first eage workshop on evaluation - erdwerk · the productivity of geothermal wells in the...

28

Upload: others

Post on 24-Jul-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: First EAGE Workshop on Evaluation - ERDWERK · The productivity of geothermal wells in the carbonate reservoir of the Malm not a question about a structural OR facies orientated exploration
Page 2: First EAGE Workshop on Evaluation - ERDWERK · The productivity of geothermal wells in the carbonate reservoir of the Malm not a question about a structural OR facies orientated exploration

® Erdwerk GmbH 2017 2

First EAGE Workshop on Evaluation

and Drilling of Carbonate Reservoirs

Kilian Beichel: Geologist – ERDWERK GmbH

Co-Authors: Steiner U., Savvatis A., Böhm F.

The Upper Jurassic In

Southern Germany –

A Carbonate Aquifer For

Geothermal Exploration

04.10.2017

Page 3: First EAGE Workshop on Evaluation - ERDWERK · The productivity of geothermal wells in the carbonate reservoir of the Malm not a question about a structural OR facies orientated exploration

® Erdwerk GmbH 2017 3

1. ERDWERK GmbH at a Glance

2. The Southern German Molasse Basin

3. The Upper Jurassic in Southern Germany

4. Geological Exploration Targets – State of Play and Current Challenges

1. Structural Geology – Faults

2. Primary facies – Diagenesis

3. Karstification

5. Conclusion

6. Discussion

Outline

Page 4: First EAGE Workshop on Evaluation - ERDWERK · The productivity of geothermal wells in the carbonate reservoir of the Malm not a question about a structural OR facies orientated exploration

ERDWERK at a glance …

• Founded in 2002 by Dr. Achim

Schubert

• Leading consultant for design and

project management of geothermal

projects in South Germany

• Currently active in Germany,

Belgium, Switzerland, UK, Costa-

Rica and Tanzania.

• Over 110,000 m planned and drilled

® Erdwerk GmbH 2017 4

Page 5: First EAGE Workshop on Evaluation - ERDWERK · The productivity of geothermal wells in the carbonate reservoir of the Malm not a question about a structural OR facies orientated exploration

5 5 5

Southern German Molasse Basin

Source: ©BGR Source: udo-leuschner.de

® Erdwerk GmbH 2017

Southern German

Molasse basin

Page 6: First EAGE Workshop on Evaluation - ERDWERK · The productivity of geothermal wells in the carbonate reservoir of the Malm not a question about a structural OR facies orientated exploration

6 6 6

Geology of the Molasse Basin

® Erdwerk GmbH 2017

Adapted from ‘Geologische Karte von Bayern 1:500000’, Bayerisches Geologisches Landesamt,1996

~ 150 °C

~ 80 °C

~ 130 km Depth

[m NN]

Munich Alpine

Nappes

Upper Jurassic

Reservoir

„Malm“

N-S Schematic Cross Section

Page 7: First EAGE Workshop on Evaluation - ERDWERK · The productivity of geothermal wells in the carbonate reservoir of the Malm not a question about a structural OR facies orientated exploration

® Erdwerk GmbH 2017 7

Paleogeographic situation

MEYER & SCHMIDT-KALER 1996

Page 8: First EAGE Workshop on Evaluation - ERDWERK · The productivity of geothermal wells in the carbonate reservoir of the Malm not a question about a structural OR facies orientated exploration

Geothermal Development in Bavaria

® Erdwerk GmbH 2017 8

Page 9: First EAGE Workshop on Evaluation - ERDWERK · The productivity of geothermal wells in the carbonate reservoir of the Malm not a question about a structural OR facies orientated exploration

The Malm has the characteristics of many different aquifer types

® Erdwerk GmbH 2017 9

Characteristics of the Malm Aquifer

Page 10: First EAGE Workshop on Evaluation - ERDWERK · The productivity of geothermal wells in the carbonate reservoir of the Malm not a question about a structural OR facies orientated exploration

® Erdwerk GmbH 2017 10

History of Exploration Strategy

Faults

Facies

vs.

Page 11: First EAGE Workshop on Evaluation - ERDWERK · The productivity of geothermal wells in the carbonate reservoir of the Malm not a question about a structural OR facies orientated exploration

® Erdwerk GmbH 2017 11

• Structural Geology – Faults/Fractures

• Primary Facies & Diagenesis – Matrix Porosity

• Karstifikation - Corrosion

Key Factors for Productive Geothermal Wells

Page 12: First EAGE Workshop on Evaluation - ERDWERK · The productivity of geothermal wells in the carbonate reservoir of the Malm not a question about a structural OR facies orientated exploration

® Erdwerk GmbH 2017 12

155195

195195

235195

275195

315195

354195

394195

434195

474195

514195

554195

594195

634195

Composite line 8

XLine 317

Composite line 9

XLine 260

XLIL

N S

0

-500

-1000

-1500

-2000

-2500

-3000

-3500

-1000.00-750.00-500.00-250.000.00250.00500.00750.001000.00

Seismic (default)

Key Factors for Productive Geothermal Wells

Structural Geology – Normal Faulting

Page 13: First EAGE Workshop on Evaluation - ERDWERK · The productivity of geothermal wells in the carbonate reservoir of the Malm not a question about a structural OR facies orientated exploration

® Erdwerk GmbH 2017 13

Primary Facies - Diagenesis

• High water-energy carbonates favour dolomitization

• Controlled by the degree of purity of the carbonates

• Size and shape of the dolomite crystals are controlled by the amount of insolvable

residues inside the primary carbonate

• Size and shape of the dolomite crystals are controlling the porostity and

permeability of the matrix

Key Factors for Productive Geothermal Wells

Koch 1997

Page 14: First EAGE Workshop on Evaluation - ERDWERK · The productivity of geothermal wells in the carbonate reservoir of the Malm not a question about a structural OR facies orientated exploration

Hydrostratigraphic Modell

Combination of Facies and Hydrostratigraphical Model

® ERDWERK GmbH 2017 14

Aquifer Aquitard

Page 15: First EAGE Workshop on Evaluation - ERDWERK · The productivity of geothermal wells in the carbonate reservoir of the Malm not a question about a structural OR facies orientated exploration

Analogous Studies Malm Relief

® Erdwerk GmbH 2017

Page 16: First EAGE Workshop on Evaluation - ERDWERK · The productivity of geothermal wells in the carbonate reservoir of the Malm not a question about a structural OR facies orientated exploration

® Erdwerk GmbH 2017

Bedded Facies Massive Facies

Type A - thin bedded facies

Type B - thick bedded facies

Type C – massive facies - limestone

Type D massive facies – bioherm

Type E – massive facies - dolomite

Essentially

for the

facies model

Facies Interpretation Using Imagelogs

Page 17: First EAGE Workshop on Evaluation - ERDWERK · The productivity of geothermal wells in the carbonate reservoir of the Malm not a question about a structural OR facies orientated exploration

® Erdwerk GmbH 2017 17

Facies Model of the Malm in the Molasse Subsurface (after Mayer 1994)

Facies Interpretation Using Imagelogs

Page 18: First EAGE Workshop on Evaluation - ERDWERK · The productivity of geothermal wells in the carbonate reservoir of the Malm not a question about a structural OR facies orientated exploration

® Erdwerk GmbH 2017 18

Imagelog classification

Mud/Wakestone

Bedded Facies

Pack/Grainstone

Dolomite

Facies Interpretation Using Imagelogs

Page 19: First EAGE Workshop on Evaluation - ERDWERK · The productivity of geothermal wells in the carbonate reservoir of the Malm not a question about a structural OR facies orientated exploration

® Erdwerk GmbH 2017 19

Locally

dolomitization

of Bioherm

Facies

Sponge

Bioclasts

Coral

Bioclasts

Coral in a

well-core of

the Upper

Jurassic

Malmian

Dolomitization Processes in Massive Facies

Facies Interpretation in Seismic Data

Page 20: First EAGE Workshop on Evaluation - ERDWERK · The productivity of geothermal wells in the carbonate reservoir of the Malm not a question about a structural OR facies orientated exploration

20

Facies Interpretation in Seismic Data

® Erdwerk GmbH 2017

Light blue: Top Massfacies

Page 21: First EAGE Workshop on Evaluation - ERDWERK · The productivity of geothermal wells in the carbonate reservoir of the Malm not a question about a structural OR facies orientated exploration

21

Facies Interpretation supported by seismic attributs

Attribut Isofrequency 15 Hz, spectral decomposition

® Erdwerk GmbH 2017

Facies Interpretation in Seismic Data

Page 22: First EAGE Workshop on Evaluation - ERDWERK · The productivity of geothermal wells in the carbonate reservoir of the Malm not a question about a structural OR facies orientated exploration

® Erdwerk GmbH 2017 22

Example of a Relief Map of the Top Massive Facies

Facies Interpretation in Seismic Data

Page 23: First EAGE Workshop on Evaluation - ERDWERK · The productivity of geothermal wells in the carbonate reservoir of the Malm not a question about a structural OR facies orientated exploration

® Erdwerk GmbH 2017 23

Karstification

Large-scale

Karstification

Sinkholes – Collapse

structures

Page 24: First EAGE Workshop on Evaluation - ERDWERK · The productivity of geothermal wells in the carbonate reservoir of the Malm not a question about a structural OR facies orientated exploration

® Erdwerk GmbH 2017 24

Page 25: First EAGE Workshop on Evaluation - ERDWERK · The productivity of geothermal wells in the carbonate reservoir of the Malm not a question about a structural OR facies orientated exploration
Page 26: First EAGE Workshop on Evaluation - ERDWERK · The productivity of geothermal wells in the carbonate reservoir of the Malm not a question about a structural OR facies orientated exploration

® Erdwerk GmbH 2017 26

Conclusion

The productivity of geothermal wells in the carbonate reservoir of

the Malm not a question about a structural OR facies orientated

exploration strategy, but is controlled by a complex interplay of

different geological factors like primary facies, diagenesis,

structural geology and especially karstification.

To further reduce the exploration risk, a deeper insight of the

seismic data is nessecery. Profound knowledge of geology and

hydrogeology of the Malm from drilled wells is the basic

rerequisite for this.

Page 27: First EAGE Workshop on Evaluation - ERDWERK · The productivity of geothermal wells in the carbonate reservoir of the Malm not a question about a structural OR facies orientated exploration

® Erdwerk GmbH 2010 27

Thank you!

Page 28: First EAGE Workshop on Evaluation - ERDWERK · The productivity of geothermal wells in the carbonate reservoir of the Malm not a question about a structural OR facies orientated exploration

® Erdwerk GmbH 2017 28

Karstification