from the jerry springer smackdown to the oprah winfrey sitdown

8/12/2019 From the Jerry Springer Smackdown to the Oprah Winfrey Sitdown

1/22

"

"#$% &'( )*(##+ ,-#./0(# ,%1234$5/6 &$ &'( )7-#1' 8./9#(+ ,.&4$5/6:;1#14.0%1&.2 ,'.9&< ./ =#1/. -$D 3-H> 75'C&-$> C&'5O4-7 -$D 6*-$'35$D5* &$D&8&D4-7'

(5*5 A*5@45$67H B)*6*-H5D -' B)65$6&-7 ;6%*5-6'? 6) 6%5 A)4$D-6&)$ )A 6%&' &$'6&646&)$E M' 6%5

"00:' B*)3*5''5D> %)(585*> 3-H -$D 75'C&-$ 345'6' (5*5 &$9*5-'&$37H D5B&965D &$ A-.&7H

9)$65O6' )$ 6%5'5 '%)('> H56 6*-$'35$D5* 345'6' (5*5 )A65$ -66-9+5D -' ;6)) '57A&'% -$D

.)$'6*)4' A)* 6%5 A-.&7H? /,-.')$> N::"> BE P"2E Q)(585*> '&$95 ,-.')$L' -$-7H'&' 6%5

*5B*5'5$6-6&)$ )A '5O4-7 -$D 35$D5*5D D&AA5*5$95 %-' -765*5D -$D C59).5 &$9*5-'&$37H

9).B7&9-65D> -$D # -*345 6%-6 6%5*5 %-' C55$ - '4C675 '%&A6 &$ 6)$5 -$D -BB*)-9%E

G%5 5OB7)&6-6&85 6*5$D )A D5B&96&$3 6*-$'35$D5* &$D&8&D4-7' -' A*5-+' )$ 6-7+ '%)('

B5*'&'6'> C46 *-6%5* 6%-$ C5&$3 D5B&965D -' D&'*4B6&)$' 6) B4C7&9 'B-95> 6*-$'35$D5* 345'6'

-*5 &$653*-65D &$6) &6> *595&8&$3 &$8&6-6&)$' 6) '&6 D)($ -$D 5$3-35 &$ ').5(%-6 9&8&7

D&'94''&)$ (&6% 6-7+ '%)(' %)'6'E #$ )6%5* ()*D'> D-H6&.5 6-7+ '%)(' -*5 &$9*5-'&$37H C5&$3

9)$'6*4965D -' - K6-7+&$3 (&6%>L -7C5&6 '6&77 .-*+5D CH )6%5*&$3> *-6%5* 6%-$ - 9).C-6&85

K6-7+&$3 C-9+EL G)(-*D' 6%5 5$D )A %&' C))+> ,-.')$ /"0012 6)49%5' )$ 6%&' 6*5$D )A

.5D&-65D $)*.-7&R-6&)$ -$D -''&.&7-6&)$> - ;6&3%6 *)B5 )A 8&'&C&7&6H? 6%-6 %-' .&O5D


2/22

N

9)$'5@45$95' /BE N:12E S%&75 C5&$3 -''&.&7-65D &$6) .-&$'6*5-. 94764*5 %-' &6' -D8-$6-35'

&$ 65*.' )A ')9&-7 -995B6-$95> C5&$3 9)$'6*4965D -' T6%5* -$D 75A6 -7)$5 3&85' 'B-95 -$D

-46)$).H 6) B)7&6&9-77H )*3-$&R5E UH -$-7H'&' B&9+' 4B (%5*5 ,-.')$ 75-85' )AA -$D

D57&$5-65' - $5( *5B*5'5$6-6&)$-7 B-*-D&3. (&6% *5'B596 6) 6*-$'35$D5* 345'6' 5.5*3&$3

)$ 65758&'&)$ 6-7+ '%)(' &$ 6%5 C53&$$&$3 )A N"'695$64*HV - ;A*5-+' 6-7+ (&6%? .)D57E

G5758&'&)$ 6-7+ '%)(' -*5 '&3$&A&9-$6 .5D&- 65O6' '&$95 6%5&* -5'6%56&9' -$D 7)3&9 &$A)*. 6%5

9*5-6&)$ )A 9)$65.B)*-*H B)B47-* 94764*5> &$A745$9&$3 6%5 A)*. -$D 9)$65$6 )A 8-*&)4'

A-964-7 .5D&- /W)85H> N:::2E S%&75 # C57&585 6%&' '%&A6 6)(-*D' - ;A*5-+' 6-7+ (&6%? .)D57 &'

58&D5$6 .)*5 C*)-D7H -9*)'' 8-*&)4' A)*.' )A A-964-7 .5D&- 7&+5 *5-7&6H GX> 6%5 $5('>

6575D)94.5$6-*&5'> 7&A5'6H75 B*)3*-..&$3> 569E> 6%&' B-B5* (&77 A)94' 5O974'&857H )$ 6%5 6-7+

'%)( 35$*5E

# 5O-.&$5 6%*55 *595$6 6-7+ '%)( 5B&')D5' 6%-6 A5-64*5D 6*-$'35$D5* 345'6'V

;G%5 Q&3% Y9%))7 Z4-*65* J-9+ S%) J59-.5 - I5'C&-$? )$ 91"$-/N[""[N:":2>

;S5L*5 P -$D 1 \5-*' T7D -$D ]$)( (5 -*5 G*-$'35$D5*? )$ (-# (/"$ *$3%& 0-78

/"[NP[ N:":2> -$D ;G*-$'35$D5* ]&D'V G)) \)4$3 6) W59&D5^? )$ 6%5 :"; 9< 0-78

/_5CE "1> N:":2E G%5'5 '%)(' &$ B-*6&947-* -*5 (%-6 Q--*.-$ /N::"2 &D5$6&A&5' -'

;&''45 )*&5$65D '%)('? /BE N=`a2> B*)3*-.' 6%-6 B*5'5$6 (&D5* ')9&-7 -$D B)7&6&9-7

&''45' &$ - B5*')$-7 9)$65O6E S&6% 6%5&* A)94' )$ 7-*357H S%&65> .&DD75 97-''> -$D

B)7&6&9-77H .)D5*-65 8-745' -$D 9)$95*$'> 6%5'5 '%)(' %-85 -77)(5D 6*-$'35$D5*

&$D&8&D4-7' 6) 5$65* 6%5 -*5$- )A .-&$'6*5-. K*5'B596-C&7&6HL (&6% 8-*H&$3

9)$'5@45$95'E #$ B-*6&947-*> 6%5'5 5B&')D5' %)7D &$ 65$'&)$ K6-7+&$3 C-9+L -$D

K6-7+&$3 (&6%L B-*-D&3.' -$D %&3%7&3%6 6%5 94764*-7 97-'% -$D $53)6&-6&)$ C56(55$

6%5 94764*-77H )*D&$-*H -$D 6%5 5O6*-)*D&$-*HE # -*345 6%-6 (%&75 6-7+ '%)('


3/22

a

B*&.-*&7H &$8&65 6*-$'35$D5* 345'6' )$ -' 94*&)'&6&5'> -' 5O-.B75' )A 5O6*-)*D&$-*H

5.C)D&.5$6> '4Cb596&8&6H -$D 7&A5'6H75> 6%5 '%&A6 &$ 6%5'5 '%)('L )*3-$&R&$3 7)3&9

6)(-*D' - K6-7+&$3 (&6%L -AA)*D' 6%5 B)65$6&-7 6)> -$D )A65$ D)5'> *5$D5* 8&'&C75 6%5

)*D&$-*H '&D5 )A @455* 7&A5> )AA5*&$3 '.-77 37&.B'5' &$6) 6%5 585*HD-H$5'' )A C5&$3

6*-$'35$D5*E

='( )"#(13< =1@3 A1236 ;1#14.0%

#$ 9)$'&D5*&$3 6%5 9)$65$6 )A KA-964-7 B*)3*-..&$3L '49% -' 6-7+ '%)('>

6575D)94.5$6-*&5'> *5-7&6H B*)3*-..&$3 -$D 94**5$6 585$6' '%)(' )A 6%5 "00:'> W)85H

/N:::2 )C'5*85' ;- '%&A6 A*). c5&6%L' K5D49-65> &$A)*. -$D 5$65*6-&$L 6) K&$A)*.> 6&6&77-65>

3*)'' )46 -$D A-'9&$-65? /BE "P2E ,*)'' /N::"2 $)65' 6%-6 D4*&$3 6%5 "00:'> 6%5 9).B56&6&)$

C56(55$ -7.)'6 a: 'H$D&9-65D 6-7+ '%)(' -$D 6%5 &$65*5'6 &$ H)4$35* -4D&5$95

D5.)3*-B%&9' -99)4$65D A)* 6%5 3*)(6% )A *)(DH -$D -$6-3)$&'6&9 '%)( 97&.-65'E ,-H>

75'C&-$> C&'5O4-7 -$D 6*-$'35$D5* 345'6' (5*5 A*5@45$67H &$8&65D )$ -' 345'6' &$ )*D5* 6)

'5*85 -' 9-6-7H'6' A)* D&'64*C-$95> -' ;.&O64*5' )A D&'*4B6&)$> 9)$A4'&)$> -$D *5-''5*6&)$ )A

6%5 (-H 6%&$3'> 5'B59&-77H 35$D5* 6%&$3'> ()*+? /,-.')$> "001> BE "F:2E M99)*D&$3 6) W)85H

/N:::2> 6%5'5 '%)(' 6HB&9-77H 5O%&C&6 -$ ;&$%5*5$6 9)$'5*8-6&'.? /BE ""12> %-*C)*&$3 'B59&A&9

9)$95B6&)$' )A 56%&9-7 *&3%65)4'$5'' -$D .)*-7 B*)B*&56HE #$ 65*.' )A '5O4-7 -$D 35$D5*5D

&D5)7)3&5'> '9%)7-*'%&B )$ 6-7+ '%)(' /dB'65&$ e Y65&$C5*3> "001f ,-.')$> "001f ,-.')$>

N::"f g7-*+5 e ]&6R&$35*> N::F2 -*345 6%5'5 .5D&- A)*.' -*5 '&65' )A *5'6*&965D $)*.-6&85

D&'9)4*'5 6%-6 -D8-$95 %565*)'5O4-7 %535.)$H -$D '4B5*&)*&6HE

Y&$95 6%5 "01:'> 6*-$'35$D5* &$D&8&D4-7' &$ B-*6&947-* %-85 C55$ .-&$'6-H' )$ 6%5

65758&'&)$ 6-7+ '%)( 9&*94&6> B-*-D5D )$ '6-35 -' '%)9+&$3 D&'B7-H' )A 6%5 )46*-35)4'E


4/22

F

dB&')D5 6&675' 7&+5 0$))/ .#& 5$1-$#)L' ;Q)6 W*-3 W&8-'?> ;,45'' M. # - U-$ )* - S).-$^?

-$D ;Y-77HL' _-$6-'H _5.-75 h-35-$6>? )* 6%5.#""/ 01"234#" 0-78L' ;#L. h*53$-$6 CH - ,&-$6

G*-$''5O4-7? -$D ;G*-$''5O4-7' M66-9+? A*-.5 35$D5* 8-*&-$95 -' 7-43%-C75> &.B*)C-C75

-$D B4*5 'B596-975E Q)(585*> ,-.')$ /"0012 '4335'6' 6%-6 6%5'5 'B-95' -*5 4$&@45 &$

)AA5*&$3 @455* B5)B75 - B7-6A)*. A*). (%&9% 6) 'B5-+V;6%5H 6%*)( )B5$ 7&6675 94764*-7

)B5$&$3' 6%-6> 9).B-*5D (&6% 6%5 *5'6 )A 9)..5*9&-7 .-''=.5D&-65D B)B47-* 94764*5> 7))+

%435? /BE "F"2E G%5'5 )B5$&$3' -*5 )A65$ '7-..5D '%46 CH 8-*&)4' )*3-$&R-6&)$-7 B*-96&95'

)A 6%5 '%)(V B*).)6&)$-7 'B)6' -$D 9)..5*9&-7' 6%-6 B*).&'5 6%5 C&R-**5> -$ -4D&5$95 6%-6

&' 5$9)4*-35D 6) 9*&6&9&R5 345'6'> -$D - %)'6 6%-6 -96' -' .)*-7 -$D 94764*-7 .5D&-6)*>

5OB*5''&$3 D&'C57&5A -$D -'6)$&'%.5$6 -6 A)*.' )A ')9&-7 D&AA5*5$95E ,5$5*-77H> 6%5

B*)D496&)$ *)46&$5' )A 6%5'5 '%)(' -7&3$ 6%5 %)'6 -$D -4D&5$95 (&6% .-&$'6*5-.> .&DD75

97-'' .-&$7H %565*)'5O4-7 8-745' -$D &D5)7)3&5'> '594*&$3 - '5$'5 )A $)*.-7&6H A)* 6%5 '64D&)

-$D -6 %).5 -4D&5$95E M' - *5'476> 6%5 6*-$'35$D5* 345'6 &' B)'5D -' - .)*-7 -$D 56%&9-7

B*)C75.> - 6*)4C7&$3 $4&'-$95 6) B4C7&9 'B-95 -$D 9)..)$ 94764*5E

i-.&')$ ,*55$ /N::F2> A5.-75=6)=.-75 6*-$''5O4-7 (*&65*> -96&8&'6 -$D B-'6 B*5'&D5$6

)A _GU #$65*$-6&)$-7> *5.5.C5*' -C)46 %&' -BB5-*-$95 )$ - 6-7+ '%)(V

;# *595&85D A*5@45$6 *5@45'6' A*). 6-7+ '%)( B*)D495*' 6) -BB5-*j# 64*$5D 6%5. -77 D)($> B-*67H C59-4'5 # 9)47D$L6 '6-$D 6%5 A)*.-6

6%5H 4'5Dj # A&$-77H D&D -BB5-* )$ 6%5 =-$")#& >#"#< '%)( &$ 5-*7H

"00`> -$D (-' D55B7H D&'-BB)&$65D (&6% 6%5 5OB5*&5$95j G%5B*)D495* .&'75D .5 -C)46 6%5 '%)(L' 6)B&9 -$D -C)46 6%5 A)*.-6>

-$D # (-' -$3*H (%5$ # 75A6 6%5 '64D&)? /BE "P`2E

M76%)43% %5 (-' 6)7D CH 6%5 '%)(L' B*)D495* 6%5 6)B&9 (-' ;G%5 6*46% -C)46 '4*3&9-7 '5O

*5-''&3$.5$6>? &6 (-' &$ A-96 ;G*-$''5O4-7' (&6% *53*56'>? - A-96 %5 A)4$D )46 -' 6%5 5B&')D5

(-' C5&$3 6-B5DE ,*55$ *59-77' 6%5 '%)( -' - ;D58&)4'? D&'-'65*V ').5 345'6' 6*-&B'&$3


5/22

`

-*)4$D 6) ;'6*&BB5* .4'&9>? )6%5*' *-49)4'7H A&3%6&$3 )$ '6-35> -$D '6-35 9*5( 5$9)4*-3&$3

345'6' 6) '9*5-. -6 5-9% )6%5* /&$ ,-.')$> "001> BE 1`2E

S*&6&$3 &$ 6%5 5-*7H "00:'> J)*$'65&$ /"00F2 - 6*-$'35$D5* -96&8&'6> (*&65*>

B5*A)*.-$95 -*6&'6> -$D A*5@45$6 6-7+ '%)( 345'6 -*345' 6%-6 6-7+ '%)(' ;B-*-D5 6%5 A*5-+'

)46 &$ A*)$6 )A 6%5 -4D&5$95>? 5OB7-&$&$3 -C)46 %5* )($ 6-7+' '%)( 5OB5*&5$95'V ;S%5$ #

-BB5-* )$ - 6-7+ '%)(> #L. 9-775D '57A=95$65*5D> '57A='5*8&$3> -$D - A*5-+? /BE "N1f "a:2E

J59-4'5 )A 6%5 -$6-3)$&'6&9 $-64*5 )A 6%5'5 '%)('> J)*$'65&$ -D.&6'> ;# +$)( # %-85 6)

B*5B-*5 -%5-D )A 6&.5 6%5 B)&$6 # (-$6 6) 356 -9*)''> ') # D)$L6 %-85 6) 6%&$+ )$ .H A556?

/J)*$'65&$> "00F> BE "N02E Q)(585*> J)*$'65&$ -7') 6%)*)43%7H 5$b)H' C5&$3 - 345'6 -$D '%5

5.C*-95' 6%5 9%-775$35 6) D5A5$D -$D D5A&$5 %5*'57A &$ A*)$6 )A - 9-B6&85 -4D&5$95E

J)*$'65&$L' -*6&947-6&)$ )A 6%5 6-7+ '%)( 5OB5*&5$95 59%)5' _)49-476L' $)6&)$ )A ;'B&*-7' )A

B)(5* -$D B75-'4*5>? 6%5 9).B7&9-65D (-H' &$ (%&9% B)(5* &' C)6% *5B*5''&85 -$D

5$b)H-C75 /BE F`2E M' W)85H -7') '4335'6' /N:::2> (%&75 6-7+ '%)(' *5B*)D495 - 'B-95 )A

94764*-7 '4*85&77-$95 (%5*5 B)(5* ;@45'6&)$'? -$D ;.)$&6)*'>? 6%5H '&.476-$5)4'7H -AA)*D

-$ )BB)*64$&6H 6) 5$3-35 &$ 6%5 B75-'4*5 )A 6*&9+&$3 -$D 5'9-B&$3 B)(5* /_)49-476> "00:> BE

F`2E

"#$% )"#(13< =1@3 A1236 &$ )"#(13< =1@3 8.&'6

S%&75 6%5 ;A*5-+' 6-7+ C-9+? B-*-D&3. &' '6&77 - D).&$-$6 *5B*5'5$6-6&)$-7 .)D5>

6%5*5 %-' C55$ 58&D5$95 )A '4C675 '%&A6' &$ 6%5 D5B&96&)$ )A 6*-$'35$D5* B5)B75 &$ A-964-7

65758&'&)$ -$D &$ %)( 6%5 &$D4'6*H 4$D5*'6-$D' -$D B4C7&97H 6-7+' -C)46 I,JG &$D&8&D4-7'

-$D &''45'E _)* 5O-.B75> *595$67H J-*C-*- S-765*' -B)7)3&R5D A)* 6%5 (-H '%5 -BB*)-9%5D

%5* (&D57H 6-7+5D -C)46 &$65*8&5( (&6% c&9+H U-*6&$ &$ N::: (%5*5 '%5 C))*&'%7H B*)C5D

%&. -C)46 %&' '5O4-7 &D5$6&6HE MD.&66&$3 6%-6 %5* @45'6&)$&$3 (-' 5OB7)&6-6&85> S-765*'


6/22

k

5OB7-&$'> ;&$ N:::> # B4'%5D c&9+H U-*6&$ 85*H %-*D 6) -D.&6 &A %5 (-' 3-H )* $)6> -$D 6%5

(-H %5 *5A4'5D 6) D) &6 .-D5 585*H)$5 D59&D5 6%-6 %5 (-'E M 7)6 )A B5)B75 '-H 6%-6

D5'6*)H5D %&' 9-*55*> -$D (%5$ # 6%&$+ C-9+ )$ &6 $)( # A557 &6 (-' -$ &$-BB*)B*&-65

@45'6&)$? /T4R)4$&-$> N:":2E Y%&A6&$3 6) 6*-$'35$D5* *5B*5'5$6-6&)$> g)4*6 GXL' /$)(

6*4GX2 N::N 9)85*-35 )A - 9-'5 9)$95*$&$3 U&9%-57 ]-$6-*-'> - 6*-$'35$D5* .-$ A*).

_7)*&D-> )AA5*5D - C-7-$95D -$D &$'&3%6A47 B)*6*-H-7E ]-$6-*-' (-' A&3%6&$3 A)* 94'6)DH )85*

%&' 9%&7D*5$ -A65* %&' (&A5 97-&.5D %5 (-' $)6 .-75 -$D *5@45'65D .-**&-35 -$$47.5$6 )85*

6%5 753-7&6H )A %5* K'-.5 '5OL .-**&-35E g)..5$D5D CH ,IMMW -$D 6%5 l-6&)$-7 g5$65* A)*

I5'C&-$ c&3%6' A)* )AA5*&$3 - 'H.B-6%56&9> &$=D5B6% -$D 9).B75O B)*6*-H-7> g)4*6 GXL'

9)85*-35 -77)9-65D 9)$'&D5*-C75 6&.5 %&3%7&3%6&$3 6%5 B5*'B596&85' )A ]-$6-*-' -$D

6*-$'35$D5* -96&8&'6' &$ )*D5* 6) 9)4$65*C-7-$95 6%5 (&A5L' -994'-6&)$'E G%5 9)85*-35 (-' -

(579).5D '%&A6 -(-H A*). A-964-7 D5B&96&)$' )A 6*-$'35$D5* A)7+' 6%-6 6HB&9-77H *5B*5'5$6

6%5. -' ;D595&85*'? )* ;.)$'65*'? /cH-$> N::02E g)4*6 GXL' '5$&)* 8&95 B*5'&D5$6 A)*

D-H6&.5 B*)3*-..&$3> U-*75$5 W-$$> 5OB7-&$5D 6%5 &.B)*6-$95 )A 6-+&$3 6%5 9-'5 '5*&)4'7H>

;G%5 9)$6*)85*'H &' $)6 6%-6 (5L*5 -&*&$3 &6E G%5H -*5 -*34&$3 6%5 &''45'j 6%5 &''45 (-' 85*H

&.B)*6-$6? /_*5&C5*3> N::N> BE aN2E

G%&' $5( *5B*5'5$6-6&)$-7 -BB*)-9% 6)(-*D' 6*-$'35$D5* &$D&8&D4-7'> (%-6 # &D5$6&AH

-' - ;A*5-+' 6-7+ (&6%? B-*-D&3.> &' B5*9)7-6&$3 .)'6 58&D5$67H )$ 6%5 D-H6&.5 6-7+ '%)(

9&*94&6E G*-$'35$D5* &$D&8&D4-7' -*5 &$9*5-'&$37H C5&$3 &$8&65D 6) B-*6&9&B-65 &$ -$ KTB*-%

'&6=D)($L *-6%5* 6%-$ - Ki5**H YB*&$35* '.-9+=D)($EL S%&75 - ;A*5-+' 6-7+ C-9+?

9)..4$&9-6&85 5$8&*)$.5$6 &' D5A&$5D CH ')4$D C&65' -$D )$5=7&$5*'> - ;6-7+&$3 (&6%?

5$9)4*-35' 5O65$D5D D&-7)345E G%5 B-*-D&3. -$&.-65' (%-6 _)49-476 /"00:2 &D5$6&A&5' -'

-$ ;&$9&65.5$6 6) D&'9)4*'5>? - (&77 6) 'B5-+ -6 75$36% -C)46 6*-$'35$D5*> 6) C*&$3 &6 &$6) 6%5


7/22

P

D&'94*'&85 *5-7. &$ )*D5* 6) 4$D5*'6-$D> /*52D5A&$5> 9)$6*)7 -$D $)*.-7&R5 &6 /BE aFf 102E

J*&$3&$3 6*-$'35$D5* &$6) B)B47-* D&'9)4*'5 *5B*)D495' - 8-*&56H )A B)''&C75 B)7&6&9-7> ')9&-7

-$D 94764*-7 9)$'5@45$95'> -' _)49-476 /"00:2 D57&$5-65'> ;D&'9)4*'5 6*-$'.&6' -$D

B*)D495' B)(5*j C46 -7') 4$D5*.&$5' -$D 5OB)'5' &6> *5$D5*' &6 A*-3&75 -$D .-+5' &6

B)''&C75 6) 6%(-*6 &6? /BE ":"2E

G%&' .)85 6)(-*D' - K6-7+&$3 (&6%L &' &$ B-*6 6%5 *5'476 )A C*)-D5* '%&A6'

(&6%&$ 6%5 65758&'&)$ &$D4'6*H -$D &$ 6%5 (-H' 6-7+ '%)(' -*5 9)$95B64-7&R5D -$D

'6-35DE M' 6%5 "00:' 9-.5 6) - 97)'5> 6*-'% 6-7+ %-D *5-9%5D &6' B5-+ -$D '6-*65D 6)

D597&$5 &$ B)B47-*&6HE g4764*-7 -$D 9)$'5*8-6&85 9*&6&9' 7&+5 A)*.5* Y59*56-*H )A

dD49-6&)$ S&77&-. J5$$566 -$D B)7&6&9&-$' 7&+5 Y5$-6)* i)'5B% I&5C5*.-$ B4C7&97H

6-*3565D 6%5 35$*5 -' - *5B)'&6)*H A)* .)*-7 D59-HE U-b)* 9)$6*)85*'&5' -$D

6*-35D&5' '4**)4$D&$3 6%5 35$*5 -7') 9)$6*&C465D 6) 6%5 3*)(&$3 -$O&56H -$D

9)$95*$ -C)46 6%5 $-64*5 )A 6-7+ '%)( 9)$65$6E _)* 5O-.B75> &$ - "00` 5B&')D5 )A

i5$$H i)$5' &$8)78&$3 *).-$6&9 9)$A5''&)$'> Y9)66 M.5D4*5 -D.&665D 6) C5&$3 &$

7)85 (&6% %&' C5'6 A*&5$D> i)$-6%-$ Y9%.&6RE Y%)*67H -A65* 5B&')D5 (-' 6-B5D>

Y9%.&6R .4*D5*5D M.5D4*5> - 6*-35DH 6%-6 C59-.5 - .-b)* $5(' '6)*HE S&6%&$ 6%&'

-6.)'B%5*5> -D85*6&'5*' &$9*5-'&$37H 3*5( 4$9).A)*6-C75 -$D 4$95*6-&$ -C)46 6%5

'9*55$&$3 )A ')9&-7 KD58&-$95L -$D 6%5 (-H' &$ (%&9% 6%5 35$*5 5$9)4*-35D *&'+H -$D

C*-R5$ 3-.5' 6) C5 B7-H5D (&6% *5-7 B5)B75E #$ *5-96&)$ 6) .)4$6&$3 9*&6&9&'.

-3-&$'6 6%5 35$*5 A*). B)7&6&9&-$'> 94764*-7 9*&6&9' -$D -9-D5.&9' -7&+5 &$ 6%5 .&D

$&$56&5'> TB*-% *59-7&C*-65D 6%5 9)*5 -$D 9)$95*$ )A %5* '%)( &$ "00`> - +5H

D59&'&)$ 6%-6 5O-95*C-65D 6%5 35$5*-7 '%&A6 -(-H A*). K6-7+&$3 C-9+L A)*.-6' /MC6

-$D U4'6-RR-> "00P2E G-7+ '%)(' (5*5 $)( 5$D5-8)*&$3 6) C5 B5*95&85D -' (%-6


8/22

1

U-$3- /N::a2 9-77' ;753&6&.-65 D&'9)4*'5? /BE 0P2> .5D&- 6%-6 &774'6*-65 -46%5$6&9&6H>

K-BB*)B*&-65L 7-$34-35 -$D C5%-8&)*> 585*HD-H *5758-$95 -$D - D5'&*5 6) 35$5*-65

').5 B)'&6&85 ')9&-7 C5$5A&6E G-7+ '%)(' D5857)B5D A)* "00k '5-')$ (5*5 6-.5D

D)($ -$D B*).)65D -' -D85*6&'5* A*&5$D7H> -$D 6%5 c)'&5 TmW)$$577 '%)( (&6% &6'

5AA)*6' 6) C5 B)'&6&85> 4BC5-6> -$D D58)&D )A ;6*-'%? 5.5*35D -' - .-b)* %&6 &$ 6%5

"00k '5-')$ /U-$3-> N::a> BE Fk2E G%&' 5.5*3&$3 C*55D )A '%)(' D5857)B5D &$6) -

'B-95 )A .&DD75 97-'' -AA&*.-6&)$ (&6% - 6%5*-B546&9> '57A=%57B 56%)'> - B4C7&9

;57596*)$&9 ;9)$A5''&)$-7?? /MC6 -$D U4'6-RR-> "00P> BE a2 6%-6 nB*&8&7535' A557&$3>

6%5 B5*')$-7> -$D 6%5 B-*6&947-*&'6&9n /U-$3-> N::a> BE"`:2E M' 6*-$'35$D5* 345'6'

-*5 &$8&65D &$6) 6%&' $5( *5B*5'5$6-6&)$-7 -*5$-> 6%5*5 -*5 D&*596 &.B7&9-6&)$' A)*

%)( 35$D5* 8-*&-$95 &' B)B47-*7H 4$D5*'6))DE

M' 6%5 94764*-7 6)49%'6)$5 -$D &$D4'6*H *)75 .)D57 A)* 6%5 6-7+ '%)( 35$*5> 6%5

91"$-'%)( D5.-$D' 9*&6&9-7 &$85'6&3-6&)$E Y&$95 N::P> &6 %-' D58)65D 6%*55 5B&')D5' 6)

9)85*&$3 6*-$'35$D5* &''45'E ;J)*$ &$ 6%5 S*)$3 J)DH? /0[N1[N::P2 A5-64*5D 6()

6*-$'35$D5* H)46% (%) $-**-65D 6%5&* B5*')$-7 '6)*&5' -$D W*E U-*9& J)(5*'> - '4*35)$ -$D

%-BB&7H .-**&5D 6*-$''5O4-7 ().-$> (%) D&'94''5D 6%5 9).B75O&6&5' )A '5O4-7 *5-''&3$.5$6

'4*35*HE M A5( (55+' 7-65* ;G*-$'35$D5* _-.&7&5'? /":["N[N::P2 D)94.5$65D 6%5 '6)*&5'

)A 6() %4'C-$D' (%) 6*-$'&6&)$5D 6) A5.-75 -$D 6%5 9)$A7&96' -$D DH$-.&9' 6%5 D59&'&)$

35$5*-65D A)* 6%5&* (&85' -$D 9%&7D*5$E J)6% 5B&')D5' B*)AA5*5D 6%5 6HB&9-7 ;C)*$ &$ 6%5

(*)$3 C)DH? $-**-6&85' -$D K6*-$'35$D5* -' C&)7)3&9-7 &$%5*&6-$95L &D5)7)3&5'E G%5 5B&')D5'

(5*5 -7') *5A7596&85 )A 6%5 ;-46)C&)3*-B%&9-7 &.B5*-6&85? /l-.-'65> N::`> BE Fk2> 6%5

.-$D-65 A)* 6*-$'35$D5* A)7+' 6) C5 '+&775D '6)*H65775*'> 6) C5 5AA596&85 &$ '57A=$-**-6&$3 -

7&$5-*> 7)3&9-7 -46)C&)3*-B%H &$6577&3&C75 6) $)$=6*-$'35$D5* -4D&5$95'E


9/22

0

G%5 6%&*D 6*-$'35$D5* 6%5.5D 5B&')D5> ;G%5 Q&3% Y9%))7 Z4-*65* J-9+ S%)

J59-.5 - I5'C&-$? /N[""[N:":2> B*5'5$65D 6%5 '6)*H )A ]&.C5*7H c55D> -

6*-$'35$D5* ().-$ -$D A&7..-+5*E S%&75 6%5 5B&')D5 .-*+' 6%5 6*-$'&6&)$ 6) -

;6-7+&$3 (&6%? -BB*)-9%> '&3$&A&9-$6 '596&)$' )A 6%5 5B&')D5 (5*5 &$A)*.5D CH 6%5

;A*5-+' 6-7+ C-9+? B-*-D&3.E #$ A)77)(&$3 6%5 A*-.5()*+ )A 6%5 -46)C&)3*-B%&9-7

&.B5*-6&85> 6%5 5B&')D5 D56-&7' c55DL' 9*)''=35$D5*5D A557&$3' -' - 9%&7D> %5* 9-*55*

-' - %&3% '9%))7 @4-*65*C-9+ -$D 8-75D&96)*&-$> 6%5 '6-*6 )A %5* 9*)''=D*5''&$3 &$

9)77535> -$D %5* *595$6 C-6675' A)* '57A=-995B6-$95E TB*-%L' 9)$'6-$6 *5&65*-6&)$ )A

c55DL' B*58&)4' &D5$6&6H -' '4995''A47 .-75 -6%7565> -' ;6%5 3)7D5$ C)H? -$D ;b4'6 )$5

)A 6%5 34H'? ()*+5D 6) 9%-*-965*&R5 c55DL' 35$D5* 6*-$'A)*.-6&)$ -' - B5947&-*

-$).-7H -$D 5$6&95D 6%)'5 4$A-.&7&-* 6) 9)$6&$45 (-69%&$3 &$ )*D5* 6) A&$D )46

;(%HE? G) A4*6%5* %&3%7&3%6 c55DL' 6*-$'&6&)$ -' '%)9+&$3 -$D 4$C57&58-C75> TB*-%

&$65*8&5(5D -$ )7D %&3% '9%))7 A*&5$D )A c55DL' 6) ')7&9&6 %&' *5-96&)$ 6) %5*

6*-$'A)*.-6&)$E G%5 5B&')D5 (-' -7') -D85*6&'5D &$ '5$'-6&)$-7 65*.'E (-# 91"$-

?23@"#/ 0-78L' B*).)6&)$-7 65-. 9%)'5 6) -46%)*&R5 6%5 K%&3% '9%))7 @4-*65*C-9+

C59).5' 75'C&-$ ().-$L 9)$95B64-7 A*-.5 )85* )6%5*'E G%5 '%)(L' ;9).&$3 4B?

65-'5* &$974D5D>;Y55 (%-6 %-BB5$' (%5$ 6%5 '6-* @4-*65*C-9+ *564*$' %).5 6) -

%&3% '9%))7 *54$&)$ -' - ().-$^? Q)(585*> D*-.-6&R&$3 c55DL' *)75 -' A&7..-+5*>

'&'65*> -$D[)* D-43%65* (5*5 5@4-77H '4&6-C75 A*-.5' A)* 9-B64*&$3 6%5 5''5$95 )A

6%5 5B&')D5E

G%5 5B&')D5 *585-7' - 'B7&6 C56(55$ %)( .5D&- 65O6' -*5 B*).)65D -$D 6%5&*

-964-7 9)$65$6E h*).)6&)$ 5$35$D5*' 6%5 '5$'-6&)$-7 -$D 6%5 6&6&77-6&$3> H56 6%5


10/22

":

-964-7 5B&')D5 (-' *-6%5* - 6-.5 ;6-7+&$3 (&6%? 6%-6 *585-75D &.B)*6-$6 37&.B'5'

&$6) )*D&$-*H 7&A5E #$ &$6*)D49&$3 6%5 B*)3*-.> TB*-% 4$&85*'-7&R5' c55DL' '6)*HV

;c&3%6 )AA 6%5 C-6 # +$)( ') .-$H )A H)4 -*5 6%&$+&$3 H)4

9-$L6 *57-65 6) ]&.C5*7HL' '6)*H C46 6%&$+ )A &6 6%&' (-H>6%5*5L' -$)6%5* (-H )A 7))+&$3 -6 6%&$3'E U)'6 )A 4' 9-$

-D.&6 6%5*5L' ').56%&$3 B5*%-B' %)7D&$3 H)4 C-9+ A*).C5&$3 -77 6%-6 H)4 9-$ C5j -' H)4 %5-* .)*5 -C)46

]&.C5*7HL' '6)*H 6%&$+ -C)46 %)( 3*5-6 H)4* 7&A5 9)47D C5 &A

H)4 9)47D b4'6 A&$D 6%5 9)4*-35 6) 7&85 H)4* )($ 6*46%EJ59-4'5 6%-6L' 5O-967H (%-6 ]&.C5*7H D&D -$D '%5L' %5*5 6)D-HE

S%&75 TB*-%L' -''4.B6&)$ 6%-6 %5* -4D&5$95 (&77 -46).-6&9-77H D&'.&'' c55DL' '6)*H

CH 8&*645 )A %5* 6*-$'35$D5* &D5$6&6H &' B*)C75.-6&9> '%5 -665.B6' 6) 97)'5 6%5

D&'6-$95 C56(55$ c55D -$D %5* -4D&5$95> '&64-6&$3 c55DL' '6)*H (&6%&$ - %4.-$

@45'6 A)* K6*46%L -$D '57A=-964-7&R-6&)$E Y&.&7-* 7-$34-35 &' *5B5-65D 6)(-*D' 6%5

5$D )A 6%5 5B&')D5 -' TB*-% )AA5*' %5* A&$-7 6%)43%6' -$D 3)-7' A)* %5* 8&5(5*'V ;D&3

&$ -$D A&$D )46 (%-6L' +55B&$3 H)4 A*). C5&$3 6%5 C5'6 6%-6 H)4 9-$ C5 C59-4'5

6%-6L' *5-77H (%-6 (5 -*5 -77 %5*5 6) D) &' 6) C59).5 .)*5 )A )4*'5785'E? S%-6

D&'6&$34&'%5' TB*-%L' D57&$5-6&)$ )A 6*-$'35$D5* &D5$6&6H 6%*)43% 6%5'5 *5.-*+'

A*). 6%)'5 6HB&9-7 )$ 6-7+ '%)(' &' 6%5 -665$6&)$ 3&85$ 6) c55DL' &$$5* @4-7&6&5' '49%

-' 9)4*-35> '6*5$36%> B5*'585*-$95 -$D C5$58)75$95E S%&75 .49% )A 6%5 5B&')D5 &'

D58)65D 6) D56-&7&$3 c55DL' B%H'&9-7> 8&'&C75 6*-$'A)*.-6&)$> 6%5 ;6-7+ (&6%?

B-*-D&3. -77)(' A)* -$ 5OB7)*-6&)$ )A 6%5 &$8&'&C75> )A 6%-6 (%&9% 9)$'6&6465' )$5L'

9%-*-965* -$D &$D&8&D4-7&6HE

G%5 '%)( A)94'5D )$ c55D $)6 )$7H -' - 6*-$'35$D5* ().-$> C46 -7') -' -

B*)A5''&)$-7 A&7..-+5*E G%5 D&-7)345 (&6% TB*-% )AA5*5D c55D -$ )BB)*64$&6H 6)

B*).)65 %5* D)94.5$6-*H >"7A24$) 073& /N::12E g7&B' )A 6%5 D)94.5$6-*H (5*5


11/22

""

&$65*'B5*'5D 6%*)43%)46 6%5 &$65*8&5(> -77)(&$3 c55D 6) '%&$5 -' - D)94.5$6-*&'6E

MDD&6&)$-77H> -76%)43% 6%5 5B&')D5 D5-76 (&6% c55DL' A-.&7HL' '6*43375 &$ 5.C*-9&$3

%5* -' 6*-$'35$D5*> - '&3$&A&9-$6 -.)4$6 )A 6&.5 (-' D58)65D 6) -$ 5OB7)*-6&)$ )A -

A-.&7H '6*4337&$3 (&6% )6%5* &''45' '49% -' '&C7&$3 *&8-7*H -$D 5.)6&)$-7 D&')*D5*'E

TB*-% 6-7+5D (&6% c55D -C)46 %5* 9)$A7&965D *57-6&)$'%&B (&6% %5* C*)6%5*> (%)

'4AA5*5D A*). - '5*&)4' C*-&$ &$b4*H> -$D 9)$A*)$65D c55DL' .)6%5* -C)46

$53)6&-6&$3 6%5 9%-775$35' B)'5D CH %5* 9%&7D*5$E g*49&-77H> 4$7&+5 .-$H )6%5* 6-7+

'%)(' 6%-6 A5-64*5 6*-$'35$D5* 345'6'> TB*-% *5'&'65D &$8&6&$3 )$ - B'H9%)7)3&'6 6)

5OB7-&$ c55DL' ;9)$D&6&)$? -$D '5*85 -' 5OB5*6 )$ %5* 7&A5 -$D '4Cb596&8&6HE

S%5$ 9).B-*5D 6) 6%5 91"$-5B&')D5> 6%5 (/"$ *$3%& 0-78L' ;S5L*5 P -$D 1

\5-*' T7D -$D ]$)( (5 -*5 G*-$'35$D5*? /"[NP[N:":2 &' .)*5 %5-8&7H &$A)*.5D CH

6%5 ;A*5-+' 6-7+ C-9+? B-*-D&3.E #$ 6%5 5B&')D5> GH*- &$65*8&5(' 6() 575.5$6-*H

'9%))7 -35D 9%&7D*5$> i)'&5 -$D ]5$$5DH> -$D 6%*55 655$-35*'> cH-$> g%*&' -$D d75$->

(%) &D5$6&AH -' 6*-$'35$D5*E G%5 .&$&=D)94.5$6-*&5' '%)($ -6 6%5 C53&$$&$3 )A

5-9% '53.5$6 6%-6 &$6*)D495D 6%5 345'6' A)94'5D )$ 8&'4-7 -BB5-*-$95' -$D

)46(-*D 6*-$'A)*.-6&)$'> '%)(5D 345'6' B5*A)*.&$3 85*H '65*5)6HB&9-77H .-75 )*

A5.-75 -96&8&6&5' -$D C5%-8&)*'> -$D )A65$ D5B&965D 6%5 345'6'L D-&7H 7&85' &$ 65*.' )A

6%5 '5$'-6&)$-7E #$ ]5$$5DHL' .&$& D)94.5$6-*H> - B&964*5 )A %&. D5B&965D -' - 85*H

H)4$3 3&*7 '7)(7H .)*B%' &$6) -$ &.-35 )A ]5$$5DH -' - C)HE ]5$$5DH 5O97-&.'> ;#

(-$6 6) D) C)H '64AAE? Q5 &' '55$ B7-HA477H B4$9%&$3 %&' D-D> -**-$3&$3 6)H 6*49+'>

-$D B7-H&$3 8&D5) 3-.5'E Y&.&7-*7H> i)'&5L' .&$& D)94.5$6-*H )B5$' CH D5B&96&$3

%5* 9%))'&$3 $-&7 B)7&'%5'> 6*H&$3 )$ D*5''5'> -$D B7-H&$3 (&6% D)77' -$D - C*-E M'

6%5 A5-64*5 9)$6&$45'> 6%5 $-**-6&)$ %&3%7&3%6' i)'&5L' -$-6).HE S5 %5-* i)'&5


12/22

"N

5OB*5'' &$ - 8)&95)85*> ;#L85 -7(-H' C55$ - 3&*7>? 6) (%&9% %5* .)6%5* *5B7&5' (&6%>

;J46 H)4 %-85 - B5$&'E? i)'&5 -$'(5*'> ;#6 (-' b4'6 - C&*6% D5A596E? #$ 9)$95*6 (&6% 6%5

'B&*&6 )A 6%5'5 .&$& D)94.5$6-*&5'> 6%5 @45'6&)$' GH*- D&*5965D 6) %5* 345'6' (5*5

)A65$ 5OB7)&6-6&85 -$D &$-BB*)B*&-65> -&.5D -6 -''4-3&$3 6%5 94*&)'&6H )A $)$=

6*-$'35$D5* -4D&5$95'E Y%5 -'+' cH-$> - 655$-35D 6*-$'35$D5* .-75> -C)46 (%56%5*

%5 '6&77 356' %&' B5*&)DE G) d75$-> - 655$-35D 6*-$'35$D5* A5.-75 (%) %-D C55$ )$ -

B*58&)4' (/"$'%)(> '%5 @45*&5' ;W&D H)4 4'5 6%5 '@4-6 B55 6*&9+ # 6-43%6 H)4^?E

G%5 .)'6 -BB-*5$6 ;A*5-+' 6-7+ C-9+? A5-64*5 )A 6%5 5B&')D5 (-' 6%5 6%*55=

B5*')$ B-$57 &$8&65D )$6) 6%5 '%)( 6) D5C-65 6%5 @45'6&)$ B)'5D CH J-$+'> ;g-$ -

9%&7D *5-77H +$)( 6%5H -*5 6*-$'35$D5*^? G%5 .5.C5*' )A 6%5 B-$57 (5*5 9%)'5$ &$

)*D5* 6) A457 9).C-6&85 D5C-65> -$D 6%5 '53.5$6 (-' B*).)65D -' - .4'6 '55

9)$6*)85*'HE ]&. h5-*')$> 5O5946&85 D&*596)* )A G*-$' \)46% _-.&7H M77&5'> -

6*-$'35$D5* -D8)9-9H 3*)4B> -$D W*E U-*9& J)(5*'> '4*35)$ -$D 6*-$'35$D5*

'B)+5'B5*')$> -*345D &$ A-8)* )A 9%&7D*5$L' D59&'&)$ 6) 9%-$35 35$D5*> -''5*6&$3 6%-6

6%5H %-85 - '6*)$3 -$D 9*5D&C75 '5$'5 )A '57AE U&9%-57 J*)($> B*)A5'')* )A l5-*

d-'65*$ I-$34-35' -$D I&65*-64*5' -$D .&$&'65* (%) ()*+' (&6% 6%5 9)$'5*8-6&85>

d8-$357&9-7 )*3-$&R-6&)$ _)94' )$ 6%5 _-.&7H> &$b5965D .)*5 %5-65D> 9)$65$6&)4'

D&'9)4*'5E J*)($ -*345D 6%-6 9%&7D*5$L' '5$'5 )A '57A 9-$ C5 (*)$3> -$D 6%-6

6*-$'35$D5* H)46% '4AA5* A*). ;C)DH &D5$6&6H D&')*D5*E? Q5 -7') @45'6&)$5D> ;-*5

H)4 3)&$3 6) 9%)B )AA 6%5&* B5$&' -$D B46 6%5. )$ D*43' A)* 6%5 *5'6 )A 6%5&* 7&85'^?

l585*6%575''> 6%5 5B&')D5 C5-*' (&6$5'' 6) 6%5 &$94*'&)$ )A - ;6-7+&$3 (&6%?

B-*-D&3.E M76%)43% 6%5 .&$& D)94.5$6-*&5' &$6*)D49&$3 6%5 345'6' (5*5

B*)C75.-6&9> 6%5H )AA5*5D - B7-6A)*. A)* 6%5 B-*5$6'L B5*'B596&85E i)'&5L' .)6%5*


13/22

"a

5OB7-&$'> ;M'&D5 A*). 6%5 A-96 6%-6 i)'&5 &' 6*-$'35$D5*> '%5 &' $)6 -77 6%-6 D&AA5*5$6j

Y%5 &' 85*H '4*5 )A (%) '%5 &'j # (-$6 %5* 6) %-85 6%5 $)*.-7 b)H' )A 9%&7D%))DE?

I&+5 TB*-%> (%&75 J-$+' 'B5$D' -$ 5O65$'&85 -.)4$6 )A 6&.5 )$ &''45' B5*6-&$&$3 6)

6%5 8&'&C75 -$D 6%5 B%H'&9-7 575.5$6' )A 6*-$'35$D5* 5OB5*&5$95> '%5 -7') %&3%7&3%6'

6%5 9%&7D*5$L' '6*5$36% -$D 9)4*-35E J-$+' B*5'5$6' 6%5 5B&')D5L' A)94' -' ;g%&7D*5$

&$ 575.5$6-*H '9%))7 C*-857H 7&8&$3 &$ 6%5 )BB)'&65 35$D5*>? -$D (%5$ .556&$3 %5*

345'6 i)'&5> GH*- D597-*5'> ;X5*H '6*)$3 7&6675 3&*7 H)4 -*5E?

M' )BB)'5D 6) 6%5 ;6-7+&$3 C-9+? B-*-D&3.> 6%5 ;6-7+&$3 (&6%? -BB*)-9% -7&3$'

6%5 -4D&5$95 (&6%> $)6 -3-&$'6> 6%5 @455* 345'6E S%5$ 5-9% )A GH*-L' 345'6' A&*'6

(-7+5D )$ '6-35> 6%5H (5*5 (579).5D (&6% 5$6%4'&-'6&9 -$D -AA&*.&$3 -BB7-4'5>

(%&75 i)'&5 -$D ]5$$5DH (5*5 3*5565D (&6% - '6-$D&$3 )8-6&)$ CH 6%5 '64D&)

-4D&5$95E _4*6%5*.)*5> - ;6-7+&$3 (&6%? B-*-D&3. -77)(' A)* 345'6'L B)&$6' )A 8&5(

6) C5 &.B-*65D> )AA5*&$3 $5( A*-.5()*+' A)* 4$D5*'6-$D&$3 6*-$'35$D5*

5OB5*&5$95E S%5*5-' - ;6-7+ C-9+? B-*-D&3. -7') -77)(' A)* 6%5 5OB*5''&)$ )A -

6*-$'35$D5* 8)&95> 6%5 %5&3%65$5D 9)$A7&96> D*-.- -$D 9)$6*)85*'H 6%-6 B4$964-65

&6' A7)( &$65**4B6' -$D )A65$ B*)%&C&6' 6*-$'35$D5* &$D&8&D4-7' A*). A477H -$D

&$6577&3&C7H 9)..4$&9-6&$3 6%5&* 6%)43%6' -$D &D5-'E G%5 (/"$5B&')D5 D&7&35$67H

()*+' 6) ')7&9&6 6%5 B5*'B596&85' -$D B5*')$-7 5OB5*&5$95' )A 6*-$'35$D5* 9%&7D*5$V

i)'&5 '6-*5' &$6) 6%5 9-.5*- 5OB7-&$&$3 6%-6 '%5 %-' -7(-H' A576 7&+5 - 3&*7 -$D 6%-6

+&D' -6 '9%))7 9*4D57H 9-77 %5* - K3-H C)HEL G-7+&$3 (&6% 6%5 .)6%5*' -7') '%5D' 7&3%6

)$ 6%5&* 4$&@45 9%-775$35' -$D (&'%5'> -' ]5$$5DHL' .)6%5* 5OB7-&$5DV ;W)$L6 97)'5

H)4* %5-*6' D)$L6 97)'5 H)4* .&$D 6) 6%&$3' C59-4'5 H)4 D)$L6 +$)( -C)46 &6E \)4

D)$L6 +$)( (%-6 &6' 7&+5 4$75'' H)4L85 D)$5 6%&' H)4*'57AE #6L' b4'6 ') &.B)*6-$6 A)*


14/22

"F

6%5'5 9%&7D*5$ 6) C5 -995B65DE? #.B)*6-$67H> 6%5 6*-$'35$D5* H)46% )AA5* - 37&.B'5

&$6) 6%5 9)..)$7H '%-*5D> .4$D-$5 A5-64*5' )A 585*HD-H 7&A5V g%*&' C4)H-$67H 6-7+'

-C)46 D-6&$3> i)'&5 6-7+' -C)46 9).B756&$3 - 6*&-6%-7)$> -$D d75$- D&'94''5' 6*)4C75'

(&6% -$ 5O=C)HA*&5$DE

#$ -DD&6&)$ 6) 6%5 *59)3$&6&)$ )A 585*HD-H 7&A5> - ;6-7+&$3 (&6%? B-*-D&3. 9-77'

A)* 6%5 K$)*.-7&R-6&)$L )A D&AA5*5$95E \56 &$ -665.B6&$3 6) -9%&585 6%&' GH*- -D8-$95'

- 9)$A4'&$3 C&)7)3&9-7 -$D .5D&9-7&R5D 9)$95B64-7&R-6&)$ )A 6*-$'35$D5*E #$

*5'B)$D&$3 6) g%*&'> - 6*-$'35$D5* 655$ (%) 5AA)*675''7H B-''5' A)* - .-75> GH*-

6%5)*&R5'V

;#A H)4 $585* 9-.5 )$ 6%5 GH*- '%)(> # ()47D $585* %-85 +$)($

H)4 (5*5 C)*$ - 3&*7j G%&' *5-77H 3)5' 6) '%)( 6%&' &' 6*47H').56%&$3 C&)7)3&9-7E G%&' &' $)6 ').56%&$3 6%-6 &' b4'6

B'H9%)7)3&9-7E J59-4'5 # D)$L6 9-*5 %)( .-$H %)*.)$5' #

9)47D 6-+5> # ()47D $)6 7))+ 7&+5 g%*&'E # ()47D 7))+ 7&+5 -3&*7 (&6% b4'6 ').5 %-&* )$ %5* A-95E?

c595$6 '9%)7-*'%&B /'55 Y6*H+5*> N::k2 )$ 6*-$'35$D5* 9%-775$35' .)D57' C-'5D ')757H &$

C&)7)3&9-7 -$D .5D&9-7 D&'9)4*'5'> -*34&$3 6%-6 '5O -$D 35$D5* '%)47D C5 4$D5*'6))D -'

')9&-7 9)$'6*496' &$A)*.5D CH - 9).B75O %)'6 )A B5*')$-7> ')9&-7> B'H9%)7)3&9-7 -$D 94764*-7

A-96)*'E _4*6%5*.)*5> 35$D5* 8-*&-$95 &' -$ )$6)7)3&9-7 A-96> - ')9&-7 *5-7&6H> -$D '55+&$3 &6'

K9-4'5L )* 9%-*-965*&R&$3 &6 -' - B*)C75. (-**-$6&$3 '9&5$6&A&9 &$85'6&3-6&)$ (%&75 75-8&$3

)6%5* ')9&-7 &D5$6&6&5' 5O$).&$-65D B5*A)*.' 6%5 ()*+ )A T6%5*&$3E

Y&.&7-* 6) 6%5 91"$--$D (/"$5B&')D5'> - :"; 9< 0-786&675D ;G*-$'35$D5*

]&D'V G)) \)4$3 6) W59&D5^? /_5CE "1> N:":2 A5-64*5D i)'&5 -$D #'--9> 6() 9)$A&D5$6

-$D %-BBH 6*-$'35$D5* H)46%'> -$D $53)6&-65D C)6% ;6-7+&$3 C-9+? -$D ;6-7+&$3

(&6%? D&'9)4*'5'E G%5 6&675 )A 6%5 5B&')D5 -$D &6' B*).)6&)$-7 65O6' *5$D5*

6*-$'35$D5* &D5$6&6H A)* 9%&7D*5$ -' D&'B46-C75> -' - 9)$6*)85*'&-7 -$D '4'B596 97-&.E


15/22

"`

G%5 5B&')D5L' 65-'5* B*5'5$65D - .)$6-35 )A '%-*B7H 5D&65D &.-35' B4$964-65D CH

.57)D*-.-6&9 -$D A)*5C)D&$3 .4'&9-7 ')4$D'> -' - .-75 8)&95 )85* $-**-65'V ;S%-6

&A H)4* ')$ 6)7D H)4 ;%5? /-BB5-*&$3 )$ '9*55$ -*5 6%*55 B&964*5' )A - '.&7&$3 .-75

9%&7D D*5''5D &$ C)HL' 97)6%&$32 (-' .5-$6 6) C5 /6%5 .4'&9 '(577' 6) - 9*5'95$D)2 -

;'%5? /- B&964*5 )A 6%5 '-.5 '.&7&$3 9%&7D &$ 3&*7L' 97)6%&$3 5.5*35'2^ G%5 $5O6

A*-.5 *585-7' - .&DD75 -35D S%&65 .)6%5* '&66&$3 $5O6 6) %5* A5.-75 9%&7D

5OB7-&$&$3> ;Y%5 -7(-H' +$5( 6%-6 '%5 &' - 3&*7E? #..5D&-657H> 6%5 9-.5*- 9-B64*5' -

97)'5 4B )A 6%5 D-43%65*L' A-95E G%5 $-**-6)* 9)$6&$45'> ;S)47D H)4 756 H)4* 9%&7D

C59).5 6%5 )BB)'&65 '5O^? T$ '9*55$ - B&964*5 )A - A5.-75 C-CH &' @4&9+7H *5B7-95D

CH -$ &.-35 )A - .-75 C-CHE #$ 6%5 A)77)(&$3 A*-.5> W*E TR -'+' - 6*-$'35$D5* .-75

655$> ;G-7+ 6) .5 -C)46 (%H H)4 D59&D5D 6) %-85 - D)4C75 .-'6596).H -6 -35

A)4*655$^? G%5 9-.5*- 6%5$ A)94'5' &$ )$ - .&DD75=-35D S%&65 A5.-75 -4D&5$95

.5.C5* $)DD&$3> B-H&$3 97)'5 -665$6&)$ 6) 6%5 345'6L' *5'B)$'5E G%5 $-**-6)*

9)$974D5' (&6%> ;#$'&D5 6%5 7&85' )A 6*-$'35$D5* +&D'E? S&6% &6' A)94' )$ 6*-$''5O4-7

'4*35*H> 6%5 9)$'6-$6 A7-'%&$3 B&964*5' )A 9%&7D*5$ R)).&$3 &$ -$D )46 )A A)94'> 6%5

D&*596 .)D5 )A -DD*5'' 6) B-*5$6' /;(%-6 &A H)4* ')$?2 -$D 6%5 4'5 )A 64.4764)4'

')4$D 5AA596'> 6%5 5B&')D5L' B*).)6&)$-7 65-'5* B*&.-*&7H 5.B7)H' - ;6-7+&$3 C-9+?

'6H75 &$ )*D5* 6) -66*-96 -$D .-&$6-&$ 6%5 -665$6&)$ )A 6%5 B)65$6&-7 %).5 -4D&5$95E

#$ '4BB)*6&$3 6%5 65O64-7 B*).&'5 )A 6%5 B*).)6&)$-7 .-65*&-7> W*E TR )B5$'

6%5 '%)( CH 5OB*5''&$3 6) %&' -4D&5$95 6%-6 (%-6 A)77)(' ;&' 3)&$3 6) C5

9)$6*)85*'&-7 A)* - 7)6 )A B5)B75E? G%5 6%5.5 )A 9)$6*)85*'H &' -7') 5.C5DD5D &$ 6%5

'%)(L' '56 -' - 7-*35 A7-6 '9*55$ .)$&6)* -96&$3 -' - 8&'4-7 -&D 6%-6 -$9%)*' 6%5

5B&')D5L' D&'94''&)$ 6)B&9' &' '&64-65D D&*5967H C5%&$D 345'6' -$D )A65$ *5-D'>


16/22

"k

;G*-$'35$D5* ]&D'V G)) \)4$3 6) W59&D5^?E G%&' B%*-'5 9-B64*5' -$ &$65*5'6&$3

65$'&)$ (&6%&$ 6%5 5B&')D5 C56(55$ - ;6-7+&$3 C-9+? -$D ;6-7+&$3 (&6%? 7)3&9E S%&75

6*-$'35$D5* H)46% -*5 A*-.5D -' B)65$6&-77H 9)$A4'5D -$D ;6)) H)4$3 6) D59&D5>?

3&85$ 6%5&* -35 -$D *57-6&85 &$$)95$95 6%5H -*5 '&.476-$5)4'7H B*5'5$65D -'

*5B*5'5$6-6&85' )A 6%5 6*46%> 6%5 -46%5$6&9 -$D 6%5 ;*5-7E? MDD*5''&$3 6%5 -4D&5$95

-$D 5OB*5''&$3 6%5.'5785' 4'&$3 D&*596 -$D 4$9).B7&9-65D D597-*-6&85'> 6%5

6*-$'35$D5* H)46% D5B7)H - 9)..4$&9-6&)$ '6H75 6%-6 &' -*6&947-65> 6*-$'B-*5$6 -$D

%)$5'6E _)* 5O-.B75> &$ D5'9*&C&$3 6%5 &$A745$95 )A %)*.)$5' -$D '4*35*H )$ %&'

7&A5> #'--9 '&.B7H -AA&*.'> ;#L85 -7(-H' C55$ .5E?

#$ -99)*D (&6% 6%5 )6%5* 6-7+ '%)( 5B&')D5'> 6%5 B*).)6&)$-7 -$D 5O6*-=

65O64-7 .-65*&-7 A)* 6%5 5B&')D5 -*5 A-* .)*5 '5$'-6&)$-7&R&$3 6%-$ 6%5 9)$65$6 )A 6%5

5B&')D5 &6'57A> (%&9% (-' %5-8&7H &$A)*.5D CH - ;6-7+&$3 (&6%? B-*-D&3.E T$5 )A 6%5

6*-$'35$D5* H)46% &$ 6%5 :"; 9 -7') -BB5-*5D &$ 6%5 (/"$ 5B&')D5E

i)'&5 -$D %5* .)6%5* -*5 .5.C5*' )A 6%5 -D8)9-9H 3*)4B G*-$' \)46% _-.&7H M77&5'>

-$ )*3-$&R-6&)$ A)94'&$3 )46*5-9% 5AA)*6' )$ 6*-$'35$D5* +&D' -$D A-.&7&5' (&6% -

6*-$'35$D5* *57-6&85E G%5 D59&'&)$ 6) '57596 345'6' A*). -$ )*3-$&R-6&)$ )A 6%&'

$-64*5 -$D 6%5 .)85 -(-H A*). '5-*9%&$3 A)* 6%5 7)4D -$D 6%5 A7-.C)H-$6> '&3$-7' -

*5B*5'5$6-6&)$-7 '%&A6E G%*)43% '&64-6&$3 6*-$'35$D5* &D5$6&6H (&6%&$ - A-.&7H

9)$65O6> 6%5 '%)( ')43%6 6) $)*.-7&R5 -$D $546*-7&R5 6%5 345'6'L 6*-$'35$D5*

&D5$6&6HE G%5 '%)( 9%)'5 6) A5-64*5 A-.&7&5' (%) D59&D5D 6) $4*64*5 -$D '4BB)*6

6%5&* 9%&7D*5$L' D59&'&)$ 6) 5.C*-95 6%5 35$D5* )A 6%5&* 9%)&95E G%&' B*)95'' )A

$)*.-7&R-6&)$ (-' -7') -99).B7&'%5D 6%*)43% A&*'6 B5*')$ -99)4$6' CH 6*-$'35$D5*

H)46% -$D 6%5&* B-*5$6'E _)* 5O-.B75> i)'&5L' .)6%5* *59-77' 6%-6 -A65* '%5 756 i)'&5


17/22

"P

C5 (%) '%5 (-$65D> ;Y%5 b4'6 C7)'').5Dj Y%5 &' )$ $) .5D&9-6&)$' $)(E Y%5 9-$L6

'6)B '.&7&$3 -$D 3&337&$3E? #'--9L' A-6%5* 5OB7-&$' 6%-6 %&' ')$L' 6*-$'&6&)$ ;.-+5'

'5$'5>? %&' .)6%5* B*)4D7H 97-&.' 6%-6 ;&6 &' - B*&8&7535 6) C5 %&' .).>? -$D #'--9

D&'97)'5' 6%-6 -995B6&$3 %&' 6*-$'35$D5* &D5$6&6H %-' .-D5 %&. %-BB&5* -$D .)*5

')9&-C75E #.B)*6-$67H> A))6-35 D5B&96&$3 #'--9 5$3-3&$3 &$ 6%5 .4$D-$5 7&+5 B7-H&$3

')995* )* 3)&$3 A)* - (-7+> )AA5*' - 37&.B'5 &$6) #'--9L' 7&A5 -' )*D&$-*HE

G%5 .5D&9-7 -46%)*&6&5' )$ 6%5 '%)( &$974D&$3 W*E TR %&.'57A -$D W*E

,-*)A-7)> - B5D&-6*&9&-$ (&6% 5OB5*6&'5 &$ 9%&7D%))D 35$D5* &''45'> -7') ()*+ 6)

.-+5 6*-$'35$D5* '55. 75'' -C5**-$6> -D)B6&$3 -$ 5D49-6)*L' *)75E g).B-*5D 6) -

;A*5-+' 6-7+ C-9+? .)D57 6%-6 -&.' 6) 6&6&77-65> '%)9+ -$D 5$65*6-&$> - ;6-7+&$3 (&6%?

B-*-D&3. A*5@45$67H A47A&77' - c5&6%&-$ 5D49-6&)$-7 A4$96&)$> -' 6-7+ '%)(' -*5 )A65$

9)$'6*4965D -$D B*).)65D -' 65O6' 6%-6 (&77 65-9% 8&5(5*' ').56%&$3 $5(E S%5*5-'

.5D&9-7 -46%)*&6H %-' %&'6)*&9-77H C55$ D5B7)H5D (&6%&$ A-964-7 .5D&- 6) 8&7&AH -$D

D&-3$)'5 6*-$'35$D5* B5)B75> &$ 6%&' 5B&')D5> .5D&9-7 -46%)*&6H &' 4'5D 6) 5OB7-&$

-$D %4.-$&R5E Q)(585*> 6%&' &' B*)C75.-6&9 '&$95 .5D&9-7 B*)A5''&)$-7' -*5

D5B&965D -' -BB*59&-6&$3 5@4-7 )* .)*5 5OB5*6&'5 )85* 6*-$'35$D5* 7&A5 -$D

'4Cb596&8&6H 6%-$ 6*-$'35$D5* &$D&8&D4-7' 6%5.'5785'E l)$56%575''> (&6%&$ 6%5

5B&')D5> W*E TR -$D %&' 345'6' -*6&947-65 -$ &$A)*.5D 9)$95B64-7&R-6&)$ )A

6*-$'35$D5* -$D -*345 6%-6 35$D5* &' .)*5 9).B75O 6%-$ .-75[A5.-75E M99)*D&$3 6)

,IMMW> 6%5 5B&')D5 &.B-*65D ;6%5 %5-76%&5'6 .5D&9-7 )B&$&)$ )A 6*-$'35$D5* 585*

C*)-D9-'6? /S&BA75*> N:":2E _4*6%5*.)*5> W*E TR 5OB7-&$' 6%-6 6*-$'35$D5* &' ;$)6 -'

*-*5 -' H)4 .&3%6 6%&$+>? -$D (%&75 6%5 6)B&9 )A '4*35*H -$D %)*.)$5' (5*5

.5$6&)$5D> 6%5 D&'94''&)$ (-' $)6 B*5)994B&5D (&6% A56&'%&R&$3 6%5 6*-$'35$D5*


18/22

"1

C)DHE I&+5(&'5> W*E ,-*)A-7) 5OB7-&$5D 6%-6 6%5 $)6&)$ )A ,5$D5* #D5$6&6H W&')*D5*

%-' 94**5$9H &$ 6%5 .5D&9-7 9)..4$&6H> C46 97-*&A&5D 6%-6 .)'6 6*-$'35$D5*

&$D&8&D4-7' -$D .-$H 5OB5*6' &$ 6%5 A&57D D) $)6 5.C*-95 6%5 &D5-E

B$/2@C - *5B*5'5$6-6&)$-7 DH$-.&9 &$A)*.5D CH 6%5 _)49-47D&-$

/"00:2 ;&$9&65.5$6 6) D&'9)4*'5? /BE aF2E S%5$ 9).B-*5D 6) - ;6-7+&$3 C-9+>? 6%&' $5(

)*3-$&R&$3 7)3&9 -AA)*D' .)*5 ')C5* -$D D56-&75D D&-7)345> '%&$5' 7&3%6 )$ -$ &$D&8&D4-7L'

&$$5* -$D 5.)6&)$-7 7&A5> -$D %-' 6%5 B)65$6&-7 6) B*)AA5* -765*$-6&85' A*-.5()*+' A)*

4$D5*'6-$D&$3 94764*-7 &D5$6&6&5'E G%5 ;6-7+&$3 (&6%? B-*-D&3. -7') B*).&'5' .)*5 6%-$

5$65*6-&$.5$6 -$D 'B596-975> &6 9)..&6' 6) 5D49-6&$3 -$D 5$7&3%65$&$3 8&5(5*'E G%5'5

'%)(' -''4*5 -4D&5$95' 6%5H (&77 75-85 (&6% ').56%&$3> (%56%5* &6 &' - $5( B5*'B596&85 )$

6%5 %4.-$ 'B&*&6 &$ 6%5 9-'5 )A 6%5 91"$- ?23@"#/ 0-78> )* - .)*5 $4-$95D 4$D5*'6-$D&$3

-C)46 35$D5* &D5$6&6H -' &$ 6%5 :"; 9< 0-78; S%&75;6-7+&$3 (&6%? B-*-D&3.' -*5 9-B-C75 )A

&.B-*6&$3 &.B)*6-$6 &$A)*.-6&)$ -C)46 I,JG 7&A5 -$D '4Cb596&8&6H> 6%5H 9-$ -7') .&'&$A)*.

-$D D) $)6 $595''-*&7H -D8-$95 B)7&6&9-77H B*)3*5''&85 -35$D-'E #$ A-96> 6%5H )A65$ '%H -(-H

A*). )85*6 B)7&6&9-7 D&'9)4*'5E S%&75 .-$H )A 6%5 6-7+ '%)(' 5$9)4*-35D 8&5(5*' 6) 9)$$596

(&6% 6*-$'35$D5* -D8)9-9H )*3-$&R-6&)$' )AA5*&$3 7&$+' 6) (5C'&65' -$D %)67&$5 $4.C5*'>

6-7+ '%)( %)'6' 6HB&9-77H -8)&D5D 9)$85*'-6&)$' -C)46> A)* 5O-.B75> 6%5 &.B7&9-6&)$' )A -

')9&56H 6%-6 '-$96&)$' 6*-$'B%)C&- )* 6%5 .H*&-D B4C7&9 B)7&9&5' 6%-6 5O974D5 )* %-*.

6*-$'35$D5* 9&6&R5$'E


19/22

"0

g*49&-77H> - ;A*5-+' 6-7+ (&6%? .)D57 ()*+' 6) $)*.-7&R5 D&AA5*5$95 -$D 4$&85*'-7&R5

5OB5*&5$95> -7&3$&$3 6%5 -4D&5$95 (&6% $)6 -3-&$'6 345'6'E G%5'5 '%)(' B5*&)D&9-77H

&774.&$-65 6%5 )*D&$-*&$5'' )A 6*-$'35$D5* 7&A5 '%)(&$3 &$D&8&D4-7' -' C*)6%5*' -$D '&'65*'>

')$' -$D D-43%65*'> $5&3%C)*'> 97-''.-65'> -$D B*)A5''&)$-7'> - D5B&96&)$ )A65$ &3$)*5D CH

.-&$'6*5-. .5D&- *5B*5'5$6-6&)$'E #$ B-*6&947-*> 6%&' +&$D )A *5B*5'5$6-6&)$ 5.5*35' &$

6() '%)(' A5-64*&$3 6*-$'35$D5* H)46%E YB)+5$ A*). 6%5 .)46%' )A H)4$35* B5)B75 (%)

%-85 H56 6) C5 9)7)*5D CH -D476 A)*.' )A B*5b4D&95> &D5)7)3H -$D '65*5)6HB5> 6%5&* '6)*&5' -$D

'57A=D&'97)'4*5' -BB5-* %)$5'6> &$$)95$6> -46%5$6&9> -$D C57&58-C75E G%5 '%)(' &774'6*-65 -

(&77&$3$5'' 6) 7&'65$> 6) '4'B5$D b4D3.5$6 -$D 6) D5857)B - '-A5 D&'94*'&85 5$8&*)$.5$6 A)*

6%5 6*-$'35$D5* &D5$6&A&5D H)46%E M6 6%5 '-.5 6&.5> 6%5&* '6)*&5' 9-$ B)65$6&-77H 7&$5 4B (&6%

.5D&9-7 .)D57' )A 6*-$'35$D5* -' &77$5''> -' -4D&5$95' A557 B&6H A)* &$D&8&D4-7' '4AA5*&$3

A*).> (%-6 i)'&5 9-775D> - ;C&*6% D5A596E?

S%&75 B*5A5*-C75 6) 5O6*5.5 .-*3&$-7&R-6&)$> 6%&' B4'% 6) $)*.-7&R5 -$D 4$&85*'-7&R5

%-' .&O5D 9)$'5@45$95'E M' S-765*' /N::"2 -*345'> - 8&'&C&7&6H 6%-6 )85*7H A)94'5' )$ I,JG

'-.5$5'' %-' 6%5 B)65$6&-7 6) ;5*-'5 -$D .-*3&$-7&R5 6%)'5 (%) D5'&*5 ').56%&$3 .)*5

6%-$ .5*5 &$974'&)$ &$ '6*-&3%6 ')9&56Hn /"02E #.B)*6-$67H> &$ $53)6&-6&$3 6%5 5O6*-)*D&$-*H

CH *5$D5*&$3 &6 *57-6-C75 -$D &$6577&3&C75> 6%5 ;6-7+&$3 (&6%? B-*-D&3. -99*5D&6' -$D -AA&*.' -

95*6-&$ $)*.-6&85 $)6&)$ )A ;6%5 )*D&$-*HE? (-# :"; 9< 0-78, (-# (/"$ *$3%&0-78, -$D (-#

91"$-B& ?23@"#/ 0-78L' A)94' )$ H)46% -$D &$D&8&D4-7' A*). B*5D).&$-657H S%&65> $4975-*

A-.&7&5' &774'6*-65 %)( ;6%5 )*D&$-*H? &' 7&.&65D7H D&'6*&C465DE _&$-77H> 6%5 6*-$'&6&)$ 6) -

;6-7+&$3 (&6%? B-*-D&3. -7') .-*+' - '%&A6 A*). 9)$95B64-7&R&$3 6*-$'35$D5* &$D&8&D4-7' -'

.)*-7 B*)C75.' (%) 6%*5-65$ B4C7&9 'B-95> 6) 9)$95&8&$3 )A 6*-$'35$D5* A)7+' -' .5D&9-7

-$D ')9&-7 D&75..-'E M' .5D&9-7 .H'65*&5'> 6-7+ '%)( A)*.-6' )A65$ A)94' )$ 5OB7)*&$3 6%5


20/22

N:

9-4'5' -$D *5-')$' C5%&$D 35$D5* 8-*&-$95> 5$D5-8)*&$3 6) &D5$6&AH &6' B'H9%)7)3&9-7 )*

C&)7)3&9-7 )*&3&$'E #$ 65*.' )A - ')9&-7 B*)C75.> 6%5'5 '%)(' -*345 A)* 6*-$'35$D5*

-''&.&7-6&)$> -$D %&3%7&3%6 &$65*B5*')$-7 '6*43375' '49% -' 6%5 D&AA&9476H )A C5&$3 -995B65D -'

6*-$'35$D5*> 6%5 9%-775$35' )A *-&'&$3 - 6*-$'35$D5* 655$> )* 6%5 DH$-.&9' )A .-&$6-&$&$3 -

7)8&$3 .-**&-35 (&6% - 6*-$'35$D5* 'B)4'5E

8$#3< B.&(4

MC6> X&9+& e U4'6-RR-> I5)$-*DE /"00P2E =7C234 D@E#" 91"$-F =G)EG"$) !$))7GE 23 E-#

D4# 7@ E-# (H ($)% 0-78E J)(7&$3 ,*55$> TQV J)(7&$3 ,*55$ Y6-65 o$&85*'&6H

h)B47-* h*5''E

J)*$'65&$> ]-65E /"00`2E I#3A#" 9GE)$8F 93 J#3, ?7C#3 $3A E-# 5#&E 7@ K&; l5(\)*+V X&$6-35 J))+'E

g7-*+5> X&96)*&- e ]&6R&$35*> g57&-E /N::F2E I5'C&-$ -$D ,-H h-*5$6' )$ 6-7+'%)('V *5'&'6-$95 )* 9)774'&)$ &$ %565*)'5O&'.^E LG$)2E$E2M# 5#$"+- 23

>&/+-7)74/> "> "0`=N"PE

W)85H> i)$E /N:::2E !"#$%&-78F !2"&E >#"&73 J#A2$ $3A !$+EG$) (#)#M2&273; I)$D)$V

h746) h*5''E

dB'65&$> WE e Y65&$C5*3> WEIE /"00 2E G(5785 '65B' 6) %565*)'5O4-7&6HV 9)..)$='5$'&C&7&6&5'

)$ 6%5 TB*-% S&$A*5H Y%)(E _5.&$&'. e h'H9%)7)3H> `> NP`=1:E

_)49-476> U&9%57E /"00:2E (-# N2&E7"/ 7@ 0#OG$)2E/F D3 P3E"7AG+E273; c)C5*6

Q4*75H /G*-$'E2> l5( \)*+V X&$6-35[c-$D). Q)4'5E

_*5&C5*3> h565*E /N::N> U-*9% "02E S%-6 .-+5' - .-$^ M G*-$'35$D5*5D .-$ A&3%6' A)*94'6)DH )A %&' 9%&7D*5$ -A65* %&' (&A5 9)$65$D' %5L' $)6 .-75E (-# DAM7+$E#; #''E 1`0>

aNE

,-.')$> i)'%4-E /"0012E _*5-+' G-7+ J-9+V G-C7)&D G-7+ Y%)(' -$D Y5O4-7

l)$9)$A)*.&6HE g%&9-3) -$D I)$D)$V g%&9-3) o$&85*'&6H h*5''E


21/22

N"

====================E /N::"2E G-7+&$3 _*5-+'V I5'C&-$> ,-H> J&'5O4-7 -$D G*-$'35$D5* _-.&7&5')$ W-H6&.5 G-7+ GXE #$ LG##" !$C2)2#&, LG##" >7)2E2+&F =-$))#34234 =G)EG"# $3A E-#

0E$E#;U-*H J5*$'65&$ e c5$-65 c5&.-$$ /dD'E2> l\V g)74.C&- o$&85*'&6H> h*5''E

,*55$> i-.&')$E /N::F2E *#+7C234 $ H2&2Q)# J$3; l-'%8&775> GlV X-$D5*C&76o$&85*'&6H h*5''E

,*)''> I-**HE /N::"2E oB _*). #$8&'&C&7&6HV I5'C&-$'> ,-H U5$ -$D 6%5 U5D&- &$ M.5*&9-E

l5( \)*+V g)74.C&- o$&85*'&6H h*5''E

Q--*.-$> I)4-$$E /N::"2E h5*A)*.&$3 G-7+E #$E G)7')$ /dDE2> (#)#M2&273 ($)%0-78&F :2&+7G", >#"@7"C$3+#, 01#+E$+)#E U-%(-%> liV I-(*5$95 d*7C-4.

M'')9&-65'> h4C7&'%5*'E

U-$3-> i47&5 d$357E /N::a2E ($)%234 ("$&-F (-# =G)EG"$) >7)2E2+& 7@ :$/E2C# (H ($)%

0-78&; l5( \)*+ -$D I)$D)$V l5( \)*+ o$&85*'&6H h*5''E

l-.-'65> X&8&-$5E /N::`2E 0#O =-$34#, 07+2$) =-$34#F 5#@)#+E273& 73 PA#3E2E/,

P3&E2EGE273&, $3A PC1#"2$)2&C; G)*)$6)V S).5$L' h*5''

T4R)4$&-$> c&9%-*DE /N:":> U-*9% k2E J-*C-*- S-765*'V S%-6 +&$D )A 6*55 &' '%5^

(7"73E7 0E$"; c56*&585D A*). %66BV[[C&6E7H[9Og0-I

cH-$> i)5775 c4CHE /N::02E c557 ,5$D5*V dO-.&$&$3 6%5 h)7&6&9' )A G*-$' #.-35' &$_&7. -$D U5D&-E W)96)*-7 W&''5*6-6&)$E J)(7&$3 ,*55$ Y6-65 o$&85*'&6HE

>"7RG#&E :2&"E$E273& S (-#&; /h4C7&9-6&)$ l4.C5* aaP"::12

Y6*H+5*> Y'4-$E /N::k2E /W52Y4Cb43-65D ]$)(75D35'V M$ #$6*)D496&)$ 6)

G*-$'35$D5* Y64D&5'E #$ Y4'-$ Y6*H+5* -$D Y65B%5$ S%&6675 /dD'E2> (-#

("$3&4#3A#" 0EGA2#& 5#$A#"; l5( \)*+ e I)$D)$V c)4675D35E

S-765*'> Y4R-$$- W-$46-E /N::"2E D)) E-# 5$4#F (-# 0E7"/ 7@ I$/ H2&2Q2)2E/ 23 DC#"2+$;g%&9-3) -$D I)$D)$V G%5 o$&85*'&6H )A g%&9-3) h*5''E

S&BA75*> M$$-E /N:":> _5CE "12E ; ;G%5 W*E TR Y%)(? c-&'5' 6%5 J-* A)* G*-$'35$D5*G-7+ Y%)( g)85*-35E? I6DD: Q)74E c56*&585D A*).

%66BV[[37--DC7)3E)*3[N:":[:N["1[6%5=D*=)R='%)(=*-&'5'=6%5=C-*=A)*=

6*-$'35$D5*=6-7+='%)(=9)85*-35[


22/22

Copyright of Conference Papers -- International Communication Association is the property of International

Communication Association and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a

listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or

email articles for individual use.

from the jerry springer smackdown to the oprah winfrey sitdown

Documents