Econ 248, UW-Milwaukee
Overview of Inequality and Poverty
Econ 248: Economics of Poverty and Discrimination
Professor Keith Bender
Econ 248, UW-Milwaukee
How do you define poverty?
Whe
n inco
me
is b
el..
Whe
n inco
me
is s
igni
...
Whe
n sic
knes
s or d
is...
Whe
n dis
crim
inat
ion...
0% 0%0%0%
1. When income is below what you need to survive.
2. When income is significantly less than average income.
3. When sickness or disability causes you to miss work opportunities.
4. When discrimination keeps you from getting work opportunities.
Econ 248, UW-Milwaukee
What Causes Poverty?• (The computer did not save
what we came up with in class because it froze up. These are just a few of the things I remember.)
• Laziness• Natural disasters• Physical and mental problems• Lack of education• The economy• Welfare programs not being
generous enough• Lack of willingness to find a job• Capitalism
• Bad life choices• Drugs• Lack of health care
Econ 248, UW-Milwaukee
Outline
1. Discuss Three Theories that summarize these reasons.
2. Discuss how these Three Theories would solve or cure the poverty problem.
3. Discuss other measures of well-being.
Econ 248, UW-Milwaukee
Three Theories
• Schiller groups the reasons into Three Theories of Poverty
1. Flawed Character
2. Restricted Opportunity
3. Big Brother
• Key to distinguishing these theories is who is at fault for poverty.
Econ 248, UW-Milwaukee
Flawed Character
• Here – the individual in poverty is at fault.
• They lack the motivation or work ethic to go out and get a job that would pull them out of poverty.
• Or they lack the motivation to get the education they need.
• Key is that people have full control over their socio-economic status
Econ 248, UW-Milwaukee
Human Capital Theory
• Latter of these relies on an economic concept called Human Capital Theory.
• Main idea is that the more education or skills you posses (i.e. investing in human capital), the higher your productivity will be and the higher pay you will get.
• Sounds great and intuitive, but…
Econ 248, UW-Milwaukee
HCT Assumptions
• There are important assumptions to be made here
1. More investment leads to a higher payoff
2. Rational choice (comparing costs and benefits)• Key here is ‘Information’
3. Pervasive Opportunity• Everyone has a chance to get schooling and job
Econ 248, UW-Milwaukee
Restricted Opportunity
• Other end of the spectrum• Restricted Opportunity is when something
happens beyond the control of the poor to put/keep them in poverty
• For example
– Death of main income provider
– Poor public education
– No access to transportation
– Sudden illness or disability
– Natural Disasters– Discrimination
Econ 248, UW-Milwaukee
Big Brother
• Here the government is at fault, but in a way it is a combination of the previous two
• Argument is that welfare programs distort the incentives to work.– Why work when you can sit on your rear end
and get a check for ‘doing nothing’?!
Econ 248, UW-Milwaukee
So which do you think is the main cause?
Fla
wed C
hara
cter
¤Re.
..
Res
trict
ed O
pportunity
Big
Bro
ther
Som
ethin
g els
e
44%
13%19%
25%
1. Flawed Character
2. Restricted Opportunity
3. Big Brother
4. Something else
X
Econ 248, UW-Milwaukee
What do other people think causes poverty?
• NPR/Kennedy School/Kaiser Foundation Poll and series of radio reportshttp://www.npr.org/programs/specials/poll/poverty
• Key phrases•General attitudes, laziness•Something for free•Do something about it (college)•Bad life choices•Don’t do enough to help themselves•Drug abuse•Single parent families
•Not enough high paying jobs•Poor public schools•Too many immigrants•Single parent families•Cycles of poverty/product of environment
•Why work when you can receive a check
Results from NPR Survey
44434245
45465145
Theory
6536
Flawed Character
Restricted Opportunity
Big Brother
1716
*
2
1
9
6
8
5
3
6
13
13
2
3
1
4
6
5
7
5
10
17
10
2
3
1
11
4
6
6
8
6
14
12
12
11
12
10
1222
13
13
13
>200%100-200%<100%Total
No item a major cause
Don’t know
None of these
Poor quality of public schools
Decline in moral values
Poor people lacking motivation
Too many immigrants
The Welfare system
A shortage of jobs
Too many single parent families
Too many jobs being part time/low wage
Medical Bills
Drug Abuse
Most Important Cause
1
4
2
5
5
7
8
9
From http://www.npr.org/programs/specials/poll/poverty/staticresults1.html. These results are Copyright © 2001 by National Public Radio, Washington, D.C.
Econ 248, UW-Milwaukee
How do you ‘fix’ poverty?• Flawed Character
1. Do nothing – can’t change motivation
2. Give them training and they will get good jobs• Key assumption – that the jobs are there
• Restricted Opportunity– Get rid of restriction
• Big Brother– Cut (end?!) welfare programs to get rid of
work disincentives
Econ 248, UW-Milwaukee
Which of the following increases your well-being the most?
Incr
easi
ng yo
ur inco
..
Incr
easi
ng yo
ur wea
lt...
Hav
ing s
afe
water
to ..
.
Knowin
g that
ther
e ar
...
Hav
ing a
good
park
...
Knowin
g that
your
U..
19%
13%
57%
0%2%
9%
1. Increasing your income by $10,000
2. Increasing your wealth by $10,000
3. Having safe water to drink and air to breathe
4. Knowing that there are social safety nets such as unemployment insurance and welfare programs
5. Having a good park system
6. Knowing that your UWM degree will open (good paying!!) job opportunities when you graduate
Econ 248, UW-Milwaukee
Money isn’t everything, is it?
• Assumption to now (and for the rest of the class) is that money is key indicator of well-being.
• Economists don’t really believe this, but it is easy to measure and it is probably correlated with well-being
• But… there are other things that influence well-being.
Econ 248, UW-Milwaukee
Other indicators of well-being
1. Wealth– Accumulated assets over a lifetime
– Are people with high assets and low income in poverty?
• Maybe, but maybe not!
– Caveat (ie. Warning!)• Not all wealth is the same – some is not liquid – that is, it is
difficult to turn some assets into cash• e.g. housing wealth, pension wealth• So, some of those with high wealth have no cash
Econ 248, UW-Milwaukee
Other indicators con’d
2. Transitory vs. permanent income– Time is key here– Transitory – snapshot of income, income in a year– Permanent – average income over a number of
years– Key issue here – transitory income doesn’t tell you a
lot, since well-being does not drop by a lot if permanent income is high
– Eg – farmers, athletes
Econ 248, UW-Milwaukee
Other indicators con’d
3. Life cycle of Income– Age-Income relationship
is key here– So where you are in your
life cycle tells you about your overall well-being
– However, so is the level of consumption
– Consider two cases…
Income
Age
Income
Age
Econ 248, UW-Milwaukee
Other indicators con’d
4. Government provision of Goods and Services
• Can be geared to poor – welfare, unemployment benefits
• Or to all – public schools, libraries, parks
5. Non-monetary issues – ‘Social Equality’• Equal access to justice, police protection,
voting, equal treatment under law• Breaks down class distinctions
Econ 248, UW-Milwaukee
Review Question 1: The Flawed Character Theory of Poverty is based on what
economic theory?
Life
Cyc
le T
heory
of..
.
Hum
an C
apita
l The
ory
Dis
crim
inat
ion
Wor
k dis
ince
ntive
th...
0% 0%0%0%
1. Life Cycle Theory of Earnings
2. Human Capital Theory
3. Discrimination
4. Work disincentive theory
Econ 248, UW-Milwaukee
Review Question 2: A person believes that poverty is caused by the poor public transportation system that is
subsidized by the government. Which ‘theory’ of poverty is this most closely related?
Fla
wed C
hara
cter
Res
trict
ed O
pportunity
Big
Bro
ther
Hum
an C
apita
l
Phys
ical
Cap
ital
0% 0% 0%0%0%
1. Flawed Character
2. Restricted Opportunity
3. Big Brother
4. Human Capital
5. Physical Capital
Econ 248, UW-Milwaukee
Review Question 3: A key variable that is highlighted by the ‘Life-cycle’ theory in regards to
well-being measures is
tim
e or a
ge.
wea
lth.
soci
al ju
stic
e.
hum
an c
apita
l.
dis
crim
inat
ion.
0% 0% 0%0%0%
1. time or age.
2. wealth.
3. social justice.
4. human capital.
5. discrimination.
Econ 248, UW-Milwaukee
A Question for You: Which poverty theory do you think is the best explanation
for poverty?
Fla
wed C
hara
cter
Res
trict
ed O
pportunity
Big
Bro
ther
Stil
l don’
t thin
k an
y ar
...
0% 0%0%0%
1. Flawed Character
2. Restricted Opportunity
3. Big Brother
4. Still don’t think any are right!
X