Download - David Ricardo 5
-
7/27/2019 David Ricardo 5
1/31
Important Writers:
Adam Smith (1723-1790) - Wealth of Nations,
1776. Thomas Robert Malthus (1766-1834) an Essay
on the Principle of Population, 1978.
David Ricardo (1772-1823) On the Principle of
Political Economy and Taxation, 1817.1817
Nassau Senior An outline of the Science of PoliticalEconomy, 1836.
John Stuart Mill (1806-1873) Principle of PoliticalEconomy, 1848.
Karl Marx Capital, Volume I, 1867.
-
7/27/2019 David Ricardo 5
2/31
A stockbroker turned economist.
Economics study in 1799 28 yrs. 1810, -1st pamphlet, the high price of bullion. 1815
essays on the Corn Law controversy.
His major work, Principle of Political Economy
& Taxation (1817) replaced Adam SmithsWealth of Nation (1776), as the accepted bookon economic Qs.
Significant contribution to economictheory: methodology, theories of value,international trade, public finance,diminishing returns and rent.
Redirected economics away from the method andscope of economics advocated by Adam Smith.
DAVID RICARDO (1772-1823)
-
7/27/2019 David Ricardo 5
3/31
Adam Smith (i) deductive theory (ii) a
descriptive, informal narrative of contemporary and
historical institutions. Blended theory with historicaldescriptive material.
Ricardo - represents the pure theorist at work.Abstracted from the economy of his time and
built an analysis based on the deductive method.
Applied abstract analysis to political issue oftariffs(importationgrain into England).
Strongly oriented toward policy.
-
7/27/2019 David Ricardo 5
4/31
Economic problems of his time: rising grain prices?????, rising rents and the
relative growth of industry and relative decline ofagriculture ( structure England).
the policy question of free vs regulated internationaltrade.
The landlords wanted protection from foreignagricultural product, but many of the rising industrialistswere advocates of free trade, particularly for Britishindustries.
Adam Smith - concerned with the forcesdetermining the wealth of the nations.
Ricardo - the principal purpose of economics isto determine the laws that regulate thedistribution of income among
landlords, capitalists and laborers.
-
7/27/2019 David Ricardo 5
5/31
To determine the laws which regulate thisdistribution (income) is the principal problems inPolitical Economy.
Observed - changes in the functional distribution of incomeover time in the system.
Economy of 3 main groups: capitalists receiving profit andinterest, landlords receiving rent and laborers receivingwages.
To explain changes in the shares received by the capitalists,landlords and laborers, he developed a theory explainingprofits, interest, rent and wages (at the microeconomic level ofeconomy).
Examined the forces causing changes in relativeprices over time. He was primarily concerned with the effectsof changes in income distribution on the rate of capitalaccumulation and economic growth.
-
7/27/2019 David Ricardo 5
6/31
The capitalists perform the essential roles in the
economy the producers, directors and the mostimportant actors.
They contribute to an efficient allocation of
resources because they move their capital to the
areas of highest return.
Ifperfectly competition markets prevail,
consumer demands are met at the lowest possiblesocial cost.
They also initiate economic growth by saving andinvesting.
Ricardos Model
-
7/27/2019 David Ricardo 5
7/31
Laboris essentially passive in his model.
Real wage = wages fund/ labor force.
The wages fund - depends upon capital accumulation, &the size of labor force is governed by the Malthusianpopulation principle.
If wages fund increases as a result of capital
accumulation, real wages will rise in the short run.
Increasing real wages will result in anincrease in population and hence in the laborforce.
Long-run equilibrium will exist when the labor forcehas increased sufficiently to return real wages to thesubsistence level (minimum level of well-being).
-
7/27/2019 David Ricardo 5
8/31
Landlords are mere parasites.
The supply curve for land is perfectly elastic and thesocial opportunity cost of land is zero.
Landlords receive income, rent, merely for holdingfactors production without serving any socially useful
function.
Instead of saving and accumulating capital, thelandlords engaged in consumption spending.
The activities of the landowning were harmful to thegrowth and development of the emerging industrialsociety.
-
7/27/2019 David Ricardo 5
9/31
Wealth & econ groups
the total output or gross revenue of the economy isdistributed to the Ls, Ks, & Lls.
The part of total output not used to pay labor atsubsistence wage and to replace the capital goodworn out is called net revenue of economic
surplus (Gross revenue (subsistence wage+depreciation) = net revenue).
Net revenue consists ofprofits, rents, and
wages over the subsistence level. In long-run equilibrium, wages will be at a
subsistence level and net revenue will equal profitsand rents.
-
7/27/2019 David Ricardo 5
10/31
The workers and landlords spendentire income on consumption, so
profits are the only source of saving,or capital accumulation.
-
7/27/2019 David Ricardo 5
11/31
A redistribution of income
favoring the landlord takesplace over time as profits
decrease and rents rise,
with a consequent reductionin the rate of economic
growth.
-
7/27/2019 David Ricardo 5
12/31
Interest in the controversy of Corn Laws -regulations placing tariffs on the importation ofgrain into England.
Growing concern over the pressure of populationon the food supply.
Food price, rents, and investment in land wererising steadily.
High tariff would shift the distribution ofincome in favor of the landlords.
The period ofNapoleonic wars, artificiallyprotected British agriculture from continental grain& couple with inability agriculturally self-sufficient -rising grain prices & rents.
-
7/27/2019 David Ricardo 5
13/31
Distribution of income over time
Rejected Smiths reasons:
i. Competion in L mkt w rises mustfall
Refuted: Malthusian doctrine w rises pop
rises L force rises w falls.
ii. Competition in the investment &commd mkt
Refuted: competition will not result in a fall inthe general P level. P falls when it is notpossible to sell at previous P & existence ofover production.
-
7/27/2019 David Ricardo 5
14/31
Who are the sole
beneficiaries of long-rungrowth process????
-
7/27/2019 David Ricardo 5
15/31
The Corn Laws imposed a flooron the priceof grain 50 shillings per quarter.
Landlords demanded a floor of 80 shilings perquarter prompted an extensive controversy.
Ricardo published pamphlets explaininghigher tariffs resulted in higher grainprices.
Higher tariff encourage greater Inv in agriculture,increased output supply & P fall.
Higher P of grain was the results ofhigher rents. Rents were price-determined & not a cost of production.
-
7/27/2019 David Ricardo 5
16/31
Average prices (shillings perquarter of a ton)
1770-1779 45 shillings
1780-1789 45 shillings
1790-1799 55 shillings 1800-1809 82 shillings
1810-1813 106 shillings
The higher price was in 1801 177 shillings
-
7/27/2019 David Ricardo 5
17/31
Corn Laws
Protection of British agriculture from foreign
competition caused grain imports to decline& output of grain in England to increase.
Intensive and extensive margin
were pushed out and profitsdeclines as rents increased.
Corn Laws accelerate the process of
redistribution of income toward thelandlord, slowing down economic growth &hastening the stationary state.
-
7/27/2019 David Ricardo 5
18/31
Theory of Land Rent
Constant return in manufacturing and
diminishing returns in agriculture.
The coefficient of production for L and K werefixed by technological consideration.
Assume a fixed quantity of land & diminishingreturns begin immediately.
The quantity of land is fixed, thus increases in
demand will result in higher prices (rents) withno increase in quantity supplied.
The opportunity of land was zero.
-
7/27/2019 David Ricardo 5
19/31
A B
Extensive Margin of Land
100
90
Bushels(wheat)
-
7/27/2019 David Ricardo 5
20/31
Ricardo
Rents were price-determined
Rents were determined by Grain Price
Corn Laws or Adam SmithRents were price-determining
High price of grain was determined by
higher rentsRents determined Grain Prices
-
7/27/2019 David Ricardo 5
21/31
Assumptions
1. Labor cost theory
2. Neutral Money.
3. Fixed coefficients of production for L & K.
4. Diminishing returns in agriculture & CTS in
manufacturing.5. Full employment.
6. Perfect competition.
7. Economic actors.8. Malthusian population theory.
9. Wages Fund doctorine
-
7/27/2019 David Ricardo 5
22/31
Assumptions
1. Labor cost theory explained changes in relativeprices o/t
2. Neutral Money - Prices.
3. Fixed coefficients of production for L & K to increaseQ, L & K must be added in a fixed proportion.
4. Diminishing returns in agriculture & CTS in manuf. - SS
curve slope upward (MCs increase as Q expands).5. Full employment.
6. Perfect competition.
7. Economic actors rational & calculating, max , higher
wages & rents.8. Malthusian population theory pop expands faster than
food prod.
9. Wages Fund doctrine real wages=wages fund/labor
force, wages fund
real wages .
-
7/27/2019 David Ricardo 5
23/31
Higher Tariff lower grain prices (dom)encouraged more production.
To increase Q demand more Lo & K in fixed prop. -Q increases.
Diminishing returns L fixed, land farmed moreintensively, marginal physical product decreases,equivalent to say marginal cost increasesgrainprices rises.
Also, more less fertile land were utilized (extensivelyfarmed) relatively, fertile L is more expensive. Marginwas pushed down.
Opp cost of L is zero, in CM on different grades
of L is uniform.Rent is the payment to l/lord that will equalize
the on different grades of L (less fertilelower rent & more fertile higher rent)
-
7/27/2019 David Ricardo 5
24/31
Increase in the cost of producing grains
(????) Higher grain prices.
Higher grain prices demand more wages
for workers to maintain a subsistence std of
living higher grain P . Cost of grain was amajor part of L food budget.
W
Pop
demand for more food
increase grain prod demand for more Landdiminishing marginal returnrents & MC
-
7/27/2019 David Ricardo 5
25/31
Rents were determined by Grain Prices.
Higher grain prices higher rents.
Grain prices is determined by labor costtheory.
SS curve is upward sloping reflectinghigher price as MC increases.
-
7/27/2019 David Ricardo 5
26/31
Tariff is harmful to the economy.
Tariff reduces profits , slower the capital
accumulation & lower the growth rate.
Higher Tariff higher money wages.
Removing tariff on grains wld be beneficial toEngland.
Removing tariff capital acc I growth.
Protectionist: Removing tariff food Prices &w depressions.
-
7/27/2019 David Ricardo 5
27/31
Theory of land rent
A labor theory of value must also deal with the question of land rent.
Suppose that there are 2 laborers of equal skill working on 2 plots ofland of different fertility.
What is the qtty of L necessary to produce a bushel ofwheat????
The price of wheat depends upon the marginalcost of the wheat produced least efficient.
Price is determined at the margin & at the margin there isno rent.
Differing rents received by lands of differingquality will not influence changes in relativeprices over time.
-
7/27/2019 David Ricardo 5
28/31
Ricardo Theory of Value
Rejected the prevailing cost of production
theory of value (Adam Smith).
What cause changes in relative Ps over time???
The value of a commodity or the quantity of any
other commodity for which it will exchange, dependson the relative quantity of laborwhich isnecessary for its production, and not on the greater
or less compensation(wages) which is paidfor that labor.
-
7/27/2019 David Ricardo 5
29/31
Ricardos Labor Cost Theory of Value.
Use value vs exchange value.
Use value is essential for the existence of exchange value. The price of commodities is derived from (i) scarcity & (ii)the quantity of labor.
Some commodities have a price that is determined by their
scarcity alone. Not freely reproducible - perfectlyinelastic ss curve picture, books, coins, wines.
The value of these goods is independent of the qtty of Lused to produce them.*
Given a fixed inelastic ss curve, demand willdetermine price.
Excluded from Labor cost theory of value.
-
7/27/2019 David Ricardo 5
30/31
Competitively Produced Goods
Freely reproducible commodities.
Manufacturing constant costs & agricultureincreasing costs.
Qtty of labor that determines relativeprices not the wages paid to labor.
Qtty of L is measured by clock hours & wagesmeasures relative productivity of labor.
Ifdiffering skills remain constant overtime, changes in the prices of goods will not be aresult of the wages paid to labor (????).
-
7/27/2019 David Ricardo 5
31/31
Capital Goods
All commodities require the utilization of both L & K.
What is the influence of K on the prices of goods???
K is a stored-up labor(L that has been applied in aprevious period).
The qtty of L in a commodity produced by both K & L ismeasured by
qtty of L immediately applied + qtty of L stored inthe K goods (time equivalent of the deprec.)
e.g:100 hours of labor + 1 hour of labor
The explanation is not satisfactory.