Republic of the Philippines )City of Manila ) S.S.

AFFIDAVIT I,Greta Cruz, Filipinocitizen, oflegal age, single to, and a resident of 522, 5th st. San Beda Subdivision, Mendiola, Manila, after having been duly sworn in accordance with law, hereby depose and say:1. That I am the sister of Melanie Batumbakal, the respondent in a custody case over Scarlett Batumbakal filed by Frank Batumbakal.

2. That according to her, she separated with her husband Frank Batumbakal sometime in 2004, and left their house to live with Joey Cedric Lee.

3. That according to her, in February 2005, Joey Cedric Lee broke up with her, so she went to my house and ask if she can live with me, which I permitted.

4. That during her stay at my house, I caught her several time using drugs.

5. That sometime in March 2005, I saw empty syringe and a rubber on her hamper while I was doing laundry. I had a feeling that she was doing something wrong but I did not have courage to confront her, at first.

6. That on April 16, 2005, a day after my 34th birthday, she came home late at about 2 am, and I noticed that her eyes were really red and she does not seem normal because when I asked her where she had been, she just laughed at me and uttered, Like I bought taho from heaven, OMG. I love you sissy!

7. That on April 30, 2005, when I came home from a company outing which unexpectedly ended early, I saw her at the living room injecting something by a syringe in her left upper arm She panicked when she saw me. Then and there, I confronted her about what she was doing. She promised not to do it again. And pleaded not to tell anyone about it, specially her husband and the police.

8. That on May 10, 2005, as I was about to ask her to get ready for Scarletts birthday party at Franks House, I was shocked to see her sniffing a white powder on her desk. She was so high and could hardly recognize me. She told me to get out of the room, shouted, I do not care about that damn birthday! Leave me alone!!! Then she threw a lamp shade at me when I tried to calm her down.

9. That afternoon she left the house and I never saw her again nor heard from her again.

10. That after the incident, I went to tell Frank about everything that happened.Further Affiant sayeth none. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto affixed mysignaturethis 27th day of September, 2006 in Manila, Philippines.

Greta CruzAffiant

SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO BEFORE ME this 27th day of September 2006, affiant exhibiting to me his Drivers License No. N-04-0020000 bearing his photograph and signature, issued on 18 March 2004 at the City of Manila and valid until 18 March 2007.

Notary Public for Manila

Doc. No. 33Page No. 2Series of 2006