIO MHCCHIO B A3HH MHPshy
H~MH H KYRbTypHbIMH MepaMH KOHetIHOA leRblO PYCshy
CKoA 3KcnaHCHH B A3HH nocpe~CTBOM ~eRe3Ho~opO~Horo
CTpOHTeRbCTBa H ToprOBbIX MeponpH~THA (KOTOpble B 3Hashy
tIHTeRbHoA Mepe a nO~tIac H nORHOCTblO cy6CH~HpOBaRHCb
rocy~apcTBOM) 6bIRO KOROHHaRbHoe rocnO~CTBo32 KaKoe-TO BpeM~ PYCCKHA HMnepHaRH3M B A3HH pa3BHBaRshy
C~ Ha BORHe onTHMH3Ma conpOBo~~aBwero CTpOHTeRbCTBO
TpaHCCH6HPCKOA MarHCTpaRH rRaBH~M nponaraH~HCTOM
3TOA ~oporH H CHCTeMaTHtIeCKOrO npOHHKHOBeHH~ POCCHH B
KHTaA tIepe3 MaHbtI~ypHIO 6bIR YXTOMCKHA Ero nOMO~HHK no CB~3~M C 3ana~HoA EBponoA repMaH BpYHxojJep (1841shy
1916 rr) tIYTb RH He B RHpHtIeCKHX TOHax onHCblBaR CBeTRoe
6y~y~ee EBpa3HH Bce pacbl CB~3aHHble OT BaRTHKH H LJepHoshy
ro MOp~ ~o THxoro OKeaHa 3TOA nOTp~calO~eA ~oporoA KOshy
Topa~ npHHeceT BbIrO~bl B3aHMHoMY ToproBoMy H KyRbTypshy
HOMY 06MeHY 6Y~YT ~HTb B nORHOM corRaCHH no~ CKHneTshy
POM lap~ B OTRHtIHe OT 6pHTaHleB B I1H~HH ~OKa3bIBaR
BpYHxoBep Y PyccKoro KpeCTb~HHHa H COR~aTa HeT tIyBcTBa
138 139
paCOBoro npeBOCXOllCTBa no OTHomeHHIO K a3HaTaM
KaH H TypaHCKaH KPOBb BCKope CMemaIOTCH B03HHKHyr HOBbie
nOrpaHHtlHbIe HapOllbI nOJIya3HaTcKoro nOJIyeBponeAcKoro
npOHCXOgtKlleHHH C03lla101IHe CBH3yJOlIee 3BeHO nOCpellCTBO
KOToporo CJIaBHHe ClleJIaIOT BblcmHe $OpMbl gtKH3HH C03llaHshy
Hble XpHCTHaHCKO-eBponeAcKoA KYJIbTYpoA llOCTynHblMH Bee elIe 3aKpblTOMY CepllLlY BHYTPeHHeA A3HH3
MOTHB 3TOT BeCbMa 3HaKOM HlleH MorJIa npHllTH tlyramp JIH
He OT BeHIOKOBa H llagtKe OT paHHero n03Ta-naHCJIaBHCTa TIOTshy
tleBa KOTOPblA B OllHOM H3 CBOHX CTpaHHblX CTHXOTBOpeHHR
PYCCKaH reorpa$HH (1848 r) MetlTaJI 0 5YllYlIeA poccHAcKOR
eBpoa3HaTcKoA HMnepHH OT HHJIa ll0 HeBbI OT 3JIb5bI ll0 KHshy
TaHIOT BOJIrH no EB$paT OT raHra ll0 llYHaH~ OllHaKO Pa3shy
pa50TaHHaH B rOllbI HnOHO-KHTaAcK09 BoAHbl (1894-1895 IT)
5pYHxo$epoBCKaH aHTHHMnepHaJIHCTHtleCKaH KOHLlenLlHft
)KeJITOpOCCHH HMeJIa HCHyJO nOJIHTHtlecKyJO LleJIb BpYHxo$ep
He TOJIbKO pHCOBaJI BeJIHtleCTBeHHYIO KapTHHY B03MOgtKHOro
CHM5H03a POCCHH H KHTaH HO H npellynpegtKllaJI 3anallHOe 0laquo5shy
lIeCTBO 05 3KcnaHCHOHHCTCKHX HaMepeHHHX SlnoHHH SInOHHft
noll $JIarOM 5YllllHCTCKOA COJIHllapHOCTH C03llaeT naHa3HaTCshy
KYIO 30HY BJIHHHHH CHatlaJIa OrpaHHtleHHYIO SInoHHeA Kopeshy
eA H KHTaeM Ho 3aTeM nOCJIe oKKynaLlHH TaAaaHH na 30Ha
nOCTeneHHO MOgtKeT pacmHpHTbCH Ha BCIO IOrO-BOCTOtlHYIO
A3HIO B ollHoA H3 CBOHX cTaTeA BpYHxo$ep C HeMaJI09 lloJIeR
np03peHHH nHCaJI 0 5YllYlIeA BeJIHKOA BOCTOtlHOa3HaTCKoR
c$epe COBMeCTHOrO npOLlBeTaHHH KOTOpaH B03HHKHeT 50 JIeT
cnycTH3S TeM He MeHee npellOCTepegtKeHHH BpYHxo$epa JIe)f(ashy
JIH BHYTPH cneKTpa HlleA gtKeJIToA onacHocTH KOTopbIe MO)f(shy
HO HaATH ygtKe Y B COJIOBbeBa H llagtKe elIe paHbme - Y K JIeoHshy
TbeBa HeCMOTpH Ha onTHMHCTHtleCKHe KapTHHbl 5YllYlIeR
ft)KeJITOpOcCHH BpYHxo$ep nO-BHllHMOMY 5bIJI 05ecnoKoeH
B03MOgtKHOCTblO Toro tlTO HHllYCTPHaJIH30BaHHble MaCCbl KHshy
TaALleB HatlHYT HeoTBpaTHMo npOllBHraTbCH Ha 3anall noll BOllHshy
TeJIbCTBOM HnOHLleB EllHHCTBeHHoA CHJIoA KOTOPaH CMO)f(eT
npoTHBOCTOHTb noA MOIIHOA 5YllllHCTCKOA BOJIHe llOKa3bIshy
BaJI BpYHxo$ep HBJIHeTCH PYCCKaH eBpOa3HaTCKaH HMnepHH
HeCKOJIbKO rpoTecKHoe B03pO)f(lleHHe 5YllllHCTCKOA TeMbI
npOH30mJIO B nepHOll rpaiKllaHCKOA B09Hbi B POCCHH CYshy
MaCmellmHA 5apoH $OH YHrepH-WTepH5epr eiblBmHA Llap-
CJltHR reHepaJI OTBeTHJI Ha PYCCKYIO peBOJIIOLlHIO nepeXOllOM B
ISYIlllH3M B 3HaK npoTecTa npoTHB Toro tlTO OH CtlHTaJI eiaHKshy
pOTCTBOM 3anaztHoA LlHBHJIH3aLlHH B 1921 r ero oeibellHHeHHbIA
llta3aLlKO-MOHrOJIbCKO-KHTaACKHR OTpHll 3aXBaTHJI YpiY CTOshy
nHUY BHemHeA MOHrOJIHH (HbIHe YJIaH-eiaTOP) rlle eiapoH eibIJ1
npOB03rJIameH HOBbIM lIHHrHCXaHoM OllHaKO HeCKOJIbKO MecHshy
ueB cnycTH YHrepH-WTeHeiepr 3TOT CHMBOJI a3HaTtlHHbI H
)KeJITOpOCCHH B OllHOM JIHLle nOTepneJI nOpa)f(eHHe OT 5oJIbshy
meBHKOB H eiblJI HMH paCCTpeJIHH36 Ba)f(HO OTMeTHTb tlTO 3Ta HlleOJIOrHH npOB03rJIamaBmaH
ISYllYlIee CJIHHHHe pac BO HMH eiOJIee OllHOPOllHOA EBpa3HH
(rlle gtKeJIaeMOe HepellKO BbIllaBaJIOCb 3a lleACTBHTeJIbHOCTb)
pa3YMeeTCH noll eiJIarOCKJIOHHbIM BOllHTeJIbCTBOM POCCHH
HHKOrlla He BJIHHJIa Ha npOLlecc npHHHTHH pemeHHA B neTepeiypshy
re KaKHM eibl Y3KHM HH eiblno onpelleJIeHHe noro npOLlecca
llnH Toro BpeMeHH B KOHetlHOM CtleTe (HCKJIlOtlaH anH30ll C Baztshy
MaeBbIM) B030einallaJIa peaJIbHaH nOJIHTHKa Ho B rOllbl rpa)f(shy
llaHCKoA B09Hbi H HeKOTopoe BpeMH nOCJIe ee OKOHtlaHHH eiOJIbshy
meBHCTCKaH POCCHH paCCMaTpHBaJIa CBOIO nOJIHTHKY B A3HH
CKopee KaK $YHKUHIO HlleOJIOrHH HlleH CMemeHHH CJIaBHHOshy
apHALleB H TypaHLleB nOJIb30BaJIaCb onpelleJIeHHOR nOllllep)f(shy
KoA JIHeiepaJIbHblX KpyrOB PYCCKoA HHTenJIHreHLlHH JIHmb ll0
Tex nop nOKa ypOBeHb p0gtKllaeMOCTH B POCCHH OCTaBaJICH Ollshy
HHM H3 caMbIX BbICOKHX B MHpe KaK 3TO eiblJIO npH LlapH3Me coshy
rJIaCHO llaHHbiM nepenHcH 1897 r 3TO cnocoeicTBOBaJIO H O$Hshy
LlHaJIbHOMY nOOlIpeHHIO KOJIOHH3aLlHH PycCKoA A3HH KpeCTbHshy
HaMH eBponeRcKoro npOHCXOgtKlleHHH B OCHOBHOM CJIaBHHaMH
HCnOJIb30BaHHe BblrOll OT OTKPbITHH CpellHeA A3HH H llaJIbshy
Hero BOCTOKa llnH PycCKoA KonOHH3aLlHH mno eibI 3HatlHTeJIbshy
HO MellJIeHHee H He eibIJIO eibI CTonb nOJIHblM 5e3 Toro BKJIalla
KOTOPblA BHecnH B 3TOT npOLlecc YtleHbIe CneLlHaJIHCTbl H
nYTemeCTBeHHHKH OHH OCTaBHnH COBeTCKOMY rOCYllapCTBY
npOtlHYIO TpallHLlHIO HaYtlHbIX HCCnellOBaHHA BbICOKoro
ypOBHH B ocoeieHHocTH B reorpa$HH H BOCTOKOBelleHHH
lla)f(e BbIllaIOIIHACH PYCCKHA BOCTOKOBell BaCHJIHA Bapshy
TOJIbll (1869-1930 rr) KOTOPbIA cYMeJI OCTaTbCH B cTopoHe
OT O$HLlHaJIbHOA nponaraHllbl H npH LlapH3Me H npH eiOJIbmeshy
BHKax B OCHOBHOM CorJIamancH C TeM tlTO OH CtlHTaJI HCTOPHshy
tlecKoA HeoeixOllHMOCTblO - C c03llaHHeM MHPOBbIX HMnepHA
141140
TaKHX KaK HMnepHH AJleKCaHIpa BeJlHKOrO MOHrOJlOS apaOOB
H la~e COSpeMeHHOR eMY POCCHRcKOR HMnepHH S CpelHeR
A3HH OH HCKpeHHe SepHJI 1JTO KpynHble CTpYKTYPbl C031alOT Jlyqshy
mHe YCJlOSHH lJIH KYJlbTypHOrO c6J1H~eHHH HapOlOS pa3J1H1Jshy
HbIX pac HeCMOTpH Ha sce 6elcTsHH KOTopble HecyT SORHbI
conpoSo~IalOlI(He C031aHHe TaKHX HMnepHR~7
HCXO~ HA BOCTOK TPYBEQKOA H CABHQKHA
HeCMOTpH Ha HeYIa1JH CSH3aHHble C PYCCKO-HnOHCKOR H
nepsoR MHposoR soRHaMH PYCCKHe npeTeH3HH Ha oc06ble
OTHOmeHHH C A3HeR npolOJl~aJlH ~HTb cpelH HHTeJlJlHreHshy
QHH a S rOlbI peSOJlIOQHH rp~IaHcKoR SORHbl H cpa3Y ~e nocshy
Jle HHX TaKHe npereH3HH la~e YCHJlHJlHCb Hp1Je scero 3TO 80shy
nJlOTHJlOCb B eSpa3HRCKOM lSH~eHHH KOTopoe cnJlOTHJlO cashy
Mble 6J1ecTHII(He yMbi PYCCKoR 3MHrpaQHH 1920-x rolos Heshy
CMOTPH Ha HepelKHe pa3HorJlaCHH OHH 6blJlH y6e~IeHbl 1JTO
JlHlUb SOCnpHHHS oc060e eBpa3HRcKoe MHpOS033peHHe MO~HO
coxpaHHTb oc060CTb PYCCKoro SKJlala S QHSHJlH3aQHIO OCHOshy
saHHoro KaK Ha rpeKO-SH3aHTHRCKOM TaK H Ha MOHrOJlbCKOM
HaCJlelHH B csoeM nepSOM MaHHlIJecTe l1cxol Ha SOCTOK
(1921 r) lBa SbIIaIOII(HXCH JlHHrBHCTa KHH3b HHKoJlaR Tpy6eQshy
KoR H POMaH HK06coH OTCTaHBaJIH espa3HRcKoe CJlHHHHe H3blshy
KOS H KYJlbTYP (TaK Ha3b1BaeMaH TeOpllH H3bIKOBoro COI03a -
Sprachbund) C03HaTeJlbHO npeYBeJlH1JHBaH SJlHHHHe TypaHcKoshy
ro 3J1eMeHTa38
EBpa3HRQbl C1JHTaJlH 60JlblUeBHKoB H MapKcH3M XYIIUHM
CJlelCTBHeM 3analHoR KYJlbTYPbl OlHaKO caMoe peBOJlIOQHIO
OHH paccMaTpHBaJlH KaK BeJlHKHR H He06XOlHMblR KaTaJlH3ashy
TOp OHa pa3pYIUHJla CTapblR MHp H np06YIHJla OlHospeMeHHO
H PYCCKHe MaCCbl H HapOlbl BOCTOKa n03TOMY pa60Ta Tpy6eQshy
Koro EBpona H 1JeJlOBe1JeCTBo lt1920 r) 1JHTaeTCH KaK HeKoe
C01JeTaHHe lIaHHJleSCKOro H npH3biSOS sToporo KOHrpecca Koshy
MHHTepHa JTO pemHTeJlbHOe 06BHHeHHe 3analHoMY HMneshy
PHaJIH3MY KOTopoe oTBepraeT eBpOQeHTpHCTCKHR nolXOl K
A3HH YHH~eHHe HcnblTaHHoe PoccHeR S XOle BoRHbl H peBoshy
JlIOQHH nHmeT Tpy6eQKoR Mo~eT C031aTb HenOBTopHMYIO
B03MO~HOCTb palHKaJlbHOrO nepecMoTpa OTHOmeHHH K Hepycshy
CKHM HapOlaM POCCHH 6YIYIJH CaMa KOJlOHHeR Mo~eT noshy
142
BeCTH lpyrHe KOJlOHHH B oc06eHHocTH CSOHX laquoa3HaTCKHX cecshy
Tepraquo Ha pelUHTeJlbHYIO 60Pb15y npoTHB pOMaHo-repMaHcKHx
KOJlOHH3aTopOB 39
OlHHM H3 caMbiX opHrHHaJlbHblX MblCJlHTeJleR CpelH
eBpa3HRQes I5blJl reorpallJ neTp CasHQKHR (1895-1968 rr) Coshy
rJlaCHO ero KOHQenQHH Espa3HH - nOlJlHHHaH KYJlbTypHOshy
reorpaIlJH1JeCKaH Ol5lI(HOCTb C lOOaS01JHblM nOTeHQHaJIOM Tepshy
pHTOpHaJlbHOR 3KcnaHCHH (MecTopa3sHTHe HJlH TonoreHeshy
3HC) rOSOpH 0 Ha1JaslUeRcH S XIX BeKe 3KCnaHCHH POCCHH Ha
lOr H SOCTOK CasHQKHR nblTaeTCH npenOlHecTH ee KaK 060shy
pOHHTeJlbHYIO Mepy S PaMKax nOHHTHH npOlsHHYTOR rpaHHshy
QbI HeCOMHeHHO aHaJlOrH1JHOrO TOMy nOHHTHIO KOTopoe
0150CHoBblBaJIO I5pHTaHcKYIO nOJIHTHKY B I1HIHH 50Jlee Toro
CaBHQKHR loKa3blsaeT 1JTO PYCCKYIO 3KcnaHCHIO B QeJIOM MO~HO
paccMaTpHsaTb KaK HenpepblSHblR npoQecc opraHH1JeCKOrO
pa3SHTHH B ero onHcaHHH 3TO BHIHTCH 1JYTb JlH He KaK 3KOshy
JlOrH1JeCKHR npoQecc l5e3 KaKOR-JlHI50 nOJIHTH1JeCKOR MOTHshy
SHPOBKH CKpblBalOlI(eRcH 3a HHM H HMnepHaJIHCTH1JeCKOrO COshy
nepHH1JeCTBa BeJlHKHX lep~as CSH3aHHOro CO cpelHea3HaTCshy
KHM H laJIbHeBOCT01JHblM sonpocaMH CJlelOSaTeJlbHO lOKa3b1shy
BaeT CaBHQKHR PYCCKaR EBpa3HR eCTb reonOJlHTH1JeCKOe elHHshy
CTSO B ce6e C031aHHOe KYJlbTYPHblM npOQeCCOM reHeTH1JeCshy
KoR MyTaQHH a He nOcpelCTSOM 3asoeBaHHA H pa3pyweHHA~ KaK BHIHM TaKOe TOJlKOBaHHe He CJIHWKOM OTJlH1JaeTCR OT KOHshy
QenQHH IHHaMH1JeCKOrO ~H3HeHHoro npOCTpaHCTBa CPPHIPHshy
xa PaTQeJlR KOTOPYlO KapJl XaycxollJep npHHRJI B 20-e rOlbl
EBPA3HAcKOE CBRH)f(EHHE H CRHHHHE
BeCbMa JlI060nbiTHO HBHOe CXOlCTBO Me~IY CJlOBapeM eBshy
pa3HAQeB H COBeTCKoA TepMHHOJlOrHeA xpYlI(eBCKoA 3nOXH
OTHOCHTeJIbHO KYJIbTypHO-HaQHOHaJIbHOrO CJIHRHHR nol JlIOshy
60BHbiM Hal30pOM CTapmero PYCCKoro 6paTa B pa60Tax nCashy
SHQKoro H B oc06eHHocTH B TpYIaX HCTopHKa r BepHaICKOshy
ro HepelKO BCTpe1JaIOTCR TepMHHbl CJ1HJ1HHe H nepeMeJIJHBashy
HHe 1JTO RKOl5bl HMeeT MeCTO B npoQecce TeppHTOpHaJlbHOR
3KcnaHCHH KYJlbMHHaQHR KOTOpoA - 1IJ0pMHpoBaHHe BeJlHshy
KOPYCCKOA KYJlbTYPbl TaK 3aMe1JaHHe BepHalCKoro 1JTO nol
BHeWHHM pa3Ho06pa3HeM CKpblBaeTCH BHYTpeHHee elHHCTBO
143
HanOMHHaeT pacxo)l(ee COBeTCKOe nOHHTHe 0 eQHHCTBe 8
MHorootlpa3HH
B MaHepe He CJIHmKOM OTJIHLlalOIleRcH OT COBeTCKHX CTaH~
QapTOB BepHaQCKHR QOKa3bIBaJI LITO BKJIIOLleHHe HepYCCKHX
rpynn B MHorOHauHOHaJIbYIO eBpa3HRcKYIO HMnepHIO C03Qa~
eT orpOMHbIe 3KOHOMHLleCKHe H KYJIbTypHbIe npeHMYIlIeCTBa O~~
HaKO BepHaQCKHR HaCTaHBaJI npH 3TOM LITO eQHHCTBO QOJI)I(HO
tlbITb 3KYMeHHLleCKHM tle3 HaBH3bIBaHHH HtlO PoccHRcKoe
rocy~apcTBO - eBpa3HRcKoe rOCYQapCTBO H Bce OTQeJIbHbIe
HaUHOHaJIbHOCTH Espa3HH QOJI)I(Hbl LlYBCTBOBaTb LITO 3TO HX
rocy~apcTBO H npH3HaBaTb ero (KypCHB BepHaQCKOrO) CHJIa
3Toro eBpa3HRcKoro otlpa30BaHHH JIe)l(HT B ero CBOtlOQHOM
KYJIbTYPHOM TBopLleCTBe41 KpOMe Toro Qa)l(e eCJIH PycCKHR
HapoQ otlpa3yeT rJIaBHYIO CHJIY eBpa3HRCKoro rocy~apcTBa a
PYCCKHR H3b1K - tla30BbiR CJIoR eBpa3HRcKoR KYJIbTYPbI Bce
3TO HeJIb3H HaBH3b1BaTb QpyrHM Hapo~aM HeCMOTpH Ha BeJIH~
LlHe 3THX HQeR BbICKa3bIBaBmHXCH eBpa3HRuaMH-3MHrpaHTaMH
He HecmHMH HHKaKoR nOJIHTHLIeCKoR OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH H
HMeSmHMH BeCbMa MaJIOe BJIHHHHe B HOBOA COBeTCKoR eBposhy
a3HaTCKoR HMnepHH QPyme CJIaBHHCKHe HapO~bI B ocotleHshy
HOCTH HaHtlOJIee MHOrOLlHCJIeHHble cnoCJIe PYCCKHX) HanpHshy
Mep YKPaHHUbl H nOJIHKH HcnblTbIBaJIH rJIytloKoe HeQOBepHe
K ueJIHM eBpa3HRueB H BbICTYaJIH npOTHB HHX2 K CO)l(aJIeHHIO
HHLlero He H3seCTHO 0 peaKUHH Ha TeopHH eBpa3HAueB a3HaTshy
CKHX HHTeJIJIeKTyaJIOB )l(HBmHX noQ COBeTCKHM pe)l(HMOM
MO)l(HO OQHaKO tle30mHtloLiHo nOJIaraTb LITO OHH BHQeJIH B
3THX TeOpHHX JIHmb YTOHLleHHoe onpaSQaHHe PYCCKoro HMneshy
pHaJIH3Ma
TaKHM otlpa30M eBpa3HRcKoe ~BH)I(eHHe caMO Toro He
C03HaBaH cnoc06CTBOBaJIO $OpMHPOBaHHIO YTonHLleCKoro 06shy
pa3a coseTCKoro LleJIOBeKa - HCKyccTBeHHoro nOpO)l(~eHHH
COBeTCKoR nponaraHQbl He HMelOIlero KaKOrO-JIH60 paCOBoro
HJIH 3THHLleCKOro npOHCXO)l(QeHHH HO rOBOpHIlero no-pYCCKH
H OIlYIlalOIlero ce6H KOHeLiHO )l(e PYCCKHM COBeTCKaH MOshy
QeJIb - TpOHua COCTOHIlaH H3 Tpex CTaQHA - paCUBeT-c6JIHshy
)l(eHHe-CJIHHHHe BeCbMa pa3BHTaH B 3noxy XPYIleBa pa3Hshy
TeJIbHO HanOMHHaeT eBpa3HRcKoe BHQeHHe 1920-x rO~OB OHa
OTpa)l(aeT TaK)I(e HCTopHLIeCKHA onbIT HaKOnJIeHHblA PycCKOR
HHTeJIJIHreHUHeR no HaUHOHaJIbHblM H paCOBblM BonpocaM
KOTopbIe PYCCKHe MbICJIHTeJIH BnepBble nO~HHJIH B XIX B
144
KaK nOKa3blBaeT 3JIeH Kappep Ii AHKOC BCsl COBeTCKasl
(OHuenUHH B otlJIaCTH onpeQeJIeHHH H 3aKOHHoro O$opMJIeHHsl
OTHomeHHA Me)l(~y PYCCKHMH H HepyccKHMH npeTepneJIa
MHO)l(eCTBO H3MeHeHHA43 B npoTHBOnOJIO)l(HOCTb neHHHcKoR
yTOnHH OTMHpaHHsl HauHA H rocYQapcTB H 3aMeHbl HX HOBblM
YHHBepCaJIbHbIM OOIlecTBOM npOJIeTapCKoA KJIaCCOBOR COJIHshy
~apHOCTH 60JIee )l(ecToKHA H OCMOTpHTeJIbHbIA CTaJIHH
nocTeneHHo npe06pa30BaJI HQelO $eQepaUHH B H~elO ueHT~
paJIH30BaHHHoro PyccKoro HaQ30pa HaQ $opMaJIbHO aBTOshy
HOMHbIMH HapoQaMH COBeTcKoro COI03a 3Ta peaJIbHOCTb npeshy
BpaTHJIa Bee COBeTCKHe TeopHH no HaUHOHaJIbHOMY Bonpocy B
nycTOnOpO)l(HHe ynpa)l(HeHHH H3 KOTOPblX H~eH CTaJIHHa TaK
H He 6blJIH YCTpaHeHbl BbI)I(HBaHHe MHorOHaUHOHaJIbHOR
eBpa3HAcKoA TeppHTOpHaJIbHOA KpenOCTH nO-npe)l(HeMY
ynpaBJIHeMOA MYQPbIM CTapmHM PYCCKHM 6paTOM 6YQeT
3aBHCeTb npe)l(Qe Bcero OT pemeHHH nOQHHTbIX eBpa3HAuaMH
BonpOCOB
145
flpHMeqaHHR
1 Andrew Malozemoff Russian Far Eastern Policy 1881-1904 (Berkeley University of California Press 1958) 42 2 FF von Martens Russland und England in Zentralasien (St Petersburg 1880) Heinz Gollwitzer Geschichte des wetpolischen denkens (Gottingen Vandenhoeck amp Ruprecht 1982) 152-70 133-36 3 F F von Martens Le Conflict entre la Russie et la Chine (Bruxel~
les 1880) 4 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) 93-103 WP Wassiliew Die Erschliessung Chinas (Leipzig 1909) 5 WP Wassiliew Die Erschliessung Chinas (Leipzig 1909)49 6 NM Prejevalsky From Kulja accross the Tian Shan to Lob-Nor (London Sampson Low 1879) 7 MA Bakunin La theologie politique de Mazzini et lInternatishyonale (Neufchatel 1871) 102 110 8 AN Kuropatkin Memoiren (Berlin 1919)7174 9 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) 1423-24 111 10 1S Bloch Les Illusions de la Conquette Chinoise Revue des Revues (August 15 1900) 11 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) 14 12 Herold J Weins Chinas March toward the Tropics (Hamden Conn Shoe String Press 1954) 13 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) p 24 14 CH IQlKaKOB AHrJIO-PycCIltaH pacnpH cmgt 1885 15 HltIgtltIgteAopoB ltlgtHJIocoIllHH oOIIlero AeJIa - UHT no HltIgtltIgteAopoB COqHHeHHH M MbICJIb 1982 0 BJIHHHHH ltlgteAoshypOBa Ha llocToeBcKoro TOJICTOrO COJIOBbeBa BepAHeBa BYJIraKOBa HAP CM Stephen Lukashevich NF Fedorov - A Study in Russian Eupsychian and Utopian Thought (Newark University of Delaware Press 1977) pp 13-34 16 HltIgtltIgteAopoB CotJHHeHHH 1982 CTp 343 Sarkisyanz Op cit 210-211 HACeTHHUKHA PyccKHe MbICJIHTeJIH 0 KHTae XapoHH 1926 17 BJIaAHMHp JIbBOB 3araAotJHblA CTapHIlt JI COBeTcKHA nHshyCaTeJIb 1977 CTp 129-135 HltIgtltIgteAopoB CotJHHeHHH (962) CTp 335-336 18 HltIgtltIgteAopoB CotJHHeHHH CTp 216 340 382 669
146
19 TaM lKe CTp 300 20 BCCOJIOBbeB TPH pa3roBopa cms TPYA 1904 21 Malozemoff Russian Far Eastern Policy (1958) p 43 22 JIeHHH 0 BoAHe B KHTae - HCKpa 1 AeKaopH 1900 23 ABeJIbIA neTepoypr UHT no H3A London Penguin 1983 CTP 65 24 Sarkisyanz Russland und der Messianismus(1955) 200 21~218
25 AJIeKCaHAP BJIOK CTHxoTBopeHHH H n03Mbl TeaTp M XYAOlKeCTBeHHaH JIHTepaTypa 1968 CTp 644-645 26 C EceHHH CoopaHHe cotJHHeHHA Mbull 1970 T5 cTP 107 27 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) 42 98-99 28 Sarkisyanz Russland und der Messianismus(1955) 218~22
29 Malozernoff Russian Far Eastern Policy (1958)43-44 30 BH Sumner Russia and Europe Oxford Slavonic Papers (1951) II 1-16B Readings in Russian Civilization nOA peA Thomas Riha (Chicago University of Chicago Press 1964) 1147331 Malozemoff Russian Far Eastern Policy (1958) 43 Sarkisyanz Russland und der Messianismus (1955)378-91 32 Gollwitzer Geschichte (1982) I 138-40 33 Hermann Brunnhofer Russlands Hand Uber Asien Historischshygeographische Essays zur Entwick lungsgechichte des Russichen Reichsdenkens (S1 Petersburg 1897) npeAHCJIOBHe llBeAuapeu BpYHxolllep onpaBAblBaJI pyCCKylO 3IltCnaHCHIO B CpeAHeA A3HH H Ha llaJIbHeM BOCTOKe B cepHH cTaTeA BnepB~e onYOJIHKOBaHHbIx B neTepoyprcKHx ra3eTax Ha HeMeUKOM H3blKe St Petersburger Zeitung H St Petersburger Herold OH n~shyTaJICH OOOCHOBaTb PYCCKHA 3KcnaHCHOHH3M B A3HH CO~shyCTBeHHblMH H3bICKaHHHMH B apHAcKoA MHlIloJIorHH CpeAH ApyrHx paooT OH onYOJIHKOBaJI TpexToMHHK Urgechichte der Arier in Vorder-und Centralasien Historich-geographische Untersuchungen uber den altesten Schauplatz des Rigvedas und Avestas (Leipzig 1983) BpYHxolllep nepeBen TaKlKe o~beshyMHCTbIA OTtJeT KHH3H YXTOMCKoro 0 noe3AKe ueCapeBHqa HHKOJIaH Ha llaJIbHHA BOCTOK Orientreise seiner Kaiserlicher Hohe heit des Grossfursten Thronfolgers (Leipzig Brockhaus 1894 1998) 34 ltIgtHTIOTtJeB JIHpHKa HaYKa 1965 TI1 M CTp 118 35 Ein ostasiatischer Dreibund und die buddhistische Weltproshypaganda B KH BpYHxolllepa Russland Hand uber Aden (1897) 24-29 BnepB~e onYOJIHKOBaHa BSt Petersburger Zeitung B 1894 r
147
36 Louis Fischer The Soviets in the World Affairs (Princeton Princeton University Press 1951) n 534-37 Sir Fitzroy Maclean To the Back ofBeyond (London Cape 1974) 119-121 37 AKatteMHK BapTOJlbtt COllHHeHHR M H3tt-BO BOCTOllHoA JlHTepaTYpbI 1963 T2 cTp 164-166345-350 38 Hcxott K BOCTOKY npettllYBCTBHR H cBepmeHHR YTBepshy)l(tteHHe eBpa3HAueB CO(j)HR 1921 COttep)l(HT CTaTbH rBltJ)JloshypOBcKoro POMaHa HKoCicoHa nllCasllHHcKoro nH CaBHUshyKoro H HCTpyCieUKoro HH)I(e nepellHCJIRIOTCR OCHOBHhIe paCioTbI 0 espa3HAuax DS Mirsky The Eurasian Movement The Slavonic and East European Review (1927) 311-320 Otto Boss Die Lehre der Eurasier (Wiesbaden Harrasowitz 1961) H A Stammler Europe-Russland-Asian Der eurasiche Deutungsshyversuch der russichen Geschichte Osteuropa 12 (1962) 521-528 Gerges Nivat Du Panmongolisme au mouvement eurasien Cahiers du monde Russe et Sovietique 73 (1966) 460-78 Nicholas V Riasanovsky The Emergence of Eurasians California Slavic Studies 4 (1967) 39-72 39 HC TpylSeUKoA Espona H lIeJIOBelleCTBO CO(j)HR 192Q Mirsky The Eurasian Movement (1927) 312-13 V Riasanovsky Emergence of Eurasians (1967) 56 Leonid Luks Die Ideologie der Eurasier im zeitgeschichtlichen Zusammenhang Jahrbucher fur Geschichte Osteuropas 34 (1986) 374-395 40 llH CasHUKHA reOnOJlHTHlIeCKHe 3aMeTKH no PYCCKoA
HCTOpHH - B rB BepHattCKHA HallepTaHHe PYCCKoA HCshyTOpHH llpara 1927 CTp 234-260 CM TaK)I(e nHCasHUKHA reOrpa(j)HlIeCKHe ocolSeHHOCTH POCCHH 2 TT npara 1927 OH )l(e POCCHR - OCOlSblA reorpa(j)HlIecKHA MHp llapH)I( 1927 Charles Halperin Russia and the Steppe George Vernadsky and Eurasianism Forschungen zur osteuropaischen Geschichte 36 (1985) 55-194 and Slavic Studies 41 (1982)477-493 41 rB BepHattcKHA YKa3 COli CTp 230-231 259-260 Charles Halperin Opcit pp 99-104 42 V Riasanovsky The Emergence of Eurasians California Slavic Studies 4 (1967) 43 H Carrere dEncausse Decline of an Empire The Soviet Socialist Republics in Revolt (New York Harper 1981) 13-46
148
npOllBH)KEHHE POCCHH K lOrY
POCCHflCKHE llPOCTOPbI
Hepa3pemHMble npOCiJIeMbI CJlHRHHR pac B orpoMHoM MHOshyrOHaUHOHaJIbHOM KOHrJlOMepaTe Ha3blBaeMOM POCCHAcKOA (a n03ttHee coseTCKoA) eBpa3HAcKoA HMnepHeA eme CioJlee 01S0shyCTPRIOTCR B reorpa(j)HlIecKHx nOHRTHRX - B TpyttHeAmeM nposhyCTpaHcTseHHoM IIHcCiaJIaHce ttoBJIeIOmHM Hall olSmHM reOCTpashyTerHlIeCKHM nOJIO)l(eHHeM HMnepHH
MeTa(j)opHlIeCKH ynpomaR HCTOPHIO POCCHAcKOA HMnepHH nottllac CBOttRT K TparHlIeCKoA Ollep)l(HMOCTH npOCTopOM HJIH K TparHlIeCKOMY lIapy npOCTpaHCTsaI COrJlaCHO 3THM npettCTaBJIeHHRM PYCCKHX - H KaK OISOpOHRIOmHXCR H KaK arpeccopOB nOCTORHHO H Heyttep)l(HMO BJIeKJlH orpOMHble npOCTpaHCTBa Espa3HH PYCCKHe rOpllRTCR TeM liTO s HX rHshyraHTCKoA cyxonYTHoA TBepttbIHe MO)l(HO pa3MecTHTb 2-3 AMepHKH 40 ltJ)paHUHA H 93 BeJIHKOlSpHTaHHH Me)l(lIY 1600 H 1900 rr K PoccHAcKOA HMnepHH 1I0lSaBHJIOCb B olSmeA CJIO)l(HOCTH 17 MJIH KSattpaTHblx KHJIOMeTpOB HOBblX TeppHshyTOPHA s cpellHeM no 57 TbIC KBatlpaTHhIX KHJlOMeTpoB e)l(eshyrOttHo3 HCXOIlR H3 3Toro HeTpyttHO npHIITH K 3aKJIIOlIeHHIO liTO reorpa(j)HR H s caMOM tteJle OKa3b1BaJla BceCTopOHHee BJlHRHHe Ha pYCCKoe H coseTCKoe BOCnpHRTHe A3HH~
TaKHM 01Spa30M reorpa(j)HlIeamA (j)aKTOp HrpaeT orpOMshyHyIO pOJlb S HCTOPHH pYCCKoro Hapottaf ocolSeHHO B CBR3H C lIpe3MepHbiM YBJIelleHHeM HMnepHaJlHCTHlIeCKoA POCCHH npOCTpaHCTBaMH H TeppHTOpHRMH )lse reorpa(j)HlIeCKHe OCOshylSeHHOCTH OTJIHlIaIOT POCCHIO llepBaR - 3TO 0llHooeipa3He peJIbshye(j)a MeCTHOCTH MOHOTOHHOCTb JlaHttma(j)Ta n03S0JIHSmaR UeHTpaJIbHOA nOJIHTHlIeCKoA BJIaCTH nOllttep)l(HBaTb H pacshynpOCTpaHRTb csoA KOHTPOJIb no JIHHHH SeJIHKHX pellHhIx nyshyTeA TRHymHXCR no OCH ceBep-IOr TaKoA KOHTPOJlb oeiJlerllaJl ttBH)I(eHHe TosapOB KOJlOHHCTOB H BoACK~ no CJIOBaM BblllaIOmeshyrOCR HCTopHKa KJIIOlIeSCKoro 3KCnaHCHR MOCKBbI MO)l(eT paCCMaTpHBaTbCR KaK B03BblmeHHe ueHTpOCTpeMHTeJlbHOA CHJIbl 3aXBaTHBmeA KOHTPOJlb HatI HCTOKaMH lIeTblpex peK B
149
ToA OnaCHOCTH B 1861 r nOCJIe ()erCTBa H3 CH()HpCKOA
KH B flOHllOH (lJepe3 HnoHHIO H CIIlA) OH BbICKa3aJI
B3rJIffJlbI B ()pomlOpe noll HalBaHHeM La theologie poIitique
Mazzini et lInternacionale (nOJIHTHlJeCKaR TeOJIOrHR Mall3H~ HH H MHTepHaIlHOHaJI) BaKYHHHCKoe BHlleHHe ()YllYIIlero
pOBoro KOHJlJIHKTa OCHOBbIBaJIOCb Ha paCOBbIX HHCTbullmiddot---shy
3TO ()bIJI ()HnOJIRpHbIA 0()pa3 MHpa KOTOPbIA lleJIHTCR
()eJIoR rpynnoA lJHCJIeHHOCTblO npHMepHo 350 MJIH
HaXOllRIIlHXCR noll yrp030A H MegtKllY 850 MJIH a3HaToB
yrp0gtKaIOIIlHX ()eJIbIM YgtKe TOrlla BaKYHHH npellcKa3bIBaJI
pacnan KOJIOHHaJIbHblX HMnepHA BeJIHKo()pHTaHHH H POCCHH
OH ClJHTaJI JlHKTHBHbIM KOHTPOJIb POCCHH Hall AMYPCKoA 01Sshy
JIaCTblO H CH()HpblO H()O TaM lJHCJIeHHOCTb eBponeAcKHX
nOCeJIeHueB HHKOrlla He ()YlleT llOCTaTOlJHOA lJTO()bl npo
THBOCTORTb orpoMHoMy nOTeHUHaJIY KHTaAcKoA MHrpaUHH
lJepe3 rpaHHUY OH npellCKa3bIBaJI lJTO PYCCKHe BJIalleHHJI
B A3HH npOCYIIleCTBYIOT He ()OJIee nRTHllecRTH JIeT
PemeHHe aToA npO()JIeMbI BaKYHHH BHlleJI BO BceMHpHoR
npOJIeTapCKoA COJIHllapHOCTH KOTOPaR OlSbellHHHT HeHMYIIlHX
He3aBHCHMO OT paCbI Ha OCHOBe KJIaccoBoA ()OpbObIbull llpyroR
PYCCKHA COBepmeHHO HHoro npoJleccHOHaJIbHOrO CKJIalla BHshy
lleJI npOTHBolleAcTBHe yrp03e C BOCTOKa B CBoero pOlla KOshy
JIOHHaJIbHOA COJIHllapHOCTH MegtKllY xpHCTHaHCKHMH llep~ashyBaMH 3anana B ocolSeHHOCTH MegtKllY PoccHeA H BeJIHKOlSpHTashy
HHeA KOTopble ISYllYT npOTHBOCTORTb HexpHCTHaHCKHM CHJIaM
A3HH 3TO OblJI reHepaJI AH KyponaTKHH (1848-1925 rr) OH
YlJaCTBOBaJI B 3aBoeBaHHH CpellHeA A3HH B KalJecTBe anblOTaHshy
Ta reHepaJIa CKOOeJIeBa ISbIJI BoeHHbIM MHHHCTPOM POCCHH
(1898-1904 rr) H rJIaBHOKOMaHllYlOIIlHM PYCCKHX BoAcK B BoAshy
He C HnoHHeA H CJIellOBaTeJIbHO OllHHM H3 BHHOBHHKOB HX noshy
pagtKeHHR 3aKOHlJHJI KyponaTKHH CBOIO Kapbepy KaK nOCJIellHHR
reHepaJI-rylSepHaTOp TypKeCTaHa (1916-1917 rr) OllHaKO ero
MHeHHe lJTO TOHKaR npOCJIOAKa PYCCKHX nOCeJIeHHA B A3HH
He nepe)KHBeT Hanopa BOJIHbI )KeJIToA paCbI B OCHOBHOM COBshy
nallaJIO co B3JIRllaMH aHapXHCTa BaKYHHHa~
MapTeHC BaCHJIbeB H HM nOllOOHbIe npellCTaBJIRIOT KpaRshy
Hee HanpaBJIeHHe PYCCKoA HlleH no OTHomeHHIO K A3HH Mx
n03HUHIO MO)KHO onpelleJIHTb KaK paCHCTCKHA HMnepHaJIH3M
nOpO)KlleHHbIA CTPaxOM nepell )KeJIToA onaCHOCTbIO nponoshy
132
aBzlHHKH 3THX MpalJHbIX npOpOlJeCTB HHCTHHKTHBHO npOTHBHshy
JlHCb Hzlee CJIHRHHR PYCCKo-apHAcKoA paCbI C )KeJITbIMH H
TYPaHCKHMH pacaMH A3HH 11M npOTHBOCTORJIH JIHOepaJIbHbIe
HMnePHaJIHCTbl nOzlOOHbIe nOJIKOBHHKY BeHIOKOBY KOTopble
l)J1aroCKJIOHHO OTHOCHJIHCb K Hzlee aCCHMHJIRUHH BoooIlle )Ke
cneKTp OJlHUHaJIbHbIX H O()IIleCTBeHHbIX B033peHHA B POCCHH B
OTHomeHHH )KeJ1ToA onaCHOCTH BeCbMa CJIO)KeH ero HeJIb3J1
npellCTaBHTb KaK OllHOMepHoe lJepHo-OeJIOe H300pa)leHHe zlBYX
npOTHBOn0J10)KHbIX nOzlXOllOB 3zleCb HeJIb3R He ynOMRHYTb
cpezlH MHorHX llPyrHx HCTOlJHHKOB TOJICTOBCKoe nHCbMO K
KHTaAUY 9 H B3rJIRllbI BbIllalOIIleroCR naUHJlHcTa-CaMOYlJKH H
TeopeTHKa BoAHbI 110raHHa BJIoxa (1836-1902 rr)~o B POCCHH KaK H B zlPyrHx eBponeAcKHx K0J10HHaJIbHbIX
rocYllapCTBax HMnepHaJIHCTHlJeCKaR HlleR nocTpOeHHaJi Ha
gtKeJ1ToA onaCHOCTH He MOrJIa H30e)KaTb HeKOToporo OH0J10shy
rnlJeCKOrO H 3KOHOMHlJeCKOrO lleTepMHHH3Ma 1lt0TOPbIR npHshy
CYTCTByeT B HeOMaJIbTy3HaHCIltHX H HeOllapBHHHCTCKHX TeopHshy
$IX 3TH TeopHH npellCKa3bIBalOT YBeJIHlJeHHe llHc6aJIaHCa
Me)KllY POCTOM HaCeJIeHHR B reOMeTpHlJeClltoR nporpeCCHH H
CpellCTB K CYIIleCTBOBaHHIO - B apHJlMeTHlJeCKoR1 OllHaKO B
POCCHH CTPax nepell nepeHaCeJIeHHeM He OblJ1 nOpO)KzleH Heshy
llOCTaTOlJHOA lJHCJIeHHOCTblO ee COOCTBeHHoro HaCeJ1eHHB
CHaooopOT lleMOrpaJlHlJeCKHA B3PbIB B POCCHH nOllTBepmiddot
)KlleHHbIA nepenHcblO 1897 r llaBaJI eA HeocnopHMble
npeHMYIIlecTBa nepezl llPyrHMH BeJ1HKHMH zlep)KaBaMH a
poccHRcKOMY J1HlSepaJ1bHO-HMnepHaJ1HCTHlJeCKoMY J1areplO
zlonOJIHHTeJ1bHbIe CTHMyJ1bl) TpeBory BbI3bIBaJIH KHTaRcKHe KYJIH
Ka3aJ10Cb OHH HeOTBpaTHMo HacTynalOT co Bcex
CTOpOH 12 TOHKHA CJ10A PYCCIltHX KpeCTbRH H ToprosueB B Iltashy
3alJbHX nOrpaHHlJHbIX nOCeJ1eHHRX no AMYPY H YCCYPH He
CMor ISbI npOTHBOCTORTb npHTOllty TPYzl0J1100HBbIX KHTaAueB
H KopeAueB eCJIH ObI He llHClltpHMHHaUHOHHbIA YKa3 uapshy
clltoro npaBHTeJlbCTBa 1882 r 1lt0TOPbIA 3anpeIllaJI HepyccKHM
npHOOpeTaTb 3eMJIIO B CHOHpH13
IOgtKAKOB H ~EllOPOB
Korl(a CTOJ1KHOBeHHe POCCHH H AHrJIHH H3-3a AJlraHHCTaHa
nOCTaBHJ10 HX Ha rpaHb BoAHbl CepreA lO)KaKOB (1849-1910 rr)
133
npe~nO~Hn HCTOPHOCO~CKOe TOnKOBaHHe ~Byx npOTHBOCTOshy
HmHX 3KCnaHCHOHHCTCKHX nOTOKOB B A3HH KpeCTbRHCKaR POcshy
CHR npHmna CnaCTH CenbCKOX03RRcTBeHHble CTpaHbI A3HH OT
A3HH KOtleBOA - OT TypaHa (A3HH ApHMaHaH) Cne~OBaTenbHO
PYCCKHR KOnOHHanH3M OCHOBbIBaIOIQHRcR Ha KpeCTbRHCKOM
nOCeneHtlecTBe - pe3KaR npOTHBOnOnO~HOCTb B~OXHOMReshy
MOMY POCTOBIQHtleCTBOM ~pHTaHCKOMY TOprOBOMY KOnOHHashy
nH3MY OCHOBaHHOMY Ha ~e3~anOCTHoR 3KcnnyaTaQHH pecypshy
COB A3HH H He B03BpaIQalOIQeMY HHtlerO ee nOtlBe lO~aKOB
nHcaTenb HapO~HHtlecKoro HanpaBneHHR nonaran tlTO o()ecshy
netlHBaR npHTOK CBoero KpeCTbRHCTBa POCCHR CTaHeT O()HOshy
BHTenbHHQeA A3HH 3aIQHTHHQeR alHaTCKHX HapO~OB CH~HpH
POCCHR nepe~aCT nocnaHHe KpeCTbRHCKOrO COQHanH3Ma
cenbCKHW o~mHHaM I1H~HH H KHTaR H nOBe~eT HX Ha ()Opb()Y
npOTHB KanHTanHCTHtleCKOR 3KcnnyaTaQHH co CTOpOH~
3ana~a14
llHXOTOMHR Me~~y QHBHnH3aQHeR OCHOBaHHOR Ha o~pashy
~OTKe 3eMnH H QHBHnH3aQHeA CTenHblX KOtleBHHKOB CTana ~Hshy
HaMHtleCKHM npHHQHnOM HCTOPHH B ~HnOCO~CKOM ytleHHH
HHKOnaR clgte~opoBa (1828-1903 rr) KOToporo MHOrHe CtlHTalOT
HaH()onee 3HatlHTenbHbiM H opHrHHanbHblM PYCCKHM MblcnHTeshy
neM XIX BeKa1S OH BepHn tlTO PYCCKaR KpeCTbRHCKaR O()IQHHa
o~na~aeT OCO~bIMH ~o~pO~eTenRMH KOTopble MorYT cnacm
MHp OT pa3nO~eHHR tlTO cenbCKoe X03RACTBO npOTHBOCTORshy
IQee ToprOBne H POCTOBIQHIQeCTBY o()na~aeT BOCKpemaJOIQHMH
cnOCO~HOCTRMH KOTopble MorYT o~paTHTb npax YMepmHX
npe~KOB B ~HBble paCTeHHR H ~HBOTHbIX no MHeHHIO clgte~oshy
pOBa cenbCKHe QHBHnH3aQHH POCCHH H A3HH (Te I1paHa I1Hshy
~HH H KHTaR) Be~YT O()opOHHTenbHYIO ~OPb()Y npOTHS KOshy
tleBbIX CTenHblX rocy~apcTB H MOPCKHX ~ep~aB B BoRHax
Me~~y AHrnHeA H KHTaeM clgte~opoB BH~en npo~on~HTenbshy
HblR KOH~nHKT KynbTa npe~KOB H KynbTa 30nOTa POCCHR
~on~Ha npHcoe~HHHTbCR K ToR HnH HHOR CTopOHe OHa MOshy
~eT npHcoe~HHHTbCR K 3ana~y tlTO~bl 3a~ymHTb CTapeAmylO
HMnepHIO MHpa HnH ~e OHa Mo~eT B03~ep~aTbCR OT
CTonb 3nOK03HeHHoro O~be~HHeHHR H pa~OTaTb ~nR ~OCTHshy~eHHR BetlHOrO MHpa Me~~y ()enblM H ~enTblM QapRMH clgteshy
~OpOB npe~naran POCCHH OTCTpaHHTbCR OT eBponeACKHX
H aMepHKaHCKHX ~aH~HTOB H BCTaTb Ha CTOPOHY cna~blX
B A3HH - H TeM nOMOtlb HH~HAcKHM KpeCTbRHaM BepHYTb
3eMnlO B CBoe Ma~eHHe16 YBnetleHHe clgte~opoBa HH~HRcKHM BonpOCOM He ~blno
cnytlaRHblM B 1899 r OH nocemn ~pyra ~HBmero B Amxa()~e cTonHQe pyccKoro 3aKaCnHR H npoexan no TypKeCTaHY ~o cashy
Moro naMHpa B Amxa()a~e clgte~opoB cornaCHnCR ony~RHKOshy
BaTb B MecrnoM ~ypHane CTaTblO B KOTOpoR OH pa3MblmRRn
ot) aHrno-poccHAcKOM cOnepHHtlecTBe 3TO t)b1na aHOHHMHaR
CTaTbR - ~Hnoco~-YTOnHCT clgte~opoB OTKaaanCR on~nHKoshyBaTb ee no~ CBOHM HMeHeM H nonyqHTb aa Hee rOHopap OHa
HOCHna HeO~bltlHOe Ha3BaHHe - 0 npeBpameHHH pa3pymHshy
TenbHoro Opy~HR B opy~He cnaCeHHRP POCCHR YBepReT
tlHTaTeneR clgte~opOB He XOtleT npaBHTb I1H~HeA OHa npOCTO
HIQeT cnpaBe~nHBOCTH ~nR t)e~Horo HH~HAcKoro KpeCTbRHHshy
Ha H 3aIQHTbI ~nR Bcex 3KcnnyaTHpyeMbIx HapO~OB HaH()Oshy
nee 3~~eKTHBHoe Hepa3pymalOIQee opY~He KOTopoe Mo~eT
HCnOnb30BaTb POCCHR tlTOt)b1 3aCTaBHTb npOMbimneHHYJO BPHshy
TaHHIO OTKa3aTbCR OT BnaCTH H~ KpeCTbRHCKOR I1H~HeR shy
npOBe~eHHe ~ene3HoR ~OpOrH ~O BOPOT I1H~HH
BH~HMO npH HanHcaHHH 3TOA CTaTbH clgte~opoB BHOBb neshy
pe~HBan Te MHHYTbl Kor~a OH CTORR B ()narorOBeHHH nepe~ naMHpOM KpblmeR MHpa HrpaBmHM CTonb Ba~HylO CHMshy
BOnHtleCKyIO ponb B ero KOCMorOHHH neR3a~H naMHpa MornH
HanOMHHTb eMY Ot) YHHBepCanbHoA ponH I1H~HH H()O clgte~oshypOB npH3HaBan ~Ba OCHOBHblX QeHTpa QHBHnH3aQHH KOHshy
CTaHTHHOnonb - ~HBYIO CTonHQY r~e rpeKO-CnaBRHCKHR MHp
BCTpetlaeTCR C xpHCTHaHCKHM 3ana~OM H naMHp - HeKpononb
npe~KOB apHAcKoR paCbI H Konbl~enb HH~oeBponeRcKHX R3~shy
KOB 3TO YTonHtleCKoe BH~eHHe npHBeno clgte~opoBa K H~ee
tlTO B ~y~YIQeM 3Ta CBRIQeHHaR BepmHHa CTaHeT CBH~eTeneM
npHMHpeHHR POCCHH C BenHKo()pHTaHHeR18
YTonHtleCKHe pe~neKCHH clgte~opOBa OTHOCHTenbHO Bceshy
MHpHoro QeHTpa HCKynneHHR19 nonytlHnH BeCbMa Manoe
pacnpOCTpaHeHHe H TonbKO B POCCHH nOCKonbKY npH ~H3HH
OH netlaTanCR OtleHb Mano OHH ()bIRH H3BecTHbi nHmb HeMHorHM
ero ~nH3KHM ~py3bRM (BAKo~eBHHKOBY H HnneTepCOHY)
H HeCKonbKHM Ot)IQHM 3HaKOMblM cpe~H KOTOPblX t)b1nH cIgt llocshy
ToeBCKHR 11 TonCToR H B ConOBbeB cnocne~HHA npH3Hasan
CBoR HHTenneKTyanbHblR ~onr clgte~opOBY) npe~CTaBnReTCR
134 135
OllHaKO qTO B nOCJIellHHe llBa lleC$lTHJIeTH$I XIX BeKa npOH30shy
WeJI KpynHbIA CllBHr B pYCCKOA HMnepHaJIHCTHqeCKOA nOJIHTHshy
Ke KOToporo He 3aMeTHJI ctgtellOpOB B CpellHeA A3HH nOJIO)f(eshy
HHe nOflrH He H3MeHHerCH HeCMOTp$l Ha TO qTO BpHraHHH
COXpaHHer B 3rOM perHOHe craryc KBO A3HaTCKa$l nOJIHTHKa
POCCHH cOCpellOTOqHJIaCb Ha ~aJIbHeM BOCTOKe CTOJIKHOBeshy
HHe C $InOHCKoA 3KCnaHCHeA B KHTae H Kopee CTaJIO JIHWb Bonshy
POCOM BpeMeHH npellBHlleHHe 3Toro KOHJlJIHKTa HaJIO)f(HJIO
OTneqaTOK Ha Bce llHCKYCCHH 06 A3HH B cpelle PyccKoA HHshy
TeJIJIHreHUHH HMeHHO 3TO npellBHlleHHe llaJIO B03MO)f(HOCTb
CTOpoHHHKaM HlleH )f(eJIToA onacHoCTH OllOJIeTb yMepeHHbIX
nAHMOHrOnH3M
nO)f(aJIyA HHKTO He 6blJI 60JIee 3aXBaqeH npellCTaBJIeHHeM
o POCCHH KaK 0 3amHTHHue EBponbI OT HacTynalOmHx Opll a3Hshy
aTCKHX 3aXBaTqHKOB qeM BHllHbIA peJIHrH03HbiA JlHJIOCOJl H
MHCTHK BJIallHMHP COJIOBbeB (1853-1900 rr) CblH H3BeCTHoro
HCTopHKa CM COJIOBbeBa HBHO pacHcTcKHe ynpa)f(HeHH$I Coshy
JIOBbeBa Ha TeMY )f(eJIToA onaHocTH BpOlle 3HaMeHHToA noshy
3MbI naHMOHrOJIH3M (1894 rgt H nOCJIellHerO ero 3cce AHTHshy
XPHCT (1900 r) rlle H306pa)f(eHO HOBoe MOHrOJIbCKOe HaweCTshy
BHe Ha EBpony B XX BeKe noll BOllHTeJIbCTBOM HnoHHH 3aXBashy
THJIH Bo06pa)f(eHHe WHPOKOA ny6JIHKH H B POCCHH H BHe ee20
COJIOBbeB KaK H MHorne ero cOBpeMeHHHKH paJlleJI$lBWHe HllelO
)f(eJIToA onacHocTH BepHJI qTO pacbl KOTopble OH KJIaCCHshy
JlHUHpOBaJI KaK HH3wHe 06peqeHbi Ha nOllqHHeHHe BbICWHM
pacaM HJIH Ha HCqe3HOBeHHe JlHWb aHapxHcTbl BpOlle neTpa
KponoTKHHa21 OTBa)f(HBaJIHCb Bnp$lMylO B03pa)f(aTb npOTHB
B3rJI$IllOB COJIOBbeBa BOJIbWeBHKH lleJIaJIH TO )f(e HO HX B03shy
pa)f(eHH$I ObIJIH ynpOmeHHbIMH OHH npOBOllHJIH napaJIJIeJIb
Me)f(lly OJlHUHaJIbHOA nponaraHlloA )f(eJIToA onaCHOCTH H aHshy
THCeMHTH3MOM22
BJIH$lHHe nponoBelleA COJIOBbeBa HenOCpellCTBeHHO HcnbIshy
TaJIH pYCCKHe n03Tbl-CHMBOJIHCTbI B HX qHCJIe AHllpeA BeJIbIA23
H AJIeKcaHllp BJIOK B npOWJIOM - yqeHHK COJIOBbeBa n03Ma
middotCKHJlbI HanHCaHHa$l B KaHYH 3aKJIlOqeHH$I BpeCTCKoro MHpa
OTKpbIBaeTC$I 3nHrpaJloM H3 naHMOHrOJIH3Ma naHMOHroshy
JIH3M XOTb HM$I llHKOl Ho MHe JIaCKaeT CJIYX OHO JTa n03Ma
BJIOKa llaJIa HM$I ueJIOMY JIHTepaTYPHOMY HanpaBJIeHHIO24 BJIOK
nOTp$lCeHHblA TparHqeCKOA cYllbooA POCCHH HlleT HanepeKop
Hlle$lM CBoero yqHTeJI$I H OTCTaHBaeT COlO3 PYCCKHX H CKHJlOB
npOTHB HarJIoA EBponbl ero npellOCTepe)f(eHHe - HenpHKpblshy
Ta$l a3HaTflHHa
MHJIbOHbl- Bac Hac - TbMbl H TbMbl H TbMbI
nonpooyATe cpa3HTecb C HaMHI
~a CKHJlbl- MbI ~a a3HaTbl- Mbll
C pacKocblMH H )f(allHblMH oqaMHI
POCCH$I - CJlHHKC JlHKY$l H CKOPO$l
Ii OOJIHBaRCb qepHoA KPOBblO
OHa rJI$IllHT rJI$IllHT rJIMHT B Te6$1
Ii C HeHaBHCTblO H C JII060BblO2S
Y)f(e B 1923 r Korlla OOJIbWeBHCTCKaR POCCH$I n06ellHJIa
B rpa)f(llaHCKOA BoAHe llpyroA PYCCKHA n03T CepreA Eceshy
HHH nHllleT H3 repMaHHH HHKaK He CTapaRCb CKpbITb CBoero
r JIy60Koro OTBpameHH$I K EBpone nYCTb Mbl a3HaTbl nYCTh Mbl
BOH$leM nYCTb Mbl oeCCTbIllHO qellleM 3allHHUY Ha rJIa3aX y
Bcex nYCTb TaK HO HeT B Hac 3Toro 3anaxa rHHeHH$I HHKaKa$l
peBOJIIOUH$I 3lleCb HeB03MO)f(Ha Bce B 3aCToe B TynHKe TOJIbshy
KO HaweCTBHe BapBapOB BpOlle Hac MO)f(eT cnaCTH HX H nepeshy
lleJIaTb Be3 HalllecTBH$I Ha EBpony He OOOAlleTC$I 26 Ho HH Pycshy
CKoe 06mecTBo HH uapcKoe npaBHTeJIbCTBO He npHH$lJIH arpecshy
CHBHoA HlleOJIOrHH BOCTOqHHKOB OHH npOllOJI)f(aJIH CB$l3blshy
BaTh 6Yllymee POCCHH C TpallHUHOHHblMH HanpaBJIeHH$lMH HMshy
nepHaJIHCTHqeCKOA nOJIHTHKH cJlOKYCHpOBaHHbIMH Ha EBPOshy
ny C npellnOqTeHHeM 3KcnaHCHH uapH3Ma Ha BaJIKaHbI H K
npOJIHBaM BOJIee Toro pHCKOBaHHble a3HaTCKHe aBaHTlOpbl
KPHTHKOBaJIHCb neqaTblO KaK $IBHa$l JIOByIIIKa nOpO)f(lleHHaR
repMaHCKHM JI066H BCerlla HMeBIlIHM BJIH$lHHe B neTepoypre
CqHTaJIOCb qTO BbIllYMaHHaR HM a3HaTCKaR MHCCH$I POCCHH shy
orpOMHa$l llHBepCH$I KOTOpa$l llOJI)f(Ha 06JIerqHTb COOCTBeHshy
HblA repMaHCKHA llpaHr Hax OCTeH B UeHTpaJIbHOA EBpone
a 3aTeM H no BceA JIHHHH BepJIHH-Barllall27
-)f(EJITOPOCCH)1shy
CTpaHHOe H llBYCMbICJIeHHOe llBH)f(eHHe )I(eJITOpOCCH$I -
HaHOOJIee JIIOOOnbITHOe H KpaAHee KPbIJIO BOCTOqHHKOB nOJIshy
136 137
Hee BCerO ero H~eH OTpa~eH~ B pa60TaX H npe~npHHHMashy
TeRbCKOA ~e~TeRbHOCTH KH~3~ 3cnepa YXToMcKoro (1861shy
1921 rr) 3TOT BRa~eRel HeCKORbKHX ra3eT 6RH3KHA copaTHHK
BH~Horo rocy~apCTBeHHOrO ~emeR~ POCCHH C 10 BHTTe B noshy
nYR~pH3alHH H~eH TpaHccH6HPCKOA ~eRe3HoA ~oporH HaCTaBHHK 6y~y~ero HMnepaTopa HaCRe~Horo npHHla HHKOshy
Ra~ pa3BHBaR nopa~alO~He MeraROMaHHeA H~eH OCHOBaHHbIe
Ha cOMHHTeRbHoA TeopHH 0 ~K06bI OpraHHtIeCKOA 6RH30CTH
POCCHH K KHTalO H ~a~e K I1H~HH28 YXTOMCKHA neR ~H(I)HPaMshy6bI KHTaAcKoA lHBHRH3alHH HO CKpbITbIM HX ReATMoTHBOM
HeCOMHeHHO 6bIRa H~e~ ~eRToA onacHocTH To tITO HCTOshy
pHK 3MaR03eMOB Ha3bIBaR H~eOROrHtIeCKOA CYTblO HBOCTOtIshy
HHKOB OTpa~eHO B Kpe~O YXTOMCKOrO A3H~ - Mbl BCer~a
npHHa~Re~aRH K HeA MbI ~HRH ee ~H3HblO H O~~aRH ee HHshy
TepeCbI LJepe3 Hac BOCTOK npHweR K OC03HaHHIO ceo~ K BbICshy
meA ~H3HH HaM He HY~HO 3aBoeBaHHA Bce 3TH HapO~bI pa3shy
RHtIHbIX pac tIYBCTBYIOT npHT~~eHHe K HaM - KPOBblO Tpa~Hshy
lHeA H~e~MH MbI npOCTO 60Ree 6RH3KH HM HHTHMHO 3TOT Beshy
RH KHA H 3ar~OtIHbIA BOCTOK rOTOB CTaTb HawHM~9 TaKHM 06pa30M MO~HO 6bIRO 6bI CKa3aTb tITO onTHshy
MHCTHtIeCKa~ BepCH~ PycCKoA lHBHRH3aTopCKoA MHCCHH Ha
BOCTOKe (BO BC~KOM CRYtIae B ~eKRapalH~X) OCHOBaHHa~
Ha pacoBoA H KYRbTYPHOA aCCHMHRH~lHH HRH no MeHbmeA
Mepe Ha COTpY~HHtIeCTBe H TepnHMOCTH KOTOPYIO npOB03shy
r RaCHR BeHIOKOB B 70-e ro~~ XIX BeKa B OTHoweHHH Cpe~HeA
A3HH MorRa HaATH npHRo~eHHe H no OTHoweHHIO K BOCTOtIHOA
A3HH CaM BHTTe 6bIR CTOPOHHHKOM H~eH tITO POCCHACK~
HMnepH~ pacnORo~eHHa~ Me~~y 6Y~~HCTCKHM HH~HAcKHM H MYCYRbMaHCKHM MHpaMH ~BR~eTC~ MHpOM B ce6e CorRaCHO
3anHCKe no~aHHoA BHTTe laplO B 1893 r TO tITO OTRHtIaeT
POCCHIO OT 3ana~a - 3TO ee OC06bIA HalHOHaRbHbIA ~yx 3TOT
~yx Hap~~y C ~pyrHMH 3ReMeHTaMH CKpenR~IO~HMH POCshy
CHIO (reOrpajJHtIeCKOe nORo~eHHe npaBOCRaBHoe xpHCTHaHshy
CTBO H caMo~ep~aBHe) 06pa3yeT KpenKoe ~~po npOtIHO
06be~HHeHHoe HO cB060~Hoe OT HalHOHaRHCTHtIeCKOA HCshy
KRlOtIHTeRbHOCTH 06Ra~aeT orpOMHbIMH B03MO~HOCT~MH
~R~ ~py~eCTBeHHOrO 6paTCTBa H COTpY~HHtIeCTBa C caMbIMH
PaJRHtIHbIMH pacaMH H Hapo~aMHO B TOM ~e ro~y BHTTe no~aR laplO e~e O~HY ~OKRa~shy
HYIO 3anHCKY B KOTOpoA no~~ep~HBaR BeCbMa B3pbIBoonacshy
HYIO H COMHHTeRbHYIO H~elO BbI~BHHYTYIO neTpOM Ba~MaeBbIM
6YP~TCKHM leRHTeReM npHH~BwHM npaBOCRaBHe (ero
KpeCTHbIM OTlOM 6bIR HMnepaTOp AReKcaH~p III) CTpaHHbIA
nRaH OCHOBbIBaRC~ Ha CHCTeMaTHtIeCKOM npOHHKHOBeHHH
6YP~TOB 06yqeHHbIx PYCCKHMH B KatIeCTBe ToprOBbIX areHTOB
B 3a~HHA ~BOp KHTa~ - Ha 3an~HYIO nOrpaHHtIHYIO nOROCy
3eMeRb npOT~HYBWHXC~ OT CHHb13~Ha ~O MOHrORHH H MaHbtIshy
~YPHH BKRlOtI~ TH6eT B 1895-1897 rr nRaH 6bIR onp060BaH
HO nOTepneR nORHYIO Hey~atIY JlHHHeA npo~BH~eHH~ POCCHH
~OR~Ha 6bIRa CTaTb HOBa~ ~eRe3Ha~ ~opora Ha JlaHbtI~oy B
npOBHHlHH KaHcyA rRaBHbIM HanpaBReHHeM nO~PbIBHOA ~e~shy
TeRbHOCTH 6bIRa no~~ep~Ka aHTHKHTaAcKoro BOCCTaHH~
MOHrOROB m6eTleB H KHTaACKHX MYCYRbMaH ECRH 6bl nRaH
Ba~MaeBa OKa3aRC~ CTORb ~e ycnewHbIM KaK r RaBH~A nRaH
BHTTe - cTpoHTeRbcTBO TpaHccH6HPCKOA ~eRe3HOA ~oporH TO BHTTe 6bIR 6bI npaB B CBoeM 3aKRlOtIeHHH tITO ftc 6eperOB
THxoro OKeaHa H BepWHH rHMaRaeB POCCH~ 6y~eT BepWHTb
He TORbKO a3HaTCKHe HO H eBponeAcKHe ~eRaft 31 XOT~ BHTTe
CTapaRC~ tIT06bI MHp nOBepHR ero ~eKRapalH~M 0 cnoc06shy
HOCTH POCCHH ocy~ecTBHTb CBOIO MHCCHIO B A3HH MHPshy
H~MH H KYRbTypHbIMH MepaMH KOHetIHOA leRblO PYCshy
CKoA 3KcnaHCHH B A3HH nocpe~CTBOM ~eRe3Ho~opO~Horo
CTpOHTeRbCTBa H ToprOBbIX MeponpH~THA (KOTOpble B 3Hashy
tIHTeRbHoA Mepe a nO~tIac H nORHOCTblO cy6CH~HpOBaRHCb
rocy~apcTBOM) 6bIRO KOROHHaRbHoe rocnO~CTBo32 KaKoe-TO BpeM~ PYCCKHA HMnepHaRH3M B A3HH pa3BHBaRshy
C~ Ha BORHe onTHMH3Ma conpOBo~~aBwero CTpOHTeRbCTBO
TpaHCCH6HPCKOA MarHCTpaRH rRaBH~M nponaraH~HCTOM
3TOA ~oporH H CHCTeMaTHtIeCKOrO npOHHKHOBeHH~ POCCHH B
KHTaA tIepe3 MaHbtI~ypHIO 6bIR YXTOMCKHA Ero nOMO~HHK no CB~3~M C 3ana~HoA EBponoA repMaH BpYHxojJep (1841shy
1916 rr) tIYTb RH He B RHpHtIeCKHX TOHax onHCblBaR CBeTRoe
6y~y~ee EBpa3HH Bce pacbl CB~3aHHble OT BaRTHKH H LJepHoshy
ro MOp~ ~o THxoro OKeaHa 3TOA nOTp~calO~eA ~oporoA KOshy
Topa~ npHHeceT BbIrO~bl B3aHMHoMY ToproBoMy H KyRbTypshy
HOMY 06MeHY 6Y~YT ~HTb B nORHOM corRaCHH no~ CKHneTshy
POM lap~ B OTRHtIHe OT 6pHTaHleB B I1H~HH ~OKa3bIBaR
BpYHxoBep Y PyccKoro KpeCTb~HHHa H COR~aTa HeT tIyBcTBa
138 139
paCOBoro npeBOCXOllCTBa no OTHomeHHIO K a3HaTaM
KaH H TypaHCKaH KPOBb BCKope CMemaIOTCH B03HHKHyr HOBbie
nOrpaHHtlHbIe HapOllbI nOJIya3HaTcKoro nOJIyeBponeAcKoro
npOHCXOgtKlleHHH C03lla101IHe CBH3yJOlIee 3BeHO nOCpellCTBO
KOToporo CJIaBHHe ClleJIaIOT BblcmHe $OpMbl gtKH3HH C03llaHshy
Hble XpHCTHaHCKO-eBponeAcKoA KYJIbTYpoA llOCTynHblMH Bee elIe 3aKpblTOMY CepllLlY BHYTPeHHeA A3HH3
MOTHB 3TOT BeCbMa 3HaKOM HlleH MorJIa npHllTH tlyramp JIH
He OT BeHIOKOBa H llagtKe OT paHHero n03Ta-naHCJIaBHCTa TIOTshy
tleBa KOTOPblA B OllHOM H3 CBOHX CTpaHHblX CTHXOTBOpeHHR
PYCCKaH reorpa$HH (1848 r) MetlTaJI 0 5YllYlIeA poccHAcKOR
eBpoa3HaTcKoA HMnepHH OT HHJIa ll0 HeBbI OT 3JIb5bI ll0 KHshy
TaHIOT BOJIrH no EB$paT OT raHra ll0 llYHaH~ OllHaKO Pa3shy
pa50TaHHaH B rOllbI HnOHO-KHTaAcK09 BoAHbl (1894-1895 IT)
5pYHxo$epoBCKaH aHTHHMnepHaJIHCTHtleCKaH KOHLlenLlHft
)KeJITOpOCCHH HMeJIa HCHyJO nOJIHTHtlecKyJO LleJIb BpYHxo$ep
He TOJIbKO pHCOBaJI BeJIHtleCTBeHHYIO KapTHHY B03MOgtKHOro
CHM5H03a POCCHH H KHTaH HO H npellynpegtKllaJI 3anallHOe 0laquo5shy
lIeCTBO 05 3KcnaHCHOHHCTCKHX HaMepeHHHX SlnoHHH SInOHHft
noll $JIarOM 5YllllHCTCKOA COJIHllapHOCTH C03llaeT naHa3HaTCshy
KYIO 30HY BJIHHHHH CHatlaJIa OrpaHHtleHHYIO SInoHHeA Kopeshy
eA H KHTaeM Ho 3aTeM nOCJIe oKKynaLlHH TaAaaHH na 30Ha
nOCTeneHHO MOgtKeT pacmHpHTbCH Ha BCIO IOrO-BOCTOtlHYIO
A3HIO B ollHoA H3 CBOHX cTaTeA BpYHxo$ep C HeMaJI09 lloJIeR
np03peHHH nHCaJI 0 5YllYlIeA BeJIHKOA BOCTOtlHOa3HaTCKoR
c$epe COBMeCTHOrO npOLlBeTaHHH KOTOpaH B03HHKHeT 50 JIeT
cnycTH3S TeM He MeHee npellOCTepegtKeHHH BpYHxo$epa JIe)f(ashy
JIH BHYTPH cneKTpa HlleA gtKeJIToA onacHocTH KOTopbIe MO)f(shy
HO HaATH ygtKe Y B COJIOBbeBa H llagtKe elIe paHbme - Y K JIeoHshy
TbeBa HeCMOTpH Ha onTHMHCTHtleCKHe KapTHHbl 5YllYlIeR
ft)KeJITOpOcCHH BpYHxo$ep nO-BHllHMOMY 5bIJI 05ecnoKoeH
B03MOgtKHOCTblO Toro tlTO HHllYCTPHaJIH30BaHHble MaCCbl KHshy
TaALleB HatlHYT HeoTBpaTHMo npOllBHraTbCH Ha 3anall noll BOllHshy
TeJIbCTBOM HnOHLleB EllHHCTBeHHoA CHJIoA KOTOPaH CMO)f(eT
npoTHBOCTOHTb noA MOIIHOA 5YllllHCTCKOA BOJIHe llOKa3bIshy
BaJI BpYHxo$ep HBJIHeTCH PYCCKaH eBpOa3HaTCKaH HMnepHH
HeCKOJIbKO rpoTecKHoe B03pO)f(lleHHe 5YllllHCTCKOA TeMbI
npOH30mJIO B nepHOll rpaiKllaHCKOA B09Hbi B POCCHH CYshy
MaCmellmHA 5apoH $OH YHrepH-WTepH5epr eiblBmHA Llap-
CJltHR reHepaJI OTBeTHJI Ha PYCCKYIO peBOJIIOLlHIO nepeXOllOM B
ISYIlllH3M B 3HaK npoTecTa npoTHB Toro tlTO OH CtlHTaJI eiaHKshy
pOTCTBOM 3anaztHoA LlHBHJIH3aLlHH B 1921 r ero oeibellHHeHHbIA
llta3aLlKO-MOHrOJIbCKO-KHTaACKHR OTpHll 3aXBaTHJI YpiY CTOshy
nHUY BHemHeA MOHrOJIHH (HbIHe YJIaH-eiaTOP) rlle eiapoH eibIJ1
npOB03rJIameH HOBbIM lIHHrHCXaHoM OllHaKO HeCKOJIbKO MecHshy
ueB cnycTH YHrepH-WTeHeiepr 3TOT CHMBOJI a3HaTtlHHbI H
)KeJITOpOCCHH B OllHOM JIHLle nOTepneJI nOpa)f(eHHe OT 5oJIbshy
meBHKOB H eiblJI HMH paCCTpeJIHH36 Ba)f(HO OTMeTHTb tlTO 3Ta HlleOJIOrHH npOB03rJIamaBmaH
ISYllYlIee CJIHHHHe pac BO HMH eiOJIee OllHOPOllHOA EBpa3HH
(rlle gtKeJIaeMOe HepellKO BbIllaBaJIOCb 3a lleACTBHTeJIbHOCTb)
pa3YMeeTCH noll eiJIarOCKJIOHHbIM BOllHTeJIbCTBOM POCCHH
HHKOrlla He BJIHHJIa Ha npOLlecc npHHHTHH pemeHHA B neTepeiypshy
re KaKHM eibl Y3KHM HH eiblno onpelleJIeHHe noro npOLlecca
llnH Toro BpeMeHH B KOHetlHOM CtleTe (HCKJIlOtlaH anH30ll C Baztshy
MaeBbIM) B030einallaJIa peaJIbHaH nOJIHTHKa Ho B rOllbl rpa)f(shy
llaHCKoA B09Hbi H HeKOTopoe BpeMH nOCJIe ee OKOHtlaHHH eiOJIbshy
meBHCTCKaH POCCHH paCCMaTpHBaJIa CBOIO nOJIHTHKY B A3HH
CKopee KaK $YHKUHIO HlleOJIOrHH HlleH CMemeHHH CJIaBHHOshy
apHALleB H TypaHLleB nOJIb30BaJIaCb onpelleJIeHHOR nOllllep)f(shy
KoA JIHeiepaJIbHblX KpyrOB PYCCKoA HHTenJIHreHLlHH JIHmb ll0
Tex nop nOKa ypOBeHb p0gtKllaeMOCTH B POCCHH OCTaBaJICH Ollshy
HHM H3 caMbIX BbICOKHX B MHpe KaK 3TO eiblJIO npH LlapH3Me coshy
rJIaCHO llaHHbiM nepenHcH 1897 r 3TO cnocoeicTBOBaJIO H O$Hshy
LlHaJIbHOMY nOOlIpeHHIO KOJIOHH3aLlHH PycCKoA A3HH KpeCTbHshy
HaMH eBponeRcKoro npOHCXOgtKlleHHH B OCHOBHOM CJIaBHHaMH
HCnOJIb30BaHHe BblrOll OT OTKPbITHH CpellHeA A3HH H llaJIbshy
Hero BOCTOKa llnH PycCKoA KonOHH3aLlHH mno eibI 3HatlHTeJIbshy
HO MellJIeHHee H He eibIJIO eibI CTonb nOJIHblM 5e3 Toro BKJIalla
KOTOPblA BHecnH B 3TOT npOLlecc YtleHbIe CneLlHaJIHCTbl H
nYTemeCTBeHHHKH OHH OCTaBHnH COBeTCKOMY rOCYllapCTBY
npOtlHYIO TpallHLlHIO HaYtlHbIX HCCnellOBaHHA BbICOKoro
ypOBHH B ocoeieHHocTH B reorpa$HH H BOCTOKOBelleHHH
lla)f(e BbIllaIOIIHACH PYCCKHA BOCTOKOBell BaCHJIHA Bapshy
TOJIbll (1869-1930 rr) KOTOPbIA cYMeJI OCTaTbCH B cTopoHe
OT O$HLlHaJIbHOA nponaraHllbl H npH LlapH3Me H npH eiOJIbmeshy
BHKax B OCHOBHOM CorJIamancH C TeM tlTO OH CtlHTaJI HCTOPHshy
tlecKoA HeoeixOllHMOCTblO - C c03llaHHeM MHPOBbIX HMnepHA
141140
TaKHX KaK HMnepHH AJleKCaHIpa BeJlHKOrO MOHrOJlOS apaOOB
H la~e COSpeMeHHOR eMY POCCHRcKOR HMnepHH S CpelHeR
A3HH OH HCKpeHHe SepHJI 1JTO KpynHble CTpYKTYPbl C031alOT Jlyqshy
mHe YCJlOSHH lJIH KYJlbTypHOrO c6J1H~eHHH HapOlOS pa3J1H1Jshy
HbIX pac HeCMOTpH Ha sce 6elcTsHH KOTopble HecyT SORHbI
conpoSo~IalOlI(He C031aHHe TaKHX HMnepHR~7
HCXO~ HA BOCTOK TPYBEQKOA H CABHQKHA
HeCMOTpH Ha HeYIa1JH CSH3aHHble C PYCCKO-HnOHCKOR H
nepsoR MHposoR soRHaMH PYCCKHe npeTeH3HH Ha oc06ble
OTHOmeHHH C A3HeR npolOJl~aJlH ~HTb cpelH HHTeJlJlHreHshy
QHH a S rOlbI peSOJlIOQHH rp~IaHcKoR SORHbl H cpa3Y ~e nocshy
Jle HHX TaKHe npereH3HH la~e YCHJlHJlHCb Hp1Je scero 3TO 80shy
nJlOTHJlOCb B eSpa3HRCKOM lSH~eHHH KOTopoe cnJlOTHJlO cashy
Mble 6J1ecTHII(He yMbi PYCCKoR 3MHrpaQHH 1920-x rolos Heshy
CMOTPH Ha HepelKHe pa3HorJlaCHH OHH 6blJlH y6e~IeHbl 1JTO
JlHlUb SOCnpHHHS oc060e eBpa3HRcKoe MHpOS033peHHe MO~HO
coxpaHHTb oc060CTb PYCCKoro SKJlala S QHSHJlH3aQHIO OCHOshy
saHHoro KaK Ha rpeKO-SH3aHTHRCKOM TaK H Ha MOHrOJlbCKOM
HaCJlelHH B csoeM nepSOM MaHHlIJecTe l1cxol Ha SOCTOK
(1921 r) lBa SbIIaIOII(HXCH JlHHrBHCTa KHH3b HHKoJlaR Tpy6eQshy
KoR H POMaH HK06coH OTCTaHBaJIH espa3HRcKoe CJlHHHHe H3blshy
KOS H KYJlbTYP (TaK Ha3b1BaeMaH TeOpllH H3bIKOBoro COI03a -
Sprachbund) C03HaTeJlbHO npeYBeJlH1JHBaH SJlHHHHe TypaHcKoshy
ro 3J1eMeHTa38
EBpa3HRQbl C1JHTaJlH 60JlblUeBHKoB H MapKcH3M XYIIUHM
CJlelCTBHeM 3analHoR KYJlbTYPbl OlHaKO caMoe peBOJlIOQHIO
OHH paccMaTpHBaJlH KaK BeJlHKHR H He06XOlHMblR KaTaJlH3ashy
TOp OHa pa3pYIUHJla CTapblR MHp H np06YIHJla OlHospeMeHHO
H PYCCKHe MaCCbl H HapOlbl BOCTOKa n03TOMY pa60Ta Tpy6eQshy
Koro EBpona H 1JeJlOBe1JeCTBo lt1920 r) 1JHTaeTCH KaK HeKoe
C01JeTaHHe lIaHHJleSCKOro H npH3biSOS sToporo KOHrpecca Koshy
MHHTepHa JTO pemHTeJlbHOe 06BHHeHHe 3analHoMY HMneshy
PHaJIH3MY KOTopoe oTBepraeT eBpOQeHTpHCTCKHR nolXOl K
A3HH YHH~eHHe HcnblTaHHoe PoccHeR S XOle BoRHbl H peBoshy
JlIOQHH nHmeT Tpy6eQKoR Mo~eT C031aTb HenOBTopHMYIO
B03MO~HOCTb palHKaJlbHOrO nepecMoTpa OTHOmeHHH K Hepycshy
CKHM HapOlaM POCCHH 6YIYIJH CaMa KOJlOHHeR Mo~eT noshy
142
BeCTH lpyrHe KOJlOHHH B oc06eHHocTH CSOHX laquoa3HaTCKHX cecshy
Tepraquo Ha pelUHTeJlbHYIO 60Pb15y npoTHB pOMaHo-repMaHcKHx
KOJlOHH3aTopOB 39
OlHHM H3 caMbiX opHrHHaJlbHblX MblCJlHTeJleR CpelH
eBpa3HRQes I5blJl reorpallJ neTp CasHQKHR (1895-1968 rr) Coshy
rJlaCHO ero KOHQenQHH Espa3HH - nOlJlHHHaH KYJlbTypHOshy
reorpaIlJH1JeCKaH Ol5lI(HOCTb C lOOaS01JHblM nOTeHQHaJIOM Tepshy
pHTOpHaJlbHOR 3KcnaHCHH (MecTopa3sHTHe HJlH TonoreHeshy
3HC) rOSOpH 0 Ha1JaslUeRcH S XIX BeKe 3KCnaHCHH POCCHH Ha
lOr H SOCTOK CasHQKHR nblTaeTCH npenOlHecTH ee KaK 060shy
pOHHTeJlbHYIO Mepy S PaMKax nOHHTHH npOlsHHYTOR rpaHHshy
QbI HeCOMHeHHO aHaJlOrH1JHOrO TOMy nOHHTHIO KOTopoe
0150CHoBblBaJIO I5pHTaHcKYIO nOJIHTHKY B I1HIHH 50Jlee Toro
CaBHQKHR loKa3blsaeT 1JTO PYCCKYIO 3KcnaHCHIO B QeJIOM MO~HO
paccMaTpHsaTb KaK HenpepblSHblR npoQecc opraHH1JeCKOrO
pa3SHTHH B ero onHcaHHH 3TO BHIHTCH 1JYTb JlH He KaK 3KOshy
JlOrH1JeCKHR npoQecc l5e3 KaKOR-JlHI50 nOJIHTH1JeCKOR MOTHshy
SHPOBKH CKpblBalOlI(eRcH 3a HHM H HMnepHaJIHCTH1JeCKOrO COshy
nepHH1JeCTBa BeJlHKHX lep~as CSH3aHHOro CO cpelHea3HaTCshy
KHM H laJIbHeBOCT01JHblM sonpocaMH CJlelOSaTeJlbHO lOKa3b1shy
BaeT CaBHQKHR PYCCKaR EBpa3HR eCTb reonOJlHTH1JeCKOe elHHshy
CTSO B ce6e C031aHHOe KYJlbTYPHblM npOQeCCOM reHeTH1JeCshy
KoR MyTaQHH a He nOcpelCTSOM 3asoeBaHHA H pa3pyweHHA~ KaK BHIHM TaKOe TOJlKOBaHHe He CJIHWKOM OTJlH1JaeTCR OT KOHshy
QenQHH IHHaMH1JeCKOrO ~H3HeHHoro npOCTpaHCTBa CPPHIPHshy
xa PaTQeJlR KOTOPYlO KapJl XaycxollJep npHHRJI B 20-e rOlbl
EBPA3HAcKOE CBRH)f(EHHE H CRHHHHE
BeCbMa JlI060nbiTHO HBHOe CXOlCTBO Me~IY CJlOBapeM eBshy
pa3HAQeB H COBeTCKoA TepMHHOJlOrHeA xpYlI(eBCKoA 3nOXH
OTHOCHTeJIbHO KYJIbTypHO-HaQHOHaJIbHOrO CJIHRHHR nol JlIOshy
60BHbiM Hal30pOM CTapmero PYCCKoro 6paTa B pa60Tax nCashy
SHQKoro H B oc06eHHocTH B TpYIaX HCTopHKa r BepHaICKOshy
ro HepelKO BCTpe1JaIOTCR TepMHHbl CJ1HJ1HHe H nepeMeJIJHBashy
HHe 1JTO RKOl5bl HMeeT MeCTO B npoQecce TeppHTOpHaJlbHOR
3KcnaHCHH KYJlbMHHaQHR KOTOpoA - 1IJ0pMHpoBaHHe BeJlHshy
KOPYCCKOA KYJlbTYPbl TaK 3aMe1JaHHe BepHalCKoro 1JTO nol
BHeWHHM pa3Ho06pa3HeM CKpblBaeTCH BHYTpeHHee elHHCTBO
143
HanOMHHaeT pacxo)l(ee COBeTCKOe nOHHTHe 0 eQHHCTBe 8
MHorootlpa3HH
B MaHepe He CJIHmKOM OTJIHLlalOIleRcH OT COBeTCKHX CTaH~
QapTOB BepHaQCKHR QOKa3bIBaJI LITO BKJIIOLleHHe HepYCCKHX
rpynn B MHorOHauHOHaJIbYIO eBpa3HRcKYIO HMnepHIO C03Qa~
eT orpOMHbIe 3KOHOMHLleCKHe H KYJIbTypHbIe npeHMYIlIeCTBa O~~
HaKO BepHaQCKHR HaCTaHBaJI npH 3TOM LITO eQHHCTBO QOJI)I(HO
tlbITb 3KYMeHHLleCKHM tle3 HaBH3bIBaHHH HtlO PoccHRcKoe
rocy~apcTBO - eBpa3HRcKoe rOCYQapCTBO H Bce OTQeJIbHbIe
HaUHOHaJIbHOCTH Espa3HH QOJI)I(Hbl LlYBCTBOBaTb LITO 3TO HX
rocy~apcTBO H npH3HaBaTb ero (KypCHB BepHaQCKOrO) CHJIa
3Toro eBpa3HRcKoro otlpa30BaHHH JIe)l(HT B ero CBOtlOQHOM
KYJIbTYPHOM TBopLleCTBe41 KpOMe Toro Qa)l(e eCJIH PycCKHR
HapoQ otlpa3yeT rJIaBHYIO CHJIY eBpa3HRCKoro rocy~apcTBa a
PYCCKHR H3b1K - tla30BbiR CJIoR eBpa3HRcKoR KYJIbTYPbI Bce
3TO HeJIb3H HaBH3b1BaTb QpyrHM Hapo~aM HeCMOTpH Ha BeJIH~
LlHe 3THX HQeR BbICKa3bIBaBmHXCH eBpa3HRuaMH-3MHrpaHTaMH
He HecmHMH HHKaKoR nOJIHTHLIeCKoR OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH H
HMeSmHMH BeCbMa MaJIOe BJIHHHHe B HOBOA COBeTCKoR eBposhy
a3HaTCKoR HMnepHH QPyme CJIaBHHCKHe HapO~bI B ocotleHshy
HOCTH HaHtlOJIee MHOrOLlHCJIeHHble cnoCJIe PYCCKHX) HanpHshy
Mep YKPaHHUbl H nOJIHKH HcnblTbIBaJIH rJIytloKoe HeQOBepHe
K ueJIHM eBpa3HRueB H BbICTYaJIH npOTHB HHX2 K CO)l(aJIeHHIO
HHLlero He H3seCTHO 0 peaKUHH Ha TeopHH eBpa3HAueB a3HaTshy
CKHX HHTeJIJIeKTyaJIOB )l(HBmHX noQ COBeTCKHM pe)l(HMOM
MO)l(HO OQHaKO tle30mHtloLiHo nOJIaraTb LITO OHH BHQeJIH B
3THX TeOpHHX JIHmb YTOHLleHHoe onpaSQaHHe PYCCKoro HMneshy
pHaJIH3Ma
TaKHM otlpa30M eBpa3HRcKoe ~BH)I(eHHe caMO Toro He
C03HaBaH cnoc06CTBOBaJIO $OpMHPOBaHHIO YTonHLleCKoro 06shy
pa3a coseTCKoro LleJIOBeKa - HCKyccTBeHHoro nOpO)l(~eHHH
COBeTCKoR nponaraHQbl He HMelOIlero KaKOrO-JIH60 paCOBoro
HJIH 3THHLleCKOro npOHCXO)l(QeHHH HO rOBOpHIlero no-pYCCKH
H OIlYIlalOIlero ce6H KOHeLiHO )l(e PYCCKHM COBeTCKaH MOshy
QeJIb - TpOHua COCTOHIlaH H3 Tpex CTaQHA - paCUBeT-c6JIHshy
)l(eHHe-CJIHHHHe BeCbMa pa3BHTaH B 3noxy XPYIleBa pa3Hshy
TeJIbHO HanOMHHaeT eBpa3HRcKoe BHQeHHe 1920-x rO~OB OHa
OTpa)l(aeT TaK)I(e HCTopHLIeCKHA onbIT HaKOnJIeHHblA PycCKOR
HHTeJIJIHreHUHeR no HaUHOHaJIbHblM H paCOBblM BonpocaM
KOTopbIe PYCCKHe MbICJIHTeJIH BnepBble nO~HHJIH B XIX B
144
KaK nOKa3blBaeT 3JIeH Kappep Ii AHKOC BCsl COBeTCKasl
(OHuenUHH B otlJIaCTH onpeQeJIeHHH H 3aKOHHoro O$opMJIeHHsl
OTHomeHHA Me)l(~y PYCCKHMH H HepyccKHMH npeTepneJIa
MHO)l(eCTBO H3MeHeHHA43 B npoTHBOnOJIO)l(HOCTb neHHHcKoR
yTOnHH OTMHpaHHsl HauHA H rocYQapcTB H 3aMeHbl HX HOBblM
YHHBepCaJIbHbIM OOIlecTBOM npOJIeTapCKoA KJIaCCOBOR COJIHshy
~apHOCTH 60JIee )l(ecToKHA H OCMOTpHTeJIbHbIA CTaJIHH
nocTeneHHo npe06pa30BaJI HQelO $eQepaUHH B H~elO ueHT~
paJIH30BaHHHoro PyccKoro HaQ30pa HaQ $opMaJIbHO aBTOshy
HOMHbIMH HapoQaMH COBeTcKoro COI03a 3Ta peaJIbHOCTb npeshy
BpaTHJIa Bee COBeTCKHe TeopHH no HaUHOHaJIbHOMY Bonpocy B
nycTOnOpO)l(HHe ynpa)l(HeHHH H3 KOTOPblX H~eH CTaJIHHa TaK
H He 6blJIH YCTpaHeHbl BbI)I(HBaHHe MHorOHaUHOHaJIbHOR
eBpa3HAcKoA TeppHTOpHaJIbHOA KpenOCTH nO-npe)l(HeMY
ynpaBJIHeMOA MYQPbIM CTapmHM PYCCKHM 6paTOM 6YQeT
3aBHCeTb npe)l(Qe Bcero OT pemeHHH nOQHHTbIX eBpa3HAuaMH
BonpOCOB
145
flpHMeqaHHR
1 Andrew Malozemoff Russian Far Eastern Policy 1881-1904 (Berkeley University of California Press 1958) 42 2 FF von Martens Russland und England in Zentralasien (St Petersburg 1880) Heinz Gollwitzer Geschichte des wetpolischen denkens (Gottingen Vandenhoeck amp Ruprecht 1982) 152-70 133-36 3 F F von Martens Le Conflict entre la Russie et la Chine (Bruxel~
les 1880) 4 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) 93-103 WP Wassiliew Die Erschliessung Chinas (Leipzig 1909) 5 WP Wassiliew Die Erschliessung Chinas (Leipzig 1909)49 6 NM Prejevalsky From Kulja accross the Tian Shan to Lob-Nor (London Sampson Low 1879) 7 MA Bakunin La theologie politique de Mazzini et lInternatishyonale (Neufchatel 1871) 102 110 8 AN Kuropatkin Memoiren (Berlin 1919)7174 9 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) 1423-24 111 10 1S Bloch Les Illusions de la Conquette Chinoise Revue des Revues (August 15 1900) 11 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) 14 12 Herold J Weins Chinas March toward the Tropics (Hamden Conn Shoe String Press 1954) 13 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) p 24 14 CH IQlKaKOB AHrJIO-PycCIltaH pacnpH cmgt 1885 15 HltIgtltIgteAopoB ltlgtHJIocoIllHH oOIIlero AeJIa - UHT no HltIgtltIgteAopoB COqHHeHHH M MbICJIb 1982 0 BJIHHHHH ltlgteAoshypOBa Ha llocToeBcKoro TOJICTOrO COJIOBbeBa BepAHeBa BYJIraKOBa HAP CM Stephen Lukashevich NF Fedorov - A Study in Russian Eupsychian and Utopian Thought (Newark University of Delaware Press 1977) pp 13-34 16 HltIgtltIgteAopoB CotJHHeHHH 1982 CTp 343 Sarkisyanz Op cit 210-211 HACeTHHUKHA PyccKHe MbICJIHTeJIH 0 KHTae XapoHH 1926 17 BJIaAHMHp JIbBOB 3araAotJHblA CTapHIlt JI COBeTcKHA nHshyCaTeJIb 1977 CTp 129-135 HltIgtltIgteAopoB CotJHHeHHH (962) CTp 335-336 18 HltIgtltIgteAopoB CotJHHeHHH CTp 216 340 382 669
146
19 TaM lKe CTp 300 20 BCCOJIOBbeB TPH pa3roBopa cms TPYA 1904 21 Malozemoff Russian Far Eastern Policy (1958) p 43 22 JIeHHH 0 BoAHe B KHTae - HCKpa 1 AeKaopH 1900 23 ABeJIbIA neTepoypr UHT no H3A London Penguin 1983 CTP 65 24 Sarkisyanz Russland und der Messianismus(1955) 200 21~218
25 AJIeKCaHAP BJIOK CTHxoTBopeHHH H n03Mbl TeaTp M XYAOlKeCTBeHHaH JIHTepaTypa 1968 CTp 644-645 26 C EceHHH CoopaHHe cotJHHeHHA Mbull 1970 T5 cTP 107 27 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) 42 98-99 28 Sarkisyanz Russland und der Messianismus(1955) 218~22
29 Malozernoff Russian Far Eastern Policy (1958)43-44 30 BH Sumner Russia and Europe Oxford Slavonic Papers (1951) II 1-16B Readings in Russian Civilization nOA peA Thomas Riha (Chicago University of Chicago Press 1964) 1147331 Malozemoff Russian Far Eastern Policy (1958) 43 Sarkisyanz Russland und der Messianismus (1955)378-91 32 Gollwitzer Geschichte (1982) I 138-40 33 Hermann Brunnhofer Russlands Hand Uber Asien Historischshygeographische Essays zur Entwick lungsgechichte des Russichen Reichsdenkens (S1 Petersburg 1897) npeAHCJIOBHe llBeAuapeu BpYHxolllep onpaBAblBaJI pyCCKylO 3IltCnaHCHIO B CpeAHeA A3HH H Ha llaJIbHeM BOCTOKe B cepHH cTaTeA BnepB~e onYOJIHKOBaHHbIx B neTepoyprcKHx ra3eTax Ha HeMeUKOM H3blKe St Petersburger Zeitung H St Petersburger Herold OH n~shyTaJICH OOOCHOBaTb PYCCKHA 3KcnaHCHOHH3M B A3HH CO~shyCTBeHHblMH H3bICKaHHHMH B apHAcKoA MHlIloJIorHH CpeAH ApyrHx paooT OH onYOJIHKOBaJI TpexToMHHK Urgechichte der Arier in Vorder-und Centralasien Historich-geographische Untersuchungen uber den altesten Schauplatz des Rigvedas und Avestas (Leipzig 1983) BpYHxolllep nepeBen TaKlKe o~beshyMHCTbIA OTtJeT KHH3H YXTOMCKoro 0 noe3AKe ueCapeBHqa HHKOJIaH Ha llaJIbHHA BOCTOK Orientreise seiner Kaiserlicher Hohe heit des Grossfursten Thronfolgers (Leipzig Brockhaus 1894 1998) 34 ltIgtHTIOTtJeB JIHpHKa HaYKa 1965 TI1 M CTp 118 35 Ein ostasiatischer Dreibund und die buddhistische Weltproshypaganda B KH BpYHxolllepa Russland Hand uber Aden (1897) 24-29 BnepB~e onYOJIHKOBaHa BSt Petersburger Zeitung B 1894 r
147
36 Louis Fischer The Soviets in the World Affairs (Princeton Princeton University Press 1951) n 534-37 Sir Fitzroy Maclean To the Back ofBeyond (London Cape 1974) 119-121 37 AKatteMHK BapTOJlbtt COllHHeHHR M H3tt-BO BOCTOllHoA JlHTepaTYpbI 1963 T2 cTp 164-166345-350 38 Hcxott K BOCTOKY npettllYBCTBHR H cBepmeHHR YTBepshy)l(tteHHe eBpa3HAueB CO(j)HR 1921 COttep)l(HT CTaTbH rBltJ)JloshypOBcKoro POMaHa HKoCicoHa nllCasllHHcKoro nH CaBHUshyKoro H HCTpyCieUKoro HH)I(e nepellHCJIRIOTCR OCHOBHhIe paCioTbI 0 espa3HAuax DS Mirsky The Eurasian Movement The Slavonic and East European Review (1927) 311-320 Otto Boss Die Lehre der Eurasier (Wiesbaden Harrasowitz 1961) H A Stammler Europe-Russland-Asian Der eurasiche Deutungsshyversuch der russichen Geschichte Osteuropa 12 (1962) 521-528 Gerges Nivat Du Panmongolisme au mouvement eurasien Cahiers du monde Russe et Sovietique 73 (1966) 460-78 Nicholas V Riasanovsky The Emergence of Eurasians California Slavic Studies 4 (1967) 39-72 39 HC TpylSeUKoA Espona H lIeJIOBelleCTBO CO(j)HR 192Q Mirsky The Eurasian Movement (1927) 312-13 V Riasanovsky Emergence of Eurasians (1967) 56 Leonid Luks Die Ideologie der Eurasier im zeitgeschichtlichen Zusammenhang Jahrbucher fur Geschichte Osteuropas 34 (1986) 374-395 40 llH CasHUKHA reOnOJlHTHlIeCKHe 3aMeTKH no PYCCKoA
HCTOpHH - B rB BepHattCKHA HallepTaHHe PYCCKoA HCshyTOpHH llpara 1927 CTp 234-260 CM TaK)I(e nHCasHUKHA reOrpa(j)HlIeCKHe ocolSeHHOCTH POCCHH 2 TT npara 1927 OH )l(e POCCHR - OCOlSblA reorpa(j)HlIecKHA MHp llapH)I( 1927 Charles Halperin Russia and the Steppe George Vernadsky and Eurasianism Forschungen zur osteuropaischen Geschichte 36 (1985) 55-194 and Slavic Studies 41 (1982)477-493 41 rB BepHattcKHA YKa3 COli CTp 230-231 259-260 Charles Halperin Opcit pp 99-104 42 V Riasanovsky The Emergence of Eurasians California Slavic Studies 4 (1967) 43 H Carrere dEncausse Decline of an Empire The Soviet Socialist Republics in Revolt (New York Harper 1981) 13-46
148
npOllBH)KEHHE POCCHH K lOrY
POCCHflCKHE llPOCTOPbI
Hepa3pemHMble npOCiJIeMbI CJlHRHHR pac B orpoMHoM MHOshyrOHaUHOHaJIbHOM KOHrJlOMepaTe Ha3blBaeMOM POCCHAcKOA (a n03ttHee coseTCKoA) eBpa3HAcKoA HMnepHeA eme CioJlee 01S0shyCTPRIOTCR B reorpa(j)HlIecKHx nOHRTHRX - B TpyttHeAmeM nposhyCTpaHcTseHHoM IIHcCiaJIaHce ttoBJIeIOmHM Hall olSmHM reOCTpashyTerHlIeCKHM nOJIO)l(eHHeM HMnepHH
MeTa(j)opHlIeCKH ynpomaR HCTOPHIO POCCHAcKOA HMnepHH nottllac CBOttRT K TparHlIeCKoA Ollep)l(HMOCTH npOCTopOM HJIH K TparHlIeCKOMY lIapy npOCTpaHCTsaI COrJlaCHO 3THM npettCTaBJIeHHRM PYCCKHX - H KaK OISOpOHRIOmHXCR H KaK arpeccopOB nOCTORHHO H Heyttep)l(HMO BJIeKJlH orpOMHble npOCTpaHCTBa Espa3HH PYCCKHe rOpllRTCR TeM liTO s HX rHshyraHTCKoA cyxonYTHoA TBepttbIHe MO)l(HO pa3MecTHTb 2-3 AMepHKH 40 ltJ)paHUHA H 93 BeJIHKOlSpHTaHHH Me)l(lIY 1600 H 1900 rr K PoccHAcKOA HMnepHH 1I0lSaBHJIOCb B olSmeA CJIO)l(HOCTH 17 MJIH KSattpaTHblx KHJIOMeTpOB HOBblX TeppHshyTOPHA s cpellHeM no 57 TbIC KBatlpaTHhIX KHJlOMeTpoB e)l(eshyrOttHo3 HCXOIlR H3 3Toro HeTpyttHO npHIITH K 3aKJIIOlIeHHIO liTO reorpa(j)HR H s caMOM tteJle OKa3b1BaJla BceCTopOHHee BJlHRHHe Ha pYCCKoe H coseTCKoe BOCnpHRTHe A3HH~
TaKHM 01Spa30M reorpa(j)HlIeamA (j)aKTOp HrpaeT orpOMshyHyIO pOJlb S HCTOPHH pYCCKoro Hapottaf ocolSeHHO B CBR3H C lIpe3MepHbiM YBJIelleHHeM HMnepHaJlHCTHlIeCKoA POCCHH npOCTpaHCTBaMH H TeppHTOpHRMH )lse reorpa(j)HlIeCKHe OCOshylSeHHOCTH OTJIHlIaIOT POCCHIO llepBaR - 3TO 0llHooeipa3He peJIbshye(j)a MeCTHOCTH MOHOTOHHOCTb JlaHttma(j)Ta n03S0JIHSmaR UeHTpaJIbHOA nOJIHTHlIeCKoA BJIaCTH nOllttep)l(HBaTb H pacshynpOCTpaHRTb csoA KOHTPOJIb no JIHHHH SeJIHKHX pellHhIx nyshyTeA TRHymHXCR no OCH ceBep-IOr TaKoA KOHTPOJlb oeiJlerllaJl ttBH)I(eHHe TosapOB KOJlOHHCTOB H BoACK~ no CJIOBaM BblllaIOmeshyrOCR HCTopHKa KJIIOlIeSCKoro 3KCnaHCHR MOCKBbI MO)l(eT paCCMaTpHBaTbCR KaK B03BblmeHHe ueHTpOCTpeMHTeJlbHOA CHJIbl 3aXBaTHBmeA KOHTPOJlb HatI HCTOKaMH lIeTblpex peK B
149
npe~nO~Hn HCTOPHOCO~CKOe TOnKOBaHHe ~Byx npOTHBOCTOshy
HmHX 3KCnaHCHOHHCTCKHX nOTOKOB B A3HH KpeCTbRHCKaR POcshy
CHR npHmna CnaCTH CenbCKOX03RRcTBeHHble CTpaHbI A3HH OT
A3HH KOtleBOA - OT TypaHa (A3HH ApHMaHaH) Cne~OBaTenbHO
PYCCKHR KOnOHHanH3M OCHOBbIBaIOIQHRcR Ha KpeCTbRHCKOM
nOCeneHtlecTBe - pe3KaR npOTHBOnOnO~HOCTb B~OXHOMReshy
MOMY POCTOBIQHtleCTBOM ~pHTaHCKOMY TOprOBOMY KOnOHHashy
nH3MY OCHOBaHHOMY Ha ~e3~anOCTHoR 3KcnnyaTaQHH pecypshy
COB A3HH H He B03BpaIQalOIQeMY HHtlerO ee nOtlBe lO~aKOB
nHcaTenb HapO~HHtlecKoro HanpaBneHHR nonaran tlTO o()ecshy
netlHBaR npHTOK CBoero KpeCTbRHCTBa POCCHR CTaHeT O()HOshy
BHTenbHHQeA A3HH 3aIQHTHHQeR alHaTCKHX HapO~OB CH~HpH
POCCHR nepe~aCT nocnaHHe KpeCTbRHCKOrO COQHanH3Ma
cenbCKHW o~mHHaM I1H~HH H KHTaR H nOBe~eT HX Ha ()Opb()Y
npOTHB KanHTanHCTHtleCKOR 3KcnnyaTaQHH co CTOpOH~
3ana~a14
llHXOTOMHR Me~~y QHBHnH3aQHeR OCHOBaHHOR Ha o~pashy
~OTKe 3eMnH H QHBHnH3aQHeA CTenHblX KOtleBHHKOB CTana ~Hshy
HaMHtleCKHM npHHQHnOM HCTOPHH B ~HnOCO~CKOM ytleHHH
HHKOnaR clgte~opoBa (1828-1903 rr) KOToporo MHOrHe CtlHTalOT
HaH()onee 3HatlHTenbHbiM H opHrHHanbHblM PYCCKHM MblcnHTeshy
neM XIX BeKa1S OH BepHn tlTO PYCCKaR KpeCTbRHCKaR O()IQHHa
o~na~aeT OCO~bIMH ~o~pO~eTenRMH KOTopble MorYT cnacm
MHp OT pa3nO~eHHR tlTO cenbCKoe X03RACTBO npOTHBOCTORshy
IQee ToprOBne H POCTOBIQHIQeCTBY o()na~aeT BOCKpemaJOIQHMH
cnOCO~HOCTRMH KOTopble MorYT o~paTHTb npax YMepmHX
npe~KOB B ~HBble paCTeHHR H ~HBOTHbIX no MHeHHIO clgte~oshy
pOBa cenbCKHe QHBHnH3aQHH POCCHH H A3HH (Te I1paHa I1Hshy
~HH H KHTaR) Be~YT O()opOHHTenbHYIO ~OPb()Y npOTHS KOshy
tleBbIX CTenHblX rocy~apcTB H MOPCKHX ~ep~aB B BoRHax
Me~~y AHrnHeA H KHTaeM clgte~opoB BH~en npo~on~HTenbshy
HblR KOH~nHKT KynbTa npe~KOB H KynbTa 30nOTa POCCHR
~on~Ha npHcoe~HHHTbCR K ToR HnH HHOR CTopOHe OHa MOshy
~eT npHcoe~HHHTbCR K 3ana~y tlTO~bl 3a~ymHTb CTapeAmylO
HMnepHIO MHpa HnH ~e OHa Mo~eT B03~ep~aTbCR OT
CTonb 3nOK03HeHHoro O~be~HHeHHR H pa~OTaTb ~nR ~OCTHshy~eHHR BetlHOrO MHpa Me~~y ()enblM H ~enTblM QapRMH clgteshy
~OpOB npe~naran POCCHH OTCTpaHHTbCR OT eBponeACKHX
H aMepHKaHCKHX ~aH~HTOB H BCTaTb Ha CTOPOHY cna~blX
B A3HH - H TeM nOMOtlb HH~HAcKHM KpeCTbRHaM BepHYTb
3eMnlO B CBoe Ma~eHHe16 YBnetleHHe clgte~opoBa HH~HRcKHM BonpOCOM He ~blno
cnytlaRHblM B 1899 r OH nocemn ~pyra ~HBmero B Amxa()~e cTonHQe pyccKoro 3aKaCnHR H npoexan no TypKeCTaHY ~o cashy
Moro naMHpa B Amxa()a~e clgte~opoB cornaCHnCR ony~RHKOshy
BaTb B MecrnoM ~ypHane CTaTblO B KOTOpoR OH pa3MblmRRn
ot) aHrno-poccHAcKOM cOnepHHtlecTBe 3TO t)b1na aHOHHMHaR
CTaTbR - ~Hnoco~-YTOnHCT clgte~opoB OTKaaanCR on~nHKoshyBaTb ee no~ CBOHM HMeHeM H nonyqHTb aa Hee rOHopap OHa
HOCHna HeO~bltlHOe Ha3BaHHe - 0 npeBpameHHH pa3pymHshy
TenbHoro Opy~HR B opy~He cnaCeHHRP POCCHR YBepReT
tlHTaTeneR clgte~opOB He XOtleT npaBHTb I1H~HeA OHa npOCTO
HIQeT cnpaBe~nHBOCTH ~nR t)e~Horo HH~HAcKoro KpeCTbRHHshy
Ha H 3aIQHTbI ~nR Bcex 3KcnnyaTHpyeMbIx HapO~OB HaH()Oshy
nee 3~~eKTHBHoe Hepa3pymalOIQee opY~He KOTopoe Mo~eT
HCnOnb30BaTb POCCHR tlTOt)b1 3aCTaBHTb npOMbimneHHYJO BPHshy
TaHHIO OTKa3aTbCR OT BnaCTH H~ KpeCTbRHCKOR I1H~HeR shy
npOBe~eHHe ~ene3HoR ~OpOrH ~O BOPOT I1H~HH
BH~HMO npH HanHcaHHH 3TOA CTaTbH clgte~opoB BHOBb neshy
pe~HBan Te MHHYTbl Kor~a OH CTORR B ()narorOBeHHH nepe~ naMHpOM KpblmeR MHpa HrpaBmHM CTonb Ba~HylO CHMshy
BOnHtleCKyIO ponb B ero KOCMorOHHH neR3a~H naMHpa MornH
HanOMHHTb eMY Ot) YHHBepCanbHoA ponH I1H~HH H()O clgte~oshypOB npH3HaBan ~Ba OCHOBHblX QeHTpa QHBHnH3aQHH KOHshy
CTaHTHHOnonb - ~HBYIO CTonHQY r~e rpeKO-CnaBRHCKHR MHp
BCTpetlaeTCR C xpHCTHaHCKHM 3ana~OM H naMHp - HeKpononb
npe~KOB apHAcKoR paCbI H Konbl~enb HH~oeBponeRcKHX R3~shy
KOB 3TO YTonHtleCKoe BH~eHHe npHBeno clgte~opoBa K H~ee
tlTO B ~y~YIQeM 3Ta CBRIQeHHaR BepmHHa CTaHeT CBH~eTeneM
npHMHpeHHR POCCHH C BenHKo()pHTaHHeR18
YTonHtleCKHe pe~neKCHH clgte~opOBa OTHOCHTenbHO Bceshy
MHpHoro QeHTpa HCKynneHHR19 nonytlHnH BeCbMa Manoe
pacnpOCTpaHeHHe H TonbKO B POCCHH nOCKonbKY npH ~H3HH
OH netlaTanCR OtleHb Mano OHH ()bIRH H3BecTHbi nHmb HeMHorHM
ero ~nH3KHM ~py3bRM (BAKo~eBHHKOBY H HnneTepCOHY)
H HeCKonbKHM Ot)IQHM 3HaKOMblM cpe~H KOTOPblX t)b1nH cIgt llocshy
ToeBCKHR 11 TonCToR H B ConOBbeB cnocne~HHA npH3Hasan
CBoR HHTenneKTyanbHblR ~onr clgte~opOBY) npe~CTaBnReTCR
134 135
OllHaKO qTO B nOCJIellHHe llBa lleC$lTHJIeTH$I XIX BeKa npOH30shy
WeJI KpynHbIA CllBHr B pYCCKOA HMnepHaJIHCTHqeCKOA nOJIHTHshy
Ke KOToporo He 3aMeTHJI ctgtellOpOB B CpellHeA A3HH nOJIO)f(eshy
HHe nOflrH He H3MeHHerCH HeCMOTp$l Ha TO qTO BpHraHHH
COXpaHHer B 3rOM perHOHe craryc KBO A3HaTCKa$l nOJIHTHKa
POCCHH cOCpellOTOqHJIaCb Ha ~aJIbHeM BOCTOKe CTOJIKHOBeshy
HHe C $InOHCKoA 3KCnaHCHeA B KHTae H Kopee CTaJIO JIHWb Bonshy
POCOM BpeMeHH npellBHlleHHe 3Toro KOHJlJIHKTa HaJIO)f(HJIO
OTneqaTOK Ha Bce llHCKYCCHH 06 A3HH B cpelle PyccKoA HHshy
TeJIJIHreHUHH HMeHHO 3TO npellBHlleHHe llaJIO B03MO)f(HOCTb
CTOpoHHHKaM HlleH )f(eJIToA onacHoCTH OllOJIeTb yMepeHHbIX
nAHMOHrOnH3M
nO)f(aJIyA HHKTO He 6blJI 60JIee 3aXBaqeH npellCTaBJIeHHeM
o POCCHH KaK 0 3amHTHHue EBponbI OT HacTynalOmHx Opll a3Hshy
aTCKHX 3aXBaTqHKOB qeM BHllHbIA peJIHrH03HbiA JlHJIOCOJl H
MHCTHK BJIallHMHP COJIOBbeB (1853-1900 rr) CblH H3BeCTHoro
HCTopHKa CM COJIOBbeBa HBHO pacHcTcKHe ynpa)f(HeHH$I Coshy
JIOBbeBa Ha TeMY )f(eJIToA onaHocTH BpOlle 3HaMeHHToA noshy
3MbI naHMOHrOJIH3M (1894 rgt H nOCJIellHerO ero 3cce AHTHshy
XPHCT (1900 r) rlle H306pa)f(eHO HOBoe MOHrOJIbCKOe HaweCTshy
BHe Ha EBpony B XX BeKe noll BOllHTeJIbCTBOM HnoHHH 3aXBashy
THJIH Bo06pa)f(eHHe WHPOKOA ny6JIHKH H B POCCHH H BHe ee20
COJIOBbeB KaK H MHorne ero cOBpeMeHHHKH paJlleJI$lBWHe HllelO
)f(eJIToA onacHocTH BepHJI qTO pacbl KOTopble OH KJIaCCHshy
JlHUHpOBaJI KaK HH3wHe 06peqeHbi Ha nOllqHHeHHe BbICWHM
pacaM HJIH Ha HCqe3HOBeHHe JlHWb aHapxHcTbl BpOlle neTpa
KponoTKHHa21 OTBa)f(HBaJIHCb Bnp$lMylO B03pa)f(aTb npOTHB
B3rJI$IllOB COJIOBbeBa BOJIbWeBHKH lleJIaJIH TO )f(e HO HX B03shy
pa)f(eHH$I ObIJIH ynpOmeHHbIMH OHH npOBOllHJIH napaJIJIeJIb
Me)f(lly OJlHUHaJIbHOA nponaraHlloA )f(eJIToA onaCHOCTH H aHshy
THCeMHTH3MOM22
BJIH$lHHe nponoBelleA COJIOBbeBa HenOCpellCTBeHHO HcnbIshy
TaJIH pYCCKHe n03Tbl-CHMBOJIHCTbI B HX qHCJIe AHllpeA BeJIbIA23
H AJIeKcaHllp BJIOK B npOWJIOM - yqeHHK COJIOBbeBa n03Ma
middotCKHJlbI HanHCaHHa$l B KaHYH 3aKJIlOqeHH$I BpeCTCKoro MHpa
OTKpbIBaeTC$I 3nHrpaJloM H3 naHMOHrOJIH3Ma naHMOHroshy
JIH3M XOTb HM$I llHKOl Ho MHe JIaCKaeT CJIYX OHO JTa n03Ma
BJIOKa llaJIa HM$I ueJIOMY JIHTepaTYPHOMY HanpaBJIeHHIO24 BJIOK
nOTp$lCeHHblA TparHqeCKOA cYllbooA POCCHH HlleT HanepeKop
Hlle$lM CBoero yqHTeJI$I H OTCTaHBaeT COlO3 PYCCKHX H CKHJlOB
npOTHB HarJIoA EBponbl ero npellOCTepe)f(eHHe - HenpHKpblshy
Ta$l a3HaTflHHa
MHJIbOHbl- Bac Hac - TbMbl H TbMbl H TbMbI
nonpooyATe cpa3HTecb C HaMHI
~a CKHJlbl- MbI ~a a3HaTbl- Mbll
C pacKocblMH H )f(allHblMH oqaMHI
POCCH$I - CJlHHKC JlHKY$l H CKOPO$l
Ii OOJIHBaRCb qepHoA KPOBblO
OHa rJI$IllHT rJI$IllHT rJIMHT B Te6$1
Ii C HeHaBHCTblO H C JII060BblO2S
Y)f(e B 1923 r Korlla OOJIbWeBHCTCKaR POCCH$I n06ellHJIa
B rpa)f(llaHCKOA BoAHe llpyroA PYCCKHA n03T CepreA Eceshy
HHH nHllleT H3 repMaHHH HHKaK He CTapaRCb CKpbITb CBoero
r JIy60Koro OTBpameHH$I K EBpone nYCTb Mbl a3HaTbl nYCTh Mbl
BOH$leM nYCTb Mbl oeCCTbIllHO qellleM 3allHHUY Ha rJIa3aX y
Bcex nYCTb TaK HO HeT B Hac 3Toro 3anaxa rHHeHH$I HHKaKa$l
peBOJIIOUH$I 3lleCb HeB03MO)f(Ha Bce B 3aCToe B TynHKe TOJIbshy
KO HaweCTBHe BapBapOB BpOlle Hac MO)f(eT cnaCTH HX H nepeshy
lleJIaTb Be3 HalllecTBH$I Ha EBpony He OOOAlleTC$I 26 Ho HH Pycshy
CKoe 06mecTBo HH uapcKoe npaBHTeJIbCTBO He npHH$lJIH arpecshy
CHBHoA HlleOJIOrHH BOCTOqHHKOB OHH npOllOJI)f(aJIH CB$l3blshy
BaTh 6Yllymee POCCHH C TpallHUHOHHblMH HanpaBJIeHH$lMH HMshy
nepHaJIHCTHqeCKOA nOJIHTHKH cJlOKYCHpOBaHHbIMH Ha EBPOshy
ny C npellnOqTeHHeM 3KcnaHCHH uapH3Ma Ha BaJIKaHbI H K
npOJIHBaM BOJIee Toro pHCKOBaHHble a3HaTCKHe aBaHTlOpbl
KPHTHKOBaJIHCb neqaTblO KaK $IBHa$l JIOByIIIKa nOpO)f(lleHHaR
repMaHCKHM JI066H BCerlla HMeBIlIHM BJIH$lHHe B neTepoypre
CqHTaJIOCb qTO BbIllYMaHHaR HM a3HaTCKaR MHCCH$I POCCHH shy
orpOMHa$l llHBepCH$I KOTOpa$l llOJI)f(Ha 06JIerqHTb COOCTBeHshy
HblA repMaHCKHA llpaHr Hax OCTeH B UeHTpaJIbHOA EBpone
a 3aTeM H no BceA JIHHHH BepJIHH-Barllall27
-)f(EJITOPOCCH)1shy
CTpaHHOe H llBYCMbICJIeHHOe llBH)f(eHHe )I(eJITOpOCCH$I -
HaHOOJIee JIIOOOnbITHOe H KpaAHee KPbIJIO BOCTOqHHKOB nOJIshy
136 137
Hee BCerO ero H~eH OTpa~eH~ B pa60TaX H npe~npHHHMashy
TeRbCKOA ~e~TeRbHOCTH KH~3~ 3cnepa YXToMcKoro (1861shy
1921 rr) 3TOT BRa~eRel HeCKORbKHX ra3eT 6RH3KHA copaTHHK
BH~Horo rocy~apCTBeHHOrO ~emeR~ POCCHH C 10 BHTTe B noshy
nYR~pH3alHH H~eH TpaHccH6HPCKOA ~eRe3HoA ~oporH HaCTaBHHK 6y~y~ero HMnepaTopa HaCRe~Horo npHHla HHKOshy
Ra~ pa3BHBaR nopa~alO~He MeraROMaHHeA H~eH OCHOBaHHbIe
Ha cOMHHTeRbHoA TeopHH 0 ~K06bI OpraHHtIeCKOA 6RH30CTH
POCCHH K KHTalO H ~a~e K I1H~HH28 YXTOMCKHA neR ~H(I)HPaMshy6bI KHTaAcKoA lHBHRH3alHH HO CKpbITbIM HX ReATMoTHBOM
HeCOMHeHHO 6bIRa H~e~ ~eRToA onacHocTH To tITO HCTOshy
pHK 3MaR03eMOB Ha3bIBaR H~eOROrHtIeCKOA CYTblO HBOCTOtIshy
HHKOB OTpa~eHO B Kpe~O YXTOMCKOrO A3H~ - Mbl BCer~a
npHHa~Re~aRH K HeA MbI ~HRH ee ~H3HblO H O~~aRH ee HHshy
TepeCbI LJepe3 Hac BOCTOK npHweR K OC03HaHHIO ceo~ K BbICshy
meA ~H3HH HaM He HY~HO 3aBoeBaHHA Bce 3TH HapO~bI pa3shy
RHtIHbIX pac tIYBCTBYIOT npHT~~eHHe K HaM - KPOBblO Tpa~Hshy
lHeA H~e~MH MbI npOCTO 60Ree 6RH3KH HM HHTHMHO 3TOT Beshy
RH KHA H 3ar~OtIHbIA BOCTOK rOTOB CTaTb HawHM~9 TaKHM 06pa30M MO~HO 6bIRO 6bI CKa3aTb tITO onTHshy
MHCTHtIeCKa~ BepCH~ PycCKoA lHBHRH3aTopCKoA MHCCHH Ha
BOCTOKe (BO BC~KOM CRYtIae B ~eKRapalH~X) OCHOBaHHa~
Ha pacoBoA H KYRbTYPHOA aCCHMHRH~lHH HRH no MeHbmeA
Mepe Ha COTpY~HHtIeCTBe H TepnHMOCTH KOTOPYIO npOB03shy
r RaCHR BeHIOKOB B 70-e ro~~ XIX BeKa B OTHoweHHH Cpe~HeA
A3HH MorRa HaATH npHRo~eHHe H no OTHoweHHIO K BOCTOtIHOA
A3HH CaM BHTTe 6bIR CTOPOHHHKOM H~eH tITO POCCHACK~
HMnepH~ pacnORo~eHHa~ Me~~y 6Y~~HCTCKHM HH~HAcKHM H MYCYRbMaHCKHM MHpaMH ~BR~eTC~ MHpOM B ce6e CorRaCHO
3anHCKe no~aHHoA BHTTe laplO B 1893 r TO tITO OTRHtIaeT
POCCHIO OT 3ana~a - 3TO ee OC06bIA HalHOHaRbHbIA ~yx 3TOT
~yx Hap~~y C ~pyrHMH 3ReMeHTaMH CKpenR~IO~HMH POCshy
CHIO (reOrpajJHtIeCKOe nORo~eHHe npaBOCRaBHoe xpHCTHaHshy
CTBO H caMo~ep~aBHe) 06pa3yeT KpenKoe ~~po npOtIHO
06be~HHeHHoe HO cB060~Hoe OT HalHOHaRHCTHtIeCKOA HCshy
KRlOtIHTeRbHOCTH 06Ra~aeT orpOMHbIMH B03MO~HOCT~MH
~R~ ~py~eCTBeHHOrO 6paTCTBa H COTpY~HHtIeCTBa C caMbIMH
PaJRHtIHbIMH pacaMH H Hapo~aMHO B TOM ~e ro~y BHTTe no~aR laplO e~e O~HY ~OKRa~shy
HYIO 3anHCKY B KOTOpoA no~~ep~HBaR BeCbMa B3pbIBoonacshy
HYIO H COMHHTeRbHYIO H~elO BbI~BHHYTYIO neTpOM Ba~MaeBbIM
6YP~TCKHM leRHTeReM npHH~BwHM npaBOCRaBHe (ero
KpeCTHbIM OTlOM 6bIR HMnepaTOp AReKcaH~p III) CTpaHHbIA
nRaH OCHOBbIBaRC~ Ha CHCTeMaTHtIeCKOM npOHHKHOBeHHH
6YP~TOB 06yqeHHbIx PYCCKHMH B KatIeCTBe ToprOBbIX areHTOB
B 3a~HHA ~BOp KHTa~ - Ha 3an~HYIO nOrpaHHtIHYIO nOROCy
3eMeRb npOT~HYBWHXC~ OT CHHb13~Ha ~O MOHrORHH H MaHbtIshy
~YPHH BKRlOtI~ TH6eT B 1895-1897 rr nRaH 6bIR onp060BaH
HO nOTepneR nORHYIO Hey~atIY JlHHHeA npo~BH~eHH~ POCCHH
~OR~Ha 6bIRa CTaTb HOBa~ ~eRe3Ha~ ~opora Ha JlaHbtI~oy B
npOBHHlHH KaHcyA rRaBHbIM HanpaBReHHeM nO~PbIBHOA ~e~shy
TeRbHOCTH 6bIRa no~~ep~Ka aHTHKHTaAcKoro BOCCTaHH~
MOHrOROB m6eTleB H KHTaACKHX MYCYRbMaH ECRH 6bl nRaH
Ba~MaeBa OKa3aRC~ CTORb ~e ycnewHbIM KaK r RaBH~A nRaH
BHTTe - cTpoHTeRbcTBO TpaHccH6HPCKOA ~eRe3HOA ~oporH TO BHTTe 6bIR 6bI npaB B CBoeM 3aKRlOtIeHHH tITO ftc 6eperOB
THxoro OKeaHa H BepWHH rHMaRaeB POCCH~ 6y~eT BepWHTb
He TORbKO a3HaTCKHe HO H eBponeAcKHe ~eRaft 31 XOT~ BHTTe
CTapaRC~ tIT06bI MHp nOBepHR ero ~eKRapalH~M 0 cnoc06shy
HOCTH POCCHH ocy~ecTBHTb CBOIO MHCCHIO B A3HH MHPshy
H~MH H KYRbTypHbIMH MepaMH KOHetIHOA leRblO PYCshy
CKoA 3KcnaHCHH B A3HH nocpe~CTBOM ~eRe3Ho~opO~Horo
CTpOHTeRbCTBa H ToprOBbIX MeponpH~THA (KOTOpble B 3Hashy
tIHTeRbHoA Mepe a nO~tIac H nORHOCTblO cy6CH~HpOBaRHCb
rocy~apcTBOM) 6bIRO KOROHHaRbHoe rocnO~CTBo32 KaKoe-TO BpeM~ PYCCKHA HMnepHaRH3M B A3HH pa3BHBaRshy
C~ Ha BORHe onTHMH3Ma conpOBo~~aBwero CTpOHTeRbCTBO
TpaHCCH6HPCKOA MarHCTpaRH rRaBH~M nponaraH~HCTOM
3TOA ~oporH H CHCTeMaTHtIeCKOrO npOHHKHOBeHH~ POCCHH B
KHTaA tIepe3 MaHbtI~ypHIO 6bIR YXTOMCKHA Ero nOMO~HHK no CB~3~M C 3ana~HoA EBponoA repMaH BpYHxojJep (1841shy
1916 rr) tIYTb RH He B RHpHtIeCKHX TOHax onHCblBaR CBeTRoe
6y~y~ee EBpa3HH Bce pacbl CB~3aHHble OT BaRTHKH H LJepHoshy
ro MOp~ ~o THxoro OKeaHa 3TOA nOTp~calO~eA ~oporoA KOshy
Topa~ npHHeceT BbIrO~bl B3aHMHoMY ToproBoMy H KyRbTypshy
HOMY 06MeHY 6Y~YT ~HTb B nORHOM corRaCHH no~ CKHneTshy
POM lap~ B OTRHtIHe OT 6pHTaHleB B I1H~HH ~OKa3bIBaR
BpYHxoBep Y PyccKoro KpeCTb~HHHa H COR~aTa HeT tIyBcTBa
138 139
paCOBoro npeBOCXOllCTBa no OTHomeHHIO K a3HaTaM
KaH H TypaHCKaH KPOBb BCKope CMemaIOTCH B03HHKHyr HOBbie
nOrpaHHtlHbIe HapOllbI nOJIya3HaTcKoro nOJIyeBponeAcKoro
npOHCXOgtKlleHHH C03lla101IHe CBH3yJOlIee 3BeHO nOCpellCTBO
KOToporo CJIaBHHe ClleJIaIOT BblcmHe $OpMbl gtKH3HH C03llaHshy
Hble XpHCTHaHCKO-eBponeAcKoA KYJIbTYpoA llOCTynHblMH Bee elIe 3aKpblTOMY CepllLlY BHYTPeHHeA A3HH3
MOTHB 3TOT BeCbMa 3HaKOM HlleH MorJIa npHllTH tlyramp JIH
He OT BeHIOKOBa H llagtKe OT paHHero n03Ta-naHCJIaBHCTa TIOTshy
tleBa KOTOPblA B OllHOM H3 CBOHX CTpaHHblX CTHXOTBOpeHHR
PYCCKaH reorpa$HH (1848 r) MetlTaJI 0 5YllYlIeA poccHAcKOR
eBpoa3HaTcKoA HMnepHH OT HHJIa ll0 HeBbI OT 3JIb5bI ll0 KHshy
TaHIOT BOJIrH no EB$paT OT raHra ll0 llYHaH~ OllHaKO Pa3shy
pa50TaHHaH B rOllbI HnOHO-KHTaAcK09 BoAHbl (1894-1895 IT)
5pYHxo$epoBCKaH aHTHHMnepHaJIHCTHtleCKaH KOHLlenLlHft
)KeJITOpOCCHH HMeJIa HCHyJO nOJIHTHtlecKyJO LleJIb BpYHxo$ep
He TOJIbKO pHCOBaJI BeJIHtleCTBeHHYIO KapTHHY B03MOgtKHOro
CHM5H03a POCCHH H KHTaH HO H npellynpegtKllaJI 3anallHOe 0laquo5shy
lIeCTBO 05 3KcnaHCHOHHCTCKHX HaMepeHHHX SlnoHHH SInOHHft
noll $JIarOM 5YllllHCTCKOA COJIHllapHOCTH C03llaeT naHa3HaTCshy
KYIO 30HY BJIHHHHH CHatlaJIa OrpaHHtleHHYIO SInoHHeA Kopeshy
eA H KHTaeM Ho 3aTeM nOCJIe oKKynaLlHH TaAaaHH na 30Ha
nOCTeneHHO MOgtKeT pacmHpHTbCH Ha BCIO IOrO-BOCTOtlHYIO
A3HIO B ollHoA H3 CBOHX cTaTeA BpYHxo$ep C HeMaJI09 lloJIeR
np03peHHH nHCaJI 0 5YllYlIeA BeJIHKOA BOCTOtlHOa3HaTCKoR
c$epe COBMeCTHOrO npOLlBeTaHHH KOTOpaH B03HHKHeT 50 JIeT
cnycTH3S TeM He MeHee npellOCTepegtKeHHH BpYHxo$epa JIe)f(ashy
JIH BHYTPH cneKTpa HlleA gtKeJIToA onacHocTH KOTopbIe MO)f(shy
HO HaATH ygtKe Y B COJIOBbeBa H llagtKe elIe paHbme - Y K JIeoHshy
TbeBa HeCMOTpH Ha onTHMHCTHtleCKHe KapTHHbl 5YllYlIeR
ft)KeJITOpOcCHH BpYHxo$ep nO-BHllHMOMY 5bIJI 05ecnoKoeH
B03MOgtKHOCTblO Toro tlTO HHllYCTPHaJIH30BaHHble MaCCbl KHshy
TaALleB HatlHYT HeoTBpaTHMo npOllBHraTbCH Ha 3anall noll BOllHshy
TeJIbCTBOM HnOHLleB EllHHCTBeHHoA CHJIoA KOTOPaH CMO)f(eT
npoTHBOCTOHTb noA MOIIHOA 5YllllHCTCKOA BOJIHe llOKa3bIshy
BaJI BpYHxo$ep HBJIHeTCH PYCCKaH eBpOa3HaTCKaH HMnepHH
HeCKOJIbKO rpoTecKHoe B03pO)f(lleHHe 5YllllHCTCKOA TeMbI
npOH30mJIO B nepHOll rpaiKllaHCKOA B09Hbi B POCCHH CYshy
MaCmellmHA 5apoH $OH YHrepH-WTepH5epr eiblBmHA Llap-
CJltHR reHepaJI OTBeTHJI Ha PYCCKYIO peBOJIIOLlHIO nepeXOllOM B
ISYIlllH3M B 3HaK npoTecTa npoTHB Toro tlTO OH CtlHTaJI eiaHKshy
pOTCTBOM 3anaztHoA LlHBHJIH3aLlHH B 1921 r ero oeibellHHeHHbIA
llta3aLlKO-MOHrOJIbCKO-KHTaACKHR OTpHll 3aXBaTHJI YpiY CTOshy
nHUY BHemHeA MOHrOJIHH (HbIHe YJIaH-eiaTOP) rlle eiapoH eibIJ1
npOB03rJIameH HOBbIM lIHHrHCXaHoM OllHaKO HeCKOJIbKO MecHshy
ueB cnycTH YHrepH-WTeHeiepr 3TOT CHMBOJI a3HaTtlHHbI H
)KeJITOpOCCHH B OllHOM JIHLle nOTepneJI nOpa)f(eHHe OT 5oJIbshy
meBHKOB H eiblJI HMH paCCTpeJIHH36 Ba)f(HO OTMeTHTb tlTO 3Ta HlleOJIOrHH npOB03rJIamaBmaH
ISYllYlIee CJIHHHHe pac BO HMH eiOJIee OllHOPOllHOA EBpa3HH
(rlle gtKeJIaeMOe HepellKO BbIllaBaJIOCb 3a lleACTBHTeJIbHOCTb)
pa3YMeeTCH noll eiJIarOCKJIOHHbIM BOllHTeJIbCTBOM POCCHH
HHKOrlla He BJIHHJIa Ha npOLlecc npHHHTHH pemeHHA B neTepeiypshy
re KaKHM eibl Y3KHM HH eiblno onpelleJIeHHe noro npOLlecca
llnH Toro BpeMeHH B KOHetlHOM CtleTe (HCKJIlOtlaH anH30ll C Baztshy
MaeBbIM) B030einallaJIa peaJIbHaH nOJIHTHKa Ho B rOllbl rpa)f(shy
llaHCKoA B09Hbi H HeKOTopoe BpeMH nOCJIe ee OKOHtlaHHH eiOJIbshy
meBHCTCKaH POCCHH paCCMaTpHBaJIa CBOIO nOJIHTHKY B A3HH
CKopee KaK $YHKUHIO HlleOJIOrHH HlleH CMemeHHH CJIaBHHOshy
apHALleB H TypaHLleB nOJIb30BaJIaCb onpelleJIeHHOR nOllllep)f(shy
KoA JIHeiepaJIbHblX KpyrOB PYCCKoA HHTenJIHreHLlHH JIHmb ll0
Tex nop nOKa ypOBeHb p0gtKllaeMOCTH B POCCHH OCTaBaJICH Ollshy
HHM H3 caMbIX BbICOKHX B MHpe KaK 3TO eiblJIO npH LlapH3Me coshy
rJIaCHO llaHHbiM nepenHcH 1897 r 3TO cnocoeicTBOBaJIO H O$Hshy
LlHaJIbHOMY nOOlIpeHHIO KOJIOHH3aLlHH PycCKoA A3HH KpeCTbHshy
HaMH eBponeRcKoro npOHCXOgtKlleHHH B OCHOBHOM CJIaBHHaMH
HCnOJIb30BaHHe BblrOll OT OTKPbITHH CpellHeA A3HH H llaJIbshy
Hero BOCTOKa llnH PycCKoA KonOHH3aLlHH mno eibI 3HatlHTeJIbshy
HO MellJIeHHee H He eibIJIO eibI CTonb nOJIHblM 5e3 Toro BKJIalla
KOTOPblA BHecnH B 3TOT npOLlecc YtleHbIe CneLlHaJIHCTbl H
nYTemeCTBeHHHKH OHH OCTaBHnH COBeTCKOMY rOCYllapCTBY
npOtlHYIO TpallHLlHIO HaYtlHbIX HCCnellOBaHHA BbICOKoro
ypOBHH B ocoeieHHocTH B reorpa$HH H BOCTOKOBelleHHH
lla)f(e BbIllaIOIIHACH PYCCKHA BOCTOKOBell BaCHJIHA Bapshy
TOJIbll (1869-1930 rr) KOTOPbIA cYMeJI OCTaTbCH B cTopoHe
OT O$HLlHaJIbHOA nponaraHllbl H npH LlapH3Me H npH eiOJIbmeshy
BHKax B OCHOBHOM CorJIamancH C TeM tlTO OH CtlHTaJI HCTOPHshy
tlecKoA HeoeixOllHMOCTblO - C c03llaHHeM MHPOBbIX HMnepHA
141140
TaKHX KaK HMnepHH AJleKCaHIpa BeJlHKOrO MOHrOJlOS apaOOB
H la~e COSpeMeHHOR eMY POCCHRcKOR HMnepHH S CpelHeR
A3HH OH HCKpeHHe SepHJI 1JTO KpynHble CTpYKTYPbl C031alOT Jlyqshy
mHe YCJlOSHH lJIH KYJlbTypHOrO c6J1H~eHHH HapOlOS pa3J1H1Jshy
HbIX pac HeCMOTpH Ha sce 6elcTsHH KOTopble HecyT SORHbI
conpoSo~IalOlI(He C031aHHe TaKHX HMnepHR~7
HCXO~ HA BOCTOK TPYBEQKOA H CABHQKHA
HeCMOTpH Ha HeYIa1JH CSH3aHHble C PYCCKO-HnOHCKOR H
nepsoR MHposoR soRHaMH PYCCKHe npeTeH3HH Ha oc06ble
OTHOmeHHH C A3HeR npolOJl~aJlH ~HTb cpelH HHTeJlJlHreHshy
QHH a S rOlbI peSOJlIOQHH rp~IaHcKoR SORHbl H cpa3Y ~e nocshy
Jle HHX TaKHe npereH3HH la~e YCHJlHJlHCb Hp1Je scero 3TO 80shy
nJlOTHJlOCb B eSpa3HRCKOM lSH~eHHH KOTopoe cnJlOTHJlO cashy
Mble 6J1ecTHII(He yMbi PYCCKoR 3MHrpaQHH 1920-x rolos Heshy
CMOTPH Ha HepelKHe pa3HorJlaCHH OHH 6blJlH y6e~IeHbl 1JTO
JlHlUb SOCnpHHHS oc060e eBpa3HRcKoe MHpOS033peHHe MO~HO
coxpaHHTb oc060CTb PYCCKoro SKJlala S QHSHJlH3aQHIO OCHOshy
saHHoro KaK Ha rpeKO-SH3aHTHRCKOM TaK H Ha MOHrOJlbCKOM
HaCJlelHH B csoeM nepSOM MaHHlIJecTe l1cxol Ha SOCTOK
(1921 r) lBa SbIIaIOII(HXCH JlHHrBHCTa KHH3b HHKoJlaR Tpy6eQshy
KoR H POMaH HK06coH OTCTaHBaJIH espa3HRcKoe CJlHHHHe H3blshy
KOS H KYJlbTYP (TaK Ha3b1BaeMaH TeOpllH H3bIKOBoro COI03a -
Sprachbund) C03HaTeJlbHO npeYBeJlH1JHBaH SJlHHHHe TypaHcKoshy
ro 3J1eMeHTa38
EBpa3HRQbl C1JHTaJlH 60JlblUeBHKoB H MapKcH3M XYIIUHM
CJlelCTBHeM 3analHoR KYJlbTYPbl OlHaKO caMoe peBOJlIOQHIO
OHH paccMaTpHBaJlH KaK BeJlHKHR H He06XOlHMblR KaTaJlH3ashy
TOp OHa pa3pYIUHJla CTapblR MHp H np06YIHJla OlHospeMeHHO
H PYCCKHe MaCCbl H HapOlbl BOCTOKa n03TOMY pa60Ta Tpy6eQshy
Koro EBpona H 1JeJlOBe1JeCTBo lt1920 r) 1JHTaeTCH KaK HeKoe
C01JeTaHHe lIaHHJleSCKOro H npH3biSOS sToporo KOHrpecca Koshy
MHHTepHa JTO pemHTeJlbHOe 06BHHeHHe 3analHoMY HMneshy
PHaJIH3MY KOTopoe oTBepraeT eBpOQeHTpHCTCKHR nolXOl K
A3HH YHH~eHHe HcnblTaHHoe PoccHeR S XOle BoRHbl H peBoshy
JlIOQHH nHmeT Tpy6eQKoR Mo~eT C031aTb HenOBTopHMYIO
B03MO~HOCTb palHKaJlbHOrO nepecMoTpa OTHOmeHHH K Hepycshy
CKHM HapOlaM POCCHH 6YIYIJH CaMa KOJlOHHeR Mo~eT noshy
142
BeCTH lpyrHe KOJlOHHH B oc06eHHocTH CSOHX laquoa3HaTCKHX cecshy
Tepraquo Ha pelUHTeJlbHYIO 60Pb15y npoTHB pOMaHo-repMaHcKHx
KOJlOHH3aTopOB 39
OlHHM H3 caMbiX opHrHHaJlbHblX MblCJlHTeJleR CpelH
eBpa3HRQes I5blJl reorpallJ neTp CasHQKHR (1895-1968 rr) Coshy
rJlaCHO ero KOHQenQHH Espa3HH - nOlJlHHHaH KYJlbTypHOshy
reorpaIlJH1JeCKaH Ol5lI(HOCTb C lOOaS01JHblM nOTeHQHaJIOM Tepshy
pHTOpHaJlbHOR 3KcnaHCHH (MecTopa3sHTHe HJlH TonoreHeshy
3HC) rOSOpH 0 Ha1JaslUeRcH S XIX BeKe 3KCnaHCHH POCCHH Ha
lOr H SOCTOK CasHQKHR nblTaeTCH npenOlHecTH ee KaK 060shy
pOHHTeJlbHYIO Mepy S PaMKax nOHHTHH npOlsHHYTOR rpaHHshy
QbI HeCOMHeHHO aHaJlOrH1JHOrO TOMy nOHHTHIO KOTopoe
0150CHoBblBaJIO I5pHTaHcKYIO nOJIHTHKY B I1HIHH 50Jlee Toro
CaBHQKHR loKa3blsaeT 1JTO PYCCKYIO 3KcnaHCHIO B QeJIOM MO~HO
paccMaTpHsaTb KaK HenpepblSHblR npoQecc opraHH1JeCKOrO
pa3SHTHH B ero onHcaHHH 3TO BHIHTCH 1JYTb JlH He KaK 3KOshy
JlOrH1JeCKHR npoQecc l5e3 KaKOR-JlHI50 nOJIHTH1JeCKOR MOTHshy
SHPOBKH CKpblBalOlI(eRcH 3a HHM H HMnepHaJIHCTH1JeCKOrO COshy
nepHH1JeCTBa BeJlHKHX lep~as CSH3aHHOro CO cpelHea3HaTCshy
KHM H laJIbHeBOCT01JHblM sonpocaMH CJlelOSaTeJlbHO lOKa3b1shy
BaeT CaBHQKHR PYCCKaR EBpa3HR eCTb reonOJlHTH1JeCKOe elHHshy
CTSO B ce6e C031aHHOe KYJlbTYPHblM npOQeCCOM reHeTH1JeCshy
KoR MyTaQHH a He nOcpelCTSOM 3asoeBaHHA H pa3pyweHHA~ KaK BHIHM TaKOe TOJlKOBaHHe He CJIHWKOM OTJlH1JaeTCR OT KOHshy
QenQHH IHHaMH1JeCKOrO ~H3HeHHoro npOCTpaHCTBa CPPHIPHshy
xa PaTQeJlR KOTOPYlO KapJl XaycxollJep npHHRJI B 20-e rOlbl
EBPA3HAcKOE CBRH)f(EHHE H CRHHHHE
BeCbMa JlI060nbiTHO HBHOe CXOlCTBO Me~IY CJlOBapeM eBshy
pa3HAQeB H COBeTCKoA TepMHHOJlOrHeA xpYlI(eBCKoA 3nOXH
OTHOCHTeJIbHO KYJIbTypHO-HaQHOHaJIbHOrO CJIHRHHR nol JlIOshy
60BHbiM Hal30pOM CTapmero PYCCKoro 6paTa B pa60Tax nCashy
SHQKoro H B oc06eHHocTH B TpYIaX HCTopHKa r BepHaICKOshy
ro HepelKO BCTpe1JaIOTCR TepMHHbl CJ1HJ1HHe H nepeMeJIJHBashy
HHe 1JTO RKOl5bl HMeeT MeCTO B npoQecce TeppHTOpHaJlbHOR
3KcnaHCHH KYJlbMHHaQHR KOTOpoA - 1IJ0pMHpoBaHHe BeJlHshy
KOPYCCKOA KYJlbTYPbl TaK 3aMe1JaHHe BepHalCKoro 1JTO nol
BHeWHHM pa3Ho06pa3HeM CKpblBaeTCH BHYTpeHHee elHHCTBO
143
HanOMHHaeT pacxo)l(ee COBeTCKOe nOHHTHe 0 eQHHCTBe 8
MHorootlpa3HH
B MaHepe He CJIHmKOM OTJIHLlalOIleRcH OT COBeTCKHX CTaH~
QapTOB BepHaQCKHR QOKa3bIBaJI LITO BKJIIOLleHHe HepYCCKHX
rpynn B MHorOHauHOHaJIbYIO eBpa3HRcKYIO HMnepHIO C03Qa~
eT orpOMHbIe 3KOHOMHLleCKHe H KYJIbTypHbIe npeHMYIlIeCTBa O~~
HaKO BepHaQCKHR HaCTaHBaJI npH 3TOM LITO eQHHCTBO QOJI)I(HO
tlbITb 3KYMeHHLleCKHM tle3 HaBH3bIBaHHH HtlO PoccHRcKoe
rocy~apcTBO - eBpa3HRcKoe rOCYQapCTBO H Bce OTQeJIbHbIe
HaUHOHaJIbHOCTH Espa3HH QOJI)I(Hbl LlYBCTBOBaTb LITO 3TO HX
rocy~apcTBO H npH3HaBaTb ero (KypCHB BepHaQCKOrO) CHJIa
3Toro eBpa3HRcKoro otlpa30BaHHH JIe)l(HT B ero CBOtlOQHOM
KYJIbTYPHOM TBopLleCTBe41 KpOMe Toro Qa)l(e eCJIH PycCKHR
HapoQ otlpa3yeT rJIaBHYIO CHJIY eBpa3HRCKoro rocy~apcTBa a
PYCCKHR H3b1K - tla30BbiR CJIoR eBpa3HRcKoR KYJIbTYPbI Bce
3TO HeJIb3H HaBH3b1BaTb QpyrHM Hapo~aM HeCMOTpH Ha BeJIH~
LlHe 3THX HQeR BbICKa3bIBaBmHXCH eBpa3HRuaMH-3MHrpaHTaMH
He HecmHMH HHKaKoR nOJIHTHLIeCKoR OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH H
HMeSmHMH BeCbMa MaJIOe BJIHHHHe B HOBOA COBeTCKoR eBposhy
a3HaTCKoR HMnepHH QPyme CJIaBHHCKHe HapO~bI B ocotleHshy
HOCTH HaHtlOJIee MHOrOLlHCJIeHHble cnoCJIe PYCCKHX) HanpHshy
Mep YKPaHHUbl H nOJIHKH HcnblTbIBaJIH rJIytloKoe HeQOBepHe
K ueJIHM eBpa3HRueB H BbICTYaJIH npOTHB HHX2 K CO)l(aJIeHHIO
HHLlero He H3seCTHO 0 peaKUHH Ha TeopHH eBpa3HAueB a3HaTshy
CKHX HHTeJIJIeKTyaJIOB )l(HBmHX noQ COBeTCKHM pe)l(HMOM
MO)l(HO OQHaKO tle30mHtloLiHo nOJIaraTb LITO OHH BHQeJIH B
3THX TeOpHHX JIHmb YTOHLleHHoe onpaSQaHHe PYCCKoro HMneshy
pHaJIH3Ma
TaKHM otlpa30M eBpa3HRcKoe ~BH)I(eHHe caMO Toro He
C03HaBaH cnoc06CTBOBaJIO $OpMHPOBaHHIO YTonHLleCKoro 06shy
pa3a coseTCKoro LleJIOBeKa - HCKyccTBeHHoro nOpO)l(~eHHH
COBeTCKoR nponaraHQbl He HMelOIlero KaKOrO-JIH60 paCOBoro
HJIH 3THHLleCKOro npOHCXO)l(QeHHH HO rOBOpHIlero no-pYCCKH
H OIlYIlalOIlero ce6H KOHeLiHO )l(e PYCCKHM COBeTCKaH MOshy
QeJIb - TpOHua COCTOHIlaH H3 Tpex CTaQHA - paCUBeT-c6JIHshy
)l(eHHe-CJIHHHHe BeCbMa pa3BHTaH B 3noxy XPYIleBa pa3Hshy
TeJIbHO HanOMHHaeT eBpa3HRcKoe BHQeHHe 1920-x rO~OB OHa
OTpa)l(aeT TaK)I(e HCTopHLIeCKHA onbIT HaKOnJIeHHblA PycCKOR
HHTeJIJIHreHUHeR no HaUHOHaJIbHblM H paCOBblM BonpocaM
KOTopbIe PYCCKHe MbICJIHTeJIH BnepBble nO~HHJIH B XIX B
144
KaK nOKa3blBaeT 3JIeH Kappep Ii AHKOC BCsl COBeTCKasl
(OHuenUHH B otlJIaCTH onpeQeJIeHHH H 3aKOHHoro O$opMJIeHHsl
OTHomeHHA Me)l(~y PYCCKHMH H HepyccKHMH npeTepneJIa
MHO)l(eCTBO H3MeHeHHA43 B npoTHBOnOJIO)l(HOCTb neHHHcKoR
yTOnHH OTMHpaHHsl HauHA H rocYQapcTB H 3aMeHbl HX HOBblM
YHHBepCaJIbHbIM OOIlecTBOM npOJIeTapCKoA KJIaCCOBOR COJIHshy
~apHOCTH 60JIee )l(ecToKHA H OCMOTpHTeJIbHbIA CTaJIHH
nocTeneHHo npe06pa30BaJI HQelO $eQepaUHH B H~elO ueHT~
paJIH30BaHHHoro PyccKoro HaQ30pa HaQ $opMaJIbHO aBTOshy
HOMHbIMH HapoQaMH COBeTcKoro COI03a 3Ta peaJIbHOCTb npeshy
BpaTHJIa Bee COBeTCKHe TeopHH no HaUHOHaJIbHOMY Bonpocy B
nycTOnOpO)l(HHe ynpa)l(HeHHH H3 KOTOPblX H~eH CTaJIHHa TaK
H He 6blJIH YCTpaHeHbl BbI)I(HBaHHe MHorOHaUHOHaJIbHOR
eBpa3HAcKoA TeppHTOpHaJIbHOA KpenOCTH nO-npe)l(HeMY
ynpaBJIHeMOA MYQPbIM CTapmHM PYCCKHM 6paTOM 6YQeT
3aBHCeTb npe)l(Qe Bcero OT pemeHHH nOQHHTbIX eBpa3HAuaMH
BonpOCOB
145
flpHMeqaHHR
1 Andrew Malozemoff Russian Far Eastern Policy 1881-1904 (Berkeley University of California Press 1958) 42 2 FF von Martens Russland und England in Zentralasien (St Petersburg 1880) Heinz Gollwitzer Geschichte des wetpolischen denkens (Gottingen Vandenhoeck amp Ruprecht 1982) 152-70 133-36 3 F F von Martens Le Conflict entre la Russie et la Chine (Bruxel~
les 1880) 4 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) 93-103 WP Wassiliew Die Erschliessung Chinas (Leipzig 1909) 5 WP Wassiliew Die Erschliessung Chinas (Leipzig 1909)49 6 NM Prejevalsky From Kulja accross the Tian Shan to Lob-Nor (London Sampson Low 1879) 7 MA Bakunin La theologie politique de Mazzini et lInternatishyonale (Neufchatel 1871) 102 110 8 AN Kuropatkin Memoiren (Berlin 1919)7174 9 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) 1423-24 111 10 1S Bloch Les Illusions de la Conquette Chinoise Revue des Revues (August 15 1900) 11 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) 14 12 Herold J Weins Chinas March toward the Tropics (Hamden Conn Shoe String Press 1954) 13 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) p 24 14 CH IQlKaKOB AHrJIO-PycCIltaH pacnpH cmgt 1885 15 HltIgtltIgteAopoB ltlgtHJIocoIllHH oOIIlero AeJIa - UHT no HltIgtltIgteAopoB COqHHeHHH M MbICJIb 1982 0 BJIHHHHH ltlgteAoshypOBa Ha llocToeBcKoro TOJICTOrO COJIOBbeBa BepAHeBa BYJIraKOBa HAP CM Stephen Lukashevich NF Fedorov - A Study in Russian Eupsychian and Utopian Thought (Newark University of Delaware Press 1977) pp 13-34 16 HltIgtltIgteAopoB CotJHHeHHH 1982 CTp 343 Sarkisyanz Op cit 210-211 HACeTHHUKHA PyccKHe MbICJIHTeJIH 0 KHTae XapoHH 1926 17 BJIaAHMHp JIbBOB 3araAotJHblA CTapHIlt JI COBeTcKHA nHshyCaTeJIb 1977 CTp 129-135 HltIgtltIgteAopoB CotJHHeHHH (962) CTp 335-336 18 HltIgtltIgteAopoB CotJHHeHHH CTp 216 340 382 669
146
19 TaM lKe CTp 300 20 BCCOJIOBbeB TPH pa3roBopa cms TPYA 1904 21 Malozemoff Russian Far Eastern Policy (1958) p 43 22 JIeHHH 0 BoAHe B KHTae - HCKpa 1 AeKaopH 1900 23 ABeJIbIA neTepoypr UHT no H3A London Penguin 1983 CTP 65 24 Sarkisyanz Russland und der Messianismus(1955) 200 21~218
25 AJIeKCaHAP BJIOK CTHxoTBopeHHH H n03Mbl TeaTp M XYAOlKeCTBeHHaH JIHTepaTypa 1968 CTp 644-645 26 C EceHHH CoopaHHe cotJHHeHHA Mbull 1970 T5 cTP 107 27 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) 42 98-99 28 Sarkisyanz Russland und der Messianismus(1955) 218~22
29 Malozernoff Russian Far Eastern Policy (1958)43-44 30 BH Sumner Russia and Europe Oxford Slavonic Papers (1951) II 1-16B Readings in Russian Civilization nOA peA Thomas Riha (Chicago University of Chicago Press 1964) 1147331 Malozemoff Russian Far Eastern Policy (1958) 43 Sarkisyanz Russland und der Messianismus (1955)378-91 32 Gollwitzer Geschichte (1982) I 138-40 33 Hermann Brunnhofer Russlands Hand Uber Asien Historischshygeographische Essays zur Entwick lungsgechichte des Russichen Reichsdenkens (S1 Petersburg 1897) npeAHCJIOBHe llBeAuapeu BpYHxolllep onpaBAblBaJI pyCCKylO 3IltCnaHCHIO B CpeAHeA A3HH H Ha llaJIbHeM BOCTOKe B cepHH cTaTeA BnepB~e onYOJIHKOBaHHbIx B neTepoyprcKHx ra3eTax Ha HeMeUKOM H3blKe St Petersburger Zeitung H St Petersburger Herold OH n~shyTaJICH OOOCHOBaTb PYCCKHA 3KcnaHCHOHH3M B A3HH CO~shyCTBeHHblMH H3bICKaHHHMH B apHAcKoA MHlIloJIorHH CpeAH ApyrHx paooT OH onYOJIHKOBaJI TpexToMHHK Urgechichte der Arier in Vorder-und Centralasien Historich-geographische Untersuchungen uber den altesten Schauplatz des Rigvedas und Avestas (Leipzig 1983) BpYHxolllep nepeBen TaKlKe o~beshyMHCTbIA OTtJeT KHH3H YXTOMCKoro 0 noe3AKe ueCapeBHqa HHKOJIaH Ha llaJIbHHA BOCTOK Orientreise seiner Kaiserlicher Hohe heit des Grossfursten Thronfolgers (Leipzig Brockhaus 1894 1998) 34 ltIgtHTIOTtJeB JIHpHKa HaYKa 1965 TI1 M CTp 118 35 Ein ostasiatischer Dreibund und die buddhistische Weltproshypaganda B KH BpYHxolllepa Russland Hand uber Aden (1897) 24-29 BnepB~e onYOJIHKOBaHa BSt Petersburger Zeitung B 1894 r
147
36 Louis Fischer The Soviets in the World Affairs (Princeton Princeton University Press 1951) n 534-37 Sir Fitzroy Maclean To the Back ofBeyond (London Cape 1974) 119-121 37 AKatteMHK BapTOJlbtt COllHHeHHR M H3tt-BO BOCTOllHoA JlHTepaTYpbI 1963 T2 cTp 164-166345-350 38 Hcxott K BOCTOKY npettllYBCTBHR H cBepmeHHR YTBepshy)l(tteHHe eBpa3HAueB CO(j)HR 1921 COttep)l(HT CTaTbH rBltJ)JloshypOBcKoro POMaHa HKoCicoHa nllCasllHHcKoro nH CaBHUshyKoro H HCTpyCieUKoro HH)I(e nepellHCJIRIOTCR OCHOBHhIe paCioTbI 0 espa3HAuax DS Mirsky The Eurasian Movement The Slavonic and East European Review (1927) 311-320 Otto Boss Die Lehre der Eurasier (Wiesbaden Harrasowitz 1961) H A Stammler Europe-Russland-Asian Der eurasiche Deutungsshyversuch der russichen Geschichte Osteuropa 12 (1962) 521-528 Gerges Nivat Du Panmongolisme au mouvement eurasien Cahiers du monde Russe et Sovietique 73 (1966) 460-78 Nicholas V Riasanovsky The Emergence of Eurasians California Slavic Studies 4 (1967) 39-72 39 HC TpylSeUKoA Espona H lIeJIOBelleCTBO CO(j)HR 192Q Mirsky The Eurasian Movement (1927) 312-13 V Riasanovsky Emergence of Eurasians (1967) 56 Leonid Luks Die Ideologie der Eurasier im zeitgeschichtlichen Zusammenhang Jahrbucher fur Geschichte Osteuropas 34 (1986) 374-395 40 llH CasHUKHA reOnOJlHTHlIeCKHe 3aMeTKH no PYCCKoA
HCTOpHH - B rB BepHattCKHA HallepTaHHe PYCCKoA HCshyTOpHH llpara 1927 CTp 234-260 CM TaK)I(e nHCasHUKHA reOrpa(j)HlIeCKHe ocolSeHHOCTH POCCHH 2 TT npara 1927 OH )l(e POCCHR - OCOlSblA reorpa(j)HlIecKHA MHp llapH)I( 1927 Charles Halperin Russia and the Steppe George Vernadsky and Eurasianism Forschungen zur osteuropaischen Geschichte 36 (1985) 55-194 and Slavic Studies 41 (1982)477-493 41 rB BepHattcKHA YKa3 COli CTp 230-231 259-260 Charles Halperin Opcit pp 99-104 42 V Riasanovsky The Emergence of Eurasians California Slavic Studies 4 (1967) 43 H Carrere dEncausse Decline of an Empire The Soviet Socialist Republics in Revolt (New York Harper 1981) 13-46
148
npOllBH)KEHHE POCCHH K lOrY
POCCHflCKHE llPOCTOPbI
Hepa3pemHMble npOCiJIeMbI CJlHRHHR pac B orpoMHoM MHOshyrOHaUHOHaJIbHOM KOHrJlOMepaTe Ha3blBaeMOM POCCHAcKOA (a n03ttHee coseTCKoA) eBpa3HAcKoA HMnepHeA eme CioJlee 01S0shyCTPRIOTCR B reorpa(j)HlIecKHx nOHRTHRX - B TpyttHeAmeM nposhyCTpaHcTseHHoM IIHcCiaJIaHce ttoBJIeIOmHM Hall olSmHM reOCTpashyTerHlIeCKHM nOJIO)l(eHHeM HMnepHH
MeTa(j)opHlIeCKH ynpomaR HCTOPHIO POCCHAcKOA HMnepHH nottllac CBOttRT K TparHlIeCKoA Ollep)l(HMOCTH npOCTopOM HJIH K TparHlIeCKOMY lIapy npOCTpaHCTsaI COrJlaCHO 3THM npettCTaBJIeHHRM PYCCKHX - H KaK OISOpOHRIOmHXCR H KaK arpeccopOB nOCTORHHO H Heyttep)l(HMO BJIeKJlH orpOMHble npOCTpaHCTBa Espa3HH PYCCKHe rOpllRTCR TeM liTO s HX rHshyraHTCKoA cyxonYTHoA TBepttbIHe MO)l(HO pa3MecTHTb 2-3 AMepHKH 40 ltJ)paHUHA H 93 BeJIHKOlSpHTaHHH Me)l(lIY 1600 H 1900 rr K PoccHAcKOA HMnepHH 1I0lSaBHJIOCb B olSmeA CJIO)l(HOCTH 17 MJIH KSattpaTHblx KHJIOMeTpOB HOBblX TeppHshyTOPHA s cpellHeM no 57 TbIC KBatlpaTHhIX KHJlOMeTpoB e)l(eshyrOttHo3 HCXOIlR H3 3Toro HeTpyttHO npHIITH K 3aKJIIOlIeHHIO liTO reorpa(j)HR H s caMOM tteJle OKa3b1BaJla BceCTopOHHee BJlHRHHe Ha pYCCKoe H coseTCKoe BOCnpHRTHe A3HH~
TaKHM 01Spa30M reorpa(j)HlIeamA (j)aKTOp HrpaeT orpOMshyHyIO pOJlb S HCTOPHH pYCCKoro Hapottaf ocolSeHHO B CBR3H C lIpe3MepHbiM YBJIelleHHeM HMnepHaJlHCTHlIeCKoA POCCHH npOCTpaHCTBaMH H TeppHTOpHRMH )lse reorpa(j)HlIeCKHe OCOshylSeHHOCTH OTJIHlIaIOT POCCHIO llepBaR - 3TO 0llHooeipa3He peJIbshye(j)a MeCTHOCTH MOHOTOHHOCTb JlaHttma(j)Ta n03S0JIHSmaR UeHTpaJIbHOA nOJIHTHlIeCKoA BJIaCTH nOllttep)l(HBaTb H pacshynpOCTpaHRTb csoA KOHTPOJIb no JIHHHH SeJIHKHX pellHhIx nyshyTeA TRHymHXCR no OCH ceBep-IOr TaKoA KOHTPOJlb oeiJlerllaJl ttBH)I(eHHe TosapOB KOJlOHHCTOB H BoACK~ no CJIOBaM BblllaIOmeshyrOCR HCTopHKa KJIIOlIeSCKoro 3KCnaHCHR MOCKBbI MO)l(eT paCCMaTpHBaTbCR KaK B03BblmeHHe ueHTpOCTpeMHTeJlbHOA CHJIbl 3aXBaTHBmeA KOHTPOJlb HatI HCTOKaMH lIeTblpex peK B
149
OllHaKO qTO B nOCJIellHHe llBa lleC$lTHJIeTH$I XIX BeKa npOH30shy
WeJI KpynHbIA CllBHr B pYCCKOA HMnepHaJIHCTHqeCKOA nOJIHTHshy
Ke KOToporo He 3aMeTHJI ctgtellOpOB B CpellHeA A3HH nOJIO)f(eshy
HHe nOflrH He H3MeHHerCH HeCMOTp$l Ha TO qTO BpHraHHH
COXpaHHer B 3rOM perHOHe craryc KBO A3HaTCKa$l nOJIHTHKa
POCCHH cOCpellOTOqHJIaCb Ha ~aJIbHeM BOCTOKe CTOJIKHOBeshy
HHe C $InOHCKoA 3KCnaHCHeA B KHTae H Kopee CTaJIO JIHWb Bonshy
POCOM BpeMeHH npellBHlleHHe 3Toro KOHJlJIHKTa HaJIO)f(HJIO
OTneqaTOK Ha Bce llHCKYCCHH 06 A3HH B cpelle PyccKoA HHshy
TeJIJIHreHUHH HMeHHO 3TO npellBHlleHHe llaJIO B03MO)f(HOCTb
CTOpoHHHKaM HlleH )f(eJIToA onacHoCTH OllOJIeTb yMepeHHbIX
nAHMOHrOnH3M
nO)f(aJIyA HHKTO He 6blJI 60JIee 3aXBaqeH npellCTaBJIeHHeM
o POCCHH KaK 0 3amHTHHue EBponbI OT HacTynalOmHx Opll a3Hshy
aTCKHX 3aXBaTqHKOB qeM BHllHbIA peJIHrH03HbiA JlHJIOCOJl H
MHCTHK BJIallHMHP COJIOBbeB (1853-1900 rr) CblH H3BeCTHoro
HCTopHKa CM COJIOBbeBa HBHO pacHcTcKHe ynpa)f(HeHH$I Coshy
JIOBbeBa Ha TeMY )f(eJIToA onaHocTH BpOlle 3HaMeHHToA noshy
3MbI naHMOHrOJIH3M (1894 rgt H nOCJIellHerO ero 3cce AHTHshy
XPHCT (1900 r) rlle H306pa)f(eHO HOBoe MOHrOJIbCKOe HaweCTshy
BHe Ha EBpony B XX BeKe noll BOllHTeJIbCTBOM HnoHHH 3aXBashy
THJIH Bo06pa)f(eHHe WHPOKOA ny6JIHKH H B POCCHH H BHe ee20
COJIOBbeB KaK H MHorne ero cOBpeMeHHHKH paJlleJI$lBWHe HllelO
)f(eJIToA onacHocTH BepHJI qTO pacbl KOTopble OH KJIaCCHshy
JlHUHpOBaJI KaK HH3wHe 06peqeHbi Ha nOllqHHeHHe BbICWHM
pacaM HJIH Ha HCqe3HOBeHHe JlHWb aHapxHcTbl BpOlle neTpa
KponoTKHHa21 OTBa)f(HBaJIHCb Bnp$lMylO B03pa)f(aTb npOTHB
B3rJI$IllOB COJIOBbeBa BOJIbWeBHKH lleJIaJIH TO )f(e HO HX B03shy
pa)f(eHH$I ObIJIH ynpOmeHHbIMH OHH npOBOllHJIH napaJIJIeJIb
Me)f(lly OJlHUHaJIbHOA nponaraHlloA )f(eJIToA onaCHOCTH H aHshy
THCeMHTH3MOM22
BJIH$lHHe nponoBelleA COJIOBbeBa HenOCpellCTBeHHO HcnbIshy
TaJIH pYCCKHe n03Tbl-CHMBOJIHCTbI B HX qHCJIe AHllpeA BeJIbIA23
H AJIeKcaHllp BJIOK B npOWJIOM - yqeHHK COJIOBbeBa n03Ma
middotCKHJlbI HanHCaHHa$l B KaHYH 3aKJIlOqeHH$I BpeCTCKoro MHpa
OTKpbIBaeTC$I 3nHrpaJloM H3 naHMOHrOJIH3Ma naHMOHroshy
JIH3M XOTb HM$I llHKOl Ho MHe JIaCKaeT CJIYX OHO JTa n03Ma
BJIOKa llaJIa HM$I ueJIOMY JIHTepaTYPHOMY HanpaBJIeHHIO24 BJIOK
nOTp$lCeHHblA TparHqeCKOA cYllbooA POCCHH HlleT HanepeKop
Hlle$lM CBoero yqHTeJI$I H OTCTaHBaeT COlO3 PYCCKHX H CKHJlOB
npOTHB HarJIoA EBponbl ero npellOCTepe)f(eHHe - HenpHKpblshy
Ta$l a3HaTflHHa
MHJIbOHbl- Bac Hac - TbMbl H TbMbl H TbMbI
nonpooyATe cpa3HTecb C HaMHI
~a CKHJlbl- MbI ~a a3HaTbl- Mbll
C pacKocblMH H )f(allHblMH oqaMHI
POCCH$I - CJlHHKC JlHKY$l H CKOPO$l
Ii OOJIHBaRCb qepHoA KPOBblO
OHa rJI$IllHT rJI$IllHT rJIMHT B Te6$1
Ii C HeHaBHCTblO H C JII060BblO2S
Y)f(e B 1923 r Korlla OOJIbWeBHCTCKaR POCCH$I n06ellHJIa
B rpa)f(llaHCKOA BoAHe llpyroA PYCCKHA n03T CepreA Eceshy
HHH nHllleT H3 repMaHHH HHKaK He CTapaRCb CKpbITb CBoero
r JIy60Koro OTBpameHH$I K EBpone nYCTb Mbl a3HaTbl nYCTh Mbl
BOH$leM nYCTb Mbl oeCCTbIllHO qellleM 3allHHUY Ha rJIa3aX y
Bcex nYCTb TaK HO HeT B Hac 3Toro 3anaxa rHHeHH$I HHKaKa$l
peBOJIIOUH$I 3lleCb HeB03MO)f(Ha Bce B 3aCToe B TynHKe TOJIbshy
KO HaweCTBHe BapBapOB BpOlle Hac MO)f(eT cnaCTH HX H nepeshy
lleJIaTb Be3 HalllecTBH$I Ha EBpony He OOOAlleTC$I 26 Ho HH Pycshy
CKoe 06mecTBo HH uapcKoe npaBHTeJIbCTBO He npHH$lJIH arpecshy
CHBHoA HlleOJIOrHH BOCTOqHHKOB OHH npOllOJI)f(aJIH CB$l3blshy
BaTh 6Yllymee POCCHH C TpallHUHOHHblMH HanpaBJIeHH$lMH HMshy
nepHaJIHCTHqeCKOA nOJIHTHKH cJlOKYCHpOBaHHbIMH Ha EBPOshy
ny C npellnOqTeHHeM 3KcnaHCHH uapH3Ma Ha BaJIKaHbI H K
npOJIHBaM BOJIee Toro pHCKOBaHHble a3HaTCKHe aBaHTlOpbl
KPHTHKOBaJIHCb neqaTblO KaK $IBHa$l JIOByIIIKa nOpO)f(lleHHaR
repMaHCKHM JI066H BCerlla HMeBIlIHM BJIH$lHHe B neTepoypre
CqHTaJIOCb qTO BbIllYMaHHaR HM a3HaTCKaR MHCCH$I POCCHH shy
orpOMHa$l llHBepCH$I KOTOpa$l llOJI)f(Ha 06JIerqHTb COOCTBeHshy
HblA repMaHCKHA llpaHr Hax OCTeH B UeHTpaJIbHOA EBpone
a 3aTeM H no BceA JIHHHH BepJIHH-Barllall27
-)f(EJITOPOCCH)1shy
CTpaHHOe H llBYCMbICJIeHHOe llBH)f(eHHe )I(eJITOpOCCH$I -
HaHOOJIee JIIOOOnbITHOe H KpaAHee KPbIJIO BOCTOqHHKOB nOJIshy
136 137
Hee BCerO ero H~eH OTpa~eH~ B pa60TaX H npe~npHHHMashy
TeRbCKOA ~e~TeRbHOCTH KH~3~ 3cnepa YXToMcKoro (1861shy
1921 rr) 3TOT BRa~eRel HeCKORbKHX ra3eT 6RH3KHA copaTHHK
BH~Horo rocy~apCTBeHHOrO ~emeR~ POCCHH C 10 BHTTe B noshy
nYR~pH3alHH H~eH TpaHccH6HPCKOA ~eRe3HoA ~oporH HaCTaBHHK 6y~y~ero HMnepaTopa HaCRe~Horo npHHla HHKOshy
Ra~ pa3BHBaR nopa~alO~He MeraROMaHHeA H~eH OCHOBaHHbIe
Ha cOMHHTeRbHoA TeopHH 0 ~K06bI OpraHHtIeCKOA 6RH30CTH
POCCHH K KHTalO H ~a~e K I1H~HH28 YXTOMCKHA neR ~H(I)HPaMshy6bI KHTaAcKoA lHBHRH3alHH HO CKpbITbIM HX ReATMoTHBOM
HeCOMHeHHO 6bIRa H~e~ ~eRToA onacHocTH To tITO HCTOshy
pHK 3MaR03eMOB Ha3bIBaR H~eOROrHtIeCKOA CYTblO HBOCTOtIshy
HHKOB OTpa~eHO B Kpe~O YXTOMCKOrO A3H~ - Mbl BCer~a
npHHa~Re~aRH K HeA MbI ~HRH ee ~H3HblO H O~~aRH ee HHshy
TepeCbI LJepe3 Hac BOCTOK npHweR K OC03HaHHIO ceo~ K BbICshy
meA ~H3HH HaM He HY~HO 3aBoeBaHHA Bce 3TH HapO~bI pa3shy
RHtIHbIX pac tIYBCTBYIOT npHT~~eHHe K HaM - KPOBblO Tpa~Hshy
lHeA H~e~MH MbI npOCTO 60Ree 6RH3KH HM HHTHMHO 3TOT Beshy
RH KHA H 3ar~OtIHbIA BOCTOK rOTOB CTaTb HawHM~9 TaKHM 06pa30M MO~HO 6bIRO 6bI CKa3aTb tITO onTHshy
MHCTHtIeCKa~ BepCH~ PycCKoA lHBHRH3aTopCKoA MHCCHH Ha
BOCTOKe (BO BC~KOM CRYtIae B ~eKRapalH~X) OCHOBaHHa~
Ha pacoBoA H KYRbTYPHOA aCCHMHRH~lHH HRH no MeHbmeA
Mepe Ha COTpY~HHtIeCTBe H TepnHMOCTH KOTOPYIO npOB03shy
r RaCHR BeHIOKOB B 70-e ro~~ XIX BeKa B OTHoweHHH Cpe~HeA
A3HH MorRa HaATH npHRo~eHHe H no OTHoweHHIO K BOCTOtIHOA
A3HH CaM BHTTe 6bIR CTOPOHHHKOM H~eH tITO POCCHACK~
HMnepH~ pacnORo~eHHa~ Me~~y 6Y~~HCTCKHM HH~HAcKHM H MYCYRbMaHCKHM MHpaMH ~BR~eTC~ MHpOM B ce6e CorRaCHO
3anHCKe no~aHHoA BHTTe laplO B 1893 r TO tITO OTRHtIaeT
POCCHIO OT 3ana~a - 3TO ee OC06bIA HalHOHaRbHbIA ~yx 3TOT
~yx Hap~~y C ~pyrHMH 3ReMeHTaMH CKpenR~IO~HMH POCshy
CHIO (reOrpajJHtIeCKOe nORo~eHHe npaBOCRaBHoe xpHCTHaHshy
CTBO H caMo~ep~aBHe) 06pa3yeT KpenKoe ~~po npOtIHO
06be~HHeHHoe HO cB060~Hoe OT HalHOHaRHCTHtIeCKOA HCshy
KRlOtIHTeRbHOCTH 06Ra~aeT orpOMHbIMH B03MO~HOCT~MH
~R~ ~py~eCTBeHHOrO 6paTCTBa H COTpY~HHtIeCTBa C caMbIMH
PaJRHtIHbIMH pacaMH H Hapo~aMHO B TOM ~e ro~y BHTTe no~aR laplO e~e O~HY ~OKRa~shy
HYIO 3anHCKY B KOTOpoA no~~ep~HBaR BeCbMa B3pbIBoonacshy
HYIO H COMHHTeRbHYIO H~elO BbI~BHHYTYIO neTpOM Ba~MaeBbIM
6YP~TCKHM leRHTeReM npHH~BwHM npaBOCRaBHe (ero
KpeCTHbIM OTlOM 6bIR HMnepaTOp AReKcaH~p III) CTpaHHbIA
nRaH OCHOBbIBaRC~ Ha CHCTeMaTHtIeCKOM npOHHKHOBeHHH
6YP~TOB 06yqeHHbIx PYCCKHMH B KatIeCTBe ToprOBbIX areHTOB
B 3a~HHA ~BOp KHTa~ - Ha 3an~HYIO nOrpaHHtIHYIO nOROCy
3eMeRb npOT~HYBWHXC~ OT CHHb13~Ha ~O MOHrORHH H MaHbtIshy
~YPHH BKRlOtI~ TH6eT B 1895-1897 rr nRaH 6bIR onp060BaH
HO nOTepneR nORHYIO Hey~atIY JlHHHeA npo~BH~eHH~ POCCHH
~OR~Ha 6bIRa CTaTb HOBa~ ~eRe3Ha~ ~opora Ha JlaHbtI~oy B
npOBHHlHH KaHcyA rRaBHbIM HanpaBReHHeM nO~PbIBHOA ~e~shy
TeRbHOCTH 6bIRa no~~ep~Ka aHTHKHTaAcKoro BOCCTaHH~
MOHrOROB m6eTleB H KHTaACKHX MYCYRbMaH ECRH 6bl nRaH
Ba~MaeBa OKa3aRC~ CTORb ~e ycnewHbIM KaK r RaBH~A nRaH
BHTTe - cTpoHTeRbcTBO TpaHccH6HPCKOA ~eRe3HOA ~oporH TO BHTTe 6bIR 6bI npaB B CBoeM 3aKRlOtIeHHH tITO ftc 6eperOB
THxoro OKeaHa H BepWHH rHMaRaeB POCCH~ 6y~eT BepWHTb
He TORbKO a3HaTCKHe HO H eBponeAcKHe ~eRaft 31 XOT~ BHTTe
CTapaRC~ tIT06bI MHp nOBepHR ero ~eKRapalH~M 0 cnoc06shy
HOCTH POCCHH ocy~ecTBHTb CBOIO MHCCHIO B A3HH MHPshy
H~MH H KYRbTypHbIMH MepaMH KOHetIHOA leRblO PYCshy
CKoA 3KcnaHCHH B A3HH nocpe~CTBOM ~eRe3Ho~opO~Horo
CTpOHTeRbCTBa H ToprOBbIX MeponpH~THA (KOTOpble B 3Hashy
tIHTeRbHoA Mepe a nO~tIac H nORHOCTblO cy6CH~HpOBaRHCb
rocy~apcTBOM) 6bIRO KOROHHaRbHoe rocnO~CTBo32 KaKoe-TO BpeM~ PYCCKHA HMnepHaRH3M B A3HH pa3BHBaRshy
C~ Ha BORHe onTHMH3Ma conpOBo~~aBwero CTpOHTeRbCTBO
TpaHCCH6HPCKOA MarHCTpaRH rRaBH~M nponaraH~HCTOM
3TOA ~oporH H CHCTeMaTHtIeCKOrO npOHHKHOBeHH~ POCCHH B
KHTaA tIepe3 MaHbtI~ypHIO 6bIR YXTOMCKHA Ero nOMO~HHK no CB~3~M C 3ana~HoA EBponoA repMaH BpYHxojJep (1841shy
1916 rr) tIYTb RH He B RHpHtIeCKHX TOHax onHCblBaR CBeTRoe
6y~y~ee EBpa3HH Bce pacbl CB~3aHHble OT BaRTHKH H LJepHoshy
ro MOp~ ~o THxoro OKeaHa 3TOA nOTp~calO~eA ~oporoA KOshy
Topa~ npHHeceT BbIrO~bl B3aHMHoMY ToproBoMy H KyRbTypshy
HOMY 06MeHY 6Y~YT ~HTb B nORHOM corRaCHH no~ CKHneTshy
POM lap~ B OTRHtIHe OT 6pHTaHleB B I1H~HH ~OKa3bIBaR
BpYHxoBep Y PyccKoro KpeCTb~HHHa H COR~aTa HeT tIyBcTBa
138 139
paCOBoro npeBOCXOllCTBa no OTHomeHHIO K a3HaTaM
KaH H TypaHCKaH KPOBb BCKope CMemaIOTCH B03HHKHyr HOBbie
nOrpaHHtlHbIe HapOllbI nOJIya3HaTcKoro nOJIyeBponeAcKoro
npOHCXOgtKlleHHH C03lla101IHe CBH3yJOlIee 3BeHO nOCpellCTBO
KOToporo CJIaBHHe ClleJIaIOT BblcmHe $OpMbl gtKH3HH C03llaHshy
Hble XpHCTHaHCKO-eBponeAcKoA KYJIbTYpoA llOCTynHblMH Bee elIe 3aKpblTOMY CepllLlY BHYTPeHHeA A3HH3
MOTHB 3TOT BeCbMa 3HaKOM HlleH MorJIa npHllTH tlyramp JIH
He OT BeHIOKOBa H llagtKe OT paHHero n03Ta-naHCJIaBHCTa TIOTshy
tleBa KOTOPblA B OllHOM H3 CBOHX CTpaHHblX CTHXOTBOpeHHR
PYCCKaH reorpa$HH (1848 r) MetlTaJI 0 5YllYlIeA poccHAcKOR
eBpoa3HaTcKoA HMnepHH OT HHJIa ll0 HeBbI OT 3JIb5bI ll0 KHshy
TaHIOT BOJIrH no EB$paT OT raHra ll0 llYHaH~ OllHaKO Pa3shy
pa50TaHHaH B rOllbI HnOHO-KHTaAcK09 BoAHbl (1894-1895 IT)
5pYHxo$epoBCKaH aHTHHMnepHaJIHCTHtleCKaH KOHLlenLlHft
)KeJITOpOCCHH HMeJIa HCHyJO nOJIHTHtlecKyJO LleJIb BpYHxo$ep
He TOJIbKO pHCOBaJI BeJIHtleCTBeHHYIO KapTHHY B03MOgtKHOro
CHM5H03a POCCHH H KHTaH HO H npellynpegtKllaJI 3anallHOe 0laquo5shy
lIeCTBO 05 3KcnaHCHOHHCTCKHX HaMepeHHHX SlnoHHH SInOHHft
noll $JIarOM 5YllllHCTCKOA COJIHllapHOCTH C03llaeT naHa3HaTCshy
KYIO 30HY BJIHHHHH CHatlaJIa OrpaHHtleHHYIO SInoHHeA Kopeshy
eA H KHTaeM Ho 3aTeM nOCJIe oKKynaLlHH TaAaaHH na 30Ha
nOCTeneHHO MOgtKeT pacmHpHTbCH Ha BCIO IOrO-BOCTOtlHYIO
A3HIO B ollHoA H3 CBOHX cTaTeA BpYHxo$ep C HeMaJI09 lloJIeR
np03peHHH nHCaJI 0 5YllYlIeA BeJIHKOA BOCTOtlHOa3HaTCKoR
c$epe COBMeCTHOrO npOLlBeTaHHH KOTOpaH B03HHKHeT 50 JIeT
cnycTH3S TeM He MeHee npellOCTepegtKeHHH BpYHxo$epa JIe)f(ashy
JIH BHYTPH cneKTpa HlleA gtKeJIToA onacHocTH KOTopbIe MO)f(shy
HO HaATH ygtKe Y B COJIOBbeBa H llagtKe elIe paHbme - Y K JIeoHshy
TbeBa HeCMOTpH Ha onTHMHCTHtleCKHe KapTHHbl 5YllYlIeR
ft)KeJITOpOcCHH BpYHxo$ep nO-BHllHMOMY 5bIJI 05ecnoKoeH
B03MOgtKHOCTblO Toro tlTO HHllYCTPHaJIH30BaHHble MaCCbl KHshy
TaALleB HatlHYT HeoTBpaTHMo npOllBHraTbCH Ha 3anall noll BOllHshy
TeJIbCTBOM HnOHLleB EllHHCTBeHHoA CHJIoA KOTOPaH CMO)f(eT
npoTHBOCTOHTb noA MOIIHOA 5YllllHCTCKOA BOJIHe llOKa3bIshy
BaJI BpYHxo$ep HBJIHeTCH PYCCKaH eBpOa3HaTCKaH HMnepHH
HeCKOJIbKO rpoTecKHoe B03pO)f(lleHHe 5YllllHCTCKOA TeMbI
npOH30mJIO B nepHOll rpaiKllaHCKOA B09Hbi B POCCHH CYshy
MaCmellmHA 5apoH $OH YHrepH-WTepH5epr eiblBmHA Llap-
CJltHR reHepaJI OTBeTHJI Ha PYCCKYIO peBOJIIOLlHIO nepeXOllOM B
ISYIlllH3M B 3HaK npoTecTa npoTHB Toro tlTO OH CtlHTaJI eiaHKshy
pOTCTBOM 3anaztHoA LlHBHJIH3aLlHH B 1921 r ero oeibellHHeHHbIA
llta3aLlKO-MOHrOJIbCKO-KHTaACKHR OTpHll 3aXBaTHJI YpiY CTOshy
nHUY BHemHeA MOHrOJIHH (HbIHe YJIaH-eiaTOP) rlle eiapoH eibIJ1
npOB03rJIameH HOBbIM lIHHrHCXaHoM OllHaKO HeCKOJIbKO MecHshy
ueB cnycTH YHrepH-WTeHeiepr 3TOT CHMBOJI a3HaTtlHHbI H
)KeJITOpOCCHH B OllHOM JIHLle nOTepneJI nOpa)f(eHHe OT 5oJIbshy
meBHKOB H eiblJI HMH paCCTpeJIHH36 Ba)f(HO OTMeTHTb tlTO 3Ta HlleOJIOrHH npOB03rJIamaBmaH
ISYllYlIee CJIHHHHe pac BO HMH eiOJIee OllHOPOllHOA EBpa3HH
(rlle gtKeJIaeMOe HepellKO BbIllaBaJIOCb 3a lleACTBHTeJIbHOCTb)
pa3YMeeTCH noll eiJIarOCKJIOHHbIM BOllHTeJIbCTBOM POCCHH
HHKOrlla He BJIHHJIa Ha npOLlecc npHHHTHH pemeHHA B neTepeiypshy
re KaKHM eibl Y3KHM HH eiblno onpelleJIeHHe noro npOLlecca
llnH Toro BpeMeHH B KOHetlHOM CtleTe (HCKJIlOtlaH anH30ll C Baztshy
MaeBbIM) B030einallaJIa peaJIbHaH nOJIHTHKa Ho B rOllbl rpa)f(shy
llaHCKoA B09Hbi H HeKOTopoe BpeMH nOCJIe ee OKOHtlaHHH eiOJIbshy
meBHCTCKaH POCCHH paCCMaTpHBaJIa CBOIO nOJIHTHKY B A3HH
CKopee KaK $YHKUHIO HlleOJIOrHH HlleH CMemeHHH CJIaBHHOshy
apHALleB H TypaHLleB nOJIb30BaJIaCb onpelleJIeHHOR nOllllep)f(shy
KoA JIHeiepaJIbHblX KpyrOB PYCCKoA HHTenJIHreHLlHH JIHmb ll0
Tex nop nOKa ypOBeHb p0gtKllaeMOCTH B POCCHH OCTaBaJICH Ollshy
HHM H3 caMbIX BbICOKHX B MHpe KaK 3TO eiblJIO npH LlapH3Me coshy
rJIaCHO llaHHbiM nepenHcH 1897 r 3TO cnocoeicTBOBaJIO H O$Hshy
LlHaJIbHOMY nOOlIpeHHIO KOJIOHH3aLlHH PycCKoA A3HH KpeCTbHshy
HaMH eBponeRcKoro npOHCXOgtKlleHHH B OCHOBHOM CJIaBHHaMH
HCnOJIb30BaHHe BblrOll OT OTKPbITHH CpellHeA A3HH H llaJIbshy
Hero BOCTOKa llnH PycCKoA KonOHH3aLlHH mno eibI 3HatlHTeJIbshy
HO MellJIeHHee H He eibIJIO eibI CTonb nOJIHblM 5e3 Toro BKJIalla
KOTOPblA BHecnH B 3TOT npOLlecc YtleHbIe CneLlHaJIHCTbl H
nYTemeCTBeHHHKH OHH OCTaBHnH COBeTCKOMY rOCYllapCTBY
npOtlHYIO TpallHLlHIO HaYtlHbIX HCCnellOBaHHA BbICOKoro
ypOBHH B ocoeieHHocTH B reorpa$HH H BOCTOKOBelleHHH
lla)f(e BbIllaIOIIHACH PYCCKHA BOCTOKOBell BaCHJIHA Bapshy
TOJIbll (1869-1930 rr) KOTOPbIA cYMeJI OCTaTbCH B cTopoHe
OT O$HLlHaJIbHOA nponaraHllbl H npH LlapH3Me H npH eiOJIbmeshy
BHKax B OCHOBHOM CorJIamancH C TeM tlTO OH CtlHTaJI HCTOPHshy
tlecKoA HeoeixOllHMOCTblO - C c03llaHHeM MHPOBbIX HMnepHA
141140
TaKHX KaK HMnepHH AJleKCaHIpa BeJlHKOrO MOHrOJlOS apaOOB
H la~e COSpeMeHHOR eMY POCCHRcKOR HMnepHH S CpelHeR
A3HH OH HCKpeHHe SepHJI 1JTO KpynHble CTpYKTYPbl C031alOT Jlyqshy
mHe YCJlOSHH lJIH KYJlbTypHOrO c6J1H~eHHH HapOlOS pa3J1H1Jshy
HbIX pac HeCMOTpH Ha sce 6elcTsHH KOTopble HecyT SORHbI
conpoSo~IalOlI(He C031aHHe TaKHX HMnepHR~7
HCXO~ HA BOCTOK TPYBEQKOA H CABHQKHA
HeCMOTpH Ha HeYIa1JH CSH3aHHble C PYCCKO-HnOHCKOR H
nepsoR MHposoR soRHaMH PYCCKHe npeTeH3HH Ha oc06ble
OTHOmeHHH C A3HeR npolOJl~aJlH ~HTb cpelH HHTeJlJlHreHshy
QHH a S rOlbI peSOJlIOQHH rp~IaHcKoR SORHbl H cpa3Y ~e nocshy
Jle HHX TaKHe npereH3HH la~e YCHJlHJlHCb Hp1Je scero 3TO 80shy
nJlOTHJlOCb B eSpa3HRCKOM lSH~eHHH KOTopoe cnJlOTHJlO cashy
Mble 6J1ecTHII(He yMbi PYCCKoR 3MHrpaQHH 1920-x rolos Heshy
CMOTPH Ha HepelKHe pa3HorJlaCHH OHH 6blJlH y6e~IeHbl 1JTO
JlHlUb SOCnpHHHS oc060e eBpa3HRcKoe MHpOS033peHHe MO~HO
coxpaHHTb oc060CTb PYCCKoro SKJlala S QHSHJlH3aQHIO OCHOshy
saHHoro KaK Ha rpeKO-SH3aHTHRCKOM TaK H Ha MOHrOJlbCKOM
HaCJlelHH B csoeM nepSOM MaHHlIJecTe l1cxol Ha SOCTOK
(1921 r) lBa SbIIaIOII(HXCH JlHHrBHCTa KHH3b HHKoJlaR Tpy6eQshy
KoR H POMaH HK06coH OTCTaHBaJIH espa3HRcKoe CJlHHHHe H3blshy
KOS H KYJlbTYP (TaK Ha3b1BaeMaH TeOpllH H3bIKOBoro COI03a -
Sprachbund) C03HaTeJlbHO npeYBeJlH1JHBaH SJlHHHHe TypaHcKoshy
ro 3J1eMeHTa38
EBpa3HRQbl C1JHTaJlH 60JlblUeBHKoB H MapKcH3M XYIIUHM
CJlelCTBHeM 3analHoR KYJlbTYPbl OlHaKO caMoe peBOJlIOQHIO
OHH paccMaTpHBaJlH KaK BeJlHKHR H He06XOlHMblR KaTaJlH3ashy
TOp OHa pa3pYIUHJla CTapblR MHp H np06YIHJla OlHospeMeHHO
H PYCCKHe MaCCbl H HapOlbl BOCTOKa n03TOMY pa60Ta Tpy6eQshy
Koro EBpona H 1JeJlOBe1JeCTBo lt1920 r) 1JHTaeTCH KaK HeKoe
C01JeTaHHe lIaHHJleSCKOro H npH3biSOS sToporo KOHrpecca Koshy
MHHTepHa JTO pemHTeJlbHOe 06BHHeHHe 3analHoMY HMneshy
PHaJIH3MY KOTopoe oTBepraeT eBpOQeHTpHCTCKHR nolXOl K
A3HH YHH~eHHe HcnblTaHHoe PoccHeR S XOle BoRHbl H peBoshy
JlIOQHH nHmeT Tpy6eQKoR Mo~eT C031aTb HenOBTopHMYIO
B03MO~HOCTb palHKaJlbHOrO nepecMoTpa OTHOmeHHH K Hepycshy
CKHM HapOlaM POCCHH 6YIYIJH CaMa KOJlOHHeR Mo~eT noshy
142
BeCTH lpyrHe KOJlOHHH B oc06eHHocTH CSOHX laquoa3HaTCKHX cecshy
Tepraquo Ha pelUHTeJlbHYIO 60Pb15y npoTHB pOMaHo-repMaHcKHx
KOJlOHH3aTopOB 39
OlHHM H3 caMbiX opHrHHaJlbHblX MblCJlHTeJleR CpelH
eBpa3HRQes I5blJl reorpallJ neTp CasHQKHR (1895-1968 rr) Coshy
rJlaCHO ero KOHQenQHH Espa3HH - nOlJlHHHaH KYJlbTypHOshy
reorpaIlJH1JeCKaH Ol5lI(HOCTb C lOOaS01JHblM nOTeHQHaJIOM Tepshy
pHTOpHaJlbHOR 3KcnaHCHH (MecTopa3sHTHe HJlH TonoreHeshy
3HC) rOSOpH 0 Ha1JaslUeRcH S XIX BeKe 3KCnaHCHH POCCHH Ha
lOr H SOCTOK CasHQKHR nblTaeTCH npenOlHecTH ee KaK 060shy
pOHHTeJlbHYIO Mepy S PaMKax nOHHTHH npOlsHHYTOR rpaHHshy
QbI HeCOMHeHHO aHaJlOrH1JHOrO TOMy nOHHTHIO KOTopoe
0150CHoBblBaJIO I5pHTaHcKYIO nOJIHTHKY B I1HIHH 50Jlee Toro
CaBHQKHR loKa3blsaeT 1JTO PYCCKYIO 3KcnaHCHIO B QeJIOM MO~HO
paccMaTpHsaTb KaK HenpepblSHblR npoQecc opraHH1JeCKOrO
pa3SHTHH B ero onHcaHHH 3TO BHIHTCH 1JYTb JlH He KaK 3KOshy
JlOrH1JeCKHR npoQecc l5e3 KaKOR-JlHI50 nOJIHTH1JeCKOR MOTHshy
SHPOBKH CKpblBalOlI(eRcH 3a HHM H HMnepHaJIHCTH1JeCKOrO COshy
nepHH1JeCTBa BeJlHKHX lep~as CSH3aHHOro CO cpelHea3HaTCshy
KHM H laJIbHeBOCT01JHblM sonpocaMH CJlelOSaTeJlbHO lOKa3b1shy
BaeT CaBHQKHR PYCCKaR EBpa3HR eCTb reonOJlHTH1JeCKOe elHHshy
CTSO B ce6e C031aHHOe KYJlbTYPHblM npOQeCCOM reHeTH1JeCshy
KoR MyTaQHH a He nOcpelCTSOM 3asoeBaHHA H pa3pyweHHA~ KaK BHIHM TaKOe TOJlKOBaHHe He CJIHWKOM OTJlH1JaeTCR OT KOHshy
QenQHH IHHaMH1JeCKOrO ~H3HeHHoro npOCTpaHCTBa CPPHIPHshy
xa PaTQeJlR KOTOPYlO KapJl XaycxollJep npHHRJI B 20-e rOlbl
EBPA3HAcKOE CBRH)f(EHHE H CRHHHHE
BeCbMa JlI060nbiTHO HBHOe CXOlCTBO Me~IY CJlOBapeM eBshy
pa3HAQeB H COBeTCKoA TepMHHOJlOrHeA xpYlI(eBCKoA 3nOXH
OTHOCHTeJIbHO KYJIbTypHO-HaQHOHaJIbHOrO CJIHRHHR nol JlIOshy
60BHbiM Hal30pOM CTapmero PYCCKoro 6paTa B pa60Tax nCashy
SHQKoro H B oc06eHHocTH B TpYIaX HCTopHKa r BepHaICKOshy
ro HepelKO BCTpe1JaIOTCR TepMHHbl CJ1HJ1HHe H nepeMeJIJHBashy
HHe 1JTO RKOl5bl HMeeT MeCTO B npoQecce TeppHTOpHaJlbHOR
3KcnaHCHH KYJlbMHHaQHR KOTOpoA - 1IJ0pMHpoBaHHe BeJlHshy
KOPYCCKOA KYJlbTYPbl TaK 3aMe1JaHHe BepHalCKoro 1JTO nol
BHeWHHM pa3Ho06pa3HeM CKpblBaeTCH BHYTpeHHee elHHCTBO
143
HanOMHHaeT pacxo)l(ee COBeTCKOe nOHHTHe 0 eQHHCTBe 8
MHorootlpa3HH
B MaHepe He CJIHmKOM OTJIHLlalOIleRcH OT COBeTCKHX CTaH~
QapTOB BepHaQCKHR QOKa3bIBaJI LITO BKJIIOLleHHe HepYCCKHX
rpynn B MHorOHauHOHaJIbYIO eBpa3HRcKYIO HMnepHIO C03Qa~
eT orpOMHbIe 3KOHOMHLleCKHe H KYJIbTypHbIe npeHMYIlIeCTBa O~~
HaKO BepHaQCKHR HaCTaHBaJI npH 3TOM LITO eQHHCTBO QOJI)I(HO
tlbITb 3KYMeHHLleCKHM tle3 HaBH3bIBaHHH HtlO PoccHRcKoe
rocy~apcTBO - eBpa3HRcKoe rOCYQapCTBO H Bce OTQeJIbHbIe
HaUHOHaJIbHOCTH Espa3HH QOJI)I(Hbl LlYBCTBOBaTb LITO 3TO HX
rocy~apcTBO H npH3HaBaTb ero (KypCHB BepHaQCKOrO) CHJIa
3Toro eBpa3HRcKoro otlpa30BaHHH JIe)l(HT B ero CBOtlOQHOM
KYJIbTYPHOM TBopLleCTBe41 KpOMe Toro Qa)l(e eCJIH PycCKHR
HapoQ otlpa3yeT rJIaBHYIO CHJIY eBpa3HRCKoro rocy~apcTBa a
PYCCKHR H3b1K - tla30BbiR CJIoR eBpa3HRcKoR KYJIbTYPbI Bce
3TO HeJIb3H HaBH3b1BaTb QpyrHM Hapo~aM HeCMOTpH Ha BeJIH~
LlHe 3THX HQeR BbICKa3bIBaBmHXCH eBpa3HRuaMH-3MHrpaHTaMH
He HecmHMH HHKaKoR nOJIHTHLIeCKoR OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH H
HMeSmHMH BeCbMa MaJIOe BJIHHHHe B HOBOA COBeTCKoR eBposhy
a3HaTCKoR HMnepHH QPyme CJIaBHHCKHe HapO~bI B ocotleHshy
HOCTH HaHtlOJIee MHOrOLlHCJIeHHble cnoCJIe PYCCKHX) HanpHshy
Mep YKPaHHUbl H nOJIHKH HcnblTbIBaJIH rJIytloKoe HeQOBepHe
K ueJIHM eBpa3HRueB H BbICTYaJIH npOTHB HHX2 K CO)l(aJIeHHIO
HHLlero He H3seCTHO 0 peaKUHH Ha TeopHH eBpa3HAueB a3HaTshy
CKHX HHTeJIJIeKTyaJIOB )l(HBmHX noQ COBeTCKHM pe)l(HMOM
MO)l(HO OQHaKO tle30mHtloLiHo nOJIaraTb LITO OHH BHQeJIH B
3THX TeOpHHX JIHmb YTOHLleHHoe onpaSQaHHe PYCCKoro HMneshy
pHaJIH3Ma
TaKHM otlpa30M eBpa3HRcKoe ~BH)I(eHHe caMO Toro He
C03HaBaH cnoc06CTBOBaJIO $OpMHPOBaHHIO YTonHLleCKoro 06shy
pa3a coseTCKoro LleJIOBeKa - HCKyccTBeHHoro nOpO)l(~eHHH
COBeTCKoR nponaraHQbl He HMelOIlero KaKOrO-JIH60 paCOBoro
HJIH 3THHLleCKOro npOHCXO)l(QeHHH HO rOBOpHIlero no-pYCCKH
H OIlYIlalOIlero ce6H KOHeLiHO )l(e PYCCKHM COBeTCKaH MOshy
QeJIb - TpOHua COCTOHIlaH H3 Tpex CTaQHA - paCUBeT-c6JIHshy
)l(eHHe-CJIHHHHe BeCbMa pa3BHTaH B 3noxy XPYIleBa pa3Hshy
TeJIbHO HanOMHHaeT eBpa3HRcKoe BHQeHHe 1920-x rO~OB OHa
OTpa)l(aeT TaK)I(e HCTopHLIeCKHA onbIT HaKOnJIeHHblA PycCKOR
HHTeJIJIHreHUHeR no HaUHOHaJIbHblM H paCOBblM BonpocaM
KOTopbIe PYCCKHe MbICJIHTeJIH BnepBble nO~HHJIH B XIX B
144
KaK nOKa3blBaeT 3JIeH Kappep Ii AHKOC BCsl COBeTCKasl
(OHuenUHH B otlJIaCTH onpeQeJIeHHH H 3aKOHHoro O$opMJIeHHsl
OTHomeHHA Me)l(~y PYCCKHMH H HepyccKHMH npeTepneJIa
MHO)l(eCTBO H3MeHeHHA43 B npoTHBOnOJIO)l(HOCTb neHHHcKoR
yTOnHH OTMHpaHHsl HauHA H rocYQapcTB H 3aMeHbl HX HOBblM
YHHBepCaJIbHbIM OOIlecTBOM npOJIeTapCKoA KJIaCCOBOR COJIHshy
~apHOCTH 60JIee )l(ecToKHA H OCMOTpHTeJIbHbIA CTaJIHH
nocTeneHHo npe06pa30BaJI HQelO $eQepaUHH B H~elO ueHT~
paJIH30BaHHHoro PyccKoro HaQ30pa HaQ $opMaJIbHO aBTOshy
HOMHbIMH HapoQaMH COBeTcKoro COI03a 3Ta peaJIbHOCTb npeshy
BpaTHJIa Bee COBeTCKHe TeopHH no HaUHOHaJIbHOMY Bonpocy B
nycTOnOpO)l(HHe ynpa)l(HeHHH H3 KOTOPblX H~eH CTaJIHHa TaK
H He 6blJIH YCTpaHeHbl BbI)I(HBaHHe MHorOHaUHOHaJIbHOR
eBpa3HAcKoA TeppHTOpHaJIbHOA KpenOCTH nO-npe)l(HeMY
ynpaBJIHeMOA MYQPbIM CTapmHM PYCCKHM 6paTOM 6YQeT
3aBHCeTb npe)l(Qe Bcero OT pemeHHH nOQHHTbIX eBpa3HAuaMH
BonpOCOB
145
flpHMeqaHHR
1 Andrew Malozemoff Russian Far Eastern Policy 1881-1904 (Berkeley University of California Press 1958) 42 2 FF von Martens Russland und England in Zentralasien (St Petersburg 1880) Heinz Gollwitzer Geschichte des wetpolischen denkens (Gottingen Vandenhoeck amp Ruprecht 1982) 152-70 133-36 3 F F von Martens Le Conflict entre la Russie et la Chine (Bruxel~
les 1880) 4 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) 93-103 WP Wassiliew Die Erschliessung Chinas (Leipzig 1909) 5 WP Wassiliew Die Erschliessung Chinas (Leipzig 1909)49 6 NM Prejevalsky From Kulja accross the Tian Shan to Lob-Nor (London Sampson Low 1879) 7 MA Bakunin La theologie politique de Mazzini et lInternatishyonale (Neufchatel 1871) 102 110 8 AN Kuropatkin Memoiren (Berlin 1919)7174 9 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) 1423-24 111 10 1S Bloch Les Illusions de la Conquette Chinoise Revue des Revues (August 15 1900) 11 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) 14 12 Herold J Weins Chinas March toward the Tropics (Hamden Conn Shoe String Press 1954) 13 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) p 24 14 CH IQlKaKOB AHrJIO-PycCIltaH pacnpH cmgt 1885 15 HltIgtltIgteAopoB ltlgtHJIocoIllHH oOIIlero AeJIa - UHT no HltIgtltIgteAopoB COqHHeHHH M MbICJIb 1982 0 BJIHHHHH ltlgteAoshypOBa Ha llocToeBcKoro TOJICTOrO COJIOBbeBa BepAHeBa BYJIraKOBa HAP CM Stephen Lukashevich NF Fedorov - A Study in Russian Eupsychian and Utopian Thought (Newark University of Delaware Press 1977) pp 13-34 16 HltIgtltIgteAopoB CotJHHeHHH 1982 CTp 343 Sarkisyanz Op cit 210-211 HACeTHHUKHA PyccKHe MbICJIHTeJIH 0 KHTae XapoHH 1926 17 BJIaAHMHp JIbBOB 3araAotJHblA CTapHIlt JI COBeTcKHA nHshyCaTeJIb 1977 CTp 129-135 HltIgtltIgteAopoB CotJHHeHHH (962) CTp 335-336 18 HltIgtltIgteAopoB CotJHHeHHH CTp 216 340 382 669
146
19 TaM lKe CTp 300 20 BCCOJIOBbeB TPH pa3roBopa cms TPYA 1904 21 Malozemoff Russian Far Eastern Policy (1958) p 43 22 JIeHHH 0 BoAHe B KHTae - HCKpa 1 AeKaopH 1900 23 ABeJIbIA neTepoypr UHT no H3A London Penguin 1983 CTP 65 24 Sarkisyanz Russland und der Messianismus(1955) 200 21~218
25 AJIeKCaHAP BJIOK CTHxoTBopeHHH H n03Mbl TeaTp M XYAOlKeCTBeHHaH JIHTepaTypa 1968 CTp 644-645 26 C EceHHH CoopaHHe cotJHHeHHA Mbull 1970 T5 cTP 107 27 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) 42 98-99 28 Sarkisyanz Russland und der Messianismus(1955) 218~22
29 Malozernoff Russian Far Eastern Policy (1958)43-44 30 BH Sumner Russia and Europe Oxford Slavonic Papers (1951) II 1-16B Readings in Russian Civilization nOA peA Thomas Riha (Chicago University of Chicago Press 1964) 1147331 Malozemoff Russian Far Eastern Policy (1958) 43 Sarkisyanz Russland und der Messianismus (1955)378-91 32 Gollwitzer Geschichte (1982) I 138-40 33 Hermann Brunnhofer Russlands Hand Uber Asien Historischshygeographische Essays zur Entwick lungsgechichte des Russichen Reichsdenkens (S1 Petersburg 1897) npeAHCJIOBHe llBeAuapeu BpYHxolllep onpaBAblBaJI pyCCKylO 3IltCnaHCHIO B CpeAHeA A3HH H Ha llaJIbHeM BOCTOKe B cepHH cTaTeA BnepB~e onYOJIHKOBaHHbIx B neTepoyprcKHx ra3eTax Ha HeMeUKOM H3blKe St Petersburger Zeitung H St Petersburger Herold OH n~shyTaJICH OOOCHOBaTb PYCCKHA 3KcnaHCHOHH3M B A3HH CO~shyCTBeHHblMH H3bICKaHHHMH B apHAcKoA MHlIloJIorHH CpeAH ApyrHx paooT OH onYOJIHKOBaJI TpexToMHHK Urgechichte der Arier in Vorder-und Centralasien Historich-geographische Untersuchungen uber den altesten Schauplatz des Rigvedas und Avestas (Leipzig 1983) BpYHxolllep nepeBen TaKlKe o~beshyMHCTbIA OTtJeT KHH3H YXTOMCKoro 0 noe3AKe ueCapeBHqa HHKOJIaH Ha llaJIbHHA BOCTOK Orientreise seiner Kaiserlicher Hohe heit des Grossfursten Thronfolgers (Leipzig Brockhaus 1894 1998) 34 ltIgtHTIOTtJeB JIHpHKa HaYKa 1965 TI1 M CTp 118 35 Ein ostasiatischer Dreibund und die buddhistische Weltproshypaganda B KH BpYHxolllepa Russland Hand uber Aden (1897) 24-29 BnepB~e onYOJIHKOBaHa BSt Petersburger Zeitung B 1894 r
147
36 Louis Fischer The Soviets in the World Affairs (Princeton Princeton University Press 1951) n 534-37 Sir Fitzroy Maclean To the Back ofBeyond (London Cape 1974) 119-121 37 AKatteMHK BapTOJlbtt COllHHeHHR M H3tt-BO BOCTOllHoA JlHTepaTYpbI 1963 T2 cTp 164-166345-350 38 Hcxott K BOCTOKY npettllYBCTBHR H cBepmeHHR YTBepshy)l(tteHHe eBpa3HAueB CO(j)HR 1921 COttep)l(HT CTaTbH rBltJ)JloshypOBcKoro POMaHa HKoCicoHa nllCasllHHcKoro nH CaBHUshyKoro H HCTpyCieUKoro HH)I(e nepellHCJIRIOTCR OCHOBHhIe paCioTbI 0 espa3HAuax DS Mirsky The Eurasian Movement The Slavonic and East European Review (1927) 311-320 Otto Boss Die Lehre der Eurasier (Wiesbaden Harrasowitz 1961) H A Stammler Europe-Russland-Asian Der eurasiche Deutungsshyversuch der russichen Geschichte Osteuropa 12 (1962) 521-528 Gerges Nivat Du Panmongolisme au mouvement eurasien Cahiers du monde Russe et Sovietique 73 (1966) 460-78 Nicholas V Riasanovsky The Emergence of Eurasians California Slavic Studies 4 (1967) 39-72 39 HC TpylSeUKoA Espona H lIeJIOBelleCTBO CO(j)HR 192Q Mirsky The Eurasian Movement (1927) 312-13 V Riasanovsky Emergence of Eurasians (1967) 56 Leonid Luks Die Ideologie der Eurasier im zeitgeschichtlichen Zusammenhang Jahrbucher fur Geschichte Osteuropas 34 (1986) 374-395 40 llH CasHUKHA reOnOJlHTHlIeCKHe 3aMeTKH no PYCCKoA
HCTOpHH - B rB BepHattCKHA HallepTaHHe PYCCKoA HCshyTOpHH llpara 1927 CTp 234-260 CM TaK)I(e nHCasHUKHA reOrpa(j)HlIeCKHe ocolSeHHOCTH POCCHH 2 TT npara 1927 OH )l(e POCCHR - OCOlSblA reorpa(j)HlIecKHA MHp llapH)I( 1927 Charles Halperin Russia and the Steppe George Vernadsky and Eurasianism Forschungen zur osteuropaischen Geschichte 36 (1985) 55-194 and Slavic Studies 41 (1982)477-493 41 rB BepHattcKHA YKa3 COli CTp 230-231 259-260 Charles Halperin Opcit pp 99-104 42 V Riasanovsky The Emergence of Eurasians California Slavic Studies 4 (1967) 43 H Carrere dEncausse Decline of an Empire The Soviet Socialist Republics in Revolt (New York Harper 1981) 13-46
148
npOllBH)KEHHE POCCHH K lOrY
POCCHflCKHE llPOCTOPbI
Hepa3pemHMble npOCiJIeMbI CJlHRHHR pac B orpoMHoM MHOshyrOHaUHOHaJIbHOM KOHrJlOMepaTe Ha3blBaeMOM POCCHAcKOA (a n03ttHee coseTCKoA) eBpa3HAcKoA HMnepHeA eme CioJlee 01S0shyCTPRIOTCR B reorpa(j)HlIecKHx nOHRTHRX - B TpyttHeAmeM nposhyCTpaHcTseHHoM IIHcCiaJIaHce ttoBJIeIOmHM Hall olSmHM reOCTpashyTerHlIeCKHM nOJIO)l(eHHeM HMnepHH
MeTa(j)opHlIeCKH ynpomaR HCTOPHIO POCCHAcKOA HMnepHH nottllac CBOttRT K TparHlIeCKoA Ollep)l(HMOCTH npOCTopOM HJIH K TparHlIeCKOMY lIapy npOCTpaHCTsaI COrJlaCHO 3THM npettCTaBJIeHHRM PYCCKHX - H KaK OISOpOHRIOmHXCR H KaK arpeccopOB nOCTORHHO H Heyttep)l(HMO BJIeKJlH orpOMHble npOCTpaHCTBa Espa3HH PYCCKHe rOpllRTCR TeM liTO s HX rHshyraHTCKoA cyxonYTHoA TBepttbIHe MO)l(HO pa3MecTHTb 2-3 AMepHKH 40 ltJ)paHUHA H 93 BeJIHKOlSpHTaHHH Me)l(lIY 1600 H 1900 rr K PoccHAcKOA HMnepHH 1I0lSaBHJIOCb B olSmeA CJIO)l(HOCTH 17 MJIH KSattpaTHblx KHJIOMeTpOB HOBblX TeppHshyTOPHA s cpellHeM no 57 TbIC KBatlpaTHhIX KHJlOMeTpoB e)l(eshyrOttHo3 HCXOIlR H3 3Toro HeTpyttHO npHIITH K 3aKJIIOlIeHHIO liTO reorpa(j)HR H s caMOM tteJle OKa3b1BaJla BceCTopOHHee BJlHRHHe Ha pYCCKoe H coseTCKoe BOCnpHRTHe A3HH~
TaKHM 01Spa30M reorpa(j)HlIeamA (j)aKTOp HrpaeT orpOMshyHyIO pOJlb S HCTOPHH pYCCKoro Hapottaf ocolSeHHO B CBR3H C lIpe3MepHbiM YBJIelleHHeM HMnepHaJlHCTHlIeCKoA POCCHH npOCTpaHCTBaMH H TeppHTOpHRMH )lse reorpa(j)HlIeCKHe OCOshylSeHHOCTH OTJIHlIaIOT POCCHIO llepBaR - 3TO 0llHooeipa3He peJIbshye(j)a MeCTHOCTH MOHOTOHHOCTb JlaHttma(j)Ta n03S0JIHSmaR UeHTpaJIbHOA nOJIHTHlIeCKoA BJIaCTH nOllttep)l(HBaTb H pacshynpOCTpaHRTb csoA KOHTPOJIb no JIHHHH SeJIHKHX pellHhIx nyshyTeA TRHymHXCR no OCH ceBep-IOr TaKoA KOHTPOJlb oeiJlerllaJl ttBH)I(eHHe TosapOB KOJlOHHCTOB H BoACK~ no CJIOBaM BblllaIOmeshyrOCR HCTopHKa KJIIOlIeSCKoro 3KCnaHCHR MOCKBbI MO)l(eT paCCMaTpHBaTbCR KaK B03BblmeHHe ueHTpOCTpeMHTeJlbHOA CHJIbl 3aXBaTHBmeA KOHTPOJlb HatI HCTOKaMH lIeTblpex peK B
149
Hee BCerO ero H~eH OTpa~eH~ B pa60TaX H npe~npHHHMashy
TeRbCKOA ~e~TeRbHOCTH KH~3~ 3cnepa YXToMcKoro (1861shy
1921 rr) 3TOT BRa~eRel HeCKORbKHX ra3eT 6RH3KHA copaTHHK
BH~Horo rocy~apCTBeHHOrO ~emeR~ POCCHH C 10 BHTTe B noshy
nYR~pH3alHH H~eH TpaHccH6HPCKOA ~eRe3HoA ~oporH HaCTaBHHK 6y~y~ero HMnepaTopa HaCRe~Horo npHHla HHKOshy
Ra~ pa3BHBaR nopa~alO~He MeraROMaHHeA H~eH OCHOBaHHbIe
Ha cOMHHTeRbHoA TeopHH 0 ~K06bI OpraHHtIeCKOA 6RH30CTH
POCCHH K KHTalO H ~a~e K I1H~HH28 YXTOMCKHA neR ~H(I)HPaMshy6bI KHTaAcKoA lHBHRH3alHH HO CKpbITbIM HX ReATMoTHBOM
HeCOMHeHHO 6bIRa H~e~ ~eRToA onacHocTH To tITO HCTOshy
pHK 3MaR03eMOB Ha3bIBaR H~eOROrHtIeCKOA CYTblO HBOCTOtIshy
HHKOB OTpa~eHO B Kpe~O YXTOMCKOrO A3H~ - Mbl BCer~a
npHHa~Re~aRH K HeA MbI ~HRH ee ~H3HblO H O~~aRH ee HHshy
TepeCbI LJepe3 Hac BOCTOK npHweR K OC03HaHHIO ceo~ K BbICshy
meA ~H3HH HaM He HY~HO 3aBoeBaHHA Bce 3TH HapO~bI pa3shy
RHtIHbIX pac tIYBCTBYIOT npHT~~eHHe K HaM - KPOBblO Tpa~Hshy
lHeA H~e~MH MbI npOCTO 60Ree 6RH3KH HM HHTHMHO 3TOT Beshy
RH KHA H 3ar~OtIHbIA BOCTOK rOTOB CTaTb HawHM~9 TaKHM 06pa30M MO~HO 6bIRO 6bI CKa3aTb tITO onTHshy
MHCTHtIeCKa~ BepCH~ PycCKoA lHBHRH3aTopCKoA MHCCHH Ha
BOCTOKe (BO BC~KOM CRYtIae B ~eKRapalH~X) OCHOBaHHa~
Ha pacoBoA H KYRbTYPHOA aCCHMHRH~lHH HRH no MeHbmeA
Mepe Ha COTpY~HHtIeCTBe H TepnHMOCTH KOTOPYIO npOB03shy
r RaCHR BeHIOKOB B 70-e ro~~ XIX BeKa B OTHoweHHH Cpe~HeA
A3HH MorRa HaATH npHRo~eHHe H no OTHoweHHIO K BOCTOtIHOA
A3HH CaM BHTTe 6bIR CTOPOHHHKOM H~eH tITO POCCHACK~
HMnepH~ pacnORo~eHHa~ Me~~y 6Y~~HCTCKHM HH~HAcKHM H MYCYRbMaHCKHM MHpaMH ~BR~eTC~ MHpOM B ce6e CorRaCHO
3anHCKe no~aHHoA BHTTe laplO B 1893 r TO tITO OTRHtIaeT
POCCHIO OT 3ana~a - 3TO ee OC06bIA HalHOHaRbHbIA ~yx 3TOT
~yx Hap~~y C ~pyrHMH 3ReMeHTaMH CKpenR~IO~HMH POCshy
CHIO (reOrpajJHtIeCKOe nORo~eHHe npaBOCRaBHoe xpHCTHaHshy
CTBO H caMo~ep~aBHe) 06pa3yeT KpenKoe ~~po npOtIHO
06be~HHeHHoe HO cB060~Hoe OT HalHOHaRHCTHtIeCKOA HCshy
KRlOtIHTeRbHOCTH 06Ra~aeT orpOMHbIMH B03MO~HOCT~MH
~R~ ~py~eCTBeHHOrO 6paTCTBa H COTpY~HHtIeCTBa C caMbIMH
PaJRHtIHbIMH pacaMH H Hapo~aMHO B TOM ~e ro~y BHTTe no~aR laplO e~e O~HY ~OKRa~shy
HYIO 3anHCKY B KOTOpoA no~~ep~HBaR BeCbMa B3pbIBoonacshy
HYIO H COMHHTeRbHYIO H~elO BbI~BHHYTYIO neTpOM Ba~MaeBbIM
6YP~TCKHM leRHTeReM npHH~BwHM npaBOCRaBHe (ero
KpeCTHbIM OTlOM 6bIR HMnepaTOp AReKcaH~p III) CTpaHHbIA
nRaH OCHOBbIBaRC~ Ha CHCTeMaTHtIeCKOM npOHHKHOBeHHH
6YP~TOB 06yqeHHbIx PYCCKHMH B KatIeCTBe ToprOBbIX areHTOB
B 3a~HHA ~BOp KHTa~ - Ha 3an~HYIO nOrpaHHtIHYIO nOROCy
3eMeRb npOT~HYBWHXC~ OT CHHb13~Ha ~O MOHrORHH H MaHbtIshy
~YPHH BKRlOtI~ TH6eT B 1895-1897 rr nRaH 6bIR onp060BaH
HO nOTepneR nORHYIO Hey~atIY JlHHHeA npo~BH~eHH~ POCCHH
~OR~Ha 6bIRa CTaTb HOBa~ ~eRe3Ha~ ~opora Ha JlaHbtI~oy B
npOBHHlHH KaHcyA rRaBHbIM HanpaBReHHeM nO~PbIBHOA ~e~shy
TeRbHOCTH 6bIRa no~~ep~Ka aHTHKHTaAcKoro BOCCTaHH~
MOHrOROB m6eTleB H KHTaACKHX MYCYRbMaH ECRH 6bl nRaH
Ba~MaeBa OKa3aRC~ CTORb ~e ycnewHbIM KaK r RaBH~A nRaH
BHTTe - cTpoHTeRbcTBO TpaHccH6HPCKOA ~eRe3HOA ~oporH TO BHTTe 6bIR 6bI npaB B CBoeM 3aKRlOtIeHHH tITO ftc 6eperOB
THxoro OKeaHa H BepWHH rHMaRaeB POCCH~ 6y~eT BepWHTb
He TORbKO a3HaTCKHe HO H eBponeAcKHe ~eRaft 31 XOT~ BHTTe
CTapaRC~ tIT06bI MHp nOBepHR ero ~eKRapalH~M 0 cnoc06shy
HOCTH POCCHH ocy~ecTBHTb CBOIO MHCCHIO B A3HH MHPshy
H~MH H KYRbTypHbIMH MepaMH KOHetIHOA leRblO PYCshy
CKoA 3KcnaHCHH B A3HH nocpe~CTBOM ~eRe3Ho~opO~Horo
CTpOHTeRbCTBa H ToprOBbIX MeponpH~THA (KOTOpble B 3Hashy
tIHTeRbHoA Mepe a nO~tIac H nORHOCTblO cy6CH~HpOBaRHCb
rocy~apcTBOM) 6bIRO KOROHHaRbHoe rocnO~CTBo32 KaKoe-TO BpeM~ PYCCKHA HMnepHaRH3M B A3HH pa3BHBaRshy
C~ Ha BORHe onTHMH3Ma conpOBo~~aBwero CTpOHTeRbCTBO
TpaHCCH6HPCKOA MarHCTpaRH rRaBH~M nponaraH~HCTOM
3TOA ~oporH H CHCTeMaTHtIeCKOrO npOHHKHOBeHH~ POCCHH B
KHTaA tIepe3 MaHbtI~ypHIO 6bIR YXTOMCKHA Ero nOMO~HHK no CB~3~M C 3ana~HoA EBponoA repMaH BpYHxojJep (1841shy
1916 rr) tIYTb RH He B RHpHtIeCKHX TOHax onHCblBaR CBeTRoe
6y~y~ee EBpa3HH Bce pacbl CB~3aHHble OT BaRTHKH H LJepHoshy
ro MOp~ ~o THxoro OKeaHa 3TOA nOTp~calO~eA ~oporoA KOshy
Topa~ npHHeceT BbIrO~bl B3aHMHoMY ToproBoMy H KyRbTypshy
HOMY 06MeHY 6Y~YT ~HTb B nORHOM corRaCHH no~ CKHneTshy
POM lap~ B OTRHtIHe OT 6pHTaHleB B I1H~HH ~OKa3bIBaR
BpYHxoBep Y PyccKoro KpeCTb~HHHa H COR~aTa HeT tIyBcTBa
138 139
paCOBoro npeBOCXOllCTBa no OTHomeHHIO K a3HaTaM
KaH H TypaHCKaH KPOBb BCKope CMemaIOTCH B03HHKHyr HOBbie
nOrpaHHtlHbIe HapOllbI nOJIya3HaTcKoro nOJIyeBponeAcKoro
npOHCXOgtKlleHHH C03lla101IHe CBH3yJOlIee 3BeHO nOCpellCTBO
KOToporo CJIaBHHe ClleJIaIOT BblcmHe $OpMbl gtKH3HH C03llaHshy
Hble XpHCTHaHCKO-eBponeAcKoA KYJIbTYpoA llOCTynHblMH Bee elIe 3aKpblTOMY CepllLlY BHYTPeHHeA A3HH3
MOTHB 3TOT BeCbMa 3HaKOM HlleH MorJIa npHllTH tlyramp JIH
He OT BeHIOKOBa H llagtKe OT paHHero n03Ta-naHCJIaBHCTa TIOTshy
tleBa KOTOPblA B OllHOM H3 CBOHX CTpaHHblX CTHXOTBOpeHHR
PYCCKaH reorpa$HH (1848 r) MetlTaJI 0 5YllYlIeA poccHAcKOR
eBpoa3HaTcKoA HMnepHH OT HHJIa ll0 HeBbI OT 3JIb5bI ll0 KHshy
TaHIOT BOJIrH no EB$paT OT raHra ll0 llYHaH~ OllHaKO Pa3shy
pa50TaHHaH B rOllbI HnOHO-KHTaAcK09 BoAHbl (1894-1895 IT)
5pYHxo$epoBCKaH aHTHHMnepHaJIHCTHtleCKaH KOHLlenLlHft
)KeJITOpOCCHH HMeJIa HCHyJO nOJIHTHtlecKyJO LleJIb BpYHxo$ep
He TOJIbKO pHCOBaJI BeJIHtleCTBeHHYIO KapTHHY B03MOgtKHOro
CHM5H03a POCCHH H KHTaH HO H npellynpegtKllaJI 3anallHOe 0laquo5shy
lIeCTBO 05 3KcnaHCHOHHCTCKHX HaMepeHHHX SlnoHHH SInOHHft
noll $JIarOM 5YllllHCTCKOA COJIHllapHOCTH C03llaeT naHa3HaTCshy
KYIO 30HY BJIHHHHH CHatlaJIa OrpaHHtleHHYIO SInoHHeA Kopeshy
eA H KHTaeM Ho 3aTeM nOCJIe oKKynaLlHH TaAaaHH na 30Ha
nOCTeneHHO MOgtKeT pacmHpHTbCH Ha BCIO IOrO-BOCTOtlHYIO
A3HIO B ollHoA H3 CBOHX cTaTeA BpYHxo$ep C HeMaJI09 lloJIeR
np03peHHH nHCaJI 0 5YllYlIeA BeJIHKOA BOCTOtlHOa3HaTCKoR
c$epe COBMeCTHOrO npOLlBeTaHHH KOTOpaH B03HHKHeT 50 JIeT
cnycTH3S TeM He MeHee npellOCTepegtKeHHH BpYHxo$epa JIe)f(ashy
JIH BHYTPH cneKTpa HlleA gtKeJIToA onacHocTH KOTopbIe MO)f(shy
HO HaATH ygtKe Y B COJIOBbeBa H llagtKe elIe paHbme - Y K JIeoHshy
TbeBa HeCMOTpH Ha onTHMHCTHtleCKHe KapTHHbl 5YllYlIeR
ft)KeJITOpOcCHH BpYHxo$ep nO-BHllHMOMY 5bIJI 05ecnoKoeH
B03MOgtKHOCTblO Toro tlTO HHllYCTPHaJIH30BaHHble MaCCbl KHshy
TaALleB HatlHYT HeoTBpaTHMo npOllBHraTbCH Ha 3anall noll BOllHshy
TeJIbCTBOM HnOHLleB EllHHCTBeHHoA CHJIoA KOTOPaH CMO)f(eT
npoTHBOCTOHTb noA MOIIHOA 5YllllHCTCKOA BOJIHe llOKa3bIshy
BaJI BpYHxo$ep HBJIHeTCH PYCCKaH eBpOa3HaTCKaH HMnepHH
HeCKOJIbKO rpoTecKHoe B03pO)f(lleHHe 5YllllHCTCKOA TeMbI
npOH30mJIO B nepHOll rpaiKllaHCKOA B09Hbi B POCCHH CYshy
MaCmellmHA 5apoH $OH YHrepH-WTepH5epr eiblBmHA Llap-
CJltHR reHepaJI OTBeTHJI Ha PYCCKYIO peBOJIIOLlHIO nepeXOllOM B
ISYIlllH3M B 3HaK npoTecTa npoTHB Toro tlTO OH CtlHTaJI eiaHKshy
pOTCTBOM 3anaztHoA LlHBHJIH3aLlHH B 1921 r ero oeibellHHeHHbIA
llta3aLlKO-MOHrOJIbCKO-KHTaACKHR OTpHll 3aXBaTHJI YpiY CTOshy
nHUY BHemHeA MOHrOJIHH (HbIHe YJIaH-eiaTOP) rlle eiapoH eibIJ1
npOB03rJIameH HOBbIM lIHHrHCXaHoM OllHaKO HeCKOJIbKO MecHshy
ueB cnycTH YHrepH-WTeHeiepr 3TOT CHMBOJI a3HaTtlHHbI H
)KeJITOpOCCHH B OllHOM JIHLle nOTepneJI nOpa)f(eHHe OT 5oJIbshy
meBHKOB H eiblJI HMH paCCTpeJIHH36 Ba)f(HO OTMeTHTb tlTO 3Ta HlleOJIOrHH npOB03rJIamaBmaH
ISYllYlIee CJIHHHHe pac BO HMH eiOJIee OllHOPOllHOA EBpa3HH
(rlle gtKeJIaeMOe HepellKO BbIllaBaJIOCb 3a lleACTBHTeJIbHOCTb)
pa3YMeeTCH noll eiJIarOCKJIOHHbIM BOllHTeJIbCTBOM POCCHH
HHKOrlla He BJIHHJIa Ha npOLlecc npHHHTHH pemeHHA B neTepeiypshy
re KaKHM eibl Y3KHM HH eiblno onpelleJIeHHe noro npOLlecca
llnH Toro BpeMeHH B KOHetlHOM CtleTe (HCKJIlOtlaH anH30ll C Baztshy
MaeBbIM) B030einallaJIa peaJIbHaH nOJIHTHKa Ho B rOllbl rpa)f(shy
llaHCKoA B09Hbi H HeKOTopoe BpeMH nOCJIe ee OKOHtlaHHH eiOJIbshy
meBHCTCKaH POCCHH paCCMaTpHBaJIa CBOIO nOJIHTHKY B A3HH
CKopee KaK $YHKUHIO HlleOJIOrHH HlleH CMemeHHH CJIaBHHOshy
apHALleB H TypaHLleB nOJIb30BaJIaCb onpelleJIeHHOR nOllllep)f(shy
KoA JIHeiepaJIbHblX KpyrOB PYCCKoA HHTenJIHreHLlHH JIHmb ll0
Tex nop nOKa ypOBeHb p0gtKllaeMOCTH B POCCHH OCTaBaJICH Ollshy
HHM H3 caMbIX BbICOKHX B MHpe KaK 3TO eiblJIO npH LlapH3Me coshy
rJIaCHO llaHHbiM nepenHcH 1897 r 3TO cnocoeicTBOBaJIO H O$Hshy
LlHaJIbHOMY nOOlIpeHHIO KOJIOHH3aLlHH PycCKoA A3HH KpeCTbHshy
HaMH eBponeRcKoro npOHCXOgtKlleHHH B OCHOBHOM CJIaBHHaMH
HCnOJIb30BaHHe BblrOll OT OTKPbITHH CpellHeA A3HH H llaJIbshy
Hero BOCTOKa llnH PycCKoA KonOHH3aLlHH mno eibI 3HatlHTeJIbshy
HO MellJIeHHee H He eibIJIO eibI CTonb nOJIHblM 5e3 Toro BKJIalla
KOTOPblA BHecnH B 3TOT npOLlecc YtleHbIe CneLlHaJIHCTbl H
nYTemeCTBeHHHKH OHH OCTaBHnH COBeTCKOMY rOCYllapCTBY
npOtlHYIO TpallHLlHIO HaYtlHbIX HCCnellOBaHHA BbICOKoro
ypOBHH B ocoeieHHocTH B reorpa$HH H BOCTOKOBelleHHH
lla)f(e BbIllaIOIIHACH PYCCKHA BOCTOKOBell BaCHJIHA Bapshy
TOJIbll (1869-1930 rr) KOTOPbIA cYMeJI OCTaTbCH B cTopoHe
OT O$HLlHaJIbHOA nponaraHllbl H npH LlapH3Me H npH eiOJIbmeshy
BHKax B OCHOBHOM CorJIamancH C TeM tlTO OH CtlHTaJI HCTOPHshy
tlecKoA HeoeixOllHMOCTblO - C c03llaHHeM MHPOBbIX HMnepHA
141140
TaKHX KaK HMnepHH AJleKCaHIpa BeJlHKOrO MOHrOJlOS apaOOB
H la~e COSpeMeHHOR eMY POCCHRcKOR HMnepHH S CpelHeR
A3HH OH HCKpeHHe SepHJI 1JTO KpynHble CTpYKTYPbl C031alOT Jlyqshy
mHe YCJlOSHH lJIH KYJlbTypHOrO c6J1H~eHHH HapOlOS pa3J1H1Jshy
HbIX pac HeCMOTpH Ha sce 6elcTsHH KOTopble HecyT SORHbI
conpoSo~IalOlI(He C031aHHe TaKHX HMnepHR~7
HCXO~ HA BOCTOK TPYBEQKOA H CABHQKHA
HeCMOTpH Ha HeYIa1JH CSH3aHHble C PYCCKO-HnOHCKOR H
nepsoR MHposoR soRHaMH PYCCKHe npeTeH3HH Ha oc06ble
OTHOmeHHH C A3HeR npolOJl~aJlH ~HTb cpelH HHTeJlJlHreHshy
QHH a S rOlbI peSOJlIOQHH rp~IaHcKoR SORHbl H cpa3Y ~e nocshy
Jle HHX TaKHe npereH3HH la~e YCHJlHJlHCb Hp1Je scero 3TO 80shy
nJlOTHJlOCb B eSpa3HRCKOM lSH~eHHH KOTopoe cnJlOTHJlO cashy
Mble 6J1ecTHII(He yMbi PYCCKoR 3MHrpaQHH 1920-x rolos Heshy
CMOTPH Ha HepelKHe pa3HorJlaCHH OHH 6blJlH y6e~IeHbl 1JTO
JlHlUb SOCnpHHHS oc060e eBpa3HRcKoe MHpOS033peHHe MO~HO
coxpaHHTb oc060CTb PYCCKoro SKJlala S QHSHJlH3aQHIO OCHOshy
saHHoro KaK Ha rpeKO-SH3aHTHRCKOM TaK H Ha MOHrOJlbCKOM
HaCJlelHH B csoeM nepSOM MaHHlIJecTe l1cxol Ha SOCTOK
(1921 r) lBa SbIIaIOII(HXCH JlHHrBHCTa KHH3b HHKoJlaR Tpy6eQshy
KoR H POMaH HK06coH OTCTaHBaJIH espa3HRcKoe CJlHHHHe H3blshy
KOS H KYJlbTYP (TaK Ha3b1BaeMaH TeOpllH H3bIKOBoro COI03a -
Sprachbund) C03HaTeJlbHO npeYBeJlH1JHBaH SJlHHHHe TypaHcKoshy
ro 3J1eMeHTa38
EBpa3HRQbl C1JHTaJlH 60JlblUeBHKoB H MapKcH3M XYIIUHM
CJlelCTBHeM 3analHoR KYJlbTYPbl OlHaKO caMoe peBOJlIOQHIO
OHH paccMaTpHBaJlH KaK BeJlHKHR H He06XOlHMblR KaTaJlH3ashy
TOp OHa pa3pYIUHJla CTapblR MHp H np06YIHJla OlHospeMeHHO
H PYCCKHe MaCCbl H HapOlbl BOCTOKa n03TOMY pa60Ta Tpy6eQshy
Koro EBpona H 1JeJlOBe1JeCTBo lt1920 r) 1JHTaeTCH KaK HeKoe
C01JeTaHHe lIaHHJleSCKOro H npH3biSOS sToporo KOHrpecca Koshy
MHHTepHa JTO pemHTeJlbHOe 06BHHeHHe 3analHoMY HMneshy
PHaJIH3MY KOTopoe oTBepraeT eBpOQeHTpHCTCKHR nolXOl K
A3HH YHH~eHHe HcnblTaHHoe PoccHeR S XOle BoRHbl H peBoshy
JlIOQHH nHmeT Tpy6eQKoR Mo~eT C031aTb HenOBTopHMYIO
B03MO~HOCTb palHKaJlbHOrO nepecMoTpa OTHOmeHHH K Hepycshy
CKHM HapOlaM POCCHH 6YIYIJH CaMa KOJlOHHeR Mo~eT noshy
142
BeCTH lpyrHe KOJlOHHH B oc06eHHocTH CSOHX laquoa3HaTCKHX cecshy
Tepraquo Ha pelUHTeJlbHYIO 60Pb15y npoTHB pOMaHo-repMaHcKHx
KOJlOHH3aTopOB 39
OlHHM H3 caMbiX opHrHHaJlbHblX MblCJlHTeJleR CpelH
eBpa3HRQes I5blJl reorpallJ neTp CasHQKHR (1895-1968 rr) Coshy
rJlaCHO ero KOHQenQHH Espa3HH - nOlJlHHHaH KYJlbTypHOshy
reorpaIlJH1JeCKaH Ol5lI(HOCTb C lOOaS01JHblM nOTeHQHaJIOM Tepshy
pHTOpHaJlbHOR 3KcnaHCHH (MecTopa3sHTHe HJlH TonoreHeshy
3HC) rOSOpH 0 Ha1JaslUeRcH S XIX BeKe 3KCnaHCHH POCCHH Ha
lOr H SOCTOK CasHQKHR nblTaeTCH npenOlHecTH ee KaK 060shy
pOHHTeJlbHYIO Mepy S PaMKax nOHHTHH npOlsHHYTOR rpaHHshy
QbI HeCOMHeHHO aHaJlOrH1JHOrO TOMy nOHHTHIO KOTopoe
0150CHoBblBaJIO I5pHTaHcKYIO nOJIHTHKY B I1HIHH 50Jlee Toro
CaBHQKHR loKa3blsaeT 1JTO PYCCKYIO 3KcnaHCHIO B QeJIOM MO~HO
paccMaTpHsaTb KaK HenpepblSHblR npoQecc opraHH1JeCKOrO
pa3SHTHH B ero onHcaHHH 3TO BHIHTCH 1JYTb JlH He KaK 3KOshy
JlOrH1JeCKHR npoQecc l5e3 KaKOR-JlHI50 nOJIHTH1JeCKOR MOTHshy
SHPOBKH CKpblBalOlI(eRcH 3a HHM H HMnepHaJIHCTH1JeCKOrO COshy
nepHH1JeCTBa BeJlHKHX lep~as CSH3aHHOro CO cpelHea3HaTCshy
KHM H laJIbHeBOCT01JHblM sonpocaMH CJlelOSaTeJlbHO lOKa3b1shy
BaeT CaBHQKHR PYCCKaR EBpa3HR eCTb reonOJlHTH1JeCKOe elHHshy
CTSO B ce6e C031aHHOe KYJlbTYPHblM npOQeCCOM reHeTH1JeCshy
KoR MyTaQHH a He nOcpelCTSOM 3asoeBaHHA H pa3pyweHHA~ KaK BHIHM TaKOe TOJlKOBaHHe He CJIHWKOM OTJlH1JaeTCR OT KOHshy
QenQHH IHHaMH1JeCKOrO ~H3HeHHoro npOCTpaHCTBa CPPHIPHshy
xa PaTQeJlR KOTOPYlO KapJl XaycxollJep npHHRJI B 20-e rOlbl
EBPA3HAcKOE CBRH)f(EHHE H CRHHHHE
BeCbMa JlI060nbiTHO HBHOe CXOlCTBO Me~IY CJlOBapeM eBshy
pa3HAQeB H COBeTCKoA TepMHHOJlOrHeA xpYlI(eBCKoA 3nOXH
OTHOCHTeJIbHO KYJIbTypHO-HaQHOHaJIbHOrO CJIHRHHR nol JlIOshy
60BHbiM Hal30pOM CTapmero PYCCKoro 6paTa B pa60Tax nCashy
SHQKoro H B oc06eHHocTH B TpYIaX HCTopHKa r BepHaICKOshy
ro HepelKO BCTpe1JaIOTCR TepMHHbl CJ1HJ1HHe H nepeMeJIJHBashy
HHe 1JTO RKOl5bl HMeeT MeCTO B npoQecce TeppHTOpHaJlbHOR
3KcnaHCHH KYJlbMHHaQHR KOTOpoA - 1IJ0pMHpoBaHHe BeJlHshy
KOPYCCKOA KYJlbTYPbl TaK 3aMe1JaHHe BepHalCKoro 1JTO nol
BHeWHHM pa3Ho06pa3HeM CKpblBaeTCH BHYTpeHHee elHHCTBO
143
HanOMHHaeT pacxo)l(ee COBeTCKOe nOHHTHe 0 eQHHCTBe 8
MHorootlpa3HH
B MaHepe He CJIHmKOM OTJIHLlalOIleRcH OT COBeTCKHX CTaH~
QapTOB BepHaQCKHR QOKa3bIBaJI LITO BKJIIOLleHHe HepYCCKHX
rpynn B MHorOHauHOHaJIbYIO eBpa3HRcKYIO HMnepHIO C03Qa~
eT orpOMHbIe 3KOHOMHLleCKHe H KYJIbTypHbIe npeHMYIlIeCTBa O~~
HaKO BepHaQCKHR HaCTaHBaJI npH 3TOM LITO eQHHCTBO QOJI)I(HO
tlbITb 3KYMeHHLleCKHM tle3 HaBH3bIBaHHH HtlO PoccHRcKoe
rocy~apcTBO - eBpa3HRcKoe rOCYQapCTBO H Bce OTQeJIbHbIe
HaUHOHaJIbHOCTH Espa3HH QOJI)I(Hbl LlYBCTBOBaTb LITO 3TO HX
rocy~apcTBO H npH3HaBaTb ero (KypCHB BepHaQCKOrO) CHJIa
3Toro eBpa3HRcKoro otlpa30BaHHH JIe)l(HT B ero CBOtlOQHOM
KYJIbTYPHOM TBopLleCTBe41 KpOMe Toro Qa)l(e eCJIH PycCKHR
HapoQ otlpa3yeT rJIaBHYIO CHJIY eBpa3HRCKoro rocy~apcTBa a
PYCCKHR H3b1K - tla30BbiR CJIoR eBpa3HRcKoR KYJIbTYPbI Bce
3TO HeJIb3H HaBH3b1BaTb QpyrHM Hapo~aM HeCMOTpH Ha BeJIH~
LlHe 3THX HQeR BbICKa3bIBaBmHXCH eBpa3HRuaMH-3MHrpaHTaMH
He HecmHMH HHKaKoR nOJIHTHLIeCKoR OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH H
HMeSmHMH BeCbMa MaJIOe BJIHHHHe B HOBOA COBeTCKoR eBposhy
a3HaTCKoR HMnepHH QPyme CJIaBHHCKHe HapO~bI B ocotleHshy
HOCTH HaHtlOJIee MHOrOLlHCJIeHHble cnoCJIe PYCCKHX) HanpHshy
Mep YKPaHHUbl H nOJIHKH HcnblTbIBaJIH rJIytloKoe HeQOBepHe
K ueJIHM eBpa3HRueB H BbICTYaJIH npOTHB HHX2 K CO)l(aJIeHHIO
HHLlero He H3seCTHO 0 peaKUHH Ha TeopHH eBpa3HAueB a3HaTshy
CKHX HHTeJIJIeKTyaJIOB )l(HBmHX noQ COBeTCKHM pe)l(HMOM
MO)l(HO OQHaKO tle30mHtloLiHo nOJIaraTb LITO OHH BHQeJIH B
3THX TeOpHHX JIHmb YTOHLleHHoe onpaSQaHHe PYCCKoro HMneshy
pHaJIH3Ma
TaKHM otlpa30M eBpa3HRcKoe ~BH)I(eHHe caMO Toro He
C03HaBaH cnoc06CTBOBaJIO $OpMHPOBaHHIO YTonHLleCKoro 06shy
pa3a coseTCKoro LleJIOBeKa - HCKyccTBeHHoro nOpO)l(~eHHH
COBeTCKoR nponaraHQbl He HMelOIlero KaKOrO-JIH60 paCOBoro
HJIH 3THHLleCKOro npOHCXO)l(QeHHH HO rOBOpHIlero no-pYCCKH
H OIlYIlalOIlero ce6H KOHeLiHO )l(e PYCCKHM COBeTCKaH MOshy
QeJIb - TpOHua COCTOHIlaH H3 Tpex CTaQHA - paCUBeT-c6JIHshy
)l(eHHe-CJIHHHHe BeCbMa pa3BHTaH B 3noxy XPYIleBa pa3Hshy
TeJIbHO HanOMHHaeT eBpa3HRcKoe BHQeHHe 1920-x rO~OB OHa
OTpa)l(aeT TaK)I(e HCTopHLIeCKHA onbIT HaKOnJIeHHblA PycCKOR
HHTeJIJIHreHUHeR no HaUHOHaJIbHblM H paCOBblM BonpocaM
KOTopbIe PYCCKHe MbICJIHTeJIH BnepBble nO~HHJIH B XIX B
144
KaK nOKa3blBaeT 3JIeH Kappep Ii AHKOC BCsl COBeTCKasl
(OHuenUHH B otlJIaCTH onpeQeJIeHHH H 3aKOHHoro O$opMJIeHHsl
OTHomeHHA Me)l(~y PYCCKHMH H HepyccKHMH npeTepneJIa
MHO)l(eCTBO H3MeHeHHA43 B npoTHBOnOJIO)l(HOCTb neHHHcKoR
yTOnHH OTMHpaHHsl HauHA H rocYQapcTB H 3aMeHbl HX HOBblM
YHHBepCaJIbHbIM OOIlecTBOM npOJIeTapCKoA KJIaCCOBOR COJIHshy
~apHOCTH 60JIee )l(ecToKHA H OCMOTpHTeJIbHbIA CTaJIHH
nocTeneHHo npe06pa30BaJI HQelO $eQepaUHH B H~elO ueHT~
paJIH30BaHHHoro PyccKoro HaQ30pa HaQ $opMaJIbHO aBTOshy
HOMHbIMH HapoQaMH COBeTcKoro COI03a 3Ta peaJIbHOCTb npeshy
BpaTHJIa Bee COBeTCKHe TeopHH no HaUHOHaJIbHOMY Bonpocy B
nycTOnOpO)l(HHe ynpa)l(HeHHH H3 KOTOPblX H~eH CTaJIHHa TaK
H He 6blJIH YCTpaHeHbl BbI)I(HBaHHe MHorOHaUHOHaJIbHOR
eBpa3HAcKoA TeppHTOpHaJIbHOA KpenOCTH nO-npe)l(HeMY
ynpaBJIHeMOA MYQPbIM CTapmHM PYCCKHM 6paTOM 6YQeT
3aBHCeTb npe)l(Qe Bcero OT pemeHHH nOQHHTbIX eBpa3HAuaMH
BonpOCOB
145
flpHMeqaHHR
1 Andrew Malozemoff Russian Far Eastern Policy 1881-1904 (Berkeley University of California Press 1958) 42 2 FF von Martens Russland und England in Zentralasien (St Petersburg 1880) Heinz Gollwitzer Geschichte des wetpolischen denkens (Gottingen Vandenhoeck amp Ruprecht 1982) 152-70 133-36 3 F F von Martens Le Conflict entre la Russie et la Chine (Bruxel~
les 1880) 4 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) 93-103 WP Wassiliew Die Erschliessung Chinas (Leipzig 1909) 5 WP Wassiliew Die Erschliessung Chinas (Leipzig 1909)49 6 NM Prejevalsky From Kulja accross the Tian Shan to Lob-Nor (London Sampson Low 1879) 7 MA Bakunin La theologie politique de Mazzini et lInternatishyonale (Neufchatel 1871) 102 110 8 AN Kuropatkin Memoiren (Berlin 1919)7174 9 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) 1423-24 111 10 1S Bloch Les Illusions de la Conquette Chinoise Revue des Revues (August 15 1900) 11 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) 14 12 Herold J Weins Chinas March toward the Tropics (Hamden Conn Shoe String Press 1954) 13 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) p 24 14 CH IQlKaKOB AHrJIO-PycCIltaH pacnpH cmgt 1885 15 HltIgtltIgteAopoB ltlgtHJIocoIllHH oOIIlero AeJIa - UHT no HltIgtltIgteAopoB COqHHeHHH M MbICJIb 1982 0 BJIHHHHH ltlgteAoshypOBa Ha llocToeBcKoro TOJICTOrO COJIOBbeBa BepAHeBa BYJIraKOBa HAP CM Stephen Lukashevich NF Fedorov - A Study in Russian Eupsychian and Utopian Thought (Newark University of Delaware Press 1977) pp 13-34 16 HltIgtltIgteAopoB CotJHHeHHH 1982 CTp 343 Sarkisyanz Op cit 210-211 HACeTHHUKHA PyccKHe MbICJIHTeJIH 0 KHTae XapoHH 1926 17 BJIaAHMHp JIbBOB 3araAotJHblA CTapHIlt JI COBeTcKHA nHshyCaTeJIb 1977 CTp 129-135 HltIgtltIgteAopoB CotJHHeHHH (962) CTp 335-336 18 HltIgtltIgteAopoB CotJHHeHHH CTp 216 340 382 669
146
19 TaM lKe CTp 300 20 BCCOJIOBbeB TPH pa3roBopa cms TPYA 1904 21 Malozemoff Russian Far Eastern Policy (1958) p 43 22 JIeHHH 0 BoAHe B KHTae - HCKpa 1 AeKaopH 1900 23 ABeJIbIA neTepoypr UHT no H3A London Penguin 1983 CTP 65 24 Sarkisyanz Russland und der Messianismus(1955) 200 21~218
25 AJIeKCaHAP BJIOK CTHxoTBopeHHH H n03Mbl TeaTp M XYAOlKeCTBeHHaH JIHTepaTypa 1968 CTp 644-645 26 C EceHHH CoopaHHe cotJHHeHHA Mbull 1970 T5 cTP 107 27 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) 42 98-99 28 Sarkisyanz Russland und der Messianismus(1955) 218~22
29 Malozernoff Russian Far Eastern Policy (1958)43-44 30 BH Sumner Russia and Europe Oxford Slavonic Papers (1951) II 1-16B Readings in Russian Civilization nOA peA Thomas Riha (Chicago University of Chicago Press 1964) 1147331 Malozemoff Russian Far Eastern Policy (1958) 43 Sarkisyanz Russland und der Messianismus (1955)378-91 32 Gollwitzer Geschichte (1982) I 138-40 33 Hermann Brunnhofer Russlands Hand Uber Asien Historischshygeographische Essays zur Entwick lungsgechichte des Russichen Reichsdenkens (S1 Petersburg 1897) npeAHCJIOBHe llBeAuapeu BpYHxolllep onpaBAblBaJI pyCCKylO 3IltCnaHCHIO B CpeAHeA A3HH H Ha llaJIbHeM BOCTOKe B cepHH cTaTeA BnepB~e onYOJIHKOBaHHbIx B neTepoyprcKHx ra3eTax Ha HeMeUKOM H3blKe St Petersburger Zeitung H St Petersburger Herold OH n~shyTaJICH OOOCHOBaTb PYCCKHA 3KcnaHCHOHH3M B A3HH CO~shyCTBeHHblMH H3bICKaHHHMH B apHAcKoA MHlIloJIorHH CpeAH ApyrHx paooT OH onYOJIHKOBaJI TpexToMHHK Urgechichte der Arier in Vorder-und Centralasien Historich-geographische Untersuchungen uber den altesten Schauplatz des Rigvedas und Avestas (Leipzig 1983) BpYHxolllep nepeBen TaKlKe o~beshyMHCTbIA OTtJeT KHH3H YXTOMCKoro 0 noe3AKe ueCapeBHqa HHKOJIaH Ha llaJIbHHA BOCTOK Orientreise seiner Kaiserlicher Hohe heit des Grossfursten Thronfolgers (Leipzig Brockhaus 1894 1998) 34 ltIgtHTIOTtJeB JIHpHKa HaYKa 1965 TI1 M CTp 118 35 Ein ostasiatischer Dreibund und die buddhistische Weltproshypaganda B KH BpYHxolllepa Russland Hand uber Aden (1897) 24-29 BnepB~e onYOJIHKOBaHa BSt Petersburger Zeitung B 1894 r
147
36 Louis Fischer The Soviets in the World Affairs (Princeton Princeton University Press 1951) n 534-37 Sir Fitzroy Maclean To the Back ofBeyond (London Cape 1974) 119-121 37 AKatteMHK BapTOJlbtt COllHHeHHR M H3tt-BO BOCTOllHoA JlHTepaTYpbI 1963 T2 cTp 164-166345-350 38 Hcxott K BOCTOKY npettllYBCTBHR H cBepmeHHR YTBepshy)l(tteHHe eBpa3HAueB CO(j)HR 1921 COttep)l(HT CTaTbH rBltJ)JloshypOBcKoro POMaHa HKoCicoHa nllCasllHHcKoro nH CaBHUshyKoro H HCTpyCieUKoro HH)I(e nepellHCJIRIOTCR OCHOBHhIe paCioTbI 0 espa3HAuax DS Mirsky The Eurasian Movement The Slavonic and East European Review (1927) 311-320 Otto Boss Die Lehre der Eurasier (Wiesbaden Harrasowitz 1961) H A Stammler Europe-Russland-Asian Der eurasiche Deutungsshyversuch der russichen Geschichte Osteuropa 12 (1962) 521-528 Gerges Nivat Du Panmongolisme au mouvement eurasien Cahiers du monde Russe et Sovietique 73 (1966) 460-78 Nicholas V Riasanovsky The Emergence of Eurasians California Slavic Studies 4 (1967) 39-72 39 HC TpylSeUKoA Espona H lIeJIOBelleCTBO CO(j)HR 192Q Mirsky The Eurasian Movement (1927) 312-13 V Riasanovsky Emergence of Eurasians (1967) 56 Leonid Luks Die Ideologie der Eurasier im zeitgeschichtlichen Zusammenhang Jahrbucher fur Geschichte Osteuropas 34 (1986) 374-395 40 llH CasHUKHA reOnOJlHTHlIeCKHe 3aMeTKH no PYCCKoA
HCTOpHH - B rB BepHattCKHA HallepTaHHe PYCCKoA HCshyTOpHH llpara 1927 CTp 234-260 CM TaK)I(e nHCasHUKHA reOrpa(j)HlIeCKHe ocolSeHHOCTH POCCHH 2 TT npara 1927 OH )l(e POCCHR - OCOlSblA reorpa(j)HlIecKHA MHp llapH)I( 1927 Charles Halperin Russia and the Steppe George Vernadsky and Eurasianism Forschungen zur osteuropaischen Geschichte 36 (1985) 55-194 and Slavic Studies 41 (1982)477-493 41 rB BepHattcKHA YKa3 COli CTp 230-231 259-260 Charles Halperin Opcit pp 99-104 42 V Riasanovsky The Emergence of Eurasians California Slavic Studies 4 (1967) 43 H Carrere dEncausse Decline of an Empire The Soviet Socialist Republics in Revolt (New York Harper 1981) 13-46
148
npOllBH)KEHHE POCCHH K lOrY
POCCHflCKHE llPOCTOPbI
Hepa3pemHMble npOCiJIeMbI CJlHRHHR pac B orpoMHoM MHOshyrOHaUHOHaJIbHOM KOHrJlOMepaTe Ha3blBaeMOM POCCHAcKOA (a n03ttHee coseTCKoA) eBpa3HAcKoA HMnepHeA eme CioJlee 01S0shyCTPRIOTCR B reorpa(j)HlIecKHx nOHRTHRX - B TpyttHeAmeM nposhyCTpaHcTseHHoM IIHcCiaJIaHce ttoBJIeIOmHM Hall olSmHM reOCTpashyTerHlIeCKHM nOJIO)l(eHHeM HMnepHH
MeTa(j)opHlIeCKH ynpomaR HCTOPHIO POCCHAcKOA HMnepHH nottllac CBOttRT K TparHlIeCKoA Ollep)l(HMOCTH npOCTopOM HJIH K TparHlIeCKOMY lIapy npOCTpaHCTsaI COrJlaCHO 3THM npettCTaBJIeHHRM PYCCKHX - H KaK OISOpOHRIOmHXCR H KaK arpeccopOB nOCTORHHO H Heyttep)l(HMO BJIeKJlH orpOMHble npOCTpaHCTBa Espa3HH PYCCKHe rOpllRTCR TeM liTO s HX rHshyraHTCKoA cyxonYTHoA TBepttbIHe MO)l(HO pa3MecTHTb 2-3 AMepHKH 40 ltJ)paHUHA H 93 BeJIHKOlSpHTaHHH Me)l(lIY 1600 H 1900 rr K PoccHAcKOA HMnepHH 1I0lSaBHJIOCb B olSmeA CJIO)l(HOCTH 17 MJIH KSattpaTHblx KHJIOMeTpOB HOBblX TeppHshyTOPHA s cpellHeM no 57 TbIC KBatlpaTHhIX KHJlOMeTpoB e)l(eshyrOttHo3 HCXOIlR H3 3Toro HeTpyttHO npHIITH K 3aKJIIOlIeHHIO liTO reorpa(j)HR H s caMOM tteJle OKa3b1BaJla BceCTopOHHee BJlHRHHe Ha pYCCKoe H coseTCKoe BOCnpHRTHe A3HH~
TaKHM 01Spa30M reorpa(j)HlIeamA (j)aKTOp HrpaeT orpOMshyHyIO pOJlb S HCTOPHH pYCCKoro Hapottaf ocolSeHHO B CBR3H C lIpe3MepHbiM YBJIelleHHeM HMnepHaJlHCTHlIeCKoA POCCHH npOCTpaHCTBaMH H TeppHTOpHRMH )lse reorpa(j)HlIeCKHe OCOshylSeHHOCTH OTJIHlIaIOT POCCHIO llepBaR - 3TO 0llHooeipa3He peJIbshye(j)a MeCTHOCTH MOHOTOHHOCTb JlaHttma(j)Ta n03S0JIHSmaR UeHTpaJIbHOA nOJIHTHlIeCKoA BJIaCTH nOllttep)l(HBaTb H pacshynpOCTpaHRTb csoA KOHTPOJIb no JIHHHH SeJIHKHX pellHhIx nyshyTeA TRHymHXCR no OCH ceBep-IOr TaKoA KOHTPOJlb oeiJlerllaJl ttBH)I(eHHe TosapOB KOJlOHHCTOB H BoACK~ no CJIOBaM BblllaIOmeshyrOCR HCTopHKa KJIIOlIeSCKoro 3KCnaHCHR MOCKBbI MO)l(eT paCCMaTpHBaTbCR KaK B03BblmeHHe ueHTpOCTpeMHTeJlbHOA CHJIbl 3aXBaTHBmeA KOHTPOJlb HatI HCTOKaMH lIeTblpex peK B
149
paCOBoro npeBOCXOllCTBa no OTHomeHHIO K a3HaTaM
KaH H TypaHCKaH KPOBb BCKope CMemaIOTCH B03HHKHyr HOBbie
nOrpaHHtlHbIe HapOllbI nOJIya3HaTcKoro nOJIyeBponeAcKoro
npOHCXOgtKlleHHH C03lla101IHe CBH3yJOlIee 3BeHO nOCpellCTBO
KOToporo CJIaBHHe ClleJIaIOT BblcmHe $OpMbl gtKH3HH C03llaHshy
Hble XpHCTHaHCKO-eBponeAcKoA KYJIbTYpoA llOCTynHblMH Bee elIe 3aKpblTOMY CepllLlY BHYTPeHHeA A3HH3
MOTHB 3TOT BeCbMa 3HaKOM HlleH MorJIa npHllTH tlyramp JIH
He OT BeHIOKOBa H llagtKe OT paHHero n03Ta-naHCJIaBHCTa TIOTshy
tleBa KOTOPblA B OllHOM H3 CBOHX CTpaHHblX CTHXOTBOpeHHR
PYCCKaH reorpa$HH (1848 r) MetlTaJI 0 5YllYlIeA poccHAcKOR
eBpoa3HaTcKoA HMnepHH OT HHJIa ll0 HeBbI OT 3JIb5bI ll0 KHshy
TaHIOT BOJIrH no EB$paT OT raHra ll0 llYHaH~ OllHaKO Pa3shy
pa50TaHHaH B rOllbI HnOHO-KHTaAcK09 BoAHbl (1894-1895 IT)
5pYHxo$epoBCKaH aHTHHMnepHaJIHCTHtleCKaH KOHLlenLlHft
)KeJITOpOCCHH HMeJIa HCHyJO nOJIHTHtlecKyJO LleJIb BpYHxo$ep
He TOJIbKO pHCOBaJI BeJIHtleCTBeHHYIO KapTHHY B03MOgtKHOro
CHM5H03a POCCHH H KHTaH HO H npellynpegtKllaJI 3anallHOe 0laquo5shy
lIeCTBO 05 3KcnaHCHOHHCTCKHX HaMepeHHHX SlnoHHH SInOHHft
noll $JIarOM 5YllllHCTCKOA COJIHllapHOCTH C03llaeT naHa3HaTCshy
KYIO 30HY BJIHHHHH CHatlaJIa OrpaHHtleHHYIO SInoHHeA Kopeshy
eA H KHTaeM Ho 3aTeM nOCJIe oKKynaLlHH TaAaaHH na 30Ha
nOCTeneHHO MOgtKeT pacmHpHTbCH Ha BCIO IOrO-BOCTOtlHYIO
A3HIO B ollHoA H3 CBOHX cTaTeA BpYHxo$ep C HeMaJI09 lloJIeR
np03peHHH nHCaJI 0 5YllYlIeA BeJIHKOA BOCTOtlHOa3HaTCKoR
c$epe COBMeCTHOrO npOLlBeTaHHH KOTOpaH B03HHKHeT 50 JIeT
cnycTH3S TeM He MeHee npellOCTepegtKeHHH BpYHxo$epa JIe)f(ashy
JIH BHYTPH cneKTpa HlleA gtKeJIToA onacHocTH KOTopbIe MO)f(shy
HO HaATH ygtKe Y B COJIOBbeBa H llagtKe elIe paHbme - Y K JIeoHshy
TbeBa HeCMOTpH Ha onTHMHCTHtleCKHe KapTHHbl 5YllYlIeR
ft)KeJITOpOcCHH BpYHxo$ep nO-BHllHMOMY 5bIJI 05ecnoKoeH
B03MOgtKHOCTblO Toro tlTO HHllYCTPHaJIH30BaHHble MaCCbl KHshy
TaALleB HatlHYT HeoTBpaTHMo npOllBHraTbCH Ha 3anall noll BOllHshy
TeJIbCTBOM HnOHLleB EllHHCTBeHHoA CHJIoA KOTOPaH CMO)f(eT
npoTHBOCTOHTb noA MOIIHOA 5YllllHCTCKOA BOJIHe llOKa3bIshy
BaJI BpYHxo$ep HBJIHeTCH PYCCKaH eBpOa3HaTCKaH HMnepHH
HeCKOJIbKO rpoTecKHoe B03pO)f(lleHHe 5YllllHCTCKOA TeMbI
npOH30mJIO B nepHOll rpaiKllaHCKOA B09Hbi B POCCHH CYshy
MaCmellmHA 5apoH $OH YHrepH-WTepH5epr eiblBmHA Llap-
CJltHR reHepaJI OTBeTHJI Ha PYCCKYIO peBOJIIOLlHIO nepeXOllOM B
ISYIlllH3M B 3HaK npoTecTa npoTHB Toro tlTO OH CtlHTaJI eiaHKshy
pOTCTBOM 3anaztHoA LlHBHJIH3aLlHH B 1921 r ero oeibellHHeHHbIA
llta3aLlKO-MOHrOJIbCKO-KHTaACKHR OTpHll 3aXBaTHJI YpiY CTOshy
nHUY BHemHeA MOHrOJIHH (HbIHe YJIaH-eiaTOP) rlle eiapoH eibIJ1
npOB03rJIameH HOBbIM lIHHrHCXaHoM OllHaKO HeCKOJIbKO MecHshy
ueB cnycTH YHrepH-WTeHeiepr 3TOT CHMBOJI a3HaTtlHHbI H
)KeJITOpOCCHH B OllHOM JIHLle nOTepneJI nOpa)f(eHHe OT 5oJIbshy
meBHKOB H eiblJI HMH paCCTpeJIHH36 Ba)f(HO OTMeTHTb tlTO 3Ta HlleOJIOrHH npOB03rJIamaBmaH
ISYllYlIee CJIHHHHe pac BO HMH eiOJIee OllHOPOllHOA EBpa3HH
(rlle gtKeJIaeMOe HepellKO BbIllaBaJIOCb 3a lleACTBHTeJIbHOCTb)
pa3YMeeTCH noll eiJIarOCKJIOHHbIM BOllHTeJIbCTBOM POCCHH
HHKOrlla He BJIHHJIa Ha npOLlecc npHHHTHH pemeHHA B neTepeiypshy
re KaKHM eibl Y3KHM HH eiblno onpelleJIeHHe noro npOLlecca
llnH Toro BpeMeHH B KOHetlHOM CtleTe (HCKJIlOtlaH anH30ll C Baztshy
MaeBbIM) B030einallaJIa peaJIbHaH nOJIHTHKa Ho B rOllbl rpa)f(shy
llaHCKoA B09Hbi H HeKOTopoe BpeMH nOCJIe ee OKOHtlaHHH eiOJIbshy
meBHCTCKaH POCCHH paCCMaTpHBaJIa CBOIO nOJIHTHKY B A3HH
CKopee KaK $YHKUHIO HlleOJIOrHH HlleH CMemeHHH CJIaBHHOshy
apHALleB H TypaHLleB nOJIb30BaJIaCb onpelleJIeHHOR nOllllep)f(shy
KoA JIHeiepaJIbHblX KpyrOB PYCCKoA HHTenJIHreHLlHH JIHmb ll0
Tex nop nOKa ypOBeHb p0gtKllaeMOCTH B POCCHH OCTaBaJICH Ollshy
HHM H3 caMbIX BbICOKHX B MHpe KaK 3TO eiblJIO npH LlapH3Me coshy
rJIaCHO llaHHbiM nepenHcH 1897 r 3TO cnocoeicTBOBaJIO H O$Hshy
LlHaJIbHOMY nOOlIpeHHIO KOJIOHH3aLlHH PycCKoA A3HH KpeCTbHshy
HaMH eBponeRcKoro npOHCXOgtKlleHHH B OCHOBHOM CJIaBHHaMH
HCnOJIb30BaHHe BblrOll OT OTKPbITHH CpellHeA A3HH H llaJIbshy
Hero BOCTOKa llnH PycCKoA KonOHH3aLlHH mno eibI 3HatlHTeJIbshy
HO MellJIeHHee H He eibIJIO eibI CTonb nOJIHblM 5e3 Toro BKJIalla
KOTOPblA BHecnH B 3TOT npOLlecc YtleHbIe CneLlHaJIHCTbl H
nYTemeCTBeHHHKH OHH OCTaBHnH COBeTCKOMY rOCYllapCTBY
npOtlHYIO TpallHLlHIO HaYtlHbIX HCCnellOBaHHA BbICOKoro
ypOBHH B ocoeieHHocTH B reorpa$HH H BOCTOKOBelleHHH
lla)f(e BbIllaIOIIHACH PYCCKHA BOCTOKOBell BaCHJIHA Bapshy
TOJIbll (1869-1930 rr) KOTOPbIA cYMeJI OCTaTbCH B cTopoHe
OT O$HLlHaJIbHOA nponaraHllbl H npH LlapH3Me H npH eiOJIbmeshy
BHKax B OCHOBHOM CorJIamancH C TeM tlTO OH CtlHTaJI HCTOPHshy
tlecKoA HeoeixOllHMOCTblO - C c03llaHHeM MHPOBbIX HMnepHA
141140
TaKHX KaK HMnepHH AJleKCaHIpa BeJlHKOrO MOHrOJlOS apaOOB
H la~e COSpeMeHHOR eMY POCCHRcKOR HMnepHH S CpelHeR
A3HH OH HCKpeHHe SepHJI 1JTO KpynHble CTpYKTYPbl C031alOT Jlyqshy
mHe YCJlOSHH lJIH KYJlbTypHOrO c6J1H~eHHH HapOlOS pa3J1H1Jshy
HbIX pac HeCMOTpH Ha sce 6elcTsHH KOTopble HecyT SORHbI
conpoSo~IalOlI(He C031aHHe TaKHX HMnepHR~7
HCXO~ HA BOCTOK TPYBEQKOA H CABHQKHA
HeCMOTpH Ha HeYIa1JH CSH3aHHble C PYCCKO-HnOHCKOR H
nepsoR MHposoR soRHaMH PYCCKHe npeTeH3HH Ha oc06ble
OTHOmeHHH C A3HeR npolOJl~aJlH ~HTb cpelH HHTeJlJlHreHshy
QHH a S rOlbI peSOJlIOQHH rp~IaHcKoR SORHbl H cpa3Y ~e nocshy
Jle HHX TaKHe npereH3HH la~e YCHJlHJlHCb Hp1Je scero 3TO 80shy
nJlOTHJlOCb B eSpa3HRCKOM lSH~eHHH KOTopoe cnJlOTHJlO cashy
Mble 6J1ecTHII(He yMbi PYCCKoR 3MHrpaQHH 1920-x rolos Heshy
CMOTPH Ha HepelKHe pa3HorJlaCHH OHH 6blJlH y6e~IeHbl 1JTO
JlHlUb SOCnpHHHS oc060e eBpa3HRcKoe MHpOS033peHHe MO~HO
coxpaHHTb oc060CTb PYCCKoro SKJlala S QHSHJlH3aQHIO OCHOshy
saHHoro KaK Ha rpeKO-SH3aHTHRCKOM TaK H Ha MOHrOJlbCKOM
HaCJlelHH B csoeM nepSOM MaHHlIJecTe l1cxol Ha SOCTOK
(1921 r) lBa SbIIaIOII(HXCH JlHHrBHCTa KHH3b HHKoJlaR Tpy6eQshy
KoR H POMaH HK06coH OTCTaHBaJIH espa3HRcKoe CJlHHHHe H3blshy
KOS H KYJlbTYP (TaK Ha3b1BaeMaH TeOpllH H3bIKOBoro COI03a -
Sprachbund) C03HaTeJlbHO npeYBeJlH1JHBaH SJlHHHHe TypaHcKoshy
ro 3J1eMeHTa38
EBpa3HRQbl C1JHTaJlH 60JlblUeBHKoB H MapKcH3M XYIIUHM
CJlelCTBHeM 3analHoR KYJlbTYPbl OlHaKO caMoe peBOJlIOQHIO
OHH paccMaTpHBaJlH KaK BeJlHKHR H He06XOlHMblR KaTaJlH3ashy
TOp OHa pa3pYIUHJla CTapblR MHp H np06YIHJla OlHospeMeHHO
H PYCCKHe MaCCbl H HapOlbl BOCTOKa n03TOMY pa60Ta Tpy6eQshy
Koro EBpona H 1JeJlOBe1JeCTBo lt1920 r) 1JHTaeTCH KaK HeKoe
C01JeTaHHe lIaHHJleSCKOro H npH3biSOS sToporo KOHrpecca Koshy
MHHTepHa JTO pemHTeJlbHOe 06BHHeHHe 3analHoMY HMneshy
PHaJIH3MY KOTopoe oTBepraeT eBpOQeHTpHCTCKHR nolXOl K
A3HH YHH~eHHe HcnblTaHHoe PoccHeR S XOle BoRHbl H peBoshy
JlIOQHH nHmeT Tpy6eQKoR Mo~eT C031aTb HenOBTopHMYIO
B03MO~HOCTb palHKaJlbHOrO nepecMoTpa OTHOmeHHH K Hepycshy
CKHM HapOlaM POCCHH 6YIYIJH CaMa KOJlOHHeR Mo~eT noshy
142
BeCTH lpyrHe KOJlOHHH B oc06eHHocTH CSOHX laquoa3HaTCKHX cecshy
Tepraquo Ha pelUHTeJlbHYIO 60Pb15y npoTHB pOMaHo-repMaHcKHx
KOJlOHH3aTopOB 39
OlHHM H3 caMbiX opHrHHaJlbHblX MblCJlHTeJleR CpelH
eBpa3HRQes I5blJl reorpallJ neTp CasHQKHR (1895-1968 rr) Coshy
rJlaCHO ero KOHQenQHH Espa3HH - nOlJlHHHaH KYJlbTypHOshy
reorpaIlJH1JeCKaH Ol5lI(HOCTb C lOOaS01JHblM nOTeHQHaJIOM Tepshy
pHTOpHaJlbHOR 3KcnaHCHH (MecTopa3sHTHe HJlH TonoreHeshy
3HC) rOSOpH 0 Ha1JaslUeRcH S XIX BeKe 3KCnaHCHH POCCHH Ha
lOr H SOCTOK CasHQKHR nblTaeTCH npenOlHecTH ee KaK 060shy
pOHHTeJlbHYIO Mepy S PaMKax nOHHTHH npOlsHHYTOR rpaHHshy
QbI HeCOMHeHHO aHaJlOrH1JHOrO TOMy nOHHTHIO KOTopoe
0150CHoBblBaJIO I5pHTaHcKYIO nOJIHTHKY B I1HIHH 50Jlee Toro
CaBHQKHR loKa3blsaeT 1JTO PYCCKYIO 3KcnaHCHIO B QeJIOM MO~HO
paccMaTpHsaTb KaK HenpepblSHblR npoQecc opraHH1JeCKOrO
pa3SHTHH B ero onHcaHHH 3TO BHIHTCH 1JYTb JlH He KaK 3KOshy
JlOrH1JeCKHR npoQecc l5e3 KaKOR-JlHI50 nOJIHTH1JeCKOR MOTHshy
SHPOBKH CKpblBalOlI(eRcH 3a HHM H HMnepHaJIHCTH1JeCKOrO COshy
nepHH1JeCTBa BeJlHKHX lep~as CSH3aHHOro CO cpelHea3HaTCshy
KHM H laJIbHeBOCT01JHblM sonpocaMH CJlelOSaTeJlbHO lOKa3b1shy
BaeT CaBHQKHR PYCCKaR EBpa3HR eCTb reonOJlHTH1JeCKOe elHHshy
CTSO B ce6e C031aHHOe KYJlbTYPHblM npOQeCCOM reHeTH1JeCshy
KoR MyTaQHH a He nOcpelCTSOM 3asoeBaHHA H pa3pyweHHA~ KaK BHIHM TaKOe TOJlKOBaHHe He CJIHWKOM OTJlH1JaeTCR OT KOHshy
QenQHH IHHaMH1JeCKOrO ~H3HeHHoro npOCTpaHCTBa CPPHIPHshy
xa PaTQeJlR KOTOPYlO KapJl XaycxollJep npHHRJI B 20-e rOlbl
EBPA3HAcKOE CBRH)f(EHHE H CRHHHHE
BeCbMa JlI060nbiTHO HBHOe CXOlCTBO Me~IY CJlOBapeM eBshy
pa3HAQeB H COBeTCKoA TepMHHOJlOrHeA xpYlI(eBCKoA 3nOXH
OTHOCHTeJIbHO KYJIbTypHO-HaQHOHaJIbHOrO CJIHRHHR nol JlIOshy
60BHbiM Hal30pOM CTapmero PYCCKoro 6paTa B pa60Tax nCashy
SHQKoro H B oc06eHHocTH B TpYIaX HCTopHKa r BepHaICKOshy
ro HepelKO BCTpe1JaIOTCR TepMHHbl CJ1HJ1HHe H nepeMeJIJHBashy
HHe 1JTO RKOl5bl HMeeT MeCTO B npoQecce TeppHTOpHaJlbHOR
3KcnaHCHH KYJlbMHHaQHR KOTOpoA - 1IJ0pMHpoBaHHe BeJlHshy
KOPYCCKOA KYJlbTYPbl TaK 3aMe1JaHHe BepHalCKoro 1JTO nol
BHeWHHM pa3Ho06pa3HeM CKpblBaeTCH BHYTpeHHee elHHCTBO
143
HanOMHHaeT pacxo)l(ee COBeTCKOe nOHHTHe 0 eQHHCTBe 8
MHorootlpa3HH
B MaHepe He CJIHmKOM OTJIHLlalOIleRcH OT COBeTCKHX CTaH~
QapTOB BepHaQCKHR QOKa3bIBaJI LITO BKJIIOLleHHe HepYCCKHX
rpynn B MHorOHauHOHaJIbYIO eBpa3HRcKYIO HMnepHIO C03Qa~
eT orpOMHbIe 3KOHOMHLleCKHe H KYJIbTypHbIe npeHMYIlIeCTBa O~~
HaKO BepHaQCKHR HaCTaHBaJI npH 3TOM LITO eQHHCTBO QOJI)I(HO
tlbITb 3KYMeHHLleCKHM tle3 HaBH3bIBaHHH HtlO PoccHRcKoe
rocy~apcTBO - eBpa3HRcKoe rOCYQapCTBO H Bce OTQeJIbHbIe
HaUHOHaJIbHOCTH Espa3HH QOJI)I(Hbl LlYBCTBOBaTb LITO 3TO HX
rocy~apcTBO H npH3HaBaTb ero (KypCHB BepHaQCKOrO) CHJIa
3Toro eBpa3HRcKoro otlpa30BaHHH JIe)l(HT B ero CBOtlOQHOM
KYJIbTYPHOM TBopLleCTBe41 KpOMe Toro Qa)l(e eCJIH PycCKHR
HapoQ otlpa3yeT rJIaBHYIO CHJIY eBpa3HRCKoro rocy~apcTBa a
PYCCKHR H3b1K - tla30BbiR CJIoR eBpa3HRcKoR KYJIbTYPbI Bce
3TO HeJIb3H HaBH3b1BaTb QpyrHM Hapo~aM HeCMOTpH Ha BeJIH~
LlHe 3THX HQeR BbICKa3bIBaBmHXCH eBpa3HRuaMH-3MHrpaHTaMH
He HecmHMH HHKaKoR nOJIHTHLIeCKoR OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH H
HMeSmHMH BeCbMa MaJIOe BJIHHHHe B HOBOA COBeTCKoR eBposhy
a3HaTCKoR HMnepHH QPyme CJIaBHHCKHe HapO~bI B ocotleHshy
HOCTH HaHtlOJIee MHOrOLlHCJIeHHble cnoCJIe PYCCKHX) HanpHshy
Mep YKPaHHUbl H nOJIHKH HcnblTbIBaJIH rJIytloKoe HeQOBepHe
K ueJIHM eBpa3HRueB H BbICTYaJIH npOTHB HHX2 K CO)l(aJIeHHIO
HHLlero He H3seCTHO 0 peaKUHH Ha TeopHH eBpa3HAueB a3HaTshy
CKHX HHTeJIJIeKTyaJIOB )l(HBmHX noQ COBeTCKHM pe)l(HMOM
MO)l(HO OQHaKO tle30mHtloLiHo nOJIaraTb LITO OHH BHQeJIH B
3THX TeOpHHX JIHmb YTOHLleHHoe onpaSQaHHe PYCCKoro HMneshy
pHaJIH3Ma
TaKHM otlpa30M eBpa3HRcKoe ~BH)I(eHHe caMO Toro He
C03HaBaH cnoc06CTBOBaJIO $OpMHPOBaHHIO YTonHLleCKoro 06shy
pa3a coseTCKoro LleJIOBeKa - HCKyccTBeHHoro nOpO)l(~eHHH
COBeTCKoR nponaraHQbl He HMelOIlero KaKOrO-JIH60 paCOBoro
HJIH 3THHLleCKOro npOHCXO)l(QeHHH HO rOBOpHIlero no-pYCCKH
H OIlYIlalOIlero ce6H KOHeLiHO )l(e PYCCKHM COBeTCKaH MOshy
QeJIb - TpOHua COCTOHIlaH H3 Tpex CTaQHA - paCUBeT-c6JIHshy
)l(eHHe-CJIHHHHe BeCbMa pa3BHTaH B 3noxy XPYIleBa pa3Hshy
TeJIbHO HanOMHHaeT eBpa3HRcKoe BHQeHHe 1920-x rO~OB OHa
OTpa)l(aeT TaK)I(e HCTopHLIeCKHA onbIT HaKOnJIeHHblA PycCKOR
HHTeJIJIHreHUHeR no HaUHOHaJIbHblM H paCOBblM BonpocaM
KOTopbIe PYCCKHe MbICJIHTeJIH BnepBble nO~HHJIH B XIX B
144
KaK nOKa3blBaeT 3JIeH Kappep Ii AHKOC BCsl COBeTCKasl
(OHuenUHH B otlJIaCTH onpeQeJIeHHH H 3aKOHHoro O$opMJIeHHsl
OTHomeHHA Me)l(~y PYCCKHMH H HepyccKHMH npeTepneJIa
MHO)l(eCTBO H3MeHeHHA43 B npoTHBOnOJIO)l(HOCTb neHHHcKoR
yTOnHH OTMHpaHHsl HauHA H rocYQapcTB H 3aMeHbl HX HOBblM
YHHBepCaJIbHbIM OOIlecTBOM npOJIeTapCKoA KJIaCCOBOR COJIHshy
~apHOCTH 60JIee )l(ecToKHA H OCMOTpHTeJIbHbIA CTaJIHH
nocTeneHHo npe06pa30BaJI HQelO $eQepaUHH B H~elO ueHT~
paJIH30BaHHHoro PyccKoro HaQ30pa HaQ $opMaJIbHO aBTOshy
HOMHbIMH HapoQaMH COBeTcKoro COI03a 3Ta peaJIbHOCTb npeshy
BpaTHJIa Bee COBeTCKHe TeopHH no HaUHOHaJIbHOMY Bonpocy B
nycTOnOpO)l(HHe ynpa)l(HeHHH H3 KOTOPblX H~eH CTaJIHHa TaK
H He 6blJIH YCTpaHeHbl BbI)I(HBaHHe MHorOHaUHOHaJIbHOR
eBpa3HAcKoA TeppHTOpHaJIbHOA KpenOCTH nO-npe)l(HeMY
ynpaBJIHeMOA MYQPbIM CTapmHM PYCCKHM 6paTOM 6YQeT
3aBHCeTb npe)l(Qe Bcero OT pemeHHH nOQHHTbIX eBpa3HAuaMH
BonpOCOB
145
flpHMeqaHHR
1 Andrew Malozemoff Russian Far Eastern Policy 1881-1904 (Berkeley University of California Press 1958) 42 2 FF von Martens Russland und England in Zentralasien (St Petersburg 1880) Heinz Gollwitzer Geschichte des wetpolischen denkens (Gottingen Vandenhoeck amp Ruprecht 1982) 152-70 133-36 3 F F von Martens Le Conflict entre la Russie et la Chine (Bruxel~
les 1880) 4 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) 93-103 WP Wassiliew Die Erschliessung Chinas (Leipzig 1909) 5 WP Wassiliew Die Erschliessung Chinas (Leipzig 1909)49 6 NM Prejevalsky From Kulja accross the Tian Shan to Lob-Nor (London Sampson Low 1879) 7 MA Bakunin La theologie politique de Mazzini et lInternatishyonale (Neufchatel 1871) 102 110 8 AN Kuropatkin Memoiren (Berlin 1919)7174 9 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) 1423-24 111 10 1S Bloch Les Illusions de la Conquette Chinoise Revue des Revues (August 15 1900) 11 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) 14 12 Herold J Weins Chinas March toward the Tropics (Hamden Conn Shoe String Press 1954) 13 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) p 24 14 CH IQlKaKOB AHrJIO-PycCIltaH pacnpH cmgt 1885 15 HltIgtltIgteAopoB ltlgtHJIocoIllHH oOIIlero AeJIa - UHT no HltIgtltIgteAopoB COqHHeHHH M MbICJIb 1982 0 BJIHHHHH ltlgteAoshypOBa Ha llocToeBcKoro TOJICTOrO COJIOBbeBa BepAHeBa BYJIraKOBa HAP CM Stephen Lukashevich NF Fedorov - A Study in Russian Eupsychian and Utopian Thought (Newark University of Delaware Press 1977) pp 13-34 16 HltIgtltIgteAopoB CotJHHeHHH 1982 CTp 343 Sarkisyanz Op cit 210-211 HACeTHHUKHA PyccKHe MbICJIHTeJIH 0 KHTae XapoHH 1926 17 BJIaAHMHp JIbBOB 3araAotJHblA CTapHIlt JI COBeTcKHA nHshyCaTeJIb 1977 CTp 129-135 HltIgtltIgteAopoB CotJHHeHHH (962) CTp 335-336 18 HltIgtltIgteAopoB CotJHHeHHH CTp 216 340 382 669
146
19 TaM lKe CTp 300 20 BCCOJIOBbeB TPH pa3roBopa cms TPYA 1904 21 Malozemoff Russian Far Eastern Policy (1958) p 43 22 JIeHHH 0 BoAHe B KHTae - HCKpa 1 AeKaopH 1900 23 ABeJIbIA neTepoypr UHT no H3A London Penguin 1983 CTP 65 24 Sarkisyanz Russland und der Messianismus(1955) 200 21~218
25 AJIeKCaHAP BJIOK CTHxoTBopeHHH H n03Mbl TeaTp M XYAOlKeCTBeHHaH JIHTepaTypa 1968 CTp 644-645 26 C EceHHH CoopaHHe cotJHHeHHA Mbull 1970 T5 cTP 107 27 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) 42 98-99 28 Sarkisyanz Russland und der Messianismus(1955) 218~22
29 Malozernoff Russian Far Eastern Policy (1958)43-44 30 BH Sumner Russia and Europe Oxford Slavonic Papers (1951) II 1-16B Readings in Russian Civilization nOA peA Thomas Riha (Chicago University of Chicago Press 1964) 1147331 Malozemoff Russian Far Eastern Policy (1958) 43 Sarkisyanz Russland und der Messianismus (1955)378-91 32 Gollwitzer Geschichte (1982) I 138-40 33 Hermann Brunnhofer Russlands Hand Uber Asien Historischshygeographische Essays zur Entwick lungsgechichte des Russichen Reichsdenkens (S1 Petersburg 1897) npeAHCJIOBHe llBeAuapeu BpYHxolllep onpaBAblBaJI pyCCKylO 3IltCnaHCHIO B CpeAHeA A3HH H Ha llaJIbHeM BOCTOKe B cepHH cTaTeA BnepB~e onYOJIHKOBaHHbIx B neTepoyprcKHx ra3eTax Ha HeMeUKOM H3blKe St Petersburger Zeitung H St Petersburger Herold OH n~shyTaJICH OOOCHOBaTb PYCCKHA 3KcnaHCHOHH3M B A3HH CO~shyCTBeHHblMH H3bICKaHHHMH B apHAcKoA MHlIloJIorHH CpeAH ApyrHx paooT OH onYOJIHKOBaJI TpexToMHHK Urgechichte der Arier in Vorder-und Centralasien Historich-geographische Untersuchungen uber den altesten Schauplatz des Rigvedas und Avestas (Leipzig 1983) BpYHxolllep nepeBen TaKlKe o~beshyMHCTbIA OTtJeT KHH3H YXTOMCKoro 0 noe3AKe ueCapeBHqa HHKOJIaH Ha llaJIbHHA BOCTOK Orientreise seiner Kaiserlicher Hohe heit des Grossfursten Thronfolgers (Leipzig Brockhaus 1894 1998) 34 ltIgtHTIOTtJeB JIHpHKa HaYKa 1965 TI1 M CTp 118 35 Ein ostasiatischer Dreibund und die buddhistische Weltproshypaganda B KH BpYHxolllepa Russland Hand uber Aden (1897) 24-29 BnepB~e onYOJIHKOBaHa BSt Petersburger Zeitung B 1894 r
147
36 Louis Fischer The Soviets in the World Affairs (Princeton Princeton University Press 1951) n 534-37 Sir Fitzroy Maclean To the Back ofBeyond (London Cape 1974) 119-121 37 AKatteMHK BapTOJlbtt COllHHeHHR M H3tt-BO BOCTOllHoA JlHTepaTYpbI 1963 T2 cTp 164-166345-350 38 Hcxott K BOCTOKY npettllYBCTBHR H cBepmeHHR YTBepshy)l(tteHHe eBpa3HAueB CO(j)HR 1921 COttep)l(HT CTaTbH rBltJ)JloshypOBcKoro POMaHa HKoCicoHa nllCasllHHcKoro nH CaBHUshyKoro H HCTpyCieUKoro HH)I(e nepellHCJIRIOTCR OCHOBHhIe paCioTbI 0 espa3HAuax DS Mirsky The Eurasian Movement The Slavonic and East European Review (1927) 311-320 Otto Boss Die Lehre der Eurasier (Wiesbaden Harrasowitz 1961) H A Stammler Europe-Russland-Asian Der eurasiche Deutungsshyversuch der russichen Geschichte Osteuropa 12 (1962) 521-528 Gerges Nivat Du Panmongolisme au mouvement eurasien Cahiers du monde Russe et Sovietique 73 (1966) 460-78 Nicholas V Riasanovsky The Emergence of Eurasians California Slavic Studies 4 (1967) 39-72 39 HC TpylSeUKoA Espona H lIeJIOBelleCTBO CO(j)HR 192Q Mirsky The Eurasian Movement (1927) 312-13 V Riasanovsky Emergence of Eurasians (1967) 56 Leonid Luks Die Ideologie der Eurasier im zeitgeschichtlichen Zusammenhang Jahrbucher fur Geschichte Osteuropas 34 (1986) 374-395 40 llH CasHUKHA reOnOJlHTHlIeCKHe 3aMeTKH no PYCCKoA
HCTOpHH - B rB BepHattCKHA HallepTaHHe PYCCKoA HCshyTOpHH llpara 1927 CTp 234-260 CM TaK)I(e nHCasHUKHA reOrpa(j)HlIeCKHe ocolSeHHOCTH POCCHH 2 TT npara 1927 OH )l(e POCCHR - OCOlSblA reorpa(j)HlIecKHA MHp llapH)I( 1927 Charles Halperin Russia and the Steppe George Vernadsky and Eurasianism Forschungen zur osteuropaischen Geschichte 36 (1985) 55-194 and Slavic Studies 41 (1982)477-493 41 rB BepHattcKHA YKa3 COli CTp 230-231 259-260 Charles Halperin Opcit pp 99-104 42 V Riasanovsky The Emergence of Eurasians California Slavic Studies 4 (1967) 43 H Carrere dEncausse Decline of an Empire The Soviet Socialist Republics in Revolt (New York Harper 1981) 13-46
148
npOllBH)KEHHE POCCHH K lOrY
POCCHflCKHE llPOCTOPbI
Hepa3pemHMble npOCiJIeMbI CJlHRHHR pac B orpoMHoM MHOshyrOHaUHOHaJIbHOM KOHrJlOMepaTe Ha3blBaeMOM POCCHAcKOA (a n03ttHee coseTCKoA) eBpa3HAcKoA HMnepHeA eme CioJlee 01S0shyCTPRIOTCR B reorpa(j)HlIecKHx nOHRTHRX - B TpyttHeAmeM nposhyCTpaHcTseHHoM IIHcCiaJIaHce ttoBJIeIOmHM Hall olSmHM reOCTpashyTerHlIeCKHM nOJIO)l(eHHeM HMnepHH
MeTa(j)opHlIeCKH ynpomaR HCTOPHIO POCCHAcKOA HMnepHH nottllac CBOttRT K TparHlIeCKoA Ollep)l(HMOCTH npOCTopOM HJIH K TparHlIeCKOMY lIapy npOCTpaHCTsaI COrJlaCHO 3THM npettCTaBJIeHHRM PYCCKHX - H KaK OISOpOHRIOmHXCR H KaK arpeccopOB nOCTORHHO H Heyttep)l(HMO BJIeKJlH orpOMHble npOCTpaHCTBa Espa3HH PYCCKHe rOpllRTCR TeM liTO s HX rHshyraHTCKoA cyxonYTHoA TBepttbIHe MO)l(HO pa3MecTHTb 2-3 AMepHKH 40 ltJ)paHUHA H 93 BeJIHKOlSpHTaHHH Me)l(lIY 1600 H 1900 rr K PoccHAcKOA HMnepHH 1I0lSaBHJIOCb B olSmeA CJIO)l(HOCTH 17 MJIH KSattpaTHblx KHJIOMeTpOB HOBblX TeppHshyTOPHA s cpellHeM no 57 TbIC KBatlpaTHhIX KHJlOMeTpoB e)l(eshyrOttHo3 HCXOIlR H3 3Toro HeTpyttHO npHIITH K 3aKJIIOlIeHHIO liTO reorpa(j)HR H s caMOM tteJle OKa3b1BaJla BceCTopOHHee BJlHRHHe Ha pYCCKoe H coseTCKoe BOCnpHRTHe A3HH~
TaKHM 01Spa30M reorpa(j)HlIeamA (j)aKTOp HrpaeT orpOMshyHyIO pOJlb S HCTOPHH pYCCKoro Hapottaf ocolSeHHO B CBR3H C lIpe3MepHbiM YBJIelleHHeM HMnepHaJlHCTHlIeCKoA POCCHH npOCTpaHCTBaMH H TeppHTOpHRMH )lse reorpa(j)HlIeCKHe OCOshylSeHHOCTH OTJIHlIaIOT POCCHIO llepBaR - 3TO 0llHooeipa3He peJIbshye(j)a MeCTHOCTH MOHOTOHHOCTb JlaHttma(j)Ta n03S0JIHSmaR UeHTpaJIbHOA nOJIHTHlIeCKoA BJIaCTH nOllttep)l(HBaTb H pacshynpOCTpaHRTb csoA KOHTPOJIb no JIHHHH SeJIHKHX pellHhIx nyshyTeA TRHymHXCR no OCH ceBep-IOr TaKoA KOHTPOJlb oeiJlerllaJl ttBH)I(eHHe TosapOB KOJlOHHCTOB H BoACK~ no CJIOBaM BblllaIOmeshyrOCR HCTopHKa KJIIOlIeSCKoro 3KCnaHCHR MOCKBbI MO)l(eT paCCMaTpHBaTbCR KaK B03BblmeHHe ueHTpOCTpeMHTeJlbHOA CHJIbl 3aXBaTHBmeA KOHTPOJlb HatI HCTOKaMH lIeTblpex peK B
149
TaKHX KaK HMnepHH AJleKCaHIpa BeJlHKOrO MOHrOJlOS apaOOB
H la~e COSpeMeHHOR eMY POCCHRcKOR HMnepHH S CpelHeR
A3HH OH HCKpeHHe SepHJI 1JTO KpynHble CTpYKTYPbl C031alOT Jlyqshy
mHe YCJlOSHH lJIH KYJlbTypHOrO c6J1H~eHHH HapOlOS pa3J1H1Jshy
HbIX pac HeCMOTpH Ha sce 6elcTsHH KOTopble HecyT SORHbI
conpoSo~IalOlI(He C031aHHe TaKHX HMnepHR~7
HCXO~ HA BOCTOK TPYBEQKOA H CABHQKHA
HeCMOTpH Ha HeYIa1JH CSH3aHHble C PYCCKO-HnOHCKOR H
nepsoR MHposoR soRHaMH PYCCKHe npeTeH3HH Ha oc06ble
OTHOmeHHH C A3HeR npolOJl~aJlH ~HTb cpelH HHTeJlJlHreHshy
QHH a S rOlbI peSOJlIOQHH rp~IaHcKoR SORHbl H cpa3Y ~e nocshy
Jle HHX TaKHe npereH3HH la~e YCHJlHJlHCb Hp1Je scero 3TO 80shy
nJlOTHJlOCb B eSpa3HRCKOM lSH~eHHH KOTopoe cnJlOTHJlO cashy
Mble 6J1ecTHII(He yMbi PYCCKoR 3MHrpaQHH 1920-x rolos Heshy
CMOTPH Ha HepelKHe pa3HorJlaCHH OHH 6blJlH y6e~IeHbl 1JTO
JlHlUb SOCnpHHHS oc060e eBpa3HRcKoe MHpOS033peHHe MO~HO
coxpaHHTb oc060CTb PYCCKoro SKJlala S QHSHJlH3aQHIO OCHOshy
saHHoro KaK Ha rpeKO-SH3aHTHRCKOM TaK H Ha MOHrOJlbCKOM
HaCJlelHH B csoeM nepSOM MaHHlIJecTe l1cxol Ha SOCTOK
(1921 r) lBa SbIIaIOII(HXCH JlHHrBHCTa KHH3b HHKoJlaR Tpy6eQshy
KoR H POMaH HK06coH OTCTaHBaJIH espa3HRcKoe CJlHHHHe H3blshy
KOS H KYJlbTYP (TaK Ha3b1BaeMaH TeOpllH H3bIKOBoro COI03a -
Sprachbund) C03HaTeJlbHO npeYBeJlH1JHBaH SJlHHHHe TypaHcKoshy
ro 3J1eMeHTa38
EBpa3HRQbl C1JHTaJlH 60JlblUeBHKoB H MapKcH3M XYIIUHM
CJlelCTBHeM 3analHoR KYJlbTYPbl OlHaKO caMoe peBOJlIOQHIO
OHH paccMaTpHBaJlH KaK BeJlHKHR H He06XOlHMblR KaTaJlH3ashy
TOp OHa pa3pYIUHJla CTapblR MHp H np06YIHJla OlHospeMeHHO
H PYCCKHe MaCCbl H HapOlbl BOCTOKa n03TOMY pa60Ta Tpy6eQshy
Koro EBpona H 1JeJlOBe1JeCTBo lt1920 r) 1JHTaeTCH KaK HeKoe
C01JeTaHHe lIaHHJleSCKOro H npH3biSOS sToporo KOHrpecca Koshy
MHHTepHa JTO pemHTeJlbHOe 06BHHeHHe 3analHoMY HMneshy
PHaJIH3MY KOTopoe oTBepraeT eBpOQeHTpHCTCKHR nolXOl K
A3HH YHH~eHHe HcnblTaHHoe PoccHeR S XOle BoRHbl H peBoshy
JlIOQHH nHmeT Tpy6eQKoR Mo~eT C031aTb HenOBTopHMYIO
B03MO~HOCTb palHKaJlbHOrO nepecMoTpa OTHOmeHHH K Hepycshy
CKHM HapOlaM POCCHH 6YIYIJH CaMa KOJlOHHeR Mo~eT noshy
142
BeCTH lpyrHe KOJlOHHH B oc06eHHocTH CSOHX laquoa3HaTCKHX cecshy
Tepraquo Ha pelUHTeJlbHYIO 60Pb15y npoTHB pOMaHo-repMaHcKHx
KOJlOHH3aTopOB 39
OlHHM H3 caMbiX opHrHHaJlbHblX MblCJlHTeJleR CpelH
eBpa3HRQes I5blJl reorpallJ neTp CasHQKHR (1895-1968 rr) Coshy
rJlaCHO ero KOHQenQHH Espa3HH - nOlJlHHHaH KYJlbTypHOshy
reorpaIlJH1JeCKaH Ol5lI(HOCTb C lOOaS01JHblM nOTeHQHaJIOM Tepshy
pHTOpHaJlbHOR 3KcnaHCHH (MecTopa3sHTHe HJlH TonoreHeshy
3HC) rOSOpH 0 Ha1JaslUeRcH S XIX BeKe 3KCnaHCHH POCCHH Ha
lOr H SOCTOK CasHQKHR nblTaeTCH npenOlHecTH ee KaK 060shy
pOHHTeJlbHYIO Mepy S PaMKax nOHHTHH npOlsHHYTOR rpaHHshy
QbI HeCOMHeHHO aHaJlOrH1JHOrO TOMy nOHHTHIO KOTopoe
0150CHoBblBaJIO I5pHTaHcKYIO nOJIHTHKY B I1HIHH 50Jlee Toro
CaBHQKHR loKa3blsaeT 1JTO PYCCKYIO 3KcnaHCHIO B QeJIOM MO~HO
paccMaTpHsaTb KaK HenpepblSHblR npoQecc opraHH1JeCKOrO
pa3SHTHH B ero onHcaHHH 3TO BHIHTCH 1JYTb JlH He KaK 3KOshy
JlOrH1JeCKHR npoQecc l5e3 KaKOR-JlHI50 nOJIHTH1JeCKOR MOTHshy
SHPOBKH CKpblBalOlI(eRcH 3a HHM H HMnepHaJIHCTH1JeCKOrO COshy
nepHH1JeCTBa BeJlHKHX lep~as CSH3aHHOro CO cpelHea3HaTCshy
KHM H laJIbHeBOCT01JHblM sonpocaMH CJlelOSaTeJlbHO lOKa3b1shy
BaeT CaBHQKHR PYCCKaR EBpa3HR eCTb reonOJlHTH1JeCKOe elHHshy
CTSO B ce6e C031aHHOe KYJlbTYPHblM npOQeCCOM reHeTH1JeCshy
KoR MyTaQHH a He nOcpelCTSOM 3asoeBaHHA H pa3pyweHHA~ KaK BHIHM TaKOe TOJlKOBaHHe He CJIHWKOM OTJlH1JaeTCR OT KOHshy
QenQHH IHHaMH1JeCKOrO ~H3HeHHoro npOCTpaHCTBa CPPHIPHshy
xa PaTQeJlR KOTOPYlO KapJl XaycxollJep npHHRJI B 20-e rOlbl
EBPA3HAcKOE CBRH)f(EHHE H CRHHHHE
BeCbMa JlI060nbiTHO HBHOe CXOlCTBO Me~IY CJlOBapeM eBshy
pa3HAQeB H COBeTCKoA TepMHHOJlOrHeA xpYlI(eBCKoA 3nOXH
OTHOCHTeJIbHO KYJIbTypHO-HaQHOHaJIbHOrO CJIHRHHR nol JlIOshy
60BHbiM Hal30pOM CTapmero PYCCKoro 6paTa B pa60Tax nCashy
SHQKoro H B oc06eHHocTH B TpYIaX HCTopHKa r BepHaICKOshy
ro HepelKO BCTpe1JaIOTCR TepMHHbl CJ1HJ1HHe H nepeMeJIJHBashy
HHe 1JTO RKOl5bl HMeeT MeCTO B npoQecce TeppHTOpHaJlbHOR
3KcnaHCHH KYJlbMHHaQHR KOTOpoA - 1IJ0pMHpoBaHHe BeJlHshy
KOPYCCKOA KYJlbTYPbl TaK 3aMe1JaHHe BepHalCKoro 1JTO nol
BHeWHHM pa3Ho06pa3HeM CKpblBaeTCH BHYTpeHHee elHHCTBO
143
HanOMHHaeT pacxo)l(ee COBeTCKOe nOHHTHe 0 eQHHCTBe 8
MHorootlpa3HH
B MaHepe He CJIHmKOM OTJIHLlalOIleRcH OT COBeTCKHX CTaH~
QapTOB BepHaQCKHR QOKa3bIBaJI LITO BKJIIOLleHHe HepYCCKHX
rpynn B MHorOHauHOHaJIbYIO eBpa3HRcKYIO HMnepHIO C03Qa~
eT orpOMHbIe 3KOHOMHLleCKHe H KYJIbTypHbIe npeHMYIlIeCTBa O~~
HaKO BepHaQCKHR HaCTaHBaJI npH 3TOM LITO eQHHCTBO QOJI)I(HO
tlbITb 3KYMeHHLleCKHM tle3 HaBH3bIBaHHH HtlO PoccHRcKoe
rocy~apcTBO - eBpa3HRcKoe rOCYQapCTBO H Bce OTQeJIbHbIe
HaUHOHaJIbHOCTH Espa3HH QOJI)I(Hbl LlYBCTBOBaTb LITO 3TO HX
rocy~apcTBO H npH3HaBaTb ero (KypCHB BepHaQCKOrO) CHJIa
3Toro eBpa3HRcKoro otlpa30BaHHH JIe)l(HT B ero CBOtlOQHOM
KYJIbTYPHOM TBopLleCTBe41 KpOMe Toro Qa)l(e eCJIH PycCKHR
HapoQ otlpa3yeT rJIaBHYIO CHJIY eBpa3HRCKoro rocy~apcTBa a
PYCCKHR H3b1K - tla30BbiR CJIoR eBpa3HRcKoR KYJIbTYPbI Bce
3TO HeJIb3H HaBH3b1BaTb QpyrHM Hapo~aM HeCMOTpH Ha BeJIH~
LlHe 3THX HQeR BbICKa3bIBaBmHXCH eBpa3HRuaMH-3MHrpaHTaMH
He HecmHMH HHKaKoR nOJIHTHLIeCKoR OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH H
HMeSmHMH BeCbMa MaJIOe BJIHHHHe B HOBOA COBeTCKoR eBposhy
a3HaTCKoR HMnepHH QPyme CJIaBHHCKHe HapO~bI B ocotleHshy
HOCTH HaHtlOJIee MHOrOLlHCJIeHHble cnoCJIe PYCCKHX) HanpHshy
Mep YKPaHHUbl H nOJIHKH HcnblTbIBaJIH rJIytloKoe HeQOBepHe
K ueJIHM eBpa3HRueB H BbICTYaJIH npOTHB HHX2 K CO)l(aJIeHHIO
HHLlero He H3seCTHO 0 peaKUHH Ha TeopHH eBpa3HAueB a3HaTshy
CKHX HHTeJIJIeKTyaJIOB )l(HBmHX noQ COBeTCKHM pe)l(HMOM
MO)l(HO OQHaKO tle30mHtloLiHo nOJIaraTb LITO OHH BHQeJIH B
3THX TeOpHHX JIHmb YTOHLleHHoe onpaSQaHHe PYCCKoro HMneshy
pHaJIH3Ma
TaKHM otlpa30M eBpa3HRcKoe ~BH)I(eHHe caMO Toro He
C03HaBaH cnoc06CTBOBaJIO $OpMHPOBaHHIO YTonHLleCKoro 06shy
pa3a coseTCKoro LleJIOBeKa - HCKyccTBeHHoro nOpO)l(~eHHH
COBeTCKoR nponaraHQbl He HMelOIlero KaKOrO-JIH60 paCOBoro
HJIH 3THHLleCKOro npOHCXO)l(QeHHH HO rOBOpHIlero no-pYCCKH
H OIlYIlalOIlero ce6H KOHeLiHO )l(e PYCCKHM COBeTCKaH MOshy
QeJIb - TpOHua COCTOHIlaH H3 Tpex CTaQHA - paCUBeT-c6JIHshy
)l(eHHe-CJIHHHHe BeCbMa pa3BHTaH B 3noxy XPYIleBa pa3Hshy
TeJIbHO HanOMHHaeT eBpa3HRcKoe BHQeHHe 1920-x rO~OB OHa
OTpa)l(aeT TaK)I(e HCTopHLIeCKHA onbIT HaKOnJIeHHblA PycCKOR
HHTeJIJIHreHUHeR no HaUHOHaJIbHblM H paCOBblM BonpocaM
KOTopbIe PYCCKHe MbICJIHTeJIH BnepBble nO~HHJIH B XIX B
144
KaK nOKa3blBaeT 3JIeH Kappep Ii AHKOC BCsl COBeTCKasl
(OHuenUHH B otlJIaCTH onpeQeJIeHHH H 3aKOHHoro O$opMJIeHHsl
OTHomeHHA Me)l(~y PYCCKHMH H HepyccKHMH npeTepneJIa
MHO)l(eCTBO H3MeHeHHA43 B npoTHBOnOJIO)l(HOCTb neHHHcKoR
yTOnHH OTMHpaHHsl HauHA H rocYQapcTB H 3aMeHbl HX HOBblM
YHHBepCaJIbHbIM OOIlecTBOM npOJIeTapCKoA KJIaCCOBOR COJIHshy
~apHOCTH 60JIee )l(ecToKHA H OCMOTpHTeJIbHbIA CTaJIHH
nocTeneHHo npe06pa30BaJI HQelO $eQepaUHH B H~elO ueHT~
paJIH30BaHHHoro PyccKoro HaQ30pa HaQ $opMaJIbHO aBTOshy
HOMHbIMH HapoQaMH COBeTcKoro COI03a 3Ta peaJIbHOCTb npeshy
BpaTHJIa Bee COBeTCKHe TeopHH no HaUHOHaJIbHOMY Bonpocy B
nycTOnOpO)l(HHe ynpa)l(HeHHH H3 KOTOPblX H~eH CTaJIHHa TaK
H He 6blJIH YCTpaHeHbl BbI)I(HBaHHe MHorOHaUHOHaJIbHOR
eBpa3HAcKoA TeppHTOpHaJIbHOA KpenOCTH nO-npe)l(HeMY
ynpaBJIHeMOA MYQPbIM CTapmHM PYCCKHM 6paTOM 6YQeT
3aBHCeTb npe)l(Qe Bcero OT pemeHHH nOQHHTbIX eBpa3HAuaMH
BonpOCOB
145
flpHMeqaHHR
1 Andrew Malozemoff Russian Far Eastern Policy 1881-1904 (Berkeley University of California Press 1958) 42 2 FF von Martens Russland und England in Zentralasien (St Petersburg 1880) Heinz Gollwitzer Geschichte des wetpolischen denkens (Gottingen Vandenhoeck amp Ruprecht 1982) 152-70 133-36 3 F F von Martens Le Conflict entre la Russie et la Chine (Bruxel~
les 1880) 4 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) 93-103 WP Wassiliew Die Erschliessung Chinas (Leipzig 1909) 5 WP Wassiliew Die Erschliessung Chinas (Leipzig 1909)49 6 NM Prejevalsky From Kulja accross the Tian Shan to Lob-Nor (London Sampson Low 1879) 7 MA Bakunin La theologie politique de Mazzini et lInternatishyonale (Neufchatel 1871) 102 110 8 AN Kuropatkin Memoiren (Berlin 1919)7174 9 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) 1423-24 111 10 1S Bloch Les Illusions de la Conquette Chinoise Revue des Revues (August 15 1900) 11 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) 14 12 Herold J Weins Chinas March toward the Tropics (Hamden Conn Shoe String Press 1954) 13 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) p 24 14 CH IQlKaKOB AHrJIO-PycCIltaH pacnpH cmgt 1885 15 HltIgtltIgteAopoB ltlgtHJIocoIllHH oOIIlero AeJIa - UHT no HltIgtltIgteAopoB COqHHeHHH M MbICJIb 1982 0 BJIHHHHH ltlgteAoshypOBa Ha llocToeBcKoro TOJICTOrO COJIOBbeBa BepAHeBa BYJIraKOBa HAP CM Stephen Lukashevich NF Fedorov - A Study in Russian Eupsychian and Utopian Thought (Newark University of Delaware Press 1977) pp 13-34 16 HltIgtltIgteAopoB CotJHHeHHH 1982 CTp 343 Sarkisyanz Op cit 210-211 HACeTHHUKHA PyccKHe MbICJIHTeJIH 0 KHTae XapoHH 1926 17 BJIaAHMHp JIbBOB 3araAotJHblA CTapHIlt JI COBeTcKHA nHshyCaTeJIb 1977 CTp 129-135 HltIgtltIgteAopoB CotJHHeHHH (962) CTp 335-336 18 HltIgtltIgteAopoB CotJHHeHHH CTp 216 340 382 669
146
19 TaM lKe CTp 300 20 BCCOJIOBbeB TPH pa3roBopa cms TPYA 1904 21 Malozemoff Russian Far Eastern Policy (1958) p 43 22 JIeHHH 0 BoAHe B KHTae - HCKpa 1 AeKaopH 1900 23 ABeJIbIA neTepoypr UHT no H3A London Penguin 1983 CTP 65 24 Sarkisyanz Russland und der Messianismus(1955) 200 21~218
25 AJIeKCaHAP BJIOK CTHxoTBopeHHH H n03Mbl TeaTp M XYAOlKeCTBeHHaH JIHTepaTypa 1968 CTp 644-645 26 C EceHHH CoopaHHe cotJHHeHHA Mbull 1970 T5 cTP 107 27 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) 42 98-99 28 Sarkisyanz Russland und der Messianismus(1955) 218~22
29 Malozernoff Russian Far Eastern Policy (1958)43-44 30 BH Sumner Russia and Europe Oxford Slavonic Papers (1951) II 1-16B Readings in Russian Civilization nOA peA Thomas Riha (Chicago University of Chicago Press 1964) 1147331 Malozemoff Russian Far Eastern Policy (1958) 43 Sarkisyanz Russland und der Messianismus (1955)378-91 32 Gollwitzer Geschichte (1982) I 138-40 33 Hermann Brunnhofer Russlands Hand Uber Asien Historischshygeographische Essays zur Entwick lungsgechichte des Russichen Reichsdenkens (S1 Petersburg 1897) npeAHCJIOBHe llBeAuapeu BpYHxolllep onpaBAblBaJI pyCCKylO 3IltCnaHCHIO B CpeAHeA A3HH H Ha llaJIbHeM BOCTOKe B cepHH cTaTeA BnepB~e onYOJIHKOBaHHbIx B neTepoyprcKHx ra3eTax Ha HeMeUKOM H3blKe St Petersburger Zeitung H St Petersburger Herold OH n~shyTaJICH OOOCHOBaTb PYCCKHA 3KcnaHCHOHH3M B A3HH CO~shyCTBeHHblMH H3bICKaHHHMH B apHAcKoA MHlIloJIorHH CpeAH ApyrHx paooT OH onYOJIHKOBaJI TpexToMHHK Urgechichte der Arier in Vorder-und Centralasien Historich-geographische Untersuchungen uber den altesten Schauplatz des Rigvedas und Avestas (Leipzig 1983) BpYHxolllep nepeBen TaKlKe o~beshyMHCTbIA OTtJeT KHH3H YXTOMCKoro 0 noe3AKe ueCapeBHqa HHKOJIaH Ha llaJIbHHA BOCTOK Orientreise seiner Kaiserlicher Hohe heit des Grossfursten Thronfolgers (Leipzig Brockhaus 1894 1998) 34 ltIgtHTIOTtJeB JIHpHKa HaYKa 1965 TI1 M CTp 118 35 Ein ostasiatischer Dreibund und die buddhistische Weltproshypaganda B KH BpYHxolllepa Russland Hand uber Aden (1897) 24-29 BnepB~e onYOJIHKOBaHa BSt Petersburger Zeitung B 1894 r
147
36 Louis Fischer The Soviets in the World Affairs (Princeton Princeton University Press 1951) n 534-37 Sir Fitzroy Maclean To the Back ofBeyond (London Cape 1974) 119-121 37 AKatteMHK BapTOJlbtt COllHHeHHR M H3tt-BO BOCTOllHoA JlHTepaTYpbI 1963 T2 cTp 164-166345-350 38 Hcxott K BOCTOKY npettllYBCTBHR H cBepmeHHR YTBepshy)l(tteHHe eBpa3HAueB CO(j)HR 1921 COttep)l(HT CTaTbH rBltJ)JloshypOBcKoro POMaHa HKoCicoHa nllCasllHHcKoro nH CaBHUshyKoro H HCTpyCieUKoro HH)I(e nepellHCJIRIOTCR OCHOBHhIe paCioTbI 0 espa3HAuax DS Mirsky The Eurasian Movement The Slavonic and East European Review (1927) 311-320 Otto Boss Die Lehre der Eurasier (Wiesbaden Harrasowitz 1961) H A Stammler Europe-Russland-Asian Der eurasiche Deutungsshyversuch der russichen Geschichte Osteuropa 12 (1962) 521-528 Gerges Nivat Du Panmongolisme au mouvement eurasien Cahiers du monde Russe et Sovietique 73 (1966) 460-78 Nicholas V Riasanovsky The Emergence of Eurasians California Slavic Studies 4 (1967) 39-72 39 HC TpylSeUKoA Espona H lIeJIOBelleCTBO CO(j)HR 192Q Mirsky The Eurasian Movement (1927) 312-13 V Riasanovsky Emergence of Eurasians (1967) 56 Leonid Luks Die Ideologie der Eurasier im zeitgeschichtlichen Zusammenhang Jahrbucher fur Geschichte Osteuropas 34 (1986) 374-395 40 llH CasHUKHA reOnOJlHTHlIeCKHe 3aMeTKH no PYCCKoA
HCTOpHH - B rB BepHattCKHA HallepTaHHe PYCCKoA HCshyTOpHH llpara 1927 CTp 234-260 CM TaK)I(e nHCasHUKHA reOrpa(j)HlIeCKHe ocolSeHHOCTH POCCHH 2 TT npara 1927 OH )l(e POCCHR - OCOlSblA reorpa(j)HlIecKHA MHp llapH)I( 1927 Charles Halperin Russia and the Steppe George Vernadsky and Eurasianism Forschungen zur osteuropaischen Geschichte 36 (1985) 55-194 and Slavic Studies 41 (1982)477-493 41 rB BepHattcKHA YKa3 COli CTp 230-231 259-260 Charles Halperin Opcit pp 99-104 42 V Riasanovsky The Emergence of Eurasians California Slavic Studies 4 (1967) 43 H Carrere dEncausse Decline of an Empire The Soviet Socialist Republics in Revolt (New York Harper 1981) 13-46
148
npOllBH)KEHHE POCCHH K lOrY
POCCHflCKHE llPOCTOPbI
Hepa3pemHMble npOCiJIeMbI CJlHRHHR pac B orpoMHoM MHOshyrOHaUHOHaJIbHOM KOHrJlOMepaTe Ha3blBaeMOM POCCHAcKOA (a n03ttHee coseTCKoA) eBpa3HAcKoA HMnepHeA eme CioJlee 01S0shyCTPRIOTCR B reorpa(j)HlIecKHx nOHRTHRX - B TpyttHeAmeM nposhyCTpaHcTseHHoM IIHcCiaJIaHce ttoBJIeIOmHM Hall olSmHM reOCTpashyTerHlIeCKHM nOJIO)l(eHHeM HMnepHH
MeTa(j)opHlIeCKH ynpomaR HCTOPHIO POCCHAcKOA HMnepHH nottllac CBOttRT K TparHlIeCKoA Ollep)l(HMOCTH npOCTopOM HJIH K TparHlIeCKOMY lIapy npOCTpaHCTsaI COrJlaCHO 3THM npettCTaBJIeHHRM PYCCKHX - H KaK OISOpOHRIOmHXCR H KaK arpeccopOB nOCTORHHO H Heyttep)l(HMO BJIeKJlH orpOMHble npOCTpaHCTBa Espa3HH PYCCKHe rOpllRTCR TeM liTO s HX rHshyraHTCKoA cyxonYTHoA TBepttbIHe MO)l(HO pa3MecTHTb 2-3 AMepHKH 40 ltJ)paHUHA H 93 BeJIHKOlSpHTaHHH Me)l(lIY 1600 H 1900 rr K PoccHAcKOA HMnepHH 1I0lSaBHJIOCb B olSmeA CJIO)l(HOCTH 17 MJIH KSattpaTHblx KHJIOMeTpOB HOBblX TeppHshyTOPHA s cpellHeM no 57 TbIC KBatlpaTHhIX KHJlOMeTpoB e)l(eshyrOttHo3 HCXOIlR H3 3Toro HeTpyttHO npHIITH K 3aKJIIOlIeHHIO liTO reorpa(j)HR H s caMOM tteJle OKa3b1BaJla BceCTopOHHee BJlHRHHe Ha pYCCKoe H coseTCKoe BOCnpHRTHe A3HH~
TaKHM 01Spa30M reorpa(j)HlIeamA (j)aKTOp HrpaeT orpOMshyHyIO pOJlb S HCTOPHH pYCCKoro Hapottaf ocolSeHHO B CBR3H C lIpe3MepHbiM YBJIelleHHeM HMnepHaJlHCTHlIeCKoA POCCHH npOCTpaHCTBaMH H TeppHTOpHRMH )lse reorpa(j)HlIeCKHe OCOshylSeHHOCTH OTJIHlIaIOT POCCHIO llepBaR - 3TO 0llHooeipa3He peJIbshye(j)a MeCTHOCTH MOHOTOHHOCTb JlaHttma(j)Ta n03S0JIHSmaR UeHTpaJIbHOA nOJIHTHlIeCKoA BJIaCTH nOllttep)l(HBaTb H pacshynpOCTpaHRTb csoA KOHTPOJIb no JIHHHH SeJIHKHX pellHhIx nyshyTeA TRHymHXCR no OCH ceBep-IOr TaKoA KOHTPOJlb oeiJlerllaJl ttBH)I(eHHe TosapOB KOJlOHHCTOB H BoACK~ no CJIOBaM BblllaIOmeshyrOCR HCTopHKa KJIIOlIeSCKoro 3KCnaHCHR MOCKBbI MO)l(eT paCCMaTpHBaTbCR KaK B03BblmeHHe ueHTpOCTpeMHTeJlbHOA CHJIbl 3aXBaTHBmeA KOHTPOJlb HatI HCTOKaMH lIeTblpex peK B
149
HanOMHHaeT pacxo)l(ee COBeTCKOe nOHHTHe 0 eQHHCTBe 8
MHorootlpa3HH
B MaHepe He CJIHmKOM OTJIHLlalOIleRcH OT COBeTCKHX CTaH~
QapTOB BepHaQCKHR QOKa3bIBaJI LITO BKJIIOLleHHe HepYCCKHX
rpynn B MHorOHauHOHaJIbYIO eBpa3HRcKYIO HMnepHIO C03Qa~
eT orpOMHbIe 3KOHOMHLleCKHe H KYJIbTypHbIe npeHMYIlIeCTBa O~~
HaKO BepHaQCKHR HaCTaHBaJI npH 3TOM LITO eQHHCTBO QOJI)I(HO
tlbITb 3KYMeHHLleCKHM tle3 HaBH3bIBaHHH HtlO PoccHRcKoe
rocy~apcTBO - eBpa3HRcKoe rOCYQapCTBO H Bce OTQeJIbHbIe
HaUHOHaJIbHOCTH Espa3HH QOJI)I(Hbl LlYBCTBOBaTb LITO 3TO HX
rocy~apcTBO H npH3HaBaTb ero (KypCHB BepHaQCKOrO) CHJIa
3Toro eBpa3HRcKoro otlpa30BaHHH JIe)l(HT B ero CBOtlOQHOM
KYJIbTYPHOM TBopLleCTBe41 KpOMe Toro Qa)l(e eCJIH PycCKHR
HapoQ otlpa3yeT rJIaBHYIO CHJIY eBpa3HRCKoro rocy~apcTBa a
PYCCKHR H3b1K - tla30BbiR CJIoR eBpa3HRcKoR KYJIbTYPbI Bce
3TO HeJIb3H HaBH3b1BaTb QpyrHM Hapo~aM HeCMOTpH Ha BeJIH~
LlHe 3THX HQeR BbICKa3bIBaBmHXCH eBpa3HRuaMH-3MHrpaHTaMH
He HecmHMH HHKaKoR nOJIHTHLIeCKoR OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH H
HMeSmHMH BeCbMa MaJIOe BJIHHHHe B HOBOA COBeTCKoR eBposhy
a3HaTCKoR HMnepHH QPyme CJIaBHHCKHe HapO~bI B ocotleHshy
HOCTH HaHtlOJIee MHOrOLlHCJIeHHble cnoCJIe PYCCKHX) HanpHshy
Mep YKPaHHUbl H nOJIHKH HcnblTbIBaJIH rJIytloKoe HeQOBepHe
K ueJIHM eBpa3HRueB H BbICTYaJIH npOTHB HHX2 K CO)l(aJIeHHIO
HHLlero He H3seCTHO 0 peaKUHH Ha TeopHH eBpa3HAueB a3HaTshy
CKHX HHTeJIJIeKTyaJIOB )l(HBmHX noQ COBeTCKHM pe)l(HMOM
MO)l(HO OQHaKO tle30mHtloLiHo nOJIaraTb LITO OHH BHQeJIH B
3THX TeOpHHX JIHmb YTOHLleHHoe onpaSQaHHe PYCCKoro HMneshy
pHaJIH3Ma
TaKHM otlpa30M eBpa3HRcKoe ~BH)I(eHHe caMO Toro He
C03HaBaH cnoc06CTBOBaJIO $OpMHPOBaHHIO YTonHLleCKoro 06shy
pa3a coseTCKoro LleJIOBeKa - HCKyccTBeHHoro nOpO)l(~eHHH
COBeTCKoR nponaraHQbl He HMelOIlero KaKOrO-JIH60 paCOBoro
HJIH 3THHLleCKOro npOHCXO)l(QeHHH HO rOBOpHIlero no-pYCCKH
H OIlYIlalOIlero ce6H KOHeLiHO )l(e PYCCKHM COBeTCKaH MOshy
QeJIb - TpOHua COCTOHIlaH H3 Tpex CTaQHA - paCUBeT-c6JIHshy
)l(eHHe-CJIHHHHe BeCbMa pa3BHTaH B 3noxy XPYIleBa pa3Hshy
TeJIbHO HanOMHHaeT eBpa3HRcKoe BHQeHHe 1920-x rO~OB OHa
OTpa)l(aeT TaK)I(e HCTopHLIeCKHA onbIT HaKOnJIeHHblA PycCKOR
HHTeJIJIHreHUHeR no HaUHOHaJIbHblM H paCOBblM BonpocaM
KOTopbIe PYCCKHe MbICJIHTeJIH BnepBble nO~HHJIH B XIX B
144
KaK nOKa3blBaeT 3JIeH Kappep Ii AHKOC BCsl COBeTCKasl
(OHuenUHH B otlJIaCTH onpeQeJIeHHH H 3aKOHHoro O$opMJIeHHsl
OTHomeHHA Me)l(~y PYCCKHMH H HepyccKHMH npeTepneJIa
MHO)l(eCTBO H3MeHeHHA43 B npoTHBOnOJIO)l(HOCTb neHHHcKoR
yTOnHH OTMHpaHHsl HauHA H rocYQapcTB H 3aMeHbl HX HOBblM
YHHBepCaJIbHbIM OOIlecTBOM npOJIeTapCKoA KJIaCCOBOR COJIHshy
~apHOCTH 60JIee )l(ecToKHA H OCMOTpHTeJIbHbIA CTaJIHH
nocTeneHHo npe06pa30BaJI HQelO $eQepaUHH B H~elO ueHT~
paJIH30BaHHHoro PyccKoro HaQ30pa HaQ $opMaJIbHO aBTOshy
HOMHbIMH HapoQaMH COBeTcKoro COI03a 3Ta peaJIbHOCTb npeshy
BpaTHJIa Bee COBeTCKHe TeopHH no HaUHOHaJIbHOMY Bonpocy B
nycTOnOpO)l(HHe ynpa)l(HeHHH H3 KOTOPblX H~eH CTaJIHHa TaK
H He 6blJIH YCTpaHeHbl BbI)I(HBaHHe MHorOHaUHOHaJIbHOR
eBpa3HAcKoA TeppHTOpHaJIbHOA KpenOCTH nO-npe)l(HeMY
ynpaBJIHeMOA MYQPbIM CTapmHM PYCCKHM 6paTOM 6YQeT
3aBHCeTb npe)l(Qe Bcero OT pemeHHH nOQHHTbIX eBpa3HAuaMH
BonpOCOB
145
flpHMeqaHHR
1 Andrew Malozemoff Russian Far Eastern Policy 1881-1904 (Berkeley University of California Press 1958) 42 2 FF von Martens Russland und England in Zentralasien (St Petersburg 1880) Heinz Gollwitzer Geschichte des wetpolischen denkens (Gottingen Vandenhoeck amp Ruprecht 1982) 152-70 133-36 3 F F von Martens Le Conflict entre la Russie et la Chine (Bruxel~
les 1880) 4 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) 93-103 WP Wassiliew Die Erschliessung Chinas (Leipzig 1909) 5 WP Wassiliew Die Erschliessung Chinas (Leipzig 1909)49 6 NM Prejevalsky From Kulja accross the Tian Shan to Lob-Nor (London Sampson Low 1879) 7 MA Bakunin La theologie politique de Mazzini et lInternatishyonale (Neufchatel 1871) 102 110 8 AN Kuropatkin Memoiren (Berlin 1919)7174 9 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) 1423-24 111 10 1S Bloch Les Illusions de la Conquette Chinoise Revue des Revues (August 15 1900) 11 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) 14 12 Herold J Weins Chinas March toward the Tropics (Hamden Conn Shoe String Press 1954) 13 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) p 24 14 CH IQlKaKOB AHrJIO-PycCIltaH pacnpH cmgt 1885 15 HltIgtltIgteAopoB ltlgtHJIocoIllHH oOIIlero AeJIa - UHT no HltIgtltIgteAopoB COqHHeHHH M MbICJIb 1982 0 BJIHHHHH ltlgteAoshypOBa Ha llocToeBcKoro TOJICTOrO COJIOBbeBa BepAHeBa BYJIraKOBa HAP CM Stephen Lukashevich NF Fedorov - A Study in Russian Eupsychian and Utopian Thought (Newark University of Delaware Press 1977) pp 13-34 16 HltIgtltIgteAopoB CotJHHeHHH 1982 CTp 343 Sarkisyanz Op cit 210-211 HACeTHHUKHA PyccKHe MbICJIHTeJIH 0 KHTae XapoHH 1926 17 BJIaAHMHp JIbBOB 3araAotJHblA CTapHIlt JI COBeTcKHA nHshyCaTeJIb 1977 CTp 129-135 HltIgtltIgteAopoB CotJHHeHHH (962) CTp 335-336 18 HltIgtltIgteAopoB CotJHHeHHH CTp 216 340 382 669
146
19 TaM lKe CTp 300 20 BCCOJIOBbeB TPH pa3roBopa cms TPYA 1904 21 Malozemoff Russian Far Eastern Policy (1958) p 43 22 JIeHHH 0 BoAHe B KHTae - HCKpa 1 AeKaopH 1900 23 ABeJIbIA neTepoypr UHT no H3A London Penguin 1983 CTP 65 24 Sarkisyanz Russland und der Messianismus(1955) 200 21~218
25 AJIeKCaHAP BJIOK CTHxoTBopeHHH H n03Mbl TeaTp M XYAOlKeCTBeHHaH JIHTepaTypa 1968 CTp 644-645 26 C EceHHH CoopaHHe cotJHHeHHA Mbull 1970 T5 cTP 107 27 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) 42 98-99 28 Sarkisyanz Russland und der Messianismus(1955) 218~22
29 Malozernoff Russian Far Eastern Policy (1958)43-44 30 BH Sumner Russia and Europe Oxford Slavonic Papers (1951) II 1-16B Readings in Russian Civilization nOA peA Thomas Riha (Chicago University of Chicago Press 1964) 1147331 Malozemoff Russian Far Eastern Policy (1958) 43 Sarkisyanz Russland und der Messianismus (1955)378-91 32 Gollwitzer Geschichte (1982) I 138-40 33 Hermann Brunnhofer Russlands Hand Uber Asien Historischshygeographische Essays zur Entwick lungsgechichte des Russichen Reichsdenkens (S1 Petersburg 1897) npeAHCJIOBHe llBeAuapeu BpYHxolllep onpaBAblBaJI pyCCKylO 3IltCnaHCHIO B CpeAHeA A3HH H Ha llaJIbHeM BOCTOKe B cepHH cTaTeA BnepB~e onYOJIHKOBaHHbIx B neTepoyprcKHx ra3eTax Ha HeMeUKOM H3blKe St Petersburger Zeitung H St Petersburger Herold OH n~shyTaJICH OOOCHOBaTb PYCCKHA 3KcnaHCHOHH3M B A3HH CO~shyCTBeHHblMH H3bICKaHHHMH B apHAcKoA MHlIloJIorHH CpeAH ApyrHx paooT OH onYOJIHKOBaJI TpexToMHHK Urgechichte der Arier in Vorder-und Centralasien Historich-geographische Untersuchungen uber den altesten Schauplatz des Rigvedas und Avestas (Leipzig 1983) BpYHxolllep nepeBen TaKlKe o~beshyMHCTbIA OTtJeT KHH3H YXTOMCKoro 0 noe3AKe ueCapeBHqa HHKOJIaH Ha llaJIbHHA BOCTOK Orientreise seiner Kaiserlicher Hohe heit des Grossfursten Thronfolgers (Leipzig Brockhaus 1894 1998) 34 ltIgtHTIOTtJeB JIHpHKa HaYKa 1965 TI1 M CTp 118 35 Ein ostasiatischer Dreibund und die buddhistische Weltproshypaganda B KH BpYHxolllepa Russland Hand uber Aden (1897) 24-29 BnepB~e onYOJIHKOBaHa BSt Petersburger Zeitung B 1894 r
147
36 Louis Fischer The Soviets in the World Affairs (Princeton Princeton University Press 1951) n 534-37 Sir Fitzroy Maclean To the Back ofBeyond (London Cape 1974) 119-121 37 AKatteMHK BapTOJlbtt COllHHeHHR M H3tt-BO BOCTOllHoA JlHTepaTYpbI 1963 T2 cTp 164-166345-350 38 Hcxott K BOCTOKY npettllYBCTBHR H cBepmeHHR YTBepshy)l(tteHHe eBpa3HAueB CO(j)HR 1921 COttep)l(HT CTaTbH rBltJ)JloshypOBcKoro POMaHa HKoCicoHa nllCasllHHcKoro nH CaBHUshyKoro H HCTpyCieUKoro HH)I(e nepellHCJIRIOTCR OCHOBHhIe paCioTbI 0 espa3HAuax DS Mirsky The Eurasian Movement The Slavonic and East European Review (1927) 311-320 Otto Boss Die Lehre der Eurasier (Wiesbaden Harrasowitz 1961) H A Stammler Europe-Russland-Asian Der eurasiche Deutungsshyversuch der russichen Geschichte Osteuropa 12 (1962) 521-528 Gerges Nivat Du Panmongolisme au mouvement eurasien Cahiers du monde Russe et Sovietique 73 (1966) 460-78 Nicholas V Riasanovsky The Emergence of Eurasians California Slavic Studies 4 (1967) 39-72 39 HC TpylSeUKoA Espona H lIeJIOBelleCTBO CO(j)HR 192Q Mirsky The Eurasian Movement (1927) 312-13 V Riasanovsky Emergence of Eurasians (1967) 56 Leonid Luks Die Ideologie der Eurasier im zeitgeschichtlichen Zusammenhang Jahrbucher fur Geschichte Osteuropas 34 (1986) 374-395 40 llH CasHUKHA reOnOJlHTHlIeCKHe 3aMeTKH no PYCCKoA
HCTOpHH - B rB BepHattCKHA HallepTaHHe PYCCKoA HCshyTOpHH llpara 1927 CTp 234-260 CM TaK)I(e nHCasHUKHA reOrpa(j)HlIeCKHe ocolSeHHOCTH POCCHH 2 TT npara 1927 OH )l(e POCCHR - OCOlSblA reorpa(j)HlIecKHA MHp llapH)I( 1927 Charles Halperin Russia and the Steppe George Vernadsky and Eurasianism Forschungen zur osteuropaischen Geschichte 36 (1985) 55-194 and Slavic Studies 41 (1982)477-493 41 rB BepHattcKHA YKa3 COli CTp 230-231 259-260 Charles Halperin Opcit pp 99-104 42 V Riasanovsky The Emergence of Eurasians California Slavic Studies 4 (1967) 43 H Carrere dEncausse Decline of an Empire The Soviet Socialist Republics in Revolt (New York Harper 1981) 13-46
148
npOllBH)KEHHE POCCHH K lOrY
POCCHflCKHE llPOCTOPbI
Hepa3pemHMble npOCiJIeMbI CJlHRHHR pac B orpoMHoM MHOshyrOHaUHOHaJIbHOM KOHrJlOMepaTe Ha3blBaeMOM POCCHAcKOA (a n03ttHee coseTCKoA) eBpa3HAcKoA HMnepHeA eme CioJlee 01S0shyCTPRIOTCR B reorpa(j)HlIecKHx nOHRTHRX - B TpyttHeAmeM nposhyCTpaHcTseHHoM IIHcCiaJIaHce ttoBJIeIOmHM Hall olSmHM reOCTpashyTerHlIeCKHM nOJIO)l(eHHeM HMnepHH
MeTa(j)opHlIeCKH ynpomaR HCTOPHIO POCCHAcKOA HMnepHH nottllac CBOttRT K TparHlIeCKoA Ollep)l(HMOCTH npOCTopOM HJIH K TparHlIeCKOMY lIapy npOCTpaHCTsaI COrJlaCHO 3THM npettCTaBJIeHHRM PYCCKHX - H KaK OISOpOHRIOmHXCR H KaK arpeccopOB nOCTORHHO H Heyttep)l(HMO BJIeKJlH orpOMHble npOCTpaHCTBa Espa3HH PYCCKHe rOpllRTCR TeM liTO s HX rHshyraHTCKoA cyxonYTHoA TBepttbIHe MO)l(HO pa3MecTHTb 2-3 AMepHKH 40 ltJ)paHUHA H 93 BeJIHKOlSpHTaHHH Me)l(lIY 1600 H 1900 rr K PoccHAcKOA HMnepHH 1I0lSaBHJIOCb B olSmeA CJIO)l(HOCTH 17 MJIH KSattpaTHblx KHJIOMeTpOB HOBblX TeppHshyTOPHA s cpellHeM no 57 TbIC KBatlpaTHhIX KHJlOMeTpoB e)l(eshyrOttHo3 HCXOIlR H3 3Toro HeTpyttHO npHIITH K 3aKJIIOlIeHHIO liTO reorpa(j)HR H s caMOM tteJle OKa3b1BaJla BceCTopOHHee BJlHRHHe Ha pYCCKoe H coseTCKoe BOCnpHRTHe A3HH~
TaKHM 01Spa30M reorpa(j)HlIeamA (j)aKTOp HrpaeT orpOMshyHyIO pOJlb S HCTOPHH pYCCKoro Hapottaf ocolSeHHO B CBR3H C lIpe3MepHbiM YBJIelleHHeM HMnepHaJlHCTHlIeCKoA POCCHH npOCTpaHCTBaMH H TeppHTOpHRMH )lse reorpa(j)HlIeCKHe OCOshylSeHHOCTH OTJIHlIaIOT POCCHIO llepBaR - 3TO 0llHooeipa3He peJIbshye(j)a MeCTHOCTH MOHOTOHHOCTb JlaHttma(j)Ta n03S0JIHSmaR UeHTpaJIbHOA nOJIHTHlIeCKoA BJIaCTH nOllttep)l(HBaTb H pacshynpOCTpaHRTb csoA KOHTPOJIb no JIHHHH SeJIHKHX pellHhIx nyshyTeA TRHymHXCR no OCH ceBep-IOr TaKoA KOHTPOJlb oeiJlerllaJl ttBH)I(eHHe TosapOB KOJlOHHCTOB H BoACK~ no CJIOBaM BblllaIOmeshyrOCR HCTopHKa KJIIOlIeSCKoro 3KCnaHCHR MOCKBbI MO)l(eT paCCMaTpHBaTbCR KaK B03BblmeHHe ueHTpOCTpeMHTeJlbHOA CHJIbl 3aXBaTHBmeA KOHTPOJlb HatI HCTOKaMH lIeTblpex peK B
149
flpHMeqaHHR
1 Andrew Malozemoff Russian Far Eastern Policy 1881-1904 (Berkeley University of California Press 1958) 42 2 FF von Martens Russland und England in Zentralasien (St Petersburg 1880) Heinz Gollwitzer Geschichte des wetpolischen denkens (Gottingen Vandenhoeck amp Ruprecht 1982) 152-70 133-36 3 F F von Martens Le Conflict entre la Russie et la Chine (Bruxel~
les 1880) 4 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) 93-103 WP Wassiliew Die Erschliessung Chinas (Leipzig 1909) 5 WP Wassiliew Die Erschliessung Chinas (Leipzig 1909)49 6 NM Prejevalsky From Kulja accross the Tian Shan to Lob-Nor (London Sampson Low 1879) 7 MA Bakunin La theologie politique de Mazzini et lInternatishyonale (Neufchatel 1871) 102 110 8 AN Kuropatkin Memoiren (Berlin 1919)7174 9 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) 1423-24 111 10 1S Bloch Les Illusions de la Conquette Chinoise Revue des Revues (August 15 1900) 11 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) 14 12 Herold J Weins Chinas March toward the Tropics (Hamden Conn Shoe String Press 1954) 13 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) p 24 14 CH IQlKaKOB AHrJIO-PycCIltaH pacnpH cmgt 1885 15 HltIgtltIgteAopoB ltlgtHJIocoIllHH oOIIlero AeJIa - UHT no HltIgtltIgteAopoB COqHHeHHH M MbICJIb 1982 0 BJIHHHHH ltlgteAoshypOBa Ha llocToeBcKoro TOJICTOrO COJIOBbeBa BepAHeBa BYJIraKOBa HAP CM Stephen Lukashevich NF Fedorov - A Study in Russian Eupsychian and Utopian Thought (Newark University of Delaware Press 1977) pp 13-34 16 HltIgtltIgteAopoB CotJHHeHHH 1982 CTp 343 Sarkisyanz Op cit 210-211 HACeTHHUKHA PyccKHe MbICJIHTeJIH 0 KHTae XapoHH 1926 17 BJIaAHMHp JIbBOB 3araAotJHblA CTapHIlt JI COBeTcKHA nHshyCaTeJIb 1977 CTp 129-135 HltIgtltIgteAopoB CotJHHeHHH (962) CTp 335-336 18 HltIgtltIgteAopoB CotJHHeHHH CTp 216 340 382 669
146
19 TaM lKe CTp 300 20 BCCOJIOBbeB TPH pa3roBopa cms TPYA 1904 21 Malozemoff Russian Far Eastern Policy (1958) p 43 22 JIeHHH 0 BoAHe B KHTae - HCKpa 1 AeKaopH 1900 23 ABeJIbIA neTepoypr UHT no H3A London Penguin 1983 CTP 65 24 Sarkisyanz Russland und der Messianismus(1955) 200 21~218
25 AJIeKCaHAP BJIOK CTHxoTBopeHHH H n03Mbl TeaTp M XYAOlKeCTBeHHaH JIHTepaTypa 1968 CTp 644-645 26 C EceHHH CoopaHHe cotJHHeHHA Mbull 1970 T5 cTP 107 27 Gollwitzer Die Gelbe Gefahr (1962) 42 98-99 28 Sarkisyanz Russland und der Messianismus(1955) 218~22
29 Malozernoff Russian Far Eastern Policy (1958)43-44 30 BH Sumner Russia and Europe Oxford Slavonic Papers (1951) II 1-16B Readings in Russian Civilization nOA peA Thomas Riha (Chicago University of Chicago Press 1964) 1147331 Malozemoff Russian Far Eastern Policy (1958) 43 Sarkisyanz Russland und der Messianismus (1955)378-91 32 Gollwitzer Geschichte (1982) I 138-40 33 Hermann Brunnhofer Russlands Hand Uber Asien Historischshygeographische Essays zur Entwick lungsgechichte des Russichen Reichsdenkens (S1 Petersburg 1897) npeAHCJIOBHe llBeAuapeu BpYHxolllep onpaBAblBaJI pyCCKylO 3IltCnaHCHIO B CpeAHeA A3HH H Ha llaJIbHeM BOCTOKe B cepHH cTaTeA BnepB~e onYOJIHKOBaHHbIx B neTepoyprcKHx ra3eTax Ha HeMeUKOM H3blKe St Petersburger Zeitung H St Petersburger Herold OH n~shyTaJICH OOOCHOBaTb PYCCKHA 3KcnaHCHOHH3M B A3HH CO~shyCTBeHHblMH H3bICKaHHHMH B apHAcKoA MHlIloJIorHH CpeAH ApyrHx paooT OH onYOJIHKOBaJI TpexToMHHK Urgechichte der Arier in Vorder-und Centralasien Historich-geographische Untersuchungen uber den altesten Schauplatz des Rigvedas und Avestas (Leipzig 1983) BpYHxolllep nepeBen TaKlKe o~beshyMHCTbIA OTtJeT KHH3H YXTOMCKoro 0 noe3AKe ueCapeBHqa HHKOJIaH Ha llaJIbHHA BOCTOK Orientreise seiner Kaiserlicher Hohe heit des Grossfursten Thronfolgers (Leipzig Brockhaus 1894 1998) 34 ltIgtHTIOTtJeB JIHpHKa HaYKa 1965 TI1 M CTp 118 35 Ein ostasiatischer Dreibund und die buddhistische Weltproshypaganda B KH BpYHxolllepa Russland Hand uber Aden (1897) 24-29 BnepB~e onYOJIHKOBaHa BSt Petersburger Zeitung B 1894 r
147
36 Louis Fischer The Soviets in the World Affairs (Princeton Princeton University Press 1951) n 534-37 Sir Fitzroy Maclean To the Back ofBeyond (London Cape 1974) 119-121 37 AKatteMHK BapTOJlbtt COllHHeHHR M H3tt-BO BOCTOllHoA JlHTepaTYpbI 1963 T2 cTp 164-166345-350 38 Hcxott K BOCTOKY npettllYBCTBHR H cBepmeHHR YTBepshy)l(tteHHe eBpa3HAueB CO(j)HR 1921 COttep)l(HT CTaTbH rBltJ)JloshypOBcKoro POMaHa HKoCicoHa nllCasllHHcKoro nH CaBHUshyKoro H HCTpyCieUKoro HH)I(e nepellHCJIRIOTCR OCHOBHhIe paCioTbI 0 espa3HAuax DS Mirsky The Eurasian Movement The Slavonic and East European Review (1927) 311-320 Otto Boss Die Lehre der Eurasier (Wiesbaden Harrasowitz 1961) H A Stammler Europe-Russland-Asian Der eurasiche Deutungsshyversuch der russichen Geschichte Osteuropa 12 (1962) 521-528 Gerges Nivat Du Panmongolisme au mouvement eurasien Cahiers du monde Russe et Sovietique 73 (1966) 460-78 Nicholas V Riasanovsky The Emergence of Eurasians California Slavic Studies 4 (1967) 39-72 39 HC TpylSeUKoA Espona H lIeJIOBelleCTBO CO(j)HR 192Q Mirsky The Eurasian Movement (1927) 312-13 V Riasanovsky Emergence of Eurasians (1967) 56 Leonid Luks Die Ideologie der Eurasier im zeitgeschichtlichen Zusammenhang Jahrbucher fur Geschichte Osteuropas 34 (1986) 374-395 40 llH CasHUKHA reOnOJlHTHlIeCKHe 3aMeTKH no PYCCKoA
HCTOpHH - B rB BepHattCKHA HallepTaHHe PYCCKoA HCshyTOpHH llpara 1927 CTp 234-260 CM TaK)I(e nHCasHUKHA reOrpa(j)HlIeCKHe ocolSeHHOCTH POCCHH 2 TT npara 1927 OH )l(e POCCHR - OCOlSblA reorpa(j)HlIecKHA MHp llapH)I( 1927 Charles Halperin Russia and the Steppe George Vernadsky and Eurasianism Forschungen zur osteuropaischen Geschichte 36 (1985) 55-194 and Slavic Studies 41 (1982)477-493 41 rB BepHattcKHA YKa3 COli CTp 230-231 259-260 Charles Halperin Opcit pp 99-104 42 V Riasanovsky The Emergence of Eurasians California Slavic Studies 4 (1967) 43 H Carrere dEncausse Decline of an Empire The Soviet Socialist Republics in Revolt (New York Harper 1981) 13-46
148
npOllBH)KEHHE POCCHH K lOrY
POCCHflCKHE llPOCTOPbI
Hepa3pemHMble npOCiJIeMbI CJlHRHHR pac B orpoMHoM MHOshyrOHaUHOHaJIbHOM KOHrJlOMepaTe Ha3blBaeMOM POCCHAcKOA (a n03ttHee coseTCKoA) eBpa3HAcKoA HMnepHeA eme CioJlee 01S0shyCTPRIOTCR B reorpa(j)HlIecKHx nOHRTHRX - B TpyttHeAmeM nposhyCTpaHcTseHHoM IIHcCiaJIaHce ttoBJIeIOmHM Hall olSmHM reOCTpashyTerHlIeCKHM nOJIO)l(eHHeM HMnepHH
MeTa(j)opHlIeCKH ynpomaR HCTOPHIO POCCHAcKOA HMnepHH nottllac CBOttRT K TparHlIeCKoA Ollep)l(HMOCTH npOCTopOM HJIH K TparHlIeCKOMY lIapy npOCTpaHCTsaI COrJlaCHO 3THM npettCTaBJIeHHRM PYCCKHX - H KaK OISOpOHRIOmHXCR H KaK arpeccopOB nOCTORHHO H Heyttep)l(HMO BJIeKJlH orpOMHble npOCTpaHCTBa Espa3HH PYCCKHe rOpllRTCR TeM liTO s HX rHshyraHTCKoA cyxonYTHoA TBepttbIHe MO)l(HO pa3MecTHTb 2-3 AMepHKH 40 ltJ)paHUHA H 93 BeJIHKOlSpHTaHHH Me)l(lIY 1600 H 1900 rr K PoccHAcKOA HMnepHH 1I0lSaBHJIOCb B olSmeA CJIO)l(HOCTH 17 MJIH KSattpaTHblx KHJIOMeTpOB HOBblX TeppHshyTOPHA s cpellHeM no 57 TbIC KBatlpaTHhIX KHJlOMeTpoB e)l(eshyrOttHo3 HCXOIlR H3 3Toro HeTpyttHO npHIITH K 3aKJIIOlIeHHIO liTO reorpa(j)HR H s caMOM tteJle OKa3b1BaJla BceCTopOHHee BJlHRHHe Ha pYCCKoe H coseTCKoe BOCnpHRTHe A3HH~
TaKHM 01Spa30M reorpa(j)HlIeamA (j)aKTOp HrpaeT orpOMshyHyIO pOJlb S HCTOPHH pYCCKoro Hapottaf ocolSeHHO B CBR3H C lIpe3MepHbiM YBJIelleHHeM HMnepHaJlHCTHlIeCKoA POCCHH npOCTpaHCTBaMH H TeppHTOpHRMH )lse reorpa(j)HlIeCKHe OCOshylSeHHOCTH OTJIHlIaIOT POCCHIO llepBaR - 3TO 0llHooeipa3He peJIbshye(j)a MeCTHOCTH MOHOTOHHOCTb JlaHttma(j)Ta n03S0JIHSmaR UeHTpaJIbHOA nOJIHTHlIeCKoA BJIaCTH nOllttep)l(HBaTb H pacshynpOCTpaHRTb csoA KOHTPOJIb no JIHHHH SeJIHKHX pellHhIx nyshyTeA TRHymHXCR no OCH ceBep-IOr TaKoA KOHTPOJlb oeiJlerllaJl ttBH)I(eHHe TosapOB KOJlOHHCTOB H BoACK~ no CJIOBaM BblllaIOmeshyrOCR HCTopHKa KJIIOlIeSCKoro 3KCnaHCHR MOCKBbI MO)l(eT paCCMaTpHBaTbCR KaK B03BblmeHHe ueHTpOCTpeMHTeJlbHOA CHJIbl 3aXBaTHBmeA KOHTPOJlb HatI HCTOKaMH lIeTblpex peK B
149
36 Louis Fischer The Soviets in the World Affairs (Princeton Princeton University Press 1951) n 534-37 Sir Fitzroy Maclean To the Back ofBeyond (London Cape 1974) 119-121 37 AKatteMHK BapTOJlbtt COllHHeHHR M H3tt-BO BOCTOllHoA JlHTepaTYpbI 1963 T2 cTp 164-166345-350 38 Hcxott K BOCTOKY npettllYBCTBHR H cBepmeHHR YTBepshy)l(tteHHe eBpa3HAueB CO(j)HR 1921 COttep)l(HT CTaTbH rBltJ)JloshypOBcKoro POMaHa HKoCicoHa nllCasllHHcKoro nH CaBHUshyKoro H HCTpyCieUKoro HH)I(e nepellHCJIRIOTCR OCHOBHhIe paCioTbI 0 espa3HAuax DS Mirsky The Eurasian Movement The Slavonic and East European Review (1927) 311-320 Otto Boss Die Lehre der Eurasier (Wiesbaden Harrasowitz 1961) H A Stammler Europe-Russland-Asian Der eurasiche Deutungsshyversuch der russichen Geschichte Osteuropa 12 (1962) 521-528 Gerges Nivat Du Panmongolisme au mouvement eurasien Cahiers du monde Russe et Sovietique 73 (1966) 460-78 Nicholas V Riasanovsky The Emergence of Eurasians California Slavic Studies 4 (1967) 39-72 39 HC TpylSeUKoA Espona H lIeJIOBelleCTBO CO(j)HR 192Q Mirsky The Eurasian Movement (1927) 312-13 V Riasanovsky Emergence of Eurasians (1967) 56 Leonid Luks Die Ideologie der Eurasier im zeitgeschichtlichen Zusammenhang Jahrbucher fur Geschichte Osteuropas 34 (1986) 374-395 40 llH CasHUKHA reOnOJlHTHlIeCKHe 3aMeTKH no PYCCKoA
HCTOpHH - B rB BepHattCKHA HallepTaHHe PYCCKoA HCshyTOpHH llpara 1927 CTp 234-260 CM TaK)I(e nHCasHUKHA reOrpa(j)HlIeCKHe ocolSeHHOCTH POCCHH 2 TT npara 1927 OH )l(e POCCHR - OCOlSblA reorpa(j)HlIecKHA MHp llapH)I( 1927 Charles Halperin Russia and the Steppe George Vernadsky and Eurasianism Forschungen zur osteuropaischen Geschichte 36 (1985) 55-194 and Slavic Studies 41 (1982)477-493 41 rB BepHattcKHA YKa3 COli CTp 230-231 259-260 Charles Halperin Opcit pp 99-104 42 V Riasanovsky The Emergence of Eurasians California Slavic Studies 4 (1967) 43 H Carrere dEncausse Decline of an Empire The Soviet Socialist Republics in Revolt (New York Harper 1981) 13-46
148
npOllBH)KEHHE POCCHH K lOrY
POCCHflCKHE llPOCTOPbI
Hepa3pemHMble npOCiJIeMbI CJlHRHHR pac B orpoMHoM MHOshyrOHaUHOHaJIbHOM KOHrJlOMepaTe Ha3blBaeMOM POCCHAcKOA (a n03ttHee coseTCKoA) eBpa3HAcKoA HMnepHeA eme CioJlee 01S0shyCTPRIOTCR B reorpa(j)HlIecKHx nOHRTHRX - B TpyttHeAmeM nposhyCTpaHcTseHHoM IIHcCiaJIaHce ttoBJIeIOmHM Hall olSmHM reOCTpashyTerHlIeCKHM nOJIO)l(eHHeM HMnepHH
MeTa(j)opHlIeCKH ynpomaR HCTOPHIO POCCHAcKOA HMnepHH nottllac CBOttRT K TparHlIeCKoA Ollep)l(HMOCTH npOCTopOM HJIH K TparHlIeCKOMY lIapy npOCTpaHCTsaI COrJlaCHO 3THM npettCTaBJIeHHRM PYCCKHX - H KaK OISOpOHRIOmHXCR H KaK arpeccopOB nOCTORHHO H Heyttep)l(HMO BJIeKJlH orpOMHble npOCTpaHCTBa Espa3HH PYCCKHe rOpllRTCR TeM liTO s HX rHshyraHTCKoA cyxonYTHoA TBepttbIHe MO)l(HO pa3MecTHTb 2-3 AMepHKH 40 ltJ)paHUHA H 93 BeJIHKOlSpHTaHHH Me)l(lIY 1600 H 1900 rr K PoccHAcKOA HMnepHH 1I0lSaBHJIOCb B olSmeA CJIO)l(HOCTH 17 MJIH KSattpaTHblx KHJIOMeTpOB HOBblX TeppHshyTOPHA s cpellHeM no 57 TbIC KBatlpaTHhIX KHJlOMeTpoB e)l(eshyrOttHo3 HCXOIlR H3 3Toro HeTpyttHO npHIITH K 3aKJIIOlIeHHIO liTO reorpa(j)HR H s caMOM tteJle OKa3b1BaJla BceCTopOHHee BJlHRHHe Ha pYCCKoe H coseTCKoe BOCnpHRTHe A3HH~
TaKHM 01Spa30M reorpa(j)HlIeamA (j)aKTOp HrpaeT orpOMshyHyIO pOJlb S HCTOPHH pYCCKoro Hapottaf ocolSeHHO B CBR3H C lIpe3MepHbiM YBJIelleHHeM HMnepHaJlHCTHlIeCKoA POCCHH npOCTpaHCTBaMH H TeppHTOpHRMH )lse reorpa(j)HlIeCKHe OCOshylSeHHOCTH OTJIHlIaIOT POCCHIO llepBaR - 3TO 0llHooeipa3He peJIbshye(j)a MeCTHOCTH MOHOTOHHOCTb JlaHttma(j)Ta n03S0JIHSmaR UeHTpaJIbHOA nOJIHTHlIeCKoA BJIaCTH nOllttep)l(HBaTb H pacshynpOCTpaHRTb csoA KOHTPOJIb no JIHHHH SeJIHKHX pellHhIx nyshyTeA TRHymHXCR no OCH ceBep-IOr TaKoA KOHTPOJlb oeiJlerllaJl ttBH)I(eHHe TosapOB KOJlOHHCTOB H BoACK~ no CJIOBaM BblllaIOmeshyrOCR HCTopHKa KJIIOlIeSCKoro 3KCnaHCHR MOCKBbI MO)l(eT paCCMaTpHBaTbCR KaK B03BblmeHHe ueHTpOCTpeMHTeJlbHOA CHJIbl 3aXBaTHBmeA KOHTPOJlb HatI HCTOKaMH lIeTblpex peK B
149