ethics of germline gene editing in non-human primates (mildred cho)

8/20/2019 Ethics of Germline Gene Editing in Non-Human Primates (Mildred Cho)

1/25

Htglks jf

Dhri`lch Dhch

Hmltlcd

lc Cjc‒Guioc Rrlioths

Il`mrhm Kgj

[tocfjrm Khcthr fjr Eljihmlko` Htglks


2/25


3/25


4/25


5/25

Dhch hmltlcd

lc

ijcahys

Fhe 52?=

Mhk 52?=

Kycjij`dus

Dhri`lch

KUL[RU Rpor‒

&

Uod?

(Cr2e?)

Clu, \ ht

o`.

Kghc, \ ht o`.

Ior 52?= Ughsus &

Kycjij`dus

]O@HCs IHKR5 @lu, G ht o`.

Nuc

52?= Kycjij`dus ]O@HCs IHKR5 @lu,

^ ht o`.

Fhe 52?8 Kycjij`dus KUL[RU p8; Toc, G ht o`.

Opr 52?8 Ughsus KUL[RU MIM Kghc, \ ht o`.


6/25


7/25


8/25


9/25


10/25


11/25


12/25

Htglko` kjcslmhrotljcs

Tgy dhri`lch dhch hmltlcd jf CGRs:

• Dhch hmltlcd

vs jtghr

trocsdhclk

ihtgjms

‛ Jc‒tordht / jff ‒tordht iutotljcs

‛ Rjthctlo` fjr cu`` iutotljcs, iu`tlp`hx dhchtlk

ioclpu`otljc

• Dhri`lch vs sjiotlk dhchtlk ijmlflkotljcs

‛ Erhhmlcd fjr

guioc

mlshosh

ijmh`s


13/25

• Cjc‒guioc

prlioth

ijmh`s

jf

guioc

mlshosh

‛ Churjpsykglotrlk ocm churjmhdhchrotlvh mlshoshs (GM, Uhtt [ycmrjih)

‛ Kockhr ‛ Liiuclty

‛ Guioc‒`lchodh sphklflk dhchs

• @ocduodh• Kjdcltljc

• Jtghr ehgovljro` trolts


Tgy dhri`lch dhch hmltlcd jf CGRs:


14/25


Ulsas ocm

ehchflts

• ]gh utl`ltorloc vlhw> whldglcd `lah`lgjjm jf

ehchflt wltg

rlsa

‛ Ulsas tj CGRs

‛ Ulsas tj guiocs


15/25

52?? LJI/CUK

rhpjrt

• Kglipoczhhs lc Eljihmlko` ocm Ehgovljro`

Uhshorkg> Osshsslcd

tgh

Chkhsslty

‛ Eljihmlko` rhshorkg krlthrlo prjpjshm>

• Cj jtghr sultoe`h ijmh` ovol`oe`h

• Uhshorkg koccjt

eh

phrfjrihm

htglko``y

jc

guioc

suenhkts

• Fjrdjlcd kglipoczhh rhshorkg wl`` s`jw jr prhvhct

omvockhihcts tj

prhvhct

jr

trhot

`lfh

‒tgrhothclcd

jr

mhel`ltotlcd kjcmltljcs


16/25


Ulsas ocm

ehchflts

• Eljihmlko` rhshorkg uslcd stjrhm soip`hs ls

hxhipt

• Oclio`s iust eh iolctolchm hltghr lc

htgj`jdlko``y opprjprloth pgyslko` ocm sjklo`

hcvlrjcihcts jr lc coturo` goeltots


17/25

52?? LJI/CUK

Uhpjrt

• ‐…utl`ltorloc nustlflkotljcs fjri port jf tgh

rotljco`h fjr

kjctlcuhm

rhshorkg

lc

oclio`s1

tgot ls, oclio`s orh suenhkthm tj rlsa fjr tgh

ehchflt jf guiocs, ocm nustlflkotljc rh`lhs jc

osshssihcts tgot

tgh

ehchflts

dolchm

frji

rhshorkg jc oclio`s orh sufflklhct tj jutwhldg

tgh goris koushm lc tgh prjkhss.’


18/25

52?? LJI/CUK

Uhpjrt

• ‐Rurh`y utl`ltorloc nustlflkotljcs orh thiphrhm

lc oclio`

rhshorkg

tgrjudg

pj`lky

rhqulrhihcts fjr guioch trhotihct ocm tgh ush jf opprjprloth sphklhs ocm ilclio`

cuiehr jf

oclio`s.’

• ‐Furtghrijrh, lipjslcd rhqulrhihcts fjr nustlfylcd tgh ush jf gldghr sphklhs ls oc

lip`lklt rhkjdcltljc

tgot

tgh

ush

jf

gldghr

oclio`s kjihs ot gldghr ijro` kjsts.’


19/25

52?? LJI/CUK

Uhpjrt

• ‐Tgl`h tgh kglipoczhh gos ehhc o vo`uoe`h

oclio`

ijmh`

lc

post

rhshorkg,

ijst

kurrhct

ush

jf kglipoczhhs

fjr

eljihmlko`

rhshorkg

ls

ucchkhssory, eoshm jc tgh krlthrlo hstoe`lsghm ey tgh kjiiltthh, hxkhpt pjthctlo``y fjr twj kurrhct

rhshorkg ushs>’

‛ O `lilthm cuiehr jf ijcjk`jco` octlejmlhs o`rhomy lc tgh mhvh`jpihcto` plph`lch

‛ Mhvh`jpihct jf prjpgy`oktlk ghpotltls K vlrus (cj

kjcshcsus jc

kjiiltthh)

‛ O chw, hihrdlcd, jr rhhihrdlcd mlshosh ioy rhqulrh futurh ush jf tgh kglipoczhh


20/25

Osshsslcd `lah`lgjjm

jf

ehchflt

• Uh`hvockh tj guioc mlshosh, h.d.,

‛ CGR rhshorkg gos cjt prhmlkthm guioc rhspjcsh tj vlro` vokklchs

wh``

‛ Liiuch systhis vory drhot`y ehtwhhc sphklhs (Vo``hcmhr & Il``hr 52?;)

‛ [jih churjpsykglotrlk kjcmltljcs jf lcthrhst (skglzjpgrhclo,

outlsi)

orh

suddhsthm

tj

eh

guioc

‒

sphklflk ocm ossjklothm dhchs ucmhr rhkhct pjsltlvh sh`hktljc (h.d., ]hffhr ocm [hihcmhfhrl 52?5)

‛ @lilthm kjdcltlvh ehgovljro` thsts fjr iorijshts, sio``

ghom slzh

ioahs

liodlcd

mlfflku`t

(Kgoc,

522


21/25

Liprjvlcd `lah`lgjjm

jf

ehchflt

• [phklhs‒sphklflk dhcjilk vorlotljc (Vo``hcmhr & Il``hr

52?;) ‛ Dhchtlk vorlotljc lc CGRs ls iukg ijrh hxthcslvh

tgoc vorlotljc lc guiocs, eut `hss wh``‒ucmhrstjjm

‛

]ghrh

orh

vhry

fhw

trocs‒

sphklhs

pj`yijrpglsis

lc

guiocs ocm kglipoczhhs (Gjmdalcsjc & Hyrh‒To`ahr

52?2)

‛ Lip`lkotljcs jf vorlotljc lc kytjkgrjih R=82 dhchs

ocm hffhkts jc mrud ihtoej`lsi lc CGRs cjt wh``‒acjwc


22/25


jf

ehchflt

• [tumy mhsldc ([hco ht o`. 5224)

‛ Oclio` stumlhs

jf

mrud

jr

elj`jdlko`

trhotihcts

orh jfthc sukkhssfu` wghrh sueshquhct guioc

stumlhs orh cjt


23/25


jf

ehchflt

• Oclio` stumlhs

tgot

skjrh

gldghr jc stumy quo`lty

kghka`lsts prjmukhm

suestoctlo``y `jwhr

hstlioths jf hffhkt slzh

tgoc `jwhr skjrlcd

stumlhs ([hco ht

o`.

5224)


24/25


jf

ehchflt

• Cjc‒rocmjilzhm stumlhs

govh gldghr

hstlioths

jf

hfflkoky tgoc rocmjilzhm

stumlhs

• [tumlhs wltgjut e`lcmhm

jutkjih osshssihct govh gldghr hstlioths jf

hfflkoky tgoc e`lcmhm

stumlhs ‛ (voc mhr Tjrp ht o` . 5224)


25/25

Kjckùsljcs• Dhri`lch dhch hmltlcd jf CGRs rolshs slilòr

htglko` lssuhs

os

tgjsh

rolshm

ey

jtghr

trocsdhclk

ihtgjms

• Gjwhvhr, dhch hmltlcd gos tgh pjthctlo` tj

erjomhc

tgh

orroy

jf

CGR

ijmh`s

jf

guioc

mlshosh tj lckùmh ijrh mhel`ltotlcd pghcjtyphs

• [ukg lcmuktljc jf shrljus mlshosh koc jc`y eh

nustlflhm

ey

korhfu`

ocm

rho`lstlk

osshssihct

jf

ehchflts `lah`y tj okkruh frji CGR ijmh`s ocm ush jf rldjrjus stumy mhsldc

ethics of germline gene editing in non-human primates (mildred cho)

Documents