hale memorandum to deny defendants motion to dismiss 2nd complaint
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
1/100
LE WAB RELWBG VWJWBV GLVW[LFW FHR[W
GLVW[LFW HN @JEVJV
Fjsb Eh. :2-7 ]jdb
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
2/100
IBDJI J[DRCBEWV
WAB VRNNLFLBEF\ HN WAB FIJLC
Le j fjsb krhudat ky j prlshebr,Ajlebs v. @brebr, khta tab glstrlft jeg jppbj
ruibg tajt tab fjsb sahuig kb glsclssbg nhr njliurb th stjtb j fijlc pbr N[F] :;(k)(>
Reltbg Vtjtbs Vuprbcb Fhurt rbvbrsbg jeg rbcjegbg wlta tab nhiihwled ijedujdb?
jiibdjtlhes sufa js tahsb jssbrtbg ky pbtltlhebr, ahwbvbr lejrtnuiiy pibjgbg, jrb s
fjii nhr tab hpphrtuelty th hnnbr supphrtled bvlgbefb. Tb fjeeht sjy wlta jssurjefb
tab jiibdjtlhes hn tab prh sb fhcpijlet, walfa wb ahig th ibss strledbet stjegjrgs taj
pibjgleds grjntbg ky ijwybrs, lt jppbjrs kbyheg ghukt tajt tab pijletlnn fje prhvb e
le supphrt hn als fijlc walfa whuig betltib alc th rbilbn. 7=7 R.V. 2:< (: (:
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
3/100
pibjgleds. Le rb Jejstjshnn? iltldjets fhestltutlheji rldats jrb vlhijtbg wabe fhurts
prbfbgbet wabrb pjrtlbs jrb slclijriy sltujtbg. Jii iltldjets ajvb j fhestltutlheji rld
tablr fijlcs jgouglfjtbg jffhrgled tab ruib hn prbfbgbet. VbbJejstjshnn v. Reltbg V
N.6g 174.
Regbr Nbgbrji [uib hn Flvli ]rhfbgurb :;(k)(>), j fhcpijlet sahuig eht kb g
lt cjy kb supphrtbg ky sahwled jey sbt hn njfts fheslstbet wlta tab jiibdjtlhes le ta
fhcpijlet.Kbii Jtijetlf Fhrp. v. Wwhckiy, 22= R.V. 277, 2>6 (;==4). Legbbg, [u
chtlhes jrb vlbwbg wlta glsnjvhr jeg jrb prhpbriy drjetbg heiy uegbr bxtrjhrglej
flrfucstjefbs. \hrgy v. Jstrub, Eh.:?=). Vtjrr v. Kjfj, >2; N.6g :;=;, :;:> (;4 N.6g 67= ( ]jdb
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
4/100
FHEGLWLHEV NH[ LEOREFWL^B [BILBN
Wab leglspbesjkib fhegltlhe hn leoueftlvb rbilbn ls j sahwled hn lrrbpjrjkib le
lejgbqujfy hn ibdji rbcbglbs. Jffhrgled th nbgbrji ijw, j pijletlnn sbb`led je leoue
gbchestrjtb tajt? (:) lt sunnbrbg je lrrbpjrjkib leoury0 (;) rbcbglbs jt ijw, sufa js c
gjcjdbs, jrb lejgbqujtb th fhcpbesjtb nhr tab leoury0 (6) fheslgbrled tab kjijefb h
ajrgsalps kbtwbbe pijletlnn jeg gbnbegjets, j rbcbgy le bqulty ls wjrrjetbg0 jeg (7)
letbrbst whuig eht kb glssbrvbg ky j pbrcjebet leoueftlhe. bKjy Lef. v. CbrfBxfaj
274 R.V. 611, 6). ]ijletlnn wlii sahw tajt jii tabsb prbrbqulsltbs ajvb kbbe
leglvlgujiiy jeg fhiibftlvbiy.
J sahwled hn lrrbpjrjkib ajrc ls bssbetlji th hktjleled leoueftlvb rbilbn. Fb
hn jftlhe, le khta stjtb jeg nbgbrji ijw, fhetbcpijtb leoueftlvb rbilbn jeg prhvlgb nhr
prbsucptlhe hn lrrbpjrjkib ajrc. Le tab bcpihycbet ijw fhetbxt, fbrtjle ourlsglftlh
prbsucptlhe hn lrrbpjrjkib ajrc le glsfrlclejtlhe jeg rbtjiljtlhe fjsbs. VbbKj`br v
Fbiiuihsb Fhrp., 12> N.;g :>4 (::ta Flr. :
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
5/100
Tlta rbspbft th tab kjijefb hn ajrgsalps kbtwbbe pijletlnns jeg gbnbegjets, d
fhurts wbldat tab ajrc th gbnbegjet ln tab leoueftlhe ls lcphsbg, jdjlest tab ajrc th
eh leoueftlhe ls hrgbrbg, prlhr th hrgbrled leoueftlvb rbilbn, walfa ls je bqultjkib rbc
gbflslhe leGbitb`, Lef. v. Luvh Vys., ;==< R.V. Glst. Ibxls 66222), prhvlgbs tajt Le
wabtabr je leoueftlhe ls jpprhprljtb, j glstrlft fhurt cust jppiy tab kjijefb-hn-ajrg
Regbr tab tbst, j fhurt sahuig bxjcleb tab nhiihwled nhur njfthrs? :) tab il`bilahhg h
ajrc th tab pijletlnn wltahut tab leoueftlhe, ;) tab il`bilahhg hn ajrc th tab gbnbegj
leoueftlhe, 6) tab pijletlnn's il`bilahhg hn suffbss he tab cbrlts, jeg 7) tab pukilf let
Wab nhrbchst leoueftlhe shudat ky Gr. Ajib ls tajt Gbnbegjet [lttdbrs kb cj
sukclt th j ajegwrltled bxjclejtlhe, lefiugled j Iheghe Ibttbr bxjc, th fhefiuslv
wabtabr hr eht sab ls tab jutahr hn tab rjflji siur, jeg j phiydrjpa tbst. [lttdbrs ls h
ajvled vhiuetbbrbg th gh khta. Ky swlntiy jeg pukilfiy bxhebrjtled tals suspbft, Gb
shudat th pijfb oustlfb kbyheg tab rbjfa hn Gr. Ajib. ^lbttl jeg Ohaeshe gbcjegbg
bvlgbefb nrhc Gr. Ajib, kut tabe flrfucvbetbg tajt phsslklilty ky salbigled [lttdbrs
bxjclejtlhe. Gr. Ajib kbilbvbs tajt tab bvlgbefb wlii sahw tajt [lttdbrs lstab juta
rjflji siur jeg tajt Gbje Jibxjegbr wjs fhcpilflt. Wals typb hn fheguft ghbs eht g
sfht-nrbb. J pahth hn Gbkrj [lttdbrs ls jttjfabg js Bxalklt Jth ]ijletlnns Cbchrj
lefhrphrjtbg ky rbnbrbefb abrble. Tltahut j ajegwrltled bxjclejtlhe hn [lttdbrs, G
rbputjtlhe wlii fhetleub th sunnbr lrrbpjrjkib ajrc. Wab il`bilahhg hn ajrc th tab G
tab stjtbg leoueftlvb ls heiy phsslkib ln [lttdbrs ls nhueg th ajvb fhefiuslvbiy wrlttbe
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb
Fjsb 2?:2 fv =7/:> ]jdb
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
6/100
levbstldjtlhe wltahut nlrst levbstldjtled tab lcpilfjtlhes hn Tbegy Fjrishes hplelh
eht ajrc fjusbg ky je leoueftlhe, kut ky Gbnbegjets hwe fheguft jeg kljs.
]ijletlnn kbilbvbs le tab cbrlts hn lts fjsb, jeg tajt lt wlii suffbbg he tab cbr
sbb`led th hktjle j prbilclejry leoueftlhe he tab kjsls hn il`bilahhg hn suffbss he ta
"ebbg eht sahw tajt suffbss ls je jkshiutb fbrtjlety."Jkgui Tjil v. Fhudaile, 427 N
:=;2 (;g Flr. : ]jdb
Fjsb 2?:2 fv =7/:> ]jdb
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
7/100
Cjstbr Jsshf., :1< N.[.G. 64:, 61;-16 (E.G. Lii. :
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
8/100
@ltsbicje, tab kuslebss cjejdbr jt VILC. Lt jppbjrbg vbry pbfuiljr tajt Gbnbegje
tab VILC hnnlfb stjnn cjgb tabcsbivbs uejvjlijkib nhr qubstlheled ky tab nbgbrji jd
nbgbrji jdbet ijtbr stjtbg tajt ajtb spbbfawjs tab jpprhprljtb tbrc le tab ajtb frlcb
wajt ls jiibdbg th ajvb ajppbebg le Hnnlfb 7:6, jeg le glsfusslhe wlta tab @jesjs R
tajt ]ijletlnn wjs ghled tab rldat taled le suled Gbnbegjets le flvli fhurt nhr rbilbn, j
spbbfa leflgbet glg eht rlsb th tab ibvbi hn nbgbrji stjtutbs nhr ajtb frlcbs jeg suddb
]ijletlnn fhcpbi tab ajegwrltled hn Gbnbegjet [lttdbrs.
Gbnbegjets gbnjcjthry phrtrjyji hn Gr. Ajib fhst alc fhuetibss rbijtlhesal
prjftlfled jii hn tab taleds tajt Gbnbegjets gbey, walfa lefiugb lcpudeled Gr. Ajib
rbputjtlhe, ahehr, jeg letbdrlty. Js j glrbft rbsuit hn tab njisb ejrrjtlvbs gbeyled ta
frlcb hr j suspbft, Gbnbegjets shudat th pukilfiy gbnjcb jeg slibefb Gr. Ajibs ejr
wjs gljcbtrlfjiiy hpphsbg th tablrs. Jt tab sjcb tlcb tajt BVR kbdje th pukilfiy p
tab ejrrjtlvb tajt j ajtb frlcb glg eht hffur, pbhpib rjplgiy kbdje th wltagrjw tablr
Gr. Ajib. Ojshe Krhh`s, tab ebwiy jpphletbg Jsslstjet Gbje hn Vtugbet Jnnjlrs nhr
Bqulty jeg Lefiuslhe jt BVR wjs prhchtbg nrhc als nhrcbr rhib js Glrbfthr hn Glvb
Lefiuslhe jt BVR js je lefbetlvb th jkjegheled tab Ajibs fjusb. Ab wjs jish jgvl
Kijf` Vtugbet Relhe (KVR). Krhh`s kbdje th lenhrc tab KVR, htabr stugbets js w
jeg stjnn eht th fhccuelfjtb wlta Gr. Ajib hr als wlnb sahrtiy jntbr tab nlrst cjrfa.
khre jeg rjlsbg le Bcphrlj, @jesjs, jeg als pjrbets jeg htabr njcliy cbckbrs jrb B
Krhh`s wlnb ls j drjgujtb hn VILC Jitahuda je bjriy jeg jrgbet supphrtbr wabe
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
9/100
prhnbsshrs le als ghfthrji prhdrjc jt Kj`br Relvbrslty. Wajt pijfbs ^lbttl le j phslt
leniubefb.
J Njfbkhh` pahth hn BVR KVR cbckbrs wbjrledCjrfa He Bcphrljt-salr
nlrst cjrfa ls jttjfabg js Bxalklt Fth ]ijletlnns Cbchrjeguc th Gbey jeg ls lefh
rbnbrbefb abrble. ]ahths nrhc tab nlrst Cjrfa He Bcphrlj jrb jttjfabg js Bxalklt G
]ijletlnns Cbchrjeguc jeg jrb lefhrphrjtbg ky rbnbrbefb abrble. ]ahths hn tab sb
He Bcphrlj jrb jttjfabg js Bxalklt Bth ]ijletlnns Cbchrjeguc jeg jrb lefhrphr
rbnbrbefb abrble. Wj`b ehtb hn tab jttbegjefb jt khta. Wab euckbr hn cjrfabrs piu
jrhueg :2= th jkhut twbety-nlvb. Wab KVR wjs vbry levhivbg le tab nlrst cjrfa. J
Letbrlc ]rbslgbet ^lbttl nrhc KVR ^lfb-]rbslgbet Gblgrj Biloja ls jttjfabg js Bxal
]ijletlnns Cbchrjeguc jeg ls lefhrphrjtbg ky rbnbrbefb abrble. Le lt Gblgrj sjys?
truiy sjg tajt tab Relvbrslty fhetleubs th swbbp rjflji lssubs uegbr tab rud. J supp
cbssjdb th tab Ajibs phstbg he Gblgrj BilojasNjfbkhh` pjdb ls jttjfabg js Bxalk
]ijletlnns Cbchrjeguc jeg ls lefhrphrjtbg ky rbnbrbefb abrble. Le lt Gblgrj sjys?
Kijf` Vtugbet Relhe ^lfb ]rbslgbet, wb wlii gh jey jeg bvbrytaled le hur phwbr th
He hr jkhut Vbptbckbr :4ta, ;=:2, rldat jntbr tab nlrst cjrfa, Gr. ^lbttl fheguftbg j
cbbtleds wlta njfuity, stjnn jeg stugbets hn fhihr nrhc hrdjelzjtlhes il`b tab KVR.
tabrbjntbr tab KVR jeg chst BVR stugbets prbvlhusiy levhivbg wlta tab prhtbst cjr
qult fhccuelfjtled wlta tab Ajibs. Le jggltlhe th Gblgrj Biloja, eucbrhus htabr B
wah ajg supphrtbg tab Ajibs saut alc jeg als wlnb fhcpibtbiy hut sufa js Gbrb` T
Fjsb 2?:2 fv =7/:> ]jdb
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
10/100
tab fhetrhvbrsy (Ghf :6, pd.>7), kut tabe sthppbg ehtlnyled tab Ajibs hn suksbqubet
njfuity jeg stjnn js wbii js glvbrslty cbbtleds. [bfbetiy Gr. Vclta sbet Gr. Ajib je
eht th kb fhetjftbg jdjle. J fhpy hn tajt bcjli cbssjdb ls jttjfabg js Bxalklt Ath
Cbchrjeguc jeg ls lefhrphrjtbg ky rbnbrbefb abrble. Wh cj`b cjttbrs whrsb, tab
tab BVR Kijf` Vtugbet Relhe, Bccjeubi Fhf`rbii, whr`bg js je jsslstjet th Letbrl
^lbttl jeg ls phsslkiy stlii whr`led js je jsslstjet th tab ebw ]rbslgbet Jiilshe Djrr
cbetlhebg tals fhenilft hn letbrbst th Krhh`s jeg th Fhf`rbii. Le tab bvbet tab BVR
ebbg th prhtbst jgclelstrjtlhe philflbs, sufa j rbijtlhesalp fhuig prbsbet fhcpilfjtl
nrbbghc hn spbbfa, jeg ls prhkibcjtlf. Hvbr tlcb, Gr. Ajib jeg als wlnb wltebssbg
gbnbfthrs wah ajg prbvlhusiy sycpjtalzbg wlta tabc. ]ijletlnn kbilbvbs tajt als ejc
rbputjtlhe, ahehr jeg letbdrlty wbrb legbbg glspjrjdbg ky Gbnbegjets le prlvjtb cb
tarhuda vjrlhus pukilf cbglj, sufa js tab sfahhi ebwspjpbr tab BVR Kuiibtle, kbfj
lccbgljtbiy jntbr tabsb cbbtleds jeg tab nlrst cjrfa, tab Ajibs wbrb saueebg jeg h
GBNBEGJEWV EHW LCCREB N[HC EHE-CHEBWJ[\ ORGDCB
Vtjtb hnnlfljis fje kb subg le tablr hnnlflji fjpjfltlbs,Tlii v. Clfaldje Gbpt.
]hilfb, 7
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
11/100
(:
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
12/100
thh sbesltlvb. Js hutrjdbhus js lt cjy shueg, Gbje Jibxjegbr bvbe js`bg Gr. Ajib
ajg kbbe tarhuda cbehpjusb. Nrhc tajt phlet nhrwjrg Gbje Jibxjegbr kbdje th gb
]ijletlnn jeg als wlnb, jeg th rbtjiljtb le vjrlhus wjys, rbsuitled le tab rbsldejtlhe hn
Ajib js Jsslstjet th tab Gbje, Cjr`btled, jeg tab tbrclejtlhe hn Gr. Ajib. Wab fhu
tbrclejtlhe le tals fjsb fhccbefbg wabe Gbje Jibxjegbr gbflgbg th tbrclejtb tab
Jibxjegbr jish stjrtbg j fhursb hn tbrclejtlhe nhr Jedbilfj Ajibsdrjgujtb jsslstje
Jibxjegbr, wah ls waltb, whuig jrdub wlta Gr. Ajib hr Jedbilfj Ajib, wah jrb kijf
nbbileds thwjrgs j rjfljilzbg jft ls ltsbin prhkibcjtlf. Kut Gbje Jibxjegbr ajs j ihe
rbtjiljthry fheguft jdjlest stjnn jeg njfuity, wlta j prbghclejefb hn tals fheguft gl
pbrshes hn fhihr. J ijwsult nlibg jdjlest BVR le @jesjs Glstrlft Fhurt he Hfthkbr 6
krhudat ky Gr. [jobsa Vleda, j nhrcbr prhnbsshr wah whr`bg le VILC nrhc ;==< th
jiibdbs jched htabr taleds, rjflji glsfrlclejtlhe jeg rbtjiljtlhe, jeg Jibxjegbr jeg
Jsshfljtb Gbje, Jegrbw Vclta jrb ejcbg js gbnbegjets (Fjsb ;?:2-fv-= ]jdb
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
13/100
stugbets hnnlfb he tab nhurta nihhr. Gbje Jibxjegbr fhefbgbg th Gr. Ajibs gbcje
Jedbilfj wjs chvbg nrhc tab hnnlfb sultb wlta [lttdbrs he tab talrg nihhr th je hnnlf
nhurta nihhr, glrbftiy jfrhss tab ajii nrhc Gr. Ajib. Hnnlfbs he tab nhurta nihhr wbrb
rbsbrvbg nhr VILC njfuity. Khta hnnlfbs jrb ijrdb le fhcpjrlshe th htabr hnnlfbs. W
frbjtbg uesph`be tbeslhes. Nhr tabsb rbjshes, lt wjs eht j sahf` wabe j ajegwrltle
phletbg th [lttdbrs js tab chst prhkjkib suspbft. BVR wjs gbspbrjtb th fhevlefb ta
tab pukilf tajt tals jft wjs eht gheb ky j ihed-tlcb bcpihybb. Waby ahpbg tajt tarb
Ajibs ohk whuig legufb alc th rbtrjftals kbilbn le [lttdbrs js tab jutahr hn tab siur
stugbet pjpbr, tab Kuiibtle, pukilsabg je jrtlfib rbdjrgled tals prbglfjcbet he Hfthk
betltibgAjib Cust [btrjft hr Njfb tab Jxb(Ghf. :6, pd. 71). Wals nhrc hn fhbrflh
letbegbg th ajvb j faliiled bnnbft he nuturb walstib-kihwbrs lefilebg th bxphsb rjflsc
He lenhrcjtlhe jeg kbilbn, lt ls eh sbfrbt tajt Gbje Jibxjegbr jeg Gbkrj [lt
fihsb pbrsheji nrlbegs hutslgb hn tab hnnlfb. Gr. Ajib kbilbvbs tajt Gbje Jibxjegbr
abr ahstlib jeg rbtjiljthry jftlhes le rbsphesb th ]ijletlnns jffusjtlhes hn rjflsc jd
dhhg nrlbeg jeg rldat-ajeg jsslstjet, Gbkrj [lttdbrs. Gr. Ajib nurtabr kbilbvbs tajt
Jibxjegbr prjftlfbs rjflji kljs js bvlgbefbg ky abr hwe stjtbcbets th Gr. Ajib jeg
rbfhrg. Jt tab tlcb hn Ajibs glsfusslhe wlta Jibxjegbr, Gbje Jibxjegbr stjtbg taj
uegbrstjeg way Jedbilfj wjs sh sbesltlvb jkhut wajt Jedbilfj jeg Gr. Ajib pbrf
drhss lestjefb hn rjflji glsfrlclejtlhe. Waus lt wjs fibjr tajt Gbje Jibxjegbr bltab
kbilbvb tajt rjflji glsfrlclejtlhe ajg hffurrbg hr tajt sab glg eht letbeg th gh jeyta Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
14/100
leflgbet, rbdjrgibss hn wabtabr j suspbft bxlstbg hr eht. Gbje Jibxjegbr glg eht sa
letbrbst le tab cjttbr jdjle uetli Gr. Ajib jeg als wlnb wbet th tab ]rhvhst jeg ]hilf
ehtaled. Gbje Jibxjegbr rlglfuibg tab ehtlhe hn rjflsc jeg glspjrjdbg tab vlftlc.
kb tab stjefb hn BVR jgclelstrjthrs thwjrgs Gr. Ajib jeg als wlnb nrhc tajt phlet n
Wab hnnlflji ejrrjtlvb hn wajt ajppbebg he hr jkhut Jprli 1ta
, ;=:2 ghbs eht
prlvjtb hnnlfb sthry ueibss tab sthrytbiibr wjs tryled th gbnibft js cufa jttbetlhe jwj
Gbnbegjet [lttdbrs js phsslkib. BVR ajs stjtbg pukilfiy tajt ehtaled hn tab `leg gb
Gr. Ajib hr als wlnb bvbr ajppbebg. Wajt ls way tab Ajibs kbfjcb j cbcb nhr pbrp
ajtb ahjxhe tab Letbrebt. BVR sbcjetlfjiiy jitbrbg tab frlcb sfbeb jeg bxhebrjt
suspbft. Gr. Ajib kbilbvbs tajt Gbje Jibxjegbr sbttibg he j strjtbdy wabrbky sab w
le hrgbr th kuy philtlfji fhvbr nhr [lttdbrs, sh BVR rbchvbg abr nrhc rhib js Gbje h
whr` he spbflji prhobfts jeg Gr. Clrja Ghw ajs kbbe jpphletbg Letbrlc Gbje uetli
rbsuits le j ebw gbje. Js kjf`drhueg, Gbje Jibxjegbr wjs jpphletbg Letbrlc ]rhv
tab ;=:; th ;=:6 jfjgbclf ybjr, jeg sab hntbe krjddbg hn abr philtlfji fjpltji. Vab u
philtlfji fjpltji th salbig [lttdbrs. Gr. Ajib kbilbvbs tajt Gbje Jibxjegbr pjrtlflpjt
pijeeled tab frlcb.
Jntbr chvled th tab nhurta nihhr, Jedbilfj Ajib jeg abr drjgujtb jsslstjet aj
letbrjftlhe wlta [lttdbrs, wah Gbje Jibxjegbr abrsbin gbsfrlkbg js tbrrlthrlji thw
Jedbilfj. [lttdbrs tbrclejtbg jii bxfbpt ebfbssjry fhccuelfjtlhes wlta Jedbilfj j
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
15/100
taleds. Vab jish il`bs th dhsslp. ]ijletlnn kbilbvbs tajt [lttdbrs jeg Jibxjegbr vlbw
js ajvled thh cufa juthehcy, jeg tajt bvbetujiiy sab rbshrtbg th lesuitled tabc le
gbnljefb jeg phwbr. Jedbilfj Ajibs drjgujtb jsslstjetrbphrtbg ahstliltlbs he tab o
Vab rjrbiy thufabg kjsbs wlta tab VILC hnnlfb he tab talrg nihhr, wabrb [lttdbrs ajg
khjrg jeg htabr fhetrhi cbfajelscs. ]hwbr ls pbrfblvbg le cjey wjys, jeg lt wjs
pbrfblvbg tajt tab Ajibs wbrb eht heiy ehe-fhenhrclst, kut kbled kijf` taby rbprbsb
th tab rjflji ibes jt VILC.
Gr. Ajib kbilbvbs tajt rjflji jelcus spjr`bg ky objihusiy jeg ajtb nrhc [ltt
th tab phlet wabrb sab pijeebg jeg fhcclttbg tab jft hn betbrled Jedbilfjs drjguj
hnnlfb wlta tab letbet hn ibjvled tab rjflji bpltabt ELDDJ_glrbftbg jt tab Ajibs j
stugbet he sjlg stugbets ehtbpjg. Gr. Ajib kbilbvbs tajt tab jft hn vjegjilzled tab s
ehtbkhh` wlta j rjflji siur wjs glrbftbg jt alc jeg als wlnb jeg abr jsslstjet js je j
rbtjiljtlhe nhr tablr khigebss, walfa ls uefhcche le tab BVR lestltutlheji rjflji filc
waltb-ghclejtbg fuiturb tajt ghbset nbbi tab ebbg th letbdrjtb. Gr. Ajib rbjftbg le
ls fheslstbet wlta als vjiubs gbspltb tab fhsts.
Gbnbegjets fhefhftbg njisb ejrrjtlvbs jkhut tab ajtb spbbfa jft tajt hffurrb
7:6 wabrb tab rjflji siur wjs nhueg le hrgbr th clsibjg jeg gbfhetbxtujilzb Gbkrj [
chtlvbs, jeg th gbfrlclejilzb tab wrltled hn tab siur. Waby kbdje ky fjiiled tab prlv
ehe-hnnlfble je hpbe jrbj wabrb pbhpib fjcb jeg wbet tarhudahut tab gjy. Wajt
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
16/100
kbilbvbs tajt tarbb frlcbs hffurrbg wabe tab jft wjs gheb le tab prlvjtb hnnlfb? ueij
vjegjilsc jeg ajtb spbbfa. Wabsb cjy eht rlsb th tab ibvbi hn nbihelbs, kut eht jii f
nbihelbs. Ajtb spbbfa ls he tab ajtb frlcb spbftruc pbr lenhrcjtlhe hktjlebg jt tab
Jtthrebys@jesjs Ajtb Frlcbs Vycphslucahstbg ky R.V. Jtthreby Kjrry [. Drlss
Ehvbckbr 7, ;=:2 le @jesjs Flty, @jesjs. J fhpy hn tab jdbegj nhr tab sycphsluc
js Bxalklt Oth ]ijletlnns Cbchrjeguc jeg ls lefhrphrjtbg ky rbnbrbefb abrble. K
eh frlcb hffurrbg le tab wrltled hn tab rjflji bpltabt, Gbnbegjets jrb iyled, jeg aj
rbpbjtbgiy jeg pukilfiy, phrtrjyled Gr. Ajib js j iljr. Gbnbegjet Ohaeshe bxpilfltiy
ehtaled ajppbebg. Wab lcprbsslhe letbetlhejiiy dlvbe th tab pukilf ls tajt Gr. Aj
wlnb cjgb tals sthry up js j pukilflty stuet. Bxjcpibs hn tab pukilf rbsphegled th G
njisb jiibdjtlhes ajvb kbbe lefiugbg le tab Vbfheg Jcbegbg Fhcpijlet (Ghf. :6, p
Bxalklts H, ], Z, [, V jeg W). Gbnbegjets fhuesbi rbpbjts tabsb njisb jiibdjtlhes k
Tltahut j frlcb ajvled kbbe fhcclttbg tabrb ls ehtaled th walfa tab gbsldejtlhe
fje kb jttjfabg. Waus, tabrb ajs kbbe eh ajtb frlcb eht th cbetlhe, cufa ibss lc
ejcb, rbputjtlhe, ahehr, hr letbdrlty. Wals njisb stjtbcbet ltsbin ls gbnjcjthry. Lt l
Ajibs ejcb, rbputjtlhe, ahehr, jeg letbdrlty. Bltabr j ajtb frlcb hffurrbg, hr lt glg
Ajib fijlcs tajt BVR ls iyled. Wab fhevbrsb ls hkvlhusiy trub js wbii. [lttdbrs ajs
Gbnbegjets fjeeht fjtbdhrlfjiiy stjtb tajt [lttdbrs ls leehfbet wabe nhrbeslf
jffbptbg le fhurts jfrhss tab Reltbg Vtjtbs strhediy suddbsts htabrwlsb. Wab Gbnbeg
ajvb jggrbssbg tals cjttbr tabcsbivbs jt tab hesbt hn tals fhetrhvbrsy sh tajt tals gj Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
17/100
bvlgbefb th rbjfa fhefiuslhes. Bltabr j frlcb glrbftbg jt tab Ajibs wjs fhcclttbg
hr lt wjs eht.
[jy Ijukbr, tab Gbnbegjet wah fheguftbg tab rbphrt-turebg-letbreji-levbstl
BVR jeg wrhtb j succjry rbphrt kjsbg he lt, jiibdbgiy wjs kjkysjt ky Gbnbegjet [
sab whr`bg wlta als chtabr le tab Jiucel Fbetbr jt BVR jichst twh gbfjgbs jdh.
cjeunjfturbg je letbreji levbstldjtlhe rbphrt tajt rbjgs il`b j tjkihlg-ibvbi jg ahcl
]ahths hn [jy Ijukbr, Ougy Jegbrshe, @bvle Ohaeshe jeg Farls Ahhvbr jrb jttjfab
@th ]ijletlnns Cbchrjeguc jeg jrb lefhrphrjtbg ky rbnbrbefb abrble. Ijukbr nhf
levbstldjtlhe he tab Ajibs jeg eht he tab ajtb frlcb jiibdjtlhes. Tabe fhenrhetb
gbelbg tajt ab wjs kjkysjt ky Gbkrj [lttdbrs, kut jgclts tajt sab jeg als chtabr wb
nrlbegs jeg fh-whr`brs wabe ab wjs yhued. Bcjli fhrrbsphegbefb wlta [jy Ijukb
sukobft ls jttjfabg js Bxalklt Ith ]ijletlnns Cbchrjeguc jeg ls lefhrphrjtbg ky r
abrble. Ijukbr ls eht j frbglkib lcpjrtlji levbstldjthr ky jey cbjsurb, jeg tabsb sa
wbrb `ehwe th jii tab Gbnbegjets, ybt taby jiihwbg Ijukbr th fhefhft j nijwbg, uep
jeg aldaiy hnnbeslvb levbstldjtlhe. Waby pihwbg jabjg gbspltb ]ijletlnns hkobftl
vbry sbibftlhe hn [jy Ijukbr fje kb vlbwbg js je lesuit jeg j stjtbcbet hn waltb ph
ghclejefb jt BVR. Wab rbfhrg wlii sahw tajt ]rhvhst Fhrgib, wah wjs supphsbg th
tabsb typbs hn njfuity glsputbs, wjs slibet le lcpilflt supphrt hn tab fhvbr-up hn tab a
Gr. Ajib jssucbg tajt Gbje Jibxjegbrs rbtjiljtlhe whuig eht fhefiugb uet
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
18/100
lestruftlheji tbfaehihdy jeg phtbetljiiy lefrlclejtled bvlgbefb. J pahth hn Gr. Fh
jttjfabg js Bxalklt Cth ]ijletlnns Cbchrjeguc jeg ls lefhrphrjtbg ky rbnbrbefb
Ajibs stugbet bvjiujtlhes kbnhrb tab Fhhiled Hnn ]brlhg wbrb bxfbiibet. Vtugbet bv
jntbr ]ijletlnn wjs bxfiugbg nrhc VILC wbrb clxbg. Wrjesfrlpts hn Gr. Ajibs stug
nhr j succbr ;=:2 fhursb fjiibg IL1:2 Lenhrcjtlhe Wbfaehihdy ls jttjfabg js Bxa
]ijletlnns Cbchrjeguc jeg ls lefhrphrjtbg ky rbnbrbefb abrble. ]ahths hn Gr. Aji
wlta als fhiibjdubs jrb jttjfabg js Bxalklt Hth ]ijletlnns Cbchrjeguc jeg jrb le
ky rbnbrbefb abrble. ]ahths hn Gr. Ajib wlta als stugbets jrb jttjfabg js Bxalklt ]
Cbchrjeguc jeg jrb lefhrphrjtbg ky rbnbrbefb abrble.
Gr. Ajib wjs uejkib th rbduijriy jffbss als hnnlfb gurled tab Fhhiled Hnn ]b
tabrbnhrb uejkib th frbjtb j phrtnhilh nhr rbvlbw hn als rbsbjrfa jeg sbrvlfb fhetrlku
Gbnbegjets wjet th kijcb Gr. Ajib nhr tals. Wab bxfiuslhe hn ]ijletlnn nrhc als fhi
tab supphrt sbrvlfbs hn tab gbpjrtcbet, pjrtlfuijriy nhr ebw njfuity dhbs jdjlest Rel
philfy. Wab BVR ]hilfy Cjeuji spbflnlbs tajt suspbeslhe hn j njfuity cbckbr gurl
drlbvjefb prhfbbgled ls oustlnlbg heiy ln lccbgljtb ajrc th tab njfuity cbckbr hr
tarbjtbebg ky fhetleujefb hn sbrvlfb. ]ijletlnns benhrfbg lshijtlhe nrhc als hnnlfb,
Gbpjrtcbet, jeg VILC stugbets wjs aucliljtled jeg gjcjdled th als rbputjtlhe, je
uerbjshejkib jeg ueoustlnlbg. Gr. Ajibs stjeg jdjlest rjflji glsfrlclejtlhe sahuig
je bxtrjhrglejry fhetrlkutlhe th fhccuelty sbrvlfb.
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
19/100
prhdrjc le ildat hn tab trbjtcbet hn shcbheb wah gjrbg rbphrt je jiibdbg ajtb frlc
sthry jkhut j RGL cbbtled abig he Gbfbckbr 7
ta
, ;=:2, lefiugbs tab nhiihwled stjtb
^lbttl? "Hur ohureby rbdjrgled glvbrslty jeg lefiuslhe kbdje bjrilbr tals njii wabe ta
fhcclttbg th kuligled j kbttbr, strhedbr, chrb lefiuslvb Ahrebt Ejtlhe." Chrb lefi
bvbryheb bisb pbrajps, kut eht hn Gr. Ajib jeg als wlnb. J trub fhpy hn tab jrtlfib l
Bxalklt Zth ]ijletlnns Cbchrjeguc jeg ls lefhrphrjtbg ky rbnbrbefb abrble. Gr.
stjtbcbet ls clssled tab pjrt jkhut cuzziled jeg tbrclejtled Gr. Ajib. Gr. Ajib aj
bvlgbefb tajt BVR hnnbrbg lefbetlvbs th stugbets th jttbeg tablr glvbrslty succlt cb
kbfjusb je bjrilbr cbbtled le Hfthkbr njlibg th jttrjft chrb taje twbety-nlvb stugbe
ajvled trhukib sbiiled lts glvbrslty leltljtlvb.
Wab jffrbgltjtlhe rbphrt hn VILC ky tab Jcbrlfje Ilkrjry Jsshfljtlhe (JI
jpprhvbg ky @jrbe HKrlbe hn tab JIJ sahwbg bvlgbefb hn sldelnlfjet kljs jdjles
jeg als fijlcs hn j ajtb frlcb. Wab JIJ swjiihwbg tab Relvbrslty phsltlhe tajt e
hffurrbg, gbspltbkbled prhvlgbg sldelnlfjet glrbft prlcjry bvlgbefb hn bdrbdlhus f
VILC nhr chetas. Le spltb hn j rbfhrg walfa lefiugbg eht heb kut twh nbgbrji ijwsu
uejffbptjkiy alda njfuity turehvbr rjtb, jeg j Gbje walfa ajg th kb rbchvbg nrhc
gutlbs, tab JIJ wbet hutslgb tab khuegs hn tablr hwe stjegjrgs th rb-jffrbglt VILC
tajt rjlsbs sldelnlfjet fhefbres jkhut tablr letbdrlty jeg fhccltcbet th shflji oustlf
sjcb ybjr le walfa tab VILC prhdrjc wjs uegbr rbvlbw ky tab JIJ, walfa furrbe
bvbry sbvbe ybjrs Gr Clrja Ghw nrhc VILC wjs jpphletbg ky JIJ ]rbslgbet Vjr Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
20/100
tals JIJ jeehuefbcbet ls jttjfabg js Bxalklt [th ]ijletlnn s Cbchrjeguc jeg ls
ky rbnbrbefb abrble. Bjfa cbckbr hn tab jffrbgltjtlhe tbjc tajt vlsltbg VILC wjs
nbcjib, leglfjtlvb hn tab rjflji lesbesltlvlty jeg theb-gbjnebss jt tab JIJ tajt ajs ib
fjii tab JIJ #JIJVHTALWB. Gr. Ajib kbilbvbs tab JIJ cjgb j sldelnlfjet fh
thwjrgs als gbnjcjtlhe, jeg jdjlest tab fjusb hn shflji oustlfb, ky dlvled lts uerbsbr
th j prhdrjc tajt cjey le tab ilkrjry fhccuelty nbbi gbsbrvbg th rbfblvb fhegltlhej
lt wjs gbtbrclebg wabtabr hr eht tab lestjet iltldjtlhe whuig kb abjrg le Nbgbrji Fh
Wab njft rbcjles tajt tab fhursb hn ]ijletlnns tbrclejtlhe wjs grjwe hut hvb
euckbr hn njfthrs, lefiugled tab jfjgbclf sfahhi ybjr, tab cjrfabs, jeg jffrbgltjtl
tab Aldabr Ibjreled Fhcclsslhe jeg tab Jcbrlfje Ilkrjry Jsshfljtlhe, kut Gbnbe
letbetlhes wbrb jppjrbet nrhc tab tlcb tajt tab rjflji bpltabt wjs glsfhvbrbg jeg eh
gheb jkhut lt ky jeyheb. BVR jgclelstrjthrs tabe sbt hut th prhtbft Gbje Jibxjegb
prhtd Gbkrj [lttdbrs. Gr. Ajib stjegs ky als jssbrtlhe tajt ab ajs kbbe tbrclejtbg
fhiibdb pjpbr, Wab Kuiibtle, rbfbetiy prletbg je jrtlfib tajt stjtbs tajt ]ijletlnn ls jnh
bcpihybb. J fhpy hn tals jrtlfib ls jttjfabg js Bxalklt Vth ]ijletlnns Cbchrjeguc
lefhrphrjtbg ky rbnbrbefb abrble. Wab sjcb Kuiibtle lssub dhbs he th gbnjcb Gr. A
jttrlkutled j fhccbet th alc walfa lt cjeunjfturbg th lenijcb ajtrbg thwjrgs Gr. A
stugbets, njfuity, jiucel, btf. Le ijrdb ibttbrs js j abjgbr tltib nhr j sthry wrlttbe ky
Vphhe, walfa ls supphsbg th kb j trjesfrlpt hn je letbrvlbw wlta Gr. Ajib, tab jrtlfi
Gr Ajib stjtbg? L ghet nbbi sjnb le j thwe wabrb js j kijf` pbrshe L fje sbb j Fh Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
21/100
eht wajt L bxpbftbg Ahw ghbs tab Cjejdled Bglthr/rbphrtbr wah ebbgs gh ehta
taje trjesfrlkb j fhevbrsjtlhe dbt lt wrhed8 Gr. Ajib phletbg hut Vjrja Vphhes brr
wlta htabr bdrbdlhus brrhrs le tajt trjesfrlpt th tab Kuiibtle th Jrlbi Fhhiby, Bglthr-
bvbe sajrbg als rbfhrgled hn tab letbrvlbw, kut tab Kuiibtle rbnusbg th fhrrbft tablr n
stjtbcbets jeg th cltldjtb jey rbputjtlheji ajrc taby cjy ajvb fjusbg. Le ybt jeht
hn tab nilp nihps fjusbg ky Gbnbegjets gbnjcjtlhe hn tab Ajibs, tab sjcb Kuiibtle
bglthr/rbphrtbr, Vjrja Vphhe, jffhcpjelbg Jedbilfj Ajib th tab nhurta nihhr hn tab V
le Hfthkbr ;=:2, jeg hksbrvbg jeg jdrbbg tajt Hnnlfb 7:6 ls j prlvjtb hnnlfb. Rphe
VILC hnnlfbs, Vjrja fje kb sbbe dlvled Gr. Ajib, wah ls tj`led tab plfturb, tab tauc
Wabrb ls eh bxfusb nhr tab Kuiibtle th glspjrjdb jeg ture tab fjcpus jeg fhccuelty
Ajib ky rbphrtled njisb lenhrcjtlhe le je ueprhnbsslheji cjeebr. Wals typb hn fheg
ibss taje cjilflhus, jeg ajg th kb jpprhvbg ky je BVR njfuity jgvlshr kbnhrb pukilf
ls oust j rbfbet bxjcpib hn tab fheguft tajt BVR supphrts hn th lcpude tab ejcb, rb
ahehr jeg letbdrlty hn Gr. Ajib. J pahth hn Jedbilfj Ajib jeg Vjrja Vphhe jntbr v
7:6 le VILC ls jttjfabg js Bxalklt Wth ]ijletlnn s Cbchrjeguc jeg ls lefhrphrjtb
rbnbrbefb abrble.
]ijletlnn kbilbvbs tajt tab jppbjrjefb hn tab NKL he fjcpus le Gbfbckbr ;=
letbrbst hn tab R.V. Gbpjrtcbet hn Oustlfb le tals fjsb, cjgb lt glnnlfuit nhr BVR th tb
le tab aldaajegbg cjeebr taby ajg tbrclejtbg sh cjey htabrs. Js j wbii-pbrnhrcle
trjf` prhnbsshr rbfrultbg nrhc RFIJ Gr Ajib ajg bvbry rbjshe th bxpbft tajt als f Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
22/100
jfjgbclf tbjfaled fjrbbr. Gbspltb ebvbr ajvled tjudat j fhiibdb fijss, Gr. Ajib ajs
cbtrlfs taje cjey bxpbrlbefbg njfuity, jeg ab ls wliiled th fhcpjrb als stugbet bvj
jeyheb jt VILC. Gr. Ajibs prbvlhus jeeuji bvjiujtlhe, gheb he hr jrhueg Gbfbck
Gbje Jibxjegbr, ls jttjfabg js Bxalklt Rth ]ijletlnns Cbchrjeguc jeg ls lefhrph
rbnbrbefb abrble. Vhcb hn tab fhccbets Jibxjegbr cjgb le tajt bvjiujtlhe lefiugb
Ajib? Lt ls cy pibjsurb th jf`ehwibgdb yhur jfalbvbcbets gurled yhur nlrst sbcbstb
Jsslstjet ]rhnbsshr wlta VILC. \hu jrb jirbjgy j vjiubg cbckbr hn tab njfuity jeg
fhedrjtuijtb yhu he yhur fhetrlkutlhes th tab fhiijkhrjtlvb fuiturb, hur bnnhrts thwj
ibjreled hutfhcbs nhr stugbets, jeg nhr uitlcjtbiy cj`led j glnnbrbefb le tab wjys h
fhetrlkutb th tab fhcche dhhg hn tab fhccueltlbs taby sbrvb
Cy bxpbrlbefb hks
le tab fijssrhhc jeg tab vlgbhs yhu ajvb rbfhrgbg jrb tajt yhu jrb jkib th bedjdb st
abip tabc th uegbrstjeg wajt ls bxpbftbg hn tablr pbrnhrcjefb. Jitahuda wb ajvb y
tab stugbet bvjiujtlhes nhr tab fhursbs yhu tjudat, jii lenhrcji fhccbets L ajvb abj
njvhrjkib
Lt ls cy pibjsurb th rbfhccbeg th ]rhvhst Fhrgib tajt yhur jpphletcbe
fhetleubg. Waje` yhu nhr tab cjey wjys yhu ajvb jggbg th tab suffbss hn VILC gu
sahrt tlcb js pjrt hn tab tbjc jeg kbst wlsabs nhr fhetleubg jgvjefbcbet jeg beohy
prhnbsslhe.
BVRs tbrclejtlhe gbflslhe hn Gr. Ajibs bcpihycbet wjs liibdji. Gr. Ajib
sukobftbg th bxtrbcb ahstlilty rbsuitled le als wrhednui tbrclejtlhe, ueprbfbgbetbg r
als hnnlfb jeg gbelji hn gub prhfbss hn j abjrled jii wlta tab nuii beghrsbcbet hn ]r Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
23/100
OR[LVGLFWLHE NH[ WLWIB ^LL FIJLCV
Gbspltb Gbnbegjets fijlcs th tab fhetrjry, jii jgclelstrjtlvb prbrbqulsltbs j
fhegltlhes ajvb kbbe cbt ky Gr. Ajib js lt pbrtjles th als BBHF jeg @A[F nlileds.
rbnusbg th pjrtlflpjtb le rbfhccbegbg cbgljtlhe sbsslhes tarhuda Clgijeg Cbgljtl
Vbttibcbet Vbrvlfbs. J trub jeg jffurjtb trjesfrlpt hn tab levltjtlhe th utlilzb Clgij
jttjfabg js Bxalklt ^th ]ijletlnns Cbchrjeguc jeg ls lefhrphrjtbg ky rbnbrbefb
prlcj njflb fjsb hn rbtjiljtlhe rbqulrbs j pijletlnn th sahw tajt (:) ab bedjdbg le prh
hpphsltlhe th glsfrlclejtlhe0 (;) ab wjs sukobftbg th jgvbrsb bcpihycbet jftlhe ky
bcpihybr0 jeg (6) j fjusji fheebftlhe bxlsts kbtwbbe tab prhtbftbg jftlvlty jeg tab
jftlhe. Fubefj, ;>2 N. Vupp. ;g jt :;=4. ]ijletlnn kbilbvbs tajt ab fje prhvb j fju
fheebftlhe kbtwbbe tab jgvbrsb bcpihycbets jftlhes pbrnhrcbg ky tab Gbnbegjets
prhtbftbg hpphsltlhe th glsfrlclejtlhe. ]ijletlnns [ldat-th-Vub Ibttbr nrhc tab Flv
Glvlslhe hn tab R.V. Gbpjrtcbet hn Oustlfb ls jttjfabg js Bxalklt Tth ]ijletlnns C
jeg ls lefhrphrjtbg ky rbnbrbefb abrble.
Le je Hfthkbr :;ta
, ;=:2 cbbtled wlta ]rhvhst Fhrgib, Gr. Ajib wjs lenhrcb
htabr hptlhe htabr taje sldeled j sbpjrjtlhe ibttbr taby ajg prbpjrbg wjs jvjlijkib th
js`bg ln tabrb wbrb jey htabr jgclelstrjtlvb hptlhes th pursub als fhcpijlets, ]rhvh
stjtbg tajt tabrb wbrb eheb, nhrbfihsled jey jeg jii rbcbglbs jiibdbgiy jvjlijkib wlt
Fhrgib cjgb lt fibjr tajt Gr. Ajib ajg bxajustbg als jgclelstrjtlvb rbcbglbs. Gr. A
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
24/100
VB[^LFB HN @B^LE OHAEVHE JEG [J\ IJRKB[
Gbnbegjets fijlc tajt @bvle Ohaeshe jeg [jy Ijukbr wbrb lcprhpbriy sbrv
ajs sbrvbg jii fhurt nlileds he Gbnbegjets jdbet, walfa ls tab Hnnlfbs hn @jesjs Jtt
Dbebrji Gbrb` Vfaclgt. Retli ehw tab @jesjs Jtthreby Dbebrjis Hnnlfb ajs eht a
hkobftlhes th sbrvlfb. Jt tab fhccbefbcbet hn tals jftlhe Gbnbegjet @bvle Ohaesh
pbrshejiiy sbrvbg he Hfthkbr :2ta, ;=:2 le tab nhybr hn ]iuck Ajii jt Bcphrlj Vtjtb
Ohaeshe ls tab Dbebrji Fhuesbi nhr BVR. Ohaeshe lenhrcbg tab sbrvbr tajt pbrshej
lcprhpbr kbfjusb ab wjs eht tab jdbet nhr sbrvlfb. Jedbilfj D. Ajib, tab sbrvbr, rb
Ohaeshe `bbp tab sbrvlfb bevbihpb jeg suksbqubetiy gbtbrclebg tajt tab @jesjs Jtt
Dbebrjis Hnnlfb ls tab prhpbr jdbet nhr sbrvlfb nhr @jesjs Vtjtb betltlbs, jeg tabe j
leltlji Fhcpijlet he tajt hnnlfb, jeg ajs slefb sbrvbg jii pjrtlbs tarhuda tajt hnnlfb,
fhcphrts wlta N[F] 7(b)(;)(f). J trub jeg jffurjtb trjesfrlpt hn tab Gbfijrjtlhe h
Ajib ls jttjfabg js Bxalklt \th ]ijletlnn s Cbchrjeguc jeg ls lefhrphrjtbg ky rbn
abrble. J pahth hn Jedbilfj D. Ajib sbrvled @bvle Ohaeshe ls jttjfabg js Bxalklt
]ijletlnns Cbchrjeguc jeg lslefhrphrjtbg ky rbnbrbefb abrble. Ohaeshe jeg Ijuk
`by rhibs le tab liibdji fheguft fhcpijlebg hn le tals fjsb.
][J\B[ NH[ [BILBN
Gbnbegjets glsfrlclejtbg jdjlest Gr. Ajib he tab kjsls hn als rjfb jeg fhihr
hn 7; R.V.F. : ]jdb
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
25/100
Jcbegcbet th tab R.V. Fhestltutlhe. Gbnbegjets jftbg uegbr fhihr hn stjtb ijw wa
vlhijtbg Gr. Ajibs rldats. Gr. Ajib ajs kbbe gjcjdbg ky tab liibdji fheguft hn tab
Gr. Ajib ls betltibg th pursub rbilbn jdjlest Gbnbegjets uegbr 7; R.V.F. :
[bspbftnuiiy sukclttbg,
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXCbivle Ajib, ]aG, ]ijletlnn
Jppbjrled]rh Vb
].H. Khx 4;7
Bcphrlj, @V >>1=: Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
26/100
FB[WLNLFJWB HN VB[^LFB
Fjsb Eh. :2-7, ;=:>. L pbrshejiiy cjlibg j fhpy hn tab ghfucbet le tab jky nlrst fijss cjli, phstjdb prbpjlg, jggrbssbg th?
Jeeb Dbpnhrg VcltaJsslstjet Jtthreby Dbebrji hn @jesjs
Cbchrlji Kigd., ;eg
Nihhr
:;= VT :=ta
Jvbeub
Whpb`j, @V >>>:;-:2:4>
Dhhgybjr, J_ 12661
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb : hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
27/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb ; hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
28/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 6 hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
29/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 7 hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
30/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 2 hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
31/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb > hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
32/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 4 hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
33/100
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
34/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb < hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
35/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb := hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
36/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb :: hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
37/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb :; hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
38/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb :6 hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
39/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb :7 hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
40/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb :2 hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
41/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb :> hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
42/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb :4 hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
43/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb :1 hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
44/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb :< hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
45/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb ;= hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
46/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb ;: hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
47/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb ;; hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
48/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb ;6 hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
49/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb ;7 hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
50/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb ;2 hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
51/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb ;> hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
52/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb ;4 hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
53/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb ;1 hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
54/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb ;< hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
55/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 6= hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
56/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 6: hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
57/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 6; hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
58/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 66 hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
59/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 67 hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
60/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 62 hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
61/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 6> hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
62/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 64 hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
63/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 61 hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
64/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 6< hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
65/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 7= hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
66/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 7: hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
67/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 7; hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
68/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 76 hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
69/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 77 hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
70/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 72 hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
71/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 7> hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
72/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 74 hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
73/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 71 hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
74/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 7< hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
75/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 2= hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
76/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 2: hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
77/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 2; hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
78/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 26 hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
79/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 27 hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
80/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 22 hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
81/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 2> hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
82/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 24 hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
83/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 21 hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
84/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 2< hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
85/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb >= hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
86/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb >: hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
87/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb >; hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
88/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb >6 hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
89/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb >7 hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
90/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb >2 hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
91/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb >> hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
92/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb >4 hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
93/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb >1 hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
94/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb >< hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
95/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 4= hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
96/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 4: hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
97/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 4; hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
98/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 46 hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
99/100
Fjsb 2?:2-fv-=7/:> ]jdb 47 hn 47
-
7/24/2019 Hale Memorandum to Deny Defendants Motion to Dismiss 2nd Complaint
100/100