Transcript
Page 1: Final CVP Chapter Activities Report for 2010 · : E-Discovery Seminar on November 10, 2010; Bankruptcy seminar on December 2, 2010; and a “brown bag” lunch on ethical issues &

5674

04_2

.DO

C

To:

From

:

Fede

ral B

ar A

ssoc

iatio

n B

oard

of D

irect

ors

W. W

est A

llen

FBA

Vic

e Pr

esid

ents

for t

he C

ircui

ts, C

hair

Re:

20

10 F

BA

Cha

pter

Eve

nts B

y C

ircui

t Rep

ort

The

Fede

ral B

ar A

ssoc

iatio

n V

ice

Pres

iden

ts fo

r the

Circ

uits

hav

e re

ques

ted

all c

hapt

er le

ader

s to

mai

ntai

n a

hist

ory

of th

e pr

inci

pal e

vent

s he

ld w

ithin

th

eir r

espe

ctiv

e ch

apte

rs.

This

yea

r’s r

epor

ts h

ave

been

sum

mar

ized

and

pre

sent

ed b

elow

for f

utur

e re

fere

nce

as n

ew F

BA

cha

pter

pre

side

nts p

lan

even

t an

d ba

r ac

tiviti

es th

roug

hout

the

coun

try.

The

FBA

cha

pter

pre

side

nts

in 2

010

have

don

e an

exc

elle

nt jo

b at

pla

nnin

g an

d ho

ldin

g si

gnifi

cant

lega

l ev

ents

that

adv

ance

the

obje

ctiv

es a

nd m

issi

on o

f the

Fed

eral

Bar

Ass

ocia

tion.

C

IRC

UIT

CH

APT

ER

EV

EN

TS

D.C

. Cha

pter

C

apito

l Hill

C

hapt

er�

The

Cap

itol H

ill C

hapt

er is

com

pris

ed o

f sev

en c

ompo

nent

uni

ts: (

1) th

e H

ouse

of R

epre

sent

ativ

es; (

2) th

e Se

nate

; (3)

the

Libr

ary

of C

ongr

ess;

(4) t

he S

upre

me

Cou

rt; (5

) the

Gov

ernm

ent A

ccou

ntab

ility

Off

ice;

(6)

the

Gov

ernm

ent P

rintin

g O

ffic

e; a

nd (7

) a c

ompo

nent

uni

t con

sist

ing

of th

e A

dmin

istra

tive

Off

ice

of th

e U

nite

d St

ates

Cou

rts, t

he F

eder

al Ju

dici

al C

ente

r, th

e U

nite

d St

ates

Sen

tenc

ing

Com

mis

sion

, and

the

Judi

cial

Pan

el o

n M

ultid

istri

ct L

itiga

tion.

Thi

s yea

r’s p

rogr

ams i

nclu

ded

the

follo

win

g:

�O

ctob

er 2

9, 2

010.

Lun

cheo

n w

ith W

illia

m L

aFor

ge. B

ill sp

oke

to th

e gr

oup

abou

t his

boo

k Te

stify

ing

Bef

ore

Con

gres

s: A

Pra

ctic

al G

uide

to P

repa

ring

and

Del

iver

ing

Test

imon

y be

fore

Con

gres

s and

C

ongr

essi

onal

Hea

rings

for A

genc

ies,

Ass

ocia

tions

, Cor

pora

tions

, Mili

tary

, NG

Os,

and

Stat

e an

d Lo

cal

Off

icia

ls.

�N

ovem

ber 1

8, 2

010.

Hap

py H

our c

o-sp

onso

red

with

the

Envi

ronm

ent,

Ener

gy, a

nd N

atur

al R

esou

rces

(E

ENR

) Sec

tion

�N

ovem

ber 2

9, 2

010.

Lun

cheo

n w

ith A

ri Sh

apiro

- N

PR W

hite

Hou

se C

orre

spon

dent

and

form

er N

PR

Just

ice

Cor

resp

onde

nt

�Sc

hedu

led

even

ts fo

r 201

1 in

clud

e a

Janu

ary

14, 2

011

lunc

heon

with

Mer

yl C

herto

ff. M

s. C

herto

ff is

D

irect

or o

f The

Asp

en In

stitu

te’s

Just

ice

and

Soci

ety

Prog

ram

. She

is a

n A

djun

ct P

rofe

ssor

of L

aw a

t

FED

ER

AL

BA

R A

SSO

CIA

TIO

N

VIC

E P

RE

SID

EN

TS

FOR

TH

E C

IRC

UIT

S 20

10 C

HA

PTE

R E

VE

NT

S R

EPO

RT

Page 2: Final CVP Chapter Activities Report for 2010 · : E-Discovery Seminar on November 10, 2010; Bankruptcy seminar on December 2, 2010; and a “brown bag” lunch on ethical issues &

Vic

e Pr

esid

ents

for t

he C

ircui

ts 2

010

Cha

pter

Eve

nts R

epor

t Ja

nuar

y 14

, 201

1

2

CIR

CU

ITC

HA

PTE

RE

VE

NT

S

Geo

rget

own

Law

, whe

re sh

e te

ache

s abo

ut st

ate

gove

rnm

ent,

inte

rgov

ernm

enta

l aff

airs

and

stat

e co

urts

. �

Febr

uary

3, 2

011.

Buf

fet l

unch

and

tour

of t

he U

.S. S

upre

me

Cou

rt Li

brar

y.

D

istri

ct o

f C

olum

bia

Cha

pter

Ever

y m

onth

a m

embe

r of t

he D

C C

hapt

er is

on

the

prog

ram

for t

he n

ew a

dmitt

ees t

o th

e U

.S. D

istri

ct

Cou

rt fo

r the

Dis

trict

of C

olum

bia.

Tha

t per

son

wel

com

es th

e ne

w a

dmitt

ees a

nd is

abl

e to

invi

te th

em to

jo

in th

e ch

apte

r. A

fter t

he c

erem

ony,

ther

e ar

e re

fres

hmen

ts in

the

judg

es' d

inin

g ro

om.

The

refr

eshm

ents

ar

e sp

onso

red

by th

e C

t. an

d th

e D

C C

hapt

er.

�Th

e D

C C

hapt

er m

akes

a c

onsi

dera

ble

finan

cial

con

tribu

tion

to th

e Jo

bs-4

-Jag

s pro

gram

the

Pent

agon

C

hapt

er p

uts o

n an

nual

ly.

�In

May

201

0, th

e D

C C

hapt

er sp

onso

red

the

Leve

nson

Sym

posi

um.

That

pro

gram

has

a p

anel

of D

istri

ct

Cou

rt ju

dges

that

par

ticip

ate,

led

by th

e C

hief

Judg

e of

that

Cou

rt, Ju

dge

Roy

ce L

ambe

rth.

In a

dditi

on, a

pa

nel o

f atto

rney

s, w

ho p

ract

ice

in th

e ar

ea o

f sec

uriti

es a

nd e

xcha

nge

law

, dis

cuss

ed se

vera

l cas

es o

f im

porta

nce.

Din

ner w

as se

rved

and

CLE

cre

dits

wer

e of

fere

d, a

ll at

no

cost

to a

ttend

ees.

�O

n M

ay 3

, 201

, the

DC

Cha

pter

was

a c

o-sp

onso

r for

a se

min

ar th

at w

as h

eld

in th

e La

w L

ibra

ry o

f C

ongr

ess.

The

pro

gram

was

title

d, "

You

Be

The

Judg

e --

Cro

ss C

ultu

ral I

ssue

s in

The

Cou

rts."

Thi

s Law

D

ay p

rogr

am w

as o

rgan

ized

by

Judg

e D

elis

sa R

idgw

ay o

f the

U.S

. Cou

rt of

Inte

rnat

iona

l Tra

de in

New

Y

ork.

Pent

agon

Cha

pter

This

cha

pter

con

sist

s prim

arily

of J

udge

Adv

ocat

es (

mili

tary

law

yers

). It

par

tner

s with

the

Judg

e A

dvoc

ates

Ass

ocia

tion

(JA

A),

and

man

y m

embe

rs a

re in

bot

h or

gani

zatio

ns (a

s wel

l as J

AA

’s c

hapt

er o

f th

e A

mer

ican

Inns

of C

ourt)

. �

The

chap

ter l

aunc

hed

a ch

apte

r Fac

eboo

k pa

ge w

hich

has

bee

n in

stru

men

tal i

n sp

read

ing

the

wor

d ab

out

Jobs

for J

AG

s (se

e be

low

). �

End-

of-te

rm re

cept

ion

(eve

ry M

ay) a

t the

Cou

rt o

f App

eals

for t

he A

rmed

For

ces (

CAA

F): C

hief

Judg

e A

ndre

w E

ffro

n is

an

FBA

mem

ber a

nd h

osts

the

rece

ptio

n. T

he e

vent

is p

rimar

ily a

ttend

ed m

y m

embe

rs

of a

ll th

e se

rvic

e co

urts

of a

ppea

ls, w

hich

are

the

Arm

y C

ourt

of C

rimin

al A

ppea

ls, t

he A

ir Fo

rce

Cou

rt of

C

rimin

al A

ppea

ls, t

he N

avy-

Mar

ine

Cou

rt of

Crim

inal

App

eals

, and

the

Coa

st G

uard

Cou

rt of

Crim

inal

A

ppea

ls.

�Jo

bs fo

r JAG

s: P

ut o

n w

ith th

e fu

ll pa

rtner

ship

of t

he JA

A, t

his i

s a fu

ll-da

y of

pan

elis

ts/s

peak

ers w

ho a

re

form

er JA

Gs a

nd w

ho p

rovi

de jo

b-se

ekin

g ad

vice

to c

urre

nt JA

Gs.

This

yea

r the

re w

ere

appr

oxim

atel

y 70

at

tend

ees (

FBA

and

non

-FB

A).

Sept

embe

r 201

0 Ev

ent a

t the

Arm

y-N

avy

Cou

ntry

Clu

b in

Arli

ngto

n, V

irgin

ia. K

eyno

te sp

eake

r was

W

illia

m K

. Sut

er, C

lerk

of t

he S

upre

me

Cou

rt of

the

Uni

ted

Stat

es.

1st C

ircui

t Pu

erto

Ric

o �

Con

tinui

ng L

egal

Edu

catio

n: E

-Dis

cove

ry S

emin

ar o

n N

ovem

ber 1

0, 2

010;

Ban

krup

tcy

sem

inar

on

Dec

embe

r 2, 2

010;

and

a “

brow

n ba

g” lu

nch

on e

thic

al is

sues

& c

ivili

ty in

mid

-Dec

embe

r 201

0. T

he

Page 3: Final CVP Chapter Activities Report for 2010 · : E-Discovery Seminar on November 10, 2010; Bankruptcy seminar on December 2, 2010; and a “brown bag” lunch on ethical issues &

Vic

e Pr

esid

ents

for t

he C

ircui

ts 2

010

Cha

pter

Eve

nts R

epor

t Ja

nuar

y 14

, 201

1

3

CIR

CU

ITC

HA

PTE

RE

VE

NT

S

C

hapt

er a

lso

has q

uarte

rly se

ssio

ns re

latin

g to

the

effe

ctiv

e us

e of

the

tech

nolo

gy in

the

cour

t roo

ms.

Oth

er

plan

ned

CLE

topi

c ac

tiviti

es: (

1) T

he b

enef

its o

f ear

ly d

ispu

te re

solu

tion:

The

“In

’s &

Out

’s”

of C

ourt

-An

nexe

d M

edia

tion;

(2) P

anel

dis

cuss

ion

by Ju

dges

& M

agis

trate

Judg

es: S

peci

fic li

kes a

nd d

islik

es -

“D

o’s &

Don

’ts”;

(3) M

eet t

he Ju

dge’

s law

cle

rks:

pra

ctic

al p

oint

ers;

(4) W

ritin

g se

min

ar: K

eep

it pl

ain

and

shor

t! (5

) Fed

eral

Ple

adin

g St

anda

rds:

Dev

elop

men

ts a

fter T

wom

bly

and

Iqba

l; (6

) Rul

es o

f Evi

denc

e:

Mos

t im

port

ant i

ssue

s and

com

mon

mis

take

s; (7

) Ess

entia

ls o

f Mar

itim

e La

w; (

8) U

.S A

ttorn

eys O

ffic

e v.

Pu

blic

Def

ende

rs: D

iffer

ent P

ersp

ectiv

es o

n Pr

osec

utin

g an

d D

efen

ding

Cri

min

al D

efen

dant

s; a

nd (9

) C

ompl

ianc

e w

ith th

e Lo

cal R

ules

: Com

mon

mis

take

s and

ove

rsig

hts.

�Pu

blic

ity &

Pub

licat

ions

: The

Cha

pter

’s N

ewsl

ette

r is a

n im

porta

nt se

rvic

e to

our

mem

bers

. W

e ha

ve

form

aliz

ed a

Pub

licity

& P

ublic

atio

ns c

omm

ittee

to g

ive

the

nece

ssar

y su

ppor

t to

the

Edito

r of o

ur

new

slet

ter.

The

goa

l is t

o pu

blis

h 4

editi

ons o

f Fro

m th

e Ba

r and

to d

evel

op a

mon

thly

e-m

ail t

o ou

r m

embe

rshi

p w

ith n

otew

orth

y de

cisi

ons.

�Yo

unge

r Law

yers

& S

tude

nt C

hapt

ers:

We

held

an

indu

ctio

n ce

rem

ony

for t

he st

uden

t div

isio

ns o

n O

ctob

er 1

5, 2

010,

in w

hich

we

had

the

parti

cipa

tion

of th

e FB

A’s

Nat

iona

l Tre

asur

er, B

ob D

e So

usa.

One

of

the

stud

ent d

ivis

ions

als

o he

ld a

Leg

al W

ritin

g W

orks

hop

on O

ctob

er 2

6. W

e ar

e al

so c

oord

inat

ing

othe

r edu

catio

nal a

nd n

etw

orki

ng a

ctiv

ities

dire

cted

to th

e “y

oung

er”

law

yers

and

stud

ent d

ivis

ions

. Th

e ac

tiviti

es p

ropo

sed

so fa

r inc

lude

: (1)

Tec

hnol

ogy

in th

e C

ourtr

oom

Sem

inar

(Nov

embe

r); (

2) N

etw

orki

ng

activ

ity b

etw

een

“you

nger

” la

wye

rs a

nd st

uden

t div

isio

n m

embe

rs (F

ebru

ary

2011

); (3

) Jud

icia

l Pan

el o

n Iq

bal a

nd T

wom

bly

(Nov

embe

r 18)

; and

(4) a

sem

inar

on

ethi

cal i

ssue

s and

civ

ility

.�

Com

mun

ity-B

enef

it C

omm

ittee

: The

Cha

pter

has

act

ivat

ed th

is c

omm

ittee

to o

rgan

ize

an a

ctiv

ity fo

r the

be

nefit

of a

non

-pro

fit o

rgan

izat

ion.

In

addi

tion,

we

have

alre

ady

begu

n th

e im

plem

enta

tion

of th

e SO

LAC

E Pr

ogra

m in

Pue

rto R

ico

(Sup

port

of L

awye

rs/L

egal

-Per

sonn

el A

ll-C

once

rned

Enc

oura

ged)

.�

Net

wor

king

and

Spe

cial

Act

iviti

es: T

he C

hapt

er w

ill h

ost i

ts tr

aditi

onal

Chr

istm

as p

arty

in e

arly

Dec

embe

r.

�Ba

r Rev

iew

Cou

rses

: Th

e C

hapt

er w

ill c

ontin

ue to

pro

vide

the

Bar

Rev

iew

Cou

rse.

�Th

e C

hapt

er sp

onso

red

and

parti

cipa

ted

in th

e 20

10 P

uerto

Ric

o Tr

ial A

dvoc

acy

Com

petit

ion,

whi

ch to

ok

plac

e on

Oct

ober

28-

30, 2

010.

�Th

e C

hapt

er is

a sp

onso

r of t

he F

BA

’s B

iann

ual L

abor

and

Em

ploy

men

t Law

Con

fere

nce

in S

an Ju

an

Puer

to R

ico,

whi

ch sh

all t

ake

plac

e on

Feb

ruar

y 20

10

�Pa

rtici

pate

d in

Adm

issi

ons t

o Pr

actic

e &

Nat

ural

izat

ion

Cer

emon

ies.

2nd C

ircui

t S.

D. N

ew Y

ork

�M

arch

1, 2

010

Ins

talla

tion

of n

ew o

ffic

ers a

nd a

rece

ptio

n w

ith th

e ne

wly

inst

alle

d of

ficer

s and

our

Chi

ef

Judg

e on

Mar

ch 1

, 201

0.�

May

10,

102

0 Th

e G

roun

d Tr

uth:

The

Unt

old

Stor

y of

Am

eric

a un

der A

ttack

on

9/11

so-s

pons

ored

with

th

e N

ew Y

ork

City

Bar

Ass

ocia

tion.

The

eve

nt fe

atur

ed, P

rofe

ssor

John

J. F

arm

er, J

r., a

mem

ber o

f the

Page 4: Final CVP Chapter Activities Report for 2010 · : E-Discovery Seminar on November 10, 2010; Bankruptcy seminar on December 2, 2010; and a “brown bag” lunch on ethical issues &

Vic

e Pr

esid

ents

for t

he C

ircui

ts 2

010

Cha

pter

Eve

nts R

epor

t Ja

nuar

y 14

, 201

1

4

CIR

CU

ITC

HA

PTE

RE

VE

NT

S

Sept

embe

r 11

Com

mis

sion

and

Dea

n an

d Pr

ofes

sor o

f Law

at R

utge

rs S

choo

l of L

aw.

�M

ay 1

9, 2

010

Win

e ta

stin

g ho

sted

join

tly b

y th

e M

embe

rshi

p C

hairm

an a

nd th

e Y

oung

er L

awye

rs

Com

mitt

ee

�Ju

ne 8

, 201

0Br

ave

New

Wor

ld: F

iling

App

eals

in th

e Se

cond

Cir

cuit

Cou

rt o

f App

eals

Cat

herin

e O

’Hag

an W

olfe

, the

Cle

rk o

f the

Sec

ond

Circ

uit,

toge

ther

with

John

McC

arth

y an

d R

aym

ond

Dow

d of

our

C

hapt

er, d

id a

CLE

pre

sent

atio

n on

the

new

rule

s and

pra

ctic

es in

the

US

Cou

rt of

App

eals

for t

he S

econ

d C

ircui

t. M

s. W

olfe

des

crib

ed in

det

ail m

any

on th

e ne

w p

roce

dure

s in

plac

e fo

r app

ella

te p

ract

ice

in th

e C

ourt,

focu

sing

prim

arily

on

the

early

stag

es o

f app

eals

. �

July

27,

201

0 Re

cent

Tre

nds I

n Et

hica

l Iss

ues C

onfr

ontin

g Im

mig

ratio

n Pr

actit

ione

rs T

his p

rogr

am b

y R

icha

rd M

. Mal

tz, f

orm

er F

irst D

eput

y C

hief

Cou

nsel

, Dep

artm

enta

l Dis

cipl

inar

y C

omm

ittee

, Firs

t Ju

dici

al D

epar

tmen

t of t

he S

upre

me

Cou

rt of

the

Stat

e of

New

Yor

k, A

ppel

late

Div

isio

n, w

ill d

iscu

ss a

nd

anal

yze

the

ethi

cal p

itfal

ls a

nd d

ilem

mas

faci

ng im

mig

ratio

n pr

actit

ione

rs a

nd o

ffer

sim

ple

step

s to

help

th

em n

avig

ate

thes

e tre

ache

rous

wat

ers.

It w

ill a

lso

addr

ess w

hat t

o do

shou

ld a

pra

ctiti

oner

stum

ble

into

an

eth

ical

pitf

all.

�Ju

ly 2

8, 2

010

U.S

. Bra

nd a

nd IP

Pro

tect

ion

Sem

inar

"Bo

rder

Enf

orce

men

t of I

P Ri

ghts

in th

e U

.S."

– A

D

iscu

ssio

n w

ith th

e U

.S. C

usto

ms &

Bor

der P

rote

ctio

n an

d "T

he V

iew

from

the

USP

TO"

How

to

Effe

ctiv

ely

Wor

k w

ith E

xam

inin

g At

torn

eys i

n N

avig

atin

g th

e Tr

adem

ark

Appl

icat

ion

Proc

ess.

The

prog

ram

will

feat

ure

Dax

Ter

rill (

an A

ttorn

ey-A

dvis

or fr

om th

e U

S C

usto

ms &

Bor

der P

atro

l) an

d D

anie

l S.

Bro

dy (a

Sen

ior A

ttorn

ey fo

r the

USP

TO) a

ddre

ssin

g cu

rren

t iss

ues a

nd re

cent

dev

elop

men

ts in

the

inte

llect

ual p

rope

rty a

rea.

Thi

s bre

akfa

st p

rogr

am w

ill d

iscu

ss th

e pr

oces

s of t

rade

mar

k pr

otec

tion

in th

e U

.S. a

nd h

ow to

avo

id c

omm

on p

itfal

ls in

the

appl

icat

ion

proc

ess.

Cur

rent

tren

ds a

nd e

ffor

ts re

latin

g to

the

seiz

ure

of c

ount

erfe

it go

ods a

t the

U.S

. Bor

der,

as w

ell a

s IP

Rig

hts e

nfor

cem

ent a

lso

will

be

disc

usse

d.

�O

ctob

er 1

9, 2

010

CLE

– D

iscu

ssio

n by

Ted

Dav

is o

n cu

rren

t iss

ues o

f Tra

dem

ark

Law

Nov

embe

r 22,

201

0 M

eet t

he C

lerk

rece

ptio

n to

wel

com

e R

uby

J. K

rajic

k, th

e ne

w C

lerk

of C

ourt

of th

e U

nite

d St

ates

Dis

trict

Cou

rt fo

r the

Sou

ther

n D

istri

ct o

f New

Yor

k.

�D

ecem

ber 1

, 201

0 C

hapt

er h

ad a

Hol

iday

Par

ty/W

ine

Tast

ing

at Jo

’s R

esta

uran

t. 3rd

Circ

uit

Del

awar

e�

June

23,

201

0 --

Ann

ual L

unch

eon

-- se

e at

tach

ed p

rogr

am -

appr

oxim

atel

y 22

0 at

tend

ees

�Ju

ne 3

0, 2

010

-- A

ppre

ciat

ion

Din

ner f

or V

isiti

ng Ju

dges

-- se

e at

tach

ed fl

yer -

app

roxi

mat

ely

32 a

ttend

ees

�O

ctob

er 1

5, 2

010

-- Ju

dge

Leon

ard

P. S

tark

's In

vest

iture

-- D

elaw

are

Cha

pter

Pre

side

nt p

artic

ipat

ed in

the

cere

mon

y fo

llow

ing

Vic

e Pr

esid

ent B

iden

and

mem

bers

of C

ongr

ess;

the

Del

awar

e C

hapt

er sp

onso

red

the

rece

ptio

n fo

llow

ing

the

cere

mon

y �

Oct

ober

22,

201

0 --

Del

awar

e C

hapt

er c

o-sp

onso

red

a La

w E

nfor

cem

ent a

nd F

inan

cial

Inst

itutio

n tra

inin

g/C

LE p

rogr

am ti

tled

“Wor

king

Tog

ethe

r to

Com

bat I

dent

ity T

heft”

at T

heat

re N

, Firs

t Flo

or, 1

007

Page 5: Final CVP Chapter Activities Report for 2010 · : E-Discovery Seminar on November 10, 2010; Bankruptcy seminar on December 2, 2010; and a “brown bag” lunch on ethical issues &

Vic

e Pr

esid

ents

for t

he C

ircui

ts 2

010

Cha

pter

Eve

nts R

epor

t Ja

nuar

y 14

, 201

1

5

CIR

CU

ITC

HA

PTE

RE

VE

NT

S

Ora

nge

Stre

et, W

ilmin

gton

, DE

1980

1.

�O

ctob

er 2

7, 2

010

-- D

elaw

are

Cha

pter

's Q

uarte

rly L

unch

eon

-- Ju

dge

Star

k w

as th

e sp

eake

r -

appr

oxim

atel

y 60

atte

ndee

s �

Nov

embe

r 3, 2

010

-- D

elaw

are

Cha

pter

co-

spon

sore

d an

eFi

ling

Tren

ds S

emin

ar --

see

atta

ched

flye

r -

appr

oxim

atel

y 80

atte

ndee

s �

Nov

embe

r 9, 2

010

-- D

elaw

are

Cha

pter

spon

sore

d an

eD

isco

very

CLE

-- se

e at

tach

ed fl

yer -

app

roxi

mat

ely

60 a

ttend

ees

�D

ecem

ber 9

, 201

0 --

IP S

ectio

n of

the

Del

awar

e C

hapt

er sp

onso

red

the

Ann

ual I

ntel

lect

ual P

rope

rty

Din

ner w

ith th

e D

istri

ct C

ourt

-- a

ppro

xim

atel

y 72

atte

ndee

s

Ric

hmon

d V

irgin

ia

Cha

pter

�Ja

nuar

y 28

, 201

0, th

e R

ichm

ond

Cha

pter

hos

ted

a re

cept

ion

in h

onor

of t

he U

nite

d St

ates

Dis

trict

Cou

rt an

d th

e U

nite

d St

ates

Ban

krup

tcy

Cou

rt (R

ichm

ond

Div

isio

ns).

The

rece

ptio

n w

as h

eld

in th

e at

rium

of t

he

Spot

swoo

d W

. Rob

inso

n II

I & R

ober

t R. M

erhi

ge, J

r., C

ourth

ouse

in R

ichm

ond,

Virg

inia

and

was

wel

l at

tend

ed b

y bo

th m

embe

rs o

f the

loca

l bar

and

the

fede

ral j

udic

iary

. A d

isco

unte

d ra

te w

as o

ffer

ed to

FB

A

mem

bers

who

atte

nded

this

eve

nt.

�N

ovem

ber 1

9, 2

010,

the

Ric

hmon

d C

hapt

er h

oste

d a

lunc

heon

and

swea

ring-

in c

erem

ony

with

The

H

onor

able

Will

iam

K. S

uter

, Cle

rk o

f the

U.S

. Sup

rem

e C

ourt.

Tw

enty

-eig

ht m

embe

rs o

f the

Virg

inia

bar

, in

clud

ing

The

Hon

orab

le Ja

mes

R. S

penc

er, C

hief

Dis

trict

Cou

rt Ju

dge,

Eas

tern

Dis

trict

of V

irgin

ia, w

ere

swor

n in

as m

embe

rs o

f the

bar

of t

he U

.S. S

upre

me

Cou

rt. T

he lu

nche

on a

nd sw

earin

g-in

cer

emon

y w

ere

held

at t

he B

ull &

Bea

r Clu

b in

Ric

hmon

d, V

irgin

ia. I

n ad

ditio

n to

the

swea

ring-

in c

erem

ony,

the

fifty

at

tend

ees a

t thi

s eve

nt e

njoy

ed re

mar

ks fr

om C

hief

Judg

e Sp

ence

r reg

ardi

ng th

e "S

tate

of t

he E

aste

rn

Dis

trict

of V

irgin

ia, R

ichm

ond

Div

isio

n,"

and

Gen

eral

Sut

er re

gard

ing

the

hist

ory

of th

e U

.S. S

upre

me

Cou

rt. A

dis

coun

ted

rate

was

off

ered

to F

BA

mem

bers

who

atte

nded

the

lunc

heon

por

tion

of th

is e

vent

. �

On

June

1,2

010,

the

Ric

hmon

d C

hapt

er sp

onso

red

a 2.

0 ho

ur C

LE p

rogr

am e

ntitl

ed "

The

Ethi

cs o

f Pre

trial

D

isco

very

." T

he sp

eake

rs fo

r the

pro

gram

wer

e Th

e H

onor

able

Hen

ry E

. Hud

son,

Dis

trict

Judg

e, E

aste

rn

Dis

trict

of V

irgin

ia, a

nd T

hom

as E

. Spa

hn, E

sq. a

Par

tner

with

McG

uire

Woo

ds, L

LP. T

he p

rogr

am w

as

held

at H

unto

n &

Will

iam

s, LL

P's o

ffic

es in

Ric

hmon

d, V

irgin

ia a

nd w

as a

ttend

ed b

y ap

prox

imat

ely

seve

nty-

five

mem

bers

of t

he R

ichm

ond

bar.

This

inte

ract

ive

CLE

pro

gram

use

d hy

poth

etic

als t

o ad

dres

s to

pics

of i

nter

est t

o lit

igat

ors,

focu

sing

on

the

ethi

cs o

f pre

trial

dis

cove

ry a

nd w

as a

ppro

ved

by th

e V

irgin

ia

Stat

e B

ar fo

r 2.0

hou

rs o

f CLE

eth

ics c

redi

t. A

dis

coun

ted

rate

was

off

ered

to F

BA

mem

bers

who

atte

nded

th

is p

rogr

am.

�O

n Se

ptem

ber 2

9, 2

010,

the

Ric

hmon

d C

hapt

er sp

onso

red

a 2.

0 ho

ur C

LE p

rogr

am e

ntitl

ed "

Proc

edur

al

Issu

es in

Civ

il Li

tigat

ion

in th

e R

ichm

ond

Div

isio

n of

the

Roc

ket D

ocke

t" T

he sp

eake

rs fo

r the

pro

gram

w

ere

The

Hon

orab

le R

ober

t E. P

ayne

, Dis

trict

Judg

e, E

aste

rn D

istri

ct o

f Virg

inia

, Dav

id N

. Ant

hony

, Esq

., a

partn

er w

ith T

rout

man

San

ders

LLP

, and

May

a M

. Eck

stei

n, a

par

tner

with

Hun

ton

& W

illia

ms,

LLP.

Page 6: Final CVP Chapter Activities Report for 2010 · : E-Discovery Seminar on November 10, 2010; Bankruptcy seminar on December 2, 2010; and a “brown bag” lunch on ethical issues &

Vic

e Pr

esid

ents

for t

he C

ircui

ts 2

010

Cha

pter

Eve

nts R

epor

t Ja

nuar

y 14

, 201

1

6

CIR

CU

ITC

HA

PTE

RE

VE

NT

S

The

prog

ram

was

hel

d in

the

Jury

Ass

embl

y R

oom

of t

he S

pots

woo

d W

. Rob

inso

n II

I & R

ober

t R.

Mer

hige

, Jr.,

Cou

rthou

se in

Ric

hmon

d, V

irgin

ia a

nd w

as a

ttend

ed b

y ap

prox

imat

ely

fifty

mem

bers

of t

he

Ric

hmon

d ba

r. Th

e pr

ogra

m d

iscu

ssed

a v

arie

ty o

f com

mon

pro

cedu

ral i

ssue

s tha

t aris

e in

civ

il lit

igat

ion

in

the

Ric

hmon

d D

ivis

ion

of th

e U

nite

d St

ates

Dis

trict

Cou

rt fo

r the

Eas

tern

Dis

trict

of V

irgin

ia a

nd w

as

appr

oved

by

the

Virg

inia

Sta

te B

ar fo

r 2.0

hou

rs o

f CLE

cre

dit.

A d

isco

unte

d ra

te w

as o

ffer

ed to

FB

A

mem

bers

who

atte

nded

this

pro

gram

.

Sout

h C

arol

ina

�L

aw S

tude

nt D

ivis

ions

: Thi

s yea

r the

Cha

pter

star

ted

a ca

mpa

ign

to c

reat

e a

stud

ent d

ivis

ion

of th

e FB

A

at b

oth

law

scho

ols w

ithin

the

stat

e (U

nive

rsity

of S

outh

Car

olin

a &

Cha

rlest

on S

choo

l of L

aw).

Boa

rd

mem

bers

hav

e he

ld m

eetin

gs w

ith b

oth

scho

ols’

adm

inis

tratio

ns to

pre

pare

for e

stab

lishi

ng th

e di

visi

ons.

In

addi

tion,

boa

rd m

embe

rs h

eld

a pi

zza

lunc

h pr

esen

tatio

n at

the

law

scho

ols t

o in

form

the

stud

ent b

ody

abou

t the

FB

A, a

nd h

ow th

e st

uden

t div

isio

n w

ill b

e in

volv

ed in

the

Sout

h C

arol

ina

Cha

pter

’s

activ

ities

. The

Cha

pter

has

pla

ns to

fina

lize

the

crea

tion

of th

e st

uden

t div

isio

ns b

y cr

eatin

g tw

o ne

w n

on-

votin

g bo

ard

mem

bers

to se

rve

as re

pres

enta

tives

of t

he st

uden

t div

isio

n m

embe

rs fr

om e

ach

law

scho

ol.

The

stud

ent d

ivis

ion

will

dev

elop

new

mem

bers

hip

for t

he C

hapt

er a

nd b

uild

aw

aren

ess o

f the

FB

A in

So

uth

Car

olin

a.

�20

10 E

thic

s CL

E a

nd A

nnua

l Mee

ting:

Thi

s is a

n an

nual

CLE

and

is h

oste

d, o

n an

alte

rnat

ing

basi

s, in

on

e of

the

thre

e di

stin

ctiv

e ar

eas o

f Sou

th C

arol

ina.

In 2

010,

this

pro

gram

was

hel

d at

the

SC S

tate

M

useu

m in

Col

umbi

a, S

C o

n Se

ptem

ber 9

, 201

0. T

his p

rogr

am is

des

igne

d as

a h

alf-

day

educ

atio

nal

prog

ram

that

pro

vide

s the

SC

mem

bers

hip

with

ofte

n ha

rd-to

-get

eth

ics C

LE c

redi

t. W

e op

en th

is e

vent

up

to b

oth

mem

bers

and

non

-mem

bers

. Th

is a

llow

s us t

o sh

ow n

on-m

embe

rs w

hat t

he S

C C

hapt

er d

oes a

nd

how

mem

bers

hip

can

bene

fit th

eir p

ract

ice.

At t

he e

nd o

f the

day

, we

hold

the

Ann

ual M

eetin

g w

hen

we

swea

r in

the

offic

ers f

or th

e ne

xt te

rm.

Afte

r the

Ann

ual M

eetin

g, th

ere

is a

rece

ptio

n in

hon

or o

f our

Fe

dera

l Jud

icia

ry.

The

rece

ptio

n in

201

0 ho

nore

d C

hief

Judg

e of

the

4th C

ircui

t Cou

rt of

App

eals

, Will

iam

Tr

axle

r.�

Nat

iona

l Boa

rd R

ecep

tion:

In Ja

nuar

y 20

10, t

he c

hapt

er sp

onso

red

a R

ecep

tion

for t

he F

BA

nat

iona

l bo

ard

of d

irect

ors w

ho w

ere

visi

ting

Cha

rlest

on, S

C fo

r boa

rd m

eetin

g.

�Fe

dera

l Mar

shal

s Lun

ch: I

n Ja

nuar

y 20

10, t

he c

hapt

er sp

onso

red

a pi

zza

lunc

h ho

norin

g an

d th

anki

ng

the

Fede

ral M

arsh

als a

nd C

ourt

Secu

rity

Off

icer

s at

four

fede

ral c

ourth

ouse

s sta

tew

ide,

and

invi

ted

all

cour

thou

se a

nd c

lerk

’s o

ffic

e st

aff.

We

held

the

even

t on

the

anni

vers

ary

of th

e FB

A.

Fede

ral M

arsh

als

and

Cou

rt Se

curit

y O

ffic

ers a

re ra

rely

reco

gniz

ed, a

nd th

e co

urt a

nd se

vera

l jud

ges w

ere

thril

led

to se

e us

re

cogn

ize

thos

e w

ho m

ake

the

cour

thou

se ru

n on

a d

aily

bas

is a

nd k

eep

us a

ll sa

fe.

�Su

mm

er L

aw C

lerk

Sem

inar

s: E

ach

sum

mer

the

chap

ter h

olds

3 se

min

ars a

imed

at i

ntro

duci

ng su

mm

er

law

cle

rks a

roun

d th

e st

ate

to th

e fe

dera

l cou

rthou

ses,

judi

ciar

y, a

nd st

aff.

The

half-

day

sem

inar

incl

udes

va

rious

spea

kers

, a to

ur o

f the

faci

litie

s (in

clud

ing

a “b

ehin

d-th

e-sc

enes

” po

rtion

), lu

nch

with

som

e of

the

Page 7: Final CVP Chapter Activities Report for 2010 · : E-Discovery Seminar on November 10, 2010; Bankruptcy seminar on December 2, 2010; and a “brown bag” lunch on ethical issues &

Vic

e Pr

esid

ents

for t

he C

ircui

ts 2

010

Cha

pter

Eve

nts R

epor

t Ja

nuar

y 14

, 201

1

7

CIR

CU

ITC

HA

PTE

RE

VE

NT

S

resi

dent

judg

es, a

nd st

uden

t mem

bers

hip

to th

e SC

Cha

pter

. Th

is h

as b

een

a ve

ry su

cces

sful

pro

gram

for

man

y ye

ars.

W

este

rn D

istri

ct o

f N

orth

Car

olin

a �

The

char

ter f

or th

e W

DN

C C

hapt

er w

as g

rant

ed in

the

fall

of 2

009

and

pres

ente

d at

the

Ann

ual M

eetin

g in

O

klah

oma

City

. �

In e

arly

201

0, th

e ch

apte

r hel

d tw

o re

cept

ions

to sp

read

wor

d of

the

new

cha

pter

and

enc

oura

ge

mem

bers

hip.

As t

he D

istri

ct e

ncom

pass

es ro

ughl

y th

e w

este

rn 1

/3 o

f NC

, we

held

one

rece

ptio

n in

A

shev

ille

and

the

othe

r in

Cha

rlotte

.�

The

Cha

pter

hel

d tw

o ha

lf-da

y C

LE e

vent

s. Th

e fir

st to

ok p

lace

in A

shev

ille

and

focu

sed

on c

ivil

prac

tice

in th

e D

istri

ct. T

he p

rogr

am in

clud

ed a

pan

el o

f our

Mag

istra

te Ju

dges

and

pre

sent

atio

ns b

y va

rious

law

cl

erks

, priv

ate

atto

rney

s, an

d ou

r Cle

rk o

f Cou

rt.

�Th

e se

cond

CLE

took

pla

ce in

Cha

rlotte

this

pas

t Nov

embe

r and

cen

tere

d on

crim

inal

pra

ctic

e. T

hat

prog

ram

was

led

by a

pan

el o

f our

Dis

trict

Judg

es (m

oder

ated

by

our f

eder

al d

efen

der)

, fol

low

ed b

y a

pane

l of

our

Mag

istra

te Ju

dges

(mod

erat

ed b

y ou

r US

Atto

rney

), an

d la

ter b

y pr

esen

tatio

ns fr

om la

w c

lerk

s, A

USA

s, an

d as

sist

ant d

efen

ders

.5th

Circ

uit

San

Ant

onio

, Tex

as

Cha

pter

�R

ecog

nize

d Fo

x Te

ch st

uden

ts w

ho p

artic

ipat

ed in

the

FBA

's U

TSA

pro

gram

dur

ing

the

Cha

pter

’s

lunc

heon

.�

Men

tors

hip

prog

ram

with

St.

Mar

y’s.

El

Pas

o, T

exas

C

hapt

er�

Jan.

'10

- Bro

wn

Bag

Sem

inar

: CM

/EC

F W

orks

hop

& F

eder

al R

ules

Upd

ate.

Gue

st sp

eake

rs in

clud

ed

repr

esen

tativ

es fr

om th

e C

lerk

's O

ffic

e, a

nd C

ara

Rod

rigue

z an

d K

ristin

Con

nor,

both

law

cle

rks f

or U

.S.

Dis

trict

Judg

e D

avid

Brio

nes.

�Ja

n. '1

0 - F

BA

spon

sore

d an

d fa

cilit

ated

for t

he in

vest

iture

cer

emon

y fo

r U.S

. Mag

istra

te Ju

dge

Mar

gare

t Le

achm

an

�Fe

b.'1

0 - B

row

n B

ag S

emin

ar: M

edia

tion,

a P

anel

Dis

cuss

ion.

Gue

st sp

eake

rs, U

.S. M

agis

trate

Judg

e N

orbe

rt J.

Gar

ney,

and

atto

rney

s Mar

kBrig

gs, a

nd R

eed

Leve

rton.

Pro

vide

d 1

hour

of C

LE

�M

ar.'1

0 - F

eder

al C

ourt

Prac

tice

Sem

inar

, 4 h

ours

of C

LE, G

uest

spea

kers

incl

uded

judg

es, a

nd

gove

rnm

ent a

nd p

rivat

e pr

actit

ione

rs

�A

pr.'1

0- C

o-sp

onso

red

with

the

Fede

ral P

ublic

Def

ende

rs a

CJA

Tra

inin

g Pr

ogra

m

�M

ay 1

0 - B

row

n B

ag S

emin

ar: "

Imm

igra

tion

in th

e W

orkp

lace

, an

Ove

rvie

w a

nd U

pdat

es o

n Em

ploy

men

t El

igib

ility

Ver

ifica

tion

and

Ant

i-Dis

crim

inat

ion

Prov

isio

ns u

nder

the

INA

." T

he g

uest

spea

ker w

as

Anj

anet

te H

amilt

on, a

n at

torn

ey w

ith th

e Te

xas R

ioG

rand

e Le

gal A

id, I

nc.

�M

ay'1

0 - C

o-sp

onso

red

lunc

heon

with

the

El P

aso

Bar

Ass

ocia

tion

at th

e Ft

. Blis

s Cen

tenn

ial C

lub.

Gue

st

spea

ker,

CO

L. M

icha

el B

enja

min

pre

sent

ed "

How

the

Uni

form

Cod

e of

Mili

tary

Just

ice

Diff

ers f

rom

the

Civ

ilian

Just

ice

Syst

em."

The

eve

nt in

clud

ed a

n op

tiona

l bus

tour

of t

he b

ase

Page 8: Final CVP Chapter Activities Report for 2010 · : E-Discovery Seminar on November 10, 2010; Bankruptcy seminar on December 2, 2010; and a “brown bag” lunch on ethical issues &

Vic

e Pr

esid

ents

for t

he C

ircui

ts 2

010

Cha

pter

Eve

nts R

epor

t Ja

nuar

y 14

, 201

1

8

CIR

CU

ITC

HA

PTE

RE

VE

NT

S

�Ju

ne'1

0 - L

unch

eon

Sem

inar

: "Im

mig

ratio

n C

onse

quen

ces o

f Cer

tain

Fel

ony

Off

ense

s." G

uest

spea

ker:

Car

los S

pect

or, i

mm

igra

tion

atto

rney

June

'10

- Int

rodu

ctio

n to

Fed

eral

Cou

rt Pr

actic

e, fo

r Sum

mer

Inte

rns a

nd N

ew A

ssoc

iate

s. Th

is p

rogr

am

incl

uded

"co

urt w

atch

" op

portu

nitie

s in

the

mor

ning

, and

subs

tant

ive

lect

ures

and

pan

el d

iscu

ssio

ns b

y ju

dges

and

atto

rney

s in

the

afte

rnoo

n, a

s wel

l as a

beh

ind

the

scen

es a

nd h

isto

rical

cou

rthou

se to

ur

�Ju

ly'1

0 - C

o-sp

onso

red

with

the

El P

aso

Bar

Ass

ocia

tion

and

El P

aso

Mus

eum

of A

rt a

prog

ram

for E

l Pas

o La

wye

rs o

f the

Arts

. The

gue

st sp

eake

r was

Ser

gio

Mun

oz S

arm

ient

o, a

n at

torn

ey a

t law

. The

pro

gram

was

he

ld a

t the

El P

aso

Mus

eum

of A

rt an

d in

clud

ed p

rese

ntat

ions

on

inte

llect

ual p

rope

rty la

w a

nd c

opyr

ight

Sept

. '10

- B

row

n B

ag lu

nche

on w

ith d

eleg

atio

n of

Col

ombi

an p

rose

cuto

rs a

nd ju

dges

that

cov

ered

the

rule

of

law

pro

ject

that

is ta

king

pla

ce u

nder

DoJ

's Pl

an C

olom

bia

�Se

pt. '

10 -

spon

sore

d re

cept

ion

for t

he n

amin

g of

the

new

, Alb

ert A

rmen

dariz

, Sr.,

U.S

. Cou

rthou

se in

El

Paso

, TX

Oct

. '10

- FB

A sp

onso

red

and

faci

litat

ed fo

r the

inve

stitu

re c

erem

ony

for U

.S. M

agis

trate

Judg

e D

avid

G

uade

rram

a �

Oct

. '10

- FB

A B

row

n B

ag lu

nche

on w

ith g

uest

spea

ker U

.S. M

agis

trate

Judg

e R

icha

rd M

esa

disc

ussi

ng

CJA

pan

el a

ppoi

ntm

ents

and

pra

ctic

e �

Nov

. '10

- FB

A B

row

n B

ag lu

nche

on w

ith g

uest

spea

ker w

ith p

erso

nnel

from

Wes

tern

Dis

trict

of T

exas

to

disc

uss c

ourt

room

tech

nolo

gy b

eing

use

d in

new

cou

rthou

se.

�D

ec. '

10 -

FBA

-El P

aso

Cha

pter

was

co-

spon

sor o

f Joi

nt H

olid

ay p

arty

that

was

wel

l atte

nded

by

mem

bers

of

num

erou

s loc

al b

ar a

ssoc

iatio

ns.

Aus

tin/S

outh

ern

Dis

trict

of T

exas

C

hapt

er

�A

pril

201

0 - S

outh

Tex

as fe

dera

l pra

ctic

e C

LE (2

day

s) h

eld

in M

cAlle

n, T

X. W

idel

y at

tend

ed (4

0+) n

ew

even

t with

spea

kers

incl

udin

g C

hief

Judg

e Jo

nes (

5th

Circ

uit).

NEW

EV

ENT.

June

201

0 - r

ecep

tion

hono

ring

ten

(10)

Bla

sk F

ello

ws (

inte

rns w

ith ju

dges

and

U.S

. Atto

rney

who

wer

e pa

id $

2,00

0 st

ipen

ds b

y ou

r cha

pter

) at B

aker

& B

otts

. Num

erou

s mem

bers

of t

he ju

dici

ary

atte

nded

. NEW

EV

ENT.

�O

ctob

er 2

010

- Ann

ual d

inne

r hon

orin

g th

e ju

dici

ary

and

spec

ial h

onor

ee Ju

dge

John

Rai

ney.

Ove

r 30

0 pe

ople

atte

nded

inc

ludi

ng a

reco

rd n

umbe

r of f

eder

al ju

dges

. Key

not

e sp

eake

r was

Judg

e D

iane

Woo

d (7

th C

ircui

t).

New

Orle

ans,

Loui

sian

a C

hapt

er

�20

10 N

atio

nal M

eetin

g an

d C

onve

ntio

n

La

faye

tte/A

cadi

, Lo

uisi

ana

Cha

pter

The

Lafa

yette

/Aca

dian

a C

hapt

er sp

onso

red

the

FBA

's A

nnua

l Con

vent

ion

by u

nder

writ

ing

the

atte

ndan

ce

of L

ouis

iana

law

scho

ol st

uden

ts.

Page 9: Final CVP Chapter Activities Report for 2010 · : E-Discovery Seminar on November 10, 2010; Bankruptcy seminar on December 2, 2010; and a “brown bag” lunch on ethical issues &

Vic

e Pr

esid

ents

for t

he C

ircui

ts 2

010

Cha

pter

Eve

nts R

epor

t Ja

nuar

y 14

, 201

1

9

CIR

CU

ITC

HA

PTE

RE

VE

NT

S

Nor

th L

ouis

iana

C

hapt

er�

On

Dec

embe

r 2, 2

010,

the

Nor

th L

ouis

iana

Cha

pter

of t

he F

eder

al B

ar A

ssoc

iatio

n he

ld it

s ann

ual

intro

duct

ion

to th

e co

urt a

nd sw

earin

g in

cer

emon

y. A

t thi

s cer

emon

y, la

wye

rs h

ad th

e op

portu

nity

to b

e fo

rmal

ly in

trodu

ced

to th

e ju

dges

of t

he W

este

rn D

istri

ct o

f Lou

isia

na a

nd g

et sw

orn

into

the

Dis

trict

C

ourts

for t

he W

este

rn, E

aste

rn, a

nd M

iddl

e D

istri

cts o

f Lou

isia

na, a

s wel

l as t

he U

nite

d St

ates

Fift

h C

ircui

t. A

rece

ptio

n w

as h

eld

afte

r the

cer

emon

y.6th

Circ

uit

Nor

ther

n D

istri

ct o

f O

hio

Cha

pter

Net

wor

king

Eve

nt (J

anua

ry 1

4, 2

010)

: A

con

tinua

tion

of a

qua

rterly

“M

embe

rs O

nly”

serie

s whe

re

Cha

pter

mem

bers

(gen

eral

ly li

mite

d to

the

first

20

to re

spon

d) m

eet a

t an

early

bre

akfa

st m

eetin

g at

the

host

mem

ber’

s off

ices

to d

iscu

ss th

eir p

ract

ices

, int

eres

ts, a

nd n

etw

orki

ng a

mon

g C

hapt

er m

embe

r at

tend

ees.

�In

trod

uctio

n to

Fed

eral

Cou

rt P

ract

ice

Sem

inar

(Jan

uary

22,

201

0):

An

annu

al “

first

of t

he y

ear”

CLE

pr

ogra

m in

trodu

cing

atte

ndee

s to

vario

us a

spec

ts o

f fed

eral

pra

ctic

e, th

e w

orki

ngs o

f the

Uni

ted

Stat

es

Dis

trict

Cou

rt fo

r the

Nor

ther

n D

istri

ct o

f Ohi

o, e

lect

roni

c fil

ing,

use

of e

lect

roni

c co

urtro

oms,

diff

eren

tiate

d ca

se m

anag

emen

t pla

nnin

g, a

nd o

ther

are

as p

ertin

ent t

o pr

actic

e in

the

Nor

ther

n D

istri

ct o

f O

hio.

Thi

s pro

gram

is o

ffer

ed to

allo

w a

ttorn

eys t

o sa

tisfy

the

Nor

ther

n D

istri

ct o

f Ohi

o’s r

equi

red

train

ing

for a

dmis

sion

to p

ract

ice

in th

e di

stric

t. T

he p

rogr

am c

oncl

udes

with

a sw

earin

g-in

cer

emon

y.

�In

telle

ctua

l Pro

pert

y: In

sura

nce

Cov

erag

e &

Liti

gatio

n St

rate

gies

Sem

inar

(Feb

ruar

y 18

, 201

0):

CLE

pro

gram

focu

sed

on th

e is

sues

invo

lved

in in

telle

ctua

l pro

perty

insu

ranc

e co

vera

ge, “

best

pra

ctic

es”

for e

ntiti

es w

ith si

gnifi

cant

inte

llect

ual p

rope

rty in

tere

sts a

nd a

ttorn

eys e

ngag

ed in

adv

isin

g su

ch e

ntiti

es,

and

litig

atio

n is

sues

invo

lved

in h

andl

ing

inte

llect

ual p

rope

rty m

atte

rs.

New

Law

yer

Tra

inin

g Se

min

ar: W

hat T

hey

Did

n't T

each

You

in L

aw S

choo

l (M

arch

26,

201

0):

The

first

in a

CLE

Pro

gram

serie

s, of

fere

d an

nual

ly si

nce

2009

, to

allo

w n

ewly

-adm

itted

atto

rney

s to

the

Ohi

o ba

r to

satis

fy re

quire

men

ts in

stitu

ted

by th

e Su

prem

e C

ourt

of O

hio

in Ja

nuar

y 20

09 th

at a

ttorn

eys i

n th

eir

first

yea

r of p

ract

ice

satis

fy “

New

Law

yer T

rain

ing”

edu

catio

n ei

ther

thro

ugh

a 12

-hou

r pro

gram

of C

LE

educ

atio

n or

thro

ugh

a m

ento

rshi

p tra

inin

g pr

ogra

m (s

uppl

emen

ted

by c

erta

in in

depe

nden

t CLE

pro

gram

-on

ly re

quire

men

ts re

latin

g to

law

off

ice

man

agem

ent a

nd e

thic

al c

lient

fund

han

dlin

g, w

hich

the

Cha

pter

of

fers

in th

e se

cond

of i

ts “

New

Law

yer T

rain

ing”

serie

s).

This

pro

gram

intro

duce

s new

law

yers

to th

ose

aspe

cts o

f “w

hat t

hey

didn

’t te

ach

you

in la

w sc

hool

,” su

ch a

s pra

ctic

al d

ay-to

-day

tips

in st

artin

g in

a n

ew

solo

, sm

all-f

irm, a

nd la

rge-

firm

pra

ctic

e, w

orki

ng w

ith o

ther

atto

rney

s (bo

th c

olle

ague

and

opp

osin

g co

unse

l), h

andl

ing

dead

lines

and

wor

k ba

lanc

e, a

nd e

stab

lishi

ng a

goo

d re

puta

tion

with

the

cour

ts a

nd le

gal

com

mun

ity.

�N

ew L

awye

r T

rain

ing

Sem

inar

: Pro

fess

iona

lism

, Law

Off

ice

Man

agem

ent &

Clie

nt F

unds

M

anag

emen

t (M

ay 7

, 201

0):

The

seco

nd in

the

“New

Law

yer T

rain

ing”

pro

gram

serie

s, w

hich

incl

udes

th

ose

subj

ects

that

are

requ

ired

to b

e ga

ined

thro

ugh

inde

pend

ent C

LE p

rogr

am e

duca

tion

for b

oth

new

at

torn

eys f

ollo

win

g th

e “C

LE tr

ack”

and

thos

e ad

optin

g th

e “M

ento

rshi

p tra

ck”

in sa

tisfa

ctio

n of

Ohi

o’s

Page 10: Final CVP Chapter Activities Report for 2010 · : E-Discovery Seminar on November 10, 2010; Bankruptcy seminar on December 2, 2010; and a “brown bag” lunch on ethical issues &

Vic

e Pr

esid

ents

for t

he C

ircui

ts 2

010

Cha

pter

Eve

nts R

epor

t Ja

nuar

y 14

, 201

1

10

CIR

CU

ITC

HA

PTE

RE

VE

NT

S

NLT

trai

ning

requ

irem

ent.

A T

ribu

te to

Jud

ges C

erem

ony

(May

25,

201

0):

This

firs

t tim

e ev

ent h

onor

ed U

nite

d St

ates

Chi

ef

Dis

trict

Judg

e Ja

mes

Car

r upo

n hi

s ass

umin

g Se

nior

Sta

tus,

and

hono

red

retir

ing

Mag

istra

te Ju

dges

Jam

es

Gal

las a

nd D

avid

Per

elm

an, r

ecog

nizi

ng e

ach

of th

ese

judi

cial

off

icer

s’ lo

ngtim

e de

dica

ted

serv

ice

to th

e N

orth

ern

Dis

trict

of O

hio

cour

t. �

Bro

wn

Bag

Lun

cheo

n w

ith S

ixth

Cir

cuit

Judg

e D

ebor

ah C

ook

and

Dis

tric

t Cou

rt J

udge

Sar

a L

ioi

(Jun

e 21

, 201

0):

A c

ontin

uing

inst

allm

ent i

n th

e C

hapt

er’s

mor

e-th

an-a

-dec

ade-

long

“B

row

n B

ag

Lunc

heon

” se

ries w

here

atte

ndee

s gat

her f

or a

lunc

htim

e pr

ogra

m fe

atur

ing

one

(or m

ore)

of t

he N

orth

ern

Dis

trict

of O

hio

resi

dent

dis

trict

, mag

istra

te, b

ankr

uptc

y, o

r circ

uit j

udge

s, co

urt o

ffic

ers (

U.S

. Atto

rney

, Fe

dera

l Pub

lic D

efen

der,

U.S

. Tru

stee

, etc

.), o

r cou

rt st

aff (

Cle

rk o

f Cou

rt, c

aree

r law

cle

rks,

etc.

), be

ginn

ing

with

an

info

rmal

lunc

h in

one

of t

he d

istri

ct c

ourtr

oom

s, fo

llow

ed b

y a

brie

f pre

sent

atio

n by

the

feat

ured

spea

ker,

then

cul

min

atin

g in

a w

ide-

rang

ing

ques

tion

and

answ

er se

ssio

n w

ith th

e fe

atur

ed

spea

ker(

s).

�R

ecep

tion

Hon

orin

g N

ew C

hief

Jud

ge S

olom

on O

liver

, Jr.

(Jun

e 25

, 201

0):

Even

t at t

he fe

dera

l co

urth

ouse

hon

orin

g th

e in

stal

latio

n of

Chi

ef Ju

dge

Solo

mon

Oliv

er, J

r., a

s new

Chi

ef Ju

dge

of th

e N

orth

ern

Dis

trict

of O

hio

cour

t.�

Bro

wn

Bag

Lun

cheo

n w

ith M

agis

trat

e Ju

dge

Geo

rge

Lim

bert

(Jul

y 15

, 201

0):

A c

ontin

uing

in

stal

lmen

t of t

he C

hapt

er’s

“B

row

n B

ag L

unch

eon”

serie

s, th

is o

ne h

eld

at th

e Y

oung

stow

n, O

hio

cour

thou

se, f

ocus

ed o

n th

e C

hapt

er’s

eff

orts

to in

crea

se p

artic

ipat

ion

in C

hapt

er a

ffili

atio

n in

the

Mah

onin

g C

ount

y (Y

oung

stow

n) le

gal c

omm

unity

.

�Su

mm

er A

ssoc

iate

Rec

eptio

n (J

uly

21, 2

010)

: C

ontin

uing

a tr

aditi

on h

eld

for m

any

year

s, th

e C

hapt

er

host

ed a

rece

ptio

n at

the

Cle

vela

nd “

Hou

se o

f Blu

es”

invi

ting

Nor

ther

n D

istri

ct o

f Ohi

o la

w st

uden

ts,

sum

mer

cle

rks,

law

cle

rks,

and

exte

rns t

o th

is S

umm

er e

vent

. A

ttend

ance

incl

uded

atte

ndee

s fro

m

thro

ugho

ut th

e di

stric

t, in

clud

ing

Cle

vela

nd, A

kron

, You

ngst

own,

and

Tol

edo.

New

Law

yer

Tra

inin

g Se

min

ar: S

tand

ing

Up

in C

ourt

(Jul

y 23

, 201

0):

The

third

in th

e C

hapt

er’s

“N

ew L

awye

r Tra

inin

g” se

ries,

focu

sing

on

issu

es re

latin

g to

in-c

ourt

prac

tice

help

ful t

o ne

wly

-adm

itted

at

torn

eys.

Mus

ic, L

aw a

nd F

rien

ds a

t Sev

eran

ce H

all (

Aug

ust 5

, 201

0):

A fr

ee “

Mem

bers

Onl

y” e

vent

(inc

ludi

ng

spou

se, f

amily

, and

gue

sts)

, fea

turin

g a

guid

ed b

acks

tage

tour

of S

ever

ance

Hal

l, th

e ho

me

of th

e w

orld

-re

now

ned

Cle

vela

nd O

rche

stra

, and

pre

sent

atio

ns (w

ith th

e at

tend

ees s

eate

d on

stag

e) in

clud

ing

the

hist

ory

of S

ever

ance

Hal

l and

a d

iscu

ssio

n of

mus

ic c

opyr

ight

law

by

loca

l atto

rney

and

form

er m

embe

r of t

he

mus

ic g

roup

"W

ild C

herr

y" (“

Play

Tha

t Fun

ky M

usic

Whi

te B

oy”)

. �

Iron

Law

yer

Com

petit

ion

II (A

ugus

t 13,

201

0):

A tw

o-ye

ar ru

nnin

g C

LE p

rogr

am fe

atur

ing,

this

yea

r fe

atur

ing

clos

ing

stat

emen

ts fr

om p

rom

inen

t tria

l law

yers

and

a p

anel

of j

udge

s.

Page 11: Final CVP Chapter Activities Report for 2010 · : E-Discovery Seminar on November 10, 2010; Bankruptcy seminar on December 2, 2010; and a “brown bag” lunch on ethical issues &

Vic

e Pr

esid

ents

for t

he C

ircui

ts 2

010

Cha

pter

Eve

nts R

epor

t Ja

nuar

y 14

, 201

1

11

CIR

CU

ITC

HA

PTE

RE

VE

NT

S

�St

ate

of th

e C

ourt

Lun

cheo

n, F

eatu

ring

Chi

ef J

udge

Oliv

er, a

nd C

hief

Ban

krup

tcy

Judg

e Sh

ea-

Ston

um (S

epte

mbe

r 13

, 201

0):

A c

ontin

uing

eve

nt o

f the

Cha

pter

, whi

ch g

athe

rs m

ore

than

500

m

embe

rs o

f the

lega

l com

mun

ity e

ach

year

.

�N

ew L

awye

r T

rain

ing

Sem

inar

: A W

hole

Tri

al in

3 H

ours

(Sep

tem

ber

17, 2

010)

: Th

e fo

urth

of t

he

CLE

inst

allm

ents

put

on

by th

e C

hapt

er to

allo

w n

ew O

hio

atto

rney

s to

fulfi

ll th

eir “

New

Law

yer

Trai

ning

” re

quire

men

ts.

As i

ndic

ated

by

the

title

, thi

s pro

gram

pre

sent

s a “

full

trial

” in

an

abbr

evia

ted

form

at, w

ith d

iscu

ssio

n af

terw

ard

on e

ach

of th

e el

emen

ts fo

r the

ben

efit

of th

ose

new

to th

e tri

al

expe

rienc

e to

lear

n fr

om se

ason

ed p

ract

ition

ers.

�In

stal

latio

n of

Cha

pter

Pre

side

nt, O

ffic

ers,

and

Boa

rd (O

ctob

er 1

3, 2

010)

: R

ecep

tion

held

at t

he

fede

ral c

ourth

ouse

for t

he in

stal

latio

n of

new

Cha

pter

off

icer

s. �

Dis

cove

ry R

efor

m: C

omin

g to

a C

ourt

hous

e N

ear

You

Sem

inar

(Oct

ober

14,

201

0): C

LE p

rogr

am

feat

urin

g U

nite

d St

ates

Dis

trict

Judg

e Ja

ck Z

ouha

ry, o

n di

scov

ery

refo

rm p

ropo

sed

by th

e A

mer

ican

C

olle

ge o

f Tria

l Law

yers

(AC

TL) a

nd th

e In

stitu

te fo

r the

Adv

ance

men

t of t

he A

mer

ican

Leg

al S

yste

m

(IA

ALS

).

CL

E S

emin

ar V

ideo

Rep

lay

Wee

k, C

leve

land

(Dec

embe

r 6-

10, 2

010)

: A

s an

acco

mm

odat

ion

to th

ose

who

nee

d bi

-ann

ual C

LE c

redi

t for

Sup

rem

e C

ourt

of O

hio

repo

rting

requ

irem

ents

, the

Cha

pter

vid

eota

pes

its C

LE p

rogr

ams f

or a

vid

eo re

play

that

can

be

atte

nded

for C

LE a

ccre

dita

tion

to m

eet s

tate

requ

irem

ents

(a

t eac

h re

play

, a li

ve “

proc

tor”

to a

nsw

er q

uest

ions

mus

t be

in a

ttend

ance

, ful

fille

d by

a C

hapt

er B

oard

m

embe

r).

�B

row

n B

ag L

unch

eon

with

Six

th C

ircu

it Ju

dges

Ket

hled

ge a

nd W

hite

(Dec

embe

r 13

, 201

0):

A jo

int

prog

ram

with

FB

A-N

DO

C a

nd T

oled

o B

ar A

ssoc

iatio

n Lu

nche

on, T

oled

o, w

ith S

ixth

Circ

uit U

nite

d St

ates

C

ircui

t Jud

ges R

aym

ond

Ket

hled

ge a

nd H

elen

e W

hite

.A

New

Tak

e on

Thr

ee (O

ld) T

opic

s, C

leve

land

(Dec

embe

r 17

, 201

0):

The

Cha

pter

’s a

nnua

l Pr

ofes

sion

alis

m, E

thic

s & S

ubst

ance

Abu

se se

min

ar (r

equi

red

by th

e Su

prem

e C

ourt

of O

hio

in e

ach

bien

nial

repo

rting

per

iod)

. W

hile

this

pro

gram

is o

pen

to a

ll (a

nd w

ell a

ttend

ed b

y al

l), it

is o

ffer

ed fr

ee to

FB

A-N

DO

C m

embe

rs.

Ea

ster

n D

istri

ct o

f M

ichi

gan

Cha

pter

App

ella

te D

o’s a

nd D

on’t

s: A

Pan

el D

iscu

ssio

n by

the

Peop

le W

ho K

now

(Jan

uary

7, 2

010)

: Th

is

prog

ram

was

join

tly sp

onso

red

by th

e C

hapt

er’s

App

ella

te P

ract

ice

and

Fede

ral L

aw C

lerk

Com

mitt

ees.

Th

e pa

nel f

eatu

red

Seni

or C

ircui

t Jud

ge R

icha

rd S

uhrh

einr

ich,

Circ

uit J

udge

Dav

id W

. McK

eagu

e, C

ircui

t Ju

dge

Ray

mon

d M

. Ket

hled

ge, a

nd C

ircui

t Jud

ge H

elen

e N

. Whi

te, e

ach

of th

e U

nite

d St

ates

Cou

rt of

A

ppea

ls fo

r the

Six

th C

ircui

t, an

d M

olly

Ham

ilton

, Car

eer C

lerk

to Ju

dge

Suhr

hein

rich.

The

pro

gram

was

m

oder

ated

by

Sara

h R

esni

ck C

ohen

, Ass

ista

nt U

.S. A

ttorn

ey fo

r the

Eas

tern

Dis

trict

of M

ichi

gan.

Mot

ion

Day

at W

ayne

Sta

te U

nive

rsity

Law

Sch

ool (

Janu

ary

20, 2

010)

: Th

e C

hapt

er h

oste

d Ea

ster

n D

istri

ct o

f Mic

higa

n D

istri

ct Ju

dge

Ber

nard

Frie

dman

’s re

gula

r mot

ion

call,

hel

d in

the

law

scho

ol’s

Page 12: Final CVP Chapter Activities Report for 2010 · : E-Discovery Seminar on November 10, 2010; Bankruptcy seminar on December 2, 2010; and a “brown bag” lunch on ethical issues &

Vic

e Pr

esid

ents

for t

he C

ircui

ts 2

010

Cha

pter

Eve

nts R

epor

t Ja

nuar

y 14

, 201

1

12

CIR

CU

ITC

HA

PTE

RE

VE

NT

S

Spen

cer M

. Par

trich

Aud

itoriu

m.

�A

n A

fter

noon

of E

ffec

tive

Leg

al W

ritin

g, E

ffec

tive

Leg

al W

ritin

g in

Tw

o Pa

rts (

Janu

ary

25, 2

010)

:Pr

esen

ted

by th

e C

hapt

er’s

Rul

es &

Civ

il Pr

actic

e C

omm

ittee

. Th

e fir

st p

art o

f the

afte

rnoo

n w

as a

pan

el

disc

ussi

on e

ntitl

ed “

Pers

pect

ives

Fro

m th

e B

ench

,” w

hich

feat

ured

U.S

. Dis

trict

Judg

es A

vern

Coh

n,

Arth

ur T

arno

w a

nd D

avid

Law

son.

The

seco

nd p

art f

eatu

red

a "N

uts a

nd B

olts

Lec

ture

" at

torn

ey b

y C

arl

Von

End

e.

�T

rial

Adv

ocac

y &

Men

tori

ng P

rogr

am (F

ebru

ary

4, 2

010)

: Th

is p

rogr

am p

rovi

des “

new

er”

atto

rney

s (i.

e.,t

hose

in p

ract

ice

five

year

s or l

ess)

the

oppo

rtuni

ty to

obt

ain

hand

s-on

exp

erie

nce

in fu

ndam

enta

l lit

igat

ion

skill

s, w

orki

ng in

tand

em w

ith Ju

dges

and

seas

oned

atto

rney

s who

off

er v

alua

ble

guid

ance

on

dire

ct a

nd c

ross

exa

min

atio

n, o

peni

ng st

atem

ents

, and

clo

sing

arg

umen

ts.

The

2010

Men

torin

g Pr

ogra

m

focu

sed

on th

e tri

al o

f a c

ivil

case

from

ope

ning

s, th

roug

h th

e pr

esen

tatio

n of

witn

ess t

estim

ony,

and

co

nclu

ding

with

fina

l arg

umen

ts.

An

intro

duct

ory

sess

ion

on T

hurs

day,

Feb

ruar

y 4,

201

0, w

as fo

llow

ed b

y tw

o in

tens

e fu

ll-da

y se

ssio

ns o

n Fe

brua

ry 9

and

10,

follo

wed

by

a cl

osin

g re

cept

ion

in th

e C

ourth

ouse

. �

Wad

e H

. McC

ree

Aw

ard

Lun

cheo

n (F

ebru

ary

17, 2

010)

: N

early

400

atte

ndee

s wer

e pr

esen

t to

see

the

conf

errin

g of

the

2010

McC

ree

Aw

ard

for t

he A

dvan

cem

ent o

f Soc

ial J

ustic

e up

on K

athl

een

Stra

us, t

he

Pres

iden

t of t

he M

ichi

gan

Stat

e B

oard

of E

duca

tion,

and

to h

ear t

he k

eyno

te a

ddre

ss fr

om E

ric H

. Hol

der,

Atto

rney

Gen

eral

of t

he U

nite

d St

ates

.�

Cel

ebra

tion

of D

iver

sity

Rec

eptio

n (F

ebru

ary

18, 2

010)

: Th

e C

hapt

er p

artn

ered

with

a n

umbe

r of o

ther

lo

cal,

Spec

ial P

urpo

se b

ar a

ssoc

iatio

ns fo

r a c

eleb

ratio

n of

div

ersi

ty m

ixer

. �

Rou

ndta

ble

Dis

cuss

ion

on R

ecei

vers

hips

, Ass

ignm

ent f

or th

e B

enef

it of

Cre

dito

rs, a

nd R

elat

ed

Issu

es, I

nclu

ding

Ope

ratin

g in

Cha

pter

7 (M

arch

10,

201

0):

The

Ban

krup

tcy

Sect

ion

host

ed a

pan

el

disc

ussi

on in

whi

ch C

hief

Ban

krup

tcy

Judg

e Ph

illip

J. S

heff

erly

mod

erat

ed th

e di

scou

rse

of a

ttorn

eys G

ene

Kog

ut, D

avid

Fin

dlin

g, P

atric

k O

’Kee

fe a

nd Je

ff G

rasl

.�

Mot

ion

Day

at T

hom

as M

. Coo

ley

Law

Sch

ool (

Mar

ch 1

6, 2

010)

: Th

e C

hapt

er h

oste

d M

agis

trate

Judg

e V

irgin

ia M

orga

n’s m

otio

n ca

ll, h

eld

at th

e Th

omas

M. C

oole

y La

w S

choo

l’s A

nn A

rbor

, Mic

higa

n ca

mpu

s. �

FBA

Boo

k C

lub

Goe

s to

Gua

ntan

amo

Bay

(Mar

ch 1

8, 2

010)

:A

dis

cuss

ion

of “

The

Leas

t Wor

st P

lace

: G

uant

ánam

o’s F

irst 1

00 D

ays,”

by

Kar

en G

reen

berg

, the

Exe

cutiv

e D

irect

or o

f the

Cen

ter o

n La

w a

nd

Secu

rity.

The

boo

k do

cum

ents

the

first

100

day

s of t

he n

otor

ious

det

entio

n ce

nter

in C

uba,

focu

sing

on

conf

licts

am

ong

offic

ials

con

cern

ing

trans

pare

ncy,

mili

tary

pro

toco

l, an

d de

tain

ee tr

eatm

ent.

�M

otio

n D

ay a

t Uni

vers

ity o

f Det

roit

Mer

cy L

aw S

choo

l (M

arch

22,

201

0):

The

Cha

pter

hos

ted

Judg

e D

enis

e Pa

ge H

ood’

s reg

ular

mot

ion

call

at U

DM

Law

Sch

ool.

�M

otio

n D

ay a

t Uni

vers

ity o

f Mic

higa

n L

aw S

choo

l (M

arch

31,

201

0):

The

Cha

pter

hos

ted

Judg

e G

eorg

e C

aram

Ste

eh’s

Mot

ion

Day

with

a p

izza

lunc

h af

terw

ards

, at w

hich

the

Judg

e ta

lked

with

stud

ents

Page 13: Final CVP Chapter Activities Report for 2010 · : E-Discovery Seminar on November 10, 2010; Bankruptcy seminar on December 2, 2010; and a “brown bag” lunch on ethical issues &

Vic

e Pr

esid

ents

for t

he C

ircui

ts 2

010

Cha

pter

Eve

nts R

epor

t Ja

nuar

y 14

, 201

1

13

CIR

CU

ITC

HA

PTE

RE

VE

NT

S

abou

t jud

icia

l int

erns

hips

and

cle

rksh

ips.

�So

cial

Med

ia &

Its I

mpa

ct o

n L

itiga

tion:

Fro

m D

isco

very

thro

ugh

Tri

al (A

pril

15, 2

010)

: A

late

af

tern

oon

pane

l dis

cuss

ion

and

rece

ptio

n ex

plor

ed c

urre

nt so

cial

med

ia is

sues

as t

hey

rela

te to

the

litig

atio

n pr

oces

s. U

nite

d St

ates

Dis

trict

Judg

e R

ober

t H. C

lela

nd g

ave

his p

ract

ical

per

spec

tive

on e

vide

ntia

ry

issu

es, j

ury

beha

vior

and

pos

t-liti

gatio

n sa

nctio

ns.

John

Birm

ingh

am, c

hair

of F

oley

’s N

atio

nal L

abor

and

Em

ploy

men

t gro

up, d

iscu

ssed

evi

dent

iary

rule

s, vo

ir d

ire

and

the

ethi

cal i

mpl

icat

ions

of p

rodu

cing

ev

iden

ce.

J. St

ott M

atth

ews,

fore

nsic

com

pute

r spe

cial

ist,

cove

red

the

evol

ving

pro

cess

es o

f sea

rchi

ng fo

r, ob

tain

ing,

and

aut

hent

icat

ing

info

rmat

ion

foun

d w

ithin

“th

e cl

oud”

and

oth

er in

tere

stin

g to

pics

that

aff

ect

the

litig

atio

n pr

oces

s. P

atric

k Se

yfer

th, f

rom

Bus

h, S

eyfe

rth &

Pai

ge P

LLC

was

pro

gram

Mod

erat

or.

�C

ompl

ex C

omm

erci

al L

itiga

tion

Sem

inar

(Apr

il 19

, 201

0):

Mor

e th

an 5

0 at

torn

eys g

athe

red

for a

two-

part

prog

ram

spon

sore

d by

the

Cha

pter

’s C

ompl

ex L

itiga

tion

Com

mitt

ee:

The

first

par

t was

ent

itled

“P

rese

ntin

g a

Big

Pic

ture

Und

erst

andi

ng in

Pre

trial

Pro

ceed

ings

” an

d fe

atur

ed p

anel

ists

Chi

ef Ju

dge

Ger

ald

E. R

osen

and

Mag

istra

te Ju

dge

Mic

hael

Hlu

chan

iuk.

The

seco

nd p

art w

as e

ntitl

ed “

Cre

ativ

e an

d Ef

ficie

nt

Pres

enta

tion

of th

e Ju

ry T

rial i

n C

ompl

ex L

itiga

tion,

” an

d fe

atur

ed Ju

dges

Ave

rn C

ohn

and

Rob

ert H

. C

lela

nd a

nd p

ract

ition

er Je

rry

Gal

ante

, and

incl

uded

a p

rese

ntat

ion

from

the

IAD

C Ju

ry T

rial R

esea

rch

Proj

ect.

An

info

rmal

rece

ptio

n fo

llow

ed a

t the

Wes

tin B

ook

Cad

illac

. �

Leo

nard

R. G

ilman

Aw

ard

Lun

cheo

n (A

pril

22, 2

010)

: D

etro

it M

ayor

Dav

e B

ing

addr

esse

d th

e C

hapt

er a

s key

note

spea

ker a

nd th

e 20

10 G

ilman

Aw

ard

was

pre

sent

ed to

crim

inal

def

ense

atto

rney

D

ougl

as M

ullk

off.

�W

alte

r Sh

aper

o Sy

mpo

sium

Din

ner

(Apr

il 28

, 201

0):

To h

onor

Judg

e Sh

aper

o an

d hi

s liv

ing

lega

cy o

f es

tabl

ishi

ng th

e Sy

mpo

sium

, Pet

er S

. Goo

dman

, Nat

iona

l Eco

nom

ic R

epor

ter f

or th

e N

ew Y

ork

Tim

es w

asbr

ough

t in

to sp

eak

on th

e to

pic

of h

is c

ritic

ally

acc

laim

ed b

ook,

“Th

e En

d of

Eas

y M

oney

and

the

Ren

ewal

of t

he A

mer

ican

Eco

nom

y.”

�L

aw D

ay a

t the

Lev

in C

ourt

hous

e, A

Dow

ntow

n T

radi

tion

(May

3, 2

010)

: W

elco

min

g st

aff,

clie

nts

and

othe

r dow

ntow

n ne

ighb

ors f

or li

ve d

emon

stra

tions

, suc

h as

bom

b-sn

iffin

g do

gs, a

nd to

urs o

f the

co

urth

ouse

. Th

is y

ear,

ther

e w

as a

spec

ial d

edic

atio

n of

the

“Pre

side

ntia

l Wal

l” in

the

first

floo

r lob

by o

f th

e C

ourth

ouse

, whi

ch h

as p

ortra

its o

f eac

h of

the

U.S

. pre

side

nts t

oget

her w

ith a

quo

tatio

n fr

om th

e pr

esid

ent b

earin

g on

the

Am

eric

an sy

stem

of j

ustic

e an

d its

judi

ciar

y. P

ast C

hapt

er p

resi

dent

s Mic

hael

C.

Leib

son

and

Bria

n D

. Fig

ot p

artic

ipat

ed in

the

lega

l res

earc

h te

am th

at b

roug

ht th

e pr

ojec

t to

frui

tion.

Law

Cle

rk C

omm

ittee

Ori

enta

tion

for

Sum

mer

Inte

rns (

June

3, 2

010)

:Th

e C

hapt

er’s

Law

Cle

rk

Com

mitt

ee, c

ompr

ised

of c

urre

nt a

nd fo

rmer

law

cle

rks

to fe

dera

l jud

ges,

cond

ucte

d a

sem

inar

for t

he

sum

mer

inte

rns w

ho w

ould

be

assi

gned

to c

ourtr

oom

s ove

r the

sum

mer

. �

CL

EO

Pro

gram

Lun

cheo

n (J

une

8, 2

010)

:Th

e C

ounc

il on

Leg

al E

duca

tion

Opp

ortu

nity

hos

ted

a So

phom

ore

Sum

mer

Inst

itute

at T

hom

as M

. Coo

ley

Law

Sch

ool’s

Aub

urn

Hill

s cam

pus.

The

Inst

itute

Page 14: Final CVP Chapter Activities Report for 2010 · : E-Discovery Seminar on November 10, 2010; Bankruptcy seminar on December 2, 2010; and a “brown bag” lunch on ethical issues &

Vic

e Pr

esid

ents

for t

he C

ircui

ts 2

010

Cha

pter

Eve

nts R

epor

t Ja

nuar

y 14

, 201

1

14

CIR

CU

ITC

HA

PTE

RE

VE

NT

S

focu

ses o

n hi

stor

ical

ly u

nder

repr

esen

ted,

low

-inco

me,

or o

ther

wis

e di

sadv

anta

ged

grou

ps w

ho st

art e

arly

in

deve

lopi

ng th

e sk

ills t

hat p

rom

ise

succ

ess o

n th

e La

w S

choo

l Adm

issi

ons T

est.

Sin

ce 1

968,

CLE

O h

as

help

ed m

ore

than

7,0

00 lo

w-in

com

e an

d m

inor

ity st

uden

ts b

ecom

e su

cces

sful

mem

bers

of t

he le

gal

prof

essi

on a

nd th

is w

as th

e In

augu

ral o

f the

SSI

in M

ichi

gan.

The

Cha

pter

spon

sore

d th

e SS

I’s J

une

8 lu

nche

on p

rogr

am b

y se

ndin

g 4

pane

lists

and

4 o

r 5 o

ther

mem

bers

to d

iscu

ss v

ario

us a

spec

ts o

f fed

eral

pr

actic

e an

d th

e di

vers

ity o

f opt

ions

ava

ilabl

e, in

clud

ing

gene

ral p

ract

ice,

focu

sed

“bou

tique

” pr

actic

e,

gove

rnm

ent e

mpl

oym

ent i

n ag

enci

es, t

he U

.S. A

ttorn

eys o

ffic

e an

d ju

dici

al c

lerk

ship

s. �

Bar

Lea

ders

hip

Foru

m (J

une

12, 2

010)

:A

s par

t of t

he C

hapt

er’s

div

ersi

ty o

utre

ach

to th

e A

ffin

ity B

ar

asso

ciat

ions

in M

ichi

gan,

seve

ral C

hapt

er le

ader

s pre

sent

ed a

nd p

artic

ipat

ed in

the

Stat

e B

ar o

f Mic

higa

n’s

year

ly re

treat

for i

ncom

ing

bar l

eade

rs, h

eld

on M

acki

nac

Isla

nd in

Nor

ther

n M

ichi

gan.

Cha

pter

Exe

cutiv

e D

irect

or B

rian

Figo

t is i

n th

e fir

st y

ear o

f a th

ree-

year

term

on

the

Plan

ning

Com

mitt

ee fo

r the

For

um.

�T

he 3

1ST A

nnua

l Din

ner

(Jun

e 24

, 201

0):

Coc

ktai

l and

din

ner r

ecep

tion,

feat

urin

g th

e Th

ird A

nnua

l Ju

lian

Abe

le C

ook,

Jr. -

Ber

nard

A. F

riedm

an F

BA

Civ

ility

Aw

ard,

pre

sent

ed in

reco

gniti

on o

f a c

ivil

prac

titio

ner w

ho is

an

outs

tand

ing

exam

ple

of p

rofe

ssio

nal e

xcel

lenc

e an

d ci

vilit

y, a

nd e

nter

tain

men

t by

A

(Hab

eas)

Cho

rus L

ine:

Det

roit’

s Ow

n Pa

rody

Tro

upe.

Eig

hth

Ann

ual F

BA

Sum

mer

Ass

ocia

te/L

aw C

lerk

Pro

gram

(Jul

y 1,

201

0):

Lunc

h, so

cial

izin

g w

ith

the

othe

r sum

mer

ass

ocia

tes a

nd la

w c

lerk

s and

pre

sent

atio

ns b

y U

nite

d St

ates

Dis

trict

Cou

rt Ju

dges

Ave

rn

Coh

n an

d G

eorg

e C

aram

Ste

eh re

gard

ing

mot

ion

prac

tice,

brie

f writ

ing,

and

civ

ility

. �

The

Tho

mas

M. C

oole

y L

aw S

choo

l Cen

ter

for

Eth

ics,

Serv

ice,

and

Pro

fess

iona

lism

, Alu

mni

R

elat

ions

Off

ice,

and

the

Fede

ral B

ar A

ssoc

iatio

n of

the

Eas

tern

Dis

tric

t of M

ichi

gan

“Int

egri

ty in

O

ur C

omm

uniti

es”

Seri

es (J

uly

8, 2

010)

: H

eld

at th

e C

oole

y La

w S

choo

l, A

ubur

n H

ills C

ampu

s.

Key

note

Spe

aker

Bar

bara

McQ

uade

, Uni

ted

Stat

es A

ttorn

ey fo

r the

E.D

. Mic

higa

n an

d im

med

iate

pas

t-pr

esid

ent o

f the

FB

A E

.D. M

ichi

gan

Cha

pter

, pre

sent

ing

to la

w st

uden

ts o

n pr

ofes

sion

alis

m a

nd c

ivili

ty in

th

e le

gal p

ract

ice.

Stat

e of

the

Cou

rt L

unch

eon

(Sep

tem

ber

15, 2

010)

:C

hief

Judg

e G

eral

d E.

Ros

en p

rese

nted

the

annu

al

“Sta

te o

f the

Cou

rt” a

ddre

ss, t

he fi

rst o

f fou

r in

the

Lunc

heon

Ser

ies s

pons

ored

by

the

Cha

pter

; whi

ch a

lso

feat

ures

the

Cou

rt’s r

ecog

nitio

n of

the

atto

rney

s who

acc

epte

d pr

o bo

no a

ssig

nmen

ts fr

om th

e C

ourt

in th

e pa

st y

ear.

�St

ate

of th

e B

ankr

uptc

y C

ourt

Lun

cheo

n (O

ctob

er 2

0, 2

010)

:C

hief

Ban

krup

tcy

Judg

e Ph

illip

J.

Shef

ferly

pre

sent

ed th

e an

nual

“St

ate

of th

e B

ankr

uptc

y C

ourt”

add

ress

(spo

nsor

ed b

y th

e C

hapt

er’s

B

ankr

uptc

y Se

ctio

n).

�Ju

dici

al In

stitu

te a

nd S

econ

dary

Edu

catio

n W

orks

hop

(Oct

ober

22,

201

0):

In c

onju

nctio

n w

ith th

e D

istri

ct C

ourt

(and

mod

eled

afte

r the

Mon

tana

Cha

pter

’s P

rogr

am),

the

Cha

pter

con

duct

ed it

s firs

t sem

inar

de

sign

ed fo

r hig

h sc

hool

cur

ricul

um c

oord

inat

ors,

soci

al st

udie

s and

gov

ernm

ent t

each

ers o

n th

e ro

le o

f an

Page 15: Final CVP Chapter Activities Report for 2010 · : E-Discovery Seminar on November 10, 2010; Bankruptcy seminar on December 2, 2010; and a “brown bag” lunch on ethical issues &

Vic

e Pr

esid

ents

for t

he C

ircui

ts 2

010

Cha

pter

Eve

nts R

epor

t Ja

nuar

y 14

, 201

1

15

CIR

CU

ITC

HA

PTE

RE

VE

NT

S

inde

pend

ent j

udic

iary

. Th

ere

wer

e pa

nel d

iscu

ssio

ns b

y Ju

dges

and

law

yers

on

this

topi

c as

wel

l as a

ca

se st

udy

of th

e V

ince

nt C

hin

case

(whi

ch is

vie

wed

by

man

y as

the

even

t tha

t gav

e ris

e to

the

Asi

an-

Am

eric

an C

ivil

Rig

hts M

ovem

ent).

The

Wor

ksho

p co

nclu

ded

with

a to

ur o

f the

Cou

rthou

se.

�R

akow

Aw

ards

/His

tori

cal S

ocie

ty L

unch

eon

(Nov

embe

r 15

, 201

0):

The

prog

ram

feat

ured

the

pres

enta

tion

of th

e Fe

dera

l Bar

Fou

ndat

ion’

s ann

ual R

akow

Sch

olar

ship

Aw

ards

to st

uden

ts fr

om e

ach

of

Mic

higa

n’s l

aw sc

hool

s and

a sp

ecia

l His

toric

al S

ocie

ty p

rogr

am fe

atur

ing

Ros

s Par

ker,

auth

or o

f the

boo

k “C

arvi

ng O

ut th

e R

ule

of L

aw: T

he H

isto

ry o

f the

Uni

ted

Stat

es A

ttorn

ey’s

Off

ice

in E

aste

rn M

ichi

gan

1815

-200

8.”

Mr.

Park

er w

as th

e ch

ief o

f the

crim

inal

div

isio

n in

the

U.S

. Atto

rney

’s O

ffic

e in

Det

roit

for

8 ye

ars a

nd a

n A

USA

for 2

8 ye

ars i

n th

at o

ffic

e. R

akow

Sch

olar

ship

s tot

alin

g m

ore

than

$16

6,00

0 ha

ve

now

bee

n aw

ard

thro

ugh

the

Cha

pter

’s F

ound

atio

n.

�N

ew L

awye

rs S

emin

ar (D

ecem

ber

7-8,

201

0):

A “

nuts

and

bol

ts/h

ow to

do

it” 2

-day

sem

inar

for n

ew

law

yers

des

igne

d to

ass

ist r

ecen

t law

scho

ol g

radu

ates

in u

nder

stan

ding

cer

tain

are

as o

f sub

stan

tive

prac

tice

and

the

fund

amen

tal p

roce

dure

s fol

low

ed in

the

U.S

. Dis

trict

Cou

rt fo

r the

Eas

tern

Dis

trict

of

Mic

higa

n an

d in

the

Stat

e co

urts

in W

ayne

, Oak

land

and

Mac

omb

coun

ties.

In a

dditi

on to

two

days

of

pres

enta

tions

and

pan

el d

iscu

ssio

ns, t

he re

gist

rant

s rec

eive

d ac

com

pany

ing

outli

nes a

nd su

bsta

ntiv

e ar

ticle

s on

a C

D-R

om a

nd a

fede

ral c

ourt

swea

ring

in c

erem

ony.

Cha

pter

Hol

iday

Par

ty (D

ecem

ber

8, 2

010)

:B

egin

ning

with

our

50t

h A

nniv

ersa

ry C

eleb

ratio

n in

200

7,

the

Cha

pter

revi

ved

the

tradi

tion

of a

Cha

pter

Hol

iday

Soc

ial,

follo

win

g th

e se

cond

day

of t

he N

ew

Law

yers

Sem

inar

, with

nea

rly 1

50 C

hapt

er m

embe

rs e

njoy

ing

each

oth

er’s

com

pany

at t

he st

art o

f the

H

olid

ay S

easo

n.

�FB

A B

ook

Clu

b –

“The

Sec

rets

of A

bu G

hrai

b R

evea

led”

(Dec

embe

r 14

, 201

0):

Sess

ion

led

by th

e bo

ok’s

co-

auth

or, C

hris

toph

er G

rave

line,

one

of t

he le

ad p

rose

cutin

g at

torn

eys f

or th

e U

nite

d St

ates

in th

e ca

ses i

nvol

ving

abu

se o

f Ira

qi d

etai

nees

by

U.S

. mili

tary

sold

iers

at t

he A

bu G

hrai

b pr

ison

. M

r. G

rave

line

is n

ow a

n A

ssis

tant

U.S

. Atto

rney

in th

e Ea

ster

n D

istri

ct o

f Mic

higa

n.

D

ayto

n C

hapt

er

�L

unch

eon

with

FB

A R

epre

sent

ativ

e B

ruce

Moy

er (N

ovem

ber

2010

): T

he D

ayto

n C

hapt

er h

oste

d a

lunc

heon

with

FB

A R

epre

sent

ativ

e B

ruce

Moy

er re

gard

ing

his l

obby

ing

effo

rts fo

r the

Fed

eral

Bar

A

ssoc

iatio

n.

�A

nnua

l CL

E S

emin

ar (D

ecem

ber

15, 2

010)

: Th

e A

nnua

l Cha

pter

CLE

Sem

inar

hig

hlig

hted

a n

umbe

r of

topi

cs p

ertin

ent t

o fe

dera

l pra

ctiti

oner

s. T

he 2

010

even

t inc

lude

d pr

ogra

ms o

n Pr

ofes

sion

al E

thic

s, pr

esen

ted

by S

enio

r Uni

ted

Stat

es D

istri

ct Ju

dge

Wal

ter R

ice

(S.D

. Ohi

o); F

eder

al S

ente

ncin

g G

uide

lines

an

d C

ompu

tatio

n, p

rese

nted

by

Trac

y G

earo

n of

the

Day

ton

U.S

. Pro

batio

n O

ffic

e; S

ubst

ance

Abu

se

Educ

atio

n, p

rese

nted

by

Mic

hael

Fla

nner

y, M

S, L

PC, L

SW, L

ICD

C; I

ntro

duct

ion

to C

JA P

anel

, pre

sent

ed

by U

nite

d St

ates

Mag

istra

te Ju

dge

Shar

on L

. Ovi

ngto

n (S

.D. O

hio)

; Ele

ctro

nic

Dis

cove

ry, p

rese

nted

by

Uni

ted

Stat

es M

agis

trate

Judg

e M

icha

el E

. Mer

z; a

nd T

he F

eder

al B

urea

u of

Pris

ons a

nd P

rison

er

Page 16: Final CVP Chapter Activities Report for 2010 · : E-Discovery Seminar on November 10, 2010; Bankruptcy seminar on December 2, 2010; and a “brown bag” lunch on ethical issues &

Vic

e Pr

esid

ents

for t

he C

ircui

ts 2

010

Cha

pter

Eve

nts R

epor

t Ja

nuar

y 14

, 201

1

16

CIR

CU

ITC

HA

PTE

RE

VE

NT

S

Des

igna

tions

, pre

sent

ed b

y R

ick

Stov

er, S

enio

r Des

igna

tor,

U.S

. Des

igna

tion

and

Sent

ence

Com

puta

tion

Cen

ter.

�Sp

onso

rshi

p of

Att

enda

nce

at D

eath

Pen

alty

Sem

inar

(Spr

ing

2011

): T

he D

ayto

n C

hapt

er w

ill b

e sp

onso

ring

U.S

. Mag

istra

te Ju

dge

Mic

hael

Mer

z an

d hi

s dea

th p

enal

ty st

aff t

o at

tend

a d

eath

pen

alty

se

min

ar to

be

held

in L

as V

egas

in S

prin

g 20

11.

Som

etim

e af

terw

ard,

the

Cha

pter

inte

nds t

o m

arke

t and

ho

st a

hab

eas c

orpu

s CLE

sem

inar

with

Mag

istra

te Ju

dge

Mer

z as

the

mai

n pr

esen

ter.

Cha

ttano

oga,

Te

nnes

see

Cha

pter

E-D

isco

very

Wor

ksho

p (F

ebru

ary

4, 2

010)

: Pr

actic

e po

inte

rs fr

om a

n E-

Dis

cove

ry st

andp

oint

by

a U

.S.

Mag

istra

te Ju

dge,

a p

ract

ition

er a

nd a

n ou

tsid

e e-

disc

over

y co

nsul

tant

. Th

e pr

ogra

m a

ddre

ssed

scen

ario

s an

d ex

pect

atio

ns re

late

d to

e-d

isco

very

incl

udin

g du

ties a

nd p

enal

ties f

or e

-dis

cove

ry.

�Fe

dera

l Cou

rt P

ract

ice

Sem

inar

(May

27,

201

0):

The

Fede

ral C

ourt

Prac

tice

Sem

inar

is p

rese

nted

two

times

a y

ear t

o pr

ovid

e C

LE a

nd a

n in

trodu

ctio

n fo

r new

atto

rney

s to

the

East

ern

Dis

trict

of T

enne

ssee

.Th

e pr

ogra

m in

clud

es c

omm

ents

and

par

ticip

atio

n by

the

Chi

ef D

eput

y C

lerk

, a c

ivil

prac

titio

ner,

a cr

imin

al p

ract

ition

er, a

n A

ssis

tant

U.S

. A

ttorn

ey, a

n A

ssis

tant

U.S

. Tru

stee

, a M

agis

trate

Judg

e, a

B

ankr

uptc

y Ju

dge

and

a D

istri

ct C

ourt

Judg

e. A

t the

end

of t

he se

min

ar, p

artic

ipan

ts a

re a

ble

to a

ttend

the

swea

ring-

in c

erem

ony

for a

dmis

sion

to p

ract

ice

in th

e Ea

ster

n D

istri

ct o

f Ten

ness

ee.

In a

dditi

on to

the

CLE

pro

gram

, the

adm

issi

on c

erem

ony

pres

ents

an

oppo

rtuni

ty fo

r the

pre

side

nt o

f the

Fed

eral

Bar

A

ssoc

iatio

n C

hatta

noog

a C

hapt

er to

wel

com

e th

e ne

w a

dmitt

ees a

nd m

ake

a pu

sh fo

r mem

bers

hip

and

parti

cipa

tion

in th

e Fe

dera

l Bar

Ass

ocia

tion.

�L

unch

and

Lea

rn B

ankr

uptc

y Se

min

ar (J

une

29, 2

010)

: Th

e Lu

nch

& L

earn

Ban

krup

tcy

Sem

inar

in

volv

ed th

e ch

ange

s to

the

Ban

krup

tcy

rule

s inc

ludi

ng ti

min

g ch

ange

s. In

add

ition

, it w

as a

n op

portu

nity

fo

r new

ly a

ppoi

nted

Judg

e Sh

elle

y D

. Ruc

ker t

o ad

dres

s mem

bers

of t

he b

ar a

nd fo

r the

bar

to a

sk

ques

tions

of J

udge

Ruc

ker a

nd Ju

dge

Coo

k, th

e C

hief

Ban

krup

tcy

Judg

e fo

r the

dis

trict

.

Mem

phis

, Te

nnes

see

Mid

-So

uth

Cha

pter

�A

nnua

l Im

mig

ratio

n Se

min

ar (M

ay 2

010)

: Th

e C

hapt

er c

o-ho

sted

the

Ann

ual I

mm

igra

tion

Sem

inar

al

ong

with

FB

A N

atio

nal.

Thi

s aw

ard

win

ning

CLE

invo

lved

a w

ho's

who

of i

mm

igra

tion

judg

es,

atto

rney

s and

aca

dem

ic e

xper

ts.

�C

LE

Pro

gram

(Jun

e 20

10):

The

Cha

pter

hel

d a

CLE

in Ja

ckso

n, T

N w

hich

invo

lved

man

y of

the

dist

rict

cour

t jud

ges a

nd m

agis

trate

judg

es fo

r the

Wes

tern

Dis

trict

of T

enne

ssee

.Th

e C

LE c

over

ed te

chno

logy

an

d th

e la

w, e

thic

s, an

d ju

dici

al ti

ps.

Parti

cipa

nts,

incl

udin

g th

e ju

dges

, atte

nded

the

JAX

X m

inor

leag

ue

base

ball

gam

e af

ter t

he e

vent

and

enj

oyed

a p

icni

c in

clud

ed w

ith th

e ev

ent.

�A

ppel

late

Adv

ocac

y Se

min

ar (J

uly

2010

): T

he C

hapt

er h

eld

a se

min

ar w

ith a

n em

phas

is o

n ap

pella

te

advo

cacy

in w

hich

seve

ral d

istri

ct c

ourt

judg

es a

nd st

ate

judg

es p

artic

ipat

ed. T

he e

vent

was

hel

d at

the

Fede

ral C

ourt

hous

e an

d w

e fil

led

the

room

to c

apac

ity.

Atte

ndee

s par

ticul

arly

like

d th

e in

volv

emen

t of

both

fede

ral a

nd st

ate

judg

es, c

rimin

al a

nd c

ivil

side

s.

�Fe

dera

l Pra

ctic

e an

d Pr

oced

ure

Sem

inar

(Oct

ober

201

0):

The

Cha

pter

hel

d its

ann

ual,

awar

d w

inni

ng

Page 17: Final CVP Chapter Activities Report for 2010 · : E-Discovery Seminar on November 10, 2010; Bankruptcy seminar on December 2, 2010; and a “brown bag” lunch on ethical issues &

Vic

e Pr

esid

ents

for t

he C

ircui

ts 2

010

Cha

pter

Eve

nts R

epor

t Ja

nuar

y 14

, 201

1

17

CIR

CU

ITC

HA

PTE

RE

VE

NT

S

Fede

ral P

ract

ice

and

Proc

edur

e Se

min

ar, w

hich

was

hig

hlig

hted

by

a U

.S. S

upre

me

Cou

rt Sw

earin

g-In

ce

rem

ony

cond

ucte

d by

Gen

eral

Will

iam

K. S

uter

. Gen

eral

Sut

er n

oted

that

it w

as th

e se

cond

larg

est

swea

ring

in c

erem

ony

he h

ad e

ver c

ondu

cted

. F

ollo

win

g th

e ce

rem

ony,

the

Cha

pter

hel

d a

day

long

CLE

pr

ogra

m w

hich

incl

uded

all

of th

e di

stric

t cou

rt ju

dges

, mag

istra

tes,

and

Cou

rt of

App

eals

Judg

es Ju

lia

Smith

Gib

bons

and

Jane

Bra

nste

tter S

tranc

h (w

ho h

ad ju

st b

een

conf

irmed

). Je

ffre

y R

osen

, pro

fess

or o

f la

w a

t the

Geo

rge

Was

hing

ton

Uni

vers

ity a

nd a

utho

r of T

he S

upre

me

Cou

rt: T

he P

erso

nalit

ies a

nd

Riva

lrie

s tha

t Def

ined

Am

eric

a, p

artic

ipat

ed a

s a k

ey p

rese

nter

.�

Ann

ual O

pen

Mee

ting

(Dec

embe

r 20

10):

Ann

ual o

pen

mee

ting,

whi

ch in

clud

ed a

soci

al lu

nche

on fo

r all

mem

bers

and

an

elec

tion

of in

com

ing

offic

ers a

nd b

oard

. 7th

Circ

uit

Chi

cago

, Illi

nois

C

hapt

er�

Chi

cago

Cha

pter

: Sig

nific

ant e

vent

s thi

s cal

enda

r yea

r inc

lude

d an

all-

day

Imm

igra

tion

Law

pro

gram

in

Nov

embe

r; an

afte

rnoo

n pr

ogra

m d

urin

g Ju

ly, i

nten

ded

for s

umm

er a

ssoc

iate

s and

less

-exp

erie

nced

law

fir

m li

tigat

ors,

feat

urin

g or

al a

rgum

ent r

elat

ing

to tw

o m

otio

ns p

endi

ng b

efor

e D

istri

ct C

ourt

Judg

e M

atth

ew K

enne

lly (N

.D.Il

l.) fo

llow

ed b

y a

criti

que

prov

ided

by

anot

her D

istri

ct C

ourt

judg

e an

d a

mag

istra

te ju

dge;

a fo

ur-h

our e

thic

s CLE

pro

gram

pro

vide

d in

May

to F

BA

mem

bers

with

out c

harg

e; th

e D

istri

ct C

ourt

Chi

ef Ju

dge's

ann

ual "

Stat

e of

the

Cou

rt" a

ddre

ss, a

lso

in M

ay; a

June

201

0 re

cept

ion

free

fo

r all

FBA

mem

bers

at w

hich

rece

ntly

dec

ease

d D

istri

ct C

ourt

Judg

e Ja

mes

Mor

an, a

long

-tim

e m

embe

r of

the

Cha

pter

's B

oard

of D

irect

ors,

was

rem

embe

red;

and

a M

ay p

rogr

am jo

intly

with

the

Dis

trict

Cou

rt to

ho

nor a

ttorn

eys w

ho p

rovi

ded

exem

plar

y pr

o bo

no se

rvic

e to

the

Dis

trict

Cou

rt.

8th C

ircui

t M

inne

sota

9th C

ircui

t A

lask

a C

hapt

er

�M

arch

201

0: M

eetin

g w

ith Ju

dges

re th

eir r

ecen

t jud

icia

l ser

vice

s trip

to A

fric

a �

Apr

il 20

10:

We

held

a lu

nche

on in

hon

or o

f cou

rt se

curit

y pe

rson

nel

�Ju

ne 2

010:

Mem

bers

par

ticip

ated

in H

abita

t for

Hum

anity

Bui

ld a

s par

t of o

ur “

Do

Som

ethi

ng

Con

stru

ctiv

e, Jo

in th

e FB

A”

Mem

bers

hip

Cam

paig

n �

July

201

0: C

ospo

nsor

ed th

e an

nual

“Q

& A

with

Nin

th C

ircui

t Cou

rt of

App

eals

” w

ith th

e St

ate

Bar

July

201

0: H

oste

d in

form

al “

brow

n ba

g” lu

nch

for m

embe

rs w

ith v

isiti

ng N

inth

Circ

uit p

anel

Aug

ust 2

010:

Mem

bers

aga

in p

artic

ipat

ed in

Hab

itat f

or H

uman

ity B

uild

as p

art o

f our

“D

o So

met

hing

C

onst

ruct

ive,

Join

the

FBA

” M

embe

rshi

p C

ampa

ign

�Se

ptem

ber 2

010:

Int

rodu

ctio

n to

the

Nin

etee

n C

andi

date

s for

the

Dis

trict

Cou

rt V

acan

cy.

We

did

a Po

wer

Poin

t pre

sent

atio

n w

ith p

ictu

res a

nd so

me

“hum

an in

tere

st”

and

biog

raph

ical

fact

s abo

ut e

ach

cand

idat

e�

Dec

embe

r 14,

201

0: T

oday

’s m

eetin

g to

focu

s on

the

upda

te to

the

Fede

ral R

ules

and

the

rece

nt a

ppel

late

Page 18: Final CVP Chapter Activities Report for 2010 · : E-Discovery Seminar on November 10, 2010; Bankruptcy seminar on December 2, 2010; and a “brown bag” lunch on ethical issues &

Vic

e Pr

esid

ents

for t

he C

ircui

ts 2

010

Cha

pter

Eve

nts R

epor

t Ja

nuar

y 14

, 201

1

18

CIR

CU

ITC

HA

PTE

RE

VE

NT

S

argu

men

t in

the

Prop

. 8/ G

ay M

arria

ge c

ase

befo

re th

e N

inth

Circ

uit.

Tu

cson

, Ariz

ona

Cha

pter

�A

mer

ican

with

Dis

abili

ties (

AD

A) L

unch

Sem

inar

. Sp

eake

r was

Ran

dall

How

e an

AU

SA in

our

Dis

trict

(f

orm

er st

ate

Ass

ista

nt A

ttorn

ey G

ener

al) w

ho is

dis

able

d an

d ve

ry in

volv

ed in

AD

A le

gal i

ssue

s (Fe

brua

ry

18, 2

010)

. �

Civ

il La

w S

emin

ar (½

day

sem

inar

on

vario

us c

ivil

issu

es in

clud

ing

answ

erin

g ap

pella

te a

rgum

ents

and

fe

dera

l ple

adin

g un

der

Twom

bly

and

Iqba

l) (A

pril

15, 2

010)

. �

The

Lege

nds (

hono

ring

thre

e at

torn

eys/

judg

es w

ho h

ave

been

pra

ctic

ing

for o

ver 3

0 ye

ars)

(May

27,

20

10).

�B

ench

and

Bar

(Ann

ual e

vent

pan

el in

clud

ed C

hief

Dis

trict

Cou

rt Ju

dge

John

Rol

l, D

istri

ct C

ourt

Judg

e R

aner

Col

lins a

nd F

eder

al M

agis

trate

Judg

e Je

nnife

r Gue

rin) (

Sept

embe

r 16,

201

0).

�Pr

o/C

on D

iscu

ssio

n of

Ariz

ona’

s SB

107

0 be

twee

n Pr

ofes

sor J

ack

Chi

n (U

nive

rsity

of A

rizon

a) a

nd D

ean

Emer

itus J

ohn

East

man

(Cha

pman

Uni

vers

ity).

Thi

s was

con

duct

ed 2

wee

ks b

efor

e 9th

Cir.

Arg

umen

ts o

n th

e in

junc

tion.

(Oct

ober

14,

201

0).

�C

rimin

al L

aw S

emin

ar (1

/2 d

ay se

min

ar o

n va

rious

crim

inal

issu

es, i

nclu

ding

refle

ctio

ns fr

om D

istri

ctSe

nior

Judg

e Fr

ank

Zapa

ta o

n th

irty

plus

yea

rs in

fede

ral c

rimin

al la

w, a

cas

e la

w re

view

by

Dou

g W

ilson

, th

e au

thor

of T

he N

inth

Circ

uit C

rimin

al L

aw R

epor

ter a

nd F

eder

al S

ente

ncin

g G

uide

; an

d ,tw

o pa

nels

di

scus

sing

pre

serv

ing

the

appe

llate

reco

rd a

nd se

nten

cing

. (W

ill b

e he

ld N

ovem

ber 1

8, 2

010)

.�

FBA

Nut

s & B

olts

Ser

ies

(Thi

s a c

ontin

uing

pro

gram

that

we

bega

n in

200

9 th

at p

rovi

des t

rain

ing

atto

rney

on

var

ious

crim

inal

topi

cs –

we

try to

do

a 2-

3 ho

ur tr

aini

ng a

t lea

st q

uarte

rly a

nd th

is is

free

to a

ll at

torn

eys.

Our

hop

e is

to e

xpan

d th

is p

rogr

am to

the

civi

l pra

ctic

e as

wel

l.)

Phoe

nix,

Ariz

ona

Cha

pter

�A

nnua

l Law

Cle

rk R

ecep

tion

that

we

host

ed in

Sep

tem

ber.

We

host

ed a

ll th

e ne

w la

w c

lerk

s and

the

judg

es o

n th

e da

y th

at th

e cl

erks

had

thei

r orie

ntat

ion

�M

onth

ly C

LE L

unch

eons

as f

ollo

ws:

Janu

ary:

“Ex

perie

nces

of t

he U

.S. S

upre

me

Cou

rt C

lerk

” G

en. W

illia

m S

uter

, Cle

rk o

f US

Supr

eme

Cou

rt �

Febr

uary

: “St

ate

of th

e D

istri

ct”

Hon

. Joh

n R

oll,

Chi

ef U

S D

istri

ct Ju

dge

�M

arch

: “Fe

dera

l Ind

ian

Law

” Pr

of. R

ebec

ca T

sosi

e, A

rizon

a St

ate

Uni

vers

ity C

olle

ge o

f Law

Apr

il: “

Lette

r Siz

e vs

Leg

al S

ize:

The

Tra

nsiti

on fr

om P

rivat

e Pr

actic

e to

Gen

eral

Cou

nsel

” Jo

sé C

árde

nas,

Gen

eral

Cou

nsel

, Ariz

ona

Stat

e U

nive

rsity

May

: “A

nnua

l Sup

rem

e C

ourt

Upd

ate”

Pro

fs. P

aul B

ende

r and

Cat

hy O

’Gra

dy, A

rizon

a St

ate

Uni

vers

ity

Col

lege

of L

aw

�Ju

ne: “

Ann

ual B

ig C

ooki

e O

lym

pics

” H

on. R

osly

n Si

lver

, US

Dis

trict

Judg

e, D

avid

Ros

enba

um, a

nd Ji

m

Bel

ange

r�

Sept

embe

r: “A

Con

vers

atio

n w

ith th

e U

.S. A

ttorn

ey”

U.S

. Atto

rney

Den

nis B

urke

Page 19: Final CVP Chapter Activities Report for 2010 · : E-Discovery Seminar on November 10, 2010; Bankruptcy seminar on December 2, 2010; and a “brown bag” lunch on ethical issues &

Vic

e Pr

esid

ents

for t

he C

ircui

ts 2

010

Cha

pter

Eve

nts R

epor

t Ja

nuar

y 14

, 201

1

19

CIR

CU

ITC

HA

PTE

RE

VE

NT

S

�O

ctob

er:

“Ann

ual B

ankr

uptc

y U

pdat

e: 5

Har

d Q

uest

ions

abo

ut B

ankr

uptc

y” H

on. G

eorg

e N

eils

en, J

r., U

S B

ankr

uptc

y Ju

dge,

Don

Gaf

fney

, Jor

dan

Kro

op

�N

ovem

ber:

“How

Not

to L

ose

your

App

eal a

t Tria

l” H

on. W

illia

m C

anby

, 9th

Circ

uit J

udge

, Hon

. Fr

eder

ick

Mar

tone

, US

Dis

trict

Judg

e, T

hom

as H

udso

n �

We

also

hel

d ou

r Ann

ual H

olid

ay P

arty

on

Thur

sday

, Dec

embe

r 9 a

t the

Pho

enix

Art

Mus

eum

. W

e ho

nore

d Se

nior

US

Dis

trict

Judg

e Ea

rl C

arro

ll an

d ha

d ov

er 2

00 g

uest

s. E

very

sitti

ng a

nd re

tired

fede

ral

judg

e in

Ariz

ona

was

ther

e.

H

awai

i Cha

pter

Dec

embe

r 201

0 A

nnua

l FB

A C

LE a

nd re

cept

ion

Id

aho

Cha

pter

Febr

uary

5, 2

010

– Pa

rtici

pate

d in

and

ass

iste

d w

ith fu

ndin

g fo

r the

rece

ptio

n fo

r the

off

icia

l sw

earin

g-in

ce

rem

ony

of th

e ne

w C

lerk

of C

ourt

Eliz

abet

h Sm

ith.

�A

pril

9, 2

010

– Fe

dera

l Jud

ges:

The

ir A

ppoi

ntm

ents

, Per

spec

tive,

and

thei

r Rul

ings

. The

pro

gram

di

scus

sed

the

judi

cial

per

spec

tive

of C

lare

nce

Dar

row

by

natio

nally

-acc

laim

ed a

ctor

Gar

y A

nder

son

from

th

e C

lare

nce

Dar

row

Fou

ndat

ion,

whi

ch fe

atur

ed lo

cal a

ttorn

eys a

nd ju

dges

read

ing

cent

ral r

oles

. In

this

pr

ogra

m w

e ad

dres

sed

the

pers

pect

ive

that

Cla

renc

e D

arro

w’s

lega

cy w

as th

e di

rect

resu

lt of

the

judg

esw

ho c

ontri

bute

d to

this

icon

ic a

nd c

ontro

vers

ial f

igur

e. A

dditi

onal

ly, t

he p

rogr

am in

clud

ed a

pre

sent

atio

n by

aut

hor W

illia

m D

omna

rski

who

abo

ut h

is n

ew b

ook

abou

t fed

eral

judg

es th

at w

as re

cent

ly p

ublis

hed

calle

dFe

dera

l Jud

ges R

evea

led.

�M

ay 4

, 201

0 –

A C

onve

rsat

ion

with

the

Cou

rt h

oste

d by

the

You

ng L

awye

rs S

ectio

n of

our

FB

A C

hapt

er.

The

brow

n ba

g lu

nch

incl

uded

bot

h re

calle

d U

.S. M

agis

trate

Judg

e La

rry

M. B

oyle

and

Mik

el H

. Will

iam

s. �

May

18,

201

0 –

Our

Cha

pter

and

staf

f atto

rney

s of t

he Id

aho

Atto

rney

Gen

eral

’s O

ffic

e ho

sted

a C

LE

prog

ram

rega

rdin

g se

ctio

n 19

83 c

ivil

right

s cas

es, a

nd re

pres

enta

tion

of p

rison

ers p

ro b

ono.

Chi

ef U

.S.

Mag

istra

te Ju

dge

Can

dy D

ale

orga

nize

d an

d ho

sted

the

prog

ram

. Th

e pr

ogra

m w

as v

ideo

tape

d fo

r fut

ure

train

ing

purp

oses

. �

May

24,

201

0 –

We

parti

cipa

ted

and

held

the

rece

ptio

n fo

r the

ded

icat

ion

of N

inth

Circ

uit J

udge

N. R

any

Snm

ith’s

cha

mbe

rs d

edic

atio

n ce

rem

ony

in P

ocat

ello

, Ida

ho.

�Ju

ly 2

8, 2

010

– Th

e M

ulti-

Dis

trict

Liti

gatio

n Pa

nel (

MD

L) h

eld

its fi

rst e

ver h

earin

gs in

Boi

se, I

daho

, w

hich

cas

es in

clud

ed B

ritis

h Pe

trole

um O

il Sp

ill c

ases

. �

Aug

ust 6

, 201

0 –

Parti

cipa

ted

and

assi

sted

in fu

ndin

g th

e re

cept

ion

for t

he o

ffic

ial s

wea

ring-

in c

erem

ony

of

the

new

U.S

. Fed

eral

Mar

shal

Bria

n U

nder

woo

d.

�Se

ptem

ber 9

– 1

1, 2

010

– Pa

rtici

pate

d in

the

Tri-S

tate

Fed

eral

Bar

Ass

ocia

tion

prog

ram

(Wyo

min

g, U

tah

and

Idah

o) in

Sal

t Lak

e C

ity, U

tah.

�Se

ptem

ber 1

7, 2

010

– Pa

rtici

pate

d an

d as

sist

ed in

fund

ing

the

rece

ptio

n fo

r the

off

icia

l sw

earin

g-in

Page 20: Final CVP Chapter Activities Report for 2010 · : E-Discovery Seminar on November 10, 2010; Bankruptcy seminar on December 2, 2010; and a “brown bag” lunch on ethical issues &

Vic

e Pr

esid

ents

for t

he C

ircui

ts 2

010

Cha

pter

Eve

nts R

epor

t Ja

nuar

y 14

, 201

1

20

CIR

CU

ITC

HA

PTE

RE

VE

NT

S

cere

mon

y of

the

new

Uni

ted

Stat

es A

ttorn

ey W

endy

J. O

lson

. �

Sept

embe

r 20,

201

0 –

Mem

bers

of t

he E

xecu

tive

Boa

rd o

f the

Idah

o ch

apte

r of t

he F

eder

al B

ar a

ttend

ed a

m

eetin

g w

ith H

arve

y Jo

nes,

Dire

ctor

of t

he P

olic

y an

d In

itiat

ives

Off

ice,

and

Car

olyn

Pea

ke, S

uper

viso

ry

Adv

isor

y A

naly

st, b

oth

from

the

Adm

inis

trativ

e O

ffic

e of

t he

U.S

. Cou

rts re

gard

ing

the

Idah

o’s

judi

ciar

y’s f

undi

ngs i

ssue

s. �

Oct

ober

13,

201

0 –

Bro

wn

Bag

CLE

pro

gram

with

Nin

th C

ircui

t Jud

ge R

icha

rd T

allm

an fr

om S

eattl

e.

He

prov

ided

an

over

view

of t

he st

ate

of th

e N

inth

Circ

uit,

and

then

dis

cuss

ed e

ffor

ts to

bro

aden

pre

trial

cr

imin

al d

isco

very

und

er R

ule

16 in

ligh

t of U

nite

d St

ates

v. T

ed S

teve

ns, t

hat w

as d

ism

isse

d w

hen

evid

ence

favo

rabl

e to

the

accu

sed

was

with

held

by

fede

ral p

rose

cuto

rs d

urin

g tri

al

�D

ecem

ber,

2010

– T

he a

nnua

l FB

A C

omm

unity

Ser

vice

Pro

ject

hel

d by

our

Cha

pter

was

for t

he S

hosh

one-

Ban

nock

Trib

e Ju

nior

Hig

h Sc

hool

, we

colle

cted

boo

ks, s

choo

l sup

plie

s, an

d ca

ndy

for k

id’s

stoc

king

s. �

The

Dis

trict

and

Mag

istra

te Ju

dges

hav

e be

en o

rder

ing

sele

cted

pris

oner

pro

se c

ases

to m

edia

tion

in th

e D

istri

ct o

f Ida

ho.

Our

cha

pter

ass

ists

the

pris

oner

s pro

bon

o th

roug

h th

e C

ourt’

s AD

R /

Pro

Bon

o Pr

ogra

m.

�Th

e D

istri

ct h

as in

itiat

ed a

Tria

ge In

itiat

ive

Prog

ram

for o

ur P

rison

er L

itiga

tion

Uni

t (fo

rmer

ly c

alle

d Pr

o Se

Uni

t).

Nor

ther

n D

istri

ct o

f C

alifo

rnia

Cha

pter

Jan.

7 -

FBA

Med

ia R

oom

Unv

eilin

g (r

ecep

tion

co-s

pons

or) –

The

FB

A sp

onso

rs a

med

ia ro

om a

t the

N.D

. C

al. F

eder

al C

ourt

Hou

se, 4

50 G

olde

n G

ate,

San

Fra

ncis

co.

�Ja

n. 2

8 - P

anel

Dis

cuss

ion

on U

nite

d St

ates

v. R

uehl

e; p

anel

ists

incl

uded

the

form

er d

irect

or o

f the

Enr

on

Task

For

ce),

a fo

rmer

dire

ctor

of t

he S

an F

ranc

isco

Reg

iona

l Off

ice

of th

e SE

C a

nd a

mem

ber o

f the

de

fens

e ba

r and

mod

erat

ed b

y a

form

er A

ssis

tant

US

Atto

rney

Feb.

25

- Co-

spon

sor o

f e-d

isco

very

pan

el d

iscu

ssio

n on

“pr

otec

ting

You

r Age

ncy

with

E-d

isco

very

and

R

ecor

ds M

anag

emen

t Bes

t Pra

ctic

es”

with

U.S

. Nat

iona

l Arc

hive

s and

Rec

ords

Adm

inis

tratio

n. P

anel

ists

in

clud

ed o

ur C

hapt

er’s

Imm

edia

te P

ast P

resi

dent

, Chr

is S

ulliv

an.

�M

ar. 2

4 - T

hirty

-Sec

ond

Ann

ual N

inth

Circ

uit L

unch

eon

Hon

orin

g th

e Ju

dges

of t

he U

nite

d St

ates

Cou

rt of

A

ppea

ls fo

r the

Nin

th C

ircui

t. Th

is is

our

sign

atur

e ev

ent f

or th

e le

gal c

omm

unity

in th

e N

D C

alifo

rnia

ar

ea.

Ove

r 400

atto

rney

s and

judg

es a

ttend

ed.

The

prog

ram

feat

ured

a fi

lm h

onor

ing

the

Hon

. Jam

es

Bro

wni

ng, f

orm

er C

hief

Judg

e of

the

Nin

th C

ircui

t, fo

r who

m th

e co

urth

ouse

in S

an F

ranc

isco

has

bee

n na

med

. Ju

dge

Bro

wni

ng a

ttend

ed a

long

with

a g

roup

of h

is fo

rmer

cle

rks.

�A

pr. 2

9 - C

o-sp

onso

r of r

ecep

tion

for t

he in

duct

ion

of U

S M

agis

trate

Judg

e La

urel

Bee

ler,

USD

C N

DC

A.

MJ B

eele

r is a

pas

t Cha

pter

pre

side

nt.

�Ju

n. 2

5 - C

o-sp

onso

r with

USD

C, N

DC

A, o

f eve

nt h

onor

ing

Hon

Max

ine

Che

sney

(and

pre

sent

atio

n of

her

po

rtrai

t afte

r she

took

seni

or st

atus

) and

(new

ly a

ppoi

nted

judg

e) H

on. R

icha

rd S

eebo

rg.

Page 21: Final CVP Chapter Activities Report for 2010 · : E-Discovery Seminar on November 10, 2010; Bankruptcy seminar on December 2, 2010; and a “brown bag” lunch on ethical issues &

Vic

e Pr

esid

ents

for t

he C

ircui

ts 2

010

Cha

pter

Eve

nts R

epor

t Ja

nuar

y 14

, 201

1

21

CIR

CU

ITC

HA

PTE

RE

VE

NT

S

�Ju

l. 15

- Pa

nel d

iscu

ssio

n on

“Pa

tent

Ass

et V

alua

tions

: C

ourtr

oom

v. B

oard

room

,” fe

atur

ing

the

Hon

. Je

rem

y Fo

gel,

USD

C, N

D C

al.

Pane

lists

incl

uded

the

Dire

ctor

of S

tanf

ord

Uni

vers

ity’s

Pro

gram

in L

aw,

Scie

nce

and

Tech

nolo

gy a

nd p

rom

inen

t int

elle

ctua

l pro

perty

pra

ctiti

oner

s. �

Jul.

21 -

Pane

l dis

cuss

ion

on “

Rev

iew

of t

he S

upre

me

Cou

rt’s T

erm

201

0,”

feat

urin

g H

on. M

arsh

a B

erzo

n,

Nin

th C

ircui

t Cou

rt of

App

eals

.A

ll pa

nelis

ts in

clud

ing

Judg

e B

erzo

n, a

re fo

rmer

Sup

rem

e C

ourt

cler

ks.

Join

ing

Judg

e B

erzo

n w

ere

cons

titut

iona

l law

pro

fess

ors f

rom

U.C

. Ber

kele

y Sc

hool

of L

aw a

nd U

.C.

Has

tings

Col

lege

of t

he L

aw a

nd a

pra

ctiti

oner

. A

ttend

ance

was

off

ered

at n

o co

st to

judi

cial

cle

rks a

nd

law

stud

ents

. �

Sept

. 1 -

Din

ner p

rogr

am fe

atur

ing

a pr

esen

tatio

n by

Hon

. Vau

ghn

Wal

ker,

Chi

ef Ju

dge,

USD

C N

DC

A, o

n “C

amer

as in

the

Cou

rtroo

m:

Use

s and

Abu

ses.”

The

pro

gram

incl

uded

com

men

tary

on

the

rece

nt g

ay

mar

riage

cas

e ov

er w

hich

Judg

e W

alke

r pre

side

d.

�Se

pt. 2

1 - S

ixth

Ann

ual I

nfor

mal

Gat

herin

g of

the

Judg

es o

f the

nin

th C

ircui

t and

the

Fede

ral B

ar.

Info

rmal

din

ner e

vent

in lo

cal r

esta

uran

t for

Nin

th C

ircui

t and

USD

C N

DC

A Ju

dges

and

fede

ral

prac

titio

ners

.�

Sept

. 30

- Co-

spon

sor o

f rec

eptio

n fo

r the

indu

ctio

n of

the

Hon

. Luc

y K

oh, U

SDC

ND

CA

. �

Oct

. 18

- Pan

el d

iscu

ssio

n on

“Fe

dera

l hea

rings

: H

ow to

Adv

ance

You

r Cas

e at

dis

cove

ry C

onfe

renc

es a

nd

Cas

e M

anag

emen

t Con

fere

nces

,” fe

atur

ing

Hon

Cha

rles B

reye

r and

Hon

. Mag

istra

te Ju

dge

Laur

el B

eele

r, bo

th U

SDC

ND

CA

; eve

nt c

o-sp

onso

red

by Y

LD o

f our

cha

pter

and

Bar

Ass

ocia

tion

of S

an F

ranc

isco

B

arris

ters

’ Liti

gatio

n Se

ctio

n.

�N

ov,.

9 –

10 --

Nin

th C

ircui

t App

ella

te W

orks

hop.

Thi

s is a

two-

day

hand

s-on

wor

ksho

p on

app

ella

te

prac

tice

held

in c

onju

nctio

n w

ith th

e N

inth

Circ

uit A

ppel

late

Law

yer R

epre

sent

ativ

es a

nd le

d by

Judg

es

from

the

Nin

th C

ircui

t Cou

rt of

App

eals

and

exp

erie

nced

pra

ctiti

oner

s. �

Nov

. 15

- Pro

gram

on

“Mee

t the

Mag

istra

tes,”

feat

urin

g tw

o re

cent

ly a

ppoi

nted

US

Mag

istra

te Ju

dges

, U

SDC

ND

CA

, Jud

ges L

aure

l Bee

ler a

nd D

onna

Ryu

. �

Dec

. 2 -

Co-

spon

sor o

f rec

eptio

n fo

r the

swea

ring-

in o

f US

Mar

shal

Don

ald

O’K

eefe

.

Sacr

amen

to,

Cal

iforn

ia C

hapt

er

�Fo

r FB

A-S

acra

men

to, 2

010

mar

ked

the

end

of o

ne e

ra a

nd th

e be

ginn

ing

of m

any

othe

rs.

In Ju

ly, w

e w

itnes

sed

the

twen

tieth

and

fina

l edi

tion

of th

e an

nual

Sup

rem

e C

ourt

Yea

r-in

-Rev

iew

pro

gram

with

Pr

ofes

sor A

lan

Bro

wns

tein

of K

ing

Hal

l and

Pro

fess

or C

lark

Kel

so o

f Pac

ific-

McG

eorg

e. F

BA

-Sa

cram

ento

is e

norm

ousl

y gr

atef

ul fo

r the

Pro

fess

ors'

com

mitm

ent a

nd se

rvic

e fo

r the

pas

t tw

enty

yea

rs.

Alth

ough

we

are

sad

to se

e th

em g

o, w

e ar

e ve

ry p

leas

ed th

at th

e pr

ogra

m w

ill re

sum

e ne

xt y

ear w

ith

equa

lly st

ella

r spe

aker

s – n

amel

y, P

rofe

ssor

Vik

Am

ar o

f Kin

g H

all a

nd P

rofe

ssor

Les

lie Ja

cobs

of

McG

eorg

e.�

In N

ovem

ber,

FBA

-Sac

ram

ento

hos

ted

wha

t we

hope

will

be

the

first

of a

new

ann

ual e

vent

in S

acra

men

to

Page 22: Final CVP Chapter Activities Report for 2010 · : E-Discovery Seminar on November 10, 2010; Bankruptcy seminar on December 2, 2010; and a “brown bag” lunch on ethical issues &

Vic

e Pr

esid

ents

for t

he C

ircui

ts 2

010

Cha

pter

Eve

nts R

epor

t Ja

nuar

y 14

, 201

1

22

CIR

CU

ITC

HA

PTE

RE

VE

NT

S

– “A

Nig

ht to

Hon

or S

ervi

ce.”

Jud

ges S

hubb

and

Mue

ller h

elpe

d us

than

k th

e Ea

ster

n D

istri

ct’s

Pro

Bon

o Pa

nel a

nd to

reco

gniz

e th

e w

ork

that

it d

oes.

We

all k

now

that

the

fede

ral c

ourt

syst

em fu

nctio

ns le

ss th

an

optim

ally

whe

n pr

o se

litig

ants

are

left

to th

eir o

wn

devi

ces.

Thu

s, th

e ta

lent

ed la

wye

rs w

ho se

rve

on th

e Pr

o B

ono

Pane

l are

per

form

ing

a tre

men

dous

serv

ice

for t

he C

ourt

and

the

adve

rsar

ial p

roce

ss.

Rel

ated

ly,

on D

ecem

ber 7

th, F

BA

-Sac

ram

ento

hos

ted

a lu

nch

hour

eve

nt fo

r the

pur

pose

of t

rain

ing

and

recr

uitin

g at

torn

eys t

o jo

in th

e pr

o bo

no p

anel

.

San

Die

go,

Cal

iforn

ia C

hapt

er

�A

nnua

l Sta

te o

f the

Dis

tric

t Lun

cheo

n: T

he F

BA

’s a

nnua

l Sta

te o

f the

Dis

trict

Lun

cheo

n to

ok p

lace

on

Mar

ch 1

8, 2

010.

The

eve

nt e

njoy

ed a

reco

rd c

row

d, w

ith a

ppro

xim

atel

y 21

0 at

torn

eys,

judg

es, a

nd o

ther

gu

ests

in a

ttend

ance

. A

fter a

n in

trodu

ctio

n by

FB

A P

resi

dent

Ted

Fat

es, k

eyno

te sp

eake

r Chi

ef Ju

dge

Irm

a E.

Gon

zale

z de

liver

ed h

er si

xth

Stat

e of

the

Dis

trict

Add

ress

. Ju

dge

Bre

wst

er th

en in

trodu

ced

Cou

rt A

rchi

tect

Dav

id A

llen,

who

gav

e an

inte

rest

ing

and

deta

iled

pres

enta

tion

on th

e hi

stor

y of

the

fede

ral

cour

thou

se in

San

Die

go a

nd c

onst

ruct

ion

of th

e ne

w C

ourth

ouse

Ann

ex.

�O

pen

Doo

rs to

Fed

eral

Cou

rts:

The

FB

A h

elpe

d th

e C

ourt

spon

sor t

his a

nnua

l com

mun

ity o

utre

ach

prog

ram

on

Mar

ch 2

4, 2

010.

The

pro

gram

is d

esig

ned

to e

duca

te h

igh

scho

ol st

uden

ts re

gard

ing

the

oper

atio

ns a

nd fu

nctio

ns o

f the

fede

ral c

ourts

. Ea

ch g

roup

of s

tude

nts h

eard

a p

rese

ntat

ion

and

had

an

inte

ract

ive

disc

ussi

on w

ith a

dis

trict

cou

rt or

mag

istra

te ju

dge.

The

stud

ents

then

hea

rd a

pre

sent

atio

n an

d to

ok a

fun

pop

quiz

on

the

use

of c

redi

t car

ds a

nd e

stab

lishi

ng g

ood

cred

it w

ith a

mem

ber o

f the

Cre

dit

Abu

se R

esis

tanc

e Ed

ucat

ion

(CA

RE)

team

led

by R

etire

d B

ankr

uptc

y Ju

dge

John

J. H

argr

ove.

Fin

ally

, the

st

uden

ts h

eard

a se

ries o

f sho

rt pr

esen

tatio

ns fr

om v

ario

us c

ourt

pers

onne

l and

loca

l atto

rney

s abo

ut w

hat

thei

r job

s ent

ail,

and

the

train

ing

and

expe

rienc

e re

quire

d.�

Man

agin

g Pa

tent

Liti

gatio

n: V

iew

s fro

m th

e B

ench

and

Bar

: On

June

8, 2

010,

the

FBA

hos

ted

an

even

ing

prog

ram

in C

arm

el V

alle

y on

Pat

ent L

itiga

tion.

The

pan

el fe

atur

ed D

istri

ct Ju

dge

Dan

a M

. Sa

braw

, Mag

istra

te Ju

dge

Cat

hy A

. Ben

cive

ngo,

and

atto

rney

s Jua

nita

Bro

oks o

f Fis

h &

Ric

hard

son

and

Ran

dy K

ay o

f Jon

es D

ay.

The

pane

l dis

cuss

ed th

e Lo

cal R

ules

for p

aten

t cas

es, c

onsi

dera

tions

bef

ore

filin

g a

pate

nt c

ase,

ple

adin

g re

quire

men

ts, e

xper

t witn

esse

s, di

scov

ery,

tuto

rials

and

Mar

kman

hea

rings

, an

d tri

al.

The

pres

enta

tion

was

ver

y w

ell r

ecei

ved.

The

FB

A a

war

ded

our C

hapt

er a

Pre

side

ntia

l Cita

tion

Aw

ard

for t

his s

ucce

ssfu

l eve

nt.

�T

he In

ters

ectio

n of

Imm

igra

tion

and

Cri

min

al L

aw: O

n Ju

ly 1

4, 2

010,

the

FBA

hos

ted

an lu

ncht

ime

prog

ram

in th

e D

istri

ct C

onfe

renc

e C

ente

r on

the

Inte

rsec

tion

of Im

mig

ratio

n an

d C

rimin

al la

w.

The

pane

l fe

atur

ed D

istri

ct Ju

dge

Rog

er T

. Ben

itez,

Imm

igra

tion

Judg

e R

ico

J. B

arto

lom

ei, M

artin

D. S

oblic

k, C

hief

C

ouns

el fo

r Im

mig

ratio

n an

d C

usto

ms E

nfor

cem

ent's

San

Die

go o

ffic

e, a

nd w

ell-k

now

n im

mig

ratio

n pr

actit

ione

r Lili

a S.

Vel

aque

z. T

he p

anel

dis

cuss

ed th

e of

ten-

com

plex

issu

es th

at a

rise

whe

n an

alie

n is

co

nvic

ted

of a

stat

e or

fede

ral o

ffen

se, a

s wel

l as t

he p

roce

dura

l fra

mew

ork

thro

ugh

whi

ch fe

dera

l im

mig

ratio

n an

d di

stric

t cou

rts a

djud

icat

e im

mig

ratio

n-re

late

d is

sues

aris

ing

out o

f a c

rimin

al c

onvi

ctio

n.

Page 23: Final CVP Chapter Activities Report for 2010 · : E-Discovery Seminar on November 10, 2010; Bankruptcy seminar on December 2, 2010; and a “brown bag” lunch on ethical issues &

Vic

e Pr

esid

ents

for t

he C

ircui

ts 2

010

Cha

pter

Eve

nts R

epor

t Ja

nuar

y 14

, 201

1

23

CIR

CU

ITC

HA

PTE

RE

VE

NT

S

The

even

t dre

w a

subs

tant

ial c

row

d of

app

roxi

mat

ely

85 a

ttorn

eys.

�Si

xth

Ann

ual J

udith

N. K

eep

Fede

ral C

ivil

Prac

tice

Sem

inar

:O

n Se

ptem

ber 1

6, 2

010,

the

FBA

hos

ted

the

Sixt

h A

nnua

l Jud

ith N

. Kee

p Fe

dera

l Civ

il Pr

actic

e Se

min

ar.

The

orga

nizi

ng c

omm

ittee

for t

his y

ear’

s ev

ent w

as sp

earh

eade

d by

the

Hon

. Ant

hony

J. B

atta

glia

, the

Hon

. Jan

M. A

dler

, Hel

en Ir

za, F

BA

Pr

esid

ent T

ed F

ates

, Pre

side

nt-E

lect

Shi

reen

Bec

ker,

and

Imm

edia

te P

ast P

resi

dent

Alli

son

God

dard

. C

hief

Judg

e Ir

ma

E. G

onza

lez

gave

a w

arm

wel

com

e, n

otin

g Ju

dge

Kee

p's g

reat

impa

ct o

n th

e le

gal

prof

essi

on a

nd th

e So

uthe

rn D

istri

ct.

The

Judg

es o

f the

Sou

ther

n D

istri

ct o

nce

agai

n su

ppor

ted

the

prog

ram

with

ent

husi

asm

. Pr

esen

ters

incl

uded

Chi

ef Ju

dge

Irm

a E.

Gon

zale

z an

d Ju

dges

Mar

ilyn

Huf

f, M

. Ja

mes

Lor

enz,

Jeff

rey

T. M

iller

, Mic

hael

M. A

nello

, Dan

a M

. Sab

raw

, Lou

isa

S Po

rter,

Rub

en B

. Bro

oks,

Ant

hony

J. B

atta

glia

, Nita

L. S

torm

es, J

an M

. Adl

er, B

arba

ra L

. Maj

or, W

illia

m M

cCur

ine,

and

Cat

hy A

. B

enci

veng

o. H

elen

Irza

mod

erat

ed a

con

vers

atio

n w

ith C

lerk

of C

ourt

Sam

uel H

amric

k on

rece

nt

CM

/EC

F de

velo

pmen

ts a

nd u

sefu

l fili

ng ti

ps.

This

yea

r’s e

vent

feat

ured

vid

eota

ped

mem

oria

ls o

f Jud

ge

Kee

p fr

om c

lose

frie

nds V

irgin

ia N

elso

n, th

e H

on. L

ynn

Sche

nk a

nd B

rian

Mon

agha

n. E

very

one

was

ho

nore

d by

the

atte

ndan

ce o

f Jud

ge K

eep’

s dev

oted

hus

band

, Rus

ty B

lock

. Th

e se

min

ar c

oncl

uded

with

a

rece

ptio

n. T

he C

lerk

’s O

ffic

e st

aff a

lso

play

ed a

n in

stru

men

tal r

ole

in m

akin

g th

e ev

ent a

succ

ess.

�H

ow to

Set

tle Y

our

Cas

e on

App

eal i

n St

ate

or F

eder

al C

ourt

: On

Oct

ober

26,

201

0, th

e FB

A c

o-sp

onso

red

a pr

ogra

m e

ntitl

ed "

How

to S

ettle

You

r Cas

e on

App

eal i

n St

ate

or F

eder

al C

ourt"

with

the

App

ella

te C

ourt

Com

mitt

ee o

f the

San

Die

go C

ount

y B

ar A

ssoc

iatio

n. T

he p

rogr

am fe

atur

ed th

e H

onor

able

M. M

arga

ret M

cKeo

wn

of th

e N

inth

Circ

uit C

ourt

of A

ppea

ls a

nd th

e H

onor

able

Jam

es A

. M

cInt

yre

of th

e C

alifo

rnia

Cou

rt of

App

eal,

Four

th D

istri

ct, D

ivis

ion

One

, and

was

mod

erat

ed b

y at

torn

ey

Edw

ard

I. Si

lver

man

. Th

e pa

nelis

ts d

iscu

ssed

var

ious

exa

mpl

es o

f how

med

iatio

n ca

n re

solv

e co

mpl

icat

ed

appe

llate

cas

es, e

ven

afte

r ora

l arg

umen

t has

con

clud

ed, a

nd a

nsw

ered

tren

chan

t que

stio

ns p

osed

to th

em

by e

xper

ienc

ed st

ate

and

fede

ral a

ppel

late

pra

ctiti

oner

s reg

ardi

ng th

e N

inth

Circ

uit's

and

Fou

rth D

istri

ct

Cou

rt of

App

eals

' res

pect

ive

prog

ram

s. �

“Beh

ind

the

Scen

es”

Cou

rtho

use

Prog

ram

: The

FB

A h

oste

d its

ann

ual “

Beh

ind

the

Scen

es”

prog

ram

on

Oct

ober

15,

201

0. T

his p

rogr

am o

ffer

s a sp

ecia

l opp

ortu

nity

to le

arn

abou

t the

Sou

ther

n D

istri

ct’s

co

urth

ouse

ope

ratio

ns a

nd p

roce

dure

s in

a sm

all-g

roup

setti

ng.

Led

by F

BA

Boa

rd m

embe

r Kat

ie P

arke

r, ap

prox

imat

ely

twen

ty a

ttend

ees b

egan

at t

he C

lerk

’s O

ffic

e fo

r a to

ur a

nd p

rese

ntat

ion

by C

lerk

of C

ourt

Sam

Ham

rick

and

Chi

ef D

eput

y of

Ope

ratio

ns Jo

hn M

orril

l. M

agis

trate

Judg

e B

enci

veng

o th

en sp

oke

with

the

grou

p ab

out t

he ro

le o

f the

Mag

istra

te Ju

dges

. Th

e pr

ogra

m c

oncl

uded

with

a v

isit

to C

hief

Judg

e G

onza

lez’

s cha

mbe

rs a

nd c

ourtr

oom

and

a q

uest

ion-

and-

answ

er se

ssio

n w

ith th

e C

hief

Judg

e.

�B

row

n B

ag L

unch

Ser

ies:

The

FB

A c

ontin

ued

to c

o-ho

st a

Bro

wn

Bag

Lun

ch S

erie

s with

the

Ass

ocia

tion

of B

usin

ess T

rial L

awye

rs a

nd th

e Li

tigat

ion

Sect

ion

of th

e St

ate

Bar

. Th

ese

even

ts fe

atur

e in

form

al

disc

ussi

ons w

ith ju

dges

and

thei

r law

cle

rks r

egar

ding

thei

r cha

mbe

r rul

es, c

ourtr

oom

pro

cedu

res,

and

Page 24: Final CVP Chapter Activities Report for 2010 · : E-Discovery Seminar on November 10, 2010; Bankruptcy seminar on December 2, 2010; and a “brown bag” lunch on ethical issues &

Vic

e Pr

esid

ents

for t

he C

ircui

ts 2

010

Cha

pter

Eve

nts R

epor

t Ja

nuar

y 14

, 201

1

24

CIR

CU

ITC

HA

PTE

RE

VE

NT

S

rela

ted

topi

cs.

In 2

010,

the

Bro

wn

Bag

Lun

ch S

erie

s fea

ture

d Ju

dges

Will

iam

H. G

allo

(Mar

ch 2

3), J

effr

ey

T. M

iller

(Jul

y 21

), an

d B

erna

rd S

kom

al (N

ovem

ber 1

7).

Each

was

a w

ell-a

ttend

ed, i

nfor

mat

ive

even

t. �

Hol

iday

Law

Cle

rk R

ecep

tion:

The

FB

A w

rapp

ed u

p its

pro

gram

min

g ye

ar o

n D

ecem

ber 2

, 201

0, w

ith

its tr

aditi

onal

Hol

iday

Rec

eptio

n ho

norin

g th

e ne

w a

nd re

turn

ing

law

cle

rks o

f the

Sou

ther

n D

istri

ct.

The

rece

ptio

n to

ok p

lace

at A

then

s Mar

ket a

nd a

lso

serv

ed a

s the

FB

A’s

ann

ual m

embe

rshi

p m

eetin

g. A

s us

ual,

this

eve

nt w

as a

cel

ebra

tion

of th

e co

llegi

al sp

irit t

hat p

erva

des t

he fe

dera

l ben

ch a

nd b

ar in

San

D

iego

.�

San

Die

go C

hapt

er to

Hos

t 201

2 FB

A N

atio

nal M

eetin

g an

d C

onve

ntio

n: T

he C

hapt

er h

as a

gree

d to

ho

st th

e 20

12 F

BA

Nat

iona

l Mee

ting

and

Con

vent

ion

in S

an D

iego

. W

e ha

ve fo

rmed

a C

onve

ntio

n Pl

anni

ng C

omm

ittee

that

is b

egin

ning

to o

rgan

ize

CLE

and

soci

al a

ctiv

ities

for t

he C

onve

ntio

n. T

he

Con

vent

ion

is se

t to

take

pla

ce S

epte

mbe

r 19-

23, 2

012.

We

look

forw

ard

to h

ostin

g ot

her F

BA

mem

bers

in

Am

eric

a’s F

ines

t City

, and

hig

hlig

htin

g th

e w

ork

and

acco

mpl

ishm

ents

of t

he S

outh

ern

Dis

trict

.

Los A

ngel

es,

Cal

iforn

ia C

hapt

er

�C

hapt

er P

ro B

ono

Act

iviti

es: T

he C

hapt

er h

as b

egun

pla

cing

con

tact

info

rmat

ion

on o

ur w

ebsi

te fo

r loc

al

reco

gniz

ed p

ro b

ono

orga

niza

tions

; we

also

are

wor

king

with

the

Dis

trict

Cou

rt to

org

aniz

e tra

inin

g fo

r at

torn

eys i

n pr

ivat

e pr

actic

e to

par

ticip

ate

in th

e C

ourt’

s pro

bon

o ac

tiviti

es, i

nclu

ding

Sec

tion

1983

cas

es,

pro

bono

civ

il lit

igan

t clin

ic, a

ltern

ativ

e di

sput

e re

solu

tion,

and

ban

krup

tcy

clin

ic.

�C

ourt

hous

e A

ttor

ney

Lou

nge

Plaq

ue P

roje

ct:

The

Cha

pter

has

rece

ived

per

mis

sion

from

the

Cou

rt to

pl

ace

awar

ds p

rese

nted

to th

e C

hapt

er in

the

atto

rney

’s lo

unge

s at t

he D

istri

ct C

ourth

ouse

. W

e ar

e in

the

proc

ess o

f col

lect

ing

the

awar

ds fr

om p

ast p

resi

dent

s so

that

they

can

by

hung

in th

e co

urth

ouse

loun

ges.

�N

ovem

ber

3, 2

010

- Law

Cle

rk’s

Rec

eptio

n: A

nnua

l eve

nt, h

oste

d by

the

Cha

pter

for f

eder

al c

lerk

s, bo

th d

istri

ct a

nd c

ircui

t and

the

resp

ectiv

e ju

dges

for w

hom

they

are

cle

rkin

g. T

he e

vent

is h

eld

at th

e D

istri

ct C

ourt

and

this

yea

r we

had

a tre

men

dous

turn

out.

�D

ecem

ber

3, 2

010

– 7th

Ann

ual B

ankr

uptc

y Et

hics

: Ano

ther

ann

ual e

vent

, whi

ch is

a h

alf-

day

prog

ram

ar

rang

ed w

ith th

e B

ankr

uptc

y C

ourt

and

priv

ate

atto

rney

s to

prov

ide

adva

nced

eth

ics t

rain

ing.

Upc

omin

g Pr

ogra

ms &

Pro

ject

s: S

tate

of t

he C

ircu

it/D

istr

ict:

Ann

ual e

vent

at w

hich

the

Chi

ef Ju

dges

of

the

Nin

th C

ircui

t, C

entra

l Dis

trict

of C

alifo

rnia

, and

Ban

krup

tcy

Cou

rt pr

ovid

e co

mm

ents

and

insi

ghts

on

the

stat

e of

issu

es c

onfr

ontin

g ea

ch c

ourt;

IP P

rogr

am: I

n pl

anni

ng st

ages

and

mos

t lik

ely

will

add

ress

le

gal i

ssue

s dea

ling

with

soci

al n

etw

orki

ng.

Pane

l will

incl

ude

IP a

ttorn

eys,

Dis

trict

Cou

rt Ju

dge

and

in-

hous

e co

unse

l; Ju

dici

al R

ecep

tion

at C

ity H

all:

Ann

ual r

ecep

tion

held

at L

A C

ity H

all f

or th

e N

inth

C

ircui

t and

Dis

trict

Cou

rt Ju

dges

; App

ella

te P

rogr

am: P

rogr

am h

eld

ever

y ot

her y

ear a

s a tr

aini

ng

prog

ram

for p

rivat

e at

torn

eys i

nter

este

d in

app

ella

te w

ork.

Writ

ten

hypo

thet

ical

dis

tribu

ted

to p

artic

ipan

ts,

who

pre

pare

a b

rief a

nd p

rese

nt o

ral a

rgum

ent t

o a

pane

l of N

inth

Circ

uit J

udge

s; N

ew C

alifo

rnia

Rul

es o

f Pr

ofes

sion

al C

ondu

ct:

Prop

osed

pro

gram

to p

rovi

de im

med

iate

trai

ning

whe

n th

e N

ew C

alifo

rnia

Rul

es

of P

rofe

ssio

nal C

ondu

ct a

re a

dopt

ed; T

akin

g th

e St

ep: A

nnua

l ½ d

ay tr

aini

ng p

rogr

am fo

r you

ng

Page 25: Final CVP Chapter Activities Report for 2010 · : E-Discovery Seminar on November 10, 2010; Bankruptcy seminar on December 2, 2010; and a “brown bag” lunch on ethical issues &

Vic

e Pr

esid

ents

for t

he C

ircui

ts 2

010

Cha

pter

Eve

nts R

epor

t Ja

nuar

y 14

, 201

1

25

CIR

CU

ITC

HA

PTE

RE

VE

NT

S

atto

rney

s who

wou

ld li

ke to

dev

elop

a c

ivil

fede

ral p

ract

ice;

Imm

igra

tion

Com

plia

nce

& E

nfor

cem

ent:

In p

lann

ing

stag

es; J

udic

ial B

row

n B

ag L

unch

es: S

mal

l gro

up lu

nche

s with

Dis

trict

Cou

rt an

d M

agis

trate

Ju

dges

, hel

d in

the

cour

troom

to p

rovi

de y

oung

er a

ttorn

eys w

ith p

erso

nal c

onta

ct w

ith th

e ju

dges

; M

ento

rshi

p: F

BA

Boa

rd m

embe

rs a

re p

aire

d w

ith y

oung

er a

ttorn

eys i

n th

e ar

ea w

ho a

re in

tere

sted

in

deve

lopi

ng a

fede

ral p

ract

ice;

Ban

krup

tcy

Ora

l His

tory

Pro

ject

: Th

e C

hapt

er is

org

aniz

ing

train

ing

to

initi

ate

an o

ral h

isto

ry p

roje

ct.

O

rang

e C

ount

y,

Cal

iforn

ia C

hapt

er

�A

nnua

l Jud

ges N

ight

Din

ner:

Prog

ram

hon

orin

g th

e Ju

dges

of t

he C

entra

l Dis

trict

with

pre

sent

atio

n of

the

FBA

/OC

's A

nnua

l Jud

ge S

totle

r Aw

ard.

Alm

ost 4

00 a

ttend

ees.

Oct

ober

, 201

0, Ir

vine

, CA

. �

Pro

Bon

o Lu

nche

on -

iden

tifie

d fe

dera

l pro

bon

o op

portu

nitie

s for

law

yers

. N

ovem

ber 2

010,

Cos

ta M

esa,

C

A.

�A

nnua

l Crim

inal

Eve

nt o

n cy

bers

pace

law

issu

es fo

r crim

inal

law

yers

. C

osta

Mes

a, N

ovem

ber 2

010,

A

bout

100

atte

ndee

s �

Ann

ual C

ivil

Sem

inar

Pro

gram

on

prel

imin

ary

rem

edie

s in

the

fede

ral c

ourts

. Ir

vine

, CA

, Ove

r 200

at

tend

ees

�A

nnua

l Int

elle

ctua

l Pro

perty

Pro

gram

: one

-day

eve

nt o

n pa

tent

law

at t

he n

ew U

C la

w sc

hool

in Ir

vine

, C

alifo

rnia

�B

ench

& B

ar L

unch

eon

1: J

udge

Sel

na sp

oke

on p

ract

ical

do'

s and

don

'ts.

Abo

ut 2

00 p

eopl

e at

tend

ed.

June

201

0, C

osta

Mes

a �

Ben

ch &

Bar

Lun

cheo

n 2:

Judg

e G

uilfo

rd sp

oke

on p

ract

ical

writ

ing

tips.

Abo

ut 2

00 p

rese

nt.

July

201

0,

Cos

ta M

esa

�B

ehin

d th

e W

indo

ws -

an

even

t foc

used

on

the

Cle

rk's

offic

e w

ith b

ehin

d th

e sc

enes

info

rmat

ion

abou

t how

th

e C

lerk

s Off

ice

oper

ates

Swea

ring-

in C

erem

ony

for n

ew b

ar a

dmitt

ees

�B

ill o

f Rig

hts P

rogr

am --

atto

rney

s tea

ch h

igh

scho

ol st

uden

ts a

bout

the

Bill

of R

ight

s. S

epte

mbe

r, D

ecem

ber 2

010.

Inla

nd E

mpi

re,

Cal

iforn

ia C

hapt

er

�Ja

nuar

y 22

, 201

0 --

Ann

ual M

eetin

g, O

ffic

er In

stal

latio

n, a

nd Ju

dges

App

reci

atio

n D

inne

r at t

he M

issi

on

Inn

in R

iver

side

. W

e in

stal

led

our n

ew o

ffic

ers f

or th

e 20

10 te

rm a

nd h

eard

a sp

eech

by

Jam

es B

rosn

ahan

en

title

d "I

n D

efen

se o

f Jud

ges:

Why

Eve

ry Ju

dge

is a

n A

ctiv

ist J

udge

" �

Febr

uary

24,

201

0 --

"20

10 A

nnua

l Fed

eral

Civ

il Pr

actic

e Se

min

ar"

pres

ente

d by

Judg

es V

irgin

ia P

hilli

ps,

Osw

ald

Para

da, a

nd D

avid

Bris

tow

, mod

erat

ed b

y K

enda

ll M

acV

ey.

Hel

d at

the

Cou

rthou

se

�M

arch

24,

201

0 --

"O

rigin

al Ju

risdi

ctio

n in

the

U.S

. Sup

rem

e C

ourt"

by

Rod

eric

k W

alst

on.

Hel

d at

the

Cou

rthou

se�

Apr

il 21

, 201

0 --

"Th

e N

uts a

nd B

olts

of P

ro S

e Li

tigat

ion"

by

Hon

. Osw

ald

Para

da, T

om B

uck,

Ter

esa

Page 26: Final CVP Chapter Activities Report for 2010 · : E-Discovery Seminar on November 10, 2010; Bankruptcy seminar on December 2, 2010; and a “brown bag” lunch on ethical issues &

Vic

e Pr

esid

ents

for t

he C

ircui

ts 2

010

Cha

pter

Eve

nts R

epor

t Ja

nuar

y 14

, 201

1

26

CIR

CU

ITC

HA

PTE

RE

VE

NT

S

McG

owan

, and

Jane

t Lew

is.

Hel

d at

the

Cou

rthou

se

�M

ay 2

5, 2

010

-- "

Elev

enth

Ann

ual C

onst

itutio

nal L

aw F

orum

" by

Dea

n Er

win

Che

mer

insk

y, a

nd

pres

enta

tion

of th

e 20

10 E

rwin

Che

mer

insk

y D

efen

der o

f the

Con

stitu

tion

Aw

ard.

Hel

d at

the

San

Ber

nard

ino

Hilt

on

�Ju

ne 8

, 201

0 --

New

-atto

rney

adm

issi

on c

erem

ony

at th

e C

ourth

ouse

. Ju

dges

Virg

inia

Phi

llips

, Osw

ald

Para

da, a

nd D

avid

Bris

tow

(all

mem

bers

of o

ur B

oard

) ind

ucte

d ne

w a

ttorn

eys i

nto

the

bar o

f the

Cen

tral

Dis

trict

of C

alifo

rnia

June

23,

201

0 --

"W

hat M

akes

a 'L

awye

r's Ju

stic

e?'

A P

anel

Dis

cuss

ion

Abo

ut th

e Q

ualit

ies T

hat

Prac

titio

ners

Wou

ld L

ike

to S

ee in

a U

.S. S

upre

me

Cou

rt Ju

stic

e" fe

atur

ing

Laur

ie L

even

son

and

Tim

othy

C

oate

s. H

eld

at th

e C

ourth

ouse

Sept

embe

r 22,

201

0 --

A re

cept

ion

hono

ring

And

re B

irotte

, Jr.,

U.S

. Atto

rney

for t

he C

entra

l Dis

trict

of

Cal

iforn

ia�

Nov

embe

r 10,

201

0 --

"A

ltern

ativ

e D

ispu

te R

esol

utio

n in

the

Dis

trict

Cou

rt: A

Dis

cuss

ion

of th

e Pr

oced

ures

Ava

ilabl

e to

Get

You

r Cas

e Se

ttled

!" H

eld

at th

e C

ourth

ouse

and

pre

sent

ed b

y G

ail K

illife

r, A

DR

Pro

gram

Dire

ctor

for t

he C

entra

l Dis

trict

of C

alifo

rnia

Dec

embe

r 9, 2

010

-- N

ew-a

ttorn

ey a

dmis

sion

cer

emon

y at

the

Cou

rthou

se.

Judg

e D

avid

Bris

tow

indu

cted

13

new

atto

rney

s int

o th

e ba

r of t

he C

entra

l Dis

trict

of C

alifo

rnia

.

Mon

tana

Cha

pter

In 2

010,

MT

Cha

pter

hel

d br

own

bag

lunc

h di

scus

sion

in M

isso

ula

with

Judg

e D

on M

ollo

y, M

agis

trate

Je

rry

Lync

h, a

nd n

ew U

S A

ttorn

ey M

ike

Cot

ter.

N

evad

a C

hapt

er

�Fe

brua

ry 1

9, 2

010:

Wel

com

e re

cept

ion

for t

he H

onor

able

Rob

ert C

. Jon

es, U

nite

d St

ates

Dis

trict

Judg

e,

Dis

trict

of N

evad

a, to

the

unof

ficia

l Nor

ther

n D

ivis

ion

�Fe

brua

ry 2

2, 2

010:

Wes

t Alle

n pr

esen

ted

a co

ngra

tula

tory

lette

r to

Judg

e G

eorg

e on

beh

alf o

f the

FB

A fo

r hi

s 80t

h "b

irthd

ay p

arty

."

�A

pril

29, 2

010:

Ann

ual C

hapt

er D

inne

r, he

ld a

t the

con

clus

ion

of th

e U

.S.D

.C. f

or th

e D

istri

ct o

f Nev

ada's

an

nual

con

fere

nce.

Our

feat

ured

spea

ker w

as L

arry

A. M

acke

y, a

par

tner

in B

arne

s & T

horn

burg

's In

dian

apol

is, I

ndia

na o

ffic

e, c

once

ntra

tes o

n w

hite

col

lar c

rime

defe

nse

and

com

plex

litig

atio

n. M

r. M

acke

y w

orke

d as

a fe

dera

l pro

secu

tor f

or e

ight

een

year

s and

as a

stat

e pr

osec

utor

for t

hree

yea

rs.

He

conc

lude

d hi

s Dep

artm

ent o

f Jus

tice

serv

ice

on th

e pr

osec

utio

n te

am re

spon

sibl

e fo

r the

con

vict

ions

of t

he

Okl

ahom

a C

ity b

ombi

ng d

efen

dant

s. M

r. M

acke

y tri

ed b

oth

case

s and

del

iver

ed th

e pr

osec

utio

n's c

losi

ng

argu

men

t in

U.S

. v. T

imot

hy M

cVei

gh .

Mr.

Mac

key

gave

a p

ower

pre

sent

atio

n on

the

evid

ence

as

sem

bled

for t

he O

klah

oma

City

bom

bing

tria

ls.

�A

ugus

t 6, 2

010:

Rec

eptio

n fo

r new

ly a

ppoi

nted

Dis

trict

Cou

rt Ju

dge,

the

Hon

orab

le G

loria

Nav

arro

.

Page 27: Final CVP Chapter Activities Report for 2010 · : E-Discovery Seminar on November 10, 2010; Bankruptcy seminar on December 2, 2010; and a “brown bag” lunch on ethical issues &

Vic

e Pr

esid

ents

for t

he C

ircui

ts 2

010

Cha

pter

Eve

nts R

epor

t Ja

nuar

y 14

, 201

1

27

CIR

CU

ITC

HA

PTE

RE

VE

NT

S

�Se

ptem

ber 1

5, 2

010:

U.S

. Sup

rem

e C

ourt

adm

issi

on c

erem

ony,

con

duct

ed b

y G

ener

al W

illia

m K

. Sut

er,

Cle

rk o

f the

Uni

ted

Stat

es S

upre

me

Cou

rt. G

ener

al S

uter

als

o pr

esen

ted

a br

ief p

rogr

am o

n th

e Su

prem

e C

ourt'

s his

tory

. 10

th C

ircui

t U

tah

Cha

pter

The

Uta

h C

hapt

er h

eld

its a

nnua

l Ron

ald

N. B

oyce

Fed

eral

Cou

rt Li

tigat

ion

Prac

tice

Sem

inar

aga

in th

is

year

, fea

turin

g pr

esen

tatio

ns b

y ne

arly

all

our l

ocal

fede

ral j

udge

s, ba

nkru

ptcy

judg

es a

nd m

agis

trate

s.

This

yea

r's sp

eake

rs in

clud

ed C

hief

Judg

e Te

na C

ampb

ell,

Dis

trict

Cou

rt Ju

dges

Dee

Ben

son,

Dal

e K

imba

ll, T

ed S

tew

art,

Cla

rk W

addo

ups a

nd B

ruce

Jenk

ins,

Ban

krup

tcy

Judg

es W

illia

m T

hurm

an a

nd Jo

el

T. M

arke

r, an

d M

agis

trate

Judg

es S

am A

lba,

Bro

oke

Wel

ls a

nd P

aul W

arne

r. W

e ha

d 14

0 at

tend

ees a

t the

ev

ent,

and

our l

unch

time

spea

ker w

as P

rofe

ssor

Jim

Hol

broo

k, o

n Le

sson

s fro

m Ir

aq:

Ref

lect

ions

on

the

Rul

e of

Law

.�

The

Uta

h C

hapt

er h

oste

d its

Thi

rd A

nnua

l Sou

ther

n U

tah

Fede

ral L

aw S

ympo

sium

, whi

ch a

ttrac

ted

reco

rd

atte

ndan

ce a

nd fe

atur

ed M

agis

trate

Judg

es P

aul M

. War

ner

and

Rob

ert T

. Bra

ithw

aite

, as w

ell a

s U.S

. B

ankr

uptc

y C

ourt

Judg

e W

illia

m T

hurm

an a

nd H

on. W

illia

m N

ixon

from

the

U.S

. Im

mig

ratio

n C

ourt.

We

field

ed a

ppro

xim

atel

y 80

atte

ndee

s and

sign

ed u

p ne

w m

embe

rs fr

om S

outh

ern

Uta

h�

Thi

s yea

r the

Uta

h C

hapt

er a

gain

hos

ted

its fo

urth

ann

ual C

rimin

al L

aw S

emin

ar w

ith th

e su

ppor

t of o

ur

loca

l fed

eral

judg

es.

The

Sem

inar

feat

ured

pre

sent

atio

ns b

y D

istri

ct C

ourt

Judg

es D

ale

A. K

imba

ll an

d C

lark

Wad

doup

s and

man

y pr

omin

ent l

ocal

pra

ctiti

oner

s.�

The

Uta

h C

hapt

er h

oste

d th

e Si

xth

Ann

ual T

ri-St

ate

Sem

inar

in S

epte

mbe

r in

Park

City

, whi

ch fe

atur

ed

elev

en fe

dera

l jud

ges f

rom

Uta

h, Id

aho

and

Wyo

min

g. S

peak

ers i

nclu

ded

Chi

ef D

istri

ct C

ourt

Judg

es B

. Ly

nn W

inm

ill a

nd W

illia

m D

owne

s; D

istri

ct C

ourt

Judg

es D

ee B

enso

n, D

ale

A. K

imba

ll, a

nd C

lark

W

addo

ups;

and

Mag

istra

te Ju

dges

Dav

id N

uffe

r, La

rry

Boy

le, a

nd W

illia

m B

eam

an, a

s wel

l as t

he c

lerk

s of

cou

rt fo

r the

Dis

trict

s of U

tah,

Idah

o an

d W

yom

ing,

and

four

car

eer l

aw c

lerk

s fro

m e

ach

of th

e di

stric

ts

as w

ell.

�Th

e U

tah

Cha

pter

aga

in h

oste

d ou

r ser

ies o

f lun

chtim

e C

LE p

rogr

ams c

alle

d "S

ide

Bar

Lun

cheo

ns"

feat

urin

g ou

r loc

al fe

dera

l jud

ges.

This

yea

r's sp

eake

rs h

ave

incl

uded

Dis

trict

Cou

rt Ju

dge

Tena

Cam

pbel

l an

d Ju

dge

Dee

Ben

son,

bot

h on

tria

l ski

lls, w

hich

was

one

of o

ur th

emes

for t

his y

ear.

�Th

e U

tah

Cha

pter

just

hel

d its

Ann

ual A

war

ds D

inne

r, w

hich

hon

ors a

fede

ral j

udge

for h

is o

r her

serv

ice

to th

e fe

dera

l cou

rts.

This

yea

r's h

onor

ee w

as U

nite

d St

ates

Dis

trict

Cou

rt Ju

dge

Dal

e A

. Kim

ball,

who

has

se

rved

as t

he U

tah

Cha

pter

's ju

dici

al li

aiso

n fo

r 14

year

s. W

e al

so h

onor

ed A

ss't

US

Atto

rney

Dav

id

Schw

endi

man

for h

is w

ork

pros

ecut

ing

war

crim

inal

s in

the

Inte

rnat

iona

l Crim

inal

Cou

rt in

Bos

nia

and

Her

zego

vina

, and

Jane

t Hug

ie S

mith

, a 3

0 ye

ar e

mpl

oym

ent l

itiga

tor,

mem

ber o

f the

AC

TL, a

nd o

ne o

f the

"f

irst 1

00"

Uta

h w

omen

to b

e la

wye

rs.

�A

s par

t of t

he C

hapt

er's

Pro

Bon

o Pr

ojec

t, th

e U

tah

Cha

pter

inst

itute

d th

e "H

ELP

RIS

E" p

ro b

ono

prog

ram

, w

hich

pai

rs u

nem

ploy

ed la

wye

rs w

ith C

LE tr

aini

ng, a

men

tor,

and

then

ass

igns

them

to p

rovi

de p

ro b

ono

Page 28: Final CVP Chapter Activities Report for 2010 · : E-Discovery Seminar on November 10, 2010; Bankruptcy seminar on December 2, 2010; and a “brown bag” lunch on ethical issues &

Vic

e Pr

esid

ents

for t

he C

ircui

ts 2

010

Cha

pter

Eve

nts R

epor

t Ja

nuar

y 14

, 201

1

28

CIR

CU

ITC

HA

PTE

RE

VE

NT

S

lega

l ser

vice

s to

parti

cipa

nts i

n th

e D

istri

ct o

f Uta

h's R

ISE

men

tal h

ealth

and

dru

g re

entry

cou

rt pr

ogra

m,

one

of th

e on

ly o

nes o

f its

kin

d in

the

coun

try.

The

Cha

pter

rece

ived

the

Ilene

and

Mic

hael

Sha

w P

ublic

Se

rvic

e G

rant

for t

he p

roje

ct.

�O

ur Y

oung

Law

yer L

iais

on a

nd o

ur F

eder

al C

lerk

's O

ffic

e Li

aiso

n ho

sted

a lu

ncht

ime

CLE

for n

ew

law

yers

and

thei

r men

tors

at t

he fe

dera

l cou

rthou

se e

ntitl

ed, "

Intro

duct

ion

to th

e Fe

dera

l Cou

rt: A

Pro

gram

fo

r New

Atto

rney

s and

thei

r Men

tors

." T

he n

ew p

rogr

am in

clud

ed fi

ve b

rief p

rese

ntat

ions

from

Mag

istra

te

Judg

e B

rook

e C

. Wel

ls a

nd Ju

dge

Dal

e A

. Kim

ball.

The

Uta

h St

ate

Bar

is o

ne o

f onl

y a

hand

ful o

f ju

risdi

ctio

ns in

the

US

that

is re

quiri

ng n

ew a

dmitt

ees t

o be

pai

red

with

men

tor a

ttorn

eys,

and

the

FBA

U

tah

Cha

pter

pro

vide

d th

is v

alua

ble

prog

ram

whi

ch q

ualif

ied

for t

heir

men

tor/m

ente

e C

LE re

quire

d tra

inin

g ho

urs.

�Fi

nally

, thi

s yea

r, th

e U

tah

Cha

pter

par

tner

ed w

ith in

com

ing

Chi

ef Ju

dge

Ted

Stew

art a

nd th

e D

istri

ct o

f U

tah

to a

utho

r a su

rvey

of f

eder

al p

ract

ition

ers a

bout

thei

r exp

erie

nces

, goo

d an

d ba

d, in

the

fede

ral c

ourt.

The

surv

ey w

as c

ompl

eted

by

mor

e th

an 6

00 la

wye

rs a

nd Ju

dge

Stew

art p

rese

nted

the

resu

lts a

t the

Ron

ald

N. B

oyce

Sem

inar

. Pa

st P

resi

dent

Jon

Haf

en a

nd B

oard

Mem

ber a

nd A

ss't

Cle

rk o

f Cou

rt Lo

uise

Yor

k w

ere

inst

rum

enta

l in

prep

arin

g th

e su

rvey

.

Okl

ahom

a C

ity

Cha

pter

�Fe

brua

ry 1

8, 2

010

-- T

hird

Thu

rsda

y Lu

nche

on –

with

Ban

krup

tcy

Judg

es N

iles J

acks

on o

f the

Wes

tern

D

istri

ct o

f Okl

ahom

a.

Each

“Th

ird T

hurs

day

Lunc

heon

” w

as in

form

al a

nd li

mite

d to

20

atte

ndee

s. T

he

casu

al lu

nche

ons f

acili

tate

can

did

conv

ersa

tions

bet

wee

n at

tend

ees a

nd ju

dges

. �

Mar

ch 1

8, 2

010

-- T

hird

Thu

rsda

y Lu

nche

on w

ith Ju

dge

Will

iam

J. H

ollo

way

, Jr.

of th

e U

.S. C

ourt

of

App

eals

for t

he T

enth

Circ

uit.

�A

pril

1, 2

010

– Le

gal S

ecre

tary

/Par

aleg

al S

emin

ar.

The

chap

ter s

pons

ored

a h

alf-

day

sem

inar

for l

egal

se

cret

arie

s and

par

aleg

als i

nvol

ved

with

fede

ral c

ourt

prac

tice.

The

sem

inar

exp

oses

atte

ndee

s to

Cou

rthou

se p

erso

nnel

and

loca

l Cou

rt pr

oced

ures

. �

Apr

il 15

, 201

0 –

Third

Thu

rsda

y Lu

nche

on w

ith Ju

dge

Step

hen

Frio

t of t

he W

este

rn D

istri

ct o

f Okl

ahom

a.

�A

pril

27, 2

010

– Ju

dici

al R

ecep

tion

Hon

orin

g th

e Fe

dera

l Jud

ges o

f the

Wes

tern

Dis

trict

of O

klah

oma

and

the

Tent

h C

ircui

t, an

nual

Judi

cial

Rec

eptio

n to

hon

or th

e lo

cal f

eder

al ju

dici

ary.

The

rece

ptio

n in

clud

ed a

“S

tate

of t

he C

ourt”

add

ress

from

Chi

ef Ju

dge

Vic

ki M

iles-

LaG

rang

e, a

nd a

“Fi

resi

de C

hat”

with

out

goin

g C

hief

Judg

e R

ober

t H. H

enry

of t

he U

.S. C

ourt

of A

ppea

ls fo

r the

Ten

th C

ircui

t. �

May

20,

201

0 –

Third

Thu

rsda

y Lu

nche

on w

ith Ju

dge

Rob

in C

auth

ron

of th

e W

este

rn D

istri

ct o

f O

klah

oma.

May

26,

201

0 –

Ban

krup

tcy

“Sm

ackd

own”

III –

a lu

ncht

ime

CLE

pro

gram

to d

iscu

ss c

urre

nt b

ankr

uptc

y is

sues

. �

May

27,

201

0 –

New

Adm

ittee

Pro

gram

for t

he U

.S. D

istri

ct C

ourt

for t

he W

este

rn D

istri

ct o

f Oka

laho

ma.

Page 29: Final CVP Chapter Activities Report for 2010 · : E-Discovery Seminar on November 10, 2010; Bankruptcy seminar on December 2, 2010; and a “brown bag” lunch on ethical issues &

Vic

e Pr

esid

ents

for t

he C

ircui

ts 2

010

Cha

pter

Eve

nts R

epor

t Ja

nuar

y 14

, 201

1

29

CIR

CU

ITC

HA

PTE

RE

VE

NT

S

The

You

ng L

awye

rs C

hairs

and

cha

pter

mem

bers

coo

rdin

ated

the

afte

rnoo

n pr

ogra

m a

nd re

cept

ion

for n

ew

adm

ittee

s. �

June

17,

201

0 –

Third

Thu

rsda

y Lu

nche

on –

with

Judg

e Jo

e H

eato

n of

the

Wes

tern

Dis

trict

of O

klah

oma.

June

29,

201

0 –

Sum

mer

Cou

rthou

se T

our –

of t

he fe

dera

l cou

rthou

se fo

r sum

mer

law

cle

rks.

Stud

ents

met

w

ith ju

dges

and

cou

rthou

se st

aff t

o le

arn

mor

e ab

out f

eder

al p

ract

ice.

June

29,

201

0 –

“The

Life

and

Wor

k of

Just

ice

John

Pau

l Ste

vens

.” –

Pro

fess

or Jo

e Th

ai, a

form

er la

w

cler

k of

Just

ice

Stev

ens,

pres

ente

d a

one-

hour

CLE

revi

ewin

g th

e lif

e an

d ju

rispr

uden

ce o

f the

retir

ing

Just

ice.

July

17,

201

0 –

Third

Thu

rsda

y Lu

nche

on w

ith Ju

dge

Tim

DeG

iust

i of t

he W

este

rn D

istri

ct o

f Okl

ahom

a.

�Ju

ly 2

6, 2

010

– FB

A S

umm

er Y

outh

Pro

gram

– th

e ch

apte

r arr

ange

d fo

r thi

rty fi

fth-g

rade

stud

ents

(fro

m

loca

l non

-pro

fit re

adin

g en

richm

ent p

rogr

am) t

o co

me

to th

e C

ourth

ouse

. Ins

ide

a co

urtro

om, t

he st

uden

ts

read

out

a m

ock

pers

onal

-inju

ry tr

ial i

nvol

ving

Hum

pty

Dum

pty;

oth

er st

uden

ts w

ere

juro

rs.

The

stud

ents

al

so h

eard

from

Chi

ef Ju

dge

Vic

ki M

iles-

LaG

rang

e, o

ur U

.S. M

arsh

al’s

Off

ice,

and

U.S

. Pro

batio

n O

ffic

e.

�A

ugus

t 19,

201

0 –

Third

Thu

rsda

y Lu

nche

on w

ith Ju

dge

Rob

ert B

acha

rach

of t

he W

este

rn D

istri

ct o

f O

klah

oma.

Sept

embe

r 16,

201

0 –

Third

Thu

rsda

y Lu

nche

on w

ith Ju

dge

Jero

me

Hol

mes

of t

he U

.S. C

ourt

of A

ppea

ls

for t

he T

enth

Circ

uit.

�Se

ptem

ber 2

3-25

, 201

0 –

Ann

ual F

BA

Con

vent

ion

in N

ew O

rlean

s �

Sept

embe

r 27,

201

0 –

The

Fifth

Ann

ual W

illia

m J.

Hol

low

ay, J

r. Le

ctur

e. A

nnua

l lec

ture

serie

s in

hon

or

of Ju

dge

Will

iam

J,. H

ollo

way

, Jr.

of th

e Te

nth

Circ

uit.

This

yea

r’s l

ectu

re w

as d

eliv

ered

by

Judg

e D

iane

W

ood

of th

e U

.S. C

ourt

of A

ppea

ls fo

r the

7th

Circ

uit.

�O

ctob

er 2

1, 2

010

– Th

ird T

hurs

day

Lunc

heon

with

Judg

e B

ana

Rob

erts

of t

he W

este

rn D

istri

ct o

f O

klah

oma.

Nov

embe

r 4, 2

010

– N

ew A

dmitt

ee P

rogr

am fo

r 6th

e U

.S. D

istri

ct C

ourt

for t

he W

este

rn D

istri

ct o

f O

klah

oma.

The

You

nger

Law

yers

Cha

ir an

d ch

apte

r mem

bers

coo

rdin

ated

the

mor

ning

pro

gram

and

lu

ncht

ime

rece

ptio

n fo

r new

adm

ittee

s to

the

dist

rict c

ourt.

Nov

embe

r 29,

201

0 –

“The

Spe

edy

Tria

l Act

and

Eth

ics i

n C

rimin

al L

aw P

ract

ice.

” A

two-

hour

CLE

in

conj

unct

ion

with

the

Loca

l Crim

inal

Rul

es C

omm

ittee

, pre

sent

ers i

nclu

de tw

o A

ssis

tant

U.S

. Atto

rney

s an

d tw

o A

ssis

tant

Fed

eral

Pub

lic D

efen

ders

. �

Dec

embe

r 28,

201

0 –

Tent

h C

ircui

t Yea

r in

Rev

iew

. Th

e ch

apte

r is o

ffer

ing

a fiv

e-ho

ur C

LE p

rogr

am I

whi

ch sp

eake

rs d

iscu

ss 2

010

publ

ishe

d de

cisi

ons f

rom

the

Tent

h C

ircui

t. J

udge

Jero

me

Hol

mes

from

the

U.S

. Cou

rt of

App

eals

for t

he T

enth

Circ

uit w

ill a

lso

disc

uss a

ppel

late

adv

ocac

y.

Page 30: Final CVP Chapter Activities Report for 2010 · : E-Discovery Seminar on November 10, 2010; Bankruptcy seminar on December 2, 2010; and a “brown bag” lunch on ethical issues &

Vic

e Pr

esid

ents

for t

he C

ircui

ts 2

010

Cha

pter

Eve

nts R

epor

t Ja

nuar

y 14

, 201

1

30

CIR

CU

ITC

HA

PTE

RE

VE

NT

S

11th

Circ

uit

Atla

nta,

Geo

rgia

C

hapt

er�

Atla

nta

Lunc

heon

Ser

ies:

A C

onve

rsat

ion

with

The

Hon

orab

le P

hylli

s A. K

ravi

tch,

Judg

e, E

leve

nth

Circ

uit C

ourt

of A

ppea

ls; A

Con

vers

atio

n w

ith T

he H

onor

able

Hor

ace

T. W

ard.

�Th

e R

ober

t S. V

ance

For

um o

n th

e B

ill o

f Rig

hts,

this

yea

r ent

itled

Hill

ary

the

Mov

ie: t

he F

inal

Act

for

Cam

paig

n Fi

nanc

e R

efor

m; T

echn

olog

y in

the

Nor

ther

n D

istri

ct C

ourtr

oom

(pre

sent

ed in

con

junc

tion

with

th

e U

S D

istri

ct C

ourt,

Nor

ther

n D

istri

ct o

f Geo

rgia

).

Nor

th A

laba

ma

Cha

pter

�8t

h A

nnua

l Lab

or &

Em

ploy

men

t Law

Sym

posi

um, 3

8th

Ann

ual S

ympo

sium

on

Gov

ernm

ent A

cqui

sitio

n.

Bot

h of

thes

e Sy

mpo

sium

s foc

us o

n is

sues

impa

ctin

g at

torn

ey's

who

wor

k fo

r the

fede

ral g

over

nmen

t or

thos

e th

at re

pres

ent c

lient

s bef

ore

an a

dmin

istra

tive

foru

m (M

SPB

, EEO

C, e

tc) o

r in

fede

ral c

ourt.

The

Sy

mpo

sium

s are

ope

n to

non

atto

rney

labo

r spe

cial

ists

, and

con

tract

ing

offic

ers.

M

ontg

omer

y,

Ala

bam

a C

hapt

er

�M

ontg

omer

y: F

eder

al P

ract

ice

Sem

inar

, Rec

eptio

n fo

r the

Fed

eral

Judi

ciar

y ho

norin

g: S

enio

r Jud

ge

Trum

an M

. Hob

bs a

nd Ju

dge

Myr

on H

. Tho

mps

on.

Ta

mpa

Bay

, Flo

rida

Cha

pter

�Ta

mpa

Cha

pter

--Fe

dera

l Sen

tenc

ing

Gui

delin

es S

emin

ar (M

ay, 2

011)

Orla

ndo

Cha

pter

--Su

prem

e C

ourt

War

Sto

ries (

from

thos

e w

ho h

ave

argu

ed o

r cle

rked

, lik

ely

mod

erat

ed b

y Ju

stic

e B

lack

man

's da

ught

er

Sally

) So

uth

Flor

ida

Cha

pter

--B

row

n B

ag L

unch

eons

with

loca

l Jud

ges

11th

Circ

uit J

udic

ial C

onfe

renc

e w

ill b

e he

ld in

Orla

ndo

in A

pril

2011

Orla

ndo-

-Eve

nt p

lann

ed to

trai

n hi

gh sc

hool

teac

hers

in M

ay, 2

011

mod

eled

on

an e

vent

star

ted

in T

ampa

last

yea

r.


Top Related