federalism, decentralisation and conflict management in multicultural societies public conference...
TRANSCRIPT
Federalism, Decentralisation and
Conflict Management in Multicultural
Societies
Public Conference fromThomas Fleiner
Budapest – January 2008
How should they be governed?
Who should govern whom?
Holding or bringing multiculturalSocieties together we have to ask:
And even more explosiv:Who should decide who should govern?
Main Questions:
Multicul-turality
Nation-state
Challenges of the Na-tion-State
Glocali-sation
Fragmen-tation
Diversi-tiy con-
flicts
The Challenge of the Nation State
Do federalism and decentralizationhelp to bring or to hold
multicultural societies together?
Why is multiculturalism a problem?
The issues:
Is a fragmented civil societyas nation builder of a multicultural
state conceivable and realistic?
Based on what concepts doesthe international community
intervene and/or manageconflicts of multicutlural societies?
EgocentricHobbes
Bearers ofunalienable
rightsLocke
RationalCitoyensRousseau
Exploitersor
exploitedMarx
Cost-benefit drivenHomo oeconomicus
State of Modernity: all human individuals are equal as being
What is the main problem?
Capable of rea-son and judge-
ment Kant
What
is
good
for
all?
Universa
l values,
but they d
o not take
cultu
re as l
egtimacy
fundam
ent
for politc
al identit
y serio
us
Nation-State facingMulticulturality
Nation - State
IgnoringCulture
DenyingCulture
Integrating in-to one cultu-re of identity
Conflict withethnic
minorities
have economic roots
are generated byfundamentalism
are promoted bywarlords
have historical rootsare stired up by
neighbours
Controversy about the roots and the potentials of the different conflicts:
Indu
ced b
y e
thnicity
Illegitimate state
State v. minority terror
Multiculturality:Diversity Conflicts
Sympto
ms o
r cause
s?
Consumers profit fromglobal market
„citoyens“ claim universalityof human rights
human beings seek local security and local identity
Reality ModernState Glocalisation
What is
good
for
us and for our
com
mu
nit
ies?To
get legi-timacy from
diversi-ties by
Promoting:shared-ruleself-rule?
Reconciling:conflict ma-nagement
power-sharing?
Tolerating:minority
protection;affirmative
action?
Equalising:collective
rights?
Challenges of the Nation-Statewith regard to fragmen-
tation by diversity
Legitim
acy of m
ulticultu
ral n
ations t
a-
kes c
ulture
s serio
usely
but is f
ocuss
ing
on particu
lar rath
er than unive
rsal v
alues
I. To bring or to hold together by
state-makingor by
state-reconstructing
Bring togetherthrough
constitution making
bydemocraticprocedure:Who is the„Pouvoir
Constituant“?
Bring together by Constitution
makingNegotiation
Hold togetherthrough
reconstructingthe federalbalance:
Creating anew canton
by secession
Berne
Jura
CH
Creating a newCanton
Juraout of
secessionand
self-de-termina-
tion
French
German
Along language
lines?
Catholic
Protestant
Or along
religiouslines?
Nation –building:
Hold togetherthrough
reconstructingthe federalbalance:
II. Hold or bring together
bydecentralization
The challenge ofelitism
To bring togetherby improving local
democracy
Transparancyand
accountability
To bring together byimproving
localdemocracy
Responsiveness
To hold together by
improving local
governance
HumanRights
To hold toge-ther by
improving local
governance
III. To hold or bringfragmented
civil society(ies)together
With Rights
To bring civil so-cieties together
with rights
Right ofSelf-determination
To bringtogether
with rights
Collective rights
Civil societiesfacing
diversities
How cancivil
societi(es)hold together
when theyface
pluralismof
languages
How cancivil
societ(ies)hold to-gether
when theyface
religiousdiversities
IV. To bring or holdtogether
by the internationalcommunity
To bring together
Role andlegitimacy
of international
action
To hold togethter
Forms of internationalinvolvement:Governance
Constitution makingState-makingState
Unity
Bri
ng a
nd h
old
mu
ltic
ulu
ralit
yto
geth
er
Negotiation
Soft secession
Nation-Building
Elitism
Transparency
Responsiveness
Human Rights
Self-Determination
Collective Rights
Language
Religion
Intervention
Int. governance
Recon-structing
State StructureDecentralisation
Local de-mocracy
Local Go-vernance
Civil So-ciety
Rights
Diversi-ties
Interna-tional C.
Bring together
Hold together
Bring together
Hold together
Bring together
Hold together
Bring together
Hold together