hampleton m&a market spotlight automotive technology 2h2014
TRANSCRIPT
M&A Market Spotlight December 2014
Automotive Technology
17, Woodstock Street, London, W1C 2AJ, UK
Suite 200, 1 Sutter St., San Francisco CA 94104, US
Automotive Technology December 2014
P a g e 1 | 8
$13.7B
Total transaction value
2.1x
Median EV/S
13.3x
Median EV/EBITDA
Automotive Technology M&A activity November 2011-November 2014
M&A activity in both volume and value increased significantly
throughout the three year period of analysis in this report. The
number of transactions in November 2014 was up 60% on 2013,
similarly the disclosed transaction value was up 69%. The median
EV/S multiple throughout the entire period was 2.1x and the
EV/EBITDA was 13.3x.
2014 has also seen many automotive-technology targets achieve
high valuations for their companies:
In November, Solera Holdings, acquired UK-based CAP
Automotive for $464 million. The transaction netted the
seller a 17x EV/EBITDA multiple and 10x EV/S multiple.
In May, Bowmark Capital acquired UK-based Autodata for
$241 million in a deal estimated at be north of 14x EBITDA.
In addition to Solera’s recent purchase of CAP Automotive, the self-styled “industrial PE” purchased
11 other targets during the last 3 years. As the top acquirer in the auto-tech sector, Solera has not
being straying far from its core collision, valuation, and parts recycling roots. You can see from the
type of acquisitions made that Solera plans to be involved in the entire vehicle ownership lifecycle. We
would expect a move into the mechanical repair space at some time in the future.
The second most active buyer was DealerTrack, which is continuing its buy & build strategy with eight
transactions completed during the past three years focused on dealer-centric assets as they continue
an impressive track record of buying (and building) into the dealer space.
$2,237M
$4,385M
$7,413M
- $4,000,000.0K
- $2,000,000.0K
$0.0K
$2,000M
$4,000M
$6,000M
$8,000M
Nov 2011-12 Nov 2012-13 Nov 2013-14
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
Transaction Count
Disclosed Transaction Value
We at Hampleton have watched with interest over the past few years, the rise in both transaction volume and value in the automotive IT-related sector. While there was some justifiable nervousness in the sector several years ago as we all wondered which OEMs/suppliers would be left standing, the sector has recovered well and bank debt to support deals in the sector has come back strongly, creating a sharp uptick in valuations.
There is general agreement that this sector has been the source of some eye-watering valuations as of late. It’s not only new/advanced technology targets obtaining these high multiples, but also longstanding (read 40+ year old) firms that have brought new technology into a tired sector such as repair data that have attracted attention (e.g., Autodata).
There are several facets of the automotive technology sector, and we’ve consolidated this down to four sub-sectors and looked into recent deals and trends in developing this report. There are several facets of the automotive technology sector, and we’ve consolidated this down to four sub-sectors and looked into recent deals and trends in developing this report.
Automotive Technology December 2014
P a g e 2 | 8
Europe55%
North America40%
Rest of World5%
Europe35%
North America58%
Rest of World7%
Headquarter of Targets Headquarter of Acquirers purchasing
European Targets
The majority of acquirers of auto-tech targets were based in North America, 35% based in Europe and
7% in the rest of the world. Of the European transactions, 55% of targets were acquired regionally.
The two European countries with the most M&A activity in the automotive-tech space were the
United Kingdom and Germany, with 32 and 23 targets respectively.
Internet Commerce and Content26%
Enterprise Applications31%
Embedded Software Devices & Hardware22%
Fleet Management21%
Enterprise Solutions & Software : CRM Automation, Dealership Inventory Management, Dealership Management, HR, Inspection Software, Insurance Claims Management, Payment & Invoice Processing, Repair Estimation & Management, Tire POS & ERP Software
Internet Commerce and Content: Advertising, Auction Websites, Classifieds, Document Creation, Marketplaces, Quotation Websites, Reference Content, Rental Websites, Tire Retailers
Embedded Software Devices & Hardware: Equipment Sensors, Interface Software, Location Tracking, Parking Surveillance, Sensor Controllers & Systems, Vehicle Control Systems
Fleet Management – Fleet Management Systems, Fuel Supply Management, GPS Fleet Tracking, Logistics Management
Breakdown by Sub-Sector
We portion M&A activity in the auto-
tech sector into four sub-sectors. The
most active was Enterprise
Applications with 31% of the deals,
followed by Internet Commerce and
Content at 26%, Embedded Software
Devices & Hardware at 22%, and Fleet
Management with 21%.
Automotive Technology December 2014
P a g e 3 | 8
Enterprise Applications
$2.7 B
Total disclosed value of sub-sector
12.2x
Highest EV/S multiple paid for a target: Nuance Comms. acquisit ion of Tweddle Group for $80m
The total disclosed value of Enterprise Applications was
$2.7 billion with a median per transaction of $47 million.
This sub-sector has been stable over the past few years
with 28 transactions completing in each of the last two
years.
One of the most notable transactions involved US-based
Cox Automotive when it acquired dealership CRM
provider, Xtime, in November 2014 for $325 million with
an 8.1x EV/S multiple. A number of transactions
involving dealership management CRM SaaS targets
completed in this sub-sector. In more than 90% of
transactions, the buyer and seller were North American.
Currently activity supporting North American dealers is
robust and it will be interesting to see how this will
impact the traditional dealer management systems
space. DMS is largely controlled by UCS owned
Reynolds&Reynolds and CDK Automotive (the $2billion
DMS giant formerly known as ADP Automotive), which
very recently spun itself out of the larger and more
HR/payroll focussed ADP Global.
France-based Dassault was the most acquisitive of
European firms. Dassault purchased three German
simulation and visualisation targets, the largest of which
was RealTime Technology AG. Munich-based Realtime
sold 84% of its shares for just under $205 million at a 2.0x
EV/S multiple and 13.3x EV/EBITDA.
Numerous transactions involving collision claims and
mechanical repair providers took place during the past
three years. We continue to see European assets in this
aftersales-focussed sector performing well, especially
those that continue to invest in new technology as they
become must-have targets for firms such as Solera. The
aftersales sector has become quite a safe haven for
investment, especially after the collapse of the auto
industry in 2008-2010, because these assets have some
anti-cyclical characteristics which makes them quite
attractive when times get tough (as consumers decide to
repair versus replace their vehicles).
Top Acquirers
Automotive Technology December 2014
P a g e 4 | 8
Internet Commerce and Content
90% Percentage increase of transactions from 2013 to 2014
4.4x
Highest EV/S paid for a target: Dealertrack acquisit ion of Dealer Dot Com for $987m
M&A activity in 2014 has been buoyant with nearly a
two-fold increase in transactions compared with last
year. The disclosed value of transactions was $4.7 billion
and the median was a high $70 million.
The two most notable transactions in this sub-sector
were previously mentioned Solera Holding’s acquisition
of CAP Automotive and Bowmark Capital’s acquisition of
Autodata. Content management assets as well as
transaction / payment processing were just a few of the
key deals in this sub-sector.
Internet Brands (IB) was the top acquirer of internet
commerce and content targets having made seven
acquisitions during the three year period, primarily in the
new and used vehicle sales website sector. IB’s most
recent acquisition was for High Gear Media, a six-year
old automotive publisher. The automotive category is a
highly competitive one in which IB is competing with a
consortium of large media brands like Cox Enterprises,
owner of AutoTrader and Kelly Blue Book, Hearst
Magazines, owner of Road & Track, and the consortium
behind Cars.com.
Another active buyer was IHS which made two
acquisitions in this sub-sector. In the second largest
transaction in the auto-tech industry, IHS purchased
online automotive reference content provider, R.L. Polk
& Co for $1.4 billion at a 3.5x EV/S multiple. Its second
acquisition was for a German content provider, BDW
Automotive GmbH for just $8 million. BDW will expand
IHS's capabilities in the automotive dealer and
aftermarket data and systems market. IHS’s recent
acquisitions show that targets at both the high and low
end of this sector are attractive to prolific acquirers in
the current market.
Top Acquirers
Automotive Technology December 2014
P a g e 5 | 8
Embedded Software Devices and Hardware
300% Percentage increase of transactions from 2013 to 2014
9.1x
Highest EV/S paid for a target: Verizon acquisition of Hughes Telematics for $612m
Top Acquirers
Embedded Software Devices & Hardware had the
highest growth of all the sub-sectors from 2013 to 2014,
with volume increasing by 300%. Several of the targets
included in this group develop software for embedded
ECUs. The growth in in-vehicle networking is largely
driven by the increasing demand for automobile
electronics and optical sensors. This has resulted in an
increase by several orders of magnitude in the number
of on-board ECUs. Advanced vehicles manufactured
today will have more than 80 complex ECU’s controlling
everything from lane departure optical sensors to hybrid
power units and energy recovery systems.
The fast-pace growth of M&A activity during the past
year within embedded software devices and hardware
can be attributed to the rise of the ‘connected-car’.
Providers are in the midst of strengthening their
offerings to capitalise on consumer and enterprise
demand. We expect this sector to remain very robust as
the race to release semi-autonomous vehicles (which
will be around, in our view, for a long time before fully
autonomous vehicles appear) is well underway. All
OEMs are working on this, most using proprietary
technology, so we expect new / start-up technology
providers to be snapped-up quickly in this sector by
either T1 providers (Conti, Bosch) or directly by OEMs.
The mobile network operators are also getting in on the
action with Vodafone’s 74% majority acquisition of Italy-
based, Cobra Automotive for $145 million in June
2014. Cobra provides security and telematics solutions
to the automotive and insurance industries and will
allow the British telecom to augment its connected-car
offerings.
The automotive sector is rapidly becoming a leading
vertical for M2M with many manufacturers paying
premiums for embedded software devices. In the US,
Verizon acquired Hughes Telematics for $612 million at
a 9.1x EV/S multiple. The deal gives Verizon a new source
of growth as it faces saturation in the U.S. market for
mobile phones and land lines. For more information on
telematics, please see our 2H2014 M&A Market
Spotlight on the Internet of Things at
www.hampletonpartners.com/report/internet-of-
things-ma.
Automotive Technology December 2014
P a g e 6 | 8
Fleet Management
$3.9 B Total disclosed value
25.7x
Highest EV/EBITDA paid for a target: Omnitracs acquisit ion of XRS Corp. for $178m
This sub-sector represents 21% of the transaction
volume in the auto-tech segment and had a disclosed
transaction value of $3.9 billion with a median of $49
million. M&A transaction volume increased by 40% over
the last year. With statistics such as “almost 60 percent
of new cars sold in Europe are company cars” it is
unsurprising that we are seeing growing levels of M&A
activity within the Fleet Management sub-sector.
(Automotive Fleet News, 2014)
GPS tracking software and systems targets accounted for
just under half of the transactions. One of the top
European acquirers, TomTom, made two regional
acquisitions in the GPS fleet management space, after
staying out of the M&A market for three years. TomTom
acquired Coordina, a provider of GPS tracking systems
and services to the transportation and construction
sectors. The acquisition is an attempt to strengthen
TomTom's fleet management offerings and enable its
expansion into the Spanish market. Its more recent
acquisition was for French fleet management software
provider DAMS Tracking. TomTom views France as one
of the largest addressable markets in Europe, with
around 6 million commercial vehicles in use. (Acquirer
press release, April 2014). As the number of TomTom
units stuck to windscreens decline due to embedded
SatNav systems, the Dutch company are looking to
remain relevant as a back-end solution provider to
OEMs.
Top Fleet Management acquirer, FleetCor, acquired two
European targets throughout the past three years. Its
most recent move was for UK-based Epyx, a fleet rental,
repair & disposal marketplace for ca. 11x EV/EBITDA.
The acquisition of Epyx is a slight departure from
FleetCor’s core fleet fueling business, moving beyond
fueling into fleet maintenance life cycle and costs
management.
Top Acquirers
Automotive Technology December 2014
P a g e 7 | 8
Auto-Tech M&A according to Hampleton
Acquirers to watch in the Auto-Tech segment
The automotive IT & Business Services sector is hot….for now. The number
and value of deals in this sector is continuing to grow despite the still-fragile
nature of key markets around the world. Opinions will differ whether this
rise is related to the stock market climb which has helped banks look more
favourably on this once scorned sector, or the inverse relationship to oil
prices (think oil price increases in 2008 which doomed the auto industry at
the time) or something else, but one thing we can all agree with is that
sooner or later, gravity will take hold. Timing is everything.
While a dramatic increase in on-board vehicle technology is partially driving
this rise, we also see an interest in highly scalable, robust, mid-to-high
growth assets with recurring revenue and long-term OE or T1 contracts.
We also see a sharp increase in aftersales-focused assets due to their anti-
cyclical traits.
If you’re reading this, there is a good chance you’re an interested seller or
buyer in this sector and if so, we would welcome a conversation with you
in the short-term as no one knows how long this sector will continue to
perform this way. As stated earlier….timing is everything.
David Riemenschneider Sector Principal
Automotive Technology December 2014
P a g e 8 | 8
In addition to our market spotlights, Hampleton produces semi-annual reports on M&A activity in
multiple sectors of the technology industry. To receive these reports on a regular basis, please visit:
http://www.hampletonpartners.com/subscribe-reports/
Hampleton provides independent M&A and corporate finance advice to owners of Internet, IT Services and
Software companies. Our research reports aim to provide our clients with current analysis of the transactions,
trends and valuations within our focus areas.
Data Source: We have based our findings on data provided by industry recognised sources. Data and
information for this publication was collated from the 451 Research database (www.451research.com), a
division of The 451 Group. For more information on this or anything else related to our research, please email
the address provided below.
Disclaimer: This publication contains general information only and Hampleton Ltd, is not, by means of this
publication, rendering professional advice or services. Before making any decision or taking any action that may
affect your finances or your business, you should consult a qualified professional adviser. Hampleton Ltd shall
not be responsible for any loss whatsoever sustained by any person who relies on this publication.
©2014. For more information please contact Hampleton Ltd.
London San Francisco
4th Floor Suite 200
17 Woodstock Street 1 Sutter St
W1C 2AJ San Francisco, CA 94104
United Kingdom United States
Email: [email protected]