field experiences on lsd vaccination in turkey · esra satir, serdar uzar, ayşe parmaksiz, hakan...

27
Field Experiences on LSD Vaccination in TURKEY REPUBLIC OF TURKEY MINISTRY OF FOOD, AGRICULTURE AND LIVESTOCK Dr. Esra SATIR National Reference Laboratory for LSD and SGP Pendik Veterinary Control Institute İstanbul/TURKEY Third Meeting (LSD 3) Standing Group of Experts on Lumpy Skin Disease in South-East Europe under the GF-TADs umbrella 12-13 December 2016, İSTANBUL, TURKEY

Upload: others

Post on 09-Jul-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Field Experiences on LSD Vaccination in TURKEY · Esra SATIR, Serdar UZAR, Ayşe PARMAKSIZ, Hakan ENÜL, Orbay SAYI, Pendik Veterinary Control Institute. Özhan TÜRKYILMAZ, Cihangir

Field Experiences on LSD Vaccination in TURKEY

REPUBLIC OF TURKEY MINISTRY OF FOOD, AGRICULTURE AND

LIVESTOCK

Dr. Esra SATIR National Reference Laboratory for LSD and SGP

Pendik Veterinary Control Institute İstanbul/TURKEY

Third Meeting (LSD 3) Standing Group of Experts on Lumpy Skin Disease

in South-East Europe under the GF-TADs umbrella

12-13 December 2016, İSTANBUL, TURKEY

Page 2: Field Experiences on LSD Vaccination in TURKEY · Esra SATIR, Serdar UZAR, Ayşe PARMAKSIZ, Hakan ENÜL, Orbay SAYI, Pendik Veterinary Control Institute. Özhan TÜRKYILMAZ, Cihangir

SYRİA ???

IRAQ

GEORGİA

ARMENİA

IR

A

N

2013

LSD OUTBREAKS SEPTEMBER-DECEMBER 2013

Page 3: Field Experiences on LSD Vaccination in TURKEY · Esra SATIR, Serdar UZAR, Ayşe PARMAKSIZ, Hakan ENÜL, Orbay SAYI, Pendik Veterinary Control Institute. Özhan TÜRKYILMAZ, Cihangir

Situation & Activities (in 2013)

LSD control strategy ;

Veterinary Services, Plant Health, Food and Feed Law no: 5996 and in compliance with Council Directive 92/119/EEC except slaughtering.

Restriction, Quarantine, Sampling, Diagnosis

Control of animal movements

Cleaning and Disinfection in outbreak areas

Insect control

Vaccination in outbreak area.

Page 4: Field Experiences on LSD Vaccination in TURKEY · Esra SATIR, Serdar UZAR, Ayşe PARMAKSIZ, Hakan ENÜL, Orbay SAYI, Pendik Veterinary Control Institute. Özhan TÜRKYILMAZ, Cihangir

Vaccine

Because of antigenic homology and cross-protection between sheep pox, goat pox and LSD virus, any of these viruses can be used as a vaccine strain to protect cattle against LSD.

Four live attenuated capripox virus strains are used for vaccine production(OIE, 2010).

Kenyan sheep pox

Yugoslavian RM 65

Romanian sheep pox

South African Neethling strains

Page 5: Field Experiences on LSD Vaccination in TURKEY · Esra SATIR, Serdar UZAR, Ayşe PARMAKSIZ, Hakan ENÜL, Orbay SAYI, Pendik Veterinary Control Institute. Özhan TÜRKYILMAZ, Cihangir

LSD Vaccination

In 1975, Sheep and Goat Pox disease occured in Bakırköy district of İstanbul. The local strain (Bakırköy strain) isolated from outbreak by Pendik Veterinary Control Institute.

After 65 passages in primary lamb kidney cell culture, vaccine strain attenuated and lyophilized. This vaccine (Penpox-M) contains at least TCID50 102,5 viruses per dose and it is still currently in use against LSD.

In 2013, Penpox – M used one dose (102,5 TCID) per cattle as OIE Manual remarked.

Page 6: Field Experiences on LSD Vaccination in TURKEY · Esra SATIR, Serdar UZAR, Ayşe PARMAKSIZ, Hakan ENÜL, Orbay SAYI, Pendik Veterinary Control Institute. Özhan TÜRKYILMAZ, Cihangir

Situation & Activities (in 2014 )

Payment of compensation (2014)

Eradication of the disease and may occur as a result of loss compensation in 2014 was added to the list of compensation diseases

Positive laboratory result and clinically symptomatic animals in outbreak zone compensated to the owners (50 % of the animal value)

Page 7: Field Experiences on LSD Vaccination in TURKEY · Esra SATIR, Serdar UZAR, Ayşe PARMAKSIZ, Hakan ENÜL, Orbay SAYI, Pendik Veterinary Control Institute. Özhan TÜRKYILMAZ, Cihangir

Vaccination Zone in 2014

Number of animals vaccinated 1.590.757

Programme Total 43 Provinces

outbreak areas their neighboring provinces

high risk provinces

Allowed to Animal Movement providing disease ended and 30 days after vaccination

Free provinces

İnfected provinces

Page 8: Field Experiences on LSD Vaccination in TURKEY · Esra SATIR, Serdar UZAR, Ayşe PARMAKSIZ, Hakan ENÜL, Orbay SAYI, Pendik Veterinary Control Institute. Özhan TÜRKYILMAZ, Cihangir

LSD Outbreaks & Years (2013-2014)

18

784

0

200

400

600

800

1000

2013 Agust-Dec 2014

Page 9: Field Experiences on LSD Vaccination in TURKEY · Esra SATIR, Serdar UZAR, Ayşe PARMAKSIZ, Hakan ENÜL, Orbay SAYI, Pendik Veterinary Control Institute. Özhan TÜRKYILMAZ, Cihangir

LSD Outbreaks (2014)

Total 784 outbreaks

Page 10: Field Experiences on LSD Vaccination in TURKEY · Esra SATIR, Serdar UZAR, Ayşe PARMAKSIZ, Hakan ENÜL, Orbay SAYI, Pendik Veterinary Control Institute. Özhan TÜRKYILMAZ, Cihangir

Observation and Evaluation of 2014 Some vaccinated animal was sick after vaccination ;

Animals in the incubation period of disease

Biological properties (Lactation, pregnancy, weak body condition) are very effect to occur the LSD; Predispose factors

The intencity of the outbreaks in region is an other factor.

Vaccination failure(cold chain, sunlight…)

Subcilinical infected animals (after the quarantina period (30 days) the animals are allowed to move from the outbreaks areas) is a source of tranmission of the disease.

Kurban festival is a potential risk for transmisson of the LSD to far away and control measures should be increased in this period.

Climatic changes and geografical status are very effected to occurance of the disease (long

summers and late coming winter, wetlands, altitude, plant cover)

Page 11: Field Experiences on LSD Vaccination in TURKEY · Esra SATIR, Serdar UZAR, Ayşe PARMAKSIZ, Hakan ENÜL, Orbay SAYI, Pendik Veterinary Control Institute. Özhan TÜRKYILMAZ, Cihangir

Situation & Activities (2015) All provinces in Turkey were included in the vaccination campaign. Vaccination determined by

each local authority (because of differences between their climate conditions, geografical status and housbandry sytem)

Vaccine dose was increased to 3 times doses sheep and goat pox vaccine (Penpox)

Vaccination campaign was planned for all cattle populations (older than 3 months and under 9 months pregnant)

Compensation rate of 2015 was raised from %50 to % 100.

Control of vaccination before animal movement after the completion of the vaccination campaign

Page 12: Field Experiences on LSD Vaccination in TURKEY · Esra SATIR, Serdar UZAR, Ayşe PARMAKSIZ, Hakan ENÜL, Orbay SAYI, Pendik Veterinary Control Institute. Özhan TÜRKYILMAZ, Cihangir

Vaccination Zone 2015

Programme: Whole country

Allowed to Animal Movement providing disease ended and 30 days after

vaccination

(2015) Number of animals vaccinated:

8.125.947

Page 13: Field Experiences on LSD Vaccination in TURKEY · Esra SATIR, Serdar UZAR, Ayşe PARMAKSIZ, Hakan ENÜL, Orbay SAYI, Pendik Veterinary Control Institute. Özhan TÜRKYILMAZ, Cihangir

LSD Outbreaks (2015)

Total 510 outbreaks,

Page 14: Field Experiences on LSD Vaccination in TURKEY · Esra SATIR, Serdar UZAR, Ayşe PARMAKSIZ, Hakan ENÜL, Orbay SAYI, Pendik Veterinary Control Institute. Özhan TÜRKYILMAZ, Cihangir

Programme: Whole country

(2016) Number of animals vaccinated:

9.846.506

Allowed to Animal Movement providing disease ended and 30 days after

vaccination

Situation & Activities (2016)

Page 15: Field Experiences on LSD Vaccination in TURKEY · Esra SATIR, Serdar UZAR, Ayşe PARMAKSIZ, Hakan ENÜL, Orbay SAYI, Pendik Veterinary Control Institute. Özhan TÜRKYILMAZ, Cihangir

Monthly LSD reports from 2013 to 2016

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

Au

gust

20

13

Sep

tem

be

r 2

01

3

Oct

ob

er

20

13

No

vem

be

r 2

01

3

De

cem

ber

20

13

Jan

uar

y 2

01

4

Feb

ruar

y 2

01

4

Mar

ch 2

01

4

Ap

ril 2

01

4

May

20

14

Jun

e 2

01

4

July

20

14

Au

gust

20

14

Sep

tem

be

r 2

01

4

Oct

ob

er

20

14

No

vem

be

r 2

01

4

De

cem

ber

20

14

Jan

uar

y 2

01

5

Feb

ruar

y 2

01

5

Mar

ch 2

01

5

Ap

ril 2

01

5

May

20

15

Jun

e 2

01

5

July

20

15

Au

gust

20

15

Sep

tem

be

r 2

01

5

Oct

ob

er

20

15

No

vem

be

r 2

01

5

De

cem

ber

20

15

Jan

uar

y 2

01

6

Feb

ruar

y 2

01

6

Mar

ch 2

01

6

Ap

ril 2

01

6

May

20

16

Jun

e 2

01

6

July

20

16

Agu

st 2

01

6

Sep

tem

be

r 2

01

6

Oct

ob

er

20

16

No

vem

be

r 2

01

6

2013-2016 LSD Outbreaks

Page 16: Field Experiences on LSD Vaccination in TURKEY · Esra SATIR, Serdar UZAR, Ayşe PARMAKSIZ, Hakan ENÜL, Orbay SAYI, Pendik Veterinary Control Institute. Özhan TÜRKYILMAZ, Cihangir

LSD outbreaks month by month between 2013 - 2016

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

LSD Outbreaks month by month

2013

2014

2015

2016

Page 17: Field Experiences on LSD Vaccination in TURKEY · Esra SATIR, Serdar UZAR, Ayşe PARMAKSIZ, Hakan ENÜL, Orbay SAYI, Pendik Veterinary Control Institute. Özhan TÜRKYILMAZ, Cihangir

Province District Village

#

exposed

cattle

#

Infected

Cattle

#

Dead Cattle

Morbidity

(%)

Mortality

(%)

Kahraman

maraş Elbistan Çatova 17 10 4 58,8 23,5

Kahraman

maraş Elbistan Çatova 6 1 0 16,7 0,0

Kahraman

maraş Elbistan Çatova 15 5 0 33,3 0,0

Kahraman

maraş Elbistan Kalealtı 7 1 0 14,3 0,0

Batman

Gerçüş Karalan 190 13 8 6,8 4,2

Early outbreak in Turkey

Page 18: Field Experiences on LSD Vaccination in TURKEY · Esra SATIR, Serdar UZAR, Ayşe PARMAKSIZ, Hakan ENÜL, Orbay SAYI, Pendik Veterinary Control Institute. Özhan TÜRKYILMAZ, Cihangir

Evaluation of Penpox M Vaccine based on one dose

Risk factor Category Population

at risk

Diseased Incidence

risk

p-value

Age (months)

<24 347 4 1.15 p<0.001

24-48 193 14 7.25

>48 199 31 15.58

Total 739 49 6.63

Gender*

Male 207 3 1.45 p<0.001

Female 514 46 8.95

Total 721 49 6.80

Breed

Local 129 9 6.98 p>0.05

European 254 20 7.87

Cross 356 20 5.62

Total 739 49 6.63

Vaccination

Yes 399 17 4.26 p=0.005

No 340 32 9.41

Total 739 49 6.63

In questionnaires, detailed data (individual biodata): 39 dairy farms, 739 animals in 16 villages .

Vaccination status data was collected from the farms 7074 animals in the same villages.

49 sick animals

20 animals unvacc. 29 animals become ill

after vacc. 17 animals become

ill within 28 days after vacc.

12 animals become ill after next 28 days or more after vacc.

Page 19: Field Experiences on LSD Vaccination in TURKEY · Esra SATIR, Serdar UZAR, Ayşe PARMAKSIZ, Hakan ENÜL, Orbay SAYI, Pendik Veterinary Control Institute. Özhan TÜRKYILMAZ, Cihangir

One dose vaccine efficacy in 2014

Yahyalı District, Kayseri Province

#cattle #vaccinated #unvaccinated #Total

İnfected 17 32 49

Noninfected 6836 928 7764

Total 6853 960 7813

Efficacy(%) 92,56 Morbidity(%) 0,2

Three dose vaccine efficacy in 2016

Foça District, İzmir Province

#cattle #vaccinated #unvaccinated #Total

İnfected 34 11 45

Noninfected 1426 0 1426

Total 1460 11 1471

Efficacy(%) 97,67 Morbidity(%) 0.2

Three dose vaccine efficacy in 2015

Uzunköprü District, Edirne Province

#cattle #vaccinated #unvaccinated #Total

İnfected 35 20 55

Noninfected 6581 19 6600

Total 6616 39 6655

Efficacy(%) 98,96 Morbidity(%) 0.5

Study area: Villages where LSD occurred in district level

District level screenning

Page 20: Field Experiences on LSD Vaccination in TURKEY · Esra SATIR, Serdar UZAR, Ayşe PARMAKSIZ, Hakan ENÜL, Orbay SAYI, Pendik Veterinary Control Institute. Özhan TÜRKYILMAZ, Cihangir

Clinical Symptom After Vaccination

Page 21: Field Experiences on LSD Vaccination in TURKEY · Esra SATIR, Serdar UZAR, Ayşe PARMAKSIZ, Hakan ENÜL, Orbay SAYI, Pendik Veterinary Control Institute. Özhan TÜRKYILMAZ, Cihangir

1.,2., 3. And 4. Days After Inoculation Bovine Dermis Cell Lines

Isolation And Attenuaiton Study

Page 22: Field Experiences on LSD Vaccination in TURKEY · Esra SATIR, Serdar UZAR, Ayşe PARMAKSIZ, Hakan ENÜL, Orbay SAYI, Pendik Veterinary Control Institute. Özhan TÜRKYILMAZ, Cihangir

Request Project Of Vaccine Efficacy Study

«The use of Bakırköy sheep and goat pox virus vaccine strain for LSD of

cattle and the investigation of immun response»

Penpox-M is needed to reveal efficacy, effective dose and the duration of immunity in large animal populations by scientific studies.

Page 23: Field Experiences on LSD Vaccination in TURKEY · Esra SATIR, Serdar UZAR, Ayşe PARMAKSIZ, Hakan ENÜL, Orbay SAYI, Pendik Veterinary Control Institute. Özhan TÜRKYILMAZ, Cihangir

Field Observations in Turkey

In winter 2014 also 2015, outbreaks was continued slightly.

Outbreaks were seen close or far from water sources.

LSD outbreaks also occurred at all heights varying between 50 m to 1300 m by difference in Turkey.

This could be evidence that LSDV can be transmitted by other vector or by other ways which can survive in the environment for a long time or different conditions or different vector???

Page 24: Field Experiences on LSD Vaccination in TURKEY · Esra SATIR, Serdar UZAR, Ayşe PARMAKSIZ, Hakan ENÜL, Orbay SAYI, Pendik Veterinary Control Institute. Özhan TÜRKYILMAZ, Cihangir

Experiences Vaccination is the most important measure

Rate of vaccination (80-90%) and vaccination time (BEFORE VECTORAL ACTİVİTY)

Clinical survey must be done periodically.

Early detection and confirmation, culled and other control measures should be applied very quicly.

Control of animal movement very important especially for subclinical infected and infected in incubation period animals.

Vector control??

Page 25: Field Experiences on LSD Vaccination in TURKEY · Esra SATIR, Serdar UZAR, Ayşe PARMAKSIZ, Hakan ENÜL, Orbay SAYI, Pendik Veterinary Control Institute. Özhan TÜRKYILMAZ, Cihangir

By the end of June 2016, active and finished outbreaks in Turkey

Page 26: Field Experiences on LSD Vaccination in TURKEY · Esra SATIR, Serdar UZAR, Ayşe PARMAKSIZ, Hakan ENÜL, Orbay SAYI, Pendik Veterinary Control Institute. Özhan TÜRKYILMAZ, Cihangir

Acknowledgements

Esra SATIR, Serdar UZAR, Ayşe PARMAKSIZ, Hakan ENÜL, Orbay SAYI, Pendik Veterinary

Control Institute.

Özhan TÜRKYILMAZ, Cihangir GÜMÜŞTEPE, Sezai CİBELİK, General Directorate of Food and Control, Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Livestock.

İstanbul Directorate of Provincial Food Agriculture and Livestock

Nazan TÜRKASLAN Edirne Directorate of Provincial Food Agriculture and Livestock

Ergün TUĞLUK, Kayseri Directorate of Provincial Food Agriculture and Livestock

Page 27: Field Experiences on LSD Vaccination in TURKEY · Esra SATIR, Serdar UZAR, Ayşe PARMAKSIZ, Hakan ENÜL, Orbay SAYI, Pendik Veterinary Control Institute. Özhan TÜRKYILMAZ, Cihangir

www.tarim.gov.tr

Contact:

Republic of Turkey Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Livestock Eskişehir Yolu 9.Km., Lodumlu / ANKARA

THANKS FOR LISTENING