dutch disease article

14
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

Upload: jan-rutherford

Post on 01-Jul-2015

145 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Dutch disease article

!?5:2?�"@FC?2=�@7��4@?@>:4D����FD:?6DD��.@=� ���&@� ����� ���� �� ��

� #@C36=�+49@@=�@7�!?E6C?2E:@?2=�+EF5:6D��-?:G6CD:EJ�@7��6?G6C����� �+@FE9��2J=@C5�+EC66E���6?G6C��'���������)�&(��!"."'�+(/+* �//+*&),+.0/� +)

(�%������%���$)�!% �$��� �$��#�����

��'��%����&%�����$��$���

�'��������# ��#����%���%�

��#��� �$ ��

�+897*,9

�"/+1. "�.& %� +1*0.&"/�+#0"*�"4,".&"* "�(�.$"�$.+30%�&*�0%"&.�"4,+.0/��/���."/1(0�+#

!.�/0& �/3&*$/�&*� +))+!&05�,.& &*$���."(�*!�&/�*+0���."/+1. "�.& %� +1*0.5���*0&(

�����."(�*!�"4,".&"* "!�(&00("�0+�*+�&))&$.�0&+*���*�0%"�)&!�����8/��."(�*!�")�.� "!

/"2".�(�" +*+)& ��*!�/+ &�(�"4,".&"* "/�0%�0��1&(0�0%"��"(0& ��&$".�� +*+)5���/1�((5�

�+2".*)"*0/�3&0%�."/+1. "�.& %� +1*0.&"/��."�." &,&"*0/�+#�/&$*&#& �*0�&* +)"�#(+3

#.+)�*�01.�(�."/+1. "/���."(�*!8/�.& %�."/+1. "/��."�&0/�,"+,("���%.+1$%�!"(�5"!�/+ &�(

$.+30%����!"(�5"!�#")&*&/0�)+2")"*0��%1$"�#+."&$*��&!��/+)"��1/&*"//�#.&"*!(5��*!

0�4��!2�*0�$"+1/�(�3/���������/& �" +*+)& � �0 %�1,�,+(& &"/��*!��,,(&"!�/ .1,("/

�*!�%+*"/05�+#�0%"��.&/%�,"+,("��0%"��"(0& ��&$".�3�/��+.*���%"*�0%.+1$%����++)�&*

!+)"/0& � )+*"5� /1,,(&"/� �*!� .�&/&*$� &*#(�0&+*�� �(+*$� 3&0%� &* ."!&�("� 3"�(0%

)&/)�*�$")"*0��*!�0%"�.",". 1//&+*/�+#���."�(�"/0�0"���/"!�$.+30%70%"��&$".�!&"!�

�%&/�,�,".� &*2"/0&$�0"/� 0%"��"%�2&+.�+#�$+2".*)"*0� ("�!"./%&,� "4,"*!&01."�,+(& 5

�*!� 9."� 0&+*�.5� " +*+)& /:� &*� ."(�0&+*� 0+����++)��1/0� /0+.5�+#��� +1*0.5�%&$%(5

!","*!"*0�+*�."�(�"/0�0"������*!�3&0%+10�3&0��/�0+� 0%"� �1/"�+#� &0/�/1 "//���%&/

,�,".�!&/ 1//"/�0%"��!2"./"�"##" 0/�+#��10 %��&/"�/"��*!�!"0�&(/�%+3��."(�*!��0%+1$%

*+0�%&*$"!�1,+*�+*"�&*!&2&!1�(��++)&*$�*�01.�(�."/+1. "��%�/�/1##"."!�0%.+1$%�0%"

/�)"�/5),0+)/�+#��10 %��&/"�/"���%&/�,�,".� (�//&#&"/��."(�*!��/���." "*0(5�")".$"!

" +*+)5��*!� 1.."*0(5�+*"�&*�!&."�*""!�+#�#&4&*$�

�."(�*!� �/� �� +1*0.5� %�/� *+0� $.+3*�3&0%� &0/� *"&$%�+./�� �%&/� ,�,".� !"/ .&�"/� 0%"

$.+30%�!1.&*$���������*!�0%"�/1�/"-1"*0� +((�,/"�

�� ��%# �&�%� �

*6D@FC46C:49�4@F?EC:6D�@7E6?�6IA6C:6?46�=2C86�8C@HE9�:?�E96:C�6IA@CED�2D�2�C6DF=E@7�5C2DE:4�DH:?8D�:?�4@>>@5:EJ�AC:4:?8�-?E:=������!C6=2?5�6IA6C:6?465�=:EE=6�E@�?@:>>:8C2E:@?� !?� E96�>:5� ���PD� !C6=2?5� 6>3C2465� D6G6C2=� 64@?@>:4� 2?5� D@4:2=6IA6C:6?46D� E92E� 3F:=E� E96��6=E:4�,:86C��4@?@>J�-DF2==J���@G6C?>6?ED�H:E9C6D@FC46� C:49� 4@F?EC:6D� 2C6� C64:A:6?ED� @7� D:8?:7:42?E� :?4@>6� 7=@H� 7C@>�?2EFC2=C6D@FC46D�!C6=2?5PD�C:49�C6D@FC46D�2C6�:ED�A6@A=6�,9C@F89�56=2J65�D@4:2=�8C@HE9

Page 2: Dutch disease article

�� �6C6<�'=D@?

�2�56=2J65�76>:?:DE�>@G6>6?E��9F86�7@C6:8?�2:5��D@>6�3FD:?6DD�7C:6?5=J�2?5�E2I25G2?E286@FD�=2HD����!��32D:4�64@?@>:4�42E49FA�A@=:4:6D�2?5�2AA=:65�D4CFA=6D�2?59@?6DEJ�@7� E96� !C:D9�A6@A=6�� E96��6=E:4�,:86C�H2D�3@C?�,96?�E9C@F89�2�3@@>� :?5@>6DE:4�>@?6J� DFAA=:6D� 2?5� C2:D:?8� :?7=2E:@?�� 2=@?8�H:E9� :?4C65:3=6�H62=E9>:D>2?286>6?E�2?5�E96�C6A6C4FDD:@?D�@7�2�C62=�6DE2E6�32D65�8C@HE9NE96�,:86C5:65�,9:D�A2A6C�:?G6DE:82E6D�E96�3692G:@C�@7�8@G6C?>6?E�=6256CD9:A�6IA6?5:EFC6A@=:4J�2?5�QC624E:@?2CJ�64@?@>:4DR� :?�C6=2E:@?�E@�2�3@@>3FDE�DE@CJ�@7�2�4@F?ECJ9:89=J�56A6?56?E�@?�C62=�6DE2E6���!�2?5�H:E9@FE�H:E�2D�E@�E96�42FD6�@7�:ED�DF446DD,9:D�A2A6C�5:D4FDD6D�E96�25G6CD6�67764ED�@7��FE49��:D62D6�2?5�56E2:=D�9@H�!C6=2?5�E9@F89�?@E�9:?865�FA@?�@?6� :?5:G:5F2=�3@@>:?8�?2EFC2=� C6D@FC46��92D� DF776C65E9C@F89�E96�D2>6�DJ>AE@>D�@7��FE49��:D62D6�,9:D�A2A6C�4=2DD:7:6D�!C6=2?5�2D�2C646?E=J�6>6C865�64@?@>J�2?5�4FCC6?E=J�@?6�:?�5:C6�?665�@7�7:I:?8

/6�H:==� 6IA=2:?� E96� 67764ED� @7� E96��FE49��:D62D6� E92E� A=28F65� !C6=2?5� :?4@CC6DA@?56?46�H:E9� E96� !>>:D6C:K:?8��C@HE9�,96@CJ� 2?5� 255:E:@?2=�>24C@64@?@>:4�2AA=:42E:@?D�� DF49�2D� DE6C:=:K65� 7@C6:8?�6I492?86� :?E6CG6?E:@?��>@56DE42A:E2=�4@?EC@=D�2?5�7:D42=�E:89E6?:?8

� %�� #�%�����$��%� �� �&%�����$��$���!!�����% ���!� !��

�# &!

!?� �����E96�5:D4@G6CJ�@7�?2EFC2=�82D�:?�E96�&@CE9�+62��23@G6�,96�&6E96C=2?5D��=65E@�2�8C62E�5:D25G2?E286@FD�:>A24E�@?�E96��FE49�64@?@>J�,96�=2C86�7@C6:8?�6I492?8682:?D�7C@>�6IA@CE:?8�E96�?2EFC2=�82D�42E2=JK65�2?�FAH2C5�D9:7E�:?�AC:46D�2?5�:?�E96=@42=�6I492?86�C2E6D��E9FD�42FD:?8�AC6G:@FD=J�4@>A6E:E:G6�6IA@CE6CD�E@�=@D6�>2C<6ED92C6�2?5�A@E6?E:2=�62C?:?8D�2?5�E96�4@==2AD6�@7�E96�4@F?ECJPD�6IA@CE�3FD:?6DDN7C@>�H:E9:?�Q,96��FE49��:D62D6R�:D�E96�E:E=6�@7�,96��4@?@>:DE�2CE:4=6�7C@>� ���H9:49� 7:CDE� :56?E:7:6D�� 2AE=J�?2>6D� 2?5�5:D4FDD6D� E9:D� :?D:5:@FD�3FE�?@E�F?:BF664@?@>:4�D:EF2E:@?�,96��FE49��:D62D6��:?�4@>A=6E6�=2J>2?PD�E6C>D��:D�E96�C65F4E:@?@7�2�4@F?ECJPD�6IA@CE�A6C7@C>2?46�2?5�?2E:@?2=�64@?@>J�5F6�E@�2?�2AAC64:2E:@?�@7E96:C�6I492?86�C2E6�5F6�E@�E96�5:D4@G6CJ�@7�2�?2EFC2=�C6D@FC46

,96� E96@CJ�2CE:4F=2E6D� E96� :?4C62D6� :?�C6G6?F6D� 7C@>�?2EFC2=� C6D@FC46� �G:26IA@CED�� 2D� 92G:?8� 2� ?682E:G6� 67764E� @?� E96� ?2E:@?PD� 64@?@>J� 3J� C2:D:?8� E966I492?86�C2E6�E9C@F89�E96�=@DD�@7�5@>6DE:4�:?5FDECJ��F6�E@�E96�:?4C62D65�7@C6:8?C6D6CG6D�E96C6�:D�2�9:896C�>@?6J�DFAA=J�=@42==J�H9:49�=625D�E@�9:896C�AC:46D�2?5:?� EFC?� :?4C62D:?8� :?7=2E:@?� C2E6D� ,9:D�>2<6D� H2J� 7@C� 2� =@DD� :?� 5@>6DE:4>2?F724EFC:?8� 4@>A6E:E:G6?6DD�� 2?5� E96� 6G6C�H2E497F=� AF3=:4� D6CG:46D� 36:?86?EH:?65�H:E9�3FD:?6DD�:?E6C6DED�7@==@H�:?�DF:E�,96�42FD6D�@7��FE49��:D62D6�2C62=D@�C64@8?:K65�2D�G2C:65�3642FD6�:E�:D�6IEC6>6=J�5:77:4F=E�E@�:?76C�E92E�E96�56>:D6@7�2�4@F?ECJPD�>2?F724EFC:?8��6IA@CE�64@?@>J�2?5�:?7=2E:@?�C2E6D�42?�36�2EEC:3FE65D@=6=J�E@�D:8?:7:42?E�?2EFC2=�C6D@FC46�23F?52?46�Q�=E9@F89�E96�5:D62D6�:D�86?6C2==J2DD@4:2E65�H:E9�2�?2EFC2=�C6D@FC46�5:D4@G6CJ��:E�42?�@44FC�7C@>�2?J�56G6=@A>6?EE92E�C6DF=ED�:?�2�=2C86�:?7=@H�@7�7@C6:8?�4FCC6?4J��:?4=F5:?8�2�D92CA�DFC86�:?�?2EFC2=C6D@FC46� AC:46D�� 7@C6:8?� 2DD:DE2?46�� 2?5� 7@C6:8?�5:C64E� :?G6DE>6?ER� ��3C29:>12569������

Page 3: Dutch disease article

/:E9�2==�E96�+J>AE@>D���@6D�!C6=2?5�92G6�E96��FE49��:D62D6� ��

,96�Q�@C6�%@56=R�56E2:=:?8�Q�FE49��:D62D6R�:D�2EEC:3FE65�E@�64@?@>:DED�/�%2I�@C56?�2?5�"�(6E6C�&62CJ�� �����@C56?�2?5�&62CJ�3C62<�5@H?� E96� DF776C:?84@F?ECJPD� 64@?@>J� :?E@� 2�?@?EC2565� 8@@5� D64E@C� 2?5� EH@� EC2565� 8@@5� D64E@CD�E96�3@@>:?8�D64E@C��2?5�E96�=288:?8�D64E@C��2=D@�42==65�E96�?@?3@@>:?8�EC2523=6D64E@C� 2?5� E96�?@?EC256� 8@@5D� D64E@CN32D:42==J� 5@>6DE:4� C6E2:=�� D6CG:46D�� 2?5C6D:56?E:2=�3F:=5:?8�,96J�=:DE�E96�3@@>:?8�D64E@C�2D�E96�AC@5F4E:@?�4@F?ECJPD�?2EFC2=C6D@FC46� @C� ?6H� =2C86� 8C@HE9� :?5FDECJ� 2?5� E96� =288:?8� D64E@C� EJA:42==J� 2D>2?F724EFC:?8

��C6D@FC46�3@@>�92D�EH@�D:8?:7:42?E�67764ED�@?�2?J�64@?@>J�!?�E96�QC6D@FC46>@G6>6?E�67764ER��@C56?� ������E96�3@@>�:?4C62D6D�E96�56>2?5�7@C�=23@C��42FD:?8AC@5F4E:@?�E@�D9:7E� E@H2C5D�E96�3@@>�2?5�5C:7E� 7C@>�E96� =288:?8�D64E@C�+9:7E:?87C@>�E96�=288:?8�D64E@C�E@�E96�3@@>:?8�D64E@C�:D�42==65�5:C64E56:?5FDEC:2=:K2E:@?��@C56?���&62CJ� �����,96� QDA6?5:?8�67764ER� ��@C56?� ����� :D� 2� C6DF=E� @7� E96255:E:@?2=�C6G6?F6�24BF:C65�E9C@F89�E96�C6D@FC46�3@@>��J�:?4C62D:?8�56>2?5�@7=23@C�:?�E96�?@?EC2523=6�D64E@C��:E�D9:7ED�7C@>�E96�=288:?8�D64E@C�E@�E96�?@?EC2523=6D64E@CN:?5:C64E56:?5FDEC:2=:K2E:@?���@C56?� ����

/9:=6�42A:E2=�:?7=@HD�92D�2�46CE2:?�4@?DF>AE:@?�6?92?4:?8�67764E��E96�67764E�@?:?G6DE>6?E�:D�86?6C2==J�:?56E6C>:?2E6�2?5�E96�C62=�?F>36CD�>2J�36�D<6H65�3J�E96C62=� 2AAC64:2E:@?�?@C>2==J� 244@>A2?J:?8� =2C86� :?7=@HD� @7� 42A:E2=�� G:2� D6G6C2=D@FC46D�,96�6IA6C:6?46� @7� 2�?F>36C� @7� 6>6C8:?8�>2C<6E� 64@?@>:6D�92D� D9@H?E92E�E96�C62=�2AAC64:2E:@?�5F6�E@�42A:E2=�:?7=@HD�>2J�?@E�@?=J�56E6C�:?G6DE>6?E�3FE42?�D6G6C6=J�56DE23:=:K6�>24C@64@?@>:4�>2?286>6?E�2D�2�H9@=6���@C56?�� ����!?� @C56C� E@�2G@:5� DF49��FE49��:D62D6� 67764ED�� 6>6C8:?8�>2C<6E� 64@?@>:6D�92G62AA=:65�2�?F>36C� @7�5:776C6?E�A@=:4:6D�� DE6C:=:K65� 7@C6:8?�6I492?86� :?E6CG6?E:@?�>@56DE�42A:E2=�4@?EC@=D�2?5�7:D42=�E:89E6?:?8�2C6�A6C92AD�E96�>@DE�A@AF=2C

,@�255C6DD� E96��FE49��:D62D6�A96?@>6?@?�2?�2?2=JD:D� @7� E96� !>>:D6C:K:?8�C@HE9��C2A9�42?�36�2AA=:65��FD:?8�E9:D�56>2?5�C6=2E:G6�DFAA=J�8C2A9:42=�2?2=JD:D2D�7@==@HD

$6EPD�DE2CE�H:E9�EH@�4@F?EC:6D��-+�2?5�!C6=2?5�:?�2� '�H@C=5��249�4@F?ECJAC@5F46D�EH@�8@@5D���F:??6DD�����2?5�.:28C2��.���FD:?8�EH@�724E@CD�@7�AC@5F4E:@?�=23@C�2?5�42A:E2=�/6�2DDF>6�96C6�E92E�8@@5���:D�C6=2E:G6=J�=23@C�:?E6?D:G6�H9:=6�.:D� E96� C6=2E:G6=J� 42A:E2=� :?E6?D:G6� 24E:G:EJ�/6�2=D@�2DDF>6� E92E� E96�-+� :D� E96C6=2E:G6=J�42A:E2=�23F?52?E�4@F?ECJ

&@H�=6EPD�4@?D:56C�E96�7C66�EC256�36EH66?�3@E9�4@F?EC:6D�!7�E96C6�:D�2�8C@HE9�:?E96�!C:D9�6IA@CE�D64E@C��H9:49�:D��F:??6DD��244@C5:?8�E@�E96� '�E96@C6>NE96�8@@5FD:?8�E92E�724E@C��:?E6?D:G6��C:D6D�3J�2�8C62E6C�AC@A@CE:@?�@7�E96�:?4C62D6�@7�724E@C2?5�E96�2>@F?E�@7�.:28C2�AC@5F465�564C62D6D

,96C67@C6��=6EPD�2DDF>6�E92E�E96C6�:D�2?�:?4C62D6�:?�E96�DFAA=J�@7�=23@C�:?�!C6=2?5-D:?8�E96�H@C=5�C6=2E:G6�DFAA=J�H@C=5�C6=2E:G6�56>2?5�8C2A9�36=@H��H6�42?�D9@HE96�67764ED�@7� E96� :?4C62D6� :?�E96�DFAA=J�@7� =23@C�2?5� E96C67@C6�8C@HE9�@7�6IA@CED64E@C�:?�!C6=2?5�@?�E96�C6=2E:G6�AC:46�@7��F:??6DD�:?�E96�H@C=5

Page 4: Dutch disease article

�� �6C6<�'=D@?

,96�EH@�2AA2C6?E�67764ED�96C6�2C6��E96�8C@HE9�:?�2�724E@C�@7�AC@5F4E:@?�H9:49D9:7ED� E96�((��@FEH2C5�� :?4C62D:?8� E96�H6=72C6� 7@C� !C6=2?5�,9:D� :D� DJ?@?J>@FDH:E9�E96�:?4C62D6�:?�8@@5���AC@5F465�:?�!C6=2?5�,96�@E96C�67764E�:D�E96�72==�@7�!C:D9,',��=625:?8�E@�2�?682E:G6�H6=72C6�67764E�+:?46�!C6=2?5�:D�DFAA=J:?8�>@C6�@7� :ED6IA@CE�8@@5�E@�:ED�EC25:?8�A2CE?6C�D9@HD�2�72==�:?�E96�AC:46�@7�E9:D�8@@5��2?5�E9FD�272==�:?�E96�,',�7@C�!C6=2?5

,96�?6E�67764E�@?�!C6=2?5�:D�4@>A=6E6=J�56A6?56?E�@?�H96E96C�E96�8C@HE9�67764E@C�E96�,',�67764E�:D�=2C86C�!7�E96�:?4C62D6�:?�AC@5F4E:@?�@FEH6:89D�E96�564=:?6�:?,',��E96?�E96�?6E�H6=72C6�67764E�@?�!C6=2?5�:D�A@D:E:G6

*6G6CD6=J�D@��:7�E96�72==�:?�AC:46�:D�8C62E6C�E92?�E96�:?4C62D6�:?�AC@5F4E:@?��E96?E96�8C@HE9� :D� 42FD:?8�2�56AC64:2E:@?�@7�H6=72C6� :?� !C6=2?5�,9:D� C6DF=E� :D� 42==65Q:>>:K6C:D:?8�8C@HE9R 6C6�!C6=2?5�72C6D�H@CD6�:?�7C66�EC256��4@>A2C65�E@�64@?@>:4DE2E6�AC6465:?8�8C@HE9��@?46�:E�6IA6C:6?46D�2�3@@>�:?�:ED�6IA@CE�D64E@C��2?5�:?�@FC42D6�2?�:?�A@FC:?8�@7���!�

,9:D�H@F=5�92AA6?� :7� E96� 56>2?5� 7@C��F:??6DD�3J� E96�-+� :D� :?6=2DE:4�� 2?:?4C62D6� :?� @FEAFE� =625D� E@� 2� 8C62E6C�A6C46?E286� 564=:?6� :?� AC:46�� C65F4:?8� E96C6G6?F6D� 7@C� E96� D6==6C�,9:D� 2?2=JD:D� 6IA=2:?D�H9J� 4@F?EC:6D�H9@� D6==� 46CE2:?AC@5F4ED�:?�E96�H@C=5�>2C<6E�AC676C�?@E�E@�92G6�2�3@@>�:?�E96:C�6IA@CE�D64E@C

�1/:7.�����0*/<*91�����

Page 5: Dutch disease article

/:E9�2==�E96�+J>AE@>D���@6D�!C6=2?5�92G6�E96��FE49��:D62D6� �

!?�2DD6DD:?8�E96�!C:D9�64@?@>J�3@@>�@7�7C@>� ����E:==�������6IA@CED�A=2J65�2A2CE��3FE�H6C6�?@E�E96�<6J�:?DECF>6?E�@7�E96�64@?@>J�4@==2AD6�:?�����

� � &�%#)� ���#�����

,9C@F89�56=2J65�D@4:2=�8C@HE9��2�56=2J65� 76>:?:DE�>@G6>6?E��9F86�7@C6:8?�2:5�D@>6�3FD:?6DD�7C:6?5=J�2?5�E2I�25G2?E286@FD�=2HD����!��32D:4�64@?@>:4�42E49FAA@=:4:6D�2?5�2AA=:65�D4CFA=6D�2?5�9@?6DEJ�@7�E96�!C:D9�A6@A=6��E96��6=E:4�,:86C�H2D3@C? !?�������!C6=2?5�6?E6C65�2�566A�C646DD:@?�,96�AC6G:@FD� ��J62CD�=625:?8�FAE@�E9:D�A6C764E�DE@C>�H6C6�@7�9:89�64@?@>:4�8C@HE9�2?5�D@4:2=�492?86N7@==@H65�3J2�D92CA�564=:?6�:?�7@C6:8?�EC256��4@==2AD6�@7�E96�7:?2?4:2=�D64E@C��2?5�7@==@H:?8�:?DF:E�2�9@FD:?8�>2C<6E�:>A=@D:@?��#2?52��� ��

!C6=2?5�:D�?@E�=:<6��C62E��C:E2:?�@C�E96�C6DE�@7��FC@A6�7@C�E92E�>2EE6C�!C6=2?5925�?@E�6?;@J65�E96�D2>6�64@?@>:4�8C@HE9�4@?D:DE6?E�H:E9�E96�C6DE�@7�E96��FC@A62?-?:@?�DE2E6D�@C�@7�3:886C�3C@E96C��?8=2?5�@C�:==68:E:>2E6�D:3=:?8�+4@E=2?5�!C6=2?5:D�2�D>2==�A=246�!?�������H96?�!C6=2?5�925�D66?�>@C6�:>>:8C2?ED�:?�E96�AC6G:@FD��564256D�E92?�E96�����J62CD�367@C6�E96?��E96�A@AF=2E:@?�?F>36C�H2D�2AAC@I:>2E6=J���>:==:@?��2C@F?5�E96�D:K6�@7�#6?EF4<J��'P,@@=6��� ��

,96C6�H6C6� D6G6C2=� 724E@CD� 42FD:?8� E96� !C:D9� 64@?@>J� E@� 8C@H� D@�BF:4<=JN=625:?8�FA�E@�E96�3:CE9�@7�E96��6=E:4�,:86C��:CDE� :D�D=:89E=J�4@F?E6C�:?EF:E:G6�3FE

�1/:7.����0*/<*91�����

Page 6: Dutch disease article

�� �6C6<�'=D@?

G6CJ�ECF6��!C6=2?5�925�8C@H?�D@�D=@H=J�367@C6�,96�A6C7@C>2?46�@7�E96�!C:D9�64@?@>JD:?46� :?56A6?56?46� :?� ����H2D� D:>A=J� 23JD>2=� �%F?=6J���,9@C?E@?� ����� :DE@C:2?�"@9?�"@D6A9�$66�4@>>6?E65�:?� �����E92E�Q&@�@E96C��FC@A62?�4@F?ECJ�62DE�@C�H6DE��?@CE9�@C�D@FE9��7@C�H9:49�C6>@E6=J�C6=:23=6�6G:56?46�6I:DED��925�C64@C565D@�D=@H�2�C2E6�@7�8C@HE9�@7�?2E:@?2=�:?4@>6�:?�E96�EH6?E:6E9�46?EFCJR��$66� �����+@!C6=2?5�H2D�D:>A=J�42E49:?8�FA�H:E9�E96�C6DE�@7��FC@A6�,96� ���PD�H6C6�2�E:>6�@79:89�8C@HE9�2?5�H:E9�?@�962GJ�:?5FDEC:2=�9:DE@CJ�9@=5:?8�96C�324<��2�E6>A@C2CJ@FEA6C7@C>2?46�H2D�:?6G:E23=6��?@E�F?=:<6�E96��6C>2?�42E49FA�A6C:@5�5FC:?8�E96:?E6C�H2C�A6C:@5�@7�E96� ���PD

!C6=2?5�H2D��2=@?8�H:E9�E96�C6DE�@7��FC@A6��C62A:?8�E96�36?67:E�@7������3:==:@?�@7�>6C:42?�!?G6DE>6?E�42A:E2=�E92E�7=@H65�7C@>�E96�-?:E65�+E2E6D�E@��FC@A6��E9@F89?@�?F>36CD�H6C6�2G2:=23=6��46CE2:?=J�2�G6CJ�D:8?:7:42?E�DF>��4@>A2C2E:G6=J�DA62<:?8E@� E96� !C:D9� 64@?@>J�@7�52E6��H6?E� E@� E96� =@H�H286�A2J:?8�2?5� C6=2E:G6=J�H6==65F42E65�H@C<�7@C46�@7�!C6=2?5���FC<2?������

��72C�=6DD�BF2?E:7:23=6�<6J�724E@C�H2D�AC@8C6DD:G6�A@=:E:4D�Q,96�!C:D9�H@>6?PD=:36C2E:@?�>@G6>6?E�3682?�:?�E96�62C=J� ���PD�2?5�:?G@=G65�2�=@?8�DECF88=6�282:?DEE96�4@?EC@=�@7�76>2=6�D6IF2=:EJ�2?5�C6AC@5F4E:@?�3J�E96��2E9@=:4��9FC49�2?5��:2??2�2:=P��'P,@@=6��� ���,9:D��A2C25@I:42==J�=625�E@�6?@C>@FD�64@?@>:4�36?67:ED�7C@>E96�C6AC6DD:@?�@7�H@>6?�367@C6�E96� ���PD��E96C6�H6C6�2�=@E�@7�J@F?8�H@C<6CD�:?�E96 ���PD��2?5�E96�DF446DD�@7�76>:?:D>�:?�E96� ���PD�5F6�E@�E96�?F>36C�@7�>@E96CPDH:E9�76H6C�49:=5C6?��H9@�E96?�H6C6�23=6�E@�DE2J�:?�E96�H@C<�7@C46�H9:=6�C2:D:?8�249:=5

,96�!C:D9�8@G6C?>6?E�2=D@�492?865�/:E9�E96�AC@8C6DD:G6�AFD9�7C@>�7C66>2C<6E4@?D6CG2E:D>�2?5�2�D@4:2=�56>@4C2E:4�=6256CD9:A�:?�E96��-��H9:49�5:5�?@E�D66�6J6E@�6J6�H:E9�E96�!C:D9�C:?8H:?8�A@AF=:DE��!C6=2?5�C646:G65�2?�255:E:@?2=����>:==:@?!*�(@F?5D�36EH66?� ����2?5� �����'P,@@=6��� ��

,96�>@DE�H6==�?@E65�2?5�:?E6C?2E:@?2==J�46=63C2E65�C62D@?�7@C�!C:D9�64@?@>:4DF446DD�2?5�>@56=�C64@8?:E:@?�?665D�?@�C62=�:?EC@5F4E:@?N:ED�3FD:?6DD�E2I�A@=:4:6D,96D6�4@?5:E:@?D�2?5�2=C625J�6I4:E:?8�!C:D9�3FD:?6DD�64@?@>J�H2D�6IEC6>6=J�6?E:4:?8E@�A@E6?E:2=�3FD:?6DD�:?G6DE@C�2?5�4FCC6?E�3FD:?6DD�@H?6CD�,9:D�3FD:?6DD�D2GGJ6?G:C@?>6?E�3C@F89E�D@7EH2C6��A92C>246FE:42=D��2?5�4@CA@C2E:@?D�=2C86�2?5�D>2==H:E9� E96�9@A6D� @7� 23D@C3:?8� D@>6� !C:D9� =F4<�-?7@CEF?2E6=J�� E9:D�H2D� E96� =2DE64@?@>:4�724E@C�E@�3C:?8�@?�E96�3:CE9�@7�E96��6=E:4�,:86C

,96?�7:?2==J��282:?�=6DD�E2?8:3=6��,96�/2==�+EC66E�"@FC?2=�2?5�C:89E�H:?8�?6@=:36C2=:DED�:?�E96�-?:E65�+E2E6D�=:DE65�!C6=2?5�2D�2�H@?56C7F=�A=246�E@�:?G6DE�:?�5F6E@�:ED�=@H�=6G6=�@7�8@G6C?>6?E�:?E6CG6?E:@?�:?�E96�64@?@>J��'P,@@=6��� ��� @H6G6C�E96�8@G6C?>6?E�H2D�@G6CDA6?5:?8�@?�:ED�65F42E:@?�DECF4EFC6D��D@4:2=�D6CG:46D�2?5A2CE?6CD9:AD�!?�E96�27E6C>2E9��2�A@D:E:G6�2EEC:3FE6�:?�E96�6?E:C6��-��!C6=2?5�92DE96�D64@?5�9:896DE�65F42E65�H@C<�7@C46��'��2=2:89������

,96�D9@4<D�E@�7@C6:8?�EC256�2?5�E96�7:?2?4:2=�D64E@C�H6C6�=2C86=J�E96�C6DF=E�@7E96�8=@32=� 4C:D:D� �2D� !C6=2?5�36:?8� D@�56A6?56?E�FA@?� :ED� C6=2E:@?D9:AD�H:E9� E96@E96C��-� 4@F?EC:6D� 2?5� E96�-+��� 3FE� E96�9@FD:?8�>2C<6E� 3FDE�H2D� AC:>2C:=J

Page 7: Dutch disease article

/:E9�2==�E96�+J>AE@>D���@6D�!C6=2?5�92G6�E96��FE49��:D62D6� ��

9@>68C@H?��D�2� C6DF=E�� E96� 64@?@>J�D9C2?<���A6C46?E� :?������� 2?5�564C62D657FCE96C�:?�����N��(�4@?EC24E65�� ����#2?52��� ���,96�8C@HE9�J62CD�AC6465:?8E9:D�C646DD:@?�?@E23=J�4@?D:DE65�@7�EH@�7:?2?4:2=�724E@CD��:CDE��!C6=2?5�6IA6C:6?465F?6BF:G@42=�D@2C:?8�2DD6E�AC:46D��:?�3@E9�:ED�9@FD:?8�>2C<6E�2?5�6BF:EJ�E92E�>2E4965E96�FAH2C5�EC6?5�@7�C:D:?8�C62=�6DE2E6�H@CE9�Q!?�E96�D:I�J62CD�36EH66?���� �2?5������AF3=:4�D64E@C�D2=2C:6D�C@D6�3J����A6C�46?E�,96�:?4C62D6�:?�E96�2G6C286�:?5FDEC:2=H286� @G6C� E96� D2>6� A6C:@5�H2D� �� A6C� 46?E� �'��2=2:89�R� �6D:56D� E96� 9F865:D4C6A2?4J�36EH66?�AF3=:4�2?5�AC:G2E6�D64E@C�62C?:?8D�E9:D�D9@HD�2�9F86�:?4C62D6:?�2G2:=23=6�7F?5D �@==@H:?8�E96��FE49��:D62D6�DJ>AE@>D���������>2?F724EFC:?8;@3D�H6C6�=@DE�:?������2=@?6�E@�E96�AFD9�@?�6IA@CED��9@H6G6C�E9:D�H2D�9:556?�5F6�E@C:D:?8�4@?DECF4E:@?�?665D�2?5�;@3D

�6EH66?� ����2?5������3@E9�9@FD6�2?5�6BF:EJ�AC:46D�>@C6�E92?�BF25CFA=65�:C64E=J�D@��2DD6E�32D65�E2I�C6G6?F6�:?4C62D65�2?5�E96?�E96�8@G6C?>6?E�DE2CE65DA6?5:?8� ,96� 9@FD:?8� D64E@CPD� C:D6�H2D� 7F?52>6?E2=�H:E9� C6D:56?E:2=� AC:46D4=:>3:?8��AC@A6CEJ�E2I6D��A2CE:4F=2C=J�42A:E2=�E2I6D�2?5�.�,�@?�AC@A6CEJ�8C6H�>F49>@C6�BF:4<=J�E92?�E96���(��#2?52��� ��

,9:D�6?23=65�E96�2FE9@C:E:6D�E@�C65F46�E96:C�C6=:2?46�@?�A6CD@?2=�:?4@>6�E2I2E:@?�H9:=6�<66A:?8�@G6C2==�C6G6?F6D�3F@J2?E� @H6G6C��E96�492?86�:?�E96�DECF4EFC6�@7E2I2E:@?�H2D�?@E�H:E9@FE�4@DE��2D�:E�D:8?:7:42?E=J�:?4C62D65�E96�6IA@DFC6�@7�7:D42=

�1/:7.����--1865�$4=90�*5-��,":155�����

Page 8: Dutch disease article

�� �6C6<�'=D@?

C6G6?F6D�E@�2DD6E�>2C<6E�4@CC64E:@?D�/96?�E96�4C:D:D�AF==65�!C6=2?5�:?��E96�6?E:C62DD6E�32D65�E2I6D�DECF4EFC6D�E:65�E@�E96�9@FD:?8�2?5�6BF:EJ�>2C<6ED�3FCDE��2?5�@?E@A�@7�E96�>:D7@CEF?6�!C6=2?5�925�8F2C2?E665�E96�&2E:@?2=��?8=@�!C:D9��2?<�/92EH2D�=67E�H2D�2�8:2?E�82A�:?�AF3=:4�7:?2?46D�2?5�E96�C6>?2?ED�@7�2�3@@>:?8�64@?@>J

�1/:7.�����*5-*����

Page 9: Dutch disease article

/:E9�2==�E96�+J>AE@>D���@6D�!C6=2?5�92G6�E96��FE49��:D62D6� ��

,96�6DE:>2E6D�@7�E96�!C:D9�64@?@>J�AC6������H6C6�32D65�@?�2�EC25:E:@?2=�'���2AAC@249��J6E�72:=65�E@�AC65:4E�DF49�2�4@==2AD6�:?�E96�64@?@>:4�DECF4EFC6�,96�-#2?5�!C6=2?5��:?�>2?J�42D6D��D92C:?8�2?�:?E68C2E65�=23@C�>2C<6E��2?5�E96�:?4C62D:?862D6�@7�Q:?7=@H�2?5�@FE7=@H�@7�=23@C�7C@>�?6H�>6>36C�DE2E6D�@7�E96��-��2�4@>>@?2DD6DD>6?E�H2D�E92E�DH:7E�492?86D�E@�>:8C2E:@?�7=@HD�H@F=5�<66A�E96�F?6>A=@J>6?EC2E6�G6CJ�4=@D6�E@�E96�&�!*-N2?5�E9FD�<66A�24EF2=�2?5�A@E6?E:2=�@FEAFE�2=D@�G6CJ4=@D6�E@�6249�@E96C��#2?52��� ��R�,96�2DDF>AE:@?�E96?�H@F=5�36�E@�92G6�72:C=JD>2==� @FEAFE�82AD�� E9:D�H2D�?@E� E96� 42D6�3642FD6�� Q2DD6E�AC:46D�2?5� 2DD6E�AC:464J4=6D�2C6�?@E�:?4=F565�:?�E96�DE2?52C5�AC@5F4E:@?�7F?4E:@?�2AAC@249R��#2?52��� ��

�7.3*5-�#.;.5:.��.9.7415*598���������

�1/:7.�����*5-*����

,96�<6J�:D�8@G6C?2?46�,96�C:49�4@>>@5:E:6D�E92E�!C6=2?5�92D��:?�E9:D�A2A6C�H62C6�E2=<:?8�23@FE�A6@A=6��AC@5F4:?8�C6?ED66<:?8�3692G:@CD��2?5�42?�3F>A�FA�E966IE6C?2=�G2=F6�@7�2�4FCC6?4J��>2<:?8�:E�92C5�E@�AC@5F46�@E96C�8@@5D�7@C�6IA@CE��FEH6==8@G6C?65�?2E:@?D�7:?5�H2JD�E@�:?DF=2E6�E96:C�64@?@>:6D�7C@>�E96�5@H?D:56�@74@>>@5:E:6D�,96C6�=:6D�2?@E96C�AC@3=6>�7@C�E96�!C:D9�'?�,F6D52J����+6AE6>36C�����E96�!C:D9�DE2E6�32?<�2??@F?465�2�4@>A=6E6�4@==2AD6��E2I�C6G6?F6D�4@==2AD65�:?7=2E:@?�D@2C65��F?6>A=@J>6?E�C2E6D�<6AE�4=:>3:?8��J�E96�7:CDE�@7�"2?F2CJ������

Page 10: Dutch disease article

�� �6C6<�'=D@?

������A6@A=6�2�H66<�=@DE�E96:C�;@3D��E9:D�4@?E:?F65�7@C�D6G6C2=�>@?E9D�,96�DE2E6@C82?:K65�32?<:?8�DJDE6>�H2D�C2>A2?E�H:E9�7C2F5�2?5�E96�=6256CD9:A�H2D�@FE�@7E@F49��E96�%:?:DE6C�@7��:?2?46�@7�E96��2:=�C6A=:65�Q!P==�CF?�E96�4@F?ECJ�E96�H2J�!�D667:ER��'��2=2:89�������,96�?6H�7@F?5�C6D@FC46�@7�64@?@>:4�AC@DA6C:EJ�2?5�C62=:K2E:@?925�5:D2AA62C65�G:2�E96�>@DE�4@>>@?�4F=AC:ENA@@C�=6256CD9:A�,96�AC@3=6>D�@7�2&2E:@?2=�563E�@7�@G6C�����3:==:@?��FC@PD�2?5�?@�>@C6�Q62DJR�H2J�@7�C2:D:?8�E96�7F?5DE9C@F89�E96�2DD6E�32D65�E2I�H6C6�E@@�>F49�7@C�E96�,2@:D6249��2�7@C>6C�=2HJ6C���E96�6AFEJ�,2@:D6249��2?�6=6G2E65�D@4:2=�H@C<6C��2?5�E96�AC6G:@FD��:?2?46�%:?:DE6C�H9@�:?4:56?E2==J�925�D6CG65�2D�32CC:DE6C�:?�4:G:=�4@FCE�2?5�H9:E6�4@==2C�4C:>6D�,96286�@=5�DJDE6>�@7�A2DD:?8�=6256CD9:A�5@H?�72>:=:2=�=:?6D�925�AC@G6?�2?�:?4C65F=@FD>:D>2?286>6?E�@7�2�DFCAC:D6�64@?@>:4�FAEFC?��D�A6C�E96�6IA@CED��!C6=2?5�H2DE96�H@C=5PD� =2C86DE� 6IA@CE6C� @7� 4@>AFE6C� D@7EH2C6�� 3J� E96� =2E6� ���PD�2?5��@C<�@F?EJPD�G6CJ�@H?�>28:4�3=F6�A:==�925�C6G@=FE:@?:K65�E96�H2J�E96�H@C=5�=@@<65�2ED6IN.:28C2��0�������E96D6�6IA@CED�H6C6�564=:?:?8��9@H6G6C��2D�27@C6>6?E:@?65�E96� 5@>6DE:4� C62=� 6DE2E6�>2C<6ED�H6C6�3@@>:?8� D@�962G:=J� :?� C6=2E:@?� E@� E96:C72G@C23=6�E2I�4@56D�2?5���!

�1/:7.� ���*26;*���*5-*��%*5/���

�+1. "/��@F?ECJ�DE2E:DE:42=�2FE9@C:E:6D���FC@D:2E��2?5�DE277�42=4F=2E:@?D

�D�2�D>2==�@A6?�64@?@>J�:?�2�4FCC6?4J�F?:@?��!C6=2?5�:D�4@?DE2?E=J�:?7=F6?4653J�6G6?ED� :?� E96�8=@32=� :?E6C?2E:@?2=�64@?@>J�,96� !C:D9�64@?@>J� :D�H:56�@A6?�H:E9�9:89�D92C6D�@7�6IA@CED�2?5�:>A@CED�E@���( !?�E96�=2DE�564256�!C6=2?5�H2DG6CJ� DF446DD7F=� :?� 2EEC24E:?8 2� =2C86�?F>36C� @7�>F=E:?2E:@?2=� 4@>A2?:6D��H:E92DD@4:2E65�=2C86�:?7=@HD�@7�7@C6:8?�5:C64E�:?G6DE>6?E�:?E@�:ED�64@?@>J�,96D6�?F>36CDD9@H�E96�64@?@>J���J62CD�367@C6�E96�4C2D9

Page 11: Dutch disease article

/:E9�2==�E96�+J>AE@>D���@6D�!C6=2?5�92G6�E96��FE49��:D62D6� ��

�� $&���#)������ ���&$� �

!?�E96�6?5��H92E�<:==65�E96�,:86C�H2D�E96�5:D2DEC@FD�>2?EC2�@7�E96��:2??2��:2=�E@C6A=246�@?6� EJA6� @7� 8C@HE9�H:E9�2?@E96C� !C6=2?5�925�364@>6�AC@DA6C@FD� 7@C� E9627@C6>6?E:@?65�C62D@?D��3FE�2=D@�3642FD6�:ED�H@C<6CD�H6C6�AC@5F4E:G6�2?5�E96�4@F?ECJH2D�6IA@CE:?8�8@@5D�E92E�A6@A=6�H2?E65�E@�3FJ�,96�8@G6C?>6?E�564:565�E92E�E9636DE�H2J�E@�DE2J�AC@DA6C@FD�H2D�E@�7@==@H�H92E�E96:C�&2E:@?2=��@>A6E:E:G6?6DD��@F?4:=H@F=5�=2E6C�42==�Q8C@HE9�56C:G65�7C@>�2DD6E�AC:46�:?7=2E:@?��7F6=65�3J�2�4@>3:?2E:@?�@7=@H�:?E6C6DE�C2E6D��C64<=6DD�=6?5:?8�2?5�DA64F=2E:@?R��'P,@@=6��,96J�AC24E:42==J�82G6E96>D6=G6D��FE49��:D62D6�:?�2EE6>AED�E@�<66A�E96:C�A2CEJ�8@:?8

,96� 7:?2=� =@8� :?� E96:C� 6J6� 4@F=5� 92G6� 366?� E96� DF>>6C� @7� ������H96?� E6?4FDE@>6CD�@7�E96��?8=@�!C:D9��2?<�H6C6�=6?E�4=@D6�E@��� �>:==:@?�6FC@PD�E@�3FJ�324<D92C6� :?�E96� 7:C>�,9:D�3FJ324<�D496>6�H2D�@C82?:K65�3J�E96?�492:C>2?�+62?�:EKA2EC:4<��'��2=2:89�������!?�E96:C�56DA6C2E6�D62C49�7@C�2?�2?DH6C��E96�62D:6DEH2D�?@E�E96�36DE�,9:D�H2D�2�4@>A=6E6�5:DC682C5�7@C�=2H�2?5�7C2F5F=6?E�>:DFD6�@732?<:?8�7F?5D��3FE�?@E�!C6=2?5PD�7:CDE�D@4:2=�>:D25G6?EFC6�!C6=2?5�92D�366?�A=28F653J�2�A6@A=6�H9@�2C6�F?:?E6C6DE65�:?�A2J:?8�E2I6D��@36J:?8�E96:C�6=64E65�@77:4:2=D�@CA=2J:?8�3J�E96�CF=6D��G6?����J62CD�62C=:6C��C6?@H?65�!C:D9�366C�>2<6C��F:??6DDA=4�H2D�EC:65�2?5�7@F?5�8F:=EJ�7@C�DE@4<�>2C<6E�>2?:AF=2E:@?�3J�E96�-#��6A2CE>6?E@7�,C256�2?5�!?5FDECJ���,!��,96�6?E:C6�>2?286>6?E�E62>�H2D�D6?E6?465�E@�AC:D@?2?5�@C�7:?6D�E@E2==J�@G6C����>:==:@?�6FC@PD��'��2=2:89������

,96�C64@G6CJ�7@C�!C6=2?5�:D�C@@E65�:?�:ED�4FCC6?E�AC@3=6>D�,96�6=64E:@?�@7�?6H8@G6C?>6?E�@77:4:2=D�H9@�2C6�?@E�36?E�@?�7C66�92?5�@FED�E@�7C:6?5D�2?5�2�+F3�+292C2�7C:42?�H2C=@C5�>6?E2=:EJ�H@F=5�36�E96�7:CDE�A2CE

�1/:7.�����*26;*���*5-*���%*5/

�+1. "/��+'�2?5�+E277��2=4F=2E:@?D

Page 12: Dutch disease article

�� �6C6<�'=D@?

+E6C:=:K:?8�>2J�96=A�!C6=2?5�:?5:C64E=J��3FE�:D�@?=J�2�D>2==�A:646�@7�E96�AFKK=6��DE6C:=:K65�7@C6:8?�6I492?86�:?E6CG6?E:@?�@44FCD�H96?�2�46?EC2=�32?<�4@F?E6CD�5:C64E:?E6CG6?E:@?� :?� E96��@C6:8?��I492?86�%2C<6E�H:E9� 2� D:>F=E2?6@FD� @77D6EE:?8EC2?D24E:@?�:?�E96�5@>6DE:4�3@?5�>2C<6E ,9:D�H@F=5�C6BF:C6�E96��?8=@�!C:D9��2?<�@C�?@H�E96�4FCC6?E�&2E:@?2=��2?<�� E@�D6==� !C:D9�8@G6C?>6?E�3@?5D�32D65�@?�E96�FC@�2?5�3FJ�7@C6:8?�4FCC6?4J�@?�E96��@C6:8?��I492?86�%2C<6E +E6C:=:K2E:@?��:?E9:D� 42D6�� :?G@=G6D�2?��?8=@� !C:D9��2?<�@A6?�>2C<6E�@A6C2E:@?� :?�H9:49� :E� D6==D,C62DFCJ��@?5D�2E�E96�D2>6�E:>6�2?5�:?�E96�D2>6�G2=F6�2D�E96�5@==2C�6FC@�D2=6�:?E96��@C6:8?��I492?86�%2C<6E�,96�=2C86DE�2?5�>@DE�@3G:@FD�5:77:4F=EJ�C682C5:?8DE6C:=:K2E:@?�:D�!C6=2?5PD�F?2G@:523=6�A68�@7�E96��FC@

�D�A6C�>@56DE�42A:E2=�4@?EC@=D�2?5�7:D42=�E:89E6?:?8��E96�2?DH6CD�2C6�2�=:EE=6>@C6�4@>A=:42E:?8�2?5�:?7:?:E6�,96�!C:D9�64@?@>J�>FDE�4@?E:?F6�2D�2�AC@3FD:?6DD6?G:C@?>6?E�H9:49�<6JD�EC256�2?5�64@?@>:4D�@A6?�!C6=2?5�:D�2�D>2==�4@F?ECJ�:?;FDE�23@FE� 6G6CJ� EC256� E6C>��5F6� E@� :ED� =@H�A@AF=2E:@?�� =24<� @7� 4@G6E65�?2EFC2=C6D@FC46D�� 2?5� 2�>2;@C:EJ� @7� :ED� A@AF=2E:@?� :?� E96�>:55=6� 4=2DD� �'� ,@@=6�� �5:G6CD:7:42E:@?�:?�:?5FDECJ�H@F=5�F?5@F3E65=J�96=A�2?5�DE2G6�@77�7FCE96C�64@?@>J4@==2AD6D��68�E96�C62=�6DE2E6�EFC>@:=�

,96�!C:D9�A6@A=6�2C6�46CE2:?=J�E96�>@DE�G2=F23=6�C6D@FC46�2?5�H:==�F?5@F3E65=JEFC?�2C@F?5�E96:C�4@F?ECJ��DE2CE:?8�H:E9�E96�=6256CD�2?5�E96�32?<:?8�DJDE6>�!ED66>D� E92E� @?46� E96J� C62=:K65� E96:C� @H?�A@E6?E:2=� @7� A2CE:4:A2E:?8� :?� E96�H@C=564@?@>J�� E96J�H:==� ?6G6C� EFC?� 324<�� ?@�>2EE6C�H96C6� E96:C� 64@?@>:4� 5:D62D6@C:8:?2E6D

�� $$�#)

�*13 M�E96�=@H6C�9@FD6�@7�E96�!C:D9�(2C=:2>6?E��@7E6?�A2DD65�5@H?�2D�2�96C65:E2CJA@D:E:@?

%��M�>6>36C�@7�E96�=@H6C�9@FD6

�1*55*��*13�M�E96�5@>:?2?E�A2CEJ�:?�!C:D9�A@=:E:4D

�15.��*.3�M�E96�=2C86DE�@AA@D:E:@?�A2CEJ

�5/36��7180��*52�M�E96�8@G6C?>6?E�4@?EC@==65�DE2E6�32?<

!76/7.881;.��.46,7*98�M�2�D>2==�3FE�9:89=J�:?7=F6?E:2=�?6@=:36C2=�A2CEJ�7@C>65:?� ����2?5�4@==2AD65�:?�����

!769.89*59��8,.5-*5,=�M�E96�8@G6C?:?8�2?5�=2?5@H?:?8�4=2DD��2596C:?8�E@�E96(C@E6DE2?E�DE2E6�49FC49��E92E�5@>:?2E65�!C:D9�D@4:6EJ�7C@>�E96� �E9�46?EFCJ�E@�E96 �E9�46?EFCJ

%*5*189.�M�E96�56AFEJ�AC:>6�>:?:DE6C

%*618.*,0�M�E96�AC:>6�>:?:DE6C

Page 13: Dutch disease article

/:E9�2==�E96�+J>AE@>D���@6D�!C6=2?5�92G6�E96��FE49��:D62D6� ��

����������

�2C56C��'H6?���(@=:4J�%2<6CPD��F:56�E@��FE49��:D62D6���6?E6C�7@C��=@32=��6G6=@A>6?E�Q,96�FE49��:D62D6R� �%"�� +*+)&/0 &@G6>36C����� �����AA�����

�3C29:>K2569���9C:DE:?6��%2C49�������.@=F>6�����&F>36C� ��Q�24<�E@��2D:4D�M��FE49��:D62D6�,@@�%F49�/62=E9�%2?2865�-?H:D6=JR �&*�* "��*!��"2"(+,)"*0�����1�.0".(5���$�6&*"�+#

0%"����

.2?�/:;?36C86?��+H656C�� ������Q,96�O�FE49��:D62D6P�����:D62D6��7E6C��==�R �%"�� +*+)& ��+1.*�(

����������

+232C@H<:���9C:DE:2?� �������� Q�2A:E2=� !?7=@HD� 2?5� E96�*62=��I492?86�*2E6���2?��:?2?4:2=�6G6=@A>6?E��FC6�E96��FE49��:D62D6��!%��/@C<:?8�(2A6C

�@C56?�/�%��&62CJ�"�(�� ������Q�@@>:?8�+64E@C�2?5��6:?5FDEC:2=:D2E:@?�:?�2�+>2==�'A6?�4@?@>JR �%"�� +*+)& ��+1.*�(������646>36C���������

�@C56?�/�%�� ������Q�@@>�+64E@C�2?5��FE49��:D62D6��4@?@>:4D��+FCG6J�2?5��@?D@=:52E:@?R�4#+.!�� +*+)& ���,"./��������

�55:D@?+>JE9�����2?5�%4)F:??��#�� �������� Q)F2?E:7J:?8�*6G6?F6�/:?572==D�7C@>�E96�!C:D9 @FD:?8�%2C<6E�R��6?EC2=��2?<� 2?5��:?2?4:2=� +6CG:46D��FE9@C:EJ� @7� !C6=2?5� *6D62C49,649?:42=�(2A6C�&@� ��*,���

#2?52���2?:6=����� ����Q�DD6E��@@>D�2?5�+ECF4EFC2=��:D42=�(@D:E:@?D��,96��2D6�@7�!C6=2?5: !%�/@C<:?8�(2A6C

%F?=6J��.:?46?E�2?5�,9@C?E@?��*@36CE� �������� Q,96�!C:D9��4@?@>J� :?�,C2?D:E:@?��+F446DD6D�(C@3=6>D�2?5�(C@DA64EDR�.@=F>6����� �

$66��"@9?�"@D6A9�� ������Q!C6=2?5� � � �����(@=:E:4D�2?5�+@4:6EJ�R��@?E6>A@C2CJ�+EF5:6D�:?�4@?@>:4�2?5��:?2?4:2=��?2=JD:D�.@=F>6���

�FC<2?��"@6���������Q�@C6:8?��:C64E�!?G6DE>6?E��,96��2D6�@7�E96��=64EC@?:4D�2?5�(92C>246FE:42=D!?5FDEC:6D�R��@?E6>A@C2CJ�+EF5:6D�:?��4@?@>:4�2?5��:?2?4:2=��?2=JD:D�.@=F>6���

�E92?2D@A@F=@F��%���������Q!C:D9�(@E6?E:2=�'FEAFE�2?5�E96�'FEAFE��2A�R�%:>6@� !?E6C?2E:@?2=%@?6E2CJ��F?5

'��2=2:89���� �������� Q�6=E:4�%6=E5@H?��/9J�!C6=2?5�:D��C@<6�2?5� @H�/6��2?��:I� !ER�,96�@==:?D�(C6DD

'P,@@=6������� ����Q+9:A�@7��@@=D�� @H�+EFA:5:EJ�2?5��@CCFAE:@?�+2?<�E96��6=E:4�,:86CR�(F3=:4�772:CD�&6H�0@C<

�6C2=5�� "� �������� Q 2D� !C6=2?5�'FE8C@H?� !ED��=@E96D�� !?7C2DECF4EFC2=� 2?5��?G:C@?>6?E2=�@?DEC2:?ED�:?�!C6=2?5R��=D6G:6C�+4:6?46

�928H2E:��"285:D9� � ������ Q!>>:D6C:K:?8��C@HE9�����6@>6EC:42=�&@E6�R �"2&"3�+#�� +*+)&

�01!&"/������"F?6���AA��� ���

#CF8>2?�� (��'3DE76=5��%� �������� Q�92AE6C� ��� ,96�+E2?52C5�,C256�%@56=R �*0".*�0&+*�(

� +*+)& /����%"+.5��*!��+(& 5���E9�65��AL ��

Page 14: Dutch disease article