factors influencing drug delivery to the brain: multiple ...€¦ · 2011-04-13  · factors...

30
1 Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple Mechanisms at Multiple Barriers April 13, 2011 April 13, 2011 NJDMDG NJDMDG Somerset, New Jersey Somerset, New Jersey William F. Elmquist Pharmaceutics 0 10 20 30 40 50 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 Pharmacokinetics Pharmacokinetics Pharmacodynamics Pharmacodynamics Target biology Target biology Pharmacodynamics Pharmacodynamics (effects at the target) (effects at the target) Pharmacokinetics Pharmacokinetics (conc conc-time in blood) time in blood) Information Information flow flow Balance Balance Pharmacokinetics Pharmacokinetics (conc conc-time at the target) time at the target) ? ? CNS CNS Blood Blood Why Does a Drug Work ?? Why Does a Drug Work ?? Connect Connect - Disconnect of the Disconnect of the PK PK-PD Relationship PD Relationship Why Doesn Why Doesn’ t a Drug Work ?? t a Drug Work ?? CNS drug development : Must keep in mind the big questions ! CNS drug development : Must keep in mind the big questions ! Why does this one work, and that one doesn Why does this one work, and that one doesn’ t ?? t ??

Upload: others

Post on 11-Mar-2021

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple ...€¦ · 2011-04-13  · Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple Mechanisms at Multiple Barriers April

1

Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple Mechanisms at Multiple Barriers

April 13, 2011April 13, 2011NJDMDG NJDMDG

Somerset, New JerseySomerset, New Jersey

William F. ElmquistPharmaceutics

0 10 20 30 40 50

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

PharmacokineticsPharmacokinetics

PharmacodynamicsPharmacodynamics

Target biologyTarget biology

PharmacodynamicsPharmacodynamics(effects at the target)(effects at the target)

PharmacokineticsPharmacokinetics((concconc--time in blood)time in blood)

InformationInformationflowflow

BalanceBalance

PharmacokineticsPharmacokinetics((concconc--time at the target)time at the target)

?? ??

CNSCNS BloodBlood

Why Does a Drug Work ??Why Does a Drug Work ??

Connect Connect -- Disconnect of the Disconnect of the PKPK--PD RelationshipPD Relationship

Why DoesnWhy Doesn’’t a Drug Work ??t a Drug Work ??

CNS drug development : Must keep in mind the big questions !CNS drug development : Must keep in mind the big questions !

Why does this one work, and that one doesnWhy does this one work, and that one doesn’’t ??t ??

Page 2: Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple ...€¦ · 2011-04-13  · Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple Mechanisms at Multiple Barriers April

2

CNS Pharmacokinetics and Pharmacodynamics(Drug Delivery) in the Era of Systems Biology

Dose and dosing regimen Mechanisms of delivery and action

“Traditional PK/PD”“Molecular pharmacokinetics”

Black box modelsSystem – structure function

Nature Biotechnology 23, 191 - 194 (2005)

Systems model“the Big Picture”

quantitativequantitative qualitativequalitative

Genetic Factors- drug targets- drug transportersdrug transporters- drug metabolizing enzymes

Environmental Factors- induction- inhibition

Physiological Factors- age, disease, etc.

Understanding Sources of Variability in Drug ResponseVariability Cycle

Connect Connect -- Disconnect of the Disconnect of the PKPK--PD RelationshipPD Relationship

Page 3: Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple ...€¦ · 2011-04-13  · Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple Mechanisms at Multiple Barriers April

3

“Locations” of Variability in Drug Response

Presystemic bioavailability questions (“traditional” bioavailability)

Site-specific bioavailability questions (drug targeting)

Oraldosageform

Systemiccirculation

Drugaction

Targeted Bioavailability

Intestinalabsorption

Liver metabolism

Cellular delivery

Intestinalmetabolism

Tissue distribution

Target site

Systemicclearance

Mechanisms that influence the fraction of the drug in the systemic circulation that is available for distribution to target tissue and the exposure of the tissue to the drug

- distribution of blood flow- ratio of total clearance to a distributional clearanceDistributional clearance - membrane permeability, competing competing carriercarrier--mediated transport (influx or efflux),mediated transport (influx or efflux), protein-binding, intracellular metabolism, tissue transit time, capillary structureTotal clearance – will affect the availability of the drug in the blood to distribute to the tissue

“Locations” of Variability in Drug Response

Presystemic bioavailability questions (“traditional” bioavailability)

Site-specific bioavailability questions (drug targeting)

Oraldosageform

Systemiccirculation

Drugaction

Targeted Bioavailability

Intestinalabsorption

Liver metabolism

Cellular delivery

Intestinalmetabolism

Tissue distribution

Target site

BBB

BTSC

EGFRmTORBRaf

Page 4: Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple ...€¦ · 2011-04-13  · Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple Mechanisms at Multiple Barriers April

4

Physicochemical PropertiesPhysicochemical Properties

Ph

ysio

log

y /

Pat

ho

log

yP

hys

iolo

gy

/ P

ath

olo

gy

DrugDrugMetabolismMetabolism

ReceptorReceptorAffinityAffinity

ProteinProteinBindingBinding

MembraneMembranePermeabilityPermeability

Drug Drug TransportTransport

GeneGeneRegulationRegulation

TargetedTargeted

BioavailabilityBioavailability

Do

sage R

egim

enD

osag

e Reg

imen

ProteinProteinExpressionExpression

Pharmacological / Toxicological ResponsePharmacological / Toxicological Response

Examine a location considering the interplay between external factors and mechanism

External factors

Mechanisms

External fa

ctors

PatientPatient

Dosage Dosage form/regimenform/regimen

DrugDrug

Importance of Transporters in the CNS Disposition of Drugs

From Lee and Gottesmann. Journal of Clinical Investigation, 1998illustration by Naba Bora, Medical College of Georgia.

One One ““LocationLocation”” : Blood: Blood--brain Barrierbrain Barrier

Page 5: Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple ...€¦ · 2011-04-13  · Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple Mechanisms at Multiple Barriers April

5

LoscherLoscher, Aug. 2005, Aug. 2005Nature Rev. Nature Rev. NeurosciNeurosci..

GLUT1GLUT1

PP--gpgp(p(p--glycoprotein)glycoprotein)

CoCo--localizationlocalizationGLUT1 GLUT1 -- PP--gpgp

brainbrain

brainbrainbrainbrain

bloodblood

CloutClout

ClinClin

BCRPBCRPPP--gpgp

Compartmental model for solute exchange in the brainCompartmental model for solute exchange in the brain

Decisions limited by available data at specific sitesDecisions limited by available data at specific sites

plasma

choroid plexusarachnoid membrane

braincapillaries

extra-cellular

fluid

intracellularfluid

ependymapia mater

neuronaland

glial cellmem-branes

cerebrospinal fluid

IV

ICV,IT

bolus IC, CEDbolus IC, CEDinputinputoutputoutputexchangeexchange

Page 6: Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple ...€¦ · 2011-04-13  · Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple Mechanisms at Multiple Barriers April

6

Modeling limited by available mechanistic data at specific barriModeling limited by available mechanistic data at specific barriersers

plasma

choroid plexusarachnoid

braincapillaries

extra-cellular

fluid

intracellularfluid

ependymapia mater

neuronaland

glial cell

cerebrospinal fluid

CSF flowCSF flowSurface areaSurface areaPermeabilityPermeabilityTransportersTransportersMetabolismMetabolismRegional variabilityRegional variability

ECF productionECF productionSurface areaSurface areaPermeabilityPermeabilityTransportersTransportersMetabolismMetabolismRegional variabilityRegional variability

ConvectionConvectionDiffusionDiffusionTransportersTransportersPermeabilityPermeabilityMetabolismMetabolismReceptorsReceptorsRegional variabilityRegional variability

Convection, DiffusionConvection, DiffusionPermeability, Regional variabilityPermeability, Regional variability

Simplified Quantitative Analysis of Drug Transfer In CNSSimplified Quantitative Analysis of Drug Transfer In CNS

Drug Drug ““BindingBinding”” –– Plasma and BrainPlasma and Brain

PlasmaPlasma

Cu,plasmaCu,plasma CplasmaCplasma

BrainBrain CSFCSF

BBBBBB BCSFBBCSFBPSPS

CLCLeffeff CLCLinin

CcsfCcsfCu,brainCu,brainCbrainCbrain CLCLbulkbulk

CLCLmetameta

[[CLinCLin, , CLeffCLeff, PS], PS]

Page 7: Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple ...€¦ · 2011-04-13  · Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple Mechanisms at Multiple Barriers April

7

Simplified Quantitative Analysis of Drug Transfer In CNSSimplified Quantitative Analysis of Drug Transfer In CNS

Extent Extent -- partitioning into brain parenchymapartitioning into brain parenchyma

bulkmetabolismefflux

uptakefreep CLCLCLPS

CLPSK

,

TightTight--junctionjunctionopeningopening

TightTight--junctionjunctionopeningopening

Inhibition ofInhibition ofEfflux transporterEfflux transporter

Substrate forSubstrate forInflux TransporterInflux Transporter

controlblood,

controltarget,

oninterventiblood,

oninterventitarget,

AUCAUC

AUCAUC

DTI

Drug Targeting Index

The critical issue in the quantitative assessment of drug targetingis the need to measure drug concentrations at the target site

A neutral intervention would lead to a targeting index of unity, where positive effect would lead to a DTI greater than one, and a negativeeffect would result in a DTI less than one.

(a measure of delivery)(a measure of delivery)

Page 8: Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple ...€¦ · 2011-04-13  · Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple Mechanisms at Multiple Barriers April

8

basolateral apicalintracellular

Complexity of the Transporter Problem at Various BarriersComplexity of the Transporter Problem at Various Barriers

Many processes can be occurring simultaneously!

PSin (TIGHT JUNCTIONS)(transmembrane permeability)

PSout

PSout

PSin

Carrier in Carrier in

Carrier out

P-gp

Bidirectional

BloodBlood

BrainBrain

Bcrp

Complex SystemComplex System

Like multiple enzymes forming the same metaboliteand the fraction metabolizedvaries with location!

Complexity of the Transporter Problem at Various BarriersComplexity of the Transporter Problem at Various Barriers

basolateral apical

Many processes can be occurring simultaneously!

P-gp

BloodBloodBrainBrain

Bcrp

Tools:Tools:

Genetic knockoutsGenetic knockouts

Mdr1a/b (Mdr1a/b (--//--))Bcrp1 (Bcrp1 (--//--))Mdr1/Bcrp (Mdr1/Bcrp (--//--))

InhibitorsInhibitors

LY335979LY335979Ko143Ko143GF120918GF120918

Page 9: Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple ...€¦ · 2011-04-13  · Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple Mechanisms at Multiple Barriers April

9

Case Study : Case Study :

Tyrosine Kinase Inhibitors forTyrosine Kinase Inhibitors forGlioblastoma Glioblastoma MultiformeMultiforme (Glioma)(Glioma)

““MolecularlyMolecularly--TargetedTargeted”” Agents. Agents. Can they find the target?Can they find the target?

Numerous clinical trials with targetedNumerous clinical trials with targetedtyrosine kinase inhibitors for glioma have failed.tyrosine kinase inhibitors for glioma have failed.

Is there a PKIs there a PK--PD disconnect for these drugs in glioma?PD disconnect for these drugs in glioma?

consilienceconsilience : to give a purpose to understanding the details

Mol Cancer Mol Cancer TherTher 2007;6(7)2007;6(7)TargetsTargets

DrugsDrugs

Page 10: Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple ...€¦ · 2011-04-13  · Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple Mechanisms at Multiple Barriers April

10

Target LocationsTarget Locations

Like Fighting a Forest FireLike Fighting a Forest Fire

Broken BBB: MRI contrastBroken BBB: MRI contrast

Intact BBBIntact BBB

Factors enhancinginfiltration of tumor

Tumor Initiation

Where is the drug needed?

Page 11: Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple ...€¦ · 2011-04-13  · Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple Mechanisms at Multiple Barriers April

11

Tumorcore

Invadingcells

NormalBrain

Glioma cell

Glioma Invasive “Stem” Cell

necrosis

Invasive Cell Migration

Localized??Localized??

LocationsLocations

In Vivo Methods

Blood Brain

Mouse models:

Wild type: FVB

Transgenic:Abcb1a/b-Abcg2 (-/-)

““MolecularlyMolecularly--TargetedTargeted”” Agents. Agents. Can they find the target in the brain?Can they find the target in the brain?

Page 12: Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple ...€¦ · 2011-04-13  · Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple Mechanisms at Multiple Barriers April

12

Blood

TargetSite

OtherTissue

CL13

CLinCL31

CLout

CL10

Targeting Intervention

3

1

2

Quantitative Analysis of Drug Targeting

Brain Brain -- gliomaglioma

BBBBBBtransporttransport

Multiple transportersMultiple transporters

5 min 20 min 60 min 120 min 180 min

Time

Bra

in/P

lasm

a R

atio

0.0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.0

1.2

1.4

1.6

1.8

2.0

WT Tri-KO

The brain-to-plasma ratio of dasatinib in wild-type and triple-knockout FVB Mice (* p<0.05, n=4)

*

*

*

*

*

Dasatinib Dasatinib –– Brain/Plasma ratios in triple knockoutsBrain/Plasma ratios in triple knockouts

Chen Y. et al., JPET September 2009 vol. 330 no. 3 pgs. 956‐963

(Abcb1a/b-Abcg2 (-/-))

Page 13: Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple ...€¦ · 2011-04-13  · Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple Mechanisms at Multiple Barriers April

13

Bri

an C

on

c (n

g/g

)

0

200

400

600

800

WT P-gp-KO Bcrp1-KO Tri-KO

120min20min

B

Brain concentration of dasatinib in WT mice with and withoutgenetic deletion of efflux transport.

Dasatinib Dasatinib –– genetic deletion of transporter genesgenetic deletion of transporter genes

Chen Y. et al., JPET September 2009 vol. 330 no. 3 pgs. 956‐963

Bra

in C

on

c (n

g/g

)

0

100

200

300

400

WT WT+LY335979 WT+Ko143 WT+GF120918

20min 120min

A

Brain concentration of dasatinib in WT mice with and withoutpharmacologic inhibition of efflux transport.

Dasatinib Dasatinib –– pharmacologic inhibition of transportpharmacologic inhibition of transport

Chen Y. et al., JPET September 2009 vol. 330 no. 3 pgs. 956‐963

Page 14: Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple ...€¦ · 2011-04-13  · Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple Mechanisms at Multiple Barriers April

14

Gefitinib Brain-to-Plasma Ratios at 90 min Postdose

Bra

in-t

o-P

lasm

a ra

tio

s

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

WTP-gp KOBCRP KOTKO

WT P-gp BCRP TKO

****

****

Agarwal S., Sane R., Gallardo J., Ohlfest J., Elmquist W.F.,Agarwal S., Sane R., Gallardo J., Ohlfest J., Elmquist W.F.,““Brain Distribution of Gefitinib is Limited by PBrain Distribution of Gefitinib is Limited by P--glycoprotein (ABCB1) and Breast Cancer Resistance Protein (ABCG2glycoprotein (ABCB1) and Breast Cancer Resistance Protein (ABCG2) )

Mediated Active EffluxMediated Active Efflux””,, J J PharmacolPharmacol Exp Exp TherTher. 2010. . 2010.

Lapatinib Brain Distribution

Ste

ady-

Sta

te B

rain

/Pla

sma

Rat

ios

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

WTP-gpBCRPP-gp/BCRP

0.3 mg/hr/kg 3.0 mg/hr/kg

WT BCRPP-gpP-gp BCRP TKO WT TKO

data from : Polli et al., An Unexpected Synergist Role of P-Glycoprotein and Breast Cancer Resistance Protein ... DMD 37:439-442, 2009

~ 40~ 40--fold fold ~ 40~ 40--fold fold

Page 15: Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple ...€¦ · 2011-04-13  · Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple Mechanisms at Multiple Barriers April

15

Ste

ady-

Sta

te B

rain

to

Pla

sma

Rat

ios

0.0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.0

1.2

WTP-gp KOBcrp KOTKO

WT Pgp Bcrp TKO

SorafenibSorafenib -- Influence of Multiple Transporters Influence of Multiple Transporters on Brain Distributionon Brain Distribution

****

****

Bcrp / P-gp and Erlotinib Brain Penetration

Ste

ady-

Sta

te B

rain

/Pla

sma

Rat

io

0.0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.0

1.2

Wild-typeTKO

WT TKO

4242--fold fold increaseincrease

AlzetAlzet pump IP, 24 hour infusion, n = 3pump IP, 24 hour infusion, n = 3

Page 16: Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple ...€¦ · 2011-04-13  · Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple Mechanisms at Multiple Barriers April

16

Vehicle Control GF120918

Bra

in T

issu

e-to

-Pla

sma

Co

nce

ntr

atio

n R

atio

(Mea

n ±

SE

)

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

2.0

Tumor CoreBrain Around TumorNormal Brain

**

* - p < 0.025 Compared to Control

**- p < 0.003 Compared to Core

** **

Erlotinib Brain-to-Plasma Concentration Ratio at Different Locations in Rat Brain Tumor

Influence of Elacridar on Erlotinib Brain Penetrationin Different Brain Regions

Rel

ativ

e In

crea

se in

Bra

in-t

o-P

lasm

a R

atio

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

Tumor Core

Tumor Rim

Normal Brain

no effectno effect

Targeted bioavailability Targeted bioavailability ↑↑↑↑↑↑

DTIDTI

Page 17: Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple ...€¦ · 2011-04-13  · Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple Mechanisms at Multiple Barriers April

17

Differences in Brain Distribution Enhancement betweenDifferences in Brain Distribution Enhancement betweenGenetic Knockouts and Pharmacological InhibitionGenetic Knockouts and Pharmacological Inhibition

Generally knockouts show greater enhancementGenerally knockouts show greater enhancement

1) accessibility of inhibitors ? 1) accessibility of inhibitors ? (dose, potency, (dose, potency, parenchymalparenchymal concentrations)concentrations)

2) locations of transporters ?2) locations of transporters ?(BBB (BBB vsvs parenchyma)parenchyma)

DornerDorner, 2009, 2009

1111CC--elacridarelacridar(GF120918)(GF120918)

WTWT BCRPBCRPPP--gpgp

WTWT

PP--gpgp

BCRPBCRP

Page 18: Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple ...€¦ · 2011-04-13  · Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple Mechanisms at Multiple Barriers April

18

wildwild--typetype

PP--gpgp/BCRP KO/BCRP KOBCRP KOBCRP KO

PP--gpgp KOKO

PP--gpgp

BcrpBcrpWTWT

PP--gp/Bcrpgp/Bcrp

EDED5050 = 1= 1--2 mg/kg2 mg/kg

Cpdt

Cb1K

Page 19: Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple ...€¦ · 2011-04-13  · Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple Mechanisms at Multiple Barriers April

19

In VitroIn Vitro-- In Vivo Correlations, What about BCRP In Vivo Correlations, What about BCRP vsvs PP--gpgp??

KusuharaKusuhara and Sugiyamaand Sugiyama

Kp (brain) Ratio (Bcrp KO/WT)ss vs CFR for BCRP and MDR1

Corrected Flux Ratio

1 2 3 4 5 6 7

Kp

ratio

bra

in

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

BCRPMDR1

Data from Data from EnokizonoEnokizono et al., DMD 2008et al., DMD 2008

In vitroIn vitro

genisteingenistein

prazosinprazosin

dantrolenedantrolene

BcrpKOBcrpKOWTWT

Flux Ratio (transfected)Flux Ratio (transfected)Flux Ratio (wildFlux Ratio (wild--type)type)

KpKp ??

Is BCRP Important in the BBB? Is BCRP Important in the BBB? -- Does BCRP KO tell the story?Does BCRP KO tell the story?

Page 20: Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple ...€¦ · 2011-04-13  · Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple Mechanisms at Multiple Barriers April

20

ErlotinibErlotinib

QuinidineQuinidineDantroleneDantrolene

FlavopiridolFlavopiridolCFR CFR PgpPgp = 4.6= 4.6CFR CFR BcrpBcrp = 1.4= 1.4

CFR CFR PgpPgp = 6.2= 6.2CFR CFR BcrpBcrp = 1.0= 1.0CFR CFR PgpPgp = 1.0= 1.0

CFR CFR BcrpBcrp = 1.9= 1.9

CFR CFR PgpPgp = 4.7= 4.7CFR CFR BcrpBcrp = 2.0= 2.0

Simple Kinetic Model to ExplainSimple Kinetic Model to ExplainNonNon--Additive Increases in BrainAdditive Increases in BrainDistribution of Dual PDistribution of Dual P--gpgp / BCRP/ BCRPSubstratesSubstrates

KusuharaKusuhara and Sugiyamaand Sugiyama

Relative Distributional ClearancesRelative Distributional Clearances

Page 21: Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple ...€¦ · 2011-04-13  · Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple Mechanisms at Multiple Barriers April

21

KushuharaKushuhara and Sugiyama, Drug and Sugiyama, Drug MetabMetab. . PharmacokintPharmacokint. 24 (1):37. 24 (1):37--52, 200952, 2009

Influence of Relative Distributional Clearanceson the Brain-to-Plasma Ratios of Dual Substrates

Re

lati

ve In

crea

se in

Bra

in-t

o-P

lasm

a R

atio

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

Wildtype

P-gp TKOBCRP

PSPS2,u2,u = 0.5= 0.5PSPSpp--gpgp = 5= 5PSPSBCRPBCRP = 2= 2

Dual Dual -- PgpPgp -- dominantdominant

e.g., dasatinib, e.g., dasatinib, erlotiniberlotinib, gefitinib, , gefitinib, lapatiniblapatinib (affinity and capacity)(affinity and capacity)

Page 22: Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple ...€¦ · 2011-04-13  · Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple Mechanisms at Multiple Barriers April

22

Influence of Relative Distributional Clearanceson the Brain-to-Plasma Ratios of Dual Substrates

Rel

ativ

e In

crea

se i

n B

rain

-to

-Pla

sma

Rat

io

0

5

10

15

20

25

Wildtype

P-gp TKOBCRP

PSPS2,u2,u = 0.5= 0.5PSPSpp--gpgp = 2= 2PSPSBCRPBCRP = 8= 8

Dual Dual -- BCRP BCRP -- dominantdominant

e.g., e.g., sorafenibsorafenib

Influence of Relative Distributional Clearanceson the Brain-to-Plasma Ratios of Selective Substrates

Rel

ativ

e In

crea

se i

n B

rain

-to

-Pla

sm

a R

ati

o

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

Wildtype

P-gp TKOBCRP

PSPS2,u2,u = 0.5= 0.5PSPSpp--gpgp = 0= 0PSPSBCRPBCRP = 5= 5

Selective Selective -- BCRPBCRP e.g., e.g., dantrolenedantrolene

Page 23: Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple ...€¦ · 2011-04-13  · Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple Mechanisms at Multiple Barriers April

23

Influence of Relative Distributional Clearanceson the Brain-to-Plasma Ratios of Selective Substrates

Rel

ativ

e In

crea

se in

Bra

in-t

o-P

lasm

a R

atio

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

Wildtype

P-gp TKOBCRP

PSPS2,u2,u = 0.5= 0.5PSPSpp--gpgp = 5= 5PSPSBCRPBCRP = 0= 0

Selective Selective -- PgpPgp e.g., e.g., quinidinequinidine

Influence of Relative Distributional Clearanceson the Brain-to-Plasma Ratios of Dual Substrates

Rel

ativ

e In

crea

se in

Bra

in-t

o-P

lasm

a R

ati

o

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

Wildtype

P-gp TKOBCRP

PSPS2,u2,u = 10= 10PSPSpp--gpgp = 5= 5PSPSBCRPBCRP = 2= 2

Increased PassiveIncreased PassivePermeability !Permeability !

Page 24: Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple ...€¦ · 2011-04-13  · Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple Mechanisms at Multiple Barriers April

24

[14C] Sucrose [14C] Inulin

Bra

in S

pac

e %

(P

erce

nt

of

To

tal

Bra

in V

olu

me)

(Mea

n ±

SE

)

0

2

4

6

8

10

Wild-type Control

Mdr1a/1b(-/-)Bcrp1(-/-)

Integrity of Tight Junctions in WT Integrity of Tight Junctions in WT vsvs Triple Knockout MiceTriple Knockout Mice

VolumeBrainTotalConcPlasma

braininAmount

SpaceBrain100

10 min post bolus10 min post bolus

n = 4, each time pointn = 4, each time point

John Ohlfest, John Ohlfest, Brain Tumor Program, U of MNBrain Tumor Program, U of MN

De Novo Induction of De Novo Induction of Genetically Engineered Genetically Engineered Brain Tumors in MiceBrain Tumors in Mice

Using Plasmid DNAUsing Plasmid DNA

Page 25: Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple ...€¦ · 2011-04-13  · Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple Mechanisms at Multiple Barriers April

25

Characterization of the NRAS/shP53/EGFRvIII modelCharacterization of the NRAS/shP53/EGFRvIII model

Large tumor in the right Large tumor in the right hemishpherehemishphereinvading the left hemisphereinvading the left hemisphere

20x increase magnification showing20x increase magnification showinginfiltrating tumor in normal braininfiltrating tumor in normal brain

John Ohlfest, Brain Tumor Program, U of MNJohn Ohlfest, Brain Tumor Program, U of MN

FVBFVBWildWild--typetype

Induce tumorInduce tumortxttxt

txt txt w/Inhw/Inh

FVB FVB Mdr1a/b (Mdr1a/b (--//--))Bcrp1 (Bcrp1 (--//--))

Induce tumorInduce tumortxttxt

txt txt w/Inhw/Inh

??

??

??

??

GeneticallyGenetically--Engineered MouseEngineered Mousemodel of gliomamodel of glioma

Page 26: Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple ...€¦ · 2011-04-13  · Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple Mechanisms at Multiple Barriers April

26

Experimental DesignExperimental Design

p53shRNAp53shRNA

PDGFPDGF

WT or TKO mice

15 mg/kg Dasatinib

Twice daily, 7 days

GFP-Guided Dissection StrategyGFPGFP--Guided Dissection StrategyGuided Dissection Strategy

NormalBrain

Rim

CoreCore

Page 27: Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple ...€¦ · 2011-04-13  · Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple Mechanisms at Multiple Barriers April

27

Normal Brain Brain Around Tumor Tumor

Das

atin

ib C

on

cen

trat

ion

s (n

g/g

m)

0

1000

2000

3000

4000

Wild-typeTriple Knockout

Dasatinib Regional Brain Distribution

rimrim corecoreNBNB

Regional Effect on SignalingRegional Effect on SignalingRegional Effect on Signaling

AKT

pAKT

SrC

Actin

pSrC

WT TKO

Normal Brain

WT TKO

Rim

WT TKO

Core

Page 28: Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple ...€¦ · 2011-04-13  · Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple Mechanisms at Multiple Barriers April

28

Less Efflux = Superior EfficacyLess Efflux = Superior EfficacyLess Efflux = Superior Efficacy

15 mg / kg b.i.dFor 7 days

14 vs. 33 days; p=0.0028

Conclusions:Conclusions:1) multiple mechanisms at multiple barriers may limit1) multiple mechanisms at multiple barriers may limitglioma treatment to invasive brain tumor stem cellsglioma treatment to invasive brain tumor stem cells

(barrier 1 (BBB); barrier 2 (BTSC))(barrier 1 (BBB); barrier 2 (BTSC))

2) several 2) several ““molecularlymolecularly--targetedtargeted”” drugs aredrugs aresubstrates of critical transport systems substrates of critical transport systems that are in both barriersthat are in both barriers

3) 3) ““molecularlymolecularly--targetedtargeted”” drugs may be effective drugs may be effective in glioma if delivery issues are overcome and allowin glioma if delivery issues are overcome and allowpersonalized therapy depending on individual tumorpersonalized therapy depending on individual tumor

4) need dirty drug (s), sharp needle4) need dirty drug (s), sharp needle

Page 29: Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple ...€¦ · 2011-04-13  · Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple Mechanisms at Multiple Barriers April

29

OverviewMajor Challenges (Opportunities) in Describing the Kinetics of Major Challenges (Opportunities) in Describing the Kinetics of Drug Distribution in the CNS (Drug Distribution in the CNS (systems biology to do listsystems biology to do list))

1) limited knowledge of biochemical, anatomical, and 1) limited knowledge of biochemical, anatomical, and physiological variables that influence drug transport physiological variables that influence drug transport and delivery in the CNSand delivery in the CNS((to doto do:: integrate locations and mechanismsintegrate locations and mechanisms))

2) develop methods to measure time and space 2) develop methods to measure time and space dependent changes in drug concentration in and around dependent changes in drug concentration in and around the target sitethe target site((to doto do:: use complementary existing technologies and use complementary existing technologies and strive to develop new measurement techniquesstrive to develop new measurement techniques))

OverviewMajor Challenges (Opportunities) in Describing the Kinetics of Major Challenges (Opportunities) in Describing the Kinetics of Drug Distribution in the CNS (Drug Distribution in the CNS (to do listto do list) ) continuedcontinued

3) design appropriate experimental and mathematical 3) design appropriate experimental and mathematical models that incorporate critical transport or models that incorporate critical transport or transformation mechanisms, allowing predictions of transformation mechanisms, allowing predictions of concentrationconcentration--time and space profiles leading to the site time and space profiles leading to the site of actionof action((to doto do:: make correlations between animal models and human make correlations between animal models and human applicationapplication))

4) incorporate pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic 4) incorporate pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic information to help design and implement more effect information to help design and implement more effect treatments for CNS diseasestreatments for CNS diseases((to doto do: educate the many disciplines involved in the discovery, : educate the many disciplines involved in the discovery, development and eventual use of new treatmentsdevelopment and eventual use of new treatments) )

Page 30: Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple ...€¦ · 2011-04-13  · Factors Influencing Drug Delivery to the Brain: Multiple Mechanisms at Multiple Barriers April

30

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgementsGraduate Students:Graduate Students:Sagar AgarwalSagar Agarwal, Ying Chen, , Ying Chen, HaiqingHaiqing Dai,Dai,Tianli Wang, Li Tianli Wang, Li LiLi, Ramola Sane, Ramola SaneCollaborators:Collaborators:John Ohlfest and group (Jose, Belle; Pediatrics and John Ohlfest and group (Jose, Belle; Pediatrics and Neurosurgery, UMN) Neurosurgery, UMN) Mike Mike VolgelbaumVolgelbaum, Cleveland Clinic, Cleveland Clinic

Funding:Funding:NIHNIH--NCI, Leukemia Research Fund, BMS, Novartis,NCI, Leukemia Research Fund, BMS, Novartis,ChildrensChildrens Cancer Research FundCancer Research Fund--Minneapolis, MN, Minneapolis, MN, Brain Tumor ProgramBrain Tumor Program--UMnUMn, Masonic Cancer Center, Masonic Cancer Center--UMnUMn, Academic Health Center, Academic Health Center--UMnUMn

Make things as simple as possible,

but not simpler.Albert Einstein

Consilience: Beware of the simplified boxes.

Systems BiologySystems Biology

Mechanistic “Molecular”Pharmacokinetics

Empiric “Black-Box”Pharmacokinetics