getting the most from lube oil analysis

Upload: guru-raja-ragavendran-nagarajan

Post on 01-Mar-2018

225 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/26/2019 Getting the Most From Lube Oil Analysis

    1/16

    GETTING THE MOST

    OUT OF LUBE OILANALYSIS

    Common Oil Analysis Tests & Their Significance

  • 7/26/2019 Getting the Most From Lube Oil Analysis

    2/16

    InsightServices,Inc. | www.TESTOIL.com | @testoil1

    TTOverview

    Thepracticeofoilanalysishaschangeddrasticallyfromitsoriginal

    inceptionintherailroadindustry.Intodaysexplodingcomputerand

    informationage,oilanalysishasevolvedintoamandatorytoolinones

    predictivemaintenance(PdM)arsenal.

    AsaPdMtool,oilanalysisisusedtouncover,isolateandoffersolutions

    forabnormallubricantandmachineconditions.Theseabnormalitiescan

    resultinexpensive,sometimescatastrophicdamagecausinglost

    production,extensiverepaircosts,andevenoperatoraccidents.

    Thegoalofaneffectiveoilanalysisprogramistoincreasethereliability

    andavailabilityofmachinerywhileminimizingmaintenancecosts

    associatedwithoilchangeouts,labor,repairsanddowntime.

    Accomplishingthisgoaltakestime,trainingandpatience.However,the

    resultsaredramaticandthedocumentedsavingsandcostavoidance

    aresignificant.

  • 7/26/2019 Getting the Most From Lube Oil Analysis

    3/16

    3 InsightServices,Inc. | www.TESTOIL.com | @testoil1

    Contents

    0B0B0B

    LubricationProperties .................................................................................................................... 4

    1B1B1BTheRoleofOilAnalysis................................................................................................................... 6

    2B2B2BElementalSpectroscopy.................................................................................................................. 7

    3B3B3BViscosity .......................................................................................................................................... 9

    4B4B4BAcidNumber ......................................................................................................................... ........ 10

    5B5B5BBaseNumber................................................................................................................................. 11

    6B6B6BWaterContamination ................................................................................................................... 12

    7B7B7B

    ParticleCount................................................................................................................................ 13

    8B8B8BFerrousWearConcentration ........................................................................................................ 14

    9B9B9BAnalyticalFerrography.................................................................................................................. 15

    10B10B10BConclusion..................................................................................................................................... 16

  • 7/26/2019 Getting the Most From Lube Oil Analysis

    4/16

    4 InsightServices,Inc. | www.TESTOIL.com

    The primary functions of a lubricant are to

    lubricate, cool, clean, protect, seal andtransmit power.

    0B0B0BLubrication Properties

    Lubeoilanalysisisusedextensivelytohelpcompaniesmaintaintheir

    equipment.Inordertotakefullbenefitfromthetestdatafromoilsamples,itisimportanttounderstandthebasicpropertiesofa

    lubricant. Equallyimportantistheunderstandingofhowthese

    propertiesaffecttheabilityofthelubricantto function.Lastly,

    knowledgeofthecommontesttechniquesandinstrumentationusedto

    analyzeoilcanaidindatainterpretationandleadtomoreproductive

    correctiveaction.

    Toeffectivelymonitorhowwellalubricantisworking,thefunctionsof

    thelubricantmustbeunderstood.Theprimaryfunctionofalubricantis

    quiteobviouslytolubricate(thatis,toreducefriction).Byreducing

    friction,wearisreduced,asistheamountofenergyrequiredto

    performthework.

    In1699,aphysicistnamedGuillaumeAmontonsdeducedthatfrictionis

    theresultofsurfaceroughness.Sincenosolidsurfaceisperfectly

    smooth,opposingfrictionsurfaceshavepeakscalledasperitiesthat

    comeincontactwithoneanother.Ideally,alubricantwillphysically

    separatetheseasperitieswithanoilfilm.Thisiscalledfullfluidfilm

    lubrication.

    Whentheproperlubricantisused,andtheproperloadisapplied,the

    asperitiesarenotincontactandintheorynowearwilloccur.When

    inadequatelubricationispresent,ortheloadisincreased,theoilfilm

    willnotbethickenoughtofullyseparatetheasperities.Mixed

    lubrication,a cross between boundary and hydrodynamic

    lubrication,occurswhentheoilfilmthicknessisequaltotheaverage

    asperityheight.Thelargestasperitieswillcomeincontact,resultingin

    increasedwear.

    Manyoilsarefortifiedwithantiwearadditivestocombatwearunder

    thesecircumstances.Asloadcontinuestoincrease,orlubrication

    degrades,boundarylubricationoccursandtheoilfilmthicknesscannot

  • 7/26/2019 Getting the Most From Lube Oil Analysis

    5/16

    5 InsightServices,Inc. | www.TESTOIL.com

    separatethefrictionsurfaces.Thiscanresultinmetaltometalcontact.

    Atthispoint,asperitiesareadheringtooneanother,causingsevere

    machinewear.Thiscanalsomanifestitselfduringperiodsofshock

    loading,startuporshutdown.Extremepressureadditivesareusedin

    oilsthatfrequentlyencounterthesetypesofsituations.

    Lubricantsalsocontrolthetemperatureoftheequipment.Oilabsorbs

    heat generatedatthefrictionsurfaceandcarriesitawaytobe

    dispersed.Manysystemsincorporateheatexchangersorradiatorsto

    aidinremovingheatfromthesystem.Alongwithheat,lubricants

    transportdirtandotherdebrisawayfromthefrictionsurface.

    Particulatecontaminationleadstoincreasedwearthroughabrasionand

    reducedoilflow.Someoiladditivepackagescontainagentsthatbreak

    upcontaminantsandholdtheminsuspensiontobefilteredout.This

    preventsharmfuldepositsandvarnishfromformingwithinthe

    equipment.Alkalineadditivesalsoprotectthecomponentsbyneutralizingacidandpreventingcorrosion.

    Hydraulicoilshavetheaddedfunctionoftransmittingpower.To

    functionproperly,hydraulicoilmustbecleanandfreeofcontaminants.

    Manycontaminantswillcauseoiltofoamandentrainairorwater.

    Entrainedaircausestheoiltocompressunderpressure,resultingina

    lossofpower.Particulatecontaminantscancausethecontrolvalvesto

    malfunctionandrestricttheoilflow.

  • 7/26/2019 Getting the Most From Lube Oil Analysis

    6/16

    6 InsightServices,Inc. | www.TESTOIL.com

    1B1B1BThe Role of Oil Analysis

    Selectingtheproperlubricant,alongwithcarefulmaintenanceofthat

    lubricant,isessentialtoensureadequateprotectiontoanymachine.Properlubricationisdefinedasacorrectamountofthecorrect

    lubricantatthecorrecttime.

    Maintainingalubricantmeansensuringthatithasthecorrectviscosity

    andthenecessaryadditivesfortheapplication.Stepsmustbetakento

    keepthelubricantcleanandserviceable.Oilanalysisisthemost

    effectivewaytoprolongtheusefullifeoflubricants,whilemaintaining

    maximumprotectionofequipment.

    Oilanalysistestsrevealinformationthatcanbebrokendownintothree

    categories:

    Lubricantcondition:theassessmentofthelubricantcondition

    revealswhetherthesystemfluidishealthyandfitforfurther

    service,orisreadyforachange.

    Contaminants:increasedcontaminantsfromthesurrounding

    environmentintheformofdirt,waterandprocess

    contaminationaretheleadingcauseofmachinedegradation

    andfailure.Increasedcontaminationindicatesthatitistimeto

    takeactioninordertosavetheoilandavoidunnecessary

    machinewear.

    Machinewear:anunhealthymachinegenerateswearparticles

    atanexponentialrate.Thedetectionandanalysisofthese

    particlesassistinmakingcriticalmaintenancedecisions.

    Machinefailureduetowornoutcomponentscanbeavoided.It

    isimportanttorememberthathealthyandcleanoilleadstothe

    minimizationofmachinewear.

    Lubricantconditionismonitoredwithteststhatquantifythephysical

    propertiesoftheoiltoensurethatitisserviceable.Metalsanddebris

    associatedwithmachineweararemeasuredtomonitorequipment

    health.Someteststargetspecificcontaminantsthatarecommonly

    foundinoils. Itisimperativetoselecttheproperblendofteststo

    monitorthemachineslubricantcondition,weardebrisand

    contaminantsinordertomeetthegoalsofsuccessfuloilanalysis.

  • 7/26/2019 Getting the Most From Lube Oil Analysis

    7/16

    7 InsightServices,Inc. | www.TESTOIL.com

    Elemental Spectroscopy is generally used to

    provide qualitative and quantitative

    information about metals in oil samples.

    2B2B2BElemental Spectroscopy

    Elementalspectroscopyisatestthatmonitorsallthreecategories

    (lubricantcondition,weardebrisandcontaminants).Aspectrometerisusedtomeasurethelevelsofspecificchemicalelementspresentinanoil.

    Twotypesofspectrometersarecommonlyused.Arcemission

    spectrometersapplyenergyintheformofanelectricarctothesample.

    Thisexcitestheatomsintovaporform,creatingaspectrumwherelight

    isgenerated.Individuallightfrequenciesinthespectrumaremeasured

    andquantifiedtodeterminethepresenceandquantitiesofspecific

    elementspresent.Theothercommontypeofspectrometeristhe ICP

    (inductivelycoupledplasma)spectrometer.Thisoperatesonasimilar

    principle,exceptthattheenergyisappliedtothesamplebyaplasma

    flameratherthananelectricarc.

    Therearetypically20elementsmeasuredbyspectroscopyandreported

    inpartspermillion(ppm).Thesemeasurementsrepresentelementsin

    solution.Spectroscopyisnotabletomeasuresolidparticleslargerthen

    roughly7m,whichleavesthistestblindtolargersolidparticles.

    Typicallevelsofwearcanvarygreatlydependingonthetypeof

    equipmentbeingsampled.Forexample,agearboxwillnormallyhave

    muchhigherlevelsofironthanahydraulicsystem.Levelsofwearcan

    varyacrossdifferentunitsofthesametypedependingonoilhours,

    operatingconditions,loadinglevelsorotherconditions.Forthisreason,

    itisimpossibletoestablishfirmlimitsforanypieceofequipmentbased

    solelyontheequipmenttype.Totakefulladvantageofmonitoring

    wear;atrendshouldbeestablishedtoprovideanoperationalbaseline

    ofdata.Thiswillensuredetectionofabnormalwearratesasthey

    developandallowsforthefactthatsimilarequipmentmaynotwearat

    thesamerate.

    Monitoringtheadditivelevelsprovidesinformationtoensurethatthe

    properlubricantisbeingusedfortheapplicationandfortoppingoff.

    Fourtypesoflubricantsaregenerallyusedinmostindustrial

    applications,andeachhasdifferentadditivelevels.Itisimportantto

  • 7/26/2019 Getting the Most From Lube Oil Analysis

    8/16

    8 InsightServices,Inc. | www.TESTOIL.com

    Many oils are formulated for specificapplications and alternative additives must

    be used.

    notethatanoilslevelofadditivesmeasuredbyspectroscopyisnot

    necessarilyanindicationoftheoilsquality.

    Engineoilswilltypicallycontainantiwearadditivescomposed

    ofzincandphosphorus.Oneshouldexpecttoseethese

    elementspresentinapproximately1000ppm(200ppm).Adetergentpackageshouldalsobepresent,composedofsome

    configurationofbarium,magnesiumandcalcium.Theselevels

    willvarydependingontheoil.

    Extremepressureoilsaretypicallyforgearapplications.Itis

    commontoseesignificantamountsofphosphorus.

    Antiwearoilsincludemanybearingoils,somegearoilsand

    hydraulicfluids.Theseoilscontainbothzincandphosphorus

    from200to600ppm.Theremaybeverylowlevelsof

    detergent(magnesiumorcalcium)presentalso.

    Rustandoxidationinhibitingoilsaretheeasiesttoidentify.

    Theyincludeturbineoils,compressoroil,andsomebearingand

    hydraulicoils.Theseoilshavenometallicadditivesthatcanbe

    measuredbyspectroscopy,sothereshouldbeextremelylow

    numbersforalladditivemetals.

    Itisnotuncommontoseelowlevels(20ppm)ofsomeadditivemetals

    wheretheyarenotexpected.Thisisusuallytheresultofresidual

    contaminationintheequipmentorstoragetanks.

    Thereareoilsthatdonotfitintothesedescriptions. Manyoilsare

    formulatedforspecificapplicationsandalternativeadditivesmustbe

    used.Anexamplewouldbeoilsformulatedforsomestationaryand

    electromotivedieselengines.Inmanycases,operatingconditionsor

    emissionconcernscallforalesstraditionaladditivepackage.

    Aswithanytypeoftesting,spectroscopyissubjecttoinherentvariance.

    Highwaterlevelscancauseinterferenceinthespectrum,ascanthe

    matrixofsomesyntheticbasestocks.Inshort,alwaysdoublecheckwith

    anothersamplebeforetakinganyinvasivemaintenanceaction.Never

    relyonjustonepieceofdatawhenmakingamaintenancedecision.

  • 7/26/2019 Getting the Most From Lube Oil Analysis

    9/16

    9 InsightServices,Inc. | www.TESTOIL.com

    A lubricant with the improper viscosity will

    lead to overheating, accelerated wear. This

    will result in the failure of the machine.

    3B3B3BViscosity

    Anoilsviscosityisconsidereditsmostimportantproperty.Themost

    commontechniqueformeasuringanoilsviscosityisfollowingASTMD445usingaviscometer(ASTM,2011).Asmallsampleoftheoilis

    drawnintoacalibratedcapillarytubeinaconstanttemperaturebath.

    Oncethesamplecomestotemperature,itisallowedtoflowdownthe

    tubeapredetermineddistance.Theviscosityistheproductoftheflow

    timeandtubecalibrationfactor.Theresultsarereportedastheoils

    kinematicviscosityincentistokes(cSt).

    IndustrialoilsareidentifiedbytheirInternationalStandardfor

    Organizationviscositygrade(ISOVG).TheISOVGreferstotheoils

    kinematicviscosityat40C(104F). Anoilsweightcommonlyrefersto

    itskinematicviscosityat100C(212F).Theweightofmultigradeoils

    isrepresentedbythesecondnumberintherating.A10W30wouldbe

    30weightoil.The10aftertheW,whichstandsforwinter,refersto

    howtheoilperformsincoldweatherconditions.

    Whenanoilsviscosityincreases,itisusuallyduetooxidation,

    degradationorcontamination.Thisistheresultofextendedoildrain

    intervals,highoperatingtemperatures,orthepresenceofwateror

    anotheroxidationcatalyst.Increasedviscositycanalsobetheresultof

    excessivecontaminationwithsolidssuchassootordirt,aswellas

    toppingoffwithahighergradelube.Watercontaminationcanalso

    causehighviscosity.

    Adecreaseintheoilsviscosityismostcommonlyduetocontamination

    withfuelorasolvent.Anoilsviscosityalsocanbeaffectedifthewrong

    oilisusedfortopofforreplenishment.

    Ifalubricantdoesnothavetheproperviscosity,itcannotproperly

    performitsfunctions.Iftheviscosityisnotcorrectfortheload,theoil

    filmcannotbeestablishedatthefrictionpoint.Heatandcontamination

    arenotcarriedawayattheproperrates,andtheoilcannotadequately

    protectthemachine.

  • 7/26/2019 Getting the Most From Lube Oil Analysis

    10/16

    10 InsightServices,Inc. | www.TESTOIL.com

    4B4B4BAcid Number

    Acidnumberisanindicatorofoilhealth.Itisusefulinmonitoringacid

    buildupinoilsduetodepletionofantioxidants.Oiloxidationcausesacidicbyproductstoform.Highacidlevelscanindicateexcessiveoil

    oxidationordepletionoftheoiladditivesandcanleadtocorrosionof

    theinternalcomponents.Bymonitoringtheacidlevel,theoilcanbe

    changedbeforeanydamageoccurs.

    Anoilanalystislookingforasuddenincrease.Whenyouroilisflagged

    forhighacidlevels,itindicatesacceleratedoiloxidation,andyoushould

    changetheoilassoonaspossible.Ifanyoftheremaininghighlyacidic

    oilisleft,itwillquicklydepletetheantioxidantsinthenewoil.

    AcidnumberismeasuredbytitrationusingASTMD664orD974.Both

    methodsinvolvedilutingtheoilsampleandaddingincremental

    amountsofanalkalinesolutionuntilaneutralendpointisachieved.

    TheAcidnumberofanewoilwillvarydependentuponthebaseoil

    additivepackage.AnR&OoilwillusuallyhaveaverylowAN,around

    0.03.AnAWorEPoilwillhaveaslightlyhighervalue,typicallyaround

    0.5.EngineoilscommonlyhaveahigherAN,intheneighborhoodof1.5.

    Acidnumberismeasuredbytitration

    usingASTMD664orASTMD974

    (ASTM,2011;ASTM,2008). Bothtest

    techniquesinvolvedilutingtheoil

    sampleandaddingincremental

    amountsofanalkalinesolutionuntila

    neutralendpointisachieved.

  • 7/26/2019 Getting the Most From Lube Oil Analysis

    11/16

    11 InsightServices,Inc. | www.TESTOIL.com

    5B5B5BBase Number

    Basenumbertestingisverysimilartoacidnumbertestingexceptthat

    thepropertiesarereversed.Thesampleistitratedwithanacidicsolutiontomeasuretheoilsalkalinereserve. ASTMD2896andASTM

    D4739arethemostcommonlyusedmethodstomeasurethebase

    number(ASTM,2007;ASTM,2008).

    Manyoils(especiallymotoroils)arefortifiedwithalkalineadditivesto

    neutralizeacidsthatareformedasaresultofcombustion.Indiesel

    engineapplications,acidisformedinthecombustionchamberwhen

    moisturecombineswithsulfurunderpressure.Measuringthebase

    numberwillhelpensurethatasufficientamountof additiveshave

    beenaddedtotheoiltohelpresistoxidationduetoacid.

    Thebasenumberofoilishighestwhentheoilisnewanddecreases

    withuse.Onceagain,condemninglimitsarebasedontheapplication.

    Asarule,thebasenumbershouldnotdropbelowhalfofitsoriginal

    value.Basenumbervaluesfornewengineoilsverygreatlydepending

    ontheapplication.

    Basenumbertestingmeasuresthe

    reservealkalinityinalubricant.The

    amountofreservealkalinityina

    lubricantiscriticalforcertainoils.

    Oftenanoilisfortifiedwithalkaline

    additivestocombatacidformation.

    Thebasenumberisatitshighestasa

    newoilanddecreaseswithservice.

  • 7/26/2019 Getting the Most From Lube Oil Analysis

    12/16

    12 InsightServices,Inc. | www.TESTOIL.com

    6B6B6BWater Contamination

    Watercontaminationisdetrimentaltoanylubricant.Asimplecrackle

    testisusedtodetermineifwaterispresentinoil.Asmallvolumeofthelubricantisdroppedontoahotplateand,ifbubblesorcracklesoccur,

    waterispresent.

    Ifacrackletestispositive,furthertestingisneededtoquantifythe

    amountofwaterbyusingKarlFischertitrationbyASTMD6304(ASTM,

    2007).Ameasuredamountofoilisintroducedintoatitrationchamber.

    ThissolutionistitratedwithKarlFischerreagenttoaspecificendpoint.

    Theamountofreagentusedandthesamplevolumearecalculatedand

    convertedtoppmorpercentbymass.

    Lowlevelsofwater(0.5%)aretypicallytheresultofcondensation.Higherlevelscanindicateasourceofwateringress.Watercanentera

    systemthroughseals,breathers,hatchesandfillcaps.Internalleaks

    fromheatexchangersandwaterjacketsareotherpotentialsources.

    Whenfreewater(nonemulsified)ispresentinoil,itposesaserious

    threattotheequipment.Waterisaverypoorlubricantandpromotes

    rustandcorrosiontothecomponents.Dissolvedwaterinoil

    (emulsified)willpromoteoil

    oxidationandreducetheloadhandlingabilityoftheoil.Waterinany

    formwillcauseacceleratedwear,increasedfriction,andhighoperating

    temperatures.Ifleftunchecked,waterwillleadtoprematuremachinefailure.Inmostsystems,watershouldnotexceed500ppm.

    UsingtheKarlFischertitration

    method,areagentistitrated

    intoameasuredamountof

    sampleandreactswiththe

    hydroxidemoleculespresent

    inthemoisture.This

    depolarizesanelectrodeand

    determinesthetitration

    endpoint.Resultsarereported

    aseitherpercentwateror

    ppm(1%=10,000ppm).

  • 7/26/2019 Getting the Most From Lube Oil Analysis

    13/16

    13 InsightServices,Inc. | www.TESTOIL.com

    High particle counts indicate dirty oil.

    7B7B7BParticle Count

    Particulatecontaminationhasnegativeeffectsonalltypesofequipment.Particlecounttestingisawaytomonitorthelevelofsolid

    contaminationintheoil.Twotypesofautomaticparticlecountersare

    usedtotestoilcleanliness:lightblockageandporeblockage.

    Lightblockage:Thelightblockagetechniqueinvolvespassinga

    samplethroughasmallorificethathasalaserlightsourceonone

    sideandanopticalsensorontheotherside.Particlesinterrupting

    thelightbeamarecounted,andsizeisdeterminedbythedegreeof

    lightblockage.Lightblockageparticlecountingisnoteffectivewhen

    oiliscontaminatedwithwaterorwhenairisentrainedintheoil.In

    thesecircumstances,waterorairbubbleswillbecountedas

    particlescausingerroneousresults.

    Poreblockage:Theporeblockageorflowdecaytechniquepasses

    thesamplethroughameshfilter.Asafilterclogs,theflowofthe

    sampleisslowed.Theamountofflowdecayiscalculated,andthe

    particlecountcanthenbeextrapolated.Becausewaterdroplets

    andentrainedairwillnotrestrictthefluidflow,thereisno

    interferencefromthesecontaminants.

    Resultsarereportedasparticlespermilliliterinsixsizeranges:4,6,

    14,25,50and100. ISOCleanlinessCodesarethenassignedfor

    particlesin4,6and14mranges(ISO4406:1999).Theresultis

    reportedbythreenumberswithaslashbetweenthem;thefirstnumber

    referstoparticlesinthe4mrange,thesecondtoparticlesinthe6

    mrangeandthethirdinthe14mrange.Thelowerthenumbersin

    theISOCleanlinessCode,ISO4406,thecleanerthefluid.

    Particulatecontaminationisameasurementoftheeffectivenessof

    filtrationandcanindicatewhenexcessiveexternalcontaminationis

    occurring.Advancedmachinewearwillalsocauseincreasedparticle

    counts.Generally,thelowersizerangesareconsideredindicativeof

    contaminationandsilt,whilethelargersizerangespointtowear

    problems.

  • 7/26/2019 Getting the Most From Lube Oil Analysis

    14/16

    14 InsightServices,Inc. | www.TESTOIL.com

    8B8B8BFerrous Wear Concentration

    Insomecases,aparticlecountisnotaneffectivetestbecausethe

    sampleisinherentlydirtyandfilteringtheoilmaynotbeplausible.Aparticlecountindicatesthatthesampleisextremelydirty,butitdoes

    notgiveanyindicationofferrouswear.Ingearboxes,ferrouswearmay

    bemoreimportantthanoverallparticlecount.Insuchanapplication,

    ferrouswearconcentrationisagoodsubstitutionforaparticlecount

    test.

    Awearparticleanalyzerquantifiestheamountofferrousmaterial

    presentinasampleoffluid. Ameasuredamountofsampleisinserted

    intotheanalyzerandamountofferrousmaterialisdeterminedbya

    changeinmagneticflux. Thischangeisthenconvertedintoferrous

    concentrationinpartspermillion.Usingthismethod,thereareno

    interferenceswithnonferrousparticles.

    Oneadvantageofaferrousdebrismonitoristhatitwillmeasureferrous

    weardebrisinalltypesofoil,fromgearboxlubricantsthrough

    hydraulics.Oneoftheotherkeybenefitsisthatitwillalsomeasure

    ferrousweardebrisfoundingrease.

    AsimilartesttotheferrousdebrismonitorisDR(directread)

    ferrography. DRferrographycollectspositivelychargedparticlesontwo

    lightsourcesandmeasurestheamountofblockedlighttodetermine

    thelevelofferrouscontaminantspresentinanoil. Althoughthesetwo

    testsprovidethesameinformation,theyarenotinterchangeable.

    Theferrouswear

    concentrationgivesa

    directmeasureofthe

    amountofferrouswear

    metalspresentina

    sample.

  • 7/26/2019 Getting the Most From Lube Oil Analysis

    15/16

    15 InsightServices,Inc. | www.TESTOIL.com

    Analytical Ferrography is the best method for

    determining severity and type of wear present

    with no particle size or metallurgy

    limitations.

    9B9B9BAnalytical Ferrography

    Analyticalferrographyisusedtoseparatesolidcontaminationandwear

    debrisfromalubricantformicroscopicevaluation.Asstatedearlier,spectroscopyisnotabletomeasurewearparticleslargerthan7min

    size.Whileparticlecounting,ferrouswearconcentrationandDR

    ferrographyareabletodetectthepresenceoflargerparticles,they

    cannotqualifytheircompositionororigin.Analytical ferrographyisable

    toidentifywearparticles,theircompositionandtheiroriginbyvisually

    analyzingthemmicroscopically.

    Adilutedoilsampleisallowedtoflowoveraspeciallytreatedslide

    whichispositionedatanangleoverastrongmagnet.Theferrous(iron)

    particlesareattractedtothemagnetanddepositedontotheslidein

    decreasingsizeastheoilflowsdownthesubstrate.Nonferrousparticles

    aredepositedrandomlywhileferrousparticleslineupinchainsasa

    resultofthemagneticflux.Theresultisamicroscopicslidewiththe

    particlesseparatedbysizeandcomposition.

    Microscopicexaminationofthedebrisrevealsinformationaboutthe

    conditionoftheequipment.Observingtheconcentration,size,shape,

    compositionandconditionoftheparticlesindicateswhereand

    howtheyweregenerated.Particlesarecategorizedbasedonthese

    characteristics,andconclusionscanbedrawnregardingthewearrate

    andhealthofthemachine.

    Thecompositionoftheparticlescanbeidentifiedbycolor.Heat

    treatingtheslidecausesspecificcolorchangestooccurinvarioustypes

    ofmetalsandalloys. Theparticlescompositionindicatesitssource.

    Theparticlesshaperevealshowitwasgenerated.Abrasion,adhesion,

    fatigue,slidingandrollingcontactwearmodeseachgeneratea

    characteristicparticletypeintermsofitsshapeandsurfacecondition.

    Solidcontaminantscanalsobevisuallyidentifiedprovidedtheyareofa

    commonlyfoundorigin.Sandanddirt,fibers,oxidationproducts,rust

    andmetaloxidesareexamplesofcontaminationdebristhatcan

    beidentified.

  • 7/26/2019 Getting the Most From Lube Oil Analysis

    16/16

    16 InsightServices,Inc. | www.TESTOIL.com

    10B10B10BConclusion

    While the results of these tests are a powerful maintenance tool, they are useless

    if not monitored and acted upon. A successful oil analysis program will be one

    where the test data and analysis are coupled with the maintenance departments

    knowledge and expertise to provide the most effective maintenance practices.

    TTAboutTESTOIL

    TTTESTOIL is a full service oil testing laboratory owned by Insight Services. Since

    1988 the laboratory has been providing fast and reliable oil analysis results

    across all industries throughout the Americas.

    TTThe firms comprehensive range of oil analysis services assists reliability

    engineers with condition monitoring and identification of machine wear.

    TTTESTOIL employs a sophisticated diagnostic technology that assists their

    Machine Condition Analysts in making equipment and HHHlubricationHHHcondition

    assessments.

    References

    ASTMD445,StandardTestMethodforKinematicViscosityofTransparentandOpaque

    Liquids(andCalculationofDynamicViscosity),ASTMInternational,WestConshohocken,

    Pennsylvania,2011.

    ASTMD664,StandardTestMethodforAcidNumberofPetroleumProductsby

    PotentiometricTitration,ASTMInternational,WestConshohocken,Pennsylvania,2011.

    ASTMD974,StandardTestMethodforAcidandBaseNumberbyColorIndicator

    Titration,ASTMInternational,WestConshohocken,Pennsylvania,2008.

    ASTMD2896,StandardTestMethodforBaseNumberofPetroleumProductsby

    PotentiometricPerchloricAcidTitration,ASTMInternational,WestConshohocken,

    Pennsylvania,2007.

    ASTMD4739,StandardTestMethodforBaseNumberDeterminationbyPotentiometric

    HydrochloricAcid

    Titration,ASTMInternational,WestConshohocken,Pennsylvania,

    2008.

    ASTM

    D6304,StandardTestMethodforDeterminationofWaterinLiquidPetroleum

    Products,LubricatingOilsandAdditivesbyCoulometricKarlFischerTitration,ASTM

    International,WestConshohocken,Pennsylvania,2007.

    ISO4406:1999,HydraulicFluidPowerFluidsMethodforCodingtheLevelof

    ContaminationbySolidParticles,InternationalOrganizationforStandardization,

    Geneva,Switzerland,1999.

    ContactUs

    TTCall:TT2162512510

    TTEmail:[email protected]

    TTWebsite:www.testoil.com