felton a. spears, et al v. washington mutual bank & eappraiseit first amended complaint &...
TRANSCRIPT
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 1/126
3
5
I
;>
0
k
8
34
33
35
373 tH .6
o >
30
[<o 0
38
54
53.
55
57
5;
5>
50
)<
51
IfsnKa. Brcvng" r.WTNG[NU TNG[NUPCJW
&MCJFL^N.T.G.[an50* @offrB0pfnrs uhokhjnThttseurna- njjsh'`vcjhc>5 8-[no9 (ko5_0;5-5744
@cx9 (;35')0;5-5748N-mcho9jbDssnm.gfm
MhgacnoK. Ercuj30<;30)EUC[HJOC\ LUFH.IT".G.3574; cjtcMfjhgcEo+k-"Wuhtn348OfsCjnnons. C 8445>[no9 (>34);5-<<>>@cx9 (734) 5-<<>0N-mcho9snrvhgnDercujocwnrfup.gfm
Hrc Wphrf 0<0;3_WTHUFMFWW -CUMWW" OT
H37<<\nstFovmfhg ovk..@h`[email protected] 8440;-3017[no9 034_57>-5;01@cx9 (734) 7>-5;>0N-mchohrcDsphrfmfss.gfm
CttfmNtsfr Tochjth`s
@NO[FJC. WTNCUW.U cjkWHKJNX WGAFOO.fjenaco`f`tanmsnovns jkcoo ftanrsshmhocroyshtuctnk,
Tochjth``s,
v.
\CWA[JL[FJMOrrqCO,HJG.c\csahjntfjgfmfrcthfj9
@HUW[CMNUHGCJ NCTTUCHWNH[.c Knocwcrngfmfrcthfj9cjkONJKNU'WWNUPHGN,-HJG.,
Icjnt hjk9rnrWfhnoenrn553850_OC\ F@@HGNWF@HW{N[
OHJKJNUWTHNOENUL35;44\hosahrnEovk..Wuhtn 44OfsCjsnons" C8445>[no9 (`o4)7851143@cx9 (734_5<1->871N-mchohoskhnoenrlDiosop.gfm
^J[[NKW[C[NWKHW[UHG[ GFH]U[
JFU[ANUJKHW[UHG[ FQ'GCOH@FUJHC
WCJIFWNKHXHWHFJ
GCWNJF.9>941-gv-44101UM_o)
GOCWWCG[HFJ
JF[HGN F@ MKO @'HOHJL
KNMCJK@FUIHIUX[UHCO
Jfogf ft [email protected]>9D"GP{411; UMHX}
Kn`njkcjts.
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 3 f` >
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 2/126
H
5
>
;.
>
0
1
8
34
33
t5
37
o;
3>
t0
3' <
31
3.8
54
5O
55
57
5;
5>
50
5<
51
TONCWN[CBN JF[HGNtactTochjth``s, @notfjC. Wpncm, r. cjkWhkjnyWgaf
ey cjk torfula tanhr ujknrshljnk fujsno,acvn`honk c Mfthfj `fr [rcjs`nrf` [cl
CofjlCgthfjtfMKOJf. o8o8whtatanIukhghcoTcjnofjMuothkhstrhgtohthlcthfj. [a
purpfsnf` tahs Mfthfj hs tfcsb anIukhghcoTcjnof trcjs`nr ancefvn-gcpthfjnkgthftf MKO Jf. 3838 fr gffrkhjcthfjcjk gfjsfohkcthfjf`prnthco prfgnnkhjlsmknr5
^.W.G.$3;4<en`frn an \nstnmKhsthgt f` \csahjltfjwanrncoo ftanr noctnkcgthfj
acvnennjgnjjcohznkey tan IukhghcoTcjno.
Tursucjt f tan Uuons f` Trfgnkurnf` tan Iukhghco Tcjno fj Muothkhsjhg
Ohthlcthfj, cppnjknk nrntfcrn tan `foofwhjl kfgumnjtsTochjth``s `honk en`frn tor
IukhghcoTcjno9)Mfthfj`fr[rcjs`nrf`[cl-CofjlCgthfjtfMKOJf.383825)E
hj Wuppfrt f` Mfthfj `fr [rcjs`nr f` [cl-Cofjl Cgthfj tf MKO Jf. 38382cjk 7
Wgankuon `Cgthfjs.
Kctnk9 ujn38,5441 WTNG[NUWTNG[NUNPCJWMCJFL^N,T.G.
Ev9 s/Ifsnfa. Brcvng. r.D
[an50tr@offrBfpjnrs uhokhjn
ThttseurntoTnjjsvovcjhc>538'[no9 (;35_0;5-5744@cx9 (;35_0;5-5748N-mcho9jbDssnrj-gfm
MhgacnoK. Ercuj.Nsqu`unEUCH]JOC\ LUF^T. .G.3574; cjtcMfjhgcEohk-. Wuhtn348OfsCjnnons.C 8445>[no9 (>34_;;5-<<>>@cx9 (734) ;5-<<>0N-mcho9snrvhgnDercujocwlrfup.gf
WTHUFMFWWE'CUJNWW.OT337<<\nstFovmphg ovk..@h`[email protected] 8440;-3017[no9 (334_57>-5;01@cx9 (734) 7>-5;>0N-mcho9rcDsphrfmfss.gfm
Jkgs ft [email protected] 0941₯P{t4;11 (UM\}
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 5 f` >
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 3/126
IcjntOhjkjnr Wphnoenrn 553850'oOC\ F@@HGNWF@ I,C3'.hN[OHJKJNU WTHNOENUL35;44\hosahrnEovk.. Wuhtn;44Ofs Cjsnons"GC 8445>[no9 (>34)>851143
@cx9(734)5<1->871
N-mcho osphnoenrlDiosop.gfm
Cttf rjqts f r T chjth`s
Jfkgnf` MKO mojlGCWNJF.9 >941;P{411; (Uot_w)
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 7 f` >
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 4/126
H
5
I
;
0
1
8
o4
o3
35
37
O;
3>
o0
t<31
t8
54
5o
55
57
5;
5>
50
) 3
51
TUFF@ F@ WNUXHGN
srC[N F@ TNJJWXOPCJHC] ,r.,
GF^J[Xf@COONLANJX )
H cmnmfofvnkj tan Gfujtvf`Coonpanjv. Wtctnf` Tnjjsvovcjhc- cm fvnr acnnf` 31 cjkaft-cf`r3y f tan whtahj cpkfj.Mv eushjnss kkrnsss [an50t @offBfppnrsEuhokhjl, Thttseurle Tnjjsyovcjhc >538.
Fj Iujn 38.5441.ushjn anJfrtanmKhstrhgt f` Gcoh`frjhc'sNongtrfjhgGcs@hohjl Wystnrqytta tjl NG@ HK rnlhstnrnk f IfsnpaJ. Brcvng,Ir., H `honk cjk snrvnmn kfguKrnjt(s)nsgjeng s9
JF[HGN F@MKO@'HOHJL
[anNG@ Wvstnms knshmnk tf cutfmcthgcoovsnjnrcrg jn-mchomnsscsnf cpcrthnsj toqn csnhwahgagfjsthtutnl nrvhgn.Cggfrkhhl tftan NG@/TCGNU ys[nm,fhahs gcsn,anpcrthnscrnslrvnk s foofws9
IcjntOhjkjnr Wphnoefl, Nsquhrn
ac Wphrf, Nsquhrn
Ufenrt rc Wphrf,Nsquhrn
MhgacnoK. Ercuj,Nsquhrn
Cttfrjnys `fr Tochjth``s
UfenrtI.T`hstnr, Nsquhrn
Mcrthj O. @hjnmcj,NsquhrnWtnpanjMhgacno Uummcln,Nsquhrn
WcmJ.Kcwffk,Nsquhrn
IfjctacjM. Oofyk Nsquhrn
Cttfrjny `fr Kn`njkcjt \csahjltfj Mutuco, Hjg.
OcurcIncj@fwonr,Nsquhrn
Cttfrjnys fr Kn`njkcjtnCpprchsno[
McrlcrntCjjnBncjn,Nsquhrn
BrhsAunGacuMcq Nsquhrn
CjlnocM. Tcpcocsbcrhs,squhrn
Garhstfpanr. GocroqNsquhrg
Bnvhj G. \coocgn,Nsquhrn
iosprnoenrlDisop.gfm
hrcDsphrfmfss.gfm
hrcDsphrfmfss.gfm
snrvhgnDercujocwlrfup.gfm
rp`hstnrDsteocw.gfm
mcrthj`hjnmcjDkwt.gfmstnvnrujrjclnDkwt.gfm
scmkcwffkDkwt.gfm
ifjctacjoofykDkwt.fm
o`fwonrDuracocw.gfm
mbncjnDko.gfm
bmcjDko.gfm
cpcpcocsDko.gfm
gigocrbDko.gfm
bwcoocgnDko.gfm
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln ; f` >
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 5/126
3
5
;>
0
1
8
34
33
o5
o7
<;
3>
<0
3<31
t8
54
5H
55
57
5;
5>
50
5<
51
In``hnyK.Uftnjenrl,squhrn irftnjenrlDpw.gfm
Uhgacrk@. AcjqNsquhrn racjsDtpw.gfm
Cttfrjnys fr Kn`njkcjtOWH Cpprchscof OG
Fj Iujn<8,5441,H snrvnk an kfgumnjt(s) nsgrhenk s9
JF[HGN F['MKO@'HOHJL
Sy.pocghjl c trun gfpy(hns)tanrnf` njgofsnk j c snconknjvnofpn(s)ckkrnssnkHfoofws9
Bnrry@fr{ Gl`tjhqla;m,squhrnTctrhgbI.Wmhta-Nstuhrn[acganrtf``hr& \ffkOOT[wf \frok @hjcjghcoGnjtnrJnwXfr_ JnwXfrb 34513
Cttfrjnys fr nCpprcosno[
Brhs A. Mcj"NsfuhrnKnwnv jk nEghnu` OTFjnNmecrgcknrfnjtnrWuhtn;44Wcj rcjghsgf,C 8;333-7038
Cttfrjnys fr OWH Cpprchsco,OOG
H snrvnkancefvn fgumnjt($ s foofws9
EX MCHO. H cm cmhohcrwhta tan`hrm'sprcgthgnf` gfoongthfjcjkfrfgnsshgfrrnspfjknjgnymchohjl. jknractprcgthgnt wfuokenknpfshtnkhta^.W.ffstsnrvhgNj actsc`rgkcvvktapfstcsnanrnfjhrooyprNfchktThttseurne-njjsvovchj tanfrkhjcry fursn-f`usthjnsso cmcwcrn-tactejmfthfjf` hork fcrtv'snrvsnrvhgnsprnshrmnkjvcohk pfstco cjgnoocthfjctn rffstcnn ntnr ct0s rhrfrn acfjnkcyc`tnrkctnf` knpfshtfr mchohjl j cjc``hkcvhto
'
. H cm,nmpolynkj tapf``hgnf` cjc`tfmny af s ckmhttnkprf cgvogn j tahcgufjcRwjfsnurngufjjnsnrvrgnwcs jcgn.
. kngocrn jknrpmco`y f` pnriuryujknran cwsf` tan jhtnkWtctnsact acKfvn s orun cjf gfr[ngt.
Nxngutnk jIujnO8,5441,ctThttseurla, njjsyovcjhc.
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln > f` >
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 6/126
' ' , 9 . ENH'FUN [AN I^KHGHCO TCJNO.FJ M[H[[HNHW[UHG[ OH[HLC[HFJ
.NUHWC'' OH[HLC[HFJ
)HJ UN \CWAHJL[FJ MOMHCO, HJG. )WNGHHUH[HNW,KEUHPC[MNCJK ) MKOKfgbntJf.3838
)
)
MF[HFJ @FU[UCJW@NUF@ [CL.COFJL CG[HFJ[F MKOJF. 3838
@notfj C. Wpncrs,Ir. cjkWhkjnyWgofoo, pochcth``s hj tan cgthfj styonkWpncrs,nt cH. v.
\csahjltfjutuco, jg.,nt co."Jf.>941-gv-44101rh.K.Gco,),nrneynspnft`hrooymfvnanTcjno
`fr cj Frknr rcjs`nrrhjlanhr cgthfj f tan jhtnk WtctnsKhstrhgt Gfurt fr tan \nstnrjKistrhgt f`
Wncttonfr gffrkhjctnk rntrhcoprfgnnkhjls hta thrn cgthfjscornckygnjhrcohznk spcrtf`MKO Jf.
3838gcpthfjnkHz rn9 \csahjltfjMutuco, Hjg., Wngcrhthns,Knrhvcthvn& "NJWC" Ohthlchfj. Hj
zuppfrtf` tanhr cfthfq Mr. Wpncr9sjk k.s. Wgafoo stctncs foofws9
3. 'Fj@nerucry53,5441,anTcjno njtrchhznk vnr wnjtycgthfjsclchjst\csamltfj
Mutuco, Hjg. `'\.cMu') hj.tan^jhtnk.-Wo7insh`rhgt Gfurt frtan \nstnmKhs`hgt f` \csahjltfj
wahga "sacrn cgtucoqunsthfjscrhshjl &fm coonlnk. hsrnprnsnrhtcthfjs r fmhsshfjsgfjgnmhjl
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-5 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 3 f` 70
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 7/126
\cMu's `hjccghco gfjkhthfjwhta rnspngt8
hts sueprhmnafmn fcjpfrt`fohf." Wn" Nxaheht 3,
[rcjs`nrFrknr,p. 3.
5. [anufknroyhjl cgarcogochms fr jncroycoo f`tan sngurhthns, nrhvc`hvl cjkNUHWC
cgthfjsgn,ortrcohznkursucjt3
`h9 [rcfs`nrFrknrs.\cor;u's oonlnk fjsphrcgywhta wf cpprchsco
mcml₯fxsjt fmpcruy`f9 tanpurpfsnf` \cMu fetrhhhhl `hcukuonjtoyahlaafmncpprchscosf
crth`hghcooy hj`octnton vcounf` hts afmnfm pfrt`fohf. [anecshs fr tanmcifrhtyf` tan gfmpochjos
gnortrcohznkj MKO 3838wcs anJnw Xfrb CttfmnyLnjnrco's fmpochjtclchjstfjn f` tan wf
cpprchscoqcjplnrjnjtffmpcjhns, hrst Cmnrhocj nCpprchsno[,cjkcoo f` tanacjs`nrrnkcgthfjs
wnrn honk suesnqunjtf tanCttfmnyLgc9nrco's gthfj"
7 Tochjthtrs@notfcC. Wpncrs,r, cjkWhkjnyWgafoo honk tanhrcgthfjclchjst\cMucjk
tan wf cpprchscomcjclnmnjtfmpcjhnscmnkj tan JnvrXfrb CttfmnyLnjnrco's fmpochjtfj
@nerucry1'5441 'Woncrs'). Tochjth`t hj tanWpncrs gthfjcoonln an scmncgarcoecshsujknroyhjl
`frtanhr gfjsumnr ochjrscs an gnjecohznk gthfjscoonln frtanhr sngurhthns, nrhvcthvn,cjkNUHWC
gochms - tacr o``cMu njt₯rnk jtf cj hoonlco gfjsphrcgywhta tan twf cpprchscom6jcln.mn
gfmpcjhns fr tanpurpfsnf` acvhjl ancpprchscomcjcln,mnjtfmpcjhns rfvhkn j`octnk afmn
cpprchscos f aco\cMu gfuokeujkon an fcjscjksnoo am fj an hjcjghcomcrbnts. nnNxaheht
5, @hrst Cmn,rrknk fmpochrt fr tan opncrscgthfu ``h0"8,77->0.
;. Fj@nerucry >,5441,onssacjcwnnben`frnon6cjno,s [rcjs`nrFrknrgcmn fwj,
\coPHuhonk cJfthgnf` [cl-cofjlCgthfj `fr Wpncrscssnrthjlact anWpncrscgthfjwcs cgtucooy
rnocInkf tanftanrcgthfjse.ctw₯trn vnjtucooy njtrcohznkj MKO 3838mktactoan Wpncrs gthfj
safuok ohbnwhsn en acjs`nrrnk f tan \nstnm Khstrhgt f`'ky'csahjltfj fr gffrkhjconkprnthco
prfgnnkhjls,fr'tangfjvnjhnjgn ` tanpcrthns jvfovnk- ,Wnn xaheht 7, \cMu,sJfthgnf` [cl-
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-5 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 5 f` 70
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 8/126
cofjlCgthfj,3o[3>-3<.
>. \covou'sJfthgnf`[cl-cofjlCgthfj`chonk fkntchoafw anWpncrs fjsumnr ochms
o,cktan nxcgtscm.ncgtucoecshscs an ftanrcfthfjs. Hk. Afwnvfr,\cMu crlunkact tan nxcgt
scmngfjsphrcgy jknroyhjlWpnczs' fjsumnr ochmswcsc rncsfj anTcjnosafuokgnjtrcohzn an
cgthfjs j MKO 3838 hj tan hjt pocgn.scnNxaheht; wcovou's Erhn`hj Wuppfrtf` wcMu,s Mfthfj
`fr [rcjs`nrf`Cgthfjs Tu$ucrt tf 51 u.s.g. $3;45p. 3(wcMu stcthjl act an gothms clchjst t
stnm rfm "cj coonlnkgfjsphrcgy ntwnnjwcMu] cjkcjcpprchsco njkfr,nCpprchsno[,nocxnk
tf cpprchsco coucthfjsfj fcjsfrhlhjctnkeywcMu]')2 pp.0-1(summ rhzhjl hvn gfmpochjtswhta
coonlc`hfjsaco \cMupueohsankmctnrhcooy cIsn jkmhsonckhjl tconmn,9rtstnoctnktf tancoonlnk
gfjsphrcgy')2p. 34(stc.thjlacomuothpon gfmpochjtsf` cgthfjswnjtucooy gffhkhjctnkj MKO Jf.
3838wnrn ecsnkfj"`t]an gfjsphrcgyn hj`octnsppposcovcounsfj rnshknjthco-sngurnkfcjswhta
tanlfcof` crthhghcooy hjgrncshjlfcj-tf-vcouncthfs,).
0. \anj tan TcjnognjtrcohznkMKO 3838cjk rcjs`nrnktan cgthfjs f tan \nstnrj
Khstrhgt f` \csahjltfj, rn Wpncrscgthfjwcs jft msjthfjnkfr gfjshknrnk y tanTcjno 9r hts
[rcjs`nrFrknr.Nxaheht3. Hr9stnch. pncrs.wcsnnmnkkmhjhstrc`hvnoytjrnoctnk'3.f KO 3838
ey tan Gonrb's f``hgncjkjf gfjkhthfjcorcjs`nr rcs ssunk-[anGonrb'sknghshfjwcsmcknwhtafut
nxpocjcthfjcs f weyWpncrgwcsknnmnk jrnoctnkf MKO 3838.
'3. Knsphtn anGonrb'sknghshfjf knnm. pncrs ,_mrnocank,, fMKO 3838tacWpncrs
cgthfj sacrns fmmfjqunsthfrsf` `cgt whta. an ftanrcgthfjscornckygnjtrcohznkj MKO 3838
rnlcrkhjlancoonlnk fjsphrcgyentwnnj cMu cjk tscpprchscomcjclnmnjtfmpmhns.C rngnjt
IfhjtTrnohr;hjtry Unpfrt h3nkey tanpcrthnsj MKO 3838gfj`rms tact an cgtucogfrnujknroyhjl
Ipncrs s tan scmn5>mcjy, ` jftcoo, f` tancgthfjscorncky njtrcohznkj MKO 3838. WnnNxaheht
-I -
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-5 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 7 f` 70
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 9/126
>, Ifhjt Trnohmhjcry Frknr. Wpngh`hgcooy, anIfhjt TrnohmhjcryFrknrsafws actc gnjtrco cgtuco
prnkhgctnf` tan fochmscoonlnkey tan mcifrhty f` tan gnjtrcohznk crthns s hmprfpnrcpprchsco
prcgthgnscjktan rnoctnk gfjsphrcgyentwnnjwcMu cjk ts cpprchsctmcjclnmnjt fmprjhns.
[ansncrn an srmn cgtucogochmsujknroyhjl tn gfjsumnr ochms j Wpnurs. Nxaheht 5, @hrsr
CmnjknkGfmpochjt,[` 0-8,77->0.
1. [_n Wpncrs cgthfj cosf sacrnsgfmmfj qunsthfjsf` `cgt rnlcrkhjl \cMu,s
sngurhthzcthfjprcgthgns`hts mfjlclns.Tochjth``s j tanWpncrs fkfjcoonln act anrncsfj\cyou
njtnrnkjtf ts gfjsphrcgywhtaan wfcpprchscomcjclnmnjtfmprjnstf hj`octnafmnvcounswcs
tf eujkon trn f9js cjksn3oan'mj tan`hmjghco mcrbntsfr suestcjthco rf`hts fvsrwact t wfuok
mcbn tan afmnswnrnprfpnroycpprchsnk. hrstCmnjknk fmpochj o`IR0,55-5;.wahon sghnjtnr
hs jft cjnonmnjtf` my f` tangcusns ` cgthfj j Ipncrq tanpochjth``s tanrnw'hoo jnnk f safw
\cMu'smfthvns ft tanhrpujhthvnkcmclnochms. k.,jjj,331, cjkprcynrctK.
8. Cs Wpncrssacrns an scmngfmmfj qunsthfjsf` `cgt cs tan cgthfjscorncky
gnjtcohznk j MKO h838, tanrnwho kupohgcthvnkhsgfvnrynlcrkhjl fta an coonlnk fjsphrcgy jk
\cMu'ssngurhthzhjlts afmnmfrtlclnfcjs. Wnn xaheht >,IfhjtWajrsUnpfrt,l<.1 (hknjth`yhjl
tan'Khsgfvnry[fphgs" f jgoukn,3ancgthfjs `kn`n,trkcjtshrst CmnrhgcjcjknCpprchnso[,".tan
cpprchsco ` tanprfpnrthnsujknrhyhjl\cMu's3fms," '3anpnfr9rhthzcIhfj 3ys3r;u'sqcjs,"cjk
"ncgakn`n,jkcjt'sjvfovnmnjtjtan c`frnmnjthfjnkgthvhthns . [rcjs`nrf`Wpncrsf tan\ns`nm
Khstrhft f` \csahjltfjs tanrn`frncpprfprhctnf cvfhk ankupohgcthvnkhsgfvnry act hs efujk f
ect9`r.cbt Wpncrs. j rn9 \csahjltfrzutuco,Hjg,, Wngwhthns,Knrhvcthvn&,,NJWC" Ohthlcthfj,
>70 @.Wupp.5k 37<<,37<1(Iuk"Tcj.Muot.Oht.5441)(gn,orrrcohzhjlrnthco prffnnkhjlsmuorhpon
cgthfjscoonlhjlfochmsecsnkfjtan scmnujknroyhjl cgtucocoonlcthfos c.sj Wpncrsc "nohmhjctn
-+
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-5 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln ; f` 70
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 10/126
kupohgcthvnkhsgfvnry').
34. Cs Wpncrs ecrnsanscmngfmmfj>uco qunsthfjsnlmkhjl\cHvHu'scpprchsco
prcgthgnscjk ts sngurhthzcthfj `afmn ofcjscs an cgthfjs n,jtrcohznkj MKO 3838, an ust cjk
n``hfhnjt gfjkugt f` tan ohthlcthfj whoo en prfmftnkey hts tcms`nr tf tan \nstnmKhstrhgt f`
\csahjltfjfr gffrkhjconk rnthco prfgnnkhjls hta MKO 3838,cjk rcjs`nrwhoo prfmftniutthghco
ngfjfmycjk gfjsnwc`hfj ` tanpcrthns'rnsfurgs. Hk {gnjtr,cohccltan gthfjs j MKO 3838 f
'ornvnjt hjgfjshstnjt rnthco ruohjls, *pnghcooywhta rnspngtf gocss nrth`hgcthfj2cjkgfjsnrvnan.
rnsfurgns `tanpcrthns,onhr gfursno cjk anukhghcry'). [rcjs`nj Wpncrsf MKO 38 8 whoo jft
fjoyprnvnjt angoncroykupohgcthvnkhsgfvnry,eut cosf njsurn fxoshstnrotrntrhcoruohjls rnlcrkhjl
hssunscefuttan coonlnkgfjqphrcgyentwnnf\'cMu
cck ts cpprcLcomcjclnmnjt fmpcjhns,
\cMu's sngurhthzcthfj ` hts afmnmfrtlclns, jk gocssgnrth`,ccohfj Hk.
PHHANUN@FUE,ursucrk f 51 ^.W.G. $ 3;4<,@notfj C Wpncrs, r. cjk WhkjnyWgafoo
rnspngo`uooy nqunst acotanTcjno rcjs`₯r tn Wpncrscgthfj f tan AfjfrceonMcrsacI.Tngemcr^
^jhtnk WtcrnsKhstrhgt Iukln fr tan \nstnrjKhsahgt f` \csahjlofj fr. gnjtrcohznkprnthco
prfgnnkhjlswhta tan ftanrshmhocr cgthfjs j MKO 3838. C Erhn` hj suppfrtf` tanhr mfthfj hs
cttcgank.
Kctnk9 ujn 38,5441 WTNG[NU TNG[NUNPCJW&H{CJFLHIN,T.G.
C
jr _),,."."53j. O--.*,t.0snfaJ. Brcvng"Ir. r
[an 50'@offr BfppnrsEuhokhjlTh`hseurla,Tnqmsyovcjhc >538[nonpafjn9 ;35)0;5-1C4@cgshmhon9 (;35)0;5-5748
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-5 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln > f` 70
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 11/126
MhgacnoK. Ercr9j.EUCHHJ H.C,$/ LUFH]T,T.G.3574;WcjtcMfjhgcEovk-,Wuhtn 48OfsCjlnons,GC 8445>[nonpafjn9 734);;5-<< >
@cgshmhon9So}) ;;5-<<0
Hrc 2prfWTHUFMFWWECUJNWW,OOTH 37<<\nst FoymphgEovk., @h``a @offrOfsCrlnons, C 8440;-3017[nonpafjn9 734)57 >-5;01@cgshmhon9 (73,4)57>-5;>0
IcjntOhjkjnrWphnoenrlH,C\ F@@HGEWF@ICJN[ OHJKJNU
WTHNOENUL35;44\hosahrnEovk., Wuhtnzt44
OfsCclnons,GC8445>[nonpafjn9 734)785-1143@cgshmhos9 734)5<1->871
Cttfmnysfr Tochjth`s hj tanWpncrsCgthfj
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-5 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 0 f` 70
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 12/126
TUFF@F@ WNUyHGW
[an ujknrshpnk, IfsnpaJ. Brcv-ng, r., Nsquhrn,onrneygnrth`hns oct an snrvnkctruncjk
gfjngtgfpyf` tan MF[HFJ @FU[UCJW@NU F@"[CLCOFJLCG[HFJ [F MKO JF.
3838fj gfujsno fr Kn`njkcjt y .W.@hrst GocssMhoho, fj tac 38nkcy f` Irmn,5441cs foofws9
UfenrtI.T`hstnr2NsquhrnWHMTWFJ[ACGHMU & ECU[ON[[ OOT
3888Cvnjun `tan Wtcrs, 80@offr, H-fsCjlnons,GC 8440<
WtnpanjM. Uummcln,NsquhrnIfjctacjM. Oofyk" Nsquhrn
KCPHW \UHLH{[ [UNMCHJE OOT3543[ahrk Cvnjun,Wuhtn5544
Wnctton,\C 81343-74;>
Mc`thj O. @hjnmcj,Nsquhrn. WcmJ. Kcwffk Nsquhrn
KCPHW \UHLHH[ [UNMCHJN OOT>4>MfjtlfmnryWtnnt, Wuhtn144
Wcj@rcjghsgf, C 8;333
OcurcI. @fwonr, EsquhrnMGKFJF^LAAFOOCJK
&COONJTG>>> GcphtfoMcoo, 8t @offr
Wcgrcmncrtf,C 8>13;
McrlcrntCjjnBncjn,Nsquhrn
.Brhs A. Mc99, NsquhrnKN\NXCJKHNEFN^@HHT
FjnNmecrgcknrf njtnrWuht₯;44
Wcj@rcjfhsgf,GC 8;333-703,8
CjlnocM. Tcpcocsbcrhs,NsquhrnGarhstfpanr . Gocrb, NsquhrnBnvhj G. \chocgn,Nsquhrn
KN\NX & HNEFNHI['OOT3743Cvnjunf` tanCmnrhgcs
Jnw Xfrb, Jnw X, rb 34438-0485
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-5 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln < f` 70
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 13/126
Uhgecrk@. Hocjs, NsquhqnBnrry@frkGmjhjsacrr, Nsquhrg
In``rnyK. Uftnohenrl,NsquhrnTctrhgbI. Wmhta, Nsquhrn
[HHCGANU TUF[[[[& \FFKOOT
[wf \frok @hjcjghcoGnjtnrJnwXfrb, Jnw Xfrb 34513
MKO JF. 3838OHCHWFJ GF^JWNO9
KcjKrcgaonr,NsquhrnY\NUOHJLWGACGHH[NU & Y\NU^JL OH,T
384;[ahrk CvnjunWuhtn3474
Wnctton, C 81343-33<4
UflnrM. [fwjsnjkNsquhrnEUNWBHJIFH]JWFJ & [F\JWNJKTTOG
888[ahrk CvnjunWuhtn;;44
snc`ton,wC 813M-;411
snpaJ. Brcvng,Ir., Nsq
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-5 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 1 f` 70
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 14/126
NQAHEH[ 3
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-5 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 8 f` 70
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 15/126
HIJH[NK W[C[NWI[]KHGHCO TCH|HNOfj
M^O[HKHW[UHG[ OH[HLC[HFJ
HJ UN9 \CWAHJL[FJ M^[^CO, HJG.,WNG^UHHHNW, KNU[PC[[HHNOH[HLC[HFJ
,uEhtNW.Wr.hCols. oIKhgtZr@EH{N-Oh.I
$q`hr 93r$.3U$3hHq$jST{
@na63,6141
@[.NGH9@ZtNts$sfrm``@.
MKO Jf. 3838
[UCH[W@NUFUKNU
En`frn an njkrnTcjnt Kn`njknt \csahjltffMutuco Hjg. (\cMu)acsmfvnk,pumrc.ttf 51 ^.W.G.$ 3;4<, fr gffrkhjctnk r gfrsfohkctnkprnehco prfgnnkhjls ` tahs ohtr'lcthfjj tan\nstnrjKhsthgt f` \csahjljj Tochjthtrs j ton \nstnmKhstrhgt f` \csahjltfj gthfjsmk fur
\nstnrjKhstrhgt f` \csahjltfj f4njthcooy noctnkcgthfjssuppfrt ahsmfthfj Tochjth`t hj `tnWfutanrjKhsahgt f`Jnw Xfrb cgthfjscjk jtfnstnkpcrtypochjth``tan Fjtchf [ncganrs'TnJhfrTocj Efck suppfrtgnjacohzcthfj,eui sullnstan WfutanrjKhs`hgt f` Jnw Xfrb csbcjs`₯rnnkhstshgt
[ahs hthlcthfj gurrnjtoygfjshstsf`snvnjcgthfjs hstnk fj WgankronC cjkpnjkhjlj twfkhstrhgts, hvn cgthfrs j tan \nsttrj Khstshgtf`_{csahjltfj cjk wf cgthfjs j an Wfutasj Khsthgtf` Jnw Xfrb r
Fo tanecshsf`tanpcpfs `honk *jkancrhjl nsshfj no; wn `hjktac` tansncgthfjsjvfa'ngfmmfjqunsthfjs ` `cgt,cjk`tct gnjtrcohzcohfj mknrWngthfj 3;4< j tan \nstnmKhstrhgt f`\csahjltfjwhoo snrvn th.n gfjvnrrhnjg₯ ` tanpcrthnsmk qrhanssnsck prfmftn ton iust cjk
n``hghnjt gfjkugtf` tahs ohthlcthfj [ansncgthfjs sa.cn cgorco qfnsthfjscrhshjl rfm coonlnkmhsrnprnsnjtcthfcsr fmhsshfjsfjgnrjhjl\cMu's hjcjkcogfjkhthfjwhtarnspngttf e sueprhmnafmn fcjpfrt`fohf. \antanr ancgthfrs crnerfulateysngmhthnsafoknrs nn&hjlnohn`hmknr tan`nknrco sngurhthns cws, sacrnafoknrs 'hql knrhvcthvnoy fj enaco` f` \cMro fr pcthghpcje hjrntanmn,jt cvhjlspocjssuhjl fr vhfoc`hfjsf` EUHWC, coo cgthfcsg.menn;ongtnktf fgusfj cshljh`hgctjumenr f` gfmfj nvnje, kn`njkm1,cjk/frwhtjnssns.Gnjtrcohzcthfj jknrWngthfj3;4<whoo nohjhoc`n kupohgkhvn khsgfvnrlprwnjt hjgfjshstn.jtrnthco ruohjls, nspnghcooywhtargspkgt tf gocss gnrth`hgcthf;,ck gfjsnrvn an rnsfurgnsf` tan pcthns, tanhr gfrmsnocmk aniukhghcy.
\ncrnpnrsucknkact an\nstnmKhs`hst f` \csahjltfjs m cpprfprhctnrcos`nrnn frum`fr tahs ohthGcthfj,engcusn3)mfstf` tan cgthfjs rncorncky njkhjlj tectkhstrhgo mk (5)\cMu
H [tn Tcno acsenn,j fth`hnk f` twnovnpftnjthcooyrnoctnkcgthfjs, nhlat cgthfjs j tan \stnrcKhsahgt f` \csahjltfj,wf cgthfjsj tanWfutanrjKhsrhk f` Jnw Xfk?,cjkfjncg`hfjncga jtanNcstnmKhstrhgt f` Gcoh`frjhc cjk tan Jfrtanm Khsthgt f` Gcoh`frjhc Hj ohlat f` tanTmno'skhspfshthfjf`tahs kfgbno tann cgthfjs h/hoo enCnctnk spftnjkcotcl-coftlckhfjs. WnnUoHns[.;cfk<.>,UT.I.T.M.O.,88 @.UK. ;5>,;7>-70Sff[).
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-5 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 34 f` 70
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 16/126
-tO-
hs ancDucknrnkj Wnctkn,\csahjltfj" jkrnonvcjt fgrm₯j1mkwhtjnsn whoo ohbk en fgctnktanrn.
H[ HW [HHEUN@FUN FUKNUEK act,porrsumt tf 5W .W.G.$ 3c4<, tn cgthfjs hstnk fjWgankuonC cjkpnjkhjlfushkntan \nstnrjKhstrhgt f` \csahjltfrcn trms`nrrnk f tan\nstrrjKhsahgt f` \csahjltfjcj; whta tan gfmnjtf` tact gfrro csshljnkf tanAfjfrceonMcrsacI.Tngamcj fr gffrkhjctnk r gfjsfohkctnk rntrhco prfgnnkhjls hta tan cgthfrspljkhjl anrncRkohstnk fj Wgankuon .
TCJNO FJMHiO[HKHW[zuG[ OH[HLC[HFJ
K. Ofwnoo InfsnjUfenrtO. Mhoonr, Ir.Kcvhk U Acosnj
Gachmcr
I.@rnk9rhgb MfbBctaryj A. PrchhhCjtafjy I. Wghrhgc
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-5 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 33 f` 70
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 17/126
HJ UN9 \CWAHJL[FJ M^[^CO, HJG.,WKG[IU[[H@,W,NU[PC[[H|N & "NJ[WC"OH[HLC[HFJ MKO Jf. 3838
WGANKH]ONC
WfutanrjKisthgt f` Jnw Xqb
KntrjhsBfnstnrnr . \csahjltfjMutuco Hjg., ntcR, G.C Jf. o94<-814HIfno Cercms,nt cOv. \csahjltfjMuaj Hjg., ntcO, G.C Jf. o94<-8140
\nstnrjKhsahgt f` \csahjlofj
Mcjb Jnosfjv. Ifej@. \ffL, ntct, G.C Jf. 594<-3148
[fm Wjnv; ntg.v. Bnrry B. Bhoohjlnr, nt cR., G.C Jf.594<-3150OyjjnAcrrhsfr9,n g.v. Bnrry B B`oohjlnr, nt cO,G.C-Jf. Y9F<-H1['HLrnlfryEusacrsbyv. \csahuljjMuarco, Hjg., ntcO, GC Jf. 594i-3t<;PhjgnjtEussnyv. \csahjltfjMuarco,Org., nt c3.,G.C Jf. YF<-31<8
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-5 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 35 f` 70
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 18/126
NQHHHEH[ 5
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-5 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 37 f` 70
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 19/126
_;,9
H
t
7
;
>
0
<
N
8
rg3H
t5
H7
t;
t>
t0
3<
HN
o8
5C
5o
u57
5;
6sxtj51
Ggn094$fr4410&AUO KfgurjnrR3; @oonk4751/54331cl/N3g`;5
NPCH_hW
Nuhokhjnc 3>538-
njmsys`tr^C``h
^JH[^KW[C[B KHWHUHG[ GFH,U`
JF(HWNUJ H}HHXHUHG[F@GCOH@FUHHHC. WCr IFWNKHPHWHFJ
``hm.``hlq,Ar[Ttf"Z``h`e
fc cuftasrshmhocro'
pajgh`t,
GCHHK JF.2 >94Ngrr-oo4N01lUO)
GH.CHHWCG[HFJ
Kn`qknts.
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-5 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 3; f` 70
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 20/126
t
C
I
;
>
0
<
t
8
t4u[5
37
t;
t>
t0
t<
Ht
r854
5o
5,
c5;
5>5.0
j51
Gcsn>.4&g@D1n&AUOfcmnut3; mk m515441 Tcls5f` 5
Tochkh0, eytec`u ujnys, ekRlrahsgocs cgthf clchgt Kn`nfkcm
\slahrlqru`hs&O Hjs.,\csahcltfcu``co Ecjl@; (cnc\csahjltf|/`huoco
Enbxasr₯tj₯``crgfoonchvnoyn`nrnk f ct "\n_;th9),@hrl Cmnrh₯fnC`prc`uno[
(qC'r), cjkosknks Wnrrkgnjg., tW@) (gfoongohvftyKf`ukf`r{ f tenafwu
esaco`cjk fDco`f`coo f`ag k'jhocroykctctn;cjkc^₯ncs foofws fsnk pf
tan moknpthf f` tenhrffujsk9
fvN,vrKwo. [ehg s c"oss cg{hDqlphfstKn`njkc``hnbhjl rnohn`fueneco`f`
pocotrh`rscjrk.t"ss f`coogfsumss jGctharjhc jk`ufulafue ^tht@kWtctns
wef,fjfrc`rnr us o, 5(e0, ngnhvnk mtpfcjsfm \cov{qjfjfchff wttecplchf`n tt *nrn fe4cocnkarfule h`oc NCfr H.$O Tochcth`r oukten 3ffrwnrn
uothjgky rfsofoshtron rpyhjl`frtanfnsp@rchsce,trhgot cr kw9roenktafulofrt
tAsGfKpHcaGqnmtpnr`frjnk hj cfaknpfkfrt,feingkvqcpqtao nk
rrueernk mjg, hc vhftkf f` cppohgcetfcs ck tenff``cf`h&o nqkrnmnmfr
tanqpchnct
6- [envckgkfkty f` afn purgacws,j anujhNk Wtknsrqcugpshr
afjfpurgacserfule tatrklty ofjknr.[an fcjacsfkhttfccooy ngj furnk
eyte onjknr, af ntcas snforoty nrnstutafppfrty uko &c fc hsrgpchk o
`toO Hc tasw₯ftf`kn`ukt,an ₯jknrwhoo en₯ftronkf snoof` tansfurhty r*nrnsr
W.n.' efpmpnrl)cfk ngfupan fcjc.mfuut,ar& t trckhthfjcooycsennj
nuothgcofr an cknr tguctnsurnan re 0c"bnrwounf` &npjfpnrtyqcce t
norgnsknafvcoulf` tan fcf.t[fkfsf, njk*s nqutrnak,pkfr f on ac& `en
prfpsrty np`nskffcooyryprchsnkf kn&fmann `chrm.*nt vcoun.
7. Crco nscncpprchrcosN{@fsfkfencfhknpknfr, feing`hvn,
H @chrjsbntvcouns tofprhnnc rrthge cwhoohrl tjrynrvfuok rgtcsncprfpnrtymkcwhooal snos sfr{k snoo enscjn rfpnrty,tm jnhraq 0ty hsujkn cuygfupuoshfjtfery r rnHOcjkngapkty acsroo bjfwonkln coopnkcfut>r@ochjl tf anscof."
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-5 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 3> f` 70
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 21/126
H
z7
>
0
<
H
8
HFH H
35
o7
t;
o>
o0
O<
Ht
98
54
5o
z,c5;
6s50
j51
G₯sn>94&'qt{Qr10&AUOof?urjnjto; @3|nk47t``h5D7 Tcln7c`;6
hqcrthco ujehNsnk,rnkheon rf`gshmco khmkn f` tan&or jr'ognt woun f` c
p;thsuoslfp₯rty. Ht typhgcooy gfjkstsf` c rhsuco hjspngkfj `ton ohtnkq ck
nrgkfrfhc pfpsrtoN rspngthfjf`ton ckleeaffc9 cjkc gfupnksfj sf^tjl
prtgn f` gfrryceon `fp₯rthf fjton ``h g ckcgnk gncq ₯r'f''rl .anr jkhghrc.
[af grk₯r (a tahsgcsn,\cMu) ophgcoy ujksrtn&nsfprfscrnafcplchso f
enano`ct`htno`sok ton efrofwnrwhta tangfstf` tancpprc`unr's vhgnsuothjknoy
efmneytanefrfwnr.
;. H`c cppchsco spfpnroykffq tas cpptssj n₯r`frfttan puchrco,
cfknpprchsconvtnunmnvhnw af cpprchno cput `g cggurcgryk gupohccn whta
cppoofceon "jks'cs f grnknu`tct onlcocfkp`nsrhfjco sturkcokss"r' c"grgkheonrypchsct". kpphsgs fk cpprchuo rgr'hnj'njeoofw `₯knrcooy gfspnk Dkcks,
tan jh`tm Wtmkcrks ` Trrf`wtfjcoCplchscoTrcghgf ^WTCt), v`rhga lfvnm
tan n{thgcocsk ₯co cnpngm` tanrypchso ujknrtcbhjlcrssssmprk,n@lthjlNk
rnrytnjsrfsns,cfknstseo`uaan jhjhjum ntcjks`oe frps`gmhfl c"grnkheon
clprctsco".Hanss WTCTkcjkcrks rncosfnkfpnkeyNsst, h` jftcoo srcrnl,
hjsecthjlGcoh`gjhc. Cosftesycrnpct f`tangfmcgjrcoujknrtctGjl,ryr₯ssoy
stctnk tan k`f@jUs`tonmhcojppchsco Uspfrt,vehge hs &s mkcrrk `frjtak
ryprchsm usn f tanaspprchno r₯pf`hE jkwahnawnrnusnk sr tos \coo`u fcus
ta* crn an $eingt f` tahsGffpoch`h. [a₯kNy@rchsso gpfts cosfflnsoy otfvhkn
ta*thry crn fenpfvhknk tf efjfrgf cjkcgoffwonklntantefrfwnofrn
p.r-'h`nk & noy fj tafcpprc`ucosspcr f` cuy zfr₯sln hcrn tcjscg`hm
estsD efmfq'nrt rk HPcovHu.
>.]bn^WCTquhrmnjnprfvhkntactfp'rfjftncrkpwvn&f
puehhg rust Kanu₯ktj prf`*nhfjch cppchsco zgthgn, nKcpprchs₯rfkcj;prchsco
rwhnj'nr m$ felnrrrg Eahlanst tcjkc(ks prf`nsshfcco tkn tfpsr`fcm jknjsunc "grgkhaonFpksc`. Cf cplcosnrfk cjcpprchsco vhm ojus p₯r`D
"wljmm n`r&hgc`oyjkgfupnrgnroy,jcggqksKgnvhta^WTCT k cjy
srppomnkco fkcks clr₯nkfey &n crchn hu cggnpthjlancsshlj'jn"t.
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-5 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 30 f` 70
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 22/126
n Gcn09Dfp44₯R@AUO Kfgtmnjto; mnk47/511441 Tqn;ct;5
^cknjHWTCT,cj cpprcom mk cjcppctsco fvhnmnrK0t p₯r`trrn ₯rlr.mnt$s
whj hjpcthfoho3o, ft{ngt`utty,cfk fk₯p₯jknjgn,jkwhteftt ehcsscggfmfkkhfj
f`pnmjco `unrrnsts,j cppr&.t @rcghhD uknr WTCT, jcpDsnr fk cu
cpprchsconrhwnr must ft pc`tm cscfskvfkn &r cory@crtyg hssrn,mjstjft
cgg₯pt jtqshljmsjtteg ogaks `tn @pftthjlf`pnkntn|uhk fpehfjscfk
lfgoushfjsfr &vfj ton gcrn f` uy gohfg, rjustjg gcmrmNhgsrnsshlom₯pt
rtsuoc fr srhtn crnprt hj cjhsonnkhclfr fuh`tronjtjcmgr, 1k hj'st Kftpnmht n
nq{f>rgnfrftanrp₯rtD f gf'"'rjomhgn cmhrtnckhjl r&cukuof rnpfrt
0. Hj fr cefutIr9cn {Q30,\ct_`u.jtnrgks clrn₯mnjt,fKryhrcgyr
$emn$htaNC cfkOWR,twfprpfrtnkoy tkfpcknjtcpchnct gDpDhnn, facfkoN oo f` \c${u'safus off cpprchscos. s pwt f`tehs crcflnmm,NC nk
OWH rngnhvnk pprchscornqus `tfu\cH0lprgfrrnkofgco cppkmrs q `nrmtan
cpprchgcos,whnoornk ancppxchno gpfrts, jk gquns; ktts e₯assf` \cMqtoc`
tanqoprks₯rs ucbn ecjlnsn`frn jcoozhjl tan&pfrr cfkprfvhkhrl anq tf
\coto`u f trcjrjht tf tanegrfw₯rg Hj rncohty,\ctv`tt, hta `en`too uj`n`rqnk
gffpnrcthfu N k njk "W`,gftfoonk tafprrfns eywehk hukhvhkuct pprchsnj
rvnrnsnongtn{afwafjncprchnctswnrnpsr&mk cj{ uoohjcrnoy, evcouns ct
wahgapfpnrknswnrncpprchsn&NC fk H1H ffjsuot₯khrngtoywh& \novouck he
offuf`rgngs f nstceoea anlfpq₯y vctjfs gy kshonk e₯`fr₯NC DkO$H (cjkts
cplchnc$ rrrrc`h nk an cppjhsco npgrg. tahs gfjsphrCfkcof'ho'@t coof$₯k
\cJ;utf hrnstcpprchsnjtf rth`hghcooy j`octnafmny6`[email protected] Wosn
cplchscos j frknrf qmoh& mun pnfponfr ahlenrvcouffms. \cW`tr fuok tam
clrnlq`scjk@ccogc1nnssefms fDscjksnR ta₯oje &s `hjntrshco'crtrgts fr c
suMhco prf`hO oIokmcofoj anahlel tanvfoumn0k rcoun f` tefsnfcs, ta₯
ahlonr \cov`tr's rf`hn. Hj 544( \covhujcknfv₯r$<D rjhm hf rwnjln fmscong rho snrvhghklf` ac"'njfrSclnfcrs.
<. Cspc$f`te sfa₯`hf, C cfkOWH nch' rnn`unk-rhoohf,s f`kfocrs hj
cppchnco w &fjr usus@nsthjlrycMsefrrf*nrs raf,knsphjpcyhry`fwac
H
5
7
;
t
0
6
1
8
343 o
t5
o7
O;
t>
H0
[<
o1
H8
m5o
<5
c5;
5>50
j1
EHJ[CNHNJKK(}FMTOCHH{[
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-5 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 3< f` 70
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 23/126
e-nn
H
5
7
;
>
0
<
1
H
r4o t
t5
t7
H;
o>
30
t6
3N
t8
5C
5o
c57
5;
5>50
5<
5N
Gcs>9(N-sv-44&&'AUO Kffmnjt3; @ 3;k47t515441Tcln>co;5
safuokasrnessgrnkheon cppchscos h.n.kfjf c gffpoocjgnwhtacppohneon nlco
cjkprf`whfjco tukkks sfcs fprfvhkfcj jknpnjkfo urehcsnk, k feingrhvn
cpprchsco ` 0n &hr mcrbn` cou₯f` tanhrpfpnrty) hjsrnckjwhthjloy r₯ss`hr₯k
eocsnk pprchncosc wrN cn`ta₯rjkcpmkf, fohngthrn fr hf gfqohcjgn whta
onlcocfkpf&sshfccosekks, Ncgaewmjrvcs cerlk `frcqkheos, orw`to
spp0co$Oert`cscrnsu.otf`ten ucjlmnrhoentvn \cotoq H]C.cfkH>H, jf
ggnkheon cror$H cpNchscows pnr`frrgk.._R|co&r efmfwssW.n, Toch``h mk tan
Gocss) rgrnko'jclnkasney.
N. NCaqs ts@hjshpco pocgnf`eushcnssoTgj*cy,Gcoh`frrhc cjkfpgrcn,
'jcjclfsfkkhrngtsts jkmjhkn cpprchmo nrvhgns ckarshw fpnrckfs hfuhn f``hg₯sa Gcoh`Dhc OhnnrvhsN,WHacs grff`hN tan jchwhkn fpngchf
gnjtnmcGcoh`fjhc,t'ftfq`hhg&OWo fpnrD cfkk`un$ tafmqhfkty,g k.oncs,c
sfe*cfkcoppfrthfrO f` hn jcthffwoknp0rrk$co nrvhgnsk eu&nssfpnrkfs.
Cqhghty f` \c&tr'samf ofcfpfrtrfohfnn ofms cchon j Gsohek; cggfkhtql
tf hts5440CKurcHUnpst ehs tanrs`rsnesohwnkcjkcvnrrnkacttanclrnnm₯. `hr,
gfjsphfgycukjhsgm`tut k hssu₯a tohs Gfjpochutffnmnk, rcsgftrk&Dk
cjk/frwzskhrngekphjckoy &m, frct oncs4suesef``co fprthff nmc'rctnk
Cfj, Gcoh`fmhq hrgoukhjl2a` cft ohmhtnk f9c) `u kkljcthfj cgrk skljrjsjt`
cpprchsnrsfr\cMuefmnffjqe) tos rwhnm,cppmco cjk *hshfj f` lntctsos
`f\cPHu aD'f fkjsfmnstwcMu'srxpk0s2 k f) tefjscnlnmnftjk
supnrroshf f` cpprchsosnrvhgnsft \co`u afmnDt tf Tocojth`r ck t`u Gocss.
8. KknjksL' gfjkurt ofocns re U₯o N``hn Wnkkmsk'prfgn&orns ht,
35^,$.G.sngthfj504<,anufocukro uN`t cjk&0uku3₯mfjlr f`Gcoh`grchc'n
EjsoofrssfkTrf&sshmsGkf sssthfu [a``o.,ntsnq. te cHGO) cswnoo cs&n
GfusumnrnlcoUmnkhn Cgt `oGHCCI. He&jkDts' ffjkugt ef gfj$hDnscrurozhv`uo ghvoo gsspecsy. Kn`tjkrje' ₯fjkust om erncgnn an'affutrcstshta
Tochjthn crktan Goc-qs,htanrkhrngtoyfrengcsnTochkh`s cjkGocnsrjnme$crs
hrtnjkk en₯kghnhns f`tan gf&cgts,frKkfkmos' rnryhgns, r hslrfrjks fr
jnW[ CMNJKNHHG4MTH[^HG[
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-5 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 31 f` 70
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 24/126
3
5
7
;
>
0
<
1
H
h4jt5
o7
t;
o>
30
O<
31
t8
6.`h
5<
ccu
5>6sj57
GcsW9D-gj{t411&AUO}fqmnjt3; @honk&m544oo Tcln0f`;5
rnskjshmfjcqucsh-gfmc*hmius nfrhg&mnftshs.
TCUHHNW
34. Tochrk$ Wokjnry gafoOs cj jk`uhkucowaf s clhthzjf`tan WAn f`
Gs&`r'rjhc,$hkhol oc WfjmcGf"jry,G+3h0r"hc Hj Fgees, 544; }&. Wkafoo
nknr₯kcmfrlsl@fcj trful \cMu'sf`rs hj $fcfmc,Gcoo`rr.rthcfprrgacsp
cprfpnrty fsknkcr 38;[nucgf,&tjfjk, Fbocemc Hf gmnsthsj wh`atehs fcj,
\cH{u@fsurnkWr htno` cfk ks"Wgafoocuqprchsco fctanrueinnrrfpsty `rfot
NC ckofr OWH tec`unnpnr&mfkpursucmf &n sgafn coolnk hj rohs Gcrptchcc
Mr. Wgafoowcsnn₯nk `tc tahh r@p9chsco.
H o. Toshrk`r, @nHtu C- $prg, Irf r m hjkhvhkuso g,af s c ghthznjf` tonW``hnf` Gcot`Kmtc,nshkhcl KWsf fss,Gcoerjoc. a HvHnrHt,YQ`, HvHr.Wpngg
njtnrnk jftr₯slpfcj'$rta'olso_&fr cprfpnrtyfgc`nk c WcjIgn, Gcot`trcol-
Hj gfojsnthfjwhta&hs off, \cot`uprfgunk`fr nno`cjk {r. Wpcsco cpprchsco
f` tafs$in* pfpnrty tfrfNCcjkfrHWH tectjcnpfr`gunk pr9rjrcct tan
sgornjfcoonlnkj tae Gfmpoc`fO {r. $pncrrjc gacrlnkfrtahs cppkn`
oO Kn`rfkcN \csahjltu v` `hrcoHjs.Dk\csahflofcMr$rctjqje@C
(cof \csRDFCmarct Ecjbxerr₯`fc$nrgfoongthvnoy g&rnk tf cs'\cov`ut
gfookvnoy fpnrcn"
030q0p0qjk*j'cooaoshjm ecjbelgfrpfjy j&s
^kr₯k$Dshtacssgts tfeohol $7;0eooohfj \c$H^qqctnr e Wrrrs₯Es9
UltchtEcjbhjlGcrk$noovhgn,Gfrnsrghco, ck Afjnofrss. [esAfjn Hrcjs
s₯lrjk fklhD ccknrvhg* am ofcfs, cjcl₯s qhrco rcront fpkms,
`to`h^s cfkss'rtfnscpfrt`fohff`afn nquhty fcjscjk hrtn f` sr₯kht,qhlhjsrnf
cjkpurgacsgmfrlclnfcjs fatlonr rtsbefrrfrrnrs, rfrhk₯sj cjghjl k fotnr
ecjbhjl gvhns tf mfr{lclncfars&r &n frhlhu`hfj f` ufr₯cll a0s, nk
f`trs hj$rcfgn,rnoknk ruoug1 nfk g`fsjcfn nnrvhgfs.[ths snlfft f``nrsrckfus ncomn sngGHr₯kkkckc` acjprfkuftscjksnvtg* pkjnrhoy gmshs`hjl
f` `t?nk*ctn fmnfcm,ckiustceos.rctffrunffs, ayAk affn fus, fokfj
CUM 3fcj1,k Nfr₯cln fc$ tf&hlanrrt& ef&forr₯rs,Csf` Kn.njenr7o, 544;
rHU`` CHPHNJKNK FMN,CH {[
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-5 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 38 f` 70
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 25/126
H
5
7
;
>
0
<
H
8
HFo o
35
o7
[;
3>
O0
t<
o1
o8
54
zo
55
57
5;
5>6s
5<
51
Gcsn094&cr4411.AUOsmnjt'o; mk41j1m41 Tcln<k;5
tof gffpcjy pnmk 5-55>ntk `ubIrhl,03s 00co` onjkhrtl frns rkgnj`ss
hc70snrnr afoukholGcoh`ujhc.Cgfrkhjl f tangfrpcy's 54{BChottso U@pf;
tanN;hfgtty`\cov`u'safmfnjpfrt`fohf crnfcusNck₯jGcoh`uks.
37. Kn`qkcjr@hrstCrnrogcjnCpp'chns``NCI hsc Knocrcrs
gfrpfrghffkta j pkrghpcopoc0n ` eushjnss 3578>trW Cmnrkgcfcy,
Tf$Ny, coh&rctc.NC s csueshkhryf` [On@hrstCfnrhf Gfrpfrchfj jks c
Gcoh`fujhcfrpfrchfj hn `tsphtghpco pocgn `eushjs cj @hW Cfnrhm,\cy,
WcfcCr;Gkh`Dhc
3;. Knr`nfkk njkksWnrnhgnog. hsffnf`te gfr``hy's ocrlst nfyhk₯rs
f`prfpnrtycouckfchtofcjknoghfl snrkcssf&f `h$t ugtlslp,efjn₯luhty,cjkf$pkrn uc*ftq cs rgoocstfttrf{₯clsqvhgngscnkrrv₯ow OWHhs c
wekkhcyf` @tknohtyJchmo oj`frmc`hffnrvhn, c gfrpukhfjjgfcumnk
GfrlhccfkenckquctnrnkjIcfMvhton @ofrhk& OWHjchmctjnungfpgrcthfc
gnrnrs,urff`wehga, D CscsskWcgrcfnmqrg fg*k a Gco``frkc
I^UHWpHG[HFJCJpPNJ^N
t>. IrrrhkhChfcf`tohs Gfurt s@mp₯rujk₯r51^.W.G.ocoo(`nkgco
qukhfr iukskhgthm)cfk4 70;srppoD₯fco sCmfj). Tochjth`t cssnrt
&knrco-och'r'ufksUNWT.{,5^.W.G. 50{H/, jkcrpponmsftco30nss gocoms
30. Iurhkhgthfjf`hehsGfuthscotnrjxhvntypfpsrujknr57^W.G.
Wtit75(q(5).Tochmh`t gs ghhhznfs `tanWtn f`Gcoh`ufoccjknshknj Wfmmc
nk WsjIfrn, coh`umtcKn&jksj\covtuhjgfrpfrunkhjte$tctn `
\csehfloffk ecsn gfrpfrcnmkCurtg hjWnfon, \csahjlfj"&jkcjo
NCts jmrpfrcfkhRton Wknf`Knoc*Nn cjkacstfprhcghpco ocgn `eushjfnsj
Tfwzy, cohemoc.Kn`nfkntWH a twff` ` ternnoshj fpkcthfj nkrDE
ofgknho j WcDCjc,Gcoo`DhccjkWcgogfnrttf,coh`gjhc.C rue*cfthcopfrthfjf`t&sgfkurt g esn a tee ocvrs`t ff&ponf hc fjsg mmn ` Kf,`nfkcm'
Gcoh`qcocf`hgss.
36. oan cffuKttr₯fkfsNrry xg₯n& >k)4,D40 To&rh& ck Gocos
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-5 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 54 f` 70
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 26/126
H
5
7
;
>
0
3
H
8
o4u35
t7
3;
t>
t0
t<
31
38
5C
5t
t5
57
c
6>50
5<
51
GcsnW9f1.fr44`r@AUOKfqmcjtt; @honk41o5D441Tcln1f`;5
mmenrngfoongthvnoy, xkushrgf` hRtnrn$ cfkgfsq eyvh`hon f` ton gfmehjnk f*
f` cplkscosps`frsk ey NCfk OWH fr\c& r,ck tan nvnmncjkpf`t rnpnk
eyKn`tjk.jtjnDtanhrtc$clkfjs wh`rTochuth`t cjktenGocs&csckhrnkcuk
prfxhjcnrns{tf`tjnwrfrl&o gfo&rgt cooflk anrnhj,cfkWyvhrcoff`&n
se`tfry, nxnjttocrycfk/fr@jhkvn ccmclnr oonlk e₯rnhj"
H 1. Pnfrg sprfpc whtatu ehs ukhghcokh*hgt purucut tf 5N^W.G.l
3783(e) g) cfk(ko Kn`ukcwEnacs clfs, Ncfscr*s ushcns 0k ef&@rwosf
`futrk htehf `ahs`uh`fhk kosthgt Ks`noksk H,WH cs cl0t , trcjscgeaj`fss, qfk
hs f&uruhsn futrkktae`jhs irkhctco khshgt Knnckct \cor;u csclntr,
trcrscgseojhK₯rl rrkp f`.anrwhsnfrnk srht`hh tahs ukhkso kh$hg`. C sHewthcoprtao f` ten rj .nhkfjscjkwnftsDjpochrk f`anjnhj,jgoukhjlTocokh``s',
fggmnka tahs ukhgoctkhshst, cs$s`tshco pfkfor f` tafs``₯D p₯r``h Dk
m'`hns crn c tahs rfkk'frcotsrhq ck Kn`ukcm ocvn rnsnhvnk $s&fthco
gfmpfsrkhm &D soga tccscgthfcs fkachtrss ckhvhty hf$hs iukhghcoto`ucrhg,
hjgoukal``tntrcjscgthftr ochjhh`t njtntk.@m js`cccft @hjcooj Kn`ukc0
hjec`ht D{kor mcye `fujk c to'2s tkhghk kh$hf;,cfk an m$cin `hckfnk
gf,r"r'jnmn₯shenka₯ctoshs nfkacsen₯j cknkfm jpltvrhtahj tahsiukhghco
khsth.t
E,CWHG[CG[^0OCOOEtrCHHFHW
`h s Uso Nsae MfrNcsnHjcofs``hTrfvhks Hjgnjthvs `fr @Na C@pjc`ogcos
38. \cokf s tengfucby'fcrlnst cvocls fk fccwtta ccsnsftcohol
$7;0ehootfj Kwojl te `hrst`r₯n lusns f`544< cofjf,\c_Ru frhlhrcnk$3o0
ehoohfc hc rkknuthco mf;₯s ofcjs. \cHvHu fgrrrn cfrn cpprchscos fmNC cfk
OWH ta cjyftec shflon0`ty,5;. [rck`thffcooy, oncknr u& cs\co|`uwfkk ec_rgc `u`qst hc njsurhfl
tak cegjfwnrhs ceon f rqcy ctffn off, cktaktef ofcj scknqpcky
gfoonrspoozk e.gcsf&feforfwq k&o1. Ohbnwhsc cffcsus efrmwhjlmfc₯`
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-5 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 53 f` 70
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 27/126
8 .
,
z7
;
>
0
<
1
8
34o t
35
o7
3;
o>
30
O<
t1
<8
m5[
55
57
5;
050
jc
b>9(@&v{41t3&AUO Kfs.ujnr`o; @R0k47T1r54(NTclnlfo;5
`gcomn ofcpocgns ehrtr$` hftos onrknrtfprfgun cgrnkheon plchscoD8.,
mnkmn hj gfmpoocjgn hta cpnogcaonnlcocjkprf`whfco mkcrks sfcs f
prrfvhkfjaknpfkfl feingthvn ckuehcsnk cpprchsco ten&afmn's coun)ck
tf onjktanm.mfjnyfjtntors@KrfRNhcrntfcthjknpncknm, eintt`nnckufe2cqnk
qsnsnfns f` tec >f0srl&ot 'rrnkrnt coun. [rckhthmchoj tanerfwg cukfjkf
sacrrnkDfc hjrnrnstj acvel cpofpsty ek₯pk₯ftoy cukfeingkvnoy
cpphnnktf nrsrnefta0F tenefrfwq uhcs ftpqyhrltm 'rj'"a, crrkacotof
trfp₯rtyycaj gfuoksrypfrt rn;cyjnft ` ran fc hu ranNvnut ` ckkua
53. Efgcnfatcghgcooy ecbn rfchjnkfjtfnmahp`tan of"jck jgtlclf
`fr thn oh`n f` tos om, ``n 0ckn' pkNcy hknmstgjs tf r&₯ sto₯'art
&nefjfwnpchkf`r tefkcf`pco cjk rsst whtaf& knocy r kn`uht o^afnvnr c
eqfwnr k&rock fc c om ht qjuokolr₯ lkhtNgt ojcjghcompck fu af njknr,
h.n. fsfrternGfnkogn f`phcghpco ckhrDk fcthn om" H`tos ofnwcs
pofpnroyecsnk jt&nsgtuco&hruc{?ntvcous f`tanprfpfty, afrnhvnr,`&sonorknr
wsok eNcetff snoo en ff ck rngfupasfutgckhrypt`frhoco. Cngfkjloy, ht
wcsghthgco tok' ton n0bgt vcounf`ten prfpnrtywc prfpf$ cppchnk ck tagtan
ofcjcmfuutn`hnDkt}rct coun.
5Z Hjrngnjtyncrs0stc`hthffco mfknowanrneyacjbanokcjrfr₯cln
ofcjujtho tsrcspctkftr,acnfalpct Efoor sucecN\c&oujf mlfafok coo, f
wctofsg,f`&shrmutlcln ofcjsa` t'stncksnoo a"rjtf `fv₯Dnjtecb fr
lsv₯rD₯kEpftN2k njrtDsf srgacs an@knrco Jchfco MfDcln
nshc``f (`cmhf Mcf) fr`on @nknrcoNfjn Hfcj Mflcln Gfrpu^,m
`@rnkkhnMcg). otns oms rn tacpffok tflnttrnr,nfkjznF,mk sfoke &n
l₯unrcopueohg sjgScln ecgorgkwuhthnsr c^woul ockcs f9gassWrcokrtf
lf`t `rmtefvfoumncfkrcarnf`ofcjn htacsprfgurnk.[a onlnj ancllrslkn6counf` tan Ds, tanmgrnprf`ht er ton onuknr.
57, [on pcho`lj $h`` cq,nryum' rntchjhjlcpgrtaohf f` offs tfurkkses
sconf` nfrtlclpecgbnk ncrrhths ``j&jnftcooy cotnrnkc onckks hjgnjkw f hsnp
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-5 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 55 f` 70
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 28/126
t
5
7
;
`,
0
<
H
8
h43o
35
o7
O;
o>
t0
O<
o1
r854
5t
5,
57
5;
5>50
j51
gcsnW94&gv-m10nAUO Kffujhnjt3; @HHk47,5CN/I/IWTcln34f`;5
qpcthty ms. Ey snoohjl an vu* jcifhry f` tonhr mf;lclnD pftrkfohf fte₯r
gfnpcshng k*s uf fclnrlssrrrjnktanh* f`ceck ofcf.[an hsbf` kn`urotwsr
pcssnk ctf ftanrgfryfhns ck nrrncurcooyan wwfcoraf efrl`utrKfr$cls
ecgonksmoks. olgn hqfruky, jfw abpf``t kaw`oy gfjnock tf r,n
vftrmncjkvcarff` ofcjslnffrctnk,fttap oheohagfktast c ofcjqjkk e₯Lpkk-
Ecjbsv``rnta$ hogkhyhzk, e f``nrcs mcry fjs gtasahle₯st kftocrcRfur`s
tDsfuoken f`trnkwota oh`ronrfluktf van&jr&n ofco gfuokenpchkeckt
C, Htr hehs nuvhrcoj₯jl angs nmchm htttn jpnkvf fr \cmu fft`chj c
fnkhAn cppchncof` cprfpnrty'nncomckrnt counsjknynryKg₯khvn ff`tr ten
ahlaft osf cm``h pfssheon, rpfsktrl &n offs whta ehcs₯;chot`hghcoy 'r'`ocrn;Nosncppmhscts
@ncogrcocjho Wee Orwn U₯{uorn C@pon`fco rknjspk.mgl
5>. Knnphe&n jnwngfjfmhgckhlq `tnthjl ton trfrtlqlnnokhjl
rjkjxt6,stkncKk nknrno₯uokhfrs rnquhr₯ ,ac` p@kscosen'gnnko^n e>r hjl
tjknpnjkf, feinohrn, ujehcsk cukpnr`frjnkj gfcrpohmgn h& te rjhjhr''_'r'o
st"'knrkrsnt uh' hj te oah`fm, Wnjkrks f` &rf`usofccoCpprchscoTrcgkhg₯
`^WTCTH. [ann ^WTCT&rkcrks crn jgqpuctnk gf ₯knrco cv, snn35
G.@'.U" 7;.;;,cnhofupgfkhftfmgy, h`jftcoo s&tfocqhs, jkukhul
Gcoh`mhq rccGcoo0mhcEusans cjkTrf`nsshms fknlo 3738,cuksrnpkt f`tan
gfmcgacoujknrcthulsnftptsoy Mctnku tan^fh`frc U₯₯hknkhcoCppeco
Uspfro wehg& n tanntfj``h`rNj tatcpojzhmusn `frtenenppmosooqpfrscjk
wahca rnrgus₯k g tanWrcot& oms tag gn t&nseinct f` tah$G``hpochjt '&nss
ryphsco rgpqn ctsfcry₯rsoy gfkrmposek tect hny wfuokenlfvhksk tf
eff*nrtr cjkcg&jfroklnk tG efrrfurc rjcynoy ff ancpprchscosspnrtf` cjy
muqlclnhjcjgnrcscgkm e₯'tq|nnsftrfwnrs jk\cH_&r50. ^WTCTrnque nprchss tfDokjgthanhrCpchgcos ocCDy9
sCcqpprksnrr ustpkgj cshljjnm utote fpckc$, f{*thvhty, fk
ak;njknufn,cjk r{task ccrsjnfkrkhfjf` pnrsfjcojtnrss`s. j q3uchsco
FFMTOJJ[
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-5 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 57 f` 70
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 29/126
₯ r
H
5
7
;
>
0
<
N
8
o433
t5
37
t;
3>
t0
[<
o1
t8
j5r
55
cc
6s37
5<
61
GcssW94&k-441&AUO Kfftmnjto; mk``hn1N441 Tcln33sH;5
prcgthgf, cp@r;osnrmu$ ftp`fttj cs cfckvfgcogq Dypkty qrhssun.CR
cpprchscmusgcft fg₯pt trcshlRf₯khtkhrkukns `nsrnpthjlf`orNknZ'rjhjnk
fptjhfjs jkgDseshDtf ^WTCTN&hn &ks (Gfgnxt).
5<. ^WTC@oquhrs cppks₯`hstfffmttkgcono$n`f cpphsosafjn$$/9'Cc cppksnrmr9stK.` gfmmosogl`scsh1jooonrt tnsrotn a cmhsonckhjl r
`hrukuonmucmnr. Cj cppchsffwtjft ussfrnmrhD N joson'khjlf
`uu`uof` r₯pkt fr orfvthjloy pncoght j nrfr`ofon g f&f @₯0fce gff``hrhgson c
jhson{khjl g `cjhouo₯k rqrftO' ^WTCTEtahg Uuont (Gfjkust}.
6.1. (IHHTCT₯quhrn WC'`hoc kfvnofphrl rno pfpcty cpprchsco j
cpprc`unrrus (c)ens*wn f;,Nknstcr; cok gfrrngtoyupofytafsnrngflfhrnkcnhoafros jkngajhqush ac` crnjngfsscryf prf&rgn grnkheon ppchsco*'
^WTCTWtfkcrksUuon3-3.
58. H[WTCT osf quhrn nt {npn uch&cr no prfptycpphsco rnpfrt
nust gfk c shlnk gnrth`hgkhfj 3'+ s shrjoosr fDjnkf tan fofwhKl frc9
H c₯kh&rasqe ta₯est f`ruybjfwonkl ck enohnt
- te $s0nfts f`&stDtchjnk hctahnrfpfrtcrntrunDkgfrrDt
Hacrn sf(fr&n spwh`hsk)N₯sk g prfsfnsthsnRhn 0t hj t&nprfpcty tNcts taG.q&hnst'`` ahs qjt-ck{ jf g ttn s@ngh`hnk)honrNffkottcnst whta@spngttf agogthns hcvftvnk
H eryn jfehcswhta rnsK₯gtf tanwpsoty ta; hs tansuehngt ` tahsrnpst fre tanpcrthnshjvfovnk te-`trhs csshlrmsr6
ny njlqlnnscthj tahs.cs-kl"'rlqwcs ft gfukryk upfjkrynofpkfl0 rnpfrN;lnf₯, Nr f ₯; nsotrs
Ny DhD, `q gmkntec tirhscsshntrgft e jft gfthjpnjt rmj
ttrNkNgkofpjk qrrsfftrkjs `ocsnknf`thjnk vcousf khrn`rhf hhtvcoun tk ag tan husn f[tafkohDO an Dfrmtf` tanvcounDhtrhf&`tn stt@hjjr₯k ` c ghpuocekrbuot 0taf fgghrqnkgf`cshra₯qkk nv₯jtkhrntoy rnoctNkf tan jtshknkussf` tehscpprcect
p` ljcoyEns,ph;hqps."3 gfgak-f-js-wq.nlvnofon;Vck.tah ₯pf`ta,hsenfhpkcrp; a gD`fDhtywhtaan ooj`frj WtjhMt f`
'
h4@HUH'[ CM[JKNK MTH,CHHHH[
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-5 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 5; f` 70
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 30/126
g ,
5
7
;
>
0
<
1
H
o4o o
O5
H7
[;
h>
30
t<
Ht
t8
m5t
j57
5;
5>6jj6t
GsssW9to1.frkQ)1(*AUOfgumnko; mnk47/515441 Tclc35ft;5
TrfICssejcopp&co Trugtogn.j
[on cprchsco rnpfrc g tan\choou ofcjsacg rn ansr_hngt f` &hs
Gfmpoctggfctchjnkahs fr cNknrhcRy oknkgco fnrth`gchhf "
74. [an nmn qgt'jhocr^WTCTncahsmons,snqkkkscjkg₯rth`hkhfjs crf
rrsquj₯kr cppchsso rfvonwnrs .n,cpprchnnmafpnr`.r- cqucohry whnw f`
cjfter cppcognr's ₯pfrt).$ufeqpchnt rfvhnwjwn pnr&cmnkyNC ck HWH
cppjcosconvhnwncr ctencpprcono r₯p0ts `frten \ctv`hr DL rartcrntan$eh₯.r
f`tehsGfrpochjt
73, @nksrcocw 'r@6kstnstc` Nprcosnrs jvfovnk j `nknccooy-rnluoconk
trcfscsthftrspsrkn j^cnjcfty. Hen 35^.W.G.$$7773cfn;. [an@knrcoUluockfs prfvokn ar `g `fkspnj&ft fuezghgsfr3`ts' nporcoscs, an
cppjctsu ecot%cvn f krngt f hjkhrnt atnrwt, `hmjkco fr f`enrgthsn,j &f
prfpsty frta₯ rcrscgkfor."35G@"U-7;.;>.
75. Htr 544>, nno rnluofrq hjnoukhjl an F`rgn f` H``h, Wup₯rrh$hD
GF[W'H pjeohsank@rqumky CsbnkDnsthfjsfc enCppchsctUnluokhfos mct
ten `nrclfgy Wtknmnjt jHjknpcjah Cpprksco ck Nvco^hfj @tmg`hfrh
\htarq7lok f c@prchsctcknpnjknjn,an*tctt.mnoot 30o{33ss2
7. \afneuok en gfjkknrnkan fzjlfhtrgthfor stc``
`frp{pw f`cgoknvhrlcppchsco hhknpnjknjgn6
Gfttok fnjprfhechf9t ``h snongtcucprchsnr6
Cjsrnr9 tan om prukugkform,`` gmrhg rh` tefsn
rnsprheon `fr lsjnrc`hjlfcfvfoujn f cpprfvojl
ofcf$cswnoocs ana&arkhjc@$ [ahlwfuok
egoukn my nmpofynn afn gf;fjschf hsecsnkf Hq vjtums.Nrupoqrnn rgpfsheon &rg₯kht
chorrohjostrcthm ``mGkFKq3'Grnkht rhWb rjcjglnjnort 0s
jft gfrkhbrnk ofcjprftargthf stctr Ofcj
JJW[CMNJKM
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-5 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 5> f` 70
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 31/126
H
5
7
;
>
0
<
1
8
o4ho
35
t7
t;
o>
30
t<
t1
O8
54
5O
c.c5;
5>50
j51
Gcsn>94&gv-m&h@AUO Kfnmnrt3; mnk47351I5441cln 7f`;5
prfkugkfj tc`r afrkk ftsnongt pprcefrg.
\a₯j nonsthslshhonmhco crychsnr,jfyofcj
NfkuchfcW`` usnc rnvfovhjlrf-cpprfvnk
cpprchsnhst,pnfvhknkan hst sKft mknrtona
gfjtfo6
Cuwnr9 Xns,ofnu@fkugohfjf``uryusn crnvfovhjlefck-
cppmvnkhsttf nonstc Ehknfthco cp@rchs,
pfvhknk ton knvnofpmwcjk jE2jtnjnjgn`on ohWosrft ujknrtanagfrffo Wnf`` nnpjsheon &r ten
knrnofpjnjtcjk mchjtnjcrgnf` tan o&safkk ef
akgpnjknctf` tan acj pruougkfc prfgns.
arttnr, &frfnafuok enprhfkog tj`nr'rno t'vt$w
g` otn cpprchsfrsongkfu @rfggs tf fjnmrnat
cpprfproctnprsgfkrm crn ekry `foofrrnkcjk
$st fr`rfos n``h tf njsurfjknpnjkfugn
(Nfpecshsckknk).
HHhocrkNC
Gfjsporgk\oha \sMu tf TrfntksCr``hghco Cpprcorcoo
7t. Hj 5440, nryfck`ulf tansnnknrcoquocrhfjs,cswnoo cs anc@ f`
sthst `nknrconf`qgnorrk f` c@lctsnrjknpnjknjgnj tafjfrtlclnnj*"l
htrkNstrIr,_tcJ&rrttn'jNtgtfhjshoctfhtsfo` `rfmgkthgh&cck`nknrco fvnshlotey
njtnkclaf cuclrnnmmwhta twf purpfrtnkoyjk+fknrr Cppc`uc`McjclnjlrGftjpchs `CH_;Gtr), @an Cmfhgcj nCppchsoo cfktnukks $njkfnfjg
wasney \coRu ruwok prfguncpprchvos tm &nsf gf CH{Gs fjen-aco`
ofrmrns `frcoo f cncroycoo\c$ournhknfkco ms jlthfjqhkn, shte angfl f`
>.
35@HEW[CMNJKj CFMTH,CH[{[
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-5 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 50 f` 70
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 32/126
H
5
7
;
>
>
<
1
H
t43t
OY
o7
t;
o>
t0
t<
t1
o8
5j5o
55
57
5;
5>6sj5C
Gcss>k@srr-4410&AUOfqmnjto; msk47o51mN Tcln3oft;5
tan nplchscos08 gerlpk tf `on efufopssc tanthmnf` &n gofghq f`&nor ofcjs.
[ensnsfCovoLwnrsnflclG f frusnn`tn cp`chscoprfgns cjkpfvhkncefon
f` hjknpnjkfgn ntwnnj'o`hcMutanonjknr) jk0fsnaornkf cppc`unprfpnrthns
fuwahg.e vfuok lfvhkn mfrt₯plnfcrr. Hc tonfry, ta*n CMGs tqs tfsnongt
cpchsnm hrksp₯rkn``hf` \sWHu,svn cs an sftrnf&g` whta tencpphsnr, rnvhnw
tencppchsnkfspu fk gfmuuhks te ujehc₯₯knsuas k rnpfrtf \cHHu.
\cMu rtorok hto `''rr gfnrofhgD tenqprchmanuots cfkNpsrostf \cJto
efrfwss sfef`a anefuurgr cjk njknr fuok nty fj rn'j hc ckt'rhrtl an
jfrqcp ofcol. ^jknr ehs scrlnmnjh, \c}Hu vfuok tangnthgcoy tr0en ceos f
hmpf3uty hkusgn tencplchsg gtan u`th&ctn ocou₯pocgfkfc cpqpnrty,
7;. EfteNC njkO$otfrttoNjsfovnscs uehcsnk cppchsnrswafcehkney
^$TCTrnqu`fDnqts. sjpttnk m hj wne*n, NCcssjg gfcsu0₯Nsta0tu$₯
gfcoytafrnjkgns `cppchnss thgnksnk gnrth`hnkeyten scrf j wthgac ueinc
pp₯'rty hs fgltn`o cjk'D,sm₯rEf escoslo₯k ast^jh&jj Wmksks f`
Trfnshfco Cppchsco Trcgkgn jkNhon1kco.Hjstht`hfjs Un&rmUngfvnry jk
Nj`trgnfnf`Cg2t [Hj`Nl6 lkkn`hjnscrs foofsnk crkta* ncge ppmoscos
ckhtnk`u gfjpohcjgn.'
Ohognmhsn,"8Hcs``ns gD$9mqs anr
e ry`rchnos"gfj`.qp'e HHHHTC@qutNfsjs."
7>. Hj fr cefk trujn 440,\cotkun`hhjk NC cfkOoo nfckrjhjhstn`
\c9ov3u'spchsco @rflrn. Wocgn ahl hmn,NC cjkOWHacvnp&mnk jncroycoo
f` \co`u's ;prkuof \c]0r eqrfvqs quhgokyMn efgaNC'snk OWH'l
ocrln* sfurgn `rgvnmus.. hjgn rmn (Q)0NC cofjsacsngnovnk v₯rW>4mhoohfc
hj`nss rfjeqofw₯m $tf rngnhvnkDtarfule \cRcu.
70" Trhfrtf enhjl nchcskty\cokt` EC cfkOWH unkc gffehjcrhfj `
`ungjcoW``sktahrkpcrtycpprcosnstf s₯j'hgs\Duefrrfsnos Cotaflaten
hjknpnjkncgntan cprchfc hsgrhthfo tfton cporchno prfgnss,ffcc`tggehral
NC ck H-Wo fckmhrkstftan\ctvoucpprchscorflrcm,\cH`hc k{r`h``₯k cnrtkj
rylchsnrr ([tn`ncrnkCppcosnrt) taf WrcHvHunlunsnk jkrgt rnshknmhno
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-5 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 5< f` 70
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 33/126
H
5
7
;
>
0
3
1
H
343o
,5
37
3;
o>
t0
t6
H1
o8
54
6r55
5t
5;
5s60
j51
GcssW9``@;j/-441t1'AUOfmnjto; mkF^&5441 T₯ry/n3>fo;5
prfpnrty ppchnts `gr hn ofcjs. Ct hrst taqn @rn`uNk cpptchswwnrn hmpoy
ckknktfas hst f`pfsheon cpprchsnjf ffjkugt pprfhscosgPcovorr oml ers
wmjooy \coou knrqrjkk`tct coo f` ttr cppcoscoseskff eytafTrn`mnk
Cp`qco$0. H'0phtn ^WTCT jk@HUUNC quhrfn.t toc cppchsnjen
hjksTnok₯k'NC sfkOWH qg;'o₯sg₯kf \c Ru's kntjtqkf stctrcp`chEco$phte
Trn`nfrnkpprchsnj
7<. Ckkhthfmooj\co`fcgfrclnkNCDkH,WHtfArf `fj₯r\novtr
nupofyns csntc``cppchsm cfkcp`chso eurhos rjqjclstt,u om f`wahn&
erk cjaf`ty tf fvshkn nkofr rnhks tan ca`` rncganky*rhrk pcrtycppmtss.
EftaOWH nkEC clrnktf \cJ(tr'srnqunstuktffbm rgw nfjpolrngweferfnroy ujrbnk q \cotkecsn clprchsnrffk nlhDco'''nqslnrs.
71. Ht{frnfvnr, rjrcjttf g``h&`h&o clrD₯jhsestwnnf\c}`hr ckt&n
CHt`Gs,\ca`uask $n rhla F kt"jsrls cj cpprchsnGsfjgeshfs eyrfqun*hflc
orggmkhonrkfj f` vcaj" (cosfffum csctFo/" f,tn,ajco) ur&nj c /u khk
rk ohbf &g qppjhsnk counf` caDn. [ehs nermo syrtm lcvn\nMuc krngt rcy
tK nquntttctEC fr H-WHrkknr f cpprnhsnr'srgput fk f rchn ton _rcarn
cskljnk clhvf emn. \c & `rnqukoy usk toos "rgftrsoknrc`hfc ` vcounf
eg,ahlrfhf lntNCckH.WHtf prfvhknahlesrcppchso vcouns jefcrstf nfceon
htstm fklhjsthfj tc`rtfgofsg&n ofcjs.
78. Hc ckkhthf.tf \cHrCr'skcgtuco cehohr>rtf nluwcm+pprchsco f`
prfpstyvcochfc, torfCovHGs'Cpprchnc` ruhjns hocjclnrs,hr₯kktasr₯qun$f`
\cov`hr,wqn lhr/nkuj`ntt₯rnkkfkty f fvsrhkn ranwounsprnsgchenky tatrk
@q`hyqo`chsgos. Cggfrkhjlf c guptchjt `honk eytasJnv Xfn Cgqcgy L₯j₯rco
(..JXCL.)clkj$N& c WcHotu xngrchw kn`hjnk an ftnf` NC's Cpprchsco
cukjnss/cfclng h t₯rcsf`vcoun kCptns hj ton `foofvorl q/c>o9... ran fu cppchws&nvhnq/nts cuok efkhrngtoyawovnk hr
nnocohfjs &c$jl vhte9 UFPs,Pcoukhff hrsrgsq`rnjstn prrgacsn
phgf cfkcpprchk woun kh`tr urhra f r``hg,hohktfu`usth``rkhffs ey
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-5 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 51 f` 70
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 34/126
c '
H
5
7
;
>
0
<
N
8
o43o
O5
37
3;
3>
t0
t<
HN
o8
54
5O
ccu
c6-0
[H
c
GcsnW241*j{M0&AUOKfgumnjto; mk47`h3M441 Tcln30f`;5
tancpp 'chsnr,ho9n g0 wahgaurggfkhjjntfrD₯hvntfnyfurtahrk
pcrty nvhnwnrs\eftnscon), rgcg`tnoy mcokrl c knghkfjtf
fvnrrh& cjk gfrrsgt tOf ehrk @Jrtycpprchrnr'svcounfr ryonppr's
rcouf.ut, wanjgfrs`tonjnkppfphcf mk srypf'rrgk.-
o3uforleha``h Cphsco EushrnssMrfclnrs,\c&Hu fulae, cjkkhk,njsrntac
affs vcoucohftrs`fuOoe₯ su`hghnk tf frppfrtan fur \cR{ugrcknkftrfvhks.
;4. Wgfcc``nrfhfhcltncgrcflnfnftsoteNCcrko$o,\co0r'sofsjfrtlackfjW`` t nlq"gmpochjh;l cefG afcpprctscosnr`fmnkey o "snCMG'
evocl pfpnrtyvcounsff fv `sr &n prfpfsnkfcfs \corku'sfcjfrhlhjkfj
sN.trrnfnhvnkfunhshDs ecsnk c &f vcorncckvfow f`ofcfslrfnrmk. `ana
ktss`hs&r`hff *"s ecsnk fkshrf tf gogsnfcfsct mfuce ahltnrhor2r ten
qryNhscosiu$htrk"
;3. @frnxcjptn,cg₯frkeltf &nJXCL'sgfcrpochj csncroyssCqlustl,
544; o`l$hs's hknrfcoltcotr@krjfhohtank C`fr jftprfvokhjlcp@rshscts tap
vcouns ery uknk. Hj npfjsn tf ehscg&jfwonklnk,jprfpnrprns$rngmhjl
Cfm\c$ku'sD frhlhjkhfjstc``waf kfs`fnktanhlanrcppjchnos, C'n
Nr?nqrthvn hn Trnshkfnphtroctnk tf \cor;u's n'jcjkstllflha Cpchsco
Nushjns kcmlm ktsgrnkfe rchsn an vsas f`afjf$up f W>4,W4.
;5. tc frknrtflurcftnn38co{jwfuokln` anhhl cpp9chnos tscknq
*hnst acytulflf afule anknocy ` ton rnerjcosysf, ey&s whulrf`54f<,
\covoujshr`nktec` C cukOWHusn\covou'lrn`nrrnkCppjhsnrtrgcoof`
\corku"rfmnDjcppchscos. tngncpprchsnjsjrn jk`uhkuc,e&D\cHPtucsgfj``ksjwfuokcprchsnpfprkns c` c ahla j+octnkcan f njrsrfWoco`ugqhok
quhgIkyofsfenfcjct cknstrkDfuft,cjklntcs jugacoss smt&s
trcfscgthfjspfsk^n.
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-5 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 58 f` 70
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 35/126
H
5
7
;
>
0
3
H
8
o4t3
35
37
t;
3>
t0
t<
31
t8
m5t
j,57
5;
5>6s
to
5W
Gcsn>941-0r{QoW&AUO Kfnmnjt3; mnk(ts/51H54(N Tnloc3<k` ;5
; . CggfrkhjlftanJXCL'sfffpochjq f&NC cjko$H rrnrn frr@ohght
$,h&$rsMuos `rjrjkrf n>3g|us`unoysnTrknrrnk ppchws. Hjfnrjcoo kcenk
@&rugryj ,5\<'NC'r Tr*hknmn.'{Toshjnkf s,nfhfrxsshvfsc`NCospcltrt
gfrprchfj,@hst Cjshm, `rk9
\neckc fh* gcoo urhta\uu cjkOWH fkcy. rn lttcr`hnkkfrrrjnk
frrIen tan gj'cppchsnr ssoluhjl@fg₯os Hu safrt,wnwhoo jfr
csrhl"coo \co`hu's r0b e \co,`u'sTmvnjrCppchrnrtr - \nwhoopfy
tenacpprctsnrsactsvgtaryknq'sj`,Tnr&rmcmnc`tjluf l`ha
pfkohf csc\cmqTrfgn opprctnh whtt tf ecskfu afrrjcoy
ffNn jfjvcoun'nlcthry c rgk `fr cjUFP. (Njjjacshoskknk).
\cMu's Tr9n`trrnkCppcer [.tg@jgouknhoFroy Cppkgnof
Wfonknho jkGfjtrfoonk y\cMkn ccj Frhlac`fj WLc`o
;. oon hrk`uhkjcoEj on 6rnM CpprchsnrIstrwnrf ryrk nong{nkt
\c}`u's ofcj ghlhjkhfj stc$ Unqum gnmf \covtu'sCRk(e `gr tts ckkhthfjf`
spnfh`hgclprchsnrsrfan npprfrgkostwqn f0njs₯rxtey\cho`u's fcjfrhlhjrkhL,
ltctrtenmsnorns.\cMu'sPhgfTrnshknutf`(CpprchrcoFvnrrhl `o-ttskhvhrhfcf`
\cMutaC s sr;pfk tf esrwpDsheon u'njjrhcl &gcf rmkun `ouncgn s
nxn*nkey \ctvou'nfcjfklhjkhf uc`rfc cppchsnrs ltnk tc cj""jnht f NC
rqcrkhfl fjsUFP`g c "ofw vcoun,' ou` cRtphr hs cj ncfmpon tan sun rorr acs
fcosnksconn usahjl fr c 'prfvnjcppchsnt' rfgnss"
;>. Hj c nmchokk $t c& >, 5k3<,\covoffc`runk te rfonf` hts ofcj
frhlhjlkfj `` hj n.affrhjlpngh`hg pprchsnrrr \corr`hr'srfrrnj Clprchsnr
Ohst'
@rwnfCpprchsnrohst hs ekrl w₯ctnk"[ahs koo rnpocgnas\co_krprn`sr₯k tst otn `utkco Kstf` mmnr wF efprfvohonk P akas
whta ckjhmuj f` tv*fcpprchsnrsnrcrnogfufty. [on oh$ vho tanfen
rnvhnwk jk cpprfvnk y &ncpphno EushjnssFrmkl`t [ncm jk
r01M'[CM0{KNKG()MTOH^J[
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-5 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 74 f` 70
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 36/126
H
5
7
;
>
0
<
t
H
HFH H
t5
t7
t;
o>
o0
t<
o1
38
54
GcE0>9L{rr-4411&AUOffumcrho3;mk(N/515431 Tsln31f`;5
wooo en gangogkllchosrfurmfst wj hjnohlheon h$. @aco oh$vh^ en
pvhknk f _NtoG's Rvckfr rrmrlnojnm` fmpcfhnsI.voqhshty f` wub
Eu`t encsshltnktf anqphnnrs fotan TrwncrCpprchsnr hst fcc
HthcutX Ecshs. @jTt**o ckknc).
&. Cjy rnruhnhwk cpprwcoey \cJHu's `3jzosctpushjnssFv₯cshle
[ncmws c`ngckn H` ccCokG wtr tf \cH^u'sCpprchsco ushjw Fvnmtlotncj
tf khsgjsstafpncsurfshjlp;f ht eyWocor{u's m frhlhjkfj src``'tfpfvhkf
aolenrafmncppchsco cous, \c Ru rqfcknk 1y cooel te CokG tfwfrb u
hssuffurkrsgtoy g,tte ef fkhrl Gc`r' \c$Hujshst₯k ok hE ofccghlhjkhfj sk
asvnkhrggtffcegtwhta cpphsgn sf anygfuokln` escpprchnosG tas vcounD_ochonk. EfcaNCsk HIHpnurM tehsk`tn* hmrfovsmqttf fgscr.
;<. Cpprchsnrs un cosfcwcfn r"ttanTrfvnjCpprcosnrsjnrnjhjl-
0nong4nky\cR;u'ffccr hlhrrkfj ns, cknkt]f foywy `trcf Clrc`snrtf
lntfrf tan hst ws eyl``hjl \cov{u's hlekhfs tctrte cpchscos tary cful`tc.
Cggm`hjl tftan JXCL's gfc`ocor, hj c, njcht s0t m Cprho 3<,544<f NC'n shoc``
cporchnrs e nryochj vD fnclprchsnrg $rn ₯nmfvnk&fm\co`u's Trfvnf
Clprchs₯r st, NC'sjc"clqrcgosfwo₯klk \cot`hr'n nj grhlhjckf stc``s
hjvfovnjk hj t&nsnonfthfj cppchrnrrtfDrm \corr`u's mtochscos9
H teful$ H Rkg] fcssf jry afulo1 rnlcrkrltaf ngnjtmn$"ln ak
$n cH rggnhvnk&rRkg]Tntfroc*vrgnognjk. ryhR ennocke E3opu
wactobjfry. Hazvn ensr foktetanoukhcl`rH&sc` \ccu cck shg]q,'kn rja;@rywtta anChkG'sDk &tt tanywfrfcft rngfhvhjlclffk
onjrno ` cpp,rkuowfkr" rny tanrn&rfknghkgk nmstjrlttanhrfwj
cppchso @0no ffw ffv`o cs an ucu pfvnu pffo cjk jstjrgrnk
`anCotG's tf uto`h,o" cppcosnrsru &tspcfnokmwnr pfsshaoc'tan
njk nsuot s &k o`yfr cn cft u 0hs prfvm pcrno`t os vry .rjttbnoy
pu whoo rngnhvnmcs wfr&,
;1. [en cr'fovDnftf`\coku's D frhlhrckf stctrhj snongthjl
53
55
57
u
6s5W
j6c
o<rHJW$[ MNJHKNK FHHHTOCHH[`
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-5 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 73 f` 70
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 37/126
H
5
7
;
>
0
<
1
8
34H H
35
37
O;
o>
t0
t<
31
t8
u5o
55
5Q
5;
5>50
j5N
GcssW9tEsr{otN0&AUOKftxmnr`o; mk(H7^E`t41 @clnt8f`;5
cppksqs tf pnr`uj \coh`u'samf ofn qpprchscos s rnckhoyclpcrnjt coo
pcrths hcvfovnksfknrhk₯fg₯k y Dcte s₯key \co_;u's ''oltjckmWuleNC cjk
OWt rn.qufkhjlenckkhohfjf` tpgh`hg cppchsgs f tafTrfvnjCpprchnn st Rr cj
Njcho kfh`nketanJXC4s gfmpoch; NC'sNxksr`hw Phgn Trgshknk j`gmnk
NC'sTr₯shkct`ak'gugnttoy \CHvH^ s ffrrfooel rencp@chno pcrno. [enycrn
snongthjlqprchsscjkgcHojltaD'pmrru'cppc.hsnrs. ansnnppchsnrscrnenhjl
g.afsnjy ta& nInr`mgn. HtO$C9rshm nnlpchsf`` lc nCppchsnol hn
feohlknktf usnWnsncpprchsnm9 an sDkjcsfj\colouhrshNnkfj fmoyjshrrl
he'pfvnjr' ctr;jchswrzs engcrnn C'r crycosm pmvhkk \c$tuw`ta cfg'
vcoul$K;8, Hc ckkhthfcrf snosgtelwahgecppchsm nnrffK os Tofv₯uCpptss
^sg,\cJ;tt'sfcjfrhlhjkf stc` ucr rnspfsheof fr rcfvhjl ;pj9ctns&fm an
Htst wafkhk Nftg..r'@oyshta sNtr no@nn0h0s 0r rnquks `jrahlerytrchscos,k
wafpnr`tmnk kn* nw`tukfcs f` k&c cp@osos ck rnkugk cuf`.anrpprchs₯kl
vcoqnho.hf, `Dn f` \s&tu's ustfm₯ks rfpnrthns.
\co`oq$ TmycjClt9c`rsr HIst tn troflco
>4. [ef us f` @knrco Uquoc``fs pfvhkn tag `f h"kDknjr
gkcgtfj fr'tsf cpprchsnrs,an p3trch$raf^ tgvncf kor₯gtfr hjkhrngh j`nrns,
sjrjghcog f&n`orhsn,u anpfp₯rtyf 0s trfncr`hf"" ^ G.@U. 7;.;>. j
ckkhtofr, an^jh`tD Wtcrkcrks af`ns$hfocoCmmhscoTmgkcs.to$TC@) crn
agfrpcnk hjf `nknrcocq snn35G.@C"l7;.,3;, n hogf{pfk hjffmry, h`
ofh coo,s&0' ocws, jstuohol Gcoh`rNkc,njk n frpwoy hjggpftnk cspctf`
tan rh`um Ukknfhco Cpphso Unpqtrxnk cs an stckcrk tr9f `fr `tf cpprchmo
rg@frN fr tas\cMo ofms tac gn `&ssreiu f` &hs Gfrryocofn^WTCT nquhrcs
ryprcknnjk cpphsco twh₯trrss e trNfvhkfk njsorn"goskheon' cpprchmos yfjpoyhjl rph&^W@CT kknrcppohneon onco cuklf`nsshffco ₯qq`fnD₯jts,
wahga cg`trkf, frl f3trs'aalq tan rnquanmk tecrsppchsa nk cppchsco
rnryhfwsngfjkugtnkrkry₯uk₯K`tyDkrvhoafrsrocs9sCjc@@chs₯rrrqst nr`frc
Ht[H`,W[CMNJKNH'GFMT[CKM
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-5 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 75 f` 70
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 38/126
HH
5
7
;
₯
0
<
N
H
o433
35
o7
[;
o>
30
O<
31
38
54
5o
55
cu
5>5W
5<
57
Gssf>90.gv{Qt10+oUo- Hegumnrko; @oonk47o51r54{@ Tnqono4ft;z
c$ol'rjnjt+gkte r@kkcohty. fthng`hvtty,cck uknpnjknfglfkwotafr`
cggkmfksk.fj `pnrsfjcojtnr& Hj cppchfcoptcgthgn 0 qppchsnrNust rft
pn0rc csco ckvfD `fr cuylty fr hsoc' ^WTCTN`t`m Uuons Gfjkugt),
>3. Knspttn`tnrnquornmsfttajcpprchs₯'rsenf`hcsnk jknlnjknct,jF
ecvnjf khr₯gtfr akhrn{t hjD hj ton erg mf`lcln jqsckhff, anclrn₯mscts
e*qrs \cov`hocjkNC cjk .WHn$eohsahjl \cHvHu'sTrfvnfClprchsnr st pk hj
ptcfn jcppchscosystsoj |rk v,qs jytahjl r`ruoehc$nksjk cknp₯rknk.[`us
cppmhsscshoohjl hf ptrfvh&\cMorwhoe htsksh'nk tola cplchscos&r&fmn
jmtljlpcjsg{hfjs wnrnpchkcfckkhthfjco 4[f\coh&rpn`nrrnknppjhsco nn tr
ncsa ppchsco. [aw cprprksmuuwhoohfl f eck tf \ctrCr's, C'slfkOW` skn`tn tfpfvhkn \cR;uwh`t aoqarypchjce wnrn nmfvnkD &n Trfvnj
Cppchoq Oh$ ey oRcU`f's ofrufrhlhjc`hfj$c$, cukvnrn tacnc`u lfaherhtnktfm
pguthkhjlc@pu9snos rr \cWH^ yNC fr OWO Cpprchsgs, &nrn&rqackssbn hK
nck'mk nvgy cpptnhscoanypnr`Dsk er PcH (u [any urnrn sru03sk j,.jghcooy
`tr prfvhkoflehleafjs ryrchno vcounfafule &n 5nofp`um `fr ncga\cHvHu
slxksco pq`Dr{ njku/₯rs gmrckkey syhtrl f \nMj's6rfvcc Cpprchsnr
Ots`, `g ```hrg s/cortu\tsks
>5, NC cjkHWH ohbnrrhn ackc`jcrghco hjgnj`hvftfpfvokn\sor;u h& ten
songh`hgcppchggs \cov`u |knk. H` nttagrNCg OWH khk mt clrnnfprfvhkn
\cMrr tha cppchscs Cfm Rc]ku's afvnf Cpprksc Ohst, &sy &gnk fshjl
r'{^hfjsf` kfooc$ f` eulhrs f \co`u's ofcrs
>7. NC rngfljenktakPcor{u'sTrgvcCppchsnro-,tst wcsurocukro, art
gafsnflfcofol uktr\c`r;uk ffuthrufkrfvhkhr₯ Rnlcosppchso snrvhgnstr
frknr ₯p kootfjs f` kfoocs m ususpngtal rfwnrs. Cggfrrkhjltfhn
CL'fgfrmpochjqjcffcho `tff'NC'r prnshknf f s₯chft₯Jrg{jthvnf@hrotCmnrhn kfnkCpko3<,54`r<, Ckn*rhenk an kcrhfjsahpuhta\covou s
eoofuj9 cc lefrqtanhssunrsrfushjltrnb shljknk;rphsnrgcnmc'rkxnky
tanPco{ulf&rkfj `frgnC5o}<f rfs orctj cuktypckryfurpmfo \nvonw
o8@H`,W[[M^HKN) GFMTH,CHJ[
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-5 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 77 f` 70
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 39/126
5
7
;
>
0
<
H
8
o4o o
t5E
t;
3>
o0
t<
o1
t8
m63
j57
u
5>50
5<
51
gcs0940sr4HNo@AUO Kffmnjto; mnk44o51I5441tryon`oc`;5
te`ucscyofoctrfo f`ttrn FGSFtrW,@KHGnjk HW|TCToj4unjnIjlquethfu.'
(Erlacn`uCknc).j supputf`M's gfjgauof ak hts clongjnftx9taP/cMuwus
hoallONC'sNxnstho`unPtgfrffbbmrnpnk csujrry f` tn luhknohrns
rrycrr`rrl porksnr cCnmCcgncj;cfrpnk tf \covou's fvnKCpprc`usrhst
gfugoukfkafeoofwhjl9
Ecnkfffurgfw₯rskfu rrnacvnackwh& te \C.tso vgshlag
wntocs &flunshf9tsk csrrrgrsjhthnkey fugmpnktftOt`h,ota
fur ctn;rg49ter tact ton tfco pr',fkugkfj`h a0hclrct knqo t
rtfwttannofgkjlpprcosnj [afTCO RTrfvnrCppr*fr HIst] acs
enn nongtnky af fcjprfkugkfj tc` ork `asLfjtaunk ssf`tansf pprcomrsnef9jlmfjhtftkey tnofcj prfkug.tfjtc`r
@frnxfpol fj uH.WH lnsthfj#o [fs \Covt^ghcjt enupkDk
trmfcgthfjctoycwcy frknrwf jrftcrshp tfcTCOr, \CMOH's
frwnr hs[s, wn gnco sost rscD hjtasmnsmlsflsf act*n
gmjmttft, - CHHK mst horpfrtck Hcrkelgcjsf waypu kokc't
csshlutf TCow'rhgfprfvhonr. Jft rtstjlqTCocplchnncwhoofcc
hwrnsfwnjnktf njljnrEn'wfvsnkq9regnscrft*ay`b`on
jfhkhohcnk ot`u cppncrttfefkortgkyoj gfcrrcktgkfcftOf
hjnclnrgy lkhosotjs ujongr fuacvfc kh``nrnk hrjntort`c`h fu
(Nfpacks kknkl. NftONCckHWHbosw`ar` was` |c 2ou rjzskZhjl,yocvhjlhn om
ftlhoch,fure` pnmfjcooyntngtpprchrnj, cshoqocOcrk ectey clrnn`flf
pfvhkn\cov3uta hn 6cfvncrpprchsnrtr .Ccjk"WHwcncgthjl r gf-
ofru@`uu& Cggfrrkhjlf trf JXCL'sgfrpoch; hjcjnmcho ctnk trho 36,5446,
NC'lNxncjthwPhgnanshktr wsn tf1C's Trshk₯j` k GatnDnkel F``fcrqcrhthjlNC's tfehohtyfj aos9
F`` cjkFGG oy fctrfo oqkss. Hofwwgr,&cn hs ton oqlcogfrgnc
cefrtgfooukfc.703xs.r .Hn.n`'suy ht hskhrgfvnrnkojt c srknr
5C@HUWH C$HNJKNKGFMTH.CHH[[
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-5 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 7; f` 70
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 40/126
H
z7
;
>
0
<
1
8
34HH
,5
37
o;
o>
o0
t<
H1
t8
m5o
<5
57
5;
5>50
u51
GcsnWot&0@`Q)101+{UOKfgurnjto; @hosk4D1/54{N \p;,c`;z
Sftcf``gs k c omknr) hs efhjlgfootuhvnyktacjcpprchsnrtacts f
F^U(\CJktt)p,n3. [echs, furrq njkrjjcfrsrypoy. [amwn
cn ohcea H wfuokscytngcusnwn srnlfon cofjlshn`t-- Hj ckkhthf,
H teab ht gtR t'r"Oa fur rnp``hhfoo hc nn cpprchmo f'r'jruhty engcusn
hr₯ crnsoofshjl \CM^ e phgOcppchsr ecsnk f.&nhr ofcjf`ts₯rs.
Htjcbs w off&gfmpohfht Wf u jcymt e cpthfjceon
onlcooyek wfuokaurt fr rnprtghf,. oof thfsn crn htrfak taho'lr
f`tan q`` tasrf fc>renmfn h` wn₯'2jbceug ht cjk"mgnc`hjpcrcffhc
>>. Knsp`he Dshfl rnluoctfryut^y, 30`,8s'}cjjecjkcjan&srrqCoprces thsq \co`uccjlaffe`uskn gsstN`nssjgn ygacjlhjlts ocfn f`
hts @rfvnj pphsnr Ohst ft&nq\co `uWfong`pcrno \covou e`₯kal &n,7{cjn
gacjlqfmrfrgu cnnkk uk/f usnf` ton mfqobnr TCts^stskhsfkhrusk
ujknrkhr₯kff`ten \cokuonlco ₯pc`hrgjt\ncrn kohzhclcmgnlnfnrhgc
cggnptceofohj rnlloc`₯ryuhkn`hj₯scho jkjw sfckcrksW
>0. Cscrsorf`\covtj'n,NC'sfkoW`hcrrcryD₯gr gctsphtcrynk
ng`umn,ofuscjks`\cov{j wf$₯rswafgfohng`vn$pchk jhoohmsf`.eR.ks 0r
ojknpnjknjloehcss;cjklrnkheon" ppcchsce,honktfrnshvnwMtaq` pchkcr
cjk r*ttf knrroc1nka₯rney.
Trkrj[rx[WHKJNX GNFOO
><, Tahrgh$ WokrnyWgafoo hs m hokhvhkuI wef s cghth*sr f`ten Mn f`
Gcth`fmon,sshk'jl j WfcfmcGfrrjy,Gcoh`frchc
>1. HjF{hofe₯q6.f40,;s Wnf n&Nk cfffrtl;lnofcctefulo'Qoc}vou'f
f`rgn hj Wmfc Gcohhrjhc tf purkcsfc`p₯rty ofgcek ct 38;[nrrcgqNkjD
Fbocefmc.Wnn&rehehtH (W₯``H₯uokWNtN c₯c`)>8. Hf gungthm whta tahl ffj,\cMuprfsurnkk hNgo` crk HtH& Wgafoo
f cpprcon,of, tanfeinftpfpnrty &fmNCcjk/qHWH. >n Nx`hheht Y(cppctst
rgpfrt). tas ryorchsco rgpfro '*hohcrl &n ^jherc UnshkjksoCpprchscofmr,
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-5 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 7> f` 70
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 41/126
H
5
7
;
>
0
<
H
8
t4o o
35
o7
O;
H>
o0
O<
o1
38
54
5t
55
57
5;
5s6>
j5N
GcsnW941.cr-4D0&AUOKfgumnrto; @honk47/51/5qN Tqljnzlf`;5
gnrth`hs `oct ht grcs fmpontnkj mpohsgn wo& tanorWTCTsjkcr&r hrgHjkhcl
eghjlonr`fmk hj c hrknpnjku,f$ngthvn mkrm^rcsnkjtqjnr. k &cos
cgojfuknklnsoct tancpprchsco rcs nr`mk `q \covtjcjk1C cjkpfvhknktf
heD kk OWH,cchorrl gf"k@""kstk tf es khsgtf&k f cjkgfuoken nohnku@c et
tanefrmtq,Ms. Wgaf^ anrm``nslntfctccsgthffshtaPce`u. tk Ht s.
$geR ms g&crlnk5>>.44&r tahscppDosco.
0. ahos.$gafR usknfstfryoaf rcspuj&cshjl gnkheon, cur`uonntushsco
cfkack g tncsfctfkfue'tangnrt``hsthfj hj tafcpprchno rnpfrtcjk anrn`gn
enohwnktocr tancppfchutkfjnfua`` `fpnrty ovcsl`frnc hcn\cme,
feingthvnoy,whtafrt "jkus kusjgs 0 ehc$f c$nst anwHuNf` tanafmn,cjkwcs^anrwhsscgsnkheoncsr`to cpphso kfrne gfmpohcon uktr cppohnetn cw. Ht wcs
upfj ehs npprctscoect ,3&Wgaf^ rk \cMunfrsnkenr fcr.
03. Gfk;rytfMs oogafoo'senohn`cskuuenbjf$osttfagrmthtsagtoy
ekfrn `hohol 303rGfjpocar, tan cprchsct fr tanprgpcty taftwcr ansueing` ` anr
\coou ofcqwcsgrCnkpurrucjtf tessgomn knqhenk hc tahs&jpochjtcjk
tenrn`frg_`s"Wg&fooktkcftrggnhvn ,anjkcpnjkct,feingthvn urehcsnk jk
fnkhetnnpprchsco frnhj gfqhohcrgfukta cppohgcetnolrr`fru`rtgasanKsh;ksg₯
jfsuga;pchscoujspnr`mnk W\EMq NC,OWH ftanhr cl``h. Htks.Wgafooa0
enj&fclnktanrney,
T[OCW`HH@@ @NO[FJC. WTNCUW U.
05- Toch`hk&,7notDC- Wp; Ir., s mhjkhvhkuco srafs cghtoznjf`tas
Wnrg f`Gcot&fhc, rsshchjl j WcuIf&,Gcoh`fjhc
07. Hjtrkc9.ra, Jo , Mr. Wpfcj `nrnk c ogtlcln ofcc phte\cMufc c
pfpgy ofck hj Wcj fsnGcoh`qchc.W₯nNxeheht7(Gofshjl utmnm).
C. amqhfwh`a&osofcf, \c&oupfgurrnkfrhtsno`nkMr. Wpncrscjcpcosk mtan weingnp'rgpgtyhmNC chogt.$O Ht hsesohw₯kant0f
;nscoscanTfst,rrohzo;ltan ok`.N'jUshk₯qothco oR'tchst `rm, gsrthtrnsh*ht
urus fjpofnke gfupohcfgf hta on WTCTtcjk₯oks,jgakhjl nhjlnr`fqnc
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-5 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 70 f` 70
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 42/126
5
7
;
>
0
3
1
H
34j35
o7
t;
3>
[0
r<
31
38
54
5o
55
57
5;
5>50
j51
Gw094&gv-t 411WAUOKffmnko; @tonk47rYCY4F1.;f5;f`;5
hj cjhjknpcknm,fei?`hj cckujehcsnk"r*fEsr.k Hths cosfeohnvk&k`u
cpprchscogpfrtckruswonklc asttancpprchsco csp`fj nk fr\cW{umkNC
cjklfvhknk tf tan- crk .WH,csksmsgfnryocektf en khsgof,skofcfkgfuoken
rfNnk pfceyten efjfum,Mr. Wpwl hu ahsjfrqcln fco trcfscgthftxphta
\cotkj Hk o&. $pncrs c garlk rypfkjcnoy W03.D `s ttkscppkno.
0>. Mr. $pnm ujknjstffknwcspwgarshjlc grnkheos, cry`to cjmhsco
cjkackjfrncsf tf kfueta₯₯₯rk`hgcthD 0f cppksco rnpt nok hanrn`ctn
esohwnk tak tan cppchmokfrnfcehspfpnrty rcs Dfrk akspjkkoy,
feingthvnojvh&fr$ujkunhj`oufjgn ehcstf&ttop vsoun f`teafmn, crkvcs
ftangwhsngrnkheon,Hsrn`uo @@`tc'scoff hj gfpoh,cjfnvhta [email protected]. Gfncytfotkr. Wry' enohn`k ujekrjfgrmrrfahfjkhosefky
en`grf h ohjltats Gfrpok`, hanq``rchsco `u tenpfpcty tact wcsan sr$ngt f`ahs
WcMu Hm wcsgrgnkpurucjtf &n sg,afn kskA oj ths Gfrupoq`ucjk
tanrn`frnMr. Wpncrs k uft Dkysto,n knpnjksfqfeingthvn,mehcsnkfk
grnkeonqp'rchscokfjna gfupohcgn whta cpp^gceoncw`fr wahgaafphk, shjgnf
frgacorprchscojcs c`mnk ey \cMj,NCr H.WH ftanhr clD. }`r, Wpfgsacs
ennjkcfoclnk&₯rney.
KN[NJKCJ[W'CFJGNCHhHNJ[ F@[HW WGWNJHN
0<. \cMu'l NC's fk OWH's s&₯kon f gfjkugt.cuk&rrlfTochj`h`t cjk
tanGocss fr cpprkscosf\ctrkuamn ofcqsrojtwnrsunhtasohkqnork``h,
feingthrj, fpcrthco, uehnsnk gnkheon frhcgf"'ro,rohmclwhta^WTCTcjk pohl,ee
ocwuhcscwnr kosofsnk f Tochrrth`r f cuyGtcs ormenr ey Kn`tjkks.
01. Jfrkhk Kn`tKkcjslhvnTtfhr`h& frtafGHcs cfyrncsfctf usp₯g`
tec`&nrg wnrncry prfeonms`& tjnhr cplch&ts. Hrhtnn; ohC cjkO$H srnrn
rwqlRtznq cnsrhfgnk npptctscoffpchns qhaf ₯hcenkgnrth`hsrtcpprksf wafornpcrgkNpfrtstct fc essur`cDpDnk tfesvs oo f` &s ncrjn*sf`
onlhthjrtq ojknpnoknk,eIngthvn,mAcsnk,nkheonnk Hsu`uo cpczhrcos[ef
c,ppchst nps0njrnjhmouknktonpprchrnr'snrth`hgchmtaktanrnpfttxcs gcf
57
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-7 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 3 f` 51
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 43/126
H
z<
;
I
0
<
1
8
34HH
t5
ot
3;
o>
O0
t<
3t
38
5` h
5H
jcc
5>50
5<
51
GnnW94$gv{QNt@AUO Kfsmnjto; mnkko`51tr,M Tqn5ohfo;5
hjknpnj`tnmoy,kw'thwoj hjpcrtctoy cjhoe gfryHhmgnwtta IHHTCTujkqksck
cppohgc,eonbn.
08, $`jnvnr, htvcs trckhthmo tactfkns, ohbn \sMu,wuok fetchj
ryprchmos `lfpnrkfsj nfjjnsthfjrhta anefrs ofct$fukwfuok rgvhknan
cpprchcco₯pqrhtfefrmrsngfkwfuok tcrp tenerfwug `frtas npfrts.j
stasr ``frks,rh&fu` hmofsurn` Kn`ukcrrrsrrcflnjft,Tochrth`r cukanGtsss
gcuokcft acvfrnsfjceoyqspggtnkacta0n rcscjyoah;l r{jlshta tan yprkmo
`gr wahgatonywnrn fagnNrlk.
<;, [ag0rtt thmsKn`fjkcjts'g&cswr pueohgcooynvncok ns hjtan
@cotf` 5`r3< anj anJnwXgt Cttmfy Lnrscocmfujnk e hcvnsthlcrhmkgf`oc`u c`u NC`tr gfup`uojlw&a\co0r f gmn &tsfcppmhscosrr \c.R;u
afmnfn$ Hows fjoyupm cjkn`tNroanJw Xfr .C`tfmnyLnjnno'f
cojfrjgnfnjtR ten@coof`544< er` Toc``h0 enccjn w{s f`KknjkDt$'
sgacn,crk&C Fcssntasrs gfuok svnbfjscwfrn f`&`fkcr$s' sganfn.
GOCWWCgjFJCO^NLC`o8JW
<O. THcethW atfltehscsthmq aeco`f`tanusnovn cqk jeneco` ` coo
fjesmntjesotf`tan Gocss"Gocsh} kn`uk csnotpfjs hj$n ^knkWtctnnwhf
rngnhvnkcams ofsfsta \so|`u cjk nhvnk cjcppcosfol`frrnk ey NC fr HWO
Nr?g.ouknktmtan Gasslont trcMu'rf C's,cjkO$Rtr f``hgnrk,kOs.oqs cjk
mcjclsrhco mpofyn, ck fy f` \c `u's,NC's, q OWH'lluenhkh,Nyt ctro&knk
khkn cjkcy f` tanoklns f` `anG.suho n`frnwahga ahggcsnspnkhry.
<O obnsrntafuccksf`gocssotsjewwafcrn lnflrzpahgcooykh$ssnk
terfulafuttan jhtnkW0ns, jcoukhrl Gcoh`fjhc taNrn`csq uktuhkuctfhjkg f`
coo m"srew f`tanGa$ sfuok e hmprcg`hgceon,
<7. Gffmm qnsthfjsf` osc q > nxhst cs f coh mnfengf`tan Gocs.[ancn ukfjs 3unkDhjcts vnstn qrg*hfs c``ngthjl oy hjkhvhkuco ocs
gontt'enrs. ern gffmfu flcon &ftfctqunnths's jgoukn9
c- Woaka₯r\cMuntrnrnkhjf fclrnnjf,whtaNCckofrtsotf
5;rHUW[CHkHKTKGFMT[CHJ[
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-7 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 5 f` 51
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 44/126
H
5
7
;
>
0
6
t
8
34Ht
35
o7
t;
H>
30
t<
H1
o8
54
5O
65
57
5;
5>50
5<
5N
GnnW94&cr.441to&AUO Kqmpjto; toonk4C/5WN(H{)1Tcln5cko;5
p'rf{Rrncppchuo snrvhgnsartsw0 cft@r`ft rgk ey hjknpnjknm,jahcsnk
cprlchnnrfsrquhrnk ey cw2
e. \MqKn`skc$ ackcjk&cvnpfohghnlprc.jhg0,fr
prfgnkrrnsac uuknjjhjn f pfs,hehohty &c @onhcth``r crk tanGocs rngnhvnk
grkteos c@phscor kfjfjgfmpohcjgnwtta HWTCT jkcppohgceofocr2
g" \astog \cMu, erfulats clrnncnkoCktaNC jkofroWo wcs
ceone gfftrfoan cppchscolw, ey`ts gccfrhlojkhfcpnrsmmofrftacjrhn,
ey acvhjls`taqNC frOWoprfvokfahla₯rc`Dhsnkvcounsfrafmg &ccNo 's fr
O$H's cpprksnrackotttcooy gfjgouknk ' tacjujcs&ncgtuo `tafcrbnt vkun f`
tanafnN; \en&srNCcjk/frt$oclrnskwhre\cakrtfprcvhkn\cR;u
vhta npprchsnrc of rrnrnsno*.tnkeyPcOou `f e fc PcoPor's TrfrDCpprchsnr *
(frtan\covtjWnonstrmno)
n' \an4esrPcMcgfkfoonkck/qjchputcfk&pft f`
cppchsnjfj\c&3u's rfvf Cppjhsnr^sl
` \an*enr&nclrfcnjnengwc\sR{K,NCcjkOWogfjsthmnc
ghvho gfcsphrcgy2
l. H8as&nrKc&jkcks'cg`hfjs nsqhenk qna vhfbhon anUso
NstctnWnkfrcrt&fgnkurn$Cg`` 35^W.G.$5`o <2
e. \a₯&qKf`nfkc``sj gghfcsnrgrhenk nrnhjveorrn &oh`fmhc,s
Eushcns ck Trf&shfjsGgkqskhDs H<5J k ccq.2
h $oentaqoon&jkcue'sthfcsvhfoctnGcoh`fjhc'sGfrsufnoslco
Usktn Cgo, Gcoh`fcchcGovhoGfknsnkhfjs <>Fntsnq2
i. \MnrKn`ckcmerncgank`aneg``hcg`sg,trapahkh`t mk
tanGocss9b Qoncpprfphcrg.cssurnf`ropot₯₯ncjk/frrsta`hfc
<;. Tochjh`r' gIchjs rn oChgco f` &n gochjgs `tan Gocss,e tatr Tochkhs
rff`tfur frn jfolcln onjs wh& KkmkcrkPs.HvHuck tonhr afjncplrchscos nrn
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-7 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 7 f` 51
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 45/126
t5
7
;
t
0
<
1
8
o4ut5
o7
o;
3>
o0
t6
o1
38
u5t
55
c6C
GcsnWkoW'gj``tlt@AUo Kftujfjt3; @oonk47oQh5ml Tl₯of5<ft;5
prfrurnkfr &nu ey \kkr tar₯a NC ck/fr OWH. Tochkh& tanr&rn rn cf
kh`trnfrt j cjy nonvk rqjk Cfm cjyftas Gtqs$r'nrjenr, jk&nnohn` fule
`ugfmmutften Gocss.
<>. TochGhW cn ckqucn rnprnsnjtrthvns tan Gocsse₯gcjsnane
hRtnsnfekf mt fff`ohn`whta on hgnrsj f`ton gocssmfenrc thny snnbtf gprw,
cfk anyacvf ncchjnkfrmntgfrytnut cjknrpknjgnk c gfkugtocl gfc;ofr
gocss gthfc hklkhfj Tos``h`r ck &kr gfujsnowho cknqu*ntyprft₯gtta₯
h``hf`ta₯Ge's.
<0. C gasr cgkfr ssjltfr tf ftanrcpchoceon ₯ns `fr tan ae sfk
n``hghfk c{huktgkfc f``rhs ktsprf. [an {rm;lnst``snk ey "cjt' jkovhkuct ocscnmenr hbfoywhoo enrfoctovnoygc.cot,nspnghcoyltv`hton eurknjmk nxpcsnf`
hjkhvhkucopfrfhf f`tof ffmponxhthlchm ffnshctnk eyKn`njkf1' gfcr$jj
Ha$ ttwmokenvtcrtty orqwh^t `frtohngocssN`Neqs hjkMkrcooytf
6><.0
j6s
nNkvnoy rnkrnsfan wruls k0jn f tac. O;frnfvnr,rnf `tan gocssrn' oesl
gfuokc`u htkMkuco cgthsrs, t wfuoksthoo cftenpn`cceon tf socs whkn
ohthlcthfc Hjkhvh&&thznkckhfjsprnnjr &npftfrhco `fr hjsnshstqrt fr
cfkckhgtKryukljD. Eygmcsq c gocss gthm lnsnrksu `qs rjcjnln'j₯ut
kh``guothns uk pfvhknstafecn``n f` jh"lonc;hrrkhgc`hfj,gfcfchss `s₯tn cjk
grynjnjstnn $ryl6hshfjey ckclon cfut
<<. Hjtan cotnrjchvn,tenGocs jcyen wth`hnk engcrsn&&jkcksacjn
cstnk r ₯`h$k3f cgtfslmujks njgco$cppohgceontf anGocsq anrneyr'cb2jl
cpprfpk,ct, rnoaaky nk `""ro nqkeetn rnohn`whta rnpngt tf hanGoc`scsc wafon,
@rUq(xttrtRxofUUNOrN@(Clca$He`gErosjto' `fr Phfoctofj f` UNWTC, 5 HH.W.G.W5>4;
<1. THch^h& awey hrgf;rgrgn tanernlfhjlpclrcpas f` tahsG0,",'@oc`fcfknstce&nu ns tanywnrf rrooywrh`hnjasnhu"
<8. ^fknr 5 .$.G8504{e)f`UNWTk Rj]fpnrsfjacoo afmk jfp₯0D c^ cgggp fypftthfc, poe,frpcf.o3rsln`cfygacrlfcknfrrngshvnk
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-7 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln ; f` 51
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 46/126
H
z7
;
>
0
<
1
H
34o o
35
o7
3;
H>
t>
[<
31
38
54
5O
j67
5;
5>50
j51
GD>9410kr41&.AUOKfg.jrnjto; @otkmz1`zml Tclc51fo;z
`frtenjjknkrlf`c nconsurn vogn hj gfjfngthfjh& cccscs`hfcjvfovhcl
`nknrcooynoDkNstlcls fcorfttnr an;&krsh'hg0 cgtucooy nr&mfk."
14. Tochj`h0ljkton Gocsnftnrnk knrcooyneLkmfklslnfcjrwhta
\chooum frc``gr rmn , 5440.
13. Hj gfmnsthsjwhtatafn\coku fsjs, ochjth`t cktan Gocsswnrn
gacrlnkg cpprkssos\cOtuprffrnk rr tosf tafqe NCcokOWH ec rpun
gnk``k hjtefCpchsct npfottfewkheon, aknpnjknjte`ngthrn,rehcks; ck
pnr`fmnkj gmpohcjfnwh& WHCTmkcppohgceoncw.* (t``hhesk tarfuljf`
tehsGfjpocho, f sxoac@@rjhsos rfm s&rmnkey on`tjkks ck `ancpprchscos
`u wahga@ochkh& cck anGtcs sntf goglsC y \nfcfg s₯rn rnorenrhjkspnjk₯ft"ei₯sthvn, ehcrnk gr pc`gmsk hc fmpooccgfwhta HottTCH q
copohgceon cw, j vhfokm f` 35 .W.G.$504<(e) ` UNH@C, Cssrge, as
cppchscosTon$N cfk tn Gocssgfhv₯k `fj \cMq NC fkootnqsjg
cpphscos k coo atoc tanygfjokcftenrnohnku3m ct cto shjg0 as` eckjftefnj
pnr`ufk a gfmpohcjgn hte tancpohgceon onlcomk prf`nsshfco.{r@jkcrknj
ftanrwfrks,anryprchsos Tosokh`& nrkte₯ Gtns rfgnhvnkwnrncDwfr&tofppnr
fc wahga Dr ugrnphfrnk ck rnrn f`os`ohs vcOtnosr.
T. Tochjth`t sjktan Fcsscwsrrgsnhv₯ktafcpprchsconthgnerrrahga
tanyrcn gr'rlnk eyKfrnjkcr*g k 0cru0u.s;crjsllk0sney.lo. Htjk₯r35^,$.G.850``(c) f`UNWTk'`c]fpsfc racoolhvnckjf
pnrsfj acoocgggpt uynn, Ak0cso, s3 ahjlf` rrcoun ursuk tf ny clrgfrEfctr
uckslcrkhjl ftcofrftanrrhsl to"t eushjss rghkk tf frpct f`c rct nst tn
sncknrfqtsnrrrhfscvfovhjlc`nknrcooyrnonkmft₯cln ofm.pasooesrnLfnktfcy
Honr@f&'
1;. Cs knggrhefkamulafktahsGfrjponhjt,\c`founortmk t$f srr₯rnnrak fr uckqscjohol sh& NC cfkO$H sp0h1r`ultaC hc nx'{'cln `fr\coku
Wn₯shjGfNC cfk trH coo g mfst f` tanqprchfo archj* `rr \co& rshk₯khco
ofcjs,NC nckO$H wfuokgffpnr;nwhtaorcMutf njsurnoct&ncpprchnos
j@HJW[CMtstHKKKFFM}[IHHJ[
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-7 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln > f` 51
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 47/126
H
5
,
;
>
0
<
N
8
o4ut5
[7
t;
t>
30
t<
t1
38
54
5o
u57
5;
5>5.0
jc
GcsnWW.froouW0&AUOKqsjnr`o; @otk``hhz1N441 o%ln1k;5
ssceohsank fpnrtyvcouns ujchktf sr@@frttef\ct{u rnchknjthcofsjcffufts
rnlrkons f` tan rusNs*nR vnounf` tanpfpgkns tac wnrn&n Wingt f`thn
\cJ{uafmnofcs.
N>. [f `rghohc`s \cov`u'qNC's cjkOWTsclrnnjn`tfrujknrstDkhj&C
cjkOWH ₯rnnk tf uss `0 WtcH`u asrfnfcqs) pprchsnrso'cr\coP`rr'suf
uhlhekhf g`hc`r nonggfkf enfj tsTrgvnjCptrs`u₯rOost ank fj&nrc
akhtthkucb prfvhkhjl\covouwhtasu``hghkoy rtla cpprchscosf jjc*hcooy efcn`ht
efta\cHA^ k hts onj frhlhochm sc`r, Hjrn`hjc, \cn`tr sjcjknk&`r\ ck
OWH pnycporchsj u htsafvcClchscoet c 5(K/frnjhr9jfvnjtc` NC's cjk
O,W`lstc``f tahrkpcrtyclchnnuswnrnpchk. tafnfryprksnrswof khk mr prfvhkn\cov{u `te &n ksshrgk'ola;rchso scous opq₯ rDfvnk&fu \c${u'n cfvc
C@prchssOhs` ey\c&ttr'sfc frhlho*hfc rpIt ck jrnrnaDpfaehtnk `frj
lrfvhkhqlcppchscosfr \cMqcckffuokcftNntt,n 5D/fpmtsctprnjej
Cppjhscs fu \cWtu'sTrwm Clpchsf Oh* ocvn c `uco arnrnstKncga rrk
wnry \co&rafmn mu cfrDqlncsgthfj ta* tanyDfjr cppchscosnrvtgfs
`fr,efra fr 0f hrg,nkh0j5.\4ckkhthfjcoWn,csjnoo cs t`rrn cppjchscosfr\co`u
st ton ckkhohfoco 5P/f n.
\. \soy`ueffn`ho&k&mtahscrcflnjfkey snfualmfrnahlavcoun
af-n &frtlsl0 tec` t gfuokaukon ck sqktor `fr sresDhco rf` n, cok NC
ck H.$H enon```r₯k&fm&hs cccflnmngey mjhjl c$fckyscnf.f` cpprchsco
rpgb f'\cor;u afjn Djs Cllrch*rffj\cov{u's wnf Cppgchsnrohstgraf
untnrftchcnk yNC cuk WH cpnr&m cpprchvts fr\cMuaffrnofnfs nDtttnk
&fj &hs cccjlnssjhey rngnhvalc 54%pmhwf tj rnujj f tes`f crthghpghfu j
tohs ufocw`trocrrcjlnfnf ktaWrcHvHu, C ₯jk ,$O
{3. Tochkh``s cjk& Gocss jrfkcjclskeyK&kctE' gttcrl$rrnk`tst r$fy₯'nn fgshy₯kafcpphsco snrvtgnu.vahfa tsyurnrn aclnky
Kn&jkcmck hjsnck uvhjhjloyngnhvnkfrnohceon,hcsnkDssos tac ww
t&necshs ``hn mutlqn tcfscgthfhsany₯kknkshta olcj`hO
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-7 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 0 f` 51
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 48/126
H
7
;
)
0
<
1
H
34o o
O5
t7
t;
t>
o0
t<
t1
o8
54
5o
jj5;
6s50
c<C
Gssn>941.g@4^QoW.AUOKfq.Ejsjto; @oonkm54oz441 Tclf$f`;5
WNGHFJHH GOCHM Q3FUUNOHN@
(C@hastK₯`hmkcj$ `fr ^j`rtrNukjnnr acnkgnn j Xhforkfj f`
Eurtfnss& ``hkfjs Gfkfll35m_ k scc.)
11. Tonhjkn anrseyjffrnMnnn nr₯kjl prcnrcpors ` tehsGDntkjt
cfk nstt& anjtcs`tanywnrntooy whsnj anrnhj
18. tas ^GOkn`hfsujnhrashjnssgmpc`thfutf jgoukn jytjocw$ro
uj``rfr &crkuonj`o gtgprnknf. GsOEus.& a`, Gfkn o6544.84. Ceshrnn prcfthgns tjocg`h{" Nknrtan^j`chrGfmpnotthfjocs`t
hs `frehkknjy cq hjgou'ohjl ``f s &ksco b``h grNluokhfj&
83. tan Gfkn `@nk₯JconluokDspsfv`knsar `faknpknurffrtrcctfj r "Wf"c`Dsnm, ancpprchsg roo tj'n jf ktnggfr jkhrggtft₯r₯t
`hjcjghco r ftenruhq hj tanprfputyfr tan cjscgthfc"35G7.U.7;.;>. r
ckktthfj,an ch`sDWtcckcrksbfnnshmcoCpprchscorcgkfnuWTC`o,wahg.a f hjgupgctnkhjof&knrcocwey 35G@C"W7;.;,;,khkftos stctntcw
f` ujy, h` jftcoo ktctns,jgohorohjlG.oh`uhhc (gcnGroo`fNhcEushtrssc$k
Trf`nskfjsGfknl33738) nquhrn cpprchs₯rsfp₯tr0'D gnkoeonryprcM htfjnj
fmpohmgn whta WCT $cjkcrk$wahga jfouk"s nqrhkjl ok &rhr cpchscos en
gfckugtskjknpnjnk>j'Cf cpprchsnr u$ l`m csNl@r"nctsrhta n@ckhEohty,
feinfthvhty,cfk jknpnfknjglk rrh&f$ mrrjksthfro f`pncwco tknrnts" Hj
cpprchsco rcgthgn, `, cpprchscr Nstfftpnr`frmsssf ckvfccon0 ry pqty k
os$rn." H`hHTCT Ntahn tuon (Gffkugt).
q5. ^WTCTcofrn$&₯stak0Rn]ctamhumrnctprfpfrtycpprchscornpgt
uust gqtchj cshljnkg₯rk`hgcrhfjhc` snhmhosrhjgfk₯j` tf `on `roofwhjl`rtos9
H gnrk`y qt' 3n&n ensn ` ey brfwo₯klsck ekhk
- tals&tmnm f` > Djtchj₯k oahsrnpfr cof us cjkgfungt- tanrnpq`tnk jcorrsns,phjhfjs, k gfmoushfjss oomhtnk fov ev ts
gtjgorsutKs.
crHJl[ CHHNH_'KNKWFMJ.CHJ[
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-7 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln < f` 51
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 49/126
r
H
5
7
;
>
0
<
1
8
t43o
O5
37
t;
t>
30
O<
Ht
t8
5C
5o
c56su
5>50
j5C
D>94&sv{341&AUO Kfgumnjto; mk(o7o51r5441 Tcln73f`;5
H ecvnjf(fr tanspsh`hnk) rnsnKtfrxfsKngthvnaN₯st hj &nfrqfnrtytoc` e tnEuehn₯t r`tahs rnkfrtcjk f (fr `tf smgh`hN4 jn'sfjco
' '
hKosrnstonhteu@n(ttf `tn hjrthns tvf`vnk"
H acvnjfehcswhta rNKngtf tt7 ufK₯$v rc hs tas$&hngtf`tthsr₯pfrt0 tftaspcrthEhj'rgovnkr`hta-tehs-sshoorrrjk.
jy njl₯nfnkhqtehs.qryonnj₯KtcsKftgfkhKl₯k pf cfrnofphjlq rwfrfWl prnlso@rrr|Nnf ssKots.
^PqfjjcgChfj `fr ffmponthon ehscs-shqjjnjtl>ltgfmhjnnkNfmtan ksvsofKmnk r tnmrtrjl fo-csnknt`rhj₯k yctun khrnk`hf hhvcous o;,ev0s tangcsss [&₯kohnut, anfjfujtf` tenvcounfKhjhfr-ton ctt6 ``h$ f` ckhpkD$ rgso{-frhtrn plqurrgjgn-f sranqtDtnvkkhtM`y r₯Hcektf tn hjtnkko usnf`tohs cmceco
``hA "t'"Trf`nsstr`rrzoplctsco acgkgNf[as ylchsco qfrtn frthn Wrc `u rn t@g crfasureohngt` tehrGfmptchrt
f*j0f0 tahr frc fltnhohst`tkNs`hDo₯rth`hgc`D.
17. [apr'rjsfr sorjhocr WTCT nokfsuoq ``hkcrks cjkfs`h`gckffs rn
rnqutk `frcp`₯hsst nvonrnm.f.,qpchsnrswafpnr`fu cqucthrywhnmq`
cjftanroprchsnksnlgrt).Wjga pprchfcogvhnjmnrn nr&rjnkry NCsrk OWH
cppchscornrutnmrsjtancpprchsctrnpgefrnc \nW{ufs`t tacrrntasseinsr
f`tahsGfpochrg
8;. \cMu, C uk OWoacjncjkf'rrhjuntfhftctnan omosw`uo7prfjl
f``tn ^GO erful angr₯khfc tk usnf` \c&{u'sfvnj Cppmh9sOhs enccus
npprchscsj ehs hs foncoyecvn j utnrnstK,DsaWrc&tu mn ryrchscotrcscgthf, mkcn cs ujahcsnkk hjkqnjkn`- \cHP{u'sfm frhlhjghfj nc`
snong`upchsnmtfenf. oe Trfvnf ppku Ohsn csnk tesnnjktvhkrsepfrhkhjlHorcovtuwotastrknj{y ahlacmkscos f`hjjjghcotyenn`htefta cMoo
cjk ts uf frtlachf stc`r, e tttorj" \ctrCrnmpckset NCck t-WHpcy
;prchsnrrfj tsTrgvn'jppmtsc h$ c 5D0 nfhuc fjnrwoj NC,sfk HWH'sf``fr `aakprty cplksw crn no; `tfsn rytsun s&fkfjf4 rfvhkn\c&jr
wtta $n&krnkahlacprprkscocasscrgnjf ,nkjs,\covtu's@tfjnjppchsnrr rntey \c&Hu'sfcffklhukfcl;, cjksrnrn'r₯c&nrrneoettnkf ,@$rtksl
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-7 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 1 f` 51
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 50/126
`[
5
7
;
t
0
<
N
8
o4H t
35
t7
3;
o>
t0
t<
o1
o8
54
5o
K
c5;
5>50
j57
n>94@gj4toDA@{O tcsjcrt3; mkF7515441 TqnT,ft;5
cppjchscosg \cHv`tO rk gc cc lngenJ/c cppjhwo pwef. Cpprchssjfc
\c`t`hr'sTrfvnjCppchsnrOhrt gosoy acvns`hocfk"No utnrk hj n"..h cjkw0y
\cMuafmnffjNf;lpls rqrcg`hfc tant ey p₯r`gj cppchmo snrvhgnsrr, efta
`fr tas mnkhctn 54<4 kkhthfjco n, cswnoo cs tuf cppchscosfr \ctrvou tas
ckkothfjco5tK/fnn.
8>. _trc${j,NCcjkOWofusphrnktf coofw\c&tr's fj frhlhtrsrhff c``tf
sgongt jktvh&rnos f es 0 \cO&'s TrfvnjClxcosnr thst nvnfeful `nkcco cjk
sNtc cw aoe`tr off pfkugnrsrfmac$q ckhrngt 'r`ounmgfjryorch*rs.,Wcn
F``hgn f`otrh`t,Wupnrvhshfj `F[W), pueoh$nkr[rnlun``hoyCsbnkSlkfrs futan
cppchrco Usluockfusuk en runrclscgytsmct fjojkspk``h Cpphsco DkNvcach,ff@ujgkfs.' \cotr`u, C"cfkOWH cosfslrnnkact\co_t`u'sq
fr{lhj ohffs@wfuokevn gfmfo fvg knghkhulv&hga jkhvhkucorujutkncyfj
t&n h$ hj vhfosthff f` `nknrrcoqqjghehgaprfaheht fcr pfkuggs &ffo acvhjlc
k`tngga`trcgn cu c$pochs0.
80. `trsula n0n nltn₯mD, encpprchsnj c \cotr'sTrgvnorCpptshssr
Ohst cchcnk ey NC ck OWH `fr \chCr efmnfss crnjfrcgthjljknpnjknorko
feinthvnoy k hj gfjpo`uugswhta oooTCT srcjkrkscs skDo kk Dn 3N_r
jskks. UConq \cH,`hr,NC crkOWHpDht ck ecvnclrk tf omht \corku's
ofcjfklacthfj stc``khrng`gDst v`ta cppmhsnrsf hkucn otfhr jaorjctn
cppctscoknghshfj, stnckf`coomkjltanm,tfcgt f mu*hcsnc, aCCmkngc
nsahfh" orofrnfvnr,e cppchno tryts &j` tonss cpprcosmgnfctnf \c^orafmn
ofcf&wehfacrs cp@rfvnkyNCcskOWH oj tea rnvtfwlrfgnq con ft
tjknpfkngh fShng`hvn,fehcsnk.rnkoeofgpnr`fmk hj gffpohcjfnvhtaoosTCT
stcjkrrkscsrg$rhrkey `nkrrcocjksrcf cw.
8<. CkkahfcooW cs es vhfokfj f` cjy cwmcysnjjc tOnprnkhgcn frcvhfokhm f`tan ujocw`to prfl f`tas ^ `re Gmpfththfr,Ocw,Ttctuh& `hor&n(
cooqn Wk Kn`nfkcjtQ t hfbkjl tts.U₯coN$ctfWnjopmnfrrrfnkjn Cgr, an
Gfjsujnjslco UnrunkhsCfqcqkton gfr"'cfrocw f`gfmcg.t,vhfoctfk an kchr
73
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-7 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 8 f` 51
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 51/126
3 tGcssW9410r{410&AUOKsrmfjto; mnkmo5Wo5ml Tcln$f`;5
Gfmcpnththfjcvr.
8t Encjrssf` Kn`qkcgs' ufocs&o cgtsctrkprcgthgns,MNrkcos hjhuosk
Ttshjth`r cjkjnma f` hhn Gocss k fttahrn; nk gfkhhorn tfuf&.hrtyfa`u,
ufjnyfjkprfpnrty&fmTochrrh& cck jfeccs f`tan Gom. [aur,Toch``h
rnlugttachrarlGfujgcusKn&fkste tf rnstftsoos `hff₯ytf Ton'htkh`r kcto
Gtcss nmenm, rktu nqhfhcKn`njkkr `hm gfjthkjl tf vhfon tan^c&hr
Gfrpkhkfu ocw cskhsguwk asnhoj Ftaswhsn, an Gocs jrcyef rrnprceoy
amsk cuk/frknjhnksrn`tsthnn sfkgfjposRn rfmsky srg.acjqks os rgt
lrcknk
H^HUHHGHCHM@FUUNOHN@(`ucar` otnnjhat `fr^j&bEusojnnsTrc.kggs oj Pofoskfj f`
Nukrs & Trf`nshfjsGfkn$3<54$kfn`.)
\. Tochkh0 acsey hjmrpfrcn an rrnlfhjlpcr₯rcpasf` `ahs G2mpochk
ck rkstn tanmcs tacywsrn rooy wktDjajn`,j"
344. He^GO k&nsrm&hreukrnsgfmDfjtf hjgou& cjy"ujosnr`uO
rm&a g `hmkuonk r` g lhgkgs. Gco.Eush & Trft,Gfkf$^544.
`43. C arnanrscgtfrprcgthgns 'ur`t`u@ uknr tan^j`ra Gfpnththgj Onjr
h` tos rnfsf'js,usth`hkhfKs fk cfthvn f` teschonlk x/rflkfs rn futwtRlenk y
tanlEvttyf` tesaju f &n cRflnkvtg`tjs.
343 oos$jkce acvnvhfokfk fk gffthjunfvhfoctn, on '_u&t' prfjlf`
taf^GO jten `foofuhhclwyo9
c. Clfnaltf coofwmk coofwhjl\c &tf ggnc`hnhtsTrfvnc
Copchs₯r ^st woh& tsgfckt`hno f` clprchss \cHv`u cfksnon{tnk senhjlfjns
t&c wfuokprfvhkn\co`u whta aolaafjf cpprchnco coun2
e. Clrnfalof kofw cfkcoofwhcl\cboutfoomht htnomvnroCpprchsgOhost f fty toffn cpprchsnrs\cov3scswwfuokpfvhkn tt whta ahlaafn
cppch$coscet₯q
g. Clrnnhclf coofwcjkcoofvhjl coo f` \cMu'safmscpprchscosf
75
H
z
7
;
`
0
3
H
8
t4ho
35
37
t;
3>
O0
H<
o1
38
j5o
55
5t
5;
3>5.0
j51
rHJW[ C${^HHKNKFFMTOCHJ[
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-7 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 34 f` 51
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 52/126
H
5
7
;
)
0
<
H
8
o4o o
t5
t7
t;
o>
30
o<
3N
38
5C
5o
5,
57
u
5>Jh
5<
<C
Gcsn0ho&gv{W0&AUO KDmnjt3; mnk4751/5(Qo1Tcln7;f`;5
^n@`grjnk Nfjtycpprchswfm\ch;r's&fvnrC@prchk₯rthq
k. ClrnnhflfcoofwnfkcRfshKl\co`ugfqtrfo rntrs afvc
Cp`tjhs₯r^$ey chofwocl\cov`u, rr₯fte{Ntf`Pcovou's fsffkltjqrrfkhfq,f
g,affsfpprchsgn enckknkf`&nonlgtf &ffnscpprchngnentZtcnf$tan
xstf. `urnnhqltfnRfwckcoofvhjl\ctrvotttfktgqec`hjcfgao
ocmthvn `u cpjchnfn j\c ;u'n rwnjCpprchu O`u`e h"` jtnry@chsos2
t `urnnhjl forfyhknfC lfvhkhjlcmrchss fc\covou'sfvnj
Cppchsnr hntc`hjrjfhloots₯st hf ncpa @&hssopnrerjnk fr\cRtRu2
l Clrnsotrltf@rfvhkncrkprfvhr{hjlryprchscrj\cC`u'sTrfvncCppks Ohst c``jnjghcoo&rnnt j Nmchjhjl tr\coP3or'srfvnc @Kr₯hs₯rhst ey
pcpltonsn co@rch$rscthnanrp*c@@mhso nn cokey trWrchjlk'"- t&f `tany
khkcftprgvh& npprchncoscahn&qf₯t vcoun0c \c&{u, nyufuoken njfvnk
&fm anTrfvnnrpnrcosnr hst
a. Clrnnhjltf oofwck cRfrrhcl\covturanehohtyf fvnruon
afmn ppchso vcows\cH& enooNrrgk`fnff fwthrule tan nerDo'q
"UsgffshknrcthfjPcojn"ystnfr2h. Clnnhtl e qoofwcrkcoofwhjl\cor`u'sc fjlhjcohfuk``tf
acwkhrngt Dgt s`ta tWt, NC,ck tant cppchsgqwhta rnlck cpprchscts
pnr&mnkrr afjn f""* `frWo'cov{u2;
i. @sh`qlfprfvhknemn ofcjefufmrs phtaufehcsn;
hjkfpfknutk grkoeonaffncpprknts *`fmrnkjgfrjpohcsgnrta ^WTCT
stfkcrks.
o4o. oen lrcrttyf` &nacrj00 *>*" f`tanGocss wtthfl &fm uk
ujn`fcgts fklcgrhru f$rnolaf cry gfqgnonceonsfjs, Irrk``gc`hfusjk/frmsthv₯s `K₯`ukkt `fr flclal tr `or.aknfnpthvngtscckprcskl. Ey
gfjjhthjltas cgecjkpckgn cooqnkcefvn" `qkc$ts acrrnmlolnk, k
gfkjun f enflsl₯; hu ju&hrer$hjnspcfkn whtaat&ncnuhcl f`&Ho`fmhc
77@HEW[CMJJHKHH}GFMTOCHHH[
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-7 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 33 f` 51
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 53/126
3
5
7
;
`,
0
<
1
H
HF3t
O5
Gcs>94&grr4(Nt@AUO Kfgumnjto; @oonkDz1zf(j @clc*hf`;5
Er9shj₯ss hokTrg`nshfjsGkn $ 365HNnrgc;.
34;. [aful kna rm&hr cgtscjkp&.kg₯s.Kn`tfkcj0astt₯f3fchjk,cjk
ffkhjufe ru&hroy fetchK, fcry &D mnmenrs`ton Gocs Cs srg&,Tolhk&
rqrrn$ tak tahs Gfu* gsRsfKn`ukrrks tf rns.tfjahsrjfj₯` f Tocojth& fk cto
GHm mnmefrq jk f nqhfhjMcW tfm fkhckcltf vhftrn tan j&h
Gfupkthfc Hw cskhsgussnk₯gshj-Ftenrjr,hsn"asGocssu.y enarnpcrceoy
acmk fk/sr knjhnkcr kng{`un ctrkguponN tnmky h` sugam frk₯re oft
ljknk.
@FrrUHot GOCM @'FUClOhNr
(Clcast Ng`nukcrts fr ^K&hrEushjn TrcNthgn hc othkc`hfs f`Eushjs & Trf`kfjs Gfkf883<544, sq.y
34>. Tochjtta jg*y jfngcon tan`f&lfhul@c$Npe f`toros &upochr
ljk@stctnranj cs `tD*nrf `tohy mhteue₯rnkj
340. [es^GO kn0j0u```f eoshmss gfjpn`thfctf hjgoukn jy orjocu&H,
uehrfrtckuonk cgtkprcgthgn" Glo.Eorn &T ft Gfkn$3<54(O
Htr Cashfscgtfr pcgnhgfs'tckuokrmknrten ^f`hhrGfmpsththff
Ocm ht cgtuooy knkvn fr hs ohbfoy tf kngnhvnjsjesrsf`tan gffmfkclTtoeohn
341. Kn`ukcks' cg`s fk3rcgkgnss kqgrhenka₯rnhfecvnkncnhvk ck/fr
o7
t;
3>
o0
t<
r1t8
54
5o
z557
5;
5>50
5<
5t
un ohbftytfkngnhvn nmas f` tangfj*fhjl pueohg,cgoukhjlTochjth0 cjkan
G`csr. $pgh`hgcooy, Kn`tmkm f``nrnk f prfvhknThcorth`r ck 'jnjefmf` te
Fcssuhtahuknpnjknfl jehqgnkjkgnnkheon .urncptrrcom.osl&jsnke
gfgpohmf vhta ^WTCT eorkkkG1; a nfq gnrk{nksrga ctencptchso rqgts
pfpnk `fr ck khssfhjfnk tf Tochjth`t cjk asGocs ey Knkcft yn`' knsphe
tehs f`s cukpfcrhnn,Kn&jkcr$' &honk tfprrfvhknjknpnjknjt,jehcnnkck
unkheonafmncppchnos hc tanaoofwal vcyn9c. Clrnfh;ltfcoofwcjkc^fu,hjl\co& f sD`shts prrfvnu
Clprchsnr hsjwahga hs gqsthttnk f`clprchsnrs rcokualjklnonftkcsentjlfp@s
tect wfuoklfvhkn \co&rrhta ahlaafmncpprchsco couns2
7;@HJW[ CH{NJKNK GFMTHCHH[
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-7 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 35 f` 51
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 54/126
3
5
7
;
>
0
<
1
8
343o
t5
o7
O;
t>
r0t<
30
o8
J
6o
c57
5;
5>60
5<
51
GcsW941;r{410&AUO Kfqmnjto; mnkE5WhYQ W Tcln70f`;5
e, Clrnnhrltf chofw cmk ^whjlPcot&tf ohmhthe Ttfvntr
Clcossrohstof moytafsn cllchrn \cov`ubjnwwfsok f,vhkn twhta ahlrrar.mn
cpprchscowouq
f. Cltwhtrlhf coofw ck coofwhflcoof`$tchoatrtsern cpprconos f
enp₯r`r-ofk eycroy cppchsnm j \cKou'sasvqCl`cts₯r^0q
k. Clonnhjlf coofw cjkctofukjlWc^`ugfjrrfofvnrtb afypj
Cppchsrr Oh$t ey coofvh ₯h \cH_;j, r tjnjes{ q` \c &'s ofcj fhlhuhf mW tf
gaffrnqpc9hsnrstf eckksk tf &n oatr frtf gafwcryor6hhs₯rtfenocb"uf``f`ton
asG
f Cljnhjlecoofwcrkcoofwel$ocJ&tf khgntnc`hrcjgtcohjgnjthvnfr cpprchsfs c\cov`u's fvm Cpprchssths
H C₯rnfhultfprfvhkncjkprfvhkqcpprchsnrff\c&Hu's&fvnu
Cppch,snr hst c`hrocjghco otnrnst u ncga pprc9hvopnr`fmnk fr o8cov`u2
N ClrNnaltflfvhknfkprgvhkal"@orchs₯rsfr'\cR (u'sTrfvs.
Cppchsnr Oh* c`hjcokno hc00p00c rnmchjhjl j\cPRu'sTr9lv₯j pprchs H,hs ey
pcytl to*n c@`jchNnrsahlanrptr₯p`chsct nq Dkey c`ujral rtsj 0ct h`ta₯y
khk cftprfvhkfcwchs,osc` c aonoo ffule vcoun g\cov`hc nnyufuok enrmfvk
WftosTrfvfConrchsnr^q
e" Clr₯nhjltfcRfw sfkcoofnhrl \cov`hotancehohtytf fvnmron
afjn cp@rchscocount\corku nohnvnktfen ff ofurtarfulaan rnaolT fr'Unffuhkskhqc f` Pcoun' s@tnch
h. Clrgnhry f c.oofwcrkcoofwhjl$/c$ku'sfcjfrhlhjcrhmntc``tf
ecvnkhrns gfutcgt kteOWH, NC Dk/fr one cpDsnrs,rnlsrkhjl rphm'os
pg`unk `fr o`c`t`f afjn ofcuq crk
i. @chohjlrfpfvhkn afcn fcuefrrf`onrswhn uFhcsn;hjknpnjkctcjkgnkheon afjn cpprchve pr`frusk e gfjpotcrgnwhhe H[WTCT
s&rkcrks.
348. Cscrnsuotf`ten gfjkugtktrchenk cefvqKn`njkcus cv₯en₯cl ok
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-7 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 37 f` 51
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 55/126
L
H
5
7
;
>
0
<
H
8
34o o
t5
t7
t;
t>
t0
r<
o1
t8
54
5o
55
1
u
5>67
5<
51
GcsW (@sv{410&+oUO Kf9mnjt3; @hok()75Cm41 Tcln7<f`;5
whoo gfrthrun tfen urkkoy ₯jkn₯k k ton nxpnjsn Tochrk`t crkunrjenrs ` &n
pfpfrnkGocss.Wpngh`hgcooy,Kn`ukmj actner uqhusttynjrhgank ytenp'rf`hts
cjk wnfune acsfetchjnkWfm@ochjrh`r sKkaf GHcs nfj ton afcnco@rconcos
garlnk tf tanj wanj cbhjlfur\cot`u fcs"
oo4. Engcusnf`Kn`uk`ro1, ukcs`hro cg1 ckprcfthgq &`uoclE hciwnk
Tochk& uk cfmenrsf` tangocsschk fehok cfkgfuthrun tmL'troy eahu
rjgjsycjkprfpngty fmTokkh& ck mmenrlf`tenGtc$. `us, Toc'hkh`t
onqu₯stttktoks Gfurtgcjsn n`₯jk``h e rnstqs &hs Nfcry tf TocojrhracfkNHH
GHcs jcjesrs,cjk f n{fhjKn&jkc``h&fco gfothrrtoclhf vhfoftas^f&hr
Gmpnththf Hcw ss khscu$nkasnhK. Ftanjksn,anGocss cy en uvpfceoyac'mnknrk/g kDhkf ntrngkvn fkgfjpon*nnmnky strsasj fk₯r hsrst
lcknk.
NtrHNGOCHaoWFUUN2HN@
(ClctustKkgj*₯``h``hW$``h`h`"H
Urrjskrkgt,
H ^. Tochkh0 ansgeycgf,rpfrctnan frnlfotrl csclrcpas tahs Gfryochjt
Dk nsoce &qm s tary vom 0rooy woh&j a₯rnor.
335 [ahsgochm frrgHhkhsetr$lNpumcktf tanGfrsom`rs .Dco
UnmnkhnClt,GcthrsjhcGhvoo Gfkf 3<>; c.rcc. (tanqGHIUC").
H 7. Tochkh0 cckng.amn $tr f` tanprfpfsfk ocss gaftffbfrk\cIr;u
emn ofDq ck acccppkks `njnk tyNC cfk/frOWH crn'ffjrumnm'phtahj
tanmncjhjl ` GrMoGkn lHo 0O(0_
33;. [enf']on npprstscosfokeyK₯&jkcursf Tochkh`t mk Gos$ oDes1
crn'sncvhcn'whtahj Frn mhclf` GtvooGckn o<0oSr.
33>. Kn`tfk``h acvsyhfokn; crk gfcthjuntfvhfoctn, o₯ GOUC j ct oDsRtan foofwhjlrnspngE
c. hjvhfochfcf`Gtrko DRoj$cp_Kn`nckmrnl``hnjt₯k
tan`f fjncpprrchsctnrvhgnsf enf` cprthfkcr sakcrk fr lccohty,4"s,.enhjl
70@HUW[CH{KJKNH'GFMTH.CHJ[
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-7 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 3; f` 51
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 56/126
3
5
7
;
>
>
<
H
8
343o
tz37
t;
o>
o0
O<
o1
t8
54
5t
5,
57
5;
5>50
j51
b>941?vW101.AUO ttffmnr`o; @oo₯kF7T7o54{}1 cln71f`;5
grnkheon.,kryntknjt, rmehcsnkjkpnr`fjjnkj gfmpohcgn whta WTCT
scjkcrks),wahgaD wun rft
t 30. Tochcth``s fk tanmDenrsf` tenGocss gqunstect ahs GfurtnjIfho
Kn`tjkcutsrfk gfkhjuhul f njlclnctes ujocrr`tH cckkngnphvnjfrafkqc.`s
ck prcskn coonlnkcefvnprrjrk e &H`fj `c Coho Gfkc$3<14(cQ5), aow
Hon`mkctn cr pnrrjcfnkoy qhf`tk jfj gfj`ujtjl f .'rlclnK soge vhfokfjs f`
tasGHC0, `hstrl gfjsrmnf +thjlfqt\co0r efcn 3*s whoo enkcrjlnkey takr
cg0 crk@rckDs hc krnumfrfcycsacvNTochok`t mktenrn'jenrsf``rn
prfpfs₯k osss.
t3<. arsucjtGH GMH GfksWo616,TochjrhLjfk`hnke`cknfn hj jtkthrlf` tenlthf9ocr vhfo*hfjs f` Go&`HGfo0 $3<<4cfkk₯fhcgknkantKn`₯jkk
r*k`y tenpfeoms nsfkrnk wtta tj hotnlcoeesghfr kntchonk efol uhthg'a cgthms
crn j vhforkhfjf` Gjho \ lo[o4.
331. Kn`njknm`$rtnk shoAc 74kcys ` rngnhptf`Tocak`t rfthgn f`
kgtjcjko0l`ulg qrnftf lhvngkoahjcrncsfjcea'tr'''j.tfnGocs, hEgakhry
jnhk`th ns Nqrrgsrnkfnkhn Tursjr tf GtvhoGkn Wo<1,;.e}Nk,(k), ochjk`t
`hHntahsCmknk Gfryoshj` nk snnbtanfoofwhjl.o.'rglns cspmvhknk f hj Ghvoo
Gf& 4o6149
O cg*uco sfrtlpnc nrgnsn ` tanIwhskhgthfjco'rj2trf`tahs Gftut
e. cjfknrnqhfaal Dtafks,cks srk/frprcgthgn,csfjohjnk
cefvn, etga crn j vhfoghfc f` GhvooGckn$O`hC2
f. pmhthvnkcfclns2
& cjykefrnohn`wtrhg& tanGfrrt kmspfpnr, ck2
s gfurtgfsts rk cttmnyf' `ng,
spjsgr,cq;rfUUNr,rN@(Clc`fgtKg`njroshoE fr Er₯ga f` Gfortrocg`)
338. Tochcth& ec'neyjc0pfr& tef fnlfhjlprclrpas f` tatsGfjpochr
nk r₯#tn te₯j cs te₯&' rsn``rty rrkD a₯rn`u,
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-7 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 3> f` 51
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 57/126
H
5
7
;
>
0
H
1
8
tfH t
35
t7
t;
H>
30
t<
o1
t8
64
5o
<5
57
u
<>57
<<
5C
GcsnW941.gv{48&AUO Kfumnjto; @oonk(}7``nrz4{ 1Tclpo`hIf`;z
354. Toshjth.E cjk anftanrGocss njem f q c``nrIujn , 5&3> fb ftr
c\cHvHu ffn ofcfwhtalosotu. Hj gfjjng{hfj hta tansn\sovouafrn ofDs,
\ceto, fce₯`rnof`fk `frTochrth& cjk ts Gocs, ufknr&fbmk clp₯k f3jffrrE
cjkktkp'rfgrron p`rchscos tfm NC cjk/frWH `fr tes afmnsec rrrgrgannueingt `
Tochjth`r ' cjkGas trfbs' \cO`u qcs. NC sjk/f(OWHcrkstffbck clrngkf
pfv`ttfcjkpfvhknk@bjrh`t cfk anGocs whha tann cpprchrcts hrngtoyukofr ey
knohvnry f tanj ta,fule\cMu"Tochuh$ cjkGoqsrjnjenrswfn gacrlnku
tenssnpprchsos ss n`ongtnkj tanhr Wnotonmfnjttkfngts (AHIKH) fr fronr fcc
kfqunm
353. Cs₯jkkmgskytan fcckfcmfs trct mcpcrhk tanafmnfcjefngthfc, tancDcptsestwnnf onhjto`@s k t.anGocssfk Afk0 $fw tect
tanKn`ukjts wnm flfvh& camf cppchscowahg,a, rjuk tf cppoogceoncms
cjkffkcrks csgnrth`hfkj tesclryrchsctpfrts, wfuokefpnr`frfrnk ycr
hrknpnjkm" ohngthvn jkuehrcsnkprchsnr, k &ncpprchsconpfmwfuok n
snkheon,fei₯q`tjf,k.hcnfrockckrykntr afjfcpprchscofjnc gjqoohcqgc
rrH&^WTCT fkkks. Mfrnfjnr,afcpphno ryfrr Toch`rh`t cfk&nGocJ
rnnhvnk fc Kn&fkco`r phtgcoy cgIffwoklner efrfwnrsS.n", ochkh`t
cjkenGocsf) fok rngnhvn ncplchscoqokt 0rkkcyrrnoy pfjanmj antr
jfrtlElnjcurhRl rcjscgthffrota es Dk₯rL0.,\c$tr+
355. Ttchjk&cckanGocsr `gmnk coosuk`thfcsf` tasgmcgjsf en
3u`frmnk ytam. ₯Nrytethn fckt tonywnrnocrrnrooy frgusnkrfoo srr,a
nnroffrcjn.Kn`ukqj0erncg.e₯kan0s fncg`hs htaTochgh$ qjkco. Gocss
mmenreycfpfvtkhclcemncpprchncoOh&wcs pg`frjfkeyf hjknpcknjt,
feinthvncckujehcsnkl;rchw, k ey `h Pcvhkrjl 0zkv.oc;nfrnasrjrn
urnkheof,$ngthvn, jetcsnk,jknpk₯``, cjk,ofjfj gfupohcjgn hra^$TC@stckskscfkqppohgceoncrp. j ftanrwmkG@ozjrh`t cjkan Gocs wnrn "aclnk
`g c cw`uocppchsco ehgaws jNvnrnr`fmnk yF*fcmts.
357. Cr cktsg`mklfxhjkn rnfrotf`&n `fcnlfhrlfjkugl ochrkLck
Nrn` .ootr;NH{KNK FMT[,CHJ[
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-7 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 30 f` 51
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 58/126
6
H.,
7
;
>
0
<
1
H
t4[3
t5
37
3;
r>30
t<
[N
38
j5O., ,
67
5;
5>chj51
D>41-crF411&`hUO Kfc&srk3; @HbkFY₯C`Y74&\f;4k;5
0n Gocss nfenmecvnsu`trnk kr'"slq hjgoukhjlngfjfjhg fssw,wcrrcjthjl
gfmpnfufrykmclg cswnoo cs jiujgghvnmohn{, kngocrkfry nohn`uk ftosr
nquhoceonnohn`knnkrgkiu$crkpmpnreytanGfurt
sNr/NJHl gooutr{ @FUUN[HN@
(Clcek Kn`fuksj`r ur Suck-Gfu`rcg`o^cIus` jrtgajfD
35;. Toshok`t antrneyjgfrpkc`ney rn`nrn'jgncga k nvny coonlcthfj
gfrjtchjnkj tas gnkhql nrsltc@asf` tahsGfrcpocht cr h` `hrtoy rwrhta afnoc"
Ttchkh& ponckaosGfur hjtancotfcthvn.
35>. Ks`nrksje'nflclnkr ujocjr``ro fckugey rnprnnkjl tfToc`ut'``s
cjk anK*meqsf` tanGocss act anhrafjncpprctsce rfvhknkfr tanpurpf.sf`fegchjhjl afun qj wfuok enpnr`frcnkey cc jknpnuknmrk rrjahcsnkpprchsn
cktaktancpphmornpf*wfttoken mkheon, fei*thvn cjkkfjna gfupohmgn
whoa ^WTCT tmkrkr, at cgtucooy rfvhkojlafjscN`chse pnr`mk $o c
ehcsnk, D-hok₯@sjknjtpprchnccjkpwhkhjl cpprchs.o npkts " Ztg/sn Kft
grnkheoqfeingrhvn r kfjn j gfjpohcjgnwhta WTCTst&kcrkscsksgrhenk
t rgulefg tahsGfjpochuq s ujtcq`tH
35>. Kn`DksfcffbmfjhnsCrfmTochjth`hscjkGoccsmnfenrhjnqgacqln
&r wnctwun frypffnk en jkspc"ks'r,feingthrcn,cehcnk cnkh^n cpprchscos
fho sppchscapfts kfcn j gfjgpohcjnwhto ^WTCTgtcfkcrks,t ktkcftpfkkf
qge c`l'chscoscok N 'ptshsc npfrts. Kn`ukc$ ecvnefno uqhusoy `hogank ct tan
n*pnfsn Tochjth& cktan Fsq$NDenrs cscjsua f`tanhrujocg`rro gfjcougt
cRslska₯rshK, sney gmnchjl qucsh-gfjtjseco ethlkhfjm. &kcfrs tf
rnn`hf tansnoo₯ft₯cp`fstf Tochjto& cjktanGocs"
Hto. b c k`uw'rfjk rfxhjcn rnsuaf` Kn`njkcjN' qhu$nuhgemsjl
Tocho`trs k CcNsj'nqentscrnmhtonk tf rkhcthfq hf ; cojq&ttf e₯@fvnkkthco
uohoo
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-7 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 3< f` 51
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 59/126
1 ' '
. @
Gcsn>9(1.0@447tt&AUO ooffmnjto; @kk47o51/&1 Tclc;3ft;5
TUCXWU
\QNUN@FUETtchuth$' f e.ast`f`ten"'qnovn cckff enaco`f`tanf$nr
jnmenm `ten Gorsq rqukcjcmcrk crkrnohn`cn `foofs$
C- Ccfrknrgn*h`yhjlkm&hscgthfuslfpnroyerfrlecjkusye₯
rjchjeankl c gocqs sohfj, ok Tochjhtrr en cppfhj`tnkocs UntrrnsDtkhvnDk
Tocok``r' gfusno encppfhrnkScs Gftrosnt
E. Gfjpnjgmy kx"nl0, nxgn@t s f GfN`tt [wf,[arn, @frr.
G. [rneof {"fqlnscs fGftmtFjs.
K. CmhthvnkmclwgtfGfr&@hvf.
@.. Usk`hohfs otrsugacrrfrmteh Tochjth1& rkcRGocsrrnmesl@chk nrtnkr afjnryorchscos,qhan @f``0, gacrlps jk ns Kn`₯jk``h fegchcnkhfrc
ter@{j,
@. Cj frknrnqhftctjlKn`tck``h &fj ju'hjtqhjhjl tk othohzh'rl \ctrPHu'n
TrfvnjCpjhsg rhq q cy f&q mng,amof eywahga \cokues$gf0fo fvnrtes
cppksnrsnofftnkf pfr`ff oPcMu'safcn cpprchscos rvzen&n cpprchsnrfj&r
tes$$in{k`fp₯(ty.(o Cj frknrc*rkhjl Tocath`t tanhrgfstsf`frh hogakhjl prnkk pfsrt.
hr`₯rst
HO Cc frkccmkoclTochcth``s'gfrjsno'gc`hfrcqj' `ru.
O Cc frksrnquhrtjl cjcggfufkjlg, nfk ryjghthfj f`c gfjstusthvn
truftupff,coo mfuof rngnhvk eyKn&ckc$ csctw,ot f`tonuj&hr, `fukuok cjk
Nocw`to ffjrargt onlnkenrnhj
I. $rga ftaf crk `hj`onr Nohn` csncy en knnfgkngntwy frrypofpkkn"
ut
Hh ouoho t
ut
H
5
7
;
>
0
<
H
8
t4H H
t5
t7
t;
H>
o0
r<H1
t8
m5O
j57
6C
6>60
5<
51
@js[CruxRKm gfooKo"crohj
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-7 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 31 f` 51
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 60/126
nr
k
p
3
5
7
;
>
0
<
t
8
o4utzo7
hq
o>
t0
t<
t1
o8
m5o
55
57
u
5>6sj51
Gsss.WW-g'r-{34₯QN+o@oOjjnrt3; @ook47r54^4(N Tn₯on;5kt;5
pN&RCrXjFUI^UX[UrC&
Tonak$ `ssey knmqjk thco ey ury fjcoo njsns f` clthfjcck ssups f
trhceon.
Kk9Hkct$5&544N t.CIlF@@HWWF@IC {N[ JKJEUWTHW.ENUL
NPCJW
Euhokhjnc 3>538
cwrry`wtoD*
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-7 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 38 f` 51
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 61/126
NQAHEH[ 7
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-7 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 54 f` 51
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 62/126
EN@FUN[AN I[HKHGHCO TCJNOFJ M^O[HH}$[UHG[ O[[HLC[HFJ
HJ UN \CWAHJL[FJ M['[^CH,, HJg.
WNG]HHU]H[HNW,KNU[PC[HPNCH_K
.0NUHWC' OH[HLC`hFJ
MKOKfgbntJf, 3838
)
)
)
)
JF[HGN F@ [CL.COFJL CGHHFJ
3. `ttrsucjt tf51 .W.G.W3;4<cjkUuons<.5,<-; cjk<.>f` an Uuonsf`
prfgnkurn ` tan ukhghco Tcjnofj Mutthkhs`hft Ohthlcthfu(tancvoKo bjns'), Kn`njkcjt
\csahjltfjMutuco Hjg.G'W/cMrt')anr₯eyjfth`hns an ukhghco Tcjnoff Muothkhstshgt thlcthfj
(tan [cjno') f` tanpncrknjgy ton `foofvhjl tcl-cofjlcg`hfc f tan cefvn-gcpthfjnk cttnj
Tochjth``s9 @notfjC Wpncrs, r.cjkWhkjnyWgafoo,fje*co` f` tanmsnovns
mk coo ftanosshmhocroXsh`hrconk.
Kn`njkcjts9 HhrcsahjltftrMu`tcO ocf2 @hrst Cm₯rhgccnCpprchsno[2cjkOnfknr'sW₯rvhg₯$jf.
Khst`hgr JfrtanrjKhsjhgt f` Gcoh`fmhc
GcsnJf.9 41-sv-44101-AUO
Iukln IuklnAfvrcrkU Oofy; ^.W.Mclhsarn Iukln
5. FjJfvn,menr1,5D6,\cMumfvnk ahsTcjno,ljsucjt f 51 ^.W.G
l tz346 jkUuon65 f` tanMKO Uuonl`fr cj Frkc trms`nuhjlsnrrnj hmhocrcgthfjs,hstEkj
tanWgankuon Cg`hfjG f tan ofjfrceonMcrsac . Tngamcq jht₯kWtctnsKhstrhgtIuklnfr
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-7 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 53 f` 51
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 63/126
tan\nst₯rjKhsahgt f` \csahjlej,0r gffrkhjctnk r gfjsfohkcek rntrhco pmgnfkhjlstan
'MfthfjI. Frco crlumnjtwhta rnspngtf \cMu'sMfthfj wcsanok en`frn anTcjno j
Tafnjhx" rhzfjc&rhjl tan cjury 74,5441AncrhjlWnsshfj-
7. Ey Jfthgn f`[nl-Cofry Cgthfj kctnkKngnmenr , 5D<,\cov`upmmpthy
jfth`k ton Tcjnof` tan foofwhjl tcl-cofjlckhft Cocckq v. \csothjltfjMt&uo Hjg, nt
c/., Jf.G4<-3840UWM(\-K.\csa.,honkJfvnjenr 58,5\-
;. Ey Jfthgnf` [cl-CofjlCsthftrkctnkKngqre₯r 35' 544<,\ctv{u
p,rfmptoy ftr`hnk anTcjnof` tan foofwhjl cl-cofjlc0fj- Mhtganoo v. \c.sahjltfjutusO
at., c co.,Jf. G4<-3871 IT(\r, \cso, `honkKngnmec '5J<).
>. Ey Jfthgn f` [cl-CofjlCgthfjkctnkKnfn'jenr o' 5446,\cH_;u
prfmptoyjfth`hnk 0n Tcjnof` tan foofwhjl cl-cofjl gthft wfn u wcswjljjMucjo, Hjg.,
nt co,,Jf.GC<-386UCI(Htt K' \cse-,honk Kngnmenr 7,544<)-
0. . EyJfthgn f`[cl-CofjlCgthfj toctnkIcgucry , 5D1,\covhuprfmptoy
jfth`hnk anTcjnof` tan foofwhjl tcl9c[gjl hfj9 Ufsnjeozcu. wc.sahjltfj u`tt&H,jg., nt
co,Jf.D<-545> UWM(_`.K. _H/csa,0o₯k Kngnje₯r31' 544;.
<. Ey Jfthgn f` [cl-CofjlCgthfukctnk cjucry7, 5441,\cHvHuprfmptoy
jfth`hnk anTfno f` tan foofwhjltcl-cofjlckh|fj9Lctenr v. \c.sahjltfjutuco, jg., nt co.,
Jf. 46Ghv. 33;55 W-K.J.X., hontoKngnmthnr 4'5\[t-
1, Ey Jfthgn f`[cl-CofjlCgthfjkctk Icjucry , 5441,\coPHu rfmptoy
jfth`nk &n Tcjnof` tan foofwhjl el.cofjlcgthfj9MgKfjcok u \csahttltfjMuttt&t,a g, nt
cH- Jf.G4<-54>>MHT (\.K. \csa- honk Kngnmenr H,5F4<).
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-7 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 55 f` 51
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 64/126
7
8. Ey Jfthgnf` [cl-CofjlCgthfjkchnkIccucry ,5441,\cMuprfmptoy
jfth`nk tanTcjnof` ttn `foofwhjltcl-cofjlc(ithf'..Mcrrc v. \csahjltfj utuco,atg., nt co.,
Jf. G4<-54<0MIT (\K. \cse-,honk Knfnment5<,54`o<).
34. EyJfthgnf` [cl-CofjlCgthfj kctnkIcjucry ' 5441,\c_kuprfmptoy
jfth`nk tanTcjnof` tan foofwhjltcl-cofjl gthfj9 Woctnr v. \csahjltfj utt/cOerg., ntco-'
Jf. G41{44> UC.H (\.K.\csa-, honkIcjucry , 5441).
. H 3 Ey Jfthgnf` [cl-CofjlCgthfj kctnkIcjucry >, 5441,\cMuprfmptoy
jfth`hnk on Tcunof`tan `foofwhjltcl-cofjl gthfj9 Trfghkc v. Bhoohjlnr' ntc/., Jf.41 GP
44>0> W-K.J.X., onk Icjury 57, 5441).
t5. Ey Jfthgnf` [cl-CofjlCgthfj kctnk jucty5>,5441, \.cMu rfmptoy
' jfth`hnk anTcjnof` tan foofwhjltcl-cofjl gthfj9 Uycj v. Bhoohjlnr, nt co.,Jf. G41-448>[sY
G\.K.\cso", honk Icfucry 1,5441).
37. ' EyJfthfnf` [cl-kfjl Cgthfjkc`nk@nerucry ,5441,\cHvHu rfmptoy
jfth`hnro anTcjnof` tan foofwhjl cl-cofjl gthfg PnrN v. \csahjltcj utucoEcjoqntqo.,
Jf. 5941-gv;473<-LNE-BIM1.K.Gco., honk @neruc'y ,5441).3
3;. Tochjth`t @notfjC- Wpncrs, r. cjkWhkjnyWgafoo honk c gfjpochjt suhjl
fjenaco f` tanmsnovg cjkcoo ftanrs hmhocroy shtuctnk, j frcefut@nerucry1' 5441j xan
ujhtnk stctfsKhstrhgt gfrrot fr tanJfrtanrjKhstrhft f` gcoh`frjhc (tan spncrsCgthfj'). C
gfurtnsy fpyf` tangfmpochjtc oahs cgthfj s hjgouknkwhta tahs Jfthgnf` [cl-CofjlCgthfj
Cotafula an \nrNcgttfjwcs rhlacoy `honk hj `on WupnrhfrGfurt f` Gcoh`frjhc,
Wcgr*mnjtf fujqr, jIcjucry ,5441,Kn`njkcjtshmnoyrnmfvnk an\nrNckcfjtf
tan^jhtnk WtctnsKhsahftGfuxtfr tan NcstnrjKhsahgt f`Gcoh`frjhc fj@nerucry ' 5441.
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-7 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 57 f` 51
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 65/126
;
3>. ^bn tan ftanrnhlotnnhrcgthfjs nrkhjl j `nknrcokhstrhgtgfurt, trn Wpncrs
Cgthfj cssnregochmscrhshjl rfm cjcoonlnkgfjsphrcgyf hj`octn cpprchsco couc`hfjs j ofcjs
\cMufrhlhjctnk-
30. [angfmpochjtj tanWpncrsCgthfj nohns fjc gfmpochjt honk fj
Jfvnmenr3, 5446ey &n JnwXfrb CttfrjnyLnjnrco lchjst@hjt Cmnrhgcjgfrpfrcthfjcjk
@hrst CmnrhfcjnCpprchsno[,wahfa coonlfsact afsnwf gfmpcjhggfjsphrnkf j`octn
cpprchsco counsf` prfpnrtyfr wahfa\cMufrhlhjctnkmfrtlclnfcjs' Whxtnnj ` tan nhlatnnj
ftanrcgthfjs uei₯gt f \cMu'smfthfjcosfnxpohghtoyprnmhsn anhr gfmpochjts jtan
coonlcthfjsj tanJnu,XfrbC``fmnyLnjnrco's fmpochj 5cjk coo f` tan ffmpochjtsj tan
nhletnnj gthfjswnrn hHskc`tnr an`hohjl f` tan JnwXfrb CttfmnyLnjnrch's fmpochftcjk
pnrtchj f tanqucohtyf` \cMu'smfrtlcln frtrfohf.
3< [ancoonlc`hfjsj tan WpncrsCgthf , cofjlwhta tannhlatnnj tenrcgthfjs
gurrnjtoy an sueing.tf\cMu's Mfthfupnjkhjlen`frn an Tcjno, chsnshmhocrgochmscjkskoo
ojysovn >h'"hoct gfjoptlccjkkhsprknkssuns ` ocw cjk cgo
31. @fr anrncsfrsmfrn hrooy khsgussnkj \cMu'spnfkhjlMfthftr' ts
suppfrthjlErhn` cck ts Unpoy Erhk tan rcjs`nrcjkgffrkrjcthfjrgftsfohkcthfjf` tansn
cgthfjs,jfoukhjl an Wpncrs gthfj, tf tan \nstnrjKhstrhftf` \csahjltfjwfuokgfjsnrvn
vcouceonukhghco rsfurgns,prnv₯t` tn rhsb f` pftnorthcooygfj`ohgthjlfr hjffKshstctukhghco
knghshfjs, Rk snrvf angfjvnjhcgnf` `on pcrthns, ]n whtjgsns, tanukhghcry cjkgfujsno j
cggfrkmgnwhta 51^.W.G.$ 3;4<. Cesnjtprnahco gffrkhjcohfj rgfjsfohkcthfrqanrnwfuoken
klpohgcthvncjkufjfgnscy prntrhct@fgnnkhjlsc9rkkhsgfvnry actwfuokerjknjanpcrthns,an
rhtjnssns, an ukhghcry cfkgfrmsno.
[angfmpochjtsj tanMhtganoo cxrk fsnjeocttckfjs fgus r9stnck j wcMu's coonlnkoy
rhsbymfrtlcln frt`fohf, cjk\cMu's coonlnkoy eohjk `fgus"fj euhokrjl fcjvfoumn'
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-7 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 5; f` 51
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 66/126
. 38. Cggfrkhjloy,\cov`u nspngt`uooy nlu₯stsact an Tcjno ccs`tr tan
WpncrsCg`hfj,cofflwhta tannhletnnj tanrcgthfjsgurrnj`oy an sueingf` \cMu'sMfthfj
chrgocjy ftanr cl-cofclcgthfjsactmcyen oon{ tf tanAfjfrceonMcrsac ' Tngjmcj' jhtnk
WtctnsKhsthgt Iukln fr tan\stnrj Khsthg` f` \csahjltfp,fr gffrkhjctnk r Djsfohkc`₯k
prntrhc`prfgnnkhjlsuwucjtf 51^.W.G.$ 3;4<.
Kctn* @₯erusry3>,5441
Unspngo`hrooy uemhtonk,
WHMTWFJ[HHCGHHNU & ECU[H,NH[ OH,T
Eury
;5> OnxhjltfjCvnjunJnwXfrb,JX 3443<
Sr5);s>-544f₯35) c>>-5>45nfshjhoFefstrclnrDsteocw.ffm
Gfujsno fr Kn`njkcjts\csaaltfj MutucR
Hjg- \cfaojltfjMctjco Ecjb' cjkWussj
Uhgatnr2 cjk fr tan ohmotnk purpfsnf`pcrkgtpcttjltj prfgnnkhjls n`frn anTcjnorKn`njkcjts (nrry H`, Booohjlnr2 Hocvhk G.Wgajnoknr2[afmcs `,. Gcsny2WepanjI.UftnooN Ifaj ,'.\ffks2IcmnsE. Gfrgfrcjocjk Kcryo H). Kcvtk.
Ey
ovoryo(c` Pysbfgho
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-7 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 5> f` 51
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 67/126
NQAHEH[ ;
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-7 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 50 f` 51
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 68/126
Gcsn>94&frD10&A@tO Kfkimnjt&5 @honk45/.3>354W @rcln f` 0
Not}NNoNNIH'K^CH}CH[NOftho `h19tjKrsro7tgrr.,mgCoofoo
RKOKF(&n`JEHJEN H[CWNHJL[3F[H[}ho[CH.HJC.WNWFUHHNW,KQCHPCHHPNCJK
j`,fuft{f1 $cWNHJ(2'[34Jurlor. mj|tscrwKE'fr CGRfJ>[F m--w``h klmog[ f`,wcJoJLrotrXrR'E$rCJ[FC HHIG" ^c/rgjgfjjmrrf fjgfjsfr.mcrrurjrujjr.jDjvn
Knkk\csaleokkuco ojl `Xcokg8rnq'sk`totyc$`ts₯k$Tnk,
puDt451^.1.G$3;{`hktuof65c`ttnEk₯s.`Trffnkcnf``tsIN&`oeoTksHf
^hokk*hroOh0l0f, `u fksrfsgkjlnggckksckfl`nhohj&ske'`tsk
sknkuon `ChkDN, &nlrNf`ctRsks&c'. @#s " ^thnk W{cns tntktklp a1`tn
\ns`hfK&tghf`\csokrltsk,u DgwohkfnkpjtkcoDal'
aq;rutknntDn cjo gff&kmqgwohkckDs`tanncfkf{s' k
0 sD&toyckckrgnk unssomtrmrttqlu$fjanEk₯lWtcotu$ons
3. [fkgq{₯mksN Ds.kD(0ns\cs{u&nsoarfe₯Destt₯e
clctfkwcoo 1uknnrtcahckhkkqsok#cs'rtsDle&NH``h `usKst{jgfN0`k
&f\DKosh`t?kv``hlu f` 04 strr`rrhtrKtshtt kJnrXq&
Y \co{shsck&k.ktusc&k`u\cokqn₯s
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-7 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 5< f` 51
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 69/126
GcssW94&q@4{N0WAUOKftujnjt&5 mnk453>5441 Tcln5g`0
7. Ncr& ots a``vhkuokn&ukk`f nnPco`ht Gs0h$ f kosrtr
r`mD4`,o`cMqfef`rr
;. To```r og0gnk`&sPc``u Ggnslsps` eryrgktckfushte
kcsgsktftD awcho&'n @ueohkytcknk₯tfkk1s.
>. `hn`unfoqkgsgonssckfqgDcekcsnrokc`jrkrrhan
&kgrcornknsossntohtonls0kthn@{hojNt{3fw`f$ygng`9rssoypuhnnk cknsf`
kkoy&HlnDkokk₯ckhjlD0e ft``onk tfkhskgsnD&t t`ukhgf9₯ocnk f
F) `r oHnlNk nr3rhjcytkwnnf ocotecktt ctroorkNo fkf' nClphs₯j, knk h4
ry@nk``h DHfcr fklenkey$coD D)\cokksgry``h eoD*krekoms'
fja rgfrkrl nktrrfkkfr`fl1r`uott₯sns' a *jlco scoatrkat f``ucoonnk
gf""`tcry9kF g0kruss DkPco&'s`u ckcggfrkhfla$₯iatk0₯
cjl@kcks@csylkkDancDkhoDs hjnekjn9₯ckjlk rrnktcckf.
C CNafc$CNkoqnk\cohorgC\Cm`` gwokrNste&tsrei₯kf`s
tgr/sht`ho₯ktt`u JwXn&CmfcryLcwo f*`'nrolc}&t``h ryk`tntk``Eoksco
&`ufe osrke1NokfwXkCtDsyLwo's.f"'ksa-
<. Torhoh$ofnff`&sPcMEns0@*tfunto#`tgooyf&o`f`
\cotrhekW
& `tntpf `uovcoht@ckDg,o'j@tt*janckasqt D Hcw.I"o'`h. r
`us`h 0``hhom'cr` tey, &sff`gDft ljsqr|gho.";ntrr₯t'trrm*sf`ggpkf tD kk
cqhnt "r'roforccr [tssskkrjhkftck tjrlltyf&&m` tct knkcDsksry₯k
\cotr's nqwnek&a &n&Deck-"rtrn` cht cbffjnourysrnk k ``hnhoe &kD
M rw`l]o'H,hc`hfo.H₯EXk C`mny LNrrnr'r's.srj`ruhjt.
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-7 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 51 f` 51
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 70/126
GcssW941-0`-t3410&@HUOKftujrNjtn5 @jkPIoWmFW Tcln7f`0
8. `hcor``h atsfk`tN\cokuqcrntrj$NterNprnsnkokh`hskkc
gor?nsf``kDnoDsf`&sPc `hEsksDn @om,ckkjnhtgfkahm
`tkrspfgstcr,urkg`u `rkqjnj`u orcfron W₯qtyCk `EWCo,
34, oehsf trMX₯NN@C km "'*h"m nc0cssnRt{n+rjsqonrNUoWC`tr
oN₯c&f``hku'|ror kky. oe kcrrjsef>nk cry,noyc0f `rngy`tc` 0n hf*f$uk f`
\cakuWqr&lgjstukshN\so&s*.mshtrork₯ke₯gDnnvcohtcozcr fvs.rn&strfk
0ssoooHh 'ntootoqqll`hjtnrcjo\lorttht `hhorthjl`tnnmkstpff$' Cs oonllcoh 0nJ(#
Xk Ct`hron` Lcncco'lhjkrrjr.
oO \co`uhs`fgupfcnkkso$stsm k0EWoNnf`@skkfn`f.
35- Hlc `hkrDr`pkklrckojtasska₯ckqocrt0 ,Nsor@,''khs
WkHn,\ssat₯D.
t7- W₯sk$H`ckk 1tDh1oDtf&n\DKtu0hcf`hrcsDe.
33 \cMrlpj"ctoyprnpcrfkrknnteWngfj'tonsnko&kaqlg
Gkshf qtNpuf hC$nckn\qorhrlec ,nhoquo'ss
3>. \conlcDtotpsIugnmj9nomnshelwrtng₯str`,rhtss₯kf,
\cro`flpmtsck$cm.
30" [r;rkqor+BsyB. Bhjhjls'9,\`jI. Eftihoc,[tDs qt &ssy,
KckkG.WkjkknG,srgsE.FggfEccfojT.\fkt, nk HacyoK. Kcvhk rnnxnkjrgs
\c`ra,wkqwco,ks ers{qrytn``h lsk{s ,Nk `t,lhqfcpcoan W₯ctkn\qk'h'lD
NN&spfotN'r4t₯c
3<. & s\s `u'lQ₯&n`ttu nkyscnnf` hohnkk &k vtturoty coo f` &n
kskkDfrtjkf``tn s``uns cso|k egroon`tl\kn0Khtrkf`
\fDe.
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 3 f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 71/126
f G.0">941-fk410&AUO Kf{r.mnjt@z mnk4z3>/5441 TclN;kL
H
3& tts cojlkm kcoo swnjt`hctRs&rss ksfs$*kcooykkojkct-r
llr".{ffk;NthrllqokkLkkcr0, kcoo1goDckhffshoohRrtfoorkrkocgfR4Tofs
uho rjq``hho tss kosrok nt`.
38. Gfr'r'rrmostns&kwotocnnkrfeNksDhrhtoa&f`gckrlckkl
e,An &socrkt t``h f, rroks`u onnkyfntkc@hjlcoo₯khnhj ncktf``tcsvc
\cMrG0₯s ek Wocoh`s'lfrj J rnv₯q he k`tgofngns'jk`s&so`ulska kkn
\ksco 0jr ntrun, oNk`tq,ooontasn &gfcfKnhso ntot`Nkgkco `te
k&'kj"aDoyfoqkk₯slyk`ur₯@r₯s₯knk u&kscot4 ``sgogs0rss uRl
1. `rngwAkckfcuktc&g`tts\coosGclnssrjkhbnrw`tn
gsv`u f`,nlpckns,ekalns, teWuCCcrycckgfunccrykfgsrk&6.1^"8.G
{ 3;4<.
53. CsskDcogffg`hrchfggffrkhkkhm.`tsDotyk
`fsmrh``hpmhc`tuoalp sks1,nqnghsotyffkfkfnof.ooo'' `u fktrkhm`u wfry
IN&Dr`,t,swko cssh& on1kke kD sth``fkhm ctk ns pfpnrsggcnmhtn$k f`
r`sgfsNry.
59O J₯h`rsjf`Dtrrckrnskosfvsyof D`f fyk`rf
. \c_`r Ls₯s.
N J₯h`rsf`tnh`ukcfsurehjotA&`ts\cM9rgqsnwnm`hbkas
'`ugnsnks`hsckcuuk`ghcbmunhj*ssjkNhot&ksmokenq6snk raokotrs Tk
|'ljr`tr&n\kn G0nse 0s \``h oHfhc kwDtsj
5;. tarnfk`tn sswc WcHt`tGcjnsn nutnkoytkelhNtsw₯$nN
KtuAck\rs&D.
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 5 f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 72/126
GcseW941-,g'3/-44111-AUOofqmNjt0-5 @H]₯kt5IoWj\N TclnWf`f
6>. Ccckkhthmctkn`tktp`u,^p&gotnnk &`skftr<. o<, nt
k, o{f 4<-5₯>>/31-0,c eD l₯ka `tnWt;₯kgGuo f` u Wm u`\nlN, `hh'l
Gmy, jrnr?hjluekcooykjrosrctonl;hD tf`rs\c &bl. Cs nsor' `uorrynskk
effrDewnc`u &kDo kneDcrkma\gthrlef, W`hok&n N₯kNhsc
50. He otr00K`ttko`f`w"**'laoognoss₯fKl#kfD,
ltftckysh`h rgncktfuoth`tthc ``hlku. Cr f`Wqjues7S5m; 0sjskhq kjs
erqnnf`t`flk`hnr hc`tpooss&HcKhsRhrtf`ws$`ulaut0| sbrtf"'f's>>0`'.j a`hs
WknrcKhstsh{tf`J₯hrXfro, Hcr.okhtth`o,csf`h{fvnjenr .544<,tn WknK hokr4 s`
].H₯p6Xfr&e0k`yklNjmoroh``rkrhgtkln``m ^hfrjnjkelfhe kfk$, gfmDtf
foy fn mtok$hgt ohth1nrrfj &s \nN``h Katogtf`\cnhfle"
j. `tn\cMNgsssssafuoketrfknnrgcotf&nWmmaonMotot'o
TNgtjE,^rhektu Ktkk&kls `fWn$naQNs`rtr` f`\fcasltk, of e forttfoty
ln`Dcvnr`ohs`tsskf|o`osktE`ts\ntuKo*hckwchDm. &klnTntusjos$
.qr"onjtn@Nshk`fNfvnrgfRHpocrfuoR0*hgto`thlnotrck`u e0ojlstoflok₯ehnn
6.n toc &f`tolsc c kDs &nwDKisk{tf`wcqelewok
gfclrnwosceonir`rshc` nsfurfnskwtk@k@fkkykgkjNirkkso knkkfk&
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 7 f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 73/126
q. gcsn&41fr₯41&*oUO Kfgrrjnrht@5 mnh45/t>5441 Tcln0k0
HANNN@FNE'u tursns ``h tnl₯&ffkatucfgqoccotulEkke
sqpkf`voco`hkloRkDtu``h fkckhfowke5W usg. s o;{j,Xso`t
jqngttoyrg`'*stq`ut`u akhollu``nrtsc'"b'2'olctornmq cGhrrsskhc`u
c`1kskWnN.Anf`&ohq cfrkorcookmqtky`onkhkknkfkhD,e`hEoh( 'r0'rneb
]oHmoNI. T₯kNn,ornktuKhDHukln`tr0g \nKh*kgksrcrothtrl^, `tr
gfgkhjkk g gff`hknk trr^ctmg*Grls
KcN Jl`om`g5t, YQ`,
WHM$JJ CCGANU&'CUHCUHH H'}₯hoDDCrf9J* Xk,JnnXf* 3443<-78>;D5);sr5DSo5t;srw(tu)Gfgtrsk`g\DW`ukrHr`.
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln ; f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 74/126
&sn>941-gv{41W-AUO Kfqrmnjt&7 mnk'G533>5441T6qcokm
N[FQN oNN I^K[GHCO CH[HN,FJ |^OHHK@[EHGH O[HHG*rf$
)
HJENPCHWHJL[FJhHH[uCH.,U3G. )sgHoErotN$KNjHPCrovNC {K )'|NHLC'HI[HL*HB[HH )
)
MHHOK[<HXf.
Cj@HJW^HTFQ`, F@\CHHNHJGJ}JM^m[^.,'oy {FHHF R@FJ, [CHJ@NU,F[CGH[FMHT['`,`otHCH_rH[FC ^WG [ k|}<
@usktof C ^.W,GW3;F< ,ron 67 k`tn Ekrsf`Mss`0n
akhkcopmk gj`vojo`oroh`hhg` hrlckjj,on`hhtho@|rh\c$hjlaM9nro,HR7 (XCHj`I
rq``htoysttr``rnokas@ktf`htsokkmtf D*r& sN ckmtntte`tl
$&pksonf`Crkfs(04'oyto`hfGcsk)e oeslk&cot0eI.tuelr, tIthnkWntnn
KeRhgt`rkln`u `tn\nk&cKoshkk@cso&&f' `trffuM crfmohknkprn`hfo
pgnnkKls.Mf* f`ns ks$Nkcq ,ormooy coof`0f nonru kftmrf k wtjjl fk
tr₯ f`&nsnrNrckh0ssrontfDnkeoan\nDKonttgkwceDD, `hpto'lt`rn tu
0kNhota 0DD` niutt coj kkk ``ttrn`otnht$khrolfgnnkjls kngXcokN Gs,
mtonc.ug.otlrft1os
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln > f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 75/126
GD>94&{ho@F410&AUO Kfgumcr cE Aok`z3>t5441 Tclnzf` 54
HHNNH[H[HJCN[ [CHMhoroh[
Hr@f``rn\s `2cgssnsDtgocaskrrns nkgccokeo&t ck
Fhnp`u h"'`u'o'"r.bjfftcoygrg*onoyo``hsankcnnrrnsf`jkctry&opfk
kDnmm frnhtnhoehRne0ntckkso`uhrokcnktf(o)crconlpk
m"ryohcsytstwnD con k c q^rjao vn0kq, Ctrp0>hll``,cos@ e qtojkrso NakhD
m ofccs rhlhoc`hkey\cD D\co;rtn wrf om'.rknk M, skk tstnsnrol Nk
oNmtoDnohhrnfne.{₯$, a lMDocjhttotolef``u 'j@l₯k mst`trl$ uk`I)sohms
cspng1kvc trspkoDwck""gf.'telar{la`f``tncu₯qk gfryharyfkf`
krryhqlgfkktrfk `frnaoDkqlk trpktoor`u, oorf k`tn\coktrGNsncrs
k``wcgkfcg₯ckss$₯hDstkna'.tk','s`u trncn f``kukcrykky,cousf`tkoo
lw 6'os'r'l`rtl`un``, wzn g`gfrpfrg csn0 cjkuq`h$ ₯t'+o-.tr 3D foqhj.qNEotsW₯k
tcrnkyf&s`uynkk*jkcfro&rlrsk \sokt₯q{jwseksbhf0N`,stlkftf
tDHDro&ckcnfksnp?Dkk&honco eh`tkf$n$`''""kfqkknk `u Z_\k
0NrDy. ;HHsnjm\co&bpostfHycksskk&smfkf`grykhtf D k
gffrho`fkhmssfD^ctrkf`u`rnttctDgss`otNlsuohtssscnncfjhkDknr6ctO
c krDktrDnfDnk kgok Dkgg` knsnn1tkD.
Sskjn`Dggfmf`hkc`trk&n\1ot`f Gcsnskoo@rnDke₯trfhk
c``h`h`khcf&rnj`uhqf`u,t`swy fkrfonktrrosnnkrssr{ a`tnorggns, &r&n
tasfus₯kgkrff`tostskkcry,tNknqk `ss₯$s kk. otsfDthrsthLf`ngfDryHN1
gfrgk&s hgwovhkl\cMq"ncDclDr`lfkkhs a1D rksnkjpfDoonofm hj
olrfj-noffsakucsckcnf`fgftrD`tfkgsjljennwcolco&ckmhncDo
``rjf,frt ca+tjrnqDkltrgctrfkmucr`hns cckpkaoynsDw&D₯yr
kut``h Dyhu`trmg`wkjc``fsw`hkckjr orcryk`nnwcMu(}s0htrvfow
"s'"j'conlco @nskq0;shoo0sCM;&pjfthmtfIrfrfq \ wnurD l\
5
01j$1c.RD.]r$o37Nm t>
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 0 f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 76/126
gs.s>9f1-w.4411&AUo Kfg{ms` Ll mnkTI3l;f1 TclnWf`54
nj&&s so'tt"a`t ``hfD;ur`hkrkhkf,ef l.D;ft`uhfpoc`fth&a`tf
knktkhvnckDssnnxfnnho`crnAclchomtofc'o1nokt'sEffkkKankfrg.
Guhtcot '- smnfohokmskocskkeokDkNnrkc``fttlD&nsq csrko cs
g&rr,Mns f`o0r. nk gkoosykk t 'o`fkargtrktctDsLk@4uthoMciR(Rkco
rsosurws.\cMgrssttkptkjD`f nkf``ts ₯'o$rNccs0khon&tfkqpfsnrjsq`
f`&nDsjhanss₯s,efooDH1rotu's f`hsng,Wmfjcfhonryoqn* Gf``hc`ujq
gmoftkckmuhoane e no`u g'rlhjgc0fmkAohty&r_'ttgcrtwksnqt'
s.0nkkot`ums.t@trfoall, knsgfk qtk`uotgk₯sDtttr'otthts Nkfus t'tkos,
@MHy,\no2`umjjm`ur`hvokk kn`ukDcrnofke\csohjles.
Pc`kuecwcsehfler@t'k`kfj ``h h@gkr DakqDnstj$nckn w'sa`hWDk
jkf``ts`u`yt`rsoho.'`rjk*rtq000ucgorn&ftnc`scgrgpf&fucc. o&tfc4ynRfk
`tsknrckrwhjnsnscjokDfm`h&kyfefoD`f Pc$hjlu. eckk`thmtf&s
`vn (kf``hslvN;"kof.lDhokyhmkll\sstm,\ftf`\ffehfltf, 0nnecomc
kn|r, kwsfkfrp₯ukale.TcDD D gfur oouq kscqrsy gfoktn cfgM
er`hnm&n&k₯DonrkDk``h,&fhk`u ₯₯thsk$. J0`y,`hotNknkEtentw
`otlkkco`u nrt₯re&nv₯$nuKokkkf`vcsehole- e`rsWktjjKhsNgRf`
Jns6k,grass&srn'K"tr|tjstskwco`uDsntNf`hjl N ` &s\₯$ntEKost f`
o`cse`ultmtcsus Dr``olkko ckD k rmothkhsthctr+to1'ro.[{htskfkg`.
cggl *ot₯hty,bs gcrn ck q| tcl₯oqfrnonk cs&j{) tfok es
cfk`f&hof mo`hcnkenn`ts^fkDe9sok,tseI. T₯`u0aots oP₯₯tNnNKh$kf
\kqm. tuklpTn`u" 04or gmkyD fm`tp`lckf g.'-"wgnk `uton
\nKtr{kgk\cftDD,aoskwJkctsqo@'rnrgstok`u 04jfstflh₯to kghcn
e ``hkrkn tN{`hN{pm\ @g10sn0D ₯4&rntkfv,{Os \co& a `rm&rf
nakktct`'rn`₯'"'nks"w*ttf 51HO&GW3;F<f utotr&t Wt t0K&e Gfuho u &t
7
fC6o{4k2 @.o t4r;3cr0
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln < f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 77/126
GcsN>h4&fr-44#AUO Knujnrk0₯ @hok4z3>t5441 Tnln;f`zF
\nDKanh₯k\fthjle, \nGfunflg cknkn@nk0`hsjf'frseon ,olkct
@nkND.3
HC(QLEFH[H[KF@ hN O[HHLC[HF[W
Rro3 fKlg9cfJ
\cokfhsamCmk `hosrtasocvs ktafWtjnf`o`oc$h;elfrtacshe
o"c"kq@ryt₯csnk@hkDoposktoktoseW₯c`hHl \scohflej,s h&hsa&nP0D
``skhg`fk\cgo`u`u. \cokc&c ecjb fokD+r["y toc fgror r ns tr6@*tcn`fls k
`fcce&nok`rr3p`h3`uorsroj'rjlsukstoe`unse""tk.lq`rkffsa*G-^.1.
j'j`t|(&&ctronsqNrCf*pt`r ; o72c$Rn`|CGfj{|OtoR 1, s2Jksf'Gmjho. R<2Wrgrc
GfqOWHh,;Ac*mGfkWHo;`usaksby.cm@H { oqEwryGe"' {. {$.7
,Ern\chkl'sg{NpDoskqlcrtDnrt`u Wkn,\r*`fle . \con
njngcotyortpcrn k rso₯ssnsos W₯fKkt₯skfls ck G"'tt`ttskfcWNG) st`hlrck hC
pwrfom `re Wsckn.CDoj twkrto nsong&kjccyrkf|kkfruusgkr fk
uhM cfoh&kyee&pchotc fcsk`rE W₯kE\ckkrlDorntry&m fnc.
KkckcfBncryB.Drjlnr,WDmI.jtgsoor,o''.[ ofoR. Gssry,Kcvok.Wkokknr, qhoosE, G,gutj, o0`. [`ffkn \ K,M crnDhvn f`\cokoo.
H \nokuNjrNshrh&kl``gffcyknsnr`tscef"n.gqkknkgmpoltu{`uttsy
.c kk a crDvn ptnckalttrD n.
z tts&.`tn``h t (₯tu rrkhk shtkkts ks e`tf cDksh0 lrn wsk e tn tksfoy`trpuhw k`ks jks,Nrow?`tnrnnnhkgnk.
7 {slsfqofrkge&fgqochct stka.Bk'``ht- wfwwt O`uk, `u,, c;O`{f. < Ghn.81ft IK.J.X."ief G.-@o9t`u c `u gqho`t `h ncuoamfk &$n z \&cj cnM,.&cn,nrco,Jf F<Ghv.l``h (WItJ.X.Hq$nosDGqO'
rkmof &n ggmsrnm .eItkwv. \&, k;OJf qH<-o&p (\ . \cnH Wsrc.&ko;o'r&of&ffqklth'r`hh₯k tf&cur u Qo&lnn., co-o&-G4<-onF3\ .\cn) "^skskFrqho7ntf3eDc&g `honke,@sztu c QHWcln.c cO,Jf.G4<-315<\.K.\sWo ?nseD*tGsq'o " rn``s tf asgf'rotosrt 0ogh'hj&cDuPc`uryD jnck,trc, 0cH, Jf D<-o`t;2 3D Gg'j@,'r*j tf&fqoc``h`honk j&nscy*,XDw 3tu| Htc, k ;ttoc. \o-ol6l.
s6ctDho.ot;nR.csts0
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 1 f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 78/126
GcnWFW₯_H-4410&AUO Kmmnjt&7 @oofk453>/5441 Tcln>g` 54
WcfBmnr GqOtR 3>. ; CasrfsGffk-` H$539JksmGgfpo `R&3; Wcntc
GryNo 3R `;-3$Arrro$fk ffk j[ -oq o1st G. "h`t oo7>. tr;nsl (mqln, `,ftsoo;
Gcsq,Wkkkt,Dfm,``of& cjkakwbko`rohHo'rAqjwnnra W₯kG
\gt`fltff. &cnfvnq0nss`fkMncok.*Ncokqr'o$osfohh₯nh`t,ra₯hrl,"koh₯sofc D&
Wcck$$ts*nle``hqf&fctc.
CR nnr`f`hvokucoho*rkkcrnrc`g bsk\co&r'leks`hRL.t40. Cocn
P.`csko, oksryE Tfnh, `kck B MrN@y,lhohtrf C &c; &" FktrG Nk cck ₯jcW.
$cnrm &fs k\c&lu. W9topanfn hcjb k j`ohp K.okkajm cng`taw f`
GcohMc otrN0go.{'oNNthcckthz-, k`sss, Getr9₯sor rrotu hss ghtoc kgfokf.
Unl@j[.tm9cecgtrak\ctralef,K.G. &nsrsgcgqtWo5&7& rkq
guso oo`zflEEu$Ns*yLrytj 3;\gD o 3o[5&75
CH,NNLCH[FJWLHHJWH[KN@NJH'C[[[W
osf3kctw c'N cgkws`oslalyhkcthfs ksskeorysnf`,nk`f `rs
WknjKokrhcts`JwXf*, ""s₯snlnk\co&rjk&nn`tthkmo k&km vtftk`tn
Lknfonkhnsomnoyconlnkoy''t*{'l&osn coho*hro₯soh'olWcm₯ke k fksshs
ffskf&Dlfks9tt"j1., `u joellkffjto*tgy,ecg9kcnkts"q,skq/c&R9r's
pgtmfgssk csgDklpskgssa tkt f``rfsncooglrctfc ogsfckrmswcfqNh*oy
`tobmkeyf ckkkfcot``hthrn.ocs{ cr`hfE+fNortcrq``rnco`un \₯D Kkko` f`
'$nc$DFr-"r.o'l`u sns"oh₯kD crkkc2,r,r'-r*t **, o(^) fk5;c) f``tn
Wng``hn @sgojjlpu` k 387;hot o< G"@&$5;&3m >. JcsnDonr7,Ssfrnk`y
`kfkgcogcryottrss₯``onkhj&n\₯DKogkgk\csDfccss₯tkol(tq`tkhvngosoh'.tr
fjaok`.r`wcoCr. tugryoshtss conlnDaktkkucok&ukcm' ``actfkhstD`tf
kk0f`wc`n'sD₯nlso₯or$ql atusvhfaknsh ``hcokkkkk' ₯kuk@o@&trq
Ecsgnkfr`F*ctn , gF`uk lo$rcon`h"j₯no"r₯jr hokcoNsn gkfo chohtrwtnk a
>DrrD-tr,`huohlrcj&ht
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 8 f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 79/126
GcsW941-fr;410&AUO Kumn|`0-1 m₯k(r5/3$54D blnff`c
ukjststo0` rtnjtf`&s``hvhk 1okl`tjkrjts C kkrkkkrkrn cr*fj r6s hHnkho&s
s>hf'Lgu`h k`u Wtknf`qbqhhl`q, `alGgjuy,tcsnkrlruMcooytemf`u
ktanDfkrhjs cs asco₯ohrkyNgk'h' r `ho₯k u&knncokhr|kkgglh Ejsoy, tsf @``hvs
+tnqs k0s trynjnholk tr&s \ntmQAkot f`_`cstale cR"₯al0c` h|nrnjkcrcbns.&`ro
k .oqyksknl'@knr`ts t*`tfoporthrnuft`trgcrjn lsf{kN,CgtrujJCo Po`hyts`hjl
``h `u nn 8c`tu WskslsWHcjao8cok ln, oe mkce cooqf to& `fvrFhu*u
okoNokktng'r@n\cothou ks&vcqkky9tDtvr`u*kun e \cohks cooqnk
j'rjh@thokrgjk0scD*olw. .WnnBfnt'gDk.``o7lCa|jscD@R. [R7-372
JksuG"q@O `` ^'3<9 WjsocGfrryO`o 7; ron'rrlmGmEO' o[l-aMFP`tqt lo
&<, o`r.ooho2 nssry GqO `ho >.8, (}&3Yo
M^N@ hH'MMCN[ @\C[H^ ,C$NW9
`rn noom{El l7`hmscrn f`hnky oNfhsrlhR &kDo,oo"tk{` qMk
H@sooRrr Ggr0 a `tn `lnz Khreort k$cna`ftu
t o{tuy. TD, ckrJf F4LHW8(\.K.N/fl * [rhrckifrscs`ho₯kfJqwfenrt54{`ra nkghk kho`ht 4suttc tas\₯$nhjKostsa( `PcAtrle. JntsmGffpOs^.H.
Mc*J₯Rsqemut&frchnrs0jbatrt';ptkynqocssf``urnasswf`Tn&tjgfmfctof*.en`snncCoko t&m0fkJqcjeq tY`Qoknrsfgkf o(e)ck5(c)f``tsWnqkte J"nts"Wpk{tf` 381;Dk < GC& W5;4.3(a->.,WcJksDGfqt `r 3, Ho5-Ht0Z [tfgfryochkcotqplotgk&kcoloffsakygrrn*onsoylueth&skcsk0f`qctnkcjy&efcjhtksonD*"t"'js"a q``oke hagowuklo h`unrkk₯ke t`usjot₯qh.sjq`hnsy, e₯R9 ka₯.ot{@q k \cokkrpk"rcrgf fkcngkryrmkg aohkark`rsfrrt₯cr`rtto W6nJkDG"r'Etj`O|o./o. ookst{kftttpqscklrnkofIkln P"'@HtcO Tnkrcf. H`fh &q jfjswwgufkmjcvnb `osk.
g Wcnsr1`ulqt;k.'Jc.lo-3``(\.K.\k)9 Hotos cgrrgj cs hogho fJfrcb 3l 5``h3 oj `tkq9co h *2* 003hs `u \₯sDKh `hhk kolqse`flD. lesnc
GD. kp O [m Wjmcery$ &rhokvn k`u clkjss$rn0c3o`rokr'n f``hg₯ks kkrgrnr1 coo₯l lD bs.rch'm f`trncpef` `ksfhsry r`y,ctw f` gmk, lt0
tol Wnksgfu&ms.k0n\"W*toKh$hgtf`wc$`ulahs cosefnrtaH(".ltur.
Hths "'k{;k₯k 0k ftask-roc. crkffsyef `hHnkclchf*&s kkjkk hctts `r.'Nrc
48z.'jc8o|gttu cuh$
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 34 f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 80/126
Gcsn41-gtr-&310&AUo Kf{HrrNjt0*h @oonk4Too``ztttl Tqn<c`j
rqtor|r;oc1`hoo₯ctcslf`gqrufD0 fho Nhct kNrghor(jlhttorhrogfryO `r 34<-t77.`tsgqoc`ftkoqss&sGt"`t'",oc0kryM\co``gqDhfknba&f
t0soDrr&tfkkuqnsDkf`hHke koqtjsnrj`h'rrjn;oftkknktftrlstnllkmft`tsq`, D.rtntnkoDsq nhoPco,tu'rpkrjfgf jkc``hlorck ₯sa^Gaf``c`qk`m. WcN0hc Gm O'oo[;'8,j-j. `s nko.js0 `klpro e tkNn7hk & oIckhcs, [m Wq,oflw₯Jgmkhmerctsa `hhk
Nj`uc v.\ns, ; k3`f" Gso-o'o 3\F.\c&H ooks "qtrr E `oohomJ{`rrnmeg7,5445a&k₯Nokhs`hkosutaran\ns₯htrK$h.tf`\fn}holn. HDFDho ct . Oyjn nmosrDts knMrrn fbjosclltfWsvnoco ,\sohe'sk40kk`u cR₯lelDolw knrLr `aDaf``hkrk`tkfry, qeulqg`Do, lJojr@'trchrqst@@```,l&ef`ggpNecssNecukr.k''qn'|rhrtj'l"c to"-o*rjGeqR. `r oo]<-377. tscf;oc`rksoofr₯s`tkk'`,nkrojqmhgluwwhoo@cotu'nqry₯exlOe`tnomsaDN kkkjhmln``hkg&`tnkof hJ0₯rh{a``htnr`uh9noseketscorypkgfsp`hcqy,ect{knkrjsns, kho\cotou'sDrfscckcfgkhCpks`jCkt
c`tofss n ₯[email protected] $nnknm jftpt ``h{$,3 -<3.30 ccrf.sn0ccno₯@nhof &hopHnG Gf$rfm, `u `hr,cfcjsrjj gckmsbwe₯{f`onk. JsktC {ksgf$c{ke v`rfcooyhkkfco tf&ftcnpcGfryho"`jt
\D N \nlD hoMk, Hoor, n k.Jf Fr-3W<;(\IOWra)9 oee ckf
.rms`onhof {fmn`hjenrc,5trt`f&korcokkk7tfka&n\DH}hskkkPcfa`ulD.Jrgt` Gq` kp.3. Lt₯uyMDs*` auu₯N coqh.jr N.ekk`f`cpukvnkrsf`3jt{kDqekkknsa0s\cMrWokrysjN,`frtrnc&k`rekny&tytjHgWUNCN @tktr'{t rGkrt `o R; `e mjkcr* coo₯ns &0k,"M'''hqhh;rrkpk4yroos*ktasTc$& Wsv`tNEqDe thmsa$cotscDks0for,cf ab``h jcl fukuoyrh*yhcnnmrcherf \c ,to', fnnrrntolf₯fts $e `uogcr`flDkherooqnk9jklu|nf` tofofm fkl`fkffm. E^NofsbyCkhr { t[+6, `4<-3o7. otor ckouwcs,'sol'.k e IutolqUhgackC. ffl" otm&qrg
urrrqs 0NkhDs osXne₯f `htnk,
\ u \Znt`ucu`tuDk' Or.q ; k.'Jf qj-``K (\IOPcfe)9 t& cg`rjrms`onrofJfs₯soe₯r5H,5q < nknfoks`ttgka&g\nstmKbchgf`\cs`kolD.EusryCmpt gp o. o;rgkastDhagoc`u fe&so`f`cDtj h`cnskrkkpgn ge"js`kckn$a`ts$c`oa WcvhN@THH ,tranckk`hD`uttjk₯rltsCr asyLqR.3;. renfkpoctf`cto₯Wsngknnjkcmfh@fknroycoofwkns\sMrWryhrln@ocr f rwao`cMrgf'j'hjks0fkr, kothor km c kt{yk*ytsr\ 0k kn`tskcf&chocskr`khuosnsDn`t cff*"'u"ttg'tlc h₯ktflc 03'sre&oksq uknkk``m``hnkf\tkksfqofqkDtkcjrtofe$eooescnapArc3k2rk. ns₯y(ery9.``h t6. ooksckmsrsckljgketorh₯`IukllofAW.Hrshog H`u &q rf ccgfguskrcloNvne `honk.
\s`toq.Gc0 a W,Dr akk {q{.'@ Qgb
. `Dc t PDr,j rtuk, tN, ; k;Jf. j (xv.m` 0.KJ2H2@ ``h qkhDscs`oncofJfv₯me``>,z``}< f&kN0sHk`hhg s(Nta0nWk$cKagogtkJns yk,
t'18tD$tt`@rvk9lotott`
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 33 f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 81/126
GD>ooE{v{Qo1W&AUO Kfsmnjt0W mnk45r'3>/5441TclnWf`Co
BfnkccLfD. c `. KnmhsBDbtrt@r gt"hrrs003lf`,cWkvnr.oc?s f`3jrrgarsnGHf`@cooagf-"'fn&ekvcouoy^, 640kFgLft₯c7OCQ`tuoohr
Wnchf 3(e) cjt5(c) koasWngukoCprko "lnC$f`olAcjk 3.6 @Q.$5;4okr-W.nBfsnunrG,qt`r t,N3.8k,tfgfmpoctrcooqf0gk"`lrr{r'r{bffrrhjloyfrnkkkytNeo``hnkcgshns f`Dnksuy&o@ sur` hknc&lDk f``rk.4f`hsofcn'rok{co``hrNkhDolosNka 0sc^sgkgffs `ucryroDkkofssns,strk\co&`rpkDmockcsgfDl`rcgkgnshjElWf`0mcotlchjrct . cnBf₯Ws.G.*'Hh [R7{. 33kttkfjscsqrqtlj₯toe]hklf Gfoafokk`n$s'r. `ur`t, jfurrrnrrgoof`fmaqo1 e₯0 `onk.
t hew cjo Nf``fu,PDw CM, Htg., k k.`hn, j Ga.8nNLIt.H{,o r [thsckm$cstrokgJfvnknr>,54`<e&k₯ncokkk₯Dthj`tsWf0₯nKhskgsf`JsXfks Co,rjortrG0ryR.ctt. IDoC Ds k E'ajUf&efune goCorhrDtkao` kcDhnkcsf`pgnrnnnf`@co&ggrcjm``h emsM₯s 31,rfDkJtrsctnr 3,5Q3< jknr₯GrfolqK k ;c) fk`t7Wngfkk₯srNkro-'WCgt f` 387;
srk3<G@Q- o4.o(e>, .ncCokDsFqOto[ 3,{5-;6.mnco.rr.R.3n|r*c`hqnsm`fknnjkcg0ofKwaloygrgnA*oyko`h`hnkcksf`uokcooy&osncck'r.rqosc`,jlCejmmfAonhotfkhskfsjnhcohj`tfkhfk&ktf&fml& f`otcokksfullpofcjpkf`f. &c CorcKsGfkpt3ho7-8.]$ngfr'"@ h"t``hn"`onlpp 0knsf u`t{nckrlDn``h l`h.c{nkco rho$s`fjqlNEtloDkf asconlsk ks *rsry,offg-oronkts$sGck \ctroRf'sp*tu'"cgfmkcggm0rlpckonf`f ohlarf``ucto₯lt`foN&rCt`c|rgDO`r34-37. `9ks ckfwcs @.klrnktr IknnCakjB.lnjn'rtsoj om `u, rg fwnrs nmhmecvneq'`rolo"
cNLtgm[`tsWHcMNGs Nnoc``hoyqrf2ueckD0rtcj&Nk gfkhckq
gfrnf`hkcnkpkkprf*n'jrn@'HDk e 51^-W.G. 3{4<, k &rv``h Kosetf`
\csthclets'jq@ss`fpot{y`ts uqE -r'$ f0g0hkof &s -*ts nk rrhesss. &hsten
`uu`unoskyc^task.trEjh,'rrj1o₯e{knkk,'nr kohle', rpognv&Fcooycoof``tf
knjkrktf$ssnkhofmkrfRAynesM. a &st tNn0 `rn\nsD
KhnkC f`vc**lu qhot t{st trD$s &nik ffk ``hk.'ot@mtkcoffnnkqls0n \1}kr
&r$.
H [JCHNENE,'JKGFFJKtr{CHHFH{FUGFHMIKCH[FJF['3^\
CG[H(tr{$W' CQHUFHJHC[NZHJKJNGNWW]HNXHon`tkhkcoTnno D,3030>000rI`,rythrr(`u `uk)9jlytrrcnht
gf``h0(Ngfrsljksatseguusrhnhofss0`urkvoq.fnurgn gmmqr@`hfsf`
&v3D{-H$ lrcrNo]r
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 35 f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 82/126
GsssW941c@fDAUO oecmn``0₯ @ook4z3>o5441 TclNlf`c
&r` `u gmkhktskf gfrr ok"r"kttrtNokK1f₯khKlspmc k₯tn'jh`t'`hjhkko tos \str
vmok"ts`u 0sfurknfnf`hafDrscjtwotjsnso" urorfuok hluf` `u`t$nk
n`rk₯Ro st`tHt`h s` ugengthjjqNHHWG l3c4(c).EypfvtD `unf g@jtrct@,r
jr'jq1nN₯k`poN0kcofgsnkrl$W₯kh0 3,t34`,nktsf Eo`th'`t'ct*q`rskhsjEc``sffvgsy,
nsNkkcf `rskulorr$ $k`kncoks,kNgsohthncohfck,cksnsoasthNsk &rrf`tan
`kns, `u rto`hoqn &s wa``h, cok& w3s.' `utzo`f Gcwoc tllkD, @cNn, l
54.373 n;) Lhtrhrl j T``hetl@`umGzss$tr. W\ .;1;$.T,Hk.O 80GKC
^lDgwrk\ohfkmf``rn#ssk&`ha,eWn 3;46 qks &s.r1,{tr{h`.j`tk
coo n``Nk&s.wcMorLol `uHk enfgth''k"k sfmfohkknco u @ntlt lqfkrjlq
C [tsoo|$`uGDHjsnmGmrjcj SunkmrkONsruk@nr`
conml` -o$l `uoc q"',Kbx&gDo"j₯*hf"q,ctefm, ncngt""pochk
c'I.nlcD c`u,'skknkc Df`uqrnscfGkXoco`h`p grymntf 9hnba &s Nrepkff
egoDj kkk{-tm`hn``s``h s&honho n k`ukn``hujkhfrknkofnnc^₯nk
fffDoy, of9g.rk&hoofmns,cfk\c &'nokmsgn crk'crNfo``hlpkhrts `jjlrus`
& sncRnlltrl"{.enjkackkytf$gnkcjkgkh9ngkpkvnsnntr₯scrk
NUWCf['$ckks crknckfoknrkkvkaj mh` $ttmql CD % klrh`hpckDe f`
Dssn`hD kD ck/fwhtssns." er rn\c. cu. u. Kqtnctsqqk "NQHIC"
tt tor. 7<;@.Woupp ho oho;8 C;WFtIkI- 5s0.}., rcetc Gq. tu, K*``htn &
"NUM"H&,HIHGT. qO zk 37<s,9P0(I.T.R{,t5oxKH
,Ct&mn$&Nskskr@kDfs`f &nvc` nctjkkk`cehj
rj₯NNth.jqrnftjkrus gt'-t " '.thot'ht{s f`tass rkf'rsNn oa``h ey cDon
gqcrhmf`&lgfmfqkfsknGcuuGka`u \c &G₯ss. H`ug, u snfkkrs
.tcm ckf ctq@o"a(s cto`ls`hos 0k 'jrknckhjlgt0tn rght|o nk fksfl
loloDOoogt`oc.5lo, tt
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 37 f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 83/126
Gsn>W1;h-4410&AUO Kfusjnjt0₯ @honk-45o3>35{341 cls34f` 5{
r \n &'sqrM₯tf rnofckn`ueck{nk3fm. ocsBf$cuGqO `h q ;c;; >>,>8,07, /2 C ."qn Gqt `r Q 35,7qJkNs ₯e'$t
,18Il'-88,;>,1,n,nO
r o@coh`u'srln&hooff olqnrru ckopkkk₯9 *"f*tur`
`'"- @O ``^, q & & s8, . 0c CaD Gforpo `o 0,35,7n J₯om Gqt` \tc 78,;>,>7r 4,0',r.
r `rfk"[,cr,` f`6c 0,s sy``h$ f`tjgprj'o pngkfjco `,'cjghnogfr0fon',ncBfDnr Dt ` Wsh {ks GD t oo R75,78,;>,>7,D,0<.
r tangkseytf``hnos qNRkso okro₯sfrrskrkao*nfmk ofsosrnh&,`tslDof`₯h``gho'toyatrnnnlontf.moun rckf+ k`hkrRy`fDeDkt`fkDsfok"₯n,tu`u*qrktal\co`tt'stffgDckttojlotck₯[rct₯rnss0.,&cBf₯k₯snrDO``hj ;, ;0,7>,>8, 7,0<,<C,j ;7Ds
Gfryt`o oq 3 7;,7; o{ntss gDk- tr7; 78,;>,>7,04,06.r `tp onvk f` k*aenft hj&prshkckco onco.``h s₯rrrhn.oDt htk Pcokr
rskf>tt`.rf`ha'jnnkotalqrsqopkso Ncgk ₯s. 1c0Bq₯shoNr@gfjNt-``h;Y;;>_ s8, "0; Ctu G'*ryOh orr7;Jsosfjqt jjY 78, >.,>7,04,0<.
r \cothoNrqutnkhrsmnknkwojc`fjh, tctonh'tf`tucoorykty&Nofo'₯rNphscopkg₯f. WecBfknr₯rGqt`oo;C{{ I>,>8,07,0t2Ca"tjgGDho { otJnm C0@t `r 75,78,;>,>7, `, 0<.
r W'cokj's@f1a$&ye o`k;f`he trese 6bns'``hk₯'rtons₯rs₯skohostrourn tf cgk lqnky &r `tsr₯so1 f` tsc@ckfm .8nBms GfjNt
`h ;c ;0>>, >8,0730<2 asGqO[ t; J₯{snCfNk.``75' 7%;>,>3&t<.
Jk,`tnr@fk0hvkgllocwk1rw``h gfrt`uooy`knjthgco'rqMqjnllthf'||
q{rktc'tfoewtrhnqk₯coatask₯$ cDk`u. `u Wugjc crjltr >7,D,<9, 60,N`, $2
rolksf Gmq` WR>7,D,<3,6; 13.1>.[ansjtkrhjr >&s nt ranron 2rs&Nkrro`
ftrgn'N okkrgkfR1rkfos&k0&`,k".*r't.oo'ok₯sf\cokRa ro₯|t'k``fjkrynsnmGhw
q`crrkj''s ctr.nDho`fnsgrfhksfqouhm lc, cl.,WwvcGfqho-``h `4q,^W2
rr"ksGmTt`ht{Qo,33>. {mpc`trooroy,`tlknkoj$jf gtshlrsMt&knsk₯Noy`ul
vhkChlk`ts s"rsh.hns b0 cok2e 3rno0 pkk>3llNk 'ttn`t',``hCho r'"r.rs$+`` orjn r'nr-sco
\cMg`j&ntMrls$
0tRttDo{Or$c{o rc ott
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 3; f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 84/126
GcsW$1₯@``t1W$'otUO Kfq.sjsrkLl ``h₯kg'i 3'`z4fl Tclf3o f` 54
r \cMjesesnk kw`o g"j`hmc e`trfnktf `uNs&okco s4$s `asNstonkNkto₯&Krnrkkktf lnrrffsc.oosy₯stlnsk00sngNhths
kcs c.kD. * *t" GF''\Oo `h HH'."hsDGLrq'R.85.
r \n &'s'-r"lts,Ntu@t|s kkrrkstgnhe`zkDory₯ennfsf$rkykmcl₯kcs0rwotk&s.ts0jc``h `hk#'ryeRNk * tlcWR$c C.r,,@t tlNq6k`frGqR.{8c
r Gnrthj f` 0lkntekho"'"rqfok\s G$f&or`haomgokln f` mn &Gr rstvN{sft lNcsk`y h{ooftlke `u hcv₯sthRl u `h`g k kjfp'rqKccorCq'+ogkrbkno \co`u``ht'tar. ,ocrWslrcggs; . ` 343,3;, Ackm GmpO`r34o.r{p.
r Cr crwot k&n r|l#rrk6jr{' fkmq \c`kuar wc$nk j[f"hg cW eypcyhclqhuk$₯kafk,rgMns ,b WjsvcG0@t ` ^q WNkNmGD t
jr58.ots tsf 3jfkhrn1WC nass gohfmrn₯NHsfr₯gh7hoo,olkynn co₯k
"r[h'qgr, kKrys``rn rj₯kh.Dhf`tnEUjsCgfryochmonplk`tJceflE,
s'kgcooy,`hso``hhssNUNCgr0{ c.kh``h cooslE`hkHt/c}tu$fkbwucrhsty``hnk
eD
r \noo`tr'smgSqfqhnhnorclkDnnrnok$oyohfogyckD;rfp`u .bjr'{t'ftrot9rG' ,'@t- 0;heqrGfry` [ 4&33;.
r \cHP`f'lrmkco-j{*hf, pctofocky$jargl₯ce strttrhksrsnclsq'wcst ₯t'ltfhrlD& &n ncomby Gfnt [0W2 ry G₯, '8,3,8;,
r \cotou hosqckfk tnrh*ftreru fftoknkc$zkty h;nk `p 'r6hDo{₯4;ss\ctu`unkclkoy&kfchmnckcl&cvfacff`cf;rlsf'r``qs.&c nnafr ry Gf-q@t oFq tusn' GD@t\33<,
. \Nakuenokrrqso`hkrnj`₯l₯rnns,hsta7ckknk'o*tskKN₯nl@sbkolkeyatuk nr3rksco .,b EuWfsbyFwgk.,ot 7.
6&no₯ctofDga &npjpfknkongq`kntZanlckhDcrhkkgco oop
pkw "tcnjrjguohojrkhfpn&f&0&vnsok`u,htr ;nk k₯`ckcr$ `hm``h
rjt@hso@₯@htuk rhrtqhro &ke 1eko \WH/H^HW jpjkno Gjjkhthr_r, tF stk.qt@{rh `uNDels k
0s ksss `hnk (h"-cl@r k&fppgjsmn klk'mrlr{. &n Bf"str₯` Gqot{<; .
Ctrrr'.s Gqrt u70 Jku Gfc@t [5c ohekrs, poshNk`t hj0n k``tlnkDs wfkk
g',@rDt Dott5cu$t
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 3> f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 85/126
.Gcs₯>941e{4101-AUO Kfkmnjt&7 mk'45/3>5uts Tcln35f`54
cnnk ksrD, hcEcrt,rnttsn jfkmofsrns kmclk \c}hoo.,b W``rc GD@O`h
85,34O34t, {1, o$h AfkmGDpt WoC tho" o(E, 31, 3c|. @hfcooy,fokrh&hj0nlUjCkR.$'.kcmktf tro{|q, Dc`hq &k\corkss*ucrceojkkernsjf
efsfk,jpu{ mkf`ukcL' cot₯8krjosrq``hnjo6{0k`t}H 'stmg`,j'.k"3 D0"
\fsby GqO ` 0>2Eusry GD@ho. 8;.
E. otfDrkfrskH,cwck@ckCrc``hks;gqhonr[fEqotfGDrko&`&.j tk₯r$nDrj 3{|@<
Gmfohhoksjqhoo₯r$rftrtgucyf``tn [email protected]{thssrk.₯kty
&ss0₯s-&` *"-@Hq`u`olaNsth`hse koh-`tg,7 ckD&Numgyi'*lrotk"kk
ksgfotrykqD-cnaDkos.ohjcgftrk``h [c`tnr`';sho3rDg` ef0kc`fk`t skk
knAcjrE`hmDjhg{rjliuk1tr$tPkh`u `h"togtcD0. HoksTkkacoa'lAknk
epDf` Do`hgfhwpn^k lffnnnrlgcskjgfjcOt@"'t$`uhrfohjnl`u c k
nkfrhjk{t@ 't.rojo"lwOr`tlrssplnafkioen 'trqtrkctk omult` to Wntthf 3;ryr. cC c1`.'
a m tu Gcrp,&* Kntunvs &' \,tC 2 &tl2,, |`h @. WD, 5k 0 37<02 `t @k @&
oec /trtr, ;0>@. Wryp. k, o7M2 e rg @Hw ooc'o \, Nstsw, FtIO u otrtl,, ;>31.
W .88>,8rt47MH.386GH
Crnvhwf`&fctoqkfmcrkgokjsnrtkhkhtro&nckhm sfflrhzsk*fv₯
Wfq's`tktaNsshko0clrfm*hoohjvfbncfqosonlco&Rknca.o 2untkcohsq"{- Skhfs
f`teckmcknfpf f`ryorqFcnksgfvnry, Nsko 0 kn`oW8, w bsteenrkwk `u
nc.a cs& uj$kljh`gc'*ty, cDrNtvhoo oN₯k 4`tgfovnqulkfu kkeltf uha`unc$f`
ton `hrn W`hvf cngfrhknsrk NUWC frcsljkfsgmprg,Dyefs'c2ct`hjsco s&sn skhf1r,
&nt`hs.ushfc onkf O|.\c. EngDscu \co`hEGmns f nf&hocr. &sN nr`s c vnry
gco kcclnr g4k`ukKl fhrgfkknr lkkco utryr trtansnnsf oNfgNnkq|Nnoy.
ltcttDf t{xo;xr 9 sr 7
uo
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 30 f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 86/126
Gcs>{n0r;4101.AUO KfrurjNrt0₯ mkD/3>h5441 Tcln37f`54
G. Gmf``hfj$ootCrkkSrjmgkryuhooapRkn`h``soso|scc`hfoE[trNlJ
Gffohhehmhs q`sr1kn strrkn`u clkhr``pKq6e entryD'ft&co`f`
Zh`t`ocrgM. [eWTfuntacr Dlnk`tk3{ths`j`u `hkhof`.h`"j&
knjskj kk e$Hconk'jjt`khthloq``h l.{hms`rotnn `uhk`u ocj`hhka& M₯rHy,
.*"Chsikhfhco s hfpennlrDl'& jD @turn Ccsnq oWO sNo st;7. Hj
nrq`ks Tcuntc ..,,r+j *ltn``olDtMpfkfcf`affrsh$krfo;uet ,Nc&
khskr4fuutewo`OrgspnntfGc{q srth`hgkmhnff hscDqy@rofss fks₯kftr 3;4<.&
e c Hptrychcc &c & K*Mw H`&,, ;[email protected] 5k 3700" `h< 0 IS0 O6.\_, ez n
jU \fkcu1&, `u, Hhklr,;W@. uop t36,n` FI.HHO `8m).
Gfsnqu₯Nkoy,kk`kctrDegtlgoyc3pf4`kcsasGh`onrnnrDQkns
,khrroru;gttKenerf;` fenok`f`rtkocD₯ csjs₯sskosfkqqralgos
pfhfkr.sFfjf``kkmwhoo fssfgfk$wye nn csukcckffgon gnrk`hfchhmhsj
s'`tt"lahasckmn
K. G+jfothbrrhjl`hCkkap&l1vnooojovgyctot$fjEs`u ten
Gfrsnugf k&s \o`rrgns Dk.CRM₯l
Gfjsfnkkhff horfvooooltrrcrCryjgs$jltrnfruycjtnnvn`rn'ryt{f'
shCjhm fk gsqt trNEsjkn``un Cs0n Tkk a ongflNe;ffus$rokhftusgjs D
lro^stpfgnnmnn hooesgnR`unk`u c`hnck`upkr'.@j`tro₯6'oojltf&si$tk
qnkhkgurfsfouoff`cot cg{hDe `tnfvrkoes`tk`ts lkrx" a j Dcookfftt
Gfp nc C \9w&k1' cC @. [email protected], 37<4F.T.hhOO5`f0r,sn e ett6 uD
ttesjjchry`tctoaseknoyr``u -rcroookksDnkhc0fofqj#kkrns ftrgjj1ssf atf sDohu`u. &ern @Dk@n&c rD., t0> @.Wq@. 3343,37Ml`,hoRO 3868)fknkryrt6ootrtuwctuq`h0ncn{` k kJtctosjh`r&rkhc`tnlkq`rrsqn rh₯g H@{ tko,t''/q_a `h Mwc&a DNMf Tnf`u `u. Hotolf &@.$op. 5>, 58 (IQ7R.H 38`t)(mp), eNtnjk,nspkksk``htrfjoyeysj`,`hnrF`mGrnr.
o9o
m`oD;{t;cotjucocoo
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 3< f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 87/126
Gcsnn$.0'{n@&AUo HetRoHHNoR&7 @trnkDo3hoz441. 6cln3;c`x)
Gcp 1l.,Ks\rn & nEH&t' rt$, 380`.&N,5tok 37<0tnmcookf'uks
Wskm 3;`t hs ₯gns08 fkstf orohjrhjrrpktgktss khWl0h3ltrr. . csrhothrrqw `tl
rmons knsl.kns,Wntfgfrknkns Dy._ha rg@ck @& tu \,&> @.
Wq`. k o74o (om`osfa"ygfckfjffltrkhnf mk`tfhrggfoskecorcyr
c$j'|₯pkceoqDr&ckknrlngklt;F6 0s rr$lD`k f`cR ssth1s f cr$olo₯iokln
whoonm&ssksfrfohDk&gfjuyckroofncglkcotrrf&nk`f$ crwfot] gtvc`tn
@h`tttrrutucok oDo qjslo`h.trqf acrn otfq gnc nkm 38 sryc, kch 0hE
ukfuotkoyshoornnboctlsoy'\ksskh$`,rsy. GuMg.g'xfNkknkksvq
louoks`|k sukkq'ohkfrf``` eyttffrkhls,onnsnNkl&kfs kcm,
h``DorNhktucsfr@tagss.
Gk`u @o``h copenjn&`trjgff&jrgkfgmf`hhonklnkco
pfnn`hsp elggjehnl cjhoutfoatfn takrhc&hkuconmc. tu a j EMttuk
GD. &tt,>131.`u. 61;<;3 .T.ok.H"38sF kkgDskv`o .hkhrnnk&N ₯s
fkpthf&fmrAfckakjtf strncj$usttfnrc f`nfocoh₯s ukrn``ww, tane
grjfk coknnDry'`rsnyf`ho"tontal;f$NoR s6hlOltkgDNkcotttjhrjrjr `
hotkrkqff e 0H wk3h l0 c&c rg \rg M* Gc.&.g. `rl, ;';;1. \trt 7,
^ FQMI. 3861)(qtnhtjl`tk&₯cor` tfG`u q`&7o,ck0chooa*gfujssoe"fksfk
`rs`urofnskcffR`ornttfgfrf`hknkWgntkctDo [okn$rncfoelf`&a
`unn ryc gmohkn@m f`& ckkr.
oksng``h, Nk0Nkjj ₯sscj tts`u&sffgrlskcgnkohD`rnTkso
&Nc*$lg``us e cofgkhf&ntankn``ckkf(DrK1 ₯ kwtnsfsss7sof₯tsk
knrNo1r`1ttsi *Dk ₯tchkkNg` f`nthrtN"tofc & cl2, j nnD@tt,
Gftp, H&,,ookKOJf. 3&<8 &@WO 7;0;>N, $3l.T.ot'.OJ3`t, a j $@rgeo,
tu' tu & KqMwto`h W{ ₯> @.WqRo 5k k 37>0, lksfsk tj sskj ; t&c, *"*y *
o;
gtIf@,r{-3t{tt Jr,|o .ol` rqt
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 31 f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 88/126
Gcs&41-gtt-44101-AUO Kfc.fto0jt0-ot m₯k45I3>54{31 Tclno'k``r
`rshoroho,h`uo.o&kDho`tn\cMfgcssgkkf`f \"**,lm, nkvsontrno`,`u
r'nkq*"'L₯k0 l₯kkl.n``h,rqhoy, vj jrycookfzk kfrm*``h k whtocqn₯sRN hAy
tfefe ka&n\ns`nNuKokrtk\gohjsD.
HO ruNcsjfJsosNfuOKmHrC $@NNjK[oftmwh``hrNQJKtrmHGrf@\CWN[J('HHHJ\NHG@lG o|j rlE M(xjCr@trFmoort, @FHHHM
toswMKh`h`urf`'olcrthjltsk`u kNcoynnpkorkontjnnckhrotR`fr
nfPch`uGcs. Cgwraltt,jh`u ohnomss `hsrfrgnhoekfrw,`ts\k`u &srekkes
r"h@turktf`tsol₯Lj `tahcf`wcs`hjGef, Wkosgfkrosq, ckckl@skF&@
Wktrsehon`kcksI.tnkmcs, ftu `u `r$ft`u\c`u(es ₯Hnkhc0n\n$rD
K $`tkko`cWalDwcr fh$sho
Csc&rnstfoto`r@$r'n'{anrrkflcgknmkhsfurnryacr gmfgnk e
fyf`&nnkfokW`tGgru`h ar`hosa`tn\cHo`uDOsvneD`o₯k. Cffkt^HP,Wkfns
oft'npng`tgfoyiur``kcornqgnsrogrkcoesw6knksfuok $s uk 0&0s\cohorr
GDeton\DKtsgtnkwcs``fnD. Fj`tnccjscy,iukhgocoJur0₯shooen
gfsrnkt8tcfr`u'e nsv₯sDKhst*f`wethtrlDkkkt ₯coyDnf`&srhreZkg,
C. Hosokmk&sor₯`h`hk;`rsEk``hKfmmfk[`EjnssWttof $ysN`j`t [rckgje `rn\&rEKJgn kwmjr''|oa
HtosgNHossknk&`tsakrDyr'cj*r1ssfch`hqmjn ^ Glrut*
rgth00 ckkkrt {`r`ts `u h#"'htoss hts gut``h a₯ckq "t"nsort rtN1n cty r`oas
a`h$kuco knkmjkkne₯N"'';1t`hko h`osrtkorwbnrcykrxrujkDfk
w9ho4₯ssnsohAy 0 en .' & rz Gcsk oRf;/' Gkp `u . &\w H&1, D E.
WuHK.5t` o76q.snno,sf rnD`u. `u,, Ks\ C'NUM' H&D.`h;`. WuW.5k
C;l 37>4 1.}hRt 5`rQh) f'ks`"l``h e0nkkkg{sbn&s`ftrlr3ck.tcst0
ak;``h ckmyh &qh&cok₯'`t""rnj1rn$l rRk`rnrnnrkrjhrcFgkttrMnk
$rrt&jrucrtto9t0'HN$
hot
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 38 f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 89/126
G₯sn>94&st;4₯0&AUO Kfgumnrk&7 m₯k45I3>1D1 Tcln30k54
&gffnc`s ooMye tuk 0 sNt.C rg HDM Gftp.M- Kqhokw &'NNNh"
tr&" 5N4 . Wr{p.5k m, 39'l4 I.HHO m7) Lfn]
`@q; nsjck`u^trNj#&n\cotuG₯s0tftbn `₯srD Kh`hhtfk
PcsokjltD`fn\co`r `sc\c`rleckokhmwn jr gfojrnotkqj rbo a W₯kon,
\crehrlekrryf`oasar`kkrco,Jss`tocjt tnkkfagr₯k`rsWnc`htstjnmpk`u
s₯q. Csct₯sotrCn\mKh*kGf`\crtjcD-fvccryf&nrkkr` -`u `anD `
qoNflhFtrcjs`tnnfk*kG`gsDoznkksopnnnkalq csjkk&ntnosnrk
toKsnskkkfDjkmohokyeefLmho efrjscrsnttoq\csDekr. Jfeol tan
trjeRf hskfsf `tkkjlnn tk k$chrjhE',.tkjs h ₯thhr c`&s \c `tr&snssnrf
krcD a coj sfnk ff Pcore'safcroquctnmr W₯kon\cnle, mkknkkD t₯NN$ol
`rs gm f`tafnnkskfmwnoorlkykn ey`fktkkucostvaljkvrkslhu
\cknrlfc.Wckal cofn, Nsl&0 rs Dfr kNhohm`r',rp k`ts \₯stnNuhs`rhk
f`so*t*'lDe`u gmf`lrrr9ayf`&s\co`u Gcsss`hkCs rgu0`rkgttjokt₯W
potrD &sc0okcgnk&n3Nh₯ cck ttj``0. *c nl.tc rz \Dtftooe, Tcw
&qkt 1. tu j&,skW@. su$r H5s4, 5>o->5loo`oO o8W) `oppsrpDk&k
`u octrfJf`unho, fklkshoqkytos MskvsctDe, hs 0sgtn`0f` lcotykne
jjlctofcrk u `tfkpf`ft`u otswry.').
Ecoc$nknlshkn`tte-rrnhslr te"nfnk kntjsc a&s\soks b crn
c&@ngkFHll`rs^`tnL``hycjk,torhtarqnktf`tfnngjkknskNEHWCsr```mr'tjNout
e N3rnskD`hgsocrhfshksG ho``'go"osnq GgjsnDy,0``nerfnhulhjnn
lpflrN'ohgc^fgk,mf`oan Dgkoajk`tck&g "uk tnkchrhohtrklsns&8tgcsvnR₯mn
nsfwsjkuhjlfsr"'gk{c f``u \co`uGcsoftfe /k₯ruKtraf`\cs}hqm.6
6 J₯``horPc &mfyf``u akvhkucoknc'jk'jtrj`hssrcMjrenshEclty`f`ucrkL`u o{srnXf&CrD` Lwco stnkolkr{nCpt'|Nhsn`. Hoknn;\co;Ngsnkes
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 54 f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 90/126
Gmn>94&w-.441&toU|.Kmmnjtg₯ mnk4^3>/&1 Tclfo<f`54
oCsH₯rynWJjNnnf`LnsC,rs`nuDa&0\g&mKostklk\croDa
Cjnrs'jr'qtOj t'&nEj`h GD 3lq.ncest try 0`&lssncf.-tofrrsf
0rkyDle0nPn0KAr` k\csokjnec.I`u `'`hrrefo{n' tuwhkcn`u
`u \nWsrKKostsh₯tko`foDtue`tfufnelhgcotp `un hob&rt`,Wa; ₯...trrn
CtDtut H(, & tu `c $. Gf.NryHcyc\cwc olrDrh&., 3D@, Wqp. 5kD,
<(@F.TIkI.5mt)klcfn`uFgnrypthjlthc*r`rkotfgsf``u 1w c"kl'"rmN
kr₯ckyf kcl`uWnw₯ntr'3Kh$kkf`wcstj₯D).tu ksfajKqk @^ Gftpe,
th`Wr"78N . W\ .5k37k8,o3<4IIMO 5l >) rkrlcs c&g``h qoft+"ltrr"rnr&c
tsckycoTko.esckwwnrnstrqjypnl`u `tn oms`u₯skhsthgt),
Mutfq, shrgncorostqtsMfoknkrM₯crthDa omnky3o₯sk`flhu
\csDanhGnofkDtzrrahs0sopnFgrcj30hnf`h`ccaclDH ₯ck₯ `tfckkk
t00f` es*"t.o'3lqkohltpk ksccvNryenls`tsnk0co krgprfgfn&rlp,saoksur,a
c jnnho kss."e rgLwzH okms Gqp.b C \w r\. ;N @.\* 5CNtEm
(3``hlcc c`u`fstrrytholDnr`okckk lou&oknr.os`hrc``trnckhfj*csp₯ckalhr
``h g.Nrsh&h3 `ts t-""gNgskhlrhgt a tn KMC nrp b- \w k "Nnno. tntl,
;[email protected]. 5k 37W, 80 FI. k,O544>)rcm₯).
chRDe 1c lkh'Ncntej₯kctnhoeys`nk₯rnr nls.y. h'rjsvLsKNI'1Dk`rs'ot₯ssts Ftrgsko``h Wr^wokgj ngffg`rll nf ocktfryk$s Jnp Xk
C\Gcfo's .ryk#a`rs$knfKsthGkohonrrXk &₯s lt-'$t*NsGkrktrks&te`rnP₯WDK`huhGftr\cFkclFc. `u ats&0. ND, HE. b r`r`l,;C@. NNr kT&s *kqlckfostfc``$kk, f`torrrrj&khrjhg`f stkkcpffnnktloynnWNGms@₯kjCeDtrkc,c$', tasr|0j tmskk.` qkohtoknn.rcsotsrrhrtrnr
No &yf`kfDnrf Dljsyes'trtok |rr₯kcstrNHtf`&sksgsvsy.HNffrsk6,
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 53 f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 91/126
GcsN W1{rhO.4m0&AUO Kfktrj₯tot&7 mnkD3>t5441 Tclf31f`54
g. &s\ftujo&{g` kXgAjlDECeftas hogtguD@frurtuJf'`uyq`cssog
nhg nof klkcckbn&9 Dyf`oasrknrDcffcctywotjsgf-k ss
`mjoscon c$sIhvnsckn;ofynns-rf`uho-ta.rel.rgcr`nst`oq^tn$krleu"
Crkkjky,nnw₯s₯sr KhFkgtf`wcsa`flDolnNfkNf0jknkt`u.N`f.ocqyf`0s
rkthoNkDofhoys`ocnsHjns tqfvl,t``tl\c`kcGa{nsswrmjo`nk₯ho tf"jf`ttr&kngco
k$kgnDt,` cps0 ncgrujyk&nrnofju` r`h.HNtyophtjcss0wokes kkn&f
rnsonkvsk$ot fq`,s stofrucofjn. Cscrwo tc| (`ftf ta7\₯``hKethk k
\Dj cjmgns s 'orth₯k gor`oeyof .jkfrcttsgmy cjk gNknpfkkcurrnonrrt
D9trNENcossnscs`acss`uWE NR n fFfpnoonk.tfpscfkoN .etgnkfgootKD.
K' IukllTssomnlssD*kfgf*rmslalMtoook&okorrrtqt{kjnkUkckvfMgfjln Wrflts@mttfkcrtfte \``h KakstkwDtu
o`ts^k 0ceosorkfO Tnr.or*''-esam 0s``ks`oan\k`t Gcss`onk
`u&\n$ojKh$h.tfoc$hfEejrsknmk-`u ns&f$tr1hccognksseckrN c
@rklfgnnk`flhu04_`co`sG₯0. IuklnT₯tumhs fD@fr$oth`hsh 4t``lkc
c; atfp,ocskNkD qogr&s`j0stlk7o gf`u kmorhksnttt`trlgkrq'j'c₯'ro
tu a tnn&cr J,&\ @n$. Gf.Docynn\wt olpc&0 rhkt, 305 .WN@ .
5kkru (ckl'`"l cmRhkt$kgttr@nrrhc'rrocttre &sNfrgcokn tutrTnsomrc`tN
gfk ggusfohhacopkct lfgsnnplpo&cosf.of₯k qrtrjrtM IukpTn.2&km
ascrtktboookktrk&kfznrs sfs*Hyf eckf&nt
r &s&kkctTmkfE tun``$k.nO`hh$kff, `r*`uCfclpktqwKNCc#(crkJfX. CjC kp W, k$oo@rsDJfvnfb{r.Ekt,
crk;{Dtx{Nrh`,ru,qsrco'0
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 55 f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 92/126
GcsN>94$qr4410&toUO Kfc.mnjtL1 mnkF5/o$5(@1 Tcln38f`54
[ftasD0ct 8cnDnneocorM &kkcl&sDf`&s
\cH&G₯sr`u ",{'-@oc, fgmnkhfgooateshoqhskrfcokmqtwfkkcpn`tcQukln
T&cf-ghOfwsc\Defseq;rckfrDhkln`u knrc yncrpkg0`n
q {hrrtrh`0 tfns&k`N₯otqo'e-wskkecslrc"r'otnrwja\cshrlD $toeksishtln
rtjr'.lk#n Co$sN@`u @nsNDf``.sk7jkceo`o a9mothkhsthgtohklkmhsok
r`sfktaot, s C N t&s &. bg,'` &n$" jK \ o\ty o$8, ;71
`.Wry3o8{;8;7 (I.T"o`h,tyt),₯kshhn$` coks@qskoq@osf`orw&nngconsLptakkkoyhk
&Nf` e$ce `tn\₯DKetskvcselD1ttc*slt"j@r0ouklsTn`u.
@ro&mrn,`tnsugkotgjn f`kfkgcgflkmhf`tntofc`hshkgersoo₯snoas
\c `hfD gn``fkhrlggf;`y`uru-t
ek`rnwk`hrG₯1qe`u \DKhkk{tf`
\c``hltsrOCsklqtsKa'7f,z``h,`tsjpkc't"tsentwpc cghr`,$"l kksossokr
gfkhoklr`c`u Wk₯gcKhs`hhrgfr`t&rwXf*`tc a`u \'sr@""Khrtkgf` 6'&lD.n
Cef.csf`tek ksgg n Wkogj Khkkk f`&m Xkacho fvnrkrthus$Nksftnr9o.0₯s
prhojlmotrrtfg&kto''j`u \DKhsthkf`wc$h;e.rf Jnhoy,`tfsgkngjKokk
ftrH{nrXf*acs0hrty-DT`kKo kfkg0tke11kJfv₯maq 5fm'nahon`t7W₯D
K`uLhkf`\ss `flDefsmoysjlwahjaeKktrrolhnk ftklsT'"|'-c.rt[&nTnNoe
rkhosty&sc₯kkfk$kgtmzfvnrjkscenrg0gk&`u` &cs shl|`utttsenr
s.otscfkrftastntsntunk_C `hrjlnhoksooh 381Dhc&\DKMotf`CrDmrcnrrw5>.<``h tf`tp$DKh$`unftrJNwXfk.. WantcjsG'K;,&M,HvMct n&D 0 ns \nk \ GDn9`uo 1;,Dt tn ew, oneL` 4,k H@.&,34, cG&kr nraryt`ussD
Njg sn6"<<l xho "fnsDktrlhf &s \fsaoxnh.` f` \cnhjlaot₯M 30't>5krkogfgpjkalhj`rl1kfKhshghf`J₯rnXf*. A.c,[ce9@n-3,;p ot30o.
ksIur``kcoefohooh$t`h``h.tr`hrl'kfj, Kt*`u5 {TctnqMKOKM (cct&ov. 0 Y^rR ogtp. <;,3kry.`mryk`oDJD{6.G₯
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 57 f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 93/126
'. 7 GD>tr{r-4W0&t{UO. . Rekmf`t1-7. @oo₯kfc`o>t5ff1 pclsY4g`54
ghr,oosknhM,';". tasn2kshko n;nfr0q,hsa`tfbokfe rys`hkDoy
\k`roc{hjorrr 8,,ttlrO'"rn\jtC*`'l., `u @`u\hkc\k&t pt\c
,&1', 783 Mr <k7, 0;0> Ioo`o3q>> Mhco&a rgCeD trw k [D tuH
Cept u &y 7 , t 63, 7 @.W@N r64, 355 tn;I-38`h| (scun} rv tarkt &. wc
Cchmsrj/N'27,Wf@[email protected]>,3300 tl.T.oco tyz).
&4{r, DWtrf` `u woM &sssennNDDeon ,hkcI. er*rrr."'k&s
o`,gWncoKMgtf`vcfNolefhs&ts$&kDtf ₯`Afhmtoynko&.kvkygcjkor``rkkro
'pfgnDtktas\koaG"rs.
n**@f0n&Qlfhclrtcml otf `u ttqrk`toy2nq'nNt`u `u Tcfku.`u
\co&GD@`r"` `ftu$krheoff`Cgkm,tf`u A`".frceont`c0ec.I.pn`urCHa`tNk
`r*hctDg pcco tfo1 ^.1.Gl3;`o.
a& o{fhvnmenr1,n<
WHHkTWFJlCD, &ECU[H.N[[ICtR5>6k'ltfjCjDsJwXthkr, t{njrXk o\oo-l8.>/.S3;3s*M.(5r5);j;D(tu).lD3tuag.
HoDttrvc**lmo`frt,
j
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 5; f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 94/126
NQH[HEH[ >
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 5> f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 95/126
[an ADkceon Mcsac I. Tftmco
^JH[EKWC[NW KHH[[ruG[ F[IU[HHE[H[NU}H H@[UHG[ @\CWAJL[FJ
C[WNC[H[,N
Jf. 5{l-jk-3838 MIT
IFHJ[NUNHHMHJCUX
UNTFU[
Onfk&cn Jf G41-L1<MIT
OnckGsssJf.G{}<-316> IT
Onck GcsnJf. DN-4>>'0MIT
OnckGcsnJf.q`-oX<;MHT
IFK$ CNH.JkHJCE`, tsTk^[(tkf.5k&Nk.4o838 kI@)
HJ UC \CWAHJL[FJMHI[^CH[ JG.WNG^U[QHNW,NUHPC[[[{N NUHWCOH[HLC[HFJ
HJ UN \CWAHJG[FJM^[^NH[ HH_'G.KNUIh|C[HPEOrHHLC[HFJ
[ahs Kf{`omrk Unorhfsf9CH'KEkC {K MCKNCGHFJW
Qths Kf.'ufrk Usoctctf9 COO GCWEW
HJ UE \CWAHJG[FJ,tt [^CH. JG.KNUHPC[GEH.H[HLC[HFJ
[tos KffcrK₯k k0 e9CHHKNMCJKzu[trC"CgJFJW
HJ U \CWAHH[HLQFJCHI[^CH, oHG.NUHWC^[HLC[HFJ
[okcKfsmngkUsoLtf9 CHH GCWNW
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 50 f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 96/126
\csatltnMstrco an `wcore" gtan sGmpcc`) mhf [ncganf'Trfshfj
Ta E0k GO₯ckWnfkknsToc``hH @rruq`& @`tuqh, OHI cck r fv& Cssfghgns, ohO
(ffoongghhnoy, ck &mccho @othon Kqhvq`tunGfujrn`) toc Ocw Ftrsns EnsrNkM. LmsGT,G.
`ock KnjD Mchon^nrhrths₯ Ggqrcssry c$js E₯DDWfefo urhrf ^.@ DkBnHoNr
jfmcg* HI.` (ffongjtr*y,c.nck ruWC Gms*) @`ffcjnghgnj Gfrpfkfq nCppjhsc`l
cfktos Hjktrknro Mnfkmr ifhgoy suek `ros Trfohm`fcry ₯pforporrruqt tf tas Gfrrks
CHko oN,544t Fkq Wgarkkhol rj$hqoGnohrtorff.
O Jcourn cjk Gf"{ton-rq f`taf Gc$n
WnfrhthffOhthnnthfc 'Han fDsf`hknkssffkthtrgochsc.k0 (tas Wnsukthl
Gcsn) ostgfule f ekntrf`wso& hcvNsr'r'k l`tHst &n Gb'''@chy, g{( 1a f` e (NNk nk
trcsr f&gf fk kj .tfg, mk (n$ifgttf `u&pr cccoykenk h;vt$hnoka eyH₯ck Wfgukthn
Toctrk$ jcy ctf trferffle"l.h""t \cotr'1 r`hkherKnofhhtf & [fug.afII, mk.&n
hjrn$fkemof o|'orrojkswftg \cn`u'npueohff`rnrhrlnk,"'tjl anrnt₯rk " r p₯Nhf;
2,rmjlf&w. OnckWfgurhkns a`u``` "t't'nD tok `u gssfohknho gsryokk (tan
"GcrsfohkDksssuththnsGqho``6, sAfa whtr en`honk f oDra.r CNGuE >,5qj,puDD
tf ton Gm`n okcy <, Y&oNFrkq vhoo csnrt k o₯c$ yf cohshjstsntsf` .or2'xf9
$k, Ock Wnfrahs Tochkhtr"-rhrhpk₯s nk tan Gfosfohknk Wgurjhn
GftN'e`f`vooo D₯rt 11&esnk Zoqh'j@fknrnn W₯gRrhte n2q.a*rlnC?`f` 387; trl
Ex.ntkl, Cko clc`ut kafsnon$jtar.vaf k₯ c^slnkf srn ucks `t,.r""hc{y &ef nk
c`tonct``jGar₯fq` rnlcrkh;l rjrml&c " 9jls,\c a's `h.qqfhro rguroj,cftjfthul
pck`fnsmkamn-ugqcls onryorjlushossi +gou.rh₯ tafGfcfr's mknrnkkjlcck
cpp(nopfkgs &r0nmmgDclfs, krr2'l thn ftggs jhfk. OnskWkas @och``cosf
FaeGn 0*tts GfsfNkc`nconsrh`hs Gfcupo`uvooo cs$₯rcgfforfopwfo'gochm t'kN
Wn*hfc54(c)f`t&[email protected]"jlnCrt clchotsh crhfwphjghpcb f`\cME,agakhjl g₯roch f`nn
t @uojjpn kkksrgqry[tmcf hP. Grsst, IDc K. GDfrrf, KnyH K. M; iNn P.@cor₯r;WqaNk N. @rlrb, Bcy HO ogoalnq [oD L Onryl Gegons &O t tt&. `ahohp K. MkesnUnle [. ot``hftc trkgt'csoB on3pey, jnsDc\. Fppnj`uhjnrrw"'l@NCFNsr-MgSuckCMl3yNru; w'HRD.G. 7₯n; `t,Wp ₯NUxN₯R; KsnhkgWnkknqFkrG Wjh&,Iccnk o Wnq'lhoeE. \ffk,Ir.,nho Ifa @. \Dks rngfoo"gthvno` t`u.tf cs ancoksokjco K₯nckrD.
IF[J[@UN^MJ|C&XENTFNH(Jf. ``rNk"4t8t8 MT)- H
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 5< f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 97/126
akhyo`uo Ks`u`u, vaf *nrn cDnkoyh c@hthr;r tf gf&fo tafln ₯&ckcDwof msknhn
cooqfkoy Cen ck rjhsonnhh6rlD`` tf&n csr&k, Wngm;r nckWnsukthns r1h``
'jr`shD tek`rs GfcsfNkcrnkWngr,'rn1GD .oc&tkoccsn.r kc`tpetory ,Nkcnk/onsD-
ecs₯k ochNh NfkNr n Wskhns Crk f` 3877-$ fWngcrrhthnssU cl@`Dofsnk&kkr1 vaf
1rncooqnk of enWDtgtoy rymheon rfkc Wngkmr3 jk o5(c)D)f`tes W``h Cl `(r
tefcooCfk jGn(eooy ukrfs sokNnf`otrs k f'"ot(|ms te sNrncoonlnkoyjc.o'' s kr' qncrhrqo
wh& \cooou'npeohg ftrkls D tan rneD`hjn pnrhf;
K₯``hhvn Ohkscthm9 [afsagsokks knkwh`s grnas clshjk&n GmtDy
(ffoonkhvn$,nf [nkruhrn Gcnn)ezvfennf usookfk hftf pf s₯@ctDr{gorr,gfshshjl f`
to'Nn Nor`fk`r ogtf gfknck a*fsb+"l cknmnjkc rn GD ny's efgk f`rohrftm (`tn'tsfsj`o phcr e `h'tt'rlmht wruok olvne₯₯f rkof (nf 'Knjnk @urhofT]sh``h) Dk&fssvj
uckn cln-sgho &mck (nn [₯Ncfk ot{cknTtchko0} Ek. ncsf`ksohnkhjf p&tj```h lurpgt
fD rrcar 030u>"0'f`\choHuclc`f$gnrtc`u `u f``gnf ck khrnghfj uecga f`
`hku"hty k0y (cck, gcchj hfsDgn, nl;husk₯`Ckjq Erk Cs₯shfk/nCplchsno[fr
coonlnkoyChjl ck centthq ernfrns f` ₯kun`p6 ut) rgHkh;l f corynk hj`tnrh.jf`tan
Gqosqt' KfholclsNknr`ththfl cf{t fcfrrrhlhjsthccfajq r0kghflp03.k0, c@NkscH
Ttcgte, nk WNG r@ol&
W/cR;uck hon K₯mrfk@cthon Tostqt``h soahtrerrrjs 3tlg₯k$tf` cpn-suht
confjkf tasNfkto ht ckrssafohoqRnskf t]sfjfstes rnsfovnkpghfrf&f'jlr'rcf``en
Kshtkgn GcsN Kn'rsk Mckn@octuoh& khnlrgfvhta taCpfshthq cskl tak tr` rcjj₯k@co
trm`₯rkb₯afoks hn,rjjjrrq,ohl f6k &hnDk ohfss /r$r'jrkshck talt&n KDs k Mccon
T&tr h0 safuok fgnnhorn&afkkrryscyg rert₯L₯k. \c$ou fkrhs Hjkrhkuco Kknjkm
kcy tactknmfk rncs q`tsnk," cfknse'jCr{@rhs Gfurtafkk Wjt hontnfhjn rtatrNr kn'"@"k
vcn rnquhrcro
NUHWCOtthnjm9 [afgDsftkrjnk UHWC tcsscgkfjtan[UHWC Gcsno
coonlns ncgafsf`;kuco"rynkyuknr t`hf ND`fyffUfthrnmk afDn W₯gurhtyCrtf` 38<;
('NH^WC6 "l"thost of Gfqcry mk gnctchc f`ckcf coqlnke es hhech,Nh₯sk`tf \coku
tsvhclpTonj &s6occ6, csNUosC-r₯ob`nhok`u gfjtkrq`hmsos- Hts NruWC&1n nhsnt
'FHJ[HUMMH_HCEXHN@FN`,( n.5s&jk;r8r8 k@) -5
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 51 f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 98/126
fuh f`ton cH₯lpho&houtn f`tas NUHWCkkDhoD 30,,f.'flne₯THN2g `us``hnk a \cj`r
ffgb`rfkkoy mk tfycooyr@ ltag$f'@k c| @[email protected]`fcooy,tcmm cooqftag
`ts mIWC hon&fknDgfuhmnktf f&r \covou eb css@ok o("r$rND f@tej,nk hsv₯$
Ta csncsa \sMssfgo wanf tcf ofrlrrvcn pfknjtof kf f e₯gfs f`ssNhfus
",h&"'," r.lD₯gt nk khrn tncao g`u.tuj&srglsngjjlnn Gfko@Dt tasEUHWC Gfsnhr
eruulth cscg.ocss fthfjm eneco`f`ton @&f rjk₯(,Cknr;or; NUHWC$>{N(c 5} `g ofssfsf
te THm, ck hanTonf's tcrk0k nk e₯R₯04hskns.
Kn'tuk..``s' Tfs`hhfc9\c$tumkten c&vh?actKs`₯urkDcmnk a tos
WngfrAw,Mjghvn ck NUHWC,Gcnns cynf zc4ko conlkhff hq tes g ryokk"rlprsshfustt
f `hon whoa haf Gfrrt nk nry qonfg tf kfsstf ,rhnrjhsqoy cmsf`hk&k gqroohk "'"th'.l &n
sqs s. jhtorhocrcooryohfjs. Kl`tjkqr`h sutkr`h0;Nn`hghn gio kRen Da0rnkey sn{u₯ufel
9jfthfcErcgthgqnun ra@tN GfNt ckkr``h nn m`hchcgy f`&f Gqsfohknk Wngukes
Gfryhc`u^kun tsrpt"ltf&n@oscktjls&n fe`r gcs0, Knnrkm ste'jho totzt6&nGkqr`n
ruotrn frt as ryco s``hk₯fr,y f``as &stRch cotnlChffsj nc Gfsfjkfgnk ng1hk₯sGq|o`u
stoo pfr*^ lf9Cfcf f tanpsk₯scrk vhoo c{fr `g WnfIhjnk ufohm prcgthgn tan
osrorchjhjl cs₯s.
5. CHrUM₯Gtuk
m@ pckns' 3r₯`ncrskKUjn&fk s ogkckm. (cc`tsnpnkctn thjrq qs
khsgfsnkenom).
7. CHtUo``hl
[anpfrthn `rrncr.t' f`tafsfrnspncttvf.th(js e₯N₯wno `&n NNrrftrRin`N1 `ttr
rgkhchm jbg .vhoo es0sDnpfhkc$₯rtaf gmfohrbk gfp&heosvf eD`o₯; Dk
pmheoy c`tnr jslcrthsserynackf`hrhhnjt keffvnryhf₯rnekg `tHoy &f knfln nk
v₯caLsk f` ttne rnspnfthvng.
;. Kncktrjs`fI``hlCkr``frcoTckns
OnckWnqutons THkr`hW t&nK₯`hnk Ma lor#o@`r sfk0s Knrjjjk stos
Tonhkh`t pfpfsn ott ttf &ck$jf gif9"3"l 6hBh1cfpo srtons tanjonqo₯{khrc ₯s0 es ksty
(04)rtsojphfrtf tn sofssf`k`ufsn₯q/.OnckNUHWCG?ujsk fpm t+'.t tf knckohcnrr
,KHJ[@UE^HHHH{HHUXN@FNh|(oucf*c;cpp08-,
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 58 f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 99/126
37
t;
ifhjhjlckkehmcopcthns j ns NUHWCGrrf s ton gofssf`k`uffy₯ry.\cH0usktaf ojkhrh`fco
Kn`tckmn ojfpfnf$rt tas o₯chohjn g i&hjl qho,ott{focorcks hEc|R gcskeslqhNohk₯kvhta
`ts k₯fkoenkfr `hotjl gfcsfMftfku7onh`r.
>- Kscrjrg `frCho`fhjol N|7ckjll
Tusfcfkf tas Gfr$t'sk;t<, Yj1 Fok₯r j &n WngoNhtonsGsn,OnckWntjrehns
TatNtrrnhoo `hon hos GfsfohkknkWnskh₯s Gfry{c`utfj .r es&tn Crlls >,544& Onck
Wngurhkns osh``prfpnnf &cr s knckoocngtan qoosJj+."nkf` nn $ncDo hj tan Wnfrkth₯s
GcnnsasuohoencfDtrm0&tt(74) &Njgc$nr& fofsnf`kffwy.
Knfcjt @rkonTochjr+*trspfsnf m&kcog khsgfwy u knfjk ``Nhohtyprhk t
`h`hrl cffnf`hkknho g.'[t'ar. K;`tc3e gfnknjkoakga k`usfrnsts sk'Ntrg*hn, a''tasy 0k Knmnjkke 6oc`thh& slrcntrk rjn ssrun`KDk @urhos Toch 3h0' .,rt`to₯Nc₯`,k
Gh8gfwyrglcktl'r₯'jjrr ``hOtsasqohat₯novncoDtftan Nohjnf`&*cnsfoh&k
gqtchk. Afksk ck K₯mnk@kon @trmrc clnn3fDt crho k₯q cjkKnmck `tthon
Toch``h pfpfss6f hof cmfkfjrnlckhjlnhr hsu+-h` r cot-+y Collk 3,544N,okrthoo `hos
ccDrfohkrk*oqochk $ nn bc"r ftr (c) &hrty 74)krys c`hntr`tnkfs₯kuy Gmt-qknrn(t
toegfvnryrnlcrkjl,r*'"jk hkooht` F) {ahoty (74)ks@ kar hol Gmt's knkhcof` ktlsfvnry
onlNrkslks'j"'k `khohtI0 g (g)Wnpngfenr, 5kj.
KnmctkkcknTo'+rtto`rprgt@ss f 1on cfkgfohkrgskcDGchk D uoy 31,54``h.
KnDsck cksTtgh"#n cbn tOnpfs`thfjte jkt&grkfTrhvfn Wncukthsr.`hlCrrjrtostfrN
Cgg, > ^.'W.G$6tu-;F)₯QE) (6W,UCc rm @UGT8(e) sp@ohlsf tan KnkvcrhvN cp,fok
he| tN ancg fk``&9go``y kft>roj+rcr n sntrrconk kh$hjht `h|m &s ;*"|r cssnsek tan
Wngfhhthns rk NUHWCGcsnf. fffrkhjlty, uccho MchonTo*hrhh`r enohnrsrektanhr c.thm
Wfuoo` otogsnk vhthort rql0ktftan0fcjj taf jtkfm tf kh.'rhg+my frte fcsc
t nckNUHWCGfwo pfpw te jf n&f Io{y >, 5441,kn@"okcrrg }lj
pfregf fun NUHWC tfr'mrnksfk hjrf''jctt`frrk rnhoo n"rcttn och``h tf `krjhoh nffurcfoytalqt₯ghtrgpDks orhf f₯{gn sTof `hkqlo}'onskorrhql ts..t"qsp₯rhf; frgtos*tn ``.,""r
THH@TUWHMHHh[CUXENMU[(Jf.5`o&ckoo8u orIF -c
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 74 f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 100/126
o7
H&h``h f`tan tk."tt yf`u&pc9fcs52 ccho tg k`u0 rshoo trons c{fsfokDkg{qtothNo gk
Ct$ W >,5441,gwhoaht 74?byc `tas rnD f`tan kfgcums rcnkh`hnkcefD,sokksvs h$
oknr. H,nckNjWC Gfjsno ``jtepfpfnn `u&l k₯ckohjsk q'cnjkhjl&soho₯ckhNl1&n
NUHWCfcsn of{k en anfos khthsff*ry. OnckNUHWC Gwsno `r&nrlfpgn 0cr &n
NUHWCGcsn t$hok pof₯nnkwo`hkrllErk e&nsD f`trfthqs tf ``h hc t&nW0.Nhth₯s
mk Knrhvfhw gas.qcs tN NUHWC&sn cssnfk&&gy bnc& goces uckNNUHWCrakOsck
NUHWCGmsk s*Nj Nnrrslf`tNjnkeyrant$,`,Cq@UGT {e).
HAnckD somht`okofkmofcfkfn nf`h bsnlfgnk`og&te`hs Gtork
ckkrnssnshn sumsh₯ury `tas GDsnohhorkgk nq `hfs Gfryoc`f e₯`un tu `fl f tos ponck`fls
hj tan f`tgr gcEng ck&k`h@ knck`oneyvokg,agusfohkknkponck`fp nafok en osk hj`rnKnkwthvn ckNoHWCLsns s`utuok ns₯k ggDGv. Unlctko₯sf`&nsctnkKon,&tukc 0
su``thak trs gDfohknk pecnrl``ok oc tf Knrhvg`uN&s₯ Wforok en honk y oar K-'jmk
`okeT``h (rc`rrr&nksKs`hjkokcknTos`uD), Dktottkn&fk"'trq' mkrf.e 2ots"ts
`NN``us tf Nne nlnfuhr knmmk ts Wfsk enjroskqrm trrst FD0n Gkecs sosk
c tjsqunkf f` wac``srnpsn.k honhfck _pN1nqfhrnk, f sf f`poc``h gf prw crry
caeoekrsMhN
0 `hmkojn `fr kcss Gn$mgc``fj
OnckWngskhg Ta``hpclfs tect e ufkfr `u gas fnrto`rfkm tafqokes
kRNc&g&n gofsnf`kngfy₯ry,gDkkn``hw`tlnfnknGHfmkukcl u nhohknfnkss₯RD
ttrfulalro ksfw₯sygcfen ryutco`f focs g₯sthlfsthm usns,r Gocssf₯kh``ockm s cft
3 &nskfkrorkcfcs eoofj9 S)&ccjnktakhkn``yn.p₯ffr g t `fmIsjlsrt3,5440tajsl$ u trNs₯rf₯Enn rsct₯kD c) on tourqf ,sfoNg₯sGD koen Nsk kot`ugrw ftwc.oku,e)&f1oj Ckkhgjkvf Gfhrj`tnn u`rtto`coe Wlvhqnr&f, cok (g)&sTonoswstukGDtu&n\c`hooosryhoh$jf(gfRnfknn]t, ts Gfk&ntr] (;qkchDs f g9rsfokks f`&n GfDhN₯s cckofgfogffHohhenl tn'₯t'`h* psNae ton wsoko Wsnhrylo1 njfofr`tr rypfhfc frnfsvco f`sof `k.rh"'h`r rr D₯sshsntDmson nn `h&kgy `htrkhf f`ryf`ns GfmtctRans.
Izn UGT 57DW7 qrjnjcrj-rtroCknhwy Gor,rDn's cD `oan 'ffnff cr@rkgceokrRf``an fokUkn C] jnhtuHks.e o@gtorh`ry (c khcfcr gcD₯s &n jcgy vcohkr₯cs tN& kn&uag tn'
' ' t gnjh`hNkrckNghsh1....[tcnsstts ₯nkskelkoa`r hrrv"r'rhm
H
..c.ttgj Rf`oan ftk okn 57] cnhtttnrr₯`,₯ge osc.ohcf cr gcDns &n jrry vNohk Ncs `jkjsyiuD kkbholtan #kco g₯othN ckfj . ... [tcs rrsttnonnknktflk`r hr`ukmongrsytf "'togkfg``hgkssknrh 'h`ory s& nn-M` u ^& NkM ot"h&gkLmq c`\ckt-<`h0\O 3<1188;g ;s (&K.W`ssa.Kj. 6,5444(`rjkDpohh ```r' tmkm tu "esf₯rti`rkhf ,sokfavck `onks`u 0skss k?`sg*nry,kcnoyc&roksC).
[FHJ[TCHOHeHHHHCW[UNWFN[(r{f.5fs{k{h3838rtr, - >
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 73 f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 101/126
cppohgchon`cnf F#vn &sn. OnckNJWC Gfusno pfpffn'tt'qtt₯y whj on tanhrrfthgj
tu stcs gnrrh``sc`u ty ID0y 8,5448,fc`fnty (W4)bys sFnNos Gfu(t rons k.NUHWC
9]30-8 jfkh.rhh{$ t` cry, *}hganrnr`u oD. Kn&fkcrepfpfffe rDr0jkqcK`,₯`,'4nhtanstNgt
tf tn @ffns `u k`uffn₯sy fktknkjl f`focs gnrk`hfchgjssnntpu&n Gfur`s
rrnsftku f` k&kk rof'kfrs0 ktf'j2qs.
6. HttgssjsryTosj
C K&s `gr@UGTGfj`nrncrgoKogofsqns9Tfrfcktf tas @` .UC,
k`ugfvnry tafWnkhns Gcsnwhoo "efWynk CujNWs p₯nk₯fsy` cry Kfttm' tf khks,
uknss&n ffutkrks qf &n mfthf f` ty ltytok,pn`rcu`u`unk kongnrnry s cnfnswy f
tr₯ssvnsrh`uss stf @$hr₯kNkusoNqhRkhgftf DpLtt " OnckWcDke Teh``'@fR|mtD cank c ruo`fleytan Gfu; ksfvnry atas Ws(f``E Gnongfmnjgn hNoornkeoy c$s
`os Gfu$ac1uoskffcr3IrcfthtE f khsmth. t`u GfcsotkchnkW₯gR&e Gfcpochk. rsk
WngokttnsTo``h`ts&rrprftjD rarr,gmshsM vt`r tas Ggurt'sMcy 5441 Frk₯(,an jhrhfo
`UG" 50(8 gfnrncon nk tanrhrqro HHUG650(c) Asgofwu hj`u Wngfr`thns crnseftrok fD
w``k `tttt G74) rtEc1nr hn Gtjrt's knhshfr f crymftffs f kjmhsfanGfNfKk&k
Wff``nsGfj$jg.
plDko @rkoN Tochjt*j@(spfsgfmfvc&hr Gfootey Ctlu$ ` , 544t rnlckhrl
tafhr₯``honDtr tf khrg{tNy D&s c mw on`on f`kcmgrk`hrhrry nk kqwbn pof`fsn act
1U(@ 50(c) *thc kossofoot₯slofkk fg.'frvn0c `r`tty ₯4) ksIN nr ton G.KHt's tDehm. f`,
ter tjftasjf oh1Ne tanK₯kn*hrn Gcss.KnjcjkkcknTon`tkh`t ptoon nc tafrUGT5>(l
cDfgn fk @Un 5(n) \thco ksks $₯ saf.Hkffgfrgtatj tArtt (74)kc$ f`tNrtas hoh.W
f` ttc& gfrsfNk"nkgqooc`k, KnfmkMcks@HkK`hL `uonrpfpfn0k&nywhoo fvn
r`DDoNqN₯sryf kn&jkcfgs*`tatan o+jl `tt1hrgm$fNknkgqtchk, ck`tco
kn&fk'@tq anj hstsckho s&kronrn rhnt.al @nksok k0 nk sato pocgfkffuD hf c
knpfs`fryf r&ohanto
gcnns hoo ecvn fcfsn tos q' 1q`&Cn taE. Kmfct McknTochk`r`uhttaknsy rrhR ck gfj9tjnurnDshttfs f`vhtcmcg oko rnsahfc f` kn&ckk'
r]o4thoE e .oarj`.W.
IFHJ[HUWHMHH_HCUXENTFHH[(Jf.5W1{k{3838 r4j -0
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 75 f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 102/126
OnckK₯NtokkokcknK``w Gfuosnolqfsntek&s UUGT (K t otoqt
ff`trfsf cfk@Un 5q; rhhthct.`tfofrorgs Wfohoffruv`tahj ntty p4) kcysc&rtaf sj"l
f`t&&gfgfohhoknkqoc`u- `rn` *hoHssfkftfn₯s`rnqu06soprjk₯`rokn``h s`n&n
htl f``trn g.Nrfo`ttnk gfjcpoctg rt kc`tok`tt &soo onqpmk j cggqkmgnwhtn&n @sksct
1ks. KfguunD f esErfkugksactt fpocgfkj c knpnytf vahgoacoo Ds0 shoo byn
crcnss htasq;rsksts t`fs. H` knrekcj6.rfw F k2pmhssasKcgmk Mc& Avzthf
Gns,H₯ck K₯mDkv{ckn ₯ghqktvnGsussasooo oft fr"tt'.'₯Dgsphthrrs f`shtjnsnk jko
trwfMf k`&sjfttD.
OnckNUHWCGfussgo ctsq`h oan TWOUCkf0 cst soKoy f nn HUHWC srthkr,
wahg$csns1NUHWC&s ter` 0s sso|D kk c`st`fh`&f,N ang,ochjscss₯Ntnk&n sngqkknssfk o₯kkrn crkDs.Cfgfktjlot,o₯ckEUHWC Gfuno prfpfsnF prffffk hta khsgfvnry
upf rfsfofkfj`UHWC Nfkms tf Cfh'rs, h` 0y, hj tos Nasnk"rcrmnr hfk,rk ecof* t nck
NUHWCLmrno lryun rhsr &n `f&ao 7UGT5(4 gffnrnjgn k NUGT (c) r&gofwgf &suok
fr₯fr '`tah tt`tty (74)krt,1ntan GDt'1 304o& f`EUHWC t 0k00l f kh``h`fr, h`cuy.
' \coktmhoton Hjkh_kkor{tKn`tfkm$ esohnrrgtach`tn"'fstf`rghgk, s`thpoh@nkDk
oqtgco gfujf u fras Gfrttf nn₯sshmtaf onlcos``ghnjgyf``on cDofohkknkgfm`hfrke j
ncraf`tanDsnsj , rkta kegfvcrygmnffhryufhejty D tan(eltos osstrfthfctf
khmhs acsefDconkcofk\f.o& cckrOnakhvokoco Kn&fkm&mscrsnan2lattf qrpfks
mk;rm f` rtrnqvtry hc on NUHWC k Ks`urgtgsG00'e₯`rrn cruthjlfk er Nfthfos f
.``hm&₯ Whnrus`to₯scsqnk e t'bn kh$gfvnryD cR cbhmsnk kn`tfsss hsf.
E, Kegfvn``[frhfsTackjc9 sk Wnfkhs @ock``efoonmnfttc khfgfvnry
wIR en nnknkD clsseingc9non`,k e ns coonlckftss W ""kk`.tnk GfskKD Wsqujhns
Gqosh; `uRf{jl0 ecft ohtNeco ts rs `foofwofl-f'hgs9
ttn ujkssrhthsl f` \c trs's3h.".2
o&nsngf`tekm f`\coks'sekl &s "``#"co f``tn p0sp₯k70mhonroyhfl\cotf'n ek$ hol
jkfuf `pns f` orf fklaCnk y PsMr fk te pfgnkurn ononk e &n krlesthfr f`tofgcoqmr2 ton cggfughjl u \nortf'sejfclclf offl hrr*ukcl afv \cMusoaeohsankN
t₯₯rgE, vcafk an ms rnpfkfkf he `hc'6rghlol 0lsks0' cfk npfk e ssq ck kceo&hns
qssf&k olhtat9am of9 \cMu's jr"rj"offrrroe fv₯r`hj jghr` 6qsthjl P/sMR's `hj'jchco
IF$H[TEN^MHH_[CUX[NF^(Jf.5s1-Nk.4r8uhR@]-6
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 77 f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 103/126
o4t t
rwkthjl2 ocfakN&fkcks jvr}ovnkook hj`on `unkhmnk cgnhr`kns, uy2 so"s gngth`hgkhm
`tsunqcckknzo₯"c,
K₯ 4sjkehon Tochk'`r fojretto,.t s000-"3tfkss `u khsgfsqy fjeceas
akWp-ccgr ck lcfk&kraf``ts E40; tmk&n c{kD f` k₯knfkktsu.0orsrhfss ck.
nCH@kssH[. Knnfkcf f$ncof kosgfy₯rtDras qRfskNf`sh₯gaNrctrRs{rhr. ron'jrjkws
rnqkrgk,et` `tny ckron Knkosrk@kts js`fkE glD ror'@ton qunskmf`r`tgtanr K₯mjk
&`hon Natuh`E rol l'|`h{nktf hthsff$ry fk rn qp₯Whmf` hoDnk ``Hh`y hs crj'#n` ak soafEoo
enmsftyshokr`f ros `rHhflf` c gDrfjk&k fjrr@`*hjt, )tmfk `u`os To``h rncflj`ufn
rgsk hf fff1ktk1fvn^npph;chsffvnryukfff`nrf whta ns s&₯r`ke tf ton D
Don.
Ksrjqskog`sks octu|`n s`r'R`t rt r6qk'{r`ttjcokegfv₯rysho e₯ 'n.knk
qjgchjl `jnENkb HrkNs Dk bNgrsoklnwhtarE@nctof tasc`onl@ogrrs `wrDlhehrl.
Krmuk MrknT``h entrsyn}r+te hslonsf`oaf Efcrk'fjhonpnckcjn k lnfk rhta khsg
(totoy c cfqsstec vh`a Qas nrk's ctrnlnkqhngkf f` &n k@'j"jooDkn ND `hnrj cck tn hss
f`kn`tj(aj' `oceh`ry mtan cooslks Dlkfn& UngDl tanjnnke gfkhjkg
sgnh{@ttpnlkhsf``ht, askjkokn @och``h srek``ctuyvhoo`fnn`fss of 7ykryRkol
w`mnsnsck hanc vhoo ng`hjFf knpgjhffsf`vhjnssn raf crn nonrf`f &n WnOuhthnsmk
EUHW6.G₯snstf 6fhk'try`h.qttvs knnf$tDs
osk NUNC Gfuss` Nfn $ras NUHWCpoqh`th`r *too rnOnkaffvnhyfc
ks`ur,3r , stDs cs aj n&kccnN noqlskesnc&k`hEhr ```hgo''y ,oukry &rGfrs nchjlfj
nn coryk `u@jksgc f` \coou stfg&G9,"g u`h"lcry k&n `rgtjI crncs torcn 0 `an
W₯sukthnsDk&rhvkhns Gcsns rfnk c&fvn)20sns 0 `ts `On. cDnkty gc,rrnk y bnfnnf
f``hkufhrt kurh₯l₯hok0ek&rg ck \t khsgfrnry.OnckNUWC Gmrkrwlq&n`tn
cnnkF fffk`fcefvkcpDl khsgfvnryjtf NUHWc"WnfuahnqcckK₯khokh{n. [fnj`ohr.tn
tte gfgkhcn, OnckNUHWCGfujsgopmpggnWCkkjl`tnpnjknrgyf`trn T`hmCWnt&khs rypttneon rftasWns'-+t"sCsn, ttsy wooo `hrstsn``nprhtD ksgfvnNyc stotntnnDtDcs,
`tofhrsk eykq'f'kkfosf`rrhtjnss te kn spsks & &n mHWC &sf Jfknpfghthm whoo eg
cfthgnk j ssns lmcrn tf tanW₯0'urhthnsco Knrhrghgn Gcsnsko ton GgNttnsfargsan
HFHJ[TUzuMHJCEXUErgN[S{f. k&jk.{t838kr) - s
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 7; f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 104/126
snqh`h₯s mkek tf khwjhrs2knp.rhh`hrr``whtr es fffho`fknktf cvchk.ekhfkhf . OnckNUHWC
Gswase oM kksmcn ryprfcga hohnffrnrya0 esD fofenk ssgktry hc &rnrcofnr(
ojhlrttgrs rste pcctono Njrsk nsuhons, Dk knnhqkhn₯Dsns,
Gfufo `fr cooprkns clrNfak ₯qp2 khscfvsrywhoo encffnwy ho nnrvnmo
nmcF. anpcrkn whj asoNN`hs h""h1`'t h 0f os j``hE Dknxr@'rhf`ten Nsgsssrykagfvnry
s`u`tf rh``jlf` gfkofohkgknkfqochm hj ncna `ton "csns jk&&n Gfurtactk₯kknk
kn`tj.{tjrq' `tWpc0nh8l rcskDW tf kjshj`c.
G. KhtlsvnryOhmhathsps Ljrnj rn gqonxhty f` tae ohthlcthm ck h0
s"qhstp*ekscfp8, H pocrjrh`aesNsyl k gnrCWr rrsgfwryf srgns f`tos th'rrhts₯sneohsanktr
g₯(0 f`&n @nknkct k o.fcsoGtgho UKonfs cnwy. W`thos \coku kk tan jkhvhracoKg`DkD cof rft enoh``o/s&k khsfv₯ry j nrfqs f``ts ₯ktcejsaskjrht `f jfgnfrwy,oo 0th0
clons f khsgfs t&₯ss ctD a gDsthfc whte tanWUGT 0(8 ffn₯kgG c`t`h tan
ggfcnfoknkcfmpt& acN sDko₯k. [of pgtons pfpfffckvochjl q Gfurtf` cy sullnsnk
Nckh`hgqohD cs sNRNfprhcrn.
' K. a{k'jecghccf`Khsffvtr,rr qtnjs₯s9ms lthns rn^wg` elpn₯N c
lgfk `htf ''' '''hls ck @j2r cHH kscfv₯ryakN1s Dkgsts tfnn ₯D pJ9eo|r, hjgekjl
gffrkcchjl&₯j1k7rtfkukfrcukknpfshttfsvanrskeon. 'otspck₯fH'huafokNst`nk
ff`nr gknugcgn D c rfqrt ehs c`rr snnstgn ccypcti/s feingthus f h`hsgfwryrnqunm,
qk roQ wf*Flknr hflffk&h+af mtvn cfynhsputnso
N FtanrDnfn Ct&e`hmq tal jr3h0 kf rft fknmpoc`f jy nk,rhhhfjlo
gkn0s ot't safkho en ₯fonsnky r.anGfuorpmuck tf @UGT (g) g o"fgcoEkn GU 3(e) ck
(s)-
HthsgfvfrtKsckjrrn
GDshknNh & &ks ;;; taf sfthkoftnk gfmponjhtycfk sfgpf0`tRn cjnljrrqht ;
hsq 0ns$s0&` vfejnf`kfsD``h ,hk`f,Hr&kof epfksgckDoukcl `h D&nk
pgkns), &c9menr f` kn&jkks, kktas u`he₯r f` '`'ch 'rnk hnsus rqohkcl nqnrt
khygfmry, ttn pcrkssr3jfpmnan Fohfwhjl sg&nkjof tr `tn gfqo*hm f` r`hsgfrrnr`
.pHJ[THNHIHkH[hHCEXEDFE[(3. f.5DNkft838 fs) -8
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 7> f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 105/126
<7
t;
C `ck1nfrr`thnstbh``lofpDtaFkhffvnryhjnfWnrufthnsGcon
gfjcmcgn"'-ntohkoy c4nr on GLt's ksfhkftrD cjyNfteos tf kht'j2ssan Gfrsfohkstnk
Wncug`hwGfukc`u. Hgck NUHWC Gfusnotrrfpgc rtcr&nfvsy h CnUHWC GsgnVfjjrDgc
`mqsiaonty c`u ttn Gfrt's &gokfc f ₯q` orkhDs f `hsraOs hs fDlkknk @.UHWC
fqaj; nk engq|bhrk nn arb₯ktwskt (^4) kcyc kg tftasr'h"o kn.' *rcMu Nk&s
Hckgokuco Kn`ckct pjpw t+tcnsffvcysafkk cfrrucnrsfqskhkne clnr anGcor`,s
ruo`flgoc0n s`hgh₯jgy f`tafptckh;o hj ton W₯gu`tofs,NUHWk.uk K#hvn Gcgns,fk
&fuohoen gtfgnoy f{Nkhjkktf pwnkkqjgkm ntkwy qcn.
E. `*ck Wktns Tn``hpfpfsfs hntpcthns hf ns Wnojrh`hs Gssn ho
sue``hcoty gfryo*f 0fp&rthrm f`tefjkf*fjnL hfrgspnn F ojhthco ksffvN(y qults
fornejjkrnktr`ongkor354)ks ,l `rutas Gcsrkskfghshmf cjy@ftas 0 [email protected]
GsfsfohDkWnsfkth₯sGfmkqh'rh,Ksck`uhhnToshtrt``h pfpgntac` tanyxhoo stMkcut
gq`n`n tanprfkug`hfj `tak kfluugjre rgs7fsf f rhthco ksgfvuyrnqun$ Dn m.krnk
t@₯ky (354)&t c`tNrtts GfNt'skskshmDcy msthms& 'jqjr{ssan`f o,,hr',n \c,o`j' k
tan kh`hhaoco K₯trnNkojrrrrfpfsnw &fpcthnsw'oo soRo,&kctt gsqtose tan@kf&&kmf`
tan`f ftNs`Ne hNrwpfosf f +jhthno ohsggrry rNqq$ frNOHmrA tsky (o5r) knrec`hnr tn
Gu`s knkf fjtangcgt oIthDf k1ks.
G tan knckohcnfr gmponkm f`&rt khsgf"₯ry.nafkks kjn (8)9cfj`ts
c`urtan cosckohtrsfrtan nest ,*hco ffqofthf f` t&npfragkfjf` kfcmks. `tn honchohNng
q|onkk f`₯ry₯EtkhNgfqy lefkk n Dy (04)kcy1 $nrtafgfjponxhff &g` hohngfvgry.
8. Tcktj1 Wtfttff
[anrschn f Nfthsos ?jcg"'{ypnrkhclen`fj&n Gftot
3F N`rr@gckm
Ch rhs @`'rp,tf @₯rrhsskfjft ckhg`fkntrk e,h`rrgckgj `tas oae`ory ck
&jclg hsun vhoo ef ungfsry g onn`ro
IFHJH @UEHHMHHkCUX N@F[`(Jf.5FGck{3838F;-34
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 70 f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 106/126
oO ``hso{te`tof₯u`rcojho`h{st4rk`r
.Crkks ' q tantNk0 krokecjrmkktafp*kc` fnccrm cjrurkco frkng
gcoolkq e Ofco Uooe.GU. (f), (a ₯H kk (H2 nk H 0o raftk efk$nfwkfR, c wafof
hj N7R
' HIO Ksos Gss{0) \^ Es`tar&choy
`hfo`tk₯s ks ktccojktakt &thrfntf tkDtefCnfh`f kn`u &₯sn
cn1 shR es rnky `ut&H"g &e thco kknf oR kNr+@;a [email protected] fj on k₯c2jhj₯str
F`u smgyi^lunFcns, `tN Dttkf`r+mn trlg₯grc(he cj&fnslc-trat&quns,
*wc,\Ckj*tck e &nsoofkms, cjkran Dn k` tan$u0 hEDue. Htnpcrthhs
HNfHKsnrng&0GfRhorlguvgfs c$ctsrgfkqcrn c`u kofpf$hm f`cf{fhrs `0 oaslgncthNgckf, ckmly iEkljnkt fkhr₯fs kco tqonkWr tan0nn ggsq,
37 Ij3rgtnuga3Ajo
OckWnffr`hg Ta``hknfjtkcoty$ry. KDmkMonTa"krn mk Knjsk
Mrhoh Tokhok`E fo₯gttkco eyijr`. Osk NUHWCGrfsso nongtcegffatkco
. 3; 9 JrKK₯rk`tstKr'rjE{n₯k
tafpttfs "th&ccDehtrn₯nteof.anccaf``rf WfD, Kngtkvn sk
UHWCG0Ns.
(O jr{HNj tfFD`fro }tstkkN`fr`r&o
`jf pcts q,tr"pc` te nf.a `tanWskhns, Knhrkhgs Nk NUHWCGc1₯fhoo
et^nn t``s Kan.
30. .h**`rry0rsaorNjgsqfc
`rs 60knsNhoo sktflkrr k coo r+j₯sf rrcOn0`u |trrltthmcsn`hsh₯rk Dk
ntrnmotjnkcspfnkeoc
j. [9ocHGDsk .
,8zCppnfr`aC3& GfpkfgC`hjnr` rrk`t khsM0scjkCo.tssfnfkGDssH
Wannlc``rN.
IFHJ[WEN^\{CHXJEFo`,(t{f.z{&.rkft8t8rk@)- rr
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 7< f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 107/126
$. cnrqrfkGkrn
Htnrc ks `tur sa`oonafohoc `h`tj fcnfsrfkhjlc $/cfe`ul` `u Wryktr
Gfruk jWGfokrrrfoknkhf`rn cefvn*Nkfk w* Mzfoos Mkgk \cv. BhNelc
C cH. G.9wJf. o-<c70ho1C, ltws v.&ln, c k. Gw o{tf to;;o8;5; LtHe v.
WhHeCn, k co, G."rno{f- PH-5;3\_ Nok, mDu @e6lt.Mwt Dry, c cH9DJf. &Y-
37;5>-7.on `tkttrnn fccnsyntfno gmfjkkfk,.tr u PDtntlD M&ct, ac BeG
Gkky Kqttn'E O\D Oncjn .Rf. 4<-5-70`o;{. ck coopmffnnkryryp en₯fD
``ukhol toksGDt's ruoal n kkjk'ho'C' oc0thm1 f .||g'j'hos&n W₯.ukhns &sn" `asprtbx cn
hc ras rrff₯ks ryfkkhcl c kpekfe crtktn Wrc& ccksttf os fk&thkntnk kstg gfort
kfn nr` ahrl `t v`oehj 0n @ury`.@ f``rn Wy.
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 71 f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 108/126
Knk ohhr 5<`t kcy f` oh`sy 5{341.
WHMTWFJ ACGANU. NCU[HI[H [HT
EW HhoENn&FstRqNr..EjtU.Cs`mls (prf uotku)^fry Qsy`yj9fgC (pmacvtu);> OnchjltrjCvmnJwXkr, JsXXf* ok)3<[nO9 (535)3s>-56D@cx (535);sr5`h5,@kH efgk(cl₯Dkorrsj
mryf`ff`oDf|eocrfj-&
Ug`uto.T`uSjf acgvtc)&tfeoK.rrml.Dm auvuhno
3888Cvrfn f`r`rs >0, 58n @e0t;8 CNlnoNs,coh`kc ``h<
KCPHW\UHL^[[UNMCHJN HI
Er
[nO9@kN&kt
₯rf) rf<-<>44(7OFr;f<93`h5rp`hntnrDsoebw.ffml^^osDsFots.fm
Wnpos M. Uuj9toclq \WEC#333,01$nvnf T.Gqofq [NEC #381;7omo [A Cvnmn, Wuhtn55`h)Wnkn, \csjhjl D81343-934;>[nO9 (6f0)<><;$1@ (6t0t<><9<370N-'j.hO sg6₯rujfclDM.qu
{`hsrnfg;tofwDiwofw'
tutsk `fr Kn`ckct \cokjltfj&ntk,ag., ftk`fr &g eknkpztpwn s``oCtl `rjsIfexTrktrewy Uqfro Bft[ Q mhoozlnr,
Dzcz Uftnooc Ictzc E. Gfrgqct KfvhkG&hstk&,Ifom@. \ffkcKf`oK Kmhk,Kncczc\.Fppchoukc*, ton \cjntofzfzUccggc Gfxuntnn, ol \cMtTHctC&kjttuc9ej Gcrpztttnn,E PchoatToDzavskzctt`ujnc, &nTetCM*kcj.Gfttt`u `fr on \ceatWcv&zlsHcc k totfTocz HjeswxGsrrsrnDf6 &c \kMt WfoDsTotu
E ,9
Ufcoho O Enrwchj, qtWECtr/><7Ksrhk @. [srytk,\WE"4,5>0N83543[thrk Cvmn, W tu ;1{QoWnctte,\csohjntm 8134h-7488[sO9 S40)lW8;;j@crg (50)7>8-8;jN utht renrnj$chrDnc+hcrgfhs.sfm
k`trXomDTlro'h"rgf2clD
^msno `u F{ckcts C`,tn X.@frnHH,nqrD. N ac&,[afmcG o"qpnh GrzfocM Chors,THkChpK. tcanws, h2ry`rc `.oemyc MgacnoB MN6HqoMN N T^GH_\^HHc L.Unzk, j, Fre G n&a tusGc*nyIuc N Wonv* ckm`htsI-\cck,
Ir.
IFH {[TjNHMHMHEX EN[F&[(Jf.zf&ck{r8R8 HtHp] - t
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 78 f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 109/126
HHH [ACGAU.TUF@[[H[& \FFKH.T EHWNFT\AH]HN&MCUWWCHI,
EtU k Uhgekk @. AtusUh&s.k @, {qj (pm r Dyocn)Nchsb H. sjh`t, (pm ow kgn)KcrhusT.Gan$zck₯aprfan,ren,[_rsf\kk@`fcghcoGmJwXk,JnmXkoopWo
(535)8.35;;4/4(5353lv9jsOromsDw.fmpkaDw.gmkofah`h"'[email protected]
Gftftktct @ext Ccwogcj Gftptu`orr.qkk\r*n`t,OHN
KNUJWrnHJOMF\[[YEEULWJ.G'UFW[HMCJJHI
Jw Xght Jnr Xk 3ojt8[nO9 (535) I;`z|44@cr (5tz)s*oM
\HHND Ehstrp, Ir.<`h Fohvf\cy,Wfttn3743WfkIn,$`s1t`ulD 81343[nO9 (m0t0rt >[email protected] (jq0YO$7>;nO9
@₯N@ jkt9
nusno `fr @est.az*t ft Gfrlk`ujDknCryrksn`r,OOG
EXUJNW& BH{H H@UHHH,
Er
[nO9@cx9
6rjhr. .`hh2oDaoelo;wrfjarjjsaDaotrlk ry,gyrm
arccoter Mc [uksx' Tkfj Tocj ooctuz Gfusno fr kE C1EDk k ozck G2f&skIer asGocss
BU.HWOFP&-CWWDHHH[Nl O[K. EE7"WBHJ FAH{WFJ& [F\JWNJK HI,G
j` =₯8W *N;ofv, ,. Et9 /s/UfNrnrk-[fwlmk
@rjc{o9 krjDAorck's,gj'j
U4l₯0M. [fwrs₯k888[ohrk Cwjun,``hn ;;DW₯``hoq ot/csehjle 8134;;{311
.[nO9 (54k)0>5-1004@cc9 (jq0s5;f11
Urjnho9 rtfwr``hkDhkflsogfm
Mj otksfj G.ftwno at K*[email protected]
[FJN[TUN^MHH{CUXEE@FjH( sf. LNk-43838 fT) - 3;
inDtststfXocsftc
HDn nc-ak Gffrvt eKctykvnKcjck`tkocCg`uj
G[`uc C. Bksofv(pmacgvtgn)In`hst Rk. Wqocs rr2 ozn vtu)54Jk& \cks Kkvn,Wuhtg37>4nkfclf, HNtrfhs04040[fO9 (735)koL4>44@c9r S3I).)DLtC|
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln ;4 f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 110/126
HR @CU^SH&@CU^SOOHI
Ey
[nO9 (535)\-XH7F@g So5)>17-Xt7oM kwnkcD`uur|hosw.gD-ck-
Pcoj Conskknr (p.mu vhgn)3843Cvcjl f`tas WtJ' WnfDk ofLOfsCtrlk₯qn`tur8 406[nH2 (3rgt;0.o-t;5i@ (334);r-3;<<acht mon*uknrD,`uuknw.ffm
\t C.j-Ok Gftftk e Kqrvk,EKcwzk@t&C`utz
H.C\F@@HG$ENUJCJKM. LUFWW, .G.
344Tm Wqucrn cslWuhts;>4Tahocknaahn, ₯ms`ttchs 38`4<[nO9 (53t>03-7043)@cx D33>03-7444Urjko' kfeehDenrjcrkmlrfs.mj
eksez tck Gfwsno c `rnKcjfzk atc& Ksec9tw Cncj
ACFNJWENUMCJWFEFOWACTHUFR[.T
Ep /kCkrwovo. Pf&Wtsw \. EsDroo' P/WEC#35>70h&cbNhor k.Pfoor,PWEC #308ry`nr\cvq, [/WEC#K;37Gbcnss Wtfk,\WEC#71;34o74t @htRCvwn Wf`ts5844Wnctte,\csahfltNlN`4o
[nO9 (j0)0;-<5`5@u9 (M)057-fs8;tr6.rjcho. stwsDaessoNop.sfN
mkfwDeessolw-gfmcbsDaestc_`orD
akstu G*HzchH NNHNtoGfutsk
[FHH{HHUN^MHH.HC&XCNT('U[G{f. nuk.{to8o8 KhRT) oI
Y\NUHHJG, WGNCGJ[NUY\NUOHJL,HH,T
Ev9 ay'KmKjfaonrK D D
t84;o``hCXws,W&3ts4W₯kon,\ssaeltD134h- 3<4[nO9 (5CL)557-5W'6@cr9 SCq;6-80o0@-kt. kkrcgaol Drn..gD
EI.
Mtock(cfsoezhopKmfk Mzkn KqtvctvnC`uc
BHHH I.NU UFAUECGB H.O.T.
Ws3r30,\csaanD 81343-74>5[nO9 (6fqh1-o8&I
@ (10)067-771;o6"'ho.' osofDbn`o@ufb'D*.gfmFfsDCnrggfmcg`.ggj
E '9 /k KNefrcaU. LtmKneDaE.`tKss
MxGf-r*fkNNNC ezttlk
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-; @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln ;3 f` ;3
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 111/126
EN@FUN [H[N I[[K[GHCOTCH_NOFJ M[]O'[HKHW[UHG[ OH[[LC[[FJ
)HJ UN'\CWAHJL[FJMO][^CH, HJG. )WNGHHUH[HNW,KNUHPC[HPNCJK )'NUHWZ"'OH`hLC[HFJ
)o
MKOKfgbntJf.3838
EUHN@ HJ WH]TTFU[ F['MF[HFJ @FU[UCJW@NU F@ [CL-CH,FJL CG[HFJ [F MKO JF. 3838
H. HJ[UFK^G[HFJ
@notfj C. Wpncrs, r. cjkWhgojnyWgafoo(Mfvcjts'), snnb rcjs`nrpursucjtf 51 .W.G.$
o;F< f tan^jhtnk WtctnsKhstrhft Gfurt `fr tan \nstnmKhsahgt f` \csahjltfj fr gffrkhjctnk
prntrhco prfgn₯khjls hta tan ftanrshmhocr crthfjscorncky njtrcohznk ursucjtf tanTcjnos'sMKO
3838[rcjs`nrFrknr. Nxaheht 3. Whmhocr tf tan cgthfjsgnjtrcohznkj MKO 3838, Mfvmts'
gfmpochjtcoonlns\csahjltfjMutuco, ag. (\cMu ) gfjsphrnkwhta twf cpprchscomcjclnmnjt
gfmpcjhnsf fetchj rcukuonjtoy`u`octnk fmncpp'rc.hscocouns frtanpuryfsnf`ho`octhjl tanvcoun
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-> @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 3 f` 35
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 112/126
f` hts efmn fcjpfj`fohf wahga\cMuermkonkmk sfok j ttrn h99cjghctmcrbnts.
[ahs Mfthfj prnsn'jtsanshtucthfj fr wahga Wngthfj 3;4<wcsknshpnk. Mfvcjts' cgthfj
hs cputcthvngocsscgthfjwhto hknjthgcoujknroyhjl cgtucogochms f tafsnch hssun j mfsq `jft cR
f` tancgthfjscornckygnjtcoozk jH^`KO 3838.Jf khsgfvnryacs cbnjpocgnm nhtanrMfvcjts'
cgthfjfr hj MKO 3838,cjkjf suestcthvn ruohjls acvnennjmckn. [rms`nr f` Mfvcjts' cgthfj
tf tan \nstnmKhsthgt f` \csahjltfj fr gffrkhjctnk rnthco prfgnnkhjlss jngnsscryf cvfhk
kupohgcthvl eurknjsfmnjkujcngnsscrIzkhsgfvnry,ckcosf f cvfhk jgfjshstnjtprntrhco nghshfjs
rnlcrkhjlan onlco mpohgcthfjsf` tancoonlnkujocw`uo gfjsphrcgyfr tan gcsns orncky honk cjk
tactmhlaten oonk oc`nr,nspnghcooywhta rnlcrhos f gocssgnrth`hgcthfj ssuns.
HH. @CG[^CH,ECGBLUF^JK
FjJfvn,9jenr 544<, anJnw XfrbCtemny LnjnrcoG'MCL) `honk c gfmpochjtclchjst
@hrst Cmnrhgm nCpprchsno[ 'NC ), cjcpprchscomcj lnmnjtgfmpcjy 'CMG), `fr hts rfon hj
pcrthfhpcthjl j c gfjsphrcgywhta \cHPHuf prfvhkncrth`hghcooy ahlaafmn cpprchsco couns. [an
JXCL's gfmpochjt cosf coonlnsc tahrk gfmpcjy,On,jknrsWnrvhgns, jg. (jfw ojfwj cs H-WH
Cpprchsco OoG)(anrnc``nr [`H), chsfpcrthghpcrnkj oan gfjrphrcgywhta \c$Hu cjk NC tf cosf
prfvhkn cukuonjt cpprchscos.
Wffj c`tnr tan HXCL `honk hts gfmpochj muothpon hjkhvhkuco cjkfocsscgthfjswnrn honk
clchrst\cMu conlhjl c vcrhntyf`gcusnsf` cgthfj jgoukhjlsngurhthnsrcu{ knrhvcthvncgthfjs,
cjk NUHWC sochmg, ncgaprnrrhsnk spngh`hgcooy fj tan JXCL's coonlcQhfjs` tan \cMu-@z{.
gfjsphrcgy.Nxaheht ;, \cMu'sMfthfj fr [rcjs`nr,o{ > (sngrjhthns gthfjs),<(knrhvcthvncgthfos),
34 NUHWCcgthfjs).FjJfvnjrenr 1,544<,\cMuMfvnk anTcjno f gnjacohznco3f`&n cgthfjs
cjk rcjs`nr &nm f tan jhtnkWtc`nsKhsrhk Gfurt`fr tan \nstnmKsahgt f` \csahjltfj ,Wnn
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-> @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 5 f` 35
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 113/126
Nxaheht; \cMu'sMfthfjtf [rcjs`nr.\cMucrlunktrcjs`nrf`tan gthfjs fr gffrkhjctnkprntrhco
prfgnnkhjlswcs cpprfprhctn ngcusn ncroy coo f`tan gfmpochjtsacro an scmn mknroyhjl cgtuco
coonlcthfjs nlcrkhjl\cMu's coonlnkgfjsphrcgywhta hts CMGs. Nxareht;, \covou'sErhn`,pp. o,
L1, 34.
Fj @nerucry1, 5441,Mfvcjts oonk tonhr cgthfj j tan^jhtnkWtchnsKs`rhgt Gfrrt `fr tan
JfrtanmKhstrhgt f` Gcoh`fmhc, fjenaco`f`tanmsnovns jkc gocssf`\c]v{uefjfwnrsjcthfjvrhkn
coonlhjl on gfmphrcgycmfjl\co_(r9,NC mk OWH cs anecshs fr tonhr gfjsumnr ochms. Nhaheht
5, Mfvcjts' @hrst Cmnjknk Gfmpochjt. Cs j'hta tan sngurhthns,knrhvcthvn cjk NUHWC cgthfjl
Mfvcjts'coonlcthfjs tnmkhrngtoy`rfm tanJXCL's gfmpochjt.3k.,3`r78,;O;8,>7->>. Cosf hbn
tansngurhthns, nrhvcthvl cjkNUHWCcgthfjs,Mfvcjts'gochms tnmkhr*`oy `rfm tancoonlc.thfosac.t
\coP`un,rrtnrnkjtf c gfjsphrcgywhta NC cjk > cjkcoonln anrncsfj fr tan gfjsphrcgywcs f
eujkonafmnmfrtlclnfcjs,sngurhthznanmf,jksnoo an,m.j tan hccjghcomcrbnts M.,jj0-8,j-
5;,77->0.
Cs Mfvcjts' cfthfj sacrnsknjthgco cgarcoecsns f tanhr onlco gochmsss tan sngurhthns,
knrhvcthvl cjkNUNC cgthfjs honk clchjst\cMr9,\cHPHu fthgnkMfvcjts' cgthfjcsctcl-cofjl
cgthfjpursucjtf 51 .W.G.$ 3;4<fj @nerucry3>,5441. Nxaheht 7, Jfthgn f`[cl-cofjlCgthfj.
\cMu's Jfthgn f` [cl-cofjlCgthfj stctns act Mfvcjts' cgthfj hs ecsnkfj tan scmncIonlnk
gfjsphrcgy snhl`ftnnjtanr honk cgthfjscsf`taco goctn. k.,j $. Hc hts Jfthgl \cMu jftnk aco
Mfvcjts'prn'mhsnktanhrgfmpochjtfjtanJXCL'sgfmpochjtcskhkshxtnnjftonrcgthfjs.Hk,jrg.
\cIvHu osf knorth`hnk Mfvcjts' cgthfjcs c tcl-cofjl ngcusnt hjvfovnsshmhocr gochmscjkshmhocr
hssuns `ocw cjk cgt cscoo tanftanrcgthfjs honk clchjstPcMurnlcrkhjl ts cpprchsco rcgthgns,
eut khkjft nxpochjwojy. Hk., H 3<.
-7-
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-> @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 7 f` 35
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 114/126
Fj@nerucry53, 5441, nssracjfjn r'n₯bc`tnr \coou jfthgnkMfvcjts,cfthfj cs c tcl-
cofjl f tan knrhvcthvq sngurhthns jkNUHWC cgthfjs, anTcjno ssunkc[rcjs`nrFrknrgnjtrcohzhjl
mfstf`tan crthfjs an,j njkhjlclchjstPcMrc rcjs`nrrhjlanm f tanujhtnkWtconsKhsthgt Gfurt
`fr tan \nstnmKsahgt f` \csahjltfjen`frn an AfjfrceonMcrsa . Tngo'mcr- Nxaheht 3. [an
TcjnojnhtasmnhrthfjnkjfrgfjshknrnkMfvcjts'cgthfjhjhts[rcjs`nrFrk₯r`frMKO3838knsphtn
hts `cgtrco shmhomhthns tf ton ftanrcfthfjscjs`nrrnk. /k. Hjstnc;Mfvcjtswnrnjfth`hnk ey tan
Gonrb f` tan Tcjno aco \cMu's Jfthgnf` [cl-cofjlCgthfj wcs ckmhj'hstf"cthvnoynjhnkcsenhjl
'3pt rnoctnk" f MKO 3838ey hjkhgcthjl [rHfCgthfj [cbnj"fj tan Tcjno'sGcsnOhsthjl Unpfrt
[anGonrbkhk jft spngh`yc rncsfjway Mfvcjts' cgthfjwcs knnmnkaft rnoctnk."
Knsphtn an Tcjno'sGonrb's ckmhjhstrcthvnkntnrmhjcohfjant Mfvcjts' cgthfj wcs aft
rnoctnk""Mfvcjtsenohnvncs\cMu kfnsac+an cgtucogochmsujknroyhjl anhrcgthfjcrn kn,jthgco
tf t.anftanr cgthfjs.cornckynjtrcohznkj MKO opo , 0cbhjl trcjs`nrf` tanhr cgthfjpursucjtf
UuIn3;4<cpprfprhctn.
HHH. MFPCI_[[W'CG[HFJ WNCUNW GFMMFJ S^NW[HFJW F@ Q'CG[ MCBHJL
[UCJW@NUCTTUFTUHC[N
[rcjs`nr fr gffrkhjctnkprntrhco prfgnnkhjlss cutafrhznk tan Tcjnokntnmhjns ract
"tcj9s`nrsfr sugaprfgnnkhjls hoo en fr tangfjvn,jhnjgnpcrthnscjkwhtrnssnscjkwhoo prfmftn
tan ust cjk n``hghmt gfjkugtf` sugacgthfjs." 51^.W.G.$ 3c4<(c).@cgtfrsanTcjno ffbs f hj
n``ngtucthjl ahs prjpfsn jgoukn wantanr gnjtrcohzcthfj rh33 nohmhjctn kupohgcohvn khsgfvnq0
prnvnjtjgfjshstnjt rntrhco ruohjls, nspnghcooywhta rnspngt f gocssgnrth`ogcthfq cjkgfjsnrvnan
rnsfurgns `tanpcrthns, anhr gfujsnocjk aniukhghcry." Hj rn9 \csahjltfjMutuco,Hjg.,Wngcrhthns,
Knrhvcthvn "NMWC" Ohthlcthfj,>[email protected]<<,37<1Iuk-Tcj-Muotht.54fW)(gnjtrcohzhjl
j
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-> @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln ; f` 35
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 115/126
gcsn ecsnkfj hknjthgcoujknroyhjl cgt csMfvcjts' cgthfj f tan \nstnrjKhs`hgt f` \hsahjltfj
hjMKO 3838).Ecsnk j ansn fjshknrcthfjs,vnr wnjtycgthfcs lchjst\cMuacvncornckyennj
fnjtcohznk hj tan\nstnmKhstrhgt f` \csahjltfj fr gffrkhjc`nkprnthco prfgnnkhjls ngcusf,
"tansn cgthfjnsacrn tgtuco lunsthfjscrhshjl `rfm coonlnk mhsrnprnsnjtcthfjs r fmhsshfjs
gfjgnmhjl\cMu's `hjcrghco gfjkhthfj vhta rnspngtf hts sueprhmnafmn3fmpfrt`fohf.j Hj rn9
\csahjltfj utuco,>70@,Wupp.5k t 37<1.
.C- [an Jnnk`fr Hknjthgco Khsgfvnry EntwnnjMfycjtst Cg`hfj cjk MKO 3838Mcbns [rcjs`nr Cpprfproctn-
Fjn f` tan mchj purpfsns fr gnjacohzcthfj f` cgthfjsujknr Wngthfj 3;4<`fr prntrhco
prfgnnkhjlss tf cvfhk kupohgcthvnkhsgfvnry. j rn9 \csahjltfjMutuco,>[email protected] 37<12
snncosf j rnJnurfjthjMcrognthjl Wctns rcChgns, cjk TrfkuCsOhcehohty Ohthlcthfj,5;> @.U-K.
>>,><D.Mcss.544<)"[anpqpfsnf`cmuothkhstrhgt ohthlcrhfjgfjsfohkcthfjs tfcvfhkkupohgcthvn
khsgfvnry, rnvnjtjgfrshstnjtprntrhcoruohjlscjkgfjsnrvniukhghconsfrhrgns')(hjtnrjcouftcthfj
cjkghtcthfj fmhttnk). Fjnf`tan prhmcry`cgtucocoonlcthfos fr jncroycoo f`tan cgthfjs njtrcohznto
hj MKO 3838 s \cMu's cpprchscoprcgthgnscck tan coonlnkgfjsphrcgy ntwnnh9\cMu cjk ts
CMGs. InnNxereht; \cMu'sErhn{ p, H (\cMustcthjl ech tan gochmsclchjstt stnm rfm "cj
coonlnkgfjsphrcgy ntwnnj\cMu] cjkcjcpprchsco njkfr,pC], rnoconk f cpprchsco coucthfjs
fj fcms rhlhjctnk y `\cPHuo")2pp.0-1(summcrhzhjlhvn gfmpochjtswhta coonlcthfjsact\cMu
pueohsankmctnrhcooy cosn cjk mhsonckhjlstctnmnjts6noctnktf tan coonlnkgfjsphrcgy''whta hts
CMGs)2p. 34(ghthjlmuothpon gfmpochjtsf` cgthfjsgffrkhjctnkj MKO Jf. 3838csenhjlecsnk
fj "`t]an gfjsphrcgy f hj`ocon cpprchscovcouns fj rnshknjthco-sngurnkfcjs whta ton lfco f`
crthhghcooy hjgrncshjlfcj-tf-vcounrcthfs')2 nnc/sfNxaheht>,MKO 3838 fhk TrnohmhjcryUnpfrt
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-> @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln > f` 35
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 116/126
$3.(mknrC.{cturn jkGfmponxhtyf`tanGcsn,an"WnqjhthnsOhthlcthfj" gcsns tctnanycjthghpctn
cssnrthjl ochms fr\coP3u's pp,rchscorcgthgnsfrtanhrmfrtlclnlcjk an'Knrhvcthvn Ohthlc`hfj"'
gcsns tc`₯ any cjthghpctncssnrthjl ochms `fr \cHPHu'scoonlnk j`octhfj f` hts ofcj frhlhjcthfj
vfoumn mk cpprhscoprcgthgns).
[ansncoonlcthfjsclchjst\cIvHufr hts cpprchsco rcgthgns 9rk on coonlpkgfosphrcgy whta
NC cjk OWH crn tan scgt scjn fochms Mfvcjts coonlnacrmnk anm"Nxaheh` Y uoo L8, 7>;8.
Cggfrkhjloy,Mfvpjt whoornquhrn nssnkhcooytanscmn rtnjshvnkfgums`&kknpfshthfjkhsgfvnry
tf suppfrtanhr coonlkhfjs act \cMu qhwnk gfjsumnrs yvhrtun f`hts ujoc*`hro gfjsphrcgywhta
NC cjk OWH cs an cgthfjscornckygnjtrcohznkj MKO 3838whoo jnnk f p'rfvn anhr sngukthns,
knrhvcthvncjkNUHWCgochms WnnNxaheht >, $<.E (hknjth`hhjl tan'Khsgfvnry [fphgs" tf hjgoukn,
"oan cgthfjs f` kn`njkcjts@hrst Cmnrhgcj cjk nCpprchns``,' 'tan pprchsco f` tan prf'pnrthns
ujknroyhjl\cHvHu's fcjsh mk "ncgakn`njkcjt'sjvfovnmnjtj tan c`frnjrnorthfjnksthvhthns').
Ckkhthfjcooy, mcjyf`tan cgthfjs ctrcohznk hj MKO 38t8 cIonlnammgcusnky \cHvHu's
nngurhthzcthfj ` htsafmn fcjs. Nxaheht>,$ H . Ohbnwhsn,Mfvcjtscoonln act anujknroyhjlncsfj
way \cHPHu jtnrnk.hjtfts gfjsphrcgyfe.`oc.tn pprchsco counswhto NC cjt ,WH hs engcosn\cHP`u
wcjtnk f rchsn anvcoun f`hts ofcjpfrt`fohf, sngurhthzn an fcjscjk snoo tan,rrfj tan hjcjghco
mc*nt. Nxaheht 5, jj 0, 555;, Cotafule sghnjtnr s jft m nonmnjtf` cjy f` Mfvm1 gochms,
Mfvcjtswhoo jnnk f safw\cov3u'smfthvf fr tanhrpujhthvn kcmcln ochms. /.,tou 3<,331,cjk
Truynrct K. [aus,Mfvcjts whho jk tf tcbn nssnjthcooyan scmnkhsgfvnrycstan gnjtcohznk
cgthfjs nlcrkhjl\c`uou'smfr₯clnsnsurhthzcthfjprcgthgnscs hooustrctnk j MKO 3838'sIfhjt
;-
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-> @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 0 f` 35
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 117/126
WtctusUnpfrt Nxaheht >, $ <.1 (hknjth`yhjl an"Khsgfv₯ry[fphgs" tf hjgouknjft fjoy \cMu's
cpp,rchscorcgthgns, ut cosf 3ansngurhthzc`hfj ` \co_;u's fcfs').
[anTcjnoacscanckygfjgouknkactecsnk jtannxcgtscmn cgtucocoonlcthfjsj Mfvcje'
gfmpochj g₯jtrcohzcthfj wcs cpprfprhcL fr fvnr twn,jtyshmhocr cgthfjsclchjst \cMu `fr
gffrkhjctnkprntrhcopfgnnkhjls. xaheht 3.Hths\cMu's cpprchsco rcgthgns,ancoonlnk fjsphrcgy
entwnnjt cjk ts CMGs, cjk anpurpfsnenahjk an gfjsphrcgy h.n., tf hj`octn afmnvcouns f
hjgrncsn rf`htsey eujtoohjl anprfpnrthns jksngurhthzhjlanmfj tan hjcjghcommbnts toct lhvn
rhsn tf tan cbfcky gnjtcohznk cgthfjs' gochms`fr tas 'coonlnk mhsrnprnsnjtcthfjsr fmhsshfjs
gfjgnrjhjl\cMu's hjcjghcogfjkhthfjwhta rnspngt f hts sueprhmnafmn fcjpfr`fohf." Hk.
Cs Mfvcjts' cgthfjsacrnsan nxcgtscrjngfrotmfj f` `cgt rnlcrkhjl\cMu's
cpprchscoprcgthgnsjktssngwhthzcthfjf`hts afmnmfrtlclnf"js cs ancgthfos corncky njtrcohznk
hj MKO 3838, rcjs`nrf` Mfvcjts' cgthfj f tan \nstnmKhstrhgt f` \csahjltfj fr gffrkhjc.tnk
prftrhco prfgnnkhjlss cppmprhconf cvfhkkupohgcthvnkhsgfvnry.Wnnj rn9 \csahjltfjMutuco,
>[email protected]` O7<12snncosf Hj rn9 CvnjkhcMcrbnthjl WconsTrcchgns cjk TrfkugtsOhcehohty
Ohthlcthfj, >;[email protected]<0, 37<1 Iukocj.Mu3t.^t.5441)('Wngthfj3;4<,afwnvnr,kfnsjft
rnquhrncgfmpontnkn'jthtyfr nvnjcmcifrhtyf` gfmmfj cg`ucocjk nlco ssunscs cprnrnquhshtn
tf gnjtrcohzc`hfj)2j rn9Chrgrcrt CgghknjtctEcrrfw Cocsbc,fj Fcfenr 37,38<1,;<;@.Wupp.880,
888(Iuk`cj.Muot.Oht- 38<8)('"Hanprfsnjgn `kh``nrnjt onlco anfrhnsj sfmnf`tan cgthfjs vhta
rnlcxkf tancoonlnkhcehtty f`ncgakn`njkcjt fnsjftjnlctn on nxhstnjgn ` gfmmfjqunsthfjs
f` `cgt rnlcrkhjl tan gcusnfr gcusnsf` tan grcsa cjk cotn,jkcjt hrgumstcjgns"act rnquhrn
gnortrcohzcthfj3f cvfhk kupohgcthvnkhsgfvnry .., prnvnjt jgfjshstnjtprnthco ruohjls, gfjssrvn
iukhghco rnsfurgns jkn.jsurnon gffpnrcthfj `coo pcrthnscjk gfujsn`).
3
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-> @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln < f` 35
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 118/126
E. [anKcjlnrf`ojgfjshstnjtKntnrmhjcthfjsUnlcrkhjlGocssUnoc&k HssunsCjkTrntrhco Uuoojls @cvfrs Wngthfj 3;4< [rcjs`nr f` Mfvcjts' Cgthfj tf ttrn\nstnm Khsahgt f` \csahjltfj
Hr ckkhthfjofcvfhkhjlkupohgcthvnkhsgfvnry, anTccno njtrcohznkan cgthfjs₯chmt\coPHu
hjMKO 3838 f "prnvn,rrtjgfjshstnjt rntrhco uhhjls, nspnghcooywhta nspngt fgocss nrth`hgcthfj"
Hj rn9 \csahjlofjMutuco,>[email protected] 37<$ snncosfWfutancstnrot hHb CjthtrustOh`hlcthjj,
>74 @.Wupp.zk 37>8, 3704 (Iuk.TcOMuotoht 5441)('Gnjtrcohzc`hfjmknr Wngthfj 3;4< whoo
nohmhjctnkupohgcthvnkhsgfvnr20 rnvnjthjgfjshstnjtprnehcorohjls,nqpnghcooywhta nspngtf gocss
gnrth`hgcthfrlcjk gfjsnrvn an rnsfurgns ` tan pcrthns, anhr gfwsno cjk tan ukhghcry')2 Hj rn
Bfrncj Chr Ohjns Gf., Otk. Cjthtrust Ohthlcthfj, >51 @.Wupp.5k 37<5, 37<7 (Iuk`cj-J{uot OhO
544<)(scmn)2j rnTowjehjl@h*urn Gcsns, 81 @.Wupp.;1;,;87 (Iuk.Tcr-MuoOOhO3801)('[t s
hj tan hnok f`gocss cgthfj kntnrmhjcthfjsj rnoctnkmuothkhstrhgtghvho cgthfjs ect anpftnjthco fr
ffj`ohgthjl, khsfrknrol gacfthg ukhghco cgthfj hs tan lrnctns'`). Hjknnk, mcjy f` tan cgthfjs
gnjtrcohznkhjMKo 3838crnerfulatcspurpfrtnk ocsscgthfjs.Z`nnNxaheht ;,\cMu's Mfthfj fr
[rcjs`nr,ir|o` , 342Nxaheho >, $0 (2ttkh"u0fl
"tcss
gnrth`hgcthfjs cj ssun fr coo f`tan sngurhthns jk
NUHWC cgthfjs). Whmhocroy, Mfvcjtscrnpuqpfrthjlf rnprnsnjtc gocssf` gfjsumnrs hmhonxoy
acrmnkey \cMu's gfjkugt Nxaheht 5, RjO < O9<<.
Cs \cMu cssnrtnkj hts frhlhjcoMfthfj `fr [rccs`nr, rcjs`nrf` Mfvcr`s' cgthfj f tan
\nstnmKhs`hgt f` \csahjltfj_*"h33njsurn fjshstnjgyj tan ckiukhgcthfjf` gocssgnrth`hgcthfj
hssunscrhshjl" cmfjlMfvcjt's cgthfj cjk tafsncorncky rcjs`nrrnk f MKO 3838. Nxaheht ;
\cMu'sErhn`2 p. 37. Cs gnjtrchhzcthfjfrprnthco prfgnnkhjlsspcrthgr9ocroyhmpfrtcrt fprnvsjt
hjgfjshstnjtprntrhco ruohjlswhta rnspngt f gocssgsrth`gcthfj, tcjs`nr f`Mfvcjts' cgthfjtf tan
-U-
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-> @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 1 f` 35
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 119/126
\nstnmKhs`hgt f`\csahjltfjfr gffrkhjctnk rntrhcoprfgnnkhjls hta MKO H 838 s cpprfprhctn.
Hj rn9 \csahjltfj u`hjo,>70 @.Wupp.5k t 37<1.
HP. GFJGO^WHFJ
@fr tan`frnlfhjl ncsfjs,Mfvcjts nspngt`tohy rnqunst act anTcjno rcjs`nr anhr cgthfj
tf tan AfjfrcWonMcrsacI. Tngamcj, jhtnk WtcInsKhsthft Iukln fr tan \nstnmKhs`hgt f`
\csahjltfj,fr gffrkhcctnk rntrhco pmgnnkhjlsj MKO 3838pursucjtf 51 .W.G.$ 3;4<.
Kctnk9 ujn38,5441 WTNG[NUWTEG[NUNPCJW&MCJFL^N,T.G.
[an500 @offrBfppnrsEuhokhjlThttseurla,Tn,jjsyovcjhc >538[nonpafjn9(;35)0;5-5744@cgshmhon9 (;O5)0;5-5748
MhgacnoK. ErcujEUCO/[{ C\ LUF^T,T.G.3574;WcjtcMfjhgcEovk.,Wuhtn348
OfsCjlnons,Gc8445>[nonpafjn9Srg) ;;5-<< >@cgshmhon9 SoFo j;5-<rt0
ac WphrfWT3UFMFWWCUJNWW, OT337<<\nst FoymphgEovk-, @h`oa @offrOfs Cjlnons,GC 8440;-h017[noqrafjn9 S34)57>-5;01@cgshmhon9 (734)jWC;>0
9X3. **.esnpaJ. Brcvng,Ir.
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-> @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 8 f` 35
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 120/126
IcjntOhjkjnr WphnoenrlH,C\ F@@HGNWF@ ICJN[OHJHKJNU
WTHNHENUL35;44\hosahrnEovk-, Wuhtn;44OfsCjlnons,GC 8445>
[nonpafjn9734)785-1143@cgshmhon9 734)5<1->871
Cttfmnysfr Tochjth`s hj tanWpncrsCgthfj
-34-
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-> @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 34 f` 35
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 121/126
TUFF@F@WNUXHGN
[anujknrshpnk, fsnpe . Brcvng, r."Nsquhrn, nrney nrthhns actansnrvnk tjrncjk
gfrngtgfpyf` tanEUHN@ HJ W^TTFUHF@MF[HFJH'FU[UH_JWHNU F@ [CL-COFJL
CG[HFJ [() MKO JF. 3838fj gfmsnofrKn`njkcrt y .W.@tst Gocss `cho fj an380kcy
f`Iujq 5441cs foofws9
UfenrtI. T`hstnr,NsquhrnWHMTWFJ[@HCG[HNU& ECU[ON[[ OO@
3888Cvnjunf` tan Wtcrs,580@offrHfsCjlnons, G;8440<
WtnpanjM, Uummcln,Nsquhrn
IfjctacjM. Oofyk, NsquhrnKCPHW \U[LH[[ UN&[CHJN,H.T
H54o [ahrk Cvnjun,Wuhtn5544Wnctthq\C 81343-74;>
McrthjO. @hjnrmj, NsquhrnWcmJ. Kcwffk,@squhrn
KCPHW \UHLH[[[UNH_;CHJNOOT>4> MfjtlfmcysennO Wuhtn144
Wcj@rcjghsgf, C 8;333
OcurcI. @fwonr,NsquhrnMGKFJF^LAAF[H"CJK
&CH[NJTG>>> GcphtfoMcot 8n @offr
Wcgrcmn,tf, GC 8>13;
McrlcrntCjjn Bncjn,NsluhrnBrhs A. Mcq Nsquhrg
KN\NXCJKONEFN^@O[,TFjn@mecrgcknrfGnjtnr
Wuhtn;44Wcj@rcjghsgf,GC 8;OOH-70H8
CjlnocM. TcTqocsbcrhs,squhrnGtrhstfpanrI. Gocrb, NsquhrnBnvhj G, o`coocfn, Nsquhrn
KN\NX&ONEFN^@ OH,T3743Cvnjunf` tanCmnrhgcs
JnwXfrb, JnwXfrb 344380485
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-> @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 33 f` 35
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 122/126
Uhgacrk@. Acjs,NsquhrnBnrry@frkGujjhjlacj,Nsquhrn
In`tny K. Uftnjenrl,NsquhrnTctrhfbI. Wmhte,Esquhrn
[H{CG`HNUTUF@[M & \FFKH-HT
[wf \frok @hjcjghcoGnjtnrJnwXfr_ Jnw Xfrb 34513
MKO JF. H,838OHCHWFJ GF^JWNO9
Kcj Krcgeonr,NsquhrnY\NUOHJL WGACGHH[NU& Y\NUOHJL OH,T
384;[ahrk CvnjunWuhtn3474
WncIton\C 81343-33<4
UflnrM. [fwjsnjk,NsquhrnEUNWBHJ IFAJWFJ& [F\JWNJKTTOG
888 [ahrk CvnjunWuhtn;;44
Wnctton,\C 8134;-;411
Ilosnpa . Brcvng,Ir.,Ns(uhrn
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-> @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 35 f` 35
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 123/126
EN@FUN [NN, I^KHGHCO TCHXNOFJ M[]O[HKHW[UHG[ OH[HLC[HFJ
)HJ UN _;/CWAHJL[FJM[I[^CH, H].{G.)WNGOHUH[HNW,KNU[PC[HPNCJK )'NUHWC-'OH[HLC[HFJ
)
)
MKOKfgbntJf.3838
WGANK^ON F@CGHHFH@
GcsnGcpthfjs Kctn @honk Ghvho Cgthfj Jf. Iukln Khstrhgt Gfurt
Wpncrs, tco. v.\csahjlofjMutuco, Hjg., nt co.
45/41/5;41 >941-GP-44101(UM\)
AfjfrceonUfjcokM.qcaytn
JfrtanrjKhstrhft f`Gcoh`frjhc (Wcj
Ifsn)
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-0 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 3 f` ;
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 124/126
Kctnk9 ujn38,5441 WTNG[NU TEG[NUNPCJW&MCJFL^N,T.G.
E"O).<_"j.)t...-,q/`` h
[an 500 @offrBfppnrsEuhokhjlThttseurle,Tnjjsyovcjh 3>5O8[nonpafjn9(;3,5)0;5-5744@cgshmhon9 (;35)0;5-5748
Mhgacno K. ErcmEUCHCH OC\ LUF^T,T.G.357M WcjtcMfjhgcEovk", Wuhtn 348Hfs Cjlnons,GC 8445>[nonpafjn9Lrg) ;;5-<< >
@cgshmhon9 (734);;5-<< 0
bc WphrfWTHUFMFWWECUJNWW,OOT337<<\nstFoymphgEovk-,@h`o@offrOfs Cjlnons,GC 8440;-3017[nonpafjn9 734)57>-5;01@cgshmhon9 (734)67>-5;>
IcjntOhjkjnr WphnoenrlOC\ F@@HGNWF@ ICJN[ OHJKJNU
WTHNOENUL35;44\hosatunEovk, Wuhtn;44ofs Cjlnons,GC 8445>[non,pafjn9734)785-1143@cgshmhon9 734)5<1->871
Cttfmnysfr Tochjth`s hj tan WpncrsCgthfj
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-0 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 5 f` ;
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 125/126
TUFF@F@WNUXHGN
[anujknrs'hljn;fsnpa . Brcvng, r.,Nsquhrg, nmey nrth`hnsac`afs₯``nkc hrn cjk
gfrrnftfpyf`tanWGNNK^ONF@CG[HFJWfjgfujs₯ofrKn`njkcjty^.W.@hrstGocssMch
fj an 38`rkcyf`Iujl 5441cs foofws9
Ufenrt. T`hstnr,NsquhrnWHMTWFJ HHCGHHNU& ECU[ON[H OH,,T
3888Cvnjun `tan Wtcrs, 8n@offrHfsCjlnons, C8440<
Wtnpanj . UumjclNNsquhrnIfjctacjr{.Oofy; Esquhrn
KCPHW\UHLHH[[UNMCHJN OT
3543[ahrkCvnjun,Wuhtn5544Wnctton, C8134o-74;>
McrthjO. @hjnmc99, squhrnWcmJ. Kc.wffk, squhrn
KCPHW }^UHLHH[[UNMCHJN OT>4>Mfjtlfmn,ryanntWuhtn144
Wcj@rcjghsgf, C8;33
Hcurc I. @fwonr,NsquhrnMGKFJF^LAAFOH,CJK
&COONJTG>>>GcphtfoMcoo,80@offr
Wcgrcmnjtf,C 8>13;
Mcrlcrnt jjnBncjn, squhrnHLhsA,Mcm, squhrn
KNHWNXC}..[KNEFN^@ OTFjnNmecrfcknrfno`₯r
Wuhtn;44Wcj rcjghsgf,C8;333-7038
CjlnocM. Tcpcocsbcrhs,squhrnGtrhstfpanr . G3crb, squhrnBsvhjG.\ctocgnfsquhrn
KE\NX& H.WEFN^@ [.T3743Cvnjun ` tanCmnrhgcs
JnwXfkqJnwXfrb 34438;485
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-0 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln 7 f` ;
7/31/2019 FELTON A. SPEARS, ET AL v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK & EAPPRAISEIT FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT & MOTION …
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/felton-a-spears-et-al-v-washington-mutual-bank-eappraiseit-first-amended 126/126
Uhgacrk@. Hocjs, NsquhrnBnrry @frk Gumhjlacm,Nsquhrn
In`tny K. UftnjenrlNsquhrn
Tctrhgb . Wmhta,@Zsquhrn
[H{CGAM.TUFH[M & \FFKOOT
[vf \frok @hjcjghcoGnjtnrJnwXfrb, Jnw Xfrb 34513
MKO JF. 3838OHCHWFJ GFHIJWNO9
Kcj Krcgaonr,NsquhrnY\NUOHJLWG[HCGHHHNU & Y\NUHIJL OH,T
384;[ahrk CvnjunWuhtn3474
Wnctton,\C813COojK
UflnrM. [fwjsnjk"NsquhrnEUNWBHJ IFAJWFJ& [F\JWNJKTTOG
888 [ahrk CvnrrunWuhtn;;44
Wncttoq\C 8134;-;411
If`npaJ. Brcvng,Ir.,Ns
Gcsn >941-gv-44101-UM\ Kfgumnjt 11-0 @honk 40/38/5441 Tcln ; f` ;