elasticity of thera-band r resistance bandsstretching the bands and graphing the stress vs. strain....

1
Elasticity of Thera-Band R Resistance Bands Kelsey McLaughlin and Aaron Titus Department of Exercise Science and Department of Chemistry and Physics High Point University, High Point, NC Abstract The elastic properties of Thera-Band R resistance bands were investigated to determine whether the material could be used in an introductory physics experiment for life sci- ence majors. Green and black bands were studied by stretching the bands and graphing the stress vs. strain. As expected for this material, resistance bands are non-linear. However, for greater than 40% strain, the material is ap- proximately linear. For longer bands (1.7 m), the elastic modulus was consistent for the two colors. For shorter bands (0.8 m), the elastic modulus for the green band was slightly less than the elastic modulus for the black band. For both colors, the elastic modulus for shorter bands was less than the elastic modulus for longer bands. Background Resistance bands are typically used by physical therapy patients to do resistance exercises needed to build strength and increase range of motion. The resistance bands are spring-like in that the magnitude of the force F required to stretch them a distance s from their unstretched length in- creases with increasing distance. Materials for which this relationship is linear are called linear materials. For a linear material: F = ks (Hooke’s Law). (1) If a resistance band is modeled as a spring, then its stiffness k depends on the length L, width w , and thickness t of the band. When a patient or physical therapist wishes to increase the stiffness of the band, she shortens the band or selects a band of greater thickness or width. This can be understood with a simple model of a solid as balls connected by springs. L W T Increasing the width and thickness of a solid is like adding chains of springs in parallel which increases the effective stiffness of the solid. Increasing the length of a solid is like adding chains of springs in series which decreases the stiffness of the solid. Apparatus A force sensor was used to measure the force on the band and a rotary motion sensor was used to measure the dis- tance stretched. A set of large binder clips was used to hold each end of the band. Material Thera-Bands come in various colors which correspond to different resistances. The bands are made of the same material but vary in width and thickness. Increasing the width and/or the thickness will result in a band with higher resistance. We analyzed a green and a black band at two different lengths. A black =4.69 × 10 -5 m 2 L black,1 =1.77 m L black,2 =0.81 m A green =2.78 × 10 -5 m 2 L green,1 =1.71 m L green,2 =0.81 m Results Stress vs. Strain (Trial 8, Black Band, L=1.7 m) 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0 200000 400000 600000 800000 Strain (m/m) Stress (N/m^2) Linear Fit for: Latest | Stress Stress = mx+b m (Slope): 8.418E+05 N/m^2/m/m b (Y-Intercept): 1.731E+05 N/m^2 Correlation: 0.9995 RMSE: 2666 N/m^2 Stress vs. Strain (Trial 6, Black Band, L=0.81 m) 0.0 0.5 1.0 0 500000 1000000 Strain (m/m) Stress (N/m^2) Linear Fit for: Latest | Stress Stress = mx+b m (Slope): 6.617E+05 N/m^2/m/m b (Y-Intercept): 2.497E+05 N/m^2 Correlation: 0.9994 RMSE: 4869 N/m^2 Stiffness, k (N/m) Band Length (m) k ave (N/m) range (m) Black 1.77 21.7 ± 0.2 0.7 – 1.1 Green 1.71 13.4 ± 0.3 0.7 – 1.1 Black 0.81 39.3 ± 1.5 0.3 – 0.9 Green 0.81 20.6 ± 1.2 0.3 – 1.1 Results Elastic Modulus, (N/m 2 ) Band Length (m) EM ave (N/m 2 ) range (m) Black 1.77 8.44×10 5 ± 1.4×10 4 0.3 – 0.63 Green 1.71 8.41×10 5 ± 0.9×10 4 0.3 – 0.67 Black 0.81 6.73×10 5 ± 2.6×10 4 0.4 – 1.0 Green 0.81 5.99×10 5 ± 3.5×10 4 0.4 – 1.0 Resistance in pounds at 100% elongation Band Company Reported estimated from L 1 measured from L 2 Black 7.3 10.7 9.7 Green 4.6 6.2 5.4 Conclusion The bands are non-linear. The black band is stiffer than the green band due to its larger cross-sectional area. Decreasing the length results in greater stiffness, but these changes are not proportional. The elastic modulus in the linear region decreased as length decreased. The resistance measurements at 100% elongation were not consistent with values reported by Thera-Band. Thera-Band should report the lengths of the bands used to measure resistance values to ensure repeatability. References Thera-Band Academy, Elastic Resistance Student Handbook: Clinical Principles of Elastic Resistance Training, Elastic Resistance booklet 5.5x8.5 REV1 V2.indd

Upload: others

Post on 08-Jul-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Elasticity of Thera-Band R Resistance Bandsstretching the bands and graphing the stress vs. strain. As expected for this material, resistance bands are non-linear. However, for greater

Elasticity of Thera-Band R© Resistance BandsKelsey McLaughlin and Aaron Titus

Department of Exercise Science and Department of Chemistry and PhysicsHigh Point University, High Point, NC

AbstractThe elastic properties of Thera-Band R© resistance bandswere investigated to determine whether the material couldbe used in an introductory physics experiment for life sci-ence majors. Green and black bands were studied bystretching the bands and graphing the stress vs. strain. Asexpected for this material, resistance bands are non-linear.However, for greater than 40% strain, the material is ap-proximately linear. For longer bands (1.7 m), the elasticmodulus was consistent for the two colors. For shorterbands (0.8 m), the elastic modulus for the green band wasslightly less than the elastic modulus for the black band.For both colors, the elastic modulus for shorter bands wasless than the elastic modulus for longer bands.

BackgroundResistance bands are typically used by physical therapypatients to do resistance exercises needed to build strengthand increase range of motion. The resistance bands arespring-like in that the magnitude of the force F required tostretch them a distance s from their unstretched length in-creases with increasing distance. Materials for which thisrelationship is linear are called linear materials. For a linearmaterial:

F = ks (Hooke’s Law). (1)

If a resistance band is modeled as a spring, then its stiffnessk depends on the length L, width w, and thickness t ofthe band. When a patient or physical therapist wishes toincrease the stiffness of the band, she shortens the band orselects a band of greater thickness or width.This can be understood with a simple model of a solid asballs connected by springs.

!

L

W

T

Increasing the width and thickness of a solid is like addingchains of springs in parallel which increases the effectivestiffness of the solid. Increasing the length of a solid islike adding chains of springs in series which decreases thestiffness of the solid.

Apparatus

A force sensor was used to measure the force on the bandand a rotary motion sensor was used to measure the dis-tance stretched. A set of large binder clips was used tohold each end of the band.

MaterialThera-Bands come in various colors which correspond todifferent resistances.

The bands are made of the same material but vary in widthand thickness. Increasing the width and/or the thicknesswill result in a band with higher resistance. We analyzed agreen and a black band at two different lengths.Ablack = 4.69× 10−5 m2 Lblack,1 = 1.77 m Lblack,2 = 0.81 m

Agreen = 2.78× 10−5 m2 Lgreen,1 = 1.71 m Lgreen,2 = 0.81 m

Results

Stress vs. Strain (Trial 8, Black Band, L=1.7 m)

0.0 0.2 0.4 0.60

200000

400000

600000

800000

Strain (m/m)

Stre

ss (

N/m

^2

)

Linear Fit for: Latest | StressStress = mx+bm (Slope): 8.418E+05 N/m^2/m/mb (Y-Intercept): 1.731E+05 N/m^2Correlation: 0.9995RMSE: 2666 N/m^2

Stress vs. Strain (Trial 6, Black Band, L=0.81 m)

0.0 0.5 1.0

0

500000

1000000

Strain (m/m)

Stre

ss (

N/m

^2

)

Linear Fit for: Latest | StressStress = mx+bm (Slope): 6.617E+05 N/m^2/m/mb (Y-Intercept): 2.497E+05 N/m^2Correlation: 0.9994RMSE: 4869 N/m^2

Stiffness, k (N/m)

Band Length (m) kave (N/m) range (m)

Black 1.77 21.7 ± 0.2 0.7 – 1.1Green 1.71 13.4 ± 0.3 0.7 – 1.1Black 0.81 39.3 ± 1.5 0.3 – 0.9Green 0.81 20.6 ± 1.2 0.3 – 1.1

Results

Elastic Modulus, (N/m2)

Band Length (m) EMave (N/m2) range (m)

Black 1.77 8.44×105±1.4×104

0.3 – 0.63

Green 1.71 8.41×105±0.9×104

0.3 – 0.67

Black 0.81 6.73×105±2.6×104

0.4 – 1.0

Green 0.81 5.99×105±3.5×104

0.4 – 1.0

Resistance in pounds at 100% elongation

Band CompanyReported

estimatedfrom L1

measuredfrom L2

Black 7.3 10.7 9.7Green 4.6 6.2 5.4

Conclusion•The bands are non-linear.

•The black band is stiffer than the green band due to itslarger cross-sectional area.

•Decreasing the length results in greater stiffness, butthese changes are not proportional.

•The elastic modulus in the linear region decreased aslength decreased.

•The resistance measurements at 100% elongation werenot consistent with values reported by Thera-Band.

•Thera-Band should report the lengths of the bands usedto measure resistance values to ensure repeatability.

References

Thera-Band Academy, Elastic Resistance Student Handbook:Clinical Principles of Elastic Resistance Training,Elastic Resistance booklet 5.5x8.5 REV1 V2.indd