franco-british symposium composite materials
TRANSCRIPT
1
FRANCO-BRITISH SYMPOSIUM
Composite MaterialsNanotechnologies, Advanced Materials, Biotechnology and
Advanced Manufacturing and ProcessingS.LEROY – IRT JV French NCP NMPB
1
1
NMBP.2014 calls: first résultats
1Calls PPP 2015
FoF.2015: participation
- 214 proposals (56/35/51/35/38)
- Private: 53-60%; SME: 1/3
- / countries: DE>>IT>UK>ES>FR
results
- 14 financed projects (6,5%!!)
- +/- 3 per topics
EeB.2015: participation
- 119 proposals (21/23/40/36)
- Private: 48-57%; SME: 1/4
- Per countries: ES>UK, IT>DE>NL, FR
results
- 11 financed projects (9,2%!)
- +/- 3 per topics
Spire.2015: participation
- 82 proposals (30/20/27/5)
- Private: 53-58%; SME: 1/4
- Per countries: DE>ES>IT>UK>NL>FR
results
- 13 financed projects (15,9%)
- +/- 4 par topics
Very low sucess rate
FoF =>programme is + & + attractive
FoF: Factories of the Future
SPIRE : Sustainable process Industries
EeB : Energy efficient Buildings
1Resultts FoF.2015
FoF. 2015 - €
FoF. 2015 – Success rate
Pays EU, main list € gagnés
DE FRAUNHOFER 5 882 662 €
IT POLITECNICO DI MILANO 1 196 875 €
NO SINTEF 1 187 865 €
DE SIEMENS 1 172 920 €
DE CERAMTEC GMBH 1 076 250 €
ES TECNALIA 1 060 000 €
DE Bosch 1 027 585 €
UK LOUGHBOROUGH Univ 970 500 €
UK Transcendata 964 375 €
NO NORSUN 874 095 €
PT UNINOVA 842 500 €
UK BRUNEL UNIV LONDON 835 000 €
DE IVW 804 375 €
AT AT&S 801 250 €
BE SAMTECH 778 125 €
IT PRIMA INDUSTRIE SPA 756 250 €
ES IK4-TEKNIKER 736 250 €
EL CERTH 723 875 €
NL TNO 702 500 €
IT SINTEA PLUSTEK SRL 683 750 €
FR RENAULT SAS 651 783 €
IT OPI SRL 645 000 €
PT INTROSYS SA 636 125 €
FR Apollon Solar 630 750 €
IT Whirlpool Europe srl 629 125 €
DK EYE D Innov 621 438 €
AT FILL 614 446 €
ITGimac di Maccagnan
Giorgio612 854 €
UK MTC 612 500 €
FI TAMPERE UNIV. Tech 611 875 €
IT CNR 608 750 €
IE Blueacre Technology 600 295 €
FR ICS 590 025 €
DE RWTH AACHEN 588 750 €
IT COSBERG SPA 581 000 €
DE XETICS GMBH 576 188 €
DE TAMPONCOLOR 574 996 €
DE ISC Konstanz 548 700 €
LT SoliTek 547 500 €
DEInmatec Technologies
GmbH545 730 €
DE Elrest 542 500 €
BE IBS 538 289 €
AT NXT 537 950 €
UK USFD 525 938 €
NL UNIVERSITEIT TWENTE 521 149 €
NL ADMATEC 518 750 €
DK SP Denmark 518 250 €
ES DGH Robotics 515 113 €
ES IRIS 508 125 €
ES CESA 504 525 €
UK Chas a blatchford ltd 502 500 €
1Results EeB.2015
0 €
1,000,000 €
2,000,000 €
3,000,000 €
4,000,000 €
5,000,000 €
6,000,000 €
7,000,000 €
8,000,000 €
9,000,000 €
ES DE IT UK IE FR NL BE EL SE FI AT PL
EeB.2015 - €
0.0%
5.0%
10.0%
15.0%
20.0%
25.0%
30.0%
IE FR BE NL DE EL ES IT UK
EeB.2015 – Success rate
EU main list € Pays
CIT 1 484 174 € IE
TNO 1 476 439 € NL
Fraunhofer 1 281 449 € DE
NOBATEK 1 095 050 € FR
VITO 1 093 750 € BE
AEE INTEC 1 085 563 € AT
BAM 957 688 € NL
Places for People 950 000 € UK
CLIVET 943 686 € IT
CHALMERS 929 889 € SE
MSIL 906 728 € IL
Enervalis 902 111 € BE
AZIENDA TERRITORIALE
TREVISO831 250 € IT
TECNALIA 819 000 € ES
AB Landskronahem 817 250 € SE
VTT 814 375 € FI
CEA 812 579 € FR
MOSTOSTAL
WARSZAWA SA747 213 € PL
IBM IRELAND LIMITED 738 632 € IE
IDOM 682 500 € ES
ACCIONA 677 950 € ES
RUHR-UNIVERSITAT
BOCHUM641 875 € DE
HALFEN 640 588 € DE
IES 632 188 € UK
MUAS 615 325 € DE
Luvata U.K. Ltd. 610 000 € UK
HYPERTECH 593 032 € EL
MONDRAGON
CORPORACION
COOPERATIVA SCOOP
585 200 € ES
CAR 581 500 € ES
EURAC 569 625 € IT
TEC 558 750 € ES
Sweco Finland Oy 551 732 € FI
SOL 545 125 € ES
STEDIN 543 288 € NL
TEI STEREAS ELLADAS
EC541 250 € EL
TYNDALL 504 428 € IE
HON 501 375 € CZ
IPS 501 250 € PT
TUD 491 750 € DE
BOUYGUES ENERGIES &
SERVICES485 740 € FR
ZAVI 483 250 € ES
GEOTEAM 482 500 € AT
Kieback&Peter GmbH 478 275 € DE
PINK 470 488 € AT
CRES 467 500 € EL
SIEMENS 446 327 € DE
SCHNEIDER 439 163 € IT
TU/e 438 750 € NL
IBP 437 500 € DE
SP SVERIGES 437 500 € SE
KEO GmbH 431 463 € DE
1Results SPIRE.2015
0 €
2,000,000 €
4,000,000 €
6,000,000 €
8,000,000 €
10,000,000 €
12,000,000 €
14,000,000 €
DE ES UK IT FR NO BE NL PT DK AT PL FI
SPIRE.2015 - €
0.0%
5.0%
10.0%
15.0%
20.0%
25.0%
ES FR UK DE IT
SPIRE.2015: Success rate
EU main list € Pays
Fraunhofer 2 303 231 € DE
EVONIK INDUSTRIES AG 2 113 766 € DE
SINTEF 2 019 588 € NO
IRIS 1 837 470 € ES
TECNALIA 1 806 214 € ES
ELKEM 1 661 454 € NO
ISL 1 230 600 € UK
VITO 1 199 759 € BE
DTU 1 189 656 € DK
TU/e 1 176 374 € NL
UNIVLEEDS 1 130 125 € UK
JOHNSON MATTHEY 1 076 058 € UK
TU Delft 1 003 438 € NL
STIFTELSEN SINTEF 977 898 € NO
SIEMENS SPA 958 750 € IT
JM 930 063 € UK
FUNDACION CIDAUT 898 138 € ES
RWTH AACHEN 897 000 € DE
Pro Automation GmbH 830 463 € AT
FAU 814 500 € DE
CNR 813 125 € IT
AVT 801 706 € NL
OSAI Automation System 796 907 € IT
VTT 772 038 € FI
UNIVERSITEIT GENT 768 125 € BE
DTI 761 625 € DK
UNIVERSITEIT TWENTE 724 670 € NL
AICE 724 528 € ES
SYNESIS 718 750 € IT
ISQ 706 925 € PT
ERIC 688 248 € BE
INSTYTUT METALI
NIEZELAZNYCH687 375 € PL
UGENT 669 726 € BE
KUL 669 469 € BE
HyGear Technology 669 169 € NL
UNEW 638 913 € UK
TUB 615 729 € DE
Amtech 611 000 € DE
POLITO 587 925 € IT
KI 574 266 € SI
UNIZAR 564 504 € ES
BIOENERGY 2020+ 564 443 € AT
SPIRAX-SARCO LIMITED 558 750 € UK
Finden Ltd 558 125 € UK
SANOFI-AVENTIS 553 438 € FR
1Calls NMBP.2014
KET Nano-Materials
Topic Nb financedprojects
Success rate
NMP.10 7 >20%NMP.13 7 >20%NMP.18 10 >20%NMP.20 12 11,1%NMP.21 13 >20%NMP.26 1 >20%NMP.28 4 >20%NMP.35 7 >20%
Topic Nb financedprojects
Success rate
NMP.1 3 11,5%NMP.4 3 15%NMP.5 2 7,7%NMP.8 2 11,1%
NMP.2014, 2 étapes, résultat 1ère phase
313 eligle proposals, 61 in phase 2
NMP.2014, Pilote, 1 étape
90 eligible proposals, 10 financed
NMP.2014, CSA, 1 étape
27 eligible proposals, 10 financed
Topic Nb financedprojects
Success rate
NMP.09 1NMP.27 1NMP.31 1NMP.33 1 11,1%NMP.34 1NMP.36 0 (1 prop.) 0%NMP.37 1NMP.38 3NMP.39 1 100%
1 PME Instrument : 1st phase
Success rate very low => Motivation from SMEs ???!!!
EC think about how to target more the future calls
Topic Nb proposals Selected Success Rate
NMP.25 305 14 4,6%
Biotech.5 73 2 2,7%
TIC 885 30 3,4%
Total 2666 (2500 unique) 164 6,2%
1
Feed Back from Evaluation
10
Individual
Evaluation
Report
Individual
Evaluation
Report Individual
Evaluation
Report
Consensus
group
Consensus
Report
Individual
Evaluation
Report
Individual
Evaluation
Report
Expert Expert Expert ExpertExpert Minimum 3 experts
(generally 5 experts)
Individual evaluation
Consensus
Proposal Eligible proposal
1
11
Receipt of proposals
Individualevaluation
Consensusgroup
Panel Review
Finalisation
Individual
Evaluation
Reports
(done remotely)
Consensus
Report
Panel report
Evaluation Summary
Report
Panel ranked list
Eligibility check
Allocation of
proposals to
evaluators
Final ranked list
8 to 12 proposals (more than 100 pages)
(2 or 3 consensus :oral + write)
Feed Back from Evaluation
1Evaluation => Starting by « - »
Proposal = Easy to read according to the number of
proposals
Proposal = Global idea is clear and coherent
Meeting with 5 expertises is a crucial step
Fill in all items relative to the call !
Argue according to the call
Ecxellence of the proposal !
Importance of TRL and Pilote site (milestones abble to
validate TRL)
Importance of the Business plan
Importance of the link with regional / national
links
12
Feed Back from Evaluation
1
Calls NMBP.2015
1Work Program 2016-2017
1st draft
New
87 topics proposed:- 37 RIA + 23 IA
- 3 ERA-NET (NanoMedecine, Manufacturing, Biotechnologies)
- 24 CSA
TRL targeted6 (TRL 3-5), 1 (3-6), 31 (4-6), 21 (5-7)
Link with societal challenges (health, energie, transport,
environnment)
1Work Program 2016-2017
1st draft - topicsFactories of the Future (FoF)
2016 Title Type TRL Description Target
FoF.1Novel hybrid approaches for additive and subtractive
manufacturing machinesRIA 4-6
Développement de machines de production additive et substractive, pour la
réalsiation de produit en une seule étape3-5M€
FoF.2Machinery and robot systems in dynamic shop floor
environments using novel embedded cognitive functionsIA 5-7
Démonstrateur de ligne de production "flexible", doté de fonctions pour la
prise en compte de son environnement (opérateurs,...) et d'apprentissage
(reconfiguration, optimisation des ressources, de l'énergie...).
4-6M€
FoF.3Zero-defect strategies at system level for multi-stage
manufacturing in production linesIA 5-7
Outils et méthodes adaptés à la une chaine de production multi-étapes pour
prévenir l'apparition et la propagation de défauts4-6M€
FoF.4Continuous adaptation of work environments with
changing levels of automation in evolving production
systems
RIA 4-6L'adaptation continue des milieux de travail à l'évolution des niveaux
d'automatisation dans l'évolution des systèmes de production.3-5M€
FoF.5Support for the further development of Additive
Manufacturing technologies in Europe
Appui à la poursuite du développement des technologies de fabrication
additive en Europe.
0,75-1M€, 1
proposition
2017
FoF.6New product functionalities through advanced surface
manufacturing processes for mass productionRIA 4-6
FoF.7Integration of unconventional technologies for multi-
material processing into manufacturing systemsRIA 4-6
FoF.8In-line measurement and control for micro-/nano-
enabled high-volume manufacturing for enhanced
reliability
IA 5-7
FoF.9Novel design and predictive maintenance technologies for
increased operating life of production systemsIA 5-7
FoF.10New technologies and life cycle management for
reconfigurable and reusable customised productsIA 5-7
CSA
1Work Program 2016-2017
1st draft - topics
2016 Title Type TRL Description
SPIRE.1Systematic approaches for resource-efficient water
management systems in process industriesIA 5-7
Optimisation de l'utilisation d'eau dans les procédés industriels, diverses
approches sont proposées.5-7M€
SPIRE.2Plant-wide monitoring and control of data-intensive
processesRIA 4-6
Développement de modèles et de systèmes de contrôle pour l'optimisation
des processus au sein de l'ensemble d'une usine.4-6M€
SPIRE.3Industrial technologies for the valorisation of European
bio-resources into high added value process streamsIA 5-7
Technologies de valorisation de résidus de la biomasse pour la production de
produits ou précurseurs à haute valeur ajoutée5-7M€
SPIRE.4Industrial furnace design addressing energy efficiency in
new and existing furnacesRIA 4-6
Nouveaux (ou rénovation de) fours industriels à plus faible impact (energie,
environnement, coût)5-7M€
SPIRE.5Potential use of CO2 and non-conventional fossil natural
resources in Europe as feedstock for the process industry
Evaluation de technologies et solutions pour la valorisation de sources C -
CO2/CO , sources fossiles non-conventionnelles - dans les procédés industriels
0,25-0,5M€, 1
proposition
SPIRE.6Business models for flexible and delocalised approaches
for intensified processingBusiness modèles pourune production intensifiée délocalisable et flexible.
0,25-0,5M€, 1
proposition
2017
SPIRE.7Integrated approach to process optimisation for raw
material resources efficiency, excluding recovery
technologies of waste streams
IA 5-7
SPIRE.8 CO2 Utilisation to produce high added value chemicals RIA 4-6
SPIRE.9Pilot lines based on more flexible and down-scaled high
performance processingIA 5-7
SPIRE.10New electrochemical solutions for industrial processing,
which contribute to a reduction of CO2 emissions RIA 4-6
SPIRE.11Support for the enhancement of the impact of SPIRE PPP
projects
SPIRE.12Assessment of standardisation needs and ways to
overcome regulatory bottlenecks in the process industry
CSA
CSA
CSA
CSA
Sustainable Process Industries (SPIRE)
1Work Program 2016-2017
1st draft - topics
Energy efficient Buildings (EeB)2016 Title Type TRL Description
EeB.1 Smart insulation materials with improved properties IA 5-7Développement de matériaux isolants et solutions d'isolation améliorées pour
la rénovation de batiments3-6M€
EeB.2Performance indicators and monitoring techniques for
energy-efficiency and environmental quality at building
and district level
Développement d'indicateurs de performance et de techniques de contrôle
pour améliorer l'efficacité énergétique et la qualité environnementale dans la
construction de bâtiment et au niveau du district.
0,25-0,5M€, 1
proposition
EeB.3Integration of advanced technologies for heating and
cooling at building and district level IA 5-7
Technologies de chauffage/climatisation appliquées à la rénovation de
bâtiment jusqu'au district.5-7M€
EeB.4New technologies and strategies for the development of
pre-fabricated elements through the reuse and recycling
of construction materials and structures
RIA 4-6Ré-utilisation ou recyclage de matériaux et structures pour la fabrication
d'éléments pré-fabriqués pour le bâtiment.3-5M€
2017
EeB.5 Development of near zero energy building renovation IA 5-7
EeB.6Highly efficient hybrid storage solutions for power and
heat in residential buildings and district areas, balancing
the supply and demand conditions.
RIA 4-6
EeB.7Integration of energy harvesting at building and district
levelIA 5-7
EeB.8New business models for energy-efficient buildings
through adaptable refurbishment solutions
CSA
CSA
1Work Program 2016-2017
1st draft - topics
2016 Title Type TRL Description
NMBP.1 Novel hybrid materials for heterogeneous catalysis RIA 3-5Nouveau matériau hybride (organique-inorganique) pour la catalyse
hétérogène5-8M€
NMBP.2Advanced Materials for Power Electronics based on wide
bandgap semiconductor devices technologyRIA 4-6
Matériaux avancés pour l'électronique de puissance basés sur la technologie
de SC à large bande interdite ?
NMBP.3Innovative and sustainable materials solutions for the
substitution of critical raw materials in the electric power
system
RIA 4-6Solutions de matériaux innovants et durables pour la substitution de matières
premières critiques appliquées à des systèmes d'alimentation électrique.3-5M€
NMBP.8Accelerating the uptake of nanotechnologies, advanced
materials or advanced manufacturing and processing
technologies by SMEs
Valorisation des nanotechnologies, des matériaux avancés et des systèmes de
production par les PME
2017
NMBP.4Architectured/Advanced material concepts for intelligent
bulk material structuresRIA 4-6
NMBP.5Design-driven advanced materials for high added value
innovative productsIA 5-7
NMBP.6Improved material durability in buildings and
infrastructures, including offshoreRIA 4-6
NMBP.7Systems of materials characterisation for model, product
and process optimisationRIA 4-6
NMBP.8Accelerating the uptake of nanotechnologies, advanced
materials or advanced manufacturing and processing
technologies by SMEs
PME
PME
Advanced materials and nanotechnologies for high added value produsts and process industries
1Work Program 2016-2017
1st draft - topics
Green vehicle 2016 Title Type TRL Description
NMBP.9Affordable weight reduction of high-volume vehicles and
components taking into account the entire life-cycleRIA 4-6
Réduction du poids de véhicule de grande capacité, à coût compétitif et
prenant en compte le cycle de vie5-8M€
2016 Title Type TRL Description
NMBP.10Biomaterials for treatment and prevention of multiple
sclerosisRIA 4-6
Biomatériaux multifonctionnels (outils ou produits thérapeutiques) pour le
traitement de sclérose multiple.?
NMBP.11 Nanoformulation of biologicals RIA 4-6 Formulation en nanomédecine de molécules biologiques 3-4M€
2017
NMBP.12Reference methods for managing the risk of engineered
BiomaterialsRIA 4-6
NMBP.13 Cross-KET for Health IA 4-6
NMBP.14Regulatory Science Framework for assessment of
risk‑benefit ratio of Nanomedicines and BiomaterialsIA 3-7
NMBP.15 Upscaling of the production of nanopharmaceuticals RIA 4-6
NMBP.16Nanotechnologies for imaging cellular transplants and
regenerative processes in vivoRIA 4-6
NMBP.17 Mobilising the European nano-biomedical ecosystem
NMBP.18 ERA-NET on Nanomedicine ERA-NET
CSA
Advances materials and nanotechnologies for healthcare
1Work Program 2016-2017
1st draft - topics
2016 Title Type TRL Description
NMBP.19Advanced materials solutions and architectures for high
efficiency solar energy harvestingRIA 4-6
Solutions matériaux pour de nouvelles technologies de captage solaire (PV ou
CSP) à très haut rendement.3-5M€
NMBP.20Advanced materials enabling the integration of storage
technologies in the electricity gridIA 5-7
Matériaux avancés contribuant à l'intégration de solutions de stockage dans le
réseau électrique (hors électronique de puissance).6-8M€
2017
NMBP.21Cost-effective materials for “power-to-chemical”
technologiesRIA 4-6
NMBP.22 High-performance materials for optimizing CO2 capture IA 5-7
2016 Title Type TRL Description
NMBP.23ERA-Net on manufacturing technologies supporting
industry and particularly SMEs in the global competitionPoursuite des activités ManuNet sur le manufacturing
10-15M€, 1
proposition
2017
NMBP.24Business models and industrial strategies supporting novel
supply chains for innovative product-servicesRIA 4-6
Advanced materials and nanotechnologies for energy applications
Eco-design and new sustainable business models
ERA-NET
1Work Program 2016-2017
1st draft - topics
Remarks from Member states
To much TRL 7 => Private participation for these projects
EC will make adjustment relative to TRL 7.
Take into account about proposals made by Advisory
Group :- less topics
- Reduce TRL Réduction TRL targeted (ex 4-5 instead of de 4-6)
- Link programs (ex: Spire & matériaux)
1
Objectif : répondre aux appels à projets européens
REGISTRATIONS ARE OPEN !
until June 19th
3 key activities in 1 day
* Plenary session : 3 high level experts’
advices for excellent EU proposals * Thematic parallel pitch sessions : #1 : Smart factory & Innovative Processes #2 : Green processes & Energy Efficiency #3 : Efficient transports & Logistics #4 : Bottom-up session for Fast Track to Innovation and SME instrument * B2B meetings
(select your meeting now!)
Why participate?
To improve project proposals success rate understanding EC expectations for 2016-2017 building upon the feedback from the first calls. To raise interest among the European audience presenting your project idea or expert profile during thematic “pitch sessions.”
To find your future partners among major companies, SMEs, universities and research organisations during pre-arranged B2B meetings.
REGISTRATIONS ARE OPEN !
until June 19th
3 key activities in 1 day
* Plenary session : 3 high level experts’
advices for excellent EU proposals * Thematic parallel pitch sessions : #1 : Smart factory & Innovative Processes #2 : Green processes & Energy Efficiency #3 : Efficient transports & Logistics #4 : Bottom-up session for Fast Track to Innovation and SME instrument * B2B meetings
(select your meeting now!)
Why participate?
To improve project proposals success rate understanding EC expectations for 2016-2017 building upon the feedback from the first calls. To raise interest among the European audience presenting your project idea or expert profile during thematic “pitch sessions.”
To find your future partners among major companies, SMEs, universities and research organisations during pre-arranged B2B meetings.
https://www.b2match.eu/ eubrokerageadvanced
manufacturing2015
+ 1 more day for the UK delegation
1Thank you
for your
attention
Sébastien LEROYMob.: +33 (0)6 48 49 96 46
Business Development Manager
www.irt-jules-verne.fr
Olivia CAHNEuropean Project Manager
Mob. : +33 (0)6 72 32 29 12
www.pole-emc2.com