DR. JEFFREY S. BROOKS, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR OF EDUCATIONAL LEADERSHIP

UNIVERSITY OF MISSOURI

PAPER PRESENTED AT THE 2009 FALL MEETING OF THEMISSOURI ASSOCIATION OF COLLEGES FOR TEACHER EDUCATION

COLUMBIA, MO

Differentiated Teacher Leadership

What is Teacher Leadership?

Teacher Leadership

…is not new! Initial inquiry as far back as the 1930’s Internationally, the English and Australian “headteacher”

approach is close to what we call teacher leadershipUntil recently, teachers interested in becoming leaders

in a formal public K-12 educational institution had three routes: (1) becoming an administrator; (2) organizing or joining activist-type teacher movements

(mainly in urban settings), and; (3) becoming involved in local union affairs, thereby

helping to improve conditions of work in the profession (Institute for Educational Leadership, 2001a).

Teacher Leadership

Ovando (1996) argued that over the past two decades “teacher participation in school leadership has expanded, and teachers are now asked to perform a variety of non-teaching duties”

Among “new” teacher-leader roles are team leader, decision maker, action researcher, staff developer, and mentor (p. 32).

These roles represent a formal, more prominent function for teachers in issues of governance and school decision-making with regard to “matters of instruction and school organization” (Miller & O’Shea, 1992, p. 197).

What is a teacher leader?

It is hard to strictly define what makes a teacher a teacher leader.

A widely-used report published by the Institute for Educational Leadership (2001a), identified “at least ten areas…where teacher involvement is actually essential to the health of a school” (p. 3). The authors cited critical issues that transcend traditional roles such as instructor, evaluator, curriculum developer, and behavior manager to include promotion and retention committee member, decider of school budgets, selector of new administrators and teachers, and designer of professional development plans.

What is a Teacher Leader?

…interpersonal, administrative, and organizational skills are important if teachers are to capably function as leaders (p. 350).

Fullan (1994a) argued that teachers must exhibit proficiency in several “interrelated domains” to function as leaders: (1) knowledge of teaching and learning; (2) knowledge of collegiality; (3) knowledge of educational contexts; (4) knowledge through continuous learning; (5) knowledge of the change process, and; (6) moral purpose (pp. 246-250).

Teacher Leadership: Some Basic Issues

We have lots of lists: skills, responsibilities, and roles, but nothing coherent that defines teacher leadership

Teachers and Administrators tend to define teacher leadership differently

In too many schools, becoming a leader means leaving the classroom or assuming responsibilities that distract from instruction rather than enhance it

Differentiated Teacher Leadership

In trying to make sense of all this, I discovered that there are four basic types of teacher leadership: Classroom Teacher

Leadership Departmental/Team/

Grade Level Teacher Leadership

Whole School Teacher Leadership

Boundary-Spanning Teacher Leadership

Differentiated Teacher Leadership: An Overview of Extant Research

Differentiated Teacher Leadership: Design of the Study

Mixed-Method Research Qualitative and Quantitative Data

Unit of Analysis Urban High School

Site and Sample Selection Criteria Exploratory

Data Collection and Data Analysis ProceduresInternal Validity

Member Check

Classroom Teacher Leadership

Some teachers were leaders in their classrooms and others were not This isn’t necessarily

bad!Varied greatly in terms of

style and focusViewing teachers this way

suggested some ways teachers might improve their organizational skills and procedures

Departmental Teacher Leadership

More curriculum leadership, less instructional leadership

Often separated by experience level

High functioning teams and leaders at this level seemed to have the greatest impact on student learning

Whole School Teacher Leadership

• These teachers tended to have a broad perspective and to be advocates for their units• Tremendous influence of informal leaders at this level• Often whole school decisions were made by too few teachers

Putting it all together: Exploring Teacher Leadership

Teachers participated in a combination of activities which suggested that the “forms” suggested by literature were not entirely salient

Teachers did not necessarily interact with peers who exhibited similar leadership activities, but interacted with people more based on their proximity, subject-area interest, or other demographic characteristics

Many teachers who didn’t call themselves leaders were indeed leaders in some respect

Toward a Theory of Differentiated Teacher Leadership

Putting it all together: Supportive and Non-Supportive Organizational Structures

“Shared” governance and decision making models were too rigid to accommodate differentiated forms of teacher leadership Schools tend to emphasize

one form of teacher leadership to the exclusion of others

When teachers’ pedagogical orientation is matched to their actual leadership activities they are more effective, committed, and enthusiastic. But administrators don’t often ask

or care what teachers think about their leadership roles

Administrative Support for Differentiated Teacher Leadership

Administrative support for teacher leadership is key, yet support must be differentiated.

While certain teacher leader-types thrive in an organization, administrative support for differentiated forms of teacher leadership are important in helping all teachers realize their individual and collective leadership potential.

Implications for Research and Practice

Due to a lack of differentiation in organizational structures, practice, and administrative support, schools are commonly not taking advantage of a great resource: teacher leadership

Due to a lack of sensitivity to the differentiated nature of teacher leadership, well-intentioned administrators are not supporting all teachers as leaders. Can we move from equality toward equity?

What does teacher leadership look like in your school?

• How do teachers and administrators view the work differently?• How is teacher leadership supported?• What kind of leaders make a difference in the education of students?

Questions and Comments?

Thank You!

Please let me know if you’d like to learn more about this research or discuss teacher leadership in your school or district. Contact at brooksjs@missouri.edu.