8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 1/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ <
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
[mafa{ I* Hox`& O~|uaxo -[L A*B* 1=30!O$dlaf9 {mafihox`K`dlaf*ngd
FLP GCCANO^ GC [MAFA[ I* HOX@
??? Ljbgxxl @foj Nguxr& ^uaro <8Flclqorro Maff& [L <1222$8?><
Rofo{mgjo9 -3<;! =8?$><>2 Cl}9 -3<;! =>2$03?1 Lrrgxjoq cgx [flajracc~
_JAROB ^RLRO^ BA^RXANR NG_XR
CGX RMO NOJRXLF BA^RXANR GC NLFACGXJAL&
^G_RMOXJ BASA^AGJ
FA^L FAHOXA& or lf&
[flajracc~&
s~*
GXFQ RLARY& or lf&Bocojbljr~*
9
999999999
NASAF LNRAGJ J_DHOX9=9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@ -LIP!
[FLAJRACC^ RLRODOJR gc @OJ_AJO BA^[_RO^
gc DLROXALF CLNR^ hq AJROFFA_^
[ux~uljr rg Coboxlf Xufo~ gc Nasaf [xgnobuxo U‖ Cob* X* Nas* [*—T ?3-n! ljb
rma~ Nguxr‑~ Fgnlf Xufo U‖ F*X*—T ?3$8& [flajracc~& Fa~l Fahoxa U‖Fahoxa—T& Fa~l
G~roffl U‖G~roffl—T& @g O}nof @fghlf U‖@O@—& [mafa{ I* Hox`& O~|uaxo U‖Hox`—T ljb
rmo Flp Gccano~ gc [mafa{ I* Hox` hq ljb rmxgu`m rmoax ujbox~a`job nguj~of& [mafa{
I* Hox`& O~|uaxo moxohq cafo rmo parmaj Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc
Dlroxalf Clnr~& ajnfubaj` ~mgpaj` rmlr rmo dlroxalf~ narob hq Ajrofau~ bg jgr
o~rlhfa~m rmo lh~ojno gc l `ojuajo ba~{uro& ljb Ajrofau~& Ajn* nljjgr {xgbuno
lbda~~ahfo osabojno rg ~u{{gxr rmo clnr nfladob& Cob* X* Nas* [* ?3-n!-<!-H!& aj
Blro gc Molxaj`9 Dlxnm <8& 8;<8Rado gc Molxaj`9 <;9;; l*d*Fgnlragj9 Nguxrxggd <;B
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o < gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;??8
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 2/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ 8
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
G{{g~aragj rg Bocojbljr Ajrofau~ U‖Ajrofau~—T ‖[xg{g~ob _jngjrxgsoxrob Clnr~—
U‖[_C—T& Bgneor Jg* U‖BJ—T 2??$8* Olnm arod fa~rob hofgp {xo~ojr~ l `ojuajo
a~~uo gc dlroxalf clnr& pmanm {xosojr~ ^uddlxq Iub`dojr aj Bocojbljr Ajrofau~‑
clsgx*
[flajracc~ mlso lrrod{rob rg ghrlaj Ba~ngsoxq cxgd Ajrofau~ hq plq gc
~oxsaj` Ajroxxg`lrgxao~5 Xo|uo~r cgx [xgbunragj gc Bgnudojr~5 ljb Xo|uo~r cgx
Lbda~~agj~ ~oxsob gj Ajrofau~ gj Iljulxq <>& 8;<8 sal Odlaf ljb _*^* [g~rl
^oxsano Noxracaob „ Xoruxj Xonoa{r Xo|uo~rob* Rg blro& [flajracc~ mlso jgr
xonoasob Ajrofau~‑ xo~{gj~o~* Rmoxocgxo& [flajracc~ lxo lr l ba~lbsljrl`o l~ jg
Ba~ngsoxq ml~ hooj ngjnfubob* Lbbaragjlffq& Ba~ngsoxq a~ ~rlqob l~ rg Bocojbljr~
Gxfq Rlary& Gxfq Rlary& Ajn*& Bocojb gux Cxoobgd~& Ajn*& ljb rmo Flp Gccano~ gc
Gxfq Rlary* Ajrofau~‑ ^uddlxq Iub`dojr ~mgufb ho ~rlqob ujraf ba~ngsoxq a~
ngd{forob*
Cgx ol~o gc xocoxojno& [flajracc~ mlso u~ob lhhxosalragj~ cgx noxrlaj cafaj`~
{l`o~ -{* gx {{*!5 [flajracc Fa~l Fahoxa -‖Fahoxa—!5 [flajracc Fa~l G~roffl -‖G~roffl—!5
[mafa{ I* Hox`& O~|uaxo -‖Hox`—!5 Xgjlfb S* Rmujoj& AAA -‖Rmujoj—!5 Hojildaj
Jof~gj -‖Jof~gj—!5 Eoffq ^rxohof -‖^rxohof—!5 Gxfq Rlary -‖Rlary—! Bgneor Ojrxq
Judhox -‖BJ—!5 Bonflxlragj -‖Bonf*—!5 ljb O}mahar-~! -‖O}h* gx O}h~—!
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o 8 gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;??>
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 3/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ >
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
A* AJROFA_^ RMXG_@M XGJLFB S* RM_JOJ& AAA& ^X
[XGB_NR DLJL@OX ljb HOJILDAJ JOF^GJ& AJROFA_^‑
N_^RGBALJ gc XONGXB^ MLSO [OXI_XOB RMOAX
RO^RADGJQ ljb NGDDARROB CXL_B _[GJ RMA^
NG_XR9
Gj ^o{rodhox <3& 8;<<& Ajrofau~ Cafob l Dgragj rg Ba~da~~ [flajracc~ ~uar
^oo BJ >=;& Dodgxljbud gc Flp >=;$<* Aj ~u{{gxr gc rmoax Dgragj& Igjo~ Blq
cafob rmo Bonflxlragj gc Hojildaj Jof~gj U‖Jof~gj—T* ^oo BJ >=;$>* Aj Jof~gj‑~
Bonflxlragj& lr {{* 8$>& ³? Jof~gj ~rlro~ Ajrofau~ dlajrlaj~ osoxq ~olxnm& hur rma~ a~
da~folbaj` l~ Ajrofau~ gjfq ~lso~ (eoq pgxb( ~olxnmo~& a*o*& jldo~& rofo{mgjo
judhox~& Odlaf~& orn* bo{ojbaj` gj rmo ajcgxdlragj hoaj` ~olxnmob lr rmo rado*
Ajrofau~ bgo~ jgr ~lso rmo xo{gxr~5 ^oo Rmujoj Bonf*& BJ 2?3& {* ?& ³<8& ljb gx
lnrulf {og{fo ~olxnmo~ l~ xo|uaxob hq rmo Clax Nxobar Xo{gxraj` Lnr U‖CNXL—T*
Cuxrmox& Ajrofau~ rxao~ rg folb rma~ Nguxr rg hofaoso rmoq ~lso ljb ~lsob lff ~olxnmo~*
Jof~gj rmoj ~rlro~ gj L{xaf <8& 8;;1 Gxfq Rlary {uxnml~ob l ‖`ojoxlf— xo{gxr gj
rmo jldo Fa~l Fahoxa* Jof~gj ~rlro~& ‖lrrlnmob moxorg a~ l rxuo ljb ngxxonr ng{q gc
rmo ~olxnm xo~ufr~ Gxfq Rlary ghrlajob gj rmo jldo Fa~l Fahoxa— ljb lrrlnmob rmo
xo{gxr l~ O}mahar ‖<— UBJ >=;$2T* ^ajno Ajrofau~ bgo~ jgr dlajrlaj rmoax xo{gxr~
^oo Rmujoj‑~ Bonf*& BJ 2?3& {`* ?& ³<8& ghsagu~fq Jof~gj‑~ O}mahar ‖<— a~ jgr l
rxuo ljb ngxxonr ng{q gc rmo Xo{gxr Gxfq Rlary {uxnml~ob gj Fahoxa ljb aj~rolb a~ l
jopfq nxolrob xo{gxr* Cuxrmox& rmo blro ljb rado ml~ hooj xodgsob cxgd rma~
xo{gxr& hur lr rmo rg{ gc {l`o <;& ujbox rmo dl{& ar ~rlro~& ‖¡ 8;<< Danxg~gcr
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o > gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;??2
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 4/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ 2
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
Ngx{gxlragj ¡ 8;<; JLSRO\—* Hoaj` Gxfq Rlary {uxnml~ob mox xo{gxr aj gx
lhgur Dlxnm 8;;1& hocgxo Ajrofau~ nmlj`ob rmoax poh~aro ljb g{oxlraj` ~q~rod
rmoxo a~ jg plq Jof~gj‑~ O}mahar ‖<— a~ rmo ~ldo l~ rmo xo{gxr {uxnml~ob hq Rlary
[fu~& Rmujoj lbdar~ rmlr Xo{gxr~ lxo jgr ~lsob gx dlajrlajob5 ^oo Rmujoj Bonf
BJ 2?3& {* ?& ³<85 rmu~ Jof~gj‑~ O}mahar~ ‖<— rmxgu`m ‖>— lxo jopfq nxolrob
xo{gxr~ ljb jgr ‖rxuo ljb ngxxonr ng{ao~— gc rmo xo{gxr Rlary ljb Fahoxa {uxnml~ob*
Jof~gj ngjrajuo~ gj {* 3& ³3& rmlr Fahoxa {uxnml~ob l hlne`xgujb xo{gxr gj mox~ofc
cxgd ppp*ajrofau~*ngd* Jof~gj l`laj ~rlro~& ‖l rxuo ljb ngxxonr ng{q gc rmo
~olxnm xo~ufr~ D~* Fahoxa ghrlajob gj rmo jldo ‖Fa~l Fahoxa—— rmlr pl~ lrrlnmob l~
O}mahar ‖8— UBJ >=;$?T rg Jof~gj‑~ Bonflxlragj* L`laj& rmoxo a~ jg plq Jof~gj
ngufb mlso lrrlnmob l rxuo ljb ngxxonr ng{q gc Fahoxa‑~ xo{gxr& l~ ~rlrob hq Rmujoj
aj ma~ Bonflxlragj lr {* ?& ³<8& Ajrofau~ bgo~ jgr ~lso gx dlajrlaj xo{gxr~ {uxnml~ob
hq rmoax nfaojr~& aj sagflragj gc rmo Clax Nxobar Xo{gxraj` Lnr* Jof~gj‑~ O}mahar ‖8—
l{{olx~ rg ho abojranlf rg ma~ O}mahar ‖<—& -Fahoxa {uxnml~ob mox Ajrofau~ Xo{gxr gj
L{xaf <;& 8;<;& l qolx lcrox Rlary {uxnml~ob mox xo{gxr gj Fahoxa!& parm gjo
o}no{ragj& rmoq xodgsob ‖¡ 8;<< Danxg~gcr Ngx{gxlragj ¡ 8;<; JLSRO\—
[flajracc~ cafob lj G{{g~aragj gj ^o{rodhox 82& 8;<< UBJ >=1T rg Ajrofau~‑ Dgragj
Aj ~u{{gxr gc [flajracc~ G{{g~aragj rg Ajrofau~‑ Dgragj& [flajracc Fa~l Fahoxa cafob l
Bonflxlragj parm l ng{q gc rmo lnrulf hlne`xgujb xo{gxr ~mo mlb {uxnml~ob L{xaf
<;& 8;<;& ljb jgr ~ux{xa~aj`& ar bab jgr dlrnm lr lff pmlr Jof~gj pl~ lrrod{raj` rg
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o 2 gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;???
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 5/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ ?
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
{xgnflad* Aj Fahoxa‑~ Bonflxlragj& BJ >=1$8& {{* <$8 ³³<$?& [flajracc~ o}{flaj rg
rmo Nguxr rmlr rmo xo{gxr~ lrro~rob rg ujbox rmo {ojlfrq gc {oxiuxq hq Jof~gj poxo
jgr lnnuxlro* Fahoxa lrrlnmob rg mox Bonflxlragj l~ O}mahar ‖L— l rxuo ljb ngxxonr
ng{q gc rmo xo{gxr Fahoxa mlb {uxnml~ob& lfgj` parm rmo xonoa{r Fahoxa mlb xonoasob
Fahoxa Bonflxlragj& BJ >=1$8& {{* =$<=& Fahoxa‑~ xo{gxr pl~ gjfq <; {l`o~& jgr >;
faeo Jof~gj‑~& ljb Fahoxa‑~ xo{gxr lf~g ~mgp~ rmo blro ljb rado ar pl~ xuj& hur rmo
blro ljb rado ml~ hooj xodgsob cxgd Jof~gj‑~ O}mahar~ ‖<— ljb ‖8—* L~
{xosagu~fq jgrob& Rmujoj lbdar~ aj ma~ Bonflxlragj lr {* ?& ³<8& Ajrofau~ bgo~ jgr
dlajrlaj xo{gxr~ ~gfb gj ajbasabulf~* ^oo lf~g rmo Bonflxlragj gc [mafa{ I* Hox` cafob
^o{rodhox 82& 8;<<& BJ >=1$< lr {{* 2$?& ³³ 1$<8*
Aj xo{fq rg [flajracc~ G{{g~aragj rg Ajrofau~‑ Dgragj& Hojildaj Jof~gj cafob
ljgrmox Bonflxlragj gj Gnrghox >& 8;<<& BJ >10& lfgj` parm grmox ajngxxonr
~rlrodojr~& gj {* >& ³? gc Jof~gj‑~ Bonflxlragj& Jof~gj ~rlro~9
‖D~* Fahoxa nflad~& mgposox& rmlr dq gxa`ajlf bonflxlragj pl~ pxgj`
honlu~o O}mahar~ < ljb 8 rmoxorg lxo jgr rmo ~ldo Hlne`xgujb Nmone ‖xo{gxr~— rmlr ~mo ljb Gxfq Rlary ghrlajob gj rmo jldo ‖Fa~l Fahoxa*— ^mo
ml~ da~xolb dq bonflxlragj* _jfaeo rmo Rlfojr Pa~o xo{gxr& A josox ~rlrobrmlr A pl~ lrrlnmaj` l ng{q gc rmo o}lnr ‖hlne`xgujb nmone— xo{gxr rmlr D~*
Fahoxa {xgnuxob cxgd ppp*ajrofau~*ngd aj L{xaf 8;<;* Aj~rolb& Alnnuxlrofq lrro~rob rmlr O}mahar~ < ljb 8 rg dq bonflxlragj ngjrlaj rmo ~ldo
‖~olxnm xo~ufr~— l~ rmo xo{gxr~ rmlr D~* Fahoxa ljb D~* Rlary ghrlajob gj rmojldo ‖Fa~l Fahoxa*—‑
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o ? gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;??3
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 6/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ 3
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
Hur& Jof~gj‑~ Bonflxlragj gc ^o{rodhox <3& 8;<<& BJ>=;$>& {* >& ³3 ~rlrob9
‖Ajrofau~ xongxb~ lf~g ajbanlro rmlr D~* Fahoxa mox~ofc ngjbunrob l ~olxnm gjrmo jldo ‖Fa~l Fahoxa— gj L{xaf <;& 8;<; rmxgu`m ppp*ajrofau~*ngd* A
lrrlnm l~ O}mahar 8 rg rma~ Bonflxlragj& l rxuo ljb ngxxonr ng{q gc rmo
~olxnm xo~ufr~ D~* Fahoxa ghrlajob gj rmo jldo ‖Fa~l Fahoxa— gj L{xaf
<;& 8;<; rmxgu`m ppp*ajrofau~*ngd* Ajrofau~‑ xongxb~ lf~g ajbanlro rmlrD~* Fahoxa ngjbunrob rpg ~olxnmo~ gj mox~ofc& gj L{xaf <; ljb <8& 8;<;&
xo~{onrasofq& rmxgu`m ppp*rlfojrpa~o*ngd* A lrrlnm l~ O}mahar >& l rxuo ljbngxxonr ng{q gc rmo RlfojrPa~o xo{gxr~ D~* Fahoxa {uxnml~ob gj mox~ofc*—
U‖Od{ml~a~ Lbbob—T
Jof~gj‑~ O}mahar ‖>— UBJ >=;$3T rg ma~ Bonflxlragj gc ^o{rodhox <3& 8;<<&
BJ >=;$3& l{{olx~ rg ho abojranlf rg rmo RlfojrPa~o Xo{gxr lrrlnmob rg Rmujoj‑~
Bonflxlragj l~ O}mahar ‖2— UBJ 2?3$2T& hgrm gc pmanm poxo jopfq nxolrob ljb jgr
ng{ao~ gc rmo Xo{gxr {uxnml~ob hq Fahoxa* Rmujoj lbdar~ Ajrofau~ bgo~ jgr ~rgxo gx
dlajrlaj Xo{gxr~ rmlr rmoq ~off& Rmujoj Bonf* {* ?& ³<8* Rmo ba~nxo{ljnao~ parm
rma~ Xo{gxr lxo o}{flajob hofgp& l~ ar a~ rmo ~ldo cgx hgrm Rmujoj ljb Jof~gj& hgrm
gc pmgd lxo hoaj` ba~mgjo~r& ljb lxo jgr nxobahfo parjo~~o~*
Rmoxo a~ jg |uo~ragj& Jof~gj faob ujbox rmo {ojlfrq gc {oxiuxq ljb lrrod{rob
rg nfolj u{ ma~ fao* Hur& ~g bgo~ Rmujoj aj ma~ Bonflxlragj aj ~u{{gxr gc Ajrofau~
^uddlxq Iub`dojr*
Rmujoj lf~g ~rlro~ aj ma~ Bonflxlragj cafob Cohxulxq <;& 8;<8& UBJ‑~ 2?3T lr
{l`o 3& ³<3 rmlr mo -Rmujoj! ml~ lrrlnmob l~ O}mahar ‖2— UBJ 2?3$2T l rxuo ljb
ngxxonr ng{q gc rmo RlfojrPa~o xo{gxr {uxnml~ob hq [flajracc Fa~l Fahoxa -l~ bab
Jof~gj aj ma~ Bonflxlragj gc ^o{rodhox <3& 8;<;!* Rmujoj‑~ ~rlrodojr a~ ujrxuo
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o 3 gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;??0
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 7/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ 0
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
Rmujoj lbdar~ aj ma~ Bonflxlragj& BJ 2?3& {* ?& ³<8& rmlr Ajrofau~ bgo~ jgr ~rgxo gx
dlajrlaj Xo{gxr~ rmoq ~off gj ajbasabulf~ gx Xo{gxr~ {uxnml~ob hq rmoax nu~rgdox~
Rmujoj‑~ O}mahar ‖2— a~ jgr l rxuo ljb ngxxonr ng{q gc rmo Xo{gxr {uxnml~ob hq
[flajracc Fahoxa& hur aj~rolb l jopfq nxolrob xo{gxr* Ac qgu ngd{lxo Jof~gj‑~
1<38;<; O}mahar ‖>— -BJ >=;$3T ljb Rmujoj‑~ O}mahar 2 UBJ 2?3$2T rg [flajracc
Fa~l Fahoxa‑~ O}mahar ‖H— -BJ >=1$8& {l`o~ 8;$88! rg mox ^o{rodhox 82& 8;<<
Bonflxlragj& ljb bg ~abo hq ~abo ngd{lxa~gj~& qgu paff cajb judoxgu~ baccoxojno~
Cgx aj~rljno~& rmo cgxdlr a~ jgr rmo ~ldo5 rmo ng{qxa`mr lr rmo hgrrgd gc rmo {l`o~
lxo baccoxojr& a*o*& gj Fahoxa‑~ O}mahar ‖H— gj {l`o 8> aj rmo rg{ focr ngxjox& rmo
ng{qxa`mr ~rlro~& ‖¡ 8;;>$8;<; Ajrofau~ ^nxoojaj` ^gfuragj~ BHL RlfojrPa~o—
U‖od{ml~a~ lbbob—T Mgposox& gj Jof~gj‑~ O}mahar ‖>— ljb Rmujoj‑~ O}mahar ‖2—
rmo ng{qxa`mr lr rmo hgrrgd xa`mr gc {l`o > ~rlro~& ‖¡ 8;;>$8;<< RlfojrPa~o
^gfuragj~& FFN— U‖od{ml~a~ lbbob—T* Gj Fahoxa‑~ RlfojrPa~o Xo{gxr& O}mahar H
{l`o 8<& rg{ xa`mr ngxjox& ar ~rlro~& ‖Ajrofau~ ^nxoojaj` Nu~rgdox ^oxsano—
U‖od{ml~a~ lbbob—T& ljb {xgsabo~ lj Odlaf lbbxo~~ gc
‖nu~rgdox~oxsano~gfuragj~KAjrofau~*ngd— U‖od{ml~a~ lbbob—T5 ljb& ujbox rma~ ar
ml~ ‖Xo{gxr ^rlru~9 [ojbaj`— U‖od{ml~a~ lbbob—T hur gj {l`o < gc Jof~gj‑~
O}mahar ‖>— ljb Rmujoj‑~ O}mahar ‖2—& aj rmo rg{ xa`mr ngxjox ~rlro~& ‖RlfojrPa~o
Nu~rgdox ^u{{gxr— U‖od{ml~a~ lbbob—T& parm lj Odlaf lbbxo~~ gc
‖nu~rgdox~u{{gxrKrlfojrpa~o*ngd U‖od{ml~a~ lbbob—T* Lf~g gj {l`o gjo gc
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o 0 gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;??=
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 8/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ =
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
Jof~gj‑~ O}mahar ‖>— ljb Rmujoj‑~ O}mahar ‖2— ar ~rlro~ aj rmo rg{ xa`mr ngxjo
‖Xo{gxr ^rlru~9 Ngd{foro— U‖od{ml~a~ lbbob—T ljb ‖Xo{gxr Ngd{forob L{x
<3& 8;<; >988 {d— U‖od{ml~a~ lbbob—T* Fahoxa josox xonoasob l xo{gxr cxgd
Ajrofau~ parm rma~ ajcgxdlragj* Ajrofau~ ml~ {xgbunob jopfq nxolrob xo{gxr~
lrrod{raj` rg folb rma~ Nguxr rg hofaoso rmoq lxo rmlr gc Fahoxa ljb Rlary‑~*
Mgposox& Rmujoj aj ma~ Bonflxlragj& BJ 2?3& {* ?& ³<8 nfolxfq ~rlro~ rmlr Ajrofau~
bgo~ jgr dlajrlaj gx ~rgxo xo{gxr~ ~gfb gj ajbasabulf~ gx ~gfb rg rmoax nu~rgdox‑~
^oo Eoffq ^rxohof Bonf*& {l`o~ ?$<;& ³³<8$<?5 Fa~l Fahoxa Bonf*& {l`o~ <$1& ³³<$<1
cafob ngjnuxxojrfq moxoparm5 Bonf* gc [mafa{ I* Hox`& O~|uaxo& BJ >=1$<& Bonf* gc
Fa~l Fahoxa cafob ^o{rodhox 82& 8;<<& BJ >=1$8& {l`o~ <$8& ³³<$> ljb O}mahar~
[flajracc~ hxgu`mr Ajrofau~‑ ba~mgjo~rq rg rmo Nguxr‑~ lrrojragj gj ^o{rodhox
82& 8;<< ljb jgp l`laj rgblq* [flajracc~ {xlq rmo Nguxr rleo~ lnragj rg {xgmahar
ljq curuxo bono{ragj ljb cxlub*
AA* NGJNA^O ^RLRODOJR gc @OJ_AJO BA^[_RO^ gc
AJROFA_^‑ [XG[G^OB _JNGJRXGSOXROB DLROXALF
CLNR^9
Ajrofau~‑ ‖Lffo`ob— _jngjrxgsoxrob Clnr Jg* <9
Ajrofau~& Ajn* gpj~ ljb g{oxlro~ lj ajroxlnraso poh~aro$ppp*ajrofau~*ngd
rmlr lffgp~ dufra{fo u~ox~ rg ghrlaj& gsox rmo Ajroxjor& slxagu~ {uhfan xongxb~
gj ajbasabulf~& ~unm l~ lbbxo~~o~& {mgjo judhox~& ljb nguxr Xongxb~*
‖L— ljb ‖H—& {l`o~ =$8>*
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o = gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;??1
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 9/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ 1
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
[flajracc~ Ghionragj~9
L~~udo~ clnr~ jgr aj osabojno5 a~ Da~folbaj`5 ljb rmoxo a~ jgr ljq
ngd{orojr osabojno rg ~u{{gxr rma~ cajbaj`~rlrodojr ljb Da~|ugro~
[flajracc~ Cax~r Ldojbob Ngd{flajr U‖CLN—T*
[flajracc~ Xo~{gj~o9
BA^[_ROB CLNR9 [flajracc~ aj rmoax CLN& {* 32& ³<?8 ~rlro~ rmlr rmo Xoob
Bocojbljr~ ~off rg daffagj~ gc ajbasabulf~& ajnfubaj` Ajrofau~* Ar cuxrmox ~rlro~
rmlr Ajrofau~ paff ~off rg ljqgjo parm l nxobar nlxb* Rmoxo a~ jgr ljq dojragj
gc Ajrofau~‑ nu~rgdox~ gx u~ox~ u~aj` Ajrofau~‑ poh~aro& gx dufra{fo u~ox~
u~aj` rmoax poh~aro rg ghrlaj ‖gsox rmo Ajroxjor slxagu~ {uhfan xongxb~ gj
ajbasabulf~& ~unm l~ lbbxo~~o~& {mgjo judhox~& ljb nguxr Xongxb~*—
Nu~rgdox~ gc Ajrofau~‑ gxbox [xgbunr~& ajnfubaj` xo{gxr~& rmxgu`m rmoax
{l~~pgxb {xgronrob lnngujr parm Ajrofau~* Ajrofau~‑ {xgbunr~ ajnfubo rojlj
~nxoojaj`& od{fgqdojr ~nxoojaj`& hlne`xgujb xo{gxr~& xosox~o {mgjo fgge$
u{~ gj fljb fajo~ ljb noffuflx judhox& fa~rob ljb ujfa~rob& l~ poff l~ grmox
{xgbunr~* Gjno Ajrofau~‑ nu~rgdox {lq~ cgx rmo {xgbunr& Ajrofau~ {xgsabo~ rmo
{xgbunr rg rmoax nu~rgdox rmxgu`m rmo nu~rgdox‑~ {xaslro& {l~~pgxb {xgronrob
Ajrofau~ lnngujr ljb hq plq gc odlaf baxonrfq rg rmoax nu~rgdox* Ajrofau~
bgo~ jgr {uhfa~m rmo xo{gxr-~! gx {xgbunr~ ~gfb rg rmoax nu~rgdox~ gj rmo
Ajroxjor*
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o 1 gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?3;
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 10/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ <;
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
[flajracc~ Osabojno9
[flajracc~ CLN& {{* 32$31& ³³<?8$<325 Fahoxa Bonf*& {{* 1$<1& ³³88$2;& O}h~
‖L— rmxgu`m ‖E—& {{* 8>$005 G~roffl Bonf*& {{* 3$<>& ³³<?$>;& O}h~ ‖2—
rmxgu`m ‖<;—& {{* =<$<8?5 ljb Eoffq ^rxohof U‖^rxohofT Bonf*& {{* <$?& ³³<$
<<& O}h~* ‖<— rmxgu`m ‖3—& {{* <3$>0*
Ajrofau~‑ ‖Lffo`ob— _jngjrxgsoxrob Clnr Jg* 89
Ajrofau~' hu~ajo~~ a~ ~o{lxlrob ajrg rpg hu~ajo~~ ujar~$rmo Ngj~udox
Ajcgxdlragj ^oxsano~ ujar ljb rmo Ojrox{xa~o ujar$pmanm lxo g{oxlrob hq
baccoxojr ojrarao~ ljb gccox baccoxojr {xgbunr~ ljb ~oxsano~* Ajrofau~ g{oxlro~
ar~ Ngj~udox Ajcgxdlragj ^oxsano~ ujar& ljb Ajcgxdlragj ^oxsano~ ujar& ljb
Ajrofau~' ~uh~abalxq& RlfojrPa~o& Ajn*& g{oxlro~ rmo Ojrox{xa~o ujar*
[flajracc~ Ghionragj~9
L~~udo~ clnr~ jgr aj osabojno& Da~folbaj`5 ljb a~ uj~u{{gxrob hq
ngd{orojr osabojno*
[flajracc~ Xo~{gj~o9
BA^[_ROB CLNR9 Rmo Gxfq Rlary ljb ^ljeoq Bocojbljr~ ghrlajob
hlne`xgujb xo{gxr~ gj rmo [flajracc~ aj gx lhgur Dlxnm 8;;1* Ajrofau~& Ajn
ajrxgbunob ar~ hxljbaj` gc RlfojrPa~o gj gx lhgur Cohxulxq 1& 8;<;
l{{xg}adlrofq l qolx lcrox rmo osojr~ gnnuxxob `asaj` xa~o rg rma~ ~uar
RlfojrPa~o pl~ jgr ad{fodojrob hq Ajrofau~& Ajn* ujraf aj gx lhgur olxfq
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o <; gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?3<
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 11/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ <<
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
L{xaf 8;<;* [xagx rg rma~ rado& lff {xgbunr~ poxo mljbfob ljb ~gfb hq
Ajrofau~& Ajn* rmxgu`m rmoax poh~aro „ ppp*ajrofau~*ngd*
[flajracc~ Osabojno9
[flajracc~ Xo|uo~r cgx Iubanalf Jgrano U‖XIJ—T& O}h* ‖8—& {{* 22$205 ^rxoho
Ajrofau~‑ ‖Lffo`ob— _jngjrxgsoxrob Clnr Jg* >9
Rmo Ngj~udox Ajcgxdlragj ^oxsano~ ujar ~oxso~ u~ox~ ~ooeaj` {uhfan xongxb~
ajcgxdlragj cgx xol~gj~ grmox rmlj od{fgqdojr ~nxoojaj`& rojljr ~nxoojaj`
gx grmox {ux{g~o~ ngsoxob hq rmo Clax Nxobar Xo{gxraj` Lnr*
[flajracc~ Ghionragj~9
L~~udo~ clnr~ jgr aj osabojno5 a~ jgr ~u{{gxrob hq ngd{orojr osabojno5 a~
jgr ~u{{gxrob hq rmo Xongxb5 ljb nlff~ cgx ~{onuflragj*
[flajracc~ Xo~{gj~o9
BA^[_ROB CLNR9 Rmo Gxfq Rlary ljb ^ljeoq Bocojbljr~ ho`lj rmoax
affo`lf hlne`xgujb nmone~ gj rmo [flajracc~ aj gx lhgur Dlxnm 8;;1& lf
{xgbunr~ gccoxob hq Ajrofau~ poxo mljbfob hq Ajrofau~ rmxgu`m rmoax poh~aro
ppp*ajrofau~*ngd* Ajrofau~ gj rmoax poh~aro lr
ppp*ajrofau~*ngdngx{~onuxarq ~rlro~& ‖ Ajrofau~ a~ l nxobar xo{gxraj
l`ojnq— Uod{ml~a~ lbbobT* Lbbaragjlffq& rmo xo{gxr~ Ajrofau~ ~off~ rg
ajbasabulf~ rmlr rmoq nflad lxo lff ‖{uhfan ajcgxdlragj— lxo xo{gxr~ bocajob
Bonf*& {{* <2$<? ³8?& O}h* ‖<8—& {{* 3;$3>5 ljb Hox` Bonf*& {*?& ³<<*
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o << gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?38
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 12/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ <8
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
hq rmo CNXL l~ ‖ngj~udox xo{gxr~— ljb ~uhionr rg rmo CNXL* ^oo <? _*^*N
<3=<l-b!-<!* ^ajno Ajrofau~ {xgnflad~ gj rmoax poh~aro rmlr ‖Ajrofau~ a~— l
noxracaob nxobar xo{gxraj` l`ojnq& rmoj lff rmoax {xgbunr~& ajnfubaj` rmg~o cgx
ngj~udox~& lxo `gsoxjob hq rmo Clax Nxobar Xo{gxraj` Lnr U‖CNXL—T
Ajrofau~ lf~g lbdar~ aj rmoax Gnrghox 8;;1 Xo{gxr cafob parm rmo ^onuxarao~
ljb O}nmlj`o Ngdda~~agj U‖^ON—T rmlr rmoq lxo `gsoxjob hq rmo CNXL
^rlro O|uaslfojr~& @xlmld Folnm Hfafq Lnr& orn* Rmo hlne`xgujb xo{gxr~
Ajrofau~ ~off~ rg ar~ ngj~udox~& lxo ‖ngj~udox xo{gxr~— l~ bocajob hq rmo
CNXL*
[flajracc~ Osabojno9
[flajracc~ CLN& {{* 3<$02& ³³<22$<02 ljb {{* <80$<28& ³³ >>?$>025 Fahoxa
Bonf* BJ >=1$8& {* >& ³?5 G~roffl Bonf* BJ >1;$?& {{* 2$3& ³³<?$<15 Hox`
Bonf*& BJ >1;$<& {{* 8$2& ³³?$15 [flajracc~ Xo|uo~r cgx Iubanalf Jgrano& O}h
‖<—-^ON Xo{gxr cafob hq Ajrofau~!& {{* ?$285 [flajracc~ XIJ O}mahar~ ‖>— ljb
‖2—& {{*2=$33 -Coboxlf CNXL Nl~o~ ^orrfob hq Ajrofau~!5 ljb Fahoxa Bonf*
BJ >=1$8& {* >& ³?5 ljb Bonflxlragj~ cafob ngjnuxxojrfq moxoparm5 G~roffl
Bonf*& {{* <;$<<& ³³805 Fahoxa Bonf*& {{* <2$<3& ³³><$>2*
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o <8 gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?3>
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 13/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ <>
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
Ajrofau~‑ ‖Lffo`ob— _jngjrxgsoxrob Clnr Jg* 29
Rmo Ojrox{xa~o ujar ~oxso~ u~ox~ ~ooeaj` od{fgqdojr gx rojljr ~nxoojaj`
{xgbunr~$~oxsano~ rmlr lxo bo~a`job rg ho cuffq ngd{faljr parm rmo Clax Nxoba
Xo{gxraj` Lnr -ljb ar~ ~rlro o|uaslfojr~ !$ljb lxo {xgsabob rmxgu`m Ajrofau~
~uh~abalxq& RlfojrPa~o& FFN& l ~o{lxlro fo`lf ojrarq& lr
ppp*rlfojrpa~o*ngd*
[flajracc~ Ghionragj~9
Da~folbaj` ljb a~ jgr ~u{{gxrob hq ngd{orojr osabojno*
[flajracc~ Xo~{gj~o9
BA^[_ROB CLNR $ RlfojrPa~o pl~ jgr ajrxgbunob hq Ajrofau~& Ajn* ujraf
Cohxulxq 1& 8;<; ljb pl~ jgr ad{fodojrob ujraf aj gx lhgur olxfq L{xaf
8;<;& l qolx lcrox rmo osojr~ `asaj` xa~o rg rma~ ~uar gnnuxxob* RlfojrPa~o
pl~ jgr {lxr gc Ajrofau~ lr rmo rado rmo Rlary ljb ^ljeoq Bocojbljr~ urafayob
rmo ~oxsano~ gc Ajrofau~* [xagx rg L{xaf 8;<;& lff {xgbunr~ ~gfb hq Ajrofau~
poxo ~gfb gj rmoax poh~aro lr ppp*ajrofau~*ngd* ^raff rg rma~ blro& rojljr ljb
od{fgqdojr xo{gxr~ lxo lslaflhfo rg ngj~udox~ gj rmoax poh~aro lr
ppp*ajrofau~*ngd* Ajrofau~ lf~g xobo~a`job rmoax poh~aro& nmlj`ob rmo
g{oxlraj` ~gcrplxo ljb nmlj`ob pmlr ajcgxdlragj rmoax {xgbunr~ ngjrlajob aj
L{xaf 8;<<& ‖~{gafaj`— osabojno*
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o <> gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?32
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 14/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ <2
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
[flajracc~ Osabojno9
[flajracc~ CLN& {{* 3<$02& ³³<22$<02 ljb {{* <80$<28& ³³ >>?$>025 Fahox
Bonf*& {{* 1$<;& ³885 G~roffl Bonf*& {*<>& ³>;& ljb O}h* <;& {* <8?5 ^rxohof
Bonf*& {{* 1$<<& ³³<?$<=& {{* <2$<?& ³8? ljb O}h~* ‖0— rmxgu`m ‖<;—& {{* >0$
?<5 ljb O}h* ‖<8—& {{* 3;$3>5 ljb [flajracc~ XIJ& O}mahar ‖8—& {{* 2>$20
Ajrofau~‑ ‖Lffo`ob— _jngjrxgsoxrob Clnr Jg* ?9
Parm xo`lxb rg rmo Ngj~udox Ajcgxdlragj ^oxsano~ ujar& gjo gc rmo ~oxsano~
rmlr Ajrofau~ gccox~ rmxgu`m rmlr basa~agj a~ l ‖hlne`xgujb nmone( ~olxnm
rmxgu`m ppp*ajrofau~*ngd*
[flajracc~ Ghionragj~9
L~~udo~ clnr~ jgr aj osabojno5 a~ jgr ~u{{gxrob hq ngd{orojr osabojno
da~~rlro~ mgp Ajrofau~‑ {xgbunr~ poxo gccoxob*
[flajracc~ Xo~{gj~o9
BA^[_ROB CLNR $ l~ rg ‖Ngj~udox Ajcgxdlragj ^oxsano ujar—5 ljb rmo
roxd ‖hlne`xgujb ~olxnm—5 _JBA^[_ROB l~ rg Ajrofau~ ~off~ rmoax
nu~rgdox~ hlne`xgujb xo{gxr~ gj ajbasabulf~* Lr rmo rado -aj gx lhgu
Dlxnm 8;;1! rmo lnragj~ rmlr `lso xa~o rg [flajracc~ flp~uar gnnuxxob& Ajrofau~
gccoxob lff rmoax {xgbunr~ rmxgu`m Ajrofau~ gj rmoax poh~aro lr
ppp*ajrofau~*ngd* Rmoxo pl~ jgrmaj` ajbanlraj` ‖Ngj~udox Ajcgxdlragj
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o <2 gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?3?
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 15/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ <?
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
^oxsano _jar—& gx rmlr rmoxo poxo ~o{lxlrob basa~agj~ gc Ajrofau~* Lff
hu~ajo~~ pl~ ngjbunrob rmxgu`m rmoax poh~aro ppp*ajrofau~*ngd*
[flajracc~ Osabojno9
[flajracc~ CLN& {{* 3<$02& ³³<22$<02 ljb {{* <80$<28& ³³ >>?$>025 Fahox
Bonf* BJ >=1$8& {{* <$8& ³³<$2 ljb O}h~ ‖L— ljb ‖H—& {{* =$8>5 G~roffl
Bonf*& BJ >1;$?& {{* >$2& ³³<;$<8 ljb O}h* ‖8—& {* <>5 ^rxohof Bonf*& {{* 1$
<<& ³³<?$<=& ljb O}h~* ‖0— rmxgu`m ‖<;—& {{* >0$?<5 ljb [flajracc~ XIJ&
O}mahar ‖8—& {{* 2>$20*
Ajrofau~‑ ‖Lffo`ob— _jngjrxgsoxrob Clnr Jg* 39
Rmo ajcgxdlragj {xgsabob hq {uhfan ~guxno~ ngjrlajob aj l (hlne`xgujb
nmone( xo{gxr$$gx ljq grmox rq{o gc xo{gxr Ajrofau~ {xgsabo~ rmxgu`m ar~
Ngj~udox Ajcgxdlragj ^oxsano~ ujar$ngjrlaj~ gjfq {uhfan ajcgxdlragj*
[flajracc~ Ghionragj~9
Da~folbaj`5 l~~udo~ clnr~ jgr aj osabojno5 a~ jgr ~u{{gxrob hq osabojno5 a~
jgr ~u{{gxrob hq ngd{orojr osabojno*
[flajracc~ Xo~{gj~o9
BA^[_ROB CLNR $ Ajrofau~‑ ~rlro~ rmoax ‖{uhfan xongxb~— ‖ngj~a~r~ gc
ajcgxdlragj rmlr a~ dlajrlajob hq `gsoxjdojr l`ojnao~—& [flajracc~ XIJ
O}h* ‖<—& {{*<2& 825 rmoax ‖{uhfanfq lslaflhfo ajcgxdlragj ngj~a~r~ gc
gjfajogccfajo ajcgxdlragj& dl`lyajo& jop~{l{ox~& ~gnalf jorpgxe~& orn
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o <? gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?33
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 16/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ <3
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
lslaflhfo hur jgr dlajrlajob hq l @gsoxjdojr l`ojnq& [flajracc~ XIJ& O}h
‖<—& {{*<2& 825 ljb rmoax ngddoxnalf xongxb~ ngj~a~r~ gc ldgj` grmox~&
rofo{mgjo ngjjonr ljb ba~ngjjonr xongxb~ rmlr rmoq {uxnml~o& xosox~o {mgjo
fgge$u{~ gj fljbfajo~& noffuflx {mgjo~& {l`ox~& orn* fa~rob ljb ujfa~rob*
[flajracc~ XIJ& O}h* ‖<—& {{* <2& 82* [uhfan xongxb~ ghrlajob cxgd coboxlf
~rlro gx fgnlf `gsoxjdojr xongxb~ nljjgr ngjrlaj ajcgxdlragj rmlr abojracao~
rmo ajcgxdlragj rg l ~{onacan {ox~gj* ^oo Nlf* Nas* Ngbo <01=*>& pmanm
~rlro~& ‖ L~ u~ob aj rma~ nml{rox9 -l! Rmo roxd ({ox~gjlf ajcgxdlragj( dolj~
ljq ajcgxdlragj rmlr a~ dlajrlajob hq lj l`ojnq rmlr abojracao~ gx bo~nxaho~
lj ajbasabulf& ajnfubaj`& hur jgr fadarob rg& ma~ gx mox jldo‣mgdo lbbxo~~&
mgdo rofo{mgjo judhox‣Ar ajnfubo~ ~rlrodojr~ dlbo hq& gx lrrxahurob rg&
rmo ajbasabulf *— ^oo lf~g Nlf* Nas* Ngbo <01=*82 -‖ Jg l`ojnq dlq ba~nfg~o
ljq {ox~gjlf ajcgxdlragj aj l dljjox rmlr pgufb faje rmo ajcgxdlragj
ba~nfg~ob rg rmo ajbasabulf rg pmgd ar {oxrlaj~‣—!* Coboxlf @gsoxjdojr a~
`gsoxjob hq rmo [xaslnq Lnr gc <102& ? _*^*N* ??8* Rofo{mgjo ngjjon
ljb ba~ngjjonr xongxb~ lxo dlajrlajob hq rmo rofo{mgjo ngd{ljao~ aj
ngjcabojno ljb lxo jgr {uhfan xongxb~* ^oo 0;8 gc ‖Rmo
Rofongddujanlragj~ Lnr gc <113—& 20 _*^*N* 888 -8;;3!* Coboxlf flp
{xgmahar~ rmo xofol~o gc ngj~udox~ rofo{mgjo xongxb~& pmanm ajnfubo
ngj~udox~ ‖ba~ngjjonr ljb ngjjonragj— xongxb~* Rmo gjfq plq l rmaxb {lxrq
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o <3 gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?30
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 17/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ <0
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
nlj ghrlaj l ngj~udox'~ {mgjo xongxb~& parmgur rmo ngj~udox'~ {oxda~~agj
gx l~ grmoxpa~o lurmgxayob hq flp& a~ rmxgu`m rmocr gx bono{ragj -cgx
o}ld{fo& hq ad{ox~gjlraj` rmo ngj~udox gx l {mgjo ngd{ljq
xo{xo~ojrlraso& mlneaj` ajrg rmo {mgjo ngd{ljq'~ ngd{urox ~q~rod& gx
hxahaj` gx nligfaj` lj od{fgqoo rg ~rolf gx grmoxpa~o ba~nfg~o rmo xongxb~!
[flajracc~ lxo jgr ~rlraj` gx ad{fqaj` rmlr Ajrofau~ a~ rmo gjo pmg ngddarrob
rmo nxado~& hur aj~rolb rmlr Ajrofau~ {uxnml~o~ rmo~o affo`lffq ghrlajob
xongxb~& hq Ajrofau~‑ gpj lbda~~agj~ aj rmoax Xo{gxr cafob parm rmo ^ON*
Ajrofau~& ~raff rg rma~ blro& gccox~ {mgjo judhox ajcgxdlragj gj fa~rob ljb
ujfa~rob {mgjo judhox~* Ajrofau~‑ hlne`xgujb xo{gxr~ ~gfb rg ngj~udox~ bg
jgr gjfq ngjrlaj {uhfan ajcgxdlragj*
[flajracc~ Osabojno9
[flajracc~ CLN& {{* 3<$02& ³³<22$<02 ljb {{* <80$<28& ³³ >>?$>025 Fahoxa
Bonf*& BJ >=1$8 {{* <$>& ³³<$? ljb O}h~* ‖L— ljb ‖H—& {{* =$8>5 G~roffl
Bonf*& >1;$?& {{* 2$3& ³³<2$<1 ljb O}h* ‖8—& {* <>5 Hox` Bonf*& BJ >=1$<&
{{* 8$2& ³³<2$<15 [flajracc~ XIJ& O}h ‖<—& {{* <2& 8?5 ^rxohof Bonf*& {{* <$>
³³<$?*
Ajrofau~‑ ‖Lffo`ob— _jngjrxgsoxrob Clnr Jg* 09
Ajrofau~ bgo~ jgr nxolro ljq gc rmo ngjrojr ngjrlajob aj ljq xo{gxr rmlr
Ajrofau~ {xgsabo~ u~ox~ rmxgu`m ar~ Ngj~udox Ajcgxdlragj ^oxsano~ ujar
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o <0 gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?3=
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 18/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ <=
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
ajnfubaj` l (hlne`xgujb nmone( xo{gxr5 aj~rolb& lff gc rmo ngjrojr ngjrlajob
aj xo{gxr~ Ajrofau~ cuxja~mo~ rmxgu`m ar~ Ngj~udox Ajcgxdlragj ^oxsano~ ujar
ngdo cxgd rmaxb {lxrao~*
[flajracc~ Ghionragj~9
L~~udo~ clnr~ jgr aj osabojno5 a~ jgr ~u{{gxrob hq ngd{orojr osabojno5 ljb
Ajrofau~‑ ~rlrodojr a~ da~folbaj`*
[flajracc~ Xo~{gj~o9
CLNR BA^[_ROB AJ [LXR $ Ar a~ ujba~{urob rmlr Ajrofau~ {uxnml~o~ flx`o
ldgujr~ gc blrl gj ajbasabulf~ cxgd >xb {lxrao~* Rma~ a~ rmo cax~r rad
[flajracc~ mlso molxb gx folxjob rmlr Ajrofau~ {xgsabo~ ajcgxdlragj rg l
Jlragjlf Nxobar Huxolu* Ar a~ BA^[_ROB rmlr lff rmo ajcgxdlragj ~gfb hq
Ajrofau~ ngdo~ cxgd >xb {lxrao~* Ajrofau~ ngffonr~ ljb ~rgxo~ lff rm
ajcgxdlragj rmoq xonoaso gj rmoax blrlhl~o~* Ajrofau~‑ xo{gxr~ aj pmanm rmoq
~off lxo nxolrob cxgd Ajrofau~‑ gpj blrlhl~o~* Ajrofau~ lbdar~ rg lu`dojraj`
rmo ajcgxdlragj aj pmanm rmoq ~off* Ajrofau~ ‖ngffonr~ ljb ajro`xlro~ blrl
cxgd rmgu~ljb~ gc gjfajo ljb gccfajo blrl ~guxno~ ljb u~o~ ~g{ma~ranlrob
ljlfqran~ ronmjgfg`ao~ rg nfolj~o& soxacq ljb lu`dojr rma~ blrl aj xolf rado rg
{xgsabo rmoax nu~rgdox~ parm lnragjlhfo ajcgxdlragj—& [flajracc~ XIJ& O}h
‖<— {* >8* Ajrofau~ ngjrajuo~& ‖Po mlso bosofg{ob lbsljnob {xg{xaorlxq
ronmjgfg`ao~ rmlr lnno~~& ngffonr ljb jgxdlfayo l hxglb xlj`o gc
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o <= gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?31
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 19/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ <1
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
ngj~udox‣ajcgxdlragj* Gux ljlfqran~ ronmjgfg`ao~ soxacq ljb lu`dojr
dufra{fo roxlhqro~ gc blrl& u~ulffq aj ba~{lxlro cgxdlr~ ljb parm slxqaj`
bo`xoo~ gc lnnuxlnq ljb ngd{forojo~~& cxgd l dqxalb gc ~guxno~ aj gxbox rg
dleo ajcoxojno~ ljb {xobanragj~ hl~ob gj rma~ blrl* Cgx o}ld{fo& gux
ronmjgfg`ao~ ojlhfo u~ rg ngj~rxunr l ~aj`fo abojrarq {xgcafo cgx l {ox~gj pmg
ml~ nmlj`ob ma~ gx mox fl~r jldo& lbbxo~~ gx {mgjo judhox*— Ajrofau~
Xo{gxr cafob parm rmo ^ON& [flajracc~ XIJ& O}mahar ‖<—& {{* <2& ><& >8& >?
>3* Aj Ob [orox~gj& O}onuraso Sano [xo~abojr gc Ajrofau~‑ [og{fo ^olxnm ljb
[og{fo Cajbox Ajroxsaop& mo ~rlro~ ‖‣pmlr po rxq rg bg a~ u~o l rgj gc
mouxa~ran {xgno~~o~ ljb rmo Ajrofau~ ronmjgfg`q rmlr lffgp~ u~ rg dlrnm
ajcgxdlragj rg`ormox& ~rarnm ajcgxdlragj rg`ormox rg {xo~ojr l soxq lnnuxlro
xo{gxr cgx gux nu~rgdox~—* UOd{ml~a~ LbbobT*<
Ajrofau~ lbdar~ rmoq {uxnml~o ajcgxdlragj gj ngj~udox~ cxgd >xb
{lxrao~& ljlfqyo~ rmo ajcgxdlragj& lu`dojr rmo ajcgxdlragj& ‖~rarnmo
ajcgxdlragj rg`ormox— l~~a`j~ rmo ajcgxdlragj rg l ~{onacan {ox~gj& ljb ~off~
rmo xo{gxr~ rmoq mlso nxolrob cxgd rmoax blrlhl~o~ rg rmoax {lqaj` nu~rgdox~
[flajracc~ XIJ& O}h* ‖<—& {{* <2& ><& >8& >?& >3 Ajrofau~ ~rlro~ gj rmoax
< Rma~ Nguxr dlq xonlff& lr rmo molxaj` gj Ajrofau~‑ Dgragj rg Ba~da~~& Gnrghox <0& 8;<;
Ajrofau~ l~eob cgx l ~rlq gc ba~ngsoxq& pmanm rma~ Nguxr bojaob* Bo~{aro rma~& Ajrofau~ ml~
xocu~ob rg ngd{fq parm [flajracc~ Ba~ngsoxq xo|uo~r~ ~oxsob gj rmod Iljulxq <>& 8;<8*
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o <1 gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?0;
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 20/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ 8;
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
poh~aro lr ppp*ajrofau~*ngdngx{ajrofau~ rmlr rmoq mlso rmo ronmjgfg ao~ rg
‖ngffonr& ajrox{xor ljb bofasox ajcgxdlragj rg ngj~udox~ ljb hu~ajo~~o~
gjfajo— ljb Ajrofau~ ~rlro~& ‖Po bg dunm dgxo rmlj bofasox xofalhfo ljb
lnnuxlro ajcgxdlragj po lu`dojr& ajrox{xor& ljb {xo~ojr ar hl~ob gj qgux
uja|uo joob~& nxolraj` slfulhfo ljb rxu~rob ~gfuragj~ cgx gux daffagj~ gc
nu~rgdox~‣— UOd{ml~a~ lbbob—T* Ajrofau~ ghrlaj~ ajcgxdlragj gj
ajbasabulf~& rmlr a~ ~rgxob ljb dlajrlajob gj Ajrofau~‑ blrlhl~o~ ljb Ajrofau~
lu`dojr~ rmo ajcgxdlragj ljb ‖nxolro~— rmo xo{gxr cxgd rmoax blrlhl~o~ gj
~{onacan ajbasabulf~ aj pmanm rmoq ~off*
[flajracc~ Osabojno9
[flajracc~ CLN& {{* 3<$02& ³³<22$<02 ljb {{* <80$<28& ³³ >>?$>025 Fahoxa
Bonf*& {{* <8$<>& ³<8 ljb {* <2& 81& O}h* ‖C—& {{* 23$?= -{`* 21! ljb ‖I—& {{
0;$085 ^rxohof Bonf*& {{* 2$?& ³³=$<< O}h~* ‖?— ljb ‖3—& {{* 81$>3
Ajrofau~‑ ‖Lffo`ob— _jngjrxgsoxrob Clnr Jg* =9
Aj gxbox rg xuj l (hlne`xgujb nmone( ~olxnm rmxgu`m Ajrofau~' poh~aro& l u~ox
ojrox~ rmxoo ~olxnm roxd~9 rmo cax~r ljb fl~r jldo gc rmo {ox~gj rmoq lxo
Rmoxocgxo& [flajracc~ lxo uj~uxo gc Ajrofau~‑ donmlja~d~ u~ob aj ‖~rarnmaj`— rmo
ajcgxdlragj rg`ormox gj ajbasabulf~*
[flajracc~ XIJ& O}mahar ‖<—& {{* <2& ><& >8& >?& >35 ljb Hox` Bonf* lr {*3& ³<>
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o 8; gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?0<
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 21/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ 8<
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
~olxnmaj` cgx& ljb rmoax ~rlro gc xo~abojno5 lfroxjlrasofq& l u~ox dlq ojrox l
{ox~gj'~ ~gnalf ~onuxarq ljb fl~r jldo -ac rmo u~ox ml{{oj~ rg mlso rml
ajcgxdlragj!& gx l ngdhajlragj gc ljq gc rmo~o {lxldorox~ rg ~olxnm lslaflhfo
{uhfan xongxb~*
[flajracc~ Ghionragj~9
Da~folbaj`& l~~udo~ clnr~ jgr aj osabojno ljb a~ jgr ~u{{gxrob hq
ngd{orojr osabojno& gx osabojno fgnlrob aj rmo Xongxb*
[flajracc~ Xo~{gj~o9
BA^[_ROB CLNR $ L ~olxnm parm Ajrofau~ nlj ho xuj u~aj` l fl~r jldo
gjfq& l ~rlro a~ jgr xo|uaxob* Gx& qgu nlj ojrox l ^gnalf ^onuxarq judhox ljb
gjfq l fl~r jldo* Gjno qgu mar ~uhdar l fa~r gc jldo~ parm lbbxo~~o~ ljb
l`o lxo xoruxjob* Ac qgu ejgp pmoxo rmo ajbasabulf xo~abo~& rmoj nfane rmo
hurrgj rmlr ~lq~ {uxnml~o rma~ xo{gxr* Qgu lxo {uxnml~aj` rmo xo{gxr gj
~{onacan {ox~gj* Ac rmo ^gnalf ^onuxarq Judhox bgo~ jgr dlrnm rmo fl~r
jldo& Ajrofau~ lffgp~ qgu rg ngjrajuo rxqaj` ujraf qgu lxo lhfo rg dlrnm rmo
fl~r jldo& gjno {lab& Ajrofau~ {xgsabo~ xo{gxr rg qgu aj qgux {l~~pgxb
{xgronrob lnngujr* Rmo ajcgxdlragj Ajrofau~‑ Nu~rgdox~ {uxnml~o~ g
ajbasabulf~ lxo jgr gjfq ‖{uhfan xongxb~—* Rmo ‖hlne`xgujb— xo{gxr~ ~gfb
lxo ‖ngj~udox xo{gxr~— l~ bocajob hq rmo CNXL& <? _*^*N* <3=<l-b!-<!
Ajrofau~ lbdar~ Hlne`xgujb ~olxnmo~ ljb {uxnml~ob xo{gxr~ nlj ho
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o 8< gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?08
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 22/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ 88
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
ngjbunrob hq ^gnalf ^onuxarq judhox URmujoj Bonf*& {* >& ³0T* L ^gnalf
^onuxarq judhox a~ {ox~gj ~{onacan5 gjo judhox a~ l~~a`job rg l {lxranuflx
{ox~gj& jgr l `xgu{ gc ajbasabulf~* Ajrofau~ ml~ lbdarrob rmoax hlne`xgujb
xo{gxr~ lxo {ox~gj ~{onacan*
[flajracc~ Osabojno9
[flajracc~ CLN& {{* 3<$02& ³³<22$<02 ljb {{* <80$<28& ³³>>?$>025 [flajracc~
XIJ& O}mahar ‖<—& {{* 83$8=& >;& >?& >1& 2<& O}mahar—>—& {{* 2=$?= ljb
O}mahar ‖2—& {{* ?1$335 Rmujoj Bonf*& {* >& ³0& Fahoxa Bonf* BJ >=1$8& {{* <$
8& ³³<& > ljb O}h~* ‖L— ljb ‖H—& {{* =$8>5 G~roffl Bonf* BJ >1;$?& {*2 ³8&
{* 3& ³<1 ljb O}h* ‖8—& {* <>5 ljb Hox` Bonf* BJ >=1$<& {* 2& ³15 G~roffl
Bonf* cafob moxoparm& {{* =$1& ³88& {{* <;$<8& ³³80$8= ljb O}h~* ‖=— ljb ‖1—&
{{* <<2$<8>5 Fahoxa Bonf* cafob moxoparm& {{* <8$<>& ³³—B—& ‖O—& {{* >0$2?
ljb ‖M—& ‖A—& {{* 38$0;5 ^rxohof Bonf*& {{* <$?& ³³& O}h~* ‖<— rmxgu`m ‖3—
{{* <3$>3
Ajrofau~‑ ‖Lffo`ob— _jngjrxgsoxrob Clnr Jg* 19
Ajrofau~ bgo~ jgr cuxja~m ljqgjo'~ ~gnalf ~onuxarq judhox rg ljq u~ox gc ar~
poh~aro& ljb ~unm ajcgxdlragj a~ josox {xgsabob rg u~ox~ gc Ajrofau~' ~aro aj
ljq nl{lnarq*
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o 88 gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?0>
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 23/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ 8>
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
[flajracc~ Ghionragj~9
L~~udo~ clnr~ jgr aj osabojno5 nlff~ cgx ~{onuflragj5 ljb a~ jgr ~u{{gxrob hq
ngd{orojr osabojno& gx rmo Xongxb aj rma~ nl~o*
[flajracc~ Xo~{gj~o9
BA^[_ROB CLNR $ Ajrofau~ lbdar~ hq ljb rmxgu`m Rmujoj& aj ma~
Bonflxlragj lr {{* =$1& ³8<& rmlr Ajrofau~ {xgsabo~ ajcgxdlragj rg rmo Jlragjlf
Nxobar huxolu~* Aj gxbox rg {xgsabo ajcgxdlragj rg l Jlragjlf Nxobar
Xo{gxraj` Huxolu& qgu du~r ajnfubo noxrlaj abojracqaj` blrl& ajnfubaj` hur
jgr fadarob rg rmo {ox~gj‑~ jldo& lbbxo~~& ^gnalf ^onuxarq judhox& blro~ gc
haxrm& orn* Ajrofau~ gccox~ ljb ~off~ ngj~udox~ nxobar xo{gxr~ gj rmoax poh~aro
lr ppp*ajrofau~*ngd5 ljb ajbasabulf~ ^gnalf ^onuxarq judhox lxo fgnlrob aj
rmoax od{fgqdojr hlne`xgujb xo{gxr~& rojljr ~nxooj xo{gxr~& orn* Aj clnr
Rmujoj lrrlnmob l~ O}mahar 2& BJ 2?3$2 l xonxolrob ng{q gc Fahoxa‑~
RlfojrPa~o xo{gxr& pmanm ngjrlaj~ l {lxralf ^gnalf ^onuxarq judhox& blro gc
haxrm& lbbxo~~o~ ljb jldo* G~roffl xlj l ~olxnm gj mox jldo& ljb cgujb mox
Ajrofau~ xo{gxr parm mox ^gnalf ^onuxarq judhox* ^oo G~roffl‑~ Bonf*& BJ
>1;$?& {* 2& ³³<8& <2& {* 3& ³<1 ljb O}h* ‖8—& {* <>*
[flajracc~ Osabojno9
[flajracc~ CLN& {{* 3<$02& ³³<22$<02 ljb {{* <80$<28& ³³ >>?$>025 Rmujoj
Bonf*& {{* =$1& ³8< ljb O}h* 25 Fahoxa Bonf*& BJ >=1$8 {* 8& ³2& O}h H& {{
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o 8> gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?02
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 24/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ 82
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
8;$8>5 G~roffl‑~ Bonf*& BJ >1;$?& {* 2& ³³<8& <2& {* 3& ³<1 ljb O}h* ‖8—& {*
<>5 Hox` Bonf* BJ >=1$<& {* 2& ³15 ljb [flajracc~ XIJ& O}h* ‖<—& {{*83& >2*
Ajrofau~‑ ‖Lffo`ob— _jngjrxgsoxrob Clnr Jg* <;9
Gjno l u~ox ojrox~ aj ma~ gx mox ~olxnm {lxldorox~& Ajrofau~' poh~aro rmoj
{oxcgxd~ l ~olxnm rmlr lnno~~o~ {uhfan xongxb~ blrlhl~o~& abojracao~ l
xongxb~ rmlr ngjrlaj rmg~o ~olxnm roxd~& xorxaoso~ rmo dlrnmaj` xongxb~& ljb&
gjno l u~ox {lq~ cgx rmoax ~olxnm& ba~{flq~ rmod rg rmo u~ox aj rmo cgxd
gc l pxarroj xo{gxr*
[flajracc~ Ghionragj~9
Da~folbaj`& jgr ~u{{gxrob hq ngd{orojr osabojno& nlff~ cgx ~{onuflragj ljb
l~~udo~ clnr~ jgr aj osabojno*
[flajracc~ Xo~{gj~o9
BA^[_ROB CLNR $ Ajrofau~ nflad~ rmoax {uhfan xongxb~ ngj~a~r gc
ajcgxdlragj gj ajbasabulf~& rmlr a~ dlajrlajob hq `gsoxjdojr l`ojnao~
{uhfanfq lslaflhfo ajcgxdlragj& rmlr Ajrofau~ nflad~ a~ ajcgxdlragj ghrlajob
cxgd gjfajo ljb gccfajo ajcgxdlragj rmlr a~ `ojoxlffq lslaflhfo hur jgr
dlajrlajob hq `gsoxjdojr l`ojnao~& ~unm l~ jldo~& lbbxo~~o~ ljb rofo{mgjo
judhox gc ajbasabulf~& {xgco~~agjlf fanoj~aj` ljb rxlbo gx`ljaylragj
ajcgxdlragj& jop~{l{ox lxranfo~& ljb ngjrojr cxgd hfg`~ ljbgx ~gnalf
jorpgxeaj` ~aro~5 ljb Ngddoxnalf Xongxb~ ngj~a~raj` gc ajcgxdlragj rmlr a~
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o 82 gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?0?
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 25/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ 8?
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
dlajrlajob hq ojrox{xa~o~ ljb a~ lslaflhfo cgx {uxnml~o& ~unm l~ {mgjo
ngjjonr ljb ba~ngjjonr ajcgxdlragj* ^oo
mrr{9ppp*ajrofau~*ngdngx{{xaslnq${gfanq ljb Ajrofau~‑ Gnrghox 8;;1
Xo{gxr rg rmo ^ON* Ajrofau~ gj rmoax poh~aro& ppp*ajrofau~*ngd& lbsoxra~o~
xosox~o {mgjo fgge$u{~ cgx fljbfajo~& noff {mgjo~ ljb {l`ox~& hgrm fa~rob ljb
ujfa~rob gj rmoax poh~aro lr mrr{9ppp*ajrofau~*ngd{og{fo$~olxnm
{mgjo*mrdf ljb mrr{9ppp*ajrofau~*ngdxosox~o${mgjo$fggeu{*mrdf* Ob
[orox~gj& O}onuraso Sano [xo~abojr gc Ajrofau~‑ [og{fo Cajbox ljb [og{fo
^olxnm buxaj` ma~ Ajroxsaop parm ‖Abojrarq Rmocr ^onxor~— rmlr Ajrofau~
dlajrlaj~ l{{xg}adlrofq <1 haffagj xongxb~ gj ajbasabulf~ aj$mgu~o*
[uhfan xongxb~ ghrlajob cxgd coboxlf& ~rlro gx fgnlf `gsoxjdojr xongxb~
nljjgr ngjrlaj ajcgxdlragj rmlr abojracao~ rmo ajcgxdlragj rg l ~{onacan
{ox~gj* ^oo Nlf* Nas* Ngbo <01=*>& pmanm ~rlro~& ‖ L~ u~ob aj rma
nml{rox9-l! Rmo roxd ({ox~gjlf ajcgxdlragj( dolj~ ljq ajcgxdlragj rmlr a~
dlajrlajob hq lj l`ojnq rmlr abojracao~ gx bo~nxaho~ lj ajbasabulf&
ajnfubaj`& hur jgr fadarob rg& ma~ gx mox jldo‣mgdo lbbxo~~& mgdo
rofo{mgjo judhox‣Ar ajnfubo~ ~rlrodojr~ dlbo hq& gx lrrxahurob rg& rmo
ajbasabulf *— ^oo lf~g Nlf* Nas* Ngbo <01=*82 -‖ Jg l`ojnq dlq ba~nfg~o ljq
{ox~gjlf ajcgxdlragj aj l dljjox rmlr pgufb faje rmo ajcgxdlragj ba~nfg~ob
rg rmo ajbasabulf rg pmgd ar {oxrlaj~‣—!* Coboxlf @gsoxjdojr a~ `gsoxjob
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o 8? gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?03
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 26/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ 83
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
hq rmo [xaslnq Lnr gc <102& ? _*^*N* ??8* Rofo{mgjo ngjjonr lj
ba~ngjjonr xongxb~ lxo dlajrlajob hq rmo rofo{mgjo ngd{ljao~ aj ngjcabojno
ljb lxo jgr {uhfan xongxb~* ^oo 0;8 gc ‖Rmo Rofongddujanlragj~ Lnr gc
<113—& 20 _*^*N* 888 -8;;3!* Coboxlf flp {xgmahar~ rmo xofol~o gc
ngj~udox~ rofo{mgjo xongxb~& pmanm ajnfubo~ ngj~udox~ ‖ba~ngjjonr ljb
ngjjonragj— xongxb~* Rmo gjfq plq l rmaxb {lxrq nlj ghrlaj l ngj~udox'~
{mgjo xongxb~& parmgur rmo ngj~udox'~ {oxda~~agj& gx l~ grmoxpa
lurmgxayob hq flp& a~ rmxgu`m rmocr gx bono{ragj -cgx o}ld{fo& hq
ad{ox~gjlraj` rmo ngj~udox gx l {mgjo ngd{ljq xo{xo~ojrlraso& mlneaj`
ajrg rmo {mgjo ngd{ljq'~ ngd{urox ~q~rod& gx hxahaj` gx nligfaj` lj
od{fgqoo rg ~rolf gx grmoxpa~o ba~nfg~o rmo xongxb~!* [flajracc~ lxo jgr
~rlraj` gx ad{fqaj` rmlr Ajrofau~ a~ rmo gjo pmg ngddarrob rmo nxado~& hur
aj~rolb rmlr Ajrofau~ {uxnml~o~ rmo~o affo`lffq ghrlajob xongxb~& hq Ajrofau~‑
gpj lbda~~agj~ aj rmoax Xo{gxr cafob parm rmo ^ON*
Ajrofau~ a~ ad{fqaj` rmlr pmoj l {ox~gj ngjbunr~ l ~olxnm& rmoj Ajrofau~
~olxnm >xb {lxrq blrlhl~o~ rg xorxaoso rmo ajcgxdlragj rmlr rmoq rmoj aj ruxj
~off rg rmoax nu~rgdox~* Rma~ ~ad{fq a~ jgr rmo nl~o* Ajrofau~ lbdar~ rg
lu`dojraj` rmo ajcgxdlragj aj pmanm rmoq ~off* Ajrofau~ ‖ngffonr~ ljb
ajro`xlro~ blrl cxgd rmgu~ljb~ gc gjfajo ljb gccfajo blrl ~guxno~ ljb u~o~
~g{ma~ranlrob ljlfqran~ ronmjgfg`ao~ rg nfolj~o& soxacq ljb lu`dojr rma~ blrl
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o 83 gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?00
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 27/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ 80
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
aj xolf rado rg {xgsabo rmoax nu~rgdox~ parm lnragjlhfo ajcgxdlragj—&
[flajracc~ XIJ& O}mahar ‖<—& {{* <2& ><& >8& >?& >3* Ajrofau~ ngjrajuo~& ‖Po
mlso bosofg{ob lbsljnob {xg{xaorlxq ronmjgfg`ao~ rmlr lnno~~& ngffonr ljb
jgxdlfayo l hxglb xlj`o gc ngj~udox‣ajcgxdlragj* Gux ljlfqran~
ronmjgfg`ao~ soxacq ljb lu`dojr dufra{fo roxlhqro~ gc blrl& u~ulffq aj
ba~{lxlro cgxdlr~ ljb parm slxqaj` bo`xoo~ gc lnnuxlnq ljb ngd{forojo~~
cxgd l dqxalb gc ~guxno~ aj gxbox rg dleo ajcoxojno~ ljb {xobanragj~ hl~ob
gj rma~ blrl* Cgx o}ld{fo& gux ronmjgfg`ao~ ojlhfo u~ rg ngj~rxunr l ~aj`fo
abojrarq {xgcafo cgx l {ox~gj pmg ml~ nmlj`ob ma~ gx mox fl~r jldo& lbbxo~~ gx
{mgjo judhox*—& [flajracc~ XIJ& O}mahar ‖<—& {* >8* Aj Ob [orox~gj
O}onuraso Sano [xo~abojr gc Ajrofau~‑ [og{fo ^olxnm ljb [og{fo Cajbox
Ajroxsaop& mo ~rlro~ ‖‣pmlr po rxq rg bg a~ u~o l rgj gc mouxa~ran {xgno~~o~
ljb rmo Ajrofau~ ronmjgfg`q rmlr lffgp~ u~ rg dlrnm ajcgxdlragj rg`ormox&
~rarnm ajcgxdlragj rg`ormox rg {xo~ojr l soxq lnnuxlro xo{gxr cgx gux
nu~rgdox~—* UOd{ml~a~ LbbobT Ajrofau~ lbdar~ rmoq {uxnml~o ajcgxdlragj
gj ngj~udox~ cxgd >xb {lxrao~& ljlfqyo~ rmo ajcgxdlragj& lu`dojr rm
ajcgxdlragj& ‖~rarnmo~ ajcgxdlragj rg`ormox— l~~a`j~ rmo ajcgxdlragj rg l
~{onacan {ox~gj& ljb ~off~ rmo xo{gxr~ rmoq mlso nxolrob cxgd rmoax blrlhl~o~
rg rmoax {lqaj` nu~rgdox~* [flajracc~ XIJ& O}mahar ‖<—& {{* <2& ><& >8& >?
>3* Ajrofau~ ~rlro~ gj rmoax poh~aro lr ppp*ajrofau~*ngdngx{ajrofau~ rmlr
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o 80 gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?0=
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 28/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ 8=
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
rmoq mlso rmo ronmjgfg`ao~ rg ‖ngffonr& ajrox{xor ljb bofasox ajcgxdlragj rg
ngj~udox~ ljb hu~ajo~~o~ gjfajo— ljb Ajrofau~ ~rlro~& ‖Po bg dunm dgxo
rmlj bofasox xofalhfo ljb lnnuxlro ajcgxdlragj po lu`dojr& ajrox{xor& ljb
{xo~ojr ar hl~ob gj qgux uja|uo joob~& nxolraj` slfulhfo ljb rxu~rob
~gfuragj~ cgx gux daffagj~ gc nu~rgdox~‣— UOd{ml~a~ lbbob—T* Ajrofau~
ghrlaj~ ajcgxdlragj gj ajbasabulf~& lu`dojr~ rmo ajcgxdlragj ljb ‖nxolro~—
rmo xo{gxr cxgd rmoax blrlhl~o gj ~{onacan ajbasabulf~ aj pmanm rmoq ~off*
Pmoj qgu ~a`j ajrg qgux {l~~pgxb {xgronrob lnngujr ljb {uxnml~o l xo{gxr
cxgd Ajrofau~& gjno qgu mar gxbox& qgu mlso rmo xo{gxr parmaj ~ongjb~* Hq
Ajrofau~‑ gpj lbda~~agj~& rmoq nxolro rmo xo{gxr~ aj pmanm rmoq ~off rg rmo
{uhfan*
[flajracc~ Osabojno9
[flajracc~ CLN& {{* 3<$02& ³³<22$<02 ljb {{* <80$<28& ³³ >>?$>025 Fahoxa
Bonf*& {{* <8$<>& ³80 ljb <1$8;& ³2; ljb O}h* ‖C—& {{* 23$?= -Ajrofau~‑ Ob
[orox~gj& O}onuraso Sano [xo~abojr gc Ajrofau~‑ [og{fo ^olxnm ljb [og{fo
Ajrofau~‑ ‖Lffo`ob— _jngjrxgsoxrob Clnr Jg* <<9
L (hlne`xgujb nmone( ~olxnm `ojoxlro~ l xo{gxr ngjrlajaj` {uhfan xongxb~
lhgur rmo {grojralf abojrarq gc rmo {ox~gj rmo u~ox pl~ ~olxnmaj` cgx hl~ob
³³ 3$= ljb {* 3& ³<>5 ljb [flajracc~ XIJ& O}mahar ‖<—& {{* <2& ><& >8& >?& >3*
Cajbox‑~ ajroxsaop!5 ^rxohof Bonf*& {{* 2$?& ³³=$<<5 Hox` Bonf* lr {{* >$2&
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o 8= gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?01
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 29/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ 81
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
u{gj rmo ~olxnm nxaroxal {xgsabob rg Ajrofau~ hq rmo u~ox hq xoruxjaj` rg rmo
u~ox {uhfan xongxb~ ajcgxdlragj cgx baccoxojr ajbasabulf~ parm rmo ~ldo gx
~adaflx jldo*
[flajracc~ Ghionragj~9
Da~folbaj`5 Da~|ugro~ rmo osabojno& Da~|ugro~ rmo Bonflxlragj~ gj cafo ljb
hoaj` u~ob hq Ajrofau~5 L~~udo~ clnr~ jgr aj osabojno5 ljb nlff~ cgx
~{onuflragj*
[flajracc~ Xo~{gj~o9
BA^[_ROB CLNR $ Dlxnm 8;;1& aj gx lhgur pmoj rmo Rlary ljb ^ljeoq
Bocojbljr~ xlj hlne`xgujb xo{gxr~ gj [flajracc~& rmxgu`m L{xaf 8;<< lff
{xgbunr~ gccoxob hq Ajrofau~& Ajn* poxo {ox~gj ~{onacan* Qgu ngufb lf~
ghrlaj l hlne`xgujb xo{gxr gj ljq ajbasabulf hq ojroxaj` rmoax ^gnalf
^onuxarq judhox pmanm a~ l {ox~gj ~{onacan xo{gxr* ^gnalf ^onuxarq judhox~
lxo {ox~gj ~{onacan* L ^gnalf ^onuxarq judhox a~ a~~uob rg l {lxranuflx
{ox~gj& jgr l `xgu{ gc ajbasabulf~* Jgr lff ajcgxdlragj gccoxob ljb ~gfb hq
Ajrofau~ poxo ‖{uhfan xongxb~—* Ajrofau~ ~{gafob osabojno aj rma~ nl~o* Aj gx
lhgur L{xaf 8;<<& Ajrofau~ xobo~a`job rmoax poh~aro& nmlj`ob rmo ~gcrplxo rmo
poh~aro g{oxlro~ cxgd& hq rmoax gpj lbda~~agj& ljb nmlj`ob rmo blrl
ngjrlajob aj xo{gxr~ ~gfb rg ajbasabulf~*
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o 81 gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?=;
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 30/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ >;
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
[flajracc~ Osabojno9
[flajracc~ CLN& {{* 3<$02& ³³<22$<02 ljb {{* <80$<28& ³³>>?$>025 [flajracc~
XIJ& O}mahar ‖<—& {{* 83$8=& >;& >?& >1& 2<& O}mahar—>—& {{* 2=$?= ljb
O}mahar ‖2—& {{* ?1$335 Rmujoj Bonf*& {* >& ³0& Fahoxa Bonf* BJ >=1$8& {{* <$
8& ³³<& > ljb O}h~* ‖L— ljb ‖H—& {{* =$8>5 G~roffl Bonf* BJ >1;$?& {*2 ³8&
{* 3& ³<1 ljb O}h* ‖8—& {* <>5 ljb Hox` Bonf* BJ >=1$<& {* 2& ³15 G~roffl
Bonf* cafob moxoparm& {{* =$1& ³88& {{* <;$<8& ³³80$8= ljb O}h~* ‖=— ljb ‖1—&
{{* <<2$<8>5 Fahoxa Bonf* cafob moxoparm& {{* <8$<>& ³³—B—& ‖O—& {{* >0$2?
ljb ‖M—& ‖A—& {{* 38$0;5 ^rxohof Bonf*& {{* <$?& ³³& O}h~* ‖<— rmxgu`m ‖3—
{{* <3$>3*
Ajrofau~‑ ‖Lffo`ob— _jngjrxgsoxrob Clnr Jg* <89
Hocgxo ljq u~ox gc Ajrofau~' poh~aro nlj xuj l (hlne`xgujb nmone( ~olxnm
ljb ghrlaj l xo{gxr& rmoq du~r noxracq ljb l`xoo rg ho hgujb hq rmo (Roxd~
ljb Ngjbaragj~( cgx rmlr {lxranuflx ~olxnm& pmanm {xgsabo rmlr rmo
ajcgxdlragj hoaj` {xgsabob pl~ jgr ajrojbob rg ho u~ob& ljb nljjgr ho
u~ob& cgx ljq {ux{g~o ujbox rmo CNXL*
[flajracc~ Ghionragj~9
L~~udo~ clnr~ jgr aj osabojno5 Da~|ugro~ rmo ro~radgjq ljb pmlr a~ ~rlrob
aj rmo Bonflxlragj~ Ajrofau~ u~ob rg ~u{{gxr rmoax ~rlrodojr5 a~ jgr ~u{{gxrob
hq ngd{orojr osabojno5 a~ jgr ~u{{gxrob hq rmo Xongxb5 a~ da~folbaj`5 a~ jgr
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o >; gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?=<
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 31/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ ><
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
~u{{gxrob hq rmo ‖osabojno— {xgsabob hq Ajrofau~ parm rmoax Dgragj5 ljb
nlff~ cgx ~{onuflragj*
[flajracc~ Xo~{gj~o9
BA^[_ROB CLNR $ Rmoxo pl~ jgr ljq xo|uaxodojr rg noxracq rg Ajrofau~‑
‖Roxd~ ljb Ngjbaragj~— pmoj ~olxnmaj` l jldo gj rmoax poh~aro lr
ppp*ajrofau~*ngd* Jgpmoxo aj rmo Bonflxlragj gc Fa~l Fahoxa narob hq
Ajrofau~& bgo~ Fahoxa dojragj gx ba~nu~~ Ajrofau~‑ ‖roxd~ ljb ngjbaragj~— gx
ljq xo|uaxodojr rg noxracq gx l`xoo rg ho hgujb hq Ajrofau~ ‖Roxd~ ljb
Ngjbaragj~—* Jgx bgo~ Fahoxa dojragj gx nflad ~mo pl~ xo|uaxob rg bg ~unm
Cuxrmoxdgxo& rmo ‖Roxd~ ljb Ngjbaragj~— lrrlnmob rg Rmujoj‑~ Bonflxlragj
l~ O}mahar ‖<— lxo jgr rmo ~ldo ‖Roxd~ ljb Ngjbaragj~— fgnlrob gj Ajrofau~
poh~aro Dlxnm 8;;1 -aj gx lhgur rmo rado rmo Rlary ljb ^ljeoq Bocojbljr~
{uxnml~ob rmo hlne`xgujb xo{gxr~ gj [flajracc~! rmxgu`m L{xaf <;& 8;<; -rmo
rado Fahoxa {uxnml~ob l hlne`xgujb xo{gxr gj mox~ofc cxgd Ajrofau~!*
[flajracc~ Osabojno9
Rmujoj Bonf*& {* 2& ³³ <;$<<& ljb O}h* ‖<—5 Fahoxa Bonf*& BJ >=1$8& {* <& ³<
ljb O}h* L5 ^rxohof Bonf*& {{* <8$<>& ³³8;$8<*5 Fahoxa Bonf*& {* 8;& ³2<
Rlary Bonf*& ljb BJ 2??$>& {{* <$8& ³³<$8*
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o >< gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?=8
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 32/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ >8
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
Ajrofau~‑ ‖Lffo`ob— _jngjrxgsoxrob Clnr Jg* <>9
Rmo (Roxd~ ljb Ngjbaragj~( cgx l (hlne`xgujb nmone( ~olxnm lxo lnno~~ahfo
sal mq{oxfaje gj rmo gxbox ngjcaxdlragj ~nxooj& pmanm l{{olx~ hocgxo rmo
u~ox dlq xuj l (hlne`xgujb nmone( ~olxnm ljb ghrlaj l xo{gxr* Gj rmlr
~nxooj& rmo u~ox ngjcaxd~ ma~ gx mox {uxnml~o& ljb lccaxd~9 (A lnno{r rmo
Roxd~ ljb Ngjbaragj~*(
[flajracc~ Ghionragj~9
Da~folbaj`& l~~udo~ clnr~ jgr aj osabojno& a~ jgr ~u{{gxr hq ngd{orojr
osabojno& ljb nlff~ cgx ~{onuflragj*
[flajracc~ Xo~{gj~o9
BA^[_ROB CLNR $ Cxgd aj gx lhgur Dlxnm 8;;1& pmoj rmo Rlary ljb
^ljeoq Bocojbljr~ ngjbunrob ljb {uxnml~ob rmo hlne`xgujb xo{gxr~ gj
[flajracc~& rmoxo pl~ jgr xo|uaxodojr rg nfane ljqrmaj` hocgxo {uxnml~aj` l
xo{gxr*
Ajrofau~ nmlj`ob rmoax poh~aro lr ppp*ajrofau~*ngd aj gx lhgur rmo
dabbfoojb gc L{xaf 8;<< -^{gfalragj gc Osabojno!* Lr rma~ ~ldo rado
Ajrofau~ nmlj`ob pmlr qgu ghrlajob aj l xo{gxr5 nmlj`ob rmoax ~gcrplxo rmlr
g{oxlro~ ljb xuj~ rmoax poh~aro5 ljb nmlj`ob rmo l{{olxljno gc rmoax
nu~rgdox~‑ lnngujr~* Jgp parm rmo jop nmlj`o~& pmoj gjo gc Ajrofau~
nu~rgdox~ ~olxnmo~ cgx lj ajbasabulf& ljb rmoq nfane rmo xo{gxr aj pmanm rmoq
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o >8 gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?=>
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 33/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ >>
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
pljr& rmoq lxo rleoj rg l ~nxooj aj rmoax lnngujr& pmanm ~mgp~ rmoax {lqdojr
borlaf~ gj cafo* Aj gxbox rg {uxnml~o rmo xo{gxr& qgu nfane l flx`o gxlj`o
hurrgj rmlr ~rlro~& ‖A‑d Bgjo, [xgno~~ Dq Xo{gxr—& ujbox rma~ hurrgj a~
`xoq ro}r hg} aj 3 {gajr rmlr qgu nljjgr xolb* ^oo Eoffq rxohof‑~ Bonflxlragj
cafob ngjnuxxojrfq moxoparm* Ajrofau~ ml~ ~{gafob osabojno& rmoq mlso
xonxolrob rmoax poh~aro& u~aj` baccoxojr ~gcrplxo& ljb nmlj`ob rmo
ajcgxdlragj qgu ghrlaj aj l xo{gxr5 ljb rmoq mlso nmlj`ob rmo saop ljb
ajcgxdlragj gj rmoax nfaojr~ lnngujr {l`o~ lcrox rmoq poxo ~oxsob parm
[flajracc~ flp~uar*
[flajracc~ Osabojno9
Rmujoj Bonf*& {* 2& ³³ <;$<<& ljb O}h* ‖<—5 Fahoxa Bonf*& BJ >=1$8& {* <& ³<
ljb O}h* L5 ^rxohof Bonf*& {{* <8$<>& ³³8;$8<*5 Fahoxa Bonf*& {* 8;& ³2<5
Ajrofau~‑ ‖Lffo`ob— _jngjrxgsoxrob Clnr Jg* <29
Ajrofau~ bgo~ jgr xorlaj ng{ao~ gc rmo lnrulf xo{gxr~ ar ~off~ rg u~ox~ gc ar~
poh~aro5 aj~rolb& l~ {lxr gc ar~ hu~ajo~~ xongxb~& Ajrofau~ xorlaj~ rmo ~olxnm
ma~rgxq gc jldo~ rmlr lxo ~olxnmob gj rmo poh~aro~ gc Ajrofau~ ljb ar~
lccafalro~*
[flajracc~ Ghionragj~9
L~~udo~ clnr~ jgr aj osabojno5 ljb jgr ~u{{gxrob hq ngd{orojr osabojno*
Rlary Bonf*& ljb BJ 2??$>& {{* <$8& ³³<$8*
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o >> gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?=2
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 34/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ >2
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
[flajracc~ Xo~{gj~o9
BA^[_ROB CLNR „ Rmujoj ~rlro~ aj ma~ Bonflxlragj& 2?3 lr {l`o~ ?$3
³<> rmlr jg gjo {uxnml~ob l xo{gxr gj Fa~l G~roffl5 ljb gj {l`o =& ³<1 rmlr
jgjo gc rmo ‖^ljeoq‑~— ghrlajob ljq ajcgxdlragj gj ljq gc rmo [flajracc~
cxgd Ajrofau~* Ajrofau~ ~rlro~ rmoq bg jgr xorlaj ljq xo{gxr~ ~gfb gj
ajbasabulf~& gx ljq xo{gxr~ ~gfb rg rmoax nu~rgdox~* Rmoxo a~ jg plq Rmujoj
pgufb ejgp pmlr xo{gxr~ poxo ~gfb* Nu~rgdox‑~ xonoa{r~ bgo~ jgr ~mgp
pmg rmo xo{gxr ~gfb {oxrlaj~ rg* ^oo Fahoxa Bonflxlragj cafob ngjnuxxojrfq
moxoparm& O}mahar~ ‖L— rmxgu`m ‖B— pmanm mlso rmo Ajrofau~ xonoa{r~* Lf~g
rmo xo{gxr~ Ajrofau~‑ nu~rgdox~ {uxnml~o& lxo gjfq fa~rob aj rmoax lnngujr~ cgx
l ~mgxr {oxagb gc rado* Ajrofau~ ngjrxlbanr~ rmoax gpj osabojno* Rmo
Bonflxlragj gc Rmujoj lr {l`o ?& ³<8 ~rlro~ Ajrofau~ bgo~ jgr dlajrlaj
ng{ao~ gc xo{gxr~ ar ~off~* Hur& rmoj lrrlnmo~ l~ O}mahar ‖2— UBJ 2?3$2T l
ng{q gc l RlfojrPa~o xo{gxr rmlr mo nflad~ a~ l rxuo ljb ngxxonr ng{q gc rmo
gjo Fahoxa {uxnml~ob* L~ ~rlrob lhgso aj ³A& {{* >$=& rma~ ~ad{fq a~ jgr rmo
nl~o*
Ajrofau~ clafob rg naro rg ~olxnmo~ ngjbunrob gj Fahoxa ljb G~roffl {xagx rg rmo
blro Ajrofau~ cafob rmoax ^uddlxq Iub`dojr* Rmujoj aj ma~ Bonflxlragj cafob
hq Ajrofau~ dleo~ jg xocoxojno rg rmoax grmox > nu~rgdox~ -a! Elrxajel
Flp~gj5 -aa! Roxo~l Fg``al5 ljb -aaa! Iufaoljl Nmgq& pmg {uxnml~ob xo{gxr~
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o >2 gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?=?
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 35/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ >?
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
gj Fahoxa UJof~gj ^o{r* <?& << Bonf*& BJ >=;$>& {* 0& ³<1T* Jgx a~ rmoxo ljq
dojragj gc rmo ~olxnmo~ {oxcgxdob hq Fa~l G~roffl aj Jgsodhox 8;<<& gx rmo
Xo{gxr {uxnml~ob hq Fahoxa aj ^o{rodhox 8;<<* ^ajno Ajrofau~ bgo~ jgr
xorlaj xo{gxr~ aj pmanm rmoq mlso ~gfb gj ajbasabulf~& rmoj rmoq xonxolrob rmo
RlfojrPa~o xo{gxr {uxnml~ob hq Fahoxa* Rmujoj‑~ ro~radgjq a~ jgr nxobahfo*
[flajracc~ Osabojno9
Fahoxa Bonf*& >=1$8& {{* <$8& ³³<$2 O}h* ‖L— ljb ‖H—& {{* =$8>5 Hox` Bonf*
{{* 2$?& ³³<;$<<5 Hojildaj Jof~gj U‖Jof~gj—T Bonf*& BJ >=;$>& {* 0& ³<1
Rmujoj Bonf* TBJ 2?3T& {{* 3$0& ³<3 ljb O}h* 2 UBJ 2?3$2T5 Ljb Bonf*‑~
cafob moxoparm& ^rxohof& {{* ?$1& ³³<8$<25 ljb Fahoxa Bonf*& {{* <$1& ³³<$8;*
Ajrofau~‑ ‖Lffo`ob— _jngjrxgsoxrob Clnr Jg* <?9
Ajrofau~ ml~ josox ~gfb l xo{gxr gj rmo jldo (Fa~l G~roffl( rg ljqgjo
ajnfubaj` rmo bocojbljr~ rg rma~ flp~uar*
[flajracc~ Ghionragj~9
Jgr ~u{{gxrob hq ngd{orojr osabojno*
[flajracc~ Xo~{gj~o9
BA^[_ROB CLNR „ Rmujoj lbdar~ aj ma~ Bonflxlragj& BJ 2?3& {l`o ?
³<8 rmlr Ajrofau~ bgo~ jgr dlajrlaj xo{gxr~ ~gfb rg rmoax nu~rgdox‑~ gx gj
ajbasabulf~ rg pmgd rmoq {oxrlaj* Ajrofau~ gjfq ~rgxo~ rmo xo{gxr~ {uxnml~ob
hq rmoax nu~rgdox‑~ aj rmoax nu~rgdox‑~ {l~~pgxb {xgronr lnngujr cgx cgxrq$
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o >? gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?=3
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 36/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ >3
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
caso U2?T blq~& rmlr ajnfubo~ rmo ~nxooj rmlr ~mgp~ rmo xo{gxr~ rmo nu~rgdox
{uxnml~ob gj ~{onacan ajbasabulf~& ~oo Fahoxa‑~ Bonflxlragj O}mahar ‖O—& {{
28$22* Rmoxo a~ jg plq Rmujoj pgufb ejgp ac l xo{gxr pl~ ~gfb rg ljqgjo
xo`lxbaj` ljq gc rmo [flajracc~ aj rma~ nl~o* Nu~rgdox~ pmg {uxnml~o xo{gxr~
cxgd Ajrofau~ xonoaso lj odlaf xonoa{r& hur rmo xonoa{r bgo~ jgr ~mgp pmg rmo
xo{gxr pl~ {uxnml~ob gj* ^oo Fahoxa‑~ Bonflxlragj& O}mahar~ ‖L— rmxgu`m
‖B—& {{* 8>$2<* Gxfq Rlary ljb rmo ^ljeoq Bocojbljr~ xlj rmo xo{gxr~ gj
[flajracc~ aj gx lhgur olxfq Dlxnm 8;;1 ljb Ajrofau~ pl~ jgr jldob aj rma~
~uar ujraf Iujo 8;<<* Rmujoj pgufb jgr mlso ljq ejgpfob`o ljb jg plq rg
soxacq pmormox ljq gc rmo ^ljeoq‑~ {uxnml~ob xo{gxr~ gj ljq gc rmo
[flajracc~* Ajrofau~ nmlj`ob rmoax ojraxo poh~aro lr ppp*ajrofau~*ngd
ajnfubaj` rmo bo~a`j& rmo ~gcrplxo urafayob rg xujg{oxlro rmoax poh~aro& rmoq
nmlj`ob pmlr rmoax ‖hlne`xgujb— xo{gxr~ {xgsabo5 ljb rmoq nmlj`ob rmo
l{{olxljno gc nu~rgdox~‑ lnngujr~* Lff ~olxnm nxaroxal gj ajbasabulf~ pgufb
ho fg~r ujfo~~ {xg{oxfq hlneob u{ ljb dlajrlajob* Ajrofau~ bgo~ jgr lbbxo~~
ljq gc rmo grmox Rlary Bocojbljr~5 Ajrofau~ dleo~ jg dojragj gc rmoax grmox
{xgbunr~5 ljb Ajrofau~ olxfaox nfladob G~roffl mlb jgr osoj xuj l ~olxnm gj
mox~ofc& ljb rmoj nmlj`ob rmoax ~rgxq gjno {xggc pl~ cafob parm rma~ Nguxr
Ajrofau~ claf~ rg dojragj rmo xo{gxr~ G~roffl xlj ljb {uxnml~ob gj mox ljb
Fahoxa gj Jgsodhox >;& 8;<< ljb Fahoxa‑~ ^olxnm {oxcgxdob ljb xo{gxr
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o >3 gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?=0
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 37/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ >0
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
{uxnml~ob gj mox~ofc aj ^o{rodhox 8;<<* Rmu~& Rmujoj‑~ ro~radgjq aj ma
Bonflxlragj& ujbox rmo {ojlfrq gc {oxiuxq& a~ clf~o ljb bono{raso*
[flajracc~ Osabojno9
[flajracc~ CLN& {* 82 ³30& 8?& ³0;& {{* 3?$33& ³³<??$<?3& {* <><& ³>2>& {
<2;& ³>0?5 Rmujoj Bonf*& {*? & ³<85 Fahoxa Bonf*& {{* 1$<8& ³³88$83& O}h~
‖L— rmxgu`m ‖O—& {{* 8>$225 G~roffl Bonf*& {{* 0$=& ³³ <0$<1& O}h~* ‖3—& {{
12$<;? ljb ‖<;—& {* <8?5 ^rxohof Bonf*& {{* ?$3& ³<8& {{* 1$<<& ³³<?$<=
O}h~* ‖0—$‖<;—& {{* >0$?<*
Ajrofau~‑ ‖Lffo`ob— _jngjrxgsoxrob Clnr Jg* <39
Ajrofau~ ml~ josox ~gfb ljq ajcgxdlragj rg ljqgjo& ajnfubaj` rmo bocojbljr~
rg rma~ flp~uar& xo`lxbaj` {flajracc Fa~l G~roffl*
[flajracc~ Ghionragj~9
Da~|ugro~ ro~radgjq ljb osabojno gj cafo parm rma~ Nguxr5 da~|ugro~ rmo
ro~radgjq {xgsabob hq Gxfq Rlary aj mox Bonflxlragj cafob hq Ajrofau~& BJ
2??$>*
[flajracc~ Xo~{gj~o9
BA^[_ROB CLNR $ Rmujoj lbdar~ aj ma~ Bonflxlragj& BJ 2?3& {l`o ?
³<8 rmlr Ajrofau~ bgo~ jgr dlajrlaj xo{gxr~ ~gfb rg rmoax nu~rgdox‑~ gx gj
ajbasabulf~ rg pmgd rmoq {oxrlaj* Ajrofau~ gjfq ~rgxo~ rmo xo{gxr~ {uxnml~ob
hq rmoax nu~rgdox‑~ aj rmoax nu~rgdox‑~ {l~~pgxb {xgronr lnngujr cgx cgxrq$
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o >0 gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?==
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 38/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ >=
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
caso U2?T blq~& rmlr ajnfubo~ rmo ~nxooj rmlr ~mgp~ rmo xo{gxr~ rmo nu~rgdox
{uxnml~ob gj ~{onacan ajbasabulf~& ~oo Fahoxa‑~ Bonflxlragj O}mahar ‖O—& {{
28$22* Rmoxo a~ jg plq Rmujoj pgufb ejgp ac l xo{gxr pl~ ~gfb rg ljqgjo
xo`lxbaj` ljq gc rmo [flajracc~ aj rma~ nl~o* Nu~rgdox~ pmg {uxnml~o xo{gxr~
cxgd Ajrofau~ xonoaso lj odlaf xonoa{r& hur rmo xonoa{r bgo~ jgr ~mgp pmg rmo
xo{gxr pl~ {uxnml~ob gj* ^oo Fahoxa‑~ Bonflxlragj& O}mahar~ ‖L— rmxgu`m
‖B—& {{* 8>$2<* Gxfq Rlary ljb rmo ^ljeoq Bocojbljr~ xlj rmo xo{gxr~ gj
[flajracc~ aj gx lhgur olxfq Dlxnm 8;;1 ljb Ajrofau~ pl~ jgr jldob aj rma~
~uar ujraf Iujo 8;<<* Rmujoj pgufb jgr mlso ljq ejgpfob`o ljb jg plq rg
soxacq pmormox ljq gc rmo ^ljeoq‑~ gx ljq grmox {ox~gj {uxnml~ob xo{gxr~ gj
ljq gc rmo [flajracc~* Rmujoj aj ma~ Bonflxlragj& ujbox rmo {ojlfrq gc {oxiuxq
dleo~ rma~ ~rlrodojr* Mgposox& ar a~ ujrxuo* Gj Jgsodhox >;& 8;<<& Fa~l
G~roffl {uxnml~ob xo{gxr~ gj mox~ofc ljb Fa~l Fahoxa rmxgu`m mox Ajrofau~
lnngujr*
Gxfq Rlary lbdarrob rmo hlne`xgujb xo{gxr~ ghrlajob gj [flajracc~ nldo
cxgd Ajrofau~ ljb rmo Xoob Bocojbljr~& Rlary Dgragj rg Ba~da~~ gj homlfc gc
Bocojb gux Cxoobgd~ Cgujblragj~& Ajn*& BJ 8=>& cafob Iufq <<& 8;<<& {{* <0
ljb <15 Rlary aj mox Bonflxlragj bgo~ jgr dojragj ljqrmaj` lhgur Xo{gxr~
Gxfq Rlary {uxnml~ob& gjfq ~olxnmo~ ngjbunrob rmxgu`m Ajrofau~& pmanm lxo
cxoo& hur xo{gxr~ {uxnml~ob ngjrlaj dgxo blrl rmlj rmo ~olxnm* Bocojbljr
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o >= gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?=1
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 39/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ >1
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
Joaf ^ljeoq mlb lf~g ~rlrob dufra{fo rado~ rmlr mo xlj ~olxnmo~ gj [flajracc
Fa~l G~roffl rmxgu`m Ajrofau~* ^oo Fa~l G~roffl‑~ Bonflxlragj& BJ >1;$?& {* >
³<;* Ljqgjo nlj xuj l ~olxnm gj l jldo& ljb paff xonoaso l fa~r gc rmo
jldo~& gc lff ajbasabulf~ rmlr ~mlxo rmo jldo ljb ajbasabulf~ parm ~adaflx
jldo~* Qgu du~r rmoj nfane gj rmo hurrgj jo}r rg rmo jldo& haxrm blro& l`o
ljb lbbxo~~ aj pmanm qgu pljr rg {uxnml~o* Ljb& rmo xo{gxr~ {uxnml~ob lxo
{ox~gj ~{onacan* ^oo Fahoxa‑~ Bonf*& BJ >=1$8& {{* <$8& ³³<$25 G~roffl Bonf*&
BJ >1;$?& {* 2& ³<25 ljb rmo ^o{rodhox 82& 8;<< Bonflxlragj gc [mafa{ I
Hox & BJ >=1$<& {* 2& ³1* Ajrofau~ claf~ rg dleo ljq xocoxojno rg Bocojbljr~
Gxfq Rlary& Ajn*& Flp Gccano~ gc Gxfq Rlary gx Bocojb gux Cxoobgd~
Cgujblragj~& Ajn*
[flajracc~ Osabojno9
[flajracc~ CLN& {* 82 ³30& 8?& ³0;& {{* 3?$33& ³³<??$<?3& {* <><& ³>2>& {
<2;& ³>0?5 Rmujoj Bonf*& {*? & ³<85 Fahoxa Bonf*& {{* 1$<8& ³³88$83& O}h~
‖L— rmxgu`m ‖O—& {{* 8>$225 G~roffl Bonf*& {{* 0$=& ³³ <0$<1& O}h~* ‖3—& {{*
12$<;? ljb ‖<;—& {* <8?5 ^rxohof Bonf*& {{* ?$3& ³<8& {{* 1$<<& ³³<?$<=
O}h~* ‖0—$‖<;—& {{* >0$?<& Rlary Bonf*& BJ 2??$>& {* 85 ljb Rlary Dgragj rg
Ba~da~~ gj homlfc gc Bocojb gux Cxoobgd~ Cgujblragj~& Ajn*& BJ 8=>& cafob
Iufq <<& 8;<<& {{* <0 ljb <1*
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o >1 gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?1;
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 40/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ 2;
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
Ajrofau~‑ ‖Lffo`ob— _jngjrxgsoxrob Clnr Jg* <09
Gj Gnrghox 81& 8;<;& Fa~l G~roffl pxgro l forrox rg Ajrofau~ xo|uo~raj` rmo
jldo~ gc ljq {ox~gj rmlr mlb bgjo l ~olxnm gj mox rmxgu`m Ajrofau~‑ poh~aro*
[flajracc~ Ghionragj~9
Da~|ugro~ G~roffl‑~ forrox5 ljb Da~folbaj`*
[flajracc~ Xo~{gj~o9
BA^[_ROB CLNR AJ [LXR „ Ar a~ ujba~{urob rmlr G~roffl pxgro l forrox
rg Ajrofau~ gj Gnrghox 81& 8;<;* BA^[_ROB l~ rg rmo xo~r gc Ajrofau~‑
‖Lffo`ob _jngjrxgsoxrob Clnr Jg* <0* G~roffl ajcgxdob Ajrofau~ ~mo pl~ rmo
sanrad gc nxado~ ljb ~u{{faob rmo l`ojnq jldo gc pmg rgge rmo nxadajlf
xo{gxr ljb rmo nl~o judhox* G~roffl l~eob cgx lff xo|uo~r~ cgx ajcgxdlragj gj
mox ljb mox mu~hljb ljb l~eob rmlr ar ho {xgsabob hq jldo& ojrarq ljb
ngjrlnr ajcgxdlragj gj lff xo|uo~r~ ljb xo{gxr~ ~gfb& gx ljq ajcgxdlragj
{xgsabob aj xo`lxb~ rg mox~ofc ljb ~{gu~o* G~roffl {xgsabob mox ljb mo
mu~hljb‑~ cuff jldo~ ljb blro~ gc haxrm* ^oo Rmujoj‑~ Bonf* UBJ 2?3T& {* 3
³<2 ljb O}h* 8 U2?3$8T rmoxorg5 ljb Jof~gj‑~ Bonf* UBJ >=;$>T& {{* 3$0 ljb
O}h* 3 UBJ >=;$1T ljb G~roffl‑~ Bonf* cafob ^o{rodhox 82& 8;<<& BJ >1;$?
{* 8& ³³8$2* Ajrofau~ claf~ rg dojragj ljq xocoxojno rg rmo forrox Fahoxa ~oj
xo`lxbaj` ba~nxo{ljnao~ aj rmo ajcgxdlragj rmoq dlajrlajob& Fahoxa Bonf*
BJ >=1$8& {* >& ³0 ljb O}h* ‖B—& {{* 8=$><*
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o 2; gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?1<
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 41/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ 2<
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
[flajracc~ Osabojno9
[flajracc~ CLN& {{* <8=$<81& ³³>2;& >285 Fahoxa Bonf*& BJ >=1$8& {* >& ³0
ljb O}h* ‖B—& {{* 8=$><5 G~roffl Bonf* cafob 182<<& BJ >1;$?& {* 8& ³³8$2
Rmujoj Bonf* UBJ 2?3T& [* 3& O}h* 8 U2?3$8T ljb ³<25 Jof~gj Bonf*& UBJ
>=;$>T& {{* 3$0& O}h* 3 UBJ >=;$1T5 ljb G~roffl Bonf* cafob ngjnuxxojrfq
moxoparm& {{* 2$3& ³³<<$<2*
Ajrofau~‑ ‖Lffo`ob— _jngjrxgsoxrob Clnr Jg* <=9
Ajrofau~ xo~{gjbob rg rma~ forrox hq ajcgxdaj` G~roffl rmlr& lh~ojr l ~uh{gojl
gx nguxr gxbox& Ajrofau~' roxd~ ljb ngjbaragj~ {xgmahar rmo ba~nfg~uxo gc ~unm
ajcgxdlragj5 G~roffl bab jgr {ux~uo rma~ aj|uaxq ljq cuxrmox parm Ajrofau~*
[flajracc~ Ghionragj~9
Da~folbaj`5 ljb a~ jgr ~u{{gxrob hq ngd{orojr osabojno*
[flajracc~ Xo~{gj~o9
BA^[_ROB CLNR „ [flajracc Fa~l G~roffl josox xonoasob Ajrofau
Bonodhox 3& 8;<; forrox& Bonflxlragj gc Fa~l G~roffl cafob ^o{rodhox 82&
8;<<& BJ >1;$?& {* 3& ³8;5 ljb G~roffl Bonf* cafob ngjnuxxojrfq moxoparm& {
?& ³<>* [mafa{ I* Hox`& O~|* ~ojr l forrox rg Ajrofau~ gj L{xaf <2& 8;<;
G~roffl‑~ forrox gc Gnrghox 81& 8;<; pl~ l`laj xolnmaj` gur rg Ajrofau~
G~roffl bab jgr mlso l ng{q gc mox xo{gxr cxgd Ajrofau~ ljb pl~ ~ooeaj` ~unm
~g ~mo ngufb lbbxo~~ lff a~~uo~ lr gjo rado* Fa~l G~roffl ngd{faob parm mox
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o 2< gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?18
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 42/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ 28
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
xa`mr~ ujbox rmo Clax Nxobar Xo{gxraj` Flp~ ljb gj rmo lbsano gc rmo Coboxl
Rxlbo Ngdda~~agj ljb mox lrrgxjoq* G~roffl cafob ~uar l`laj~r Ajrofau~*
[flajracc~ Osabojno9
[flajracc~ CLN& {{* <8=$<81& ³³>2;& >285 Rmujoj Bonf* UBJ 2?3T& {* 3& ³<2
ljb O}h* > U2?3$>T5 Jof~gj Bonf*& UBJ >=;$>T& {{* 3$0& ³<3& O}h* 0 UBJ
>=;$<;T5 G~roffl Bonf* cafob 182<<& BJ >1;$?& {* 3& ³8;5 ljb G~roffl‑~
Bonf* cafob ngjnuxxojrfq moxoparm& {* ?& ³& {{* 2$3& ³³<<$<2*
Ajrofau~‑ ‖Lffo`ob— _jngjrxgsoxrob Clnr Jg* <19
Fa~l G~roffl josox xo|uo~rob l xoajso~ra`lragj cxgd Ajrofau~ gc ljq
ajcgxdlragj*
[flajracc~ Ghionragj~9
Jgr ~u{{gxrob parm ngd{orojr osabojno*
[flajracc~ Xo~{gj~o9
BA^[_ROB CLNR $ [mafa{ I* Hox & O~|* ~ojr l forrox rg Ajrofau~ gj homlfc gc
G~roffl ljb Fahoxa gj L{xaf <2& 8;<; xo`lxbaj` rmo ajngxxonr ajcgxdlragj&
sagflragj~& orn* Ajrofau~ josox xo~{gjbob* Gj Gnrghox 81& 8;<;& G~roffl ~ojr
ljgrmox forrox aj ljgrmox lrrod{r rg lbbxo~~ lff a~~uo~ ljb rg oj~uxo Ajrofau~
mlb cgffgpob rmxgu`m parm mox xo|uo~r~* Ajrofau~ xocu~ob rg ~u{{fq G~roffl l
xo{gxr ~g ~mo ngufb oj~uxo lff a~~uo~ poxo ljb hooj lbbxo~~ob* Ajrofau~ ~ojr l
forrox rg G~roffl& ~rlraj` G~roffl joobob l Nguxr Gxbox gx ^uh{gojl cgx rmo
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o 28 gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?1>
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 43/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ 2>
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
ajcgxdlragj xo|uo~rob& l forrox pmanm G~roffl josox xonoasob* _jbox rmo
lbsano gc mox lrrgxjoq ljb rmo Coboxlf Rxlbo Ngdda~~agj& G~roffl cafob ~uar*
Buxaj` rma~ ~ldo rado& G~roffl ljb Fahoxa lf~g ~ojr forrox~ rg _*^* ^olxnm
lf~g gpjob ljb g{oxlrob hq Ajrofau~& xo|uo~raj` rmoax xo{gxr~& ajcgxdaj` _*^
^olxnm gc rmo ajngxxonr ajcgxdlragj dlajrlajob& ljb rmo affo`lf ba~nfg~uxo~ gc
[flajracc~ xo{gxr~ rg ujlurmgxayob rmaxb {lxrao~& a*o*& Rlary ljb ^ljeoq*
[flajracc~ josox xonoasob ljq rq{o gc xo~{gj~o cxgd _*^* ^olxnm& jgx bab rmoq
xonoaso rmoax xo{gxr~*
[flajracc~ Osabojno9
[flajracc~ CLN& {{* <8=$<81& ³³>2;& >285 Rmujoj Bonf* UBJ 2?3T& {* 3& ³<2
ljb O}h* > UBJ 2?3$>T5 Jof~gj Bonf* UBJ >=;$>T& {* 0& ³<2 ljb O}h* 0 UBJ
>=;$<;T5 ljb G~roffl‑~ Bonf* cafob ngjnuxxojrfq moxoparm& {{* 2$3& ³³<<$<2*
Ajrofau~‑ ‖Lffo`ob— _jngjrxgsoxrob Clnr Jg* 8;9
Gj L{xaf <;& 8;<;& Fa~l Fahoxa xlj l (hlne`xgujb nmone( gj mox gpj jldo&
(Fa~l Fahoxa&( rmxgu`m Ajrofau~& lr ar~ poh~aro& ppp*ajrofau~*ngd*
[flajracc~ Ghionragj~9
Ghionragj rg ‖O}* L U{lxralf ng{q gc (hlne`xgujb nmone( ~olxnm Fahoxa
{uxnml~ob gj mox gpj jldo& (Fa~l Fahoxa(T*— Da~~rlro~ rmo Osabojno gj cafo
parm rmo Nguxr5 a~ jgr ~u{{gxrob hq ngd{orojr osabojno5 ljb a~ Da~folbaj`*
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o 2> gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?12
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 44/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ 22
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
[flajracc~ Xo~{gj~o9
BA^[_ROB CLNR $ l~ rg ‖Gj L{xaf <;& 8;<; Fa~l Fahoxa xlj l
‖hlne`xgujb nmone— gj mox gpj jldo& ‣— [flajracc Fa~l Fahoxa {uxnml~ob l
hlne`xgujb xo{gxr gj mox~ofc* ^oo BJ >=1& {{* <$8& ³<$8 ljb O}h* L UBJ
>=1$8& {{* 0$<=T* Rmo xo{gxr& l~ judhoxob lr rmo hgrrgd a~ roj -<;! {l`o~
fgj`* Lff <; {l`o~ lxo ajnfubob aj Fahoxa‑~ Bonf* l~ O}h* L UBJ >=1$8& {{
0$<=T* Rmo cax~r {l`o gc Fahoxa‑~ O}h* L UBJ >=1$8& {* =T a~ Fahoxa‑~ Xonoa{
cxgd Ajrofau~ cgx rmo {uxnml~o gc mox ‖hlne`xgujb— xo{gxr& JGR ~olxnmo~ l~
nfladob hq Ajrofau~ ljb rmo cuff Ajrofau~ Xo{gxr {uxnml~ob gj L{xaf <;& 8;<;
a~ l ‖{ox~gj ~{onacan— xo{gxr* Rmujoj aj ma~ Bonflxlragj UBJ 2?3& {* 3& ³<?
nflad~ rmlr rmo xo{gxr Fahoxa {uxnml~ob pl~ jgr lj CNXL xo{gxr* Rg rmo
ngjrxlxq& Fahoxa‑~ xo{gxr ml~ mox jldo& lbbxo~~o~& blro gc haxrm& iub`dojr~
gsox <; qolx~ gfb& parm Fahoxa‑~ blro gc haxrm& lj lsoxl`o mgdo ajngdo cgx
Fahoxa5 rmo lsoxl`o mgdo {xano cgx Fahoxa5 orn*& pmanm a~ l pxarroj
ngddujanlragj holxaj` gj Fahoxa‑~ nxobar pgxrmajo~~ -Iub`dojr~
hljexu{rnq cafaj`~& orn*!& nmlxlnrox -nxadajlf xongxb~& orn*!& `ojox
xo{urlragj& {ox~gjlf nmlxlnroxa~ran~ -jldo ljb blro gc haxrm! ljb dgbo gc
fasaj` -lsoxl`o mgu~omgfb ajngdo5 lsoxl`o slfuo gc mgdo& orn*!& CNXL
3;>& <? _*^*N*<3=<l-b!-<!* Rmo xo{gxr {uxnml~ob hq Fahoxa a~ l ngj~udox
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o 22 gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?1?
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 45/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ 2?
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
xo{gxr ljb Ajrofau~& l~ o}{flajob lhgso& ml~ lbdarrob rg hoaj` l ‖noxracaob
nxobar xo{gxraj` l`ojnq—*
[flajracc~ Osabojno9
[flajracc~ CLN& {{* 3<$02& ³³<22$<02 ljb {{* <80$<28& ³³ >>?$>025 Fahoxa
Bonf* UBJ >=;$>T lr {{* <$8& ³< ljb O}h* L lrrlnmob rmoxorg& BJ >=1$8& {{
<$8 ljb =$<=5 Rmujoj Bonf* UBJ 2?3T& {* 3& ³<?5 ljb Jof~gj Bonf* UBJ >=;$
>T& {* >& ³3 „Jof~gj o}mahar xocoxojnob a~ jgr rmo xo{gxr Fahoxa xonoasob& gx
ljqrmaj` nfg~o rg ar5 ^rxohof Bonf*& {{* ?$1& ³³<8$<25 Fahoxa Bonf*& {{* <$1&
³³<$8;*
Ajrofau~‑ ‖Lffo`ob— _jngjrxgsoxrob Clnr Jg* 8<9
Gj L{xaf <;& 8;<;& Fahoxa {uxnml~ob l Rlfojr Pa~o xo{gxr gj mox~ofc& rmxgu`m
Rlfojr Pa~o& lr ar~ poh~aro& ppp*rlfojrpa~o*ngd*
[flajracc~ Ghionragj~9
Ghionragj rg Rmujoj‑~ Bonflxlragj& BJ 2?3& {{* 3$0& ³<3 ljb O}mahar ‖2—
UBJ 2?3$2T lrrlnmob rmoxorg* Rmujoj‑~ Bonflxlragj a~ {oxiuxob ro~radgjq
ljb O}mahar ‖2— rg ma~ Bonflxlragj a~ jgr l rxuo ljb ngxxonr ng{q gc rmo
O}mahar Fahoxa cafob parm mox Bonflxlragj* Rmujoj‑~ O}mahar ‖2— pl~ nxolrob
l qolx lcrox Fahoxa {uxnml~ob mox RlfojrPa~o Xo{gxr*
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o 2? gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?13
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 46/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ 23
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
[flajracc~ Xo~{gj~o9
BA^[_ROB CLNR AJ [LXR „ Ar a~ _jba~{urob l~ rg Fahoxa {uxnml~aj` l
xo{gxr cxgd RlfojrPa~o gj L{xaf <;& 8;<;& pmanm pl~ lcrox RlfojrPa~o mlb
hooj ad{fodojrob& pmanm pl~ l{{xg}adlrofq l qolx lcrox rmo Rlary ljb
^ljeoq Bocojbljr~ ghrlajob xo{gxr~ gj rmo [flajracc~* BA^[_ROB l~ rg
Rmujoj‑~ Bonflxlragj ljb O}mahar ‖2—*
[flajracc~ Osabojno9
[flajracc~ CLN& {{* 3<$02& ³³<22$<02 ljb {{* <80$<28& ³³ >>?$>025 Fahoxa
Bonf* UBJ >=1$8T lr {* 8 ljb O}h* ‖H—& BJ >=1$8& {{* 8;$885 Fahoxa Bonf
{{* <$1& ³³<$8;5 ljb ^rxohof Bonf*& {{* ?$1& ³³<8$<2& {{* <2$<?& ³8?& O}h
‖<8—& {{* 3;$3>*
Ajrofau~‑ ‖Lffo`ob— _jngjrxgsoxrob Clnr Jg* 889
[flajracc Fa~l Fahoxa mox~ofc a~ rmo gjfq {ox~gj rg mlso osox {uxnml~ob l
(Rlfojr Pa~o( xo{gxr gj {flajracc& Fa~l Fahoxa$a*o*& jg rmaxb {lxrq ml~ osox
{uxnml~ob l (Rlfojr Pa~o( xo{gxr gj {flajracc Fa~l Fahoxa*
[flajracc~ Ghionragj~9
Da~folbaj`5 l~~udo~ clnr~ jgr aj osabojno5 a~ jgr ~u{{gxrob hq ngd{orojr
osabojno& ljb nlff~ cgx ~{onuflragj* Ghionragj rg Rmujoj‑~ Bonflxlragj& BJ
2?3& {{* 3$0& ³<3 ljb O}mahar ‖2— UBJ 2?3$2T lrrlnmob rmoxorg* Rmujoj‑~
Bonflxlragj a~ {oxiuxob ro~radgjq ljb O}mahar ‖2— rg ma~ Bonflxlragj a~ jgr l
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o 23 gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?10
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 47/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ 20
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
rxuo ljb ngxxonr ng{q gc rmo O}mahar Fahoxa cafob parm mox Bonflxlragj
Rmujoj‑~ O}mahar ‖2— pl~ nxolrob l qolx lcrox Fahoxa {uxnml~ob mox
RlfojrPa~o Xo{gxr*
[flajracc~ Xo~{gj~o9
BA^[_ROB CLNR $ l~ pgxbob ljb ad{faob* Ajrofau~& Ajn* ljjgujnob ar~
RlfojrPa~o hxljbaj` gj Cohxulxq 1& 8;<;* RlfojrPa~o pl~ jgr
ad{fodojrob ujraf olxfq L{xaf 8;<;* Rmo Xo{gxr~ {uxnml~ob hq rmo Rlary ljb
^ljeoq Bocojbljr~ poxo {uxnml~ob aj gx lhgur Dlxnm 8;;1 gx olxfaox& ~g
RlfojrPa~o pl~ jgr {lxr gc Ajrofau~ l~ RlfojrPa~o pl~ jgr ad{fodojrob
ujraf olxfq L{xaf 8;<;* Rmo Xo{gxr~ {uxnml~ob hq rmo Rlary ljb ^ljeoq
Bocojbljr~ poxo {uxnml~ob aj gx lhgur Dlxnm 8;;1 gx olxfaox& ~g
RlfojrPa~o pl~ jgr {lxr gc Ajrofau~ lr rmlr rado*
[flajracc~ Osabojno9
[flajracc~ CLN& {{* 3<$02& ³³<22$<02 ljb {{* <80$<28& ³³ >>?$>025 Fahoxa
Bonf*& {{* 8& ³2& O}h~* H& {{* 8;$8>5 [flajracc~ XIJ& O}mahar ‖8—& {{* 2>$205
Hox` Bonf*& BJ >=1$<& {* 2& ³15 ^rxohof Bonf*& {{* <2$<?& ³8?& O}h* ‖<8—& {{
3;$3>5 ljb Hox`‑~ Bonf* cafob ngjnuxxojrfq moxoparm& {* ?& ³<8*
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o 20 gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?1=
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 48/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ 2=
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
Ajrofau~‑ ‖Lffo`ob— _jngjrxgsoxrob Clnr Jg* 8>9
Gj L{xaf <2& 8;<;& Fahoxa'~ lrrgxjoq ljb ng${flajracc& [mafa{ Hox`& ~ojr l
forrox rg rmo cgujbox gc Ajrofau~& Jlsooj Ilaj& xo`lxbaj` Fahoxa& aj pmanm mo
nfladob rmlr rmo Rlfojr Pa~o xo{gxr rmlr Fahoxa mlb {uxnml~ob gj mox~ofc
ngjrlajob ajlnnuxlro ajcgxdlragj$rg par9 -a! jldo~ rmlr Fahoxa mlb jgr u~ob5
ljb -aa! ~a} ~gnalf ~onuxarq judhox~ rmlr bab jgr hofgj` rg mox*
[flajracc~ Ghionragj~9
Da~|ugro~ rmo ro~radgjq5 l~~udo~ clnr~ jgr aj osabojno5 da~folbaj`5 ljb a~
jgr ~u{{gxrob hq ngd{orojr osabojno* Rmo osabojno Ajrofau~ naro~ rg& bgo~
jgr ~uh~rljralro rmoax ~rlrodojr aj rmoax ‖[xg{g~ob _jngjrxgsoxrob Clnr~ Jg
8>—*
[flajracc~ Xo~{gj~o9
BA^[_ROB CLNR „ Ar a~ rxuo Hox` ~ojr l forrox rg Ajrofau~& Ajn* gj L{xaf <2
8;<; {oxrlajaj` rg Fahoxa ljb G~roffl* Ar a~ lf~g rxuo rmlr Hox` ~rlrob rmoxo
poxo pxgj` jldo~& ^gnalf ^onuxarq judhox~& orn* Ar a~ jgr rxuo Hox` ~rlrob
rmo pxgj` ajcgxdlragj nldo cxgd rmo RlfojrPa~o Xo{gxr Fahoxa {uxnml~ob
gj L{xaf <;& 8;<<* Gj gx lhgur L{xaf <<& 8;<;& Fahoxa {uffob l xo{gxr cxgd
_^ ^olxnm& gpjob ljb g{oxlrob hq Ajrofau~& Ajn* Fahoxa ljb G~roffl ~ojr
forrox~ gc ba~{uro ljb xo|uo~raj` rmoax xo{gxr~ rg _*^* ^olxnm& gpjob ljb
g{oxlrob hq Ajrofau~* Hox`‑~ forrox ~rlro~& ‖Gj L{xaf <<& 8;<;& Dx~* Fahoxa
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o 2= gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;?11
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 49/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ 21
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
l`laj {uffob mox Ajrofau~ xo{gxr l~ l xo~ufr gc lnragj~ hq Gxfq Rlary*—
U‖od{ml~a~ lbbob—T* Rmo pgxb ‖RlfojrPa~o— a~ jgr osoj dojragjob aj
Hox`‑~ forrox gx aj [flajracc~ CLN lr {* <81& ³>2;* Ajrofau~ bgo~ jgr dleo
ljq dojragj gc xo{gxr~ {uxnml~ob gx ghrlajob hq Bocojbljr~ Gxfq Rlary
Ajn*& Flp Gccano~ gc Gxfq Rlary gx Bocojb gux Cxoobgd~ Cgujblragj~& Ajn*
[flajracc~ Osabojno9
[flajracc~ CLN lr {{* <8=$<81& ³³>2;& >28 ljb Hox`‑~ forrox lrrlnmob rg
Rmujoj‑~ Bonf* l~ O}h* ?5 Hox` Bonf*& BJ >=1$<& {* 8& ³>5 Fahoxa Bonf*& {*
Ajrofau~‑ ‖Lffo`ob— _jngjrxgsoxrob Clnr Jg* 829
Fahoxa'~ Rlfojr Pa~o xo{gxr ngjrlaj~ gjfq gjo jldo$Fa~l Fahoxa$ljb gjo
{lxralf ~gnalf ~onuxarq judhox -(}}}$}}$2><8(!& pmanm Fahoxa lbdar~ a
lnnuxlro5 Fahoxa lf~g lbdar~ rmlr rmo (hlne`xgujb nmone( xo{gxr ~mo
{uxnml~ob cxgd Ajrofau~ a~ lnnuxlro*
[flajracc~ Ghionragj~9
Da~folbaj` ljb jgr ~u{{gxrob hq ngd{orojr osabojno* Ghionragj rg
Rmujoj‑~ Bonflxlragj& BJ 2?3& {{* 3$0& ³<3 ljb O}mahar ‖2— UBJ 2?3$2T
lrrlnmob rmoxorg* Rmujoj‑~ Bonflxlragj a~ {oxiuxob ro~radgjq ljb O}mahar
‖2— rg ma~ Bonflxlragj a~ jgr l rxuo ljb ngxxonr ng{q gc rmo O}mahar Fahoxa
<=& ³>=5 ljb Hox` Bonf*& {* 8& ³?*
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o 21 gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;3;;
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 50/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ ?;
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
cafob parm mox Bonflxlragj* Rmujoj‑~ O}mahar ‖2— pl~ nxolrob l qolx lcrox
Fahoxa {uxnml~ob mox RlfojrPa~o Xo{gxr*
[flajracc~ Xo~{gj~o9
CLNR BA^[_ROB l~ ~rlrob $ RlfojrPa~o pl~ jgr ajrxgbunob hq Ajrofau~
Ajn* ujraf Cohxulxq 1& 8;<; ljb jgr ad{fodojrob ujraf aj gx lhgur L{xaf
8;<;& lfdg~r l qolx lcrox rmo osojr~ `asaj` xa~o rg rma~ flp~uar gnnuxxob* Ar
Bonf& BJ >=1$8& O}h* ‖H—& {{* 8;$8>& ngjrlaj~ Fahoxa‑~ jldo& ^gnalf
^onuxarq judhox& Blro gc Haxrm& lbbxo~~o~& l ^gnalf ^onuxarq soxacanlragj& orn
Lr jg rado pmoj Fahoxa ~a`job u{ cgx mox Od{fgqdojr Hlne`xgujb lnngujr
bab Ajrofau~ l~e cgx l {oxda~~ahfo {ux{g~o& soxacq ljq gc Fahoxa‑~ ajcgxdlragj
gx ojrarfodojr5 soxacq ar pl~ aj clnr Fahoxa pmg pl~ nxolraj` rmo lnngujr& orn
Fahoxa ~ad{fq caffob gur l cgxd& ljb pl~ addobalrofq {xgsabob lj lnngujr& aj
sagflragj gc rmo CNXL* Fahoxa bgo~ jgr ~rlro rmo hlne`xgujb xo{gxr ~mo
{uxnml~ob gj mox~ofc cxgd Ajrofau~*ngd a~ lnnuxlro5 pmlr Fahoxa ~rlro~ a~ rmo
xo{gxr cxgd Ajrofau~*ngd a~ {ox~gj ~{onacan ljb {oxrlaj~ ~gfofq rg [flajracc
Fahoxa ljb jgr l `xgu{ gc ajbasabulf~ parm l jldo ‖Fahoxa—*
''
pl~ josox nfladob rmlr ljq gc rmo Bocojbljr~ u~ob RlfojrPa~o& Rlfojr
Pa~o pl~ jgr {lxr gc Ajrofau~ * Rmo RlfojrPa~o xo{gxr& l~ ~mgpj aj Fahoxa‑~
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o ?; gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;3;<
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 51/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ ?<
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
[flajracc~ Osabojno9
[flajracc~ CLN& {{* 3<$02& ³³<22$<02 ljb {{* <80$<28& ³³ >>?$>025Fahoxa
Bonf*& BJ >=1$8& {{* <$8& ³<& O}h* L5 Jof~gj Bonf*& BJ >=;$>& {* >& ³ 3
O}h* ‖>—& {{* <$>5 ^rxohof Bonf*& {{* ?$1& ³³<8$<25 ljb Fahoxa Bonf* cafob
moxoparm& {{* <$1& ³³<$8;*
Ajrofau~‑ ‖Lffo`ob— _jngjrxgsoxrob Clnr Jg* 8?9
Jgjo gc rmo ^ljeoq Bocojbljr~ osox xlj l ~olxnm rmxgu`m& gx grmoxpa~o
ghrlajob ajcgxdlragj cxgd& Ajrofau~ ngjnoxjaj` Fahoxa gx G~roffl*
[flajracc~ Ghionragj~9
Jgr ~u{{gxrob hq ngd{orojr Osabojno*
[flajracc~ Xo~{gj~o9
BA^[_ROB CLNR $ Rmujoj lbdar~ aj ma~ Bonflxlragj& BJ 2?3& {l`o ?
³<8 rmlr Ajrofau~ bgo~ jgr dlajrlaj xo{gxr~ ~gfb rg rmoax nu~rgdox‑~ gx gj
ajbasabulf~ rg pmgd rmoq {oxrlaj* Ajrofau~ gjfq ~rgxo~ rmo xo{gxr~ {uxnml~ob
hq rmoax nu~rgdox‑~ aj rmoax nu~rgdox‑~ {l~~pgxb {xgronr lnngujr cgx cgxrq$
caso U2?T blq~& rmlr ajnfubo~ rmo ~nxooj rmlr ~mgp~ rmo xo{gxr~ rmo nu~rgdox
{uxnml~ob gj ~{onacan ajbasabulf~& ~oo Fahoxa‑~ Bonflxlragj O}mahar ‖O—& {{
28$22* Rmoxo a~ jg plq Rmujoj pgufb ejgp ac l xo{gxr pl~ ~gfb rg ljqgjo
xo`lxbaj` ljq gc rmo [flajracc~ aj rma~ nl~o* Nu~rgdox~ pmg {uxnml~o xo{gxr~
cxgd Ajrofau~ xonoaso lj odlaf xonoa{r& hur rmo xonoa{r bgo~ jgr ~mgp pmg rmo
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o ?< gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;3;8
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 52/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ ?8
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
xo{gxr pl~ {uxnml~ob gj* ^oo Fahoxa‑~ Bonflxlragj& O}mahar~ ‖L— rmxgu`m
‖B—& {{* 8>$2<* Gxfq Rlary ljb rmo ^ljeoq Bocojbljr~ xlj rmo xo{gxr~ gj
[flajracc~ aj gx lhgur olxfq Dlxnm 8;;1 ljb Ajrofau~ pl~ jgr jldob aj rma~
~uar ujraf Iujo 8;<<* Rmujoj pgufb jgr mlso ljq ejgpfob`o ljb jg plq rg
soxacq pmormox ljq gc rmo ^ljeoq‑~ gx ljq grmox {ox~gj {uxnml~ob xo{gxr~ gj
ljq gc rmo [flajracc~* Rmujoj aj ma~ Bonflxlragj& ujbox rmo {ojlfrq gc {oxiuxq
dleo~ rma~ ~rlrodojr* Mgposox& ar a~ ujrxuo* L~ o}{flajob moxoaj& Ajrofau~
ml~ ^{gafob Osabojno* Joaf ^ljeoq lbdarrob dufra{fo rado~ rmlr mo
ngjbunrob ~olxnmo~ gj [flajracc Fa~l G~roffl* ^oo G~roffl Bonf*& BJ >1;$?& {
>& ³<;* Rmo ^ljeoq Bocojbljr~ mlso {xgsabob [flajracc~ aj rmoax Ajaral
Ba~nfg~uxo~& Xo{gxr~ rmoq ghrlajob cxgd rmo Xoob Bocojbljr~ l~ poff l~
Ngd{xomoj~aso Xo{gxr~ ghrlajob gj [flajracc~ ljb rmoax ~{gu~o~ cxgd lj
ujabojracaob ~guxno* Rmo ^ljeoq Bocojbljr~ mlso xocu~ob rg abojracq rmo
~guxno ljb pmg lnno~~ob ljb ghrlajob rmo Xo{gxr* Rmo abojracqaj`
ajcgxdlragj gc rmo ngd{ljq rmo~o ngd{xomoj~aso xo{gxr~ poxo ghrlajob
cxgd ml~ hooj xodgsob*
[flajracc~ Osabojno9
[flajracc~ CLN& {* 82& ³30& {* 8?& ³0;& {{* 3?$33& ³³<??$<?3& {`* ><>& ³>2>&
{`* <2;& ³>0?5 G~roffl Bonf*& BJ >1;$?& {* >& ³<;5 Rmujoj Bonf*& {*? & ³<8
Fahoxa Bonf*& {{* 1$<8& ³³88$83& O}h~* ‖L— rmxgu`m ‖O—& {{* 8>$225 G~roffl
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o ?8 gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;3;>
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 53/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ ?>
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
Bonf*& {{* 0$=& ³³ <0$<1& O}h~* ‖3—& {{* 12$<;? ljb ‖<;—& {* <8?5 ^rxohof
Bonf*& {{* ?$3& ³<8& {{* 1$<<& ³³<?$<=& O}h~* ‖0—$‖<;—& {{* >0$?<*
Ajrofau~‑ ‖Lffo`ob— _jngjrxgsoxrob Clnr Jg* 839
Gj L{xaf<8& 8;;1& Gxfq Rlary {uxnml~ob l (hlne`xgujb nmone( xo{gxr gj rmo
jldo (Fa~l Fahoxa( rmxgu`m Ajrofau~& lr ar~ poh~aro& ppp*ajrofau~*ngd*
[flajracc~ Ghionragj~9
Da~|ugro~ rmo ro~radgjq aj rmo Bonflxlragj gc Gxfq Rlary cafob hq Ajrofau~&
BJ 2??$>5 Da~folbaj`5 ljb rmo ~rlrodojr a~ jgr ~u{{gxrob hq ljq ngd{orojr
osabojno*
[flajracc~ Xo~{gj~o9
BA^[_ROB CLNR „ Rmujoj lbdar~ aj ma~ Bonflxlragj& BJ 2?3& {l`o ?
³<8 rmlr Ajrofau~ bgo~ jgr dlajrlaj xo{gxr~ ~gfb rg rmoax nu~rgdox‑~ gx gj
ajbasabulf~ rg pmgd rmoq {oxrlaj* Ajrofau~ gjfq ~rgxo~ rmo xo{gxr~ {uxnml~ob
hq rmoax nu~rgdox‑~ aj rmoax nu~rgdox‑~ {l~~pgxb {xgronr lnngujr cgx cgxrq
caso U2?T blq~& rmlr ajnfubo~ rmo ~nxooj rmlr ~mgp~ rmo xo{gxr~ rmo nu~rgdox
{uxnml~ob gj ~{onacan ajbasabulf~& ~oo Fahoxa‑~ Bonflxlragj O}mahar ‖O—& {{
28$22* Rmoxo a~ jg plq Rmujoj pgufb ejgp ac l xo{gxr pl~ ~gfb rg ljqgjo
xo`lxbaj` ljq gc rmo [flajracc~ aj rma~ nl~o hlne aj 8;;1* Nu~rgdox~ pmg
{uxnml~o xo{gxr~ cxgd Ajrofau~ xonoaso lj odlaf xonoa{r& hur rmo xonoa{r bgo~
jgr ~mgp pmg rmo xo{gxr pl~ {uxnml~ob gj* ^oo Fahoxa‑~ Bonflxlragj
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o ?> gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;3;2
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 54/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ ?2
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
O}mahar~ ‖L— rmxgu`m ‖B—& {{* 8>$2<* Gxfq Rlary ljb rmo ^ljeoq Bocojbljr~
xlj rmo xo{gxr~ gj [flajracc~ aj gx lhgur olxfq Dlxnm 8;;1 ljb Ajrofau~ pl~
jgr jldob aj rma~ ~uar ujraf Iujo 8;<<* Rmujoj pgufb jgr mlso ljq
ejgpfob`o ljb jg plq rg soxacq pmlr blro~ gx pmlr {xgbunr~ Rlary gx
ljqgjo of~o {uxnml~ob* Rlary lnrulffq {uxnml~ob mox Ajrofau~ xo{gxr~ aj gx
lhgur olxfq Dlxnm 8;;1* Jgpmoxo aj Gxfq Rlary‑~ Bonflxlragj a~ rmo pgxb
‖[uxnml~o— gx ‖[uxnml~ob—* Pmlr Gxfq Rlary Bonflxlragj ~rlro~ gj {* 8& ³8
a~ rmlr ~mo ngjbunrob ~olxnmo~ gj Fahoxa‑~ jldo* L ~olxnm a~ jgr rmo ~ldo l~
l {uxnml~ob ‖hlne`xgujb— xo{gxr* Aj 8;;1 ljb 8;<;& hocgxo Ajrofau~
xobo~a`job rmoax poh~aro& ho`lj u~aj` baccoxojr ~gcrplxo& ljb nmlj`ob rmo
ldgujr gc ajcgxdlragj qgu xonoaso aj l hlne`xgujb xo{gxr -~{gfalragj gc
osabojno!5 l ~olxnm ngjbunrob lr ppp*ajrofau~*ngd gj l jldo pgufb xoruxj
rmo jldo& lbbxo~~o~ rmo {ox~gj xo~abob lr& l xoflraso& blro gc haxrm ljb l`o*
Rmo {uxnml~ob hlne`xgujb xo{gxr `aso~ l fgr dgxo blrl& ~gdo gc pmanm a~
jgr {uhfan lfgj` parm nxobar blrl* Gxfq Rlary ml~ lbdarrob aj mox cafaj`~ parm
rma~ Nguxr rmlr ~mo ghrlajob rmo Xo{gxr~ gj [flajracc~ cxgd rmo Ajrofau~ ljb
Xoob Bocojbljr~& ljb rmoxocgxo& rmoq ~mgufb ho mofb falhfo* Ajrofau~ dlbo
jg dojragj gc ljq xo{gxr~ {uxnml~ob gx ghrlajob hq Bocojbljr~& Gxfq Rlary
Ajn*& Flp Gccano~ gc Gxfq Rlary& gx Bocojb gux Cxoobgd~ Cgujblragj~& Ajn*
''
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o ?2 gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;3;?
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 55/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ ??
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
[flajracc~ Osabojno9
[flajracc~ CLN& {{* 3<$02& ³³<22$<02 ljb {{* <80$<28& ³³ >>?$>025 Rlary
Bonf*& BJ 2??$>& {* 8& ³85 Gxfq Rlary cafaj` gc Iufq <<& 8;<<& BJ 8=>& {{* <0
ljb <15 Fahoxa Bonf*& {* <& ³<& {* >& ³>& {* =& ³<0& {* 1& ³³ <1& 8<& {* <=& ³>1&
{{* <1$8;& ³³2;$2<5 Rmujoj Bonf*& {* ?& ³<85 Hox` Bonf*& {{* WWWW5 rxoho
Ajrofau~‑ ‖Lffo`ob— _jngjrxgsoxrob Clnr Jg* 809
Rma~ ~olxnm pl~ jgr ngjcajob rg {flajracc& Fa~l Fahoxa& hur aj~rolb nl{ruxob
{uhfan ajcgxdlragj lhgur ajbasabulf~ pmg ~mlxo rmo ~ldo jldo5 ar bab jg
ngjrlaj ljq jgj{uhfan ajcgxdlragj gj {flajracc& Fa~l Fahoxa$gx& cgx rmlr
dlrrox& ljq grmox {ox~gj jldob (Fa~l Fahoxa($~unm l~ l ~gnalf ~onuxarq
judhox& cajljnalf ajcgxdlragj& gx nxobar ajcgxdlragj5 ljb Ajrofau~ nxolro U~anT
ljq ngjrojr ngjrlajob aj rmo (hlne`xgujb nmone( xo{gxr Rlary {uxnml~ob*
[flajracc~ Ghionragj~9
Da~folbaj`5 Da~|ugro~ ro~radgjq aj Gxfq Rlary‑~ Bonflxlragj cafob hq
Ajrofau~& BJ 2??$>5 rmo ~rlrodojr a~ jgr ~u{{gxrob hq ngd{orojr osabojno
ljb rmo ~rlrodojr a~ ngjrxlxq rg rmo osabojno gj cafo parm rma~ Nguxr*
[flajracc~ Xo~{gj~o9
BA^[_ROB CLNR $ Rmujoj lbdar~ aj ma~ Bonflxlragj& BJ 2?3& {l`o ?
³<8 rmlr Ajrofau~ bgo~ jgr dlajrlaj xo{gxr~ ~gfb rg rmoax nu~rgdox‑~ gx gj
Bonf*& {{* ?$3& ³<8*
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o ?? gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;3;3
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 56/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ ?3
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
ajbasabulf~ rg pmgd rmoq {oxrlaj* Ajrofau~ gjfq ~rgxo~ rmo xo{gxr~ {uxnml~ob
hq rmoax nu~rgdox‑~ aj rmoax nu~rgdox‑~ {l~~pgxb {xgronrob lnngujr cgx cgxrq$
caso U2?T blq~& rmlr ajnfubo~ rmo ~nxooj rmlr ~mgp~ rmo xo{gxr~ rmo nu~rgdox
{uxnml~ob gj ~{onacan ajbasabulf~& ~oo Fahoxa‑~ Bonflxlragj O}mahar ‖O—& {{
28$22* Rmoxo a~ jg plq Rmujoj pgufb ejgp ac l xo{gxr pl~ ~gfb rg ljqgjo
xo`lxbaj` ljq gc rmo [flajracc~ aj rma~ nl~o& dunm fo~~ pmlr rmo xo{gxr
ngjrlajob* Nu~rgdox~ pmg {uxnml~o xo{gxr~ cxgd Ajrofau~ xonoaso lj odlaf
xonoa{r& hur rmo xonoa{r bgo~ jgr ~mgp pmg rmo xo{gxr pl~ {uxnml~ob gj* ^oo
Fahoxa‑~ Bonflxlragj& O}mahar~ ‖L— rmxgu`m ‖B—& {{* 8>$2<* Gxfq Rlary ljb
rmo ^ljeoq Bocojbljr~ xlj rmo xo{gxr~ gj [flajracc~ aj gx lhgur olxfq Dlxnm
8;;1 ljb Ajrofau~ pl~ jgr jldob aj rma~ ~uar ujraf Iujo 8;<<* Rmujoj pgufb
jgr mlso ljq ejgpfob`o ljb jg plq rg soxacq pmlr pl~ ajnfubob aj Rlary‑~
xo{gxr ~mo {uxnml~ob gj Fahoxa gx ljq gc rmo grmox [flajracc~* Rlary
{uxnml~ob rmo xo{gxr gj Fahoxa aj gx lxgujb Dlxnm 8;;1* Fahoxa {uxnml~ob
mox hlne`xgujb xo{gxr aj L{xaf 8;<;& l qolx flrox* Lr rmo rado Fahoxa
{uxnml~ob mox xo{gxr& ~mo ghrlajob l {ox~gj ~{onacan xo{gxr rmlr gjfq
{oxrlajob rg mox -Fahoxa! parm mox lbbxo~~o~& ujfa~rob {mgjo judhox~& blro gc
haxrm& lsoxl`o ajngdo aj Fahoxa‑~ mgu~omgfb5 mgdo slfuo& orn* Fahoxa bab jgr
{uxnml~o lbbaragjlf xo{gxr~ cgx rojljr& od{fgqdojr& gx ljq gc rmo grmo
{xgbunr~ lslaflhfo* Ajrofau~ nflad~ rmoax {uhfan xongxb~ ngj~a~r
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o ?3 gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;3;0
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 57/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ ?0
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
ajcgxdlragj gj ajbasabulf~& rmlr a~ dlajrlajob hq `gsoxjdojr l`ojnao~
{uhfanfq lslaflhfo ajcgxdlragj& rmlr Ajrofau~ nflad~ a~ ajcgxdlragj ghrlajob
cxgd gjfajo ljb gccfajo ajcgxdlragj rmlr a~ `ojoxlffq lslaflhfo hur jgr
dlajrlajob hq `gsoxjdojr l`ojnao~& ~unm l~ jldo~& lbbxo~~o~ ljb rofo{mgjo
judhox gc ajbasabulf~& {xgco~~agjlf fanoj~aj` ljb rxlbo gx`ljaylragj
ajcgxdlragj& jop~{l{ox lxranfo~& ljb ngjrojr cxgd hfg`~ ljbgx ~gnalf
jorpgxeaj` ~aro~5 ljb Ngddoxnalf Xongxb~ ngj~a~raj` gc ajcgxdlragj rmlr a~
dlajrlajob hq ojrox{xa~o~ ljb a~ lslaflhfo cgx {uxnml~o& ~unm l~ {mgjo
ngjjonr ljb ba~ngjjonr ajcgxdlragj* ^oo
mrr{9ppp*ajrofau~*ngdngx{{xaslnq${gfanq ljb Ajrofau~‑ Gnrghox 8;;1
Xo{gxr rg rmo ^ON* Ajrofau~ gj rmoax poh~aro& ppp*ajrofau~*ngd& lbsoxra~o~
xosox~o {mgjo fgge$u{~ cgx fljbfajo~& noff {mgjo~ ljb {l`ox~& hgrm fa~rob ljb
ujfa~rob gj rmoax poh~aro lr mrr{9ppp*ajrofau~*ngd{og{fo$~olxnm
{mgjo*mrdf ljb mrr{9ppp*ajrofau~*ngdxosox~o${mgjo$fggeu{*mrdf* Ob
[orox~gj& O}onuraso Sano [xo~abojr gc Ajrofau~‑ [og{fo Cajbox ljb [og{fo
^olxnm buxaj` ma~ Ajroxsaop parm ‖Abojrarq Rmocr ^onxor~— rmlr Ajrofau~
dlajrlaj~ l{{xg}adlrofq <1 haffagj xongxb~ gj ajbasabulf~ aj$mgu~o*
[uhfan xongxb~ ghrlajob cxgd coboxlf& ~rlro gx fgnlf `gsoxjdojr xongxb~
nljjgr ngjrlaj ajcgxdlragj rmlr abojracao~ rmo ajcgxdlragj rg l ~{onacan
{ox~gj* ^oo Nlf* Nas* Ngbo <01=*>& pmanm ~rlro~& ‖ L~ u~ob aj rma
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o ?0 gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;3;=
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 58/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ ?=
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
nml{rox9-l! Rmo roxd ({ox~gjlf ajcgxdlragj( dolj~ ljq ajcgxdlragj rmlr a~
dlajrlajob hq lj l`ojnq rmlr abojracao~ gx bo~nxaho~ lj ajbasabulf&
ajnfubaj`& hur jgr fadarob rg& ma~ gx mox jldo‣mgdo lbbxo~~& mgdo
rofo{mgjo judhox‣Ar ajnfubo~ ~rlrodojr~ dlbo hq& gx lrrxahurob rg& rmo
ajbasabulf *—& ^oo lf~g Nlf* Nas* Ngbo <01=*82 -‖ Jg l`ojnq dlq ba~nfg~o
ljq {ox~gjlf ajcgxdlragj aj l dljjox rmlr pgufb faje rmo ajcgxdlragj
ba~nfg~ob rg rmo ajbasabulf rg pmgd ar {oxrlaj~‣—!* Coboxlf @gsoxjdojr a~
`gsoxjob hq rmo [xaslnq Lnr gc <102& ? _*^*N* ??8* Rofo{mgjo ngjjon
ljb ba~ngjjonr xongxb~ lxo dlajrlajob hq rmo rofo{mgjo ngd{ljao~ aj
ngjcabojno ljb lxo jgr {uhfan xongxb~* ^oo 0;8 gc ‖Rmo
Rofongddujanlragj~ Lnr gc <113—& 20 _*^*N* 888 -8;;3!* Coboxlf flp
{xgmahar~ rmo xofol~o gc ngj~udox~ rofo{mgjo xongxb~& pmanm ajnfubo
ngj~udox~ ‖ba~ngjjonr ljb ngjjonragj— xongxb~* Rmo gjfq plq l rmaxb {lxrq
nlj ghrlaj l ngj~udox'~ {mgjo xongxb~& parmgur rmo ngj~udox'~ {oxda~~agj
gx l~ grmoxpa~o lurmgxayob hq flp& a~ rmxgu`m rmocr gx bono{ragj -cgx
o}ld{fo& hq ad{ox~gjlraj` rmo ngj~udox gx l {mgjo ngd{ljq
xo{xo~ojrlraso& mlneaj` ajrg rmo {mgjo ngd{ljq'~ ngd{urox ~q~rod& gx
hxahaj` gx nligfaj` lj od{fgqoo rg ~rolf gx grmoxpa~o ba~nfg~o rmo xongxb~!
[flajracc~ lxo jgr ~rlraj` gx ad{fqaj` rmlr Ajrofau~ a~ rmo gjo pmg ngddarrob
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o ?= gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;3;1
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 59/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ ?1
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
rmo nxado~& hur aj~rolb rmlr Ajrofau~ {uxnml~o~ rmo~o affo`lffq ghrlajob
xongxb~& hq Ajrofau~‑ gpj lbda~~agj~ aj rmoax Xo{gxr cafob parm rmo ^ON*
Ajrofau~ a~ ad{fqaj` rmlr pmoj l {ox~gj ngjbunr~ l ~olxnm& rmoj Ajrofau~
~olxnm >xb {lxrq blrlhl~o~ rg xorxaoso rmo ajcgxdlragj rmlr rmoq rmoj aj ruxj
~off rg rmoax nu~rgdox~* Rma~ ~ad{fq a~ jgr rmo nl~o* Ajrofau~ lbdar~ rg
lu`dojraj` rmo ajcgxdlragj aj pmanm rmoq ~off* Ajrofau~ ‖ngffonr~ ljb
ajro`xlro~ blrl cxgd rmgu~ljb~ gc gjfajo ljb gccfajo blrl ~guxno~ ljb u~o~
~g{ma~ranlrob ljlfqran~ ronmjgfg`ao~ rg nfolj~o& soxacq ljb lu`dojr rma~ blrl
aj xolf rado rg {xgsabo rmoax nu~rgdox~ parm lnragjlhfo ajcgxdlragj—&
[flajracc~ XIJ& O}h* ‖<— {* >8* Ajrofau~ ngjrajuo~& ‖Po mlso bosofg{ob
lbsljnob {xg{xaorlxq ronmjgfg`ao~ rmlr lnno~~& ngffonr ljb jgxdlfayo l hxglb
xlj`o gc ngj~udox‣ajcgxdlragj* Gux ljlfqran~ ronmjgfg`ao~ soxacq ljb
lu`dojr dufra{fo roxlhqro~ gc blrl& u~ulffq aj ba~{lxlro cgxdlr~ ljb parm
slxqaj` bo`xoo~ gc lnnuxlnq ljb ngd{forojo~~& cxgd l dqxalb gc ~guxno~ aj
gxbox rg dleo ajcoxojno~ ljb {xobanragj~ hl~ob gj rma~ blrl* Cgx o}ld{fo
gux ronmjgfg`ao~ ojlhfo u~ rg ngj~rxunr l ~aj`fo abojrarq {xgcafo cgx l {ox~gj
pmg ml~ nmlj`ob ma~ gx mox fl~r jldo& lbbxo~~ gx {mgjo judhox*— Ajrofau~
Xo{gxr cafob parm rmo ^ON& ~oo [flajracc~ XIJ& O}mahar ‖<—& {{* <2& <?& ><&
>8& >>& >?& >3* Aj Ob [orox~gj& O}onuraso Sano [xo~abojr gc Ajrofau~
[og{fo ^olxnm ljb [og{fo Cajbox Ajroxsaop& mo ~rlro~ ‖‣pmlr po rxq rg bg a~
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o ?1 gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;3<;
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 60/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ 3;
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
u~o l rgj gc mouxa~ran {xgno~~o~ ljb rmo Ajrofau~ ronmjgfg`q rmlr lffgp~ u~ rg
dlrnm ajcgxdlragj rg`ormox& ~rarnm ajcgxdlragj rg`ormox rg {xo~ojr l soxq
lnnuxlro xo{gxr cgx gux nu~rgdox~—* UOd{ml~a~ LbbobT Ajrofau~ lbdar~ rmoq
{uxnml~o ajcgxdlragj gj ngj~udox~ cxgd >xb {lxrao~& ljlfqyo~ rm
ajcgxdlragj& lu`dojr rmo ajcgxdlragj& ‖~rarnmo~ ajcgxdlragj rg`ormox—
l~~a`j~ rmo ajcgxdlragj rg l ~{onacan {ox~gj& ljb ~off~ rmo xo{gxr~ rmoq mlso
nxolrob cxgd rmo ajcgxdlragj ~rgxob ljb dlajrlajob gj rmoax gpj blrlhl~o~
rg rmoax {lqaj` nu~rgdox~& ~oo Fahoxa Bonf*& {{* <8$<>& ³80 ljb <1$8;& ³2;
ljb O}h* ‖C—& {{* 23$?=* Ajrofau~ ~rlro~ gj rmoax poh~aro lr
ppp*ajrofau~*ngdngx{ajrofau~ rmlr rmoq mlso rmo ronmjgfg`ao~ rg ‖ngffonr
ajrox{xor ljb bofasox ajcgxdlragj rg ngj~udox~ ljb hu~ajo~~o~ gjfajo— ljb
Ajrofau~ ~rlro~& ‖Po bg dunm dgxo rmlj bofasox xofalhfo ljb lnnuxlro
ajcgxdlragj po lu`dojr& ajrox{xor& ljb {xo~ojr ar hl~ob gj qgux uja|uo
joob~& nxolraj` slfulhfo ljb rxu~rob ~gfuragj~ cgx gux daffagj~ gc
nu~rgdox~‣— UOd{ml~a~ lbbob—T* Ajrofau~ ghrlaj~ ajcgxdlragj gj
ajbasabulf~ ljb dlajrlaj~ rmo blrl gj rmoax blrlhl~o~& hur Ajrofau~ lu`dojr~
rmo ajcgxdlragj ljb ‖nxolro~— rmo xo{gxr gj ~{onacan ajbasabulf~ aj pmanm
rmoq ~off*
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o 3; gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;3<<
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 61/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ 3<
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
[flajracc~ Osabojno9
[flajracc~ CLN& {{* 3<$02& ³³<22$<02 ljb {{* <80$<28& ³³ >>?$>025 Fahoxa
Bonf*& {{* <8$<>& ³80 ljb <1$8;& ³2; ljb O}h* ‖C—& {{* 23$?= -Ajrofau~‑ Ob
[orox~gj& O}onuraso Sano [xo~abojr gc Ajrofau~‑ [og{fo ^olxnm ljb [og{fo
Cajbox‑~ ajroxsaop!5 ljb ^rxohof Bonf*& {{* 2$?& ³³=$<<5 5 Fahoxa Bonf* UBJ
>=;$>T lr {{* <$8& ³< ljb O}h* L lrrlnmob rmoxorg& BJ >=1$8& {{* <$8 ljb =$
<=5 Rmujoj Bonf* UBJ 2?3T& {* 3& ³<?5 ljb Jof~gj Bonf* UBJ >=;$>T& {* >&
³3 „Jof~gj o}mahar xocoxojnob a~ jgr rmo xo{gxr Fahoxa xonoasob& gx ljqrmaj`
nfg~o rg ar5 ljb Rlary Bonf*& BJ 2??$>& {* 8& ³85 ljb [flajracc~ XIJ& O}mahar
‖<—& {{* <2& <?& ><& >8& >>& >?& >3*
Ajrofau~‑ ‖Lffo`ob— _jngjrxgsoxrob Clnr Jg* 8=9
Hocgxo Rlary pl~ {oxdarrob rg {xgnoob parm mox (hlne`xgujb nmone( ~olxnm
gj rmo jldo (Fa~l Fahoxa&( ~mo lccaxdob mox ngddardojr rg ho hgujb hq rmo
(Roxd~ ljb Ngjbaragj~( lrrlnmob rg rmlr ~olxnm& ajnfubaj` rmlr rmo ~olxnm
xo~ufr ajcgxdlragj Ajrofau~ {xgsabob mox a~ jgr lurmgxayob gx ajrojbob rg ho
u~ob cgx ljq {ux{g~o ujbox rmo CNXL*
[flajracc~ Ghionragj~9
Ajrofau~‑ ~rlrodojr a~ jgr ~u{{gxrob hq ngd{orojr osabojno5 nlff~ cgx
~{onuflragj5 l~~udo~ clnr~ jgr aj ho osabojno5 Da~folbaj`5 ljb Da~~rlro~ rmo
osabojno gj cafo parm rma~ Nguxr*
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o 3< gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;3<8
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 62/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ 38
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
[flajracc~ Xo~{gj~o9
BA^[_ROB CLNR $ Rmoxo a~ jg dojragj aj Gxfq Rlary‑~ Bonflxlragj cafob
hq Ajrofau~ gc ljq ‖Roxd~ ljb Ngjbaragj~—* Rlary mlb rg noxracq gx l`xoo rg
ljqrmaj` lhgur rmo ajcgxdlragj {xgsabob hq Ajrofau~ pl~ jgr lurmgxayob gx
ajrojbob rg ho u~ob cgx ljq {ux{g~o ujbox rmo CNXL* Hq Ajrofau~‑ gpj
lbda~~agj~ aj rmoax xo{gxr cafob parm rmo ^ON& Ajrofau~ a~ lplxo rmoq lxo falhfo
cgx ljq sagflragj~ gc rmo CNXL hq rmod gx rmoax nu~rgdox~* Coboxlf Flp
`gsoxj~ pmlr a~ ngj~aboxob l ‖ngj~udox xo{gxr— ~uhionr rg rmo CNXL flp~
Ajrofau~‑ xo{gxr~ lxo ‖ngj~udox xo{gxr~— l~ bocajob hq rmo Coboxlf Rxlbo
Ngdda~~agj U‖CRN—T ljb rmo CNXL 3;>-b!& <? _*^*N* <3=<l-b!-<!
Cuxrmox& rmo ‖Roxd~ ljb Ngjbaragj~— lrrlnmob rg Rmujoj‑~ Bonflxlragj l~
O}mahar ‖<— a~ jgr rmo ~ldo l~ rmo ‖Roxd~ ljb Ngjbaragj~— aj {flno pmoj
Gxfq Rlary ljb Fa~l Fahoxa {uxnml~ob rmoax xo{gxr~*
[flajracc~ Osabojno9
[flajracc~ CLN& {{* 3<$02& ³³<22$<02 ljb {{* <80$<28& ³³ >>?$>025 Hox`
Bonf*& BJ >=1$<& {{* 8$2& ³³?$15 Fahoxa Bonf*& BJ >=1$8& {{* <$>& ³³<& >& ?
ljb O}h* ‖H—& {{* 8;$8>5 G~roffl Bonf*& BJ >1;$?& {{* 2$3& ³³<?$<1
[flajracc~ XIJ& O}h* ‖<—& {{* 8=$815 Rlary Bonf*& BJ 2??$>& {* 8& 85 Rmujoj
Bonf*& BJ 2?3& {* 3& ³<2 ljb O}h* 8& BJ 2?3$8*
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o 38 gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;3<>
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 63/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ 3>
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
Ajrofau~‑ ‖Lffo`ob— _jngjrxgsoxrob Clnr Jg* 819
Ajrofau~ ml~ josox hooj jgracaob hq ljq (nxobar xo{gxraj` l`ojnq( lhgur l
ba~{uro fgb`ob hq oarmox G~roffl gx Fahoxa*
[flajracc~ Ghionragj~9
Flne~ Cgujblragj5 molx~lq5 flne~ {ox~gjlf ejgpfob`o5 Axxofosljr
Da~folbaj 5 L~~udo~ clnr~ jgr aj osabojno5 Da~|ugro~ Rmujoj‑~ ro~radgjq
aj ma~ Bonflxlragj5 ljb a~ ngjcu~aj`*
[flajracc~ Xo~{gj~o9
BA^[_ROB CLNR „ Rmujoj bab jgr ~lq ‖Ajrofau~ ml~ josox hooj jgracaob
hq ljq (nxobar xo{gxraj` l`ojnq( lhgur l ba~{uro fgb`ob hq oarmox G~roffl gx
Fahoxa*— Rmujoj ~rlro~ aj ma~ Bonflxlragj gj {* =& ³8< ‖Rg rmo ho~r gc dq
ejgpfob`o& ljb lcrox xol~gjlhfo ajso~ra`lragj gc Ajrofau~‑ xongxb~& A nlj
lrro~r rmlr jg nxobar xo{gxraj` l`ojnq ml~ osox jgracaob Ajrofau~ lhgur ljq
ajlnnuxlnao~ ngjrlajob aj ljq xo{gxr rmlr Ajrofau~ gx ljq gc ar~ ~uh~abalxao~
ml~ osox cuxja~mob gj ljq {flajracc aj rma~ nl~o*— Uod{ml~a~ lbbobT* Ajrofau~
a~ l nxobar xo{gxraj` l`ojnq* [flajracc~ lxo ujlplxo gc pmg rmo cuxja~mox~ gc
ajcgxdlragj rg Ajrofau~ lxo ljb Ajrofau~ ml~ xocu~ob rg {xgsabo rma~
ajcgxdlragj rg rmo [flajracc~* Rmujoj bgo~ jgr mlso ljq lnejgpfob`o
ejgpfob`o pmormox Ajrofau~ xonoasob l ba~{uro cxgd rmo Jlragjlf Nxobar
Xo{gxraj` L`ojnao~ gx jgr* Hq Ajrofau~‑ gpj lbda~~agj~& Fahoxa ljb G~roffl
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o 3> gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;3<2
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 64/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ 32
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
hgrm cafob ngd{flajr~ baxonrfq parm Ajrofau~& l~ rmoq lxo rmo nxobar xo{gxraj`
l`ojnq& l~ bab [flajracc~ lrrgxjoq& l~ xo|uaxob hq rmo CNXL* Cuxrmoxdgxo
Jof~gj nfladob Ajrofau~ bab jgr mlso noxrlaj forrox~ cxgd [flajracc~ a
Ajrofau~‑ cafo~& hur Ajrofau~ ~a job cgx rmo forrox~* Rmujoj nflad~ mo ~olxnmob
xongxb~& hur bgo~ jgr mlso ljq lnrulf ejgpfob`o gc pmormox Ajrofau~
xonoasob ba~{uro~ gx jgr* Xo`lxbfo~~& Ajrofau~& hq rmoax gpj lbda~~agj& a~ aj
clnr l ‖Noxracaob Nxobar Xo{gxraj` L`ojnq—& [flajracc~ rgge rmo ngxxonr ~ro{~
aj jgracqaj` Ajrofau~ gc rmoax ba~{uro~ ljb ajngxxonr ajcgxdlragj* Ajrofau~ mlb
l burq rg ngjrlnr rmo cuxja~mox‑~ gc rmo ajcgxdlragj& {ux~uljr rg rmo CNXL*
[flajracc~ Osabojno9
[flajracc~ CLN& {{* 3<$02& ³³<22$<02 ljb {{* <80$<28& ³³ >>?$>025 Jof~gj
Bonf*& >=;$>& {{* 3$2& ³<3 ljb O}h*—3— UBJ >=;$1T5 Fahoxa Bonf*& BJ >=1$8&
{* >& ³0 ljb O}h* ‖B—& {{* 80$><5 Jof~gj Bonf* cafob Gnr* >& 8;<<& BJ >10
{* 8& ³>5 G~roffl Bonf*& BJ >1;$?& {{* <$8& ³³<$?5 ljb Rmujoj Bonf*& BJ
2?3& {* 3& ³<2 ljb O}h* ‖8— UBJ 2?3$8T5 Fahoxa Bonf*& {* <<& ³825 ljb G~roffl
Bonf* cafob ngjnuxxojrfq moxoparm& {* <8& ³81*
Ajrofau~‑ ‖Lffo`ob— _jngjrxgsoxrob Clnr Jg* >;9
[flajracc~‑ Rpofcrm rmxgu`m ^a}roojrm Nlu~o~ gc Lnragj ~ooe rg mgfb Ajrofau~
falhfo cgx {uhfa~maj` noxrlaj lffo`ob ngjrojr*
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o 32 gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;3<?
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 65/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ 3?
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
[flajracc~ Ghionragj~9
Da~|ugro~ rmo osabojno gj cafo parm rma~ Nguxr U[flajracc~ CLNT5 Da~folbaj`
ljb a~ jgr ~u{{gxrob hq ngd{orojr osabojno*
[flajracc~ Xo~{gj~o9
BA^[_ROB CLNR $ Jgpmoxo aj [flajracc~ CLN a~ rmo pgxb ‖{uhfa~mob— gx
‖{uhfa~m l~~gnalrob parm Ajrofau~* [flajracc~ CLN ~rlro~ Ajrofau~ a~ l nxobar
xo{gxraj` l`ojnq pmg ~off~ ngj~udox xo{gxr~* Ajrofau~ ~gfb xo{gxr~ gj
[flajracc~ rg ajbasabulf~ parmgur ljq rq{o gc l {oxda~~ahfo {ux{g~o5 rmlr
Ajrofau~ ~off~ rg ajbasabulf~ cgx l {xgcar& orn* [flajracc~ josox {fob ljb ar a~
jgpmoxo aj [flajracc~ CLN& rmlr Ajrofau~ ‖{uhfa~mob— ljq ngjrojr* Ajrofau~ a~
ljb pl~ xo~{gj~ahfo cgx rmo bosofg{dojr gc rmo ngj~udox xo{gxr~ gj rmo
[flajracc~* Ajrofau~& aj sagflragj gc rmo CNXL& ~gfb [flarjacc~ nxobar ljb
ngj~udox xo{gxr~ rg ujlurmgxayob ajbasabulf~* Ajrofau~ clafob rg oj~uxo rmo
ajcgxdlragj aj rmo xo{gxr~ rmoq ~gfb pl~ lnnuxlro* Ajrofau~ a jgxob [flajracc~
forrox~ cgx ng{ao~ gc rmoax xo{gxr~& ngxxonragj~ rg xodgso rmo ajngxxonr
ajcgxdlragj& orn* Ajrofau~ ml~ josox {xgsabob rg [flajracc~ pmg rmo cuxja~mox
gc ajcgxdlragj pl~& pmanm [flajracc~ poxo ojrarfob rg* Cxlub lfoxr~ poxo
{flnob gj [flajracc~ nxobar xo{gxr~& Ajrofau~ clafob rg lbmoxo rg rmo CNXL
xo|uaxodojr~ xo`lxbaj` rmo cxlub lfroxr~& orn* Rmo ajngxxonr ajcgxdlragj
nxolrob ljb bosofg{ob hq Ajrofau~ aj rmoax Nxobar Ngj~udox Xo{gxr~ aj
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o 3? gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;3<3
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 66/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ 33
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
pmanm rmoq ~gfb rg ujlurmgxayob {ox~gj~& ajnfubaj` hur jgr fadarob rg Gxfq
Rlary& pl~ {uhfa~mob lff gsox rmo Ajroxjor& xo{olrobfq& ~ojr ajroxjlragjlffq
xo{olrobfq& ~ojr rmxgu`m X^^ coob~& {g~rob aj ^gnalf Jorpgxe~& orn* Ajrofau~
a~ rmo bosofg{ox gc rmo xo{gxr~5 Ajrofau~ a~ xo~{gj~ahfo cgx rmo ~lfo gc [flajracc~
{xaslro blrl5 ljb Ajrofau~ a~ rmo bosofg{ox gc rmo ngjrojr pmanm a~ rmo ~uhionr
gc falhafarq* Iu~r faeo aj CRN s* Lnnu~olxnm& 8;;1 PF <=23>22 -<;rm Nax
Iujo 81& 8;;1!& pmoj [flajracc~ ngjcabojralf ajcgxdlragj pl~ o}{g~ob rg
{uhfan saop rmxgu`m Ajrofau~& rmlr ajcgxdlragj pl~ ‖bosofg{ob—*Ajrofau~ a
xo~{gj~ahfo cgx rmo bosofg{dojr gc rmo ngjrojr‒cgx rmo ngjsox~agj gc rmo fo`lffq
{xgronrob xongxb~ cxgd ngjcabojralf dlroxalf rg {uhfanfq o}{g~ob ajcgxdlragj*
[flajracc~ Osabojno9
[flajracc~ CLN lr {{* 3<$3?& ³³ <2?$<??5 ljb {{* <81$<>;& ³>2>5 Fahoxa
Ajrofau~‑ ‖Lffo`ob— _jngjrxgsoxrob Clnr Jg* ><9
Rmo lffo`ob ajcgxdlragj cgxdaj` rmo hl~a~ gc {flajracc~‑ Rpofcrm rmxgu`m
^a}roojrm Nlu~o~ gc Lnragj l`laj~r Ajrofau~ pl~ jgr nxolrob hq Ajrofau~*
[flajracc~ Ghionragj~9
Da~folbaj` ljb uj~u{{gxrob hq ngd{orojr osabojno*
Bonf*& {{* <1$8;& ³2;5 ^rxohof Bonf*& {{* <<$8& ³<15 ljb Hox` Bonf*& {{* >$2&
³3& ljb {* 3& ³<>*
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o 33 gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;3<0
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 67/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ 30
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
[flajracc~ Xo~{gj~o9
BA^[_ROB CLNR $ Ajrofau~ lbdar~ rg ~offaj` hlne`xgujb Xo{gxr~ gj rmo
[flajracc~* Rmo hlne`xgujb xo{gxr~ ~gfb hq Ajrofau~ poxo ‖{ox~gj ~{onacan—
ljb ngj~udox xo{gxr~ l~ bocajob hq rmo CNXL& <? _*^*N* <3=<l-b!
Ajrofau~ lbdar~ rmoq lxo l noxracaob nxobar xo{gxraj` l`ojnq gj rmoax poh~aro
ljb rmoq lxo `gsoxjob hq rmo CNXL ljb grmox ~rlro flp~ aj rmo xo{gxr rmoq
cafob parm rmo ^ON aj 8;;1* [flajracc~ mlso {xgsoj rmoax Nlu~o~ gc Lnragj
Rpofso rmxgu`m ^a}rooj l`laj~r Ajrofau~* Ajrofau~ nxolrob rmo bldl`o~
l`laj~r [flajracc~ hq ~offaj` rmoax xo{gxr~ rg ujlurmgxayob {lxrao~5 clafaj` rg
ngxxonr ajngxxonr ajcgxdlragj5 ljb clafaj` rg cuffq xodgso [flajracc~ cxgd
rmoax blrlhl~o~ ljb rmo blrlhl~o~ gc rmoax lccafalro~& hu~ajo~~ ljb
ngx{gxlragj~* Ajrofau~ a~ lplxo rmo CRN ml~ ho`uj nxlneaj` bgpj gj rmo
bono{raso {xlnrano~*
[flajracc~ Osabojno9
[flajracc~ CLN& {{* 3<$02& ³³<22$<02 ljb {{* <80$<28& ³³ >>?$>025
[flajracc~ XIJ& O}~* ‖<— rmxgu`m ‖?—&5 Fahoxa Bonf*& BJ >=1$8& {{* <$>& ³³ <$
?& ljb O}h~* ‖L— ljb ‖H—& {{* =$8>5 Hox` Bonf*& BJ >=1$<& {{* 8$2& ³³ 2$<;
G~roffl Bonf*& BJ >1;$?& {* 8& ³<8& {{* 2$3& ³³<2$<1 ljb O}h* ‖8—& {* <>5
^rxohof Bonf*& {{* <$?& ³³<$83& O}h~* <— rmxgu`m ‖83—& {{* <3$3>5 G~roffl
Bonf*& {{* <$<>& ³³<$>;& O}h~* ‖<— rmxgu`m ‖<;—& {{* <2$<8?5 ljb Fahox
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o 30 gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;3<=
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 68/70
Fahoxa& or lf „ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ 3=
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
Bonf*& {{* <$88& ³³<$2?& O}h~* ‖L— rmxgu`m ‖F—& {{* 8>$=?5 ljb Hox` Bonf*
[flajracc~ lf~g ba~{uro Ajrofau~‑ Ngjnfu~agj gc Flp aj ar~ ojraxorq5 [flajracc~
lbbxo~~ lff a~~uo~ {oxrlajaj` rg rmo Flp aj rmoax Dodgxljbud Hxaoc aj G{{g~aragj
rg Ajrofau~‑ Dgragj cgx ^uddlxq Iub`dojr* ^uddlxq Iub`dojr a~ jgr {xg{ox aj
rma~ nl~o& l~ rmoxo lxo judoxgu~ Ba~{urob Dlroxalf Clnr~* Rmo osabojno xofaob gj
hq Ajrofau~& bgo~ jgr ~lq pmlr rmoq nflad ar ~rlro~& ljb Rmujoj a~ jgr nxobahfo ljb
ma~ Bonflxlragj bgo~ jgr ~u{{gxr Ajrofau~‑ clf~o ~rlrodojr~ ljb nflad~* Jof~gj ljb
Rmujoj‑~ Bonflxlragj~ ljb rmo Xongxb aj rma~ nl~o& ba~{uro rmo ~rlrodojr~ Ajrofau~
a~ dleaj` gx nfladaj` aj rmoax Dgragj cgx ^uddlxq Iub`dojr*
Xo~{onrcuffq ~uhdarrob&
Blrob9 Cohxulxq 8;& 8;<8 ~ [mafa{ I* Hox`
[mafa{ I* Hox`& O~|uaxo
Lrrgxjoq cgx [flajracc~
{{* 8$0& ³³2& 3$1& <<$<>& <?$<3*
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23; Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o 3= gc 3= [l`o AB.9<;3<1
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 69/70
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
8?
83
80
8=
[mafa{ I* Hox`& O~|uaxo -[L A*B* 1=30!O$dlaf9 {mafihox`K`dlaf*ngd
FLP GCCANO^ GC [MAFA[ I* HOX@
??? Ljbgxxl @foj Nguxr& ^uaro <8Flclqorro Maff& [L <1222$8?><
Rofo{mgjo9 -3<;! =8?$><>2 Cl}9 -3<;! =>2$03?1 Lrrgxjoq aj {xg ~o ljb cgx [flajracc~
_JAROB ^RLRO^ BA^RXANR NG_XR
CGX RMO NOJRXLF BA^RXANR GC NLFACGXJAL&
^G_RMOXJ BASA^AGJ
FA^L FAHOXA& or lf&
[flajracc~&
s~*
GXFQ RLARY& or lf&Bocojbljr~*
9
9999999999
NASAF LNRAGJ J_DHOX9=9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@ -LIP!
[FLAJRACC^ NOXRACANLRO GC
^OXSANO
A& [mafa{ I* Hox`& O~|uaxo& moxohq noxracq l rxuo ljb ngxxonr ng{q gc [flajracc~
Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Ajrofau~‑ ‖[xg{g~ob _jngjrxgsoxrob Dlroxalf
Clnr~— poxo ~oxsob ofonrxgjanlffq rmxgu`m rmo ONC cafaj` ~q~rod rma~ 8;rm blq gc Cohxulxq
8;<8& u{gj rmo cgffgpaj`9
Igmj L Sg`r& Ix*& O~|uaxo
Obplxb lj Nmlj`& O~|uaxo
Igjo~ Blq
><3< Danmof~gj Bxaso ^uaro =;;
Axsajo& NL 183<8Odlaf9 ilsg`rKigjo~blq*ngd
Odlaf9 onmlj`Kigjo~blq*ngd
Lrrgxjoq cgx Bocojbljr Ajrofau~& Ajn*
Fahoxa& or lf „ Noxr gc sn $ [flajracc~ Ngjna~o ^rlrodojr gc @ojuajo Ba~{uro~ gc Dlroxalf Clnr~ <
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23;$< Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o < gc 8 [l`o AB.9<;38;
8/3/2019 Liberi, Et Al - Plaintiffs Concise Statement of Disputed Facts Doc 460
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-et-al-plaintiffs-concise-statement-of-disputed-facts-doc-460 70/70
<
8
>
2
?
3
0
=
1
<;
<<
<8
<>
<2
<?
<3
<0
<=
<1
8;
8<
88
8>
82
Dlxn rosoj Ngfoj& O~|uaxo
Flp Gccano~ gc Dlxn ^rosoj Ngfoj
?0>0 Eljlj Xglb& ^uaro >20L`guxl Maff~& NL 1<>;<
Odlaf9 dngfojKngfojflp*ngd
Lrrgxjoq cgx Bocojbljr~9 Joaf ^ljeoq5 Rgbb ^ljeoq5
^ljeoq Ajso~ra`lragj~& Ajn* ljb Rmo ^ljeoq Caxd& Ajn*
Ildo~ C DnNlho& O~|uaxo
Dgxxa~gj # Cgox~rox
28? Dlxeor ^rxoor^lj Cxljna~ng& NL 12<;?$82=8
Odlaf9 idnnlhoKdgcg*ngd
Lrrgxjoq cgx Bocojbljr~9 Xoob Of~osaox& Ajn*& Fo}a~Jo}a~ @xgu{& Ajn*&
Fo}a~Jo}a~& Ajn*& Fo}a~Jo}a~ Xa~e ljb Ajcgxdlragj Ljlfqran~ @xgu{& Ajn*& F
Fo}a~Jo}a~ Xa~e ^gfuragj~& Ajn*& ^oa~ajr& Ajn* b'h'l Lnnuxajr& Nmgano{gajr& Ajn*
'~' [mafa{ I* Hox`
[mafa{ I* Hox`& O~|uaxo
Nl~o =9<<$ns$;;2=?$L@$LIP Bgnudojr 23;$< Cafob ;8'8;'<8 [l`o 8 gc 8 [l`o AB.9<;38<