gs/oas – caribbean emergency legislation project/activity: comparative analysis … ·...

32
Environmental Advisors Inc.| Mailing Address: 556 Creekstone Drive, Jonesboro, GA 30236 USA| Phone: 678-545-1862| Fax: 678-545-1862| website: www.environmentaladv.com GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks – Environmental Advisors Inc. Proposal Contact: Judy Daniel Email Address: [email protected] Project Summary:

Upload: others

Post on 26-Jul-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis … · 2009-08-14 · Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks 4

Environmental Advisors Inc.| Mailing Address: 556 Creekstone Drive, Jonesboro, GA 30236 USA|

Phone: 678-545-1862| Fax: 678-545-1862| website: www.environmentaladv.com

GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION

PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis of international legal and

institutional frameworks – Environmental Advisors Inc.

Proposal

Contact: Judy Daniel

Email Address: [email protected]

Project Summary:

Page 2: GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis … · 2009-08-14 · Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks 4

GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity:

Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks

2

Table of Contents

Project Summary............................................................................................................2

Project Description.........................................................................................................2

Description of Approach, Methodology, &Work Plan for Performing Assignment.....5

� Technical Approach & Methodology......................................................................5

� Methodology............................................................................................................5

Work Plan.......................................................................................................................7

Bar Chart of Scheduled Act..........................................................................................12

Organization Staffing...................................................................................................14

Form 1 Work Schedule................................................................................................15

Form 2..........................................................................................................................22

Curriculum Vitae – Associate Staff..............................................................................23

Page 3: GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis … · 2009-08-14 · Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks 4

GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity:

Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks

3

Project Summary:

Legislation is the framework by which governments achieve their purpose. To

politicians and administrators, legislation is a means to attain their economic, cultural,

political and social policies. Thus a State has to legislate in order to accomplish

political objectives and particular public policies. The enactment of state of

emergency legislation is such an objective that requires legislation.

Law does not operate in a vacuum. A law is intended to guide and regulate the

conduct and affairs of those to whom it is addressed. A sound knowledge of these

conditions is very necessary. It is usual to consider laws from other jurisdictions in

arriving at this knowledge platform. The scope of work for the project recognises this

and requires a comparative analysis of existing legal and institutional frameworks for

emergency response in both civil (applicable to Haiti and the Dominican Republic

and common law countries (OECS and other participating countries). The legislation

must provide a solution to the problem it is required to address. It is therefore

necessary to thoroughly understand the issues in order to turn government policy into

effective legislation. Comparing other laws on the subject that regulate similar

problems that are being considered will broaden the understanding of the draftsman

and enhance the legislative framework for state of emergency and improve

accountability in disaster management.

:

Project Description:

A. Consultant’s experience

Environmental Advisors Inc. (EAI) is an environmental management firm that has been providing the highest quality consulting services in the Caribbean for nearly two decades. The Company is incorporated in Trinidad and Tobago. The firm works with its Caribbean and international expert associates to provide advice on all aspects of sustainable development management. Legal, policy and institutional issues are among the key focus areas of EAI. Other action areas include integrated water resources and natural resources management, sustainable energy, climate, engineering, natural resources economics, development planning and capacity-building. Judy Daniel is the President of the firm and its senior legal, institutional and international law expert.

EAI has worked on a broad range of sustainable development issues for a variety of

clients that include Caribbean governments, international, regional and public and

private sector clients such as the World Bank, IADB, ILO, UNEP, UNECLAC,

PAHO, OAS, OECS, CARICOM, CEHI, CARICAD, GWP/CapNet, NEDECO

(Holland), UNEP, USAID, European Union, the Environmental Management

Authority of Trinidad & Tobago, the Environmental Protection Agency of Guyana,

Chester Engineers of Philadelphia, the USVI Legislature and recently the Republic of

Ghana. The motivation of the firm is to make the best expertise available to the Caribbean. By combining the wide-ranging expertise of its national, regional and international associates we take the full spectrum of an issue into account while equally affording a

Page 4: GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis … · 2009-08-14 · Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks 4

GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity:

Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks

4

capacity-building opportunity to regional and local experts. More importantly, our regional and local consultants have a stake in the outcome of the projects providing an added assurance that their advice are of the highest quality. The success of our outputs is guaranteed since our Clients are provided with a no-cost follow-up support up to a period of three months after the delivery of project outputs. EAI team’s project delivery approach and corporate business model enables an expert associate to be always “on the job”. Our approach upholds the desire for advancement, the vision, culture and challenges of the Caribbean region and the duty to act responsibly in the interests of present and future generations to ensure a balanced and realistic project implementation. We at EAI are committed to working with you as our Client to surpass expectations and bring innovative solutions to all your sustainable development issues. We offer the following referees – Sasha Gottleib GEF-IWCAM Project Coordinator [email protected] Elizabeth Mwrena UNEP Nairobi Prof. A. Ralph Carnegie Professor of Law University of the West Indies Cavehill Campus Barbados Tel: 246-425-1310/4216 B. Description of Approach, Methodology and Work Plan for Performing the Assignment

a. Technical Approach and Methodology

Technical Approach

The Scope of Work section of the Terms of Reference adequately summarises the

various sub-tasks that will be required of the Consultant. The following is our

preliminary assessment, based on the understanding of the project, of the work

required of each of the sub-tasks, as well as an indication of how we would staff the

effort. We have included in Form 1 attached to this proposal, a Work Schedule which

provides an indication of the time frame in which this work will be performed. The

Work Schedule is also presented in a bar chart. In addition, a Financial proposal

which provides a detailed cost breakdown is attached at Form 2 to this proposal.

1. Start of Assignment

1.1 Finalisation of Workplan & Timetable Inception

Page 5: GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis … · 2009-08-14 · Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks 4

GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity:

Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks

5

The EAI Team and OAS Project Secretariat will hold an inception

meeting via teleconference. The EAI Team leader will prepare an agenda for this

meeting that will include a discussion on the draft project schedule and timetable.

2. Preparation of Preliminary Assessment Report on Key Legislative and Administrative provisions at the constitutional and supplementary levels

related to state of emergency and budget appropriation and execution

This exercise will include –

(a) a review of state of emergency laws and institutional frameworks of civil and

common-law countries to consider their scope and operability;

(b) review periodicals, journals and other media that provide background

information on the political, cultural, social and economic state of affairs that led

to the enactment of the laws at paragraph (a) to determine the success of the

legislation in solving the problems it was enacted to address;

(c) identify and set out in a Table the key provisions in statutes, administrative

provisions and international legal instruments that may be replicated in similar

legislation in the PCs;

(d) prepare a Preliminary Assessment Report on the matters mentioned at paras (a)

–(c).

3. Conduct a comparative assessment study between the key legislative and

administrative provisions of civil and common-law countries and Caribbean

legislative and institutional frameworks

This activity will –

(a) take into account the assessments of the legal and institutional frameworks of

Caribbean countries related to state of emergency1.

(b) compare the provisions identified in the Draft Assessment Report at Activity

2(d) and the assessments made at paragraph (a) to identify the gaps, weaknesses

and differences that occur between these two scenarios taking into account the

circumstances described at Activity 2(b).

(c) recommend the best approach[es] that should be adopted to improve the legal

and institutional framework in the PCs.

4. Identification and assessment of effectiveness of legal and administrative

provisions as regards channels of responsibility during a state of emergency.

The Team will-

(a) Examine the legislative and administrative provisions of the

selected civil and common-law countries to identify

1 Produced under the project.

Page 6: GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis … · 2009-08-14 · Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks 4

GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity:

Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks

6

procedures and other administrative

arrangements for state of emergency;

(b) Identify the institutional arrangements for state of emergency

(where legislation exists) or the institutional protocol that

obtains for state of emergency in PCs.

(c) Prepare a report identifying the similarities and differences

between the two circumstances in paragraph (a) and (b) and

recommendations as to their ability to be replicated in the

PCs.

5. Preparation of Draft Final Report A draft final report will be prepared setting out-

(a) a set of best practices and recommendations for Caribbean and legal and

institutional frameworks in developing state of emergency legislative frameworks and

institutional arrangements

(b) legislative provisions that could be considered in developing effective laws,

institutional arrangements, procedures, budget appropriation and execution pertaining

to state of emergency in natural disaster circumstances.

6. Revision of Draft Final Report

The Team will -

(a) revise the Draft Final Report to take account of any comments or revisions

proposed by the OAS/DSD;

(b) prepare and finalise an Executive Summary for the Draft Final Report. The

Executive Summary will contain, inter alia, recommendations at the national

level, identify regional trends, similarities and differences between the PCs;

regional recommendations.

(c) submit Final Draft Report to OAS/DSD.

Methodology

The proposal is structured such that Environmental Advisors Inc. is the tendering

consultant. Project outputs will be delivered by a two man team of associate consultants

comprising Team Leader Dr. Jean Andre Victor and John Wilson. Dr. Victor is an

international and constitutional law expert while Mr. Wilson is well-versed in matters

pertaining to disaster management and post-recovery activities. EAI will provide no-cost

overall project management support.

The conception of a piece of legislation involves 3 significant processes. Firstly the

formulation of the policy that leads to the enactment then the research undertaken and

Page 7: GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis … · 2009-08-14 · Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks 4

GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity:

Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks

7

lastly the drafting of the Bill. Each piece of legislation has a policy and

by legislation, policies are translated into law. Sound policy built on an understanding

of the issues for which solutions are being sought is integral to the formulation of

effective legislation. In response to this, EAI has combined the international law skill of

Dr. Victor with the policy and practical knowledge of John Wilson as a joint team to

deliver the project outputs.

John Wilson oversaw the post hurricane recovery/rehabilitation work in Grenada,

Tobago, Bahamas, Antigua, St Lucia and Dominica following the passage of

Hurricane Ivan. His experiences are significant as regards both policy development

and research aspects of the project. The activities were diversified: Grenada (11

medical clinics,250+ house repairs, 5 biodiversity projects and 6 schools repairs);

Tobago (3 road stabilisations and community emergency capacity building of 45

residents ); Antigua (Safer building techniques) and in St Lucia and Dominica

(community land stabilisation and flooding/landslide mitigation work in two

communities) and in the Bahamas 20 new homes. All works were delivered on time

and within budget despite programmatic issues including a late start, the additional

impacts of hurricanes and shortages of materials.

In partnership with the OECS Secretariat, Mr. Wilson also coordinated the

development of a disaster risk reduction strategy (benchmarking tool; and has in the

past conducted project Management for ICT/Disaster Project (CDERA).

Dr. Victor also has specialised knowledge about the French and Spanish (civil) legal

and institutional frameworks and their operations. The preparation of the Executive

Summary to the Report, the Report and recommendations will be a joint team effort.

The project will be conducted as a desktop study as the resources that are available

will not cover field trips.

Page 8: GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis … · 2009-08-14 · Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks 4

GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks

8

b. Work Plan

DRAFT WORKPLAN & TIMETABLE

Activity

No.

Details of Activity Start date Finish

Date

Milestone

‘09

1. Finalisation of Workplan and Timetable

A meeting between OAS Project Secretariat and

EAI Team will be held via teleconference

The EAI Team Leader will prepare the agenda

June 1

June 1

Workplan & Timetable finalised.

Project Kickoff

Page 9: GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis … · 2009-08-14 · Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks 4

GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks

9

2. Preparation of Preliminary Assessment Report

(a) a review of state of emergency laws and

institutional frameworks of civil and common-

law countries to consider their scope and

operability;

(b) review periodicals, journals and other

media that provide information on the

political, cultural, social and economic state

of affairs that led to their enactment to

determine the success of the legislation in

solving the problems it was enacted to

address;

(c) identify and set out the key provisions in

statutes, administrative provisions and

international legal instruments that may be

replicated in similar legislation in the PCs;

(d) prepare a Preliminary Assessment Report.

June 2 June 30 Preliminary Assessment Report

Page 10: GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis … · 2009-08-14 · Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks 4

GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks

10

3. Preparation of comparative assessment Report

(a) take into account the assessments of the

legal and institutional frameworks of

Caribbean countries related to state of

emergency2.

(b) compare the provisions identified in the

Draft Assessment Report at Activity 2(d) and

the assessments made at paragraph (a) to

identify the gaps, weaknesses and differences

that occur between these two scenarios taking

into account the circumstances described at

Activity 2(b).

(c) recommend the best approach(es) that

should be adopted to improve the legal and

institutional framework in the PCs.

Jul. 1

July 15

Comparative Assessment Report

2 Produced under the project.

Page 11: GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis … · 2009-08-14 · Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks 4

GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks

11

4. Identification and assessment of effectiveness of

legal and administrative provisions

(a) Examine the legislative and administrative

provisions of the selected civil and common-law

countries to identify procedures and other

administrative arrangements for state of

emergency;

(b) Identify the institutional arrangements for state

of emergency (where legislation exists) or the

institutional protocol that obtains for state of

emergency in PCs.

(c) Prepare a report identifying the similarities and

differences between the two circumstances in

paragraph (a) and (b) and recommendations as to

their replicability in the PCs

Jul 16

Jul 31

Identification and Assessment Report

5.

Preparation of Draft Final Report

A draft final report will be prepared setting out-

(a) a set of best practices and recommendations

for Caribbean and legal and institutional

frameworks in developing state of emergency

legislative frameworks and institutional

arrangements

(b) legislative provisions that could be considered

in developing effective laws, institutional

arrangements, procedures, budget appropriation

and execution pertaining to state of emergency in

natural disaster circumstances

Aug 1 20

Draft Final Report

Page 12: GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis … · 2009-08-14 · Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks 4

GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks

12

6. Revision of Draft Final Report

(a) revise the Draft Final Report to take

account of any comments or revisions

proposed by the OAS/DSD;

(b) prepare and finalise an Executive

Summary for the Draft Final Report. The

Executive Summary will contain, inter alia,

recommendations at the national level,

identify regional trends, similarities and

differences between the PCs; regional

recommendations.

(a) submit Final Draft Report to OAS/DSD.

Aug 21

Aug 31

Final Draft Report & Executive Summary containing set of recommendations

Page 13: GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis … · 2009-08-14 · Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks 4

GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks

13

BBBBAR CHART OF SCHEDULED ACTIVITIES TIME

Finalisation of Work

plan and Timetable

Consultation

June 1

July 1

Preparation of

Preliminary

Assessment Report

Aug1

Sept1

Preparation of

Comparative

Assessment Report

Identification and

Assessment of

Effectiveness of Legal

and Administrative

Provisions

Preparation of Draft

Final Report

Revision of Draft

Final Report

DELIV

ERABLES

Page 14: GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis … · 2009-08-14 · Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks 4

GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks

14

b. Organization and Staffing Project

The tasks will be performed by a Consultant Team comprising Team Leader Dr. Jean Andre Victor and John Wilson. Their cvs are attached at

the Annex to this proposal. We offer the experience and qualifications of the members of our team to this project and it is our hope that they

find your favourable consideration.

Main disciplines of the assignment, key experts and proposed technical and support staff The Consultant Team members will comprise - John Ricky Wilson

Mr. Wilson is a highly motivated professional of proven ability with notable technical and programmatic experience in post disaster project

management and environmental management. He brings to the Team over 15 years negotiating experience in regional and international fora,

sound international development assistance experience, policy formulation, familiarity of sustainable development matters as it relates to Small

Island States and multi-island project management capacity. As an IDB Consultant Mr Wilson

• Oversaw the post hurricane recovery/rehabilitation work in Grenada, Tobago, Bahamas, Antigua, St Lucia and Dominica following the

passage of Hurricane Ivan in the amount of USD20 Million. The activities were diversified: Grenada (11 medical clinics,250+ house

repairs, 5 biodiversity projects and 6 schools repairs); Tobago (3 road stabilisations and community emergency capacity building of 45

residents ); Antigua (Safer building techniques) and in St Lucia and Dominica (community land stabilisation and flooding/landslide

mitigation work in two communities) and in the Bahamas 20 new homes. All works were delivered on time and within budget despite

programmatic issues including a late start, the additional impacts of hurricanes and shortages of materials;

• Coordinated the development of a disaster risk reduction strategy (benchmarking tool) in partnership with the OECS Secretariat;

He has also provided Project Management for ICT/Disaster Project (CDERA).

Page 15: GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis … · 2009-08-14 · Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks 4

GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks

15

Dr. Jean Andre Victor Among his many career accomplishments Dr. Victor is a Law Professor of Law at the University of Haiti. He earned his Msc. Degree form the

University of Costa Rica and pursued his Ph.D. in International Law at the University of Limoges in France (2000-2002). He has been involved

in several project activities for USAID, the Government of Canada and IICA. His responsibilities included project evaluation and budget

allocations. His work assignments include (1967 – 1991) the Ministry of Agriculture, Natural Resources and Rural Development before joining

the University in 1987. Dr. Vicor has also led many project activities as an international law consultant. A full description of his capabilities is

attached in the Annex to this proposal. Support Staff

Danielle N. Paul

Ms. Paul is a recent graduate of Mercer University with a dual major Bachelor of Arts degree in English and Women and Gender Studies. At EAI, Ms. Paul provides

administrative and report writing skills to the associates of the firm and ensures the timeliness of the delivery of project activities.

Page 16: GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis … · 2009-08-14 · Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks 4

GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks

16

Form 1: Work Schedule Months

Task No.

Deliverable 1 2 3 4 5 6

1. 1. Final

Workplan &

Timetable

Project

Kickoff

.

Final Workplan

& Timetable

finalised

Prepare and

finalise Terms

of Reference for

Team members

22 Preliminary

Assessment

Report

(a) take into

account the

assessments of

the legal and

institutional

frameworks of

Caribbean

countries related

to state of

emergency3.

(b) compare the

provisions

identified in the

Draft

Assessment

Report at

Activity 2(d) and

3 Produced under the project.

Page 17: GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis … · 2009-08-14 · Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks 4

GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks

17

the assessments

made at

paragraph (a) to

identify the gaps,

weaknesses and

differences that

occur between

these two

scenarios taking

into account the

circumstances

described at

Activity 2(b).

(c) recommend

the best

approach(es) that

should be

adopted to

improve the legal

and institutional

framework in the

PCs.

(d) prepare

Preliminary

Assessment

Report

11

Page 18: GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis … · 2009-08-14 · Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks 4

GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks

18

33. Review and

Comparative

Assessment

Report Inventories

Prepare (a) take into account

assessments of legal

and institutional

frameworks of

Caribbean countries

related to state of

emergency4.

(b) compare

provisions identified

in the Draft

Assessment Report at

Activity 2(d) and the

assessments made at

paragraph (a) to

identify the gaps,

weaknesses and

differences that occur

between these two

scenarios taking into

account

circumstances

described at Activity

2(b).

(c) recommend best

approach(es) that

should be adopted to

improve the legal and

institutional

framework in the

PCs.

1.

4 Produced under the project.

Page 19: GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis … · 2009-08-14 · Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks 4

GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks

19

4.4. Identification

and

Assessment

Report Re

2. (a) Examine the

legislative and

administrative

provisions of the

selected civil and

common-law

countries to identify

procedures and other

administrative

arrangements for

state of emergency;

(b) Identify the

institutional

arrangements for

state of emergency

(where legislation

exists) or the

institutional protocol

that obtains for state

of emergency in PCs.

(c)Prepare report

identifying the

similarities and

differences

between the two

circumstances in

paragraph (a) and

(b) and

recommendations

as to their ability to

replicate in the PCs

Page 20: GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis … · 2009-08-14 · Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks 4

GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks

20

5.55. Draft Final

Reportt

3. 4. Prepare

(a) set of best

practices and

recommendations

for Caribbean and

legal and

institutional

frameworks in

developing state of

emergency

legislative

frameworks and

institutional

arrangements

(b) legislative

provisions that

could be

considered in

developing

effective laws,

institutional

arrangements,

procedures, budget

appropriation and

execution

pertaining to state

of emergency in

natural disaster

circumstances

Page 21: GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis … · 2009-08-14 · Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks 4

GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks

21

6. 6. Final Report &

Executive

Summary

5. 6. (a) revise the Draft

Final Report to

take account of any

comments or

revisions proposed

by the OAS/DSD;

(b) prepare and

finalise an

Executive

Summary for the

Draft Final Report.

The Executive

Summary will

contain, inter alia,

recommendations

at the national

level, identify

regional trends,

similarities and

differences

between the PCs;

regional

recommendations.

(c) submit Final

Draft Report to

OAS/DSD.

Page 22: GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis … · 2009-08-14 · Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks 4

GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks

22

Form 2: Financial Proposal

Task No Description Unit Unit Cost

2-6 Remuneration Consultant Fees

12,000.00

Communication Costs

1000.00

2,6 Drafting,

reproduction of Reports

500.00

1 Office rent, clerical assistance

500.00

Page 23: GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis … · 2009-08-14 · Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks 4

GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks

23

Annex

Curriculum Vitae of Staff

Team Leader - Dr. Jean Andre Victor

OCCUPATIONS ACTUELLES

Consultant

Professeur des Universités

ETUDES UNIVERSITAIRES

A. UNIVERSITE D’ETAT D’HAITI 1 Licencié en droit 1961 – 1964

Faculté de Droit et des Sciences Economiques

2 Ingénieur-Agronome 1963 – 1967

Faculté d’Agronomie et de Médecine Vétérinaire

B. UNIVERSITE DE COSTA-RICA

3 M. S. en Sciences Environnementales ( Option Cultures et Sols Tropicaux ) 1974 – 1976

C. UNIVERSITE DE LIMOGES ( France ) 4 Doctorat en Droit International de l’Environnement ( 2000-2002 )

Faculté de Droit et des Sciences Economiques

D. Principaux Programmes de Formation Courte ( de 3 jours jusqu’à 3 mois ) de 1971

à 2000

Page 24: GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis … · 2009-08-14 · Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks 4

GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks

24

Université de Costa Rica Physique des sols

France ( Canal de Provence ) Gestion de l irrigation

Taiwan Machinerie Agricole

Israël Cultures irriguées

MARNDR – HAITI

Budget de programme ( Coopération Canadienne )

Utilisation du Cadre Logique ( Coopération Canadienne )

Préparation et Evaluation de projets ( IICA )

Management moderne au service de l’agriculture haitienne ( USAID )

AUPELF _ UREF ( France ) Droit International de l’environnement

BID / MDE – HAITI

Etude D’Impact Environnemental

OCCUPATIONS PASSEES ET ACTUELLES

5 Au Ministère de l’Agriculture des Ressources Naturelles et du Développement Rural ( 1967 – 1991 ) Vulgarisateur/Chercheur – Coordonnateur de l ODPG – Directeur Général du DRIPP - Directeur Général de

l’ODVA – Directeur des Ressources Naturelles – Directeur Général du Ministère

Au Mimistère de la Planification Consultant en Aménagement du Territoire ( 1979 )

Ministre ( 1992 )

Page 25: GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis … · 2009-08-14 · Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks 4

GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks

25

6 A L’ UNIVERSITE Professeur à l’ Université d’ Etat ( 1987 – 2006 ) – Droit Rural – Environnement et Développement-

Professeur au Programme de Maitrise du Centre Technique d’ Economie et de Planification Appliquees (

2000 – 20064 ) – Utilisation du sol urbain

Chercheur inscrit au Réseau Francophone de Droit de l’Environnement

( 2000 – 2006 ) – Programme de recherche partagée avec les Universités Antilles – Guyane, Québec à Montréal et

Paris I.

Professeur de Droit de l Environnement ( 2006 ) au Programme de Maitrise en Etudes Judiciaires à la Faculté de

Droit et des Sciences Economiques ( UEH )

7 Au PNUD / HAITI Consultant / Expert National - Options : Environnement et Mobilisations de fonds internationaux ( 1995 – 2005 )

SERVICES A LA COMMUNAUTE

8 Président élu du Conseil d’Administration de la Fondation

Haïtienne de l’ Environnement ( 2002 – 2005 )

9 Directeur Technique élu de la Division Législation et Normes de l’Association Interaméricaine de Génie Sanitaire

et de l’Environnement ( 2001 – 2002 )

10 Membre élu du Conseil d’Administration du REDLAC 2003/2005 ( Réseau des Fonds Environnementaux de

l’Amérique Latine et des Caraübes )

11 Membre du Conseil d Administration de la Banque de l Union Haïtienne ( 2004 - 2006 )

PUBLICATIONS CHOISIES AU NIVEAU INTERNATIONAL

12 Tourisme et aires protégées en Haïti et à la Guadeloupe . In L’ écotourisme, un nouveau défi dans la Caraïbe.

Uuniversité Antilles-Guyane . 2001.

13 La mise en œuvre nationale du droit international de l’environnement. Ouvrage Collectif. Université de Yaoundé.

2000.

Page 26: GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis … · 2009-08-14 · Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks 4

GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks

26

14 La protection internationale de la biodiversité dans la mer des Caraïbes. Ouvrage Collectif. Université de

Limoges.2001

15 La problématique des cours d’eau internationaux de la République d’Haïti et de la République Dominicaine. Le

cas de la rivière Artibonite. Université d’Etat d’Haïti. 2002.

16 Tourisme et biodiversité marine dans la Caraïbe. Ouvrage Collectif. Université Antilles –Guyane. 2004

.

PUBLICATIONS CHOISIES AU NIVEAU NATIONAL

Code des lois haitiennes de l’ environnement. Annoté. PNUD / 1995

Guide pour la mise en œuvre des conventions internationales de l’environnement . PNUD

Système d’information pour l’aménagement des bassins versants. PNUD

L´enfant et l’ environnement Save the Children / 1999

Le cadre légal et institutionel des aires protégées Minnistère de l’ Environnement /

1995

PUBLICATIONS DE DIVERS LIVRES IMPRIMES 1 Les fables de l an 2000 ( 1972 )

2 Sur la piste de la réforme agraire ( 1989 )

3 Sur la piste des déchets toxiques ( 1989 )

4 Bouqui et Malice ( 1992 )

EXPERIENCES PROFESSIONNELLES

Page 27: GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis … · 2009-08-14 · Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks 4

GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks

27

Enseignement Sciences de l’Environnement

Droit de l’Environnement / Droit Rural / Droit Agraire

Sciences Agricoles

Ressources Phyto-génétiques

Planification du Développement

Consultations d’ Expert

Ecole Internationale de Bordeaux

Université Antilles/Guyane

Banque Interaméricaine de Développement

Food Agricultural Organization

Délégué du Gouvernement Haïtien pour la négociation de la Convention de Bâle sur les déchets dangereux Genève

Délégué du Gouvernement Haïtien pour la négociation de la convention sur la Biodiversité

Union Européenne

USAID

Consultations Récentes au Ministère de l’Environnement

Etat des lieux pour la gestion des polluants organiques persistants ( 2004 )

Projet de décret pour l’utilisation des substances qui appauvrissent la couche d’ozone

( 2005 )

Décret cadre sur l’environnement ( 2005 )

Décret d’application du décret-cadre sur l’environnement pour ce qui concerne la mise en œuvre du Conseil National de

l’Environnement ( CONATE )- 2006

Consultations récentes au PNUD Homologue d’expert international en Aménagement du Territoire ( 2005 )

Appui au renforcement des municipalités pour la gestion de l’environnement ( 2005 )

Page 28: GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis … · 2009-08-14 · Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks 4

GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks

28

Consultations récentes à l’USAID Aspects juridiques et institutionnels de l’environnement ( 2006 )

Organisation de Séminaires en Haiti Université Quisqueya ( Réforme Agraire )

Caritas Diocésaine de Jérémie ( Cultures Organiques )

Care International ( Planification Agricole )

Fonds d’ Equipement des Nations Unies ( Pouvoir Règlementaire des Collectivités

Territoriales )

Décentralisation ( CEFOPAFOP )

Renforcement institutionnel des municipalités ( FENU )

Pan American Development Foundation ( Protection du Morne du Haut du Cap )

Atouts Particuliers

Savoir-faire et longues expériences en élaboration, gestion et évaluation de projets

Expériences en définition de politiques publiques et analyse institutionnelle

Habiletés en élaboration d’ Etudes d’ Impact Environnemental

Grandes possibilités de rédaction sous pression

Aptitude à coordonner et à travailler en équipe

Bonne maitrise des principaux logiciels informatiques

Habiletés Linguistiques Créole – Français ( langues maternelles )

Espagnol ( langue seconde )

Anglais ( compréhension )

Portugais – Italien ( lecture )

Page 29: GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis … · 2009-08-14 · Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks 4

GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks

29

John Ricky Wilson

QUALIFICATIONS: 1994: Tufts University, Boston, USA:

• Post Graduate Certificate in Environmental Management

(Specialisation in Negotiation and Conflict Resolution)

1987: University College of North Wales, Bangor, UK

• Masters of Science Degree (M.Sc.) in Fisheries Biology

1986 UNIVERSITY OF WEST INDIES – BARBADOS:

• Bachelor of Science Degree (B.Sc.) Biology (2nd Class Hons)

CAREER SUMMARY:

Jan 2007 – Present Managing Director & CEO - eco- Natural Resources Management Consulting (Barbados)

Nov 2003 – Nov 2006 Development Program Specialist (Env) - Office of Caribbean Regional Programme/USAID

Sept 1996 - Nov 2003 Senior Environmental Officer - Ministry of Environment, Barbados

July 1994 – Aug 1996 Environmental Officer (Biodiversity)- Ministry of Environment, Barbados

Aug 1993 – Aug 1994 Environmental Education Officer - Ministry of Environment, Barbados

Nov 1990 - Aug 1993 Research Officer (Biodiversity) - Ministry of Environment, Barbados

Jan 1989 - Oct 1990 Assistant Town Planner - Town & Country Development Planning

July 1988 – Jan 1989 Sales Representative - T. Geddes Grant

Page 30: GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis … · 2009-08-14 · Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks 4

GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks

30

• Supervised and managed 8 technical staff and associated programmes (climate change, ozone, environmental education, biodiversity,

sustainable development, and chemicals management) for 7 years;

• Provided technical advice to all branches of the Government of Barbados;

• Coordinated national strategies and activities to comply with various multilateral environmental agreements

• Sat on various national developmental planning and policy coordination committees e.g. Tourism Advisory Council, Planning and

Priorities Committee of the Cabinet and Harrison’s Cave Expansion project;

• Coordinated Environmental Impact Assessment Reviews of major private and public sector projects

Including IADB projects for the Port Expansion and Integrated Coastal Zone Management;

• Technical Head of Delegation for Barbados at over 75 regional and international environmental/sustainable development meetings

including : CARICOM; Association of Caribbean States (ACS) ; Organisation of American States (OAS); Commission on Sustainable

Development (CSD) ; Global Environment Facility (GEF); United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) and United Nations. In

addition held negotiating briefs on behalf of CARICOM and Group of 77 and China (UN) at international meetings.

• Monitored housing and commercial applications in all developmental zones to ensure protection of specially protected areas and

general compliance with Town and Country Planning standards;

• Conducted research and prepared various policy papers on but not limited to beach access, disaster risk reduction, Environmental

Impact Assessment, introduction of unleaded gas, energy, and protected areas.

CONTINUING EDUCATION (selected)

Page 31: GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis … · 2009-08-14 · Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks 4

GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks

31

2005: USAID: Financial Management

2004: USAID: Assistance and Acquisition Management, Planning Achieving and Learning;

Development Credit Authority and Reg 216 (Environmental Compliance)

2000: National Productivity Council: Improved Management through Strategic Planning;

Motivating and Mobilising Teams;

Productivity Improvement at Work;

7 Habits of Highly Effective People;

1998: Dalhousie University : International Environmental Management Seminar (3 weeks)

CARICAD/Commonwealth Association for Public Administration : Senior Management Workshop

1994: Tufts University: Post graduate Course in Environmental Management (3 months)

1993: Caribbean Law Institute: Environmental Treaties Workshop

1992: Duke University: Intensive Course in Coastal Geology, Erosion & Coastal Management

AWARDS: USAID : Superior Group Award (Nov 2005); CTO Certification (August 2005)

Meritorious Honor Award (April 2004)

Commonwealth Secretariat: Environmental Management Fellowship (1998)

United Nations Environment Programme : UNEP/Tufts University International Fellowship for Environmental

Management (1994)

Page 32: GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis … · 2009-08-14 · Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks 4

GS/OAS – CARIBBEAN EMERGENCY LEGISLATION PROJECT/Activity: Comparative Analysis of international legal and institutional frameworks

32

OAS/ Duke University : Coastal Management Fellowship (July 1992)

PUBLICATIONS (selected) :

1999: The Impact of Land Degradation on the Fragile Eco-systems of Island States of the Latin America and Caribbean region and

Adopting Measures for its Protection. Paper presented to 5th Regional UNCCD Meeting, Lima, Peru.

1992: Biological Diversity: Working Towards an International Legal Instrument. Wilson J and Griffith M. Bulletin of Eastern Caribbean

Affairs. Vol 17 No2.Institute of Social and Economic Research, UWI, and Cave Hill Campus May

1992: Looking Towards the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development. . Wilson J and Griffith M.D. Bulletin of

Eastern Caribbean Affairs. Vol 17 No2.Institute of Social and Economic Research, UWI, and Cave Hill Campus May 1992

1991: National Report of Barbados for the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development

OTHER:

Director of National Petroleum Corporation (March 2008-Mrch 2011)

Member and Director of Barbados Institute of Environmental Professionals