groningen seismic dataset - sheer project seismic dataset elmer ruigrok, bernard dost, jesper...

45
June 8, 2016 Groningen seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler, Laslo Evers, Gert- Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta

Upload: buikiet

Post on 05-Jun-2019

216 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

June 8, 2016

Groningen seismic dataset

Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler, Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta

Page 2: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

Induced seismicity in the Netherlands

Bourne et al. (JGR, 2014)

Page 3: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

Groningen gas field

Page 4: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

Groningen pre-2015 geophone network

Page 5: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

Groningen event catalogue

Page 6: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

Groningen new geophone network

Page 7: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

Groningen new network status

Page 8: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

75 m

Borehole FSW

30 m

Borehole NIW,

SPY, SUH

50 m

Borehole ENM,

ENV, HWF, VLW,

WDB, ZLV, G*

Borehole variation

Page 9: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

Borehole EQ response

Page 10: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

• Data resources

• Developments

• Conclusions

Page 11: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

• Data resources

• Developments

• Conclusions

Page 12: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

Zuidbroek 1.8 event

http://www.knmi.nl/nederland-nu/seismologie/aardbevingen

Page 13: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

http://rdsa.knmi.nl/dataportal/

Page 14: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

Event catalogue

http://rdsa.knmi.nl/fdsnws/event/1/

KNMI data retrieval with FDSN webservices

Station info

http://rdsa.knmi.nl/fdsnws/station/1/

Continuous data (last year) & event data

http://rdsa.knmi.nl/fdsnws/dataselect/1/

Page 15: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

Depth of reservoir rock

Geologic model (DGM-

deep) made available

by TNO:

https://www.dinoloket.nl/

en/

Page 16: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

Fault network

Geologic model (DGM-

deep) made available

by TNO:

https://www.dinoloket.nl/

en/

Page 17: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

Faults & seismicity

Event catalogue with

induced events:

http://www.knmi.nl/kennis-

en-

datacentrum/dataset/aa

rdbevingscatalogus

Page 18: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

• Data

• Developments

• Conclusions

Page 19: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

1 = N

2 = EZ

Accelerometer

Orientation of horizontal components?

Geophones

N

φ

Page 20: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

Estimating P-wave profile

Page 21: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

Estimating S-wave profile

Page 22: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

FSW

Enhancing detection

Page 23: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

Enhancing detection; field data

FSW

Page 24: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

• Data resources

• Developments

• Conclusions

Page 25: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

Conclusions

Lots of data available

• > 300 3C geophones

• > 70 accelerometers

• Induced earthquake catalogue

• Event data

• Continuous data (1 year)

• Geologic model

Ungoing efforts to

• Facilitate data acces

• Improve network connection

• Publish near-surface model

• Publish sensor orientations

Page 26: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

?

Page 27: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity
Page 28: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

Phi estimation approach

Accelerometer Geophone

Page 29: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

Phi estimation results

Page 30: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

75 m

Section view at borehole FSWMap view, borehole locations

Borehole arrays

Page 31: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

Borehole noise recording

FSW

Page 32: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

Earthquake recording

FSW

Page 33: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

Near-surface filter

Page 34: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

.

.

.

Multi-depth-level solution

Page 35: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

Enhancing detection; synthetics

Page 36: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

Enhancing detection; synthetics

Page 37: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

Prior to orientation correction

Page 38: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

After orientation correction

Page 39: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

Backup material

Page 40: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

Borehole seismic interferometry

Page 41: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

Borehole seismic interferometry

Page 42: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

Estimate vp and vs of refracting layer

Supergather Z-comp Supergather N-comp

Vp=5.1 km/s

Vs=2.8 km/s

Page 43: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

Spetzler, 2015

Page 44: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

Spetzler, 2015

Page 45: Groningen seismic dataset - SHEER project seismic dataset Elmer Ruigrok, Bernard Dost, Jesper Spetzler,Laslo Evers, Gert-Jan van den Hazel, Jordi Domingo Ballesta. Induced seismicity

Spetzler, 2015